Transfer Deconstruction: James McCarthy
James McCarthy is supposedly the next name on Roberto Martinez's close season shopping list with the Spaniard reportedly willing to ‘swoop’ down on the DW with an offer of £15m. So is the Irishman any good then? Is he massively overpriced? How will he fit in should the deal materialise?
» Read the full article at The Executioner's Bong
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Posted
31/07/2013 at
15:29:41
Insightful article. I have a hard time justifying that much money for a defensive mid. I think we need a strong No. 10 and I'm not sure Barkley is quite ready to fill that role yet, though I'm willing to give him a chance. If Fellaini goes for around 20, I'd like to see two midfielders take his place, one to drop back and one to playmake up front. The YouTube video made him look quite good though, reminded me of Arteta a bit at times. Can't help but think there's a lot of less expensive options, though if we get 3 good seasons out of him and move him on for 25, it'd certainly be worthwhile.
Posted
31/07/2013 at
15:53:29
From what I've seen of him (which is very little) he looks like someone who mops things up a bit, gets himself in a position to help out his team mates by collecting the ball sometimes in enclosed areas and distributing simply and on the ground with short tidy passes.
I don't know whether he's worth £15M as I'm also not sure Fellaini is worth £25M but I think he is important to how Martinez wants his teams to play and begin a different style of play. I wouldn't mind a double swoop for McCarthy and McManaman as replacements if Fellaini is sold.
Posted
31/07/2013 at
18:51:44
The 2008 version of Arteta.... Best player the club has had for 20 years.. And worth more than the 2013 version of Fellaini.... Anyway.... Not the point really. Have to say the write up doesn't show a 15 m value player.
Posted
31/07/2013 at
19:55:39
I'd be concerned with a deep mid of McCarthy/Gibson or McCarthy/Osman. Too little height or speed. Prefer Fellaini paired with either of the current two. Although the transfer fee is steep, I guess he'd be relief on the wage bill if we have to sell Felli to get him.
Posted
31/07/2013 at
20:08:05
Another outstanding read.
Wasn't a believer before hand but I have to say a good deal on Felliani and some tough bargaining with Wigan on McCarthy and i'll be a happy bunny - the combination of two sitting (Gibson and McCarthy) behind three more creative players looks mustard to me.
Posted
31/07/2013 at
20:39:49
Agree with conclusion of the EB. McCarthy would be a good signing but at around the 8-10m not 15m. If he were a direct replacement for Fellaini I think we would have a team too lacking in physical prowess and stature for the premier league.
Posted
02/08/2013 at
09:03:57
We've already got a DM in Hietinga. There he can make his mistakes and not get punished as bad. I've a feeling that's who will end up there.
Posted
08/08/2013 at
16:11:31
I was at the meet and greet in Miami and specifically asked RM was McCarthy coming on board. Basically his answer was that we want him, he's an Everton-type player (his words), we are doing our best to bring him in but it's going to cost a lot of money.
I think we will see him at Goodison Park this season.
About these ads
© ToffeeWeb
1 Posted 31/07/2013 at 15:29:41