Martinez: Baines issue is closed

, 14 August, 137comments  |  Jump to most recent
Boss believes rejected United offer was final
Roberto Martinez says he believes that Manchester United will not be pursuing Leighton Baines any further this summer after an initial bid, believed to be £12m, was rejected out of hand by Everton last month.

The Blues' manager told the Liverpool Echo that any reports of United returning with a higher offer for the 28-year-old since then has been pure speculation as Everton consider the matter closed.

CEO Robert Elstone said as much at the first supporter event in San Francisco and Martinez has reiterated the Blues' stance that the focus with regard to Baines is very much now on preparing for the coming season.

“Before we went to Austria one club officially contacted ourselves with an offer and it was a final offer," he said.

“They put something over and the valuation wasn't anywhere near the quality of Leighton Baines. That was the end of it but since then there's been all the speculation, which has been part of what the transfer window is.

“There's never been another club or anyone else putting in an offer for Leighton. Since then we've moved on and we're continuing to focus on the start of the season.”

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (137)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Matt Traynor
1 Posted 14/08/2013 at 08:52:43
Doesn't exactly mean the matter is closed is it? Especially as the Red Echo's big brother paper The Mirror has been championing this move for 2 seasons now.

Still, if Man U said the offer was final, who am I to disbelieve that? I mean they told us they only contacted OFM for the job when Taggart had to bring forward his retirement announcement, didn't they?

Mark Tanton
2 Posted 14/08/2013 at 08:55:52
I'd like to hear more about plans to bring other players in, and less about those meant to be on their way out.

We're being outspent by just about everyone again and will probably start with Leon Osman in midfield on Saturday - we're desperately short.

Phil Walling
3 Posted 14/08/2013 at 08:55:04
I read Evra has had an outstanding close season which has pleased OFM, so I`m reasonably relaxed about the Baines situation.

Fellaini is another matter. I think we shall have to wait until about 7 days before the window closes for the bidding fun to start. The Mancs could afford to pay £25-£30Mil for the Big Man but Moyes being Moyes, he will probably start at £18M.

Kenwright being Kenwright, he`ll probably accept whatever`s on the table at 11:50 pm on 2 September!

Mark Tanton
4 Posted 14/08/2013 at 09:04:26
If Moyes comes in late for Fellaini it will be hard to stomach - how can his dithering still fuck us over from beyond the Goodison grave?
Mike Keating
5 Posted 14/08/2013 at 08:59:17
No matter how frustrating it is to see our targets going to the likes of Norwich and Cardiff (FFS), I can't see how we can get players in without selling first. As the window closes options diminish and prices go up especially if we suddenly have £20m+ to spend.
Simon Bell
6 Posted 14/08/2013 at 09:13:06
It always makes me laugh when I see people comment on other teams signing our "targets". Can we please get it into our heads that these people are 99% of the time fabricated rumours by the media to attract football fans to their sites, buy papers etc. Yes these teams have spent money on player, but in all honesty who'd heard of the players the RS have bought?

I personally think we've done well in the market so far and if Fellaini does get sold then at least it will make transfer deadline day a bit more interesting for us to whinge about more players we're supposed to be chasing that we don't sign!

Sam Higgins
7 Posted 14/08/2013 at 09:44:08
I imagine the £12M offered was Baines was intended to get the player to force a move through when the offer was rejected. Fucking ginger shithouse. As for Felli, if an offer comes in within 7 days of the window closing it should be rejected whatever as we won't have time to replace
Kevin Tully
8 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:05:39
The issue won't be resolved until Baines signs a new contract, which is under negotiation this summer.
Thomas Lennon
9 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:17:26
This is an illustration why the end of the transfer window needs to coincide with the start of the season. We have 2 - 3 weeks of unsettled teams to get through with frantic deals playing out after several matches have been played. Those hoping for a move will be soft pedalling.

How do we properly plan for a transfer request coming in from one of our players on 30th August? Wait till January?

Andrew Bone
10 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:23:32
Said it once and I'll say it again: After the way we have been treated, I would hope BK would tell Man Utd not to come back as we are unwilling to do business with them.

I will be so pissed off to see Ossie starting in midfield Saturday. I thought we would've bought another player by now so I'm guessing the BT money has gone towards the debt.

I hope the youngsters can fill the void when our I injuries pick up.

Peter Thistle
11 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:47:39
If it's closed, offer him a new contract and get it sorted.
Chris Matheson
12 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:43:18
Once again, everything boils down to our Board.

Having put no money into the club, their only financial strategy is to sell assets. Other clubs know this, they know we have to sell, which means our bargaining position is crippling weak and we cannot drive prices up. I would like to think that the additional tv money would keep the wolves from the door in respect of player sales, but probably that's already being used to pay off other debts.

So it will be the board's financial ineptitude that will decide who and when we sell.

What saddens me the most about this situation is the way so many blues accept it on face value. They accept that we have no money and have to sell instead of asking WHY we have no money and WHY we have to sell. They excuse selling our top players on the grounds that it will "pay off the debt" ; but it never does, does it, because the reason for the debt is still there.

So until we get in a board that knows how to run a football club we will have the same problem every season where other clubs circle like vultures to pluck off our best players at cut price rates. Watch this space, as they say.

Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:54:44
Find it strange only Moyes has come in for Baines and not a sniff for Fellaini - wonder why?
Ciarán McGlone
14 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:58:11
Aye, the matters closed...er...until it's opened again.
Dean Barton
15 Posted 14/08/2013 at 10:44:09
Some people give me ass ache I swear!

Osman has been our most consistent MF for the last 12 months. The lad dies for the cause on a weekly basis and is Everton through and through. He is the only MF we have that fits the RM mould. Quick-footed with an eye for a pass and will take the ball when under pressure.

All I read is that we should play sicknote Gibson and "I'll turn up when I want" Fellaini, the same Fellaini that flicked the V-signs at our crowd last year and has been talking up a move for 12 months.

If we are talking about dropping anyone because of form then how about Baines. The lad is the best left back in the world but where has he been this pre-season. In most games he has been anonymous and against Real Betis he reminded me of Rhino, turn toward the touchline and hoof it. He did it over and over again. Nobody can tell me that Oviedo has not been more impressive this summer.

I agree that the MF needs strengthening but get off Ossie's back for Christ's sake. The people that moan about Ossie all the time are probably the same people that say Kone's 14 goals last year doesn't make him good enough and he was partly at fault for Wigan's relegation. Oh yeah, these same people say Jelavic is good enough, a man who scored 2 goals in 20 apps in a top 6 side.

Let's get real people, the only thing we need to worry about right now is why we have only spent a pittance on players on less wages than the ones before, and yet we have more income this year than ever. If the club has no transfer budget, and no plans to sell anybody, then why hasn't RM come out and said that our business is over and he is happy with the squad, barring sales? I think there is more to come but I think we will leave it late!

The RS have brought in more money through sales then they have spent. Chelsea, Arsenal, Man Utd and us are still to do business. The last few days of the window are going to be the best for years for the press!!

Maybe not so much for us?!

Dean Barton
16 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:08:53
Barry 998,

Maybe it's because he isn't as good as he thinks he is. If Man Utd go for Fellaini, then that proves they are desperate, to me. He is not and never will be up to that standard!

Ciarán McGlone
17 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:12:44
"Osman has been our most consistent MF for the last 12 months."

--------------------------------

Aye dead consistent...apart from the fact that he was crap for the second half of the season. Osman cannot hold onto the ball consistently, tries to do too much, can't shoot, can't head, dribbles himself into trouble and his passing is usually suspect...but apart from that, he dies for the club every week.

James Martin
18 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:12:22
Dean actually watching the game to form an opinion of players rather than just looking at their price tag or nationality is not a common thing anymore sadly. You could not be more right about Osman and Fellaini and sometimes even Baines yet you'll probably be shot down for it. Osman was fantastic at the start of last season and carried Neville for months yet as soon as fatigue set in as he was overplayed everyone jumped gleefully upon it like the favourite scapegoat he is.

Shock horror I'll bet he'll form a key part of Martinez's team just as he was under Moyes and that will be two good managers along with Hodgson who have rated him.

Barry Rathbone
19 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:15:27
Dean, 990 and 991 I think you may have nailed it.
Kevin Tully
20 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:15:29
Dean #990, you say ;

"The lad is the best left back in the world but where has he been this pre season."

Now read that back to yourself, and go and have a lie down.

Christine Foster
21 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:10:20
A year or so ago, I penned a view regarding the demise of Moyes and the most likely impact. A cheaper Moyes brought in, best players sold off with poorer versions brought in, BK not spending and the gullible prepared to wait and see if the new man can pull off a miracle. He won't.

More money to the banks means less debt. Less debt means more money will go to the shareholders when the club gets sold. Guess who profits from a reluctance to spend if we sell?

So, where is the money if it's really available? Porkies?

The sound of hands rubbing together fills the boardroom..

Get the sodding cheque book out.

Jamie Barlow
22 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:25:35
If you read the whole paragraph Kevin "If we are talking about dropping anyone because of form then how about Baines. The lad is the best left back in the world but where has he been this pre season. In most games he has been anonymous and against Real Betis he reminded me of Rhino, turn toward the touchline and hoof it. He did it over and over again. Nobody can tell me that Oviedo has not been more impressive this summer."

What's wrong with that? No lie down needed.

Dean Barton
23 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:23:53
Ciaran 992

Please explain to me who in the last 12 months has been more consistent in MF? Gibson is never fit for long enough to be relied upon, Neville was finished and Fellaini played there a handful of times and always looked better up front. So please explain to me with the current MF's that we have, why Osman doesn't deserve to be in the team. I agree we need better, but with what we have he is a shoe-in!

James 993,

Completely agree, Osman was a victim of the never rotate system that Moyes used.

Kevin 995,

My point is that his form has been poor......Why? He was brilliant at times last season but since March or April hasn't looked like the same player. If you think that form doesn't matter then I suggest you head butt a wall a few times until your tunnel vision disappears.

Kevin Tully
24 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:36:50
So Baines is shit now because of his pre-season (getting match fit) form?

Feck me, without doubt the largest serving of tripe ever posted on these boards.

Our LEFT BACK and PLAYER OF THE SEASON was our most prolific attacking threat last season - oh sorry, change that to 'The player who made the most chances in any European League.'

I'm off. Ta ra.

Jim Knightley
25 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:42:41
Pre-season means nothing...I would have thought every season would have been an indication of that. It's good for seeing how teams set up, but not a barometer of form, because some players cant motivate themselves for friendlies, some players need to be fitter, and the games are played at a lower intensity which benefits players of a certain type. Mauro Boselli is the perfect example of misguided pre-season notions... scored tons of goals two seasons running...and wasnt in the picture when it began for real.

Baines is our best player...and our best creator. Oviedo is not as good going forward...or in defense, and doesn't have his experience. Would you swap Messi for Pedro, because Messi looked out of sorts in pre-season?

Steve Guy
26 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:45:28
Baines should be first name on the team sheet if fit... end of. Don't understand this anti Felli verbiage... again no-brainer if fit. Osman is awesome when allowed time on the ball and can be a real handful when playing in the hole behind Jelavic but too inconsistent and when not allowed time on the ball usually loses it (Real Betis game a classic in this regard). Moyes played him too often last season and he was knackered so, as he already lacks pace, he faded badly.
Dean Barton
27 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:45:55
Kevin 001,

Of course I don't think we should drop him. My point was about picking players based on pre season form. Should we say that Jelavic pre season form doesn't matter and he is still as shit as last season? This mindset also means that all the talk about Kone having a bad pre season is pointless too. How about Stones and Oviedo.....should we discredit their good performances this pre season too and say we have absolutely no idea how we will play.

Remember we were only getting match fit!!!!

Peter Cummings
28 Posted 14/08/2013 at 11:54:58
As much as I have always admired Bainsy and rate him as top left back in the country, I think he should have come out with a statement of his own, yet to date he has made no comment whatsoever. Something like his feelings about the club the fans and the city, for example, would go down well. And as far as ''the transfer matter is closed'' statement goes, I won't beleive it is until the fat lady sings.
Tony J Williams
29 Posted 14/08/2013 at 12:21:22
Can we ban the phrase "Get real!"?

Thanks

Drew Shortis
30 Posted 14/08/2013 at 12:19:16
This news sounds encouraging and it should be the ideal opportunity to use some of the freed up wages to give Baines the pay rise he deserves and put the speculation to bed for good.

Its possible Fellaini could still be off, and I hope Martinez has several replacements lined up if this does happen. As we saw with the four he got in early on he can move quickly if he has the funds. The lack of activity since them is a clear sign that the limited budget he had to spend was used up on Kone and Roubles. Both were essential signings. Where else would Everton pick up a proven PL striker for £5-6m? I hope Jelavic continues his good form, but we couldn't gamble on that so it made sense for Martinez to get another striker in.

Unfortunately it looks like he had the choice between a striker or a central / defensive midfielder and could not afford both. Perhaps he was expecting an earlier bid for Fellaini and had planned to bring in midfield players with the proceeds. As I see it if Fellaini stays we have a strong starting midfield but little in the way of cover. If he goes we will be a little weaker in midfield but we can add some competition and depth. I'm torn between which is better, but as deadline day nears the decision may be made for us with a big bid. Having paid £15m for the lad we should stand our ground and demand the release fee figure as a minimum, especially if players like McCarthy are looking to cost £12-15m.

Still some drama to come me thinks!

Tony J Williams
31 Posted 14/08/2013 at 12:42:08
As someone already mentioned, if the Mancs come in for Fellaini near the end of the window, tell them it's too late so do one. (We all know this will happen, as it's Bill's MO to get the money in the bank not back into the team.)
Ciarán McGlone
32 Posted 14/08/2013 at 12:43:16
Dean,

What about Junior or Barkley? Oviedo could also do a very good job in the middle..

You complain about Moyes sticking to an intransigent plan... but then adopt the same mentality.

Ian Edwards
33 Posted 14/08/2013 at 12:47:19
Don't be surprised to see our former Manager trying to raid us on deadline day. Especially if Man Utd have a bad start to the league season and he's under pressure to bring in new players.

Paul O'Hanlon
34 Posted 14/08/2013 at 13:14:19
All summer I've been of the opinion that if a good enough offer comes in for Felli (and Baines to a certain extent) then we sell, move on and quickly.

But it's 3 days before the start of the season. Utd and others have left it too late. If either players want to leave they have left it too late too, they could have handed in a transfer request by now and waved their right to a loyalty bonus, but they haven't so the club needs to be single minded.

As for where the hell all this extra TV money is for new signings...Welcome to the "Everton Way" Roberto

Paul O'Hanlon
35 Posted 14/08/2013 at 13:27:30
And without singling out any player, our centre midfield looks poor. We're lacking both bite and creativity IMO.
Richard Reeves
36 Posted 14/08/2013 at 13:28:39
I think Moyes will come in with a last-minute bid for Fellaini, Baines or both. I even think it has been agreed between Moyes and Kenwright before he left. When it happens, there will be no time to spend again; most of the money will go somewhere else with a small amount like maybe £5-8 mill retained for January.

Forget about the record TV rights deal, when the window closes, it will turn out that we didn't really spend anything. Just my opinion, a gut feeling if you like... or maybe years of this same spin.

Colin Glassar
37 Posted 14/08/2013 at 15:00:04
I've always said Bainsey would stay. Now we need to tie him down to a long term contract to keep the wolves at bay. Apparently, we've put a £30m price tag on Fellaini, after the buy-out clause expired, so unless OFM or wenger become totally desperate I can see him staying as well. I just hope we can get a player or two in on loan to further strengthen the squad (Martinez has said he'd like more players) as it looks like the well has dried up again.
Iain Johnston
38 Posted 14/08/2013 at 14:20:44
Baines, Peinaar and Osman were all run into the ground last season. Using them sparingly in pre season has hopefully allowed them to rest, I think they will all start at Norwich.
I believe RM will use them differently as in allowing the likes of Oviedo, Barkley etc more game time. They were part of a team last season which finished sixth but now they're not good enough? I don't believe that.

Why do we still bang on about spending money when having a short sighted, blinkered, tight fisted board is the only thing we can rely on?
I like Martinez, he will get my full support but I think the only thing that will change on the pitch is the playing style. The results, performances and league places will remain the same until we start to by real quality and that wont happen til BK is carried out in a box.

Pablo Connelly
39 Posted 14/08/2013 at 15:08:56
Ciaran (014). Did you really just suggest using an as yet inexperienced left back in oviedo, a young lad who has no premiership experience in junior or an attacking midfielder in barkley as plausable options to replace osman in a defensive midfield position? Seriously? I am not
Shane Corcoran
40 Posted 14/08/2013 at 15:20:05
Pablo, one of the cooler names on TW of late.
Phil Bellis
41 Posted 14/08/2013 at 15:32:07
Not as cool, though, as Everton de Viña del Mar
Ben Dyke
42 Posted 14/08/2013 at 15:22:34
Its daylight robbery that the extra income has disappeared in a black hole. Can't wait for the accounts that will no doubt be heavily massaged to cover up all expenditure trails. How will the board avoid it all over again? Its so gutting to watch the smaller teams continue to outspend us because they don't have the same accumulated debt we do.

Anyway, I believe what Kenwright was quoted as telling fans recently "no one else coming in" and maybe some sales. Sums it a up. Getting sick of it.

It's good news but Baines should have come out earlier to make a definitive decision. Hope his head turns back once season starts but the window closing after season starts is ridiculous for a club like ours. It's OK for the big boys who already have enough of a squad but for us, you could start and then see heart ripped out of a team.

Tony Draper
43 Posted 14/08/2013 at 16:49:45
I really do hope that the "Baines Issue" is now closed... yet, without the "Hallelujah!" moment of a new hefty contract offered and signed by Lord Leighton, then sadly my breath is still baited

For now, I would definitely be wanting two centre-mid loans because:

1) Gibbo is sound BUT picks up injuries (not bumps 'n' knocks) frequently;
2) As a result of #1, Fellaini is our "Obi Wan Kenobi" in centre-mid;
3) The Big Fellai is subject to transfer speculation, picks up yellow cards, and is not automatically immune to injury.

Therefore, two loans NOW, means we have "in-squad cover" from the kick-off. So, if Fellaini gets sold last second, when Gibbo is lame, we still have replacements with the option to buy, not play, or send back, as needs dictate.

Drew Shortis
44 Posted 14/08/2013 at 16:49:02
Ciarán 014

Junior looks like he could be a tidy player, but he looks a little lighweight for me at the moment, needs to be brought through with a quite a few substitute appearances when the game allows.

Oviedo looks like a decent, pacey left side player, but he is also too lightweight for central / defensive midfield.

Barkley is the most likely of the three to be used in the middle, but I think Martinez see's his role as a more attacking midfielder. Perhaps when he has had more playing time and is more confident with his short passing he could drop deeper and I'm sure he would work hard if called on, but he isn't a Rodwell type player.

I still think that, despite being another Wiganer, McCarthy would be ideal for us as a central midfield dynamo. We also need a Carsley type battler. A player of this type should be easier and cheaper to find.

I wonder if Martinez is waiting for deadline day to see if we hang on to Fellaini before he brings in a couple of midfielders on loan. There must be a few out there who would be good backup for Fellaini and Gibson, the sort of player who has been pushed down the pecking order at their clubs by flashy new signings and who would jump at the chance of a season at Goodison. If Fellaini leaves we reinvest in a couple of quality players, if he stays we get some backup on loan. Sound plausible?

Ian Burns
45 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:09:16
I have just noticed on Sky Bet that Fellaini is 2/7 to leave this transfer window.

Is this old news or do they know something we don't?

Kevin Tully
46 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:13:12
Ian – Bill will want Fellaini gone ASAP so he won't be outspent by every other team in the division come 2nd September.

It's only a matter of time before he is off to Old Trafford. The only stumbling block is the fee.

Dean Barton
47 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:02:25
Ciaran 14

Is your hatred for Osman such that you would rather play an unproven left back in midfield? While we are at it why don't we play Anichebe in goal and Tony Hibbert up front!

Phil Bellis
48 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:18:46
"If Fellaini leaves we reinvest in a couple of quality players.."

Not at 23:55 31/08 we won't

Paul Andrews
49 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:25:04
If Baines is staying Fellaini is off.
The chairmans arse will be carried now in case we can't attract a buyer.
Colin Glassar
50 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:27:58
Drew, I think Martinez wants McCarthy because he is the master of the short, crisp, passing game which is vital for his style of transition play. Fellaini is brilliant running with the ball, while Gibson is a great passer of said ball. All three of them in the midfield could be the making of a new Holy Trinity as they would all complement each other perfectly. I can but dream.
Harold Matthews
51 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:21:44
With regard to all this "lightweight" business.

The best defensive midfielder I ever saw was 5'-7" tall and weighed in at a paltry 10st-5lbs.
Yes, you guessed it. ...The great Claude Makelele.

Of course, such was his anticipation, he seldom put in crunching tackles. He just pinched the ball which, done properly, is almost an art form.
The only other guy I've seen with this particular ability is Oscar, the Brazilian matchstick. He did it to young Barkley at Goodison who was blamed for losing possession. I felt sorry for Ross. Oscar does it all the time....and to more experienced players.

Tony Rice
52 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:06:18
Translation:
1. Baines doesn't want to go....
2. Fellaini is off ....

Pretty much same preseason as ever.... late sale, money disappears. New TV money? Arteta money? Money from our fake Jan bids?

Nice to see RM playing the kids, because we have to.... Prem's smallest squad.

Bill Gall
53 Posted 14/08/2013 at 17:41:14
Why if Fallaini is sold for say £30M do supporters expect that the manager will be able to buy a couple of replacement midfielders?

From what I have read, transfer money is not given to the selling club in a lump sum. The fee is usually in a down payment with money to follow depending on appearances, goals scored, league position and trophies won.

Going on this assumption, if he is sold, I expect Martinez after the bank recieves a payment to be given about £8M. With this amount, he will be expected to replace one of the league's best midfielders.

I will say it again: selling our best players will never improve the team.

Colin Glassar
54 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:16:43
Bill, you basically explained it yourself. We won't see the £30M in the bank the next day, neither will any of the clubs whose players we could buy. It's all smoke and mirrors and lots of I Owe Yous.
Paul Andrews
55 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:28:36
Bill Gall,

Could we not use the same method to buy players? Down payment... then stage payments?

Paul Landon
56 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:23:58
Holy Trinity? When will Everton supporters stop harping on about the past? It's irrelevant, move on for god's sake.

By the way how many trophies did that three win for Everton? Not much more than Moyes did. We are delusional at times.

We need some skill in the middle of the park and we need another striker. I think we will be fine.

I worry about the style of play; Swansea are the most boring side I have ever seen with more passes than anyone in their own half... Wigan similar. I don't want that style of play; I want attacking wing play which we have the players to do that with.

Time will tell but I am pessimistic at the moment. Get it right with the players we have and I can see a top four challenge, no problem.

Denis Richardson
57 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:38:40
I see Fellaini is currently 2/7 on to leave and only 5/2 against to stay. Bookies not always right but I will be very surprised if the fro is with us come September.

If we get £20M+, Man Utd are welcome to him (assuming RM gets a good chunk to reinvest).

Trevor Lynes
58 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:55:10
I fully agree with Christine and we are being out spent by ALL the clubs who finished below us last season. Ironically it's the likes of Man Utd and Arsenal who are not spending!! Teams like Hull and Sunderland are putting our miserly board to shame and I can see the dark hair of Martinez turning grey very quickly!!

Investment by the fans is all we can count on; they buy the merchandise and pay to watch. The major shareholders will hang on to what they have and hope that Roberto can follow in Moyes's footsteps. I do not see any major signings unless we sell Fellaini.

Harold Matthews
59 Posted 14/08/2013 at 18:34:38
My God. What a thread. My head is whirling.
Black holes, Daylight robbery, Christine with a big stick, Dried up wells, Obi Wan Kenobi, Bill's arse in a box, Smoke, Mirrors, The Holy Trinity and Victor in goal.
Time for a lie down.
Iain Johnston
60 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:18:55
Nice one Harold!, diverse aren't we?
Simon Temme
61 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:10:00
Phil 078, Tony 095.

Spot on both.....how many years are we going to have to put up with this opportunism from BK and the board.

I hope you're both wrong but going on past experience get ready for Felli black hole on deadline day with no time to invest and say 5-6mill for January.

Happy days.

Paul Andrews
62 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:26:37
Simon Temme,

"You can fool some of the people all of the time.
You can fool all of the people some of the time.
But you can't fool all of the people all of the time"

Unless they are Evertonians.

Raymond Fox
63 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:21:47
I think you're right, Dennis, it looks pretty ominous to me also, 5/2 a big price if he's not certain to go!
Bill Gall
64 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:19:46
Paul Andrews.

We tried that with Fer but his club would not accept £1M down with the rest over 5 years and free West End theatre tickets.

As well as a number of other supporters on this thread, my problem is with the board – in either spending or providing funding to the team. This was highlited in January last year and with the small amount spent this year.

Matt Traynor
65 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:34:56
2 points to add:

If you know the buying club is desperate, you can demand the entire amount up front. Newcastle famously did this to Liverpool knowing full well they'd sold Torres to Chelsea. Now Bill could be brave for once here - especially if OFM is yet to make a significant signing for Man U.

As things stand, Fulham could yet spend less than us. They've spent on Skeltenberg (sp?) officially undisclosed but believed to be £3m. They may yet hijack QPR for Scott Parker for £3.5m from Tottenham which will put them about level with us?

Colin Glassar
66 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:38:51
The more I think about the more I believe that Boys Pen Bill is actually........ The Antichrist in disguise.

Just joking, BPB, I'm sure you are a good Christian sole.

Phil Sammon
67 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:32:58
There's been a few post recently about Evertonians accepting BK and even supporting him. I'm sure that's the case with a very small number of fans. Better the devil you know and all that. However it's pretty tiresome to see the more informed fans treat these people as idiots and clapping seals. These people need educating, not mocking. If this club is ever going to get anywhere we need to unite and boot the current incumbents out of Goodison Park.
James Stewart
68 Posted 14/08/2013 at 19:44:20
You can bet your bottom dollar gollum will come a bidding on deadline day same as when he always does his transfer business.
Kevin Tully
69 Posted 14/08/2013 at 20:02:05
Some figures for Bill's supporters to mull over - we receive approx £4m a year from Chang and approx £3m a year from Kitbag.

Both these payments are cancelled out by the interest payments each year of £7m.

He's a blue, though, so that makes it OK.

Thomas Lennon
71 Posted 14/08/2013 at 20:13:21
Loans cost £3 - 4 million according to 2012 accounts.

Kitbag deal promises a guaranteed £3-4 million up to a certain amount of profits. After that target has been reached we have no details what happens - further payments may well result.

Kitbag had large up front expenditure too - keep things in perspective.

Kevin Tully
72 Posted 14/08/2013 at 20:21:47
Thomas - the club operate under three companies ; Everton football club, Goodison park Stadium ltd and Everton investments.

Combined interest over the past 5 years add up to over £35m = £7m per season.

NOT included would be arrangement fees etc. for the likes of the Vibrac loan, and other short term finance that has kept the club afloat.

Is that enough perspective for you?

Paul Andrews
73 Posted 14/08/2013 at 20:56:08
Phil Sammon,

"We need to unite and boot the current incumbents out of Goodison Park."

I agree 100%. What's our first move?

Paul Loins
74 Posted 14/08/2013 at 21:20:58
I wonder what all the Moyes fans will say when he comes in on deadline day with a low offer for Baines and Fellaini? Maybe they will support him even though he knew he was leaving for months and went on about waiting to see if we got European football before signing a new deal. I for one didn't cheer him after his last game managing Everton and was embarrassed to hear Everton fans chanting his name.
Roger Helm
76 Posted 14/08/2013 at 21:40:49
We will have a better midfield this season because I think RM will rotate the players better. The EPL is too demanding to play every game, but Gollum picked the same team every week, with Osman getting older, Gibbo half fit and Fellaini demotivated - his only plan B was; winning - bring on a defender for a forward, losing - play Fellaini up front for a bit of hoofball. We have some good young players to bring on like Barklay, Ovieda, Junior, etc. They may be inexperienced, it there's only one place to get experience.
Ross Edwards
77 Posted 14/08/2013 at 21:49:36
I know you'd like it to be closed Robbie, but Moyes will make a double bid on deadline day, so just be ready.
Drew Shortis
78 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:04:09
Tom Huddlestone has just gone to Hull on an undisclosed fee. Tidy player and the sort of player who would have given Gibson some competition. I take the undisclosed fee to mean it isn't a huge fee. Livermore on loan too, though I doubt Spurs would have considered loaning him to a rival team.

If Fellaini does go there is still one Keisuke Honda at CSKA with six months left on his contract, which means that we can discuss a free transfer for him in January if he agrees to terms now! Alternatively, if Fellaini goes it sounds like he would be available for a reasonable fee. All the more reason for Fellaini / Man Utd to stick or twist now so we don't miss out on another player. I will be fuming if they leave it to deadline day!

Ross Edwards
79 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:16:39
I'm afraid he might be heading to Milan Drew.

Scott Parker anyone?

Ciarán McGlone
80 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:08:32
Drew,

You suggest both Junior and Oviedo are too 'lightweight' when being considered for centre midfield. However that seems like a rather odd critique whenever the debate is about replacing Osman who would have difficulty contending with a leaf blower..

As for the idea that Oviedo is only a left sided player...In some of the games I have seen him play for us (and i'll admit he hasnt had many) - he has switched between the left and right. I think he's pretty much equipped to be effective as a central midfielder..

And this is not about a deep lying midfield role...that's not the position Osman plays. Barkley is an absolute shoe-in for the role.

Dean,

If you have a problem with my critique Osman, then try and articluate it - rather than coming up with unimaginative, lazy and frankly childish stuff about my 'hatred' for him...

Ross Edwards
81 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:19:34
"Pablo, one of the cooler names on TW of late."

Who can forget Paolo Hogerio, who claimed to have photos of Howie and Bill meeting with Bielsa in Bilbao?

Mark Frere
82 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:16:25
Drew

Tom Huddlestone is Gibson mark 2, he's a deep lying midfielder with a good range of passing, he's less mobile than Gibson and injury prone. So I think we need a more mobile tough tackling midfielder. Also, we need a midfield enforcer like Honda.... but I can't see us competing with the likes of Milan for his signiture

Ross Edwards
83 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:31:00
What about Scott Parker?
Jamie Barlow
84 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:28:11
Who says Fellaini is off if Baines stays? Has Martinez made noises of wanting to sign any more players? He might be perfectly happy with what he has. Frightening.
Colin Glassar
85 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:34:51
What about Scott Parker? Does he come with a Zimmer frame Ross?
Ross Edwards
86 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:37:41
Forget that suggestion. He's going to join Wheeler Dealer 'Appy 'Arry at QPR.

Diame?

Mark Frere
88 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:47:47
Ross

Diame supposedly wants to stay in London, last time I heard. Shame if true, he would be perfect for a measly £3.5 million.

Ross Edwards
89 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:51:07
Shame Huddlestone, Capoue and Medel have moved on, any of them would have been good.
Mark Frere
90 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:52:12
Shame we haven't got a pot to piss in, Ross. This is the reality of being a Everton fan under the stewardship of BK and his cronies.
Ross Edwards
91 Posted 14/08/2013 at 22:55:22
It is sadly Mark, can't see that changing unless drastic action is taken.
Robin Cannon
92 Posted 14/08/2013 at 23:36:43
@Drew (164) - Now you made me think about how great Honda could be for us, so I can get depressed that there's no chance of it happening.
Colin Williams
93 Posted 14/08/2013 at 23:15:01
Ciaran, great points you make concerning Oviedo and Junior. These two very talented players could fill central midfield roles within our team. There is no substitute for talent and they certainly have that!!

It beggars belief how Osman still gets selected!!! There are better performing players within our squad, also the U21s are full of talented m/f players. I would be happy to see Oviedo playing on left side or central mid in a two or three on a regular basis. I believe Junior should be brought into first team squad to maximise his potential.

The one player who will hopefully play on a regular basis is Barkley, he is a special talent who with the right type of players around him can make our future bright.

Jamie Sweet
94 Posted 14/08/2013 at 23:37:01
The moment Bill used the press conference when Martinez became manager to mention "we've got a lad with a buy-out clause that everyone is aware of" it became very clear that he wants to cash in on the big-haired Belgian.

Make no mistake, we are still in a situation where we need to sell assets to keep the banks happy.

Just on a side note: can you really imagine a midfield of Fellaini and Huddlestone? There would be so much hair that there wouldn't be enough room on the pitch for the other 20 players!

Patrick Murphy
95 Posted 15/08/2013 at 00:06:20
it might have made use of all those recently acquired lawnmowers though Jamie.
Mark Boulle
96 Posted 15/08/2013 at 00:22:56
Just back from the England game. For anyone who cares, Baines was sluggish in the first half but upped his game in the second, starting to make some of his trademark surges. Jags was solid enough, certainly in comparison with Cahill, who turned like a bus when Kenny Miller scored Scotland's second.

Anyway, there was much discussion of club football too. Fans of other teams are intrigued by EFC's situation and also fail to understand how the likes of Sunderland, Norwich, Cardiff and Saints can apparently be throwing the TV money around while we can't. Most are surprised to hear that Kenwright is thought of so negatively. In the course of discussing his chairmanship and getting wound up, as I usually do, I used the throwaway line that I think we are stuck with his hopeless mismanagement until he pops his clogs.

I thought about that some more afterwards. I would never, of course, wish upon my worst enemy a premature departure from this Earth but, seriously, BK is in his 60s now I believe. Do others think that we really will see him remain in post for the next 20-30 years or however long he lives? I am certain he has no desire to sell his stake, whatever pronouncements he may make to the contrary in public. In which case, we are stuck with pre-seasons like this one (which started so promisingly on the transfer front but has now become as frustrating as ever) for some time yet.

I wonder who his will bequeaths his 30% shareholding to? A certain Mr P Green perhaps...?

Dean Barton
97 Posted 15/08/2013 at 00:27:27
Ciaran 166

I made "sensible" points re Osman earlier. You made a suggestion to play Oviedo in centre mid. Why? Have you seen him play there? If it was known that he could play that position then I see your point. You can't just name a player and say that he can play in a position to suit our needs. The lad is a left back! If your argument was that he could play as a winger then fine, that would have some validity to it. But centre mid, instead of a seasoned pro....

My responce felt reasonable considering the idiotic post that I was replying to.

Tom Dodds
98 Posted 14/08/2013 at 23:46:14
Re What we should do regarding action against the shyster supreme Kenwright and his board of parasites:

Simplen — take a leaf out of the Reds book of protesting, and stand outside (and inside/away games) Goodison or Kenwright's house and scream both the bloody places down.

I mean, does anyone on this site honestly think if the Reds had had the same gang of parasites running their club for just one bloody season, there wouldn't of been riots outside/inside Anfield?!? ... never mind tHe last tweleve seasons!!!!

People go on (and quite rightly) about the Venkeys, but at least they have some money. I'm afraid their (the board's) plan from here-on in is to hope Martinez makes good and mends, while they rake the new mega Sky money in year after year... then sell — without overseeing a new stadium, of course.

Dean Barton
99 Posted 15/08/2013 at 00:51:54
Mark 198

I Have come across that before where other clubs fans are surprised when I slag off Kenwright. The problem is with us fans. After the Wigan game there was a lot of discontent among the fans with the result, tactics, attitude and Fellaini. Did anything come of it......no! I said after that game that Fellaini should not have been allowed to put a blue shirt on again and others agreed.

After Moyes was announced utd manager there was discontent, did anything come of it.... no.

After Arteta was sold.... no.

The Blue Union march was belittled and meant nothing.

I don't know why but us Evertonians don't seem to like making a fuss. That there is the reason that Kenwright a) looks good to media and neutrals and b) the reason he still has a job.

Paul Andrews
100 Posted 15/08/2013 at 06:29:39
Good to see more and more fans realising the useless board we have will eventually cause our downfall.

It is all well people and good advocating action, but we need them to put forward ideas of how that action commences.

Sam Hoare
101 Posted 15/08/2013 at 07:26:16
I have the feeling now that neither Fellaini or Baines will be leaving and that our squad will remain unchanged. Not sure if this a good or a bad thing.

Not sure where this talk of Oviedo in CM comes from? Has he ever played there before?

If we are looking for a youngster to fill in for Gibson then look no further than John Lundstram. Very talented passer of the ball and a fair bit more mobile than Gibson and less error prone than Junior from what I've seen.

Mark Griffiths
102 Posted 15/08/2013 at 07:56:37
How many years left does left does Baines have left on his contract?
Tom Dodds
103 Posted 15/08/2013 at 07:18:51
Re Action:

Those guys (The Blue Union) that initially organised the marches outside Goodison Park need to be reactivated and reorganise more of the same, but with the added main ingredient of banners inside the ground. That's the most important and foremost weapon we have, to do it in front of the cameras. Once that course of action starts, the vulture media will do the rest.

Unfortunately all this will never happen as our fans in the main just simply don't seem to have that type of passion for a fight, imo. I hope I'm wrong, though, as the new Sky money has given the ownership situation (as I said previously) more life to those governing couldn't-give-a-fuck not-getting-any-of-my-billions wankers.

There is I believe an honourable exception here on the board in Lord Grantchester. [Ed note: Lord Grantchester is NOT on the Everton Board of Directiors.] He wants to run the club himself, I believe, and is worth £1.2 billion. Grantchester's problem is of course Kenwright's majority shareholding status and the collective of his other mates in the gang.

I believe he (Granchester) has offered to buy Kenwright out many times (at the going share rate) in the past, but they've all clung on to the idea through thick and thin of the big club sell-off....

A situation that in the past arose when Kenwright was offered £200 mill for the club when Moyes was new on the block and we got into Europe, but the stupid greedy bastard held out for more and lost out on what would have undoubtedly been our club's best lifeline.

So there you go, people... we're stuck fast with owners that are that fucking slow, they couldn't even grab hold of a windfall... And as for Kirkby... Ha!

Matt Traynor
104 Posted 15/08/2013 at 08:17:25
Mark #221, he has two years remaining on his current deal.
Mark Griffiths
105 Posted 15/08/2013 at 08:19:10
Thanks Matt. I thought it was one year and Moyes knows that he won't sign a new contract and will wait a year to get him for free.
Matt Traynor
106 Posted 15/08/2013 at 08:45:59
Further to my post at #123 about Fulham potentially being lower spenders than us, or joint lowest, seems they're about to sign Darren Bent, so unless something happens between now and the end of the season, which probably means selling someone we'd rather not, we could be the lowest spenders.

I'm pretty sure that even amongst the 10 players Palace have signed there's been a few fees involved that eclipse our total spend.

Kevin Tully
107 Posted 15/08/2013 at 08:53:12
Matt - if you take a look here:

http://www.soccernews.com/soccer-transfers/english-premier-league-transfers/

There seems to be a trend with the likes of West Ham, Swansea, Norwich, Palace, Southampton and Sunderland to have spent IRO £25m this summer.

I think we have used our new TV money to pay off Vibrac from last season.

Good eh?

Matt Traynor
108 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:02:39
The Vibrac money was borrowed against the following season's TV money, at the current 3-year deal value. Therefore the net increase in total money (don't forget, overseas TV deal has shot up too) shouldn't have made any difference in theory.

Forget FFP. It's not going to affect us anytime soon as it only affects teams qualifying for Europe. Plus, I've seen an early draft and there are so many exemption clauses for teams deemed "commercially important" to the competition that if the likes of us non-commercially important teams were to ever be excluded because of FFP, a threat of legal action in the European Court of Sports Arbitration would have UEFA back-peddling so quickly they'd give Wiggins a run for his money (I know a Footy Agent who's also a Corporate Lawyer).

Back to Everton, I just wonder if there's any cough c-off balance sheet debts we (obviously) don't know about?

Ciarán McGlone
109 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:07:50
The lad is a left back!
----------------

How many times you seen him play left back for us?

I was asked for alternatives to the paragon of inconsistency that is Osman...I offered 3....it's called opinion.

In those matches where he drifted from left to right he also played through the middle at times..it was clear to me that he could play that role if required.

In your world, Gareth Bale is also a left back.

Matt Traynor
110 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:08:45
Actually Kevin, seems there's a few teams that've spent little/nowt so far...
Arsenal (can't believe that'll stay the same. Wenger will get lynched!)
Newcastle - to be fair they did a lot of business in January
Hull - can't imagine the undisclosed fees amount to much.
Stoke - although Hughes is rumoured to be after Hoillet who he signed for QPR
West Brom - surprises me that they seem yet to spend

All moot though with 2.5 weeks to go.

Ciarán McGlone
111 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:11:21
Sam,

No I haven't seen Oviedo played specifically in centre midfield. I was simply offering the opinion that I think he may be capable of playing there. Perhaps I was venturing into fantasy football territory - but what the hell, everybody else does it!

I had forgot about Lundstram..however the obvious candidate is Barkley.

Matt Traynor
112 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:40:17
Kevin #239, remember "It doesn't take £5m to sign a £5m player"?
Iain Johnston
113 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:27:39
Matt, Hull have spent about £9m now with Huddlestone moving. Saying that though, It's something they have needed to do just to hopefully maintain prem status.

With us It's a little different. We want investment so we can push on from a 6th-8th place finish to top four. My frustration is that the board don't seem to want it, they don't want the best.

They want commercial interests and they want third parties to pay for it. No ambitions on the pitch at all. It's the only difference between us and Spurs, their board invest.

I wouldn't be surprised that come Sept 2nd some Championship team's board members have invested more than ours.

Matt Traynor
114 Posted 15/08/2013 at 09:42:04
Iain #242, I posted something on the end of the Barkley U-21 thread (don't ask, the conversation wandered!) about how clubs and sponsors are actively seeking new and innovative partnerships. What I wrote is just the tip of the iceberg.
Pablo Connelly
115 Posted 15/08/2013 at 10:06:48
Cairan, to suggest that Oviedo is a plausible alternative to Osman is more than fantasy football: it would be football suicide.

The idea is mostly unfair to Oviedo himself. The lad looks a prospect but he is still learning his own position at the highest level; playing left back in Norway (or wherever it was) is a completely different proposition the Premier League, the speed of thought and physical requirements are a lot more demanding, and that is his own position! The idea of then throwing him in the deep end to replace a man with 10 years top flight experience in midfield is then put into perspective.

As much as you clearly don't rate Osman, the role he plays requires positional awareness at all times. He has to pick and choose the times he gets ahead of the ball; it is his job to collect the ball from the centre halves and dictate. While it's your right to have an opinion on how good he is at that, to suggest we play an untried left back in his place is bordering on ridiculous.

Also, for all the reasons I mentioned above, Barkley is anything but a 'shoe-in' in Osman's position. He is an attacking midfielder, he needs to play in front of Osman and Gibson to stand a chance of being effective.

Just one final note, Cairan, you seem really adept at using condescending language to discredit others; however, your comments, in my opinion, stink of someone who hasn't got the first idea what is happening on the pitch. Maybe you should spend some time playing the game and give your word-a-day thesaurus a break!

James Martin
116 Posted 15/08/2013 at 10:45:49
Pablo well said about Osman. Why can't people see that until Barkley learns to keep hold of the ball better and find a forward pass under pressure, Osman is going to remain in the team because he is the only one who can take the ball under pressure and retain possession. Fellaini and Gibson can only really play the way they are facing. Moyes constructed his midfield so that Osman got the ball off the defenders turned and played in Gibson who could then spray it the way he was facing. Fellaini was utilised to bring the wider players into play with his back to goal.

Barkley could play as a Lampard type breaking from a midfield three to get into the box but until a player can be found to manage the transition from defense to midfield then Osman will remain in the first team picture. This player is not Oviedo/ Anichebe/ whichever other ridiculous idea that has never played centre mid that anyone might want to shoe-in.

Whatever happened to the most beloved catchphrase of this sight? how did it go again - square pegs in round holes or something like that? Good job it was only Moyes who ever thought like that hey.

Colin Glassar
117 Posted 15/08/2013 at 10:29:54
I agree Kevin Tully, I can see Fellaini leaving late in the day to be replaced by McCarthy and probably another player.
Ciarán McGlone
118 Posted 15/08/2013 at 10:46:36
Cairan, to suggest that Oviedo is a plausible alternative to Osman is more than fantasy football, it would be football suicide.

------------------------

Footballing suicide? I think you're over-egging the pudding a little.

It was a left-field suggestion, but it's also based on observation of the lads talent.

It's also firmly based on the firmly held opinion that Osman was rubbish for half of last season...To suggest replacing a rubbish player with Oviedo is 'footballing suicide' is utter tripe.

You also don't appear to appreciate where Osman plays on the pitch...he was NOT a deep lying midfielder, like Gibson, as you appear to suggest. And Barkley would not be playing 'ahead' of him.. Osman played in the final third of pitch for most of last season - perhaps you should spend a bit more time watching our team.

James Martin
119 Posted 15/08/2013 at 10:57:03
Ciaran players positioning is mostly subjective but they do start somewhere. Baines spent large parts of every game in advance of Pienaar but Pienaar doesn't play leftback for us does he? Equally Osman may well have joined in attacks but his primary role in the team was to play as a deep lying playmaker alongside Gibson.

We used to play with only one deep holding player in Carsley but Moyes changed the team structure to a two man midfield with 3 ahead of them. We've been playing this way for ages.

Pablo Connelly
120 Posted 15/08/2013 at 11:07:24
'perhaps you should spend a bit more time watching our team'. If you say so Cairan but in my opinion and several others by the sound of it you have a very rigid view on what a deep lying midfielder is. If Osman spend a lot of time in the last 3rd that is because invariably we were dominating posession and he would arrive late, I think you actually watch the games from a tactical perspective (and not just follow the ball) you will see he very rarely gets ahead of the ball. He plays a completely different position to Barkley. If Barkley plays he will stay reasonably high up the pitch, he will be asked to do a defensive job on the oppositions defensive midfielder without the ball and provide for the striker with it. He will look to get into shooting positions as much as possible. If you cant see that is a completely different role to Osman's I am just glad you don't manage the team mate.
Ciarán McGlone
121 Posted 15/08/2013 at 11:28:27
If you say so Cairan but in my opinion and several others by the sound of it you have a very rigid view on what a deep lying midfielder is.
-----------------

And you have a very rigid view of what Barkley's is...

Barkley's best position and role is a lot closer to Osman's than Gibson's...

Our best games last season came from a very fluid midfield, and a big part of that was Osman (when he was playing well) getting into advanced positions and receiving the ball from Fellaini an d Gibson. You can deny this all you want, and couch it in all the childish insults you want as well - it won't change the fact that it happened.

Pablo Connelly
122 Posted 15/08/2013 at 11:38:11
How can he have received the ball from ahead of Fellaini when Fellaini spent the huge majority of the season from behind the striker? In the first half of the season when you say Osman played well he would have been the player looking for Fellaini not the other way round, you seem to change your story to suit your argument Cairan but you are contradicting the facts, that is what is childish mate, you have doug a hole and won't admit you we're wrong. Anyways I am going round in circles with you, busy day! On a good note though RM has confirmed felli's clause has indeed expired. I just hope our hopeless board now has the strength to reject any offer less than 30 million
Jim Knightley
123 Posted 15/08/2013 at 11:50:53
Osman was more of a transition midfielder I'd say (than a fixed deep lying)...Barkley is too naive to play in Osman's role imo, he would give the ball a way too much. His role should be in the hole for the moment, until he has more experience.

Oviedo would be destroyed in a central midfield position, it would just not work. He doesn't protect the ball well enough, and doesn't have the physicality to make up for that. It would be Osman magnified imo.

If we are going to move anyone inside, Pienaar makes the most sense. He was brilliant in a central midfield position for South Africa in the Confed Cup a few seasons ago, and has great awareness and vision, and his lack of pace would be less of an issue. Although obviously he has a relationship with Baines which magnifiers the left back's strengths.

That we are fishing about for options though, illustrates the reality of the problem we face. We must bring in at least one person on loan, just for numbers, especially because Gibson will get injured, and Fellaini will be out at some point during the season, for one reason or the other. Theoretically, if that happened, what we do? Heitinga, Osman and Barkley? It's just not good enough. I think we could bring in someone cheap...someone like Faurlin from QPR would provide great cover, and vastly improve our passing game in the center of the park. But we must bring in someone.

Mark Taylor
124 Posted 15/08/2013 at 12:40:12
I think we will get another midfielder- but a two bit one, on a loan or out of contract, having sold Fellaini and with the £20m or so disappearing into the black hole.

In my more optimistic moments, I imagine the board having already lined a like for like replacement (or maybe more than one) in the likely event of Fellaini's sale. But I don't have those moments very often...

David Heaton
125 Posted 15/08/2013 at 12:47:11
Regarding Baines, I thought last nights performance was terrific I'd have given him the man of the match (I could be Biased!) he used the ball intelligently his crosses were superb and the corners were faultless and indeed Ricky Lambert scored off one, After the match Lambert went over to Baines to give him a big hug for the excellent crosses. Funny thing was non of the commentators picked up on it and not much praise in the papers today. Just goes' to show what chancers they are, most of them seem to watch the matches as a school boy would watching his first match, no insight what so ever.

I hope he stays at Everton for his whole career and 12 million is just a joke, more like twenty five million to get the best English right back in the premiership.

Colin Glassar
126 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:07:08
David, until the media darling that is Cashley Cole retires, Bainsey will never get the recognition he deserves.

England don't use him properly IMO. He's always making great runs but the likes of gerrard and Wilshere prefer to play the ball down the middle, always looking for Rooney. It looked like Roy told them to give the ball to Bainsey in the 2nd half and we (England) were much improved.

Kev Johnson
127 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:12:16
"After the match Lambert went over to Baines to give him a big hug for the excellent crosses." Not sure that was the reason, David. I noticed that after his goal and at the end, Lambert and Baines did hug in quite a genuine way. I think they must be friends already. They're both Kirby lads, aren't they? Or maybe Leighton was assigned to be Lambert's "buddy" since it was his first time with the squad. I must say, Lambert came over very well in the post match interviews. He struck me as a decent bloke. Made a welcome change from the usual big heads!
Alan Smith
128 Posted 15/08/2013 at 12:27:09
All this negativity around Barkley is astonishing!

He's a born an bred CM and has played there all his life. Been asked last season to come on away at stoke and at home to Chelsea. He started LW against the England RB away at spurs and started the arsenal away game in which he was very good in the number ten role.He gave the ball a few times, big deal. he might give it away a lot less at home to weaker sides, especially if playing a bit deeper with more time an space. God forbid he gets a chance to have the time and space Gibson gets and looks better than him. ToffeeWeb posters really will go after him then. Count how many times other crowd favourites, Pienaar, baines( who gave a goal away against spurs), and jags gave it away in those games Barkley played.

We have the best DM in the league, so playing either Barkley, Gibson or Osman alongside him isn't a problem. they're all good players, as good as a £15-20m McCarthy. Pienaar or Naismith can play number 10, once deulofeu gets his act together and wins left forward slot. mirralas right side. So What is everyone worried about?

I think it's time to lay off our two most talented CMs Barkley an Fellaini, most fans would love to have them. Half the people on here can't wait to shoot down.

Denis Richardson
129 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:20:03
Two days to go and it's all a bit quiet – seems like the end of August transfer rush has been saved for....end of August.

Rome wasn't built in a day so probably good that we've not had whole scale changes and won't have the 'gelling' problem that will likely see Sunderland go down this year – think they've signed 11 new players.

Looks like the team we have now is what we'll have until Fellaini leaves at the end of the month.

Lets all focus on the Norwich game and hope Gibbo is fully fit and one of Kone or Jelly remembers to pack their shooting boots.

48 hours and counting....

Ciarán McGlone
130 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:20:01
but you are contradicting the facts
-----------------------

No i'm not...im contradicting you.

As I said the midfield was very fluid and Osman was quite advanced a lot of the time. Fellaini played different roles last season but the one he played most was 'box to box'..

Jim,

Not sure I agree on Oviedo not being able to protect the ball..I think he has the technical ability to do that quite well..in fact, he actually reminds me a young Ronaldo in that respect. However it probably is a pie-in-the-sky idea.

I think Pienaar showed in the world cup that he doesn't have enough awareness in the middle to play that role...he gets caught out too much. He did do well in the ACON, but that's a much slower pace than the prem..

Alan Smith
132 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:28:36
Lets hope gibbo is injured so he's forced to play Barkley and keep Fellaini.

We will be making another signing I expect on deadline day. We normally do. Maybe a top quality international left winger from la liga, that would be nice.

David Heaton
133 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:26:27
Just read my post "Right back" ....sorry..... what an idiot, we will have the best right back in the premiership in a year or two,,, come on Coleman...
Harold Matthews
134 Posted 15/08/2013 at 13:16:35
Left back David.
Hodgson still doesn't know how to get the best out of Baines.
Jags still looks lost.
Naismith is razor sharp.

Sam. Stubbs is all about experience and will probably recommend a loan move for his favourite lad, Lundstram.

Matt Traynor
135 Posted 15/08/2013 at 14:06:16
Patrick #284, why would he moan? He knew he was off anyway!
Eric Myles
136 Posted 15/08/2013 at 14:09:52
Colin#271, Baines will never get the recognition he deserves while he's at Everton!
Jackie Barry
137 Posted 15/08/2013 at 14:33:09
That's the thing though, there are people who don't want the recognition, they just want to do the job and get on with it. I believe Baines is one of these people, very down to earth and family orientated. I think he may well finish his career with us.
Phil Sammon
138 Posted 15/08/2013 at 14:38:12
Kev

At the end of the game Lambert definitely went to Baines and said, "What a ball." He also thanked him in the post match interview. But yes, it's quite possible they already know each other well too.

Alan Smith

You go on about people bashing Fellaini and Barkley. All you ever do is slag off Gibson. Every frigging post you tiresome bore.

Ian Burns
139 Posted 15/08/2013 at 14:58:23
Just picked this up on the BBC website. Probably old news - but it was timed at 13,43pm today. Looks to me as though somebody is pushing an agenda here.
Leighton Baines will have to hand in a transfer request at Everton if he wants to force through a move to Manchester United, reports the Daily Mail.

Everton manager Roberto Martinez has claimed that United's £12m bid for 28-year-old Baines was a "final offer" and the England left-back will be staying at Goodison Park.

But the Daily Mail understands that United want Baines to push harder for a move before they make an improved bid, with a written transfer request the ultimate way of showing that he wants to leave.

Dean Barton
141 Posted 15/08/2013 at 15:43:38
Alan 274,

Fellaini best DM in league.......are you being paid by his agent to say that?

His release clause expired on 31/07. Why, if he is the best DM in the league, has nobody purchased him at a bargain price of 24 million. I know he splits fans opinion, but come on. If he was as good as you say wouldn't the majority of us agree??

On his day he is unplayable I agree. But his day does not come often enough. His temperament is disgraceful at times and that would never be accepted at a club like Utd. All an opposition player has to do is rough him up a bit and his game goes to pot.

Think about it. A player who, as you say, is the best in the country in his position, and has a goal in him has been unable to get a move for £24 mil!!!!!

Gavin Ramejkis
142 Posted 15/08/2013 at 16:07:35
Tom #222 re banners in Goodison Park, have mentioned this before that the stewards have been instructed to remove banners the second they appear so unless you get lots of them around the ground with reasonably big lads holding them they won't get much chance of TV time.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb