New badge to adorn Main Stand

, 8 August, 162comments  |  Jump to most recent
Iconic old crest on the gable end will be replaced

Everton have announced that the controversial new club badge will replace the old crest on the gable end of the Main Stand, despite opposition that has Director of Communications Alan Myers providing a 'personal' committment to involve the fans in seeing through the redsign for the 2014-15 season.

Alan Myers said: "As you know, we have made a commitment to allow supporters to choose our crest for the 2014-15 season but for this coming season we have our 2013-14 crest and we will wear it with pride, and, accordingly, will support it as our crest for the duration of the season.

"It is vitally important we are consistent and what we see on TV, around the stadium and elsewhere is the same as on our shirts. Having two crests in existence and visible is not good for the Club's identity at home and abroad.

"Of course, we all know it will change in 2014-15, and we have introduced the new crest in the most cost-effective way possible.

“I am finalising the plans to allow supporters to choose the Club's next version and these will be released later this month.

"A significant amount of work has already been undertaken on this project and we will be launching a major consultation with our fans on the next version of the Everton crest shortly.

"This will give every supporter the opportunity to have their say on what they think should be included on the badge. We have made that commitment and I will personally see it through."

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (162)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Shane Corcoran
1 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:26:03
I'm anticipating complete support for this announcement from TW posters.
Robin Cannon
2 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:36:00
I'm sure there'll be uproar, but it's really the right decision. Even changing the badge next year, we should pursue consistent branding this year. Would look even worse to have one badge in one place, and the old badge on the Main Stand (which is a very public part of, say, pre-game TV coverage).
Patrick Murphy
3 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:37:52
I hope that Alan has another job lined up for the summer of 2014 as we all know that if the board don't want to spend or are unable to spend money we will probably end up with the new badge exactly the way it is now. But seriously if the club have a proper consultation and actually listen to what the majority of the fans want then that has to be a good thing for all concerned.
Nick Entwistle
4 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:43:48
"It is vitally important we are consistent and what we see on TV, around the stadium and elsewhere is the same as on our shirts. Having two crests in existence and visible is not good for the Club's identity at home and abroad."

A very few people are paid a lot of money to think like this.

Just take it down and dust it off next Summer. No need for any vote.

Phil Sammon
5 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:44:00
It's annoying but its the right to do given the circumstances. Fair play to Alan Myers for actually communicating with the fans.
Martin Paice
6 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:53:26
Totally agree with what he says. It should be consistent, even if it's consistently poor.
Tony Fearns
7 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:54:20
That new badge will be with us for more than one season.
Declan Burke
8 Posted 08/08/2013 at 17:53:15
Will have to keep my eyes closed every time I pass the gable end of the Main Stand's next season. 10 foot high mickey mouse crest, designed by a two year olds.
Eugene Ruane
9 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:00:36
Shane (322) - "I'm anticipating complete support for this announcement from TW posters"

Now that made me smile.

Peter Thistle
10 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:10:49
I feel sorry for the people who live opposite the main stand, every day leaving their house they will have to see that monstrosity. Poor bastards.
Paul Gladwell
11 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:08:15
To be fair to the club they could have carried on with that NYPD badge after all the uproar as a few clubs have done just as that in the past.
The new badge is garbage,but on the kids kit it looks ok due to the size, people would have just got on with it in the end, thankfully the club looks like its sticking by its work and changing it.
Ross Edwards
12 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:19:42
That tells me that they aren't changing it.
Lyndon Lloyd
13 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:25:30
The club reaffirmed the commitment to change to badge at the supporter event in San Francisco, Robert Elstone restated it again in his blog yesterday and now Alan Myers has added his commitment as well. I very much doubt they'd be digging themselves that big a hole if they had no intention of following through on the promise.

I'm with Robin on this one; as much as it pains me to see the new badge go up on the side of Goodison (it hasn't grown on me at all since I first saw it leaked), it does make sense from the perspective of consistent branding.

Let's grin and bear it for a season, trust in the club to make good on their pledge, and hope that the options we get to vote on in the coming months are worthy of our great club.

Drew Shortis
14 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:26:38
Seems the logical thing to do. Like it or not it is the clubs badge for this season and we should be consistent. As long as they deliver on their promise of allowing the fans to select the new badge next season. Personally I'm Ok with the current one. It can be and should be improved, but its not that bad. I'm far more concerned with transfers and how we play.
Jeremy Benson
15 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:22:11
Surely, if they want to be consistent, then it's just as easy to change the badge on the shirts to match the existing one on the stand and other pre-2013-14 badge places that must need to still be done?

Our merchandise isn't in that many shops.... consequently, there shouldn't be huge stockpiles of stuff that would need to be shifted. They'd just order in small batches as they needed to satisfy the club shop etc, you would think. Most businesses work to the "just in time" model these days, not stockpiled in huge quantities in advance (necessarily..) like the MOD.

Just saying like...

Peter Truin
16 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:27:34
Why do people say "to be fair to the club" fair my arse

Did the Nuremberg trials say "to be fair to Adolf and his board they did have a huge back stock of Zyklon B,it had to be used"

Fucks sake,just take the big old crest down and don't put anything up for a year,then when the monstrosity is gone replace it with the voted it crest

Eugene Ruane
17 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:30:26
Sits, looks at calender, folds arms and............waits.
Eric Myles
18 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:38:27
" Having two crests in existence and visible is not good for the Club's identity at home and abroad."

What about when the telly shows all those supporters at the game wearing shirts with the old badge?

Or are they just not going to let them in?

Kevin Tully
19 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:42:43
Honestly,who gives a fook?

We could be on the verge of losing our two best players, priorities anyone?

The sleight of hand is good though.

Colin Glassar
20 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:47:11
It's not an issue for me (I hate it btw). I support the team, not a badge.
Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:44:36
When we all arrive at Goodison on Sunday we'll have to watch out for all the two-year-old toddlers surrounded by confused nanny's and parents as they thought the sign was for a newly opened Summer Playschool.
Paul Thompson
22 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:52:29
@453 - 'the Nuremburg trials'?! Get a fucking grip. We're talking about a slightly shit badge not mass murder.
Peter Truin
23 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:58:26
Mass fucking genocide actually.......

And it's a very shit badge not a slightly one

Richard Reeves
24 Posted 08/08/2013 at 18:29:26
I still don't know why the original badge is so hard to reproduce. They weren't specific about what part of the badge was causing such a problem. I could only guess it was the 1878 or Everton on the outside of the badge...

I mean, how can the badge and scroll be the problem? They're not exactly overcomplicated in detail. Take the shape of the crest with the wreaths and Rupert's Tower — how is that more difficult to reproduce than Man Utd's with the devil, fork and ship? I'm no expert but I don't think it is.

Then there's the scroll with our motto, how many other clubs have changed their badge but still kept a scroll with wording? From what I've seen most other clubs that have changed have kept theirs.

So the most important questions that need to be asked if we do get some kind of imput are:

1) Does 'Everton' have to appear on the badge?
2) Does '1878' have to appear on the badge?
3) Does 'EFC' have to appear on the badge?

If the answer to #2 is No but the answer to 1 and 3 is at least one has to be incorporated, then the anwer to a new design is simple: we just go back to the badge from the Johnson era and have 'EFC' either on the tower or placed in the middle of the scrolls, as has been done before.

Stuart Eaton
25 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:02:27
What a total waste of time and the clubs money, has anyone a figure as to how much this has all cost, designers fees, re printing of god knows how much merchandise and even the cherry picker and his mates to take down and put up a new one.

Brent Stephens
26 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:12:23
Stuart, it will come under operating costs!
Ross Edwards
27 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:14:44
They could save money by getting an image from Google and sticking it on with Sello Tape Brent and Stuart.
Peter Cummings
29 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:03:55
Interesting comparison re the Nazis, Hitler, etc, Der Fuehrer 'promised' a thousand year Reich' but ended up shooting himself after 12 years, so if the 'promised' return of our beloved Nil Satis badge, is reneged on, can we expect the board members to resign en masse, (shooting themselves would be a bit extreme).

But then didn't her Majesty welcome Hirohito back into the Buck House fold and give him back all the British gongs and titles after he masterminded the slaughter of millions in WW2 instead of hanging the little fart, so much for 'promises' eh!!

Warren Culshaw
30 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:25:45
Consistent branding? They best let Sky 'Manure' Sports know then because they still use the old one - then again....
Brent Stephens
31 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:32:14
Maybe with Prat Stick, Ross.
Doug Harris
32 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:35:06
Said it before and I will say it again: every time I look and see "that" shite badge, on any website, I think that badge is shite....
Ross Edwards
34 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:41:05
Speaking of removing things, will the "In Moyes We Trust" banner at the Gwlady's Street End be removed? Surely it should be replaced with "In Martinez We Trust"
Lenny Kingman
35 Posted 08/08/2013 at 19:49:04
Did no one at GP think that a risk assessment may have been a good idea for the new badge.

As for the reputation of those involved in this misguided new venture.

Blindfolds and a courteous escort to face a dawn firing squad.

Guy Hastings
36 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:23:05
Has BK been told the cost of scaffolding thse days?
Guy Hastings
37 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:24:25
What will happen to the old badge once it's off the wall. Charity sale?
Mark Knight
38 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:35:24
Cherry picker,FFS Stuart couple of lads from Scotty Rd with ahem next doors ladders...
Paul Gladwell
39 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:40:14
Peter, I say to be fair to the club, because like many on here I spend a good part of my time slagging them off, so if I think they do something ok they deserve the plaudits too.
Ross Edwards
40 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:45:03
We could get BK to take it down. Leave him on the scaffolding and take the ladder away.
Peter Truin
41 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:45:49
Paul

There is no to be fair,to be fair the fucking thing shouldn't have been allowed in the first place

I find anything coming out of the club now is either bollocks or has a hidden motive

Oh and I never asked you if you give a flying fuck if I disagre with you

Ross Edwards
42 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:51:55
It's clear that this is a permanent crest Peter, why would they waste time putting on if it's only a temporary crest for this year anyway?

Their promises to listen to us was only to shut us up and calm the fury before the season started.

Paul Gladwell
43 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:53:58
Peter, we all know it should not have been done, that has been done to death on here over the summer, we spoke our words and got a result on the dopes, but at least they backed down to fan pressure, clubs like Arsenal never over similar issues.
Rob McFawn
44 Posted 08/08/2013 at 20:55:11
If seemingly everyone (Myers included) is in agreement that it's awful and is only going to be around for 12 months, why waste yet more time and money on it? I'd rather the spaces were left blank until next year...
Pat Finegan
45 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:02:42
Why does any crest have to be up there in the first place? How about just Prince Rupert's tower and the word, "Everton." Maybe put "nil satis nisi optumum" up there as the club made a commitment to having the motto be used around the club. Plenty of other options here other than to display a badge that over 90% of Evertonians think looks hideous.

I see the logic in it but at the same time we should avoid using it as much as possible.

Barry Rathbone
46 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:03:53
The words "it'll all blow over" should replace "nil satis ...".

I imagine Kenwright and Elstone say it 6 times a day.... absolutely laughing their cocks off they are.

Danny Kewley
47 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:16:10
A badge and /or crest of a any football club is much more than a mere symbol of the history of the club and all its supporters, without whom the club would obviously not exist! Therefore, it is my humble contention that until the fiasco of the avitar new mickey mouse badge has been resolved can't we just put EVERTON on the main stand?
James Byrne
48 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:39:44
Why do I feel I'm being shafted here...........

I've struggled for years to trust or believe anything our club say's anymore. This horrible badge shouldn't have even been allowed to be created in the first place.

How many people actually believe the club will change the badge next season; come next season when nothing has changed it will be a case of "What Badge" and fuck the fans coz they're so gullible.

Gavin Ramejkis
49 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:46:29
I hate that joke of a badge and sit in the ParkEnd so will have to walk past the ugly bastard thing on a match day, passing motorists and RS can enjoy looking at it wondering what clown came up with that and why make it worse by putting a big fuck off huge thing in public view.

Global brand bollocks, who much merchandise does the club sell overseas? Seriously?

A simple Home of Everton Football Club could be placed on the side and retained when a new suitable emblem is created, why piss away money on scrap iron no one wants or has no longevity?

Mark Knight
50 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:55:01
Pound to a pinch of shit,you'll still see the outline of the old badge.thats how cheap we are..
Ian Hollingworth
51 Posted 08/08/2013 at 21:59:11
This will probably get me banned from TW but Lyndon your post smacks of my new bessie mate would not lie to me.

I am sorry guys but I would not be surprised if the club went back on its promise. The chairman has been called out on numerous lies over the years and it does not seem to bother them.

I presume the club are starting to sell merchandise now as apathy sets in so they can safely change the branding knowing that a reasonably decent season will make it all forgotten in 12 months

I mean what will happen if they don't change it next year?

Phil Sammon
52 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:11:20
Ian

What are you on about?

Lyndon said that two pretty key members from the club had confirmed the badge will be reviewed. Alan Myers going as far as to say that it would be changed. Why would they say these things unless they planned to do it? They'd be setting themselves up for an even bigger fall.

As shit as it is, the badge has to go on the stadium. It's our club badge for the year and we've got to keep it uniform.

Karl Masters
53 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:22:47
Goodison will look like a Fisher Price Fire Station with that badge on it.

I understand why it's going up, although I suspect they ordered it months ago and think they might as well put it up as throw it away now they have paid thousands for it.

Ian Hollingworth
54 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:20:59
Phil my comment regarding Lyndon was tongue in cheek but referring to the picture posted of him and Robert Elstone in San Francisco and then him defending the club like they would not lie

You believe them if you wish and I choose not to

I will ask again what will happen if they do not change it next year?

Ray Roche
55 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:27:42
"Alan Myers said: "As you know, we have made a commitment to allow supporters to choose our crest for the 2014-15 season"
I wonder if these fans will be the knobheads picked by the club, you know, the ones who designed the latest monstrosity ?
Phil Sammon
56 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:33:28
Ian

Sorry, I didn't get that reference. I take back the narky attitude.

You are right to be suspicious of the board. However I feel that after this badge disaster they will seize a real PR opportunity with the new 2014 crest. A badge designed by fans and voted for by fans. It's what we've all asked for and it would be stupid of them to ignore it.

....of course they are famed for their stupidity.

Peter Laing
57 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:34:12
It seems that Elstone has been on a charm offensive stateside, Greg O'Keefe commenting in the Echo tonight that he was accessible and approachable to all and sundry. Pity he can't be as affable when on normal duty in the UK with his poxy fans forums etc. Leopards don't change their spots and it will be business as usual as the new season gets under way.
Barry Rathbone
58 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:36:35
Phil Sammon, are you seriously suggesting EFC officials haven't told porkies to us peasants in the past?

"Review" is not "change" as much as "investment" is not "for sale".

I can see Ian's concern.

Eugene Ruane
59 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:01:36
Remember how Cool Hand Luke got his name in the movie? (of the same name).

He wins a big poker hand on a bluff and when the cards are turned over, George Kennedy says "He had nuthin!!'"

Luke smiles and says "Yeah well, sometimes nuthin' can be a real cool hand".

And 'nuthin'' would have been a cool hand in this matter, but instead some nob-head thought "No, let's do...SUMPTHIN'"

The most incredible thing for me is that all that had to be done to avoid bad feeling, anger, petitions, letters, designs, redesigns, apologies, argument, loss of face, loss of goodwill, bad press, was to have simply done...nothing.

To have left the bleeding thing alone, to not fix what wasn't broken

(and remember, nothing would have cost....nothing).

But no, someone (no doubt trying to look busy) said "Hey guys, I've got an idea..."

And instead of responding "Yes, a SHIT idea!", everyone apparently rubbed their chins and went "Hmmmmm...tell us more"

On TW I have seen just about everything (Everton-related) argued over, analyzed, pulled apart, agreements, disagreements..but I don't think I ever saw a post (could be wrong) along the lines of 'Our badge needs changing to something more modern' or 'Time to drop the latin'.

It was possibly the only thing no one had a problem with

Every time this issue is raised, I get a mental picture of a big fat-headed village idiot sticking his face into a wasps nest and then screaming "I've been stung!"

(a bit like in that film 'Uncool Stung-Faced Idiot')

Phil Sammon
60 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:50:21
Barry Rathbone

No, I am clearly not saying that I trust the board.

Ian Hollingworth
61 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:51:09
Phil, apology accepted but not needed

I hope you are proven to be right but I fear I may be

Gary Seed
62 Posted 08/08/2013 at 22:55:02
It's a badge! I tend to worry myself over games, opponents, injuries, signings (or lack of them), Fellaini & Baines potentially leaving, will Roberto deliver, will Jelavic rediscover his goalden touch, will we qualify for Europe, will we finish above the shite AGAIN, will we win a trophy?

Yes, I worry about my team and my club... but ffs, a badge and one that they have stated publically will be changed? Chill pills, anyone?

Phil Sammon
64 Posted 08/08/2013 at 23:40:59
Myers is a decent guy, Phil, and he does actually give a shit about the club.

We have been lied to, countless times so I fully understand the pessimism.

Chad Schofield
65 Posted 08/08/2013 at 23:51:33
I just hope that they made it out of cereal boxes.

Agree on grounds of consistency... but I won't be buying anything with that thing on it.

Ernie Baywood
66 Posted 08/08/2013 at 23:52:36
They already said that the stadium would be changed to replace he old badge so this is no news. Of course we shouldn't have two badges.

But I'm still cynical about the whole "oh we'll change it again next year". I reckon after some proper consultation with the fans they'll just keep it anyway.

Julian Wait
67 Posted 09/08/2013 at 01:08:29
2014 - "the response to the Everton crest has been fabulous, and after consultation with fans we have decided together that it is the best option, add it is a wonderful reflection of both our heritage and our forward thinking mindset"


Julian Wait
68 Posted 09/08/2013 at 01:16:18
while here, apologies to Phil Sammon for my remark the other day during Real game. I was pissed off at the ref and took it out on you. sorry
Eddie McBride
69 Posted 09/08/2013 at 03:52:28
We could take it down at the end of the season, and present it to Kenwright as a retirement present. Complete with his own Latin motto, if anyone knows the Latin for "Any al' shite will do..."
Tom Hughes
70 Posted 09/08/2013 at 05:56:43
Eugene,
As ever...... spot on!!!

The badge is a joke and an insult...... we certainly do not need to repeat it so prominently on the stands. It is possible to have a badge and corporate identity as two separate entities. In the mid 80's the badge on the shirt was the simple tower and laurels...... but the actual badge that appeared on all other things was the traditional badge. The same can apply now.

Paul Andrews
71 Posted 09/08/2013 at 05:57:48
"Consultation with the fans"

The "fans" will be the same hand-picked "don't rock the boat" fans who sit on the present Fans Forum.

No disrespect to them, but they were not picked because the CEO thought they had a rebellious streak.

Simon Smith
72 Posted 09/08/2013 at 06:33:09
"Of course, we all know it will change in 2014-15, and we have introduced the new crest in the most cost-effective way possible. "

Just wondering if this means cheap and tacky as in knocked up in 5 mins with double sided tape and egg cartons a la Blue Peter???

Time will tell....

Tom Edwards
73 Posted 09/08/2013 at 06:52:49
When my youngest son was 4 he made me a birthday card which had the old crest and motto on it. He drew this from memory! Can't be that bleeding hard to reproduce if a 4 year old can do it without even looking at it!

I rest my case, your honour,

Paul Gladwell
74 Posted 09/08/2013 at 07:02:44
Change of subject slightly, I walked into Jds in Birkenhead yesterday and lo and behold there was the new kit for sale, I nearly fainted, what's all that about? Next thing the clowns will have realised they can sell it in Speke airport too.
Peter Truin
75 Posted 09/08/2013 at 07:02:43
IF there is a review of the crest or indeed IF they actually change the crest does anyone actually believe they will consult the fan base as a whole?

Does anyone believe they will consider designs by the fans,this isn't Duncs tattoo we're talking about

Does anyone believe that the same graphic design clowns employed on the current thing won't be involved on any future attempts if they go ahead

it seems to me that the club have thought 'lets get alan myers back,he's popular and these idiots will take him on his word'

Derek Thomas
76 Posted 09/08/2013 at 07:18:39
Nick #331 spot on, once removed, some one will know what was done with it and once that comes out for good or ill we will know what the fate of the badge will be next season.... I like Eugene will keep an eye on the calender but as the have form going way back for throwing things out ( didn't Dr David rescue half of what was in his collection after they threw it all out before the 66 world cup...and what ever happened to the Iconic Square clocks.
Phil Sammon
77 Posted 09/08/2013 at 07:56:46
No problem Julian.
Tony Cheek
78 Posted 09/08/2013 at 08:00:05
Can I have the old one?
Paul Smith
79 Posted 09/08/2013 at 08:18:29
Just throwing this out there (maybe a but of mischief making!!!) – oh and I hate the abomination of a new badge, by the way – but what happens if we actually won something this season or finished in the top 4 or both?!?! Would we keep the 'lucky' new badge then!!!!????
Alan Williams
80 Posted 09/08/2013 at 08:31:59
My son has the new badge on a dinks bottle, polo shirt and the home kit; it’s not as bad as I thought if I’m being honest. Look at the New York train painted in Everton colours and yes it has the new badge but in the eighties we didn’t even have a badge just the tower and EFC so I think we need to sit back really and look at our badge history before we dismiss the new less is more approach.
Andrew Laird
81 Posted 09/08/2013 at 08:42:13
I wonder if fans will get this as a letter and ballot paper:

Dear Evertonian,


As a valued supporter and fan of Everton F.C. we consider you the lifeblood of our business and would welcome any suggestions you may have in order for us to strive to be the best we possibly can in all aspects of the business. Please mark the attatched voting form accordingly:

Do you want to keep the new crest ( ) Yes

Many thanks Everton FC.

Peter Truin
82 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:01:16
Alan

i would 100% take the 80s iconic EFC tower and laurels as our shirt crest

that current thing is shit and anyone who likes it have the same taste as people who wear white socks with sandals and shorts

Scott Hamilton
83 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:01:54
I'm getting used to it. I wouldn't say I like it but I am becoming more neutral by the day.

I think if we have a great season then fans may warm to it by association and it'll end up staying. If however we flirt with relegation then many might even suggest that it was a contributing factor and the pressure to ditch it will be intense.

Ultimately, it's our current branding so the idea of it adorning our stadium shouldn't be a surprise. It would actually be very amateur of a Premier League club to miz old and new insignias. A little like the team wearing last year's shorts but this years shirt!

Scott Hamilton
84 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:07:24
(Miz = Mix)
Tony I'Anson
85 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:05:52
Anyone know how merchandise sales are doing? It will be interesting to see the net effect of that on match-days next season. I bet we end up winning a trophy.
Simon Smith
86 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:10:22
Said it before and will say it again,
What happens if we have a good year and win something, will the new crest be treated as good luck charm???
Steve Brown
87 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:19:34
From what Elstone has said – and I know many of you don't trust him – the crest will be removed at the end of the season. In the meantime, it doesn't make sense to have one crest on the merchandise and another on the stadium.

Reading Lyndon's piece from the US, I expect them to produce a number of designs and ask fans to vote. Which, for once, we should accept – mainly because Alan Myers has said it also, and I respect him a lot.

Peter Truin
88 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:22:03
Right

liverpool fc have a shirt crest and a club crest on their stadium,the club crest incorperates the eternal flame with relevance to the hillsbrough victims and it incorperates their motto

so tell me again why everything has to be uniformed,one good reason...................

Peter Truin
89 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:28:09
Simon

let me assure you that wont be an issue

but if so NO!!!!

Scott Hamilton
90 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:33:39
Peter (523) - So tell me again why the RS should be held-up as an example of how we should do things...
Peter Truin
91 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:40:55
Scott

What like trophies and titles won?

or business model? Cos theirs is better than ours on both counts

Ian Burns
92 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:14:25
Peter - 515 - spent the past hour reading the latest posts on TW. Then I came across your post. I realised I was sitting here in white socks; shorts and sandals sipping coffee!

Out of respect for good taste, which is not in any way a reference to our new badge, I have taken off the white socks.

Eugene Ruane
93 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:10:14
Scott (516) - "I think if we have a great season then fans may warm to it by association and it'll end up staying"

What fans?

The only way I would ever 'warm to it', petrol and matches would be involved.

(what are we, made of sponge?)

I don't care if we win both derbies, the PL, league cup and FA cup - that piece-of-shit, embarrassing cartoon, better be gone by this time next year (nb: as promised!)

Jon Ferguson
94 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:37:03
I'm with Ross, this sounds like a slowly slowly catchy monkey tactic to me. An excuse will be found to keep the badge next year.

I hate the new badge with a passion. It undermines our fine club. It looks like a 1st year secondary school tech project.

I think the only decision they could have made (of this kind) which could upset me more would be if they started playing shite tunes after every goal.

I love walking down the street on evening games and seeing our beautiful badge lit up. It fills me with pride.

I thought they might forget about that badge or decide we couldn't afford or be arsed to take it down.

Gutted!

Why put one up for just one season?

I don't know if it's just because I hate the new badge so much, but the ToffeeWeb badge looks a million times better. If someone offered me that for next season now, I'd take it, worried about what other crap the design team might come up with.

I try not to be overly emotive on here usually. Sorry for the rant!

Peter Truin
95 Posted 09/08/2013 at 09:50:58
Ian

smart move mate your half way to tasteful

Ian Burns
96 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:05:07
I have just noticed Hull City are going to be re-branded Hull City Tigers. I pray nobody on our board sees that one!!
Peter Truin
97 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:20:53
Everton mints fc

we could play in black and white stripes

then that fucking crest would be suitable

Kev Johnson
98 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:24:51
Everton Mints FC or Everton Toffees isn't dynamic enough for the brave new world of Rugby-style monickers.

Maybe the Dogs of War tag could come in handy? Everton Elephants would chime with the Chang sponsorship and our mascot.

Eugene Ruane
99 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:21:29
Ian (534) - "I have just noticed Hull City are going to be re-branded Hull City Tigers. I pray nobody on our board sees that one!!"

I know what you mean, specially as that Tommy Testicles costume might still be knocking about.

Announcer: "Awwwwrite Goodison, arrrr yoooou READY!!? Please welcome the boys with blue balls, it's the Everton Testicles!!!"

(cut to beaming BK)

Phil Walling
100 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:33:35
It`s just got to be` Everton Bluebills`-well,we are aren`t we? Forever.
Kev Johnson
101 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:36:01
We've already got the following animal nicknames in the Premier League: Eagles, Magpies, Bluebirds (or should that be Redbirds?), Swans, Black Cats. The following sound "dynamic" enough to be used... Hammers, Gunners, Red Devils - and I suppose Saints would do, at a pinch. That leaves Cottagers, Pensioners, Potters, Citizens, Baggies and Lillywhites needing rebranding. Also, the ultra-lame Reds.

Come on, Everton Elephants would be perfect!

Scott Hamilton
102 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:36:44
Eugene (530) - Ah, but as we know ToffeeWebbers are not necessarily representative of Evertonians, hence the applause when Uncle Bill's boat race appears on the big screen at Goodison.

I can see the previously negative consensus of opinion re: the badge turning into either apathy or, as I said earlier, fondness due to association.

Clearly "Eugene's not for turning" though!

Ian Burns
103 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:49:19
I was thinking more like Everton Eagles - or Kenwright's Knobblers - he wouldn't want to miss out!!
James Marshall
104 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:55:29
It's really no big deal. The crest has changed several times over the years anyway.

Personally I don't really care too much about it - we have to move with the times. Everton have been guilty for some years now of stagnating and being left behind. Look at the way we missed the (money) boat when the Premier League launched.

We will likely keep this crest for some years yet - look at how it's already been plastered all over the US. Seems unlikely it'll be changed just when the Premier League is being promoted so heavily over there.

Loads of teams have changed them lately, it's a non-issue.

I'd love us to play in black & blue stripes as someone mentioned above.

Patrick Murphy
105 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:59:29
Everton Eels would represent the slipperiness of the Board.
Everton Electric - For all those machines they buy but we never see.
Chris Fisher
106 Posted 09/08/2013 at 10:58:18
I prefered the old badge but don't have a major problem with the new badge, I think its fine, and I don't like wearing white socks and sandals, we are all entitled to our opinion, and if you like the new badge thats great and if you don't then im not going to say oh well that means that you must support Liverpool or something equally as stupid, anyway the problem I have with replacing the old badge with the new badge on the stadium is the cost. If we are indeed changing the badge again next season and having to go through this again at the start of next season, taking down the new old badge and replacing with the newer new badge then what a waste of money that will all be for a club that doesnt have money to waste, working in marketing I can tell you that creating a badge that size, that is weather resistant and is safe so it wont fall off and kill someone is much more expensive than you might imagine. We havent had to do it for such a long time and suddenly we are going to do it twice in a year?! If we are indeed having a new badge for next season an alternative for this season should of been thought of.
Peter Truin
107 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:07:06
Eugene

I can already see on here how people seem to be softening to that hideous thing

I like you will never be turned it is an imposter,a cuckoo in the nest,gypos camping in the back garden

personally I know not one single blue who will except it,I would suggest that those accepting it are maybe out of towners viewing from a distance

James Marshall
108 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:14:28
Peter #554.

The badge you know & love isn't the original badge anyway. What's the problem with change? It's always changed, the kit changes, everything changes.

With respect, a lot of Evertonians are so hung up on history - it holds us back.

We all want to stay at Goodison for example because we all feel like it's our home, but it's not. I mean, how far back do you want to keep going. Look forward, not backwards.

I don't like the new crest, I much prefer the old one like you do - I just don't think it should be such a major issue when it just happens to be the one we know in our lifetime.

Scott Hamilton
109 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:16:09
Peter (554) - Are we back to the old "unless you spent your Christmas money in Buchanan's on County Road then you're not a proper Blue" arguement? Certainly looks that way!
Peter Truin
110 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:23:52
Scott

not at all just I would imagine from a distance it would be easier to come accustomed to it than having it in your face every day

James Marshall
111 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:26:33
Fair enough, Peter.

The new one was clearly designed with the World market in mind - simplified massively and removing the motto. Can you imagine Americans wondering what the hell it says? It could well alienate people, and we're clearly trying to branch out and create a much larger fanbase around the world.

The club is trying to take a wider view than just those who walk down the Goodison Road every day, and I think that's really the point here.

I'm defending something I actually don't like either by the way!

Peter Truin
112 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:25:57
James

I embraced the kings dock ambitious fantastic stadium

I voted against kirkby

but as a club how can they say they're moving forward when we are still at a stadium with wooden floors

it seems to me that they want to appear like they're moving ahead but actually we're not and this crest is a step in a completely wrong direction

I actually loved the design by one of the fans with the tower,motto inside a large set of laurels,classy and dignified so im not being sentimental I just hate that thing

James Marshall
113 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:48:11
Appearing to move forward is exactly right. We don't have the money to build a new ground, we all know that and that's why we're in an old ground. You kind of answered your own question there.

We can't redevelop, we can't move. Not without a huge investment and we also all know that Everton is simply not a good, stable investment for anyone. There isn't a billionaire out there crazy enough to pump money into something that isn't going to return anything on the investment, so we're stuck in a catch-22 situation.

We all want a new ground, or a redeveloped Goodison, it's just isn't viable without the cash to do it, so I guess that 'appearing' to move forward is our best option at the present time. Pushing ourselves as a Global brand (in the US & Asia) is best case scenario without the vast funds required to really make the changes we all want & need.

Hopefully the crest will be changed, but I have a feeling that with the new one already becoming something people in the US are going to know, it'll be with us for longer than we all want or anticipate.

Colin Wainwright
114 Posted 09/08/2013 at 12:15:31
Another bullshit lie to add to the list then? And some people are happy to accept it.
Peter Truin
115 Posted 09/08/2013 at 12:16:48
Ah but James

You see we're not investable because of our business model,our kit deals etc

These deals and models are run by the same people who think this crest is a good idea,it all comes down to the same point,the stadium issue is a side issue as even if we had a 150 exec boxes they'd be empty anyway,we can't even sell out the derby

And what a lot of people still don't understand is that buying the shirt to merchandise is not supporting the club,we've had our share

Matt Doyle
116 Posted 09/08/2013 at 11:50:01
Is it really worth having the Fisher Price Beehive hoisted onto the side of Goodison only to be unceremoniously torn down again in 12 months?

I'm guessing the club is smelling potential new shirt sales in the US in the wake of the pre-season tournament / parnership with Nike, hence the 'consistent branding' idea.

Still not sure why they insist on one single graphic - the shite wear the liver bird as shorthand of the 'full' version of their crest. Why can't Everton do the same like they did in the 80s?

I hope our next badge is designed by an Evertonian who understands the graphical language of the club.

To those who have softened on this season's badge, put it next to a decent design then decide whether you still think it's good.

Peter Truin
117 Posted 09/08/2013 at 12:35:04
Matt Doyle 573

I made that same point before with regards to the RS to which I was questioned about why we would follow their example

I mean the biggest kit deal in premier league history can't be bad can it,what have we got,free advertising for Nike cos they give us fuck all,and kitbag whoopie fucking doo

James Marshall
118 Posted 09/08/2013 at 12:52:42
Whichever way we (you or I) spin it, Peter, Everton are not a good investment - we clearly agree on that.

There just aren't (as you rightly point out) enough people to take Executive boxes because Everton (being in Liverpool) doesn't have the same base of wealth that say, London clubs get due to all the companies based there.

There are so many reasons why we're stuck as we are, and shirt sales really isn't the point at all, as far as I can tell.

I haven't bought a shirt for years, purely because I don't want to, and don't feel the need to wear one to support my team - and that has nothing to do with cost, or wanting to support Everton financially. I just don't like wearing one. I do however, own a scarf which cost about £6 as I recall.

The thing is, the crest will change again at some point as it always has. During the 70's we just had 'EFC' as our crest - there was no graphic at all for years.

Things will change again, and people will be happier, we just have to suck it up for now because it's simply not going to change in the short term, in the same way our ability to attract an investor isn't either.

Peter Truin
119 Posted 09/08/2013 at 13:21:46
James

Agreed

Eugene Ruane
120 Posted 09/08/2013 at 13:01:32
Peter Marshall - "Personally I don't really care too much about it - we have to move with the times"

I'm sure this is NOT simply a means-absolutely-fuck-all bit of nothing-speak (like 'we need to move on') but could you go into a little more detail?

Maybe explain WHAT (in football or general terms) you believe 'the times' are and then explain why we HAVE to move with them.

Do you apply this to everything?

I WOULD contradict you on - "The thing is, the crest will change again at some point as it always has"

Fact: The crest has never changed - it has BEEN changed.

It is not a natural process, someone (nb: in the case of the recent change, a blind prick) has to actually come along and change it.

There is no metamorphosis, it's not some happenstance - it needs an idiot.

Matt Doyle
121 Posted 09/08/2013 at 13:04:34
Peter 576

Apologies I read your post, didn't have time to name check through the thread when I wrote mine!

Too right though - If Everton's crest design & branding is strong enough, it should be identifiable regardless of text or whether bits go 'missing'. Everyone recognises a Nike shirt from the swoosh regardless of whether it says "Nike" underneath.

The club said they were getting pissed off with parts of the badge being removed when reproduced by third parties which is why they opted for an all-in-one self-contained graphic. The problem is they went about it the wrong way from the start and mis-identified which parts of the badge were considered "essential", hence the loss of "Nil Satis" and the wreaths, and subsequent fan outrage. It is possible to reform the original crest into a single contained image without losing anything essential - I've mocked one up myself, but from the evidence it seems they didn't even bother trying!

As for Liverpool's kit deal compared to ours, yes it's really annoying. On the other hand have you seen that away shirt? Looks like someone ate an old Man U away shirt then vomited it out. Dunno how they're goner sell that!

Eugene Ruane
122 Posted 09/08/2013 at 13:33:33
Matt - "On the other hand have you seen that away shirt? Looks like someone ate an old Man U away shirt then vomited it out. Dunno how they're goner sell that!"

PT Barnum - "There's a sucker born every minute".

Matt Doyle
123 Posted 09/08/2013 at 13:50:55
Touché as always Eugene

heartily enjoyed reading your "Bill tells jokes to a piece of cheese & a lettuce" bit the other day

Paul O'Hanlon
124 Posted 09/08/2013 at 13:55:34
You can tell it's pre-season when a story about the new badge (which we were already aware of) being added to the side of the Main Stand get's this many comments!

I hate it too, but we're stuck with it for a season, so let's move on and see what the consultation process brings.

Mark Stone
125 Posted 09/08/2013 at 14:35:02
I don't mind it now, to be honest . When compared it with the other clubs that were in that International Champions Cup, I thought it fit in fine. I think it looks alright on the new kits, too.
Peter Truin
126 Posted 09/08/2013 at 14:33:40
Matt

I made a comment on our new away kit saying its not the worst I've seen,that award goes to the shites new away kit

Thing is mate Eugene is right,seems like every kid round here is wearing it so its obviously popular or people just don't see what's in front of them when buying something

James Marshall
127 Posted 09/08/2013 at 15:20:51
Eugene # 589

Generally I like your posts, but for this one, you haven't even managed to get my name right.

Of course someone has to change it, do you think I'm from another planet where things just magically change on their own. Your tone is piss-taking, and this thread has so far been pretty peaceful, so reign it in a bit would you, please?

The badge/crest has changed about 10 times since it's inception. Fact. What's the problem with that, exactly?

I said I don't like it, I just think there are bigger things to worry about than a club crest and the wider issue of us not having a pot to piss in happens to be something I personally think warrants more thought.

This isn't an argument or a place for you to go stomping on people's opinions with your 'look down on Peter/James Marshall' attitude, so unless you have something sensible to add, I shan't bother speaking to you any further.

So there! ;-)

As for my thoughts on 'the times', I'm talking about modern 21st century football and the marketing machine that runs it. Take a look at the crests/badges on the recent US tour, all lined up on the website and you'll see what I'm driving at. All very much simplified and actually, love it or loathe it (I dislike it), ours does actually fit in with what the rest of the World's clubs are doing.

It's not 1878 anymore.

Matt Doyle
128 Posted 09/08/2013 at 15:03:17
Agreed Peter,

I think my "how are they goner sell that" comment was a bit tongue in cheek - the perennial annoyance as we know is that some clubs have the luxury of being able to churn out any old rubbish knowing their fanbase will lap it up, and their merchandise deals guarantee substantial profits regardless of the quality of the product.

I take heart in the fact that Evertonians seem far more discerning about how we present the image of the club to the world & which merchandise we buy, and how the club benefits (or fails to!) from it's potential revenue.

Paul Columb
129 Posted 09/08/2013 at 15:31:54
They fucked up and, following the backlash, admitted it. Once the crest was decided upon, dominos would have fallen and merchandise, signage, letterhead and god knows what else ordered to be in place for the new season. Question is, should they scrap it all or make use of it to keep branding consistant for the season?

Who gives a shit....? That's their business decision to make.

I agree that the crest needed to be simplified; dropping the unneccessary 'Everton' and 1878 would likely have sufficed. A more accurate representation of Rupert's Tower was also not a bad call as the base fencing had morphed into a wrap-around escalator. The result was a disaster.

I don't see the offerings for next seson changing too much. The new tower will likely stay, but shrink a little to accomodate NSNO.....'Everton' and '1878' will remain and all will again be rebranded, including the Goodison signage at significant cost. Will everyone be satisfied....? Will we fuck. I am glad Myers will lead the effort though and do believe it will happen.

I won't make it to Goodison until mid season, so can someone post a picture of our Fisher Price stand when it's up??? I'll need a graded exposure before getting off the 19 on the Lane.

Eugene Ruane
130 Posted 09/08/2013 at 16:53:22
James Marshall (610)

I will reign nothing in, I was very specific to make a point, which is that when pressed on these empty none-specific expressions "need to move on" "move with the times" there is, imo, very little of sense or substance.

You inform me - "As for my thoughts on 'the times', I'm talking about modern 21st century football and the marketing machine that runs it. Take a look at the crests/badges on the recent US tour, all lined up on the website and you'll see what I'm driving at. All very much simplified and actually, love it or loathe it (I dislike it), ours does actually fit in with what the rest of the World's clubs are doing. It's not 1878 anymore"

This is exactly the attitude that depresses the shite out of me, a complete lack of imagination, seemingly content to follow a herd we can never catch, rather than looking at what we have that IS different and attempting to utilise it - making it a strength, something unique.

You seem pleased/content that our crest somehow 'fits in' with the others. I want the opposite, I want ours to stand out (nb: and had we left it alone, it WOULD have done).

You say 'It's not 1878 anymore'

True, but we were formed back then and have a history we can use or throw away.

Our badge can either say 'stature, history, pride' or 'look at us, we're all modern', neither gives us a trophy but to chip away at one of the things we CAN have some pride in is a fucking disgrace.

I suggest that given we play in a league we can't win, have no money and aren't in Europe - 'moving with the times' is just about the dumbest thing we could do.

As for you shan't bother speaking to me, up to you entirely, but I shall respond how I want, to what I want and if I believe something is substance-free fluff, I shall say so and endeavour to explain why.

Aiden Doyle
131 Posted 09/08/2013 at 18:21:11
I‘ve got to say that I’m inclined to agree with James on this one.

When the site hosted match previews / matchday threads during that recent tournament in the US, they used the old logo on the preview pictures on the front page. When seen side by side with the relative simplicity of some of those other badges, it really showed what an amateurish, overly complicated fustercluck the old design was.

The final implementation of new badge may leave a lot to be desired but, to me, the idea of moving to something simpler and more elegant was definitely a move in the right direction.

Peter Truin
132 Posted 09/08/2013 at 18:32:18
Aiden

The problem is not being stuck in the past,it's that badge is fucking shite

Tasteless,tacky,childish,cartoon like,the list is endless please don't defend the undefendable

And lets be honest apart from silly pre season tournaments(if this isn't a one off)when are we ever going to be put alongside juventus and Real Madrid..............never that's when because there is no ambition at our club in fact lack of ambition from our board is like they say like they say 'in our DNA'

Ross Kerry
133 Posted 09/08/2013 at 19:31:44
A lack of ambition tends to go hand in hand with a negative persona, slagging off anything that changes the status quo, even when the status quo isn't that good. So, who's got a lack of ambition? Would the club introduce a crest that's hated by 90% of the TW fans who voted just because they like a scrap? It's only for one year, unless we win something in which case it will probably be "iconic".
Mark Stone
134 Posted 09/08/2013 at 19:11:04
I see Hull City AFC have changed their name to Hull Tigers, to appeal more to the international market. Apparantly 'city' is too common. Interesting.
Ross Kerry
136 Posted 09/08/2013 at 19:55:25
Come on Peter, even Rolf Harris was iconic.
Phil Sammon
137 Posted 09/08/2013 at 19:55:25
Yep, saw that one Mark.

'City' is too common and an irrelevant moniker according to their owner. He also claimed 'the shorter the name, the better'.

So he's not only kept the 'city' but also made the name longer!

Genius.

Aiden Doyle
138 Posted 09/08/2013 at 19:58:17
Please don't try to defend the indefensible? That's probably better paraphrased as please don't try to rationalise with the irrational.
Ross Kerry
141 Posted 09/08/2013 at 20:27:39
2024: The Everton Toffees (with a wanky Fisher Price badge) win their seventh PL title at Googleson Park in 10 years. There is no longer any doubt that after 3 successive Champions League victories that this is the dominant force in world football.

Is this a vision of the future you would sign up to?

David Marsden
143 Posted 09/08/2013 at 20:26:31
I like the new badge. It's modern, relevant, and very marketable.

Ross Edwards
144 Posted 09/08/2013 at 21:45:56
"It's not 1878 anymore."

Is it not? Thanks for telling us James. I was getting worried that my time machine had broken!

Patrick Murphy
147 Posted 09/08/2013 at 23:04:10
BT must like the old badge as they seem - my eyes aren't great - to have used it as part of an advert they're running in tomorrow's Daily Mail.

I only saw a brief glimpse of it on Newsnight when they run through the front pages. If I'm wrong I'll apologise in advance.

Eugene Ruane
149 Posted 09/08/2013 at 23:49:59
David Marsden (697) - "I like the new badge. It modern, relevant, and very marketable"

Yes thank you Don Draper, so were platform shoes, but they got old and tired-looking REALLY fast (and if you wore them now you'd look a twat)

A decent pair of brogues on the other hand - never out of style!

By the way, how EXACTLY (given 22,500 Evertonians registered their disgust at the child's doodle badge) is it 'very marketable'?

For that matter, why is it 'relevant' or what/who is it relevant TO?

Very strange to think that the badge nobody had a problem with WASN'T relevant, but the one loathed by thousands of Evertonians IS.

(nb: and if that IS the case, relevance has no....relevance.)

Andrew Vernon
170 Posted 10/08/2013 at 02:06:28
Can anyone tell me how many extra fans this new badge is supposed to generate? Presumably the purpose of "branding" is to create new supporters?

For those who say that we have had numerous versions of the badge during the 70s and 80s, I have to tell you that throughout that period we had one badge – which is (in design) what it is today without the 'Everton' and '1878' addenda. On our shirts we either had nothing (my favourite) or some form of insignia like EFC BUT throughout our badge / crest was the same. If you would like proof I still have my school exercise books adorned wth said crest and Latin motto.

Karl Masters
175 Posted 10/08/2013 at 02:48:33
Getting back to the badge theme, we pretty much all agree the new one is crap, but one valid point that has been overlooked by many is that the old one was not exactly perfect either.

Bill commissioned a re-working for the millennium that added the 18, 78 and Everton to what was a badge that hadn't changed since 1938. It also went multishades of blue and I didn't like it much to tell the truth.

Point I'm making is we should be thinking about what we do want rather than just slagging the new one ( even though it deserves it ) because simply just changing it is no guarantee it will be any better. Personally, I like the simplified look of some of the designs we had on here when the new badge was first revealed.

David Marsden
176 Posted 10/08/2013 at 06:48:43
Eugene Ruane (#761):

I like it; you don't — fair enough.

Relevant — in comparison to other badges we are competing against (financially not physically).

Modern — again in a highly saturated digital media age this looks and impresses modernity.
Marketable — due to the above.

The above is true. The previous badge was a great badge. This new one is more relevant for "now".

Okay, 22k fans said they didn't like it. Change is something that the majority, in my experience, struggle to accept. The stat doesn't surprise me.

Disagree with me but don't criticise me.

IMO, having 'Everton' in the badge is a game changer. This makes us instantly recognisable and memorable to those who don't. Why do we make such an effort to encourage new, annoying the old, well, that's economics! I don't like it but accept it.

Some of those on here hate the Everton marketing department for lacking vision, this badge has vision. I'll accept, however, the application to core fans... was shite. I can understand this as in economics us core fans are generally price elastic. Meaning the club, brand, can do almost anything they want but we 'have' to continue buying.

Matthew Williams
177 Posted 10/08/2013 at 13:36:12
Am sure our board will just add "Nil Satis" to the new joke badge that we have now, for when next season rolls round... Job done as far as they're concerned!

I really like our away kit, btw, it could have been worse: we could've had what Coventry had years ago, a BROWN shirt, to match that shitty new badge!

Peter Truin
178 Posted 10/08/2013 at 16:07:39
David

Financially how are we competing against other badges? What does this mean?

As for modernity, well that's a matter of opinion. I personally believe that the club crest was modern anyway – or does modernity mean it has to look cartoon-like?

And the fact that they changed the crest without consulting the fanbase, apart from the shithouse nodding-dog gobshites from the Fans Forum, acceptance was always going to be difficult.

Man City haven't changed their crest since they got all the money so why the fuck do we need to?

I personally believe that they've been told by Nike to get it changed cos it'll be cheaper to reproduce. I'll never accept that thing as the crest of my club.

Tom Hughes
179 Posted 10/08/2013 at 17:24:20
This badge was designed in house........ they didn't commision a well known branding/marketing design team.The process was presided over by a Liverpudlian and designed by Liverpudlians..... it is a skit, a carricature. There is no obvious evolution in the design. Our badge has essentailly gone unchanged since 1938, with the basic addition of 1878 and the name.
David Marsden
180 Posted 10/08/2013 at 18:14:18
Peter #914
My reference to competing is against clubs. It's not footie any more its bullshit wanky greedy corporate business bollocks. Economics rules.
Totally agree its a matter of opinion.
Maybe this'd nodding gobshites liked it like I do.

What the fuck has City got to do with this?

I do agree with you that Nike will have been involved. I know from working with fashion houses that the cost to produce the previous badge would have been greater than this simpler new one. The cost to reproduce will be less. Of course that's a major consideration to Nike.

Tom Hughes #932
Evidence?

Andy Walker
181 Posted 10/08/2013 at 19:19:23
Why do people say "To be fair to the club"? Fair, my arse...

Did the Nuremberg trials say "To be fair to Adolf and his board they did have a huge back stock of Zyklon B, it had to be used."

This is the mindset of some fans. Very embarrassing. To compare the changing of our badge to the Nazis......
Words fail me.

Matt Traynor
182 Posted 10/08/2013 at 18:16:01
Peter #914, when the new design was leaked, a couple of months before the official announcement, a poster on here who worked for a client of Nike said it was due to the current badge being expensive to reproduce. Everton also released a short video to explain the rationale, and also suggested the cost issue.
Tom Hughes
183 Posted 10/08/2013 at 19:22:22
David,

I am a shareholder, and attended the meeting with Robert Elstone, and the Shareholders Association just days before the official unveiling. The badge issue was discussed at length (but not shown to us). The design team are employees of the club, and they were led by our former communications officer (a Liverpudlian) who boasted openly about his input and how well he felt it would be received.

I asked was it the image that was leaked on various websites, because if so I didn't share his confidence one bit......... Days later the perpetrator was given his cards.

The only sample consultation was with a few members of staff and the Fans Forum membership..... A very poorly planned and executed process. The whole marketing angle is a complete red herring to attempt to hide the blunders and nonsense that is the new badge......... simple as!!

Ron Sear
184 Posted 10/08/2013 at 20:25:54
It could be worse, think of the poor Hull City fans having their club renamed with a soon to be extinct animal. 'Everton Aardvarks' anybody?
Eugene Ruane
185 Posted 10/08/2013 at 20:44:58
Ron (986) - I like 'Everton Aaardvarks'.

I understand why Hull supporters would be pissed off, as Tigers are kinda big and hairy and stripey yeah?

Too much going on imo (teeth, hair, stripes, ears, yaaawn)

Design-wise, the tiger is an over complicated clusterfuck

I mean there's a reason they're almost extinct - HELLOOO!!

(if they wore shoes they would wear brogues and brogues are shit because...I say they are).

Aardvarks are imo better designed.

When they 'ball-up', they fit in with other well know animals that ball-up, like Porcupines and Hedgehogs.

Aardvark are modern, relevant, and very marketable probably.

Don't agree, fine - let's just...move on, yeah?

Patrick Murphy
186 Posted 10/08/2013 at 21:03:38
Aardvark is a character in the Pink Panther Show and he's blue. What if a Tiger wore Sandals And White socks would that help or hinder its chances of survival?
Tommy Meehan
187 Posted 10/08/2013 at 22:34:16
Eugene, finally a bit of common sense on this issue. Aardvarks are exactly what this club needs to “take it to the next level”, but unfortunately some fans (a mere 90-95%) still think “it’s 1878 or the 1980s”. I mean Tigers are rooted stagnantly in the “past”, while Aardvarks gambol victoriously in the “future”.

Aardvarks “know how to get things done” and “move with the times”. They are sleek, eye-catching and RELEVANT. Tigers, on the other hand, are too busy having poems written about them in the 18th century (i.e. THE PAST). Actually I wouldn’t be surprised to find out that Tigers are in Latin!

Phil Bellis
192 Posted 11/08/2013 at 02:01:40
David Marsden...
I wish I was as sure of anything as you are about everything

Aardvarks never hurt anyone

Coat donned

Peter Mills
194 Posted 12/08/2013 at 22:28:38
Eugene # 761 "A decent pair of brogues...- never out of style". # 990 "Brogues are shit". Perhaps brogues are the Martin Dobson of the shoe world?
Steven Sturm
195 Posted 12/08/2013 at 23:06:49
Oh, they're shoes.

As for the new badge - I think it works as an Icon on my phone, but needs work for anything larger than a square centimeter.

Matt Geraghty
196 Posted 13/08/2013 at 08:18:05
I personally think we should be much more concerned about the mediocre new manager and the second-rate players he seems to want to fill our team with.

The club crest/ badge is shit, so what? I support Everton, not the badge.

Norman McIlwain
197 Posted 13/08/2013 at 13:33:53
I always thought the image of an old lock-up on the badge rather strange. It is only there because it is the oldest building. We should be nicknamed 'The Jailbirds' (as opposed to The Liverbirds!)'. It's like having an image of Walton Jail on the badge. Is that the best?

The motto I like.

Anthony Newell
198 Posted 14/08/2013 at 20:19:00
@451

You mean, like Keith Wyness?

Have to agree with the opinion that we shouldn't trust a word that comes from these dopes

'Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me'

Paul Gladwell
199 Posted 14/08/2013 at 20:53:05
Norman that tower has been on the badge since 1938 I'm sure the reason they put it on was because it was a focal point of the area we are named after and that it also stood close to Mother Nobletts and not because it was the oldest building.
Kev Wood
200 Posted 15/08/2013 at 12:53:15
I just had a quick flick through the 150 comments on here- I can't see anybody who has said how long the existing badges have been on the main stand for — I can't recall how long myself. Does anybody know? I want to include it in my next general knowledge quiz right after 'Which genius from the world of science invented the cat flap?' Roll on 3pm Saturday!
Ross Kerry
201 Posted 17/08/2013 at 02:34:52
I can't believe my views on brogues have been censored. They are shit.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb