Club confirms 'derisory and insulting' bids

, 19 August, 462comments  |  Jump to most recent
Man Utd bid £28M for Baines and Fellaini
In an unprecedented move, Everton have issued a club statement confirming rejection of a double bid from Manchester United labelled 'derisory and insulting' for Marouane Fellaini and Leighton Baines.

Director of Communications, Alan Myers issued the following:

Everton can confirm that it has received bids from Manchester United for two players. Those bids were immediately rejected out of hand as derisory and insulting.

The Club did not make public these details as it was vital Roberto Martinez's preparations for the opening game of the Premier League season were not disrupted in anyway.

According to The Echo, Manchester United's offer, which was made by chief executive Ed Woodward only 48 hours before the start of the new Premier League season, is understood to have left considerable bad feeling on Merseyside — especially given that Fellaini's true market value is widely considered to be in excess of the £23.5m clause in his contract which expired on July 31. A £16M bid for the Belgian was tied to a repeat of the £12M for Baines, which had already been rejected by Everton.

A letter of rejection, reputed to be from Everton, that began circling online on the Busby Way website wherein director Jon Woods appeared to admonish the United board for not honouring an agreement that Moyes would not be back for any of his old players, has been declared a fake by Myers on Twitter.

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (462)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ian Campbell
1 Posted 19/08/2013 at 01:58:02
Surely he has to be worth at least the £23.5M clause amount.

He was pretty much an unknown entity when we bought him for £15M and surely his value has to have risen £8-10M no problem.

Either that or Moyes massively overpaid for him when he bought him to us.

Noel Early
2 Posted 19/08/2013 at 10:49:18
Call me a skeptic but why even make this bid public knowledge? It has all the hallmarks of Bill trying to save face. This is now going to drag on until the final minutes of the window. A distraction we don't need, if Martinez wants to sell, I hope he puts bids in for players immediately and not in the final hours when panic sets in.

If Fellaini leaves, get £25M at least, James McCarthy is younger and will be a better holding midfielder in the long term. Baines is worth £20M imo; hard to imagine him in another jersey but by not offering him a new deal, the board have made intentions clear.

ps: When are the Blue Union marching again? Enough is enough!
Jason Davenport
3 Posted 19/08/2013 at 11:05:15
If I was Kenwright, this is what I would say:

"Your recent bid for our 2 players is an absolute insult and shows no respect for our great club. We will have no further dealings with Man Utd."

Richard Reeves
4 Posted 19/08/2013 at 12:24:22
This will be the second to last bid in my opinion which, as being so little, will enable them to come in with a final bid of no more than £35 M for the pair, on deadline day.

I hope Roberto has players lined up and waiting on the end of their phones right up until the final minute of deadline day or maybe Kenwright has broken the habit of a lifetime and been honest by telling him he'll have nothing to spend anyway.

I've said all along that one will go at the last minute but now I think they both will.

Tony Savage
5 Posted 19/08/2013 at 12:58:23
What is this crap? David Moyes was at Everton long enough to know exactly what we will take for Fellaini, Baines or both together. So why all the bull? The whole thing is either media generated or a smokescreen to make it look like he is trying to strengthen the squad to satisfy his new following.

Get real.

Pat Waine
6 Posted 19/08/2013 at 13:50:56
Feli and Baines for £28m? You're having a laugh. Maybe Moyes thinks he is in Tesco and can get two for the price of one. Man Utd should be told to not come near the club until they get serious.
Matt Traynor
7 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:43:24
Well said.

Now stick to it.

OFM is not winning any friends in Manchester either. As much as we value them, Baines and Fellaini aren't the marquee signings they're after.

Deluded idiots!

Paul Kennedy
9 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:47:14
There is a great report in the Mail highlighting what a hypocrite Moyes is well worth the read .Stick to our guns give him nothing but our contempt.
Ken Buckley
11 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:40:36
Part one of strategy to unsettle players and get them sulking and putting transfer requests to the club. I hope the club tell the players that if they put in written requests they will be allowed to go but only if the clubs valuation is met. Going on transfer fees being asked for top players at this time then 50 million pounds the two should be the least figure discussed. Keepiing unsettled players rarely works but they should not expect to be virtually given away.
Peter Jones
12 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:47:00
We should send a 10 million bid in for Rooney. See what they say.
Patrick Murphy
13 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:48:53
That article in the Mail is one of the strongest rebukes I have ever read against an incumbent MUFC manager and is very supportive of Everton FC. Man U have been yanking our chain since the Kanchelskis saga in 1995, tell them where to go and if the players put in transfer requests drop them and make it clear they are contracted to Everton FC, if they don't like it so be it - they will not want to be without first team football with the World Cup coming up next year.

The one good thing about the whole episode is that Evertron's 'special relationship' with United may well have ended and not a day too soon for my money.

Nick Entwistle
14 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:52:01
I don't know if Moyes is going to be the one who decides how much a transfer should be, but you can't expect our most talented players to not be sought after. The timing sucks, but timing is all part of the negotiating business.

Peter Jones - absolutely right. I think Man City bid £1m for Cantona when he was in his Utd pomp just to piss off Fergie.

Paul Melarange
15 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:52:41
How to upset the fans who virtually worshipped you for finishing 6th in just over a month, well done, Moyesie sure you will not get a great reception at Goodison if you carry on like this when Man Utd visit us!

They must be crazy if they think Felliani and Baines combined for £28 million, Baines alone should be worth £28 million in these money mad transfer times.

How about just wondering Felliani to Man Utd and Rooney back to us no cash involved? That's if Mr Rooney would not mind playing for a paltry £75k a week, save them selling him to a title rival and Rooney gets regular first team action as no way he gets a game at Man Utd third choice now after Van Persie and Welbeck, just a thought!!

Up The Toffee's!

Richard Reeves
16 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:52:45
Peter Jones (#798), Would be good wouldn't it? I would except a swap for Rooney with Fellaini and £15 Mill for Baines.
Matt Traynor
17 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:51:44
Ken #797 - that is exactly what the club should do.
Peter #798 - ditto
Mark Tanton
18 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:02:32
I think it's safe to say that Moyes is having a summer transfer window worse than he ever subjected himself to at Everton. What is it about him and too little too late transfer activity? I hope he ends up with fuck all come Sept 2nd.
Guy Hastings
19 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:00:22
I don't usually bother with financial pages but since when has the Manchester pound been worth double the Liverpool pound?
Nick Entwistle
20 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:01:41
Matt, I don't know if Utd do marquee signings, a term that's been bandied about in the press but bares no reality to what they need.

Obviously RVP was of that type, but Fergie had always gone for best when it came to first team signings. But Vidic for example, who'd heard of him before his transfer?

Baines is the best in his position and Utd fans will see how good he is, and Fellaini would add to their midfield brilliantly. Because of this, £50m - no lower.

But then I wouldn't sell them at all. You can lose one of our best every so often, but two go and its a very slippery slope especially if we're faltering come January.

Mark Taylor
21 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:00:09
My hunch is that

1) Utd come back with a higher offer of £35m (maybe in stages) and

2) Kenwright allows RM a cheap deal or loan signing, then banks the cash.

Must be my cynicism....

Tony Draper
22 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:06:17
Class response Everton, not even dealt with until it suited US! This is how we should respond publicly: in our time and in our way with no frills.

I love the fact that The Club offers no indication who they may be; Harry Catterick & Sir John would be proud.

Dan McKie
23 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:06:53
The thing that bothers me about the statement is that it doesn't say the players are not for sale, just that it's a crap bid. Also, it suggest that the bids were made last week, but the club didnt make it public so to not disrupt the Norwich game. So why make it public now? Does disrupting the West Brom and Cardiff games not matter?

If it was United that made the bid public, then they should be brought in front of the FA for clear tapping up, but I do suspect it was Everton, in order to put pressure on Man U to up the bid. Preferably at around 10.30pm Monday 3rd September.

Mike Gaynes
24 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:05:32
The key line in the Mail story is the very last one:

"Despite his long association with the club, David Moyes is no longer Everton, he is 100 per cent Manchester United and solely has their interests at heart."

And that's the way it has to be. Much as it pisses us off, Moyes is doing exactly what he's supposed to do... trying to get the best possible players for Manchester United.at the cheapest possible price. To do anything less would be breaching his fiduciary duty to his employer. And if it unsettles a side that has given United fits in recent years -- Fellaini dismantled them once last year and we knocked them out of the title with that 4-4 draw two seasons ago -- so much the better.


Business is business.

David Chait
25 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:16:00
Flip that is news.. And from our official site...
Alan Smith
26 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:13:42
Spurs would get about £60m for these two players, Kenwright will get about £35m for them.
Brian Cleveland
27 Posted 19/08/2013 at 14:44:24

Whether we're personally fans of Baines and Fellaini or not, I think Manure should be told to take a hike whatever the price. Just maybe now that they've got Moyes they've lost their inside man!

Go away, you're not welcome.

Jamie Barlow
28 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:14:51
I too think it's a good reply from Everton. Short and straight to the point.

Fuck off would have been better.

Paul English
29 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:07:05
For once can our club take a leaf out of LFC and treat MUFC and have nothing to do with that club? The Rooney saga, the pathetic apology over the tap-up of Moyes, the humiliation of the offer for Baines and Fellaini — and it won't end there, because, make no mistake, they will want Barkley.

This is a club whose history is only 50 odd years, just like our neighbours.... Come on, EFC and all our fans — wash your hands of MUFC and stand up to the football world and them: we a massive club in our own right.

Mike Rourke
30 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:17:37
My word, that IS a good article in The Mail.

How long did it take for him to stop slouching in the dug-out and retrieve his dummy after the Lescott saga? 6 months at least and he certainly let it wreck that season.

Article is spot on. He is a hypocrite.

Tommy Coleman
31 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:21:42
Good reply.. now we need to stick to it or end up looking like fools that no one will respect in the future.
Matt Traynor
32 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:17:07
Nick #806 United do marquee signings in a big way.
Vidic may have been unknown to most of us, but when they signed him from Spartak they still paid around £7m for him.

Berbatov, Ferdinand - both £30m+ signings. Remeber Veron? £28m and they sold him for half that to Chelsea.

The one player they have signed this window was a done deal before OFM got there. He's panicking as none of his targets have materialised for one reason or another. So he's gone for the safe option of trying to nick 2 decent players he knows well on the cheap cos he knows we're run by Arkright. Granville has moved from the corner shop to the Supermarket.

Paul Mackie
34 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:25:14
I'm liking this Alan Meyers chap. It seems our Communications department finally has some balls.
Ian Burns
35 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:17:00
This is BK's BIG opportunity! I know he is overwhelmingly disliked on this site (to put it mildly) but he has a chance to do the right thing by the supporters of EFC and not necessarily the board of EFC.

If Moyes' strategy is to unsettle these two players - and it may well succeed - tell Utd to pay the right price and immediately, so we can re-invest or make it publicly clear that we will not do business in the week running up to 2nd September.

In this way, he has an opportunity to show strength because if he banks the money as suggested on this thread, then it would be a public demonstration to the "majority" of how this club is being run.

I hope and pray he does in fact take the opportunity to show some balls for once.

Mick Quirke
36 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:28:55
Our PR is getting so much better. OK, there are issues (and major ones) with the running of the Club, but the US tour, the stuff with the fans' meetings over here, the evenings with Martínez over here, even the somewhat cringeworthy 'Martínez march' all show that Elstone and Myers are getting stuff right.

Man Utd are arrogant bastards, treating us like needy cousins who'll accept the crumbs from their table. Clearly the fact that BK and the Board were in the dark about Moyes being tapped up months earlier is coming out. 'Derisory and insulting', with Man Utd being named. Our Board are clearly fuckin' angry, but they're channelling it to get the fans on board, really good stuff.

Nick Entwistle
37 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:25:44
True, Matt, but then depends how you define marquee of course... if Vidic is marquee then so is Baines and Fellaini.

Who was their GK when they signed him? Carrick raised some eyebrows at the time.

Mike Oates
39 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:34:19
The stakes will be raised over next 2 weeks with one or possibly both saying they want to go to UTD. Everton will respond, fine if UTD meet our valuaton ( I suspect £16m Baines and £22m Fellaini), which UTD will offer £35m and will get it accepted by Everton are afternoon of Sep 2nd.
Moyes will feel chuffed as he will have returned the shafting to Kenwright following the Arteta and Fer episodes over last 2 seasons.

Kristian Boyce
40 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:46:33
The sad fact is that will be a large potion of our fans will be clapping and cheering him when he brings his new team to Goodison.
John Ford
41 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:00:18
Marquee.....Moyes buys a tent?

Marque?

Agree that Moyes is just doing business but you can see this rolling on to close to the deadline then we sign no one or vastly inferior replacements. This has the potential to improve our bank balance but also to completely fuck our season over.

Robert Collins
42 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:06:57
Fuck them (and Gollum) and let them sweat!

They need to bring in players more than we do, Roberto has time and lots of it, Gollum does not, If he has a bad couple of seasons he's out the door.

They're simply more desperate than us, with the CL (which they look a million miles away from winning) and now the competition they'll face from Chelski (the Special one) and Siteh (with a new man and more money than he knows what to do with).

We're looking for offers in the region of 45M+ for those two.

I personally can't see the need to sell unless the above price is met, we've got TIME!

James Stewart
44 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:22:18
Typical Moyes approach submits a final offer for a player gets rejected and within a week he's back with the same offer.

All the rubbish spouted by Wenger and Moyes is hilarious. AVB didn't have any trouble getting good players in.

Tony Marsh
45 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:16:26
Why all the surprise at these latest revelations? It's only the stupidity and the blind faith of certain Evertonians that stopped this fraud Moyes being run out of town years ago.

I always knew what he was about and this disgusting behaviour validates everything I said on many occasions. If it wasn't bad enough the shithouse way Moyes ran his contract down and prevented us getting compensation from Man Utd (probably Fergie inspired), he now tries to back-door us on two of our top players. It stinks and I hope the fans who cheered him will now turn on him at last.

Since when did the world's biggest clubs start paying under the going rate for players? It's always the other way round... Man Utd, like Chelsea and Man City, have had to stump up more for players in the past because of who they are and the riches they have. Now Moyes thinks he is that clever he can turn the tables on us. Tell him to fuck himself, the dirty Coward.

I knew Moyes was as bad as BK and in bed with him in all the shenanigans over the years. I disliked Moyes when he was here... now it's beyond comprehension what I think of him. Moyes should be scrubbed from our history forthwith.

Ed Fitzgerald
46 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:21:23
It is good to see the scales fall from people's eyes about Moyes. He regularly whined about clubs unsettling players and derisory bids etc whilst he was in charge of us.He is a hypocrite of the worst kind

For once the club get its PR right. This is a pivotal moment for Kenwright he has three options sell the pay of them for no less than 45 Million, hang on to both of them or offer a straight swap for Rooney and Buttner plus 5 Million for us!

I would like him for once to speak with some anger about condem Moyes for insulting him and more importantly Everton Football Club

Mark Pierpoint
47 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:27:59
Good response from the club. Really strange actions from Utd too. Don't know what they possibly thought may be achieved from this, all they have done is put Everton's back up (I type Everton rather than we as I am referring to the club officials rather than the fans). In all honesty had this been conducted in a more gentlemanly way Utd could do a deal for a decent price. It wouldn't take much to get Kenwright to sell to Utd for a average fee and a few empty promises of a 'special relationship' continuing. Instead they are now faced with a board who are that pissed off that a sale is less likely.

I would tell them 40m the pair if they are interested. Take it or leave it. Fellaini and probably Baines will have to be pacified somehow as both will surely want Champions League football. A figure around this mark £15m Baines and £25m For Fellaini will probably keep them on side. I actually feel sorry for Baines, he is in an unenviable position as he clearly has a strong affinity for the club but it will be his last chance at the big time.

Jim Potter
48 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:33:30
Fellaini - £25m +.

Baines - no amount. If he puts in a request (hopefully unlikely 'knowing' the character of the man) - £20m +.

Or Fella / Rooney swap. (Well I want it).

Then Bill will have to free money up for a midfielder.

Nick Entwistle
49 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:38:39
Ed, how has he (Utd) done that? They haven't made it public their intention to buy these players, and Everton too kept it under wraps.

Moyes doesn't decide the level of bid, the Utd board do that. They're a little more advanced that way.

The bid was last week, private, with plenty of time to get in replacements. Moan about the offer yes, but everything else has been above board.

Ed Fitzgerald
50 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:43:29
Nick stop the love in with Moyes, if you think managers are not involved in the valuation of players think again. Everton for once have played a blinder on the PR front. Other officers of he club conduct but you are trying to tell me that Moyes isn't involved in the initial valuation. I never thought I would say this as a devotee of the Guardian but read the bloody mail article, he is a hypocrite.

As the Echo states the offer is laughable as is his bloody conduct. He knew he was going to Man Utd before the Derby, I am sick of his bullshit and I am sick of your adoration of him.

Paul Ferry
51 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:21:14
Jesus wept Moyes is doing his level best to take on the spotty mantle of manure boss.

So on the same day we have a 'derisory' or 'hypocritical' double swoop on his former club and his bizarre freaky raving and ranting about the FA stitching up manure's fixture list 'for sure'.

i said to myself over and over again Paul do not become bitter about ginger and female Ferry was on red-alert to warn me if I was slipping. Everything was going well until July and the Baines bid and now it's like a steam train running out of control.

The lack of respect for EFC from someone who we thought had dignity and decency in spades when he was in our hot seat is quite frankly breath-taking.

So near the end of the window (Lescott), with the full knowledge of the Fellaini clause, and in the full knowledge of the pair's worth both financially and on the pitch to EFC this ginger double-dealing hypocrite is now my new dogleash.

We are no longer your puppets manure as the shitbag who turned us into your puppets is now your gaffer. We will publicly humiliate you you charlatan and we will get the press to write what you are. You will not get Baines so forget it but you might possibly get Felli but on our terms you deluded clown not yours.

Six months ago just about every footie fan in Blighty thought well of you and Everton but now your reputation has nosedived - not just because you are now where you are but because of the way you have behaved since getting the job - but our reputation is still in good shape and it will continue to grow as you you fecking Beelzebub hpyocrite continue to act so disrespectfully and with such disdain in full public glare.

I hate you ginger Beelzebub, there I said it, I hate you and I was trying hard to keep my cool and be charitable. I will be in England for the Old Lady manure game and already this morning I have been practicing booing, shouting blood-curdling insults, and learning semaphore for Beelzebub hypocrite slug.

Matt Traynor
52 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:52:07
Ed #858, he knew before which derby he was going?
He certainly knew in December 2012. That's when the deal was finalised.
Mike Green
53 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:51:12
Maybe this is why we had so much bother signing players for the last 11 years. It wasn't just the budget, it was the fucking approach.
Dan Parker
54 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:51:56
I don't think 40 is enough, they're worth more than that. Baines is the best left-back in Europe and Fellaini is worth at least 25.

Would Arsenal sell Ashley Cole for 20 mill at the height of his career, don't think so.

40 values them at least half the price of Gareth Bale.

Ed Fitzgerald
55 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:54:19
Matt I was talking of the later Defby, don't mention that he knew in December, Nick will go into meltdown if he thought St. David was colluding with future employers whilst still employed by us
David Greenwood
56 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:55:50
Dan, spot on mate. best left back in the world for 12 mil, jeezus.

At least fifty for the pair, plus Rooney! Set the bar high BK. Unfortunately I think 35 will have him biting their hands off.

Mark Tanton
57 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:55:22
Mike I agree, I think that Man Utd's summer transfer window so far tells us much about him and why Everton struggled to bring in players.

Apparently United have been interest in Modric for quite some time but Moyes has been dithering, asking everyone who's ever met him for a character reference. They won't get Modric because Moyes has been dicking about for weeks - so now they're coming for Fellaini as the time ticks down. I guess we can console ourselves with the prospect that by the time Moyes ponders upping the bid by three quarters of a million quid it will be Haloween.

Karl Masters
58 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:52:41
How I wish it wasn't so long till April 19!
David Greenwood
59 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:01:28
Get through the league cup tie Karl and hopefully we get them at home in the next round. Bring it on. The Old Lady will be rocking that night.
Karl Masters
60 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:02:56
Back in the 70's , 80's and 90's before this special relationship crap, we used to fuckin hate those arrogant Mancs. Bring it back I say, even pensioners were trying to climb on the fences to tell them to fuck off, Goodison was rabid. If this isn't sorted now and they back off, I expect a ferocious reception when they next roll up!
Matt Traynor
61 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:55:37
John Ford #841, over there in pedant's corner (is that apostrope in the correct place?)

From dictionary.reference.com:

adjective
4.
superlative; headlining: a marquee basketball player.

Matt Traynor
62 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:10:49
Of course I had to spell apostrophe incorrectly.
David Greenwood
63 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:07:11
Could be wrong, but Jones and Smalling cost them 26 mil.

So these two with next to no PL experience between them are worth the same as our two with all their years between them. That's before we talk ability.

I'm getting more annoyed the more I think about it.

Phil Walling
64 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:57:21
Have no doubt,the deal will be finalised sometime NEXT week for an undisclosed sum which media will report is around £35M. Almost certainly that figure will be inclusive of add-ons of the complexity that accompanied the Rooney deal.

Time should be just about sufficient for Pedro to get his mate in from Wigan and a loanee to cover Oviedo at left-back.

Kenwright will tell us all that it`s good business because both players were adamant that they wanted to go.

Mike Green
65 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:05:16
As an aside if you pronounce Edward Woodard's name without the 'd's', it becomes 'Ewar Woowar'. Always made me laugh that when watching 'The Equaliser'.

And no funny quips about there being no 'd' in (insert derisory and insulting term) either :)

Paul Andrews
66 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:16:10
Several posters on here(you know who you are) ridiculed those of us who said this would happen.
One or two of the smart arses got very annoyed because they opined we could not see basic logic.
Conspicuous by their absence
Shaun Lyon
67 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:55:17
I was pro-Moyes when he was our manager and without, I hope, being biased, I thought he tended to be as straight and as 'moral' a figure as you're likely to find in the Premiership circus. So his reaction to say Man City's 'lack of respect' seemed to carry some weight. And now we find he is just as hypocritical as the rest of them.

And incidentally, when it was announced that he was off to Man U didn't I read that he and Bill - those bosom buddies - had a little chat in which it was agreed that he would not be coming back for any players? Or did I dream that?

I'd love to see a journo ask Bill directly if he still think so highly of his 'close friend'.

Utterly utterly shoddy.

Utterly utterly shoddy.

Paul Columb
68 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:11:06
Go do one Moyes and MUFC. The facade of integrity he built up during his time at Everton has faded and his return to Goodison should be greeted with nothing but deathly silence and stearn stares. Everton as a feeder club for that lot should fade as a bad memory. Have to say, this club statement and posturing has all the hallmarks of an effort to drive up the bid and I won't be surprised to see them go. That'll free up 5 million for deadline day desperation signing to accompany a Barry loan move.
Nothing will change during this cursed Knewright tenure.
Raymond Fox
69 Posted 19/08/2013 at 16:58:18
I've said it elsewhere, nobodies taking into account what the players want to do.
If they want to go, utd will know though their agents, this will affect the price.

We can take a stand of course, and say their not going at any price, but is it wise to keep disgruntled players?
Or we can say to the players, if utd meet our valuation you can leave, which is the policy at Wigan
Wigan have been relegated, so you can argue the merit of that policy!

David Edwards
70 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:10:05
I used to think Moyes was OK and had the club interest at heart. Not anymore after accepting the Manure job months before the season ended and hiding it like a guilty little boy and now coming back to steal players with nothing short of insulting and disgusting bids he is doing what he said was wrong. It just shows what he thinks about the club that gave him his chance to manage in the premier league.

They have made bids for other players that would have jumped to play for Fergie but maybe Moyes charm and personality have put people off. I now hope that he loses the title to anybody gets knocked out of the cups and Champions league at the earliest opportunity and we will see how long the Manure faithfull put up with the double dealing little snot.

While understanding that his interest is now doing the best for the Manure he should be told to shove his bids where the sun doesn't shine and the club should refuse to do any business them for the forseable future. Hope it happens but cant really see it.

Paul Ferry
71 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:17:11
I do have a little feeling, however, that while Leighton is at home tapping his precious left foot to an indie band we have not yet heard of the other fella Felli is texting Bobby and Billy asking the pair to open talks with hypocrite Beelzebub and co. as 'this move is in the best interests of both parties boss'.

Nick Entwistle
72 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:19:07
Ed, you want your perceptions molded by the Daily Mail or the Echo you're welcome. All of a sudden when the papers are having a pop at the old manager they become reputable and trustworthy...

All that's happened is Utd have made a bid. Its not high enough such as Chelsea twice with Rooney etc. Do you know how negotiation works?

This has as more to do with your opinion on the former manager as mine, I just think this is having a go for the sake of it. Utd bid for Everton players shock!

Tim Lampshire
74 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:26:22
@ Paul Ferry, I think you have a somewhat inflated opinion of Fellis grasp of English....Only teasing mate!
Paul Ferry
75 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:37:11
Er Nick - 883 - I think it's less 'All of a sudden when the papers are having a pop at the old manager they become reputable and trustworthy ... ' and rather more that our ex-gaffer and his new club have behaved so poorly that even these papers are now having a pop at him.

This is seen rightly in my view at any rate as fair evidence of the utter disrespect and disdain that said ex-gaffer - or hypocrite in the Mail's words - is now showing to EFC.

Danny Jones
76 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:27:34
The next Everton statement, should they choose to make one, which they by no means have to, should read something to the effect of, 'Everton Football Club has received no serious bid for any of its players. Everton Football Club do not need to sell. Until a player makes the club aware of a desire to leave, we will not be discussing valuations'.

Of course, the club has put a figure on each of these players but it doesn't have to advertise it.

The club should then follow up by rejecting out of hand any bid which does not meet or exceed the agreed figure.

Only if a player puts in a transfer request should the club state their value with a message that bids below that value will not be considered.

We all know that, in all probability, at least one of our best players is off in the next week or so but we should be negotiating hard.

In my opinion, £20m for Baines and £30m for Fellaini. No discounts for bulk orders!

Richard Dodd
77 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:35:22
Nick,in our appreciation of our former manager,you and I often `sang from the same hymn sheet` but much as it hurts me to say it he has now been exposed as a very shoddy practitioner of the very arts he derided in his fellow managers.

Of course,he must do what he sees as right for his new employers and I don`t think that embraces too many favours but his behaviour over the last 8 months stinks to high heaven.Glory be,just for once the Club`s media department have struck just the right note in stating the derision we now feel for the man.

Even you must see that!

Nick Entwistle
78 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:43:48
Erm, Paul no. If Chelsea did exactly the same then we'd all complain at the initial bid, but that is all.

Done on the quiet, its not last minute. There's no amnesty on bids before the season starts. How have Utd behaved poorly?

Danny Jones
79 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:45:09
Incidentally, I don't care if the Daily Mail has published a favourable article, I will never read it. I am neither a racist or an homophobe and will not swell their coffers.
Ed Fitzgerald
80 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:34:19
Nick

I know exactly how negotiation works I also know how employees should behave when under contract and I have some issues with the way your good mate Davie conducted himself last season. As paying season ticket holder I expect a person paid 4 million a year ( a question I have asked before without answer is do you actually attend the match?)to attend to our business not be sorting himself with a new job. The whole episode brought him into disrepute as does this latest fiasco.

Yes my opinion of him changed over 11 years, but no trophies combined with negativity eventually put paid to that. My opinions are not formed by reading a couple of articles by the mail and the echo but of the previous 11 years tenure.

Nick Entwistle
81 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:48:15
Doddy, why? Because Moyes wants two of his former players? We got three from Wigan (bar the technicalities)! It happens. Sure we don't want them to go, but its because they're good... Utd quality good. Again, if Chelsea were to come in for them....
Mike Green
82 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:48:35
Nick #883 - quality negotiation doesn't work by getting the other parties backs up from the off by making an offer far below what you yourself valued the goods at when the shoe was on the other foot.

What do you think Moyes reaction would have been if Fergie had made the same offer? Sorry, bad example....but you know what I mean.

Karl Masters
83 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:45:10
IF the players want to go, let them go. Either £50m or £28m plus Rooney.

And I want Shearer, Hansen & Lineker on MOTD to spend five minutes retracting all the words they have stated saying what an honourable man Moyes is and what a top bloke he is.

Ross Edwards
84 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:50:58
Well, Davey, you want to know why you haven't signed anyone?

Answer, you are trying to sign top class players like Cesc, Felli, Thiago, Bainesy on the cheap.

Now, I'm not going to get hot and bothered, but all I can say is that considering £16m for Felli is well below the expired release clause, and the fact that Moyes himself valued Baines at £20m last season, he is taking the mick.

Richard Dodd
85 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:51:01
Nick,he`s left it till the last minute knowing he can get them on the cheap. He`s playing on Kenwright`s weakness even though the clown let him take the piss out of the club for a good six months.

Our signings from Wigan were made within days of Roberto`s arrival-different ball game entirely!

Nick Entwistle
86 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:54:49
Ed, You've formed for yourself a bias on an unrelated matter. That's not exactly objective.

As for asking if I go the match, that's frowned upon by de management of these pages. So you don't get an answer.

Karl, the press release from Everton is their negotiation technique. It says to Utd fuck off, or come back with something to make us interested.

The games afoot.

Neil Payne
87 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:35:01
I just wish that Everton would man-up and grow some balls, if BK had no intention of selling Baines and Fellaini then throw one back at Man U and tell them we will swap Fellaini for Rooney and make it public.

Everyone would know we are only taking the urine and it would make them look like a bunch of clowns, but in true BK style we won't do that as we all know the pound signs are flashing in front of his eyes like a kid on a fruit machine and sooner or later he will cash in and say the player wanted to go so he got the best deal possible for the club.

So sort it out now if reports are to be believed we are in the process of offering Baines a new contract' offer it to him now as we all know we will be in the same situation come January, if he doe not want to sign one then its time for him to go while we have time left to spend the money.

As much as we love Baines and wouldn't want him to go the rumors are that he would like to go to utd but wont ask to leave so get him to sign the contract NOW....its not rocket science.... unless BK has another agenda Arteta style and the moneys going to the Bank Manager.

Danny Jones
88 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:55:44
Do those people suggesting Rooney in part exchange realise that Everton would need to sell another half dozen first team players in order to meet his wage?

I was going to say, 'Stop being silly' but realised I'd get the answer 'Man Utd started it'.

Paul Ferry
89 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:53:25
Nick - 889 - you're wrong and in a minority of er one on here (although tiny minorities have been right in the past to be fair as Eugene keeps reminding us about appeasers!) and I'm sorry but if you cannot see relevant merit in these words (886):

'I think it's less 'All of a sudden when the papers are having a pop at the old manager they become reputable and trustworthy ... ' and rather more that our ex-gaffer and his new club have behaved so poorly that even these papers are now having a pop at him'.

then I fear for you mate.

What I think of - rightly or wrongly - as your sanctified stance in trying to cut principles and morals out of the equation - it's just footie isn't it and he's just doing his best for his new club - is utterly out of place in this particular series of events.

Kudos to Richard (Dodd) and if I could be transported to the Freshy this minute I would buy him a half of whatever he wants.

Dan Brierley
90 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:31:14
I agree Nick 883, it appears to be what was brilliantly described as 'faux outrage'.

I would be willing to bet Moyes is not even authorised to make bids to other clubs, his job will be to identify the targets only, somebody else will actually make the approach and determine the amount.

I personally couldnt give a shit if he is morally bankrupt now or not as he is not our manager. But then again, I am not trying to justify my own personal agenda with the guy. So personally, I feel no need to join in with the criticism of the man who would 'never get offered a top job' or 'win a trophy'.

Coming back to the bid itself, I believe it's sole purpose is to confirm to the players United's interest. I don't think for one minute they believed it would be accepted. The seed is now planted, which makes any future negotiations much easier for the buying club. The agents will now be doing their best to make sure their clients move, and I would expect both players would not turn down a move to a CL club, whether that be United or any other. Felli and Baines both showed glimpses of their abilities on Saturday, but neither looked really fired up for the new season which is worrying.

Make no mistake, it will be a huge blow if either of them leave but to lose both is going to be sickening. I sincerely hope that Martinez is working day and night to identify replacements, more so for Felli as Oviedo looks like he may be able to do a job for us.

Mike Hughes
91 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:54:19
Karl#894

Shearer, Hansen and lineker won't risk upsetting the ginger scrotum. It's all old boys network at the NBC.

Danny#887

A tad harsh there, mate. For bulk orders of £50m I'd offer Moyes a free year of Everton tv.

I hope the miserable get gets absolutely stuffed and his career is on a steep, steep decline.

For those who say it's just business, there are ways and means of going about things the right way. Suddenly he's a big time Charlie calling the shots. I never thought I'd see the day I agreed with the curtain twitching daily mail but their article hits the nail on the head.

Eric Myles
92 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:00:43
By making the announcement of the double bid the Club are declaring that both players are for sale.
Ross Edwards
93 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:05:12
Basically Dan and Nick, you would let our two best players leave on the cheap?
Nick Entwistle
94 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:03:09
Paul, I dare say the morals and principles up for argument here with this bid is simply a follow on from when exactly Moyes knew about Utd. Which I think on these pages goes back as far as last century.

You say it better than I, Dan. That's two in our corner then.

Paul Andrews
95 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:04:28
Eric,

Once again you are spot on.
As you have been since the start of the debate re a lesser fee being offered after the clause lapsed.

Kevin Tully
96 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:57:04
According to a few posters, the manager doesn't make the offers for players.

But he is lauded when we sign a player, then sell at a profit for being able to spot a bargain.

Glad I know how this transfer malarkey works now!

All negotiations are nothing to do with the manager eh? Who knew?

Ross Edwards
97 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:07:38
‘I've always said it’s expensive to buy off Everton. If you’re going to come and try to take our better players we don’t sell cheap, that’s for sure,’

David Moyes, 17th October 2011.

Now he is attempting to sign our two best players on the cheap.Does he think he can do whatever he wants?

I find it unbelievable Dan and Nick that you would seemingly let our two best players go on the cheap. Or would you just defend Moyes at any cost, now matter what he does to our club?

Mike Green
98 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:04:35
Dan #901. You're absolutely right.

Why would Man Utd consult the former manager of both players now under their employ, the same man that signed both players for Everton, knows their ambition, perosonalities and situation and also knows pretty accurately what Everton would accept for them Both.

I'd keep him well and truly out of it - no use whatsoever!

(Hits heel of palm on forehead)

Matt Traynor
99 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:09:50
To all those saying OFM has nothing to do with the amount bid. He does. He has quite a bit to do.

Y'all need to remember at the end of the day, he's the public face of Man U. He's the one with the journos asking questions with a camera/digital voice recorder in front of him.

He may not set the price, but he is very much involved.

Dan Brierley
100 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:09:03
Kevin, the manager is lauded for identifying players such as Cahill, Jags, Lescott, Arteta etc. who are playing at a lower level or have lost their way, and making them into top class players. It has nothing to do with for how much they are sold, its for being able to identify the right players in the first place.
Mike Green
102 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:11:38
Paul #906 - please tell me that's sarcasm...?
Phil Bellis
103 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:11:06
Nick and Dan are always consistent and constant in maintaining their staunch support of all things Moyesian

It'll end in tears

Dan Brierley
104 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:11:49
Ross, when I have (or anyone) said that the players should be sold on the cheap? I personally want both players to stay, as they are our best players and not easily replaceable.

Ed Fitzgerald
105 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:03:31
Nick

I am sick of your sanctimonious tone and your inability to take the temperature of how the vast majority of Evertonians 'feel' about this issue. I invite you to air your views about Moyes conduct in the Park End or any other part of the ground.

Even Doddy the biggest Moyes supporter can see he is out of order.

Dan Brierley
106 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:14:19
Phil, just because I am able to see things with a broad and objective view does not make me a supporter of anyone. I would say exactly the same thing if it was the manager of another club that made an approach of that nature.
Barry Rathbone
107 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:46:55
It's "line in the sand" time - about time we told Utd to sling their hook.

A public statement sticking it to both Moyes and Utd would restore some long overdue pride and dignity regarding these clowns.

Lets get a semblance of defiance and independence going - instead of the "usual" craven posture DEMAND, YES DEMAND! at least 3 crocked/over the hill cast offs before caving and getting 10 quid a week for the pair over 50 yrs.

Fully expect the pair posing with Utd scarves within a week.

Ross Edwards
108 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:15:07
You seem to be defending OFM's actions Dan as alright. Stand by Davey boy and do it seems to be what you are implying. Despite him saying when he was our manager that Baines was valued at £20m, and a few years earlier that no player would leave on the cheap.

If Doddy can see that Moyes is wrong Dan, then he must be wrong.

Karl Masters
109 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:07:17
Actually Danny, we wouldn't need to sell six players to finance Rooney. Baines and Fella must be on £130k a week between them and the remaining £100k a week would come from the extra money the Mancs would have to pay us. At £5m a year we could afford him for five years.

So it adds up financially, but whether we actually need or want him is another matter altogether! It was a tongue in cheek statement on my part.

We all know they will bid more, but no need to panic, just get the real value, ie £50m or tell them to do one.

Al Reddish
110 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:13:26
You can't blame the Mancs. They are only doing the same to us as we did to them when we tapped up Phil Neville with no time for them to replace him. In fact it's taken them 8 years to get him back.
Kevin Tully
111 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:12:59
Dan - you and a few others are full of shit to be honest.

I don't even have to justify that comment, it's quite clear that YOU are the one with the agenda - feigning faux indifference on so many levels.

It's so fucking transparent I could never take any of you seriously again.

Jokers.

Gavin Ramejkis
112 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:21:23
Sad bastards still trying to defend that ginger two faced shithouse, should get a baptism of fire when he turns up to Goodison.
Karl Masters
113 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:19:55
That's right Al Reddish and what about that time SAF gave Walter Smith the nod that a certain Jesper Blomqvist was available? He'd never have done that for LFC!
Dan Brierley
114 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:18:01
Ross, unfortunately my opinions are based on my own feelings. I don't follow Doddy, or any other 'majority'. I don't personally feel the need for social acceptance on a football website.

I think the bids themselves are ridiculous, but as I have already said, they are designed to unsettle the players and now put their agents in a position where they know there is formal interest. Believe it or not, the same thing happens throughout the football world, I would not say it is uncommon. Is it 'alright'? For me personally, its not. I would prefer either they offer 50 million, or fuck off. But unfortunately you cannot prevent other clubs bidding for your players. United have already been knocked back by Barca for Fabregas. My guess is they didn't follow it up as the player didn't show an interest.

Nick Entwistle
115 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:23:31
Gavin, would that be similar to his goodbye from hell at his last Goodison match?

Eugene Ruane
116 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:17:26
"Re Moyes, Dan Brierley has a broad and objective view y' know"

SFX: Audience laughter.

(leans on mike-stand, pulls on ciggy)

"I'm here all week"

Al Reddish
118 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:25:27
Karl, maybe he should've done!
Phil Walling
120 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:22:31
Kevin,I do wish you`d speak your mind!

I do so hope that today`s exchange may wake up Wenger enough to come in and sew up a Felli deal for £30M.

It would show up OFM for the prick he is !

Kevin Rowlands
121 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:19:53
I hate to say it but it wouldn't surprise me in the slightest if this is all posturing and a deal is already in the works, unfortunately we are a selling club and if they up the bid, which they will, to an acceptable price both will be gone. If they go and we bring in McCarthy, Moses and perhaps another striker, I don't think we'll be weakened to badly as Oviedo will be a very good replacement for Baines, just my opinion of course!
Dan Brierley
123 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:24:36
Kev Tully, that was a very poor and unnecessary response just because I proved what you said was factually incorrect regarding how a manager is lauded in the transfer market. If you don't want to have an balanced conversation and just continue to spit your dummy out someone does not agree with you, I would appreciate if you can just ignore my points in future.
Karl Masters
124 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:24:28
And Al, you know what, I nearly forgot the great favour they did selling the ' very promising' John O'Kane to us for £500k in 1998. Free transfer to Bolton in the end.

Those Mancs have been so helpful over the years. Piss takers, it should end now. Moyes move was shady to say the least, this is just another in a long line.

Ste Traverse
125 Posted 19/08/2013 at 17:53:23
Why are we still getting whoppers asking United to throw Rooney into any deal?

Where, I ask, will we get his £250,000 a week wages?

As for Moyes, the man IS a total hypocrite. I really hope he gets a hostile reception when he comes back.

Al Reddish
126 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:29:16
John O Kane, that's a blast. They even did us over when Mark Higgins retired through injury, only to pop up over there a few months later.
Mike Green
127 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:28:13
Kevin #934 - good post but ultimately every club is a selling club. If we offered Real £250m for Ronaldo what do you think they would say? Probably 'derisory and insulting', whilst pulling some chairs up to the table.

I've no problem Moyes coming in for our players but offering £28m for two players he valued at £15m more is frankly a piss take. And no one like having the piss taken out of them, do they?

Karl Masters
128 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:31:31
And Al, remember us getting Mickey ( so many nicknames I could put in there! ) Thomas in a straight swap for the outstanding John Gidman back in 1981. Gidman gave them five great years, Thomas was sold to Brighton after three months for refusing to play for the reserves after an injury. It's. been going on a long time!
John Crawley
130 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:30:13
Nick 905 - Moyes knew about Man United wanting him to replace Ferguson months ago, he's admitted it after the event to Everton and to journalists on Merseyside. That is why Man United sent a written letter of apology to Everton about the way they acted in order to avoid an embarrassing complaint to the Premier League. Your defence of Moyes, no matter what, is tiresome.
Al Reddish
131 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:37:06
Right, it stops here!!!!!!! Send them Osman.
Ross Edwards
132 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:34:30
Dan, Nick this somes up OFM's stunning hypocrisy:

‘I've always said it’s expensive to buy off Everton. If you’re going to come and try to take our better players we don’t sell cheap, that’s for sure,’

Moyes on October 16, 2011.

"The way it has been handled is disgusting and all it has done is disrupted our club,’ . ‘Most clubs have a price for a player. The offers were not big enough.

Moyes on the Lescott saga.

Now he is doing exactly what he was ranting about.

Matt Traynor
133 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:39:45
Al #945, I need to send you an invoice for a new screen.
Mike Green
134 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:43:32
Al 945 - how about we accept £28m if they agree to take Osman, Naismith and Anichebe as part of the deal.....?

Just a thought....

Ste Traverse
135 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:40:11
It could also be argued that United fucked us over in 1989 with sale for £750,000 ( a lot back then) of Norman Whiteside.

Although Big Norm was good in the 1989/90 season scoring 14 goals, he rarely looked completely fit and retired through injury in after making just 2 appearances in the 1990/91 season

Eugene Ruane
136 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:31:22
Ste (939) - "As for Moyes, the man IS a total hypocrite. I really hope he gets a hostile reception when he comes back"

More chance of plaiting soot.

If Everton supporters will applaud BK - someone who has lied to them again and again and again - Moyes could wear an 'Everrton are shite' t-shirt on his return, you'd still get loads flinging rose-petals in front of him.

I'd like to think those who prostrated themselves in front of Moyes and applauded themselves stupid when United's manager took charge of Everton's games against West Ham and Chelsea last season might be feeling suitably stupid but I know that isn't going to happen and instead it'll be a case of 'yeah but no but waffle blah'.

Kevin Tully
137 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:37:32
Moyes, whilst being paid IRO £4m a year is plotting his move to another club at least 6 months before his contract expires - people defended him.

Moyes - still on the payroll of Everton when he is holding meetings with Utd staff - people defended him.

Moyes leaves Everton for the richest club in the world, Everton get no compensation, even though it is announced when we still had games to play - people defend him still.

Moyes sanctions bid ( said to be one & final offer ) for our player of the year, massively undervaluing him - people defended him.

Moyes sanctions a bid for our two best players 13 days before the window closes, and two days before the start of the season, again, massively undervaluing BOTH players this time - people defend him.

The most difficult thing for me to get my head around, is that these people defending him are Evertonians FFS!

Can someone explain that to me in simple English?

Mike Green
138 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:49:57
Kevin #955 - great post, penultimate paragraph had me in stitches. Pure gold. :D
Ross Edwards
139 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:51:48
Kevin, even if Moyes went on a killing spree people would still defend him. It's unbelievable.
Dan Brierley
140 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:50:54
But even more delusional, is Brenda Rodgers latest statement:

"Very few teams come here and win, we have sent out a message to the two manchester clubs"

That is seriously funny....

Gavin Ramejkis
141 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:52:53
Yeah Nick you and the seals clapping him into the sunset? Grow up and grow a pair
Paul David
142 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:52:30
Kevin you forgot to mention his lies about it only taking 5 mins to sign a new contract, in January ect and his defenders saying this was a ploy to get more money out of Kenwright.
Ross Edwards
143 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:53:44
What is seriously funny Dan, is that you have actually quoted something from a fake Twitter account!

Doh!!

Drew Shortis
144 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:31:23
Good strong statement from the club. We have to stand firm on this issue. I can't understand the logic in Man Utd's bid. If they had bid £35+ I still think we would have rejected it, but at least it would be closer to their market values and would not have been viewed as an insult, but a possible starting point for negotiations. By getting everyone's back up surely it makes a deal less likely. Sure it might unsettle the the players, but they are under contract and it is a World Cup year for both of them so I'm sure they will get over it, there is always January after all. Now is the time to get a new deal done with Baines.

If we manage to hold on to them both we will be making a statement of our intentions in this new era. Hopefully the new TV money means we are not desperate to sell. If either of them still want to leave in January we should get a deal lines up to allow us plenty of time to bring in the right replacements. It is too late in the day now to start with all this. Be strong Kenwright and show your doubters you really do have Everton's best interests at heart!

Mark Tanton
145 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:55:26
Dan, if 'very few teams' means Everton, than he's absolutely right.
Ross Edwards
146 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:57:05
It's from a fake Twitter account Mark.
Dan Brierley
147 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:56:29
This is an interesting article on the guy behind these bids:

/>http://www.theguardian.com/football/2013/aug/09/edward-woodward-manchester-united

Ross Edwards
149 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:02:03
OFM would say who he wants to Woodward and the price he would want and leave Woodward to do the rest Dan.
Dave Lynch
150 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:51:12
He's got the morals of a Sun journalist.

I always thought he had a narcissistic streak in him and this proves it to me.

His arrogance knows no bounds and he displayed this on many occasions whilst with us. Now he's at the Mancs it will only fuel his ego even further.

50 million or " Go boil your fucking head you back stabbing ginger bastard".

Karl Masters
151 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:00:13
Agree with the sentiment Drew. But will BK hold strong? Is it even his decision? Wonder what Phil Green will, sorry ( of course it's nothing to do with him is it ) would do - in an advisory capacity as a good friend of Everton of course,
Mark Pierpoint
152 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:34:30
Firstly I am struggling to see the big deal with what Dan Brierley has said. I have read through it again and all he has suggested is that the 'bid' is an attempt for United to unsettle and show there hand. What is wrong with suggesting that? he has hardly suggested selling them, or that the suggestion that it is unwelcome is fair?

As Dan and others point out this is now a game. Its a game that needs sorting out soon though but its not the panic stations a la Rooney/ Arteta. We still have two weeks and we already have a replacement for Fellaini who we can get. We also have Oviedo at Left Back. We have to play on this and get the price up. For all of the criticism of the board with the exception of Yakubu in recent transactions we have always sold well (I wouldn't count Rooney as recent, as financially we were in a worse state then) We have to do it again.

I feel sorry for Baines and I genuinely wouldn't want to price him out of a deal at his age, but he signed the contract until he was 31, for better or for worse.

On Fellaini we hold the cards. He is contracted for 3 years, if they don't meet the price, tough. Belgium will have a good world cup you would imagine, that will get us at least the buy out price. At 26 he can't say its his last chance and if he does, take a leaf out of Liverpool's book.

The ending I imagine will be with Fellaini going. If Baines joins him on a personal and football level it will be VERY hard to take but so be it. we have lost equally good players and come back. We wont find another left back like him, so the money will have to be reinvested to give the team more options from other areas. That is what Martinez is paid to do.

Phil Bellis
153 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:59:55
Dan

I had a similar broad and objective view of Debbie Harry, Alexandra Bastedo and Maddy Smith
That, also, ended in tears

Brent Stephens
154 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:19:51
I neither loved not hated Moyes. He was what he was (I'll save the waffle on that).

So a club / manager fancy a couple of players from another club (you can read MU/Everton or Everton/Wigan here). They put in a bid. It gets accepted or rejected (with or without an improved offer). It's what they do. I can't get upset about the business goings-on.

I am peeved that we might lose Baines (worse still both of them). And the money ending up we know where.

Paul Ferry
155 Posted 19/08/2013 at 18:52:48
I just got an email from Nick (Entwhistle) - I quote":

Hi Paul,

How's it going mate well I hope.

Having a great time on the Baines/Fellaini thread winding the huge majority
up and deliberately trolling an unpopular, clearly erroneous, and anti-for-the-hell-of-it line.

Tee hee hee it's such a wheeze being deliberately cantankerous like this; I keep texting Dan to tell him to keep up the good work. Nothing better than when I get these guys to respond angrily to me; I just love that and to be honest I get off on it.

Take Care, as ever,

Nick

Ross Edwards
156 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:06:46
Is that real Paul?
Paul Ferry
157 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:10:31
Ross
Kevin Tully
158 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:11:34
Well that's just cheered me up.
Ross Edwards
159 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:11:40
I'm just very gullible Paul.
Colin Glassar
160 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:06:37
No wonder that OFM missed out on so many transfer targets over the years he probably offered 500k for the likes of Parker, arshavin, Owen et al...
What's wrong with these people like whinger and ginger who think they can make ridiculous bids for top players and the rest of us are just going to bend over?
Yair Kaye
161 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:09:13
If we ever aim seriously at getting back to the top, the club should start acting accordingly. This means not letting anyone raiding our top players – be it the Mancs or anyone else. It's about time clubs started showing respect towards EFC.

I would keep both of them at least until next summer. Alas, I'm afraid it will never happen as long as we are owned by our spineless chairman.

Paul Tran
162 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:06:41
This is a non-story as far as I'm concerned. He's not our manager and it's his job to get the best deal possible for his club. The only issue is for the people who have spent the last ten years going on about Moyes' 'moral fibre' - one of many pieces of nonsense to compensate for the fact that he didn't win trophies.

The real scandal here is that after all his time in charge, the great ToffeeWeb debate is not how players pass the ball, but whether they should pass the ball.

I'd rather focus on Roberto Martinez and his campaign to re-acquaint our players with passing the ball, moving rather than running and winning rather than avoiding defeat.

Kevin Tully
163 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:16:11
Forget about that ginger tosser anyway. Just been on Monday night football - guess which team had the most possession, and most completed passes in the League this weekend?

Not bad for his first game in charge, and away from home.

Richard Dodd
164 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:11:02
Kevin @955: All in all,OFM did a good job at Everton over a good number of years.And I treasured him for it. But the charade over the past six months -and I`m convinced BK was in on it-disgusts me.

What I do not understand or can forgive is that he seems intent on `doing us over` ! Has he had a dust up with his former idol (best chairman in world etc) or is he under immense pressure from his new employers to save them a few bob. ?

One day,it may all be writ.Until then the venom will build until we can vent our spleen next April.

Colin Glassar
165 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:19:24
He's stuck in my throat like a fish bone Kevin and every time I see/hear him it just digs in deeper and makes me madder and madder. He is a horrible little man and I can't wait till the mancs come to GP to give him a piece of my mind. The little shit.
Paul Ferry
166 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:18:49
and Kev hearing the response to this dual bid on the show - basically what nearly all of us on here have been saying all along: United have disgraced themselves, ginger has his hands all over this bid, and - this one I was not ready for, Robbie Savage just said that Nick Entwhistle and Dan Brierely were wind-up buffoons and Mcnulty agreed.
Kevin Tully
167 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:21:26
It's like he's intent on rubbing our noses in it Richard, he took the piss the way he left - but this!

Isn't some semblance of respect due?

Didn't we show him the utmost respect letting him have his send off?

Paul Ferry
168 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:24:44
Can't believe that I'm writing this: spot on Doddy (987).
Peter Warren
169 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:11:03
V surprised other clubs aren't interested in these two. Infact I think they are and statement is basically to invite bids and try and start bidding war. Wouldn't be surprised to see Baines at utd and Fellaini at Arsenal come Sep 2
Kevin Tully
170 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:25:20
Let's forget about him fella's - every Evertonian deserves better (even Nick & Dan, the poor souls) he doesn't deserve the electricity it takes to even type his name - the ginger rat!
Lenny Kingman
171 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:22:26
Moyes is a self serving, sanctimonious, pontificating, dithering turd. Now the world outside of GP is awakening to the fact.
Mike Green
173 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:28:01
The line it is drawn
The curse it is cast
The slow one now
Will later be fast
As the present now
Will later be past
The order is
Rapidly fadin'
And the first one now
Will later be last
For the times they are a-changin'.
Ross Edwards
174 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:27:27
And to think we gave him a sendoff a King would receive against West Ham. Probably inflated his ego to 10x it's size. He probably thought that we would accept anything he'd do to us, but you're wrong Davey.

We all fell for your contract charade, but you wait till you return with your Manure team, you won't get that West Ham reception, that's for sure.

Matt Traynor
175 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:22:59
Kevin #855 - a reasoned and articulate post. I'm on the wrong website! Seriously, good post - well thought out.

Richard #987. My dear Richard. One of a select band of TWebbers I would wish to meet. But don't ask me to haul up to the Freshy. It's shit.

OFM had a long-held ambition to manage Man U. Fair play to him, in games too numerous to mention I could accuse him of lacking ambition.

He trousered £24m in his time at Everton. A club that under the stewardship of your hero BK is skint. We did alright by him. I actually think he'll be successful at Man U, but even if he got sacked tomorrow, he'd be set for life.

This transfer bollocks is purely about him not landing any of his targets, and panicking. If Everton, buoyed by the new TV deal, are able to resist (unless both players demand transfers) then I will have a growing respect for Bill. He's the one who needs to be strong here. Not Roberto. he's "just" the manager.

Mike Hughes
176 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:31:21
Kevin # 985

......and the most draws; level with Norwich.

(But agree with the general sentiment of your post :) )

Tommy Coleman
177 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:09:37
Kevin T 955... absolutely right.

Some just can't take down their wall posters of Moyes.

Colin Glassar
178 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:36:00
I didn't applaud him Ross. IMO, he overstayed by 5 years his welcome.
John Gee
180 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:27:50
I'm as outraged at this as the rest of you. But part of my can see a bit of an angle here...

If Man Utd don't try to destroy Moyes' relationship with his former employers then we could have another Benitez situation. Moyes gets cheered by Evertonians at GP while 3000 cockney mancs boo him.

Either way, Moyes is fucked. Either he sanctioned the bid or he's got nowhere the amount of control SAF had. Maybe a bit of both.

Note to editor: Am I allowed to use the word 'c**t'? Because if I am, I'd like to call Moyes a c**t. If I'm not allowed to use the word 'c**t' then I'll refrain from calling him a c**t. But I really do think he's acting like a c**t.

Sam Hoare
181 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:35:39
Ross 998. Don't be so sure. A lot of the Goodison crowd will still cheer him. Not the TW contingent obviously!
Gary Seed
182 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:33:04
Kevin #955 I think the answer ( in plain English ) FUCKING DELUDED KNOBHEADS or KOPITES !! Moyes / Utd are c**ts and while I'm getting all hotheaded, where is all the TV cash ? We are being outspent massivley by Southampton, Sunderland, Swansea etc ! Cold flannel time !
Phil Gardner
183 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:39:26
Just seen Doddy with a 'Marshy was right!' T-shirt on.......
Ross Edwards
184 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:40:36
Kenwright will Sam, I know that much.
Phil Rodgers
185 Posted 19/08/2013 at 15:35:26
Very sad all this for me. 11 years of managing Everton and it just feels like the guy doesn't give a fucking shit about us. I know I'm being naive but I honestly thought he was better than this.
Sam Hoare
186 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:42:40
Ross, I hear they may have fallen out and BK is pretty fuming about these bids...
Ross Edwards
187 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:42:40
Don't think Doddy's changed that much has he?...
Ross Edwards
188 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:44:40
That's probably why he looked quite cheesed off at the Norwich game Sam.
Mike Gaynes
189 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:35:27
Why did anyone here expect anything else? Does nobody else here run a corporation of some kind?

You're the president of a company. You get hired away by the competition. The minute you accept their offer and cash your first paycheck, you owe them your very best effort. And your former employer is now your competitor.

So what's the first thing you do? You look at your organization, see the weaknesses, and try to shore them up with the best people you know -- your best former employees at the previous company. Not only do you know them already and know they will serve you well, but it will damage you competitor. And that's your job!

Moyes is doing exactly what he is supposed to do for his new employer, and you can be sure that keeping his former bosses and the Everton fans happy is way, way, way down his priority list. He's just signed on for one of the highest-pressure jobs in world football. Do you think he gives a damn whether he is given an angry reception when he comes back to Goodison?

Yeah, this pisses me off too. But it will piss me off a hell of a lot more if the club sells its two best players on the cheap.

Colin Glassar
190 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:47:58
I'd like BK to come out and call OFM a cunt on the telly and/or press John. That would put him in his place. I hope the cretin is squirming right now in his Preston mansion with all this negative press he's getting.
Nick Waters
191 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:44:41
Lots of good points on here, (not Nick and Dan obviously). Whatever Moyes' level of involvement in this 'bid' no-one can deny that he would have vetoed it if he didn't support it. An interesting possibility is that Moyes did suggest something reasonable for the pair, but was laughed at by the Man U board who told him not to be ridiculous - "don't you know we've been taking the piss out of that lot for years, and they always cave in! Don't you remember the Howard unavailability clause, and offloading sicknote Saha? OK Neville turned out a bit better than we thought, but the Rooney purchase is still the stuff of legends here"

Alternatively Moyes could have understood the one-sided nature of the special relationship and thought he could screw us just as easily.

Whatever happens we cannot allow ManU to screw us again; this episode has to be the end of that 'relationship'

Richard Dodd
192 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:47:15
You are right,Ross ! I meant everything I said in praise of HIM in those bouts with Marshy and so many others. But the man has so depreciated in my estimation since all my Pie Eater colleagues started painting a picture of the future as soon as we went back to work after Christmas.And they were absolutely spot on except that it was Robles who came to us not Al Absie.

All a fecking game of charades-and Kenwright had to be a supporting script writer! And the curtain hasn`t come down on it yet,for sure.

Ian Bennett
193 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:53:57
Wow, how to destroy eleven years of toil.

I had respect for him, and genuinely gutted to see all this come out. Deal to united agreed ages ago, derisory bids put in.... Football really is a soulless mistress.

Jackie Barry
194 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:56:42
Need to get rid of these Moyes lovers, they don't have a clue what it means to support a club like Eveton, our former manager is an idol to them.

We need to be asking those that come thought the gates, "Do you love Moyes?", if they answer "YES" tell them to get out of here and give them directions to Old Trafford.

Sam Hoare
195 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:56:34
Mike 014. I agree. This is business and it sucks but I don't take it personally.
Ross Edwards
196 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:58:53
Some reports that Gollum could come back in with seperate bids next time.

He'll make another double swoop with about 1 hour of the window left and screw us over one last time.

Mark Frere
197 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:41:14
I fail to understand what is wrong with Dan Brierley's post(901), he's talking total sense for once. Moyes will just identify his targets then it will be left to other people a Manure to decide what offer is submitted. Like Dan correctly says - everyone at Man Utd including Moyes will know 28 million will be nowhere near enough to purchase our prized assets.

It really doesn't matter weather OFM is a man of integrity or not. It was our boards incompetence which led to DM moving to Manure without us getting any compensation.

The ball is now in BKs court, its up to him now to make sure our most expensive assets are not sold on the cheap

I can't believe I'm actually agreeing with Dan, because usually he spouts some of the worst shite iv'e ever had the misfortune to read on these boards...but on this occasion he's spot on

Paul Dark
198 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:39:44
Yes, I think Moyes is being a hypocrite - but then he was one as Everton manager, so nothing new there. Man Utd suits him perfectly - ugly, ugly club with no class at any level.

It's sad that Martinez's and the club's words are inviting more bids from The Scum. Martinez should say that players are NOT for sale and ask Man Utd courteously not to bid again. That kind of comment would give the right message to Evertonians, too.

I don't know if others have noticed, but Martinez plays a lot with words in interviews and doesn't give straight answers to straight questions. I suspect some Evertonians are going to be disappointed in time with Sr Martinez, but let's see. I, for one, don't like his style. I consider him to be more than slightly insincere, in short: a bit of a smarmer. Still, I hope he does well.

Robbie Muldoon
199 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:53:58
I think Everton genuinely should ask for Rooney from United, as a PR stunt. Just highlighting a current weakness in their house as they're doing to us.
Paul Dark
200 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:01:02
OFM?
Ross Edwards
201 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:01:31
You are defending Moyes' actions Mark are you?
Harold Matthews
202 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:53:38
Trying to visualize Maddy Smith. hmmm.
Gavin Ramejkis
203 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:01:22
Man U are rule breaking gobshites and should be told in no uncertain terms where to get off, for those still daft enough to pine for the ginger misery and think what he did to replace whiskey nose is "just business" and his current tack let me ask you for your commentary on Rule J 3 page 124 of the Premier League Handbook - http://www.premierleague.com/content/dam/premierleague/site-content/News/publications/handbooks/premier-league-handbook-2012-2013.pdf

Man U breached that rule in an illegal early approach for Gollum, he's admitted he knew before the fairytale decision made in a single beat bullshit at the time, Man U apologised, the club should have said foul play and fucked them over right back.

John Gee
204 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:55:08
Mike, I've mentioned this once or twice before on here. Football isn't a business and to try to make a comparison doesn't work. Football is a sport whose currency is loyalty. Moyes has shown himself to be as bankrupt as most of the over rated, self serving, narcissistic, over paid, average ability, superstar dickheads who rob a living from the fans they pretend to have loyalty towards.

John Gee
205 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:55:08
Mike, I've mentioned this once or twice before on here. Football isn't a business and to try to make a comparison doesn't work. Football is a sport whose currency is loyalty. Moyes has shown himself to be as bankrupt as most of the over rated, self serving, narcissistic, over paid, average ability, superstar dickheads who rob a living from the fans they pretend to have loyalty towards.

Joe McMahon
206 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:03:09
Some choice language on here tonight guys & gals. Gotta say though, Tony Marsh and many others (including me) never trusted Moyes, his 4 million a year salary was bleeding us, he was happy to take it, and couldn't even give us one win at Anfield in 11 bloody years. I'm 43 and the last time we won there I was still in my friggin twenties.
He knows they will both want to go to OT, show us some respect Moyes, we made you a multi-millionaire.
Sam Hoare
207 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:07:00
John Gee, "Football is a sport whose currency is loyalty". Seriously? It looks to me like the currency is money...certainly far more of that than loyalty around. Football is very much a business.
Jackie Barry
208 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:07:28
Totally John Gee and not many businesses are run like football clubs, us at 45+ million in debt and Manure at what is it, 850 million in debt? Crikey the shareholders would be after your head!
Sam Hoare
209 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:11:25
Jackie, Man u do have shareholders.
Kevin Tully
210 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:09:56
Love the fact ginge just sent an email to his chief exec;

Ed,

Want Fellaini & Baines before window closes.

Cheers,

Dave.

Then had nothing more to do with the matter.

Best defence of the sly dog so far. Well done.

Jackie Barry
211 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:12:52
I know Sam, that's the point I am making, if a normal everyday business was that much in debt the shareholders would have you removed.
Tony McNulty
212 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:13:19
Didn't some manager at one time make comments about Man City and their lack of class?
Ross Edwards
213 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:14:14
I can actually see him doing that Kev.

"Alright Ed, get Fellaini and Baines, but as cheaply as we can, but if rejacted, you take the flak"

Dean Adams
214 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:13:33
That "ginger tosser" sold his soul to the devil (utd) and in doing so lost all credibility as a man of honour. Now he tries to take the piss with this pathetic offer. Tell him we will take Rooney on loan (utd pay his wages) until his contract expires, in a swap for Felli. Baines is not for sale at any price.
Never thought I would hate Moyes so quickly but he has defied lgic this year.
Ross Edwards
216 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:17:23
Just make a double offer for Rooney and RVP for £10million, see how ginge likesit.
Kevin Tully
217 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:17:06
Hopefully, when some people can see their theory in writing, they may wake up Ross. Very much doubt it though.

Moyes will of course had a major input into all the figures, he is well versed in every penny the club has/needs.

Mike Gaynes
218 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:14:03
John Gee (032), I wish your romantic view of the sport was still true, but it isn't. It's a multi-billion-dollar worldwide business in which loyalty, particularly to a previous employer, is as extinct as the dodo bird.

And Manchester United is a publicly traded corporation whose stockholders have every right to expect their manager's absolute commitment to making ManU the best it can be. Loyalty to Everton wouldn't be just an anachronism... it would be a breach of Moyes' fiduciary duty to his employers and shareholders. He owes them nothing less than his best efforts to cut our throats and everyone else's.

And Sam Hoare, like most here I do take it personally. Very personally. But unlike most here, I was certain this would happen. I understand why it had to happen. And I realize how pointless it is to throw tantrums about it.

Let's not get mad. Let's get even. Starting with beating the bastards again this year.

Tommy Meehan
219 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:16:44
Kevin, I think the e-mail back probably went something like this:

Sorry Dave,

We've spent all our transfer money on Varela. Obviously you didn't know this as it has nothing to do with you.

Your humble and obedient servant,

Teddy W

Ross Edwards
220 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:22:55
Just make a £10 million double bid for Rooney and RVP, see how Gollum likes it.
Ross Edwards
221 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:24:18
Tommy,

PS, BTW, they are offering Osman and Naismith. The new Iniesta and Messi, so I'm told

Mike Hughes
222 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:24:58
Just looked on the BBC thread relating to this story and it has received around 1300 comments at the time of writing. That must be a record.

A quick glimpse of the feedback ranged from angry Evertonians; mixed reaction Mancs and the usual quota of bitter, bell-end, care-in-the-community RS.

Mark Frere
223 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:25:27
Kevin

So what you're saying is: Moyes will of advised his employers to put in a 28 million offer thinking we will except it?

Ross Edwards
224 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:29:21
Mark, do you seriously think a Chief Exec would make a bid for a player without consulting the manager first?

Come on.

Matt Traynor
225 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:27:43
John Gee #005. I think we got the gist of your use of the female bodypart.
Kevin Tully
226 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:30:18
To say Moyes has no input to the actual bids is sheer lunacy Mark, guessing who said what is pure conjecture, so why go there?
Mike Corcoran
227 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:29:33
Ok......why are Everton issuing a press release about derisory offers, unless to indicate that these two players are for sale at the right price. MUFC have said nothing about making offers have they?

Why didn't the club just keep quiet if the bid wasn't enough and they didn't want to sell.

Remember Everton don't talk about transfers until they're done....except for this and the Fer bollox.......stinks on our side I think

Matt Traynor
228 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:31:23
John Gee #032, apologies for replying quickly to two of your posts - the first was a joke.

Football absolutely is a buisness. As an economist with a passion / bent for sport, I've spent an inordinate amount of time looking at how clubs operate in this country, Germany, France, Spain, Italy.

It is absolutely a business. One that we're not too good at it would seem.

John Gee
229 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:23:23
'you only sing when you publish your fiscal forecasts, sing when you publish your fiscal forecasts'

'the referee's an investor, the referee's an investor'

'my old man said be a Tottenham shareholder, I said not in this current economic climate'

'I'm forever blowing capital expenditure, pretty capital expenditure in the air'

'stand up if you hate interim balance statements'

It's not a business, it's a con that sucks money out of people who are happy to prove their loyalty. Without that loyalty, there is no money. These greedy pricks should realise that.

But you have it your way if you want. For me, it's still a sport. Albeit, populated by parasites.

Mike Corcoran
230 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:33:10
Would love Rooney back for Fellaini .......
Ian Bennett
231 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:34:56
Mike - the press have been talking about this for weeks, whilst the players have said what the situation is to fans when asked. Going public to me is drawing out a put up or shut up approach. The uncertainty is sure to be impacting the players, whilst the club will surely want as much time to get replacements in.
Ross Edwards
232 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:37:45
Just offer something just as jnsulting for Rooney, like £5 million plus Osman.
James Stewart
233 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:39:44
I think a bid for Rooney would be the perfect retort.
Mark Frere
234 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:34:06
Kevin

Moyes will probably have intimate knowledge of our finances which he can pass on to his employers, but he will also know we wont let players go on the cheap.

Its up to our board now to get the best deal possible.

Karl Jones
235 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:30:45
Its vitally important that Everton do not succumb to these bullying tactics and take a leaf out of Liverpool and Spurs book, otherwise what is the point in having any aspirations of winning anything?

Its always been one step forward , two steps back with Everton up to now. The perennial selling club, despite a despicable act from a man who two months ago said he'd do anything to help Everton.

Every time we get a top player despite a lot of severe words coming out of the club , we always eventually sell; Rooney, Lescott etc, etc, so all blues who feel strongly, should contact the club and leave them in no doubt.

John Gee
236 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:36:51
Matt 055, apologies for allowing my amateur interest in gynaecology to intrude onto a football forum. But he is acting like one. A big one.
Matt Traynor
237 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:45:50
John #067 no apology needed. It seems they have kid-friendly software on here that removes the offensive text and replaces with asterisks.

You Axe Wound!

Urban Dictionary is your friend!!

Ross Edwards
238 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:42:22
Mark, so why did he agree to go ahead with this derisory and insulting bid then if he knows that?

Answer, he doesn't give a damn about us now he's at Manure.

He would have been briefed about his budget and he would have asked his Chief Exec if he could have £28 million from that to sign Felli and Baines.

He was very much involved in that offer. Woodward didn't just make a bid on a whim, Moyes would have asked him to set aside £28m from his budget to make a double bid.

Jimmy Hill
239 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:36:51
Just read the news. I was a Moyes supporter and wished him well. One word sums him after this "TWAT".

Maybe everyone has been too hard on BK this is looking a very familiar style. We are about to find out who's style it was.

Come on Chelsea and Spurs if we cant win fuck these Mancs for good.

Matt Traynor
240 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:51:34
Ross #070, I'm repeating myself here...
But OFM was involved in the bid. He's the public face of that club. Equalizer won't face the cameras to talk about a bid.

That's how it works. Why is that so difficult for people to understand?

Off topic - I've asked MK and LL to give me a column for interviews with people in the game. I've lined up a referee (hopefully the post will appear soon), I'm trying to score a football agent I used to work with, pundits at a broadcaster etc.

A real opportunity for you guys/gals to ask some questions to the people that work in the biz.

Sorry for straying.

Ross Edwards
241 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:56:15
That's what I just said Matt. I said OFM was very much involved. Mark was suggesting otherwise.
Mark Frere
243 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:51:08
Come on Ross, Moyes will know 28 mil will be nowhere near enough to sign both players. I guess the bid is a statement of intent to buy both players - maybe a further move to try and unsettle MF and LB

I really don't know or care if Moyes gives a damn about us. Maybe he isn't a man of integrity. Like i've said its up to our board now

Brent Stephens
244 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:56:17
Mike Gaynes #014. Not much wrong with what you say as far as I'm concerned.

There IS a business side to football. I hate it but that's the reality.

Ross Edwards
245 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:01:47
If he knew that, he wouldn't have sanctioned or agreed to it.
Paul Mackie
246 Posted 19/08/2013 at 20:56:43
I hope everyone complaining about these Man U bids are also aghast at us signing Kone, Robles and Alacaraz.
Matt Traynor
247 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:01:35
Ross #073 I apologise - I realise after that it sounded like I was having a go at you. I wasn't. I was agreeing with you!

I'll give you the first question to the referee I interview (as per post hopefully to appear). Ask him about Clive Thomas....

Brent Stephens
248 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:02:45
Matt #072 - that sounds great.
Colin Glassar
249 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:02:07
I think a straight swap, Naismith for Rooney would be a fair deal. Let's be honest, even the mancs are embarrassed with this offer.
Matt Traynor
250 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:05:07
Brent #080 when my post finally appears, I give a hat -tip to Becky Tallentire, who penned Talking Blue.

It really is gonna be down to you guys - I know most of the answers already!

Patrick Murphy
251 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:06:07
The problem will be, we probably will lose both players, but we will never ever find out how much we were paid for them all hidden behind the Undisclosed Fee clause. Although do MUFC have to declare exactly how much they paid for an individual player because they are listed or doesn't it matter?
Nick Waters
252 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:07:37
Paul 078 - what have those 3 AGREED deals got to do with an 'insulting' and derisory' bid?
Paul David
253 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:06:16
Why do people keep thinking we did the same to Wigan?

Birdman was a free agent.

Robles wasn't even a Wigan player.

We paid the asking price for Kone straight away.

We also did our business early so Wigan had plenty of time to bring other players in.

How is any of that the same as Utd offering a piss taking amount on the eve of the season?

Ged Simpson
254 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:09:34
A derisory bid is derisory to the seller not the buyer.

Look - he is just not the guy some of us thought, Mainly becuse he is employed by someone else.

The real key here is to see if BK is the same

John Crossley
255 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:10:56
The clubs statement doe's not state the two players are not for sale. I will be very disappointed if we lost these two.
Ian Bennett
256 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:11:19
Quite Nick. I have heard this one a couple of times. Those 3 signings were a combination of a free, an activated release clause and a player unwanted by athletico Madrid. We didn't offer massively below their market worth. A shit comparison.
Brent Stephens
257 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:14:43
I don't give a shit what is offered. What do we expect? Nobody is going to offer more than they think somebody is worth, nor what they think they will eventually have to pay. When does that ever happen? Not in any business I'm familiar with (and, as above, football is partly business).

What would be insulting to us is if Bill accepted way below what we think our lads are worth.

Peter Warren
258 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:13:39
Just heard Gary Neville saying bids weren't derisory but could be a few million more. I actually like him as a pundit but what a load of balls. We paid £23-5m and they been fantastic. I don't believe we paid over odds.

Now one of biggest clubs in the world with premier league awash with money offer less than £5m than we paid not for one but both of them!!!! Clearly as even a starting point only they're worth more than £5m each to what we have paid, £38m would be a starting point and I would still tell them to fuck off

Ged Simpson
259 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:19:45
BK on twitter. @BKL_Productions

Now tell him !

Ged Simpson
260 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:20:16
or @Everton
Tony Christian
261 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:05:49
Paul Mackie - Robles was never a Wigan player (merely a loan) and Alvarez was out of contract - kindly take your tongue out of your beloved Moyes's arse or take your support to Old Trafford. Too many gobshites like you appear to want Roberto to fail and Moyes to succeed so you can say 'I told you'.
Lewis Barclay
262 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:10:10
Bear with me:

Rooney is hacked off, doesn't want to play for Manure any more.
Moyes won't sell him to any team he considers a challenger for the PL.
Moyes makes derisory bid for Baines and Felli, gets turned down as expected.
Manure wait until thee days before transfer deadline having already set the bar low for offers on Baines and Felli, and unsettled them both and then offers Rooney a way out via a season long loan at Everton with three-quarters of his wages paid plus first refusal at the end of the season to Everton as a sweetener plus £30mill.

Ged Simpson
263 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:27:52
Not worth bearing with Lewis mate. Silly
Nick Waters
264 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:28:02
Lewis - I did bear with you - but I wish I hadn't.
Peter Laing
265 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:25:23
Everton need to up the ante, counter Man United's derisory approach and go on record stating their desire to be reunited with one of their current players who is clearly unhappy. Start with an offer of a down payment of £10 million, £10 million to be paid next season and the remaining £7 million paid in add-ons related to performance.
Sean Patton
266 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:25:42
They paid 15M for Zaha in January a player who had never played in the top league and now offer just 1M for Fellaini how is that not a piss take.
Paul Mackie
267 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:31:12
Tony. Get off of your high horse you daft cunt. Where have I said I want Martinez to fail? Also I'm hardly a fan of Moyes. Some of the hypocrisy in this thread was just making me laugh is all.
Alan Ross
268 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:16:29
Letter to United from Woods

http://thebusbyway.com/2013/08/19/picture-evertons-written-response-to-uniteds-28m-bid/

I would love this to be genuine. If it is, then something has changed at Board level for the better

Joe Edwards
269 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:31:33
Moyes has now taken the final step in his breakaway from the club, he has now proven himself to be a ruthless ginger tosser of the highest order, making a mockery of the parting statement — "I am leaving Everton in great shape" only to come back and fuckin cherry pick our assets as Manure have done so many times in the past.

I for one would sell Fellaini as he is more than replaceable but tell them to shove any bid for Baines up his hybrid Scottish Manc arse.

Tony Christian
270 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:35:33
Paul - no offence intended I just get feeling one or two so-called Evertonians on here are pretty much praying for Martinez to fail.
Kevin Tully
271 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:36:42
Seems to be a completely professional response Alan - but you can't believe a thing you see or read on t'interweb these days!
David Chait
272 Posted 19/08/2013 at 19:59:37
Whether Moyes should us more respect than any other club is a debatable issue... Clearly... But he is undeniably a hypocrite... And a hate hypocrites. It does have a real feel of the start of negotiations though....
Richard Reeves
273 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:24:38
There's a picture of the responding letter on the internet. The first paragraph basically says that the bid is derisory but the second paragraph looks suspiciously like a "you know the price and know we will sell" line. This is the second paragraph.......
"We did speak about the agreement we have in place with David Moyes and would appreciate those terms and conditions to be honoured in both a professional and dignified way".
You could look at it as a "hands off Baines" comment but I've always thought that Kenwright and Moyes have had an agreement that both can be sold for the right price.
Justin Packett
274 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:38:01
So the Baines bid is still same as before when it was rejected???? They might be good football, but SHITE at maths.
Steve Mink
275 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:46:54
I just don't follow 90% of the responses on here.

MUFC bid for some EFC players in private.

Everton make it public.

Squealing about it being insulting and derisory is weak.

Shades of the Arteta deal to all of this.

If they take Felli for more than £20m I'll be happy.

Brian Harrison
276 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:46:53
I really think that the transfer window should close before a ball is kicked, how long do these managers need to complete deals, they have had all summer. Pellegrini bought all his players in early, how often do we hear managers saying how important pre-season is, so why buy after the club has finished its pre-season. Obviously the richer clubs who have not done their business early still believe they have enough clout to take it to the final day. Tonight Arsenal make a bid for Cobhay from Newcastle and it has obviously affected the lad because at the last minute Pardew has left him out of their starting line up.
Christian Watson
277 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:44:34
Insulting and derisory... And that's just Moyes!!!! I know football is a business (more than ever these days) but just who does Moyes think he is??

Baines and Fellaini bids aside for a miniute, did you hear him on MotD on Saturday? — "I need to win more games here than when I was at Everton."

Back to the 'bids'. He's playing a flanker by letting the £24mil clause window expire and come in lower, let's not forget he has DEEP knowledge of our financial plight and is banking on it... twat.

The other slightly disturbing fact is that the bids were only 'dismissed' unlike our lovable scum bag members who received a clause-breaking bid for the nibbler only to be told 'he's not for sale' 4 words sadly lacking from our limited transfer vocabulary.

Unfortunately I tend to agree with David Chait, this is the start of negotiations. If Skybet have Fellaini as 2/7 to join Man Utd before the window closes, I think we all know the eventual outcome!!

Patrick Murphy
278 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:57:31
I agree Brian but it's all down to UEFA, however, why not bring a rule in that says clubs belonging to the same association cannot sign players or sell players to each other once that associations league has started.
Derek Knox
279 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:00:30
Regarding this so-called letter, if you look, the date on the letter, it is today's. I would assume with the 'official crest' on the one shown, it would have been posted, possibly Friday, would have been dated as such!
Colin Glassar
280 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:58:43
Steve mink, so you don't like the fact that the club made their shitty offer public? You'd take £20m for Fellaini? Who do you work for?
Kunal Desai
281 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:24:46
Moyes maybe smiling now and may well get his way, but I will be there to see him fall flat on his once manure has booted him out of OT in less than two years time. He'll be begging BK for his job back.
Patrick Murphy
282 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:01:26
That letter looks genuine, but who would want it leaked? Certainly not Man U, so it seems maybe it was leaked prior to it being posted? I hope this isn't some sort of ploy by Kenwright to pacify the fans by saying look how good we are, we have kept you're two favourite players but we're not adding anybody to the squad.

Remember although it's blatantly obvious who they are - neither player has been named, knowing our luck DM was trying to do us a favour and bid £28 million for Heitinga and Naismith.

Keith Young
283 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:51:03
I am finding this thread particularly informative and not just for its grammar lessons.
Is there anybody who wonders, as I do, why did BK spend £15m ( with add ons £17m) on an unknown player from Belgium? It was so out of character for the Board to do it.
I wish our PR said " Mr Kenwright ( NOT Everton) finds the offer derisory but of course he will sell at the right price". You must remember that his mission remains the same " to make a killing". If he was genuinely looking for an investment he simply needs a "rights issue" and thereby encouraging wider share ownership.
John Shaw
284 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:09:30
Nick E
There's a very big difference between what has happened during the summer with below value bids from Utd and old Ginger Nuts and what we have done with Wigan.

Firstly, when Martinez left Wigan, Whelan came out and publically stated that all of his players could be bought, for the right price, he would also have no problem with Martinez and EFC buying them!!

Compare that with Kenwright stating publically that he had agreed with Moyes that he would not come back in for any of our players, allied to the fact that Moyes/Utd have bid well below what Baines and Felli are worth and it is nonsense to state that 'we have done the same with Wigan'.

Oh we also purchased Kone, Alcaraz was on a free and Robles wasn't actually a Wigan player, he was only there on loan last season!!!

Facts, facts, facts..............

Patrick Murphy
285 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:17:31
Keith that was the start of the 'spending spree' which was carried out to persuade the fans that we were a club on the move - literally to Kirkby - and by adding to the assets for that brief period of a couple of years the asking price would net a fat profit for the owners and major shareholders - since the Kirkby fiasco crashed and burned we reverted back to being a selling club. That's my take it may well be inaccurate but it does have logic on its side.
Kevin Tully
286 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:16:32
Derek- just wondering if any fake letter would have had BK's name as the obvious author?

Whatever, we will soon find out the Board's stance come the 3rd Sept.

I personally hope both players are still here, and the Mancs are looking all over Europe, with dithering Dave on the blower to Marine FC for a 16-year-old centre-half.

Jamie Sweet
287 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:05:42
When I saw that Moyes had bid £28m for two of our players, I just assumed that it would be Hibbett and Osman.

What a prick.

I think he knows Bill needs to sell at least one of our assets to balance the books though and is taking advantage of his "inside knowledge".

Moyes may have generally bowed down, bent over and taken it up the arse from Man Utd for the best part of a decade, but we need to start showing we're bigger and better than that now!

What a prick!

John Shaw
288 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:26:11
Keith (125)

A share rights issue will never happen for two very big reasons:

1). Any rights issue of this type would normally be underwritten by a guarantor in case any of the newly issued shares are not 'taken', the underwriter will then purchase those new unsold shares!

2). Any new issue of shares will, by default, dilute the ownership of the current major shareholders.

So in the case of 1 our current Board can't or won't guarantee the rights issue in case they are left holding the baby and have to stump up more cash, in the case of 2 they won't lessen their grip on the train set!!

Matt Traynor
289 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:40:36
Richard #110, that's fake. That's not how clubs communicate!
Peter Jones
290 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:45:15
For the record, we did formally tell them that we won't negotiate any further.

http://thebusbyway.com/2013/08/19/picture-evertons-written-response-to-uniteds-28m-bid/?

Jamie Sweet
291 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:47:23
Just read the article on "The Busby Way". I'm guessing it is a fake.

What struck me most was the comments section. My word, do they have no schools in Manchester? I felt I had to comment:

"I was surprised that Moyes seemed to have lost his class and dignity so quickly after moving to Manchester Utd.

However, since reading the comments on this thread, I realise that your team is supported by a phenomenal number of illiterate dimwits.

I am no longer surprised that Moyes has decided to present himself as a classless twit in order to fit in with his new fan base".

Michael Kenrick
292 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:55:02
Lovlie, Jamie... exactly my thoughts when I scanned those twitterings. But methinks most are actually in foreign parts, with English as a 2nd, 3rd... or 4th language.
Guy Hastings
293 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:37:33
Lewis 097 - I'll bear with you. I've been posting this for the past week or two on this and another sites. Not sure about the loan bit. To be honest I'd give them a straight Fellaini/Rooney swap offer. All depends on Colleen...
Drew O'Neall
294 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:59:45
It's a basic premise of negotiation to offer a very low amount, something that you know wouldn't even be considered and yet here we all are working away from that amount speculating what the club would be willing to let them go for using that incredibly low figure as one of our yard sticks.. It's beauty mag psychology and it works.

The low low bid also draws out any latent desire the players have to leave and they use the bid as a figure to work away from.. 'Well they've offered another £5m on top of the original bid now Everton are just being unreasonable..yada yada'

Given this is an intentional hand grenade I would be inclined to make a derisory bid for Rooney and invite Sky Sports round for tea.. See if Rooney wants to kick up a hornets' nest.

Carl Peters
295 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:58:13
To be honest, the the older heads amongst us could probably see this coming. There is no doubt that Man Utd will come back with another offer for Fellaini and Baines, and I would not put it past them to come in for Barkley either — which for me explains why he would not play the kid last year to try and keep him under wraps till he could come back for him when at Man Utd. But one thing is for certain: he will come for them.

Personally I would love Everton to just tell them to fuck off, but that won’t happen. What will happen though — and I’d be willing to bet on it — is that we sell to Man Utd for an undisclosed sum, and will be told by the the club it was too late to replace them. Remember, we are dealing with Kenwright here... who will probably accept £30M provided it does not become public.

Michael Kenrick
296 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:03:50
Yea, Kevin, I would expect 99 out 100 fakers would put Teary Billy's name on that letter.

The only thing 'missing' to my eye is the destination address. Odd that there is only the date... and that is in American style (missing a comma) rather than the English style: 19 August 2013... but that is a minor detail that I suspect means nothing.

Ahhhh... but the watermark badge is badly off-centre... and does not seem to bend properly at the fold in the paper... [I think we could have a whole new thread just on this letter!!!]

Drew O'Neall
297 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:08:21
Peter Jones 135

All I could think was what a horrible letterhead!

Ian Hollingworth
298 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:46:18
Shit this is bullshit billy we are talking about. They are both gone I am afraid.
Why did Everton announce this?
I suspect BK is hoping to start an auction

My worry is that the club announcement does not say the players are not for sale

Be prepared to be shafted once again!
I also suspect a soon to be leaked rumour of a potential takeover

Si Cooper
299 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:49:58
Some of the usual guff about 'how business works' to excuse this insulting offer.

Has nobody ever worked for a firm that identified a crucial piece of equipment, worked out how much money it would make / save them and then went out and paid the market rate as long as the figures added up. Sure, everyone tries to get a deal but that doesn't mean it always has to be the maximum discount or you are failing your company.

What about the £50 million paid for Torres or the £35 million for Carroll? To suggest that a manager can't swing an over the top offer every now and then is ludicrous, and all people are expecting of OFM is some straight dealing if he really is interested in these players.

Winston Williamson
300 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:13:58
I'm fucking furious! Not that the ginger bastard and his club have put in a bid for our players, but that the offer is below what Moyes paid for a rough diamond in Fellaini and how he is insulting the best left back in Europe!

Here's my solution...offer 5mil for Rooney, in installments, and tell them to fuck off!!

Kevin Tully
301 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:15:42
M.K - I would usually email a scanned copy over as a reply, so often don't use full recipient addresses on any correspondence.

The plot thickens.

David Booth
302 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:11:18
Against all my instincts, I fervently hope Baines will show what a unique modern day footballer he is by remaining loyal to Everton.

However, David Moyes knows enough about Bill Kenwright, Everton's financial situation (whatever that may be) and the player himself, to take Fellaini just by pressing 'send' on an e-mail offer.

Pardon me for being cynical, but I think this is a PR stunt to avoid him apparently taking Fellaini from us on deadline day.

He couldn't attract Fabregas, looks like doing likewise with Modric and other midfield targets, but is surely relaxed in the knowledge that if all else fails, he can have Fellaini within half an hour.

I'd be absolutely delighted of he stayed. What a statement of intent that would be. But fear the inevitable will happen.

Which begs the question, when the likes of Norwich, Southampton and Swansea have all spent multi millions more than us: where does he money go at Everton?

How long will it be before we can't even scrap for signings with the Boltons and Wigans of this lunatic football world?

That being said, if we are using the £60m-ish we get from Sky to keep players like Baines and Fellaini happy, then we'll all be happy too won't we?

Harold Matthews
303 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:56:45
Jamie. There are also plenty of Blue sites with the ability to scare the pants off any schoolmaster........and let's not forget the travelling companions of our famous fullback. There are literally millions of the same ilk all over the country.

As for ToffeeWeb. Well ,unfortunately, todays transfer news caused the normally above average levels to dip quite alarmingly.

Mark Taylor
304 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:19:16
I don't see why there's so much anger against Moyes. He has a new employer now and his task is to do the best for them. He is only coming after Fellaini because he can't get his first choices like Fabregas. Even assuming he is involved directly in negotiations, which I doubt, he is hardly going to bid his final price. Would you bid what you could afford for a house you were buying- or what you thought the seller might accept, or an opening offer that set a baseline for subsequent negotiations?

Let's get real here. The real issue is whether the players want to leave. You don't need to make a bid nowadays to achieve that position. If they want to leave, whose fault is that?

If they do want to go- and even possibly if they don't- who would be to blame if we lost the players for less than they were worth and/or with no time to replace them.

To be blunt, I think the latter is what is going to happen and I think Kenwright will be happy to enable it, so he can bank the proceeds. If you hate the idea we are a selling club and want to point the gun, aim it in the right direction.

Phil Bellis
305 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:19:42
Harold (029) re Maddy Smith

"Hands on TOP iof the desk Matthews!"

Patrick Murphy
306 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:21:35
Kevin #150 Whether fake or real that letter has been folded, so it looks like it has been in an envelope, unless those new fangled copiers are even more sophisticated than I thought. I think it probably is a fake though. I can't see why we would give a reply in writing and go on to give the actual amount of the bid, looks like a big wind-up, which is perhaps why the OS put out a statement in the first place. Who knows This Is Everton, a conspirators paradise for donkey's years.

John Bourne
307 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:24:52
Tony Marsh #847

You saved me the trouble Tony, Gollum is beneath contempt, it's just a shame that it takes something like this to make people realise that he was always the mercenary, nothing more.

Clive Lewis
308 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:33:24
Also did anyone notice the "Leter" spelt wrong, got to be fake.
Paul David
309 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:31:53
Mark

If a house is worth 250k, would your first offer be 50k?

No you wouldn't think of offering less than 185k cos one is taking the piss and the other is testing the water.

Kevin Tully
310 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:31:37
Imagine if the whole truth was ever revealed Patrick?

I think it would be a best selling book, a hit movie, and a Broadway production.

Hang on a minute.......

Si Cooper
311 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:30:14
Mark Taylor (#153) - suggest you review Moyes' previous views on the subject of late and paltry bids for players, consider how accommodating / generous BK has been with him, and remember that our chairman and our former manager are supposed to have some sort of agreement in place.

Moyes may not be directly involved with the mechanics of the process, but he can't be considered to be entirely divorced from the shenanigans either.

Patrick Murphy
313 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:44:22
Perhaps the title would be 'Pound Signs in their Eyes' or 'For a Few Dollars More' or an English version of twenty-four "24 - 7", 'The Loan Arranger'

Kevin Tully
314 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:50:16
On the spaghetti western theme Pat - all directed by Sergio Loan me.

Goodnight. It's been along Tweb day. Fecking loads to do in work now 'cos of that ginger minge.

Patrick Murphy
315 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:55:43
See ya Kev, don't you dare act on any of those murderous thoughts, they won't allow you access to t'internet in San Quentin.
Clive Lewis
316 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:46:55
Moyes and his brother can go do one! The possibility is that Baines and Fellaini handing in transfer requests. I am not sure if Baines would do this, I think fellaini would. I actually think fellaini thinks he is better than he is, in reality he passes the ball, scores a few. But not sure if this is enough to win in europe. If Fellaini is not in the side regularly he could lose his place for the world cup, the same for baines, becuase Evra is probably better going forward and defending at the moment. Its a risk for both.
Fellaini and his agent have been quiet this transfer window ???
Mark Taylor
317 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:53:19
Paul 159

If my fears are correct, Kenwright will take £35m and quite possibly not much more than £30m.

Man U are not offering one fifth of what they will pay. They are offering roughly 80% of what I think our board will accept. That is the problem.

Tony Marsh
318 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:39:37
Stick in there... fight Moyes all the way. Take the twat to deadline day and nail his balls to the floor. Moyes needs these two players more than he is letting on.

Derisory Dave is a creature of habit and needs players around him he knows. It's the way he has always operated. In the end, Moyes will cave in because he is a quitter with no bottle. Moyes is trying to impress his new bosses with his dynamic bargaining skills but he will fold if we turn up the heat.

If Moyes really wants the two players, tell him to up his bids and there will be no more contact after Thursday. Make the bastard sweat. Let Moyes know we think he is a pudding who doesn't have any of SAF's ability to wheel and deal or any of the fear factor Ferguson used so well over the years.

Moyes is a mouse amongst men.

Dick Fearon
319 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:06:31
Much to my disgust and disbelief Moyes has been bigging Osman for years. Now when he is in a position to sign him he does not want a bar of him.
Leave the other two alone.
Paul David
320 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:00:42
Mark

Neither of us know what the club will except but 35m is still low for me. I don't think the club want 5X what Utd offered but I think the point is still valid, their offer was a piss take.

Mark Taylor
321 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:58:39
Si 161

I'm not especially interested in what has been said before. I'm not actually that interested in Moyes since he is now no longer interested in us.

My point is a simple one. There is zero point in throwing a hissy fit like the club has, unless

a) you know or fear the players may press for a move and/or

b) you know you are going to accept an offer, possibly not far north of what is tabled

If you have no desire or intention to do business, you make no announcement. You just tell the bidder where to get off. Our board can choose to do that and Moyes' role is an irrelevance.In essence, there is power in silence.

You make an announcement like this when you are preparing the PR to deal with the fallout from voluntarily selling the club's best assets. In fact, you are pretty much confirming you will sell and are merely opening negotiations.

Justin Packett
322 Posted 19/08/2013 at 21:38:01
So the Baines bid is still same as before when it was rejected???? They might be good football, but SHITE at maths.
Mark Taylor
323 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:07:21
Paul

I'm not saying £35m is enough, or not. That would depend on what we could buy with that money. On more than one occasion, selling one big player has meant we have brought in several, and undoubtedly improved the squad.

But my fear is, this is going to happen and RM won't even get the cash, or at best, only a fraction of it. That is more important to me than whether we get £30, 35 or 40m.

We are about to discover more about the scale of our board's ambition and the cynic in me is preparing to be disappointed...

Ernie Baywood
324 Posted 19/08/2013 at 23:35:01
It's a shit bid, designed to start negotiations at a low point. We don't like it but, well, that's the way it is regardless of who manages the big boys. Words like 'derisory' are just part of the game. We're not really offended are we? Just like OFM wasn't really offended by the Lescott bid. He's a big player in this game - he knows how it works.

I expect nothing from Moyes. This bid says nothing about his 11 years with us, it just says something about his few months at Utd.

The two players in question will likely go, with our board putting up enough of a fight as to save face. Hopefully they're lining up the replacements as we speak.

Bobby Thomas
325 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:17:24
Forget all the indignation.

We are being played like fiddles.

The old EFC trick of the blame game is getting into full swing.

Theres a reason the details of these bids have been leaked by US for christ sakes!!


Paul David
326 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:16:51
Mark

I personally don't mind if Fellaini goes, as long as we got good money cos I think we could put it to good use or we could have and that's part of the problem.

There have been some bargains bought over the summer by other clubs. If Utd had bought Fellaini in June then some of them players could be with us now but instead Moyes as usual leaves it late and the pool of available players is smaller and will cost more than they would have done a month a go.

Paul David
327 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:16:51
Mark

I personally don't mind if Fellaini goes, as long as we got good money cos I think we could put it to good use or we could have and that's part of the problem.

There have been some bargains bought over the summer by other clubs. If Utd had bought Fellaini in June then some of them players could be with us now but instead Moyes as usual leaves it late and the pool of available players is smaller and will cost more than they would have done a month a go.

Andrew Cutler
328 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:27:27
That photo of the leter (sic)...Sharpies ph # is the same as general enquiries...really?
Paul McGinty
330 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:20:24
The Guardian newspaper projects the joint bid will be separated into two bids, one for each player.

According to the newspaper, Man Utd argue, since the Felli buyout clause was not activated, then the player was and is not worth the £23.5M amount in it. Everton in turn have to pay 20 percent of any profit back to Standard Liege.

Unfortunately its a case of deja vu all over again as far as our transfer window goes. Sweating it to the end.

Paul David
331 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:38:45
We owe Standard 20% of profit?

They really did a number on us.

Bobby Thomas
332 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:47:32
If we have to give Liege 20% then we have indeed been done over, we've overpaid for him.
Si Cooper
333 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:40:58
Mark (175) you asked why people were angry with Moyes so I pointed out a few things that people may bristle at.

Now we are expected to believe that nobody in football / business has any personal principles they aren't prepared to surrender and every utterance is spin?

Harold Matthews
334 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:56:20
No, not me sir. It was Phil Bellis.
Matt Muzi
335 Posted 20/08/2013 at 00:46:06
I have to agree with previous statements on this blog, why was the details of this derisory bid released to the press?

Wen I first heard about this when it broke the first thing that came to mind was Man City & Mark Hughes pursuit of Lescott, which The mail journalist has noted, what else I remember is this was one of the only times I can remember Moyes actually condemning another manager/club to the press regarding transfers

We all had a good idea that Fellaini was going to go and a lot of us had accepted it, as long as RM got all the money and could re-invest in the squad.
What worries me, is are Man U doing this to unsettle Baines & Fellaini and see if they will submit a transfer request, which will put us in a predicament.

Like a lot of people if they wanted either player, I personally feel they should of come in with an appropriate bid in June, not at this stage of the window. Ths along with the other bids has been done to see if they can get a reaction from the players & their agents in my opinion and Man U clearly have a good understanding of our Chairman.

If we sell either player and don't get a realistic value for them, or find appropriate replacements, or as we've seen previously the deals are done last minute, the funds promised in full to the manager next window, which never happens then I think major questions need to be asked of our board.

I'm not completely anti our board, but when Southampton have spent 40 million, West Ham around 25, Norwich & Swansea around 20 million, you look at their current match attendance position in the league etc etc, and we have spent 8 million and don't appear to have any more funds, it does beg a big question.

If this is the pre-cursor to either Fellaini, or Baines going then I would expect it to be for a realistic amount, with time to bring in appropriate replacements, otherwise our board in my opinion is not only letting the club down, but also sticking two fingers up to us the fans who pay our money into the club season in season out.

Jamie Crowley
336 Posted 20/08/2013 at 01:10:07
Having worked all day, and having to keep working late into the night, I just sat down to grab a quick bite to eat. Tuned into TW and saw this.

I'll go back and read all 300+ comments when I have the time. But...

You absolutely have to be fucking kidding me! Anyone not enraged by this ought to be. Moyes is an absolute dick. Yes, business is business, but does it need to be conducted utterly without class while sticking your middle finger as high in the air as possible?! Or that V thingy you fine gentlemen do over there...

Baines at least £20 mil. Fellaini at least £25 mil. That's £45 mil total Dave the Dick. Pony up or fuck right the hell off. No bulk discounts.

We should not sell either now. After the way Moyes and Man U have treated Everton Football Club we simply can not sell either of these two players to that team.

It's called PRIDE. And it's about high time we showed some.

If BK caves on this one I pray the uproar is so massive he has no choice but to exit stage left. If he finds his backbone and tells them to stick it, I'll be very proud of that theater impresario.

Kristian Boyce
337 Posted 20/08/2013 at 01:25:46
As this saga of OFM under bidding for our players continues, I think Moyes is starting to turn into the new Mark Hughes. Hughes' first two manager jobs for Wales and Blackburn quickly gained him praise and even popularity from a wider audience. Slightly surprizing as he wasn't the most likable player. On moving to City and the influx of the oil money, his antics in the transfer market using his new found wealth disgusted fans; other teams and especially other managers (including most obviously OFM). Hughes' lack of success and his arrogance led to his dismissal. His career following City has shown him up to be a money grabbing idiot, who's later performances haven't lived up to his once regarded skills and talents.

The first few months into OFM's reign is showing up his poor judgement, lack of respect of other clubs and an arrogance as he's the 'Big Man' at the 'Biggest Club in the World' (Their term not mine). Here's hoping for him to fall flat on his face this coming year. His dour disposition would suit Stoke tremendously in a few years time.

Roman Sidey
338 Posted 20/08/2013 at 01:17:49
Paul Ferry, that one worded response to Ross' gullibility had me in bits on the couch mate. Perfect.

Doddy, your singing is pleasing to the ear tonight mate. Very glad to learn you are actually from planet earth and that you aren't as hypnotized by OFM as some.

For me, if I were running the club, I would be actively trying to sell both these players to City or Chelsea for £35-40m in the next week or so, just to stick it right up United's arse. Obviously I don't truly want to them to leave, but I just feel like we need to do something really drastic to show United and that ginger twat Moyes that we aren't going to be his little farm while he's 50 miles up the road eating prawn sandwiches.

Ben Jones
340 Posted 20/08/2013 at 02:11:03
I think the Everton response of the bid was brilliant!

They didn't have to say anything, yet they say United bid and bluntly insulted the offer, making us look good and United like idiots.

To be fair, I think the treatment on Moyes is harsh here. He obviously wants these players, and Martinez did the same with Wigan. Do you genuinely think Moyes came up with the exact figures? If you do, you're naive. It's all done by the board nowadays and Ed Woodward, new chief exec, is a crap negotiator.

Im not saying Moyes is not completely to blame, the thing over his contract annoys me a hell of a lot more, but this is more Utd's fault and not Moyes.

Paul Ferry
341 Posted 20/08/2013 at 02:16:06
Harold Matthews - 29 - Maddy Smith mate you're 78 and you'll have a coronary and I for one would rather have you around on here for a long time to come.
Kristian Boyce
342 Posted 20/08/2013 at 02:21:13
Ben, Martinez didn't do the same with Wigan. Kone had a 5M release clause, we met it (as another team supposedly did) and he joined. Alcarez was a free agent, no longer a Wigan player. Robles was an Atletico Madrid player, we signed him from them, not Wigan.

Our situation is nothing like what Moyes is doing. Felliani had a 23.5M release clause and he didn't meet it, then offers 7.5M less.

Mark Stewart
343 Posted 20/08/2013 at 02:39:38
The club's response is a holding one; using the language they did but not saying they're not for sale is about getting the Mancs to increase their offer(s). Also, why did we make the bid public? Everton will have a price in mind, more so for Fellaini than Baines; Bill told everyone about the release clause when he unveiled Martinez, who then reminded the media about it expiring only last week.

Regardless of whether Moyes has set these offers or not, he's behaved like a twat for months.

Peter Barry
344 Posted 20/08/2013 at 03:30:53
To presume, as some of the diehard Moyesistas continue to do in their pathetic attempts to mitigate in his defense, that Man Utd would both make bids for Everton players — and place a valuation on those bid WITHOUT consulting their new ex-Everton manager — displays a naive gullibility bordering on insanity.
Peter Barry
345 Posted 20/08/2013 at 03:36:58
Historical note for Jamie Crowley #196 and our other American cousins and maybe some Englishmen too. That 'V-thingy' as you call it started when during, the 100 Years War against the French (and not long enough in my opinion), British Longbowmen used to display the two fingers on their right hands, used for pulling back the bowstrings, towards the Froggies to demonstrate they still had them as the Froggies were in the habit of cutting off said fingers if they ever got hold of a much feared English Longbowman.

It has of course nothing whatsoever to do with Winston Churchill's V-for-Victory which is done with the fingers displayed palm to the front as opposed to the 'Fuck You' display with your palm towards you.

Harold Matthews
346 Posted 20/08/2013 at 03:25:17
Yeah Paul. Guess your right. All the same, she is safer than Chisato Shoda and Riko Tachibana.
Can't help being an oddball. My excuse is always "I'm an artist".
Listening to the great Nora Jones album, "The Fall".......brilliant.

Have you seen that amazing "small town, America" movie "Mumford"? Got it from Amazon this morning and it's going on next.

Robin Hunuki
347 Posted 20/08/2013 at 04:02:04
Thought this was worth a read to be honest, on how dealings went if Moyes (ManUtd) and Moyes (EFC) had discussed this topic...
Robin Hunuki
348 Posted 20/08/2013 at 04:02:52
http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/soccer-dirty-tackle/dt-exclusive-david-Moyes-negotiates-david-Moyes-fellaini-023809427.html
Steve Carter
349 Posted 20/08/2013 at 04:39:36
I haven't read all 300 odd articles on this post; however, here is a protective angle on this for Everton. The law will protect (by injunction) the use of an employer's confidential information from misuse by an ex-employee, regardless of whether there is a written covenant in restraint of trade in place.

I would have thought that Moyes would have been in possession of a fair bit of information about how Everton valued Fellaini and Baines, their strategies for the retention and possible sale, etc. If such information was and is confidential to Everton – it is certainly arguable, at the very least, that it is – then why isn't Everton threatening injunction to restrain Moyes AND Man Utd from making offers for them? (It beggars belief that Man Utd could be going about this uninfluenced by Moyes's inner knowledge of Everton's thinking.)

Paul Ferry
350 Posted 20/08/2013 at 04:47:28
Best excuse of all Harold. I haven't heard of that movie but gonna Amazon it - ugh is that a verb yet - when I end this. I'm watching with a good red and female Ferry safe in bed my fave film of all time - La Belle Noiseuse - for the what the 29th time?

Nora Jones Harold. Nice. But Nora Winstone mate aaahhhh!

Don't forget zzzzzzzzz Harold mate.

Harold Matthews
351 Posted 20/08/2013 at 04:12:08
Nice post Jamie. I'm with you all the way on the "Pride" thing.
They have deliberately unsettled our two best players and we must stand tall and be strong. It is they who are panicking, not us.
They cannot be allowed to succeed.

Roberto must also understand this. He'll have his list and, quite naturally, he'll be touting for money. How BK will react is anyones guess. I'm hoping he will tell them to get stuffed and maybe he will.
We'll see.

Eric Myles
354 Posted 20/08/2013 at 06:06:49
Tony #847 "Since when did the world's biggest clubs start paying under the going rate for players? It's always the other way round... Man Utd, like Chelsea and Man City, have had to stump up more for players in the past because of who they are and the riches they have"

Just like what happened with Rooney you mean?

Eric Myles
355 Posted 20/08/2013 at 06:18:52
John #132

2). Any new issue of shares will, by default, dilute the ownership of the current major shareholders.

Not by default John, only if the current makor shareholders do not exercise their right to purchase additional shares in the rights issue to maintain their controlling interest.

Eric Myles
356 Posted 20/08/2013 at 06:38:20
Christian #117 "Back to the 'bids'. He's playing a flanker by letting the £24mil clause window expire and come in lower'

I don't know why you're so surprised. Do you think all the EPL managers were waiting for Fellaini's clause to expire so they could bid MORE for him?

Paul Andrews
357 Posted 20/08/2013 at 06:48:59
To be fair Eric.220
Quite a few on here thought that was how it would happen
Jim Harrison
358 Posted 20/08/2013 at 06:46:22
Sorry guys, but odds are Moyes identifies the targets, discusses the top fee that he believes the players are worth then leaves the negotiation down to the business people who actually bid and haggle and has minimal involvement until a price is agreed between the two clubs. In this instance I thing Woodward has underestimated Everton and started too low. He might just have cocked the whole thing up as BK has good reason to be obtuse now.

This is no defence of Moyes, or the bid, which is shocking, just my opinion.

There has been a lot of talk about loyalty on this thread, but in my eyes the only people who are loyal in football these days are the fans (And Tony Hibbert), managers and players are transient and loyal to their own purpose

Kevin Rowlands
359 Posted 20/08/2013 at 07:24:26
I believe both will be gone before the transfer window unfortunately, TBH I accepted a long time ago that we are stuck with Kenwright till his toes curl so this is what will inevitably happen each and every season, ask yourself why would this transfer window be any different to the previous ones? we will be going through the same shite in the next few seasons with Barkley the next big cash cow up for grabs to the highest bidder, believe me it pains me to say it, as for the ginger twat as soon as things go tits up over there them daft Mancs are going to be all over him, Imho Chelsea and MC are better teams and have spent very well this summer, infact I'd argue that Swansea were the better team against them at the weekend, he's gonna have a long hard season ahead without a luvvie Chairman stroking his ego!
Christian Watson
361 Posted 20/08/2013 at 07:24:10
No Eric that's not what I was suggesting. I was alluding to the fact that, when the clause date expired, EFC should rebuff all future bids with a 'He's not for sale' response. Moyes is a chancer; in his own words, not too long ago, ''Everton do not sell cheap, we don't need to sell our best players!"

However, yet again, we as Evertonians are probably being mis-informed and lied to again and one or both will be playing in the devil's colours by September. Everton have a history of having their pants pulled down and this is no different.

If it was anyone other than EFC, we would have taken FA action on Manure for 'unsettling' or tapping up our then manager (as it appears the deal was done at New Year). And this 'theatre drama' is probably part of the deal and we're naive if we think otherwise.

Steve Cotton
362 Posted 20/08/2013 at 07:48:58
http://thebusbyway.com/2013/08/19/picture-evertons-written-response-to-uniteds-28m-bid/?

anyone else think that Jon Woods would have at least been able to spell 'letter' not 'leter'

fake and a poor one at that....

Carl Sanderson
363 Posted 20/08/2013 at 07:47:41
Kevin 225,

I think Fellaini will definitely go.

His contract contained a release clause that expired early so that Everton wouldn't be in the same situation as they were with Arteta and Rooney, ie scratching about for replacements at the last second before the window closed.

On the face of it that's a good thing, but the unintended consequence is that United are now taking the piss because they know there's time for all the usual to-ing and fro-ing.

United have offered low because there have been no bids. Everton have gone public with a view (I hope) to initiating an auction.

Incidentally I find it surprising that Arsenal have not gone for him.

Carl Sanderson
364 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:14:38
Steve 228:

It is a fake. Either that or it is illegal (contains no registered address or company number)

Colin Wainwright
365 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:15:10
Peter @ 207. Do you work for UKIP, or do you just bevvy with Nigel Farage?

Would love both players to publicly state they are not and wont be, seeking a transfer. Not gonna happen though.

Kevin Rowlands
366 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:18:26
I agree about Fellaini Carl, he's gone, Baines I have a glimmer of hope, the one thing that I don't think I've seen mentioned on here is that Moyes obviously knows the two of them personally and no doubt has their phone numbers, It would be naïve to think he hasn't actually spoke to both of them personally, this is going to happen I'm afraid.
Oliver Molloy
367 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:32:56
I agree with those who have said that kenwright did not have to release a statement about the bids for our players.
The statement should have said that the players were not for sale if that was the case - clearly it is saying we want more money!

Just for once kenwright needs to grow some balls and tell it like it is....
Yes Fellainni is for sale but only at £££££.....? or forget it
No Baines is not for sale so forget that
This looks very much like another episode were Everton will end up a laughing stock!

Barry Stevens
368 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:33:17
How people still defend Moyes to the hilt amazes me. All his moral high ground talk was shallow. His actions do not back up his words.
Kevin Rowlands
369 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:33:33
I'm afraid another ominous sign re. Baines is that MU are reportedly very close to sending the reserve LB Buttner out on a year long loan, brace yourself, this all points to us loosing Baines, although I personally think Bryan Oviedo will be a very capable replacement so its not all gloom and doom.
Karl Masters
370 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:15:26
Having thought about this some more, I'm coming round to the reason that Everton went public is either to

1/ Drive the prices up.

or

2/ They are angry at Moyes and Utd breaking the agreement not to come back for players and want the whole world to know what low lifes they are.

It could even be both, but I have to agree with Bobby Thomas that it could well be 1/. So, players leave, BK gets the money he wants and everybody says at least he tried to stop it happening.

The key part for me is that nowhere does that announcement say that they are not for sale, just the price is too low.

Peter Bourke
371 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:51:08
@ Karl 239.
Everyone and everything IS for sale my friend.
It's just a matter of how much.
Carl Sanderson
372 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:50:15
Karl,

Your first explanation is by far the most likely one, in my opinion. They may well be trying to, er, flush out the Arse, so to speak.

With regard to your second point: Kenwright would be naive to think that United would not approach our players. We would be even more naive to believe that any such agreement exists.

Duncan McDine
373 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:55:53
BK and RM have both given indications in interviews (in my opiion) that they were inviting clubs to come in with the release clause fee... that never happened, so will be interesting to see what happens. I think he'll go late in the window, and we may or may not get some kind of replacement for him.

On a seperate note, I'm still amased that Heitinga isn't making noises about moving on. It seems he is pretty much obsolete to the new manager. Could really benefit with him off the wage bill, and surely he needs to get regular footy if he wants a sniff at WC 2014.

Drew Shortis
375 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:56:22
If we are not desperate for the money to pay off loans (due to the TV money that came in covering that) and we are determined to keep them both why shouldn't we refuse to sell. They are both under contract and what is the worst that can happen? Fellaini has a sulk. Its a World Cup year and both of them will want to continue their good form to guarantee a starting place for their country. If they are denied a move they will get over it. I can't see a Tevez situation with Felli buggering off back to Belgium for an unauthorized holiday.

We need to make a stand as a statement of our intentions. If we aspire to challenge for a Champions League spot we cannot sell our best players at the last minute without time to find suitable replacements. If we allow this to happen now then it won't be long before the likes of Coleman, Mirallas and Barkley are following them out of the door!

I'm not saying that we should never sell, but if we do it should be at a time that allows us to reinvest the money sensibly and at a price that reflects the players market value. To give in at this point would confirm the reputation we have developed as a selling club. Time to make a stand!

Mark Taylor
377 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:58:56
Paul 182,

I also don't mind if Fella goes if we can get a decent price for him. As I said in an earlier post, we have actually been quite good in the past using star player transfer money to build a better squad. Also I think Fellaini won't be happy until he has CL football.

Given all on here knew about Fellaini's position, one would hope that we are well advanced in identifying the playe (s) we would bring in to replace him and even perhaps having ourselves had some initial negotiation.

However that pre supposes Kenwright intends to re-invest all the proceeds and there, I have some serious doubts.

Kevin Rowlands
378 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:02:31
For what its worth, I asked RM at the meet and greet in Miami was James McCarthy coming on board, he told me right to my face that they believed he was an Everton style player(his words) and they were actively pursuing him but it was going to cost a lot of money, at the time Fellaini was sitting next to him and I asked was he staying, RM's reply was we hope so, anyone want to fill their boots, get all over McCarthy joining Everton at evens, financed imho by the sale of MF and possibly LB.
Sam Hoare
379 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:09:15
Drew, I wouldn't worry too much about finding suitable replacements. I'm sure Martinez, since the moment he arrived, has had a list of replacements drawn up and I would not be surprised if alot of those players' agents had already been contacted to say that a move will come pending on the Baines/fellaini sale. McCarthy i'm sure is one such player.

Andrew Laird
380 Posted 20/08/2013 at 08:53:40
Mr "greater things" has lost out on his top transfer targets in an amusing public charade and has now moved on to Plan B, another facet he never showed at Everton.

How anybody, regardless of who they support, can defend this megalomaniac is beyond me. To even suggest, as some have, that he would have NO input into the fees is naivity bordering on sycophantic adulation for a guy that won nothing for this club.

Time to take this self - serving, hypocrite's posters off the wall lads....

Mark Taylor
381 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:10:54
Si 189

In a nutshell, no I don't think that generally people in football do have personal principles, or not to the standard you are suggesting.

The other critical point here is that, for the most part, for all the huffing and puffing by clubs, it is the player who holds the power. If they want to go, you can pretty much forget what the contract says. There can be a face off- and I think both the Rooney and Suarez cases are interesting in this regard- but my opinion is that if the player doesn't end up moving, it's because they weren't absolutely set on the move in the first place.

So if Fellaini wants to go, and I presume Moyes will know that position intimately, then there's not much we can do other than hold out for as much as possible. We certainly can't afford to pass up the chance to get tens of millions and make the guy play in the reserves.

James Martin
382 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:04:23
Players leave every club. Even Man U had to sell Ronaldo. Real Madrid may even have to sell him back at some point. Arsenal have sold Fabregas, Van Persie, Song, Nasri. Liverpool Torres, Alonso, Meireles, Arbeloa, Mascherano. Spurs have sold anyone decent that they've ever had and will probably do so again with Bale. This happens to every single club in world footbal apart from a handful.

We make out as though its a massive shock every time someone comes in for our players or that the board cashes in on them. (This is in no way a defense of the board btw). People bleat on with 'big clubs don't sell their best players' of course they do, all the time, every single window. They know when to sell them and then they reinvest their funds properly and move on. We did that once with Rooney and were the better for it. I believe that Moyes then messed up the proceeds from the Lescott sale and since then we've had a paranoia about selling any players whatsoever.

Its not a sign of a lack of ambition if the club doesn't put out the 'he's not for sale' sign every time anyone ever makes an enquiry. Its just not true. Fellaini is for sale because he quite possibly wants a move. So we take the funds and move on a player who gave us service but now wants to play elsewhere. What's wrong with this? It's not a lack of ambition, its not being a 'selling club', we don't always sell (we have resisted overtures for Jagielka Baines and Fellaini for a while now), its not a small club mentality, its just a natural part of football that for some reason our fan base has an unnatural fear of. Its like a revolving door at some 'big' clubs with top players in and out every season yet we keep hold of ours longer than a lot of others but still moan at the club at the possibility that they might have to sell these players (even though they haven't yet).

Andrew Laird
383 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:16:29
naivety!!!
Drew Shortis
384 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:11:05
If an offer of around £40m comes in, which reflects their true market value, and they both want out then we could consider it. Reinvesting the money in Siqueira (£7m+), McCarthy (£12-15m), Diame (if release clause of £3.5m exists), Barry (Loan), Sinclair & Moses (both on loan with an agreed fees of say £6m and £8m). We could come out of this with a stronger squad. Of course I use these players as examples only. I'm sure Martinez has identified his own targets which we may be unaware of.

Would we have enough time to get in six players? It would be pushing it now and I would rather see us wait until January now before doing anything. By then we may be in a position where CL football looks like a possibility and both players may be willing to stay. If we are mid table and a sensible offer is on the table we would have time to get the negotiations done so the money comes in at the start of the window and Martinez has time to get the deals completed.

Conn Prosser
385 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:29:14
.. Taking a Moyes to a gunfight..
Conn Prosser
386 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:29:14
.. Taking a Moyes to a gunfight..
Drew Shortis
387 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:34:46
James Martin 253
I agree with a lot of what you posted. And as my previous post said, it needn't be doomsday if they do go. It is clearly the timing of the bids and the insultingly low valuations that have caused such offence to Everton. Ronaldo left Man Utd for £80m. Real Madrid didn't come in with a a bid of £30m and Drenthe in part exchange! Man Utd didn't want him to leave so they made them an offer they could not refuse.

If Man Utd had come in with a bid of £40m we might have considered it. Trying to mug us off with £28 when they know full well our valuation of Fellaini (the £23m clause) and had already flatly rejected £12m for Baines IS an insult and clearly designed to unsettle our players. That is why people are up in arms.

Iain Johnston
388 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:36:56
Drew, I think £35m and they'll leave. The fullback is a good call. Is he the one Keith Curle bangs on about on Sky? I would also welcome McCarthy, If we bid a serious £10m I think Wigan would except. Why not buy Sinclair outright?. Valued at £6-£8m is decent. Unsure on Moses, maybe a cheeky £7.5m bid for Defoe?. He's proven, quick and would probably be 1st choice here and we'd get three years out of him.
If we take into account it's World Cup build up year, would Baines want to move from a club where he is Guaranteed 1st team football?. Playing for us hasn't hampered his squad selection so that old chestnut can't be used as an excuse.
Brian Harrison
389 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:43:26
SSN are reporting that Man Utd will be back with a final offer of £33 million for both. So will be interesting to see how our board react I mean if the original bid was derisory surely this still isn't the market price for both.
Zack Yusof
390 Posted 20/08/2013 at 09:09:59
And the saga rumbles on... two seperate bids soon to be incoming.

http://www.theguardian.com/football/2013/aug/19/everton-marouane-fellaini-manchester-united

Like Richard Dodd and many others on here, I stood up and supported OFM throughout his tenure with us - against my better judgement a lot of the time - out of loyalty to our great club but the way he's gone about this farce (Let's not kid ourselves here. I'd bet my mortgage that OFM has been thoroughly consulted all the way through the process) simply reeks of total disrespect for the club that gave him his first chance in top tier football management. The ridiculously low bid and more importantly, the fucked up timing of it is indefensible in my book.

Had he come in at the start of July with a realistic offer, he probably could have sewn up deals for both. But now and on a matter of sheer principle... no fucking way!

Kevin Tully
391 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:09:18
It's funny that every ex-pro who has commented on this offer hasn't mentioned Woodward.

On T.V. radio, and in print, they are all saying MOYES has made this offer.

Glad I can come on here though to get the truth, some very knowledgeable transfer guru's on here alright!

James Martin
392 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:17:14
I agree with you Drew the timing of the bids and the value of them are insulting. I can see why people would be hacked off about that, I just don't understand this reaction of whenever any bid comes in for anyone the immediate reaction must be 'he's not for sale' ad anything else is the mentality of a small-time selling club. Hardly any clubs say a player is not for sale and those that do are usually lying and regret their words at a later point. Every single player at every single club has a price. When that price is met sometimes selling and reinvesting is not a bad thing. I would certainly not class us as a selling club at all considering that the only notable sales upwards over the whole Moyes period were Rooney, Lescott, Arteta and Rodwell. In comparison to some of the names I listed in my previous post for so called 'top' clubs this is not that bad. Some of them have sold far more in a far shorter space of time. (Obviously they show ambition by not just reinvesting but investing which sadly our board does not but their inability to keep hold of top players is just as great if not greater than ours)
Brian Griffin
393 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:18:24
Someone - well, ManUre/Moyes, actually - is taking the piss here. How can Baines and Fellaini combined be worth significantly less than Fabregas? If we're going to sell them - I'm hoping we don't, though I suspect that Fellaini and his dad might start making more of their noises about going - we should make ManUre pay so much that it hurts. If Baines and Fellaini go, the heart will be ripped out of the team - we'll need some serious cash to replace them with players of a similar calibre. The absolute minimum should be the highest amount that they were willing to spend on Fabregas.
Colin Glassar
394 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:38:15
I think we have to look at this coldly now. Felli is off for anything over £20m so billy boy can turn around and say, "look, we've made a profit on him and he wanted to leave so what's the problem?". He might dig in his heels a bit more with bainsey but if they offer anything close to £15m they'll accept that as well. It's the way he works and it will be £20m for Martinez and £15m for the bank.
Carl Peters
395 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:35:26
What I would like to know is where has the £60M gone that we got from Sky, that we have to sell Felli or Baines to buy McCarthy? Everton have spent around £6M since May.

So where’s the money going — and it’s a question that needs answering quick because, with PL teams spending money all around us, if we lose these two, we’re in deep shit because they are irreplaceable.

Simon Smith
396 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:45:53
If we have to sell one or both of them, then so be it so long as Everton screw Man ure for every penny they got!
Stand firm and don’t cave in just because they are a big club, and if we do sell then I hope we have time to get someone in to replace whoever goes
Drew Shortis
397 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:46:37
I don't agree Colin. I know people have been frustrated that more of the TV money has not been for incoming transfers, but I think a lot of that extra cash has gone to service the debts meaning that we DON'T have to sell to balance the books. This is just my opinion, I could be living in a dream world, but we did get the money like every other team and looking at our finances (£9m loss last year) it would make sense to me that the extra TV money has filled that gap. IF my theory is correct then we can hold out for a much bigger fee or even hold onto them without the banks being on our backs.

I'm not saying I totally trust Kenwright when it comes to the running of Everton, but in the case of Rooney, Lescott and Arteta we had to sell. Partly because they wanted the move and partly because we owed money and there must have been pressure from our creditors to sell. I do believe Kenwright loves the club and if we are in a healthier financial situation due to the TV money I'm sure he will do what is best for the club.

Colin Glassar
398 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:55:47
I think this is now the real debate Simon. We know who runs our club and how he operates. I don't want either of them to leave but these are my scenarios.

My valuation: £50m for both of them.

Realistic valuation: £40m for both of them.

BK's valuation: Anything over £35m

Sad but true.

David Ellis
399 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:39:22
On the basis of logic I am with Dan and Nick - OFM just doing his job.

But - on an emotional level this is unacceptable. I would do no further business with Utd. Sell Fellaini to Chelsea if they come in with a good bid but OFM is now "persona non gratis"

Duncan McDine
400 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:53:35
Exactly Colin. The timing doesn't help us though, but I agree this is the most probable outcome.

Going back to a previous comment (can't remember who posted it), about why Everton don't buy and sell more, you have to consider that buying and selling players is not as simple as:
Sell Felli for £20m. Spend £10m on a replacement, £5m on a young prospect, and £5m to the bank.

With agent fees along with godknows whoever else taking little cuts, sell on clauses, performance related stuff, split payments etc etc, we probably end up with about 90% of the actual selling fee, and pay an extra 10% when buying. Just like the 6 or 7 grand I'll never see again when we moved house, you don't want to do it too often!!!

Brian Harrison
401 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:55:44
James 267

Yes every player has his price as you rightly say and yes Man Utd sold Ronaldo to Real Madrid, but they got a world record price and Ronaldo had said he wanted to go to Real. As you say we have not sold a lot of players in the last 10 years,I think the difference this time is we are talking about 2 players with very little time left to replace them. I heard Gary Neville the other night saying Man Utd would be mad to sell Rooney but thought if Man Utd up their offer by a few million then Everton should sell 2 of their best players. My main worry is that we all saw what impact it had on the team when the Lescott saga was going on, can you imagine what it will do to team morale and fans if we lose 2 players with our first home game only days away. I don't know about a march for Martinez I could envisage a different type of march if both these players are sold.

Raymond Fox
402 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:04:28
Colin, I think your valuations are correct, it all depends if the players are keen to go to utd.
If they do, its not sensible to keep them here, we should tell utd and the players if utd come up with what our valuation is, they can go, if they don't they cannot leave.

I too think we should say, give us £20m for each, or £38m the pair, not a penny less.

Al Reddish
403 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:17:45
Taking out the Moyes part from the equation, would you accept £35m? Individually £15m for Baines and £20m for Fellaini? Personally I think we should be aiming for £38-£40m upfront with a deadline of Friday to allow us to do our business.
Colin Glassar
404 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:12:31
There's a relatively easy solution to all of this, EFC make a statement that either both or one of the players (Baines) is/are not for sale at any price, like the rs (biter), Manu (Rooney), spurs (bale) have done.
I think Martinez desperately wants McCarthy and is willing to sell Felli to get him, the only problem is how much we get for Fellaini and if Wigan will try and screw us over macca knowing we've got the money.
Chris Ashton
405 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:03:57
i have said it before but we could sell both player sand be worse off. Martinez would not get the whole amount of money and we would lose 4 players at least.

HOWEVER here is a thought to mull. We sell Fellaini, take as much as we can get, roughly round 22-23 million I would have thought. We sign the following players with the money, with the rest going on wages. I ask you, would this make us better?

MCcathy- 8 Mill plus add ons. No brainer, he will be coming in as a replacement. Ball playing midfielder, can start play off, pick a pass, tackle and known to the manager. Pay as little as possible with add ons sell on clause etc to sweeten the deal.

Diame-3.5 Mill. Diame would replace the strength in the middle of the park. Tough in the tackle, no nonsense and could do a job for us, especially when paired with Mcarthy and Barkley in the centre.

Kalou- 2.5 mill. An extremely fast player, can score the odd goal, can play both out wide and through the middle and is available for hardly anyhting. Again would do a job, increase our attack options and the possible 6-10 goals in him could win a few games.

Sessegnon- 6 Mill. Controversial choice I am guessing but he would bring power to the attacking midfield role to replace what we have lost. May not be world class but I think would perform a lot better than Osman in that role and a Foil again for Barkley. He seems to be available according to the media and like the others could do a job.

Those 4 players above would replace Fellaini, Ball playing, Strength/Tackle, Strength in Attack all part of the squad. It would also add 2 additional central midfielders to what we have now, and we would still get to keep Baines.

Liam Reilly
406 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:19:33
If Fellaini doesn't put in a transfer request, as I understand it, Everton have to buy out his contract. that would be funded as part of the incoming transfer fee, ergo add that to the initial fee paid and we could end up losing money for him at the offer price.

Fucking farcical.Great article by the Mail though. Hypocrite of the highest order.

There's a lot of folk on here ready to vent their anger at him when he returns to Goodison, I have my doubts he'll last that long at United before Whiskey Nose is parachuted back in to save the day.

Carl Peters
407 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:24:28
So we’ll need 4 players to replace one... sounds like good logic.
Colin Glassar
408 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:21:43
Al, I think it would be very hard for billy to sell Bainsey because of the emotional tie the lad has at GP, but I also believe the he values him around the £15-18m mark and would seriously consider selling him at that price.
As for Fellaini, well he's never made a secret of his desire to play in the CL, although he sweetens that with statements like, "I hope it is with Everton". I'm sure the lad is happy with us but he has no emotional ties to the club and would probably jump at the chance to play for the mancs or gunners. In his case we need to play hardball and get the best price possible. Like I've said before, my minimum price would be £25m and not a penny less. Remember, £5m of that would go to standard liege so we are hardly making any profit out of him.
Brian Harrison
409 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:24:10
I think it is worth remembering that Everton have to give Standard Liege 20% of Fellainis value so if we sell him for £20 million then Liege get £4 million. Plus if you add in agents fees and loyalty bonuses we will actually be selling him for less than we paid for him. The Manchester evening news are reporting that Arsenal are also interested in buying Fellaini if true that might change the picture somewhat. Mind would that make Utd forget about Fellaini and up the offer for Baines oh to be a football fan during the transfer window.
Jamie Barlow
410 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:27:47
The way I see it. Everton wanted a release clause for Fellaini set at £30 million. Fellaini wouldn't sign a new contract unless the release clause was set at £23.5 million. Unless the clause is met we shouldn't sell whether he puts in a transfer request or not.
Eugene Ruane
411 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:48:59
These two players (nb: a full back and a defensive midfielder) scored almost ONE THIRD of our PL goals BETWEEN THEM.

To sell them (either of them) means there is a very good chance our goals tally will be reduced, which could mean our points/league position suffering, which would mean our prize cash.

So even if they offer £40m, with what we could lose in points/prizes/TV/money, it could in reality be a LOT less than that.

Yesterday (on another thread ) I wrote that I believe there should be some sort of reverse add-ons.

"My suggestion is that whatever fee our good/best players are sold for, we should insist on financial add-ons based not on what THEY achieve with our (former) players, but compensation for what we might NOT achieve. We finished 6th last season WITH these players, so - for what would have been the remainder of their contract/s with us - for each place we finish below 6th, they should give us a million (eg: we finish 12th, they give us £6m, if we finish 6th or above, we get nothing). And they should also pay for any TV games revenue lost (we get a guaranteed 10 but were on 14 times last season - anything under 14, they should pay).

I hope and pray the two of them go nowhere, but if we're considering selling them, we should be smart and do so with EVERY financial arse-covering add-on we can think of.

There's a good chance that (for example) £35m, within one season could turn out actually to be £28m/£29m, because if we throw away 19 goals (Baines, Fellaini - all comps) we might also be saying goodbye to a shit-load of prize money.

Colin Glassar
412 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:33:30
Looking at it like that then, unless we sell Fellaini for something like £30m plus then we risk losing money on the big haired git. What with agents fees, paying off his contract, sell on money to former club etc...it's probably not worth selling him just now.
Zack Yusof
413 Posted 20/08/2013 at 10:57:32
If the incoming tv money means that we don't have to sell then we shouldn't. The top teams keep their best players and we should be no different.
Al Reddish
414 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:39:27
It's a shame we can't keep them both and splash the cash to prove to them we are serious in our ambitions to break into the top 4.
Al Reddish
415 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:39:27
It's a shame we can't keep them both and splash the cash to prove to them we are serious in our ambitions to break into the top 4.
Colin Glassar
416 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:43:58
Just seen both lads training at finchy and they both looked totally relaxed. Just produce a statement Everton saying they're not for sale and lets put this to bed once and for all.
Kev Johnson
417 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:38:07
Eugene - come on, it doesn't work like that. If we have certain players then we set up to play in a certain way which utilises their strengths. If we have a different line up then the emphasis changes and different players come to the fore and are more likely to score.

Playing behind the striker, Fellaini scores goals but makes us play more long balls, especially in the air. Check out the most recent Executioners Bong blog...

http://theexecutionersbong.wordpress.com/

As he says, Felliani plays with his back to Jelavic whereas RB is facing him. Likely result? Jelavic scores more when RB plays Attacking Central Midfield and RB nets a few himself. The best example was Cahill - he scored around 8 a season but effectively stopped others from scoring because we set up to utilise his strengths, thereby reducing the scoring possibilities of others.

What you gain on the swings you lose on the roundabouts.

Patrick Murphy
418 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:47:09
If both players go on to play and do well in next year's World Cup then their values will increase, which is another reason we should fight to keep them.
Zack Yusof
419 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:36:53
My thoughts exactly Patrick. One game into the season is not the time to go selling off our best players. I mean, what a message to send out to all concerned with our club.
Bobby Thomas
420 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:57:16
Kev Johnson

Spot on about the Fellaini/Jela situation last season.

There was nothing between them, no combination play or understanding. Fellaini, whilst unorthodox and effective in the 10 role, can never play for a top top side in that role as he doesnt play facing the opposition goal with his head up. It was all back to goal and get it wide.

As the season wore on we became increasingly functional and predictable when we played that way. The ease with which United nullified it after having one look at it was very telling.

It served its purpose last season. But that, the way Jelavic was asked to perform the lone striker role and the lack of depth were all contributory factors in Jelavic struggles last season.

Alan Smith
421 Posted 20/08/2013 at 11:51:14
Kev Jelavic is pooh. Whilst playing Barkley ACM would help him more than playing Fellaini there, so would having Fellaini DM rather than Osman/Gibson. As the team in general would perform better.

We need to keep both players and play each player in their natural positions, I don't think anyone wants to see Fellaini behind the striker. I actually think Barkley would score more as a normal CM as well. Coming from deeper he'd be harder to pick up and arrive on the edge of box with more time to pick his spot. Eventually him and Fellani could dominate every midfield in the prem. and I said that last season. Not only are they more skill full than most of our players their stronger and win more tackles.

We gain nothing if Fellaini goes, there are swings but no roundabouts. We will end up paying over the odds for McCarthy who's not as good. Then after dropping a couple of league places we end up no better off financilly

Eugene Ruane
422 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:02:30
Kevin (301) - "Eugene - come on, it doesn't work like that. If we have certain players then we set up to play in a certain way which utilises their strengths. If we have a different line up then the emphasis changes and different players come to the fore and are more likely to score"

I agree, it doesn't work like that - my resorting to the goals scored by the two IS a little simplistic and 'clumpy'.

However the players (whatever the formations) DID get the goals they did and I believe (if they're sold) we should be looking to be smart and (financially at least) cover our arse, should their replacements (or alternative formations that include their replacements) not prove as successful.

My main point is that we're smart BEFORE the event, rather than sell them and in a year's time, look back and say "Actually, with us finishing 15th, the £38 mill we got for them two only works out at £29m if you think...."

Etc.

Alan Smith
423 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:31:46
And signings like that keep utd in the top 4. So Fellaini and Bains are worth £60m absolute min. £30m and £20m transfer value and at least £10m compensation!
Alan Smith
424 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:31:46
And signings like that keep utd in the top 4. So Fellaini and Bains are worth £60m absolute min. £30m and £20m transfer value and at least £10m compensation!
Nick Entwistle
425 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:36:59
I'd keep Fellaini over Baines, though it is a tough call.

He's a catalyst in the middle, a presence, a cut above anyone that would come to Goodison, a beast, and with Gibson in the side (cough) we're getting his best.

He is our stand-out player.

Kevin Tully
426 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:38:04
I hope this doesn't happen for two reasons. Firstly, I believe we will not be able to find any replacements who will slot straight in to our first team, it takes time for players to settle into a new club.

Secondly, Moyes has failed or dithered with every player he has targeted this window, if this doesn't come off, him & his team will look like utter fools.

Wonderful result.

Robbie Muldoon
427 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:39:13
Keep Fellaini until after the World Cup... if he plays well there, we can sell for a much higher fee and we have no disruption on this our new managers debut season. Moyes is taking the absolute piss out of us, to think he was cheered off to United makes me cringe.
Kev Johnson
428 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:46:48
Robbie - it's true, Fellaini might have a fantastic World Cup, causing his value to soar. But then again, his flailing elbows might get sent off in the first game, thereby reducing his value! Who knows which way it will go?

Alan (313) - that is purely hypothetical. Buying players is always a risk. No one is guaranteed to do the business. Man Utd could grab both players and do really badly. (I can see them finishing third and winning nothing, with or without MF and/or LB.). Actually, I think the opposite is true. They are worth more than us than they are to the Devil Reds, especially Bainesy who is utterly irreplaceable.

Colin Glassar
429 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:52:45
Like I said on the other thread, Martinez and/or BK should either come out and say they are not for sale or give a ridiculous valuation and see if whinger and ginger are serious or not.
Drew Shortis
430 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:36:49
Patrick Murphy 302
Good point. If Belgium have a good World Cup, as many are predicting, then Fellaini's draw will only increase. He is young enough (25) to stay for one more season. Its not as if he is knocking on 30 and is desperate for his final big money move and Champions League football. If he hold out now he might feel a little agrieved, but he will get over it and next summer we can have a proper bidding war for him early on and get some sensible cash plus the time to bring in the right replacements. We don't have to be bullied into anything. Once that window shuts he will have no choice but to crack on!

Baines' story is slightly different. He is heading into the last four or five years of his career and he might see this as the last opportunity to move to a Champions League team. I have said before that we are in an unusual position at Everton where our left-back is our best (IE most creative) player. I think we could find another attacking fullback for a reasonable fee and reinvest the bulk of the fee on a creative player in midfield or attack to compensate.

I sincerely hope that we manage to hold on to both players. This is important from a footballing perspective, but also as a statement of intent by the club. If we cave in now we only encourage the richer teams to use us as their academy. If one or both do force the issue and leave my biggest concern is if we can get in the right replacements in time. For that reason I think we should not sell right now.

Harold Matthews
431 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:26:42
Yes, Eugene/Kev. Even without the goals, their worth to us far exceeds any normal transfer fee.

"Real Madrid can go and get stuffed", stated ardent Spurs fan Danny Kelly on Talk Sport. "To me, he is worth £300 ml."

Eric Myles
432 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:44:33
Drew #235 "If we are not desperate for the money to pay off loans (due to the TV money that came in covering that) and we are determined to keep them both why shouldn't we refuse to sell." And #275.

I had honetly thought the same thing, that the extra £20m from the telly would cover our annual losses of the same amount so we wouldn't have to sell anyone.

But with the lack of a 'not for sale' notice going up and soundbites seemingly encouraging higher bids I can only think that last years accounts have been much worse than usual and we need money to pay off additional debt. OR Martinez, knowing that he has to sell to buy wants to offload so he can get in new players.

Or maybe a mixture of both, half on players and half to the banks.

Alan Smith
433 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:13:27
Kev

You say Baines is utterly irreplaceable but there are LB out there as good. Marcelo, alba etc obviously out if our price range, but they do come along. However, Fellaini is totally unique as a footballer. I've never seen a player that big and strong with as good a touch and ball control, who can also play up front. Yaya toure is the closest and we won't be signing him. We could find a player capable of charging down the wing and smashing crosses over though. Oviedo, or Luke shaw, theyre easier to find top CMsSince spurs away last season Coleman has performed better than Baines.

However I agree there worth more to us and I would not sell either of them. As I said before there worth £60m to us...but Rooney was worth £100m and we let him go for buttons!

Colin Glassar
434 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:27:57
The flip side to that Alan is we get a good, young replacement for Baines and after one good season another top 4 club come in for him and he's off. As a club we need to decide where we are going. As a feasible top 4 challenger or a feeder club for said top 4?
Jackie Barry
435 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:34:18
This is why we need to attach a price of 60+ million on Barkley and 40+ million on Stones. We need to show that we will not be bullied into selling our best players.
Colin Glassar
436 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:38:49
£40m on Stones jackie? I rate the lad but surely that's a typo or you being very optimistic.
James Lauwervine
437 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:37:54
Just to say that if that letter's genuine I'll eat my frigging trousers.
Drew Shortis
438 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:35:52
Eric Myles 337
I have not picked up any sense of desperation to sell on our part from the statements the club has made. I thought their "insulting and derisory" statement was a pretty strong message that we were NOT interested in selling. It certainly isn't the sort of language I would use if I wanted to initiate negotiations. Yes, if a low bid came in you would knock it back, but the language would be along the lines of "we value the two much higher". Perhaps this time we can take what is coming out of the club at face value. Perhaps.
Eric Myles
439 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:45:13
Drew, we may not be desperate to sell but all the soundbites point to the Club saying they're available at a price, just not the price quoted.
Jackie Barry
440 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:42:06
Colin, but that is what it is based on, optimism. He is one for the future and we need to show that, do you think this will be the last time Man U will come knocking to steal our better players? not likely. This is why we need to cut the ties we have with them, it's like we feel we owe them something and this is Moyes fault. He signed Neville, Howard, Saha and Gibson from them, basically their cast offs, and we gave them Rooney who has created far more money than he cost. We may as well have become their B-team due to the love affair we have had with them.
Carl Peters
441 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:46:57
This could get interesting as Arsenal have been rumoured to of entered the race for Fellaini.
Tony Draper
442 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:39:54
I posted here on another thread a few weeks back that Moyes IS a Judas; I was reprimanded

My logic was as follows:

1) His contract did not suddenly expire – he allowed it to run down;

2) As I recall, BK had been publicly saying that new improved terms had been offered for at least 18 months prior to it's expiry;

3) Moyes's reason(s) for not snatching BK's hand off changed... initially it was something to do with focussing upon the remaining games and league position (this being said in early new year);

4) Moyes is and was at the time a personal acquaintance of SAF and in regular informal contact with him, this was common knowledge even at that time;

5) The 18-month figure is not inconsequential, for around the same time SAF first became aware of health problems (heart I seem to recall), SAF made the decision that, should certain conditions worsen, then he would understandably retire to take care of his health;

6) That season, the outcome of the Premier League was decided in favour of Man City by a late late late winner, otherwise the trophy would have landed at OT. Most likely triggering SAF's retirement in victory;

7) SAF announced his retirement "suddenly" as soon as the League title was won;

8) Man Utd announced David Moyes as incoming manager within just 4 days of making their "initial approach", a remarkably short time for contract negotiations under such "surprise circumstances";

9) David Moyes had a "gentleman's agreement" NOT to return to Everton for signings;

10) Bill Kenwright has disclosed that, during Moyes's interview for the Everton manager's post, that it was his ambition to one day "rise" to manage Man Utd;

I did NOT applaud or cheer him at the West Ham match. My reception for him upon his return will be much more vociferous. He was extremely well paid. He won nothing with Everton – and he won it every year for 11 years

I said before and will repeat again: David Moyes is a fucking Judas!

Kev Johnson
443 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:49:28
I don't know what people honestly expect. We have rejected a bid, gone to the unusual lengths of putting out a strongly worded official statement, and the manager has backed that up. That's as much as we can reasonably do.

If we receive an offer we can't refuse then, guess what, we won't refuse it. Unless that happens, we are not selling.

Colin Glassar
444 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:53:17
I agree jackie about the risk of becoming their feeder club. Moyes has broken every rule in the book (of decency) IMO e.g. Negotiating with fergie and man u behind our back, effectively becoming man u manager while we were still paying his wages and now, making insulting offers for our two best players. We should tell him to do one and we won't have any more to do with him from now on.
Dan Parker
445 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:00:47
I agree Colin, I hope he gets a frosty reception at Goodison.
Jackie Barry
446 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:58:38
We have also created possibly Evertons worst nightmare in Moyes, he has the potential to come shopping at our club for many years ruining any chance we have of building any success. This is one of BK's biggest errors, he should have kept their relationship strictly professional and not become all pally, pally with his employee. This is one of the reason why I hope his career is a big fail at Man U.
Jackie Barry
447 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:02:20
He won't though, Dan, there are just too many Moyes lovers in the rafters of Goodison Park, it makes me feel sick when I think what this club was and what it has now become.
Michael Brien
448 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:54:56
Personally I was very pleased with our response to the "joint bid" from Manchester United – it seemed to me a polite way of saying to them "fuck off". I have seen the link to the Daily Mail, where the reporter suggests that DM is something of a hypocrite. Perhaps some may feel that is rather harsh, but would he have accepted such an offer this time last season? We all know that he would have regarded the offer as derisory and he would probably have come out and said so.

Maybe DM has forgotten what he accused Mark Hughes of doing in 2009 with the Lescott transfer. He is now doing exactly the same and the fact that he was one of our longest serving managers makes me even more annoyed. Respect works both ways and personally I think our new manager could teach our old manager a great deal in with regard to integrity.Clearly David Moyes has shown that he is an integrity free zone.

Liam Reilly
450 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:08:08
Eugene,
You are not taking into account what RM would do with the money should he sell these two. Under your model would United not be within their rights to suggest that if we dropped from 6th to 10th or 14th, then that equates to poor investment from the incoming fees.

Alternatively, if we sell them and break into the top four because we stumble across two gems, should we not be paying United?

Tony Fearns
451 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:21:09
You would think we were on the brink of going bust. We have just been given 60 million by sky and we don't need to sell. I just wish that stupid cnut kenwiright would come out and say something.
Mark Tanton
452 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:26:26
Does anyone here think we can get Fellaini go to Man Utd and keep Baines? Someone mentioned it earlier, but I don't think it would be reasonable of Everton to do that, should Baines want to join them. I also think it's both or none for Utd. Who know's how it will end, but it's not finished yet I don't think.
James Marshall
453 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:40:35
Whichever way we spin it, and regardless what any one of us would actually like to happen, it seems now that the club have made their stance very clear. Neither player is for sale.

Well we've all heard that one before.

I (and others) pointed out weeks ago that as soon as Fellaini's clause expired, we would invite (not literally) offers LOWER than the clause quoted around £23m. Surprise surprise (Cilla 'ere!) it has now come to pass.

I would suggest that at this point, the only way in which we'll do business with Utd, or anyone else for that matter is if either player puts in a written transfer request. If neither of them do that, then there is no reason for us to sell either of them.

If we sold Fellaini, we'd struggle to replace him in time (and this coming from someone who doesn't really rate him anyway) and Baines likewise, so why sell unless the players agitate for a move?

No reason as far as I can tell so to my mind, unless the above happens and we believe the press reports of Everton's stance on this, the matter is pretty much closed.

John Shaw
454 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:52:42
Eric (219)
I'm working from the assumption that nobody on our existing Board is likely to invest more of their own money to purchase additional shares, after all, Billy keeps telling us he simply hasn't got any further funds, Woods seems completely uninterested in investing in the business further than what he has and Earl has disappeared off the face of the Everton earth since Destination Kirkby fell on it's sorry pathetic arse!

So, sadly, I'm pretty comfortable in my assumption!

Christian Watson
455 Posted 20/08/2013 at 15:38:49
Wise words Jackie Barry. I still think Man Utd owe us money for Rooney hence all the dealings with them. I mean Gibson for 1m!!!!!! Seriously, what can you buy for that kind of money these days?

The other valid point is this is the richest year EVER to be in the PL (£60m thankyou BT) + our prize money for finishing 6th so why oh why are we again scratching round the bargain basement (wigan) to put a team together? Yet again we appear to leaking money somewhere but as per there is no explanation for it. A bit of clarity and a touch of truth would go along way indeed.

Sam Higgins
456 Posted 20/08/2013 at 15:56:48
This must be the longest thread on ToffeeWeb ever! I wonder if it will carry on right up to TDD?!
Great comments though. I'm still of the opinion that Moyes is an utter shithouse.
Eugene Ruane
457 Posted 20/08/2013 at 16:23:06
Liam Reilly (379) - "Eugene. You are not taking into account what RM would do with the money should he sell these two. Under your model would United not be within their rights to suggest that if we dropped from 6th to 10th or 14th, then that equates to poor investment from the incoming fees. Alternatively, if we sell them and break into the top four because we stumble across two gems, should we not be paying United?"

My 'model' is not a model for ALL football, it is a suggestion of what Everton should demand from United (and why)

It's this simple - "I have players, someone else wants them, I dictate terms"

My terms aren't consistent?

Tough shit, they're still my terms.

As far as football goes, I'm not interested in fair (particularly regarding United/City/Chelsea as their wealth gives them an unfair advantage over Everton at the start of every single season) my ONLY concern is Everton FC and the best deal for us (if every other club in the world ends up being ripped off in the transfer market, I couldn't care a monkey's toss).

For the 'terms' of a deal to satisfy me, all that has to happen is we get the ABSOLUTE most we can and if the team we're dealing with don't like it, then they should be told 'fine - fuck off then'.

James Marshall
458 Posted 20/08/2013 at 16:52:00
Utd's valuation has nothing to do with ours. I agree with Eugene (shock, horror) on this one. They can offer whatever they like, but it's up to us to decide what a player is worth, nobody else.

We set his clause to £23m (ish) so that's clearly what we value the player at.

That said, this was always going to happen as soon as the clause ended and Moyes damn well knew it as much as the Utd money-men.

Kevin Tully
459 Posted 20/08/2013 at 16:57:29
Even teary bollocks must be sick of being made to look like Utd's poodle.

An egomaniac such as Bill doesn't like to be made to look a fool. (Not 24/7 anyway)

Let's hope his ego is sufficiently bruised by his best pal wanting to work it up him.

Brin Williams
460 Posted 20/08/2013 at 16:53:12
It's about time we stood up to be counted - stand up to the likes of Moyes, Manu and all the others who think that Everton is a small club waiting to have their star players plucked away for a pittance.

If there is any truth in that letter then I am pleased that perhaps we may be at a turning point and beginning to realise that we have things that others want - albeit they want them at their valuation.

I believe that now, in Martinez, we have a manager that will resist the Manu's of this world. I believe that he has the ability and nous to tell his Chairman what he expects and will most probably get his way.

Fellaini will at some stage leave and I happen to think that in the next twelve months so will Baines as we have a ready replacement in Oviedo. Martinez will want to build 'his' team and there will be others to go as well.

I cannot wait to see Martinez's team when he gets it together - it will be different - and it will be successful - have no fear.

James Marshall
461 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:15:36
I have a lot of fear, Brin. I admire people's optimism, but his record isn't great and his teams are historically wide open & sometimes get battered.

We've all seen it. You might be right, only time will tell but I tread very carefully days where Martinez is concerned.

Mohammed Horoub
463 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:16:41
If reports of Bale to Real Madrid are true (93 - 80 cash + Coentrao rated at 13) this makes Man U's offer look even more insulting...
Based on that rate Felli + Baines are worth atleast 50-60. I really hope that is the level being quoted to Moyes so he can know his place.
The way things are heading I think a transfer request will be submitted by atleast Felli although can't see him doing it without Baines.
Like many have said it's the timing that's killing us.
Once again another window where we are hoping it closes ASAP rather than it staying open as long as possible to bring players in.
James Marshall
464 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:42:45
Mohammed - the price for any given player is as high as the buyer/seller wants. That doesn't dictate the market value of any other player, simply because one club (Madrid) is stupid enough to pay such a high price.

That's really not the way it works at all.

Carl Peters
466 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:47:03
What’s happened to the money from sky we’ve 5-6 mil on transfers we were told last year there was money still in the pot should we want it ,but the same old shite year after year were told we have to sell to buy.

make no mistake about it if these two players go we’ll end up in the same boat mc carthy will come in, and the rest of the money will disappear ,and we’ll be told there is still money in the pot for January ,come January we’ll sign no-one unless it’s a loan,of another fer saga.

Get used to it it’s the Everton way and were just the dickheads that support them.

Richard Leddy
467 Posted 20/08/2013 at 18:34:53
The decision to post a statement is interesting. Call me a synic but could this just be a negative integration tactic to disguise problems in our own back yard?Bķ, the fact we've spent like 7 million all transfer window (wheres the new tv money gone?) Etc.
Dan Brierley
468 Posted 19/08/2013 at 22:23:34
Whilst all the honourable chest bashing about how we should stand up to United, because decades ago we were better than them is great to read, the reality of these situations are far more complex.

I repeat again, David Moyes will not be able to contact clubs and table bids on behalf of Manchester United. This is not because I have some need to defend him, I couldnt give a fuck about him now as he is not our manager. I would say the same thing if this was Liverpool, Spurs, City or Chelsea. The managers of these clubs simply do not have that amount of power to determine fee's, clauses and salaries, they can literally be sacked within minutes if deemed necessary. United are a PLC, with a completely different management structure to Everton with regards to Transfer Policy and Strategy. Furthermore, anybody who thinks that Baines and Felli have only just appeared on Uniteds radar because Moyes arrived has been living in a wooden shack for the last 5 years (actually, I could believe that about some people on here). I think they would have both had bids, even if Moyes was still here. Baines is simply the best LB in the country and the best replacement for Evra, and I am sure Felli's commanding performance during last seasons opener would have ensured a big green tick appeared next to his name on the 'list of potential candidates to replace Scholes'.

My last point, is with regards to the impact of agents on these situations. For example, Everton come out and publicly slap hefty price tags on their players that they do not wish to sell. This immediately means that other clubs back off. The downside to this, is that the agents of players valued at 30-60 million will demand that their clients are paid wages similar to players of such a valuation. And if the clubs refuses to pay this, I guarantee they will lose those players for free, as they simply won't sign a new contract. This is a big win for the player, as he then gets a signing on fee which he would not have received in a straight transfer, and higher wages than he would have previously got because as a free agent he will be able to negotiate with multiple clubs without the need of agreement by Everton. You cant publicly value a player at 60 million and then only pay him 20,00 a week.

To be fair to what is an inept board, they appear to have treated this well and come out and made a statement about how insulting the offer is. But we are in a difficult situation, as both players would undoubtedly receive higher wages if they transferred. The same happened with Rooney a while ago, he made noises about wanting to leave United and was silenced with a new bumper contract if memory serves correct. If we do manage to resist all bids, its going to be a tough test for Martinez to keep both players committed to the cause and not put in transfer requests. If only the window shut tomorrow, I have an awful feeling we are going to be left in the shit here and our season preparations are going to be in tatters, never mind what effect it will have on the rest of the squad to lose two of our best players.

Mohammed Horoub
469 Posted 20/08/2013 at 18:37:09
James, I agree that the fairer valuation is 40-45 but we can still hope someone out there values them at that inflated rate because Martinez will only see 50-75% of any sale
Jamie Crowley
470 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:05:22
There is positively no way we should sell Felliani for less than 25 mil and Baines for less than 20 mil. If we actually received 60 mil from increased TV revenues and that money is "ringfenced" to pay down our debt, it all but wipes it out or reduces it to an exceedingly manageable number. I have no problem with the Board, as inept as they can be sometimes, putting Everton Football Club back on "solid" financial ground. In fact I think it's imperative we do so.

However, if my above "assumptions" are correct, we do not need to cave into Man U and need to (have to) stand firm on our valuations of our players.

Having said all that, I believe at the end of the day Felliani is, in all probability, gone. We'll settle for 20 mil and I'll be sick to my stomach over it. That's a roll over and die situation. I pray my crystal ball is on a fucked up wave-length.

Peter Barry @ 207 - TY for the history lesson. Love it. I'd expect nothing less from the English - arguably the wittiest human beings to roam planet earth.

Paul Andrews
472 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:46:06
Dan Brierly 493

"A big green tick appeared next to his name on a list of potential candidates to replace Scholes"
You could not find two more different football styles if you searched non stop for a year.

Paul Low
473 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:43:22
if we could get £35m I don't think it would be a disaster...I honestly believe Oviedo can be as good as Baines after a season playing every week.. he is quick, can pass, has great control and loves to get forward.........sound like anyone you know???
If Baines is to go for £12-15m then surely we could get cover for Oviedo for £3-4m leaving over£30m to replace Fellaini!!!
£12-15m for Mcarthy from Wigan and still around £18m for a MARQUEE SIGNING!!!! or 2-3 more typical everton types(Marillas,Gibson,Kone etc) at around £6m each.
Sometimes you have to go backwards to go forwards as we have done many times selling the odd top player but investing in quality and improving our squad.
Take spurs for example if Bale does go and they do sign willian then along with paulinho, and soldado they will have taken a massive step forward despite selling their best player!!!
Ian Bennett
474 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:57:10
Dan - of course the manager has input. The idea that the manager would have no input in the valuation of players or how the wage budget is spent is also as fanciful. The telephone and email has been invented which has probably addressed the communication issue.

Moyes sanctioned those bids. On the continent the directors will handle this, but here the power resides with managers far more.

Dan Brierley
475 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:54:11
Paul, I don't see your point? All footballers have their own style, from Cruyff to Maradona, Messi to Ronaldo. It doesn't mean they can't play in the same position.

You think Felli is on United's radar to replace Rooney or Kagawa in an advanced role? I would suggest he is more natural sitting in the middle of the park controlling the build up and breaking up the opposition attacks.

We have used him in a more advanced role in the past, when we had nobody better! Now we have Barkley showing promise in that role, I would suggest you wont see Felli up front as much anymore, only perhaps during tactical changes during a match.

Paul Andrews
476 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:17:59
Two totally different players Dan

One,the best player of his type in a generation.One of the top 3 players to have played in the Prem.

The other,not.

Kevin Tully
477 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:23:20
Dan Brierley - Involved in transfers for Man Utd since they were listed on the NYSE, who knew?

I wish some people wouldn't state their 'informed opinion' as fact.

You know as much as the rest of us Dan, unless you have some inside information you are not prepared to share?

Or are you involved in football in some capacity, if so, I humbly apologise.

Dan Brierley
478 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:26:23
Paul, so considering Scholes retired at the end of last season, which position do you think United are chasing Felli to play then?
Sean Patton
479 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:39:35
Woodward : What players do you want boss

Moyes : Fellaini and Baines

Woodward : Say no more I will handle the money side of things

Moyes : Good stuff Ed

Woodward : Great news Everton have accepted the bid

Moyes : Well done how much

Woodward : 70 Million

Moyes : Wow a bit too much there if only I was somehow involved in the bidding process this would never have happened.

Dan Brierley
480 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:32:35
Damn, you are good Mr Tully. You can see through me like a cheap persian rug. You are indeed correct, and I can reveal myself as.....none other than Bill Kenwright himself.

My plot to destroy Everton Football Club using the nuclear weapons hidden in the secret bunker underneath GP is now out, and its all thanks to you Kevin. You were right all along.

P.S. This is all complete 100% fact.

Paul Andrews
481 Posted 20/08/2013 at 21:16:41
No idea Dan.
I can say with certainty it won't be as a replacement for Scholes.
Ian Hollingworth
482 Posted 20/08/2013 at 21:49:56
Tony Draper (364) well said and I for one fully agree
I bet there are plenty who still applaud him on his return this season though
James Marshall
483 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:56:16
Replacing Scholes would be like trying to replace Zidane of Pirlo - you just can't do it.

I think what Dan means, Paul, is that Utd could do with a presence in midfield - not that Fellaini is in any way anything like Paul Scholes.

There isn't a midfield player in this country, and not many in the World today that can hold a candle to Scholes in his pomp.

Peter Warren
484 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:09:56
Sean 532# funny
Paul Andrews
486 Posted 21/08/2013 at 06:46:07
Now if he said he was Darren Fletchers replacement..........
Eric Myles
487 Posted 21/08/2013 at 06:33:56
Jamie #606 "If we actually received 60 mil from increased TV revenues and that money is "ringfenced" to pay down our debt, it all but wipes it out or reduces it to an exceedingly manageable number."

We only receive 20 million from increased TV revenues, the other 40 mill we are receiving, and spending, already.

Considering that our annual losses without sales of assets are 20 mill then the increased telly money should just about see us break even next year.

So there is no money to pay down debt.

Harold Matthews
488 Posted 21/08/2013 at 06:55:53
I had an official letter from Everton dated 10th August 2013 and it bore little resemblance to the "Busby" effort.

The crest on my letter is a one inch square version of the old design with "Everton" printed below. There is also no yellow and blue line.
At the bottom of the page there is a one inch square Chang logo.

Whether the "Busby" letter is genuine or fake is anyones guess.
As a retired professional artist I can only say that it fails to impress me.
Unlike my letter, it has no class.

Drew Shortis
489 Posted 21/08/2013 at 08:53:54
The new rumour today is that United are switching their focus onto Luke Shaw of Southampton for around £10m. The interesting thing is that Yahoo Eurosports describe the Saints as "relative financial minnows". Jeez, what does that make us, financial amoebas?

Still, this could be good news for us if there is any truth in it. Makes sense too. This season United still have Evra, but Shaw looks like a fantastic prospect and he has ten years on Baines. Could be a goer.

James Marshall
490 Posted 21/08/2013 at 10:57:38
That letter looks ridiculous - surely a fake? Why would it have been photographed by anyone and leaked onto the Internet anyway?

It reads like a letter on a Football Manager game, put together by a teenager in his bedroom.

If that's real, I'll eat my hat.

Karl Masters
491 Posted 22/08/2013 at 00:30:29
Darren Fletcher. Now there's somebody I could see ending up at Goodison.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb