Brilliant Barkley goal but Blues are held by Norwich

, 17 August, 233comments  |  Jump to most recent
Norwich City 2 - 2 Everton

Everton started with a line-up that included Barkley, Baines, Fellaini and Jelavic. The first forward movement from Everton was an overhit hoof from Distin after a minor amount of crossfield passing following the kick-off. Patient build-ups followed, with Everton dominating the early play, Pienaar winning an early free kick.

More patient but unproductive play eventually led to another hoof, lost possession and an attack by Norwich that also won a free-kick, defended away.

A slightly stronger development through the middle looked promising but more overworking of the play around the Norwich area only led to a half-chance for Pienaar that curled well wide. The next attack looked better, but ended with a poor overhit cross from Coleman.

Norwich meanwhile looked to break quicker and more directly, winning a couple of corners that ended with a push on Howard. Their next corner saw a handball against Martin.

Baines finally got a chance to whip in a decent cross that led to Everton's first corner after 20 mins, headed over by Fellaini. Jelavic finally set up Mirallas after more PBUP, but the Belgian screwed his shot wide.

Everton came close on another Baines corner,whipped in and flicked on by Jelavic but it was too strong for Fellaini at the far post. Coleman then got behind off a good Pienaar pass and Mirallas's goalbound shot hit an arm.

Osman gave Norwich an advantage that led to a free-kick and corner but Everton's defence was doing its job, as the pace of the game improved on the half-hour, both sides pressing for the first goal, and more Baines corners that Norwich took in their stride.

Great outfield play by Everton but the pace was often slow to laboured to downright retrograde when they would pass it back to Howard. Great possession play but few real chances being created. Off Everton's 6th corner, Jagielka was off balance and shot well over.

A faster break forward with Pienaar ended when Mirallas was fractionally offside. Coleman looked to penetrate but seemed to be making the wrong choices after getting into some great positions. But it seemed the Blues were under instruction not to shoot from too far out, but a block on Mirallas set up Baines for a free-kick that finally came to xf who drilled his shot just over the angle.

After the break, Coleman gave Mirallas a better ball that he drove from close range into the side-netting. But it was Norwich who finally took the lead, Whittaker waltzing past an uninterested Fellaini and beating Howard, smacking the far post, then scoring from a narrower angle with the rebound.

The goal seemed to add a little more urgency to the patient passing play and it eventually paid off when COleman from a throw-in, cut inside and eventually found Barkley moved the ball to his lethal left foot then powered in a fantastic strike, smacking inside Ruddy's side netting in brilliant style. A great goal from the young lad!

It was a tremendous goal and a worthy celebration, the whole team going to the corner to celebrate.

Everton kept pressing and went into the lead after a good forward pass to Jelavic whose shot was parried by Ruddy and Coleman following up had an easy tap-in, much to the supreme delight of the traveling Blues fans. Martinez then put Naismith on in place of Mirallas.

But Norwich were back level off a mishit cross from Whittaker that Van Wolfswinkel too easily headed past Howard to equalize with Everton at that sage rampant and looking solid for the win.

Coleman came close with a meaty left-foot shot near the end.

Norwich City: Ruddy; Whittaker, Turner, Martin Y:44', Garrido; E Bennett, Howson, Johnson, Redmond; Hoolahan (73' Tete); Van Wolfswinkel.
Subs:

Everton: Howard; Baines, Jagielka, Distin, Coleman; Fellaini, Barkley, Osman, Mirallas (67' Naismith), Pienaar; Jelavic (80' Kone).
Subs: Robles, Heitinga, Deulofeu, Naismith, Stones, Anichebe

Kick off: 3pm
Referee: Michael Oliver

Attendance: 26,824

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (233)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Anto Byrne
1 Posted 17/08/2013 at 15:54:27
Im thinking we should win this game, the finishing and final ball being poor so far. Osman very quiet?
Ralph Basnett
3 Posted 17/08/2013 at 16:11:48
Groundhog Day, had a whole summer with extra tv money and the so called money we did not spend it January and we still field a Moyes team!!!

Hold on to your hats, it's going to be a long season and all for the wrong reasons.!!!!!!!

Robin Cannon
4 Posted 17/08/2013 at 17:15:36
Two points dropped because of a lack of cutting edge and a total inability to hold on to a lead against an average team.

We even conceded immediately after making a momentum-undermining substitution by bringing Naismith on for Mirallas!

The more things change, the more they stay the same...

(...and yes, I know there were subtle differences in how we played, and we definitely tried to keep the ball better, and it's just one game, but it was just as frustrating as so many similar occasions last year)

John Crawley
5 Posted 17/08/2013 at 17:50:47
On balance I think we were a little bit unlucky not to get a deserved win. The two Norwich goals were both fortunate in their build up if not in the execution, either Naismith or Jelavic should really have scored the winner.

Passed the ball round well if still not as much of a cutting edge as we should have had in the final third. But we have just witnessed a very good performance from Barkley, topped off with a great goal. He is clearly playing with a lot of confidence and some of that has got to be down to the new manager's change in emphasis on focusing on what Barkley can bring to the team instead of the mistakes he has made in the past. His stat's today were certainly impressive, 96% pass completion with 23 out of 24 being made in the final third. A star is born I think.

Colin Wainwright
6 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:07:52
Never a Moyes team Ralph. Ross Barkley got a game.
Tony J Williams
7 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:10:23
At least we are a point up from last seasons game
Paul Ferry
8 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:08:12
Jesus wept Ralph what a crock of shite mate - celebrate some good footie for once and a new EFC star in the making.
Phil Sammon
9 Posted 17/08/2013 at 18:59:17
Ralph & Robin

What utter dross!

What were you expecting? God, some people are thick.

First game for the new boss and its away from home in a fixture which we lost last season. The team passed it around well, much better than we've seen pre-season. Coleman, Baines, Pienaar all looked very good, Fellaini looked happy deeper and what a performance from Barkley.

We were toothless up front - there's no denying that. We spent the majority of our transfer budget on a man who will hopefully solve that problem. Sadly he is just not match fit yet. We conceded two of the unluckiest goals you're ever likely to see. Their fullback stumbling through players to play a one-two with the far post. Then the same lad completely shanks a shot straight onto their forward's bonce.

There were negatives - I was disappointed that we reverted to a long ball game after 65 minutes and that Osman was on the field for the full 90. However, if you can't draw the positives from a performance like that then I really think you ought to invest in a noose.

Tony J Williams
10 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:11:34
Nor a crock of shite Paul, if Gibson was fit Ross wouldn't have started
Kunal Desai
11 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:08:10
Ralph - Are you for real? how is it going to be a long hard season? Did you actually watch the game. Norwich were fortunate to escape with a point. On another day we would easily have won that game. Martinez is being positive and is getting the side to play football with more fluidity and passing. When does a manager come and change his playing personnel in one summer. It doesn't happen, it took Moyes 6-7 years to build his own side. Get behind Martinez and the side and stop talking rubbish
Tony J Williams
12 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:13:30
Cracking point Phil, lucky as Fuck their goals
Mike Allison
13 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:12:31
This has an awful lot in common with what happened under Moyes last season. In fact the pattern of the game is very similar to games last year, the Fulham away one springs to mind. In the long run that could be a good thing. It means Martinez isn't trying to make too many changes all at once and he has the good sense to try to develop things gradually. I have to admit, Naismith for Mirallas is extremely disheartening.

However, overall we should be looking at positives. Coleman and Barkley looking like they'll do damage all season, Jelavic looking better than the shadow man that played the second half of last season and Norwich fans all over the BBC saying how lucky they were to get a point.

My main reflection however? Don't read too much into just one game.

Mike Powell
14 Posted 17/08/2013 at 18:56:08
Piss poor defending; midfield was woeful except for Barkley who was MotM. How the fuck does Osman get in our team? He was shite last season, even worse this year after that performance. Norwich are a poor team and we conceded two goals against them. I said before the season started, we will struggle this season.
Geoff Freeman
16 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:11:40
Agree with you Paul, a decent performance and a point more than we got last year.
Matt Traynor
17 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:13:37
Tony #068, can see where you're coming from - Gibson in, Ossie further forward, Barkley bench. But, Ossie still looks off the pace. Barkley is prone to mistakes, but no more so than Ossie - hopefully RM will persist with Barkley and really give him a chance to nail down a place. If he doesn't, Ossie is a more than capable replacement.

People shouldn't forget that Norwich has spent to improve their squad - mainly their forward line, which was their achilles heel last season. Their defence is still suspect - we didn't play well, but we didn't lose.

Can't be too down after that. Roll on the Baggies!

Paul Ferry
18 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:16:27
I disagree, TJW, and I think the majority will be with me, mate.
Jay Harris
19 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:10:43
A draw snatched from the jaws of victory.

Positives: MOTM performance and cracking goal from Barkley, some good passing and possession.

Negatives: lack of bite and poor defending for Norwich's only 2 chances.

Sum up: Same old same old flatter to deceive against a very poor Norwich side missing 4 first team choices.No goal threat and poor defending looks like another long season.

Raymond Fox
20 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:15:51
Wish they had a champions league for moaners, I think we could pick a team that would qualify and 'piss it' every year!
Ralph you've been nominated.

Not seen the game, but I would have taken a draw gladly before the match.
Norwich is a difficult place to go to.

Phil Sammon
21 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:19:48
I wouldn't have last season...but I've got to defend the decision to remove Mirallas for Naismith. The Scot has been very much improved in pre-season and Mirallas wasn't at his best. We were winning at the time (weren't we?) - perhaps it would have been Deulofeu if we were drawing.

Anyway, Naismith has done enough to convince me he has something to offer for now. Incredible change from last seasons hopeless form.

Dan Parker
22 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:23:24
Not a bad result but a little concerning to leak a couple of goals. Good, strong team selection, Barkley excellent. Huge amounts of possession but failing to really pressure heavily in front of goal.

A solid start, time to build on it.

Sam Hoare
23 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:23:18
I think we really should have put a poor Norwich side to the sword to be honest and lack of ruthlessness was definitely a flaw of the old regime. Its ear;y days though.

The performance was mostly strong and obviously great day for Ross and that confidence will do him wonders though we must be careful not to expect him to play that well every week.

Hopefully Kone gets up to speed soon and we can find another CM to bolster competition and get Ossie out unless he's on form.

Carl Taylor
24 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:21:02
The Moyes-lovers can kiss my arse! How was that similar to last season? We dominated last season and lost from a winning position. Today we went behind but kept playing positive, attacking football until the very end at got a point. We didn't defend a lead, going deeper and deeper into our own half. We're one point better off, so it's a solid start from a game was expecting nothing from given the Betis performance.
Mark Pierpoint
25 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:26:43
I think that things look Ok. Look at Villa against Arsenal, even us against Utd last year, a first day performance is never indicative of where a team is. Positives were surely attacking intent. Negatives, as RM says soft goals (in particular Norwich's first) conceded. We will get better results from that performance (similarly with Swansea) It is a bit of an anomaly opening weekend, this is why I would prefer to play the top 4 early, don't worry.
Phil Friedman
26 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:28:14
Positive result, keep Barkley in, Gibson for Osman (or a new signing) and we'll be fine. Jags looked tired late from Wednesday's England match, couldn't get off the ground for the tying header.
Mark Pierpoint
27 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:31:41
Phil I don't see Deulofeu playing many games away from home really. Especially in the first half of the season. There are more experienced players than him who have come in from abroad and struggled in the early stages. Drip feed him into the team, especially in the initial months
Patrick Murphy
28 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:25:21
Jay you've either forgotten what a long hard season looks like or you've never experienced one. This Everton side is a pretty good team that lacks in certain areas, and has done for 5 years. Norwich on their own midden are always hard to beat and we don't win there very often. If we had lost the game by a couple of goals then maybe your views may be valid but we didn't and got a point away from home.

Just before Barkley scored the equalizer today I was going to post on the Live Forum, because I couldn't believe some of the things that I was reading. If some of those guys think slagging the team off at every opportunity is supportive then I must have missed something. I know that being conservative by nature Evertonians are not fond of shouting from the rafters, but I'm not familiar with the way some find it all so easy to denigrate our own players and staff, regardless of what they witness with their own eyes.

Everton even in their good moments have never been an easy club to follow, the roller-coaster ride has always been with us, but if we're not happy when we score a couple away from home and manage to get a point what will it take? Five goal wins all over the world? It's not going to happen even if you rig FM or other Computer games it still won't allow the team you like to win easy every week.
Rough with the smooth, take it or leave it.

Tony Marsh
29 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:31:43
What are you people moaning at? I haven't seen an Everton side with that amount of possession for over 25 years. Wave after wave of attacks, two cracking goals scored and two freak once-in-a-lifetime goals for Norwich. Their second was outrageous.

You can see what Martinez is trying to do and, once his ideas start to click, we will give some teams absolute hidings. Pass-and-move football way better than launch-it-and-pray shit we became accustomed to..

It's early days and I reckon RM is looking not to change the team too much too soon — hence Osman the Horrible playing. Once proper assessment has been made of the current players, change will happen.
What about the Boy Barkley? What a talent and what a disgraceful way Ross has been treated by the other fella for the past few seasons. A few more games once we start to gel and Barkley finds his feet I reckon we will be flying.

Jim Bennings
31 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:29:10
Well we played some pretty decent stuff there at times..The one thing though that does concern me is how Roberto Martinez can eventually turn this Everton team into a side with a winning mentality. We really need to rid ourselves of the old habits that have dogged us for probably more than two years now if we are honest. We just don't seem to really be able to turn enough winning positions into winning results.

Fair play to Martinez, there is absoloutly no blame at all attached to him, he was quite brave out there today going with Barkley and it paid off; Moyes would have gone with Heitinga or Naismith from the off.

Okay, it's a decent point away from home but when you look at Villa who go to The Emirates and win the match 3-1 it gets you thinking: "Hang on, maybe we need to start doing that a little bit more often you know, be clinical when that chance comes along and start learning to see out winning positions." It's happened too often with this team.

Let's be honest, we were probably better than Norwich today, they did very little to test Howard or even the defence, and they were also missing more key players than us, yet we managed to switch off at crucial moments like we do too often.

I did get a little tired last season especially after away matches saying how well we played but then wake up to the fact that a potential 4-1 win was actually only a 2-2 draw (think Fulham away, Reading away... a loss actually, Stoke away, Spurs away, Norwich away last season).

I am trying to take the positives: yes it's Roberto Martinez`s first point, unbeaten; good enough and I am content-ish but they say old habits die hard... I think it's true that the current players of this team still have to learn to be a bit more ruthless and a bit more unforgiving at the back at times. Let's hope Roberto is a good teacher.

Andrew Bone
32 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:36:49
If Gibson was fit, I would have hoped to have seen Barkley in and Osman on the bench. I still think we need a decent striker – Norwich got one and he punished us. Hopefully Jelavic can get some form and Kone should make us more dangerous. It was refreshing to see a striker come on at 2-2 rather than Heitinga.
Colin Williams
33 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:28:48
FFS stop talking about Ossie even playing. How many shit games does he need to play before he has the boot!! The glass is half- full with players like, Barkley, Coleman and Oviedo in our team.
Excellent team performance with Barkley the star man. Give Robbie time to develop his team. I believe there are good times ahead.


Paul Andrews
34 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:44:44
We were winning at the time 2-1; Distin went on a bit of a run into their half, the ball was 20 yards inside their half. The commentator said"every player except Howard is in the Norwich half" — That is a statement that would never have happened under our former manager.
Stephen Brown
35 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:46:14
Encouraging points from today's game.
1) Barkley getting a start and producing a great performance.
2) The 3 substitutions all being attacking players.
3) Seamus Coleman is turning into a very effective attacking right back.
Ralph Basnett
36 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:41:44
Biggest moaner yes, because I believe for the money Everton pay its players it requires high standards. If my employees decide to slack off after their holidays after I pay them extortionate amount I deserve to sort it!!

I am fortunate that as my son is in UEA I get to watch, observe and don't have to pay to stay over!

I am not so much slating the fact that even with our good finishes over previous years, and we beat Manure first game last season, every team that gets a new manager starts with a win, it's a done deal until it comes to us!!!

Naysmith on for Mirallas? Whilst Mirallas was ineffectual give the Barca kid a go. Osman is a squad player not. First team player. oooops, forgot, we don' t have a squad because they have never been given the opportunity to be purchased or introduced.

Once again, we played a Moyes team, it didn't work and we need a fuck load of money to transform this shower.

But I still buy my season ticket (30 years now so earned my dues)!!!!!!

Matt Muzi
37 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:44:37
Completely agree with Andrew @ 090, it was refreshing to see Vic come on for Barkley, as our previous manager would have certainly put Heitinga on.

Also completely agree with Robin @ 060, what an awful substitution bringing Naismith on & straight away they score the equaliser, while I am sure he is a nice fella he offers us nothing and I for one would like to see him moved on.

Like a considerable amount of our fans, how can we expect RM to field his own team, when he's given an absolute pittance to develop a threadbare squad, which didn't even have a reserve goalkeeper. You only have to look at who Norwich have brought in this summer to realise how limited RM is.

Trevor Lynes
38 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:44:39
I just think back a few years when we never scored a goal from open play and, once we went one goal down, it was all over!! Not too many years ago either.

This team is a really good playmaker away from a top four side. I predict Kone will improve the team and possibly will play in home games as a two-pronged strike force.

We need luck with injuries to have a decent start to the season though as our squad is small. Barkley has had a great start but he is young and may struggle to remain consistent in the long haul.... he could be a second Rooney???

Mark Tanton
39 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:00:37
Very good point Matt; I thought we were very good today but Norwich have three good players to come in and they have every right to believe they'll finish above us.
Mark Frere
40 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:49:52
Like many others have suggested already, that performance was typical of all the draws we had last season. We dominated the game but didn't have the cutting edge to finish Norwich off.

Still, by no means depressing or a disaster. There were plenty of positives like Barkley's dazzling display, I really hope he's given a decent run of games in our starting 11. Its obvious now Osman should be nothing more than a squad player.

All-in-all a satisfactory first outing

Stephen Brown
41 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:56:48
Watching Soccer Saturday was a bit of an eye opener today when the panel were discussing how much money teams like Norwich, Swansea, Sunderland, Cardiff and Hull had spent. Swansea, Cardiff and Norwich spending in excess of 20 million pounds. If this sort of money was spent on the Everton team, these draws would quickly turn to wins! It is very frustrating!
Gerard Carey
42 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:50:45
What did everyone think of Fellaini?
Jamie Sweet
43 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:04:45
We all thought we'd score more this season but probably concede more.

Well, we conceded the same, scored more and claimed more points than from the corresponding fixture from last season, so things are looking good!

Iain Johnston
44 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:35:46
Firstly, how are Norwich very poor? Last season they finished two points behind Swansea. Are they very poor too?

They opened the scoring very much against the run of play due to a certain mop headed midfielder who let him dance past without so much as a heavy breath and a lucky far post rebound. Previously that would have been the end of us with no idea and no Plan B.

We responded very well I thought, with a bit of intelligence and patience. Lovely goal by Ross and a tidy follow up by Seamus, who, previously wouldn't have been on the pitch or wouldn't have been that far forward.

What's most important for me is, we didn't sit on the lead or drop back, we went looking for a third. We all know their equaliser came from a miss hit shot.

West Brom will be interesting; I can see Gibson starting in place of Osman.

Barry Rathbone
45 Posted 17/08/2013 at 19:47:54
Great first day all things considered, I wouldn't have complained at a loss while bedding in a completely new way of playing.

The young boy Barkley gets a full game and responds with a cracker - the youth ranks of Stones, Green etc will be jumping for joy knowing if you're good enough you get a shot.

Naismith coming on follows the same vein - what's passed has passed if you're up for it and contributing (which the lad has been pre season) you get a go.

Jelavic continues his resurrection and Coleman grows in stature every game he plays.

Fantastically positive this first effort well done Bobby and the boys you did great.

Joe McMahon
46 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:05:36
Ralph, Their 2nd goalscorer cost over £8 million. Roberto hasn't had that much to spend. The real culprits/problems we have are with us every year – Kenwright and our inept board, they are parasites.
Mark Tanton
47 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:08:37
I thought Jelavic led the line well and put in a real shift, he worked hard and linked up well. He looks a more happy and fitter player. Distin and Jagielka are very good together and ordinarily you wouldn't expect a defensive paring like this to ship goals, which must be more the fault of the midfield than anything else.

Leon Osman is just absolutely finished, I don't know if it's age or something else but he is shot. Gareth Barry would bring some solidness and beef into midfield and I think he is needed. I'd like to see Kone and Jelavic together at some point too.

A promising performance and hopefully we'll see one, or maybe even two more players before September. There are reasons to be cheerful.

Matt Muzi
48 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:12:54
Gerard, I thought he played ok, it certainly wasn't his best performance, but he put a shift in.

In response to Barry Iain & Jamie, while we played well today & had the lion share of possession, we played a Norwich team who were bedding in a number of players, unlike us & on that possession level if we aren't converting our chances better teams will punish us.

I saw a number of sloppy passes and at times too many lateral passes, we need someone to cover Gibbo, because when he's out, our play at times is limited.

Which brings me back to investment in the team & what Norwich have done that we haven't, bought in a player, (possibly two if Hooper works out), who they believe have the potential to score 20 goals + a season, because I don't see anyone doing that at Everton this season.

I pray that 'Bill The Deceiver' proves me wrong & gives RM the funds to get a few more players in, even if they are loan deals, before the window closes. But going on past history and I really hope it doesn't happen don't be surprised if we lose a key player at the end of the window, or no one comes in & every player we've been linked to signs for one of our rivals.

Paul Corbett
49 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:33:19
Some people really do like to moan.

We played well, conceded two very unfortunate goals and Barkley finally got some game time.

The way I always see it is by comparing the same game last year hence we're already a point off.

Bill Gall
50 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:18:00
Not getting carried away but a decent performance. In regards to team performance, the second goal that came from the goalkeeper to Coleman's goal via 17 passes was a positive side of the style the Manager is looking to provide.

One of the negatives to me seems that the centre backs become too far apart, passing the ball around... and on a quick counter attack, they struggle to get back into position.

The bright spot to me was the performance of Barkley. Talent like his does not develop over the last couple of weeks and it raises the question of OFM not playing him because of a couple of mistakes.

We still need a creative midfielder to provide for the forwards. Osman is not the player he was before his England call up..

Colin Malone
51 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:31:45
To some people on this forum, Rome was built in a day.
Peter Cummings
52 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:25:41
A poor and very pedestrian first half, too many back passes with a total lack of penetration up front. I can only agree that Ossie seems past his sell-by date. Felli put in a good shift and Barkley was number one.

It's hard to believe we only came away with a point after dominating for 80% of the game. Their goals were lucky but they all count and we probably should have won.

It was a very encouraging second half, in spite of sloppy goals, and at least Howard wasn't at fault for the goals but he is still punching instead of catching.

Anyone know why we bought Kone???

Gavin Ramejkis
53 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:45:15
A decent enough game with a lot of my views already mentioned. Found the defence takes some getting used to, Osman made some really poor passes today and I do wonder what his role is now. Fellaini played ok and looked interested, a great game from Barkley which shows what many have said, give the lad time to play games, make mistakes and earn his living at the same time, Coleman was fabulous and but for a fluky equaliser Everton had Norwich under the cosh and lucky to get a point out of a game when they were camped in their own half for big chunks of the game trying to defend against the Everton attacks.

Lots of positives to be taken from the work in progress on show today, someone is due to get a right kicking this season once this is polished up.

Harvey Miller
54 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:34:55
Osman was and will be the weak link. Get rid of him asap. With Gibson we might have won. Ross was great, but with Moyes on board, he would have never started. I think it was a good result even if we were the better team.

The change might not be so quick, RM played his team like DM used to do, 4-4-1-1. Most of the time, you would think old Dither was still in the dogout!

Colin Grierson
55 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:30:59
I like to immerse myself in all things Everton, hence I find myself on TW. It amazes me how many posters are negative about today's performance? There will always be things that can be viewed as negative but I could see a new dawn today. Some of you moaners on here are absolutely clueless. What's worse you sound like kopites who think we have a divine right to success!

Moyes has gone and I for one am delighted as Barkley would probably be on loan if he were still here. Give Martinez a chance and the players he inherited. How can today's side be Moyes's side? Ozzie had a bad game but he deserves a chance to make amends. I'm sure if he doesn't then he will be dropped. I may be wrong but one game in and the whingeing is almost as cringeworthy as the Martinez March!

If you call yourself supporters then give support. Oh and I might be wrong but didn't Mirallas tweak his hamstring? Hence the substitution?

Peter Laing
56 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:01:48
Barkley demonstrated today why Everton should be building a team around him, negatives - the more senior pro's were wank today Jagielka, Osman and Fellaini.
Noel Early
57 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:51:39
The main feeling I have is one of frustration; we were the better team for long periods. Barkley was outstanding, didn't put a foot wrong really. I felt we would have scored a couple more if it hadn't been for that poxy 2nd Norwich goal.

Going forward, I can see Gibson coming into the side in place of Ossie. I thought Pienaar's final ball today was terrible and the sooner Jela gets a goal, the better he will be for it.

James Martin
58 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:04:39
Wow, another Premier League manager who thinks it's a good idea to 'play one up front at places like Norwich', 'sub Mirallas off for Naismith', 'bring a sub on for only a few minutes', 'sit back after going in front'.

Crazy how the miracle man Martinez and the inept PE teacher (now the Man Utd boss) display such similar behaviour.

Raymond Fox
59 Posted 17/08/2013 at 20:57:43
Well said Colin.
Jim Bennings
60 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:01:59
Things we learned today:

Roberto Martinez will be bolder than David Moyes was as Everton but will suffer from the same financial restraints and also must overcome the task of turning a nearly team into a side with a winning mentality instead of "a draw's not a bad result" mentality which Moyes installed in all the players' mindsets after years of trying.

Osman is definitely not one for the future, we knew that already like, just thought I would say it anyway... Barkley is... but he will be wasted if played too deep. I think Martinez has picked up on this a lot quicker than Moyes did, or ever would have done.

Pienaar does some fantastic things followed by other things which you feel you could have executed better yourself; very frustrating player at times. As is Mirallas, a player who has all the ability in the world yet is going to have to learn not to go missing in so many away games this season. Jelavic played okay but still isn't quite there yet. I don't know what will happen with Kone... or Deulofeu.

The defence is still leaky, and that's not down to Martinez, it's been an on-going problem for a few years since the departures of Carsley, and Lescott.

Finally we need to learn how to both be more clinical and also keep things tight at the back when we are in a winning position. Let's hope Martinez is a good teacher. All-in-all, a decent point, not disappointing but certainly frustrating. Never mind; it's a start. Let's build on it and take six points from the next two games.
Colin Glassar
61 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:14:02
James, how many teams play with two out and out strikers nowadays? Just out of interest.
Paul Andrews
62 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:15:29
"Sit back after going in front"
That didn't happen
Gary Reeves
63 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:05:21
Hmmmm? Leon Osman.

Wigan's finest.
Little cheeky Leo.
Ossie, Ossie, Osman.
England's number 12.
Quick feet Leon.....

Ah fuck it - he's shit ain't he!

Jim Potter
64 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:06:08
Christ almighty – did some of you moaning negative so and so's actually watch this game?! We dominated it. We played great stuff at times and conceded two goals that contained lucky breaks for them.

We played football – not hoofball. Not tedious shite – we tried to be creative. We were away at a team who has spent considerably more than us and outplayed them. With Moyes we would have played this well occasionally. With Bobby it'll be most of the time – and luck won't be against us as often.

Well done Bobby and the lads – screw the moaners – celebrate some School of Science play.

Half of you would fucking moan if you slept with Marilyn Monroe in her prime. Ah she was ok ... Expected better ....

Mark Frere
65 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:13:21
Peter (120)

I don't know how you came to the conclusion Fellaini was wank, yes he was a fault for Norwich's first goal....but I thought he played very well and looked much more comfortable playing in his natural position

Phil Sammon
66 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:11:58
James

More hopeless bollocks from you mate. You really don't have a clue do you?

Paul Andrews
68 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:16:57
Jim Potter,

Pour yourself a large one buddy
Well said

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
69 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:22:39
Yes, Jim... but don't ever post on here for any Evertonians to go support someone else. If you can't tolerate a diversity of opinions... well you know what happens.
Barry Rathbone
70 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:18:29
James 122, bet you don't see any difference between Anne Widdicombe and Carmen Electra.

Both have tits and a fanny and appear on the box from time to time - 2 peas in a pod according to your logic.

Matt Muzi
71 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:13:35
In response Colin at 119, and if anything I post causes any offence I apologise in advance.

How can we call today's team a Moyes team, because everyone playing was either bought, or developed under Moyes, dare I say it even Barkley. Hence my earlier point RM is limited with the funds given to him thus far.

Did Osman have a bad game, well that's going to vary with people's opinion/analysis, the issue is we don't have someone to cover a DM, (Defensive Midfielder) position, or Gibbo, when he's out & Osman is not, nor has he ever been a DM.

I don't think anyone has an issue taking Super Kev off, I think the issue is bringing Naismith on to replace him, not Oviedo & moving Pieenar to the right, or Deulofeu.

James Martin
72 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:26:27
Touchy touchy a few on here tonight. It was obviously a joke. The differences in play were evident (at times). It just made me laugh when we started with the exact same formation as last season, he took Mirallas off for Naismith and we let a lead slip.

Paul Andrews 'sitting back' didn't happen all the time last season either but it didn't stop every one just saying it did. I remember we pummeled Fulham and got done on the break and everyone made out that we'd defended for most of the game. It seems as ever that, no matter how similar some things are (this was the typical Everton away performance) perception can just sway the verdict one way or another depending on whether you want to bash Moyes or big up Martinez.

Paul Ferry
73 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:09:33
Can't believe some of the negative or shall we say shades of grey dross on here, although of course I agree that we are not yet near the finished object.

Let's get a canarie's fan's point of view shall we - please Kerrie; Kerrie Furlong: Glad Canaries don't play Everton every week, mullered for 90 mins, very lucky to get a draw. Other teams wont get away with it.

Thanks Kerrie.

Now we played very well today with evident shortcomings up front and in the middle - it is essential that by hook or by crook we pick up a creative centre-mid before the window jams shut.

Passing and keeping hold of the ball was not far off top-drawer today but the final ball was lacking all too often and striker service was decidedly grade D.

But I for one feel buoyed by today's '90 and am firmly of the belief that we are heading in the right direction.

Barkley was quite simply terrific today (wonder whether all those who had a pop at him - some well below the belt - after the US trip will have the decency to eat their words?) and we have a star-in--the-making: upper-body strength, touch, vision, always trying to push things forwards, confidence one hell of a shot.

Cheer up. There is zilch reason for depressed dogs bollocks; enjoy the footie, it will get better, and if our inept chair and board - the main reason why we cannot at this point move up a level - actually dug deep into their deep pockets or let go there may be plenty of blue skies ahead in a bright future.

.

. ,
m

John Malone
74 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:07:32
You've got to take positives from that game, even though it's disappointing drawing from a winning position.

Their first goal was poor from Baines then Fellaini but their second goal might have started with sloppy play from Osman but was it very jammy Whittaker's shot slicing straight to Ricky Van Wolfswinkel's head.

That was the best I've seen Barkley play what a great strike with his left peg makes me think there's a lot more to come.

Mirallas looked on fire early on and probably should have scored, Jelavic was unlucky with shot that made our second and his interplay looked sharper than last year, if Naismith chance goes in were buzzing with an away win, unlucky to draw in my opinion.

Tony Christian
75 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:31:37
James - My recollection was that Moyes brought Distin on for Jelavic in the 88th minute and invited Fulham to throw caution to the wind.
John Audsley
76 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:31:41
I'm full of hope for this season after watching today's game.

Apart from Osman's worrying lack of any kind of form, we played really well and, with a touch of luck, could have won the game.

It's going to take at least this season for Roberto to get it right so if some are moaning like hell after a draw away from home then god knows how you will feel when we get beat.

And to the cretins that slag RM off for starting with a "Moyes" team...... with that idiot Kenwright and his clueless, inept board – what do you expect??? RM to sell half the squad and start again in a few weeks???

Some people need a reality check.......and very fucking quickly!

Good first game, Roberto, and thank fuck for the change in manager, we had got so stale under Moyes it was horrible.

Phil Sammon
77 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:48:12
Everyone seems keen to blame Fellaini for their fist goal. Their right back attempts a pass, it hits about six shins and the lad is practically already around the big Fella. I think it was either let him go past or hack the guy down. A little harsh to put the blame his way.

Just had a bit of a browse of a Norwich forum by the way. The general consensus it that we hammered them and they got away with one. That's how I saw it too.

Matthew Williams
78 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:25:23
Not bad today... but we still need a major threat up front. Kone ain't the answer either; maybe we could play young Ross supporting Jelly up top next week verses The Baggies? Play Oviedo wide left, Coleman wide right, Fellaini & Pienaar in the middle for a little bit more in the way of creativity. Play young Stones at right back.

Ozzie now looks spent and should be moved on now; both Super Kev & Gibbo should not be rushed back... give 'em time to sort out their respected injuries or they could risk further damage, if played too soon.

With a bit more luck, us Blues could still build a winning team yet. I would still love Vossen up front though!

Tony Christian
79 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:57:33
56% possession, 19 shots at goal and attractive football but there are still people out there who like to find faults - do us all a favour and follow Man United and your beloved Messiah.
Colin Wainwright
80 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:06:34
Didn't see the game but watched Soccer Saturday (free Sky day on Pick TV, never knew it existed until this afternoon).

One telling moment was, half way through the 2nd half, Geoff said, "Gonna get an update from Carrow Road, and I have to say, if Everton play like this for the rest of the season, there will be a lot of extremely happy Evertonians."

Not the result I wanted, but sounds like we were a class apart. Looking forward to West Brom.

Colin Grierson
81 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:48:26
Matt 136 (not offended in the slightest mate).

It's not the players but the mentality of the players that matters. Obviously the players were from Moyes period but I didn't see Moyes style of play today. I agree that we could do with more in midfield but I think that hinges on whether we sell Fellaini or not. Like it or not we don't have the money to spend. I won't go into why as its been done to death on here!

With regard to Naismith, he looked good in pre-season and obviously showed something in training and Martinez showed belief in him. Sometimes a player can come good given some praise and belief.

Those old enough to remember will know that,before Howard Kendall's great side won the FA Cup v Watford, we were shite! Really shite and that cup run and the plaudits surrounding it dragged some of our players from poor form to world beaters. Kendall was berated prior to the cup run and that was the most successful period in our recent history.

Maybe Oviedo or Gerry would have been a better replacement for Super Kevin but Naismith nearly scored to be fair so I honestly feel we were unlucky today and not tactically lacking in way.

Ossie was poor but it's too early to say he's finished IMHO.

Game 1! ... Bing on the Baggies!

Paul Andrews
82 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:16:44
James,

We never sat back today.
We never had everyone saying it happened ,just you

Andrew James
83 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:17:29
Delighted for 2 players I was feeling positive about this season. Barkley and Coleman. I think the young lad could be on the cusp of something. Didn't he debut 2 seasons ago and impressed before being loaned out? The fact he's seizing his opportunity is great especially as some have indicated his decision making isn't great. From what I saw of him at Arsenal last season, he will be alright.

As for Seamus, we already have the best left back in the league. We might well have the best right soon.

All in all, some team flaws still but plenty of things to get excited about regarding the individuals.

Paul Mackie
84 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:23:55
Same problem as last season. Dominating games but dick all in the way of a formidable goal scorer up front.

Was good to see it wasn't a complete revolution as some on here we're predicting. Say what you want about Moyes but he at least left the new guy with a top 6 capable side.

Phil Sammon
85 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:25:03
I said this about Barkley before todays game. Once he's relaxed and knows he's in the manager's plans he will relax and stop trying to force it. We saw that today.
Harold Matthews
86 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:32:43
A promising performance against a team set up to hit us on the counter.
Young Barkley was a joy to watch and Fellaini seemed to be everywhere. I hope he stays.

Did someone say Mirallas tweaked his hamstring.? Not surprised with the substitution. He just wasn't at the races.

Interesting to see how we fare against better teams when we will not be so heavily marked in the final third.

The Premier League is a mighty strange place. Swansea have improved out of sight but despite looking seriously good they were hammered. Villa murder Arsenal and Fulham win away. What next?

Pass the brandy.

Colin Grierson
87 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:31:24
Bang on the money Phil. Proper management of the lad and he shows it on the pitch.
Phil Sammon
88 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:36:50
Harold

The teams that don't mark us so heavily will be the ones who also close down our back 4 a la Real Betis. I think that will be more of a challenge to be honest. That's when our defenders may be most tempted to hoof it. Anyway, a debate for another day.

James Martin
89 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:36:59
Ok Paul you're right of course (despite the matter being wholly subjective). I've long since discounted any sort of weight of opinion on this site being representative of anything anyway. The facts are that however we played we still threw the lead away and didn't create enough in the last 20 mins or so to win the game. 2 points dropped but an encouraging performance, some decent attacking some dodgy defending. That's all you can say really.
Phil Sammon
90 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:43:51
If you'd have said that first time around then nobody would have argued, James.
Peter Jones
91 Posted 17/08/2013 at 22:36:38
I love that after going 2-1 up we kept the pressure on and went for the third. We didn't sit back and defend. Unlucky to have their only 2 shots on target end up in the back of the net. So happy to see Barkley shine and show the world he's class! No way Osman gets his job back when Gibson returns. We should crush WBA next week playing the way we played today.
Kev Johnson
93 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:00:46
Phil - do you remember me saying last season that Ross has a bit of the old Zinedine Zedane about him? You were the only one on TW who could see the similarity.

Ha! We're not looking so silly now, are we?

Paul Ferry
94 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:09:32
I too have never ever sad anything but good about Ross all the way though last season and I expect him to be a full England international inside three years

There was an awful lot of shite spouted on here about Ross last season and post-USA

Peter Warren
95 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:13:40
Fantastic comments by Roberto about Barkley. And what a performance by Barkley so so exciting
Patrick Murphy
96 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:17:24
How embarrassing for the BBC that Lineker had to do a special interview with RM. I assume that RM wasn't interviewed on Final Score? Then they top it off by linking Wigan's goals against last season, I'm beginning to think either some TW's have infiltrated the BBC or perhaps it's the other way round.

Don't want Ross being built up to quickly though, he'll be targeted and we don't want that do we?
Great goal though, not many goals seem better the more you view them.

Colin Wainwright
97 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:21:17
Does Phil Walling work for the BBC? Two jammy fuckin' goals and they're comparing our defensive record to Wigans.
Gerard Morgan
98 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:10:47
I never comment on TW but I must. Today, last season and the season before there was and is three things wrong with Everton and two of them are Tim Howard.

Being of the Nev generation, maybe I'm over critical of goalies but I have to say Howard is shite. He's nothing more than a decent shot-stopper at best. His distribution from possession is awful; a hoof out to an opposing player 8 times out of 10. He was at fault for both goals today.

We were so close last season. What held us back? The inability to keep a clean sheet. Roberto, have the balls to drop him for Christ's sake.

Barry Rathbone
99 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:17:22
I never saw what the fuss was about re Barkley, in fact based on first team cameos could see why Moyes wouldn't play him.

"I'll have humble pie with chips and mushy peas please".

The last time I saw a player in royal blue that smooth and instinctive with his first touch was a little ginger haired lad ... Alan Ball.

Kev Johnson
100 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:20:05
The "highlights" on MOTD gave the impression it was a pretty even game. The truth is that we battered them. Our general play merited a two goal lead by the time they scored.

We did lack a bit of penetration when we were on top, Jags still seems uncomfortably positionally and Ossie was dire - and I say that as an admirer of him in general. But apart from those things, I thought were pretty impressive. A really encouraging start to the Martinez reign.

Before the game, a lot of people were saying what a tough match it was, away to Norwich. Afterwards, a fair few are saying it was an easy game and we should have walked it! Make your minds up, folks.

James Flynn
101 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:27:08
Roberto, just keep playing Barkley. He's the key this season.
Paul Andrews
102 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:25:11
Compare last seasons away v Norwich to this season.
Last season winning 1-0 and retreat into our shells hold what we have defend for our lives on the edge of our 18 yard boxand end up with nothing.
OR.. Get in front and go for the 3 rd killer goal getting numbers forward.
Patrick Murphy
103 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:25:39
Gerrard I know Tim isn't the best in the world but I can't see what more he could have done with both goals today, the first was a great curling effort that deserved to go in but hit the post and fell right for the incoming player to score, the second was a perfect header that even Nev at his brilliant best would have struggled to keep out.

I'd also prefer Tim to the other keeper who looks too nervous for my liking and he could be a problem if he has a run of games, at least you know and more importantly the defence knows what Tim is going to do.

Colin Wainwright
104 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:26:59
Agree Barry. Excited about what the lad can achieve. God knows we could do with a new Bally.
Phil Sammon
105 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:26:23
Kev Johnson

I remember it well mate. Ahhh, it's great to see him do what we knew he could. Tip of the iceberg too, Kev.

And Gerard, no keeper on the planet would have for near either of today's goals.

Phil Sammon
106 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:33:32
That didn't make a lot of sense - but you get my drift.
Milos Milenkovic
107 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:26:21
We deserved to win; we had around 70% possession away from home and more than 20 shots. It's incredible that we totally battered them in last 3 games, but still won only two points. Anyhow great approach from EFC and hopefully results will follow our play.
Gerard Morgan
108 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:30:59
But Patrick what held us back last season? Not keeping a clean sheet. Was that down to Baines, Jags, Distin, Coleman, who?
Derek Thomas
109 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:10:56
7/10; could have been better, could have also been worse.

Barkley; keep him in until he's an absolute liability, then keep him in some more ( I mean it was good enough for Neville and some others last season )...let him learn by doing, the apprentice won't learn much by making tea and brushing up.

Miralles was a bit ordinary and also sometimes a bit too far inside. This had the effect of leaving Coleman on his own and space for Redmond(?) to get in between and behind Coleman and Jags, which He did for 30 mins until he seemed to fade.

Jags and Distin; anybody who attacks that space between them is always liable for something...been this way for years.

Jelavic looks better and the little we saw of Kone, leaves me asking ' How much! '

1) Keep hold of the players we have until 3rd Sept. 2) Get 1 or 2 in that make Gibson and Osman the cover not the starters, then reassess in Jan...although I feel we won't get 2) without breaking 1).

All in all Onwards and upwards / OK...bring on WBA

Matt Muzi
110 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:18:14
Colin @ 150, my opinion of Naismith, is he's never really been played in his natural position which is a striker/centre forward, but for me more importantly, like a lot of players he isn't the same player he was before the injury that ruled him out of most of his last season at Rangers.

I watched him play the season before his injury a few times on the TV, which I accept doesn't give you a completely accurate view, but he was head & shoulders better than he is, or has been since he came to us.

Yeah I agree tactically we were different than under Moyes, but when we were put under the cosh a bit & were getting tired, the old Moyes tactics came to fruition again.

I think my main concern is the funds RM has been given thus far, I personally am made up he's our manager, but I would hope that he could get more funds for players than he's had thus far, because as you mention about the Kendall cup run/showing faith in players bringing them on, so I believe does bringing in quality new signings gee up the entire team. But as you have very rightly said we could spend days & days on the clubs finances, management, development investment etc. Hopefully Gibbo is back next week & we can start pushing onwards & upwards!!

Patrick Murphy
111 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:40:27
Matt I agree with your view on Mirallas, he can be a match winner but either because he is still struggling with that ham-string or because it's not in his nature he doesn't always protect the full-back and seems too intent at times of going for glory rather than looking to lay off the simple pass.

Maybe that's part of our problem as a team, in that players like Ossie, Pienaar and RM are luxury players at times. That's why we need a midfield general who will gee the players up at the right times and make sure they play for the team at all times. But Pienaar's end product today and for some considerable time has been woeful, he can be a great little player but too often moves fall down because of his failure to produce a good ball following some good approach play.


Colin Williams
112 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:41:03
Gerard-169, you are so right! Howard is nothing more than a shot stopper. Can't catch the ball, his distribution is very poor and he is always on the ground!
Joel has much more talent, just needs the experience! Really, just the same as Ross in m/f, except he is the real thing!!!
Paul Dark
113 Posted 17/08/2013 at 23:57:08
We should be pleased with a point, given that Osman played. it was 12 against 10. He orchestrated a number of Norwich attacks - as he does with the opposition every game.

He needs to be dropped and retired this week.

Patrick Murphy
114 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:00:16
I like Ossie but he is feeling the pace these days I wonder if we could get McCarthy in a straight swap for him?
Roman Sidey
115 Posted 17/08/2013 at 21:04:15
Personally I'm fairly happy with how the game went - obviously their equaliser gutted me though. The signs are there that the players can actually play football (Moyes just didn't know how to coach it) and some of last years issues seem to be ironing out.

For one, Jelavic found space on a few occasions and set attacking play up nicely. Barkley and Coleman were the obvious standouts and Howard seems to be using his arms more than his legs when distributing which is a nice change from the grab, hold, belt it of the last seven years.

I would have liked to see Oviedo on the bench at least, but, as I said on the preview thread, if Gibbo is injured, why can't slip into the middle with the Costa Rican on the wing?

As much as I thought I wouldn't be saying this so early, the centre halves were probably our biggest concern today. Syl had a good game but both goals came from his side - no help from Fella or Ossie there - but Jags just looks off the pace and is really beginning to struggle with aerial balls.

All in all, very excited about next week's home opener against very beatable opposition.

Colin Williams
116 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:02:30
Ossie was dire, again but there were a few senior players that I thought were poor!! (again)
Phil Sammon
117 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:06:10
I know what you mean about the CB's. I love Jags and Distin but I think they are the two players who will struggle most with a new style of play. I have to say, it actually excites me. We have John Stones on the bench who is just waiting to come and do the business.
Ed Fitzgerald
118 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:05:46
Pretty pleasing on the whole and unlike earlier In the year we didn't try to shut up shop and throw away all the points. Poor defending collectively for the first goals including Baines and Fellani who I thought was daily average today.

Negatives Osman and Jagielka. Jags will may struggle I he is expected to defend higher up the pitch plus his distribution is very weak, it will be interesting to see how it pans out for him under Martinez. Ossie was awful today.

Positives include nearly 70 per cent possession and great performances form Coleman and Barkley and a more attractive approach to the game.

Colin Wainwright
119 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:08:37
Roman, I think the signs were there in Moyes last game. It was like the shackles had been thrown off, the players didn't give a shite for his zonal crap and just played. I'm really excited about what this team can do under RM, this season.
Suresh Gill
120 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:11:18
We deserve to finish better in a game where we had more possession. Lack of finishing again. Naismith should have scored to make it 3 at the end.
Coleman is turning out to be great piece of work, he's more confident using his left foot as well.
Good performance from Barkley, he plays very instinctively and hammered a great goal in for us.
Paul Ferry
121 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:20:45
Anyone yesterday who posted such shite about Bobby and his apparently - remember - awful public performances that put him on a par with or below Brenda according to one rocket scientist ought to hang their heads in fucking shame watching his 2 post-match interviews this evening.

The shite on that that thread was embarrassing.

We are very lucky to have such an articulate, smart, media-savvy, upbeat, progressive, gaffer unlike .......

Phil Sammon
122 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:34:11
Well said Paul (you socialist scumbag) mate!
Steve Brown
123 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:33:37
That wasn't too bad. Time to persevere with Barkely and drop Osman to the bench, even when Gibson returns.

Main downside was another sloppy start from Jagielka. Every season he seems to take 4-5 games to get going.

Paul Ferry
124 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:37:32
UP THE WORKERS
Phil Sammon
125 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:39:05
Haha.
Drew Shortis
126 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:09:29
Good game to watch, especially in the second half. After the Norwich opener the sinking feeling was back again and I was wondering just why I had been looking forward to the agony of football again. Thankfully this was followed by the sheer ecstasy of Barkley's brilliant strike and joy at Coleman putting us in front. I liked the way we continued to play football and felt we would go on to get a third. The move leading to Van Wolfswinkel's goal was a little fortunate for Norwich with a sliced cross which may have taken a slight deflection off of our guys back, but the header was fantastic and I can't begrudge them their point.

68% possession away from home shows the potential of the new system once everyone is up to speed. At times we struggled to find a killer final ball (especially Pienaar) or to break fast enough (Mirallas), but I'm sure that will come. Little hoof ball on display. I saw Jags go to lump it a few times only to check himself and play a shorter pass.

Osman was Ok in the first half, but became a liability in the second. He does not belong in the deep role. For me he is much more useful in the forward three midfielders where his lack of pace and strength is less apparent and his dribbling and quick short passing can be better utilised. Shame Gibson was injured and I still hope there is some truth in the Barry rumour.

I think the comments about Tim by Gerard 169 are a bit harsh. I don't think he as to blame for either goal today and his distribution seemed a lot better, often opting for an accurate throw to try and initiate a break. Kone had less than ten minutes to make an impact and he got involved with play, coming deeper to get a touch before making his forward runs. Some strikers can come on with ten minutes left and not even touch the ball. Its a bit early to write him of Derek 180.

Obviously Barkley was the biggest plus point to come out of this match. Really glad to see Martinez giving him the opportunity. I have no doubts Ross will repay him for the faith he has sown in him. His goal was a beauty, what a way to open your Everton account. I'm sure I wasn't the only one to have a premonition about him finding a bit of space and thumping one in from the edge of the box!

Not a perfect start to the Martinez era, but not a bad one. On reflection I'm please with what I saw today and I can't wait for West Brom!

Jimmy Sørheim
127 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:06:36
I must admit I am very pleased that Barkley scored his debut goal. However, I have never seen a more frail defensive performance since the year Lescott was sold and we lost heavily to Arsenal.

Come on, if this is the best RM can do with regards to getting the right defenders together and having them be fully fit and ready for the new season, then I can see us heading down a dark, dark path.

That first goal we conceded was exactly the sort of thing that makes me hate Fellaini, he just cannot be bothered in these matches as is the same for many other players. Osman was abysmal, how on earth is he still at the club?

Please sell Fellaini, he simply does not care about winning, and we need the money.I want the whole team except Barkley and Coleman to look into themselves. This season will be a terrible one with this midfield. Osman and Felli should be sold NOW!!!

Phil Sammon
128 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:39:33
Since our little to-and-fro I've kept an eye out for you posts and I do tend to find myself agreeing with you. Particularly the one about enjoying mojitos on Miami beach.
Paul Ferry
129 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:45:50
Likewise Phil but it was a proletarian mojito - no umbrella or fresh mint - and I did apologize to the minimum-wage bartender

UP THE WORKERS

Roman Sidey
130 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:51:19
As long as you tipped slightly more than the given gratuity that they love to put on bills in the US, Paul. Keep them just financial enough that they can come to work every day.

"If there is hope..."

Andy Crooks
131 Posted 18/08/2013 at 00:55:58
I don't expect a bedding in period. We haven't suddenly signed 10 new players. We have a good settled squad and I expect our manager to do well with them. If we get a few hidings it should no more be tolerated than it would have been under Moyes.

I believe that those who are prepared to accept a bedding in period,
when a thumping will be acceptable, are actually the negative ones. I thought today was a good show and a game we deserved to win. There is much to be positive about with Roberto but it does no harm to have some dissenting voices.

Paul Broadhead
132 Posted 18/08/2013 at 01:33:10
A decent result from the Blues, although I think we need to wait 4-5 games to get a better picture. I'm worried about our defence though this season.
Anto Byrne
133 Posted 18/08/2013 at 02:02:20
I'm so happy with the possession game: we have the ball, they can't score. We had chances to score 4 or 5 so RM has work to do. It was a Moyes-esque performance in that we had loads of the ball but less than clinical up-front.
Si Cooper
134 Posted 18/08/2013 at 02:17:43
Watched the extended highlights on Sky which confirmed the impression given by the live radio commentary - one side was far better and deserved to win.

Norwich were more than 4 half-decent players poorer than us. What they did well was get 8 outfield players within spitting distance of their eighteen yard box for the majority of the time, hitting us on the break and converting their only clear-cut chances of the second half. It would be hyper critical to really slag off any of our players though I wouldn't disagree with any who pointed out that Osman, Pienaar and Mirallas were way below their best / most effective, Fellaini was caught out on his heels for their first, and Seamus unnecessarily strayed a yard too far back to play van Wolfswinkel onside for their second.

Overall, the basics were good and everyone pitched in; they stifled the flanks pretty effectively (where most of our creativity normally comes from) but we had more to offer going through the middle than in previous seasons; some more accurate shooting and marginally more precise crossing could have had us in front long before their opener.

As long as we can build on this performance in relatively small ways we will have a decent season, if we can possibly bring in a couple of key reinforcements then we could be really competitive.

Ernie Baywood
135 Posted 18/08/2013 at 02:36:41
Decent performance and just about deserved 3 points instead of the 1 we got.

First half we dominated but lacked a cutting edge. In fact, it was all a bit "same old". Lots of neat possession. Barkley and Mirrallas the ones most likely to produce a 'spark' to ignite the game.

Second half Ross took the game by the scruff of the neck. Not the whole time, but in spells. At times he just looked incredible. Kind of like when we used to watch Rooney generating his own MOTD highlights package. MOTM for me, narrowly ahead of our under-appreciated lanky Belgian.

Some real positives, and one real negative. The only defence I can think of for Osman's performance is that he doesn't select himself. He turned 50/50s into 05/95s, he gave the ball away, he played pointless passes that stopped the flow of the team. He also did something that he did right through pre-season - got beaten and stopped playing to complain at the ref (repeatedly). If there was ever a sign that someone has lost 'it' and can't stomach how far away from his peak he is, well that's it. RM's first big decision this week.

Derek Thomas
136 Posted 18/08/2013 at 02:54:12
Drew #198, I know that Kone only came on for 10 mins, but to me he looked a bit like Jelly when he ' only came on for 10 mins ' last season - not quite there, onlya run will cure that, trouble is, Jelly ISN'T the guy of last year and there can only be one or the other. Comes down to players maintaining their form and Managers choice.

Early doors yet but happy enough for the moment...with a little worry in the CMid area.

Rob Smith
137 Posted 18/08/2013 at 03:03:38
Ernie, spot on.
Maybe it was part of RM's contract of employ, BK and DM told him, " You have the job Roberto but Osman has to make the first team weekly" Really on todays performance Gibson comes back in Osman to the bench, you just can't drop Barkley, Osman can't score from 6 yrds let alone a cracking 25 yrd drive.
Rob Smith
138 Posted 18/08/2013 at 03:10:23
Kone was on Ramadan, must take a little time to get fitness back into the body, would think he will only get stronger and quicker sooner rather than later.
Albert Perkins
139 Posted 18/08/2013 at 03:45:56
Just read that Arsene Wenger said Arsenal is working 24/7 to buy more players.

Arsenal were very unlucky to go down 3-1 today. Those 3 points could mean a lot at the end of the season. Man U batter up and coming Swansea, and Lpool lucky to survive with a win.

I think we are doing OK on the first day out. Bit unlucky not to win, but lots of promise out there. Barkley could be in the England squad this year and Bobbie could find the right mix to move us on. COYB.

Zack Yusof
140 Posted 18/08/2013 at 05:14:45
Enjoyed the match and thought there were plenty of positives to be had from it. A draw from a ground we rarely win at is not the worst thing in the world on opening day. Some of the moaning on here is quite unbelievable though. Fellani crap, Kone crap, Ossie crap, Martinez clueless for bringing on Naismith etc etc...You would have thought we took the lead, dropped deep to defend, inviting the opposition on and ended up with nothing to show. Oh wait...

Naismith came on, could have scored and did a decent job. Maybe if we as supporters got behind him more, he might just turn into a useful player for us. Certainly, his recent form has earned him a chance to show us all what he can do. So why don't we just cut him some slack? Fellaini and Barclay bossed the midfield for me and on a luckier day, we would have been on here toasting a great opening day win.

If we play like that every week, we will win more than we lose so some perspective please!

Zack Yusof
141 Posted 18/08/2013 at 05:51:42
Sorry Michael, of course I'm referring to our Zidane in the making Ross Barkley. Bloody auto correct!! Oh and Ossie was pretty dire but I won't be writing him off just yet. Can't wait for next week now..
Mike Green
142 Posted 18/08/2013 at 06:56:31
Andy #205 - bloody hell mate its his first game! Of course he needs a bedding in period.

He doesn't know the players, doesn't know the club, they don't know him or his ideas and between the two of them they're working out if they can do what he wants on the pitch.

In almost any new job you'd be given a bit of slack for the first few months, why should he be any different?

Sam Hoare
144 Posted 18/08/2013 at 07:17:52
No concrete conclusions should ever be drawn from the first couple of games of the season but I think there were definitely more positives than negatives. The biggest of which was obviously Barkley but we must not expect to much of him, exciting as it is.

Only in another 3 or 4 weeks will we have a better idea of how we are adapting to RMs football but a thrashing of WBA would be a good confidence builder.

Finally, I do find it vaguely hypocritical that some posters who were unremittingly negative under OFM are crititising others for daring to see fault with the new era. Horse for courses and all of that.

Eugene Ruane
145 Posted 18/08/2013 at 07:45:22
I thought we played some really great stuff yesterday and if not for some cacky, rushed final balls would have pissed it.

Tony I'Anson
146 Posted 18/08/2013 at 08:06:34
There are two types of draws in my view. The one that feels like a win when we grab a last minute equaliser and everyone is happy we got a point. Then there is the draw when we were winning and should have shut up shop for the 3 points.

Anyone got the stats on this from last season?

Paul Andrews
147 Posted 18/08/2013 at 08:16:54
I enjoyed the game,thought it looked very promising for the future.
It will get better with time as well.
One concern would be Distin and Jagielka,especially Jags.He looked all over the place positionally at times.Not comfortable with distribution either.
As said above our final ball let us down on several occasions.Coleman in the first half got into some great positions on the by line and didn't deliver.
All in all I am we'll pleased with Robertos first game
Paul Andrews
148 Posted 18/08/2013 at 08:39:59
Reports this morning that Utd are preparing an £18 million bid for Fellaini.

That's fucking shocking.Right out of the blue
Who could have seen that coming.

Derek Thomas
149 Posted 18/08/2013 at 08:38:54
Tony #221 IMO and from experience, all shutting up the shop when you are winning does is hand the opposition the initiative. I feel the correct way to go about ' defending ' a 1 or 2 or goal lead is to keep on doing what you where doing to get said lead, keep your shape, keep the ball, score a few more...simplistic? maybe, but the overall facts seem to bear it out.

How many times over the years have you seen a team cruising at 2-0 end up with a draw or even get mullered 3-2...I still haven't got over Forest and Ian Storey Moore in 67.

Tony Marsh
150 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:02:52
Sam @219 — the big difference between Martinez and the other fella is and was we were talking about the same things done or not done for 11 full years under Moyes. The game plan throughout the whole Moyes tenure was a survival-based plan with no room or thought for expansive football. Once in a while, when decent stuff was played, the players were reeled back in the very next game.

You need only look at the Barkley scenario to see the massive difference in manager mindset and way of doing things. Moyes treated Ross Barkley like a leper while Martinez has embraced the lad and given him a massive confidence boost.

Come on, lad — how on earth can you look for or find fault in Martinez after one game? We lost last season at Norwich when the Canaries were a weaker outfit. I don't think you're engaging the brain before you post, mate.

Tony I'Anson
151 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:16:12
Fair point Derek, but the point I was making is between a point earned or 2 lost. Eg 3 all v Man Utd that we could have won at the end.
Ben Hayes
152 Posted 18/08/2013 at 08:41:58
Only about half way down the page but what are some of you on about same as Moyes and we are no different than last year. We dominated and should have won yes that's similar but we passed the ball better than we ever had we played Barkley and he was class 96% pass success I have heard. We didn't sit back and both of their goals were lucky as f**k we got a point from a game we lost and things look good. It was also Martinez's first that's FIRST real game in charge give the man and the team a chance and they will come good.
Ray Robinson
153 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:19:59
Very disappointed with only a draw but overall I thought that we played quite well. It's too early to make any decisions on the Roberto effect as it seemed to me that he picked the team, chose tactics and made substitutions exactly as Moyes would have done - with one possible exception and that was selecting Barkley (arguably, Moyes may have done that also in the absence of Gibson).

All these experts saying that we may score more goals but concede more at the same time may well be right ultimately but to base this on the evidence one match is ridiculous. The team played exactly as it would have done under Moyes, again with one possible exception. We didn't lump the ball forward to Fellaini as he was playing in a more withdrawn position. With Barkley playing, we were always likely to get more long distance strikes away on goal. So we may lose some goals from Fellaini but gain more from Ross.

There's too much labouring of the point that we will be poorer defensively under Martinez just because Wigan's record was poor. It's the same defence as under Moyes! We started off poorly last year I seem to remember but solidified as the season went on.

To me, we're still several signings away from seeing any real Martinez effect.

Paul Andrews
154 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:20:43
Sorry Ray,

That was as far away from how Moyes would have played the game that you can get.

Ray Robinson
155 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:31:49
Paul, in what way? Apart from the use of Barkley/Fellaini. The first half in particular reminded me so much of the Moyes era, laboured build-up, no pace, no cutting edge.
Eugene Ruane
156 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:29:23
Imo, Everton's response to any bid for Fellaini should include the words 'money' 'up' 'shove' and 'arse'.

Agreed he doesn't 'perform' in every game but he does have a presence that makes sides nervous and without him we will appear flimsier and a LOT less of a threat.

Would love to think we might follow the present trend of "We don't give a shite what you want, you're under contract, you're staying."

(nb: I appreciate the clubs who have said this are financially able to do so, as they are not run by a 'fur coat and no knickers' Tom Pepper, rob-Peter-to-pay-Paul clown like we are).

Tony Draper
157 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:48:17
We played well, dominated most of the play, scored two goals away from home, increased Barkley's playing time significantly (and encouragingly so) and conceded two goals that the home side won't be repeating again all season.

Verdict: Unlucky only to come away with a single point, away performances like that will earn us more victories than draws plus defeats.

Gavin Ramejkis
158 Posted 18/08/2013 at 09:59:21
Just read the Independent article with Martinez, so refreshing from the misery we used to have, about Barkley he says - "“This is football. You play with your feet so you are going to make mistakes. It is a game of errors,” Martinez says. “But what I look for from players is how you react to a mistake: does it stop you getting on the ball again? Do you become a bit more cagey? What I have seen from Ross is that it doesn't matter whether he makes a mistake, he is ready to get on the ball again. He just carries on playing in the same manner.”
Andrew Bone
159 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:09:19
I agree with the idea of building a midfield around Barkley. Watching the hour highlights on Sky showed not only how comfortable he is on the ball, but his ability to break up an attack, set up a counter attack and play a simple ball quickly rather than dithering. Osman gave the ball away around their box too often and broke up our attacks on occasion.

I thought Jelavic showed more interest and linked the midfield in well. I can't blame RM for making the same sort of subs as Moyes as he is limited in squad depth, but at least he went for a win by putting Vic on... despite his limited time.

Is Mirallas able to complete 90 minutes yet, or was he just not playing well yesterday? Have we seen the end of Hibbo with the attacking play of Coleman?

Just our luck with their two goals yesterday, a shanked shot turning into a cross. We could do with a bit of good fortune to help this season along...

Kev Johnson
160 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:18:58
Gavin - I'm all for Barkely and all for Martinez, but I came across that quote a couple of days ago and I found it a little worrying. It's the last sentence. "He just carries on playing in the same manner". It does not suggest that anything is being learnt from mistakes.

While I love the fact that RM is not risk-averse (like DM) and is prepared to chance it sometimes, there has to be a learning curve. It's not as though Ross is going to get the errors out of his system just by playing, he needs to take on board where he went wrong and put it right in future. It's really going to help him having a manager who believes in him, but - unless he's going to turn in a MOM performance every week (which I doubt) - then he can't just "carry on playing in the same manner".

Matt Traynor
161 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:29:48
Kev #238 I think you are over-thinking it here. Remember 10 years ago when Rooney was playing for us? Wasn't exactly following team orders etc, he was just playing and showing us, and Man U unfortunately, what he was about.

Ross has made a few mistakes, and I'm sure he will learn from them. I watched yesterday's game in a pub with a load of ST holders, and the feed was crap - kept cutting out. Watched the highlights on MOTD this morning, and to his credit, Shearer was waxing lyrical about his performance, and highlighted how he hunts for the ball etc. Don't forget, the lad lost a year of his development due to that triple leg break on England U19 duty.

OFM will probably surprise us all and the deadline day bid won't be for Fellaini, but...

Nick Entwistle
162 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:39:19
Thought the highlights offered on MOTD were pretty week so can't comment on performance, but having kept away from the match until then it was atypical or last season. Go behind, fight back, screw up almost immediately. Oh well.
Jely looked to be reinvigorated and could have dummied his shot at the end then just poked it it. Erm,.. its what I would have done...
Colin Grierson
163 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:46:19
Just watched Footy Focus on playback and the 'camera glimpsing' Lawrenson reckons we'll do we'll to finish in the top half! Savage agreed!! Pair of .....! I couldn't watch it from then on!
Colin Grierson
164 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:46:19
Just watched Footy Focus on playback and the 'camera glimpsing' Lawrenson reckons we'll do we'll to finish in the top half! Savage agreed!! Pair of .....! I couldn't watch it from then on!
Kev Johnson
165 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:58:31
Michael/Lyndon - how about a TW poll on where we'll finish this season?
Colin Malone
166 Posted 18/08/2013 at 10:51:21
Ossie does get knocked off the ball easily, but if you're going to play touchy, touchy, keep ball, then Ossie is the best at the club.

Give them time.
Jim Knightley
167 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:04:20
Colin...you are a quite a supporter of Robles. How many times have you seen him play exactly?

Re. reminded me of Moyes etc rubbish...We played alot of good football under Moyes last season, so I don't the point in bringing them up as a critique. But...of course how football this season will remind us of the Moyes era. None of new signings started...Martinez has been at the club less than 2 months. What did you expect to see...Barcelona? It will be a season of transition to a gradually more passing concentrated style which will hopefully not cost us too much defensively. Personally I think 2-2 is a good result, and the performance was encouraging. Let's get another cm in though, pronto. I fancy us to win next weekend, and take 4 points from our opening two games. That would do nicely going into an away match at Cardiff.

Trevor Lynes
168 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:26:41
I thought everyone put a good shift in and we bossed the game considering we were away!

Their second equalizer was a fluke because the right back was shooting and sliced the ball which could have gone anywhere. It just cleared our defence and landed on the Wolf's head and his header was brilliant.

Their fullback Whittaker looks a decent player and for me was their best player along with Redmond. The great part was the three young ENGLISH kids were great!! Barkley has all the innate ability Rooney had when he was even younger, ie, strength, vision, pace and an eye for a goal. If he is taken care of, he will be a future star.

I have not seen Stones but he sounds like another star in the making. I'm sure that RM will bring them both on in the right way.

The game was really enjoyable and the football on view was excellent. We are one top class midfielder away from a genuine challenge for Europe. Distin is amazing and Martinez singled him out as a player with a knock in the first half who insisted in carrying on. We have fine team spirit and there seems to be no-one who is unhappy playing for EFC.

Jamie Barlow
169 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:38:06
I've seen Robles play a few times now and he looks shit. If he's one for the future, play him in the future. Football is simple really.
Winston Williamson
170 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:36:24
There were times yesterday where Ross Barkley played as a number ten, something not seen at Everton! He looked quality.

I cannot agree about us being the same as we were under Moyes. There is a difference...we look to keep the ball better and for longer.

A huge improvement would be to inject some speed into the team. Replacing Pienaar, with someone quicker, but his technical equal, would be a start. Additionally, replacing Osman with a dynamic midfielder would be advantageous...

Matt Traynor
171 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:38:07
Colin #255, I heard that! And on Friday's preview show on 5live (what happened to Colin Murray, Pat Nevin and Perry Groves??) Robbie Savage was one of Dan Walker's pundits, and he re-iterated there. But someone (I think it was Sav) said he thought we'd finish in the lower half of the table but win a cup...

I won't get too antagonised by it though - we essentially have the same squad as last season (barring any late drama in the window) but arguably teams around us have strengthened their squads, so it's easy for a pundit / journo to make a case to say we'll slip.

Under OFM we made a habit of defying expectations, to the point where we were labelled "best of the rest" etc. Hopefully RM will continue that.

Anthony Hawkins
172 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:53:09
I was at the match yesterday and I think Pienaar's legs have gone. He's never been the fastest player but the usual Baines Pienaar partnership just wasn't there despite Baines' efforts. Coleman was immense down the right, Mirallas was really good and Barkley will be an immense player for us. Fellaini will be a big loss for us if he goes as everything goes through him. May be it will enable another player to step forward. Maybe a Barkley and Gibson partnership? We missed Gibson holding play together.

One player who looked lost the entire game was Osman. There have been games last season where Osman was key but this game Osman was carried.

It's one game into the season but I'd say we need a left midfielder and a replacement for Fellaini if he goes.

Howard. Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, Mirallas, Gibson, Barkley, Fellaini, ??, Jelavic

That would be my preferred first team lineup.

Oh and Norwich's #22 and #17 are ones to watch. #22 is going to cause teams plenty of problems this season.

Brin Williams
173 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:18:11
McCarthy??
Paul Andrews
174 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:01:16
Ray,

Apart from the 2 exceptions you mention.
Starting from the back;

Howard threw or rolled the ball out more than under Moyes,trusting his defenders.

Centre backs had more touches of the ball than under Moyes.

Full backs played further forward BOTH in advanced positions at the SAME time.
Under Moyes one went and one stayed the majority of the time.

Midfielders showed more for the ball,man in possession had several options every time.
The midfielders interchanged position a lot,a trait of Martinez style of football and the main reason Wigan wiped the floor with us in the cup game.

And just a general air of confidence in the midfield.

John Audsley
175 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:26:21
I think, if you had swapped Osman for Gibson yesterday, we would have won.
Ian Bennett
176 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:30:22
Anthony 273 - I thought the same during pre season. Osman and Pienaar either need to deliver consistently or find that they will be no more than squad players. I really hope we get a decent centre midfielder in to up the competition in that space. Poor form needs to be rewarded with a spell on the sidelines.
Mike Allison
177 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:39:32
Everyone seems to have forgotten the way we played at the start of last season. We were already doing this last year.
Paul Andrews
178 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:44:48
Doing what Mike?
Ray Robinson
179 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:47:28
Exactly Mike! Playing the ball out from the back with midfielders and fullbacks asking for the ball and breaking forward. Villa and Swansea away anyone? Even Martinez has stated that any fundamental change in play will take some time. To me, the Everton match yesterday could have been Everton game from last season. Tottenham away for example. Yesterday wasn't the first time that Howard has ever rolled the ball out (though admittedly he and Jags can tend to hoof). He was doing that for a large part last season. Distin and Jags also played the ball along the back last season - sometimes to the point of tedium.

In my opinion, we will only truly change style when we get more pace in the team and are able to hit teams on the counter attack - something that all progressive teams are capable of.

Mike Powell
180 Posted 18/08/2013 at 11:56:18
How can people be happy with with that performance? We drew with a poor Norwich side. Yes, we had loads off the ball and did nothing with it. They had about four shots and scored two, says it all.

Please don't play Ossie again – how many bad games does he have to have before he is sent packing? If we had played a better team today, we would've got murdered.

Gary Carter
181 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:50:19
I'm not too disappointed with the result, I guess, an away point on the opening day. I don't quite understand people raving about our possession from last season, we had more possession than the opposition last season and created more chances too in most games and that's a statistical fact.

It was good to see Barkley get a game and do so well, I hope he stays in when Gibson is fit but we'll see on that one.

I hope that conceding sloppy goals isn't a Martinez trend as it was at Wigan last season. Other than that, I feel similar to how I felt when RM was appointed, slightly underwhelmed!

Mark Frere
182 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:59:31
Well said Ray and Mike. People like Paul appropriately forget how we played early last season. I still can't believe certain people single out the Fulham game last season as a example of us being negative
Matt Traynor
183 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:08:30
Mark #285, I assume you refer to the away game? We could be accused of a lot of things in that game. Failing to put chances away, too many individual errors etc. But one thing I have never heard is anyone say we were negative!

Even the normally dour / reserved Martin Jol commented after the game that how we didn't spank them out of sight was beyond him!

My simplistic view of our style for most of last season was that we were more expansive, but at cost to our defence.

Mates of mine from other clubs said that they were pleasantly surprised with how we played (in most cases). I don't know any Stoke fans though.

If any further proof were needed that we'll continue in that vein, we weren't last on MOTD last night - despite Lovejoy and Dawson predicting we would be on the BTS pre-show yesterday.

Paul Dark
184 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:14:20
I thought Kone looked out of it yesterday - and feel (for now) he should be third in the pecking order behind Jelly and Victor.

I think Osman should retire this week; I would do a better job than him, no question.

Thought Kevin looked a little out of sorts yesterday - but Seamus, Ross and even Felli played well. Thought Pienaar was OK, Baines very good as ever.

Stroking the ball around is not enough; we need more movement, wit and penetration.

Losing Fellaini and Baines before 2Sep is not an option. I hope RM is listening because he gave the distinct impression of inviting bids in the recent BBC interview.

He's quite smarmy, Martinez.

Harold Matthews
185 Posted 18/08/2013 at 12:53:32
Anthony. I think we were watching different games.
In my match Pienaar was buzzing here there and everywhere and was still going strong at the end.
Also, in your match Mirallis was "very good" but in mine , after a promising start, he disappeared without trace.
Brian Keating
186 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:29:52
For years people have been saying that Osman only gets a game because he's a Moyes pet.

Then he gets an England cap. Either that Hodgson fella is a muppet or there's a serious lack of midfield talent in England.

So now we have a new manager, who does he pick? Osman. Even though apparently it should be obvious to everyone he's finished apparently.

So either:

1. 3 top class football managers are wrong about Osman and he's no use.

Or

2. Osman is a decent player.


I know which option is more logical.

Paul Andrews
187 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:43:19
Ah well,
I suppose it's different folks for different strokes.
Paul Andrews
188 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:45:31
Mark Frere,

What did you mean by " people like Paul appropriately forget"

Mark Tanton
189 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:48:58
Brian, England have a talent puddle at the moment and it's not very deep. Osman won a cap. So did Ricketts when he was at Bolton.

Osman has been fucking dreadful for as long as I can remember, but he's currently taking it to new levels which are almost impressive.

Carl Sanderson
190 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:44:42
Brian,

Joe Royle used to say that midfield players need to be able to pass, tackle and/or score. A good one can do two out of the three. Reidy couldn't shoot, Bally couldn't tackle, Scot Gemmill couldn't do any of them. The best can do all three, e.g. Roy Keane.

Ossie is a really good player in my book. He has a great first touch; he can see a pass; he is brave; and he can score goals. He lacks physical stature and he can't really tackle. But I love the fact that someone with his skills and his personality plays for Everton.

Anthony Hawkins
191 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:37:22
Wherever Pienaar was going it certainly wasn't down the left wing most of the time, which is where he was supposed to be. Pienaar moved inside because he couldn't run past players and didn't look to have the capacity to out manouvor them either.

Mirallas did fade during the game but it can not be denied that he was one of most creative players.

Barkley was definitely MOTM.

Dan Brierley
192 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:12:11
Ultimately, it was a game where we enjoyed a huge amount of possession which did not translate into clear cut chances. Lots of shots, but goals aside, Ruddy literally had only a point blank save to make that I can remember. Ross Barkley's goal was a moment of sheer genius, what a joy to watch. Our second goal was due to a great through ball from Pienaar, but you have to blame Ruddy for palming it right into Colemans path. But that said, Norwich were not exactly peppering our goal either, their second goal being something out of Monty Python script....

I got the impression that the general ethos yesterday was 'keep the ball at all costs', that was something new and certainly came from Martinez. My only concern with this, is that the players looked unwilling to take any risks, as they were more focused on keeping the ball hence the frequent cut insides and lay offs.

But in general a decent day and happy not see any signs of defensive frailties at the back, their goals were not linked to major defensive errors. Our lads about the back generally kept Norwich quiet.

But of course, the highlight was watching Ross Barkley, who looked miles better than the shaky, anxious teenager we previously saw. I am not interested in the brownie point debate about who or how he was developed, what is important that Ross's game was dripping in maturity and confidence, not to mention he has certainly beefed up a lot which was reflected in his ability to retain the ball. Although I will at least give him a few games before I even compare him to Ossie in his prime, perhaps a bit premature for the Zidane comparisons. Nevertheless, the obvious potential there is something very exciting and a joy to watch.

Anthony Hawkins
193 Posted 18/08/2013 at 13:54:20
@Brian - Full credit to Osman for getting his England cap and there's no taking that away from him.

The flaw in suggesting he's International quality can be seen by looking at the current England squad and its performances. The current England squad has to be the weakest for a long time and the performances have been pretty dire. May be that's due to the manager but the midfield particularly is shocking! There's a lack of balance and solidity in the midfield exacerbated by a lack of quality strikers.

Ernie Baywood
194 Posted 18/08/2013 at 14:22:09
Anthony, any recollection of the names adorning the #17 and #22 shirts?

I'm guessing Dogsdick and Redmond. Both will give teams a hard time with their pace and willing but, defensively, Redmond was Coleman's bitch yesterday. Caught out time and time again and wouldn't get within a mile of our side.

Anthony Hawkins
195 Posted 18/08/2013 at 14:37:07
Redmond was #22 and played on the right wing. He never got the better of Baines but caused problems when he carried the ball inside.

#17 was Bennett. Whilst not as skilful as Redmond he always comfortable and confident on the ball. Bennett played on the left and was owned by Coleman.

Ross Edwards
196 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:05:51
Very encouraged by our performance yesterday. Martinez must be making a positive impact, 88% pass completion compared to 79% under Moyes. We played some excellent stuff and I liked Robbie's all out attacking style even when we were ahead.
Jamie Barlow
197 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:16:03
Here's a nice stat Ross.

So far - of the players to attempt 50+ passes this weekend - nobody tops Ross Barkley's 96.2% accuracy. Just two misplaced passes (51/53).

Ross Edwards
198 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:21:09
But Jamie, all this is well and good, if you take your chances, and we didn't yesterday. This has to be sorted out.
Barry Rathbone
199 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:00:16
Paul Dark 287,

"He's quite smarmy, Martinez."

The same man who remained loyal to Wigan when 99 out of 100 managers would have jumped ship at the mere mention of the Villa and Liverpool jobs.

Your Moyes colours are showing, the sale of Baines, Fellaini or anyone else is a reflection of our financial state and zip all to do with RM. Far better to deal with it in an adult businesslike manner than posture a la Moyes/Lescott with all the ill effect that provided.

Ridiculous assertion.

Paul Andrews
200 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:28:31
Ridiculous indeed
Jamie Barlow
201 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:29:39
I'm sure they'll start to put the chances away Ross.

Ossies stats surprise me. 63/68 - 92.6%. Just 5 misplaced passes.

I thought Moyes did well with the Lescott deal.

Ross Edwards
202 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:30:32
Missing Moyes are we Mr Dark? If there's anyone that's smarmy and smug it's Moyes.
Nick Entwistle
203 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:37:45
Dour and smug. Are they compatible?
Paul Andrews
204 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:53:49
Round and Moyes?
Apparently
Matt Traynor
205 Posted 18/08/2013 at 15:52:03
This thing about RM's public utterances are bizarre!

For my sins, I worked in and around sports marketing / media. And for 99.99% of managers, the media interviews they are compelled to give (by the Premier League Broadcast Contract) are fucking tedious.

The suits above them give them a very tight brief before each PR appearance. "Say Lots. Say Nothing".

Whilst on the subject, I don't agree with immediate-post match interviews either. Too much passion / stress etc. But it's part of "the contract".

Phil Sammon
206 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:05:43
Is there anything more boring than pass completion stats?
Ross Edwards
207 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:17:27
Yes Phil, a David Moyes press conference.
Jamie Barlow
208 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:16:53
Most of your posts come close Phil.

I only posted Ossies because it looked to me every time he got the ball, he lost it. When he only lost it 5 times.

Jamie Barlow
209 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:19:31
"Whilst on the subject, I don't agree with immediate-post match interviews either. Too much passion / stress etc." I totally agree Matt.

You could say the same about posts on here straight after a game.

Matt Traynor
210 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:20:36
Jamie. You, madam, are a bitch.
But I was gonna give the same snark at Phil, as a joke.
Kevin Tully
211 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:17:09
Just watched fat head Steve Bruce saying he would be 'made up' if they got a draw at Chelsea - 10 minutes before kick-off.

How do you think they will go on?

Jamie Barlow
212 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:22:40
Of course I'm joking Matt. I love all of Phils posts.
Thomas Windsor
213 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:19:07
I think a lot of us supporters on here are having a pop at Kenwright, not Martinez. He promises us every year he will spend the cash but never has; how is Martinez going to get that team in the Champions League? It will be impossible.

Some of my friends have given up their season ticket because of his lies. I am still going but financially and the board not spending is making it harder for me to keep on going... but COYB!

Matt Traynor
214 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:22:24
Jamie #334 I just caught your reply after my earlier response.

For me, it's an issue. Anyone remember the Good Friday Derby? Graham Poll? The FA stepped in straight after to ban refs from giving post-match interviews.

It was needed, Poll was embarrassing - but he wasn't a bad referee. PMGOL was formed off the back of the Premier League, but I agree with it.

Interview players immediately after, no prob. But give refs/managers/owners some time to reflect before they speak. Of course, it won't happen.

Paul Andrews
215 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:33:47
Jamie,337

Not only are you a bitch.
You are a sarcastic bitch :-)

Ross Edwards
216 Posted 18/08/2013 at 16:29:03
They are being battered Kevin.
Paul Ferry
217 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:23:17
He's playing for Hull for sure but in 5 minutes Huddlestone playing quite deep has sprayed three peach passes over distance and Hull look a different side.

Exactly the sort of player we need and he has promised to cut that hair when he scores his next premiership goal.

Patrick Murphy
218 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:35:04
Paul being the overoptimistic guy I am, I bet he cuts his hair straight after Hull's game against us. Just heard that Villa play at Stamford bridge on Wednesday, tough start for Villa. Arsenal and Chelsea away and the Dark Side at the weekend.
Colin Glassar
219 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:43:06
Kevin Tully, Steve Bruce is a perennial loser. Hull will be relegated and he'll be whingeing in May as usual.
Ross Edwards
220 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:47:32
As well as eating a lot of pies along the way Colin.
Colin Glassar
221 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:50:12
Are the pies in Hull any good? He almost ruined Wigan after eating Dave broken leg Whelan's private supply of pies.
Ross Edwards
222 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:53:49
Forgot he broke his leg Colin. He hasn't mentioned it recently since.... last week...
Paul Ferry
223 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:50:39
Steve Bruce drives me nuts - I even hate his voice (though not as bad as creepy Jol).

Fashion note: chubby blokes ought never to wear tight shirts with hands tucked into pockets to open jacket out therefore revealing said gut.

Yep: Hull, Palace, and Stoke to go down this season I think.

Roman Sidey
224 Posted 18/08/2013 at 14:43:24
Brian, "[e]ither that Hodgson fella is a muppet or there's a serious lack of midfield talent in England."

I'd say both are actually pretty accurate. What we saw Osman do yesterday is what he's done consistently for the past three or four seasons. The only thing that keeps debating is that he occasionally has moments of brilliance - Man City goal last year a cracking example. Central midfielders really don't have the luxury of being ordinary 98 per cent of the time and brilliant the other two.

I actually meant to mention this earlier, and I'd be willing to put it down to his usual partner in crime being well below par, but Baines didn't impress me for the hype around him yesterday, and hasn't for a while. As I said, he was at his best when Pienaar was also firing, but his crosses haven't been anything to write home about, and when was the last time he put a corner kick on one of our player's foreheads? I honestly can't remember the last time we scored from a corner.

Ross Edwards
225 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:01:41
Another manager I can't stand Paul is Pardew. Dislike him hugely. Especially his comment about us.
Andrew Clare
226 Posted 18/08/2013 at 17:32:24
Pleased with the performance but disappointed with the result.
Very worried that we are probably going to lose Fellani- maybe Baines on the last day of the window and bring in mediocre replacements or not have enough time to replace them
Roman Sidey
227 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:01:13
And you lads discussing post-match pressers, try taking the Super 15 rugby seriously these days when they do half-time interviews with a player from each team. Absolutely embarrassing.
Ross Edwards
228 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:13:36
It's not the managers' fault for these press conferences. The interviewers ask them stupid questions.

I remember someone asked Gordon Strachan at his first Southampton press conference "Are you the right man for the job?" Strachan "No"

If you get asked a boring, mundane, obvious question, that's the answer you're going to get.

Colin Glassar
229 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:18:25
Most press conferences are a waste if time. The journos have their own agendas e.g. Trying to force transfers, hyping up their favourite players, asking stupid questions, generally causing trouble. I think fergie was right banning most of them.
John Audsley
230 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:26:09
Hoddle was very complimentary about Everton's style of play.

Mourinho looked like a rustic James Bond today.

Bruce like a fat, seedy second-hand car dealer.

Paul Dark
231 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:43:40
I didn't like Moyes - as many of my previous posts attest: he was surly, put himself before the club, put his ego before the club and was a poor tactician (though he was very good at buying players).

None of it affects my assertion that RM is smarmy and that he doesn't really say what he thinks. I don't like him either - though I hope he does really well and we win the league!

Osman should be retired tomorrow.

Ross Edwards
232 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:51:52
Why don't you like him Paul, out of interest?
Colin Glassar
233 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:56:35
Paul, I think Martinez is just very media savvy and despite being asked the same, stupid questions all the time he handles the media very well. OFM on the other hand let his boredom, and frustration, with the press show very clearly. He's obviously a trackie who likes being out coaching his team rather than facing the bright lights. A question of styles.
Colin Williams
234 Posted 18/08/2013 at 18:59:25
Roman sidey-378. Great comments! Spot on everything you said.
Colin Williams
235 Posted 18/08/2013 at 19:07:04
Roman sidey 371. Great stuff!!
Patrick Murphy
236 Posted 18/08/2013 at 19:09:00
The most annoying thing about some in fact quite a few press conferences from all spheres but usually sport I find is when you can't hear what the original question was, what's the point, if you can only hear the answer?
Obviously it's easier to guess the question being asked if you're familiar with the respondent, but if you don't it makes it very difficult.

Interviewer :"Mumbled Question"
Respondent "I find that cheese is probably best, but sometimes it can be chicken"

Viewer / Listener What to catch a Mouse? to put in a sandwich? To catch fish?

Lev Vellene
237 Posted 18/08/2013 at 19:16:20
I take heart from the commentators on the live broadcast (well, on the net anyway...) As they said a few minutes before curtains, a draw would be a travesty, a loss even worse! As I understood most media, the 2-2 was sort of lucky, except for the execution...)

And yet, we did go away, scored goals and we didn't start sucking our thumbs waiting for the whistle... :P

Ross Edwards
238 Posted 18/08/2013 at 19:26:15
Obviously a question about what Steve Bruce eats for breakfast Patrick.
Harold Matthews
239 Posted 18/08/2013 at 20:45:47
Blues are popping up all over the place. Fri Aug 16 Twitter:

Roger Bennett ESPN Soccer Gent, Co- host of Men in Blazers-on@ grantland33, SiriusXM FC Ch.94
proud purveyor of Sub-Optimal Radio
New York City

"I have exactly 12 hours left in which I can convince myself Everton are going to win the Premier League before they are Wolfswinkled."
.................................................
Me to him post match: "It was your fault. We have indeed been Wolfswinkled".
.................................................
Him to me this morning.
" GUILTY AS CHARGED."
..................................................

He'd probably love the idea of being mentioned on ToffeeWeb.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb