Everton stitched up in narrow defeat to Real

, 3 August, 173comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 1 - 2 Real Madrid
Everton went down to a narrow defeat to Real Madrid in Los Angeles but can feel hard done-by following some maddening decisions that favoured the tournament darlings.

Cristiano Ronaldo romped through to slot home the opener after 16 minutes before Sylvain Distin's headed goal was chalked off for a "foul" and a trip on Kevin Mirallas just inside the box was called as a free kick instead of a penalty.

Mezut Ozil then tucked home a second as the Blues' high line was ruthlessly exploited before Jelavic, on after the break for the pedestrian Kone, scored a nice half-volleyed goal that bounced in off the post.

Match Summary

Roberto Martinez has picked a fairly strong side but one with a couple of surprises for this Round 2 game in the International Champions Cup from Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles... perhaps with a retro attacking 4-3-3 line-up: Howard; Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines; Osman, Heitinga, Fellaini; Naismith, Kone, Mirallas.

Everton kicked off a little late in the LA evening sunshine with a bit of reverse possession football, a clumsy Osman foul giving Real Madrid the first opportunity to put the all-Blues under pressure. The ref was protective of any contact, though.

A great steal by Naismith was not anticipated and the Blues were again on the back foot. But Coleman totally bamboozled Marcello and won a great free-kick wide right that Baines curled over, beating the keeper, but evading Kone and Fellaini. Some great controlled play and passing from Everton lead to the first decent shot, from Mirallas, just wide.

Baines was struggling a little with his passing, making a couple of atypical mistakes. A lively forward ball for Ronaldo was lashed high over the Everton goal. Some snappy Everton passing down the right almost paid off but Coleman and Jagielka needed to be alert in defence, blocking off Ronaldo at the byeline.

Everton were giving a good account of themselves, retaining the ball well and working it forward patiently, unintimidated by their illustrious opposition. Ronaldo again got free but Jags and Coleman were on him. However, he got behind the Everton defence on the left this time and, clearly two yards offside when the ball was played, he went on unhindered, drawing Howard before slotting home the opening goal. Shocking non-decision.

Everton had ceded the initiative to Los Blancos and now had to up their game significantly, especially in the final third, to get back into contention. Mirallas did brilliantly to beat Khadieria who brought him down, clearly inside the area, but the ref shamefully only gave a free-kick that was whipped in buy Baines and went out for the first corner, taken by Mirallas, leading to a second corner on the other side. Baines took this one and Fellaini headed it onto the post.

Mirallas is clipped just inside the box but the referee awards only a free kick

Some better play saw a sweeping move own the right but the positioning was wrong. However, a corner from the left was headed home by Distin, a perfect headed goal, but incredibly disallowed. And soon it was 2-0, Modric sending a ball over the top for Ronaldo, who centered for Ozil (offside?) to easily slot home.

Baines was perhaps missing Pienaar as his passing was out of sorts. And on the other side, Coleman was not as effective in dodging inside. Jagielka had his hands full keeping track of Ronaldo and his wicked forward runs.

Some shocking decisions in the first half and an impossible uphill climb for the Blues in a match that was clearly fixed. Jelavic came on in place of Kone, who had a poor half, while Madrid made a slew of changes after the break. Odd that Roberto resisted making more changes...

Everton were soon under pressure in the second half, their passing game failing to yield sustained forward progress. Some neat play created a half-chance for Jelavic but his flick was never going to score, and after pulling down a great cross from Baines, he got the ball mixed up in his legs. Jelavic again tripped over the ball.... poor.

A great move so nearly paid off but Fellaini was denied. While at the other end, Howard had to pull of an amazing one-handed save off a curling shot from Edilson(?). Ronaldo went off on the hour mark, replaced by Jese.

A good move finally led to an Everton goal that could not be disallowed, Coleman's deep cross headed back in to Jelavic whose technique was superb to power it past Lopez in the Real Madrid goal, and thankfully no possible way it could be disallowed, so Everton finally on the scoreboard.

Howard pulled off another brilliant save when it looked like he would be beaten with ease, Di Maria (?) firing low and Howard sticking out his foot to stop the goal. Fellaini gave way to Barkley and Gibson came on for Heitinga.

Barkley did well to force the play forward and win a handball decsion. But Jelavic's execution from the set-piece was shockingly poor. Everton were getting more calls in the second half, another excellent free-kick position wide left was so nearly powered in by Jagielka's header from a superb Baines delivery.

Deulofeu came on for his first appearance in a blue shirt, but a cross from him was rather wayward as Everton could not chisel out the chance that could tie the game and lead to penalties. The football from both sides was a lot more scrappy, with far too many subs disrupting any momentum on either side.

Three minutes of added time was not enough for Everton to find the equalizer and the 'expected' — if grossly unfair — result was registered, with the tournament favourites progressing to the final, Everton not really clicking well enough to counter the biased officials despite winning the second half.

Goals: Ronaldo (17') Ozil (25'), Jelavic (61')

Everton (4-3-3): Howard; Coleman (83' Stones), Jagielka, Distin, Baines (83' Oviedo); Osman, Heitinga (68' Gibson), Fellaini (68' Barkley); Naismith, Kone (46' Jelavic), Mirallas (83' Deulofeu).
Subs: Robles, Anichebe, Vellios.

Real Madrid: Casillas (46' Lopez), Pepe, Ramos (46' Nacho), Khedira, Ronaldo (60' Jese), Benzema (71' Kaka), Özil (85' Cherishcev), Marcelo, Arbeloa, Modric (46' Coentrao), Isco (46 Coentrao).

Referee: Baldomero Toledo.

Attendance: 40,681

 

Reader Comments (173)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Terry Davies
1 Posted 04/08/2013 at 00:26:49
I've just seen tonight's team. Osman, Naismith and Heitinga start. Bit surprised...
Ben Hayes
2 Posted 04/08/2013 at 00:33:22
Any links guys?? I tried Stuart's and didn't work on my computer
Ernie Baywood
3 Posted 04/08/2013 at 00:28:38
While you're waiting for the game... a bit of US soccer fun...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6KeG_i8CWE8

Ernie Baywood
4 Posted 04/08/2013 at 00:56:59
4-3-3? Surely that's 3-4-2-1 (or whichever way you to prefer to say it) with Heitinga as the ball playing CB?

Ben Hayes
5 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:04:38
I've paid for Everton TV but nothing has happened... any ideas??
Si Cooper
6 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:05:45
Looks like a really strong Madrid team and will be really impressed (amazed) if we produce a good performance against them.

Are these games played under standard rules or are we allowed more substitutions than normal (as in friendlies)?

Jim Potter
7 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:13:09
I suppose Robbie's looking to give everyone a run out.

Some nice stuff so far. Coleman and Miralles already looking dangerous.

Jim Potter
8 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:27:48
0-1 Ronaldo. Coleman gave away possession too easily there. Skippy finishes with class.
Jim Potter
9 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:30:10
Mirallas chopped down in the box .... but the (presumably Spanish) referee gives a free kick! Fellaini hits the post from a corner. Osman then a great goal-saving interception from the ensuing Madrid break.
Jim Potter
10 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:35:35
No sooner does Distin have a legitimate header ruled out for a "push" than Madrid, through a great Modric pass, puts Ronaldo away who passes to Ozil and 0-2. This ref should be wearing white.
John Mckay
12 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:53:02
Missing Gibson I think, wasting too much in the middle of the park.
Phil Davies
13 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:58:55
Heitinga seems to be struggling with his position, is he a defender going forward into midfield or a midfielder getting back to help in defence? Naismith is playing well which is something I didn't expect to say and Kone looks completely isolated and doesn't know what to do about it.

2 sloppy goals given away and we should have at least pulled a goal back.

Robin Cannon
14 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:03:52
Not a bad first half. Yeah, they're better than us...but we knew that anyway. In no way outclassed, though, and playing some reasonable football.

Mirallas looking excellent (though, to be fair, that probably was just outside the area), and definitely swindled out of a goal.

Thought their second might have been disallowed, but Ozil was behind Ronaldo when he played the ball, so probably legit.

Kone been pretty anonymous, and Naismith takes about five touches to get every ball under control, but overall it's reasonably promising.

Si Cooper
15 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:56:45
Unfortunately they have the pace, vision and directness to challenge our offside 'trap' though their second included what must have been two very close calls.

Thought Buzz was leaning on Khedira(?) but missed our penalty shout. Naismith looks sharp and has twice made very good runs that could have led to something if the passes to him had been better.

Think we are missing Gibson's passing ability from the centre of the park and we shouldn't be relying on the accuracy of Jag's long passes. Need to try to be more direct as some of our play is good but with little end result. Hopefully a few more early crosses will be whipped in second half (Seamus wasted a good position by trying to run it past two defenders on the edge of their box.

Are the pictures on the OS the same as Fox's coverage there is little in the way of decent camera angles or meaningful replays on the marginal decisions.

Les Golding
16 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:06:12
Very disappointed in Kone, Heitinga doing well!
Mathew McKay
17 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:07:43
According to www.worldreferee.com "Baldomero Toledo - Born USA - Speaks: Spanish / English". Think of that what you will.
Tony Anetts
18 Posted 04/08/2013 at 01:58:59
Just joined (clearly cannot work out PST/BST/EST/WTFITT) so missed the first half. EvertonTV is continually freezing and I want to smash something!

Have not seen the game so far but it is a hugh call for MK to say the match is fixed! Is it that obvious? What has the balance of play been like and how have we looked with the ball?

Si Cooper
19 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:06:33
Agree that Mirallas is looking good, apart from one terrible ball for Naismith who could have been played through about 5 seconds earlier in any case, and maybe should have found Fellaini on the penalty spot instead of very nearly finding him.

I think Naismith looks a lot fitter and quicker than last season and has an eye for an attacking run so he could be a useful player for us. He is not a dribbler or an intimidating midfield presence so it will depend very much on how the team is set up.

Fellaini hard working without really taking charge of the midfield. Definitely a pre-season 'friendly' feeling to the game rather than a full-on competitive game, which is to be expected.

Jim Potter
20 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:11:31
Tony - get a flight to LA and smash the ref.

We have been tidy and played some good football. They have looked very dangerous on the break. 6 changes by Real Madrid at half time. We have Jelavic on (for Kone). To me, a one goal difference between us at most.

Tony Anetts
21 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:18:41
Thanks Jim. I'm off to play over 35s soon (in Sydney) - someone is going to get it!!
Jim Potter
22 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:23:24
Jelavic getting far more ball than Kone did - and could have scored (or left it for Naismith who would have done. Bright start in second half.

Naismith playing well enough (we need to give him a chance rather than slaughtering him all the time - a lot sharper than the guy we saw last year). Heitinga ..... erm ...?

Wayne McNee
23 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:27:57
Score aside... We're playing tippy, tappy footy against the mighty Real & we look comfortable doing so. I've got up to watch this in Spanish & glad I've done so. Excellent tournament to be involved with!
Jim Potter
24 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:31:04
Cross by Seamus - good header down by Naismith - and Jelavic scores!

COYB!

Jim Potter
25 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:36:05
Great save with an outstretched foot by Howard.

Gibbo and ross on for Fella and Johnny H. Good time for these changes.

Mike Jones
26 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:42:22
Come on, Everton. I remember the 1-6 in 1985-86(?) when John Ebrell played under HK Mk 1. This looks much better tonight at 1-2.
Jim Potter
27 Posted 04/08/2013 at 02:42:27
Am watching this on DSTV in Tanzania - really annoying English guy commentating - fawning on everything they do and quite condecending about plucky little Everton. It's doing my nut in!

He's like the ref - "Wow! This is Real Madrid"! Real pain in the arse more like it.

Jim Potter
28 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:01:20
Baines, Coleman and Miralles off. Deufaloe (? get me a job in the Everton shop), Stones and Oviedo on.

Only a few touches from Gerard D - but he looks exciting. Barkley looked sharp. Final whistle.

Really sound second half by the Blues. A decent referee with some cajones and we would have had a draw. Played some decent footy and showed character having been 0-2 down.

Promising.

Terry Davies
29 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:07:15
Bugger
Phil Walling
30 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:06:14
Our transformation into Wigan Athletic is now complete !

Spread out three man defence which leaked like a sieve; tippy tappy midfield play with absolutely no end result and a first-half centre -forward who looked like Saha on a bad day.

I am already despairing for my bet on 7th place !

Si Cooper
31 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:04:59
Good in parts but we seem to go back to the goalie far more than we should and a lot of players were laying the ball off when they could have taken it and turned into space.

Contrast with Madrid who very rarely looked to go back unless it was part of a quick triangle with the aim of releasing one or two players into space behind our markers.

Guess the gulf in money shows in these instances and overall there was a lot of promising stuff.

Really would have liked to have seen Fellaini, Gibson, Barkley, Deulofeu and Mirallas on the pitch all at the same time. Maybe in the next game?

Edward Simpson
32 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:12:38
Phil- Stop talking bollocks.

We competed very well against them in the 2nd half.
Who were we playing again?

Michael Winstanley
33 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:11:08
I agree about Kone, not sure what he brings to the table yet?
We won't play a team of that quality all season.

Lot's of positives Phil, for individual performances and we created chances in both halves. Yes we gave them two easy goals, there are errors waiting to happen, that's obvious but hopefully as the players work out how to play it we'll improve our performances.

Anto Byrne
34 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:07:03
http://webfirstrow.eu/

Roberto has a bit of work to do yet. Good signs though.

Phil Walling
35 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:14:33
Who were we playing against? Questions like that show we still have the Moyes mindset !
Andrew Cutler
36 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:18:01
sheesh Phil...are you playing devils advocate or being a plonker. I suggest, by the time the first REAL game kicks off (Carrow Road), we will be WELL set. Amazing pre-season stuff. I am so excited
Phil Walling
37 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:19:41
Tell me you are kidding, Andrew !
Phil Sammon
38 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:14:17
There were many flaws in the performance, but 2-1 to Real Madrid with some shocking decisions against us, its not that bad.

Slight concerns:

Tim Howard's feet
Gibson is our only player who can spray a pass
Kone has fasted himself into invisibility
Osman gave the ball away a million times

Positives:

Coleman is shit hot
Fellaini looked slightly more interested
Jelly finding the net
Barkley and Deulofeu genuinely get you out of your seat
Mirallas is a top player
Naismith has a good leap

Derek Knox
39 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:09:37
Just finished watching, I thought a few decisions robbed us of at least a draw! I found that the commentary kept apologising for audio problems,which was okay on mine but the picture was very jerky in both halves! Due to this impairment I couldn't see if it was a brown envelope that fell out of the referee's pocket!

I think it was a good exercise and gave most of the lads a run out! Although I thought the substitutions were a bit Moyes-esque (too near the final whistle) to give any real chance of impact! Having said that Ross and Gerard showed some great touches!

I was really surprised with Nais, who could almost be a good candidate for MotM!

Rory Silke
40 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:15:26
Played against a very strong Real team in the first half and it showed. Also Kone and JH were poor. Second half we were much better, Jely's movement was a big improvement. Mirallas played well throughout and Naismith put in a decent shift.
Michael Kenrick
41 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:10:56
I got the slow-mo and replayed their first goal.

Ronaldo is clearly TWO YARDS offiside.

And the trip on Mirallas, clearly one yard INSIDE their penalty area.

And as for Distin's disallowed goal...

I fucking hate this shit.

Jay Harris
42 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:10:12
Ignoring the dreadful officials decisions I thought Naismith put a MOTM performance in.

Overall deserved draw despite the poor defensive mistakes.

Felli looked a lot sharper and was irritated about being taken off.

Thought Ossie had another poor game looking weak and unfit and Johnny just needs to hurry up and get on his bike.

Thought Jelavic showed Kone up with his second half contribution.

Disappointed with Bainsey ( has his contract been sorted yet?)

Coleman another great contribution and ever improving defensive work especially against Ronaldo.

Kevin Tully
43 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:17:22
Does anyone realise you play at about 70% of your capacity in pre-season.

Results mean nothing, fitness is all, and avoiding injury.

If anyone is not excited a bout 4-3-3 they have been brainwashed into keep it safe mode.

Who dares wins my blue brothers. Ask Wigan when they beat City in the Cup Final you bunch of scaredy cats.

Patrick Murphy
44 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:17:49
There are plenty of Everton sides from the past who would have folded and got beaten heavily in tonight's game. The first half was poor defensively and no matter what system you play, if you don't play well you'll concede goals. But even though we were out of sorts we still could have easily gone in level at half-time. Second half was a vast improvement, but we need to be more single minded when attacking and go for the jugular of the opposition more often.
The only game that matters is the one at Carrow Road in a fortnight, then we'll see what we're made of and whether the players can cope with RM's preferred method of playing. It's got to be better playing the likes of Juventus and Madrid than Bury and the likes in the pre-season.


Bobby Mallon
45 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:10:34
Phil Whalling, change the record. Yes, we need a striker... but we are much better than Wigan.
Phil Walling
46 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:22:45
Agree on Naismith as MotM. Says a lot for some of the others, though, doesn`t it?
Si Cooper
47 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:13:27
Missed the first twenty minutes so didn't see their first goal or the penalty claim, but couldn't really fault the referee from what I saw (a proper replay with decent camera angles of their second goal would have been helpful though I think Ronaldo released it just as Ozil got level with him). I think Buzz's goal falls into the 'sometimes you get them, sometimes you don't' category.

Barkley plays right on the edge; if he can get it to something like 90% of the time it comes off then he will be a star for us. If the cameo is a sign of things to come, Deulofeu will give some premier league defenders the fright of their life.

No problems with my feed from the OS either.

Patrick Murphy
48 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:26:39
Si, if it's an Everton player in the opponent's area, we never get the benefit of the doubt.
Phil Sammon
49 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:25:57
I appreciate that one, if not both, of their goals were offside. But we really are playing a risky game if we rely on officials to get these decisions 100% of the time. Today is an exception as I honestly think they had an agenda, but asking a PL linesman to get 10/10 close calls is going to result in a lot of goals conceded.
Derek Knox
50 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:27:07
I forgot to mention on the previous post, that I know we will not play the likes of Real, too often, in the next year anyway! But, I thought during the first half especially, that a quick break showed our lack of speed at Centre of Defence and also reinforced our need for a quality CM!
Phil Davies
51 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:26:07
My issue came in the last 20 minutes or so when Jagielka and Distin let the pressure get to them and every pass over 5 yards was a punt up the pitch, usually to Madrid's keeper.

Another good half from Jelavic, think he could probably do with starting the next game, talking of the next game we really need to sort out whether we'll be playing a back 3 or a back 4, Heitinga looked lost at times in the first half and was often to far forward to get back in time to defend.

Alan Smith
52 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:29:01
When Ronaldo was surrounding the referee before the corner why didn't one of our players have a word with the ref? Ronaldo was obviously making him doubt his last decision, knowing refs always spot an infringement for a 'get of jail free' after they've made a mistake.

"Don't listen to him ref he's trying influence you. He wasn't fouled, the fanny is trying making sure he gets something at this corner. Don't fall for it."

Gamesmanship! Sometimes it may not work, but you should always be seeking an advantage... the big teams do

Si Cooper
53 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:32:23
Patrick, I thought Buzz had his arm on the defenders shoulder and Ronaldo's pass to Ozil was just about perfect so I don't think we can complain about the decisions in those two instances. If during the game we had had mirror image incidents that were called the other way then you have a case for blasting this particular ref.

I would be interested to see where Ronaldo was when Modric played his ball for the second goal as he was well clear when he received it but couldn't declare it as definitely offside from what I have seen so far.

Unfortunately, didn't see their first goal or the penalty claim so can't comment on them. The ref seemed to give us plenty of decisions elsewhere on the park so my overall impression was that he wasn't favouring them, but it is possible he was never going to give us a penalty or a goal if he could in any way avoid it.

Ernie Baywood
54 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:35:42
Good run tonight though pretty concerned that we're still chopping around with the formation. Tonight looked more like 2CBs with Johnny in no man's land. Why? Is it a transition to 3 at the back? We haven't got the players for 3CBs so give up on it for now. Johnny isn't an option.

This decision affects every other position in the side. Time to nail it.

Phil Sammon
55 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:48:23
Ernie

I get what you're saying but I feel Martinez wants to be able to switch the way we play throughout the season. Even mid-game.

Id like to see Heitinga sold but I think it was worth trying alternatives in that area of the pitch.

Martinez was very quick to dismiss praise with the Juve win, I think he has every right to do the same with this defeat. It's his chance to build fitness and assess the team.

Si Cooper
56 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:44:34
Phil, I thought the game deteriorated quite badly after we scored. They definitely upped their tempo for a bit though we still had opportunites to punish them if our decision making had been better at times.

Obviously the large number of substitutions disrupted things, but I was disappointed we didn't have all of our main threats on the pitch at the same time. I didn't think Ossie had a bad game but he got 90 minutes when he hasn't been effective for more than 70 for as long as I can remember, and Naismith faded out of the game as well. Not surprising for either of them given their physical attributes / relatively recent injury history (as applicable).

Peter Bourke
57 Posted 04/08/2013 at 03:51:16
I think this pre-season has been the best for years. A lot players getting runs plus tinkering with the formation, which I think is an excellent thing. For those concerned about us chopping and changing from 3 to 4 at the back, that is what pre-season is for. RM is looking at what players he has suited to different scenarios. Clearly Jags and Distin face the most difficult transition as they have been used to defending with their lives and then hoisting it out of trouble.

Today's game against Real Madrid was a great workout and to be honest we are way ahead of where I expected us to be.

The most impressive thing for me has been the emergence of Stones, Barkley and Oviedo. Going on what little I saw of him today, I would throw Gerard Deulofeu into that basket as well. Naismith seems more suited to this style of football and maybe he will improve leaps and bounds under RM. So far I cant complain about anything from what I've seen.

Phil Walling, your comment "our transition to Wigan is complete" is the most bizarre comment I have read on hear for years. Pre-season is for experimentation and fitness and after seeing today's game you come up with the above comment shows you need a break from football my friend. Let go of this evil that is resting on your shoulders and be optimistic about the future. What else can you do?

Robin Cannon
58 Posted 04/08/2013 at 04:03:43
Pretty exaggerated headline. Only one outright wrong decision (the disallowed goal), definitely no real evidence of bias.

Overall, reasonably content. Thought we competed well, kept trying to pass positively and look to build attacks. Inconsistent at keeping possession, and tough to get the ball back when we gave it away.

Mirallas in particular looked excellent. Coleman and Howard also very good. Concerned at how anonymous Kone looked.

We played one of the best sides in the world reasonably close (and had a perfectly good goal disallowed), and *not* by simply trying to keep things tight and approaching the match defensively.

Jackie Barry
59 Posted 04/08/2013 at 04:08:30
Totally agree with you Peter, this has been the best preseason for years and there is no way we would have played against the like of Juventus or Real like this previously. I think Martinez will know what his best team is come the start of the season, he knows what he is doing and is giving all his players the chance to show what they can do.
Jackie Barry
60 Posted 04/08/2013 at 04:11:30
Also Graeme Sharp should also be removed from Everton commentary, liked him as a player but he is so dour and full of doom and gloom.
Phil Sammon
61 Posted 04/08/2013 at 04:17:39
Jackie

De-FINTELY agree about Sharpy

Jackie Barry
62 Posted 04/08/2013 at 04:16:17
Ronaldo was offside too though Robin, after watching it again and again trying to prove this decision correct it's the only conclusion to make. The Distin goal should have stood and their should have been a penalty, which oh my goodness adds up to bad refereeing. If this had happened in an EPL game we would be complaining no doubt, so in all I am glad that the fans are taking it all seriously.
Iain Johnston
63 Posted 04/08/2013 at 04:51:11
That about sums it up Martin, nice one. I think Martinez is pretty sure about his strongest eleven now. I'll get lambasted for this but, I think Naismith will start against Norwich. I know he was good last pre-season and went to bits but RM's style seems to suit him more. He looked comfortable this evening making some good tackles his passing wasn't too bad either.

Many have said it and I'd have to agree, we need a pacey, strong midfielder. Ross will get there but he can't do it on his own.

Ernie Baywood
64 Posted 04/08/2013 at 05:11:32
I'd be shocked if Nais started against Norwich. Surely we'll have Pienaar and Kev behind one of Kone or Jelly.
Jamie Crowley
65 Posted 04/08/2013 at 05:05:21
Ronaldo played the ball forward to his man with no defenders behind...

Offside. the second goal surely was offside... My knowledge of the offside rule in that situation is suspect so I stand to be corrected....

Anyhow good game. Naismith was excellent – can't believe I said that.

Well done Roberto for playing everyone and seeing how they perform. That's what preseason is about.

Overall satisfied. Decent game to be sure.

Excited for the season to come!

Peter Leslie
66 Posted 04/08/2013 at 05:07:21
Others have said it all about the officials; clearly the narrative surrounding the Superstars of Madrid didn't fit with Everton getting a fair shake. Don't care about that or the result – we came away from a game against one of the giants of World football with honour intact, and could easily have won the match. In seasons past a) we wouldn't have entered the competition – it would have been games against Preston, Dundee, Prescot Cables in between slogging up sand dunes. Or if we had Moyes in charge we'd have been beaten before taking the field, played a 7-2-1 formation and lost 5-0.

My main gripe was the fucking gobshite commentator who totally ruined the game by bigging them up at every turn, and running us down to fit his own pre-conceived notion of how the game was supposed to go – and he was English, the cunt.
Once Ronaldo went off and Everton got a foothold in the game he was excusing himself by saying all Madrid's changes messed up the flow of their game. The prize whopper.

It got so bad I turned off the voice commentary and listened to the effects track only (possible here in SA, thank fuck) – which was a blessing, as you could clearly hear the Blues singing Grand Old Team, and calling 'cheat' at the officials.

Anyway, we can pick holes in the performance, selections and tactics, so I will a little bit:

Two 'holes' in particular were Osman and Shiteinga - I love Ossie but his little legs have gone; but Jonny is just a fraud and can eff off.

Tactically, again, it's all been said – the high defensive line was a mistake... but I'm sure the lesson will have been learned; it's okay to play that against your Grant Holt level centre-forwards, but not a freak athlete like Ronaldo; he made even Jags look pedestrian.

No quibbles with the formation really, but two things:

I don't think it suits Baines or Coleman – neither really had much impact going forward as the wide forwards in the 3 were in their space. Secondly, It definitely doesn't suit Distin: the last two games against good opposition both teams sussed that he turns like a truck and slid balls down the side of him. If we play like that against Coutinho and Suarez level players we'll get murdered.

On selection, I question why we didn't put our best 11 out against Real first half? Gibbo and Fellaini in MF with a ball player like Pienaar or Barkley in front would have kept the ball so much better and the pressure off our back line.

I would echo others in saying Naismith looked really good on the ball and very sharp though, and made some very clever late runs into the box.

Apart from that, though, lots to be proud of lads – it's not so long back we were getting twatted 3-0 at Tranmere in pre-season remember...

Anyone know if that result means we play Milan in the next game or not?

COYFBB!!

Tony Rice
67 Posted 04/08/2013 at 05:38:34
Galaxy 3 Juve 1
Tournament organizers changed back....now we are playing the loser of Chel - AC for third.
Peter Leslie
68 Posted 04/08/2013 at 05:40:49
Thanks, Tony.

Let's hope its AC then, or maybe we'll learn more about where we really are by playing Chelski?

Robin Cannon
69 Posted 04/08/2013 at 05:45:23
@Jamie (876) - Ozil was behind Ronaldo when the ball was played, so no offside. I thought it was offside until I saw the replay.
Peter Thistle
70 Posted 04/08/2013 at 06:07:14
It's maybe not fair to compare us to Real but you could see a major difference in the way they cut through us quickly and efficiently when going forward and we couldn't get past the half way line without passing it backwards. Money buys ya players who are more confident on the ball and can spot a quick opportunity, ours are a coupla levels below that bar 1 or 2. Considering the massive difference in cash spent on the teams we held our own and coulda got a result on a different day.
Paul Ferry
71 Posted 04/08/2013 at 06:49:00
Phil Sammon - 866 - spot on capitalist mate, perfect call

Sitting on Manhattan Beach drinking mohitos reflecting on a good performance.

Leaving for Miami in 11 hours.

Up the Unions Phil mate!!!

Seriously, spot on in your analysis!

Paul Ferry
72 Posted 04/08/2013 at 06:55:15
I got a blue toe in the pacific as I tap public wi-fi Manhattan Beach love it - mohito in left paw. We have done really well these 2 games, really well.

So many good points, be happy, spoke to Jelly post match and if he was being gen don't doubt his commitment and his fiancee loves Liverpool the city

I spoke to John Stones, lovely guy, another Baines, and Leighton reeled off the three scorers at Rotterdam, he's going nowhere.

Shook hands with Bobby and sort of said thanks, when I meant I love what you're doing

Told Seamus he's the player who is most improved and he said no, it's Ross Barkley, he sees him in training.

Jim Potter
73 Posted 04/08/2013 at 07:06:35
Phil W - you're not a 'glass half full' person mate - you're turning into a 'Martinez stole my glass' person. I hate to imagine if Juve and Real had killed us. Give him a fair crack of the whip mate.

Barry Rathbone
74 Posted 04/08/2013 at 07:09:53
Didn't see it but by all accounts not too shabby.

Great to see Roberto finding out who can play and who can't against one of the globe's top teams I really love his mental strength, quiet determination indeed whole approach.

Jelavic scoring again .... Naismith, Coleman, Mirallas playing well and the young kids getting game time and doing well - fantastic.

Just saw the goals on SSN - after much rewinding and pausing my view is both goals onside - but close!

Tony Draper
75 Posted 04/08/2013 at 07:19:34
I missed the game and have only managed to catch "highlights" and replays.

Afraid that I'm not convinced that we were so badly done to as some seem to think. Maybe in watching the whole game the bias was more apparent, but from replays alone it was not so clear cut to me.

The trip on Mirallas? Looks outside/on the line to me. Also, our Kev "made no attempt to stay on his feet, having anticipated the challenge"

Real's first goal onside/offside? The crap camera angles really don't help (probably camera's sited as they would be for baseball/rounders....etc) but, not 2 yards offside as originally reported here, marginal at best. Must allow that as a "friendly tournament" that marginal decisions are more likely to be allowed for sake of "Wow Factor".

Distin's goal? Even the guy doing the music in the ground played the "Post Goal" tune. But the slowmo looks like Distin had hands "near" the defenders shoulders.

Their second? Hmmmm... questionable, the dodgy bit was about 30 yds out for me, but dodgy is all, certainly not a clear cut case of Dick Turnip.

Real also had a goal chalked off And Jela's goal was a keeper's howler, if USA Tim had let that in then there'd be a lynch mob on here calling for his scalp.

Overall, well it was a run out against a decent side with a result not to be ashamed of. As I haven't seen the actual 90 mins I can't say what kind of performance it was at all.

Very encouraging that Naismith put in an impressive shift, maybe playing him nearer his best position is a masterstroke by Roberto? No more "versatile" or "utility" players please, one or two are more than adequate in a squad, that always pointed to "enditherment" for me. HK only had two and his were the best teams we've ever had. Be great at being good and make the opposition worry about you.
And never ever take a teaspork when you know in advance that there's a gunfight in the offing!

Mark Rankin
77 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:00:28
Funny how that have to begrudgingly show Everton in the highlights. Don't seem to let much get in the way of the Real/Ronaldo show. The build up to Everton's goal was class.
Andy Crooks
78 Posted 04/08/2013 at 07:54:40
I'm glad to see some perspective from Phil Walling... I'm glad Moyes is gone and there is a lot to like about what is happening. However, some of the euphoria reminds me of the Champions League talk under Moyes which was usually followed by an appalling start.
Tony Marsh
79 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:10:48
Plenty of the Old Guard ready to come on and have a dig at Martinez because we were robbed in a pre-season friendly. Jesus wept — it was Real fucking Madrid and we held our own for most parts. Under the other clown we would've been twatted but the other clown shunned playing pre-season against the massive clubs. Let's not forget, RM has had this team two fucking months – not 11 years!
Matt Traynor
80 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:32:28
Andy #896, there will always be people who will lean towards blind optimism rather than dour realism - in fact some have already posted on TW that, with the transfer business we've conducted, they think we can challenge for 4th! To be fair the accept Man U, City and Chelsea will lock out the top 3, This despite that other teams around us have or will spend over £50m on strengthening!

It is always unwise to read too much into pre-season preparations but to my eyes, the football has improved but we will be shown up with a lack of bite up front (not that I'm advocating signing Suarez). Whether that's a lack of sharpness or deficiencies in the players time will tell - but I recall last season we created a lot of chances and failed time after time to finish them. That's the difference between top 4 and "the rest".

Ben Dyke
81 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:28:34
Good workout and good practice at tactics and formation and positions etc. Players don't play at full tilt because they don't want to get needlessly injured. This affects a team like Everton more than Madrid in my opinion because more of our game relies on aggressive pressing. Its brill that we have been in this but perhaps we won't get any more invites as we spoil the big boys party!

Juve are Italian champs aren't they and they have lost both games so we can't focus on results in pre-season.

Can't wait til Norwich game now to see how we line up and how we play. It's not a foregone conclusion and I don't expect us to come flying out the traps under a new boss but I hope we do. I suspect some players will adapt better and we'll find out who can't soon enough.

We have some genuine wildcards now in Mirallas, Barkley and Deulofeu which is exciting. I am concerned about centre mid and up front.

Paul Andrews
82 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:44:48
I agree with last seasons efforts re our strikers not firing, Matt. I think we may see a different Jelavic this season, hopefully back to the form of his first 6 months with us.

The 13 goals Kone scored last season would have made him our top scorer. If he can get around 15 and we can get more from Mirallas and midfielders we won't be too bad.

One thing: I think we will score more this season than last.

Scott Mongomery
83 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:47:16
I've been watching Sky Sports News for about 2 hours this morning and I've seen all the goals from the Cchampionship, Leagues 1 and 2, Tottenham's score and goals against Monaco, interviews with Arsene Wenger, Brendan Rogers about that Uruguayan pikey, and the massive transfer news regarding Clint Dempsey (ffs!) but not a breath of a whisper regarding Everton having played one of the grest sides in Europe this morning.

It just goes to show how much of a non-entity we are commercially and in the media at the moment and amongst many things is the area where our current leadership has most let us down. We have no profile to bring us additional commercial revenue or attract a new worldwide supporter base.

Kevin Thompson
84 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:53:35
As long as we get those dubious decisions, when it really matters, ie. against Norwich etc., it won't be too bad of a season. Naismith played well along with Coleman as contenders for Everton's MOTM.
Michael O'Brien
85 Posted 04/08/2013 at 09:05:17
I know it's probably been said as I haven't taken the time to read all the comments but they aren't gonna let Real lose. They want the superstars to battle it out in a perfect match up against Chelsea.

I think we played really well today and we're yet again bollicked out of a perfectly good goal and penalty. I also thought that their first goal was offside as Ronaldo was previously called off 2 times prior and the linesman lost his bottle. I thought we looked sharp and composed for the most part, Barkley seemed to show a bit of class when he came on Imo.

Wayne Smyth
86 Posted 04/08/2013 at 08:04:23
Didn't watch the game live... but on the main talking points, the Ronaldo goal was too close to call (having seen it 2 or 3 times), so I'm happy to accept it was on-side.

The Mirallas non-penalty was actually outside the box as best I can see. Marcello's foot is just outside the box so I don't see how it can be given as a pen.

The Distin goal he did have his arms on the defenders shoulders. It was a decision that may not have been given in the Premier League, but was likely to be given in Europe, so I'm not too disappointed.

On the Ozil goal, it was definitely offside when Ronaldo plays it, so we were hard done by on that occasion.

Madrid are probably the bet (or second-best) attacking side in world football and the richest club in the world. Their team are, without exception, filled with superbly technically gifted footballers who work incredibly hard either with or without possession.

In terms of our performances, I thought Jags was excellent (my MotM), Mirallas and Barkley looked superb, Fellaini played well as did Naismith. Coleman played well overall, but his distribution in the first half was very poor, culminating their first goal. If Ossie had done that, he would be getting incredible stick on here.

Kone was shit. If it's down to his fasting then quite simply he should not be in the team. However, in his defence, our forward play was far, far too slow making it very difficult for him to do a lot. It was great to see Jelavic back on form.

What I will say is that, while it was disappointing to lose, we didn't do too bad. We were narrowly beaten by probably the best side in world football. We wont come up against a Real Madrid in the Premier League. We really attacked them especially in the second half, created some chances, scored a goal, and were unlucky with a few decisions that could've gone either way.

Under the previous manager we wouldn't have even given it a go. We'd have played with 8 defenders on the pitch and probably got battered for the entire game, scored nothing.

As someone has already pointed out, we've played some really tough games this pre-season. We narrowly beat the Italian champions, we've beaten Blackburn and narrowly lost to Real Madrid. We also have another really tough game coming up.

The Premier League will actually be a (big) step down in terms of quality of opponents, and unlike the frankly ridiculous Phil Walling, I think we're in rude health and I am looking forward to the Norwich game.

Aidy Dews
87 Posted 04/08/2013 at 09:23:14
Let's remember, when we kick off vs Norwich on the 17th, we won't have Ossie or Heitinga in midfield! Osman got seriously found out last night and was way out of his depth; Heitinga didn't know whether to sit in midfield or drop into defence and there seemed to be some confusion which didn't help with our organisation in defence.

And it looked to me like we started with a 4-2-3-1 formation but when Madrid attacked we went to a 3-4-3 with Heitinga dropping in. But during the game, I don't think either Ossie or Felli did enough to sit and drop back and protect the defence and that's where we missed Gibson big time IMO.

With him in midfield he sits and plays that deep-laying playmaker who sits and screens the back 3/4 and always makes himself available for a pass out from the back. When he isn't in the team, we don't look as comfortable on the ball to me; I think we need to still make a signing in CM to either play or cover for when Gibbo is out cos I do think we're inferior when he's out of the side.

I didn't think we played too badly against Madrid last night and tbh, their quality in midfield and attack shon through. We just couldn't handle the pace, movement and passing ability of the likes of Modric, Ozil, Isco & Ronaldo, and not many teams can, that's why they're one of the best teams in the world. But we faired well against em, we didn't get shown up by them, even though it was only pre-season!

I think we are looking fit and sharp and in the next two pre-season games I think Martinez will start to play his preferred formation and line-up to get his starting 11 used to what he wants and expects of them and we'll take it from there.

Steve Brown
88 Posted 04/08/2013 at 09:38:01
So far so good for Martinez. I hated his appointment but now looking forward to eating some delicious humble pie. We've played Juve and Madrid and not looked out of place, which goes to prove if the board had invested in the team in the winter break and we hadn't dropped off, then we would have done credibly in the CL (lots of "ifs" there, granted).

Three things – we need to give Kone some time; it's amazing how much better Naismith looks with a full pre-season; Osman has gone and should not be a starter. Now let's put a full strength team out against Milan or Chelsea.

Gerry Western
89 Posted 04/08/2013 at 09:46:49
Lots of positives to take away from early pre-season form. Kone, I feel will come good after Ramadan has passed this may also explain some of Fellaini's lacklustre performances. As an aside, I see Chelsea are rumoured to be making another bid for Rooney estimated to be in the region of 40 million. As I understood it at the time of his transfer we were due a cut of any future sell on fee. Can anyone advise as to whether this was the case at the time and if so what kind of percentage we might we be talking. Might come in handy if we were to consider a bid for Mc Carthy who I think would be the final piece in the jigsaw.
James Morgan
90 Posted 04/08/2013 at 09:48:41
I got up to watch the game and was pretty pleased with what I saw. It's easily noticeable how we are building from the back and keeping the ball on the deck as much as possible as well as switching formation to change the game. The squad feels considerably bigger to me simply because it seems Martinez is willing to use it to its full potential.

The pace we have throughout the side now is quite frightening too, when you look at our full backs, particularly Coleman who is rapid, Mirallas and Kone have bags of pace, Naismith actually can shift, and to be fair had a decent game, and Oviedo who can switch on the after burners in a flash.

It's interesting how Martinez has also got a tune out of Naismith, last season he looked like one of the worst players I had ever seen in royal blue, now he is looking quite sharp and a useful squad player.

Oh and Deulofeu in his small cameo also showed he had quick feet and a burst of acceleration in him and could be our "secret weapon."

As for Madrid, well they can counter attack in a split second and will put any team to the sword with that quality.

Anyway, I am really positive for this season, COYB!

Mike Corcoran
91 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:02:33
Never mind the formation, why is Jags wearing a Hooters uniform in this vid

http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=S1zZAQKyjGg

Sam Hoare
92 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:20:44
Just has a crazy idea but what about... Naismith up front?

I actually thought he was one of our best players last night and could possibly suit the system. He's actually pretty rapid, he wins a lot of headers and most importantly I think his movement and touch and positioning in the box are very strong.

Last season he was abysmal but has genuinely looked sharp pre-season and certainly no worse than any of Kone, Jelavic and Anichebe.

Daniel Whyment
94 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:25:50
Just watched the game. Pienaar would have been better than Naismith. Fellaini was average and we looked better with Gibson in. Promising stuff from Barkley, needs to keep the ball better.

According to Sky Sports News we were lucky apparently and it should have been more. Don't know what game they were watching! Disallowed goal, 2 penalty shouts, hit the post and Ozil's goal was offside!

Paul Kennedy
95 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:33:13
It's funny since we beat Juve, on BBC sport it just showed our next and last match was against Southport – not a mention of the win. But get beat by Real and it's there in a flash.
Alan Smith
96 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:34:25
It seems to me that we've got cover in every position accept a decent DM. We should do everything therefore to keep Fellaini. If we have to sell one of them, I would rather it be Baines because we have a good LB in Oviedo.

I hope they both stay, but having watched these pre season games closely, Baines is more replaceable out of the two. And Oviedo is looking really good. Plus more of our attacks will come down the right with Coleman next season.

Kev Johnson
97 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:54:14
Anyone know who we play in the last game? I know its the 3rd seed from the other group, but who's that?

(Sorry if someone already said this in the above thread, but I'm in a rush!)

Sam Hoare
98 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:57:58
Kev, I think its whoever loses tonight's match between chelsea and ac milan.
Sharabi Singh
99 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:41:03
Good game. I'm not bothered about losing. Main thing is game time. RM will be happy. We had some bad decisions but as usual RM takes it gracefully in the interviews. There's nothing to look too in-depth at this game
Mike Benjamin
100 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:54:35
For those who have complained about hootball over the last few years will have no complaints about the way RM wants us play. In last night's game, for example, Howard always plays the ball out to his defenders, no aimless up-field punts in the hope of winning a throw-in. It will though I think lead to conceding more goals through giving away possession in our own half. I like RM's principles but I just wonder whether he is prepared to alter tactics when it is needed. I hope so because if he does then we in for a good season.
Andy Crooks
102 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:48:51
Good point Sam. I never thought Naismith was a dud. He was recovering from serious injury. Also, Roberto seems to have this novel idea of playing players in their best position which will help Naismith greatly.

I thought Moyes was pretty good with signings and I think Naismith was a good one. These are strange days indeed, Competitive pre-season friendlies, early signings, some self- belief... Whatever next?

I like the change of attitude and apparent lack of fear but sometimes pragmatism is required and that is what tempers my enthusiasm. Bring on Norwich.

Kev Johnson
103 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:59:43
Thanks, Sam. I've looked at it again, and if Chelsea and Inter win then we do play Milan. If Chelsea and Valencia win then I think it's Valencia. If Milan and Inter win then it's one of them or Chelsea, depending on goals scored. If Milan and Valencia win then... it could be any of them, depending on goals scored. Or something!

Here's the schedule: http://internationalchampionscup.com/schedule/

I fancy Inter. Just as long as it's not Chelsea.

Jamie Barlow
104 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:04:56
It doesn't matter if Mirallas was in the box or Distin fouled a defender, whether Ronaldo or Ozil were offside, if it were the other way round the decisions would have been also. You could almost see the officials swooning every time the amazing Ronaldo came anywhere near them.

Good game to watch, good football, quite a bit of pace. I just hope Martinez hasn't wasted what little money we have.

James Marshall
105 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:10:23
I don't fancy Inter - they're a team of hatchet men. I'd rather we played Milan.
Brin Williams
106 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:06:23
There was no way we were down to win this comp.

The gods had already decreed a Real V Milan (?) final.

No a bad game to watch lots of learning still to be done and despite having being drilled in the Martinez School of Ball Possession we still managed to give it away more often than not.

Our passing was not slick enough and when we did manage to string a few passes together the final ball always seemed to be telegraphed or was it that the opposition was that much more attuned to read the game and that much quicker in cutting out those 'well intended' passes.

All in all a satisfactory evening's work that gave Martinez food for though and we will only be that much better for the taking part and rubbing shoulders with this class of player.

It also showed that we do have depth in numbers and options although I happen to think that we need someone to boss the mid-field and a back three that can read the offside runs, otherwise we are going to get stuffed.

Well worth the late night tho. COYB

Brent Stephens
107 Posted 04/08/2013 at 10:49:05
I'm seeing these pre-season games as just that. It's a chance for a new manager and coaching staff to get to learn more about individual players; to give players not really given time under DM a chance to show Bob what they can do; to raise confidence levels in players whose confidence might have become shot under DM; to experiment to see which players, in which combinations, are suited to Plan A, B, C; to get fitness levels raised without incurring injuries.

So for me a really interesting start: cautiously excited to see what Stones can do; how Coleman continues to develop; how much Kevin promises the new season; how injuries so far avoided (apparently one of Bob's strengths was on the physio side and minimal layoff for injured players); how perhaps Nais and Jelli are recovering confidence; real competition for places so the squad is "larger" qualitatively if not quantitatively; how fluid the play looks at times (just one example is how fast and how far a CB will surge out of the back to cut out a developing threat; there are many others).

I'm just seeing so much that's new. It might work well in Prem, it might not (I guess it will work to our advantage. Unsure how far a high-line back 3 will be used and will be solid enough.

So for me rating individual performances in these games only takes us so far. It's more about all the other things above.

Arthur Westhead
108 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:14:10
This game really emphasised how important Gibson is to us. And we have no effective cover for him. Ossie and Felli together just doesn't work.

Mirallas could be so good this season, just stay fit. You could see Deulofeu being used sparingly early season, probably coming on for Mirallas towards the end of games. But the two of them together would be frightening for defenders.

Colin Glassar
110 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:23:17
I think Fellaini and Kone will get better once Ramadan finishes (7th) and they can get some food in them.
Wayne Smyth
111 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:23:18
Brin, I think its harsh to be overly critical of the players against such good opposition. You'll notice Madrid worked very hard and their players are simply (quite a bit) better than ours, throughout their team. The fact they can bring on players with the calibre of Kaka and Di Maria just goes to highlight the gulf in quality between the two teams.

If we are to beat teams like Madrid, we need to get a bit of luck, or for them to have an off day, and today we had neither.

The fact we were able to try a passing game against them and didn't look that much out of our depth speaks volumes for the work that RM has managed to do with the players. Hopefully it has given the players a fair bit of confidence that they were able to go toe to toe with a team of world-class players and do themselves justice.

Like many, I'm yet to be convinced that this will work in the Premier League, but I'm more confident than not, in playing this way. In any case it'll be very interesting finding out.

Phil Walling
112 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:08:46
To the contrary, Kev, I do so hope we play Chelsea. This will give us a far better indication of how we are likely to fare when the serious stuff starts in two weeks.

I hope `The Great Roberto` is not so addicted to his three-man defences as he was at Wigan for I fear whoever gets to play that outdated tactic alongside Jags and Distin, we will be in for a torrid time.

For all the pretty passing – mostly sideways and backwards – we have displayed little incisiveness and, in any case, there's still no one up front to stick it away...

Even with money to spend in the event of a major sale occurring, I can`t say I have much faith in this manager`s judgement. A dodgy goalie... a crock centre-half, and a striker who looks spaced out. (On a fast during pre-season? Do me a favour!) It seems that this guy only signs `em because they played for Wigan!

So for me,one who is not a fan of `tippy-tappy` without an end result, I want to see how we shape up against one of our Premier League opponents. Only then will we really have a clue as to what the season holds for us.
.

Max Wilson
113 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:40:22
I totally agree with Phil! This was real opposition, not really trying hard, and they left us wide open at the back. Let`s hope all this "new style playing" is not going to damage the solid defending that has been a feature of our playing in recent seasons.
Alan Newton
115 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:41:13
I watched the game last night and must admit to being a little surprised by some of the comments made, especially regarding Naismith. When did we stoop to such depths to allude delude ourselves about the worthiness of a footballer?

There were three usual suspects for me last night: Osman, Heitinga and yes, Naismith. I'm genuinely surprised by the level of praise he has received and MotM would be taking it way too far in my humble opinion. Granted, Naismith looked fitter and maybe even a little sharper than last season, twice making good turns that I can recall in the first half and a good lay down for Jelavic – fine. However, I lost count of how many times he give away the ball via a loose pass or by running aimlessly into a Real Madrid player, head down.

Guys, I understand we were playing Real Madrid and maybe I shouldn't expect him to look class against such opposition, but some of the basics of football seem to be missing with this guy and one or two good touches doesn't – in my view – make up for it.

In respect to being stitched up, I would certainly agree there were a number of dubious decisions to ensure the Spanish giants had right of passage to the final, which will work well for the MARKETEERS of the tournament. Distin's disallowed goal was soft, but we have seen them chalked off in the Prem. That said, if it happened the other end, we would have counted ourselves lucky to have been given the defensive decision. Ronaldo looked off for his goal and Ozil certainly looked off-side for his, unless the replays I didn't see showed that he was still behind Ronaldo. Mirallas was a good yard inside the penalty area, and the decision to stop Fellaini in his tracks before he fired in, was a little over zealous too.

On the positive side, we played some good attractive football against quality opposition. Coleman looks to have come on again, Jags is looking every bit an Everton captain, Mirallas looks hungry and a real threat, and Jelavic would appear to have found his magic touch again.

Negatives - I'm concerned this three-at-the-back formation will be something Martinez rigidly sticks to. I think we need to play in different ways according to the opposition or where we are playing i.e. three at the back may be okay at home but against such quick, counter attacking opposition, is too dangerous as we were too often caught out. I personally felt we should have reverted to a 4-4-2 at half-time with Jelavic, Barkley and Deulofeu on to replace Osman, Heitinga and Naismith.

With the players we now have at our disposal, I think we can look a real attacking threat with a 4-4-2. I'm not against the 3-4-2-1, 3-2-4-1, 4-3-3, 3-6-1 or whatever formation it actually is, but we need to be adapting it to the quality of the opposition.

We also need to be careful not to be overpassing it and still be happy to lump it forward once in a while. In both the Juventus and Real Madrid games, we were caught flat-footed at the back a number of times and lost the ball because of overpassing it or spending too much time in possession. These are errors that could cost us at vital moments in the Premier League and need addressing.

Andrew Cutler
116 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:02:42
@ Phil ...what's the old saying? 'I may disagree with what you say but will defend to death your right to say it'.... so you might be right mate. Regardless, I feel that that Norwich, who have bought very well in the window, are going to lose
Barry Lambert
117 Posted 04/08/2013 at 11:23:59
Very encouraging signs. RM seems to be generating a positive vibe throughout the team. I'm sure privately he still has a few doubts about certain individuals; however, he will not be drawn into anything negative.

Unlike Moyes, I really think RM is close to persuading the players to genuinely believe in themselves. This can only bode well for the future and build a real tight unit.

With reference to Kone's dubious performances, apparently due to his Ramadan fasting. Is it not the case that Fella is also a Muslim and has also had to adhere to the same restraints?

Brent Stephens
118 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:23:43
Phil #936 "It seems that this guy only signs `em because they played for Wigan."

Surely they played for Wigan because he signed em in the first place? (Did he?). If so, no surprise he still likes 'em!

Mark Tanton
120 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:35:29
I thought Baines looked out of sorts last night - was he looking for Pienaar? Not often you see him as ineffectual as he was last night.
Pablo Connelly
121 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:03:08
Alan 939, I watched the game and I can see what you're saying about Naismith. However, I wouldn't be quite as critical; I thought he looked bright and he seems leaner than last year which has helped his movement. At his best, Naismith is gonna be someone who works hard and gets on the end of things, possibly an 8 to 12 goals a season man if he played every week.

The problem Naismith has though is that we have much better technicians in his position. Martinez wants to play out from the back with a high defensive line. So – regardless of 3 at the back or 4-3-3 – we need players who are going to take responsibility to make something happen with the ball, therefore keeping the opposition pinned in and keeping the pressure off the defends who may be excellent defenders but not necassarily great footballers.

Naismith seems to want to lay the ball off and spin in behind most every time it comes near him. This may be okay if we are dominating but his style means he will disappear when the going gets tough. For this reason, more than any, he will find it very difficult to get opportunities when the real stuff kicks off.

Say what you like about Peinaar but no-one can label that criticism of him; he will always be happy to take the ball, keep it and try and make something happen – which is much more important with the way Martinez wants to play. The same can be said of Mirallas, Barkley and I suspect the Barca kid even though I have only seen 10 minutes of him. Therefore I just don't see how Naismith gets in the team; but time will tell...

Peter Cummings
122 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:15:22
Daylight robbery!

A blatant pen not given, perfectly good goal disallowed, a header off the post, and both Real goals offside — the first blatant, the second marginal. Some of our passing was poor, caught in possession too often, too many back-passes to Howard, Kone stunk, Jags, Heitnga and Distin solid, Coleman out of sorts, surprisingly good shift by Naismith, and Ossie worked his socks off.

Why didn't Baines take the free kicks from outside the box? Jelavic could have got us to pens which we deserved... but a lot of positives to bring back to Norwich,
Alan Newton
123 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:40:43
Pablo 948 - I'd largely agree with your comments to be fair.

I think you may be being a little more kind on Naismith than I, but I do tend to think that in a more advanced forward position i.e. as a 2nd striker, the style (or strengths?) you outline in Naismith would likely be more effective and less damaging when things are tough.

But, as you say, you've named a number of players there who would and should be picked ahead of him. Maybe a good squad player as a 4th or 5th striker, but he doesn't cut it as a midfielder or wide man for me.

Gerard McGregor
124 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:41:28
Did anyone see Graham Sharp`s latest tour report video on the official web-site? It starts with a quick glimpse of a “business meeting” of Everton (& probably some non-Everton) suits, Martinez and “some of the players” but, of the players, saw only Baines (looking talkative) and Fellaini (looking enigmatic). Interesting?

In what I have seen of the pre-season games, get the impression that Fellaini is playing with an upcoming medical on his mind.

Phil Sammon
125 Posted 04/08/2013 at 12:54:20
Not seen it Gerard.

To be honest I try avoid anything with Sharpy. He may be a club legend but the more I hear from him the more he annoys me. For a former footballer his understanding of the game is, at times, baffling.

I know he's an 'in-house' commentator, but is it really appropriate to be letting out groans every time a pass goes awry? It does my head in.

He's also part of a very depressing list of players who refuses to condemn our board. He's got a very cushy number with us and won't rock the boat.

Paul Holden
126 Posted 04/08/2013 at 13:25:22
Is Kone going to get his ass in gear before the season starts - keep seeing the word "pedestrian" alongside his name. Or is he the journeyman Mick Ferguson type frontman who will shine one in every ten games?
Ross Edwards
127 Posted 04/08/2013 at 13:27:31
I think that there are a lot of positives from this tour we can take. To only concede 3 goals against two of the best teams in Europe and score 2, which should have been more is something we can be proud of.

To limit a full strength Madrid side to 2 goals is excellent and it sounds like could have got a result judging by the penalty and offside shouts.

It was clear they wanted Madrid in the final anyway.

Jamie Crowley
128 Posted 04/08/2013 at 13:28:15
I really think Pienaar needs to move into the middle. We actually have options out wide. Where we need some depth / help is at CM as Osman - who I actually like - just seems to be aging in front of our eyes.

That or we need one more signing - wont hold my breath.

Pienaar to the middle.

Phil Sammon
129 Posted 04/08/2013 at 14:15:33
I think with the way we are trying to play it is imperative we find a new deep lying centre mid. Distin and Jags aren't great with the ball at their feet so Gibson has the job of taking the ball from them and starting attacks. His absence is all too noticeable. We have no other player who can spray the ball around. God knows how Heitinga has convinced successive managers that he can play the role. The guy has absolutely nothing to offer.
Ernie Baywood
130 Posted 04/08/2013 at 15:11:12
I'm all for positive vibes but on this thread I've seen "Moyes would have put out a team of defenders", "RM plays players in their true positions". Did no-one watch the game?

We played well but last season the manager would have been hung for that selection! Osman, Naismith, and a midfield Heitinga! I know it's pre-season but how do you get lauded on ToffeeWeb for that???

I see two key changes this year. We are attempting to pass the ball out from the back more and we are trialling different defensive formations. Personally, just personally, both of those changes fucking terrify me with the players we have in the squad.

Bill Gall
131 Posted 04/08/2013 at 15:27:05
Regardless of the score or controversial decisions, the game showed me that Everton need a quality midfielder that can win a tackle and can open up the opposition's defence.

Osman to me woks hard but, since his call up to the England squad, his performances have deteriorated and I don't think he will improve.

Fellaini tackles well and finds openings for himself but does not have the killer pass.

Naismith is just a journeyman player and we have younger players coming up just as good and with experience will be a lot better.

I realise that the club is not supposed to have a lot of money to spend but the only player they have spent any money on is Kone and he is not any better than what we have so surely there must be money from TV, our league position last year, and general income that we can move the club to the next level by signing a quality midfielder.

Regarding our new manager, despite what people say about his knowledge of other players in other European leagues, the only players he has signed as permanent players, are players he knows from Wigan, of whom none would have been a regular last season with Everton.

Harold Matthews
132 Posted 04/08/2013 at 13:17:08
We looked like a team slowly learning to pass the ball. Everything was telegraphed and robotic. The upfield progress too lethargic and clueless, especially first half. By the time the ball landed anywhere near Kone he had two or three defenders on his back.

Baines looked too hesitant and Coleman kept unsuccessfully trying to dribble the fullback. When he eventually smacked it over first time, we scored. A good turn and shot from Jelavic but,as much as I like this lad, he is too slow and clumsy.

Despite everyone wanting too much time to think, move and pass, it was a decent workout against class opposition. As with everything new. The more we practice, the better we'll get.

Tom Bowers
133 Posted 04/08/2013 at 15:44:29
Okay on the face of it, a 1-2 defeat to a full strength Madrid team isn't bad and I thought the Blues competed well for long periods. The starting eleven showed that RM was more concerned about giving players a start and getting them match ready against a top class team and with a little luck and better officiating it was a game whereby a draw would have been a fair result.

Some players looked below par including Kone and Osman but so did one or two others. Whilst winning is the object of every game, I suspect RM is satisfied with what he has seen in the two games so far and he is quickly formulating what his squad will be for the Norwich game.

We all have our opinions of who is worthy of a starting place but generally I see most are not happy about Heitinga, Osman or Naismith although Naismith battled well for the most part. Kone looked like he hadn't had a bite in days, seemingly lacking in something, although I suspect he will come good by the Norwich game. Howard proved to many that he is still top class whilst Coleman continues to shine.

Roman Sidey
134 Posted 04/08/2013 at 15:56:52
The schedule confuses and pisses me off. I've scanned through the comments so apologies if I'm rehashing anything, but in a "tournament" it is usually knockout, so if they're having playoffs for 3/4, 5/6 etc, we should be playing off for third place. This is an American tournament and they love their bracketology here, so what the actual fuck?

I can understand if they're going with the "goals scored" system that has obviously never been used, but shouldn't it be round robin pools if that happens?

I've got tickets to both days in Miami, so I know I'll see all the teams regardless, but it would have been nice to say we finished in the top half of this particular comp.

"Oh well it's only Everton so we'll just push them down as far as we need and they won't mind."

Roman Sidey
135 Posted 04/08/2013 at 16:02:47
Oh, and for the record, I like the 1-2-3-3-1 formation. Reminds me of the Christmas Pud formation with Fella in the middle as the sixpence.
Brent Stephens
136 Posted 04/08/2013 at 16:14:51
My guess is that Osman starts at Norwich but Nais and Kone don't.
David Chait
137 Posted 04/08/2013 at 16:54:55
Jim Potter.. Are you just visiting Tanzania or live here? As a blue who recently relocate here I didn't expect another blue in sight! Knew there were a few lurking in my old town in South Africa.

Btw, saw the goal eventually... Awesome build up. Typical Jelavic burying half a chance... Big fan!

Wayne Smyth
138 Posted 04/08/2013 at 16:49:32
Harold, I agree that our passing was lethargic and everything was telegraphed, however you have to take into account the quality of the opposition.

Those players are at the top of their game. They are some of the best in the world. Our players are mostly average quality, and unfortunately it shows. You can't expect Osman or Gibson to dominate the madrid midfield and start out-passing them.

When you're playing against world class attackers, its natural not to make that forward run, incase they hit you on the break, so you stay back, and its then one less forward option for your team mates. Forward passes become more difficult and the number of possible forward passes you could make becomes very few and hence they are easy to pick off.

There isn't a lot we can do short of spending a couple hundred million on top quality players.

Arthur Westhead
139 Posted 04/08/2013 at 16:50:46
Brent, No way can Osman start as first choice. If you take it that Jags, Distin, Baines, Coleman, Felli and Gibson are certain starters, that only leaves 4 to fit in from Jelly, Kone, Mirallas, Pienaar, Barkley, Deulofeu, Naismith, Oviedo and Osman. If Stones or Heitinga start in a back 3 then it would only let 3 fit in! I would pick every one of them ahead of Ossie.
Arthur Westhead
140 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:08:59
From the brief opportunities we have seen of Oviedo, he looks a quality player to me. Am I right that we paid £5m for him? And under Moyes he virtually never got a kick!
He really should get a game regularly and I would definitely be playing him a lot more this season.
Patrick Murphy
141 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:11:12
What happened did we play another half of football after I had gone to my pit? This headline certainly doesn't reflect the game I watched 'Toffees come unstuck as Real run riot' To be fair the report is a fairly accurate reflection of the game as I saw it. But the Headline?


http://www.enca.com/sport-soccer/toffees-come-unstuck-real-run-riot

Paul Low
142 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:06:27
before nit-picking about individual incidents in the game and criticising players, people need to put the game into perspective!!!
There is a reason everton have NEVER played real Madrid in a competitive mach and that is because they are on a different level to us by an absolute mile!!
I for one am excited for the season to start as from what I have seen in the last few weeks the team seems to be playing with the shackles off!
Each and every player looks to be performing 20-30% better than under Moyes. I mean don't get me wrong Moyes brought some really good players in but his safety first approach did not allow some of those players to play to their strengths.
I think what Martinez will bring us is a team with enough attacking ambition to get us 5 goals a game in a couple of matches a season, I mean how many thumpings did we dish out last season under Moyes?
also I think he will give us a team that will go to the top 4 away from home and take the game to them as we tried to do last night.
The biggest difference is we keep the ball more and don't give it straight back to the opposition, I mean sure we lose the ball with the odd stray pass in a slick passing move from time to time which can be frustrating but how many times did we used to give it to the opposition with long balls? long goal kicks? the keeper just booting it upfield from his hands? instead of now playing the ball from the back allowing us more possession and more chances of building an attack
Alan Newton
143 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:26:27
Arthur #999 - I've been saying for a long time that we should be playing Oviedo, either as a left-back with Baines playing a Bale type left wing role, or the other way around. Some may say the Baines-Pienaar partnership shouldn't be broken up and on the evidence of last night, that would be fair. However, I was starting to think Pienaar was loosing his way a little last season and age is creeping up on him. I'm confident Oviedo and Baines could strike up a good partnership on that left-side and essentially rotate positions throughout the game

I'd like to a 4-4-2 formation in one of the friendlies set up as;
Howard - Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Oviedo - Mirallas, Barkley, Gibson, Baines - Kone, Jelavic

Yes, no Fellaini, but I think that's because we'll have to get used to that pretty soon and with experience, I believe Barkley will deliver more in terms of the killer defence splitting passes Fellaini doesn't give us. Still need another quality Central Midfielder though + a striker. I think we are well covered on the wings with Mirallas, Coleman, Pienaar, Oviedo, Baines and Deulofeu

James Stewart
144 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:37:06
Officials were a disgrace. That is all.
Paul Low
145 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:33:54
Arthur 999
You are spot on about Oviedo, he looks a class act, pacey, good control,grafter,tackler, and a top professional by all accounts
He isn't the only player to be overlooked by Moyes last season though
Ross barkerley looks like he has bags of confidence and although he has a lot to learn yet(which he will do by playing) he looks to have a lethal attacking streak and sharpness around the edge of the box
Brin Williams
146 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:47:57
I don't know about Ramadan - Kone's motto should be Ramidin!!
Jamie Barlow
147 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:08:03
When should Oviedo play? Should we drop Baines?

Baines and Pienaar need to play together. It's a shame really because Oviedo looks really good. Unless Oviedo plays left wing which I don't know if he can do.

Arthur Westhead
148 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:10:53
Alan 003, definitely. Oviedo should be on the left side, maybe that would shake Pienaar up a bit. He needs it.
Kevin Tully
149 Posted 04/08/2013 at 17:51:56
By the time Martinez puts his stamp on this team, we will be unrecognisable from the way we play the game now.

Moyes played a percentage game, balls into channels, and a hard pressing old-fashioned English type of football. I'm not arguing it wasn't effective though, he clearly got results over the course of a season.

There is no doubt we will witness a few pastings over the transition period, but we never scored 4 goals in a League game last season.

There are two ways to bridge the money gap, we can revert to KITAHTNO, and HOPE for a draw at top six clubs away from home, or we can go at teams in a continental style with sin miedo!

There will be tears and tantrums along the way, but I'm convinced we will come out of the other end with a real footballing team we can all watch with pride, and actually believe our 'school of science' title when we say it.

It won't happen overnight, but we have just given OFM 11 years of support, so surely we can give Martinez two seasons?

Jamie Crowley
150 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:15:59
It looks as if we've succeeded third place - we've moved to the 9 pm on Tuesday slot and will play the winner of Valencia v Inter. The Galaxy have moved "up" to the third place game and will play the Chelsea - AC Milan loser.

My guess is someone at Everton (Roberto?) wants to get Everton back home sooner if they aren't playing to win the thing.

Works way better for my schedule anyhow... Won't stick around for the Wednesday games in Miami.

Note to Paul Ferry - You'd better start driving from LA now sir! Chop! Chop!

Mark Frere
151 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:22:50
Arthur 999

I think we paid £1.8 million for Oviedo, he didn't have long left on his contract. Oviedo could be very important to us this season, especially if god forbid Baines ever got injured. I really can't see Oviedo starting too many games next season because where is he going to fit into our team?Think we will see much more of him in Cup competitions and when Baines and others are either injured or need a rest.

Brent Stephens
152 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:33:55
Arthur #997. I'm not saying I personally prefer Ossie, just that I think Roberto will start him. And yes, before the others you list.

But, hey, it's no more than a gut feel and my guts can be quite bad at times.

Solo Lo Mejor!

Paul Ferry
153 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:35:31
HA having a late breakfast, but we are in Arizona Jamie!
Mark Frere
154 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:39:17
Paul Low

I think you need to put things in perspective before you start talking about Martinez getting an extra 20-30% out of each player. We haven't played a competitive game yet, so you can't start making them judgements.

Lets not forget, these games are just a warm up process to the real thing which starts against Norwich. Only then can we start making real judgements

Raymond Fox
155 Posted 04/08/2013 at 18:07:05
First off, the result doesn't matter, how many times has RM said that.
He's finding out through the matches and training who's suited to the game he wants to play!
The teams he's selected are in no way the teams he will settle on.
That was Real Madrid, our teams cost peanuts in comparison, little wonder they were sharper than us.
The team he plays at Norwich and West Brom at home will be considerably better suited and balanced than the team that started against Real.
The problem he has, is converting Moyes team, picked and trained to play in a more defensive style of football into the type of play he wants!
In a perfect world ie city/chel/utd he would go and buy the players he needs.
So for my money we cant expect miracles straight away.
Don't get me wrong, we have some cracking players.
Id be tempted to bring in Barkley sooner rather than later, he injects some bite in the team when he comes on.
Mirallas is world class, as are our full backs, Gibson when fit is class, Stones is probably our future Distan, time will tell!Dont think Fellaini will be playing for us at the start of the season.
I also think we'll have a decent season, not a spectacular one, but its going to be a interesting one at least.
James Flynn
156 Posted 04/08/2013 at 19:24:45
Nice run-out. Good training and fun game to watch. And, most important, no injuries.

I really want Barkley to get more game time. I love Ossie, but want to see more Barkley... much more.

David Donnellan
157 Posted 04/08/2013 at 19:33:17
Unfortunately, never saw the game, but have seen the goals, Nice to see Jela get another goal.

After reading the comments of my fellow blues on here, regarding the game, I can see that we gave a good account of ourselves against one of the worlds greatest sides. Ive had to listen to Rodney Marsh on talksport, compare the game to the Mohammed Ali v Brian London fight, insinuating we took a one-sided walloping, still what does he know, I would rather listen to all of you guys who watched the game & more or less have a consistent view of how the game went, different to his view.
I wonder whether when teams like Real Madrid play, commentators, pundits, etc, have already decided how a game is going to pan out, before a ball is kicked & this influences how they watch the game & then report on the game afterwards.

Gavin Ramejkis
158 Posted 04/08/2013 at 19:43:54
If you want to grind in the stitch up, Everton have been relegated to the Fifth place playoff game now, LA Wankstars get the Third Pplace playoff game vs Juventus
Lenny Kingman
159 Posted 04/08/2013 at 19:45:07
Though Everton could beat Real Madrid all things being equal, I'm afraid that even Martinez can't make that happen just yet. Too many variables. But its coming. .
Eugene Ruane
160 Posted 04/08/2013 at 19:11:45
Raymond (017) - "That was Real Madrid, our teams cost peanuts in comparison, little wonder they were sharper than us".

Hard to argue with that - they don’t spend £80m on players so we can be just as good as them.

On what they DO pay for the players they want, in today’s Observer, there is a club-by-club list of what the big spenders across Europe are prepared to lay out.

In each case, they show a (big spending) club’s top 10 most expensive buys since 2000, then give an average outlay based on these buys.

On their (most expensive top 10) list, Real Madrid have Ronaldo most expensive (£80m) and their ’cheapest’ (or number 10 on their list) Di Maria at £20m - their average is 38 million.

Few more averages (just to give an idea) - Barca £32m, City £28m, Chelsea £27m, Utd £23m, Liverpool £21m.

Everton?

We don’t make the list, probably as our record signing cost $5m less than Di Maria.

(be interested to know our top 10 most expensive buys since 2000 and what out average would be).

All that said, the players we DO have need to keep possession a LOT better.

If we’re going to be a passing side, we simply can’t give the ball away like we did at times last night.

Steve Guy
161 Posted 04/08/2013 at 21:31:09
Sky's report of the game on their website is hilariously biased
Peter Warren
162 Posted 04/08/2013 at 21:43:53
Jelavic finish was fabulous. Lets hope he's back on form
Antony Matthews
163 Posted 04/08/2013 at 22:32:34
When the season starts it will most likely be the same in the premiership where the top four get all the decisions. Money talks. Nudge nudge wink wink say no more.
Phil Sammon
164 Posted 04/08/2013 at 22:40:29
Steve Guy

I read that report from Sky.

No mention of our penalty claim or our disallowed goal. They even said the game was being played in the wrong city!

The comments section was a good read though. The reporter got a good pasting.

Liam Reilly
165 Posted 04/08/2013 at 23:07:37
Take it or leave it with the ref, result etc because the only game that matters is the next one. Norwich.

The only thing that concerns me is that he's picking the same team I would expect Moyes to pick. All the usual suspects and the youngsters are only getting a sniff.

I've supported Everton for over 35 years, but if we get the same team, same shite that's been dished up for the last 11 years, I will find it hard to carry on.

Harold Matthews
166 Posted 04/08/2013 at 23:06:26
Wayne #995. Agreed. It is very difficult.

It's all new and the more we play, the better we'll get.

Noel Early
167 Posted 05/08/2013 at 00:16:45
Naismith plays well, looks sharp and still he gets lambasted on here. I have always said to give him a second season before we make our minds up about him.

The lad had a terrible injury 2 years ago and spent last year regaining his fitness. It didn't help that DM tried to turn him into a workhorse so I would give him to Xmas before passing to much more judgement.
Chris James
168 Posted 05/08/2013 at 01:10:17
Changing the topic slightly.

But assuming Chelsea hang on for the next 10 mins, it looks like the final will be Chelsea vs Madrid, the wooden spoon Juventus vs Inter and we've been squeezed into 5th place match vs probably Milan (on basis that LA Galaxy bet Juve 3-1 tonight and Valencia notched 4 vs Inter).
Another good test for the boys before we head back!

Chris James
169 Posted 05/08/2013 at 01:34:29
Actually scratch that, I think it'll be vs Valencia (as Milan beat them head-to-head in first game).
Patrick Pulis
170 Posted 05/08/2013 at 03:28:16
After watching a recording of the match it's hard to look too much into it. I don't get people taking a load of positives from it though. True the second goal was offsides. At the same time Howard made a ton of really nice saves and Coleman made a few last ditch blocks. Distin's no call goal could really go either ways with being called a foul or not. The biggest thing that I take issue with is that we weren't dangerous in open field play at all. One of the only nicely played balls came from from Barkley for Jelavic toward the end of the game and it was overhit. We really only looked dangerous on set pieces. Once again nothing to be concerned with, this is pre season against Real and we're still very early in learning RM's style of play, but at the same time I didn't take many positives from it.
Max Wilson
171 Posted 05/08/2013 at 09:50:09
Re Alan Newtons comments with regard to Naismith, he appears to agree with loads of us that this guy is out of his depth in the PL and one of those "bargains" that have proved to be less than satisfactory. Playing him anywhere will just reveal more of the same in my opinion.
Andrew Flanagan
172 Posted 05/08/2013 at 12:25:38
Why are people saying Real's second goal was offside? Clearly wasn't.

I'm not sure if they have corrected things since to cover themselves but the structure of the competition looks pretty clear to me. LA Galaxy won 1 game the same as us but had a better goal difference. Therefore, go into the third place play off. off

http://internationalchampionscup.com/

Patrick Pulis
173 Posted 05/08/2013 at 19:12:25
You might be right Andrew, I'll have to look at the goal again. Overall though it's inconsequential. It was called a goal in a friendly.
Harold Matthews
174 Posted 05/08/2013 at 22:11:34
Tim Howard has probably been our best player but once again, as illustrated with the Ronaldo goal, with time to think his brain goes walkabout.
Steven Sturm
175 Posted 05/08/2013 at 23:07:54
Harold Matthews. Walkabout? What were you expecting Howard to do differently one on one against Ronaldo?
Gerry Quinn
176 Posted 06/08/2013 at 00:07:48
Andrew #123 - I have been constantly in and out of that site since it first appeared those rules NEVER appeared in the original website and have been added recently!
Phil Walling
177 Posted 06/08/2013 at 00:19:48
I think Naismith had his best game ever against Real — and that ain`t saying much. But he looked half decent in last year`s pre-season.

About on par with the Scottish Rooney Mk 1?

Harold Matthews
178 Posted 06/08/2013 at 03:05:31
Steven. That's just it . I wasn't expecting him to do anything else. With time to think his judgement of space, distance and direction has cost us dearly in the past and will continue to do so.
He's a great shot-stopper but that's as far as it goes.

It's all about opinions. You trust him. I don't.

Harold Matthews
179 Posted 06/08/2013 at 03:51:18
Steven.

In one way you are right: Ronaldo is very special and would probably have scored no matter what Howard did. It still doesn't alter my opinion of his judgement and decision making.
Robin Cannon
180 Posted 06/08/2013 at 05:26:31
@Andrew (123) - People are saying it was offside because of a misreading of the offside rule. The ball was played forward and Ozil was in an offside position when he tapped it in, but it doesn't matter, because he was behind Ronaldo when Ronaldo played the ball, so he's onside.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb