Pre-season drastically different says Jags

Much more emphasis on ball play
Phil Jagielka says: "It's been drastically different to what we've done before but it's been enjoyable" as he and the rest of the squad come to terms with the pre-season training programme under Roberto Martinez.

"It's been a lot more training with the balls and a lot more concentration required - and that sometimes isn't the easiest thing when you're tired. It's been tough but pre-season is always tough.

"Sunday's result wasn't exactly what we wanted but we can still look at a few positives and this can put us in good stead for the next few weeks."

In reference ot the youngsters who played, he said, "In terms of their attitudes and their ability, they've all done really well.

"It's nice for the manager to give them all game time. He could have just brought them all on for 10 minutes at the end but it was nice that most of them got 45 minutes.

"It's a test now to see if they can stay in the squad when a few more senior members come back."

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports News



Reader Comments (81)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nicholas Page
1 Posted 15/07/2013 at 13:45:36
So the focus is now on FOOTBALL. Also note the potentially barbed comment at the end too, about the 10 minutes of game time.
Trevor Lynes
2 Posted 15/07/2013 at 14:19:39
The potentially barbed comments are yours I reckon!! You see more into innocent comments than most people apart from amateur sleuths.
Al Reddish
3 Posted 15/07/2013 at 14:41:37
To be honest I thought he had a bit of a dig at the end, just like Kenwright did when he said the previous regime didn't want to enter the youth team into that competition but we will do from now on.
Paul Andrews
4 Posted 15/07/2013 at 14:47:17
David who ?
Stephen Coles
5 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:01:53
Sounds promising. we're gonna win the league!
what? it's good to dream :)
Bob Skelton
6 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:05:36
Jags could be struggling then! Football and not hoof ball.

Judging by his suicidal pass to Osman over the weekend his days could be numbered. Will we miss his sweeping right to left 50 yard passes to the opposition...think not. We'll see how it pans out with him and Hibbo neither of whom could pass wind. Good job Neville has gone with his cultured chips to the corner flag he wouldn't have lasted!!

Kevin Rowlands
7 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:15:09
'drastically', bit of a poor choice of words there by jags, all sounds very positive though, looking forward to seeing them in Miami in a couple of weeks.
John Ford
8 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:14:22
Its a bit of an irony that Jags is the one with this news. Is he being kept late for extra lessons?

It would be ridiculous to drop him. Hes an outstanding centre half and a potential replacement would first and foremost need to match his defensive qualities. Seeing and executing a pass would be great but the priority is defending.

Paul Gladwell
9 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:22:52
Bob, some of his performances last year were top draw, the lad is quality in a Dave Watson quality, not the best at distribution but at defending he is, that yesterday was just general sharpness, it will be back soon.
Bob Skelton
10 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:37:38
Paul, I agree that he is good defensively but these Latin Managers demand a bit more than pace and a good sliding tackle. We'll see how it pans out...
Brent Stephens
11 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:40:47
So the new manager might not play Jags? I don't think so!
Phil Walling
12 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:42:36
I thought Jags looked `drastically`uncomfortable yesterday.With a large area to cover rather than tight up to attackers,his lack of accurate passing skill was highlighted but not so much as that of Duffy who did nothing to enhance his right to a place.
With over a month to work on new systems and personal skills,lets hope Martinez can not only get his ideas over but make some of our players `better footballers`for truth to tell,we loked a lot like Wigan yesterday!
Andrew Ellams
13 Posted 15/07/2013 at 15:59:14
He doesn't seem to struggle playing the ball out of defence for England, and I don't see anybody in that team that would make him particularly more confident than those at Everton
Nicholas Page
14 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:04:24
Some of you are making it sound like its some sort of dark art. He's an extremely well paid professional footballer......its passing a ball for God's sake....for a couple of yards!

Mind you, watching the Ingerlund lot its quite clear that most of them didn't make it through the ranks on technical ability.

Paul Andrews
15 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:11:48
Leave Jagielka out of the starting 11 ?
Pack that in straight away
Mark Frere
16 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:04:15
Jags has played in midfield before earlier in his career, so his distribution can't be as bad as some people make out. I don't think any of them hopeful long hoofs up the field did much to enhance Jags reputation. I'm sure RM put a stop to long hoofs up the field and just make his CBs play a short simple pass to players in front of them
Patrick Murphy
17 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:05:47
The failings of the defenders being able to pick a pass is not only down to them it is down to the midfielders to get themselves into space to receive the ball and keep it moving. Yesterday, the Austrian side pushed right on to the defenders and it was worrying how uncomfortable we looked. RM may have to ditch that strategy until we have the players who can adapt and adopt that way of playing.

It's always difficult assessing things at this time of year, but many have highlighted our poor ball retention all over the park in the past, especially when it gets into the last third. So there are areas that the squad will have to work on and it looks as if RM has identified these areas, whether he can improve the players, we'll just have to wait and see.

Perhaps the players we have are not as good individually as we would like and that is why the emphasis has always been about the team and for large parts playing the percentage game. It will be a bit of a bumpy ride for the first half of the season, but if RM can instill his beliefs and the players respond it will be worth it.

Ross Kerry
18 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:20:04
Let’s not try to read anything into Jagielka’s comments about a meaningless game when he is doing the usual captain’s job of answering the questions he’s asked with the answers expected of him by his employers. Showing an interest just encourages more of this tripe.
Brian Harrison
19 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:16:23
I feared that Martinez would want to play the ball out of defence and that is not the strong point of our defenders. I think you need really gifted players to play that system so seems Roberto doesn't seem to take on board that sometimes you have to compromise your style a little to suit the players on your books. I don't think you can adopt one style of playing and try to convert non playing centre backs into something that they are not comfortable with. Jagielka and Distin are 2 smashing defenders but if they are expected to play in a different way we may end up like Wigan, conceding a bagful of goals.
Richard Dodd
20 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:17:39
David Moyes was never obsessed about our playing 'pretty' football-much more about hard work and playing to the team members' strengths. He strongly believed that defenders were there to defend and if that meant a hoof up field at times, so be it.

What worries me about Martinez is that rather than recognising and accepting players' strengths and shortcomings, he will try to make silk purses out of sows' ears and we shall finish up with a defence akin to Wigan's.
We may well come to rue the loss of Moyes's more pragmatic approach, particularly if we continue to exist without a prolific goalscorer. All those draws we moaned about will become defeats, methinks.

Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:30:52
Doddy have you been drinking again? After 11 years, we should have had players who can actually do what they are paid to do, play football, I don't mean that they all have to be Messi's but they should have the basic skills. A good team has a mix of Artists and Grafters. 11 artists, whilst easy on the eye won't win things and a team of out and out grafters won't do it either. I'm sure RM is intelligent enough to realise the players weaknesses and will alter his game plan accordingly.

As an aside I found this part of the Echo's match report of interest.

'While the result meant nothing, there was nevertheless an interesting and encouraging post-script. Owner Bill Kenwright, board member Jon Woods and chief executive Robert Elstone were all present to show their support for the new manager – along with the usual contingent of travelling Blues.'

Now if we could just attract Mr Earl and Mr Green to the games maybe we would have a strategy for the future? I am a bit concerned about Jelavic, I think he might well be on his way out of Goodison following his omission from Saturday's squad - why would he need extra rest?


Andrew Ellams
22 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:39:04
Sorry Richard but if you are trying to promote hoofball over football then I'm sorry but no way.

A managers job is to work to his teams strengths and not limitations.

Jay Harris
23 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:37:36
Doddy,
I had the same concerns about Martinez and particularly his 4 years at Wigan but to be fair we cant judge him on one result preseason against a half decent side with a number of our kids playing.

The only thing I got from it was Duffy is not yet ready for the big-time and lacks pace but Matty Kennedy and Conor McAleny were much better than I expected.

I think with our first choice back 4 we should do a lot better but the attacking third is still a problem for us.

Derek Knox
24 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:48:53
When do the ones who were not in Austria (due to extended leave for International involvement) return? Is it next Monday?
John Daley
25 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:52:00
Richard,

"All those draws we moaned about will become defeats,methinks."

Given the fact that your musings are normally about as 'bang on' as a British remake of 'Any Which Way But Loose' starring Keith Harris & Chuckles instead of Clint Eastwood & Clyde....then you've just topped up my optimism tank to dangerously high levels.

Peter Laing
26 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:55:10
I remember reading a story about how the likes of Duncan McKenzie hated training under Gordon Lee. The emphasis would appear to have been pre-season spent running up and down the sand dunes at Freshfield with very little ball work. Pre-season undoubtedly requires fitness work, however it should be rare these days that professional footballers return to training over a stone overweight. I hope that Jagielka and the rest of the boys can adapt to Martinez new methods, ball-work fantastic I say and long may it continue and we adopt an approach of treating the ball not as a hot potato !
Mark Frere
27 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:49:42
Patrick Murphy

I might be wrong, but isn't Jelavic on extended leave because of International duty?

Regarding your comment about having 11 players good enough to play football - It all depends on what a manager wants from his back 4. Remember the famous Arsenal back 4? Which consisted of Adams, Keown, Dixon and Winterburn, by no way were they good footballers, but boy, could they defend and keep clean sheets.

I suppose it all depends on a managers philosophy, and if a manager prefers his defenders to play from the back

Phil Walling
28 Posted 15/07/2013 at 16:53:39
Doddy and others: Let`s not forget it was Roberto`s strict adherence to his footballing philosophy that got Wigan relegated from the Prem.He chose to ignore the fact that too many of the players at his disposal were not up to what he expected of them.
No Moyesista me,but the Scot would have recognised that fact early on and concentrated his efforts on shoring up the defence via his beloved KITAHTNO method.Martinez,on the other hand, was all too proud of his `philosophy` to do that and week in,week out told the world `We shall keep playing the way we do and the results will follow`.
Well they didn`t and now he`s ended up with us.I just hope that he`s learned something in the process although I suspect he`s too much of a theorist to do that!
Graham Mockford
29 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:08:40
My biggest concern for the forthcoming season is the potential for some poor results as we try to transition to a new style of football.
We knew what we we were getting when we appointed RM and to be honest our previous style was only ever going to get us so far but it did come with a fairly safe bet that it would get us in the Top 8. Not good enough I hear you cry and I agree, hence the need for change.
However I think it is naive in the extreme that the new manager will wave his wand and suddenly players start playing in a different manner. It is very easy to talk the talk when it comes to playing attractive football ( one only has to listen to that gobshite Rodgers) but turning it into reality that produces winning football is a completely different matter. Lets face it other than a 6 match winning Cup run he never really managed it at Wigan. Lets hope with better players he does it here, but I certainly don't share the optimism of some on here.
Tom Bowers
30 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:23:04
Most successful teams these days play the ball out of defence and keep possession rather than play hoofball and concede possession cheaply and quickly back to the opposition.
Perhaps now in the ''new'' Everton era this will be the philosophy.
Only time will tell if it will provide dividends for this Everton squad.
The old ploy of hoofing the ball upfield to the lone striker will only be successful some of the time and only if that striker has great ball control and speed which will make something of the situation.
We cannot read anything into the Austria game as it is too early and many players only played a short time although one would have expected players like Duffy to have impressed a little which didn't happen.
Jay Harris
31 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:45:08
Tom
I totally agree with you but in football you have to be able to adapt and mix your style of play up.

What I DONT want us to become is the "tippy-tappy" team that keeps playing it across the back 4 because we have got the ability to get it forward with speed and precision.

That was exactly Wigan's problem though I would hope our quality is a lot better than theirs.

Steavey Buckley
32 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:50:24
What's important to the back 4 is to have players in front of them, who can take the ball of them, keep possession and find the right pass to the right player. Barcelona have 2 master footballers who do this in Iniesta and Xavi Everton just have Gibson at best at the moment. So unless RM can find high calibre players, it maybe hoff is safe and best from the back 4
John Brennan
33 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:54:56
If we are going to play this new way, fine.
That means the more Latins we get in, the better.
English (British players ala Naismith etc), cant play that type of football. They havent got the ability.
I have, and although I'm 60 with a busted leg (3 times), Roberto should take a look at me.
I'd appreciate it if he would bring along Fabregas's young lady as well.
Drew Shortis
34 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:38:39
If I was Martinez I would be looking at how Swansea evolved last season under Laudrup. Yes they can play possession football, but when required they can can go more direct and with Michu up front it worked very well for them. I hope he is patient with his philosophy and does not try and push it too far too quickly. I think the midfield will have to work hard to give the centre-backs an outlet for the short ball, but when in doubt Jags should stick to what he knows and go long. His 'pass' to Osman was sloppy, but it was the first game and everyone looked rusty. At least he was trying to adapt to the new style. He is a quality defender and I'm sure Martinez will stick with him as captain for his defensive ability and let him off for the odd long ball. We have Baines and Coleman at the back who can both bring the ball out of defence, so I wouldn't panic.

In the long term Martinez can bring in younger players who fit his philosophy and the team can evolve over time. Pre season is the right time to try out new things and assess how well they work. As long as he learns from these games and gets things right come the start of the season we will be fine.

Phil Walling
35 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:57:03
One side effect of this pre-season programme is the view Baines and Fellaini will have of how they are asked to play.If they have concerns one or both may agitate for a move,if they are happy then they will want to stay and then, I guess ,we can suspend all our angst!
Phil Walling
36 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:57:03
One side effect of this pre-season programme is the view Baines and Fellaini will have of how they are asked to play.If they have concerns one or both may agitate for a move,if they are happy then they will want to stay and then, I guess ,we can suspend all our angst!
Mike Gaynes
37 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:10:32
Love the emphasis on ball skills. Can't wait to see Jags' first stepover. And three words that have never been used in a sentence before... Tony Hibbert, backheel.

Should be an interesting season.

Jay Harris
38 Posted 15/07/2013 at 17:45:08
Tom
I totally agree with you but in football you have to be able to adapt and mix your style of play up.

What I DONT want us to become is the "tippy-tappy" team that keeps playing it across the back 4 because we have got the ability to get it forward with speed and precision.

That was exactly Wigan's problem though I would hope our quality is a lot better than theirs.

Chris Morris
39 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:15:52
Hang on a second

Forget about the middle men, the front 2 and the back 4 for a minute and ask: who is going to be the Gaoalkeeping 1?

If football from the back is what Martinez wants then I see no position for Howard. Personally I think he's been weak for last 2 years but I know almost absolutely nothing about Robles

Richard Dodd
40 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:22:09
Chris: I think Tim has done well enough over the years to deserve the top spot from the start but he will know that this manager thinks highly of the man waiting in the wings.That should be enough to keep him on his toes although we may have seen the last of those mega punts that bounce off Our Victor!
Patrick Murphy
41 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:21:46
Mark I didn't say we should have eleven players, I said we should after 11YEARS, have players who are comfortable on the ball and pointed out that

A good team has a mix of Artists and Grafters. 11 artists, whilst easy on the eye won't win things and a team of out and out grafters won't do it either. I'm sure RM is intelligent enough to realise the players weaknesses and will alter his game plan accordingly.

I don't think Winterburn or Dixon were bad footballers, Keown and Adams I'll admit were the proverbial stoppers though.

John Ford
42 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:13:31
We played better football than Wigan last year especially pre Christmas. If its the case hat RM is now in a position to apply his style successfully because he has a better team then fine. Phil Walling is right. It's no good having a philosophy without the right players and it's going to take time. Moyes got the best from his players because he knew their strengths. I hope Martinez is equally astute, but at adapting and renewing a teams approach.

One thing Everton fans will pick up on is a flimsy defence. My fear is that we become a mid table team because like many teams we don't get the basics right. Teams playing occasional pretty football but with a weak core. 'attack is the best form of defence' has to be the most banal philosophy in football..

Mike Hughes
43 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:23:38
Richard #890 "What worries me about Martinez is that rather than recognising and accepting players` strengths and shortcomings,he will try to make silk purses out of sow`s ears and we shall finish up with a defence akin to Wigan`s." I agree with that part of your post as that is also my concern - i.e. concentrating on a "philosophy" rather than winning. However, I for one have moved on from DM completely now. His pragmatism was OK up to a ceiling of mediocrity. I'm hopeful and even slightly confident that we can and will progress from 6th place. Even if we convert every 2 DM draws to a RM win and loss, we'll still be a point better off.
Patrick Murphy
44 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:39:58
Perhaps Barcelona and Spain are not worth watching, what with their flimsy defences. Where's Gordon Lee when you need him!
Paul Gladwell
45 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:31:39
I thought Duffy was awful yesterday and I have been one calling for his introduction.
I know these players deserve holidays like us all, but surely for a lad hell bent on making a breakthrough he should not have been on twitter everyday pissed up in Ibiza for two weeks just a week or two before pre season starts on the most important season of his career and then thinking few runs around Sefton Park when he got back will kick him back into shape.
If you want things badly you sacrifice certain things and he looked shambolic yesterday, it's early days yes, but not a good start.
Richard Dodd
46 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:32:07
Where I`m at odds with you,Mike @960 is that I don`t think you can justly describe our style of play as mediocre-particularly over the last two seasons.Neither do I consider a 6/7th finish in these terms.
RM may well have been seduced into promising Champions League football but if he can only replicate DM`s record (and add a cup or two)he will have done very well,indeed!
Mark Frere
47 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:37:31
Patrick. Sorry mate, I must of misread or misunderstood your post. My mistake
Colin Glassar
48 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:45:56
I think we should go easy on Duffy. Ok he was rubbish yesterday but most of them were. This is a talented player who has been out in the wilderness and is probably a bit short on confidence. Trappatoni rates him and with his best mate, Seamus, back soon we will see an improvement. It's also the job of the senior players to talk to these lads and get their heads straightened.
Mike Hughes
49 Posted 15/07/2013 at 18:51:44
Richard I didn't describe our style of play as mediocre. DM's last match at home v WHU was testament to that. I described DM's pragmatic approach as reaching a ceiling of mediocrity - referring to the lack of away wins against the "Sky 4", disappointing approaches and consequently results in key cup games, semis and finals. And most derby matches. If he only replicates DM then I for one will not be content. One of the reasons I thought we needed a change from DM (and him from us) was that 5-6th seemed to be the ceiling of expectation. Anyway I'm off out for a run (pre-season and all that......)
Susong Hermawan
50 Posted 15/07/2013 at 19:13:47
#877.. 'we looked a lot like Wigan'.. Sure, that's where the manager and staff came from. :D
Jimmy Kelly
51 Posted 15/07/2013 at 19:18:08
I can't claim to have seen him an awful lot myself but according to a few people who have, Duffy's performance yesterday was very much par for the course for him.

I think it will be interesting to see how many of the people regularly mentioned as being underused on here (Duffy, Vellios, McAleny, to a lesser extent Barkley and Oviedo) are used more by Martinez than they were previously. Personally I think very little will change in the case of the first three.

Steve Guy
52 Posted 15/07/2013 at 19:26:46
Back four per last season with Fellaini just in front of J ags and Distin to pick up the ball and do the passing....Simples
Richard Dodd
53 Posted 15/07/2013 at 19:45:58
Much talk of zonal marking yesterday.Any of our ToffeeWeb coaches have a view on this?
Mike Gwyer
54 Posted 15/07/2013 at 19:44:09

Can't see what the fuss is about our back four - our full backs will give any full backs in the EPL a run for their money and both of them will gladly play the ball all day long. Distin will happily hoof it or play the ball to feet and Jags just hoofs it somewhere, roughly two thirds up the pitch. But he defends like a lion and is a player that will give RM a bit of headache (if he sticks with playing the ball out of the back four). Anyways, as stated above, Fellaini will always be gagging for the ball so he can do all of Jags distribution.

Probably only thing of real note yesterday was that Duffy was slow and his passing was extremely piss poor, meaning that Jags spent a lot of time covering him. Everything else, like Naismith, Osman and our attempts at shooting into the opposition net were just like last season. Fucking shite.

Chris Morris
55 Posted 15/07/2013 at 20:17:51
Duffy has never done anything to warrant the clamour that he gets. He's not quick nor can he pass when I've actually seen him. He's just big.

Hope he does well in future but he's always looked consistently average

John Ford
56 Posted 15/07/2013 at 20:43:09
Totally agree that Fellaini should be just in front of the back four. He can do a job up front but he is far better employed as defensive cover where he's able to impose himself in the most important area of the field. He has more options around him now too.

......I'm not sure how or even if a Gibson Fellaini centre pair would work though.

Sean Roberts
59 Posted 15/07/2013 at 21:01:45
Hopefully under the new manager some of the better ball players will actually make themselves available for jags to play a simple ball to; then they can pick the Hollywood passes out and leave jags to do the main part of his job.... To defend!!!
Phil Brown
60 Posted 15/07/2013 at 21:11:37
Re Duffy's poor performance - might he, and the others, be pretty tired after the first week of pre-season, even if with more of the ball?

Tiredness affects some more than others and Duffy is not the most elegant athlete in the squad. They all deserve more chances although I think that he, Lundstrum, Garbutt, Stones and Vellios would benefit from a season on-loan in the Championship.

Ross Barkley may benefit from a half-season loan at one of the clubs at the top of the Championship, he needs to get his confidence back, thought he did pretty well at the U20 WC but could have shown a lot more, he has it in him to have been the stand-out player at that tournament.

Mind you, he had a very heavy load to carry!

Phil Sammon
61 Posted 15/07/2013 at 21:24:37
Phil

Like all Phil's you talk a lot of sense.

Duffy would benefit from a year in the Championship. He has one tremendous strength - ariel ability. He has one major weakness - pace. Sadly, in the Premier League pace is very important. If you don't have it as a centre back then you had better have 10 yards in your head. Duffy is not going to gain that sitting on the bench, he needs to go out on loan. I think he could actually become a top Championship CB within a year or two, due to the differing styles of play, whether he can make a step up into the Prem is another challenge for him.

Mark Frere
62 Posted 15/07/2013 at 21:19:11
John Ford

I think a CM pairing of Gibson and Fellaini could work perfectly well, just as long as Fellaini keeps his discipline and sits in front of the back 4 and doesn't venture forward too much.

Gibson will be the deep lying CM with the good range of passing, and Fellaini will be the midfield destroyer. A bit like Xavi and Busquets at Barcelona, or dare I say like Alonso and Mascherano at the RS a few years ago. I'm not saying DG and MF are as good as Xavi and Busquets, but they could have the similar qualities.

All been said though, I still hope Fellaini is sold so RM can improve the overall quality of our squad with players of his choice

James McPherson
63 Posted 15/07/2013 at 21:41:05
".. and a lot more concentration required - and that sometimes isn't the easiest thing when you're tired.".

Modern day footballers...
priceless.

Just when many of us are tired through lack of sleep worrying about keeping our jobs and avoiding financial armageddon...

Love football...hate footballers...no matter whether they don the blue of EFC....am I alone?

Drew Shortis
64 Posted 15/07/2013 at 21:33:56
I wonder if Fellaini is played in his preferred defensive midfield role he will go missing from matches less often?

If he is in the thick of things he will have to be winning the ball to protect the back line, not be wandering up-field waiting for a pass where he can end up drifting out of the game. His tackling is good, as is his passing, but for me his greatest asset is his strength and ability to hold onto the ball when he has players snapping around him.

In a deeper role he can be the linchpin that our game pivots on. This would ease the burden on the centre-backs as they will have someone to pick out and take over the burden of playing the ball out of defence. Alongside Gibson in a slightly more central role we can build our attacks from a strong core.

Osman is too lightweight in the centre and no good out wide, which only leaves the attacking midfield role. I know Jags pass to him yesterday was terrible, but he was brushed off the ball way to easily. We need presence in that central area. Osman always looks better in the final third when his quick feet and eye for a shot come into play more.

Felli did a great job for us last year and got the goals we were lacking from the strikers, but I think the likes of Kone, Mirallas and Deulofeu can take over this responsibility and allow Fellaini to thrive in his preferred role.

Phil Sammon
65 Posted 15/07/2013 at 22:02:08
Mark Frere

I get what you're saying about these CM partnerships. However there seems to be an obvious problem. Every other partnership has a deep lying 'enforcer' who's main asset is tackling. The CM ahead of them is normally the more technically gifted player with a wide range of passing.

Unfortunately, we at Everton have all those attributes in our two CM's, but they are not ideally distributed. Fellaini is our enforcer - but is not a deep lying midfielder. Gibson has the keys to unlock defences but prefers to sit just in front of the defenders.

Perhaps the key is to have Fellaini sit deeper than Gibbo - which I can't recall ever happening. If Fellaini drives on, Gibbo can sit in. Ask type this I'm actually convincing myself that this is the way we should play next season.

Thoughts?

Kev Johnson
66 Posted 15/07/2013 at 22:10:56
Maybe our poor passing in the Vienna game was due to excessive ball work in training? When it came to the game, we would sick of the bloody ball and just wanted to get rid of it. Bring back the sand dunes!

I say "our poor passing" but I'm just going on the TW reports. I didn't see the game. I'm hoping free highlights become available on Everton TV at some point.

Phil Sammon
67 Posted 15/07/2013 at 22:13:24
*As I type this*
Mark Frere
68 Posted 15/07/2013 at 22:28:54
Well Phil, that was basically what I was trying to say when I wrote Fellaini needs to keep his discipline, and just sit in front of the back 4, not venture forward too often.

When Gibson first signed for us, I don't think anyone including Moyes thought he was signing a holding midfield player, Gibson by his own admission just sort of made that role his own.

I think Gibson has all the attributes to play a little further forward than MF, and it would make more sense IMO. My only concern is, like I said before, Fellaini never seems capable of just sitting in front of the back 4 like C. Makelelele used to do so successfully for Chelsea

Kev Johnson
69 Posted 15/07/2013 at 22:54:58
I don't think Fellaini is currently capable of playing in front of the back four because he lacks one of the crucial qualities for that role - concentration.

It's not just a case of him remembering to stay back, it's a case of him being more spatially aware and being responsible for picking up opposition players when we are not in possession.

It's a rare player who can actually do that role well., and it might even be getting rarer. For the last ten years, holding midfielders have been all the rage but playing styles tend to change and I think the role is pretty much exhausted. Certainly if RM plays a 3-4-3 of a 4-3-3 then the defensive/holding midfielder is redundant.

Phil Sammon
70 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:06:10
Mark

Sorry if I elongated your succinct point, I just thought I'd clarify exactly what I see on the pitch.

I think the problem is that Fellaini sees himself as a box to box midfielder. I'm sorry to raise his name on this forum but Satan Gerrard is about as good a B2B midfielder as you're going to get. Fellaini has so many fantastic qualities, but I still don't see him driving the ball forward, laying on passes for full backs to run onto.

Hand on heart, I think we've seen the best of Fellaini. He is world class on his day, in the right position and against the right team. But a lot of the time he's just a good player.

Colin Glassar
71 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:28:58
Sounds like DM is ready to trigger the release clause for Fellaini. £50m for him and Fabregas.
Mark Frere
72 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:17:51
Good point Phil, I think Fellaini has always been a box to box player, a real handful on his day.

Kev Johnson - I think your right, the defensive/holding midfield players are a bit of a dying breed. I'm just trying to think of a PL player who is a specialist at playing that role. Guess what - I can't actually think of one. wheres Owen Hargreeves nowadays? Mikel at Cheasea maybe or Sandro at Spurs.

I don't actually agree that formations have anything to do with lack of holding midfielders. Chelsea used to play 4-3-3 when Makelele played there and Barcelona play 4-3-3

Kev Johnson
73 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:37:06
Colin - I very much enjoy your good humour, but your transfer speculation is well off target! If Man Utd buy Fabregas, then they definitely won't buy another central midfielder.Surely that's obvious.
Colin Glassar
74 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:40:14
Not according to The Guardian Kev (serious paper). It makes sense as Fellaini will play deep while Fabregas will be the creative player. Who else do they have? Carrick? The rest (Nani, Valencia, Young etc....) are wingers.
Kev Johnson
75 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:44:03
I'd say Cleverley is a first choice, Colin. Then there's Kagawa and, as you say, Carrick. (Plus the far from excellent Anderson.) I don't see it, mate.
Colin Glassar
76 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:50:11
Well cleverly is a poor mans Scott Gemmil IMO. Kagawa was disappointing last season, Anderson is rubbish according to the mancs themselves which leaves carrick as their only dependable MF player.
Tony Farrell
77 Posted 15/07/2013 at 23:32:02
A lot of supporters on here are having a pop at Jags, reffering to his new style of play under El Bob. I have played football all my life (at good levels) and a good centreback was paramount. You don't have to be a brilliant footballer but a reader of the game knowing where and when to position yourself.

To me, Jags has these qualities; he dosen't have to thread 30-yard passes – his job is to stop strikers and to me he does that. There's not a defender in the Premier League that sweats blood for his team like him. How many times has he thrown in last-ditch tackles to prevent goals?

Once he's won his challenge, all he needs to do is pass a 5-yard ball to his midfielder, then it's their job to make killer passes. So come on, boys, give him the credit he deserves. He's good at what he does, don't try and change him, Bob. Get the midfielders to do their job.

(I played in midfield and I was told to always support ya defenders by being in a position to receive the ball off them.)

Jim Knightley
78 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:27:05
Colin, Kagawa wasn't disappointing..don't believe his rhetoric. He had injury problems...and displaced Rooney in matches at the end of the season. He can be remarkable player next season if used in an AMC role by Moyes. Did anyone see him for Borussia? or indeed his performances for United at the end of the season?

I don't get the hype re. Cleverly though... I think he will end up at a bottom half Prem team soon enough. Jones could have a future as a dm, based on his first league performance against Real in the Champ League, although I see him as a CB long term. He has that versatility which is a gift, and a curse.

I also don't agree that holding mids have gone Kev...look at the best European teams. Barca have Busqets, Bayern have Martinez, Real have Khedira (and arguably Alonso). They are just less one dimensional now. Similarly, City generally have used at least one holding mid in the league, whilst Chelski have used Mikel, and most recently Luiz. I think the ideal now, is a holding midfielder next to a deep lying play maker or even a box to box mid, with 3 attacking mids (one AMC, and two wide men) supporting a striker. I think Fellaini could perhaps play next to a more defensively orientated one, and act as a transition behind defense and attack. I think Yaya is the perfect representation of that transition type...and I think Fer will be a really good example of it for Norwich.

Andy Crooks
79 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:28:46
So Duffy has had a holiday and was shite on his return. His performance in our Vienna Champion League qualifier really should see him fucked off to the lower leagues where he belongs. I believe Mirallas Fellaini and Jagielka were equally poor.Let's get rid of them too.

It seems to me that there are some ready to write off young players after a totally meaningless game.Shane Duffy is a quality defender.I have seen it and I know it.

Jim Knightley
80 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:41:22
I'm not sure about Duffy...but I'm with Andy entirely. Messi could look crap in the first game back after a few months off...esp in a team which is not use to playing together, and coping with a managerial and consequently a tactical transition. Judge players on Pre-season friendlies by all means...if they are happening a week or two before the start of the season. The rest are for fitness, tactical transition and assessment...and that's all.
Denis Richardson
82 Posted 16/07/2013 at 09:13:44
Good to read that some of the youngsters impressed in hte first warm up game (velios, oviedo, junior).

Not surprised to read that Naismith and Gueye were shite (again) - need to just get rid of these two, if only to get them off the wage bill. They won't ever be first team regulars.

Conn Prosser
83 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:36:49
I've never been a fan of fellaini. Not when he was a lazy whining donkey with ludicrous elbows and not even when he was banging them for a few weeks before christmas last year. He's awkward and a liability for suspensions etc. phil and mark point out the problems of where he would best-fit this new system. Save the bother, OFFLOAD and get a player that will fit - we're not going to be hanging the entire team around him like last time. I honestly don't see any club bidding 20 mill though, regardless of release clause.

Just my opinion and I know it's controversial. But the 'unplayable on his day' monicker applies to too few days.

Derek Wadeson
84 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:54:13
As some of the "other operating costs" have recently been spent on the Goodison Park pitch making it ideal to play pass and move football on. What is wrong with RM demanding that the players use it to it's maximum effect?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads