Moyes admits his fear of Old Trafford

, 23 July, 357comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes has described his cowardly mindset when visiting Old Trafford as Everton manager: "I remember going there as a manager. You want to get out of Old Trafford alive, that used to be our saying, you know."

» Read the full article at Daily Mail



Reader Comments (357)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Andrews
1 Posted 23/07/2013 at 06:42:52
Moyes in today's press interview...."You used to say oh no we are going to Old Trafford....you just wanted to get out alive, that was our saying"

No wonder he never got 3 points there.

Paul Gladwell
2 Posted 23/07/2013 at 11:38:23
So that's his latest classic: "We used to think oh no Man Utd next I hope we get out alive."

Unbelievable, well actually it's what many of us thought.

Richard Reeves
3 Posted 23/07/2013 at 11:56:09
Paul (#826), I've just seen it myself and was going to comment on it but you beat me to it. It's almost unbelievable that he came out with that comment even though as you say it's what most of us thought anyway. Another case of the man with no balls buttering up the Man Utd faithfull and media with praise for Fergie in order to gain popularity with the fans as he will need a lot of time to challenge for the league title.

I'm just happy that he's not with us anymore and that we have a new manager who wants to play football without excuses. Crikey,a friend of mine who supports Man Utd already has the bug, he texted me the other day saying,"Now I know how you've been feeling". The only words of encouragement I could give were,"you should count yourself lucky, you'll only have him for two years max."

David Donnellan
4 Posted 23/07/2013 at 12:27:31
Paul #826, I think he had that mindset against other teams also, namely the shite. Judging by some of our cautious performances against them.
Jackie Barry
5 Posted 23/07/2013 at 12:29:36
I read that too Paul, couldn't believe what I was reading! It made me think is this why we never really won at the so called big clubs? It all makes sense now when you have a mentality like that.
Paul Gladwell
6 Posted 23/07/2013 at 12:32:35
Shocking really, did Brenda across the park have that attitude despite the fact they have finished below us two years on the bounce?
Ross Edwards
7 Posted 23/07/2013 at 12:59:09
Can you imagine Paul how Moyes will crumble if Barcelona play him in the Champions League?

I can't see them "getting out alive" from that!

Paul Gladwell
8 Posted 23/07/2013 at 13:03:57
He did a good job but I always felt we were patronised by outsiders telling us how good he is and how lucky we are blah blah blah and I think he is going to get found out and hope he does. Bitter? Yes but I cannot help it, even though what his side kick (Round) had to say today about they are involved in a different level altogether, now I still felt hurt that he said that.
Ross Edwards
9 Posted 23/07/2013 at 13:09:04
I said when he got the Utd that he didn't give a damn about us and how we got on in future, he is trying to forget everything about the last 11 years. He used us to get that job. Plus he was damned lucky as well.

If Ferguson wouldn't have been in the decision process, Moyes would not have got that job. People may and will disagree with me, but it's my own personal opinion.

He has done nothing remotely deserving of the Man Utd job. 1 trophy in 15 years. He only got that job because Ferguson chose his successor. Martinez has been a manager for 6 and has won more major silverware than him already, the FA Cup last season.

If he lasts longer than 3 years at Man Utd I will be surprised.

Ross Edwards
10 Posted 23/07/2013 at 13:21:39
Also Paul, Man U have just lost their 2nd game out of 3 under DM. 3-2 defeat to Yokahama. 2-1 up at HT. KITAP1 obviously failing already it seems.
Simon George
12 Posted 23/07/2013 at 15:39:06
It may have been our saying, but I'm not sure it's everyone's.
Kevin Tully
13 Posted 23/07/2013 at 15:46:37
I don't know why we never just sent them 3 pts in the post?

We actually paid this man £3-4m a year??????

Matthew Williams
15 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:05:59
What a gobshite. 11 years, no trophy, shit attitude — no wonder we never got close to beating them at OT.

I hope he gets found out & hounded out of his job for the fraud he is, should be fun when the dour one returns to Goodison. Let's do 'em, boys, cos we're Everton! Not fucking phony bandwagon jumpers who think they have a divine right to do as they please! Manc pricks!!!

Paul Andrews
16 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:17:28
And there you have it.

Confirmed inferiority complex against the bigger clubs.

I thought the "knife to a gunfight" comment was cringeworthy, this one beats it hands down.

Andrew Laird
17 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:22:42
Moyes has gone, fuck him.
Paul Ferry
19 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:14:25
"I used to hate playing Yokahama, all we wanted to do was get out of there alive" (David Moyes, Yokahama coach, June 2015)

Since taking the Man Utd job – his last home game aside – Moyes Manure has been digging deeper holes for himself with respect to us. If this continues – not giving up on LB, for instance, more choice comments – then I hope he gets volleys of jeers when he comes back next year.

On another note, he looks so much out of his depth / comfort zone on the Man Utd bench. He's grinning like an ape

http://i3.dailyrecord.co.uk/incoming/article1878429.ece

But inside where it matters he is bricking it.

Dear Lord, one of the world's top-3 now have Hieroglyphics Round with is jiggle bore board, chubby Kes Lumsden who looks on the brink of a coronary when he breaks into a gentle run, hand-clap pointy Pip, and king of the manure pile, David William Moyes, 'Och, Robin track back ... och Roundy 77 minats, time fer first sub'

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1693999-has-david-Moyes-made-a-mistake-with-his-coaching-team-at-manchester-united

Just read those buzzing narky Man-U boards.

No wonder Scholes who adore the club turned down Ginger's coaching offer. He can see the writing on the wall for sure.

IHHFB

Paul English
20 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:38:04
The more I read about this man, the more I feel I'll I'm just glad I never clapped him in his last game at GP. He's not worth a carrot... his ginger will soon turn white...
Mike Hughes
21 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:54:53
Un-bloody-believable.

My opinion of DM has gone on a pretty steady downward slide since about last Christmas. A slight upward peak at the WHU game but steep downward slope since.

I'm sure his career has already peaked and it's all downhill from here.

All the balls of a soprano that's just been dropped from a great height and landed with a railing between his legs.

Mind you, it makes me even more optimistic for this coming season.

Scott Hamilton
22 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:50:52
I'm in no way defending Moyes but I think you are taking him too literally here. He is obviously just trying to butter-up the Utd faithful in the same way as he did with his "The People's Club" comments when he joined us.

I agree that his results against the top 4 were generally poor but I seem to remember a thrilling 4-4 at OT the time before last that we went there plus a follow-on season opening victory at Goodison.

And the article is in the fucking Daily Mail for Christ's sake!

Just another opportunity for the MOB to dust-off their cut-and-paste comments and keep another thread chasing its tail for the next few days...

Mike Hughes
23 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:03:05
Scott - I was never a "MOB" but I'm now a "GHG" (glad he's gone).
Colin Glassar
24 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:45:56
"Knife to a gunfight", "Lucky to get out alive", "Let's get to 40 points first", "They're a really tough team" etc, etc, etc....... I'm just glad he's come out of the closet and declared himself a gutless, mindless, dour, boring, insipid, back-stabbing, inferiority-complexed, small-minded little man. I always knew it and the Mancs will soon find out for themselves what they've got.

ps: "When I was SUMMONED by SAF" was the worst one IMO. Traitor!!!

James Morgan
25 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:51:45
I dislike the man more and more. It's refreshing after 11 years of this yellow belly we have a manager who likes to hammer home his motto, 'without fear.'
Scott Hamilton
26 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:06:18
Mike (903) - I was never a MOB but am also a GHG.

Doesn't prevent this whole thread from being nonsense though!

Brin Williams
27 Posted 23/07/2013 at 16:38:57
It is difficult for a Moyes fan to realise that his faith in the man was at best ill-founded.

During his reign at Goodison my admiration/disappointment with the man fluctuated from one extreme to the other but in the main his popularity declined and I questioned the reasons for giving him the benefit of another contract.

People say that the past two seasons were our best under
his stewardship - nevertheless I was not been entirely happy with our style of play and some of his decisions/substitutions were open to ridicule.

His decision to jump ship was in my view very welcome. I had enough and pondered the renewal of my season ticket unless there were sweeping changes in the running of the club. Thankfully that has not been necessary and I shall be sitting in my same seat in a month's time.

Martinez was not my first choice replacement - but boy have I been surprised and gladdened at the new fella's attitude, demeanour and outlook on the game we all love. I really hope he succeeds for the sake of all of us fans and the club in general. I have a distinct feeling that Uncle Bill has come up with a Gem and the way money is suddenly becoming available (?) is in its self encouraging.

But back to DM - I didn't really want to talk about him now that he is longer associated with Everton - but his latest comments really do sum up what others, I must admit I hadn't, seen in him for sometime now.

I always had him down as a dour, play it safe, a draw is better that a loss, sort of chap and I also know that he chickened out of that Semi and shit himself whenever faced by a red shirt. BUT I never thought he would openly admit it.

So what's all this about you say.

Well just this, sod Moyes, sod Man U they deserve each other and while Everton are looking forward to the new season with newfound joy and expectation of a Champions League place -he and his ilk are quaking in their boots, probably shitting themselves in trepidation of what lies ahead.

I remember a once wealthy fellow telling me that 'being poor' was not as bad as 'going poor'. That is what frightened the shit out of him!!

The King is Dead Long live the King - Viva Roberto, Viva Everton.


Mike Hughes
28 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:08:47
Scott - fair enough (and it was the Daily Mail and he is buttering up MUFC fans as you say).

But read Colin's post at #904 and imagine those words uttered by a manager of any standing.

They're the words of a manager of Steve Bruce's ilk.

But not of Mourinho or SAF or even Wenger.


Paul Doyle
29 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:03:02
The man is a shit-bag, full stop!

Under him we never got anything at the so-called top four. I can't wait to watch him as his kicks curl up in the Champions League, let's see how the Mancs respond to such tactical innovations like pulling forwards off to be replaced by defenders or sending out a team with 6 centre-halves on the pitch.

Yes this is the tactical genius that gives youth a chance!

The feed back from our players over the pre-season training says it all really about sergeant major Moyes, where last year training was about 10 mile runs up and down sand dunes pulling tyres on the end of rope, this year it's about football and lots of it.

Moyes is a phoney who will be lucky to last a season.


Kevin Tully
30 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:11:55
Can't imagine any other P.L. manager saying to their wife ; "Quick, take me home to get changed, Sir Alex wants to see me, and I can't turn up at his house in jeans"

Tony McNulty
31 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:15:05
At least he might have more of a chance of winning at OT now.

Ferguson to take over again in an emergency within 6 months.

Scott Hamilton
32 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:14:00
Mike (908) - I have no real argument with anyone who feels that Moyes was a negative/defeatest manager.

My point is that he is saying the sort of thing that I would expect any new manager to say. Wouldn't you love it as an Evertonian if Roberto said something very similar about visiting Goodison Park as Wigan manager? Why everyone is therefore using this as an excuse to once again bang on about "the ex" is beyond me! Let's move on.

Karl Jones
33 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:23:14
Typical of his mentality really...No wonder we never came close to winning there. Good riddance.
Gerry Quinn
34 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:21:53
Let's move on - altogether now...

Follow, follow, follow,
Everton are the team we follow
And we'll play our concerto to the tune of Roberto,
He's the Spaniard that plays "Sin Miedo"

Brent Stephens
35 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:21:21
I honestly couldn't give a toss.
David Greenwood
36 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:19:35
I am coming round to the notion that when we play them at Goodison next April he won't be in charge.

It looks like he has upped his bid for Fabregas to from 25 mil to 35mil.
If he really wants Baines then please BK don't roll over for him. Get the top price for the best player in the world in his position.

DM is prepared to go to 35 probably 45 for Fabregas (he needs a signing) if he comes back for Baines set the bar high.

Like most of the people on here I would rather have gone to OT in the past and gone down having a go, rather than just trying to keep it tight and hoping not to be hammered.

Cant wait for the start of the season, I think Bobby is currently and will continue to be a breath of fresh air.

18 out of 18 after six games, no problem :)

Tony Marsh
37 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:07:13
Ha Ha, slow to learn some of you lot. Do you remember the uproar a few seasons ago when I called Moyes a football coward?

I was on this Joker from Day One. I never liked Moyes, his football or his mindset. So many of you refused to see through this terminal loser and stuck by him no matter what.

Well the truth is out now Moyes is an Arsehole. So glad he has gone and I can't wait to watch the Ginger Prick squirm when he gets dismantled by Mourinhio and the rest of Europe/s elite coaches. Good riddance to bad rubbish, I say.

Colin Glassar
38 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:25:47
Even Phil Mcnulty on twitter is saying his comments show "a real poor state of mind". Can you imagine any manager, in whatever walk of life, admitting to having such a pathetic, defeatist, negative attitude towards a rival?
Chris Leyland
39 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:23:17
Jesus - cant we just move on? He isn't our manager any more and I'm getting sick of logging on to ToffeeWeb to read about the team I support, Everton, to see many articles about Man Utd 's manager and people who disliked him simply confirming what we already know - they didn't like him or those who did like him confirming they did. What's done is done, let's look forward instead of obsessing on our former manager.
Denis Richardson
40 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:19:38
End of the 20 odd years of dominance for manure. Moyes will be found out and their tough start to the season may just be the catalyst for that happening sooner than later. Also looks like a few players suddenly don't fancy transfering to manu - wonder why!

Will be 'interesting' it to see him against the top european sides.

Am over the moon the guy has finally gone and we can make our football fun to watch again.and try to first get 3 points, as opposed to protecting the draw from the off!

What odds we finally get a win at one of the 'sky 4' this season.

Tony Marsh
41 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:41:36
It's strange how many fans on here keep telling us to move on from Moyes and forget him yet some of these same fans would bring Walter Smith into the equation when trying to defend Moyes and his crap footy.

Strange one.

Paul Gladwell
42 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:41:29
Chris there is not exactly a lot to chat about until the season starts, but why can people not chat about this?

I got slated on here a few months back for claiming he was a coward when it came to going to Anfield a his record proved that, then when you read stuff like this, it just confirms it.

I am moving on, I thought he did a good job, but also have not looked forward to a season so much for years and I will tell you what, if he starts playing one up front and getting found out tactics wise I shall comment on it as I was sick of getting patronised by outsiders for years telling me to shut the fuck up and count my lucky stars we have some God-like manager.

We can move on and still debate the past you know.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
43 Posted 23/07/2013 at 17:55:00
Chris, I've been suppressing as much as is reasonable but I think some stories will cross the line, and this one clearly had before I logged on today — there were comments about this cowardly quotation on a number of other threads. I decided to gather them in one place.

It relates directly to his time as Everton manager, and it relates directly to a mindset which his supporters would not hear spoken of or accept at the time. So, sadly, this one gets air.

I, more than anyone, wish to forget him completely, and would not have any posts about him at all if it were my way, but clearly this is never going to happen.

Paul Andrews
44 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:10:14
Tony Marsh, Paul Gladwell: I agree 100%.

it is relevant, because the fans who denied the previous manager played scared, tactically inept football and got away with it for years have been proved wrong. Out of the horses mouth an all that.

Michael, well done: it is a good point for debate. Hopefully some of the IMWT will accept their misinterpretation of Moyes.

Chris Leyland
45 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:11:35
Tony Marsh - And stranger still that those people who couldn't wait to see the back of him and wanted him gone so desparately to move the club on now seem to be the ones who want to talk about him all the time
Jeremy Benson
46 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:14:51
Paul, I don't think anyone would disagree that we wish we could have done better and played with more confidence against the top 4 sides.

But to accuse Moyes of being "tactically inept" when under his tenure we largely had the most successful spell in the last 20 years, and brought huge stability to the club, is a bit silly. It's a bit like calling your ex-girlfriend fat after she dumps you. Its all a bit school-yard stuff.

Moyes has gone, let him go. He had his faults - but despite this, he was overall a success. To deny this, when the largest club in the world have chosen him to be their manager, suffers from a bit of credibility issue in my eyes.

Kevin Tully
47 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:23:21
Jeremy, I would describe his methods & football as effective, rather than successful.

We aren't exactly going to be waxing lyrical about his teams in 20 years time, are we?

Derek Williams
48 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:30:26
I'm with Scott (902) - it's a daft thing to say but you would hope it was intended more as a positive message for the Man Utd fans, as in EVERY club felt intimidated going to OT, not just Everton.

Still, having dropped a clanger by giving Rooney the impression he will only be required if RVP has an off day (which I don't think he meant either) he does need to do a crash course in sound bites and diplomacy.

Or keep his gob shut!

John Crook
49 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:24:00
The general consensus is that we are thankful for the Moyes contribution early on and the stabilisation of the club but the fact that he got 11 years takes the piss. As mentioned above several times, forget about Moyes and get behind Senor Martinez!
Paul Ferry
50 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:30:50
Chris Leyland (919) 'Jesus - cant we just move on?'

So, you are suggesting that discussion of the Moyes era is an example of not moving on?

How silly.

From now on all you toffeeWebbers I am placing an absolute ban on any discussion or even bare mention of say the Kendal '85 team. Got it. Move on you sad bastards. And if anyone ever dares mentioning Alex Young, you will be in serious deep water sunshine. The past is past. Move on. Get a life. Stop ruminating on what has gone.

I can't believe that a comment from Moyes that we first heard of today that has a direct bearing on the culture of the club in his hands has generated so many posts.

You shower of sad sickos. Me, I'm already thinking about the gaffer after the gaffer who replaced Martinez in 2027.

There is the present and there is the future and it's more than high time that you Moyes-dwellers got to grips with this.

All history is bunk.

Eugene Ruane
51 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:29:40
Odd (dumb?) thing to say but..only what many Evertonians thought.

Can't help getting a mental picture of Shaggy Moyes jumping into Scooby Rounds arms and shouting "ZOINKS!" as a ghost wearing a Utd shirt hovers into view.

Colin Glassar
52 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:43:47
Paul, stop quoting Henry Ford. I think this is more an exercise in self exorcism more than anything else and a question of free speech. I still have big issues with messrs Catterick, Bingham, Lee, HK (mark II and III), Walker, Smith and OFM aka ginger. Too many gripes to put on here but I'm thinking of writing a book.
James McPherson
53 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:43:21
I agree it's folly to expect any discussion around Moyes to immediately disappear.

But more folly still is the belief that this is debate.

It is not. it's a thread that merely enables existing prejudices to be aired again.

His comments do not surprise me in the least...and tells me absolutely nothing new. Silly pre-season stuff.

Mind, I think all the "gushing" over Martinez is equally daft...all this optimism...3 ex Wigan players and (agreed) a really positive loan. New beginnings...errrr...no.

Oliver Molloy
54 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:23:35
Lets be honest,he could never have turned the utd job down,but in accepting this huge post I truly believe that Moyes is going to be found to be out of his depth.
I am so happy he has left us.

Although boring as a coach I was grateful to him for raising our expectations while he was our manager.

I admit I did buy into his thinking until the semi final against the other half,when he proved to me once and for all he has no bottle,that result was the one that broke the camels back for me.

We should have easily won that match,and but for Moyes, we would have.

Jose is already winning the "mind games" hands down and Moyes looks like an amateur in press conferences,he says stuff without thinking,and the pressure from the press and media has not even got going yet.It seems to me Moyes knows full well there are a lot of utd fans that are very very worried at his appointment and is coming out with all kinds of drivel just to try and win them over,but it is not working,and I say come on Swansea.
He has had no respect for Everton since leaving,and that will come back to haunt him hopefully.


In Martinez we have a guy who is not afraid to "go for the win",he will be fully aware that Everton fans have had to put up with a coach who in general was "a score and defend at all costs" type.
He will also know if he get's the results in the right places he will endear himself to us fans,and get himself noticed elsewhere.
I am looking really forward to the new season and if we can hold to our best players I think it will be exciting to say the least!

Barry Rathbone
55 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:08:15
With every passing day another comment from this "arrogant buffoon" ticks a box from the list of denials by his devotees, (remember the slagging I got for that little observation?)

Such comments as these are integral to all the shite of the past 11 years a fundamental reason why we never won anything.

But he can't be blamed for the myth, evertonians (notably absent these days) who really should have known better gave life to that desperate misjudgement.

No miracle worker was he just a bog standard defensive coach more hindrance as each year went by.

Dreadful attitude and a source of embarrassment he got away with it for over a decade taking millions out of the club en route.

Genuinely hope he gets mullered at OT, about time a bit of come-uppance landed at his door for what he did to my Everton.

David Greenwood
56 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:00:34
Oliver, totally agree, semi final was a disgrace.

James, if this isn't new beginnings, jeezo, what is it?

Utd have far more to worry about with their new manager than we do with ours.

Exciting times ahead.

James McPherson
57 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:07:36
David Greenwood - fair comment - with this board we are going nowhere...Martinez/Shmartinez - makes no odds.

Kenwright needs to go and not just Moyes

Mike Green
58 Posted 23/07/2013 at 18:55:19
It's not even as if Old Trafford's all that anyway - just a big stadium filled with dumb, spoilt, quiet, glory hunters.

Where Moyes' saw shark infested waters, Roy Keane quite rightly saw nothing but prawn sandwichs.

Lobster pot to a harpoon fight.

Phil Walling
59 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:11:01
Cucumber sandwiches more like. (Crusts removed).
David Greenwood
60 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:12:08
James, yep BK needs to go next, no doubt about that.
Terry Downes
61 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:07:08
Tony Marsh — I've agreed with you all along in everything you've said about Moyes. I'm just amazed how many fans are now changing their tune.

For me, Andrew Laird said it all: He's gone... Fuck Him!

Paul Ferry
62 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:12:18
In an absolute nailed on nutshell:

David Greenwood (943) - Utd have far more to worry about with their new manager than we do with ours.

Richard Dodd
63 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:21:58
I can`t believe the slagging Moyes is getting in this thread. If St Martin does half as well he`ll be lucky.

No doubt, six months from now the MOB2 will be in full voice!

Steve Woods
64 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:14:06
David @ 943 "Exciting times ahead".

Yes indeed... it could be thrilling, in a perverse sort of way.

Let's just hope that Roberto gets his "mindset" sorted out for when we next visit OT.

His previous results there were:

Played 4, Lost 4, Conceded 16, Scored 0

2012 Man Utd 4 - 0 Wigan
2011 Man Utd 5 - 0 Wigan
2010 Man Utd 2 - 0 Wigan
2009 Man Utd 5 - 0 Wigan

David Greenwood
65 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:37:05
I'm sure it will be different Steve.

He's due a win then...

maybe even a goal...

Steve Woods
66 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:43:31
A goal would be nice David.

It would help with the end of season goal difference...

Paul Ferry
67 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:37:53
Steve (952): your point being?

Richard (950): I am so sure that you are a nice chap, and I mean that, but I am so sick and tired of the shite you spout to put Moyes in as good a light as possible.

You have to be one shade off retarded not to realize how this latest Moyesballs will generate a shower of criticism, not least quite frankly because out of the Moyes mouth we are hearing first hand what a fair number of Toffeewebbers have been saying for ages and you, for one, have been countering with blind loyalism.

Your Messiah has turned your reiterated defence on this score upside down.

And it is people like you who bask in the MOB tag/thing who keep it alive. You have used that term over and over again to create polarities, divisions, dissension, tension. You as much as anyone have been responsible for the deep divisions on these boards that were more often than not fabricated and existing only in such minds as yours.

Move on Doddy. Get yer head out of the Moyes sand. And stop trying to perpetuate divisions on which you thrive and seem to be your oxygen.

Sam Hoare
68 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:46:28
Good Lord. How such a meaningless soundbite to please the Manyoo fans is perceived by some (Tony Marsh) as vindication of all their vitriolic bollocks I have no idea!

Patrick Murphy
69 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:44:13
it is now year zero and all of our history is to be forgotten. Ball, Kendall, Dean, Young, Labone, Hickson, Ratcliffe, Reid, Sharp, Gray, Catterick, Makepiece and all the other players and staff, Rotterdam, Wembley, Munich, Burnden Park, Villa Park, Highbury, Carrow Road and all the other great days and nights forget them they have no importance. Concentrate on the here and now, stop singing about knowing your history - it doesn't exist any longer.

On the note about Old Trafford it was a place when we visited in the 70s and 80s that I did consider having a good day if we managed to escape the neanderthals on the way in or out of the stadium.

Football wise it is a stadium that should inspire any Everton team worthy of the name, even when we were a weak team we always felt we could win there, I just hope that we can gain a win once more at the 'Theatre of Dreams'.

Eddie McBride
70 Posted 23/07/2013 at 19:08:23
I think that the debate on the pros and cons of our former leader have just begun.People like myself who asked questions of what Moyes was actually trying to achieve where usually shouted down pretty quickly by IMWT.

Personally i`m not bothered weather he succeeds or fails,i`m only glad that he has left our once great club and that his successor be given the time and support to repair the damage.

I`m hoping that Evertonians have`nt`taken their eye off the ball just because we have a manager who conforms with our school of science history.We all need to act together and show BK his time is also up.

Mark Frere
71 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:04:54
Its amazing how one little bullshit comment from our ex manager can provoke such a frenzy of bitter posts. Tony Marsh and Richard Dodd should stop obsessing about the Ginger one - for very different reason may I add.

I will be happy to discuss Moyes reign as Everton manager in the future.... like we do with Howard Kendall or Walter Smith. Can we at least leave the discussion about Moyes for a year or so, it would be a welcome break.

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

LETS MOVE ON!

Wayne Smyth
72 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:07:41
I'd definately not call Moyes methods successful. Kevin Tully hits the nail on the head; they were merely effective, in keeping us slightly punching above our weight most of the time.

Thing is, you could argue that Tony Pulis was effective too, and people aren't exactly queuing up to employ him since he left stoke. What I will say for Moyes is that he can spot a bargain in the transfer market and his teams are nothing if not well organised and difficult to beat.

But as I think Man U are about to find out, organisation and not wasting money in the transfer market don't win you trophies in the games where it takes belief and confidence to succeed. For me Moyes never had a winning mentality; it was all about not losing and I think that will grate with fans used to competing.

Because Moyes was here so long and because there were so many heated discussions on his abilities and his ability to move us on, I'm actually quite interested in how he gets on at one of the richest clubs in the world.

There were so many individual criticisms levelled at him over the years, such as whether he ruins strikers, for example or how he gets on against "big" clubs, this season is going to be like the morbid curiosity of watching a car crash in progress.

Paul Andrews
73 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:30:56
Jeremy 931,

Can you post a few examples of Moyes tactical awareness please.
Just a few games where he changed our formation or style of play to win a game from a drawing or losing position.

Ed Fitzgerald
74 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:25:49
Mark

It seems reaonable to pass comment on Moyes quote today as he is referring to his time as Everton manager which only came to an end on the 1st of July. Sadly his comment reveal an appalling lack of ambition and a betrays all the paying Blues who went to watch routine capitulations at OT. I will grant you the 4-4 draw was great.

It is indicative of his cautious approach, who knows what the Martinez reign will bring. what it definitely will herald is a return to an outlook of positivity not seen since Joe Royle was manager (Im not talking about the football) but the attitude. We are Everton FC for Christ sake, the only time I used be scared at OT was getting in and out of the place when the shiny glint of a Stanley knife was de rigeur. On the pitch we did win there quite a few times even when we were shite.

Jamie Barlow
75 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:39:00
Paul, we won over 20 points from a losing position last season. I'm sure Moyes had a part to play in changing some of those games.
Paul Andrews
76 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:43:36
He did Jamie,
He stood on the touch line shouting tactically aware instructions like "come on,come on boys.Get it in to Felli"
He is good at whipping them into a 100 mph style of play,the crowd respond and the tempo goes up,but tactical,positional changes?
He was like a rabbit caught in the headlights on numerous occasions.
Martinez Donald ducked him with tactics set out to win the game and I am afraid he sat on the bench and did not respond in any way,shape or form.
Mark Frere
77 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:35:50
Ed

I wouldn't read too much into Moyes's comments, He's just saying what the Man Utd faithful want to hear. I don't remember too many of the non money teams having a great record at Old Trafford anyway.

Also, often threads on TW seem to escalate into Moyes debate when the thread actually doesn't have anything to do with DM. People are obsessed.

There's one thing for sure - there's going to be some very smug people on TW in the future saying : "I told you so". Will it be the MOB or the MIB?

Paul Andrews
78 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:51:17
Mark,
You may want to read the headline on the top of this column.
Paul Washington
79 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:44:26
Patrick @ 960,Anyway re. Dithery Dave — the man is a disgrace to PL managers, sending highly paid / trained / conditioned athletes out to compete with a "let's get out alive" mentality; no wonder our cupboard was empty under him. Every team in the prem is capable of beating everyone else..... why didn't we try??
Tony Marsh
80 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:37:16
Sam Hoare and Co — I don't want to talk about Moyes all the time but, after years of being shouted down for my views about the man, the drivel this Gobshite keeps uttering only proves I was right all along. Some of you obviously don't like that.

From the "Baines is 2nd best LB in the country" to the "knife to a gunfight" shite, we now have this pathetic shithouse comment "Escape with our lives"... WTF??? Why shouldn't we discuss the ramblings of this Madman Moyes?

It is quite clear to me that those who still yearn for Moyes are lashing out at those of us who are exstatic he has gone. Can you imagine SAF or Jose coming out with crap like that??? Can you imagine Big Joe Royle admitting his Everton were scared of the Bogey man of OT???

FFS, grow a spine and admit Moyes is and was a fraud who shits his kecks in the big games. Once you realise this, then we can all move on.

Mark Frere
81 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:53:52
Paul

I know this column is about Moyes, I was talking about other threads which aren't about Moyes.

I wish Lyndon and Michael wouldn't encourage so much debate about Moyes with threads like this one.....that's just my opinion though. I understand I might be in the minority here

Ross Edwards
82 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:03:14
Mark, as much as we try, you can't stop debates about Moyes as MK says in his comment in the thread. He has played a part of our recent history, 11 years in fact and you can't erase it even if you we ban reference to Moyes, which you are seemingly suggesting.

I mean, for instance JFK was killed 50 years ago, people still talk about him and grassy knolls don't they? You don't get people in the US going "no, not him, shot from a above in a depository building 50 years ago, lets move on, forget him" do you?

Paul Gladwell
83 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:05:58
Jamie, we also lost a huge amount of points from winning situations usually at the end of games when we sat back with a change of tactics.
Phil Walling
84 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:01:07
So by supporting Moyes`s when he was here and asking for a little more reasoned comment now he`s gone,I cause divisions in these columns.
So,Paul Ferry,you wish everyone to see it your way or be damned.
That`s how Hitler started!
Gary Reeves
85 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:55:34
Remember when he used to work the players like they were going into battle with the Fuzzywuzzy. And that was before the game had started. Would have still been doing it if Big Dunc hadn't told him to stick it. . That's how I'll rememberDM. That and those brown shoes. He's a Glaswegian centre-half with all the tactical know-how of those Peter Kay adverts. . He got a bit more out of lesser players,but a bit less out of better players.
Ross Edwards
86 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:11:52
"I remember going there as a manager. You want to get out of Old Trafford alive, that used to be our saying, you know."

How is a man with such a defeatist attitude manager of the Champions of England? It's absurd.

Phil Walling
87 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:10:52
Because that`s how it looks when you hint that Doddy and others are divisive. Moyes was far from `all bad`although he bored the arse off me but don`t deny ANYBODY the right to have a view — even daft Doddy!
Steve Guy
88 Posted 23/07/2013 at 20:35:19
You reap what you sow. We know in our hearts he was already gone before Christmas but hedged his bets and kept his options open, ruining an opportunity (again) to tilt at the top 4. The killer for me was (ironically) at home to Wigan in the Cup, downright embarassing tactically and the result and didn't even look that bothered afterwards. He virtually ran out of Goodison and was working at OT before his contract was officially up. He has treated the Club (that paid him handsomely, tolerated years of dire football and missed opportunities) poorly, with sound bites and deeds which show a lack of respect at best and a complete lack of understanding of the Club he left behind at worst. I won't even start on his pursuit of Baines, using tactics he deplored in others.

So I think Moyes' continued derogatory remarks about our Club, such as the one which sparked this thread are worthy of comment by those who put up with the last 11 years with Moyes at the helm. Not sure about Martinez but happy to see the back of DM and willing to support Martinez as he tries to get us playing like an Everton Team should.

Ross Edwards
89 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:14:31
"I don't remember too many of the non money teams having a great record at Old Trafford anyway."

Didn't Bolton have a good record against Man U when Allardyce was manager Mark? Just shows what you can do when you ATTACK opponents, not showing cowering in the corner. "we need to get out alive", pathetic and above all, defeatist attitude to football.

He will be exposed to be utterly clueless in the Champions League. He will fill his pants and have a breakdown of massive proportions when Bayern, Madrid or Barca play him. Can you imagine Moyes telling RVP to track back?

Fabregas will be very wise to turn him down. Maybe Dithering Dave hasn't got the message yet, HE DOESN'T WANT TO COME, STOP WASTING YOUR TIME!!

Paul Ferry
90 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:20:33
Jamie (969): how many points did we drop from winning positions?

I might be wrong but I would not be surprised if the total is somewhere in the region of 20.

Hmmm is dropping points in the last 10 more telling than gaining a point when down? Not sure about that one. But games like Norwich and Stoke left me depressed for a long long weekend.

Mark Frere
91 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:12:27
Ross

I'm not suggesting we should never mention Moyes again, or ban any reference to Moyes which you are absurdly accusing me of. I just think we should focus on the new exciting era of Matinez.

Like I suggested before, in years to come on TW when we like to talk about previous managers like Mike Walker, Joe Royle and Walter Smith - yes it will be fun to discuss Moyes's era. There just seems to be to much unecessary focus on DM for my liking.

Stephen Stott
92 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:22:57
Mr Kenrick You have banned me on a number of occasions for questioning some comments by fellow ToffeeWebbers as being too personal. Can you please explain why Paul Ferry's comment at 957 is acceptable. It is totally reprehensible.

As for this article, please let's move on.

Chris Leyland
93 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:20:16
Paul Ferry - of course people can discuss whatever they want. If some people on here, who wanted rid of the manger, thought he was shit and couldn't wait to see the back oh him, now want to leap on his every comment in his new role to help them prove to the world that they might have been right all along then that is clearly their prerogative. Not sure what it achieves though other than allowing people to indulge in some self-righteous sanctimony and hand-wringing. Each to their own though.

Me, I'd rather look forward to the new season and a new era with optimism and a tinge of excitement at what could be. I'd like to do this with out benchmarking it all against Moyes.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
94 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:30:37
Stephen, unfortunately Paul is spot on in his analysis of Doddy's love affair with our ex-manager. I don't know how his post can be characterized as "reprehensible".

And Doddy, for all his faults, has a pretty thick skin. If he tells me he's been crying in his beer since reading that (I know he's been crying in his beer for other reasons) then yes, I will show Paul a virtual yellow card but I think in his time Richard has read a lot worse about him.

As for "let's move on" the fewer who post on Moyes, the faster that might happen...

Ross Edwards
95 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:38:10
Fair enough Mark.
Chris Leyland
96 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:38:56
Michael K - I suspect Stpehen struggled to find how Paul's description of Doddy's post as "the shite you spout" or inferring that Richard was "one shade off retarded" dovetails with the terms of use, specifically:

3. You acknowledge that you share with other contributors an equal right to comment on anything Everton-related, without prejudice, provided you do it respectfully, without abusing other contributors, the website, or its editors.
4. You agree not to denigrate other website users or contributors, no matter how much you may disagree with their freely expressed views and opinions

Maybe you can explain how they do?

Jim Lloyd
97 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:12:45
It seems to me that Moyes' statements are stillrelevant to us ifhis statements concern our club, so I wonder why some posters onthis thread are only too anxious to "let's move on" or variations on that statement and one post seeming to glory in the fact that Wigan got tonked there most seasons! So,presumably it's ok for David Moyes to come out with the statement quoted.

To me, it is a valid debate about the man who was the Manager of Everton Football Club. and what he is saying relates to the time he was manager of our club.

I'm probably niaive because believe he was an honourable man and I believe him when he said he went to SAF's house, expecting to be told he was afer one of our players.I beieve him when he said around Christmas time that he would see how we went on in the league and the cup before making his mind up about staying on as our manager and I hope he does well at United.

However, this debate (I think) is about his footballing philosophy and not about his integrity and it is a fair debate to have. It follows a line of logic that has been expressed in a number of statements he has made; and they relate to many debates on here over the years of his managership.

It might have been that he uttered the statement to win over United fans but the statement was about the Everton team he managed. Considering it in relation to other statements he made, epitomised by the *knife to a gunfight," had many supporters, (me included,) concerned about the messages he was sending out to the football world and equally importantly, what mind set did that philosophy give our players.

It was the picture of a "plucky little Everton, fighting above their weight" and gave the impression (or so I believe) that when it came totthe "Big Boys) we would dutifully doff our caps and be thankful if didn't recieve to much of a beating. That indicated to me (perhaps wrongly) the mind set of David Moyes. He was generally,a successful manager in as far as he brought in decent players and got us into the top half of the league and then to fighting around the top six. But it meant that he paid due deference to some teams; as good as told them that we couldn't really be expected to compete with them.

I remember sitting in Wembley Stadium at the Cup Final with Chesea and saw this philosophy played out before us as the match went on. It was like he'dsaid tothe team "Fuckin Hell boys. thats torn it we're gonna cop it now. And at the end of he match I came away thinking "we didn't go for the throat,we surrendered."

So this latest statement is relevant. It shows to me that David Moyes would never have taken us any further than he did. Because I don't think he believed that he could.

Ross Edwards
98 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:04:11
He just doesn't have the bottle to win silverware, especially with an attitude like that. If he thinks like that this season he won't be anywhere near the top 4.
Wayne Smyth
99 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:35:49
Chris, do you really not care anything about how he gets on?

Even from a purely selfish Everton-only point of view, I'm still interested if he's going to be a failure at OT because it means they'll be another team we have a chance of finishing ahead of. The ability to be a bit smug and see if peoples predictions about his limitations were correct is just an added bonus!

Tony Marsh
100 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:01:33
Have any of the "Let's move on" fans on this thread thought that there might be some of us here who are enjoying watching Moyes self-implode at Man Utd and wish to continue sticking the boot in? The Ginger Genius has already been knocked back by all his transfer targets, lost 2 out of 3 games Man Utd would normally win and upset Transplant Head all in his first month in charge at OT.

After admitting popping round to SAFs gaff for a cup of tea and a chat about taking over from him at OT which basically is tapping up Moyes now comes out with toe-curling, "hide behind the couch when Dracula is on" bullshit about EFC being a gang of shitbags who only turned up at Old Trafford to survive. Well, I am sorry but maybe Moyes himself felt that way but the fans who followed Everton certainly didn't.

I say let's have at him and slaughter the twat for days as he fully deserves it. I for one am made up Moyes has exposed himself for the fraud he really is.Basically this Gormless Glaswegian is destroying the name of all Evertonians with these Fight for our lives comments.,Not only Evertonians by the way but he is destroying the name of the city of Liverpool.

How many Scousers do any of you know that would take kindly to letting Mancunians know or think we were scared of them... It's a joke to be honest. Moyes might be a Shithouse but the rest of us aren't. Roll on the season and watching this prick ruin Man Utd... Keep on putting the size 10s in, lads — it's good for the soul. Moyes deserves a good verbal kicking.

Tony Cawson
101 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:19:37
3rd December Everton win at old Trafford.
Week before Christmas Moyes goes.
Boxing day a warm welcome awaits Davey at Goodison.
In his Sunderland tracksuit.
Peter Laing
102 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:21:01
The FA Cup Semi Final against the shite and the debacle a couple of weeks before at castle grey skull with Gerrard skulking off the pitch with the match ball tucked up his top in mock indignation summed Moyes up, when the chips were down he could never deliver.
James Stewart
103 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:26:46
Moyes won't last long there. Already looking out of his depth.
Moyes is a percentages manager. Never bets on anything. Never gambles always plays it safe. A coward.

I would never want him back no matter what Martinez does.

Ross Edwards
104 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:31:20
Hear Hear James, agree 110% there.
Paul Ferry
105 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:14:27
Stephen Stott (989)

Doddy can take care of himself, not least because he has an enviable ability to take things in his stride and also to completely ignore what is said as if it was never said, and then to continue in the same vein that caused the comments in the first place ...

As for 'reprehensible', fair comment if that is what you believe. But I don't think that my post was at all reprehensible'. I didn't insult Doddy at all - perhaps you are concerned at my use of 'retarded' but that was not aimed at Richard in particular but a general comment along how obvious the Moyes swipe was - I was, quite frankly, reminding Richard of something I have been saying for a while now that never seems to sink in.

In a nutshell, Richard (who can at times be a lot of fun) perpetuates tensions and divisions that often existed only in his mind and like minds, and that led to some sharp cross swords as you may well know.

Move on some on this thread have said. Well, who uses the label MOB these days? Answer, the ones who dreamed it up in the first place and seem sorry to let it go.

I don't think that I deserve to have you calling for my head and a ban. Admittedly I did call for someone to be banned a couple of weeks back but that was because he physically threatened me twice.

I'm not proud of some of the things I have said about Richard on here, but I think that I would always defend the underlying assumptions and beliefs no matter how crass the formulation/expression.

Anyway I, for one, was delighted to have Richard back on these boards in May after a few months away. Can't stand his Moyes-never-wrong attitudes, but you will not find a word anywhere in my post that says that he does not have the right to express them or to condemn me for my view of things which, by the way, is rather more flexible.

Jamie Barlow
106 Posted 23/07/2013 at 21:57:24
Paul@979 and Paul@ 987, Paul said "Can you post a few examples of Moyes tactical awareness please.
Just a few games where he changed our formation or style of play to win a game from a drawing or losing position." Not how many points he lost from winning positions. We won(I think) 23 points after going behind in a game. Paul Andrews is trying to make out Moyes had fuck all to do with this except for shouting instructions from the side. He hasn't got a clue whether Moyes made any tactical changes. If you agree, fair enough. I just find it hard to believe and it's a bit harsh.

"Sam Hoare and Co — I don't want to talk about Moyes all the time". Yes you do Tony. It's very rare for you to post on here without mentioning Moyes, unless you're too busy bigging up the idea of Neville being our new manager.

Paul Ferry
107 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:32:52
Jesus, just saw this one: Chris Leyland (993).

Listen carefully - retarded - I was speaking generically, okay.

Jeez, some people.

And, trust me, shite, a lot worse has been said about Richard on here by me I suspect and others. And, just for the record Mr. Leyland, he does spout shite.

Will you now put an end to your campaign to get me banned and, next time, try to read things/statements in their true contexts and connotations.

Tom Dodds
108 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:18:46
I quite agree with most of the posts so far, re Moyes's 'knife to a gunfight' stance, but I wonder if the Editors would be just as keen on a similar decomposition of our penniless Chairman, and his 12-year "zero pence to a multi-billion pound Premier League fight" stance??? — Without the backup (by the fuckin way) of the Trojan dogmaticness of David Moyes, who built the foundations of the club's survival in said league, garnering the heroes of Baines, Cahill, Fellaini, Mirallas et al that we now covet and look up to, to keep him there.

Martinez of course being his last throw of the dice.

Paul Ferry
109 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:36:57
Jamie (14): I always read what you say with interest and we've been sparring partners in the past but you always make sense, even if I disagree,

But please can you unpick that 2nd paragraph mate and tell me what it is supposed to mean. There are clearly some important comments there and I was very interested in the remarks about DM's input.

I don't mean to be insulting - see 989/993 - but I want to follow this debate as it is one I am extremely interested in.

Sam Hoare
110 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:35:33
Good point Jamie. I genuinely think those who wanted Moyes gone are bringing him up a lot more than those who were happy for him to stay. Wonder why that is.
Simon Harris
111 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:32:00
Wayne, I agree, I'm intrigued as to how Moyes will fare but with my tin hat donned I hope he does well, although feel he'll struggle under the weight of Utd expectations.

It was time to move on for both parties though and I await the Martinez years with nervous excitement.

Tony Marsh
112 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:34:53
Jamie Barlow... another still wounded by the departure of Moyes; move on, lad — get over it.

As for Neville for manager, Wasn't Me!!! To be honest I would've taken Neville over Moyes. I would've taken Phil Neville's Ma over Moyes but I got my wish with Roberto Martinez so I'm happy. I haven't spoken about Moyes for weeks, by the way, I have only just started using his name again in this thread.

It actually gives me a warm glow reading this posts and realisng who the real Wimpy posters are. Moyes is gone and you're right, we shouldn't be discussing him but the prick has just insulted the good name of Everton FC with his gormless comments... You take it if you must but some of us refuse to.

Richard Dodd
113 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:39:47
For my part, I have now picked up on Michael`s English lesson on another thread, so whilst appreciating the support of Wally and Chris for my right `to spout the alternative viewpoint`, I shall respond to Paul (as one retard to another) with a single word. BOLLOCKS!

(Asterisks deleted as requested by the Editor.)

Jamie Barlow
114 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:44:32
Sorry Paul, I don't know which bit you mean.
Kevin Tully
115 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:49:44
Simon - do you hope he does well with Baines in his team ( for approx 1/3 of his true worth)?

Peter Mills
116 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:29:51
Jim#995, I agree with much of what you say, especially about that feeble cup final performance. But you say that when David Moyes was summoned to Sir Alex Ferguson's house he thought it might be because Ferguson was AFTER one of our players.

That is not what Moyes said. He actually said "I thought he was going to TAKE one of our players". To me, that said an awful lot about his mindset.

Ross Edwards
117 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:54:11
Simon, why do you want a man who has no respect for the club that has actually provided him the opportunity to manage United, a man who has taken our coaching staff and has made frankly insulting bids for our top players to do well?

Paul Andrews
118 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:47:47
Jamie Barlow.

Did you see any tactical changes?

If so, share them with us.

Kunal Desai
119 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:35:40
Dithering Davy is already feeling the heat, 2 defeats out of 3 in their pre season tour and focusing all efforts into signing Fabragas is always a danger, especially if it does not come off. Wouldn't surprise me if he can't land the likes of Fabregas, Bale, Baines and Fellaini. Big name players also want to play for the best managers in the world, wouldn't surprise me if neither of the above players signed for him.
Paul Ferry
120 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:45:00
Hmmmm .... Sam (020) I'm not exactly sure that is as crystal clear as that. The crux of that you say I think is that Moyes-bashers or however we label them simply cannot let go and want to continue to rave and rant about all things Moyes.

Well, first of all, I think that the majority of Toffee-webbers are neither obsessive anti-Moyes or obsessive-pro Moyes. They are somewhere in between on sliding scales and their thoughts and positions are continually modified by say how it all went in the past month of footie.

I think that more people have turned against Moyes and dug their heels deep in the anti-Moyes camp since he left us and not just because he has left us, but because of the very sort of statement that kicked off this thread. For what it's worth I think this thread is important and highly relevant for the times as we thrash out what Moyes means for us and begin to think about his legacy.

I think it's healthy to discuss say the last two years or so, if only to compare and contrast with the here and now. But I think that there are meaningful and necessary discussion irrespective of Martinez. The Moyes discussion does not detract in any shape or from our many discussions of Bobby and the present and future and our hopes and expectation. Indeed, it is necessary I think at any rate because it is directly about who we are and how we came to be where we are now.

Paul Ferry
121 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:59:29
Sorry Jamie, I wasn't very helpful, I agree.


I couldn't follow the flow of the argument here: 'Paul Andrews is trying to make out Moyes had fuck all to do with this except for shouting instructions from the side. He hasn't got a clue whether Moyes made any tactical changes'.

There are clearly points missing that you made in previous posts on this thread, but I just felt that I was missing something to make complete sense of this and I would like to make sure that I have your views coz, as I said, I enjoy reading you.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
122 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:09:18
Tom Dodds (#017), you are the epitome of a broken record when it comes to Kenwright. Have we not heard every possible angle of such arguement?

But don't let me stop you. I'm sure TW is all set for yet another thread about how BK has contributed nothing and is looking for his big payday. Have at it.

But please follow this simple advice: Write in coherent English, and keep those sentences short. Oh, and NO NAUGHTY WORDS!!!!

Paul Ferry
123 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:11:15
Richard (23) grow up lad and stop playing the Moyes martyr. I never ever questioned your absolute right 'to spout the alternative viewpoint'. Never have, never would.

Thanks by the way for calling me a 'retard'. You're wrong to claim that you are simply imitating me here. But honest I don't mind being called a retard by you, not least given the often less than solid foundations and justifications you have given in the past for your always welcome opinions.

Mike Hughes
124 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:23:47
For those who don't think it's relevant:

£3.5m per year for leadership qualities as described.

And he's still characterising us as a small club - just like Benitez - ie scared shitless of the big boys.

I wasn't a "mob" but taking the piss??????

Paul Ferry
125 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:28:58
Sorry to be so out of the loop, but who is 'Transplant Head' (003)?

Mike Hughes
126 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:33:42
Paul #031 - well said!
Colin Glassar
127 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:34:45
Left this thread ages ago. Who's winning? On another note I've noticed some of the players might be having little digs at OFM with comments like, "we actually train with the ball now", "it's not all about running", "I think he'll (RM) make us better players" etc.... Just a thought.
Kev Johnson
128 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:38:47
What we need is a new thread to comment on...
Paul Ferry
129 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:40:03
Colin (51) Richard Dodd won with a highly controversial and debatable 5-4 decision by the 9 referees.

Spot on with your player quotes which, on the one hand, make us all feel uplifted about the next few months, but also, on the other hand, justify, I think, ongoing discussion (and comparing and contrasting) of late-Moyes and early-Martinez.

Not sure if I would label these player quotes 'little digs' at the departed one, but they make you feel good about things, don't they.

Jamie Barlow
131 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:26:44
Paul@28. Do you know that he didn't?
I've no idea if he did and I cant be bothered going back to look and see if he did. I'm just sure he did. It is his job to change things all the time, all through the match. Little things we wont necessarily notice. Pushing players up more, breaking quicker. Players changing wings. We wasn't exactly shite last season. You can't blame Moyes for everything when it was going bad but not give him credit for when it went well. It's bullshit.

Tony, get a grip. He hasn't insulted Everton FC. He's insulted himself. It was his mindset. Another overreaction.

"Move on, lad — get over it." Ha ha, I hope your kidding with that comment. It's hilarious coming from you. I'm not bothered in the slightest that Moyes has gone.

And it was you... I remember reading a lovely post on here about how you was warming to the idea of Mr Phil Neville becoming our manager.

Paul Ferry, what I wrote is confusing me the more I read it now. My argument is that Paul Andrews is trying to make out Moyes never changed our formation or style of play to win a game from a drawing or losing position. Saying all he did was shout "lump it to Felli, or come on boys" and I'm saying he must have as we won 23 points after going a goal behind. I can't prove he did because I can't be arsed. I just can't get my head around why anyone would think none of it had anything to do with Moyes. Maybe it was Roundy.

Eddie McBride
132 Posted 23/07/2013 at 23:43:42
If I can try and sum up my opinion of the reign of David Moyes I think the best way of doing so would be by telling you a true story.

It was nine years ago when I finely persuaded my sister to allow me to take my 7-year-old nephew to his first game. Now every Evertonian knows how important that day is, a day that lives with you for the rest of your life. Believe me, I had one very excited youngster on my hands. On the way there, all the stories of the Holy Trinity, Sheeds and Reidy were re-told. Expectation was in the air.

When we arrived, he could not believe his eyes. The big crowd, the noise... everything was in place for the perfect day. Then Dour Davey sent out the boys. After five minutes, you could of heard a pin drop. It was the worst display of football I ever witnessed.

Not long after half-time, a sad face looked up at me and said, "I`m bored, can we go home?" I couldn't argue; so was I. Off we trotted out into what I thought would be the empty streets. They weren't... Davey had managed to send a lot more home for an early tea.

To end on a happier note, that same nephew came around to my place last Saturday. As we were chatting, he asked if I still went to the match, I told him not since that terrible day. He suggested now we have a new manager, we should try again, as I still owe him half a match. I agreed.

Tony J Williams
133 Posted 24/07/2013 at 00:36:51
What game was it Eddie?
Paul Ferry
134 Posted 24/07/2013 at 00:34:42
Agree completely Jamie (63) that Moyes is the key voice and that we cam measure and judge games by his decisions, if we won, drew, or lost.

I don't think that you are saying this and I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I have always felt that, when all is said and done, what happens on the pitch has far more to do with Moyes before and during the game than with the eleven on the pitch.

I know Michael is not fond of meandering threds, but I think that this one with all its twists and turns is a good read with roughly 56 points of view that could be the subject of a single thread.

Eddie McBride
135 Posted 24/07/2013 at 00:51:46
It was that bad I don`t remember, Tony. But my nephew seems to think it was Fulham.
Seamus Murphy
136 Posted 24/07/2013 at 01:09:20
Well I have to say that thread was a great read!

I can't believe there are so many people trying to stifle the conversation with the "Let's move on" and "I'd rather focus on the new manager and next season" attitude. I can't help but think that many of these guys are the same people who were spouting the "get behind the team" crap when anyone dared question Moyes over the last couple of seasons.

I would also question why we should have to "move on". Why not discuss this? It was Moyes who referenced going to OT as Everton manager so he instigated the discussion and people are fully entitled to have an opinion on that and share it on here. If you don't like it then counter the points made or simply click into one of the many articles on the new manager and focus on the future to your heart's content.

Steven Telford
137 Posted 24/07/2013 at 01:09:14
Ross #854
Quote "He used us to get that job"

Come on.............. they way you say it would like 11 years ago, he had a Pinkie and brain moment, and when he was told he got the Everton job he rubbed his hands together and said "next stop Man Utd".

He got the united job, because he managed to have a financial basket case of club knocking on the door of Europe.

He may fail or he may succeed, personally I don't care. If he chases Baines, I will be disappointed in him, if not (apart from the games against us) I see no special reason to wish him to fail.

Anyhow, Half the people predicting him to fail are the same guys who said "a big club would never touch him".

Patrick Murphy
138 Posted 24/07/2013 at 01:10:22
Moyes can go and do one if he honestly believes that Everton FC should be happy to be where they are and if not happy then grateful. We were a good club before he came, a good club when he was here and will continue to be a good club in the future.

Psychology and sport are intertwined if you don't believe you won't achieve.

I welcome Roberto Martinez at Goodison because he'll ask the right questions of the board, demand improvement of the playing staff and give the fans a renewed sense that we can win trophies and mix it with the big boys home and away. He may not last long he may be here for a decade, but his personality is exactly what the club requires at this moment in time.

If RM can match the results of DM and get us near that top 4 it will be a far more enjoyable ride than we have been used to in recent times, it may even see the return of some absent friends to Goodison who lost faith over the last few years.



Paul Ferry
139 Posted 24/07/2013 at 01:32:39
Seamus (79): spot on mate, spot on
Anto Byrne
140 Posted 24/07/2013 at 05:38:10
Fresh optimism now running through Everton with players looking to work with RM and by all accounts enjoying the experience.

Moyes has the biggest job in the world and good luck to him. He has money to burn, it's going to be interesting as teams going there were much afraid of Ferguson as they were of Man Utd.

Fergie has gone so, given the inflexible tactics Moyes will employ, it's going to be interesting watching and for him to prove all the doubters he has what it takes. Dour, Defensive, Dull... let's wait and see.

Vijay Nair
141 Posted 24/07/2013 at 06:52:17
Anto, he may have the biggest job in the world and money to burn, but you don't see any big names clamoring to sign for dour defensive Dave do you?

Oh well he's United's problem now not ours..

I just hope Kenwright doesn't bring him back here when he gets sacked..

Anthony Hawkins
142 Posted 24/07/2013 at 07:16:40
I can't believe the comments in most of this thread and put it down to silly season.

Most teams and managers who go to Old Trafford, Stamford Bridge or the Etihad stadium all hope they come out with an arse kicking and it's not just Moyes who thought that. If we asked most of the managers and they were being honest they'd say the same. They probably wouldn't admit it as they have to keep a brave face.

Also remember that Moyes is now on the other side of the fence and his job is to extol the virtues of UTD which includes playing games by saying things like "we're fearful to play against".

Pick any team from about 8th down and tell me they go Old Trafford thinking "we're going to win" as opposed to "let's keep the score down". When we were 17th in the league few of us thought we could beat UTD and we would have taken a draw at the start of the game.

Moyes is not saying anything different.

Sam Hoare
143 Posted 24/07/2013 at 07:22:51
Paul, 31. I have no problem with people discussing Moyes. The last 10 decade naturally informs our present and our future. But there are some on here (not the majority by any means) who will use every single thread and tenuous opportunity to have a dig at the man and then have the temerity to tell others to let it go and move on as though their years of spouting have been totally vindicated.
Paul Andrews
144 Posted 24/07/2013 at 07:27:36
Jamie Barlow,

"I can't prove that he did,but can you prove that he didn't" — Poor argument that, Jamie. If, after 11 years of his management, not one game sticks out for you, I think you have answered my question.

I use what I see at the game to form my opinion, he is not a manager who reacts quickly to any given situation. Witness the Wigan cup game: the opposition manager ripped his team apart with a team set out to play in a specific way tactically. You could see what was happening from the stands – Moyes sat frozen on the bench as if he was hypnotised. Play the tape back and have a look.

That is just one example of his inability to react to what's happening on the pitch.

David Ellis
146 Posted 24/07/2013 at 07:28:45
Moyes is just telling the truth. His view was realistic. I don't like this particular truth. But no need to throw the toys out of the pram over it.

He is a good manager. He did a good job for us. He's left. I am not interested in his career after Everton..

I am optimistic about Martinez - it could go seriously pear shaped, but it could also be a lot better than before. I want us to try and win matches and I hope Martinez will try to do this more than Moyes - even if it means we lose a few more (which I am sure we will). Just hope the fans accept the downside as well as the upside of a more positive approach.

Mike Green
147 Posted 24/07/2013 at 07:53:50
It's a bit like a bloke stood at a bar with his new missus, talking to his mates after a relatively amicable split with his wife of 11 years, whilst his ex-missus is in earshot beside them at the bar.

'The things is lads, when I was with Tracy all I ever wanted was Sharon but thought she was out of my league.'

Might be true, might be what Sharon wants to hear, but you don't say it in public and you don't say it in earshot of your ex-wife. Or if you do don't be surprised if your ex-wife turns around and pours her drink over your head.

Barry Rathbone
148 Posted 24/07/2013 at 07:57:15
Moyes told lies over his contract and if Kenwright is to be believed lied about not coming back for our players. He now confirms the fearful attitude many of us RIGHTLY pointed out as contributing to this nothing decade.

The man is a self serving shithouse - people still defending him need to take a good hard look at themselves.

Sam Hoare
149 Posted 24/07/2013 at 08:17:55
Barry, when your argument rests on Kenwright telling the truth you know you're in trouble.

Why on earth do those defending him need to look at themselves? It's very simple, while he was Everton manager we improved as a team, going from bottom half/relegation candidate to top 6 or 7 and European hopeful. He did a good job.

Chris Keightley
150 Posted 24/07/2013 at 08:29:31
I'm unsure how you could ever defend his latest comments. Pro- or anti- Moyes, a ridiculous statement by Moyes, and shows lack of respect to the many that followed Moyes, and also explains to all his mindset in the big games against the best teams. If this vibe and attitude was picked up by the players, it's clear why we never won anything with this man, and also why we shat ourselves in derbies.

All I want is a team to go and play to win, not play to avoid defeat, or hope for a draw. Go out and win!

Kevin Tully
151 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:03:00
It's not just against one team he adopted this attitude though is it?

His record tells a story, and it's no coincidence that his ridiculous record at certain grounds lasted for 11 years!

Liverpool went through some seriously bad times, and we had a better side, but still didn't have the belief to win at Anfield.

That Wembley semi summed up his philosophy in one half of football.

Joe Bibb
152 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:08:35
David Moyes the new Jimmy Saville.

He seemed such a nice man at the time but now the truth is coming out.

Dave Lynch
153 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:12:49
He may have been a "perceived" success with us but Man Utd fans have a much higher expectation than us. Not winning the title is a failure to a lot of their fans and failure to win a trophy or get out of the CL group stage is unthinkable.

Moyes will deliver none of the above and I for one hope he bombs spectacularly, the way he has treated this club, the club that paid him millions a year for fuck all return shows what a twat he is/was.

He knew he had the Man Utd job months before the season ended and he strung all and sundry along. The derisory offer for Baines was nothing short of an insult.

Ged Simpson
154 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:29:50
Moyes was an average manager who has a skill of stopping a club in decline from dropping a division but was very risk averse. Some liked that and some didn't. I am not surprised by his comments. I expect no loyalty to us (this is modern Premier League) and think his comments are a sign of a man who is very nervous, possibly out of his depth and using simplistic ways to try and get Man Utd fans on his side. Who is losing here? Him and Man Utd.

As a club we have moved on - and I think moved on well. I understand the legend of Tony Marsh wants a thread dedicated to praise of his consistent view of Moyes and the other TW legend Doddy may want the same. But the reality is he was no Mike Walker and no Howard Kendall. Just someone in between who gave us some highs, lows and a lot in between.

Ian Bennett
155 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:32:29
Nice, Mike. I hope he fails.

A sound bite titbit for the manure fans, but the senior players will want to see leadership. A comment you wouldn't see from Jose that's for sure.

Anyway back to the blues - I see we are being linked with Chantome and Capoue, a joint swoop with the fellaini cash?

Barry Rathbone
156 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:46:17
Sam, that's right, just ignore the points about his contract deceit and the words from his own gob. I'd expect nothing less from you and the others in the Moyes FC cult.
Ciarán McGlone
157 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:45:40
This the equivalent of his 'Peoples Club' sound-bite whenever he arrived here..

An attempt to ingratiate himself with his new victims..

Sam Hoare
158 Posted 24/07/2013 at 09:56:09
No, Barry, unlike you I'm actually prepared to take up others people's points.

Tell me about his contract deceit and why that means that it is unacceptable for me to think he did a good job. Try some genuine argument rather than angry rhetoric.

You can call me Moyes FC cult and I can call you MOB if you want...or we could not be children and actually have a grown up debate.

Ciaran is spot on, there is not much to see here other than a stereotypical new manager's soundbite attempting to ingratiate himself with the news fans, a bit tactless perhaps but nothing more.

Ged Simpson
159 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:01:59
To hell with my attempt at perspective. Not much fun in that anyway !.
Nelly Verdonghan
160 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:23:41
He obviously thought the same very time he went to Stamford Bridge, The Emirates & Anfield... the fuckin shithouse. Good fucking riddance to a coward who is now showing his true colours and feelings about Everton FC.

Ged Simpson
161 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:27:28
Better for that, Nelly?
Barry Rathbone
162 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:08:45
Sam you support your football club in whatever way you want and I'll support Everton my way.

Winning fuck all in 11 years for reasons I and others have been shouting about which if addressed earlier may well have altered this dismal decade does not constitute "doing a good job" for the Everton I support.

The irony when you pick out the Kenwright point as a a desperate justification for Moyes is this is the same man Moyes vociferously endorsed during his time and when he left. That he's on the blower just after Kenwright states during the Martinez intro no-one is available (except felli) offering 5 quid for Baines should open even your eyes.

But so ingrained is this loyalty to a man at home exposing his "friend" Kenwright in such a manner who lied about signing his contract and now freely admits the shithouse attitude driving up the east lancs to OT (and doubtless across Stanley Park, Stamford Bridge et al) you've lost all perspective.

Phil Bellis
163 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:42:01
Steven (080)

Phil Neville's BBC video
"...someone told me the other day that when he signed for Everton 11 years ago his main ambition was to manage Man Utd eventually..."

Just a comment

Nelly Verdonghan
164 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:35:16
you betcha Ged....never rated Moyes as anything more than average. Thought he did a decent job to stabilise the club after Walter but never EVER believed we would win a trophy whilst he was in charge.

To me he will ALWAYS be remembered as THE man who drove me away from Goodison due to his tacticial incompetance and KITAP1 mentality...now he’s gone I’ll be there at Blackburn on Saturday with renewed hope that we will actually TRY to play attacking football this forthcoming season and might actually WIN at one of those places where Cowardly Davie obviously used to shit himself

Mike Rourke
166 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:19:15
He can big up United and play to their fanbase as much as he likes "Biggest club in the World", "Theatre of Dreams", "Giggs gives great head", etc. No problem with that, it's expected.

HOWEVER, none of it, absolutely none of it, either from him or his cone-setter, needs to be done while making us out to be some kind of semi-professional outfit...although that Deulofeu shirt WAS embarrassing...meh, regardless we deserve some respect and he should engage his brain before making these utterances, for his sake too, not exactly confidence inspiring for United fans when Barca or Madrid get drawn out of the hat.

Nelly Verdonghan
167 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:43:59
btw P 3 W 0 D 1 L 2....Dour Davie is off to his usual flyer....expect him to last no more than 12 months...they won’t put up with his tactics for 11 years like we did !!

I’m told that if you read their fan websites, blogs,message boards etc there is plenrty of unrest already and the majority y never wanted him in the first place...Fergie’s puppet that’s all he is !!

Derek Thomas
168 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:46:02
Preaching to the choir, the peoples club sound bite 11yrs on...but the ' that used to be our saying you know ' is a direct provable ( or disprovable ) quote..condemed from his own mouth, no weasel words, no mandy rice davis...' well he would say that wouldn't he ' from the disciples can change how he discribed his attitude...he was a very well paid surrender monkey...we're well rid
Ged Simpson
169 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:04:59
Oh for Christ's sake. Are we so daft to think an ambitious but not great manager wanted to always be at a badly funded club like we are. Get a grip - this is like a delusional Sh*te site now.

We are what are are for now.

If I offered you all a better job would you take it ?

Maybe if you thought you could do it.

Can he ?

Doubt it.

Gary Reeves
170 Posted 24/07/2013 at 10:58:38
He's been frightened in a lot more places than Old Trafford believe me! Wembley and Anfield come to mind but he must have kittens if anyone ever opens a brochure for Portugal! . . But the one that topped it for me - the very worst was Fiorentina. They were a proper average football team (there for the taking) but he shat his pants. That Final was in touching distance but we blew it in Italy with a cowardly,spineless performance. To put the top-hat on it they were knocked out in the next Round by those European Goliaths,Glasgow Rangers! Shitbag.
Barry Rathbone
171 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:11:37
Ged, nobody is questioning that ... have you read the OP?
Ged Simpson
172 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:25:24
OP ? What is that ?
Steven Telford
173 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:16:11
Phill #144

"someone told me"
Ok, Fair enough, but my best mate''s sister's cousin says it's not true.

Moyes was not an Evertonian from his childhood, how many managers out would you guess harbour an ambition to mange the galacticos?
What, you think it's Martinez ambition to stop with Everton? Unfortunately, the lack of mobility in football is now so entrenched, all but the elite become stepping stones. Sad, but true. all the same, the incentives to achieve with an underdog are not diluted.

Ged Simpson
174 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:37:12
Too realistic Steven !
Jamie Barlow
175 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:38:47
Paul@105&106, you're right, it is a poor argument but you started it. ;o)
Mike Green
176 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:49:20
Steven #157 @ Phil #144 - rightly or wrongly I can assure you, knowing someone who knows and has worked with Moyes for years, that Phils post is accurate. Being the next Man Utd manager has been Moyes ambition for at least since he told me, which was about 5 years ago. I don't think it's any secret, and probably could apply to half the managers in the league any way.
Nelly Verdonghan
177 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:49:31
Gary #151...agree 100% mate....& Chelsea in the League Cup semi 1st leg...we had em on the rack at 1-1 until that shithouse called em all back into their own half to defend the draw for the last 15mins....the rest is history

BTW I don’t think the problem is because he’s left to manage Man U...it’s Moyes’ attitude immediately prior to leaving (obviously when he knew he had the job) and his attitude since he has gone....let’s be honest he did give the impression that he thought he was bigger than Everton at the end of his days here and that has left a bitter taste with a lot of people particularly when you consider he won FUCK ALL in 11yrs.

Coming back for Baines is another thing that sticks in my craw.....especially after what he said about Hughes when he came after Lescott....as for Felliaini he can take him...straight swap for Rooney if I had my way...but unfortunately Kenwright hasn’t got the balls to suggest that one

Mike Green
178 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:58:29
For the record, when we had the conversation I laughed, shook my head and said 'Really...? No chance...!' :D

Who's laughing now.....

Nelly Verdonghan
179 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:01:49
He won’t be in 6 months when he gets the chop....!!
Nick Smallridge
180 Posted 24/07/2013 at 11:15:19
Paul Andrews — here are a few examples of Moyes's tactical changes to get results from just last season:

1) After being down 2-1 to Wigan, he brought on Mirallas and Distin at half-time to readjust the attacking prowess; result: earned a draw.

2) Down 1-0 to Sunderland, he brought on Naismith (how 'bout dem apples?) and Vellios to overwhelm the Sunderland defenders; result: 2-1 win. Naismith even got an assist.

3) Two words: Tottenham home. Bringing on, again, Vellios and Naismith, the tactical shift of having an extra attacker gives Jelavic the opportunity to win the game.

My point: Moyes was a good coach. He also made mistakes (any Norwich game springs to mind). Overall I'm glad we had him. But also equally excited about Martinez.

Sam Hoare
181 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:11:53
Barry, 139 you're right he didn't win anything and that is a fact and a black mark against his tenure. Not a lot of clubs outside the rich elite did (maybe 4 clubs in ten years?) but still he perhaps should have done better.

It's also a fact however that he dramatically improved our league standing and indeed the playing personnel at the club.

What he did or did not say to Kenwright, how involved he was in the amount Man Utd bid for Baines is speculation. If you choose to take everything with a healthy dose of cynicism that's your prerogative but to suggest that those defending him need to take a look at themselves is provocative, churlish and patronizing. In short it has the not so faint whiff of bitterness.

Matt Traynor
182 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:17:33
To those saying we should move on, why are we not able to talk about a former manager who for many fans was the only manager they knew? He was at the club a long time - he must rank as one of the longest serving in our history.

Overall he did a good job - at least in the eyes of his boss. His time was punctured with highs and lows. To my eyes he was starting to believe his own publicity, and I can almost sense the media have been sharpening their knives just waiting for the start of the season - and the EPL computer hasn't been kind with their opening fixtures!

It's long been known he coveted the Man U job, and when he was offered it, he had to take it - he'd be a laughing stock if he turned it down - a clear lack of ambition. I don't think he'll last, and I hope he struggles - but I would wish that on any manager of the other 19 teams in the division! I was surprised he got the job, but it wouldn't surprise me if his time there is short and Bill finds some reason to get rid of Martinez and bring him back. Let's hope we're sold soon!

Tony J Williams
183 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:11:04
Just logged on, sorry to go back to 075 but I will call bullshit on that post. 9 years ago playing Fulham we won 3-1, with a "scintillating" first half, as per the BBC report.
We have a 100% Premiership home record against them.

Barry, how long will you go before calling Martinez a loser? as I doubt we will win anything with him either. I pray to God he proves me wrong. we certainly won't win the league with him so it's the lottery of the cups again.

Moyes has gone and he is now the manager of the enemy so we should all wish him ills in regards to football.

This thread IS for all the MOB to stir up their "I was right!" feelings and have yet another go at Moyes. Even so much that Nelly is changing history and denying the 5-1 victory less than a week ago.

Paul Andrews
184 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:24:36
Jamie,
And you have still to answer it ;-)
Tony Marsh
185 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:27:55
Gary @ 151

You're right about Florentina: it was shocking... but what really put me off him for good was the pre-season leading up to the Villarreal game. The shite Moyes brought in that summer and the lack of a striker killed us off in the end.

Come on, James Beattie up front on his own in a Champions League qualifier??? After that, the humiliation in Bucharest should of been the end for him.

11 years on and Moyes is still acting like the twat that he is. Rubbishing the club and fans who gave him his big chance makes me sick. Moyes has admitted what we always knew he is a choker and a coward. End of story.

Jackie Barry
186 Posted 24/07/2013 at 12:34:28
I don't have any issues with him going to Man U, I don't think may do. The problem is to do with what he said, it makes him sound like Eeyore that Winnie the poo character and explains a lot about how we went into those games and others, basically our aim was for a draw or loss, it's all we expected. Before a game the manager is supposed to instill some self-belief into his team not an it's already decided lads don't bother trying to win attitude.
Brent Stephens
187 Posted 24/07/2013 at 13:15:26
I don't have a problem with Moyes not being an Everton fan from childhood. I don't have a problem with people having ambitions and trying to see them through. I don't have a problem with him joining us, given that ambition.

I don't think he was a great manager for us (never winning at..., semi-final surrender...) nor was he a disaster (league position on minimal net spend).

I don't have a problem with him moving to Man Utd, given his ambition. Having moved to Man Utd, I don't have a problem with him trying to buy an opponent's players.

I don't want to see him, personally, fail. I do want to see Man Utd fail (unless a result suits us).

I don't know what Roberto Martinez will do for us. I fear the worst and hope for the best.

I guess all that sounds too relaxed to some. Well, even at Accrington Stanley last week I felt it was like Xmas again, the excitement of a new season just around the corner.

It's just that I couldn't give a shit obsessing about the past manager.

Nelly Verdonghan
188 Posted 24/07/2013 at 13:26:32
Tony my apologies.....P4 W 1 D1 L 2.....has a familar ring to it don’t you think.....
Brendan McLaughlin
189 Posted 24/07/2013 at 13:36:25
Does indeed Nelly #193
The familiar ring of the MOB desperately scrapping the bottom of the barrel for something to throw at Moyes...even something as embarassingly weak as the results of his first few friendly matches as Manchester United manager. Frankly who gives a shit...
Ste Traverse
190 Posted 24/07/2013 at 13:43:23
What's new? We knew Moyes was a coward anyway.

I hope he fails at OT and am pretty much certain he will.

How sweet would it now be to get our first win at United for 21 years while this twat was their boss?

Brian Denton
191 Posted 24/07/2013 at 13:48:26
Look, being realistic Moyes's opening few months at Man Utd are bound to be of interest to us, then it will fizzle out. Much the same way as you watch the progress of a player who has left us - for a while, anyway.
Brian Denton
192 Posted 24/07/2013 at 14:07:19
Anyway, reverting to old git mode, my finest memory of going to Old Trafford was oddly enough not a game we won, but the league game in 1984-85. We drew 1-1 but it was the most one-sided draw you are likely to see. This at a time when they quite fancied themselves for the Championship too.

Hope the kids (I say kids, but I guess many of them are now in their thirties!) who know nothing but the Premier League will enjoy such a day. Sometime !

Kevin Quilliam
193 Posted 24/07/2013 at 14:43:12
As much good as Moyes brought to EFC in his time with the blues, I can't help but have a hint of satisfaction at seeing his new side get beat, even if it is only pre-season.

Bitter blue? I sure am! :)

Eddie McBride
194 Posted 24/07/2013 at 14:24:53
Tony # 180

Im not in the habit of bullshitting Tony. I know for a fact we were losing 0-1 when we left and could`nt hit a cows arse with a banjo.

possibly got the year wrong [I don`t think so ]but you go off and trawl through your shoot annuals, then you can come back and tell everyone you where wrong and Im not a liar.

If it helps the game would have been in January, because it was also a birthday treat

Stephen Stott
195 Posted 24/07/2013 at 14:36:25
Michael. No problems. I just find it quite amusing and to be honest pathetic the vitriol still being aimed at Moyes. Whilst we all know Mr Marsh is secretly Moyes's love child and it is just his way of hiding the fact, the constant other vitriol of calling Moyes a "coward" and worse is unacceptable and has no place here. Surely we can have a reasoned debate without it resorting to the gutter.
Steven Telford
196 Posted 24/07/2013 at 14:39:03
No matter all the swings that people take at Moyes, a fact that will remain is that he dug us out of the deepest hole we were ever in.


I don't know exactly what people are expecting of Martinez. Personally If he has us in the same position as Moyes, I don't think anybody will have a right to be disappointed in him. If he moves us up a gear, great (hopefully it happens), but lets not put the cart before the horse and let see the show before we decide to light the fireworks

Gary Reeves
197 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:00:13
No he didn't Steven... After the obvious ones, ie, the clubs with the dosh, Eveton are still (and have always) been one of the bigger clubs in England. The standard in The Premier League is not great once you get to the middle/bottom of the league and only mad,bad or drunk Managers should be getting us into trouble. I don't buy that Moyes got us out of a hole.
Michael Kenrick
198 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:09:06
The problem, Stephen (#212) is that Moyes has condemned himself as a coward by his own words. His attitude in the big games was there for all to see. Many chose not to, that is true. But when he comes out with shit like this... Well, I think his supporters doth protest just a little too much.
Tony J Williams
199 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:07:25
Eddie, I won't be trawling through anything. I just don't understand/accept that a person would leave half way through a game and never go back, even through the years where we were back in Europe for a couple of seasons.

I did look at my Shoot albums in regards to the Man U home record results for the 11 years that Moyes was at Everton as a matter of interest and what do you know. In 11 years for the sum of 209 games, they have lost 16, drew 24 and won 169. 2 seasons they lost 3 times, 3 seasons they lost twice, 5 seasons they lost once and one season they were unbeaten.

10 of those 16 games lost were by either City, Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool and Spurs.

So 6 clubs (outside the normal top clubs) in 11 years have beaten Man U at home. Yeah! what is everyone worried about?

Sam Hoare
200 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:13:34
Condemned himself as a coward, Michael? Or maybe admitted that Old Trafford is one of the hardest grounds to get anything from in the country and that maybe a point would not be disastrous. Surely that's a matter of opinion and not fact.

Paul Andrews
201 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:27:54
Tony J Williams,

Spirited defence of the Moyesiah there.
Have a look at your shoot annuals for how many managers were quoted as saying " we just looked to get out of Old Trafford alive"

Michael Kenrick
202 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:26:03
Why couldn't he have said something like, "As a manager, I always brought my players to Old Trafford with the belief that if we played well enough, we could win, but it's a hard place to come and do that."

No, this soundbyte encapsulated his cowardly persona and, when put alongside the utterly demeaning "knife to a gunfight" bollocks, makes the case against him all-too compelling. These are his own words, remember.

Brian Harrison
203 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:09:51
Well seeing Moyes was so bad and constantly got us in the top6 then I am right to expect at least a top 4 place within the next few years from Martinez. I think he has better PR than Beckham he has done absolutely nothing in the Prem, could you imagine the stick that Moyes would have got if he had spent all the time in the relegation zone. Even when you speak to fans of Martinez none of them think he will do better than 7th and I think that maybe optomistic.

Moyes has nothing to do with our club anymore so stop slagging off the guy who overall did an excellent job, and concentrate on what Martinez does.

Paul Andrews
204 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:40:43
Another spirited defence from a Moyesiah follower.
We're all doomed now the Frankie Howard has moved on to pastures new.
The end is nigh.
Barry Rathbone
205 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:39:58
Brian, marvelous point why talk about trophies eh? it's all about "challenging for Europe" isn't it?

Glad to see you compare Wigan to us btw, oddly I don't remember us slashing the wage bill by 20% over Moyes reign and selling his best player every year à la Wigan.

Got any more pointless gems?

Eddie McBride
206 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:26:22
Tony just checked my own Shoot albums, and guess what? Everton 1 Fulham 1. Everton equalising in the last minute of a dire encounter. So I will ask you once again if you think you're right in calling me a bullshitter when I am totally correct in the story I related.
Paul Ferry
207 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:39:12
Ged (138) I thought that you did a nice job summing up what I suspect most of us believe, but you're right it was zzzzzzzzzzzz ........
Gary Reeves
208 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:41:52
That's a fair point well made Brian, but I like others were fed-up with Moyes. It seemed to suit him perfectly – us finishing 6th. I would strongly make the point that in a few seasons he could have converted those 6th/7th positions to 4ths, if he had bigger bollocks.
Paul Andrews
209 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:50:19
Definitely true Gary Reeves.

Far from overachieving, I firmly believe he underachieved last season.

Brian Harrison
210 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:51:43
Gary I think he could have converted some 6th and 7th places into 4ths if he had been allowed to strengthen during many transfer windows that went by without anybody coming in.

Barry, you think Moyes didn't have to sell his best players? Rooney, Arteta, Lescott and Pienaar... so tell me how he could have kept these players. Also I never mentioned Wigan; I said our new manager's record in the Prem is appalling. How do you categorise his time in the Prem? Also, please don't quote lack of money — for years, you have said that about Moyes. Don't make having little funds an excuse.

Barry Rathbone
211 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:50:22
Tony J, I'll give Martinez the same time I gave Moyes ie as long as I can see he's trying and if not winning show signs of progress he'll get my support.

Your indignation is terrific:

"This thread IS for all the MOB to stir up their "I was right!" feelings and have yet another go at Moyes."

Carry more weight if you could prove why we were wrong and why we shouldn't get after a fella who has/is taking the piss.

Patrick Murphy
212 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:50:41
DM did save us from the dreaded drop in 2002, but it wasn't the biggest hole we had been in, that was when Mike Walker was in charge in 94 and Big Joe came to the rescue.

Oh and Moyes could have said something along the lines that 'Even at a club as big as Everton, we always found it difficult visiting OT and we would be happy to escape with a point' similar sentiments but less harsh on us and himself.

Sam Hoare
213 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:58:39
Michael, #224. I don't think the case is quite as compelling as you make out. Bear in mind that this is after all simply a suck-up to the new fans sound bite. Lots of room for interpretation.
Paul Andrews
214 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:02:48
And that is the hat trick
Sam Hoare
215 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:01:55
Barry, 237. Do you totally fail to recognize the good work Moyes did in improving our team?
Ged Simpson
216 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:01:03
Sod off Paul Ferry. It was not deserving of so may z's !
Steven Telford
217 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:53:41
Gary #215

You seriously don't thing Moyes dug us out of a hole? I cannot be sure, but I am willing to be even his most hostile of critics may disagree with you there. It's beyond dispute.

The decline of the club can clearly be seen as being with Colin Harvey taking over from Kendall. with the exception of the odd "cup blip" the trajectory was downwards – almost out of the top flight.
Moyes may not have restored the glory, but he stopped the rot and gradually restored dignity. For some supporters it was "too gradual" and I can understand the frustration from that, and frustration at defensive play, but realistically it was a very tough task at hand.

I am sure there are greater club historians than me, maybe they have a different take. But it seems clear as day to me.

I cannot help but wonder if perhaps it's simply a matter of demographics that separates the anti-Moyes from the pro-Moyes,

Barry Rathbone
218 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:59:45
Brian, you are clearly making a comparison betwixt Moyes Prem record and Martinez don't come with the old "I didn't say that" guff when the message is quite clear. Compare apples with apples please.

Moyes had 11 years here he didn't lose his best player each year and when the lads you mentioned went he got most of the loot whereas Martinez didn't.

Oh yeh we'll ignore reducing the wage bill by over 20% because that in addition to having no money equates to the circumstances re Moyes.

Taking these factors into account (know you don't want to) Martinez escapes for so long was remarkable and there was something else .....

No can't think what it is, think it had something to do with his Wigan twatting us in the cup but just can't put my finger on it.

Just stop with the nonsense will you.

Jim Knightley
219 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:08:46
What a surprise...a comment from a Manchester United manager, which, unsurprisingly, represents the fear factor involved in going to Old Trafford, and clearly aims to get the fans on board?

No one ever thought it could be rhetoric?

And 200 posts...

Moyes took us from a bottom 6 (ish) team, to a top 6 (ish) team on a net budget of little over a million a year. It was a remarkable achievement and that's why he has got the United job. He was too negative sometimes...but that negativity also left us with a fantastic defence which ultimately predicated the relative success we enjoyed. He did attack sometimes...the 4-4 result at United was pretty indicative of that (4 goals by a team who tried to get out their alive? imagined what would have happened if the players wern't shaking in their boots), and I think he improved our attacking side over the last 18months, and gave us some exciting football. I personally want Moyes to do well at Old Trafford (although I'm not sure he will because of so many factors), because he improved us on a shoestring...and has, whatever way anyone looks at, left us in a better state than when he arrived. How many managers, in the modern game, can say that? without the support of a billionaire...or indeed, an owner who can even support the team to a competitive level.

p.s - If Baines goes to Old Trafford, I will rescind my comment re. wanting Moyes to do well.

Paul Ferry
220 Posted 24/07/2013 at 15:47:08
Am I the only one who is sick and tired of lazy, smug, daft and juvenile comments like this?

Tony J Williams (180): 'This thread IS for all the MOB to stir up their "I was right!" feelings and have yet another go at Moyes'.

Not sure what anyone else feels, but there seem to be people who think that this is a constructive, decisive, convincing, and devastating argument.

They just can't let go of their label can they?

It's a mantra along the lines of diehard tea-party bigots on big government, tax-hikes, and slashing welfare budgets.

If you knock Moyes in any shape or form you are most certainly MOB.

If you criticize me you are denying me the right to air my views (classic Dodd).

If you continue to criticize Moyes even after he is gone you must be MOB.

It's so f-----g pathetic. Takes me back to schoolyard tiffs at Ursuline Primary School.


'I love my label' (TJW) but it says far more about you than it does the people you seek to tar and feather with your ideological stereotypical tripe.

Tommy Coleman
221 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:18:34
I'm loving watching The Coward implode at OT. He's already lowering expectations there.

He'll be gone in 2 years after destroying the team I hate most.

Barry Rathbone
222 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:12:42
Sam, Moyes did well with the basics of up and at 'em in his first few seasons he had a few bob to spend, no expectations and Rooney plus some decent players from Walter.

Once the next level was called for he was found wanting his purchases remained basically utility men, attempts to cultivate creativity floundered and every single time a team came at us we lacked the basics of skill and consequently belief and got nailed.

The season of reckoning was after 4th he realised what he could and couldn't do got a few pastings and we settled into possibly the drabest epoch in this clubs history.

He should have been shipped out but the symbiosis of Kenwright and himself allowed top half, crap football, no trophies to continue. He knew he was onto a good thing earning top wack and could stay till he got a job he wanted.

Only he and Fergie know the timescale of the Utd job but while I have a hole in my arse I'll never believe Moyes last year of contract nonsense wasn't somehow linked.

He should have been out years ago, he took the piss in the ensuing years and is taking the piss now - in answer the first 4 years reasonable after that a con.

Tommy Coleman
223 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:28:07
Jim - Why on Earth do you want Man Utd to do well !?
Barry Rathbone
224 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:28:32
Paul Ferry, people hate to admit they were wrong can you imagine the gulping that went on as Moyes words were reported. There is no argument so they don't want to talk about - that simple.
Jim Knightley
225 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:33:04
Why not Tommy? I wish Moyes the best...United are not within our reach, and I'd personally prefer to see them win the league, than City or Chelsea.
Steve Brown
226 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:24:55
I never thought I'd write these words, but I completely agree with every word Jim Knightley has just said. Quite what some of the posters here expect the Manchester United manager to say about how his last team approached matches at Old Trafford I am not clear - "We thought they were a pushover and we always fancied beating them?"

Come on let's get real. He will say anything he can to get psychological advantage for his team and if Martinez does anything less we will all be soon calling him on it.

John Ford
227 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:17:47
He probably could have said something a bit more even handed, but talk about an overeaction from his detractors.

Im content that the closest thing to a TW popularity poll on Moyes at the end of last season showed TW to reflect my general understanding of Evertonians at large - that the majority on balance wanted him to stay on, even if I suspect we all have reservations. I hold the view that TW reflects the wider Everton family though the 'anti's' were/are a vocal, persistent and articulate group.

Im looking forward to the new season esp with a new manager which brings new possibilities, but i'll recognise the good work DM did, even if he showed way to much respect at times.

Sam Hoare
228 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:33:29
Barry, I could be wrong but I think Paul's point was that the use of perjorative labels to categories people is what annoys him. The same sort of label you threw at me earlier.

As for your appraisal of Moyes tenure I find it strange that you think his team in the first 4 years compares to his team in the last year or so. You don't think he's left us with a considerably better team than the one he arrived to?

Ged Simpson
229 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:42:39
And the award for funniest comment in midst of serious folk having a scrap goes to

"but while I have a hole in my arse I'll never believe Moyes last year of contract nonsense wasn't somehow linked."

Paul Andrews
230 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:46:03
I think he left us with a better team than the one he inherited.
After 11 fucking years,and with the team he inherited,I think a
PG Tips chimp would have achieved the same.
Barry Rathbone
231 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:49:01
Sam, it goes without saying but Paul Andrews says it much better than I ever could:

"I think he left us with a better team than the one he inherited.
After 11 fucking years,and with the team he inherited,I think a
PG Tips chimp would have achieved the same."

In one.

Ged Simpson
232 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:46:16
Jim 252 -agree with you mate. - especially last para about Saint Leighton of Baines.
Ged Simpson
233 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:53:20
Barry/Paul - that is nonsense. It is a better team and has taken some ability to make it so. OK, not what you or I dream of but neither is my life without the Lottery win I hope for every Saturday. Don't reinvent history for the sake of a spat on TW
Ged Simpson
234 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:57:46
By the way Barry - can you say "in one" in voice of Jim Bowen ?
Tommy Coleman
235 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:57:36
Jim - "United are not within our reach". That's Moyes talk. We are capable of overtaking them, it's been done in the past when the gap has been larger.
Barry Rathbone
236 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:59:17
Ged, only if there's a caravan or speed boat as a prize !!
Ged Simpson
237 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:02:01
It was great - it was always someone from Dudley that won the boat - miles away from sea and no trailer !
Phil Bellis
238 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:34:17
Where to start...
David Moyes brought us stability after Disappointed Walter had kept us just about afloat

On very rare occasions, his teams produced quality, inventive, old-school football; the pity was he was never given the tools to show us if he actually could take us further

However, his mind-set did appear to be "start with a point"; I think he was genuinely shocked by the rage and venom shown after that Spurs game

Contrast that, though, some time later, secure in his position, with his "up yours, I'm the manager" stance after the weakened side at Anfield; think he'd have done that against Rangers as Celtic manager? No, me neither

When all (yes, a big all under Kenwright's largesse!) you have to do to be seen by your boss as successful is attain 40 points a season, there's not a lot of pressure

He oversaw a plethora of shameful all-time lows for our club, though, and was instrumental in making me, for one, actually feel half-arsed about going to the match at times; I sometimes went out of habit, loyalty and a mis-placed sense of duty

Jesus, our performances could be so soul-less

So, another era dawns, the king is dead, us arl-arses can dream of getting back to letting the opposition worry about us, for a change

The outgoing Man City manager recently told me he hated going to Goodison Park; it was a bearpit; he believed the crowd were the prime reason for our performances against City

If Martinez can produce an exciting side that can engender the kind of passion this crowd is capable of, it could be interesting times ahead

Sam Hoare
239 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:58:37
Barry/Paul what nonsense. If time and a consistent manager is all that's needed then why do all arsenal fans keep telling me their team doesn't compare to the one in the 90s. Equally why had our team improved more than any other premiership team with comparable resources? Try again.
Paul Andrews
240 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:08:31
I am trying again.
Is tag the same Arsenal who have qualified for the Champions League in the last (not sure exactly how many years) .
And actually won a trophy or two?
Jim Knightley
241 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:05:18
Tommy, if you think we are capable of overtaking United, you don't know football.

To put the Moyes improving us over his time in charge into context, here is a representation of the last 20 years of our league record.

1993-94 - 17th
1994-95 - 15th
1995-96 - 6th
1996-97 - 15th
1997-98 - 17th
1998-99 - 14th
1999-2k - 13th
2000-01 - 16th
2001-02 - 15th
2002-03 - 7th
2003-04 - 17th
2004-05 - 4th
2005-06 - 11th
2006-07 - 6th
2007-08 - 5th
2008-09 - 5th
2009-10 - 8th
2010-11 - 7th
2011-12 - 7th
2012-13 - 6th

Can anyone suggest he did not bring about significant improvement? and, with one of the lowest net budgets in the league over an extended period. I don't see how anyone, with any ability to read, or understand stats or football, can't say Moyes did a good job here. I know alot of you remember the 80's...but look at where we generally finished before Moyes? We were a lower half team.

Barry Rathbone
242 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:08:56
Sam, don't think you've thought that through the Arsenal team in the 90s were champions so the base level is pretty damn high in fact arguably the only way is down. Throw in paying for a new stadium and it's a tenuous comparison.

Whereas the "PG Tips chimp" scenario is unburdened by such gaiety.

Tony J Williams
243 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:08:07
Eddie I stand corrected, you are talking about the 2004 Cup Game.... however the excerpt below is from the toffeweb report "Radzinski and Rooney were playing particularly well, working the supply lines and getting very promising balls into the Fulham penalty area. Lots of good play and excellent effort from Everton, but worryingly nothing to show after a very promising but ultimately frustrating first half — full of excellent play and Everton domination but lacking the vital winning shot."

Excellent play and domination, doesn't sound boring to me.

Paul, you may be sick and tired of my tone, I am bored with the Moyes is baaaad mmmmkay comments.

He is gone, couldn't give a toss what he does at Man U but I will pick up on reorganised history and made up points so get used to it.

Up the Martinez and all that but just because Moyes is now viewed (by me and others) as another teams scummy manager I won't change my views of the last 11 years.

Paul Andrews
244 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:16:02
Sam,

Just a further snippet.
Wengers net spend over the last 11 years is very similar to Moyes.

Try again.

Jim Knightley
245 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:20:35
Comparisons between Wenger and Moyes are both apt, and at the same time reductive. When Moyes took over, Arsenal were arguably the best team in the league? is that a correct claim to make? in that period, they have slipped away into perenial fourth, or third, placers. Wenger has done an incredible job imo to maintain them, but Arsenal have certaintly got weaker without spending. They also havent won a cup in 7? years now. Similarly, Arsenal's wages are over the double the size of ours.
Barry Rathbone
246 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:19:45
Jim, the problem with just presenting league finishes is it ignore the salient point of this thread ie he was a shithouse when it mattered.

If "best of the rest" justifies that.... well frankly that's something you'll just have to live with.

Sam Hoare
247 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:20:05
Paul, the matter is one of improvement not what you've won or not. They have not improved, in fact the opposite.

Barry, that is a fair point but nonetheless your the assertion was that time and consistent management was all that needed to improve the team. The current Arsenal and in fact Man u team suggest that to be true.

You also fail to address the other point which is that if its really so PG Chimp easy then why has no one else done it?

Sam Hoare
248 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:24:42
The current Arsenal and in fact Man u team suggest that 'NOT' to be true.

whoops.

Barry Rathbone
249 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:25:13
Sam, they're fully booked
Jim Knightley
250 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:25:58
Barry, I think it's fair to say that this thread has moved into a general criticism of Moyes. I think his achievements clearly transcend those a 'chimp'?

And as related before...to take his words as 100% authentic is beyond naive.

One more thing...I think Paul clearly has worked out something most have been missing? Chimps apparently make great managers. Someone should inform Sunderland, Newcastle, Liverpool etc etc. I think they'd take improvement on a net spend of 1-1.5mil a year.

Kevin Tully
251 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:26:33
Wenger won 2 League & Cup doubles, went a whole season unbeaten, signed the best young players across Europe, played the finest football ever witnessed in the Premier League, and has basically made that club what's it is today.

Please do not under-estimate his achievements, when they were at their peak, that were scintillating, as good as the great Barcelona side of recent years in my opinion.

David Graves
252 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:24:58
Steve Brown (265) - Do you know what I "expect the Manchester United manager to say about how his last team approached matches at Old Trafford"? Nothing. Nada.
Paul Ferry
253 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:27:04
TJW - if I may (289), I agree that there is constructive criticism of Moyes on the one hand and also sniping and seemingly hateful bile on the other (but sometimes both). But this piece of shit takes the biscuit and needs to be expunged:

Joe Bibb (120) David Moyes the new Jimmy Saville.

He knows exactly what he is doing here our Joe, though he will, needless to say, come up with something along the lines of 'I was just making a comparison'.

There are a million and one examples of public figures once golden who fell by the wayside but our Joe had to plump for Saville and I think we all know why.

Shameful, fxxxxxxg shameful.

Barry Rathbone
254 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:30:52
Jim, his words are authentic doubtless umpteen journos and mutv have recordings the question is do people want to spin them into something other than what they say.

11 years of watching the man suggests take them at face value otherwise people will talk about you.

Speaking heresy I know but do you think RM has a chimp like visage?

Are we onto something here?

Jim Knightley
255 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:33:26
I think there failures in Europe prevent comparison with Barca.

But I'm in agreement Kevin. I think Wenger is the second best manager of the Premier League era...not just because of that incredible period, but because of the last 8/9 years, when they've managed to maintain Champions League football whilst building a new stadium. I personally expect Arsenal to re-emerge over the next 2-3 seasons as genuine title contenders, now that they have reached a level of economic sustainability which will allow them to bring at least one top player into the club a season, aka Bayern. I think Suarez may be the first peice of the puzzle.

Personally, I don't think that bodes well for us, or those outside of the top 4. I can see a position where the title race becomes interesting, but the chase for champions league football ceases to be interesting.

The sooner we get a buyer, and improve our/build a new stadium the better.

Jim Knightley
256 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:40:12
Barry I'm not talking about inauthencity in terms of him saying them...but the notion of taking a football manager's comments as utterly authentic of his beliefs.

As per my initial post:

What a surprise...a comment from a Manchester United manager, which, unsurprisingly, represents the fear factor involved in going to Old Trafford, and clearly aims to get the fans on board?
No one ever thought it could be rhetoric?

- Football is about rhetoric. Moyes used it to pressure referees before the cup game a few seasons ago... Managers used it consistently to put pressure on the board, alleviate or raise expectation...Ferguson was perhaps the best exponent of it during my lifetime. I can't believe one comment, from a new manager at a new club where he is under so much pressure to prove himself and prove that he can encapsulate the club's ambition, has received so many comments and so much criticism.

Paul Andrews
257 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:46:53
Jim Knightley,

Wait until Sunderlands and Newcastles chimps have been there for 11 years before making comparisons.

Jim Knightley
258 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:48:48
Sorry Paul, did it take Moyes 11 years to improve us?
Paul Andrews
259 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:48:04
Sam,

The point being the comparison of the last 11 years between the performance of Wenger and Moyes on the same net spend over the 11 years.

I wish Everton had been lucky enough to have a similar decline.

Wayne Smyth
260 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:30:24
I'm sorry, but anyone who says its acceptable for a professional manager to be going to a team in the same league with the attitude that they just "want to get out of there alive" is a disgrace. We're not talking amateurs vs a world 11 ffs!

It happens, I know, and not just to Moyes, but how many times have we been told that teams at Old Trafford are beaten before they kick a football? That is a spineless shitty attitude to take to any competitive game by the leader of a football club who is paid a fucking fortune to be a professional manager and compete and motivate the players to believe they can compete.

We've shown that we can go toe to toe with them if we believe we can and put the effort in and many other teams have done the same over the years. To be honest, I'm angry that we paid that cretin £3.5M per year to poison our club with that kind of small minded shite.

Wayne Smyth
261 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:54:15
Jim, I think one thing your missing is that it goes to prove the mentality that Moyes had while our manager.

One of Moyes traits is his honesty, and so I think we can take it at face value, rather than some bollocks he made up to ingratiate himself with the mancs.

Barry Rathbone
262 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:48:30
Jim. undoubtedly his audience is the Utd fans but it reminds me of the excuses regarding Kenwright and why we haven't been sold ie "no-ones buying football clubs these days". You can make a tenuous case for this given the global crisis but inside the depths of your soul and the parts of the brain where logic prevails you think "bollocks".

It's the same with Moyes his dreadful record at such grounds makes your theory plausible but inside the depths of ....

Well, you get the picture.

Jim Knightley
263 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:56:45
Wayne, do you actually think everything Moyes has said publically has been honest?

I think Moyes is innately defensive...too defensive for much of his tenure. But our results are not equivocal... we beat plenty of the top teams at home during Moyes tenure, illustrating he could instill a mentality to beat the best. His away form at the top clubs was overly poor...but how many do United lose at home? Moyes also won at City and Spurs whilst they were top four, but this is conveniently forgotten by some on here, who like to present a selective representation of his top four results.

Paul Andrews
264 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:04:50
No Jim,he steadily improved us for 4-6 years ( apart from one year,can't remember which one,when we finished 17 th I believe)
Then he went stagnant
Wayne Smyth
265 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:10:13
Pretty much Jim. If you have any examples of lies he's told in public I'd be interested to hear them. I'm really struggling to recall anything he's said like that.
Jim Knightley
266 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:11:23
So Paul, what has eleven years got to with anything? Moyes improved us over his tenure...and as you said, over a shorter period. He remained our manager precisely because he didnt waste large amounts of money, and take us to relegation, or oversee sustained periods of regression, as has been demonstrated by recent Liverpool managers in particular, and Newcastle, Sunderland and several other high profile examples.
Sam Hoare
267 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:08:22
No, Paul. The point was improving the squad over the last ten years. Moyes has and Wenger has not.

The main point being that obviously, improving your squad over time isn't nearly as easy as you have made out.

Barry Rathbone
268 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:14:48
Jim, I disagree when the wheels come off he got a stay of execution because Kenwright isn't really up to the job - a good chance he'd have been shown the door elsewhere.
Wayne Smyth
269 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:11:40
Jim, if he has proved he can instill a mentality to beat the best, why is he going to OT with the mentality that he just wants to get out of there alive?

Home advantage and Sky4 power are obviously a powerful force in how they influence referees. That accepted, I want my managers mentality going into every single game, whether its Accrington Stanley at home or Barcelona away to be that we're going out there and we're going to give 100% effort and this is the plan we're going to use to WIN THE GAME!

That is the minimum I'd expect from ANY manager of ANY football club. I'd expect premier league managers to just have a better bloody plan about how they were going to win the game!

If the team doesn't win it doesn't matter, provided we tried our best. But to openly have a defeatist attitude is shocking. Privately hoping to escape from OT with a point or not to lose by 3+ goals is one thing, but I expect a professional leader who is motivating my team to present a far more positive face to the players.

Jim Knightley
270 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:18:14
re. his honesty Wayne. I think there have been clear conflations in rhetoric, as demonstrated last season, when he both played down, and emphasised, our chances of Champions League football.

I don't think we can ever assume that what a manager says in public is what he says to his players, or necessarily what he thinks. Part of football, whether for the better or the worse, is about performance. I think some favour dampening expectations (Wenger has fallen into this category of late) and others favour heightening (Harry's Spurs for the title rhetoric springs to mind). But I think we cant managers' comments as gold...especially when they have a very specific context, as Moyes' most recent ones clearly do.

Paul Andrews
271 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:22:06
Sam,

You are twisting more than Chubby Checker.

Jim,

My point is the vast majority of managers would improve their team given 11 years in which to do it.
I would give an example but can't find another Prem manager allowed to keep his job for 11 years without winning a trophy

Sam Hoare
272 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:24:26
Wayne, Jim makes a good point. What DM said to his players pre matches at old Trafford and what he says now to the media at a press conference for the Man U manager are obviously likely to be very different given the context.
Sam Hoare
273 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:27:16
No, Paul.

Here's your original point to make it clear:

'I think he left us with a better team than the one he inherited.
After 11 fucking years,and with the team he inherited,I think a
PG Tips chimp would have achieved the same.'

Once again, the matter in question is improving the team over time.

Paul Andrews
274 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:30:50
"Like we did last summer"
Wayne Smyth
275 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:24:40
Jim, there is a clear difference between expressing an opinion about the future(i.e. him commenting on our champions league chances), and offering some facts about your personal state of mind at a point in the past.

He clearly states:

" that used to be our saying, you know"

So, its not just his private thoughts he didn't share with his players. Its a common ingrained mentality among several people; possibly just the coaches, but I suspect the players too.

You can assume the most positive spin on this if you like, but I think Moyes is a very straightforward, honest person and it goes to explain some of the other traits we regularly witnessed, such as 11 behind the ball at corners, defending a 1 goal lead for 60 minutes, taking your only striker off the pitch late in games, etc, etc.

They're all traits of a person with a fear of losing. Losing is something you should just not want to do. You shouldn't be paralysed by it.

Ste Traverse
276 Posted 24/07/2013 at 17:45:38
The worst comment Moyes ever came out with during his time here was when just over a year ago he descibed a 7th place finish is 'the equivalent of us winning the Champions League'.
Wayne Smyth
277 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:32:32
Sam(326), its only "obviously" likely to be different if that is what you want to believe.

If he says that was "our" mentality when we went there, then I believe him.

Paul Andrews
278 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:32:49
Wayne,

That last paragraph of yours should be carved into the dressing room wall.

Paul Andrews
279 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:34:44
The last paragraph in post 330.
Sums the previous manager up perfectly.
Sam Hoare
280 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:40:37
Wayne, if you truly believe that Moyes pre-match team talk went along the lines of 'All right lads, we'll be lucky to get out of here alive. Give it your best' then I guess it not 'obvious' at all.
Paul Andrews
282 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:47:06
I think "give it your best" may be an exaggeration considering some of the games where we lay down and had our bellies tickled....league at anfield...semi final against liverpool etc etc
Wayne Smyth
283 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:51:17
Sam, I'm talking about his general mindset which would impact the nature of his team talk. I didn't expect it was his team talk word for word.

To be clear, I think it highly unlikely that he went there with a plan to win and a belief that we could achieve it. I think it more likely he went there with a plan of how not to lose 3 or 4-0.


Sam Hoare
284 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:54:23
Surely laying down and having your bellies tickled could be quite nice? Better than what happened to us at Anfield anyway.

BTW if you think we won't be due a pasting or two under Martinez then just you wait...Excited to see what he brings but there will be some bad days.

Sam Hoare
285 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:58:42
Wayne, I suspect he went with the attitude that Man u had the better team and that best chances were to try and keep it tight and fight hard for everything. No doubt that he had a highly defensive attitude but equally he was clearly a man who hated to lose.
Matt Traynor
286 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:59:45
Sam #349, you do come across sometimes as more of a fan of Moyes than Everton.

Of course we will lose a few games, and some will be heavy defeats. Martinez will to well though to surpass your hero's 7-0 at Arsenal. In fact his Wigan side managed a win there 2 seasons ago.

Paul Andrews
287 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:59:32
It would be quite nice Sam
Perhaps you could ask David to arrange it,he is good at that.

ooooh you sound like you are your shivering with anticipation re the pasting.
Unless it is the imagination running away re the tummy tickle.

Sam Hoare
288 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:04:13
Matt/Paul- far from it. I'm 110% behind Martinez and excited to see what he does.

Till today i've tried quite hard to refrain from commenting on all the anti-Moyes bile as he's no longer my concern. It's just some of the self righteous nonsense on here got me riled up...

Ray Atherton
289 Posted 24/07/2013 at 16:44:45
I am glad that Moyse has gone and look forward to a better future with our new manager. Tony 180 you don't speak for me when you say Man U. are the enemy. The real enemy in my eyes are the RS, When our team couldn t compete with them united would always make my day winning quite often. Leave the bile to the rs followers.
Paul Andrews
290 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:09:46
Not forgetting the 1-6 home defeat against the rapidly declining Arsenal Matt.
Tommy Coleman
291 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:57:55
Jim - its no wonder you think so highly of Moyes, you have the exact same defeatism.

If you don't think it's possible to overtake Utd then you don't know football history. Much bigger gaps have been bridged. If you have the right manager, you can do anything.

Why even bother following football if you think you're beat before kicking a ball.

Sam Hoare
292 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:15:05
Outliers, Paul. Perhaps like yourself.
Wayne Smyth
293 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:00:50
Sam, his definition of lose and my definition I think are different. To me its simple. Its 11 vs 11 and professional players on both sides. You lose if they score more than you.

His definition might be to not have tomorrows papers full of MU 5 EFC 0. His pragmatic viewpoint might be that if we lose the game 1-0 no-one will kick up a fuss. After all, like you say they have the better players and will have the best chances.

Just run about and work hard and spend the entire game trying to stop them from scoring....we'll have a think about creating something of our own if they let us. People will talk about plucky everton taking on the giants of english football and we will have forgotten about the result the following week.

Its all about "managing expectations", Sam. Its the same mentality that leads to talking about the 40pt mark when you're 2nd or 3rd in the league after 10 games.

P.S. I agree about martinez by the way. I think its entirely possible we'll be on the end of a few hidings due to his style of play and his willingness to give inexperienced players a chance. But I think I'd rather lose a few games 4 or 5 nil but win a few trophies along the way than finish 7th every season and have no chance of winning anything because the manager is too scared.

Matt Traynor
294 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:11:44
Sam #357,. agree some of the comments on the thread (and others) have been gratuitous. As I've mentioned elsewhere, I was a fan of his for a while, but couldn't wait for him to go by the end. Nothing to do with the style of play (which actually on balance was better in the latter stages), I just think he got fed up of BK's crap, and his dream job came up. The turning point for me was the 3-0 defeat at Anfield, when he rested half the squad prior to the replay at Sunderland, and then had the audacity after to respond to criticism from fans by saying he should've rested more. He lost this fan, and daresay a few more at that moment.

Paul #359, yes, I still remember that, but didn't want to start rattling them off. To be fair, we did have a 7-1 win against Sunderland, but I reckon we had more cricket scores against us than for us during his time.

Mike Green
295 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:13:22
Sam #252 - he couldn't have hated losing that much.

A man who hates losing puts a team out to be 3-0 up at half time and then tells them to go for it in the second half.

A man that hates losing tries to get his team away from the other team, and from losing, by making the gulf between them and their opponents impassable.

I'm not saying Moyes liked losing, I just think he liked to flirt with, tried to cosy up next to it and tease it, and in doing so more often than not ended up with the ugly sister instead - the draw.

We had 11 years of him walking into the night club once or twice a week, to walk out more often than not with some right shockers on his arm. He said it was because he had no money, couldn't get the nice ones a drink, got in some real trouble too - but that's what you get when you take a knife to a gunfight.....

Paul Andrews
296 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:23:51
I agree Sam, out liars! Pronto if you please
Ross Edwards
297 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:04:47
Sam, I know you are boldly predicting that we will recieve some pastings but remind me again, didn't we recieve quite a few when Moyes was in charge?

Oh yes, we did:

0-7 v Arsenal
1-6 v Arsenal
1-4 v Arsenal
1-4 v Blackburn
1-5 v Dinamo Bucharest
0-5 v Benfica
0-3 v Wigan
0-3 v Liverpool

Oh, we had our bad days under Moyes as well. I know you are desperate to defend Moyes at any cost but at least Martinez is never going to get hammered by a useless Romanian side and roll over shamelessly in a Merseyside Derby.

At least Martinez won't treat the club and the fans like he has over the last 2 months. Moyes treated this club with contempt, and quite how he got the Utd job showing a defeatist attitude like "I wanted to get out alive" is beyond me, but then again his mate Fergie got his mate Moyesy a job didn't he?

Paul Andrews
298 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:31:17
Matt,

The post above proves your point.

7-1 v The Mackems was a great performance.
That was part of the problem with Moyes,he had a side capable of inflicting defeats like that but would not let them off the leash for the majority of the time.
Terrified to risk a defeat by going for a win

Paul Johnson
299 Posted 24/07/2013 at 18:56:17
I was never a Moyes fan and I'm very happy to see the back of him.

How SAF will defend giving him the ManYoo job once his negative "don't lose" tactics are found out will be interesting, to say the least.
At least Pip is there along with the rest of the wrecking crew. LMFAO ;-)

COYB!!!

Sam Hoare
300 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:40:14
Is that it Ross? Less than 1 a season?

I'll be quite happy if RM keeps that up.

Ross Edwards
301 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:50:16
You want us to be beaten heavily under Martinez Sam, just so you can be proved right?
Colin Glassar
302 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:52:10
This thread has been very therapeutic IMO. Long may it continue. Btw, I'm enjoying reading some of the manc sites. Some very entertaining, and worried, comments regarding OFM.
Sam Hoare
303 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:13:27
Erm, no Ross. Thats why I said i'll be happy if it less than that. But feel free to take the opposite of what I said as the truth if you need, fits in with your usual interpretation!
Jamie Barlow
304 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:05:18
There are definitely some posters obsessed with Moyes on here. Take a look at Colin's post above. Checking Man Utd sites? Dear me.

Ross, you're talking bollocks again. Nowhere does Sam say he wants us to get beat. Never mind heavily. Not everyone who doesn't have the same faith as you about Martinez wants us to get beat or struggle to prove you wrong.

While I'm on here, I'll give Paul Andrews a game off the top of my head. Everton vs Spurs. 0-1 down. Vellios comes on, no doubt changing tactics and formation. Everton win 2-1. Is that one alright? Does that match your Wigan? You probably remember this game and quite a few others though.

Paul Andrews
305 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:25:24
Off the top of my head my arse.
Took you two days to come up with that "off the top of your head"
Jim Lloyd
306 Posted 24/07/2013 at 19:46:48
I wonder why some posters on here immediately start throwing out their refrain of "Oh this is just a thread to let the Moyes out Brigade to vent their bitter bile" and variations on that theme.

There may be some who always thought Moyes was not the manager for them but discussing the mindset of a man who uttered the phrase which started the thread off doesn't automatically mean all the comments are just bitter bile. That sort of thinking seems to me to be just a way of attempting to stifle or belittle any debate.

I think this is an extremely interesting post about a man who managed us for over a decade. I don't see that the thread was started with an all out attack on all that David Moyes had achieved while at Everton. It was to focus on an aspect of his psyche that many fans, me included, felt was an ultra-cautious and almost "beaten before you start" mentality, that seemed to come to the fore when playing for high stakes.

That seems to me to be a genuine and valid discussion about a man who managed our teams. And it is also a valid discussion to have now that he's left. What he publicly said as the Manager of Man Utd, was said about our club and (I assume) the message he and his backroom staff instilled into his players.

Along with some of his other statements and some, what many consider to be, totally abject performances when it looked very much like the towel had been thrown in before the contest finished, or on some occasions, started! That to me is not an excuse for the MOB — as you call all fans who criticise aspects of Moyes's approach during his tenure as manager at EFC — to pour out bile. It is a discussion about a possible major flaw.

I certainly don't believe Moyes was a bad manager by any stretch of the imagination but I do believe he had an element of his nature that gave out a picture of submission in those high-stakes games.

I think that, generally, he did us more good than harm but there are some posts that I've read on here, that seem to see any criticism as outright opposition to everything he did. There might be some that have never liked his management style but many are saying that this "flaw" in his character prevented us achieving success that we might otherwise have had, if we'd have had a manager who believed that we could succeed.

I'm in agreement with the many posters on here that criticise him for this. As I said earlier. I sat in Wembley watching us get taken apart by Chelsea and I felt embarrassed that the match was on show to the football world. I'm sure those who went to the FA Cup Semi-final against Liverpool felt a similar emotion. And there are other matches which could be listed, where it looked like we were beaten before we started.

That's a valid criticism I think. It is not a denigration of all that Moyes achieved.

Sam Hoare
307 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:31:38
Jim Lloyd, fair enough. I am more than happy to listen to any well argued criticism of Moyes and I think you are probably spot on. His defensive approach was a flaw that saw some uninspired performances in big games and often left me with the feeling of what might have been. Unlike our new manager, Moyes was very risk averse and that's one reason I'm excited about a new, less predictable Martinez era.
Jamie Barlow
308 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:36:31
I'm not as desperate to win an argument as you Paul. You should really take two days out before you post the shite you post. You might make a little more sense.

I see you ignored the games Nick@173 gave you.

Ross Edwards
309 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:39:24
Hang on Sam, you were defending Moyes to the hilt a minute ago, make your mind up.
Sam Hoare
310 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:43:48
I'll defend spurious criticisms and accept valid ones, Ross. It's called attempting to be balanced and reasonable. You should try it some time.
Paul Andrews
311 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:44:20
Jamie,
What argument?
Patrick Murphy
312 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:33:05
Totally agree Jim, A manager of Everton who had been at the club for so long should have been adored and loved by our supporters. The fact that he was only well-liked or respected tells its own story.

Ross Edwards
313 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:46:22
Sam

I think it's called flip flopping.

Paul Andrews
315 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:45:56
Just looked at Nicks post.
Is that where you got the Spurs game from?
Sorry it was off the top of your head.

"Distin to readjust the attacking prowess"?

Ray Jacques
316 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:44:58
Not going to get involved with petty disputes over Moyes. He improved the team over the years and I have both good and bad memories from his time at Goodison. On Martinez, time will tell and he will be judged on results.

I work in Manchester and the faith of their fans is already starting to wane. Ive a £50 bet with a manc work colleague that Man U wont win the league this season. Initially he was keen on the bet and confident that they will remain on top. Once I gave him the stat s that in 11 years Moyes had never won a game at Arsenal, Man U, Liverpool or Chelsea (didnt mention the penalties in the cup) the colour drained from his face. I then added a couple of european gems such as Bucharest and Benfica which meant he spent the rest of the day trying to cancel the bet.

Also got him into thinking that Rooney can see the rot setting in and wants out!!!

Its a long time since I could have some fun with my manc mates.

i am more optimistic about our season than they over theirs.

Patrick Murphy
317 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:58:24
I've been looking through the web to see if there is a term for being fearful of Old Trafford or the other places mentioned, I can't find any but I did find these which may or may not be relevant.

Acrophobia – fear of heights

Decidophobia – fear of making decisions

Hoplophobia – fear of weapons, specifically firearms

Jamie Barlow
318 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:55:55
I was thinking of the game last night. I just couldn't be arsed to check it out.

I'm sure Moyes played Distin on the left wing in that game.

Nah, probably not.

Sam Hoare
319 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:02:31
Which is probably why you are so devoid of balance Ross!
Jim Lloyd
320 Posted 24/07/2013 at 20:54:07
Well said Patrick. You've said it in a nutshell, how many fans thought about David Moyes.
Sam. My sentiments too, I'm excited with Roberto's appointment and it could be a bit unpredictable indeed! I'm even thinking of getting a seasonticket again..must be the heat!
Robbie Muldoon
321 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:02:35
Like the saying, my only fear of death, is reincarnation'; well, my only Fear of Moyes is him ever coming back to Everton! With weepy Bill there, you know there is a chance...

My only hope, and it's a good one right now, is that Roberto Martinez will prove the yin to Moyes's yang. The Catalans seem to have faith in him. I have never been so excited for a new season to start!

Jim Lloyd
322 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:04:27
Patrick some good phobia things there. Hoplo from the Ancient Greek Hoplites. The foot soldiers. I think he suffered from OTT, Old Trafford Terrors
Mat Fearon
323 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:05:08
If Moyes is such a poor manager, can someone explain to me how one of the most successful clubs in the world decided to choose him to run the team ? I mean, quite an important decision for the Man U board do you not think, and perhaps they would have given a number of options serious consideration before choosing Moyes. I wonder why they chose him, bearing in mind they probably know a thing or two about football and management.
Paul Andrews
324 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:15:02
Nick must have read your mind Jamie :-)
Paul Gladwell
325 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:24:41
Don't know if its been mentioned but there is another story out today about his (Moyes's) brother asking Jimmy Calderwood can he look for jobs for him in Holland — this was eight months ago; he absolutely had no intentions of staying.
Mike Green
326 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:15:01
Mat #429 - Im sure you'll poo poo this but at the end of the day I think Fergie did genuinely have an awful lot to do with it.

And why not? Fergie surely knows more than any of them about football management, and more than most about the football club, so it's logical that he has a major influence in who his successor is doesn't it? You'd be mad to turn that kind of knowledge down.

However, just because someone was a good football manager, doesn't necessarily mean he's good at picking football managers.

I think Moyes was picked because he's consistent, he's proved he's got stickability, will be loyal to the board, won't take any shit from players who think they're bigger than the club, can play hard ball and make money on transfers plus he's a known quantity who comes highly recommended by Fergie who must hold serious sway at OT. So why not? If it works out he's still young in managerial terms and they cold have another dynasty on their hands, if not he can be the fall guy and they get the next guy in they fancy. I don't think they've brought him in for his reputation for sparkling football.

Kevin Tully
327 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:25:37
Can I turn your question around Mat? (Only for fun!)

Would Moyes have been offered the Man U job if he wasn't Scottish, and big pals with Fergie?

To take that one a step further, let's say Moyes was Welsh, and had a bad relationship with Fergie over the years, would he be at Utd based upon his 'achievements' at Goodison?


Mike Green
328 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:34:33
Besides - they must've always liked him - after all they let him get out of Old Trafford alive enough times.
Michael Kenrick
329 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:26:31
Jim Lloyd (#399) — a superb post. Spells it out exactly for those so keen on "thread drift".... This issue is exactly about what you said, and nothing else.

Mat (#429), it is a puzzzler... but I've got this theory.... a bit crazy but it could well be true (vague on details as I don't have time right now to fact-check — sorry!).

1998(?) A young and bright-eyed David Moyes applies for the highly prestigious job of Number Two at Old Trafford under the magnificent management of one (Sir?) Alex Ferguson, fellow Glaswegian. Moyes is turned down... but given some sage advice:

Keep your nose clean, get some decent management experience here in the northwest, find yourself a good little position where you can hone you skills, show what you can do — without presenting too much of a challenge to "the biggest and the best club in the world".

Then, when SAF is ready to finally call it a day, "this could all be yours for the asking". Just bide ya time, wee, fella....

And the rest, as they say, is history.

Mike Green
330 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:37:30
Kevin #437 - got to the end of your post and the Family Fortunes 'urng urrrgh' sound went off in my head :)
Robbie Muldoon
331 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:36:26
Matt, who is the 'they'? It was one man, Alex Ferguson. One jock seeing a bit of himself in a younger jock who were friendly with each other. That's it.
Peter Warren
332 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:36:44
Mat 429# no one knows for sure. We will have to wait and see - personally I think he is alright but can't see how he can be considered potentially great especially as he often refers to himself in the third person.

The board / man who appointed Fergie you would think we're a good judge but the same board were one game away of sacking one of the best managers ever. I don't buy that they are more qualified than us who have watched him for over 10 years, week-in, week-out.

Barry Rathbone
333 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:35:15
Mat 429, Moyes plays golf with Ferguson - it was all Fergusons doing.

Remember Utd are a commercial venture run by yanks with no idea about football - what expertise could they call on? Dear old Bobby Charlton is in his dotage it's no surprise they turned to the most successful manager ever.

Trouble is Fergie is an egomaniac and Moyes clearly pushes all the right buttons, to all intents he is Ferguson's doppelganger minus one thing - talent.

Utd's money disguised the Ferguson mis-judgements in the transfer market (and boy he made some big 'uns) this will be the biggest error of judgement he ever made.

Mat Fearon
334 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:51:12
Barry,
So now you are suggesting that Ferguson is not a great manager are you?
Lets go with the suggestion that it was just Ferguson's decision, (which I don't buy for one minute as they are a listed company and the whole board would have to be bought into the decision), do you think Fergusion understands what it takes to manage Man U, and do you think that continuing his legacy would be very important to him ? Ie, he would have thought very carefully before selecting/recommending anyone?
And please don't give me any Scottish mafia nonsense.
Mike Green
335 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:56:42
Mat #445 - he could equally not care how his successor did, if he falls flat on his face who does it make look even better?

Win / Win.

Mat Fearon
336 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:56:34
Kevin,
I agree that ferguson had a lot to do with the decision, but he should do bearing in mind he managed the club for 25 years and is viewed as the best in the game. But the board would have to have been bought into it, and I don't buy the Scottish mafia element. Ferguson will view Man U as being far more important than Moyes; ie he would only have recommended him if he thought he would/could take the job on and be successful. And ferguson understands what it takes to manage Man U. I guess we will have to wait and see if he is right.
Barry Rathbone
337 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:56:48
Mat, this is a typical Moyes disciple nonsense:

"So now you are suggesting that Ferguson is not a great manager are you?"

Please read the post again and stop being silly if you ask a question but don't like the answer by all means stamp your feet but don't make things up.

(hint: look for "most successful manager ever")

You don't have to apologise.... why break the habit of 11 years?

Kevin Tully
338 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:02:15
Mat - don't under-estimate how closely the two families are connected ;

"As a boy, Ferguson played for a youth team coached by Moyes's father. Like Ferguson, Moyes is a graduate of Glasgow's Drumchapel Amateurs FC, where his mother washed the team kit and his father was on the board."

Mike Green
339 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:07:11
Jesus, it gets worse...
Mat Fearon
340 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:09:13
Barry,
I am not a "Moyes" disciple, so don't suggest that I am just because I don't agree with your one sided vitriol.
Generally I think he was good for the club but certainly had his faults, so I am able to take a balanced view on his time as manager, unlike your good self.

Kevin, sorry I just don't buy the Scottish thing. The fact they got on clearly helped, but there is no way on earth Ferguson would have backed Moyes if he thought he was not upto the job. Just think about it, why on earth would he?

Kevin Tully
341 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:16:44
Mat, I'm not saying he got the job because they were pals, or knew each other's families, or both were massive labour supporter's, or both racehorse owners, or Fergie was pal of Moyes's father - I'm just saying it helped!
Barry Rathbone
342 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:15:07
Mat, if you can't argue your case without making things up that really isn't a balanced view although it is common for people in your position.
Brin Williams
343 Posted 24/07/2013 at 21:55:12
PM 420 - 'I've been looking through the web to see if there is a term for being fearful of Old Trafford or the other places mentioned, I can't find any but I did find these which may or may not be relevant.
Acrophobia – fear of heights

Decidophobia – fear of making decisions

Hoplophobia – fear of weapons, specifically firearms'

How does 'Yellow" sound?

Mat Fearon
344 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:24:33
Barry,
I did not make anything up. You insinuated that ferguson lacks judgment, , (transfers example), and suggested his decision to back Moyes is another mistake. Very clear to me.

Kevin,
Yep, agree it was important, but if ferguson thought he was not upto the job, the relationship would have been irrelevant.

Gavin Ramejkis
345 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:05:01
Mat, I'll add another little twist onto the why Moyes? Old Whiskey Nose has only moved upstairs and is a well known control freak, Moyes has always being subservient to him so Fergie knows getting a manager in who he can still call the shots over if it turns to rat shit is the winning sales pitch. If you think more closely about that, before Moyes moved his band of cronies in with him; scraps of paper Round and Kes, you'll note Fergie had already lined up Dorian Giggs as player coach (the player I think Fergie knows the fans want as manager) as long as no one finds that picture in Gigg's attic he will still be about to get his badges ready to slide in when Moyes cocks it up. Extra insurance from Phil Chuckle Brother who has just fast tracked his badges and you have another die hard Manc the fans can relate to. A win win for whisky nose - if it turns to rat shit, Moyes ends up on a Domino's pizza moped and Man U get internals to replace him.
Barry Rathbone
346 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:33:39
Mat, righto .... as long as in your world it makes sense.

Brin, how about this on the basis Utd were originally Newton Heath a railway team:

Trains, railroads or train travel- Siderodromophobia.

Brian Waring
347 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:30:49
Being the manager of Man United, one of the biggest jobs in world football, you must admit, the appointment of Moyes does have you scratching your head.
Colin Glassar
348 Posted 24/07/2013 at 22:29:21
It will be interesting to see OFM up against the likes of Guardiola, Klopp, Conti, etc.....in the CL. That's where he wanted to be so, no hiding behind lack of finances, small squads etc....
Paul Ferry
349 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:04:12
Good work Detective Tully (449), Jesus wept it's worse than the Borgias. So it all began three decades or so ago in Glasgow,hushed whispers in corners, secret sabbats, secret handshakes, blood agreements.

Have you told the fuzz yet Kev? There might be cold cases that will need reopening.

And Damien Moyes, renamed David at the suggestion of a youngish SAF, has all the telling facial signs of some sort of hellish cabal

Look:

http://i3.dailyrecord.co.uk/incoming/article1878429.ece/ALTERNATES/s1023/David-Moyes-1878429.jpg

Top drawer work Tully and to think that poor old Ross Edwards was getting stick and flack on here for claiming that the link went back to the start of this year when in fact it all goes back to a time when Kajagoogoo were top of the hit parade.

Paul Ferry
350 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:11:35
Col (463): OFM?

Let me in on it will you mate, please.

Ernie Baywood
351 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:30:25
So Moyes was tactically inept for playing cowardly football, and Martinez is our saviour because he played brave open football wherever he went with Wigan? Run that by me again...

I was never happy with Moyes's negativity but I'm probably less pleased with the appointment of a man who valued style over points and took his side down.

I'm glad to be shut of Moyes's attitude. Just not sure that Martinez's is better.

Patrick Murphy
352 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:37:32
Paul - OFM = Our Former Manager.
Kevin Tully
353 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:41:29
Ha ha PF - pissing myself at the thought of all these Glaswegians in a washouse somewhere holding up the baby David!!

You could say he's been groomed like an angel faced altar boy in a roomful of Bishops.

Oh shit - back on religion again! More tea vicar?

Phil Sammon
354 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:44:10
Deary me, aren't we all fed up of this yet? I'll be glad when there's a ball kicked.
Paul Ferry
355 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:53:14
Cheers Patrick
Paul Ferry
356 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:55:18
No Phil (480), think of this as our pre-season warm-up/friendlies (well, sort of)

Up the workers Phil!!!!!

Patrick Murphy
357 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:54:25
Don't forget the parts played by Walter and Archie in this ongoing Scottish soap opera, without them DM wouldn't have found a club in such a state to cut his teeth on.

Paul Ferry
358 Posted 24/07/2013 at 23:58:02
Willy fecking Donachie Patrick, the missing link, an altar boy at Moyes's ma and pa's wedding:

http://www.lilligren.com/Redneck/images/redneck_wedding_2.jpg

Now, look carefully at this. It is Donachie, but who does it remind you of?

http://i2.chroniclelive.co.uk/incoming/article1338893.ece/ALTERNATES/s2197/teaser-willie-donachie-913226513-1338893.jpg

Yes, Moyes!

Murkier and murkier.

There is a chain of sexual congress here that Agent Tully needs to investigate but all roads lead to Glasgow a long time ago

Patrick Murphy
359 Posted 25/07/2013 at 00:03:41
Donachie's up at Newcastle with the youngsters I think I read recently. Did we have any Scotsmen in leading roles at the club before the PL started, I may be wrong but I can't remember any off the top of my head.
Paul Ferry
360 Posted 25/07/2013 at 00:20:08
Georgie Wood on the turnstiles?
Patrick Murphy
361 Posted 25/07/2013 at 00:26:47
Bear in mind that Jelavic was on fire until that other Scotsman arrived on the scene, namely, Mr Naismith....mmm...the plot thickens.

Just watching USA v Honduras I like the look of that Holden lad, the Americans are playing some good footy going forward and Landon has been playing well in this tournament.

Steven Telford
362 Posted 25/07/2013 at 00:25:08
Barry #294 "Jim, the problem with just presenting league finishes is it ignore the salient point of this thread ie he was a shithouse when it mattered."

.......and so by that logic "aggregation" is irrelevant in judging a person performance? League position is irrelevant in judging a manager performance.

Honestly, play that one back to yourself a few times.
Because points are points, and it is precisely in aggregation that they matter.

And as well, another comment you made on the thread #260 "people hate to admit when they are wrong"
Yeah, and "a big club would never touch him"
Ring any bells.


Roman Sidey
363 Posted 23/07/2013 at 22:18:20
Scott, 912, the difference between Moyes saying what he's said, and IF Martinez said it, is that Martinez has actually won at Goodison. If he was fearful of what we might do to his side, he sure still had enough brain space not afraid to turn up trying to win.
Barry Rathbone
364 Posted 25/07/2013 at 11:09:26
Steven Telford, you and your compadres aversion to accepting Moyes shithouse attitude at the old sky 4 places and against all and sundry in the cups by bleating on about best of the rest is the totem of all that is Moyes FC.

What is this dreadful aversion to the big picture regarding Everton and winning things or even just having some guts?

As for Moyes getting the Utd job you clearly don't get it - do you honestly believe if Moyes and Fergie weren't buddies he'd have got the job?

Old Traford is only 40 mins up the road if you miss him that much - don't let the door smack your arse on the way out.

Mark Riley
365 Posted 27/07/2013 at 21:53:00
I'm gonna get shot down in flames here by most after reading the comments...

It's disappointing to read the disdain for someone who was in all a good manager for our club and the best one we've had since Howard's first reign.

Yeah, his tactics were negative at times but look at the facts, he took us from the brink of the Championship when he took over, to the Champions League, a run in the UEFA cup, an FA cup final and semi final, top six finishes, and just as important, finishing above Liverpool.

We're now regarded as one of the top 6/7 teams in the league, can you honestly say this was achieved by any of the other Everton managers of the last 20 years.........Mike Walker? Howards disastrous third term? Walter Smith? Okay Joe Royle won the FA Cup but that was short lived. For the resources he had its some achievement.

I don't understand the loyalty thing either, he took one of the top jobs in the world............who on here wouldn't take a better job offer?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb