Fellaini remains a big part of Martinez's plans

, 15 July, 191comments  |  Jump to most recent

While speculation continues over Maroaune Fellaini's future, Roberto Martinez is keen to stress that he sees the Belgian as an integral part of his plans for his first season in charge at Everton.

The Guardian have raised the prospect of David Moyes pairing the man he initially signed from Standard Liege with Cesc Fabregas at Manchester United, but Martinez sees the 25 year-old continuing his development into one of the Premier League's finest midfielders at Goodison Park.

"Marouane is an international footballer and he's going to be involved, if all goes well, in a World Cup next year," the new Blues boss told evertonfc.com.

"He's had a fantastic impact in the Premier League and hopefully now is the time he can carry on showing his massive influence in the game for us.

As if to further impress his importance to Everton on Fellaini, Martinez made the midfield powerhouse captain in the second half of Sunday's friendly against Austria Vienna.

"He's still a very young man but I am really looking forward to seeing Marouane working hard and making sure that he sets really good standards at this club," Martinez continued.

"We have a very good group of senior players in our dressing room, and some players need that extra bit of responsibility.

"We have youngsters at the club and they need to get opportunities but the senior players at the club are massively important to start the season as strong as we can be."

Moyes is reported to have offered Barcelona £26m for Fabregas and it would take a bid of a similar or equal amount to trigger Fellaini's release clause and prise him away from Everton this summer.

 

Reader Comments (191)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Andrew James
2 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:10:30
Moyes is not the class act I once thought he was.

If he is out there bidding for our players he should take a look at himself. We gave him a massive opportunity. He should do the honourable thing and see Everton as a no go area for transfers for at least a season.

It's the hypocrisy that winds me up most. Remember the Lescott saga yet now we hear Manure are in for nearly half that amount for Baines?

Andrew James
3 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:15:32
And to add...wow Bobby M is a heck of an optimist.

I bet we do either do Arsenal or the RS at their place this coming season.

Otherwise, we will finish...errr...6th....

Andy Crooks
4 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:20:03
Andrew, why would Moyes do the honourable thing?. He said that he had good players at Everton but has excellent players at Man U. Self serving and vastly over rated. I predict an Old Trafford MOB by the end of October.

I'd like us to keep what we've got and add one more.. I would honestly rather have Martinez and our squad than Moyes and theirs.

Jim Knightley
5 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:37:04
I don't see why Moyes shouldn't bid for our players? esp ones with releases clauses. There is miles of difference between this and the Lescott scenario. And remember...Moyes contract was up with us..he didn't leave with 3/4/5 years left and he did as much for us (look at our positions in the 10 years before he came) as we did for him. The important thing, if having to sell a player, is to get the right price. Personally, I think 24million for us would be the right price, and would allow us to bring in a couple of top players to improve both our first 11, and team. It doesn't matter whether this 24million comes from United, or Juventus.
Dennis Stevens
6 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:37:20
October, Andy? I'm not sure they'll give him that long before they lose patience.
Albert Perkins
7 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:38:59
To be worth the asking price, I think Felli will have to learn to control his temper and develop his tackling ability a bit more. Some commentators still stereotype him as all elbows and fouls. And big hair!

And of course, occasionally unplayable. He is still not the finished product, fortunately. One more season till Roberto sorts himself and his team out to see who he needs to balance the play.

Phil Davies
8 Posted 16/07/2013 at 00:47:34
I don't have a problem with Moyes coming back for any players, he shouldn't have any loyalty to Everton any more as he has nothing to do with us. I treat him like any other manager in football if he wants any players from Everton then he will have to pay the price that is set for them.

On another point Martinez comes across as a real man manager and it will be interesting to see how players react to that as Moyes never seemed the type to put his arm round your shoulder and give you that extra encouragement.

Patrick Murphy
9 Posted 16/07/2013 at 01:09:42

The Mirror are reporting that Jelavic and his agents are unsettled following the arrival of Kone and he doesn't see his future spending a large part of the season prior to the WC in Brazil sitting on the bench. They claim that he seeks talks with RM in the coming week and that his agents want to know what his asking price will be if he leaves in the current window.

I can't see us fetching much of a fee for him given his poor form last season, although he could be used in a makeweight in a swap deal.

Jim Knightley
10 Posted 16/07/2013 at 01:15:13
I reckon if Jelavic did go, we could still recoup a good 6-7million for him. He has a good standing on the continent, is a current international, and showed he could cut, albeit only for a little bit, in the Prem.
Alan Smith
11 Posted 16/07/2013 at 01:12:49
Nice one Jim,

Get £24m for Fellaini and buy two players blah blah.

Rooney and Fellaini at Man U next season. Bains too possibly

Arteta at arsenal

Rodwell and lescott at man city

FFS when will the penny drop? 5 ex players in the top 4 and we will be sixth again or maybe even 7th.

Who do we get in better, after we have sold?

We're would we finish with them 5 and the rest of our squad?

There's a reason why Martinez made Fellaini cpt in that friendly. There's a reason why man utd and arsenal want him. There a reason why Belgium pick him every game yet hazard was on the bench last WC qualifier. Can we not give him the same love as bains? If he reads these pages there is no chance of him staying

Alan Baillie
12 Posted 16/07/2013 at 01:36:56
Alan 050: I really don't think Fellaini would be arsed on anything the fans said. I believe that the problem with fans like me have is that all we hear from him (true or not) is negative comments about staying with us. He has never given me the feeling that he is a Baines when it comes to EFC. Guess its called feeling that the player has respect for EFC.
Chris Jones
13 Posted 16/07/2013 at 01:56:59
I reckon Roberto's playing this just right: talk the big Fella up in the media, give him the armband in a pre-season game and do the "part of our future" thing. Remember the way he spoke about Baines in he media too. This can leave both players in no doubt about their value to the manager and the club in general.

All this talk about what we could do with the money and I'm left with the feeling that we'll be better off keeping both players if both feel wanted by the manager - something the previous incumbent didn't seem capable of expressing.

Alan Smith
14 Posted 16/07/2013 at 01:46:23
Your right. But football is cold business. You may feel bains is one if us. He may be more respectful by keeping his trap shut. Or rather, his dad keeps it shut.

But im talking in cold hard facts. Fellaini is pure class and he contributes just as much to the team as bains, if not more. Goals wise, possession wise, tackles wise.

And saying otherwise is wrong in two ways. One, your deluding yourself and two your not encouraging a player we need to stay.

Its highly unlikely bains would turn down a move to Man U anyway. Just because his keeps his council doesn't make him any more loyal than Fellaini. If loyalty even matters. All I care about is contribution to the team.

Given a straight choice both would pick Man U.

I think there's a lot of evertonians who spent the fellianis first season criticising him so much that they ended up looking stupid when he turned out to be great. And they still have that in the back of their minds. They think they can vindicate themselves in some way.

Either way, ill tell the truth. What ever he or his dad say of the pitch the lad has been class. Immense work rate, fantastic touch an ball control, always wants the ball, always gets stuck in and scores goals. Brilliant from day one and Everton are better with him than without him.

I think love works both ways. Give to him he might give back. In fact I've heard him say loads of positive things about us.

It's crazy cant imagine arsenal fans in such high numbers nit picking over Viera. And yes I am comparing the two

James Stewart
16 Posted 16/07/2013 at 03:35:05
He'll be at United come 1st September. He's been itching to move for awhile so let him have his move. Could be replaced easily enough. Baines could not thats the difference.
Laurie Hartley
17 Posted 16/07/2013 at 04:16:32
Jim @ 042

"It doesn't matter whether this 24million comes from United, or Juventus."

Not being smart Jim but it does matter. Fellaini was perhaps the biggest difference between us and United when we beat them last season. We will be playing them twice next season - Juventus - we will have to wait for another year.

COTB

Stuart Gray
18 Posted 16/07/2013 at 06:04:09
If Moyes is to come in for Fellaini I'll be pissed off. Not because he had come in for him but because he hasn't done it straight away. I think he owes it to us to get this wrapped up so we can push on.
Ben Hayes
19 Posted 16/07/2013 at 06:47:04
Alan, btw it's Baines, I can see positives if we sell Felliani or keep him, if we sell lets do it soon and get 3 players 2 cm and a playmaker looks like Honda is going to ac Milan though
John Ford
20 Posted 16/07/2013 at 07:27:56
It's confirmation if ever it were needed of our standing if we continue to be happy to sell our best players in the hope that we replace them with the same quality. I've no problem with Moyes coming for Fellaini, that's his job. What a message it would send if Martinez could actually retain Fellaini and Baines. A statement of intent about what we are trying to become.
David Donnellan
21 Posted 16/07/2013 at 07:29:27
Although im not in 100% agreement of what Alan Smith has said, I do agree with him on post #050, we do sell our best players to rival top 4 sides every season & end up stagnating around 6th or 7th. We never really replace what we sell straight away either. I can remember a time when we would never have sold our best players consistently to the likes of Man Utd, Arsenal, etc.. Its sad that we have become a selling club over the years..I remember when we were much more than that.
Liam Reilly
22 Posted 16/07/2013 at 07:36:52
The difference between Moyes and any other Manager coming in for our players is that he knows what BK will accept for each of them, so the club is at a disadvantage.

Same when any Manager joins a rival however. Its just part of the game. If either of them are to go, needs to happen quickly.

Mike Green
23 Posted 16/07/2013 at 07:42:25
Fellaini is fair game, just as Kone, Alcaraz and Robles were for us.

I think so far Martinez has done a great job getting players in, especially when you add the Deulofeu coup to the three above. Now we're probably going to see how he handles keeping players or selling them on, and my gut feeling is he's not going to let anyone take him for a mug.

Martinez is saying and doing the right things with Fellaini but behind closed doors would he rather have £24m in his back pocket to strengthen the squad? Are we sure Moyes really does want Fellaini at that sort of price?

I don't think he's going anywhere to be honest but if he does, and we get decent money for him I won't be too bothered provided Martinez gets every penny to spend. It's a new dawn after all.

As for Jelly - a bit different, if he doesn't like it he can do one! Sulky fucker.

Paul Gladwell
24 Posted 16/07/2013 at 08:29:24
Alan, we don't give him the same love as Baines as Baines has been performing 8/10+ each week for three years solid playing every game.
Fellaini on the other hand plays World class at the start of the season, goes AWOL for two months, gets suspended for how many games, plays great for a month then goes AWOL at games at Anfield, Wigan and Wembley and him and his father each year appear to instigate big clubs to come and get him, whilst Baines goes about his business with dignity.
Peter Warren
25 Posted 16/07/2013 at 08:46:50
Paul 81# Fellaini is a fantastic player. I thought he was our best player at Wembley v Chelsea. I've also seen him have immense games away at Old Trafford, Ethiad and Emirates. Unsure why you say he goes missing in the big games. He was crap in cup against Wigan and everybody on his back since then.

£24m I believe is cheap. I don't understand why people are desparate for any of our players to go. I'm happy to place trust in Martinez and give him a chance.

Roberto Birquet
27 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:14:26
Laurie 59
We're playing Juve this month.
Laurie Hartley
28 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:19:36
Roberto - I'll go to the corner.

But I wish we wouldn't sell our best players to the opposition.

Kevin Tully
29 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:33:12
Let Fellaini go, we have plenty of tough tackling, ball winning midfielders who can play as a striker, and end the season as our top scorer.

Most of our team couldn't tackle a full breakfast - does anyone actually take any notice of what Fellaini actually does in a game?

Let him & Baines go to United, our two best players. Fuckin' great start for Martinez.

Kevin Tully
30 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:44:27
Mike #076 - Kone publicly stated he wanted to leave, Alcaraz had no contract, and Robles came from Athletico Madrid.

How is that even remotely the same situation as Baines & Felliani??

Ged Simpson
31 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:52:28
I think Fella is crucial to us next season. He does loads of unseen work
Sam Hoare
32 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:04:10
Kevin 108, Fellaini has publicly stated that he wants to play for a champions league club many time.

I say if he doesn't want to be here then let him go.

As for Baines, Man U have been chasing him for a while, if they pay the money and he wants to go then fair play to him but I reckon he'll be staying.

Paul Gladwell
33 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:58:53
Peter, I think he is a very good player, I spent two years backing him on here when he first came.
He had a great game against Arsenal last year and Man Utd, however he goes AWOL at Anfield each year and was below par for a good while last year after a great start and in our two last biggest games against Wigan and at Wembley he vanished and for the hype he receives about how good he is he should be doing more in my opinion, he`s not in the same league as Baines with regards to consistency and value for money.
Paul Gladwell
34 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:08:24
And I also want him to stay, why sell him and spend £10m on a gamble?
Barry Rathbone
35 Posted 16/07/2013 at 10:52:32
Moyes owes us nothing he never uttered a word to support the ludicrous myth of honour he was as detached from EFC as Benitez..

If he wasn't giving interviews about managing elsewhere he wasn't talking.

The media and Kenwright cast the bait about loyalty, miracle worker etc and boy did people take it

Suggesting he shouldn't come back for any of our players ahead of the interests of his new club is as unreal as the original myth.

Kevin Tully
36 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:06:30
Yes he did Sam, but that's par for the course in most interviews he's given whilst on International duty.

As far as I'm aware, he hasn't publicly said he wants to leave?

Baines certainly wouldn't be actively looking to leave the club this summer.

The problem is though Sam, it's going to be hard enough for any new manager - losing your top scorer, and the best left back in the P.L. will really upset the balance of the team.

Give him twelve months to implement his ideas, and it may be easier to let them go.

I am sure Fellaini is half being pushed anyway, by the "We've got no money" buffoons who own this club. ( I get a little embarrassed every time I type that, I don't know how they can show their face at a match!)

Ged Simpson
37 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:17:26
Do we have money K ?
Alan Smith
38 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:01:28
People moan about fellianis dad agitating for a big moves all the time. But that's not him it's his dad. Do people really think bains' agent isn't behind the scenes asking Man U and bayern to up there bid?

Does anyone really care what players parents and agents want? If so, why?

I care weather that player is making a good contribution on the pitch. If he is, I want him to stay. If people want to mention consistency I can think of only one game, Wigan, in four years were fellianis performance dropped below 8/10.

If people want to clutch at straws and go on about his suspensions I have 2 words; Keane and viera.

Kieran Fitzgerald
39 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:16:50
Alan and David, where does the money come from to buy these players in the first place? When did we last go into a transfer window with a spare 15m to 20m just lying around the place?

It's the same tired line all the time. We sell all our best players. That's shit that is. However, I've also conveniently forgotten, or chosen to ignore, that the club doesn't have a pot to piss in, has no other revenue stream, unless you count the T.V. money, which is already promised to other people to pay debts, and the Board refuse to put one penny of it's own money into the club.

We have to sell in order to buy. Moyes had to wheel and deal and I bet you that Martinez will too. We never have enough quality at any one time not to. How often have we seen that our first eleven is quite good but the squad overall can't hack it?

Where will the money come from to keep the first eleven and buy two or three quality players? Serious question, where do you think it will come from at the moment?

I'm not happy with selling players either. But unless we win the euromillions, or can fool the quality players into thinking that they can win league titles with us and earn 200,000 quid a week, then we're going to be selling our best players.

And for what it's worth, I am genuinely surprised that Baines, Felliani and Mirallas are still here of their own accord and that the first two have stayed for as long as they have.

Kevin Tully
40 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:28:12
Ged, the extra £15-20m T.V. money may be there to spend, but I doubt it.

I don't think they have renewed the Vibrac Loan this year, but there is still time.

We may be using the new T.V. money in place of the Vibrac loan, which was around £14m plus interest & arrangement fees.

Ciarán McGlone
41 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:26:03
To suggest Fellaini is as important to us as Baines.. Or has been as good or as consistent - is utter nonsense.

Fellaini is a luxury player who has had far more stinkers than shiners at Everton..

When we bought him some defended his price are still clinging to their belief that hes the next Viera.. He isn't.

20 mill is about right.

Alan Smith
42 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:27:52
Fellaini's being pushed by our own fans.

Some if our fans are actually worse than our inept board. They want to sell our best players to rivals making them stronger and us weaker.

This one month after an EGM when we learnt our wage bill was only £63m and the debt is serviceable. And non of us are Everton's bank manager were its fans.

The squad is now big enough for not being in Europe. I can't see any advantage in Fellaini or bains going.

Someone needs to make a category for all you "sell to buy three" fuckers. STBT's or amateur bank managers ABM 's. you all must be music to BK's ears

We've just got 4 in without selling!

Sam Hoare
43 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:36:05
Kevin, he publicly stated that he would be moving on I think last summer or so, though you never know how much is lost in translation.

I think Fella is a tremendous player and does great service for the team, lots of which goes un-noticed. However his wages are enormous and I would rather RM have 24m to spend than to carry on with a player who's heart is not really in it. Our results without him last year suggest that we could manage OK though you're right when you say we would need to bring in a dynamic midfielder to cover ground and make tackles as I don't see anyone else in the squad doing that.

Harold Matthews
44 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:14:20
I'm a big fan of Fellaini even though he and his mate,Mirallis, don't always bust a gut against lower opposition.
The other day on ESPN they raved about his performances for Belgium and how he had become a leader.

Nevertheless, he and his dad appear to be chasing big money and I'll be surprised if he stays.

My main concern is pre-season preparation. Professionals are continually stressing how it can make or break the year which lies ahead and we don't want to be bringing in players on Sept 2nd..

Let's hope it's sorted soon.

Sam Hoare
45 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:42:16
Ciaran, if 20m is about right then those who defended his price were correct to do so.
Kieran Fitzgerald
46 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:41:39
Alan, answer the question, where will the money come from?

Kone and Rubles cost the guts of 8m between them. Where will the money come from to pay for that? Spare cash we have floating around? More debt? Or selling players?

To buy someone of the quality of Mirallas will cost at least 5m, where will we get that money from?

Where Alan?

Kevin Tully
47 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:48:12
Ciarán, How can you say our top tackler (and top scorer) is a luxury player???

"First thing’s first, his statistics were good last year. The fact he only managed half a season will have undoubtedly affected the Toffees who are always a far more resilient outfit with Fellaini on board. However, there are a few areas where he has clearly taken his game to a new level this season.
First up, tackling. As mentioned, Everton are now the best tacklers in the Premier League. Nobody beats their 79% team tally and they are clearly lead here by their influential Belgian. He is easily the side’s top ball winner and, over time, has dramatically honed his tackling skills which are right up there with the best in the league. He is now making 87% count over the respectable 71% he managed last season, a truly impressive transposition."

"Easily the side's top ball winner"

Because he's clumsy, I think people vastly underrate his tackling.

Jim Knightley
48 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:48:28
Alan...where we would be if we had all those players? In a fantasy land, where our owner supported investment. In case it's escaped your attention, we have sold to buy under Moyes...and making 28million or whatever for Rooney, or whatever for Lescott, has allowed us to invest in the likes of Baines and Fellaini

I'm with Ciaran, 20mil is about right. Fellaini can be fantastic...but he is as good as Mata, Hazard, Cazorla or Thiago? all of whom have been sold for around, or less than, his reported buy out clause. Bullocks. Get your head out of the clouds Alan...without selling, this season, Swansea, Southampton and Norwich will all have outspent us by the end of the window. We sell to survive, to maintain our position, or to improve... we will always have to do that under the current ownership. It comes down to whether we can get a good price for a player...and for Fellaini, 24million is a great price. And don't talk bollocks, fans are not forcing Fellaini out. We are just looking at a logical reality: Fellaini has a buy out clause...well documented, and supposedly Arsenal and United are interested (which is just supposition btw). To consider whether to sell him or not, on a fan discussion board, makes logical sense.

Ciarán McGlone
49 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:47:09
Sam.. They defended the price on the basis of his anticipated progression-not inflation.
Colin Glassar
50 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:57:56
In all fairness to Fellaini all he has ever said is that he wants to play European football WITH Everton. If not, then he'll move on which is understandable IMO. I bet Bainsey, Ossie, Mirallas etc...all feel the same. It's not a crime to be ambitious is it? Felli might've felt that under the previous regime that ambition wasn't matched with his.
Kevin Tully
51 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:58:44
If any player is looking to move, such as Lescott or Rooney, sell them quickly and get the best deal we can.

I don't agree we should be pushing our most effective midfielder out of the door when a) we may not attract a decent replacement, and b) Half the money may go toward servicing the debt.

I said on another thread, I would be happy to start the season as we are. It's galling to see clubs like Southampton, Norwich and Swansea leave us trailing in the transfer market, but that's where we are with the"Super scrimpers" as our money men.

Phil Walling
52 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:03:00
If we were to lose both Felli and Baines Roberto`s chances of replicating Moyes` average 6/7th would become nigh impossible.
OK,he might-just might-get half the money to replace them but whoever came in would need time to settle and are most unlikely to be as good.
Oviedo looks half decent and I guess Barkly could do a job but neither are within a mile of our two `stars` but you wouldn`t want to depend on either of them.
Interesting close season,isn`t it?
Alan Smith
53 Posted 16/07/2013 at 11:45:26
Ciaran

"More stinkers than shiners."

Can't believe what your saying. Last season he played out if posn yet gave a 100% in most games and finished leading scorer.
In previous seasons when he played CM he consistently dominated possession in ever home game we played. The away games I watched on TV he was class too.

If your right and I'm wrong. Moyes, wenga, the Belgium coach must all be mad.

Would you rather have Gibson and Osman over Fellaini?

Becuase that's what your advicating.

Kevin Tully
54 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:11:13
This isn't a bad link to paste on your desktop to compare spending as it progresses ;

http://www.soccernews.com/soccer-transfers/english-premier-league-transfers/

Sam Hoare
55 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:10:16
Ciaran, as you well know inflation does not work quite so simply with footballer, just look at Andy Carroll. The fact that we will likely sell him for upwards of £20m more than vindicates his purchase price.
Colin Glassar
56 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:11:20
We are being strongly linked today with moves for Rolando, Toby and Sighiueros, all defenders. If true, this means that Robbie either A) doesn't rate our defence or B) someone big is leaving.
I think it is option A as he wants players who are comfortable with the ball. Obviously, to finance this, some players (not Baines) might leave e.g. Heitinga.
Max Wilson
57 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:22:15
Well, from what everyone is saying, if Baines and Fellaini DO want away, what we have presently will not replace them. Maybe some of the youngsters will eventually come on and grow into masters of their game like these two.

What we are buying seems to be attempts at finding bargains — but let's be realistic: how often does this come off? Not very often, I don`t care how good a coach someone is. There is now a wait to see what we are left with before we know what sort of season we can expect. Weren't we all told that Moyes had agreed to lay off our players? It sounds like bullshit.

David Donnellan
58 Posted 16/07/2013 at 12:48:14
Kieran #123, I don't disagree with the point you are making, i'm just disappointed that, that is where we are as a club. Especially as some on here have alluded to, Swansea, Norwich & Southampton are leaving us behind in the spending stakes. We will always finish around 6th/7th, with our current transfer policy. I just want to see us move to the next level, where we once were.
Under this current board, I acknowledge that we will forever be selling our best players to generate funds for players. It just narks me when we sell to teams in the top 4 whom we would never of sold to in the past.
Ross Edwards
59 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:01:13
Just let him go. The more this "will he, won't he" saga goes on for, the more this affects morale in the squad with the uncertainty. If a club meets the clause, let him go and then we can spend that money on some replacements.
Craig Walker
60 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:14:01
Interesting that Moyes the other day said in a press conference that he was amazed at how much the Man United players wanted to win, even in training. To me it implied that he never had that at Everton. Despite that, he still seems keen to raid our players. Moyes set out his stall every season with the objective of reaching 40 points. If you set your sights so low then you can hardly blame the players for going to places like Anfield, OT, Stamford Bridge, Emirates etc. and having an inferiority complex. I, for one am encouraged by RM's enthusiasm and positivity and it makes a welcome change to Moyes' pragmatism and negativity.
Kev Johnson
61 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:17:14
That doesn't really help, Ross. Yes, obviously if someone meets the sum stipulated by the release clause then we will "let him" go - that's the kind of the whole point of the clause!
Ross Edwards
62 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:19:17
Just as long as we get the money Kev, I don't care where he goes.
Ross Edwards
63 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:20:06
Craig

"Interesting that Moyes the other day said in a press conference that he was amazed at how much the Man United players wanted to win, even in training"

Mr Obvious with another one for the scrapbook, welcome to your new world Mr Moyes!!

Colin Glassar
64 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:22:38
Spot on Craig. I've said it before and I'll say it again, Moyes is not a natural born winner.
Jay Harris
65 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:09:41
Why would top 4 clubs pay around 24 million for Felli when there are better options available?

Why? Because there are NOT better options available at that price. Felli is a world class player and all football experts know it. His link up play,pitch covering and goal contribution is only matched by a few

Top midfielders are at a premium so why would we want to sell him.

In addition he has been at the club for so long now he is familiar with the setup and most of his colleagues.

You don't blow stability you build on it.

Mark Tanton
66 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:25:49
Fabragas doesn't want to move, he's rejected any notion of joining Utd.

A) Is Moyes finding it hard to attract top players because he's not a household name?

B) Next stop Fellaini?

Jay Harris
67 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:09:41
Why would top 4 clubs pay around 24 million for Felli when there are better options available?

Why? Because there are NOT better options available at that price. Felli is a world class player and all football experts know it. His link up play,pitch covering and goal contribution is only matched by a few

Top midfielders are at a premium so why would we want to sell him.

In addition he has been at the club for so long now he is familiar with the setup and most of his colleagues.

You don't blow stability you build on it.

Kevin Tully
68 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:32:45
Colin#148 - Didn't 'Rolando' (chubby goalie) play for the Grange Hill first XI?
Jim Knightley
69 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:31:12
Craig and others...it's too easy to blame Moyes. The reality is that, our players are at our club, because they are not quite good enough, in general, for a top top team. Part of that reason, is because they lack the winning mentality. Just like in Tennis...there are top players, who never quite manage to win a Grand Slam, because they lack what has been described as a 'killer extinct'. Works the same way in football. You can't go sticking everything at the manager's door... do you not think that some footballers are too blame? Do you think Ronaldo is so good because of a manager? do you think Federer held his nerve on so many big points because of a coach? Some players have fantastic ability, others have fantastic ability and incredible mental strength.

Jay you suppose two things 1) That big clubs want Fellaini. Firstly, who has made an official offer? United and Arsenal, two of the clubs supposedly interested, have both bid for Fabregas and Suarez respectively, implying that they have other priority targets. Similarly, City added Fernandinho and Garcia the summer before instead of bidding for Fellaini. Chelski also havent made a bid.
2) As previously mentioned, top mids have been sold for less, or around Fellaini's buy clause.

Question everyone - why are we discussing Fellaini? answer: his RELEASE CLAUSE. There is alot of talk about us pushing him out the door (absolutely bullocks), but why does he have a release clause? because he wanted one. Why did he discuss a transfer openly after his stock rose again last season? because he wants a big move. If United, or Arsenal, or Chelski put a bid in for Fellaini...I'd guarantee he'd be asking for a move within a day or two.

Kev Johnson
70 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:51:27
Jim Knightley - while you're online, can you answer my question on the "Ajax defender" thread? You're normally good on tactical stuff, I think.

Dan Parker
71 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:49:36
Spot on there Jim, one of the frustrations watching Everton sometimes is that you know they have the talent but they don't seem to have the winning mentality week in week out, especially evident in draws/losses or holding onto a one goal advantage against weaker teams last season. How much of this was down to Moyes' management style or tactics, we'll find out next season. I'm really looking forward to this season, we might not do quite as well for a couple of seasons while Martinez moulds his own style but it's exciting times as I felt we were really starting to stagnate. I got sick of hearing the punching above our weight nonsense and excusing our failure in cups and capturing European qualification on lack of money spent.

Completely different players but Felli reminds me of Rooney's last season with us somewhat (and Rodders when fit), he clearly had the talent, excelled in big games against the likes of ManUre but didn't always have the patience or motiviation against lesser teams.

If Felli is going, I'd rather it be sooner than later so the squad can settle and adapt ahead of the new season.

Ciarán McGlone
72 Posted 16/07/2013 at 13:38:19
If all these 'experts' think he's 'world class' (whatever that means).. Why are they not beating down our door?
Colin Glassar
73 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:04:49
Jim knightly, you are wrong sir. Moyes isn't a winner. He's won sweet FA as a manager (unlike Martinez) and with his knife in a gunfight, let's get to 40 points first mentality doesn't bode well for the mancs.
Cloughie had a team of nobodies and discarded, over the hill players but he instilled a winning mentality in them and they took the league and Europe by storm. Fergie, at Aberdeen, did the same as did Mourinho with an average Porto side.
I think you underestimate the role of the manager. It's his job to psyche the team up, his job to make them feel like super stars, his job to be positive. Was it Barry Fry who when one of his players was concussed during a game and couldn't remember his name, Fry told him he was Pele?
Andrew Ellams
74 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:12:40
The will he or won't he saga seems to taking place on here and not really anywhere else apart from small piece space fillers in the red tops. I have not seen anything concrete.

Speaking of which, Goal.com (I know) reckons we have offered Wigan £10million for McManaman but Whelan wants £15million

James Martin
75 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:12:58
He probably won't go anywhere because he's just not that good. Slow, ponderous, and can only play one position to any sort of effect (the middle presser in a 3 man midfiled between holding and attacking mid). Top sides don't buy players without pace and creativity. Look at United's targets, Alcantara, Fabregas formerly it was Modric. Notice a difference between those players and Fellaini?
Colin Glassar
76 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:26:09
I've always been a massive fan of Fellaini and would be more than happy if he stays. I think clubs might be a bit wary of him due to his disciplinary record and the fact that certain refs have it in for him. But quality wise Felli's one of the best in Europe as a CM player.
Phil Sammon
77 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:27:13
James Martin

Yes, they are entirely different players who specialise in different things.

Daft point.

Jim Knightley
78 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:12:12
I've replied Kev.

Whatever happens, I don't think the Fellaini result will be that catastrophic. If he goes, we will have a good 20mil to spend...if he stays, we will have kept one of the best central mids in the league. As I said before, I'm more concerned about Baines, because I see Baines as more essential to our play. However, I think we could buy two very good players (at least) to replace Fellaini's goals, and his defensive capacity. If he does go to United, I wouldn't be surprised if we got someone from them on loan too. Personally, I think Cleverly (although I think he is overrated) or Anderson could improve the squad and team.

Jay Harris
79 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:44:25
Some posters are correct that top players do have a winning mentality which is why the likes of Phil Neville with such a limited ability managed to get so many honours.

However I don't believe you can level that at a number of our players including Felli. How many games have we rescued from a losing position.

That is winning mentality.

Our problem is a top class goalscorer and even though I hate the guy Suarez was a steal at 20 million and that is where our problem as a club is.

The last big spend on a proven goalscorer was the Yak but can anyone honestly see us spending big on a top striker now.

And without that we will always be also rans.

Mike Green
80 Posted 16/07/2013 at 14:55:57
Kevin #108 - it's exactly the same.
Lenny Kingman
81 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:32:47
Get rid. Get the money and get in some fresh faces. His reflection belongs to yesterday.

If mediocre Moyes wants him then good. It will come back to haunt him as we sail past.

Drew Shortis
82 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:21:27
I'm stunned that so many here think so little of Fellaini. The guy is quality and that's why the likes of Man Utd and Arsenal are looking at him. I agree he could be more disciplined and he needs to work harder to ensure he is up for every game, but his physical presence and his goals were a big part in our 6th place finish last season. I hope he stays and is played in his preferred DM role. It would not be a disaster if he goes, but we would be a poorer team for it, unless Martinez excels in reinvesting the money.
Dan Parker
83 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:55:28
I wonder how much opinion results from past experiences with Rooney, Lescott, Arteta and losing such good players at the worst possible time and in the worst manner. I think most of us want Felli to stay I hope, it's just we don't want the last day of the transfer window circus coming to town.
Andy Crooks
84 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:39:15
Fellaini was magnificent in our opening game last season and looked top class.However, the game was played to suit him and I'm not sure that Roberto will play that way.

It seems to me that when on song Fellaini can look like a £30 million player, quite often he really doesn't which is why I believe we can get more for him than his value to our team is worth.

I know a few United supporters who would love to have him; if they get him he will fundamentally change the United way . He is the Moyes version of world class and I suspect he will become an expensive stick for the United supporters to beat Moyes.

Ian Bennett
85 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:58:33
Question off topic - if Suarez puts in a transfer request will his team mates wear a t-shirt of support, "free Luis"?
Patrick Murphy
86 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:10:02
Ian I am dismayed but not surprised that other English clubs are chasing the Rat! I wouldn't take him on a free, he's a despicable character and has no place in PL football.
Jim Knightley
88 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:17:36
Haha Ian :D

Patrick...of course other clubs are chasing him. He is one of the best strikers in the world...works incredibly hard, and sets up lots of opportunities for his team mates. He is a horrible individual of course...but there's a few horrible individuals who have been very good footballers (Roy Keane).

Ross Edwards
89 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:13:24
Moyes off to a good start isn't he? A month ( if you take into account his swanning around Carrington with Giggs and Fergie while still employed for a month) in the job and he has upset one of his top players already.

Losing the dressing room already methinks?

Colin Glassar
90 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:25:20
Ross, it's not sour grapes or anything but I think the job might be to big for him. He was famous for cowering some of our players with his Glasgow glare and ostracised quite a few in his time for no apparent reason. At OT with a dressing room of massive egos, full of players who've won everything under the sun, his blank C.V. might prove to be a problem.
Can you see him telling RVP he needs to improve his defending? Or that Rio needs to stop tweeting or leave the headphones in the dressing room? How will he handle Evra after courting Bainsey like an old tart? Will he tell Carrick to quicken his pace?
I look forward to seeing how he handles these issues and see how long that stupid grin lasts.
Paul Smith
91 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:26:03
i cant get my head around why there are fans out there that think selling your best players is good for the club. Even if you think football is a cold business or 'thats the way it is these days' your a fan not a pundit or member of the Mail on Sunday. Your meant to want whats best for the club. Think about it before you decide because a player has a clause its best he leaves, wouldnt you rather sell Naismith Heitinga an a few other before a top player like Fellaini? Wouldnt you rather have a squad that can push the top 4? Wouldnt you think if a top 4 manager wants our player he must be class? When all is said an done we pay to watch Everton so therefore should want 'nothin but the best' when you turn up to see them play. Regardless of a clause or a champions league ambition you should think about whats best for the starting 11 not what Fellaini thinks is best for him. If any player goes then obviously theres nothin we can do but talking like an apprentice contestant in terms of where the money can go 9before hes even gone) is irrelavent and pathetic and only the chairman can decide these things. I'm sick of seeing good Evertonians go wild with a keyboard and acting like their on champ manager when all their energy should be focused on keeping our best players.
Ross Edwards
92 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:34:59
I completely agree Col, no sour grapes required. He won't be able to handle the press. Remember his pathetic smug silence when some reporter asked him some questions about Vic, or when he stormed out of a press conference when a journalist asked him a question about Drenthe?

He's upset a player who has great influence in that dressing room within two weeks of arriving, I mean, he is managing players like Giggs who has won 13 PL titles and two CLs, and what has he won, diddly squat!

I think this has all the hallmarks of AVB at Chelsea, he's upset a top player already and he's barely started yet. And you wouldn't announce publicly that England's best player is basically a bench player.

Watching Martinez, he knows exactly what to say, how to say it and how to act on it, he has filled his pants already.

Ross Edwards
93 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:43:54
*In the last post, I should have said that Moyes has filled his pants, not Martinez
Jim Knightley
94 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:43:18
Paul...as i've said previously, there is one big reason why we are all discussing this: Fellaini has a release clause. Baines on the other hand, doesn't. That release clause, compounded by some of his comments last season, suggests he will leave us. Now we obviously want to sell the likes of Naismith and Heitinga first...but that release clause hangs over Fellaini, and I would stake alot of money on him leaving this club at some point in the next couple of season. Because of that clause, it's inevitable we focus on some of his bad points...and it's inevitable that we positively discuss his departure, in view of a release clause which will leave us powerless to stop him going. Personally, i'd rather not go through this every window, esp in January, when he would be harder to replace. I'd rather a bid came in tomorrow, we accepted it, and invested the money elsewhere. Or he'd come out and say he is staying at Everton for other season, and will reject other offers. But I doubt the latter will occur.
Barry Rathbone
95 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:41:27
Paul 373, I think most realise having Kenwright and his pals means no option.

Unless we get 11 like Baines the fact is any genuinely talented player will leave when better money/CL/Trophies are dangled in front of their agents eyes.

There is tacit acceptance of the board among fans that while we exist in the Prem we keep our powder dry. Damn sure none of us like it but it's pissing against the wind, the Blue Union tried and look at the abuse they get.

Alan Smith
96 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:46:41
I'm not surprised you agree Ross

You never think things through logically. You want Fellaini out so manager has funds. But the manager wants to keep him. You say he's not that good when top 4 clubs want him. He's not that important, when his first posn is DM yet still finishes leading scorer playing out of position.

Now, with Moyes you say will fail. Based on one bad interview out of hundreds, and snipits of rumour about his personality

I don't like Moyes for he done, and I criticised a lot of his tactics. But all the evidence suggests that he is a good manager. He improved Everton, he improved Preston. He signed fantastic players and lost out on fantastic players due to cash. Man U have great players, facilities, staff and resources.

So logic would say that it more likely Moyes will do well

Logic would also suggest that Everton would be better keeping their best players, especially when the new manager want them and the board say we need to sell

But Ross, Ciaren, and Kieran you don't need logic, you know best. More than Martinez, Moyes, wenga.

Jim Knightley
97 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:54:57
On the discussion of handling players and the press....everyone knows United's ex-manager was Ferguson right? Seriously guys, try to take off the anti-Moyes specks for a moment and think of the larger context. Sometimes I wonder if some on here only follow Everton. Ferguson alienated players, banned individual members of the press, refused to speak to sports news organisations etc etc. Personally, I think Moyes will struggle at United because I think the achievements of last season were unusual...and I think the squad as a couple of problem areas. I think he will have difficulty replacing the great manager of the Premier League era...but Ferguson got alot wrong with the press as well...and Rooney asked for a transfer, again, before Ferguson left.
Alan Smith
98 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:57:20
Jim knightly

Realistically no player will come out and say that there definitely staying as Barca could come in the next day.

We should accept that is the case, but speak positively about him and do as much as we can to persuade him to stay. So that if only the likes arsenal come in he may say no, feel loved and decide to stay.

There's also no panic about the deal being done to late for reinforcements as there's a time limit on the clause.

Every argument against him is void IMO. I think it's more to do with personalities, than football or business sense.

Alan Smith
99 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:03:47
Correction #384

Was meant to say; "according to board we don't need to sell"

Ross Edwards
100 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:02:14
Alan, kindly point out the sentence or phrase where I said I knew more than Martinez, Moyes and Wenger please.

Also Alan, you say Moyes won't fail but a manager who has won nothing of note in his career managing players who have won everything at club level there is to win.

AVB breezed into Chelsea thinking he could tame the egos, but in the end they got rid of him as he lost the dressing room, and I can see the same happening to DM, he has upset Rooney already, and he would have a lot of sway in that dressing room.

Jim Knightley
101 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:08:40
Alan, i'd mediate your posts a bit...we've already had some ridiculous representation of a string of great Everton players, who were funded by the sales of others, all playing in one team.

We don't know what Martinez will do if he gets a big offer for Fellaini...of course he is going to say he wants him to stay, don't be naive. Do you think he is going to come out and say otherwise? And Alan, as stated, how do you know that big clubs want Fellaini? yet again, I will ask, why has there been no offer? United, today bid for Fabregas yesterday, not Fellaini. Arsenal bid for Suarez, not Fellaini. City have brought central midfielders and have not...bid for Fellaini. Chelsea, who put a CB in defensive midfielder yesterday...have not bid for Fellaini. I'm not saying it won't happen, but you claim your assessment of a player is valid because of press speculation about interested clubs. No one is saying Fellaini is bad player...the question is whether a player who has asked for a release clause in his contract, has talked about leaving, might be worth selling (when we can't stop it happening anyway).

Jim Knightley
102 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:10:21
Also, there is a difference between a fans forum and a match. I doubt anyone on here will be shouting 'sell Fellaini, 24million is a great amount, we can better strengthen the team and squad with that money' during one of the Pre-season matches. I don't think we need Fellaini to feel love on the internet do you?

Also, Bale came out and said he would stay at Spurs for another year...it clearly does happen. Bale also has/had a more realistic chance of a move to a top top club than Fellaini.

Paul Andrews
103 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:18:46
No takers at £24 million.
Surely if there was several clubs wanting him at that price they would have triggered the clause by now.
Jim Knightley
104 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:24:29
Again, sorry for the numerous typos. It has been a very long day. I can't wait till it kicks off again...And then we will really have something to discuss. Objectively, it looks like being the most exciting season in years. City are going to be more attacking, United will be...god knows what. Chelsea with Mourinho back at the helm, with a plethora of ridiculous attacking talent in front of him, but a naturally more pragmatic approach. We've a new manager, and Swansea, Southampton and Norwich are throwing money at some very good players. And Suarez's, Bale's and indeed Fellaini's futures are still unclear. We could still start the season having seen two of the best three players from last season leaving the league. Will be a very interesting year. And hopefully, we can bring in at least one more player before the season starts.
Ross Edwards
105 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:31:06
It's becoming pretty clear that no clubs are interested in Felli. Dithering Dave is living up to his name with his thoughts "who shall I sign, Cesc, Felli, no. Baines, Cesc again, back to Fellaini again"

Alan Smith
106 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:12:31
Jim

I don't think it's worth selling our best player. You may think hes our second best. So, I also say its not a good idea to sell our 11th best.

All of our players want to play for Man U, barca, Madrid, bayern...I would have thought, or are you the naive one?

Just because one has a release clause, doesn't make me want to sell him.

Especially when the usually tight Moyes broke the transfer record to get him. He picked him every time he was available without exception even after that Wigan game.
Martinez has already given him the armband and wenga has enquired!

My pt to you jim was that there's no need to fly of the handle screaming sell because a player has a clause and no rush to sell as the clause runs out two weeks before the deadline

I'm not naive, I know there are players Martinez would swap Fellaini for, but I don't reckon there's any under £24m and even if there are (people have mentioned matas fee, carzorlas fee etc etc...) would they sign for us? Can you think of any? Would Eriksen of Ajax sign?

So the board say they don't want to sell, Martinez says he doesn't want to sell, but some fans do, for no logical reason that's been explained on here.

Except the two illogicall reasons;

1) to buy three unknown players, when just signed 4 good ones already

2) or pay back the "bank" who based on evidence haven't asked for there money back and £25m a year better off next season. And how would selling Fellaini to pay back the bank benefit me as a fan if the team suffered?

Ross my point to you was about Fellaini, who you don't seem to rate, but Martinez, wenga and Moyes it seems, do.

Also on Moyes there's no evidence to suggest he can't manage big egos. Never heard a player speak ill of him. And I'm sure most Man U players will be ultimate professionals to reach them levels under ferguson.

Ross Edwards
107 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:43:37
When did I say I didn't rate Fellaini, Alan, because I have never said that.
Alan Smith
108 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:42:56
Jim your using City as an example...they bought Rodwell

Now I think Rodwell is class, but evertonians couldn't wait to get rid. If I used city buying him as an example of why he's good you wouldn't have it.

Therefore it hypocritical to Fellaini not that good because city haven't bid for him.

No of it matters anyway, he's one of our best players so why WANT to sell him?

There's no logical reason that your yet to come up with.

Ross Edwards
109 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:48:38
"Some if our fans are actually worse than our inept board. They want to sell our best players to rivals making them stronger and us weaker."

Well, Alan, if it wasn't for us supporters buying merchandise, season tickets, matchday programmes, tickets and actually attending, Everton would cease to exist. We are actually putting more into the club financially than the board are.

I would also prefer to sell one player, who wants to play CL football and get £24 million than keep Felli. Sorry if you disagree but the only way we can get money is by selling and if we have to sell him than we can't do anything to stop it.

Alan Smith
110 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:06:15
Why do we need money. If the window shuts right now. What's the problem?
Ross Edwards
111 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:08:44
"why do we need money"

Er, we don't have any, and if we want to sign players, we need it, so we will have to sell Felli if we want to bolster the squad further.

Alan Smith
112 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:07:50
The board have said no need to sell. Martinez does not want sell

So your reasoning has no factual base

And you don't want to sell for money. You originally said buy 3 players with money. Players you never named and players Martinez has not mentioned or needs

Alan Smith
113 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:11:20
Our squad is fine now. It will be weaker if sell Fellaini and buy three ship hits players
Alan Smith
114 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:11:20
Our squad is fine now. It will be weaker if sell Fellaini and buy three ship hits players
Alan Smith
115 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:11:20
Our squad is fine now. It will be weaker if sell Fellaini and buy three ship hits players
Jim Knightley
116 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:03:14
Alan...I havent said Fellaini was not good because City have not bid for him. I am responding to your suggestion that he was good, because he was interesting top four clubs, specifically: 'You say he's not that good when top 4 clubs want him.' A supposition on your part, without proof.

Now no one has flown off the handle except you, no one is screaming sell. I don't know why you making such claims. As I've said a million times, he has a release clause...that's why we are discussing him. Because if a bid comes in that meets that, we are powerless to keep him. He has a release clause because HE wanted one. And he made his feelings clear about furthering his career last season. For those reasons, if he goes, I wont cry myself asleep.

With respect to potential acquisitions - Who knows about Eriksen...his manager has come out and said he can go to Liverpool...who have finished the last two seasons below us in the league. Personally, I think we could go for one of Sigurdsson or Holtby...very good players, with big potential, who (well at least Sigurdsson) are wasted at Spurs atm. I think either would cost less than a third of any Fellaini fee. There are plenty of good players playing in good leagues, who are not 'unknown' (unless you only refer to Prem players and high profiles as known?) who could aid this team. I'd like us to look at Ashley Young personally, who may again see his first team opportunities restricted based on 1) United's formation 2) the presence of Zaha and Nani. I'd look at Dzagoev too, as AMC. And I'd like to see us bid for Honda. My point is, that there are plenty of good players in world football who may be willing to move to the Premiership. IF we have to sell Fellaini, then we don't have to roll the dice. We don't have to bid blind. We could bring in good young players, or players with experience, and make a difference. Diame, with his 3.5 buyout clause, is another example.

As I said in my original post on this thread:

The important thing, if having to sell a player, is to get the right price. Personally, I think 24million for us would be the right price, and would allow us to bring in a couple of top players to improve both our first 11, and team.

As you will note... 'if' and 'having' appear. Not 'please sell now'.

Ross Edwards
117 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:19:28
And you believe what the board say do you Alan? We need more players Alan, we have a small squad, a lack of depth and you say our squad is fine? We have an ageing squad and we need younger players to replace them.
Paul Andrews
118 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:20:44
He is not interesting "top clubs" enough for them to make a bid.
They obviously don't think he is worth the £24 million.
Alan Smith
119 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:22:29
We have 2 internationals for every position almost and no Europe. You can only name a 25 man squad. And Fellaini is hardly ever injured and will miss a max of 5 games through suspension

There's no argument to sell a top player, unless its a Portsmouth/ Leeds situation and as the EGM revealed we are no where near

You can't have it both ways. Three good players would cos t more wages than Fellaini earns. And thre crap players would be pointless

Also are Swansea fans wanting 20m for michu and villa fans wanting 25m for benteke to buy three shite players

Your position makes no sense whatsoever. Buy three squad players so we can have a worse starting 11. And if we do that we are no better off financially so that argument is out the window

So which is it Ross, the money for the factious "bank" or the 3 shit squad players?

Either way we will have a worse 11 players on the pitch!

All we now factually, is the debt is serviceable (£4m a year in payments), Fellaini is our first or second best player, the manager wants him, most fans want him.

Yet you know better.

Jim Knightley
120 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:29:11
With respect to the size of the squad: I don't think we have to sell Fellaini. I think we need at least one more central midfielder for depth, and personally I'd love to see an AMC with playmaking ability arrive (I don't think Barkley is ready yet). At the moment, im guessing we could fund a loan deal and that's it. However, if we could find buyers for some of the lesser performers (Heitinga, Naismith, Gueye..) I think we could fund one 5mil ish player. Diame's supposed 3.5 release clause continues to look attractive, in view of his impressive defensive capacity and energy. I'm hopeful we could take an AMC from a bigger squad to improve us too. Sigurdsson on loan perhaps? Ramsay (although more a cm)? Anderson?
Brendan McLaughlin
121 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:31:33
Paul #416
If the tabloids are to be believed there's a month to go yet...so what's the rush from the "top clubs" point of view? Arteta?
Paul Andrews
122 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:33:19
Alan,

The question is academic.
If no one will pay the fee that triggers the clause £24 million,and the club won't sell him for less than £24 million after 15th August he is going nowhere.

Paul Andrews
123 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:36:09
Brendan,

To be first in the queue ?

Jim Knightley
124 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:35:19
Alan, im not saying I agree with Ross' position. But you can't keep saying we are going to buy three shit squad players... you don't know how we are going to spend any potential. There are good players out there. Swansea signed Hernandez for 7ish if I remember rightly? Coutinho came in for 8.5. They were hardly unknown quantities, and both went to clubs who finished last season, and the season before, beneath us in the league. We don't need to risk silly buys.
Alan Smith
125 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:32:41
Jim

I'd like think Diame would be a realistic buy without having to sell. The others probably wouldn't come here and non of the players you mentioned are as good as Fellaini anyway and or play different positions.

As for him wanting to go I read quotes from Gibson saying he doesn't know yet if Moyes wants him at Man U. Suggesting he would want to go back if the opportunity arose. But no one holds that against him the way you do Fellaini. And all Fellaini said is he wants champ lqu football one day, preferably with Everton

You must admit he's come in for unfair criticism since the day he signed.

I think it's disgraceful.

Paul Andrews
126 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:40:35
Get in there Jim.
Perfectly put
Brendan McLaughlin
127 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:38:13
Paul #423
You're not a poker player then?
Paul Andrews
128 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:41:40
Alan,

Gibson thinks he may have a chance of going back to Utd?
Did I read that right?

Alan Smith
129 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:40:57
Coutiniho? 3 good games at end of season when players were planning there hols.

It was Ross who said 3 squad players with Fellaini money. I'd have Diame no doubt, straight in with Barkley and felliani

Paul Andrews
130 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:43:46
Brendan,

If the ante is the same for all sitting at the table...............

Alan Smith
131 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:44:00
That's what he said Paul...which worse as its a bit deluded. It said he was on a stag do in Ireland and told a reporter we will wait and see who he comes back for, I don't know yet if he wants me.
Paul Andrews
132 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:46:15
Alan,

Deluded is a kind terminology for full to the brim of Ireland's finest if he thinks that.

Alan Smith
133 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:45:58
You lot pick your team without Fellaini, you can have coutiniho, sigurdsso and Hernandez. Plus all the current Everton squad

Ill pick my team with just the current squad

And we will all have Diame for 3.5m too

Alan Smith
134 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:48:58
I know Paul. Good player like but I think he gets too much praise some times. especially when you look at the grief Fellaini gets. I can't understand it.
Brendan McLaughlin
135 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:46:04
Paul #431
That's the point...the ante is only the same for all at the minute....wait a month & everything changes. Or to put it another way why pay 24 mill now for a player you think you'll get for somewhere south of that in a months time?
Alan Smith
136 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:51:41
Still waiting...you must have realised that coutiniho would only be a squad player at Everton. Hernandez I can't even remember doing anything last season and sigurdson can't get a game for spurs, who were are trying to overtake.
Alan Smith
137 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:54:51
Surely the price goes up not down, if Everton play their hand right!
Brendan McLaughlin
138 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:56:27
Alan #438
"if Everton play their hand right"...so the price is going down then?
Paul Andrews
139 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:57:44
Brendan,

I have been saying the same for quite a while now.
Why would a prospective buyer,if there is one at £24 mil,jump in early?
Wait until the clause runs out ,play hardball with a skint club who need to get the new manager a transfer budget,and pay a lot less than £24 mil.
I think he will be sold for around £18-20 mil

Paul Andrews
140 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:02:13
Alan, 438,
If they won't buy him at £24 million,they certainly won't buy him at £25-26-27-28 etc etc
Alan Smith
141 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:06:23
Yes so surely he stays.

Martinez will not sell him after the deadline for less, as he won't need a transfer budget having already added 4 players and maybe Diame.

The board couldn't sell him if Martinez doesn't need to buy because they'd be lambasted by the fans for selling late cheaply and not spending the money on a replacement.

Alan Smith
142 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:15:36
Either it's a really big high paying club, ie not arsenal, who come in on the last day of the clause with 24m. Or arsenal have a 18m bid rejected on transfer deadline day
Brendan McLaughlin
143 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:22:26
Alan 446
Just like we rejected their Arteta bid?
Alan Smith
144 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:26:00
I'd like to think the board will give Martinez a chance. And Arteta begged to go. If Fellaini begs to go, we'd be within our rights to say;

"well you signed the release clause"

and there could be no rational argument against him staying if £24m wasn't met.

Also he would have to get on with playing well, as its a world cup year.

Jim Knightley
145 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:57:44
Alan...you clearly don't know football.... Coutinho was fantastic for Liverpool...Hernandez is a brilliant player, who also did very very well in Spain. So what if Sigurddson isn't getting a game for Spurs? does that mean he would poor for us, when we are weak in that position? He played brilliantly for Swansea, and is a natural goal-scoring AMC. Are you actually naive enough to think we can't be improved by a rival's squad player? Were you aware that Spurs were considering loaning Bale, prior to his making his breakthrough because of injury problems in the squad?
And Gibson's supposed quotes (I've yet to see any evidence) are hardly comparable to Fellaini's. Wasnt he quoted : 'I am just starting my fifth season at Everton, this will be one of my last. I have seen everything. In January or at the end of the season I will turn to another club or championship'. One of several during a short period if I remember rightly.

I also love the way your throw 'international' around, as if it validates the quality of our players. How many players in this league are not international? Are still stuck in the 80's, when being an international in a top European league actually meant something?

Your arguments are bizzare. You argue against claims which other people haven't made...you still haven't withdraw your inane comment about adding the five top players we sold to the rest of the squad...as if it is a reality. Some bizzare interchanges...maybe try watching some football apart from Everton maybe?

And Alan, your argument on 449 makes no sense. We were in our rights to say to Arteta: 'you've got a contract'. That's not the point is it though? It's about being left vulnerable to bids from Fellaini, who has previously publicly said he wants to go, and has a release clause. I wonder if that will finally click at some point during these discussions, but I very much doubt it.

Alan Smith
146 Posted 17/07/2013 at 02:07:35
Jim,

Your out of order.

1) "I don't know football"

because I don't agree with you? Coutiniho I have watched just as much as you this season unless your really a Liverpudlian. He's looked good against poor sides and hasn't been overly impressive when teams get tight. He destroyed weak teams like Newcastle who were a shambles. My experience in watching football for twenty years tells me to reserve judgment. Lets see if he does it in big games or at the start of next season.

For me Pienaar and mirralas are better and we have Deulofu in that posn so no need to strengthen there.

2) you've put words in my mouth, for that you are a total bell end!

I never said that we couldn't improve by buying off our rivals. Nor am I naive. I just don't think Sigurdson is as good as you say he is.

3) "was I aware bale was available for loan" and "naive"

you arrogant fucker! I've had a season ticket since I was 14, watched a lot of all premier lqu and international football for years. I make my own judgements. Where as you sound like you get carried away with shit you hear hyped up on sky or MofD. I suggest you stop playing champ manager as well.

So yes I was aware of bale being available to loan a few years ago. and it has has absolutely nothing to do with sigurdson being a good footballer. And for the record I said Everton should sign bale when he was at Southampton.

4) gibsons quotes were referenced on here after people enquired about his op.

5) "just throw international around"..."stuck in 80's when it meant something"

Well oh wise one, how many caps do you have? And it means a player is valued more highly in the transfer market, and he will usually get a pay rise when he becomes an international. So factually it means something

Did I throw it around or just make the point we had almost 2 internationals for every position? which for a club not in Europe with an excellent youth system, is enough players. So why weeken the starting eleven to add more squad players? Which was your idea.

6) which inane comment?

The one which I ponder how good we'd be if we didn't have to sell the players Moyes wanted to keep and the fans wanted to keep? This was to help make my point, that the team would ultimately be stronger if we never had to sell our best players like Rooney, Rodwell, Arteta, Lescott. Do you disagree with that point then? I think it's a relevant example of why most fans hope Fellaini stays. Can't you see that relavence?

7) I suggest you read 449 again.

After the clause expires I say we could realistically still hold out for £24m plus. Not as previous the poster suggested, selling him for less, using Arteta as the example.
Think about the situation BK/Moyes was in. Arteta was a last min once in life time move, for a 29 year old and he begged to go. I was unhappy when he left to a rival. But hard to say no to a player in that situation.

Easier to say no to Fellaini on deadline day, if someone comes in last minute offering less than the clause. Due to the fact that all parties have agreed on his value previously. Fellaini himself as he insisted on the clause. Then there is the added bonuses that if we refuse a low bid and he has to stay. Fellaini will still perform for us in a World Cup year

Make sense, you all knowing, all footballing watching genius?

How many Swansea games have you watched then expert? I'm genuinely interested to know?

8) "vulnerable to bids"..."finally click"

Cheeky t$#t you know quite well I understand the clause? My argument throughout this has been:

I know we can't stop Fellaini from going, but I want him to stay. I just disagree that we will be better off with the £24m.

9) "arguments are bizarre"

I refer you to 415 Ross

In which he says sell to buy three squad players. Which is the basis of your argument. But you don't say how this would improve the starting line up.

You also know Martinezs thoughts. Have you met guy? You say he doesn't want to keep Fellaini after he made him cpt and said he wants him stay.

10) so please go on record and say which of the three players you've just indentfied, that I could never of thought if myself, Coutiniho, Hernandez or sigurdson, that is better than Fellaini. And all of them now would cost a combined 30 odd mil not £24m


Gavin Ramejkis
147 Posted 17/07/2013 at 02:18:47
Dup
Gavin Ramejkis
148 Posted 17/07/2013 at 02:18:47
Listening to the radio driving into work today, reports are Man Utd have put a price tag of £80m on a second choice striker in Rooney, cheeky cunts. Simple logic, next time they come knocking for our first choice midfielder we tell them £50m cash or get tae fuck.
Steve King
149 Posted 17/07/2013 at 09:17:35
Gavin,
I believe you have misheard that, they are estimating it will cost Chelsea/Barcelona/Arsenal £80million.

£25 million Transfer Fee + £200,000 a week four year contact + Signing on and agency fees.

Dan McKie
150 Posted 17/07/2013 at 09:30:45
It's folk reading the headline only, Gavin. That includes salary and bonuses over a 5 year contract too. The fee is estimated at £28 million in the article. You should see all the reds giving it 'If Rooney is worth £80 mil, Suarez is worth £100 mil etc. etc.'

I'd like us to keep Fellaini for 1 more season, playing in his proper position of centre mid alongside Gibson, with a more creative player in front of those two. If we are going to sell him though, get it done fast, and hand the cash to Roberto, as the stories of this, that and the other coming to Everton have well and truly dried up over the last few days.

Phil Walling
151 Posted 17/07/2013 at 09:39:21
Unless Moyes has changed character, he will sew up the Felli and Baines deals on deadline day and thus allow his buddy BK to bank all the money until at least the January window.
Martinez is about to learn what it`s all about to manage Everton.
Eric Myles
152 Posted 17/07/2013 at 09:38:38
If Arteta was so desperate t go how come he waited until 1 hour before the transfer window closed before "begging to go"?

More likely it was BK doing the begging as money was needed for the banks.

Gavin Ramejkis
153 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:40:07
Thanks guys was wondering where the hell they got £80m from, even £28m is a cheek given they themselves are labelling him as a backup striker and given the price they paid for RVP
Colin Glassar
154 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:45:56
Baines is staying. Moyes won't improve his latest £12m bid and BK refuses to lower his £20m valuation. So that's that. The Bainster stays. Felli on the other hand might still go. My only concern is that we might spend all his money on one player, James McCarthy. Now I like McCarthy but I'd prefer to buy 2-3 players with that money and not sink it all on one player.
Brian Harrison
155 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:45:19
Players have all the power these days, They sign 5 year deals and also write in a get out clause allowing them to cash in if they have a god season. I am sure all clubs interested are well aware of Fellainis buy out clause and when it expires, that's not to say they cant offer less closer to deadline day. Then the player utters the best get out clause of all time " I want to move" and the deal will be done.

So I expect Moyes to come back in for both Fellaini and Baines we might have a better chance of keeping Baines unless he says he wants to go. I would imagine that Moyes will be desperate to get some signings in to appease his new fans after all he has lost out on Thiago and looks like Fabregas is staying at Barca then add the Rooney speculation and Moyes needs to sign someone very quickly. So all the speculation from fans saying how good next season could be I think it best if we wait till the window closes before we know who will be starting the season for us.

Dan McKie
156 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:58:37
Agree, Colin. If we pretty much ended up with McCarthy as a straight swap for Fellaini, I would be gutted. The £12 million touted as our offer for McCarthy is more than fair, and would represent a huge profit for Wigan. I would want 3 or 4 promising players brought in if we sold.
Jim Knightley
157 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:37:01
Alan...what's the point. You still don't get it, do you.

Your post 050 - Nice one Jim,
Get £24m for Fellaini and buy two players blah blah.

Rooney and Fellaini at Man U next season. Bains too possibly

Arteta at arsenal

Rodwell and lescott at man city

FFS when will the penny drop? 5 ex players in the top 4 and we will be sixth again or maybe even 7th.

Who do we get in better, after we have sold?

We're would we finish with them 5 and the rest of our squad?

-Do you need see how confused these notions are? clearly, from selling, we have got better. Consistently, under Moyes, we improved the squad and team, BY selling.

Re. your comments: 'Still waiting...you must have realised that coutiniho would only be a squad player at Everton. Hernandez I can't even remember doing anything last season and sigurdson can't get a game for spurs, who were are trying to overtake.'

No idea what the 'still waiting' related to. I'm not sitting here 24/7 waiting for you reply far enough. Question... How is your memory a validation of his ability? and I'm arrogant? You can right off a player because you can't remember him doing anything? Prioritising your own subjectivity a little bit? and you are surprised when I gain a conception that you don't know football? Is it lonely on your pedestal? For information purposes, I was excited by Hernandez's arrival, because I watched him play in La Liga, and thought he was the kind of player that could improve us, and would easily improve Swansea. And I was impressed by him, and can remember him doing good things. Coutinho similarly, is a highly exciting player. He had more three good games for Liverpool? that comment is bizzare. If you can't remember...go back and look through some post-match articles. And re. Sigurdson. You clearly invalidate him, because he can't get a game for Spurs, and because we are tying to overtake them.

And Alan - re. your quote: 'You also know Martinezs thoughts. Have you met guy? You say he doesn't want to keep Fellaini after he made him cpt and said he wants him stay.' Now when did I say Martinez doesnt want to keep Fellaini? And I refer you back to my earlier comment: 'You argue against claims which other people haven't made.' You are joke mate. And you just emphasise it by stating that we have a squad full of internationals, and therefore not a thin squad. We have how many senior central midfielders at this club? Fellaini, Osman, and Gibson....We've got three natural wide mids who are good enough for the first team, one of whom is utterly untried in this league, or in Spain's top league, although I personally think he will do well. One of those three wide men, the best of them imo, spent alot of last season on the treatment table. If we want to improve, we need to match those above us...not to have the squad depth of a lower Prem side. I don't think we have 2 internationals for every person... I'd personally love to see you set this out please?

Finally - 'So why weeken the starting eleven to add more squad players? Which was your idea.' Again...your idiocy is alarming. I'm not advocating weakening the first 11....I genuinely think we can improve the first 11. I'm personally not sure that Martinez will play 3 at the back season...I still think we may operate using a 4-2-3-1. I think we could improve on Gibson, and Osman, or at least one of them, and bring in an AMC to do the job Fellaini was doing in the AMC position last season. Fellaini is not a natural goal scorer, he is just a very good player. He won't get 11 from a more advanced position every season, whereas a natural AMC, could. Which is why I proposed Sigurdson as an example. I'm also not sure that Fellaini will necessarily enjoy Martinez's tactics as much, as I think in a deeper position, his passing, which is sometimes brilliant, and sometimes sporadic, will be a problem.

But come on, let's see these 22 internationals. 2 for every position. This will be great fun.

Ciarán McGlone
158 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:51:18
I don't know why people keep stating, as fact, that Fellaini is a defensive midfielder...

Is it just because he said it? In the same way that Phil Neville thinks he was a midfielder?

Fellaini's best spells in our team have arguably been as a box-to-box player..

In fact, I don't recall him having a single memorable game in defensive midfield...

As for the sale itself..there's a huge dose of naivety on show here. Ultimately we are team who run a financial model that is based upon selling our best player to fund our debts..

If someone offers around 20 million for Fellaini then we are probably obliged to take that money, to placate the various institutions we are in hock to..

This is the reality of the situation.

Jim Knightley
159 Posted 17/07/2013 at 11:44:39
I agree, I think he is a box to box guy. He has good energy, is powerful, and needs to have some license to get forward, which a DM position will not give him.

Btw, I can't believe the rumored Chelsea offer (10mil plus either Mata or Luiz for Rooney). Sounds like Mata, who from my perspective has been Chelsea's best player over the last seasons, is expendable.

Brian Denton
160 Posted 17/07/2013 at 11:52:13
Jim, yes I was surprised at that. Mata is a great young player, and is the last player I would have expected Chelsea to throw in as a makeweight.
Jim Knightley
161 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:05:02
On this subject, do we have a buy on clause for Rooney? Personally, I'd be surprised if he went for more than we sold him for...but, in that event, could we pocket some money?
Ciarán McGlone
162 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:12:09
Looks like Mata's been earmarked for departure Jim..

I think he's a superb player..however even without him Chelsea still have the strongest midfield in the league.

Kieran Fitzgerald
163 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:10:36
Alan, same question from yesterday, where does the money come form to buy a Daime or a Mirallas or anybody else of note? You keep saying we don't have to sell players.

The club has been running at a loss of 5m a year for the last couple of years. Any of the new extra T.V money will go towards this, servicing debt and to anybody else we owe money to.

So again, where will the money come from to pay 3m - 5m each for two or three players?

Ged Simpson
164 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:27:36
This thread got exciting - those snappy posts do it for me !
Tom Bowers
165 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:27:10
We are all agreed that Everton don't have much in the way of finance for the bigger buys and that selling players is the only way to go if RM wants anybody else of real stature.
I believe that RM does not want anyone to leave except those who believe they have no future at Goodison and those who are seeking richer pickings.
Heitinga,Fellaini and Baines are the names bandied about in the media and if unfortunately they have to go I am sure adequate replacements will be found although Bainsey is a gem.

I for one wouldn't miss Fellaini despite his improved form over the last 18 months.
He was a diamond in the rough and still is in some departments.and wasn't worth his salt in his first 2 seasons.
Everton still have some rich talent and in this new era who knows who is going to break through under the guidance of RM.
I believe Fellaini wants a bigger deal but also wants Champions league and he knows he can probably make that move now and Everton can reap the rewards.

Ross Edwards
166 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:52:15
"So which is it Ross, the money for the factious "bank" or the 3 shit squad players?"

Alan

I didn't say I wanted 3 rubbsh squad players, and I certainly didn't say that I knew Martinez's thoughts, neither did I say that Martinez wanted to sell Fellaini.

It's not up to the manager or the board, if Man U or Arsenal meet the clause, he's gone. I'd rather get that money in the transfer kitty, get a suitable replacement like Honda and use the rest to bolster the squad.

Alan Smith
167 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:11:40
Jim

we haven't improved by selling our best players. We improved by making shrewd buys. The Lescott money and Arteta money was either not used or wasted and improve the quality of the team.

Moyes would have preferred to have kept those 5 players I mentioned rather than sell them. And his best squad was probably when we had yak, Saha, Arteta, Cahill Rodwell and Fellaini. The last 3 seasons I would disagree about us improving....more like RS and villa failing

You said Martinez 'had to say he wanted to keep Fellaini' implying he never meant his comments that he wanted him to stay

I said "ALMOST 2 internationals for every position"

And as for needing an extra midfield player, we both said Diame at 3.5m, which doesn't require selling Fellaini.

4-2-3-1

Howard.............Robles.........springthorpe

Bains.................Oviedo.........garbutt
Coleman...........stones..........Hibbert
Distin................Hieghtinga.......Duffy
Jagielka...........Alcaraz

Fellaini............Osman
Gibson............Barkley........junior

Mirralas...........Kennedy
Pienaar............Naismith
Deulofu............gueye

Kone...............Jelavic......anichebe

That is 16 internationals. Distin and Hibbert are experience and quality players and the rest probably will be one day.

I agree we need a winger that why went for Moses on loan, who is far better than, sigurdson in my opinion. And we need a CM possibly if because if Barkley and juniors youth. I would take sigurdson but would prefer Diame at £3.5

Therefore no need to sell. To bring Diame and a wideman in. Or sell, Hieghtinga, gueye Velios to raise a small contribution.

I have faith in that squad and in my opinion, sigurdson would struggle to get in that side. I would play Pienaar number10. And if he took fellaini a place the team would be slightly weaker.

I too would play Fellaini CM and make him the fulcrum of the side. There is hardly any better in the prem lqu. Certainly not Carrick who got in team of the year

Sigurdson is what, the 12th best AMC?

So you answer my question now. who would you rather have Fellaini or sigurdson?

Alan Smith
168 Posted 17/07/2013 at 12:56:51
One more thing you said, selling made us stronger but also said the squad is weak.
A contradiction.

My pt about selling those five players was just a simple I wish didn't have to...and so do you I reckon so stop nit picking

Ciarán McGlone
169 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:06:26
I agree we need a winger that why went for Moses on loan, who is far better than, sigurdson in my opinion. And we need a CM possibly if because if Barkley and juniors youth. I would take sigurdson but would prefer Diame at £3.5

---------------------------------

Again for the clarity of the thread..where does the money for these players come from?

Colin Glassar
170 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:04:48
How much could we get for Naismith and Gueye? Serious answers only please.
Ross Edwards
171 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:11:17
Probably £1.5million for Gueye from some French side and I'd let Nais go for free. We can't make a loss as he was a free transfer.
Robbie Muldoon
172 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:02:24
Alan Smith wins! Keep hold of Fellaini and Baines, fight tooth and nail!
Ross Edwards
173 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:13:01
Everyone knows we need to sell to buy, and £24 million, plus the Sky money Alan will give us more than enough to get 3 or 4 players. I think it is a good piece of business myself.
Ross Edwards
174 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:14:46
How does Alan win Robbie? Felli wants Champions League football, which we can't provide him, Baines, no doubt at his age, 28, would like to play CL football.

If Man U make a £44 million double bid, Bill will accept. That will give us the opportunity to replace them and get more players to bolster what we have already got.

Jim Knightley
175 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:11:19
Alan...I don't know why you can't get this. Seriously, it is getting tiresome. It's not a choice between Sigurdson and Fellaini (Although I personally would prefer the former in an AMC) role. I was simply bringing up the kind of player, likely available for cheap, who I believe would improve this team. You can't compare Moses and Sigurdson...because one is more naturally a wide player, and one a central player. Sigurdson would probaly cost about 5/6mil if he was available, Holtby, who I think may also struggle to hold down a place (although I think it will be criminal if that happens) will cost slightly more, if he happened to be available. These are simply examples of very good players who I believe we could attract. The notion, as brought up on this thread repeatedly, is that we could sell Fellaini, and strengthen our first team by not just bringing in a replacement for Fellaini, but someone else too. If we do play a 4-2-3-1, Gibson, Osman and Fellaini will likely play. Osman, I think is overly criticised, but I believe we can improve on him. Gibson is a decent player, but has an horrendous injury record, and we can improve on him. Despite your suggestions to the contrary, I believe we have a weak squad, and desperately need more in central midfield. Similarly, we have one slightly natural right sided mid at the club (personally I think Mirallas is better on the left also), who also suffered from injury problems last season. I think we could add Moses who you apparently like, or even someone like Ashley Young, Sigurdson and Diame, with money to spare. I believe doing this would not only 1) bring our age down 2) but improve the squad 3) and the first team.

We lost any chance of fourth last season, not imo, because of our first 11 (bar perhaps the striker we needed), but the squad. When Mirallas was injured, who came in? When we needed something different from the bench, who could realistically change things? When Pienaar was out of form, who could we realistically swap him with? (Personally, in respect to his one, Oviedo should have been used more). Now, if we genuinely want to improve, we need to improve our squad. I think our money is gone now...and I think we maybe have even brought Robles on the basis of the assumed sale of Heitinga (who, if we aim to play a 3 at the back, which I'm not sure we will, we will have to replace). Now, as I've said alot, I like Fellaini. I think some criticism of him is unjustified, and I think on his day, he is as good as any box to box mid in this league. But, I do think he is worth 24million. I think he will be slightly less effective player in a predominately passing centred team. I also think his clear indications in the past that he wants to leave, forebodes an eventual departure, which may be less convenient than a move this July.

With respect to Martinez. I didn't imply anything of the sort. I was simply illustrating that Martinez's rhetoric was not an adequate way of determining whether he would actually turn down an appropriate offer.

Jim Knightley
176 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:30:00
If it came to it, I think we could get a good 2-4 million for Naismith, as he has a decent reputation in Scotland, and would do well there, or in the Championship. I'd take a million for Gueye in a heartbeat, but wouldn't be surprised if we got less.
Matt Traynor
177 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:28:17
Ross #535, I'm sure every player would like to play CL football. Unfortunately only 4 teams from the EPL qualify to enter. Unless you're coveted by one of them, then you're stuck with the drudgery of the Premier League.

Fellaini (or rather his old man) has been talking about CL football from the minute we signed him. On his day he's a great player. When he's not on form, he's worse than anonymous. We've had plenty of experience of playing without him due to injuries / suspensions, and personally I'd be happy to see the back of him as long as our manager is given the chance to reinvest the proceeds.

Baines is a different matter. I think he's much more integral to our play than Fellaini. Whilst he won't agitate for a move it wouldn't surprise me if he did go. In fact it wouldn't surprise me if we start the season with Fellaini but not Baines, sad to say.

Colin Glassar
178 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:37:00
Hull seem to be spending so why don't we offer them Naismith? I think a few teams would be interested in him for around £2-2.5m. I'd also accept a million for Gueye. We could get a decent Spanish player with that money.
Phil Walling
179 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:14:58
Colin@530: I doubt whether either Gueye or Naismith would attract a fee although some Scottish club might lob £50k for the latter.

Trouble is, I suspect he is on far more money than the Scots can afford and Everton would probably have to buy out his contract. Unlikely.

I believe his signing was inspired by David Weir who might well take him on loan early on.

Colin Glassar
180 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:43:44
Phil, well neither of them seem to have anything to offer us on the field so maybe it's a question of cutting our losses.
Alan Smith
181 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:47:44
Jim

I think its quite simple really. fellaini is better than anyone youve mentioned, at playing football, IMO.

I may rate him higher than most. I cant think of anyone id rather have in the role role Busquets plays for Barca. Not even Busquets. I genuinely believe hes as good as Viera was. id rather have fabregas, scwienstieger, xavi but they're different types of CM

I am very happy with our squad, would have liked a better striker but feel Martinez has covered last seasons weaknesses. easy two good players for every position in my opinion.

Therefore buying expensive players like Sigurdson and a couple of others, at the expense of selling FellainI would not improve the 11 IMO. Him and Holtby would cost 10m each easy. lfc would approach sigurdsson driving the fee up. them 2 for Fellaini no thanks.

I have faith in Barkley and Osman. Barkley will be better than Sigurdsonnext season...theres a case for Ossie being better too. More squad playerrs would just restrict Barkleys development

I'd love Young...but theres no reason Mirralas and Deulofeu can not be as good as him. and there's no pt bringing young in if you lose your best midfielder, just to have him and a stronger bench.

Is young for sale, what wages is he on? would he step down? is he better than a moses loan deal?

I hope Fellaini stays and we buy Diame.... the squad and definately the 11 would be stronger with them 2 rather than any 2 you have mentioned replacing Fellaini with.

The board said we don't need to sell. My overriding pt in all this is that as a fan we should try and make them keep this promise. You may say niave, I say hold them to account. We can assume and speculate all day, but having heard the evidence for the EGM, I believe we do not need the cash desperately. Some people on here saying "get the deal done quick"

No one is going to bid the the 24m until the final day of the clause because, they will be trying to get him for less...so everton have to hold out.

lf Fellani gets an Arteta type offer, less wages, smallish fee (or they meet the clause). I would hope our board, fans, and manager do there best to persuade him to stay. But the feeling I was getting from some posters on here was the opposite.

I think there are BETTER ways to IMPROVE the squad without SELLING our better players.

Ill be sad to see him go and believe it will hurt our chances of catching Arsenal and Spurs because IMO he is more important than Bains. no matter what 3 we bring in we will loose that dominating presence in midfield that allowed us to push teams back at home and dominate possession.

Jim Knightley
182 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:54:58
Fellaini as good as Vieira...did I just read that? Sorry mate, but I think that comment has invalidated everything you've said in this thread. I like Fellaini, but Vieria was the perfect defensive midfield player...he was a better mover, and defensive player than Fellaini, and consistently dominated matches. Fellaini, has not yet, had a season where he has consistently dominated matches.

I also doubt that Sigurdsson would cost 10mil...Levy is a dick, but he came in for 8ish, and will probaly be surplus to requirements because of Spurs' inane buying strategy (They could prob field an entire team of central midfield players). Similarly, I'm not sure what Barkley has done to justify the optimism of some on here. I'm hopeful he can become a goal player for us in time, but Sigurdsson came to this league, and scored 7 goals for a relatively average Swansea team in less than half a season. He similarly showed his goal scoring ability for Reading a few seasons before. But whatever, it is an imaginary deal, which is unlikely to happen. As I said before, he was meant to be representative of the type of players out there.

Finally, you keep talking about buying Diame. On several occasions, it is has been made clear on this thread (and a brief look at Everton's buying history) that we are financially incapable of buying Diame. I don't think your argument can assume him as a possible target before selling either Fellaini, or some else we don't expect. With Robles likely fee, the Barca guy's loan fee, and the Kone price (5-6.5 est...personally, I think nearer 5) I expect we have spent 8-9mil this season. That's beyond out budget. I think we can afford another loan, irrespective of whether Heitinga goes or not. And if Heitinga does go, and we do line up with 3 at the back, we will need to add another cb imo, as Duffy is untried, and going into the season with only 4 central defenders for 3 positions would be suicide.

Alan Smith
183 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:17:31
I think Fellaini did consistently dominated matches when played CM he made monkeys out of Allen an SIGURDSON. And the Scott Parker the season he won player of the year.
The first time I saw Fellaini he dominated Gerrard for Liege


At almost home game for the last 4 years that Felliani was CM, he had control of possession. He was the only player Moyes never ever dropped and played from the moment he signed. Didn't even need to bed in.

Because I'm prepared to back my judgement doesn't invalidate my other arguments.

You say SIGURDSON was in a bad Swansea team. Well how good would fellaini be in Vieras invincable side? Ge would look just as good, get sent off less ( and we criticise his discipline) and score more goals. Ok, a little bit slower but technically as good with the ball.

Fair enough if we can't get anyone else in without selling. but we wee promised a kitty before sales. If this is already gone then sound! we can't afford Diame or a poss winger on loan. I don't care. Shut the window.

I'm good to go now, I believe our players are better than the likes of SIGURDSON and do not want to sacrifice one brilliant player for 2 or 3 good players we don't need.

If come jan we have major injuries, look at it again.

Maybe loans for donavan and Cahill.

I'm supremely confident in Barkley, felli, Osman, Pienaar mirralas etc... Lets go COYB

SIGURDSON would not get a touch playing against the power and work rate of felli, Barkley and Pienaar, with deloufeu and mirralas out wide.

Bench: anichebe, Jelavic, Alcatraz, Osman, Gibson, Naismith and Robles. All internationals the outfield positions

And if hieghtinga goes I would not play three at the back, but go for Diame instead. We both agree 4-2-3-1 is the way forward, I think.

And if you look at what our debt cost us (£4m a year) and add the extra tv money,I expect a kitty of 12-15m. Given the wages we've got rid off, the average spend of the board being £5m I previous years and the fact they will want to help the new manager.

There must be scope for a winger on loan and a CM if not.

Norwich, Swansea and Southampton have less income than us and there spending. We will match half of their net spend at least.

All this pessimism, you might say realism, helps our board get away with not spending.

Jim Knightley
184 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:04:53
The average net spend of our club, per season, in the last decade is 1.5million. This summer we have likely spent between 8 and 9, and paid compensation for Martinez. It's simple really. History, and our financial state, says we will not buy another player.

I'm glad you are supremely confident in those players. I'm confident in some of them...but ultimately, I like to look at cold stats. The reality is that last season, we finished 9 points off Spurs in fifth. Granted, last season was bizzare, and I believe Spurs' total would have got them 4th in every season but last (and i'm pretty sure enough for second? in one particular season...the article was read a while back).

Now, I rate some of our players very highly. I think Baines is incredible. A wonderful wonderful player, and up there with the very best left backs in the world. I think Jagielka is a super central defender and Coleman will blossom this season. I also think Mirallas is good enough for a top four club easily, and will have a great season. And I rate Fellaini very highly, and he can be world class on his day. But whilst our core is strong, the rest, ultimately is not. There is a reason we have finished where we have every season...despite having a manager deemed good enough to take over at arguably the biggest club in England. So I'll make a prediction now - If we go into next season with these players, and no further additions, sixth will be out limit. Osman will have good games and bad games. Gibson will get injured, and Mirallas. And the 'internationals' who come into replace them? will let us down. I would love to keep Fellaini, and improve the squad further, but it won't happen. I would love Fellaini to state unequivocally that he will stay, but it won't happen.

When did Moyes drop Baines btw?

Fellaini is good, but you are overrating him. One day he will get his move, and you will get how well he does at a top club. I say that as confidently as I did when I claimed Moyes would get a move to a top club too.

And if he does half of what Vieira achieved when he gets that move, I'll be amazed.

But ultimately, the proof will be in the pudding. We are at cross-purposes. As Ive said, I will be happy if Fellaini stays, and I won't be disappointed if he goes. I think his departure would weaken one position, but improve the team and squad via additional players. You think it wouldn't, and continue to criticise player models I have suggested are of the irk available. That's about it really.

One more thing...if the potential did come up, I would sign Holtby in a minute. I can't believe he may be left on the bench at Spurs. I think he has everything it takes to be a top top player

Ciarán McGlone
185 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:22:53
" I genuinely believe hes as good as Viera was."
---------------------------

Bang, crash, wallop.

Colin Glassar
186 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:43:56
Looks like OFM is turning his sights towards yohann cabaye as he refuses to pay the asking price for either Fellaini and Fabregas. So unless wenger makes a decision the big man could be staying.
Colin Glassar
187 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:00:55
The man u CEO is flying back from OZ as I type to "conclude" some transfer business. I wonder who it is, Rooney? Fabregas? Fellaini? I wonder.
Alan Smith
188 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:02:44
"Bang, crash, wallop"

i think viera was outstanding and has acheived that much its hard to see that fellaini maybe as good as him.

Add to the fact that Fellaini is playing in a much weaker side, in much stronger era.

If you look at ball control, work rate, passing and competitiveness he is on a par. He scores far more goals and is better in the air. Viera maybe have been possibly a little quicker and better leader.

Bianes had to wait 6 months to dislodge a CB...fellaini was in straight away

Alan Smith
189 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:23:08
the problem last season was not lack of depth, more like lack of forwards that could score
Ross Edwards
190 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:12:31
" I genuinely believe hes as good as Viera was."

I'm sorry, but that is utter crap. I'm sorry, but it is, you can't argue against this criticism Alan. Fellaini, BETTER than Viera?? Lunacy, utter lunacy.

What next, Gibson better than Roy Keane?

"the problem last season was not lack of depth, more like lack of forwards that could score"

The problem was lack of depth as we didn't have enough back up attackers to provide goals during Jela's drought, nor did we have enough players to freshen the team up, especially during the end of the season. The reason why we had to keep bringing Nais on as we didn't have any other choice.

If we sell Fellaini, get the £24 million, we can bolster what we already have, plus get a suitable replacement, what's wrong with that?

Ged Simpson
191 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:19:54
"...was not..."

Crap.

"...insert quote here ..."

I have seen thoughout my 450 years as a blue the ups and downs of our great club but to say "was no" is just beyong fucking belief and frankly insane and as for ........

Jesus I can't wait for the season or even the friendly to start. I am just becoming a mischievous idiot who is now annoying myself. .

Alan Smith
192 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:33:29
I said he was as good as Viera not better!.

I said he is better in the air and scores more goals..indisputable. In my opinion his ball control and work rate are as good. I don't think you say Vieras ball controll is vastly better even if you were his biggest fan.

But time will tell, if he gets his move.

People on here say Baines is the best left back in world. Is that lunacy or just someones opinion?

depth..i think are issues Martinez has addressed already. a few more would be nice but selling Felliani to do it, doesnt make sense to me. Just as selling Bains to do it doesnt make sense to most people.

I wont mention your ridiculous Gibson comment.. I thought we were having a constructive debate, but if you cant resist needless point scoring then just answer this question.

If Fellaini decides to stay. Should we sell Bains if someone offers "£22m to strengthen the squad?

Please bear in mind that we are weak in CM according to others on here. We also have Oviedo ,garbutt at left back. Plus LBs are a lot easier/cheaper to replace

Alan Smith
193 Posted 17/07/2013 at 20:01:03
"A Suitable replacemant for Fellaini and strengthen wahts wrong with that?"

a player as good as Fellaini would cost more than £24M. Thats why hes asked for the clause.


Ciarán McGlone
194 Posted 18/07/2013 at 08:53:58
Alan,

Fellaini stepped straight into midfield because we'd sod all central midfielders and he was a club record signing... Baines was a victim of Moyes' penchant for playing players in the wrong position..As soon as Baines got his chance he took it and has been pretty much a consistently high achiever ever since..

Your revisionism of Fellaini is astounding...He was decidedly average for the first three seasons - granted he was injured and suspended quite a lot - but when he did get his chances he certainly didn't look like he was worth a fraction of the price we paid for him...

However, the last couple of seasons he has shown that he can, on any given day, be a cracking player..

However he HAS NOT shown that level with any consistency - last season he came storming out of the blocks and ended the season with a whimper..I would personally put his good performances at about a third of the season - and the rest he fluctuated between plain average and utterly useless..

The fact that he wasn't dropped again says more about Moyes than it does about Fellaini..

As for your continued suggestion that the board should be believed..frankly words desert me...

Paul Smith
195 Posted 18/07/2013 at 21:07:29
There is no need to sell Fellaini unless he wants to go but he hasn't stated this. Ross, I saying we need to sell to bring younger players in? that's crazy. We've got a great academy and several younger players looking to make thee first team this year and most importantly of all Fellaini is still in his younger years, so again a theory that has no substance.

Like I've said we've got to have the best possible team to compete with the best and Fellaini is in that bracket. All these myths about selling Rodwel/Arteta and improving the squad mean absolute shite when you finish 5th one season and 6th the next. What improvement is that?

The situation will never change while fans believe selling a great player helps improve the squad and i'll bet Man Utd never thought that when Ronaldo left. You can never have enough good players and as a fan that's all you should be arsed about instead of trying to do business the manager doesn't even want.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb