Robin van Persie's pre-season injury niggle is down to 'dinosaur coaching' methods, says Dutch fitness expert

, 25 July, 117comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes’s pre-season handling of Robin van Persie has been called into question by a Dutch fitness specialist who has worked with several leading clubs and was assistant to the late Wales manager Gary Speed.

Writing on his Twitter account, Raymond Verheijin wrote: “In Sydney Moyes said: ‘We’ve overtrained Robin this week to build up his fitness’. [In Japan] he picked up a muscle injury. It really makes you wonder how these prehistoric training methods can still take place at the highest level.

"The only way to solve this problem in Jurassic Park is to improve education of these dinosaur coaches, fitness clowns & scientific cowboys.

"All over the world in pre-season you see the pattern ‘overtraining-fatigue-injuries’. Always avoid accumulation of fatigue in pre-season.

"But as long as most dinosaurs are still in denial & ignore how things develop in other countries, nothing will ever change in Jurassic Park. Obviously, players like RVP should learn to protect themselves better against ‘overtraining’ & ‘punishing training’.”

» Read the full article at The Telegraph



Reader Comments (117)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kieran Kinsella
1 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:13:27

Roberto Martinez made a point a few weeks ago that player development should continue after players reach the age of 17/18. Baines has been talking a lot in the media about how Martinez's training sessions have focused on passing and technique. The reason I mention this is because it makes you wonder what went on before.

Cameron Jerome of Stoke City was quoted this week as saying that Mark Hughes uses "scientific" methods" in training. He elaborated and said the techniques included drills that recreated "game type" scenarios. Scientific? Erm, I thought that was just football training 101.

And after reading this Telegraph stry about Van Persie, I couldn't help but think back to all the discussions we have had on Toffeeweb about matters such as Arteta's awful corner kick routines. We wondered if these were rehearsed or if Arteta just took them because he was regarded as the best player. According to Cameron Jerome of Stoke, Tony Pulis never practiced such things and just chose the same players regardless of what happened in training. It doesn't take much of a leap here to suggest that Moyes and Pulis come from the same mold.

Think about all the strikers who lost their way as they were run into the ground. Yakubu, Johnson, Jelavic etc and all the "promising youngsters" who were much touted at 17 or 18 and never progressed. e.g. Barkley, Vellios, Plessis, Scott whathis name, that Icelandic kid, Mustafi, Duffy, etc etc. Could it have been because training was more reminiscent of an army boot camp rather than a "scientific" sports session? I am hoping that things improve now that the dinosaur has gone.

Michael Kenrick
2 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:16:31
OMG... I'm not saying a word!
Mike Green
3 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:22:12
I hate to say it but Moyes damns himself with his own words here again (assuming its an accurate report).

'We've overtrained Robin'.

I'm not bashing Moyes, and this story is relevant to us as it puts perspective on how the team were handled under him. It could be that his training methods are fine but risk the odd minor injury as they push players to the edge.

The interesting thing for me though is Moyes never received criticism for his 'Boot Camp' pre-seasons at Everton, as if it was all we were good for, a bit of borstal mentality for our Luddite players. At Man Utd though the spotlight is on and all of a sudden this approach is under swift criticism.

My guess is our players are warming to Martinez's methods just as swiftly.

Derek Thomas
4 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:17:15
Truth will out they say as more and more stuff ' leaks' out. Running up and down sandhills was not state of the art in the 80's let alone now. I fear though, that 11 weeks of Martinez will not be enough to redress all the balance.

I was amazed when ( and where ) Moyes went but the more stuff that leaks out the more I think we are well rid.

Yes, it might all turn to mike walker flavoured custard, but it will be new and up to date custard not stale stuff well passed it's best before 1983

Chris Williamson
5 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:39:10
There's nothing worng with wanting your squad to be as fit as they can be - I remember the mid 80's side coming out of the changing room onto the pitch already sweating, tearing around the field for 90 minutes, sometimes using 1 sub and then repeating this throughout the season. Aupremely fit they were.

However, they avoided injury. With Moyes I think we have had a lot of injured and burned out players, so something wasn't right.

I lay in bed this morning thinking about why Arsenal are thinking of smashing their transfer record over Canibal Lector ... my conclusion is that they see this season as being more open in terms of the top spot. Moyes will not do well in his first season, I think, Man C have a new manager too, and how well will Chelsea do with Morinho back - they say never go back for a reason.

I think this is Arsenal's season, if they sign big. Unless it's us to win it of course.

Mike Green
6 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:50:53
Chris - the issue might be down to giving the lad a month off after a tough season then smashing him into the ground as soon as he gets back....
Keith Harrison
7 Posted 25/07/2013 at 07:47:05
There's fuck all wrong with running up and down sandhills. We used to spend all pre-season in a local sand-quarry building up both fitness and stamina. We hardly saw a ball during this time.

Furthermore, we were quite happy to chase long kicks into the corners during an actual game. That's why Aspatria RUFC were the best Rugby team in Cumbria during the 80s and 90s!!

Phil Sammon
8 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:07:03
It's an interesting one.

When you have players of limited ability, your two greatest attributes can be work ethic and sheer fitness. I think that was typified by our 'Marcus Bent era'. Not the greatest players, but everyone gave it their all for 90 minutes.

Now at Man Utd, and arguably Everton the last couple of years, Moyes has has a better quality group of players to work with. Do these gifted international footballers respond to the same methods? Van Persie is probably the perfect example; glorious technique and ability, but made of glass. Does this man really want to be pushed to within an inch of his life?

Another interesting point is the injury situation at Everton under Moyes. If initial prognosis said a player was out for 2 weeks, you could bet your bottom dollar it would be over a month. I appreciate this happens from time to time, but it was literally every injury!

Mike Rourke
9 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:10:53
Wow, I was under the impression RVP, being the thoroughbred sicknote that he is, needed his glucose levels to be constantly monitored and blood tested to determine the likelihood of injury and how hard he should train on any given day.

Surely taking him to Japan and 'overtraining' him is akin to filling up your Rolls Royce with diesel and doing handbrake turns in a Tesco carpark, no good can come of it.

In contrast the noises of pre-season enjoyment coming out of our camp are encouraging, but whether a more enlightened philosophy translates to more points on the board is yet to be seen.

Colin Glassar
10 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:44:02
We will have to start calling OFM Fred Flinstone if he uses these dinosaur training methods and tactics.
Adam Luszniak
11 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:41:25
Moyes's last season at Everton was arguably one of his best, certainly in terms of the way we came out of the blocks. As I recall, we were due to play a pre-season tournament in Indonesia that never came off, and as a result the players got some more time off. When we began the season, we went off like a rocket! Tells you something about the strain Moyes's pre-season was putting on the players.
Paul Gladwell
12 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:46:07
Wait till he gets them up the Lake District in February....whoops lets move on eh.
Tony Marsh
13 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:43:28
Moyes truely is a Dinosaur. His ancient methods and outdated tactics are what drove many a good fan away from Goodison Park on match days. Think Bernard Manning when you think of Moyes the football coach. We are so lucky SAF has fucked up and taken T-Rex of our hands.

As members of our squad are now saying, pre-season has become enjoyable and interesting and football related. The days of running up Brecon Beacon with house bricks in a back pack are long gone. Even those of you who didn't like the Martinez appointment are coming on board and it's happy days all round. For once in a long time we are looking forward to the season and the football we will play. RM has swept away 11 years worth of Dusty Dave's cobwebs in a few weeks and it feels good to breath again.

Kevin Tully
14 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:01:32
Roberto on SSN saying no further interest for either Fellaini or Baines. Let's hope dinosaur Dave is distracted by spending his unlimited funds abroad.
Richard Dodd
15 Posted 25/07/2013 at 08:57:34
Most of you will know that I don`t usually subscribe to anti-Moyes propaganda. However, in this one, I do believe there is an element of truth.

About a year ago, I bumped into one of our former players then plying his trade in the Blue Square Conference North. He told me that Moyes `DRILLED` his players rather than coached them and that as a forward the main focus had been on `work rate` and `tracking back`.

"We got more shouting practice than shooting practice," he added! I reported this meeting on ToffeeWeb at the time although I did think the observation smacked very much of sour grapes at his being released. Now I`m not quite so sure.

Tony J Williams
16 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:09:44
Imagine making your players do fitness training......how antiquated!!!!
Andrew Ellams
17 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:15:40
Some of the recent comments from current players in regards to the current pre season and Martinez's training methods subscribe to this theory as well. In particular, Osman's comments about actually training with a ball.,.. who would have thought it?
Matt Traynor
18 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:19:51
Adam #515 I wish people would stop perpetuating the myth we "started like a rocket" last season.

The first 10 games was 5 wins, 4 draws and a defeat. 19 points out of a possible 30. A commendable effort but we weren't knocking over all and sundry. Too many drawn games in the first half of last season followed by the predictable lack of reinforcements in January meant last season somewhat petered out.

Steve King
19 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:24:08
Raymond Verheijin got a reputation whilst working for Wales as a pain in the arse, arrogant, troublemaker. He caused a number of arguments between clubs and the Welsh FA for his outspoken comments and attitude towards club's management.

This isn't a defence of Moyes and his training techniques, I just think its important to understand the source of the comments.

Buy the way can we PLEASE stop talking about David Moyes and the past?? Maybe when the season starts we will finally stop discussing the Man Utd manager and get on with discussing our own team?

Paul Gladwell
20 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:34:38
Tony, training without a ball is.
Gavin Ramejkis
21 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:25:28
Surprised he didn't have them flailing themselves and plunging them in ice-cold baths and showers.
Derek Thomas
22 Posted 25/07/2013 at 09:38:42
Because Steve (#524), Moyes's 11-year legacy, while having some good points, has left every player in the Club with institutionalised KITAP1 — witness the incredulity of actually training with the ball.

This 'further revelation' of antiquated Moyesology will be affecting us NOW — and for many months, if not years, so the 'get over it ' card has little or no bearing...

Also the guy might've been a pain in the arse, arrogant and a trouble maker but he might only be a trouble maker to those who don't agree with him and subscribe to their own version of the Moyesology Method. No doubt all the Welsh coaches went through the same run-it-off type coaching.

Shane Corcoran
23 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:04:58
Is this really an Everton story? One guy thinks our former manager's training methods are suspect. I don't think TW posters need another reason to criticise Moyes. Maybe if someone at the club or formerly at the club had said it, it might be worthy but surely not this.
Patrick Murphy
24 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:02:34
The one major criticism of DM was the painfully slow starts we made to the season, might it have been down to his training regime, however, our second-half's to the season always seemed to garner more points and our fitness could have been a factor in that.

But the problem he has in his new job is that there will be many people with axes to grind against his new club, which they couldn't have done with SAF at the helm. He will have to be even more careful about what he says as every word he utters will be scrutinised by the club's enemies as well as its friends. But it is funny from Theatre of Dreams to Jurassic Park in a matter of months.

Steve King
26 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:13:26
Derek #527 – I had a boss at work, he was a stubborn git that refused to "get with the times" and update our procedures and systems. He'd been at the company for over 10 years. When he left there was no lasting legacy. A new guy came in and immediately began using new techniques and embracing change. The staff didn't complain that it wasn't what they're used to for months, they got on with it and enjoyed a refreshing change.
Can you explain why you think Moyes's training techniques "will be affecting us NOW and for many months if not years"? He's gone and the players have openly stated they are enjoying a change of direction.

Shane #528 – Spot on.

Scott Hamilton
27 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:00:54
Unlike the other Moyes thread which for some inexplicable reason has been running for days now, this is genuinely worthy of discussion.

It will be interesting to see whether replacing Moyes's "drill" approach to training with Martinez's more football-driven one will bear fruit. We obviously all hope so as we want to see quality football but we also want results. Where you have a squad that varies from barely average (Heitinga) up to world-beater (Baines; Fellaini on a good day) then it might be argued that you need to compensate for the team's deficiencies by ensuring players are at 100% fitness and run their arses off. If however you now manage a squad populated by some of the world's finest then it is highly doubtful that this approach will work.

Many felt last season that we had the opportunity to push-on and secure a top 4 place but that Moyes wasn't able to adapt in style to accomplish that. Maybe Moyes really is a one-trick pony and is only able to motivate lesser players to perform at their best but then struggles to play flair football with a more talented side. Time will tell.

Tony J Williams
28 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:30:54
It is interesting to compare the two managers then. One didn't moan that much about injuries though we lost Mirallas and Gibson for quite a while, the other ball trainer moaned and moaned about the injuries being the reason why his team was relegated.

Just throwing that out there! Is it really the training that makes that much difference to bigger injuries or just bad luck?

Derek Thomas
29 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:27:47
Steve the Training methods are only part of it... I said the players were KITAP1 institutionalised – that's years (for some) of deep deep brainwashing until it becomes second nature...

Maybe not the best example, but it may take more than a couple of weeks with the ball to stop Jags, under pressure, especially under pressure (for that's what training is about, to do things instinctively) giving it the big HOOF...

Bad habits are the easiest to get and the hardest to get rid of.

Brendan McLaughlin
30 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:45:54
Derek #535
There were a lot of people on here comparing how Jagielka's England performances contrasted with his Everton displays in terms of the lack of hoofball. I'd seriously hope that with the amount of money these guys are on they can readily adapt to whatever gameplan Roberto thinks will take us forward.
Barry Rathbone
31 Posted 25/07/2013 at 10:56:07
Get outta this one, Moyes boys.
Tom Daly
32 Posted 25/07/2013 at 11:36:57
Not much in this one. By the sounds of it, this 'Dutch fitness expert' hasn't even talked to Van Persie, never mind conducted a medical on him to ascertain the reasons behind the injury. Nor, it would seem, has he been present at the United training sessions.

Could it just be that he wants a bit of free publicity on the back of his country's best player???

PL sides these days have too much riding on the outcome of injury and fitness for it to be left to the training of the bad old days. I remember reading an article about Shankly in which it was said that he didn't make players run up hills during pre-season because there are no hills on a pitch.

I think that with all the sports science available, the pre-seasons at PL sides are more complex than most of us can imagine. Same with just about all aspects of a football club – it is a shame that articles such as this are given the time of day by TW as it again reduces debate to ill-informed guess work. Anyone using this as a stick with which to beat Moyes needs to look a little deeper methinks. Moyes clearly had preferred pre-season training methods and guess what? They worked! None of us have any insight much beyond the performances we see on the pitch and the final league table. And on that basis, his training worked pretty well!

Quick one – Sylvain Distin said this is the hardest pre-season (in terms of fitness work) he's ever endured...

Kevin Tully
33 Posted 25/07/2013 at 11:50:17
You would hope we have a head start when it comes to fitness, training, recovery times etc - Our Roberto has a degree in physiotherapy (as well as business management).

Moyes was well qualified in steely-eyed Glaswegian glaring.

23 days and counting.....

David Donnellan
34 Posted 25/07/2013 at 12:06:03
It is interesting, we did have more than our fair share of injuries under Moyesies reign, some seasons were more horrific than others in terms of injured personnel. Although, as Tony has touched upon, Martinez had many injuries himself last season. It will be interesting to see how many injuries if any we may suffer in the new season. I will say that any training methods that include using footballs throughout can only be a good thing in my opinion.
Patrick Murphy
36 Posted 25/07/2013 at 12:53:56
With reference to Bill Shankly - Is it true that when Neil Armstrong set foot on the Moon and when Hillary climbed to the summit of Mount Everest, there was this wee Scotsman there waiting for them and uttering the immortal words 'Nice to see you laddies - what took you so long?"

James McPherson
38 Posted 25/07/2013 at 12:56:13
Michael/Lyndon,I am sorry but frankly this is getting ridiculous.

Michael, you are adopting the persona of Madame Defarge - scheming behind the scenes to once again seek a "forum" to lay into the former regime. Staing 'OMG I am not saying a word' - well you have - you have gone out of your way to put a 3rd party article onto the site, knowing full well the outcome - duly delivered by people with almost vitriolic hatred of Moyes.

I wanted Moyes to depart. The semi final to me was his end point. I was dismayed with his conduct towards the end of his reign and his clumsy utterings in this pre-season.

Under Moyes, as a paying season ticket holder, I saw excellent, average and downright appalling. As a club, you cannot deny that our credibility improved under him. However, as EFC fans this was not enough to show for 11 years and yes time to part.

But where are we now? He's gone, but we have a daily feed to stoke up the mob (in every sense of the word). The article in the Telegraph is sourced from a reknoned trouble-maker. Additionally, where is your evidence of the RVP injury that substantiates what he alleges? Sadly lacking - but hey, who needs facts when there is opiniated prejudice at play?

I come on here to talk about EFC - the future, the season ahead, our players, our outlook - dare I say - our pre-season training regime. If you were Martinez reading this iste, you could almost be forgiven for thinking that you are in situ and the fans are with you purely because of you not being Moyes - nothing to do with your own potential attributes.

I wanted Moyes to go. But I have no desire to turn this is into triumphalist bigotry. Aren't we supposed to have class?

Dave Lynch
39 Posted 25/07/2013 at 13:20:31
He's grooming him for left back. Don't want this Johnny come lately Dutchman scoring goals, he may get above his station and think he can play in the other teams half.
Lee Mandaracas
40 Posted 25/07/2013 at 13:41:57
As much as I sympathise with the view we are 'over-Moyesed' on here and pretty much everywhere (wtf is it with Everton's official twitter feed having purely Man Utd stories on as recently as yesterday? Sort that shit out right now!) I have to say I believe this story to be pertinent to our current squad.

The story was printed in a national newspaper and, therefore, has not been skewed to make a point but quoted for us to draw our own conclusions if we are interested and I, for one, am.

I believe Adam (515) has a very fair point and Matt (523) is, in my opinion, mistaken to say we didn't do that well as he omitted to account for the plethora of proven points lost in the first half of last season due to shambolic officiating. Some say they balance out but firstly they don't and secondly they certainly didn't in the first half of that season. As such, Adam is spot on in saying the way we came out of the blocks last year.

For anyone saying we need to stop talking about Moyes, does that mean we should also have a moratorium on Kendall, Harvey, Royle, Catterick, et al too? Someone in this feed even had the audacity to mention Mike Walker!

In summary, balance is needed. Moyes is still very pertinent to our present squad and club but to nothing like the degree the media and many websites would have us believe so his every move is no longer our concern but ones that reflect on us and how we are acting at this moment very much do, such as training routine differences year-on-year for example.

Tom Daly
42 Posted 25/07/2013 at 13:55:33
Spot on James - we'd do well to remember the good times under Moyes and put the rest to bed. A shame to see just how short some memories and how unrealistic some expectations are.

As it is, I have a sneaking feeling Moyes is going to be a huge success at Man Utd.

Paul Andrews
43 Posted 25/07/2013 at 14:00:43
9/4 for the league Tom.

Get in there, you are buying money.

Tony J Williams
44 Posted 25/07/2013 at 14:05:50
Just had a look at Wigan's injury list and came across this in December 2012 "There have certainly been extenuating circumstances, most notably their lengthy injury list – Wigan could be without eight players, including four central defenders, for Saturday's clash with Arsena"

Bloody stupid ball training has done for 8 of his players......... (tongue in cheek).

Another long thread about a pointless comment not even about Everton.

Steven Telford
46 Posted 25/07/2013 at 14:12:17
Firstly, Raymond Verheijin is arrogant bastard - a glorified gym teacher with a big mouth.
Secondly, look at RVPs fitness record - it's hardly shining, and guess what (SHOCK) his injury record was before Moyes even got there. Huge problems Took places under Wenger. But does Raymond Van big mouth make any criticism of Wenger. No - because he kisses the ass of more established manages, whilst joyously taking shots at smaller fish. Would you have said that is a fair definition of asshole?

RVP had a niggle in a pre-season friendly, and was taken off at half-time. and some people feel the need to extract criticism of Moyes for that....... well, grasping at straws.

It may not be an Everton story, but the TW editorial team are perhaps not unjustified in posting it – as people clearly still have an interest. However, if they are to be non-partisan (which I don't think they are) they are surely equally obliged to post positive stories about Moyes if and when they emerge. I wonder if we will see consistency. Either let go of the Moyes stories, or publish all. Make a decision guys.

Chris Keightley
52 Posted 25/07/2013 at 14:47:59
Keith Harrison I too remember Aspatria of Cumbria having been on the receiving end of a bashing by there forwards in the early 90's whilst playing for a more fashionable club, they were fit lads, back on topic though Moyes seems to have turned into Ian Holloway over night, sensationalist comments almost daily – if we are to believe the press!!
Gerry Quinn
53 Posted 25/07/2013 at 14:55:15
Why am I not surprised that the media/sporting snipers have arrived from all sides with the new boy in hot seat? After all, Man Utd's Manager for the last 20 odd years has been untouchable and totally feared by media, pundits or whoever. Time to make up for lost opportunities.
Paul Ferry
57 Posted 25/07/2013 at 15:30:28
I simply do not understand why some people (528), for instance, and (562) feel that there is something wrong about this thread and recent others where the cue is a review of the last few years EVERTON - our club - on an EVERTON site. How dare us. We must do penance.

The past is no more; it is forbidden 'officially' by Mr.James McPhereson (562):

I come on here to talk about EFC - the future, the season ahead, our players, our outlook - dare I say - our pre-season training regime.

The past is past. It is, indeed, a foreign country and we must not go there.

100 per cent buffoonery. We have no entitlement on July 25 2013 to talk about say the culture of our club since say July 2011? We have no right to discuss late-Moyes even though that story is an essential element in explaining where we are and what we have become and what we must do on July 25 2013.

And to hammer the nail into the past's coffin we get twaddle like this, the ultimate lazy poverty-stricken fall-back position. McPhereson again:

But where are we now? He's gone, but we have a daily feed to stoke up the mob (in every sense of the word).

Ah, that label once more. If we knock Moyes we are MOB in his time with us and in his time after us. If we must talk about Moyes boys be nice, be fair-mannered, and don't say rude words.

(1) How on earth is it irrelevant on this day to discuss ANY aspect of say the last two years to examine the position(s) we are in today?

(2) People on here have an absolute right to knock or praise Moyes, not least on a matter like this (and Mr. McPhereson, there is more to it than someone you label 'a reknoned [sic] trouble-maker') where for a long while now people on these boards have wondered about training methods and the fate and fortunes of our front-men: 'work-rate' and 'tracking back' - Richard Dodd (520).

(3) Knocking Moyes is not MOB although it seems to be in certain minds.

(4) We must continue to discuss the late-Moyes years as we continue to move forwards. Well done Madame Defarge and LL for keeping those discussions going

Tony J Williams
58 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:09:33
Knocking Moyes for comments made to ingratiate himself into the Manc fans and a comment from a fella, who it seems hasn't even examined Van Persie, for, God Forbid, giving him extra training is a bit MOBish.

A crap quote and a disgruntled Dutch fella who doesn't know anything, like us, about Van Persie's actually training regime and we have two huge threads with the usual suspects giving it all, "I told you he was shite" routine, as if these meaningless things somehow substantiate their continuing battle against anything Moyes.

He has gone, we have a new manager and a new training routine, hopefully more points will come and let's see if we have less/more/the same amount of injuries following this new routine. If Wigan's injury list is anything to go by, it isn't much better than ours.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
60 Posted 25/07/2013 at 15:57:02
James McPherson and others.

This story was submitted by Kieran Kinsella in what was then converted to the first post on the thread. As a number of posters have observed, it does have a bearing on the Moyes era at Everton, and therefore merits discussion by those with interest in the topic.

Clearly Moyes lovers will have trouble with this kind of story; I understand that. But take it up with Telegraph if you don't like it. As with the previous one, your calls for censorship and suppression of reasonable topics for discussion are not likely to be heeded in the circumstances.

Remember, you don't have to click on the headline, you don't have to read the story, and your certainly don't have to post your opinion if you don't want others to be talking about it. Just step away from the keyboard. Or, if you have comments on our editorial policy, submit them to us through the feedback page. Such posts on threads will be removed.

And if you are serious about wanting to see 'nice' stories about OFM for the sake of 'balance', you're welcome to submit them for consideration.

James McPherson
62 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:22:55
Michael, thanks for the repsonse. I am no Moyes lover. I thought it was time for him to move on. The only thing I seek is balance. Just solely reporting the bad to then migrate back to EFC to reflect on the Moyes era is fair if that is matched with the good. Somehow, I don't think there would be much appetite to talk about that.

Paul Ferry
63 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:23:26
James, I think we can talk about Moyes so long as it has a bearing on things Everton. And please, in your label-minded way, do not paint me as this or that, pro- or anti-Moyes or indifferent. Guess what, there are people who are more flexible than this depending on contexts and circumstances.

Now, rather than an off-the-cuff piece of Moyes-Manure, perhaps you might respond to the substance of my post: in a nutshell, it is essential to discuss the recent past to explain where we are now and what we must do?

Substance please, not tittle-tattle.

Barry Rathbone
64 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:10:28
Paul, it's called "shooting the messenger".

Digging at the TW editorial team for providing a forum that finally offers independent 3rd party and "horses mouth" evidence re Moyes influence thus shedding light on the PRESENT issues Martinez must deal is cowardly.

Though the reasons why are clear enough.

The opinion that the mindset was negative that pre-season prep was archaic are being confirmed and certain fans are in turmoil about the exposure. On a daily basis a check list of what some of us have been saying for a long time and been attacked for are being ticked off.

Fair play to those saying it's an eye opener - no problem at all with that - but calls for suppression of debate because they don't like what is coming on the air waves is poor.

What did one balanced poster resort to?

"Raymond Verheijin is arrogant bastard - a glorified gym teacher with a big mouth."

Marvelous.

Tony J Williams
65 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:35:52
Paul, of course it is essential to revert to the immediate (or not so immediate past sometimes); however a slight muscle injury is in no way substantive evidence of a shite training regime.

iIt's a nothing story about someone in a different country knocking a manager for a quote he made in a different country to where the injury occurred... in a game.

Also lets look at the subject too, not exactly a paragon of robustness, is he? As I said, a nothing story but apparently another one to suggest Moyes was shite etc.

Barry Rathbone
68 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:56:24
Steven - negativity is in the eye of the beholder - how do you judge?
Tony J Williams
69 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:52:17
"The opinion that the ............... pre-season prep was archaic are being confirmed "

No they haven't, one comment from one fella who hasn't a bobby on what the training regime does not confirm anything.

I'm all for having a go at Moyes if he starts being twatty (probably comes with being manager of the mancs), but this isn't proof that our pre-season training was crap.

Phil Bellis
72 Posted 25/07/2013 at 17:02:15
Michael (Ed)
Tried not to shout be putting less than greater than brackets around the word "not" in the last sentence - instead, the not in "not to win" has disappeared; apologies
Barry Rathbone
73 Posted 25/07/2013 at 17:02:45
TJW,

"No they haven't, one comment from one fella who hasn't a bobby on what the training regime does not confirm anything."

If he knows and talks to RVP there's more than a reasonable chance he does - else why is he posting?

Head in sand here lad.

Michael Kenrick
74 Posted 25/07/2013 at 17:06:15
Phil (And anyone else) — don't use angled brackets.... they are used in HTML to indicate formatting/structure code on web pages. Anything between them will not appear, but will be interpreted as an HTML instruction.

But more importantly, let's not go off-topic, please!
Paul Ferry
75 Posted 25/07/2013 at 17:05:55
Fair TJW (618) but I was speaking in more general terms about the silliness of precluding talk about the last year or so rather than this particular focus. In fact, I don't even mention RVP and this Dutch fella in my post.
James McPherson
76 Posted 25/07/2013 at 16:58:43
Barry Rathbone/ Paul Ferry - can I just say (again!) that in my eyes Moyes had to go - I am no Moyes lover - as a season ticket holder for all of the 11 years of his tenure - I saw excellent, average and appalling.

I am glad Moyes has moved on and now await to see what Martinez will do. He's clearly different - will have his own ideas and what we see we will then judge. Twas ever thus.

"Horses mouth" evidence Barry??? Really? How do you know that?

Rio Ferdinand ( a present player) stated two or so weeks back (BBC Football website) that working with Moyes was going really well and he was excited by the new challenge.

Barry/Paul is this opinion worth regarding?

My view is I am not really interested in anything other than Martinez and EFC - but if you are going to look at the indifferent surely it is fair to look at the positives.

Or is it the case that your loathing of the man, yes the man, is such that his departure is not enough - you want to just keep kicking.

Again, I say this as a person who wanted him to go

Wayne Smyth
80 Posted 25/07/2013 at 17:37:03
Look, it's really simple.

You don't like posts discussing Moyes and his time at Everton? Dont fucking read them.

The constant stream of soundbites and other information coming from current Everton players, past Everton players, Man Utd players who've suddenly been switched from trophy-winning coaching methods to Moyes's coaching methods and people such as this Dutch coach go to add weight to lots of concerns that many Everton fans had about him during his time with us.

While he was here, our players kept their traps shut for good reason. Now he's gone, details are sneaking out. This next 12 months is a really good bloody opportunity for us to get an insight into what kind of coach we had on our hands for the last decade and whether many of our problems were self-inflicted.

As a fan of Everton Football Club, I bloody well want to know that information in order to better assess any future manager we may get.

If people find discussions of Moyes based on new information uncomfortable because it affects how they want to remember him, please just stop reading these threads.

Paul Ferry
82 Posted 25/07/2013 at 18:57:05
Crumbs.

James (640):

'Rio Ferdinand (a present player) stated two or so weeks back (BBC Football website) that working with Moyes was going really well and he was excited by the new challenge'.

Well of course he did, what else do you expect him to say FFS!!!!!

A by now veteran player who wants to cling to his place.

Er: it's going real shite with this Moyes fella, and I am not in any way excited by this new challenge.

To be taken at face value?

Nope.

James: 'My view is I am not really interested in anything other than Martinez and EFC'.

Well, that is your view and good for you damn it, but I suspect that you are in the tiniest of tiny minorities.

James: Or is it the case that your loathing of the man, yes the man, is such that his departure is not enough - you want to just keep kicking.

How on earth in anything that I have said in this thread can you characterize me as loathing Moyes, 'the man', or claim that I 'keep kicking'?

So, here's a little question and challenge for you James: produce evidence that I loath Moyes. Go on, find it, produce it, post it. Go on.

If, as I suspect, you will not directly respond to this request for evidence that I loath Moyes, keep your mouth shut/finger off button in future, and stop trotting out false characterizations of people you misrepresent.

Okay.

Ross Edwards
84 Posted 25/07/2013 at 19:13:10
Moyes the tactically inept, dour dinosaur? I like it. Might use that more often from now on.

Of course, his lack of success is down to his totally defeatist, bottling nature, as well as his use of dinosaur tactics. 1 up front and hoofball, something that has been knocking about since the grim days of Taylor and Wikinson.

The Man Utd egos won't appreciate Moyes's (ahem!) style, (if that's the right word!) of football.

Wayne Smyth
89 Posted 25/07/2013 at 19:45:09
James (640), I think the opinion of players making positive statements about their current manager is neither here nor there. It's an entirely expected, self-serving and rational thing for them to do given that one of the quickest and easiest routes to the bench is to step out of line.

Personally, I find it far more interesting to listen to negative comments, or factual bits of information. For example, I don't give a toss if an Everton player says he loves working with Martinez, but ossie's assertion about how they're doing loads of running with the ball and how that is a "refreshing change" is an eye-opener on the difference in methodologies between the two managers.

Man Utd are far less likely to tolerate poor, outdated practice having been fortunate to have one of the world's greatest managers managing them for 26 years and turning them into one of the biggest, best run clubs in the world, so its really enlightening to watch how they perceive our former "Messiah" and his methods.

Steavey Buckley
90 Posted 25/07/2013 at 20:28:35
Roberto Martinez will be sending out his new Everton team on one one of the best playing surfaces in the world at Goodison park, so there will be less possibility of injuries that Wigan fc Athletic players experienced by playing on a surface that was shared with Wigan Warriors. And rugby league teams do cause undulating playing surfaces by the very nature of the game.
Jim Knightley
91 Posted 25/07/2013 at 20:46:28
No idea how this relates to us...in theory every single comment about Moyes make have some kind of tenuous relation to our club? He is not in control of our pre-season preparations now is he?

Players frequently get injured during pre-season...but I think everyone forgets that between pre-seasons. RVP, De Bruyne, Kosc, Lampard of those I can remember off the top of my head have picked up minor injuries during this last week or so. I'm sure one of our players will as well soon. There needs to be quite an intense schedule to get players up to speed before the season starts... and naturally, with players having had 4-7 weeks off, this causes issues.

Ross...one up front..really? do you watch much football? last time I checked, most of the top clubs in the world have been playing one through the middle, and employing variations of a 4-2-3-1/433 formation not dissimilar to ours last season. I will hate it if we stick two up front next season personally, as I think it's an outdated tactic.

Ross Edwards
92 Posted 25/07/2013 at 21:02:07
I said Moyes plays 1 up front Jim. Before accusing me of now knowing anything about football, try reading the post first.
Mat Fearon
93 Posted 25/07/2013 at 21:27:02
According to the BBC RVP will be playing this Friday. Fuck me, this really is a "big news" story. Amazes me that the Moyes haters will grasp onto anything.
Mark Stone
94 Posted 25/07/2013 at 21:15:26
The term 'overtraining' is used incorrectly here by Moyes. The term 'overtraining' refers to a training regime that results in a persistent performance decrement which takes months to recover from and can seriously damage a sportsperson's health. No coach would purposely 'overtrain' an athlete.

What Moyes is more than likely referring to is functional overreaching, which is a training regime which results in a very short term decrement in performance following a greater than normal training stress. Full recovery is made within a few days. Functional overreaching is a normal part of most athlete's training regimes.

In reality, what has happened here is that Moyes has noticed that Van Persie's endurance is below what is should be (perhaps as a comparison to last year's results) and has focused on that factor over the last couple of weeks. That is perfectly normal.

Phil Sammon
95 Posted 25/07/2013 at 21:47:24
It sounds very much, Mark, like you have been on a McDonalds sponsored football coaching course.

'Overtrained' may just mean he's over-exerted him in training. Hard to believe, I know.

Mark Stone
96 Posted 25/07/2013 at 22:02:19
Phil, I've a PhD in Exercise Physiology, and work as a university lecturer and as a consultant to several professional football teams. I'm also an accredited strength coach and I have 9 peer reviewed publications you can find in pubmed. Thanks for your input though.
Kieran Kinsella
97 Posted 26/07/2013 at 03:02:52
As Michael Kenrick pointed, I was the one who started this debate by submitting a letter to the Mail bag. So don't blame him and Lyndon for being Moyes bashers. Personally, I think it is perfectly legitimate to compare/contrast training methods used by Moyes and Martinez. Yes Moyes has gone. However, as of yet we haven't played a competitive match under Martinez so we can't just pretend the last 11 years didn't happen. Martinez is working with a squad that was built and trained by Moyes. For the next few years at least, Moyes's management will still have an effect on us because of the legacy he left in terms of the squad Martinez inherited.

I am interested to see if his methods work better than those seemingly employed by Moyes and similarly minded managers. The people who want to complain about "Moyes bashing" are just like jilted lovers who haven't yet come to terms with the fact that they've been dumped. Any real or perceived criticism of Moyes is unbearable to them because they are still licking their wounds. In contrast, I am a practical person and am simply concerned with Everton and the good and bad influences on the squad.
Kieran Kinsella
98 Posted 26/07/2013 at 03:19:48
...and as for "moving on" the last time I checked this was a forum for Evertonians and not a site run by the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia. You can't wind back the clock and start from year zero now that we've got a new boss. As Evertonians we can say what we like about any and all of the people who have played a role in the history of this great club. For crying out loud, how many threads have we had psycho-analyzing the Scottish Rooney long after he left the club? Some of the best threads on here are about the past and frankly that is in part because we haven't had much to cheer about for the last 20 years -- Moyes era included.
David Ellis
99 Posted 26/07/2013 at 03:12:53
It's a myth that we had more than our fair share of injuries under Moyes. We didn't. Sure we had injuries, sometimes quite a few (Yakubu, Arteta and Jags in 2008-09 being a low point), but if you look at the injury league tables we were not consistently high or low and nothing out of the ordinary.

As others have pointed out, Wigan had a lot of injuries last year.

Walter Smith was a dinosaur (hear the testimonies of Ball (and Parkinson in relation to Joe Royle)) about pain killing injections and over-playing that pretty much ruined his career. Moyes tended to keep his players out for longer periods, but that would be non-Dinosaur behaviour to allow them time to properly recover rather than rushing them back.

Elsewhere in the press Moyes was praised for his scientific approach to signing and using players (with his stat division a la Moneyball). It's too simple to label him a Glaswegian dinosaur (and what was Fergie then?).

As lawyers would say, this whole discussion is more prejudicial than probative – it helps support people's pro or anti-Moyes prejudices but actually has very little fact behind it (we do not know the extent of the injury or reasons behind it).

Kieran Kinsella
100 Posted 26/07/2013 at 03:50:43
I'm not as concerned about injuries, I am more concerned about training that focuses on fitness, running etc rather than technique, ball skills, set plays etc.

I remember hearing about training in the School of Science and it largely involved players having balls thrown at them from every conceivable angle until they were adept at controlling it and passing it accurately to another player. Clearly, Joe Parkinson, Tony Hibbert, David Unsworth and Victor Anichebe have never attended a session like that. Oddly enough, we were highly successful during the School of Science era.

Since then, we've had moments (eg, 1995) when we've done well with the try really hard, run around, rough up your opponents and hoof it approach but it is not a recipe for long term success.

The idea that it is all about money is a fallacy too. Ajax produced great teams on shoe string budgets because they used the proper technique based training through all age groups. Barcelona do the same now, and granted – they spend money but they also produce homegrown players. Pound for pound, the Portuguese clubs punch above their weight with a similar approach.

I feel that we might do better with a more technique based training regime for all ages – including the first team. As far as I can tell from player comments, club officials' comments, the evidence I have seen with my own eyes, and comments from "Moyes' detractors" the club didn't place an emphasis on technique in training while Moyes was at the club.

Paul Andrews
101 Posted 26/07/2013 at 07:15:22
Phil 752,

Would you like large fries with that?

Mike Green
102 Posted 26/07/2013 at 07:33:04
Touché Dr Stone #757 - and I also stand corrected :). Hope you're well.
Ray Roche
103 Posted 26/07/2013 at 07:23:40
Kieran Kinsella @ 811

It's also worth remembering that the School Of Science and even our great 1980's sides training regime included snooker sessions in the afternoons and plenty of boozing. You only need to ask Snodin about the drinking in the Kendall mk1 era to appreciate just what Jurassic Park training really was. And if you ever get the chance, ask Snods about his "medical"!>
But we played great football and even won things.

Timothy Sebastian
104 Posted 26/07/2013 at 10:07:14
Adam, the fact that we started well last season had nothing to do with less pre season training. Check out the Phil Neville interview on YouTube just after the opening game of the season against Man Utd (titled Neville interviews Neville). Pip said in that interview that Moyes started pre season training earlier that year than any other club and that the training had been tough. Neville attributed Everton's victory over Utd to this hard training. Unfortunately he spoke too soon because as Matt Trayor pointed out, we didn't really start the season all that well last year.
David Ellis
105 Posted 26/07/2013 at 10:21:12
Kieran Kinsella
Your examples of exceptions to the "its all about money" rule are good ones. But the reality is that success in the Premier League is very closely correlated with the wage bill - and this is no accident. And the higher up the league you go the better the correlation beocmes and the bigger the gulf becomes (I saw one stat that had the wage of an average Everton first team player being half that of an average Liverpool one for example).

Everton have outperformed on this measure for years (in terms of league position as opposed to style).

I truely hope that Martinez can outperform both in terms of style and league position.

Mark Stone
106 Posted 26/07/2013 at 10:32:14
Hi Mike #822 hope you're well? Funnily enough I've been working with the chairboys a bit over the last few weeks and those lads are looking in great shape for next Sat. Hopefully they'll surprise a few this season. Probably fitter, quicker and sharper than many prem teams!
Mark Stone
107 Posted 26/07/2013 at 11:09:27
By the way, Philip Sammon 'Overtrained' may just mean he's over-exerted him in training. Hard to believe, I know.'

What is your point? Purposely over exerting him in training is ... functional overreaching! It's a part of every athletes training regime. Do a google search of the general adaptation syndrome and educate yourself about the basics of training. Only becomes a problem when it becomes non functional or 'overtraining'. That wont happen if the correct monitoring and and recovery strategies are in place. Incidentally, non-functional overreaching or overtraining is more likely to result from high intensity (eg small sides games/plyometrics/SAQ type work) than high volume (endless running/cycling) training. That's why it's important to give players a good base of volume before doing increasingly more high intensity work and reduced volume as the season approaches.

Tony J Williams
108 Posted 26/07/2013 at 11:10:49
Anyone who believes that league doesn't have anything to do with money, is frankly deluded.

In every single professional league in the world the teams with the most money fight it out for the title (a massive assumption I know, as I don't follow other countries leagues, but I doubt it is a huge leap of faith to suggest it)

Tony J Williams
109 Posted 26/07/2013 at 11:29:14
I see Van Persie is playing and should have had three already.... A bet the Dutch fella feels a bit of a tit now.
Robbie Shields
110 Posted 26/07/2013 at 11:17:35
David #839, didn't we finish above Liverpool last season...... And the season before that for that matter..... Your point being??????
Jim Knightley
111 Posted 26/07/2013 at 11:42:32
Kieran...Barca have spent an awful lot of money...as have Bayern, and Real. In this league, which team is successful now without spending alot of money? Arsenal are the one top club, aside from us, who have not invested heavily in their team...yet they have had a massive wage bill for sometime, and fallen from the best team in the league to finishing 4th, or 3rd, every season. Some leagues are less about money than others...but we play in the Premier League.

I 100% back Tony on this...And honestly, I don't think it's even a subjective judgement. Money buys the best players...the best players win leagues and cups. There are transition issues sometimes...but as City and Chelsea have proved, if you have enough money, u can overcome numerous bad buys/player issues.

And with respect to the editorial decision to run this story... ToffeeWeb is fantastic, but some comments re.Moyes a week or so ago, suggested an editorial reticence to publish articles related to Moyes, because Moyes was no longer Everton. Accordingly, it's hardly surprising that a few of us questioned the decision to run an article which, tbh, is absolute bullocks, and has not real reference to Everton, who, as has been pointed out, did not really suffer that badly from injuries...despite having one of the consistently smallest squads in the division. Personally, I'm fine with stuff being published which has a tenuous relationship with Everton via a Moyes link if it is not speculative rubbish, but that does not mean that some won't question it its publication. After all, a healthy dialogue between the editors and the contributors is a great part of this forum...and I suppose separates us from larger less specialised forums for debates which exist elsewhere.

Robbie Shields
112 Posted 26/07/2013 at 11:55:05
Guys, anyone heard of "Lessons Learnt"?????

I am led to believe that Karl Marx said "History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce."

Let's not repeat the last 11 years as a farce shaw we????

Andy Boyer
113 Posted 26/07/2013 at 12:54:41
At the risk of being laughed off the site, could someone please enlighten me as to what KITAP1 actually means.....?

Go easy boys......

Patrick Murphy
114 Posted 26/07/2013 at 12:55:56
Keep It Tight And Pinch One. Andy
Although for a long time I thought it meant Keep Irritating The Audience Part 1
Gerry Quinn
115 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:00:10
Andy, I'll take a 50% share of your flak - consider me your team-mate in the embarrassment stakes. I work in the Oil Business here in Houston and it is one of my pet-hates attempting to wade through the continuous bombardment of acronyms, synonyms, abbreviations used 24 bloody 7.

Know what I mean?

COYB

IMWT

TTFN

Gerry Quinn
116 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:04:51
So, with Roberto it will be KIS ASS - Keep it slack and score a second?
Tony J Williams
117 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:04:36
I see Man U have another draw....Hmmmmm!
Andy Boyer
118 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:05:58
Patrick, thanks for the mate, it was reall doing my head in.

Gerry, thanks for backing me up there mate, I had a headache trying to figure out what each letter meant....

And yes, I do know what you mean about acronyms etc, my personal most hated one is ROFLMAO and I only know what that means cos of my kids, it's something I wish I could unlearn :(

Jackie Barry
119 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:04:38
While money may win you the league, there is still a wrong and a right way to go about it.. Sure you can spend, spend, spend and eventually you will get the right combination that works, however that doesn't speak to me of a good manager it just say's they spent their way to the title. Alex Ferguson built up Man U to where they are now, there is no doubt about it, a good crop of young players came through and he has built on it from there, with money yes but money that has been far more carefully spent than Man City or Chelsea. He brought something else to that team as well, something that if Moyes isn't careful he will lose and it could set them back for years to come.
Patrick Murphy
120 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:08:23
S.M.A.R.T. - Score More Against Rival Teams - Roberto Smartinez
Kieran Kinsella
121 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:15:06
Exactly Jackie Barry. Wenger and Ferguson both built a foundation on skilled young players and then spent money to take them from 3/4th up to 1st. Guy Roux worked wonders for years in France at a time when Monaco and Marseille were spending like crazy both on players (Klinsmann, Waddle, Papin etc) and on bribing referees and opposing defenders. Despite that, Auxerre were there or thereabouts every year. It can be done.
Kevin Tully
124 Posted 26/07/2013 at 13:37:55
Someone will strike gold without going out and spending £100m on players to win the title (City have spent as much this summer alone!)

The crop of youngsters to come out of Utd's academy in one generation was incredible. Beckham, Giggs, Scholes, Butt, Sharpe, the Nevilles and a few others.

Look at the players Liverpool got for nothing - Gerrard, Carragher, Fowler, Rush, Owen, McManaman - all these players who were WORLD CLASS at some point, and local FFS!!

Man U started their new era of dominance with kids from their youth set up, and built their club into the best supported team in the world. This was only 20 odd years ago, so to say it's impossible is ridiculous.

If we could find a golden generation, add some bargains like Arteta, Baines, Jagielka and had a Board with ambition (like shitty Swansea) we could challenge the money clubs one day.

Unfortunately,any stars we unearth (like Rooney) will be flogged so Bill can keep his big chair, sobbing away quietly in the corner of the Boardroom.

Gary Reeves
125 Posted 26/07/2013 at 14:05:47
To be fair Kevin, re; Rooney - I'm sure the club would have prefered the player rather than the money. I don't think there was any Champagne being popped,the night he left. You can't blame BK for that episode.
Kevin Tully
126 Posted 26/07/2013 at 14:15:51
Do you think Spurs, Utd, Liverpool or Arsenal would have let the best 18yr old in the world leave Gary?

ALL roads lead to the Boardroom I'm afraid Gary, and the requirement to pay back loans, mortgages and 'Friends of the club.'

Gary Reeves
127 Posted 26/07/2013 at 14:45:19
No sorry Kevin,that's just not fair. If you read the biography (though I wouldn't recommend it - it's shite) you get apicture of a petulant teenager,being guided by greedy hangers-on. Everton were planted firmlyl behind the black,on that one. You're placing blame in the wrong people there.
Andy Boyer
128 Posted 26/07/2013 at 14:45:31
Kevin,

Have you forgotten the events that led to Rooney being sold.....?

His agent is/was on eof the most corrupt and vile individuals ever to (dis)grace the sport and his agency held a stake in Newcastle FC, if you remember there had been no bids whatsoever for Rooney (who has asked to leave, no doubt his ear was filled with the poison dripped by Stretford) then suddenly one came in from who.......? Newcastle - a coincidence I don't think - swiftly followed by United and off he went.

The club was screwed over massively by Stretford and to some extent Rooney although I honestly don;t believe that at the time he was clever enough to have worked it our for himself, also I heard his parents had a hand in it too.

No doubt the lack of investment and the financial position of the club didn't help but to blame the board wholesale for it is, in my opinion, not on.

I know I will take some flak for this but tough, it's how I see it.

Gary Reeves
132 Posted 26/07/2013 at 14:54:04
Just read that back,and it's pretty badly written but hope you get the point.
Kevin Tully
133 Posted 26/07/2013 at 14:55:06
Gary/Andy,

"Do you think Spurs, Utd, Liverpool or Arsenal would have let the best 18yr old in the world leave?"

Answer the question above, then ask yourselves why he wasn't tied into a long contract before he went to the Euro's?

When he cam back from those Championships, he was the hottest property in world football. I can categorically state that a proper Chairman/Board would have had that lad tied into a massive contract, before any shit with Man U even occurred.

Andy Boyer
134 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:01:45
Kevin, you may have a point there but let's be honest here we have a kid who's running round the pitch wearing a t shirt under his top saying "once a blue always a blue"......

The club trusted Rooney and his representatives and they got knifed in the back, with hindsight was it naive and short sighted...yes undoubtedly but the blame is squarely at the feet of Rooney, Stretford and also I believe Moyes who I think Rooney just didn't like.

It's no co-incidence that Rooney has asked to leave now Moyes is in charge.

Andy Boyer
135 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:08:36
My point being that the majority of the blame lies with Rooney and his representatives, the club has to take some grief for naivete but I know in my own life there are people I thought I could trust and I learned that I couldn't the hard way.
Gary Reeves
136 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:07:29
Kevin, unhappy/unsettled players are no use to Spurs, Man Utd, Liverpool or anyone else for that matter. Rooney shit on Everton. Top and bottom.
Gary Reeves
137 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:11:10
Having said that, would I have a more mature, experienced, financially secure, honest-to-goodness Evertonian back at the Club?

You betcha!

Paul Andrews
138 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:22:56
Gary Reeves,

So the club were dragging him back as he tried to leave then?
They did everything possible to keep him?

Kevin Tully
139 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:23:06
Fair enough lads, Rooney & his 'orrible representatives have to take some of the blame.

But my point is we have never had a truly professional approach to this 'business.'

Gosling, Manny Fernandes, the Leroy Fer debacle, Badgegate, Moyes walking away without any compensation all tell a story about the way the club is run - ten years after Rooney left!

This is all without the commercial side, and Bill dreaming of a new stadium in the sky. Without Sky we would have gone under many years ago.

What other Chairman do you see in tears FFS! ( Or on Corrie!!!)

Tony J Williams
140 Posted 26/07/2013 at 15:46:11
Kevin, many, many things can be laid at the door of Kenwright, but once Stretford got his orrible fingers in the Rooney pie, Rooney was gone.

When to scumbags, sorry, agents get the most money? When they client's get sold or sign a new bumper contract. The liar (proven in a court of law) was no doubt whispering sweet nothings in a naive 18 years olds ear and that was that.

Mike Green
141 Posted 26/07/2013 at 16:04:31
Mark #849 - I'll keep my eye out, might take my boy down this year, if you fancy a pint and a match one night give me a nudge :). Have a nice weekend.
Kevin Tully
142 Posted 26/07/2013 at 16:18:41
At our club Tony, it was clearly easy for Rooney & Stretford to run rings around the Board.

I still maintain it wouldn't have happened if he was at Liverpool, Spurs, or Arsenal. Nothing to do with money, just look at Fowler & Owen.

When Owen came back from a World Cup at a similar age, there was no question of him leaving, and I bet Liverpool would have had the likes of Stretford banned from the ground. We were caught cold, and had no choice but to sell, regardless of who instigated the move. That is down to trusting the player and his agent to do the right thing. My point here is, other clubs don't leave these things to chance.

It's not as if we didn't know what a talent we had.

Wayne Smyth
143 Posted 26/07/2013 at 17:57:08
Looks like van persie's missed a couple of sitters today.

Could be pre-season rustiness, or.....I wonder if he was running the wings, or knackered from being "overtrained".

Mark Stone
144 Posted 26/07/2013 at 23:37:06
Mike #936 let me know if you want to take your lad mate, and I'll get a couple of tickets put aside on the door for you mate, seriously. You still still got my phone/twitter?
Mike Green
145 Posted 26/07/2013 at 23:44:44
Got your phone, can't even remember how to do twitter :D I'll take you up on that - take it easy :)
Robin Cannon
146 Posted 27/07/2013 at 00:02:08
"Personally, I think it is perfectly legitimate to compare/contrast training methods used by Moyes and Martinez."

Which is essentially comparing/contrasting one set of training methods for which we know no real details about with another set of training methods for which we know no real details about. Brilliant.

Mark Stone
147 Posted 27/07/2013 at 00:01:03
Hi Mike, just text you! Will defo sort you out, happy days!
James Carlisle
148 Posted 27/07/2013 at 21:21:50
No wonder our players were always injured! At least now United's players can have their careers ruined by that dodgy coaching staff.
Joe McMahon
149 Posted 28/07/2013 at 20:17:01
Ha Ha.....In Moyes We Trust.

I'm not convinced Roberto can have us finish any higher in the league (the money gap gets bigger every year) but we may just win a cup competition, and it will be nice to see football with a smile on it's face at Goodison again!

Pablo Connelly
150 Posted 28/07/2013 at 22:57:49
I haven't read the comments above but can someone explain to me what this story has to do with Everton? I am grateful to Moyes for everything he done but I couldn't care less whether his methods work at Man U. Can't we just look forward to a new era and a potentially exciting season without over analysing the past?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb