From boys to men

, 16 July, 59comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez eager to change Everton's development strategy
Chief Executive Robert Elstone, speaking at a Liverpool Business Week breakfast yesterday, explained Roberto Martinez's mission to turn promising teenagers in the Everton Academy into accomplished first teamers.

“Clearly our Academy graduates are very very important,” he said.“Roberto has come in and probably one of the first things he has looked at is the transition between 16/17 years of age when players are almost leaving the Academy up to 21 and 22. He feels that we have improvements to make in that age group.

“In this country, at an age when development ought to be at its most intense and at its most valuable, we almost stop developing. Players go from the Academy into reserve or Under-21 football and the development plan stops.

“Roberto has already started to look at coaching and structures and how we go about looking at that very important age group.

“It's not an area of expertise for me, but our head of Youth Development Alan Irvine and Roberto will tell you that at a point when a player is on the cusp of professional football it seems rather perverse to slow down their development. We should be accelerating and intensifying it at a time when technical development is still really, really important. We certainly can't assume that a boy has reached his technical development by the time he reaches 17 or 18.”

“Sometimes maybe the focus is on converting a young lad into being a tough, winning Premier League footballer to the detriment of maybe some of his technical development. What you have to achieve is a blend of both.

“Roberto's going to focus closely on that. And he's got a great, great guy leading that in Alan Irvine and that augurs well for us getting that right.”

He explained the impact the new boss has already had: “He's hit the ground running, is full of enthusiasm, has a great work ethic, but above else has come in with new ideas, a fresh approach — but absolutely sensitive to what's already there because there's already a lot of good stuff here which has been built up over a number of years.

“But he's been terrific and we're all excited and optimistic. He never stops working and he's a very nice man. So it augurs well.

“We know this is a results game and Roberto has been absolutely phenomenal in the very short space of time he has been with us and we are all very optimistic for what lies ahead.”

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (59)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Patrick Murphy
1 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:06:15
See even Alan Irvine is using that word - Phenomenal!
But it's good to see one of the old guard making positive comments about the new manager, although he couldn't say anything to the contrary could he?
Come on Alan bring us a batch of 4-5 first players from the youngsters in the next 2-3 years.
Drew Shortis
2 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:05:30
I would be interested to see how our academy stacks up against other top sides in terms of players produced. All players start off as youngsters so they must come from somewhere. We produce some half decent youngsters who go on to play in the lower leagues and in turn we pick up talented youngsters from them. It all goes around. I would like to see us produce more of our own talent, but this will only happen if they are good enough to step up. Currently the only one on our books who looks like a potential first team player is Barkley, the rest could do with some loan time to get match practice. In the same way we are going to develop Deulofeu, we should sent the likes of Stones, Junior and McAleny out on loan to get competitive games in L1 or the Championship.
Andrew Ellams
3 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:19:44
We have sent plenty of players out on loan over the last few seasons and lots of them seem to end up playing at that level on a permanent basis. ie Agard, Bidwell, Wallace, Mark Hughes and even going back to the likes of Phil Jevons.

Whatever happened to Iain Turner?

Steavey Buckley
4 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:34:25
Unfortunately, football is in the results business. And the only clubs who will rely upon home grown talent are those clubs who have little or no money spend on transfers and are going nowhere in their respective leagues. Everton for quite awhile having been doing quite well in the league without much need for home grown talent. And I don't see much change to that. Unless Martinez can unearth a Ryan Giggs or Wayne Rooney from the reserves.
Alan Humphreys
5 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:38:28
Says a lot about the previous regime along with Kenwrights comments about our non participation in the elite u21 comp.

When we signed Stones we should have done the same thing as Man Utd and Zaha, in loaning him straight back to the selling club, that way he was playing more competitive football as he was already a starter for Barnsley.

Like Stubbs said recently, when loaning a player out you need to ensure the club is right for the player and Everyon, no better example is surely Coleman's time at Blackpool under the astute stewardship of Ian Hollaway. The reverse could be said for Barkley and Neil Warnock at Leeds.

I would hope that under RM we might even loan the odd player out to an overseas club, where possibly a young player could hone his technical ability rather than learning how to take a kick in Division 1 (not that that subject shouldn't be on the curriculum, but its less and less in the modern game!)

Derek Knox
6 Posted 16/07/2013 at 16:53:49
Taken on board everything that has been said on this thread! Rooney's and Giggs's don't come along that often! However, I think Roberto will get more involved in the monitoring of 'potentials' progress in his tenure!
Remember that McManaman was considered not good enough and allowed to go! He's now, as a Wigan player being talked of as £7M target for Sunderland !
Hopefully that was a one off!
Phil Sammon
7 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:02:26
Alan

Completely agree. I have thought over the last few years that we have always had decent crops of 18 year olds. Unfortunately they get to that stage and stagnate in the reserves. It was one of Moyes' major flaws and something Martinez has quickly addressed.

You quite rightly point out the John Stones debacle. Withdrawn from competitive first team football to play in the U21's for 6 months. Who in their right mind thought that was a good idea?

I'd like to see Garbutt, Stones, Lundstrum, Junior, McAleny and Kennedy all have 6 month spells out on loan. Vellios too actually. Not all at once so as to deplete the squad of course.

It may also be nice to give some of these guys first team football in our own side. 10 minutes to go, leading 2-0 I'd much rather see McAleny brought on than Hitzlsperger of Heitinga. They need to get used to the big stage - something Moyes was petrified of enabling.

Andrew Ellams
8 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:19:31
I never understood Moyes fear of trying youngsters, his job was never on the line if the odd risk went wrong and he had the smallest transfer pot around so surely throwing in youngsters was a win win situation for him.
Steavey Buckley
9 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:13:59
Derek Knox: Everton have brought in someone named Gerard Deulofleu who appears better than Ryan Giggs and Wayne Rooney.
Wayne Smyth
10 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:13:45
Phil, unless they're needed for the first team squad I'd absolutely loan them all out. I'm sure the club can insert a recall clause in the contract, incase we get injuries and need the extra bodies.
Derek Knox
11 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:29:52
Steavey (268)
I think you have misconstrued what I said!
Deulofeu is only with us for 1 year, unfortunately! I was talking about young players on our books!
Al Reddish
12 Posted 16/07/2013 at 17:39:13
Wayne, I am with you there. Loan as many as you can out and promote those behind them that way everyone goes up a level. We can then sell them or play them.
Phil Brown
13 Posted 16/07/2013 at 18:01:04
Steavey # 268 - I think you're in for a bit of a shock if you think that he's better than Rooney or Giggs. He may well be a very good player in a few years but he's pretty raw at the moment.

Won't get the time and space afforded him on the YouTube videos. At his best on a flat curved run left to right, ball on his right foot, round the goalie to the right and side foot finish.

Alan Humphreys
14 Posted 16/07/2013 at 18:16:30
The Austria game if nothing else proved that RM is seriously looking at the depth of our squad which includes Academy/Reserve/U21 players - how he proceeds with them will be the key.

As Al (280) says promote the players I they're good enough, sell them if they're not, loan them out if unsure as to how they're progressing.. An addendum to that is that we should have on every contract on outgoing youth players, a decent sell-on percentage and also first option to buy.

Colin Glassar
15 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:01:02
Like I said on another thread we need to have a holistic approach towards all the players at different levels like at Barcelona's La Masia. They should all play in the same style and, at the youngest level, concentrate on the basics and leave the 110 mph stuff until they get older.
Martinez needs to put in place the people who will implement this policy. If that's Stubbsy and Irvine great if not then find the people who will.
Jimmy Kelly
16 Posted 16/07/2013 at 18:31:33
It's interesting to see that a number of people are assuming Martinez will improve the youth set up and give more chances to youngsters when it's something he has no real track record of.

At Swansea he was loyal to older players like Denis Lawrence, Kevin Austin and Kris O'Leary and allowed a couple of younger local lads (Shaun McDonald, Owain Tudur Jones) to go, they've gone on to have decent careers at that level. He even the let the Welsh Xavi go out on loan after he'd made a decent start to his career as a youngster there

At Wigan they were one of the infamous teams not to field an English player under 21 all of last season (I may be wrong but I think this was also the case the season before and the season before that they fielded one, who was on loan). Again he relied on stalwarts like Gary and Steven Caldwell and Emerson Boyce and used no marks like Crusat and Piscu to beef up the squad rather than try youngsters. He didn't even play McManaman in the league until March when he was all but 22 - looking at he way the lad played after that it's difficult to believe he wasn't ready some time before that.

I know this reads like criticism but it's not of Martinez in general, just the fact that he may not come in and give chances to all the youngsters like some seem to think . It also looks to me from the comments made that he is talking about English football's way of developing players rather than Everton's in particular.

James Stewart
17 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:32:13
Can't say any of the current crop look up to much. Duffy was dreadful the other day.
John Brennan
18 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:10:48
I'm delighted with what we have been hearing re Roberto looking at everything, not just the first team.
I was down at the Emirates when van Persie scored a cracker against us.
Mcaleney came on (as usual, too late to make much difference), and almost equalised for us.
That was Dec 2011, and we've seen bugger all of him since !
I hope this new Spanish kid has an influence on our youngsters re training, technical development, etc, but I also hope at the age of 17 plus, we arent already leaving it too late.
Re. this business of sending out kids on loan to Championship teams, is it such a good idea? I would agree with carefully chosen teams who played football the right way ala Swansea, but I wonder if we should'nt consider developing a relationship with a Spanish club through Roberto, where our youngsters could spend a season down there?
As long as they stay off the San Miguel and don't eat too much paella, perhaps this could be beneficial to our youngsters in the long run.


Mike Gaynes
19 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:31:21
Alan Humphreys (250), I agree with you on loaning players back to the same clubs, but ironically Coleman is an example of that strategy failing. In my opinion, he learned nothing from Holloway and returned from Blackpool the same ball-watching, head-turning, out-of-position defensive disaster he was when he left. The guy whose tutelage gradually turned Coleman into a solid Prem defender was David Moyes.
Colin Glassar
20 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:38:38
John Brennan, I like your idea about sending the youngsters abroad but, IMO, it would only be the very youngest as the older players will have picked up too many bad habits of the English game e.g. Panicking when under pressure, belting the ball anywhere, becoming desperate with 10 minutes to go etc... Cruyff always used to say that football is 30% stamina, 40% technique and 30% mental strength.
Mark Frere
21 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:49:09
We should just send 5 or 6 of our best youth players to Tranmere Rovers on season long loans, with the option to recall them
Colin Glassar
22 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:57:15
Why tranmere rovers mark? What could they possibly learn there apart from dodging some waist high tackles? I like the idea of some sort of deal with a European club where we could interchange with their youngsters.
Derek Knox
23 Posted 16/07/2013 at 19:34:43
Colin (310)
With you on that one 100% ! How many times have we watched a game, where everything is building up for a promising attack, there are a couple of attacking players homing in, someone delivers an absolute peach of a ball, and due to lack of control (basics) promise is replaced by despair!
This the case in most sports if you can't master the basics, you cannot hope to attempt the the more sophisticated manoeuvres!
I think and hope that RM will get these facets across!
Colin Glassar
24 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:06:01
Derek that's the problem with English players, when they are cornered they panic and usually make the wrong decision I.e. belt it anywhere. There are exceptions like Rooney and Wilshere but the majority are not taught to play themselves out of trouble. This will take years to fix but we, as a club, can make a start at youth level.
Mark Frere
26 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:14:56
Colin,

It would teach boys to become men and give them a real taste of professional football. League 1 isn't a bad standard for youngsters to learn, and being at Tranmere would keep the lads nice and local.

Its just an idea I suppose

Raymond Fox
27 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:22:36
Have to agree with John and Colin, loaning out young players to lower div. sides wont improve their skill levels.

Lack of ball control in the England National side has been our failing for the last 30-40yrs, and its no better now.

How many UK players are wanted by the bigger European clubs?

Colin Glassar
28 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:41:51
Mark, we seem to have some sort of deal with David Weir and Sheffield Utd so I suppose that is an option. As long as Weir can improve them then that's ok with me.
Lev Vellene
29 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:41:06
All absolutely well and good, and I couldn't agree more with the sentiments!

But I still have this feeling that Elstone is saying: "...this is what I was told, but I don't really understand anything without a £-sign in front of it... But this sounds like something that will raise spirits with the fans (fickle bastids that they are!), so I'll endorse it FULLY! The King is dead, long live the King!" ;P

And yes, I'm really hoping we'll be able to develop our youth instead of just releasing them on a free transfer when it's clear they can't immediately replace a first-teamer... :)

Kristian Boyce
30 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:31:48
To me the most interesting piece of info to out of the last Shareholders meeting was Bill saying the previous regime wasn't interested in entering in a team to the Next Gen competition. For some reason we've been lauded in the press as a team that brings through youth, Moyes especially. If that was the case, great, but in reality we've always had a bench full of youngsters due to having the smallest squad in the league, but never giving them a game.

I think Moyes not entering them into the competition, which would of pitted them with some of Europe's best youngsters show how much little faith he had in the U-21's and there development. Hopefully now a new regime this will change with RM.


Also I'm in full favour of us sending out players for a year abroad. Even if it was a loan like we got with Eric Dier. Imagine the education they would get even if they didn't get a game. Having a year learning the more technical side of the game would do wonders for some of these youngsters, and give them a huge advantage over their peers.

Steavey Buckley
31 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:41:50
Derek Knox: The fact is, there is no one really good enough from the reserves who is really good enough for first team action. Barkley is on the margins. David Moyes understood that, when he had no hesitation playing a 17 year old Wayne Rooney. Premier league is not the place to 'blood' youngsters who need time to develop and progress when results are everything.
Barry Rathbone
32 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:29:32
We breed athletes and physical specimens for the battle that is British football because "we" as fans won't tolerate a continental game.

Diet and conditioning expertise permeates even the poorest regions of the globe, athleticism is a given a level playing field not a trump card over skill anymore.

Brazilians are every bit as athletic as us but skill has never lost it's value as here every year they produce decent kids.

Whisper it ... but Rooney was decent for our game because of power and aggression, not at all convinced he would have been feted abroad.

Hopefully RM can pioneer a return to basic footballing technique (at least among our players) - British players have been over-rated for a few decades.

Lev Vellene
33 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:51:03
Steavey (#353): This is the sad truth these days. And yet Man U started off the 'glory' of the PL by mostly using their youth players to build a new team.

But now? Too much at stake just by losing not just a PL spot, but even by finishing too low in the league. And from a report I just saw today, Wigan didn't use an English player under 21 last year (in the league, at least). Hope that piece of news was not too correct...

Steavey Buckley
34 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:50:04
Phil Brown: I would say that Gerard Deulofleu is as good if not better than a 17 year old Wayne Rooney or Ryan Giggs. When there is no one nearly as good from the reserves who is even 20 years of age.

It is not so much about local talent lacking skills and technique, it's the demands of competing in a premier league where the likes of Swansea can go out and buy first class talent from abroad without waiting for their home grown talent to develop.

Paul Gladwell
35 Posted 16/07/2013 at 20:57:06
Is it me or is the wording from people at the club lately slightly having a dig at Moyes and his youth policy?
I did mention those rumours that Sheedy and the big fella never got on with him and he barely went to see the youth set up, this was said at a function not long after Moyes had got the Utd job from the men themselves, whether this was true I don't know.
Ross Edwards
36 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:05:23
Well, that phenomenal!!!
Steavey Buckley
37 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:01:34
Lev Vellene. The demands are so great these days, best talent from abroad is 'killing' off home grown talent. And the average fan does not matter as long as the results go their way. For I have not heard any fan from a successful team complaining that they would prefer local home grown talent to buying players from somewhere else.
Daniel Lawrence
38 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:15:49
Lundstram's off to Watford on loan by the looks of it. Great move
Colin Glassar
39 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:19:34
That is good news. Gianfranco will get him right for us.
Nicholas Page
40 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:26:22
Here's a radical thought.....we've taken on a Barca/La Maisa youth, why not send ours out there? Murray learned all his tennis in Spain and they certainly do technical development in football far far better than our bunch of hoofers. Would be great to see. Sticking some young lad in a team of run-a-round all day-kickers in 2nd/3rd division is hardly development. May as well play sunday league ale house footie. We need to be creative vs the monied-up Sky teams.
Colin Glassar
41 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:35:44
Nicholas, my point entirely. If not Barca any Spanish side that have a good academy system.
Wayne Smyth
42 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:36:29
Steavey, I disagree completely about Barkley and about not being able to give youth a chance in the premier league.

One of Moyes actions a few seasons ago was to bring journeymen into the team when we needed numbers. There was straq and there was McRooney. McRooney we'd seen before, and he was shit then and had already developed as much as he was going to. Straq was an unknown quantity, but quickly proved he was shit(albeit he always gave 100%, but then so would I and I shouldn't be near the first team).

Both of these players were short term fixes, and neither of them improved the team. If we're going to play players who don't have the ability to play at this level, I'd argue we should play our own academy players, like Barkley, who have the ability to improve and who will be here 12 months on.

Incase further proof were needed, Barkley went from not being good enough to get 10 minutes against a bottom of the table side, to being good enough to play against Spurs and Arsenal away....and he was one of our best players.

I'm no expert in developing footballers, but you don't go from being shit, to being capable of not looking out of place against arsenals players at their place overnight.

John Brennan
43 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:38:06
Nicholas, see my post above.
Wayne Smyth
44 Posted 16/07/2013 at 21:48:45
One more thing. We're in a results business, so we are told. We can't afford to lose points by allowing younger players to learn their trade with 20 minutes here and 10 minutes there. After all, each place in the league is worth, what, 800k?

Naismith adds very little to the squad, yet he's probably earning about 30-40k / week. That is about £1.5M / season, or roughly a couple of league placings.

It should be clear that its not obvious that we would be worse off financially should we get rid of a bit of the deadwood and replace them with young, cheap, hungry players from our academy, even if we did drop down the league as a result.

John Crook
45 Posted 16/07/2013 at 22:30:10
I believe that 2 or 3 of the 7 subs should be young players (the likes of Kennedy, Stones, Lundstram & Barkley). In games we are winning by 2 or 3 (optimistic I know), then this is the best time to insert youngsters straight into the team. Hopefully Roberto will do this and the days of bringing on Neville or Hibbert in the 82nd minute for a striker are over.
Alan Humphreys
46 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:01:07
Barry (354) completely agree, you only have to look at the premium English (rather than British) players attract if they show a small modicum of talent - the RS is a prime example of overpaying for such (Carroll, Henderson etc).

Nick (371) agree also. You can see the opposite with Dier, has honed his skills in Portugal and learnt the more physical aspect at Everton - has the making of a very good CB. Imagine what Lundstram or Barkley could learn just training with Iniesta et al.

Steavey Buckley
47 Posted 16/07/2013 at 23:50:31
Wayne Smyth: Steavey, I disagree completely about Barkley and about not being able to give youth a chance in the premier league.

Whatever you 'say' about Moyes giving youth a chance and the likes of Naismith been given chances to play in the first team, they did so because they had experience by playing in some recognisable league before joining. Where has Barkley been playing most of his football? Here and there and then back in the academy.

Everyone knows that the under 21 academy was dreamed up by the football league to improve the quality of home grown players, when most premier league clubs need the finished articles now, not in 2 or 3 years time.

Most games Everton are involved in, are being fought to the end. So there is not too much confidence in using inexperienced players even for 10 or 20 minutes. 1 point is useless when 3 can be obtained. That's why Moyes was wary using inexperienced players.

Daniel Starkey
48 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:17:43
Augurs well, hit the ground running, full of enthusiasm, work ethic, new ideas, fresh approach, and another phenomenal thrown in for good measure, getting cliched to death here, at the end of the day, sorry another cliche, it doesn't matter what kind of training regime you lay on for these youngsters, you can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear to coin a phrase or is that a cliche.
Chris Williamson
49 Posted 17/07/2013 at 00:50:46
You're right, Daniel. That's exactly why I try to avoid cliches like the plague.
David Ellis
50 Posted 17/07/2013 at 02:11:50
Hold on - we are buying Cliche ?
Phil Walling
51 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:03:11
I can`t help feeling that had Naismith been in our Academy he would never have qualified for a senior contract.
Extensive experience in the SPL is about on par with the Blue Square North,so it hardly counts does it?
Colin Glassar
52 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:42:46
David, I doubt city would sell Cliche just now unless..............they want Bainsey!!!! Nooooooo, they can keep Cliche, he's rubbish.
Daniel Starkey
53 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:42:01
Phil 459 They used to produce some of the best players in the World up there but you get sod all now, puzzling isn't it.
Steve King
54 Posted 17/07/2013 at 10:57:22
Udinese sent most of their youth and reserve squad to Watford last season to help them develop, albeit the opposite way around. They probably wanted to toughen them up, with their technical development well cared for in Italy.

I think it would be hugely beneficial if Martinez could use his Spanish connections to set up something similar with someone like Celta Vigo or Mallorca.

Colin Glassar
55 Posted 17/07/2013 at 11:25:34
We could also have a look at the Southampton academy. They have produced Bale, Walcott, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Shaw etc.... Very impressive.
Colin Glassar
56 Posted 17/07/2013 at 11:27:45
P.S. Whatever happened to WHU? They used to have the best youth system in the country.
Suresh Gill
57 Posted 17/07/2013 at 13:58:19
I have a feeling Martinez is going to have his best years as a manager with us. He will give Barkley more game play than Moyes ever did. He looks like he works hard on the training field with the lads too. That's always good to see in a manager.

Its great to smell a sense of freshness coming into the squad.

Colin Glassar
58 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:18:40
I agree Suresh, it might take him time but I can see he has a vision for the club which I like.
Trevor Lynes
60 Posted 18/07/2013 at 13:36:30
I think that a ceiling on the number of foreign players in a club's first eleven would encourage development of homegrown players. It's unfair that a club can just use money muscle to buy success at the expense of Brit youngsters. If Martinez can develop two or three of our youngsters to progress into the first eleven, it will be good for the club finances and the national side.

We seem to empty out lots of kids each season and they have included players like Jags and Baines who were subsequently developed elsewhere then bought back. McManaman could well be another!!

Haydn Milloy
62 Posted 18/07/2013 at 15:42:48
I don't understand where the lad George Green is? Why has the lad from Barcelona been brought in when we have the same style of player in George Green? If you go to Finch Farm and watch the youngsters play, like I have, the lad Green is different class but seems to come off the bench a lot of the time. Maybe he is not fit enough; he is only a small lad but by god does the ball stick like glue to his feet.

I hope to see him play a lot more this year and break through into the first team... but, when you see some that do come through ahead of the others, you ask yourself "How can that be?" Maybe it's a case of if the face fits,or they just don;t care. I don't recall a game at Finch Farm where I've seen Moyes present, so I hope to see Martinez out watching the youths.

The lad Pennington also looks like he could be ready to make the jump to the first team, strong fit lad that likes to play the ball out from the back. Man Utd did it with the kids – give ours a chance, and the England side might profit from it.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb