Time for Wayne Rooney to end his Manchester United nightmare and return home to Everton

, 17 July, 69comments  |  Jump to most recent
Rooney’s career now stands at a cross-roads. His form over the past few years has dipped alarmingly. Rather than go on and fulfil that undoubted talent he first displayed at Goodison and then during the early years at United, the England striker has stagnated.

Now it is Rooney who is ‘angry and confused’. ‘Angry and confused’ at comments from new manager David Moyes apparently hinting that this is now Rooney’s role at Old Trafford – to fill-in wherever the team may need him.

» Read the full article at Metro



Reader Comments (69)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Laing
1 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:17:04
With the seemingly endless speculation and in light of the recent comments from Wayne Rooney's representatives regarding his desire to quit Manchester United surely this is the right time and at the right stage in his career for Rooney to return to Everton.

Over the summer there have been a couple of posts on these pages which have discussed the pro's and con's of a return, with Chelsea waiting in the wings it isw or never for Evertonians to get behind the campaign to bring him back. The deal-maker would obviously be Fellaini moving in the opposite direction, a player Moyes would been keen to have in the ranks at United. I would have Rooney back now at 28 with 4-5 years ahead of him, never in my opinion should we be offering him a final swansong at 32-33, over the hill, overweight with nothing to offer.

John Crook
2 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:18:15
Rooney for Fellani straight swap no cash involved! If Rooney was to accept a 'normal' salary say Fellani's reported £75k a week maybe a bit more depending if there is anything left over from the new tv deal would you see this as good business?

It's obvious Rooney isn't happy at Man Utd and its obvious he doesn't want to play abroad. Get a swap deal done and get him back whilst he still at peak age.

The last thing Evertonians deserve is Rooney age 35 turning up on a one-year deal. Get him back now! Show some ambition! And Rooney wake up and smell the coffee! You have made your money for a thousand and one lifetimes!

Peter Laing
3 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:26:35
My thoughts John, the last transfer that had a player moving for the football rather than merely money or medals was Shearer when he went to Newcastle United.
Steve Guy
5 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:50:02
Never....going........to........happen. Ridiculous speculative rubbish
Jim Knightley
6 Posted 17/07/2013 at 14:54:56
I cant believe some of you are even considering this as a realistic possibility... please say it's sarcasm.
Patrick Murphy
7 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:15:05
Jim it probably is all pie in the sky thinking, but wouldn't it be fantastic if Rooney did decide to come here - sacrificing his high earnings to play for the club he supported as a boy. It won't happen though and I'm more worried that if the other lot sell rat-face and replace him with WR that would be hard to swallow.
Karl Masters
8 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:21:25
Patrick - it's 33 degrees outside and it must be that hot where you are and you are tied down like that fella in 'Bridge on the River Kwai' for you to think Rooney will ever go to Anfield. They are the one Club he wont sign for!

It's 100 times more likely he'd sign for Everton so that makes the odds of him slumming it in front of The Kop about a million to one!

Jim Knightley
9 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:23:05
It would be fantastic Patrick...but it won't happen. Firstly, swapping Fellaini for Rooney would be bad for us...it would change our whole system, as Rooney would want to play up top, and it would leave us even shorter in midfield. But apart from potential tactical problems

1) He would demand in excess of 100,000 in wages.
2) He would want Champions League football
3) Without selling Fellaini or Baines, we couldn't afford him.

But don't worry, Rooney will not, in a million years go to Liverpool. He is an ambitious player, and he will want a top four club without a shadow of a doubt. I also think there is a difference between an Everton fan moving to United, and to Liverpool, and irrespective of his past 'disloyalty' (not necessarily fair, hence the apostrophes) I doubt he would move to our rivals. But as I said, it just wouldn't happen anyway, because they are not good enough. I think Arsenal and Chelski are far more likely Premier League alternatives, and I wouldn't be overly surprised to see him move to Real Madrid, in view of their striking issue. Honestly, I can see Rooney coming back here at some point, but at 32/33, where I still think he could do a job in a deeper position.

Tommy Gourlay
10 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:28:17
@ Peter Laing (553) I don't think that was the last such move, I think you're forgetting our beloved Rhino's move back to us!!!!!
Stephen Karnes
11 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:25:03
Has everyone forgotten what his wages are? I just phoned Stephen Hawking to check (because they're astronomical) and it seems he's a bit pricey for us blues at the moment. Let's pay Phil Neville to leave cigarettes and Hot Pockets around the dressing room and try to pick him up after his stock plummets a bit further.
James Stewart
12 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:35:19
He won't come here but he does need to leave United. Didn't take long for Moyes to upset someone there did it.
Kevin Tully
13 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:28:09
Apparently he's worth £50m - so he could 'afford' to play for £100k a week if he wanted.

If we were a 'normal club' we could pay him another £50k per week just on extra merchandising & season ticket sales - but those two revenue streams are already tapped.

He will go for another big pay-day, probably with Chelsea. Don't want to see him back for his swansong when he's 32/33 - would love to see him here now though, but no chance unfortunately.

Steve Brown
14 Posted 17/07/2013 at 15:43:45
His basic salary is £250k a week and he won't take a penny less than that in his next deal. Footballers are only interested in money - just look at Sneijder who moved to Turkey rather than reduce his pay.
Paul Ferry
15 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:19:43
Moyes has started well at Man-U hasn't he?

Wiping streaming tear off cheek,
'
Anyone else feel that he looked a little out of place in the dug-out at the weekend?

Botched Ces bid - stupid public comment about WR - poor performance at the weekend - surrounding himself with Roundy and the boys.

Those Manure boards are buzzing.

WR needs to leave Moyes Manure to get himself back on track. He would be better off at Arsenal than Chelsea but wherever he goes fingers crossed he knocks them in against Moyes Manure.

Starting to really dislike Moyes now.

IHHFB

Colin Glassar
16 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:30:26
Rooney and our former manager are like oil and water. There's no chemistry there, in fact I think they really dislike each other. The mancs aren't happy and I imagine some of the senior players aren't either. It will be an interesting season at OT. Fergie to the rescue in December?
Steve Pugh
18 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:36:12
Felli to United on loan for the season, Rooney to us same deal. Parent clubs pay wages. No end of loan clauses. By the end of the season I reckon Felli's stock will have soared, Roo's will have fallen (because he's at Everton), hopefully we will be on CL (making Roo want to stay), at which point we can negotiate a permanent swap deal.
Brendan McLaughlin
19 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:46:45
Steve #613
OK I'll play...if Fellaini's stock soars and Rooney's falls...why do we want to negotiate a swap deal?
John Ford
20 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:46:14
There's some pretty strong coffee down your way Steve.......nice thought though

This is the bloke who wanted out of Man Utd because they weren't aiming high enough! His ego is the only thing to have grown commensurate with his pay packet.

Sadly the happy smiling evertonian kid who loved a kick about at Goodison faded away years ago. Oh boy how much I'd love to be proven wrong. The prodigal son returning, even with all his faults, would be welcomed.

Barry Rathbone
21 Posted 17/07/2013 at 16:38:27
A Utd mate just asked is Moyes a bit simple.

I told him he's a miracle worker, all round good guy and only money stops him being the greatest manager on the planet.

(Can't have them twigging too early - at least a half season of destruction will be a tremendous boost to the Prem).

Brin Williams
22 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:17:08
The Bellamy move to Cardiff worked out well for all concerned.

Why wouldn't Rooney WANT to come and play for us again.
I bet he's chomping at the bit for a return - ??

Roger Sunde
23 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:17:45
I think United fans are starting to see Moyes weakness, conclude all transfers on deadline day and start the season in January.
Robert Jones
24 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:21:02
Unless you are United fan why does anyone else care about Rooney wanting out at Utd and Moyes handling of the matter?
Colin Glassar
25 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:21:46
Well done Barry, they might want to send him back before long. Tell them he's great finding bargains but when it's big money signings he'll need a bit more time to find his feet.
Shane Corcoran
26 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:25:15
Richard Wright left the bench at Arsenal to sit on the bench (eventually) at Everton for less money.
Who thinks using Manure instead of Man U is funny?
Barry Rathbone
27 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:27:03
Colin, the "give him time" comment sailed through my mind but resisting "we give him 11 years and look at us" would have been impossible - would have nailed me right there.
Kevin Rowlands
29 Posted 17/07/2013 at 17:48:47
Anyone who seriously believe this will happen is living in lala land, the lad and his greedy bastard lawyer are looking for that final big payday, 200k plus a week wages, % of probably 30 mill transfer fee, living in Lahndan with the opportunity for his Mrs to commercialy cash in down there aswell, I'm afraid were not in Rooney's league financially, the next time we will see him put on an Everton shirt he will be well into his thirties if that ever happens.
Colin Glassar
30 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:04:36
Tell them that after a decade with him they can decide if he was good or bad.
Adam McCulloch
31 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:05:56
I daren't ask this question, judging by the incompetence of our board regarding transfer dealings...but didn't we have a 25% sell on clause with Rooney, if the offer was over about £26 million? He looks to be on his way, and if they're talking about a £40 million fee in the papers, that's quite a tasty windfall.

It will probably turn out that we traded it in for Pip, Saha and a packet of Polos. Wishful thinking eh?

Roger Sunde
32 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:23:02
@ Adam

We do have 25% from Rooney sale but its will be coming in over a period of 48 months, so not sure how good it will do us.

James Bowman
33 Posted 17/07/2013 at 18:05:42
Whether or not it's viable, I would definitely like to see him back. The dream of every footballer is success with the team they support, not playing for a Champions League team or earning £X per week.

Everton is in your blood, we all know that, so why would Rooney be any different?

I was upset when he left and it has taken a long time to see why, about 11 years. Clearly from the beginning Moyes has tried to hold back an amazing talent and he has become frustrated. Moyes seemed to have a way of teasing the youngsters with a glimpse of the first team, only to then destroy them by leaving them on the bench or in the reserves.

Rooney was too good for Moyes's youth system and I think now we will see many more coming through the ranks.

Brendan McLaughlin
34 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:16:50
Robert #627
It's a bit like your wife dumping you after 11 years for a local celebrity who also happens to be minted. We know that we should try and salvage some self-respect & dignity but try as we might we can't help the lame comments.
Peter Foy
35 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:22:06
He should come back and play for a modest salary plus shares in the club. Wouldn't be too long before he could kick Bill out of Goodison.
Ged Simpson
36 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:27:37
My big dream is to say "No thanks - we don't need you."
Ross Edwards
37 Posted 17/07/2013 at 19:36:55
Ha ha, won't happen. Can you imagine us competing with the likes of Chelsea for him? Man U want £50 million, money we don't have. 100k a week, no chance we can afford that especially with Billy No Dosh in charge.
Steve Pugh
38 Posted 17/07/2013 at 21:45:18
Brendan #617, because Felli won't get any better, nor Rooney any worse, their respective value will change due to the club they are at.
Alan Smith
39 Posted 17/07/2013 at 22:13:18
Webster rule.

That's why Arteta was £10m, and the Baines offer around £12m. Players don't want to implement it but clubs will not pay much more than what the player could tecnically buy themselves out for.

A very reliable source told me Chelsea about five weeks ago...II had £20 at 6-1

Brendan McLaughlin
40 Posted 17/07/2013 at 22:04:17
Steve #702
So the value of a player is determined not by his ability but by the club he plays for. So if Manure took Naismith off our hands on a free they could sell him for a few million in a year or two? Isn't credible is it?
Mike Allison
41 Posted 17/07/2013 at 22:21:03
Brendan it may not be right, but it definitely happens. Look at the shite United have sold on for money in the past. Ronnie Wallwork and Luke Chadwick would have been free transfers from anyone else, but because they'd come from United they were worth £1M apparently. That's what we need to do with young players we don't want.
Brendan McLaughlin
42 Posted 17/07/2013 at 22:28:17
Mike #712
I'm not saying it never happens... simply disagreeing that i'ts a given...
Peter Warren
43 Posted 18/07/2013 at 06:31:42
Pie in the sky? Perhaps. But maybe we could afford Rooney.

Sell Fellaini and Baines could bring in c£40m+. This should be enough. United would surely prefer selling to us rather than Chelsea or a team abroad in the Champions league.

Steve Pugh
44 Posted 18/07/2013 at 07:52:56
Brendan, a players value isn't determined by the club they play for, but it is influenced by it. Even players that bomb at the mega clubs seem to hold, or increase, value
Jon Ferguson
45 Posted 18/07/2013 at 08:02:03
Peter - If we sold Fellaini and Baines to buy Rooney we'd be screwed. We'd have an unproven left back and a giant hole in the midfield without any cash to fill it. We need to increase the size of our squad, not reduce it.
James Morgan
46 Posted 18/07/2013 at 08:21:21
The funny thing is he asked for a transfer because the club didn't match his ambitions with regards to signings. So they got RVP. Then he kicks up a stink. You got what you asked for, Wayne.
Peter Warren
47 Posted 18/07/2013 at 08:33:37
Jon 780# I was not advocating either way. I was just showing that we could probably afford the transfer in response to people who said we couldn't.

I don't think Rooney would come back here anyway even if we could afford him.

Bobby Thomas
48 Posted 18/07/2013 at 08:55:11
Absolute bollocks, he will go to Chelsea or Arsenal.

Chelsea are openly courting him, but he's gonna come back here?

Anyone believing its a possibility is a bit simple.

Andrew Cutler
49 Posted 18/07/2013 at 09:01:55
This thread is a cul-de-sac: it leads nowhere when and if ratiocination is applied. WR is 28 and still has a big ego to fry. Personally, I think he's a fabulous footballer but, in adult terms, he's still a young man. He will go where the global prestige and big money hang out. Everton isn't that place...yet!

In short? : the whole WR issue is a red-herring. We Evertonians are on the cusp of a VERY exciting renaissance and let us dedicate our thought, devotion and intelligent passion to this 'frisson event'.

Chris Fisher
50 Posted 18/07/2013 at 09:49:10
I think its possible that it could possibly be a deal that EVENTUALLY suits all parties, Man United wont sell him to Chelsea because they are worried that it could come back to haunt them, Rooney wont move abroard, Man United cant have him at the club any more because of the distraction he would cause and the fact that the United fans will give him dogs abuse after all this, Man United want Baines or possibly Fellaini, we will want a lot of money or a really good deal, as the transfer deadline approaches Rooney just wants out and could realise that he has alot of money now and the challenge of getting Everton into the champions league and becoming a hero at the club he and his kids support is worth more to him than £££ United bid for Fellaini we turn it down and ask for a straight swop for Rooney, United realise that this suits everyone and agree, we make Roney our highest paid player on 80 thousand and everyones happy.
Colin Glassar
51 Posted 18/07/2013 at 10:11:36
Chris, if that's the case then let him buy out BK and his gang and then he can become owner/captain and everyone will be happy.
Alan Smith
52 Posted 18/07/2013 at 11:03:41
He's going to Chelsea. Deal done weeks ago, before Moyes got there.

I totally agree though Chris. If Everton would have put to him like that, he may have been tempted. No9 shirt, cpt, etc...

However selling either Baines or Fellaini would not inspire him. And neither would £80k a week. With the revenue he'd bring to the club I think we could offer him £160k plus image rights. Can you imagine how many shirts he'd sell, season tickets would sell out and we'd be sky almost as often as the RS.

Don't think he wants to play for a selling club though.

Alan Smith
53 Posted 18/07/2013 at 11:03:41
He's going to Chelsea. Deal done weeks ago, before Moyes got there.

I totally agree though Chris. If Everton would have put to him like that, he may have been tempted. No9 shirt, cpt, etc...

However selling either Baines or Fellaini would not inspire him. And neither would £80k a week. With the revenue he'd bring to the club I think we could offer him £160k plus image rights. Can you imagine how many shirts he'd sell, season tickets would sell out and we'd be sky almost as often as the RS.

Don't think he wants to play for a selling club though.

Steven Telford
54 Posted 18/07/2013 at 11:29:20
Ok, so some people have desires for Moyes will fail.
I like Moyes, but don't particularly care how he gets on an Man united, I understand (and share) the animosity of the chasing of Baines....etc
Fine, but to talk about him not getting off to a good start before he has actually properly started betrays a bit too much internal bitterness.
The Rooney issue was there before he even go there, and friendlies don't count for much. Maybe he does well, maybe not - who cares. Why wish him any worst that you wish any manager of any other club.

If Martinez does not work out it I bet it will be the same people who at this moment are singing his praises most loudly that most sharply turn on him. Both managers have something to prove, and neither has yet properly started.

Alan Smith
55 Posted 18/07/2013 at 11:56:19
He left us for a competitor, it's only natural for people to want him to fail.

I on the other hand want him to succeed, to prove that I was right about him being a good manager in all those arguments with kopites for the last 10years.

No none could fail at Man U anyway. They are now the bayern of our leaque, even Chelsea and city can only sustaine a challenge for one or two years before they have to rebuild again costing millions.

You watch, Man U will get the best prem lqu player again this summer- Bale. Like they do almost every year. if not they'll get him next season and settle for Ronaldo this summer.

Steven Telford
56 Posted 18/07/2013 at 12:30:38
Alan,
If he left us for Spurs or Liverpool, then we could more acutely say he left us for a competitor. But United, - kind of, in some ways, but not really. He left for the biggest job in English football. That's more forgivable these days than it was in the 1980s-1990s
As well, people can fail at Man united, because failing at Man United is defined as not wining the league. And Jose is back and Man city can buy it again.
Ste Traverse
57 Posted 18/07/2013 at 13:38:37
When are the idiots banging on and on about Rooney's return going to wake up and smell the fucking coffee?

WE'VE NOT GOT THE MONEY TO ACQUIRE SUCH A PLAYER.

"Bring him home" etc...do shut the fuck up.

Peter Jansson
58 Posted 18/07/2013 at 22:09:05
What do you guys think of a Baines-Rooney swap? Is that a good or a bad deal for Everton? And is it possible to get a deal like that if we wanted? What do you say?
Ross Edwards
59 Posted 18/07/2013 at 22:29:38
No Peter, it would be a bad deal. We would be getting rid of our best player, the player who created the most chances in Europe last season, for a striker who is very inconsistent, whose wages are very high and who is very arrogant and self centred, and lets not forget, the "Once a Blue" rubbish, then kissing the badge in front of us.

Don't want that to happen.

Ross Edwards
60 Posted 18/07/2013 at 22:35:35
"No none could fail at Man U anyway"

Really? I point to you Wilf McGuiness and Frank O'Farrell, who were both sacked within a year of each other after succeeding Sir Matt Busby after 24 years, working under his shadow, and DM will be the same following Fergie.

Managers coming in to big clubs often crumble under pressure, especially succeeding a manager of such a high stature and legend of the club.

Colin Glassar
61 Posted 18/07/2013 at 23:18:29
Dave Sexton was a massive flop after leaving Chelsea, Ross. Tommy Doc and his young uns were one of the best manc sides I've ever seen. He got the sack for screwing his physios missus didn't he?
Kev Johnson
62 Posted 18/07/2013 at 23:28:39
Ah yes, the old "Who's up Mary Brown?" chant! I remember it well. You're right, Colin, he had a very good team there.
Alan Smith
63 Posted 18/07/2013 at 23:30:51
Times have changed. Man Utd are worth £3billion, Chelsea might win a couple of titles on the spin but Man Utd will always be there now.

The Premier League and sky have created a monster. It will always pick up titles the moment Chelsea or city have one transition season or a couple of injuries.

Players still prefer to play them over the other 2 as well, so most seasons they'll have the best players.

I'd bet 13 more titles in next 20 years. Will Ambramovic still be at Chelsea in 20 years.... Man Utd will be worth £6 billion by then.

Colin Glassar
64 Posted 19/07/2013 at 12:08:00
Alan, players might have prefered to play under SAF but now under dour Dave things have changed a little. While city buy the worlds best no one seems to want to join the ginger revolution!! Plus the fact that he's pissed off his marquee player for no reason at all. This news has gone global and doesn't help.
Ross Edwards
65 Posted 19/07/2013 at 12:47:54
How much are you willing to bet Alan on Man U winning 13 more titles, because they won't win anywhere near 13, not with Dithering Dave in charge.
Andrew Ellams
66 Posted 19/07/2013 at 13:09:29
Even if we suddenly became Man City type rich I wouldn't touch Rooney with a barge pole. Nothing do with what's happened in the past, I just think the guy has fast become the biggest prick in football which in the current world is some achievement.

His attitude stinks, his game has gone backwards and I just don't think he can be arsed anymore.

Ross Kerry
67 Posted 19/07/2013 at 13:14:04
Alan@953 I’ll take your bet all day long, no chance of them winning 13/20. Moyes still hasn’t bought anyone, this would be unbelievable if we didn’t know better. He’ll dither and dither and come to the conclusion that he knows what he gets with Baines and Fellaini and buy them – when he should already have bought players with a winning pedigree.

Chelsea and City will carve up the titles with Utd pretty evenly over the next 10 years and in that time another club (or two) will have the backing to be in the frame. I hope so anyway.

Ross Kerry
68 Posted 19/07/2013 at 13:15:13
The Scottish Rooney has gone back to his roots I see, I would swap Baines for the English one if it was on the table but I can’t believe it would be and he can command a bigger wage than we should pay any player.

I do think he’ll be back in 4 years time when he is (hopefully) having to fight for his place in the England team with a world cup on the horizon and isn’t guaranteed a place in the team at Chelsea/City or whoever. That is unless he couldn’t get in our team which I wouldn’t rule out.

Ross Edwards
69 Posted 19/07/2013 at 22:23:46
Alan Smith

Tottenham are more likely to win the PL before Dithering Dave does.

Steven Telford
70 Posted 21/07/2013 at 12:36:35
Andrew #043
Too true
Simon Jones
71 Posted 22/07/2013 at 14:33:53
If the gossip is to be believed and Wayne Rooney is to leave Old Trafford, then does anyone know if we have a sell-on clause in his contract? I recall that we received £20M in two £10M payments plus a bunch of add-ons that would amount to another £7M over time.

So if the club were far-sighted enough to insert a sell-on clause, then we might have another decent slice of income on its way.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
72 Posted 22/07/2013 at 14:34:27
Simon,

You submitted this as a new Talking Point but, as this thread shows (#637), we have discussed this point recently, so I moved it here.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb