Martinez determined to keep focus

, 20 August, 99comments  |  Jump to most recent
Boss dismisses United shenanigans as a waste of time
Echoing the club's official rejection of Manchester United's insulting double bid for Marouane Fellaini and Leighton Baines, Roberto Martinez says that the Champions' approach for two of his star players was 'a bit of a waste if time', particularly given its timing at the start of the new season.

"It's been well documented what happened with the transfer speculation, that's been dealt with and it was all a little bit of a waste of time — time I don't want the players to waste," Martinez told evertontv.

And he emphasised that his primary focus is to keep the players' minds on starting the new campaign in the best way possible.

"I'm not a big believer in having the window open while the games are starting," the Spaniard said. "I think the start of the season was important for us at Norwich and I won't come out now and carry on talking about the speculation.

"When there is something to tell our fans we will do that — they'll be the first ones to know if there are any players coming in or any players going out."

Martinez's comments come in the wake of confirmation from Everton of a £28m offer from Old Trafford for Fellaini and Baines, one branded as derisory in a letter attributed to director Jon Woods to the Manchester club.

 

Reader Comments (99)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tommy Coleman
1 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:36:07
I don't think the players will be unsettled by the Desperate Moyes. I think we'll end up keeping both.

No sale, at any price.

COYB.

Robbie Muldoon
3 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:38:50
Keep hold of them both and offer them the chance to go next season, after the World Cup. We don't need any disruption now and we shouldn't be selling to Moyes who has played us like clowns.
Dave White
4 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:43:12
The funny thing about these proposed transfers is that United fans don't appear to want either player.

Evra had a fantastic season and I can't see how Felli would add anything to their side. That's not to say I'm devaluing either player as I would have Baines over Evra every time and rate Felli hugely.

I feel the outcome of this saga could define our season, to sell either player would undermine any genuine CL ambitions, especially given that any subsequent player acquisition would be rushed.

In time Barkley may prove to be the player we all hope but I'd still keep Felli as we are beginning to look like a genuine squad, and not just a strong first 11 which cannot soak up injuries without resorting to players on the periphery who don't really appear to have the minerals, Gueye, Velios etc.

On another note, as much as I thought he was a fricken donkey last season has anyone else noticed what a promising pre season Naismith has had? If he could find his form it would be like a new signing!

Colin Glassar
5 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:48:37
One of them, at least, is leaving. He's not closing the door on this but instead saying its a waste of time. Very different from saying, they are NOT for sale!! So he's keeping his options open IMO rather than slamming the door shut. We will be kept on tenterhooks now until the TW closes.
Ian Burns
6 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:50:08
An interesting 2 weeks ahead of us. Baines and Fellaini out and Barry/Kolorov and McCarthy in?

Could happen despite what is being said.

Colin Glassar
7 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:56:30
No thanks Ian. Apart from McCarthy, the other two wouldn't be an improvement on what we already have.
Andrew Presly
8 Posted 20/08/2013 at 12:57:01
An ambitious team would keep them both and add the extra CM we need (McCarthy by the sounds of it...) and have a proper go at making the top 4 / wining a cup on the back of the extra tv money.

Anything happens to RVP (here's hoping) and we can finish ahead of Man U FFS!

Sick of the feeder club / making up the numbers mentality.

Paul Dark
9 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:12:52
It's clear he's leaving the door open. He could be a bit more sincere and honest about it.

Beware the false smile and (heavily) qualified promises.

Gary Joyce
10 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:10:22
A dignified response to a shabby little man who has fallen into the trap of believing the madia hype, just like a certain Mark Hughes when he was givern the keys to the vault at City.

Shabby little men tend to end up forgotten whereas class is permanent. Well done Bob.

Ian Burns
11 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:13:27
Colin - 327 - I wasn't suggesting that is what would improve the team or indeed what I would personally like to see - it just my guess and a feeling that is what we will end up with.

Colin Glassar
12 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:16:25
I hope you're wrong Ian but with us you never know. I would've prefered a stronger statement from Martinez tbh.
Patrick Murphy
13 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:14:28
Paul I just think RM is astute enough to realise that if a club comes in with a bid for any player on his staff that the club will if they deem fit sell that player. You and others would be all over him like a rash if today he said nobody is for sale and next week a player was sold.
Jay Harris
14 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:14:40
Echo your thoughts Gary but I think EFC are already prepared for life without Felli as RM seems so keen to get McCarthy who IMO isn't fit to lace Felli's boots.

Would love to see us keep both who again IMO keep the team ticking over and know the club and players well as opposed to an unknown quantity coming in.

That would be a double whammy for me as it undermines Man U and Moyes and it keeps our stability.

We need to add quality not give it away to the competition.

Derek Knox
15 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:14:34
I don't remember in previous seasons the Transfer Window being open this late. Who's idea was that then? I think it has proved, with the recent events, to be more disruptive than productive. I admire Roberto's stance in this but, nevertheless, it can only be unsettling, not only for the players concerned, but for the whole squad. Even if the whole thing remains as it is now, it will take some time to get back to normal.
Robin Cannon
16 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:24:29
I thought it was suitably dismissive. He can't outright say "not for sale", because every player has a price and he'd just be undermined if we did end up selling one of them.

He's totally right about the stupidity of the window being open for weeks after the season starts.

Ian Burns
17 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:25:03
Colin, I think RM has diplomatically said all he can whilst leaving the door open so he can get McCarthy into the fold. It is all guesswork of course and I agree wholeheartedly with you in the hope I have got my guesses wrong!
Kev Johnson
18 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:24:06
Even better, why not hire Daniel Levy on a freelance "consultancy" basis to handle all our transfers, in and out. We could intentionally lose our away game to Spurs as payment, calculating that we would gain in excess of three points over the season as a direct consequence of Levy's tough negotiating skills. Mind you, if anyone found out about it we'd have to bribe them to keep quiet, which could prove expensive, and would only make matters worse. The shit would eventually hit the fan and we'd be punished by the FA by being forcibly relegated to the Blue Square Premiership, doomed to play local derbies against Chester City.

All in all, it's probably not worth it. Next idea, please...

Chris Davies
19 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:23:59
I'm not really bothered if Fellaini goes. Play Gibbo and Ross in mid with Super Kev just behind Kone or Jelly. Sorted. Fellaini who!?! JUST KEEP HOLD OF BAINES, FFS.
Kev Johnson
20 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:32:30
Oops, I posted this on the wrong thread. Sorry. It should have been on the Woodward and Whelan one. Can you please move it, dear editors?
Paul Dark
21 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:31:32
Patrick: he should say: 'Fellaini and Baines are not for sale. We would ask Man Utd not to bid again.' He's smarmy.

Moyes isn't covering himself in glory either.

P.S.
What does OFM stand for? Been away ...

James Lauwervine
22 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:27:10
Generally I've been happy with everything RM has said so far, including this. It must be pretty tiresome when you're hounded day after day about the same topic and always having to watch what you say as it will be analysed to death.
Don't want either player to go but if it has to be one then Fella for £20m+ and maybe just enough time for RM to spend a few bob.
Colin Glassar
23 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:31:39
Ian, I suppose as you and Robin have said he can't in all honesty slam the door shut only for the club to accept an offer further down the road. Like Jay, I would love to see Fellaini and McCarthy play together in MF but this is not going to happen. Sadly, I can see McCarthy replacing Fellaini in the next week or so.
Gary Joyce
24 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:28:55
Jay, Martiunez knows exactly what he has inherited. He has already blown his huge transfer budget of £6m for this Summer and, as others are saying, he can't say nobody is for sale in our current situation. It's not his call to make ulimately. He definately wouldn't sell either if it was.

What he has done is not get involved in a slanging match and treated the whole situation, and the opposing manager concerned, with the distain it deserves..

The performance on Saturday was encouraging, whilst still leaving some question marks, but if Martinez can continue to show the class he has so far,displayed, on and off the field, it shows he understands our club and what we expect, given that he is always going to be limited in what he can achieve given the financial restraints he has always known he is going to have to work under.

Carl Peters
25 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:35:19
It now seems if you believe reports that Arsenal are about to enter the race for Fellaini. This could get interesting if Wenger offers £20M +50p.

Personally I’d rather let Arsenal have him cheaper just to piss that ginger cunt off.

Phil Walling
26 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:32:42
Martinez is right to get on with his job and leave the dirty dealings to Kenwright and Elstone. My bet is that at least Felli will go-though not necessarily to the Mancs- and more Wiganers will come our way. St.Robert and his predecessor don`t seem to look any further than their old clubs whether it`s for staff or players!

Be that as it may,lets hope our man is left to concentrate on sorting out his self-created shambles of a defence before the Baggies come to town. Oherwise that march will be in the opposite direction!

Brian Harrison
27 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:47:35
I am surprised that some fans think so highly of McCarthy, and surely if he was as good as some think why has no other Premiership club made an offer. To be honest I thought Maloney played better for Wigan than McCarthy last season. Reading some of the press they reckon Wigan will ask £15 million for him, and knowing Whelan he will conduct the transfer through the press as he does with most things.
Mark Dunford
28 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:47:56
Waste of time is a very polite, accurate description. It doesn't rule out or invite subsequent bids, but we all have a clear idea of what is likely to occur in the next couple of weeks.

Agree with everyone who says Martinez has played this well while Utd have behaved stupidly and their dithering in transfer market does start to look like Everton's Moyes with a bigger budget.

Colin Glassar
29 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:00:00
Phil, it's King Robert not saint. He'll become Saint Robert after he's won a few trophies and snuffed it.
Tony Marsh
30 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:00:31
Brian @ 336 — using your method of judgement about McCarthy the same could be said about Fellaini. Why have no other Premier League clubs been in for him before now? There's always a first time for everything, mate.
Carl Reid
31 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:57:22
Well I am tired of hearing posters talk of our financial predicament whilst the manager says we are stable.. Uncle Bill should prepare for a fans genuine reaction one day and it will not a march in the park. We should sell neither player the way we are run makes local sweet shops seem like multi nationals.
Kev Johnson
32 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:01:04
I'm with you on that, Brian. I don't know if I've got a bit of a blind spot here, but I just can't see what's so good about McCarthy. I know he's highly rated but he just seems very ordinary to me. Puzzling.

Last time I looked, I wasn't the Everton manager (more's the pity). Martinez is - and he evidently thinks the world of him. So I expect to see him here in the not too distant future.

Phil Walling
33 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:05:54
You are spot on, Colin, and I will indicate so in future references to the great man. But wouldn`t we all like to see your dream come true? As I shall already `be up there` by the time it does, I will lobby for his beatification the very first time we visit Rome in the Champions League!
Carl Sanderson
34 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:11:25
So if we buy McCarthy to add to Robles, Alcaraz and Kone we will have the spine of the team that was relegated/won the Cup. Oh shit/oh excellent.

[Delete as appropriate according to your point of view.]

Steven Kendrew
36 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:30:09
$50m and they can take them both. We should then play Barkley more and another youngster and continue to build from there. With that kind of injection of cash, perhaps someone might then buy the club....unless Bill puts the price up by $50m...lol.
Mark Tanton
37 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:33:17
I think we'll probably buckle when it gets into the high thirties, and be lucky to reach £40m.
Harold Matthews
38 Posted 20/08/2013 at 13:43:10
I'm supporting Martinez but don't agree with this determined pursuit of McCarthy when there are players of equal ability out there for less than half the price. Mix Diskerud, "The Norwegian / American Pirlo" is less than a quarter the price and there are others out there. The USA fans gave him that title, not me, and if he's good enough for Klinsmann, he's good enough for us.

Even so, these guys are like Gibson. They are definitely not like Fellaini who, in my opinion, will be almost impossible to replace. In fact, I can't think of anyone available who is remotely like him. This makes him a valuable asset and if he does move, it will not be for buttons.

Brian Cleveland
39 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:48:32
Did anyone else notice this sentence by Martinez..."I don't believe in getting involved in the transfer window when the games are underway..."

So can I read that as no more players in? If not he would be contradicting this statement... and we all know managers (past and present!) never tell porkies!! :-)

James Marshall
40 Posted 20/08/2013 at 14:53:30
I would echo comments above - if McCarthy is so good, why has nobody else bid for him? By the same token, if Fellaini is so good, why has nobody else bid for him apart from Utd?

I've never really rated him (square peg/round hole zzzzzz) and I don't think he'd fit into a Champions League, title chasing team. They play with fluidity and Fellaini is a stumbling cart-horse in so many ways. He tackles like Paul Scholes with a gammy leg, and generally slows play down - not exactly the type of player to spark a team and light up a fast moving midfield.

Moyes wants him because he missed out on his two main midfield options this summer, and knows what he can get out of Fellaini. Other managers are clearly not convinced either.

Trevor Thompson
41 Posted 20/08/2013 at 15:05:44
Paul #349 I think it might stand for Our Former Manager. I'm not entirely sure,though.
Carl Sanderson
43 Posted 20/08/2013 at 15:13:48
Trevor 409:

I think you're probably right. Immature, isn't it?

Devin Massopust
44 Posted 20/08/2013 at 15:23:09
I think a similar player to Fellaini that I would love to see at Everton is Michael Bradley. Passes the ball well and quickly, protects the back four wonderfully, and runs powerfully into the final third to support the attack. However, I'm not sure if he could be lured from Roma or what his price is
Harold Matthews
45 Posted 20/08/2013 at 15:46:02
Devin. With you on Bradley all the way. What a player. Klinsmanns number one man.

Kev. I'm equally puzzled with this McCarthy thing. I've never considered him to be anything special yet Martinez sees him as the answer to all his prayers. My God, I hope he's right. With Gibson forever injured we need another "spraycan" but didn't expect it to be gold-plated.

Kevin Rowlands
47 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:01:48
The one thing that concerns me and I haven't seen it mentioned in any of the threads is that Moyes knows Baines and Fellaini personally, hes without doubt got their phone numbers and vice versa, I would be astounded if they haven't spoken to each other which means the players obviously haven't said anything to discourage these rumors and bids, hate to say it but I feel this is going to happen, also I think McCarthy will for sure be an Everton player by the close of the transfer window, if we add a couple more(striker/midfielder) I don't think we will be to weakened by their departure, I understand Oviedo isn't LB but he will be a very good replacement imho.
Paul Ferry
48 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:14:15
Worrying if it is one of his principles:

"I don't believe in getting involved in the transfer window when the games are under way and we are in a very, very important moment of our season," he added.

Well on the day that Spurs are lining up a 30 million quid Brazilian attacking midfielder - surely Bale is out the door? - we still need two or three more on board - especially if Felli walks as more than a few on here think he will do.

A hunch is that these words might make Bobby look a little silly in a week or two.

Karl Masters
49 Posted 20/08/2013 at 16:59:23
OFM = Outrageously Fun-loving Moyes I heard.
Colin Glassar
50 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:29:26
James #404, I don't know where you get your info but Fellaini is one of the best tacklers in the game!! He doesn't slide tackle but he takes the ball off the opponents feet so easily. I know we are all accustomed to the lunging, last gasp, spectacular sliding tackle but that is fastly becoming a thing of the past. Felli is a great exponent of the clean tackle and he is a master at it. Plus his passing rate is at 80% which is pretty decent for a MF player.
James Marshall
51 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:46:02
Colin #462

Whenever I watch him play all he ever seems to do is either miss tackles because he's too slow, being passed around or bundle right through the back of people, and push them over.

I'll happily stand corrected by stats, I just find him to be such a big ungainly lump that he does nothing for me. It might well be being harsh on him, it's just the way I see him when he plays.

His pass rate at 80% is generally sideways too isn't it? I never see him split a defence open with a great ball.

Basically I have it in for him!

James Marshall
52 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:50:25
From this blog you're right, Colin. I find these stats incredible....

http://www.eplindex.com/22943/fellaini-best-position-stats-analysis.html

Harold Matthews
53 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:58:24
James. Sorry mate. I've got to go with Colin......and yes, you've had it in for him for quite some time. When he did something stupid last season I posted, " Hope James is up the Amazon."
Colin Glassar
54 Posted 20/08/2013 at 18:12:55
As you can see James he is a far more effective defensive MF player than an attacker. For such a big man Fellaini sometimes shows sublime skill my beef with him is his inconsistency/attitude but when he's on top of his his game he's unplayable.
Raymond Fox
55 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:29:43
Paul 349.
You call Martinez smarmy, I'll stick you in front of a bunch of journalists asking probing questions or even Everton TV, I'm sure you'll find it none too easy to say all the right things.
Besides Roberto wont have the authority to say they wont be leaving.

Another factor is one or both of them might want to leave to a club that's in the CL and have made this clear to management, its not usually smart to keep players that want to go.

Peter Cummings
57 Posted 20/08/2013 at 18:14:23
Like many on the site I think a stronger statement from both the manager and the board, not to mention the two players named, is warranted here,Loyal Everton fans should not be kept in limbo on a situation like that across Stanley Park where, at least, they know the score involving you know who, courtesy of BR and his board, if we want to compete with the so called Premiership 'elite' we have to follow their lead and state loudly and clearly,''No Sale At Any Price'' especially to the ginger hypocrite.
Mark Taylor
58 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:44:31
I agree about the concern over McCarthy's valuation. That is around the level you could have got the likes of Gustavo or Strootman for, and I think both of those two are a level at least higher.

Frankly I don't want any more Wigan players till I see some evidence that the £6m we paid for Kone isn't a waste of money.

Colin Grierson
59 Posted 20/08/2013 at 17:39:26
I think that people are being far too analytical of the phraseology of RMs response to the rejected bid. He clearly felt he had to say something prior to the West Brom game.
I think he was genuine in what he said about getting involved in the transfers when the games have begun and I'm with him on that. If in a few weeks Fellaini and Baines decide to go then he will be forced to enter the transfer market and may should already have a deal ready to go should his hand be forced. He would be negligent if he hasn't got someone lined up to replace one or both of them.

In my opinion we have replaced Moyes with a better man and a better manager. I watched a documentary on Swansea the other week which showed that RM is the reason they are where they are now, playing football their fans can only have dreamed of before he revolutionised them.
What will be will be. The key to the outcome of the transfer saga is whether Baines and Fellaini wish to go to play CL football. Fellaini does and Baines silence doesn't fill me with confidence. However, I think we must trust Martinez to make the best of a bad situation if the worst comes to the worst.

Raymond Fox
60 Posted 20/08/2013 at 18:32:26
Whelan has said £15m for McCarthy, we'd prob. get him for £12m.
I think its fair to say that none of us has seen a lot of him, you don't get a true picture if you only see the odd match.

On the other hand Martinez has, the way I see it, he's is not going to bring any player to Everton that he doesn't think will be a success, his jobs on the line!
What bit I've seen of McCarthy he reminds me of Alan Ball, all those years ago (showing my age now) same build, not spectacular, but runs, passes and tackles all day, a good team man.

Colin Grierson
61 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:04:51
Your right Ray, Martinez knows the lad inside out and would be mad to bring him in if he' s not up to it.
Drew Shortis
62 Posted 20/08/2013 at 19:56:56
Check out this You Tube video of McCarthy versus Man Utd: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCxji7TyAQU

He might not do anything spectacular, but what he does is win the ball well and keep his team moving forward with quick, crisp passing. Has a bit of pace when needed and can pick out team mates with longer balls when needed. Contrast that with Osman's performance against Norwich and you might see what Martinez sees in the lad.

James Martin
63 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:06:48
Drew that was one bad performance by Osman against Norwich (even then was no worse than Fellaini's or Mirallas's) for a lot of last season he was very consistent and at times excellent. McCarthy equally has had many horrendous games that funnily enough don't turn up on youtube. Barkley is a better version of McCarthy and doesn't cost 15 million. We can't just have a midfield of people recycling th eball to each other. Someone's got to create something. I'd rather see Osman or Pienaar give the ball away going for something creative rather than another player who just goes for the safe sidewyas balls all the time.
Andy Walker
64 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:03:38
The siege mentality at Old Trafford is being rebuilt. If you want to ensure that your new manager of your multi million pound plc who had 11 years of loyalty towards one other club forgets that loyalty as quickly as possible and recognises very quickly that United is now his only friend, simply alienate everyone else outside the club and make them hate you. Job done.

I just wish our club hadnt risen to the bait by using emotive language like derisory etc, its just what those bastards wanted. A simple rejection would have been far more powerful. But of course they wanted to imply we would sell our pair for a suitable offer, so wait and see.

Paul Gladwell
65 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:37:00
Andy,I think those words were a dig at Moyes as he used the exact words for Arsenal when they bid buttons for Jagielka.
Drew Shortis
66 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:29:18
James 523
I have been a fan of Osman's over the years and I think he can still play a role for us in the attacking midfield role, but he isn't up to the deep lying / defensive midfield role. I honestly thought we were going to concede from one of his mistakes. He was brushed off the ball far too easily too. Perhaps I'm being too harsh on Ossie, but I think McCarthy would fit right in to our team. Whenever I have seen him play he has been very possitive with his passing. I remember many games where Rodwell seemed incapable of making a forward pass. I can't claim to be an expert on McCarthy, but from what I have seen he isn't just a safe player.

From my point of view Fellaini had a decent game against Norwich, not outstanding, but he won challenges and kept possession in tight spots. I made notes during the match and his passing was good too, initiating several attacks. He was also a threat to the opposition from set pieces. Mirallas had a quiet match, but he did have a few shots in the first half and his speed meant Norwich had to defend deep.

Kevin Rowlands
67 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:46:57
Where Everton are concerned there is a common theme when we have constant rumors and bids in the transfer window about our better players, nearly everyone of them has eventually been sold (Rooney, Lescott, Arteta and Rodwell) I don't hold out much hope that this will be any different, as for Moyes he should have been shown the door as soon as he announced he was off, that whole send off was a complete frigging farce, the same twat is now circling us like a vulture to take our better players for a pittance, will we ever learn?
Mike Gaynes
68 Posted 20/08/2013 at 20:36:42
Devin and Harold, I promoted Bradley here a couple of years ago when he was loaned to Villa from Moenchengladbach. I thought we should have made a move for him when Alex McLeish dumped him, but I was laughed at for wanting a McLeish reject. Nobody's laughing now. He would make our folks forget Fellaini in about 90 minutes. Last week when the USA beat Bosnia, he completed 92 of 100 passes, and most of them were forward. He's world class.

Last year he moved from Chievo to Roma for less than four million, but we might not be able to afford him now, even if Roma were to make him available. He's immensely popular there.... the fans call him General Bradley.

Karl Jones
69 Posted 20/08/2013 at 21:10:40
Agree with Kevin 536...There's always alot of posturing that comes from Everton..Not for sale...Loves the club.. etc. Even Tim Howard was on Sky news before saying Everton players arent affected by speculation because its a special club. Utter bollocks !

This is almost a carbon copy of the Lescott affair where I think the opening bid was 13 million, but we eventually sold for 22 million. The same will happen here, probably after a transfer request is lodged or Kenwright will come out and say the players went to him and said "let me go" in order to save face. Then it will be too late to replace them.

The whole transfer system is a predictable farce. What a backstabbing hypocrite Moyes is.

Jimmy Sørheim
70 Posted 20/08/2013 at 21:19:36
Has anyone noticed that the media hype of Moyes has gone totally quiet now?

I hate the fact that we can never just say no and stand by it. To allow this transfer speculation is very bad for our club and season.

I am under no illusion; I know we need to sell to buy right now, but I would rather sell Fellaini than Baines.

Fellaini will be a loss along with his goals but, with BK lurking behind the scenes pushing for a transfer at every turn, how can we keep anyone!!

I think RM is fully aware that Fellaini will be sold, and he seems to be holding out for the highest bidder. No doubt he wants McCarthy at Everton. It is fake to say anything else.

Felli did not seem like himself during the Norwich game and is already out the door mentally which is bad. I think he will put in a transfer request very soon.

The thing that irks me just as much is the fact Heitinga has not been sold, yet he has a year left in his contract.

HOW ON EARTH CAN EVERTON SURVIVE IF WE LET EVERY COSTLY TRANSFER PLAYER IN THE PAST GO FOR NOTHING???? It makes me angry just thinking about it.

The fact is Felli represents the highest transfer fee possible at our club, and we should hold out for at least £23 million because the rest of the squad represents little or no value except Baines.

Roberto is doing the right thing, trying to keep the squad focused, but the truth is he will fail in the end. Can he afford to not buy any more players?
My answer is No. That is why the sale of Felli and the price is so important. To let any player at this club go for less than his value is suicide.

The fact is RM will now set the standard for how Everton will operate in the future.

Mark Taylor
71 Posted 20/08/2013 at 21:39:41
Karl 544

I could live with that. It would mean, proportionately, that we would get £50m for the two. I don't think I'd be alone in taking that in a shot. As I posted earlier you can get fantastic players for £15m and if you are canny, as hopefully RM is, a lot less.

All this is provided that RM gets to keep all or most to re-invest and that is the part I doubt. I think a lot of the cash (and Kenwright will sell for a lot less than £50m) will just go into our black hole.

More likely, we sell for little over £30m. After agent fees and the 20% to Liege, and after BK banks £15m, RM will be lucky to get much more than £7-8m. If BK gets it nearer to £35m, we might just end up with McCarthy. That's it. Not a good piece of business from a fan point of view.

Kevin Rowlands
74 Posted 20/08/2013 at 22:17:33
Karl, Mark, I believe they will go for approx 35 mill, I also believe it will be done before deadline day, the reason being RM told me right to my face that we were in for McCarthy and praised him big time infact even telling me he is an "Everton type player", I have no reason to disbelieve him, he will be given SOME of the proceeds to bring McCarthy in and perhaps one or two others, possibly loans, the rest of course will be banked. Obviously I do not know RM personally but met him at the meet and greet In Miami and had a brief conversation with him, I also asked was Fellaini staying and his answer was we hope so, make of that what you will.
Anthony Flack
75 Posted 20/08/2013 at 22:38:00
Stating the blindingly obvious but this is better done in the next 48 hours and not dragging on. Keep them both and state no offers considered (unlikely), sell one or both for a much as we can get.

Neither are irreplaceable

It was a long time ago when we were a club who could play on par with the big boys, selling them is not a sign of a lack of intent, it is real life. If they want to aspire to win the league, play in the Champions league I am afraid it will not happen with us in the next few years - we all know that

I would prefer them to go with best wishes, fuck Moyes and let Roberto pick players he wants with as much as the money as he can get his hands on.

But do not fight for the sake of public face and then cave in at the end i.e. 23.55 on the last day of thw window

Kevin Tully
76 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:03:15
If you take a look at the Utd fan forum's, they're all up in arms about this transfer window.

Moyes is under massive pressure to bring some players in now. How many games can the champions rely on a 40 yr old Giggs for?

Funny thing is though, the majority think they should be signing better players than Fellaini & Baines.

Paul David
77 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:28:39
Giggs is just a pup, I fully expect Moyes to give him a 5 year deal.
Chris Jones [Burton]
78 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:27:37
I'm inclined to think Baines and Screech will stay with us pro tem. The thing is, with what's been done and said...

1. Having described a combined bid of £28m as "disrespectful and derisory", and a "waste of time", we couldn't accept a bid of much less than £35m without looking foolish, and...

2. Manyoo couldn't offer circa £35m without looking like (yes, I know they are...) absolute twats, having offered a miserable £28m in the first instance.

I think the 'best' we can hope for is the Arse, Manyoo, and perhaps Spurs engaging in a bidding war for Felli (£25m?) and Manyoo coming back with a new 'final offer' of £15m for Baines. I can see the former, not the latter.

Colin Glassar
79 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:31:30
If OFM does buy Bainsey I hope Evra goes into his office the next day and gives him a good hiding.
Tom Dodds
80 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:30:02
You would think the present ongoing transfer farce is bad, ill make a perceptive future scenario of even larger (yes larger) proportions, when Moyes comes in for Barkley in the January transfer window. So leaving us (assuming of course if he takes the 1st and 2nd best players we have in this window) with an almost unreal job of wandering round Europe/wherever scratching round for bits and (suddenly dearer) pieces to try and rebuild the team.

I emphasise the latter scenario as we might suddenly find when we try to buy McCarthy the bloody prices will skyrocket. Plus the fact has anyone noticed how scarce good `stock` is at the moment ??p>Ya know unless we make a stand and KEEP our best players and actually ADD to this good present Everton team, we will truly go nowhere fast.... unless we're all only paying our season tickets in the hope we win the FA Cup ...

Dig?

Kevin Rowlands
81 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:45:29
Kevin #590 just shows you how thick they are, they want a better left back than Baines? erm... like who? also Fellaini when in the mood could probably get into the starting eleven in nearly any team in the world, they would both be fantastic signings for them, when it goes tits up over there the ginger twat is going to be pining for his days back at Goodison because them twats are gonna be all over him like a rash.
Harold Matthews
82 Posted 20/08/2013 at 23:39:17
Mike G #537. You have managed to make me feel quite ill.
Yes, I watched the Bosnia game and he was absolutely awesome. Doesn't say a lot for McLeish does it.?
Martinez is also beginning to worry me. I'm supporting him all the way but he's like a man walking a straight line who won't glance left or right. Either that or he's a damn fine actor.
Harold Matthews
83 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:10:24
Drew. When you compiled your notes did you leave a blank space for Jags or did you just cross him off.? He was crap.
Harold Matthews
84 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:10:24
Drew. When you compiled your notes did you leave a blank space for Jags or did you just cross him off.? He was crap.
Harold Matthews
85 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:27:39
Osman abusers please note. Your arm waving, finger pointing captain played like a Sunday league amateur.
Alan Smith
86 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:44:29
Why isn't Moyes or wenga signing McCarthy? Answer; he ain't that good. Spurs sign paulinhio and going for willian. McCarthy would not get in a top 6 team, ever! He'd struggle to get in Necastles side. Well he wouldn't. Cabaye and Tiote.

Let's get things in perspective, replacing Fellaini with McCarthy is a serious downgrade. I'd like our manager to know the market better and not keep helping his old club out. Moyes could identify moutiniho, Felli, Fernandez, benega and half the current spurs side.

Kevin Rowlands
87 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:50:45
C'mon Harold, arm waving, finger pointing? PJ is certainly not Phil Neville, probably did not have his best game but they hardly had a sniff except for two jousy goals, as for Osman, he was definitely shaky and should only be a bit part player this season.
Kevin Rowlands
88 Posted 21/08/2013 at 00:58:18
Too funny Alan, Moyes could identify all these players you mentioned, I think any footy fan could have done that but guess what pal, you've got to have the financial support and back up to bring them in! Moyes didn't get it and nor will Martinez, get in the real world, we have to sell to buy, btw McCarthy is a very good player, sorry but reality is the Paulinho's and Willians are out of our league, what part of that don't you understand?
Peter Cummings
89 Posted 21/08/2013 at 01:14:21
I'm very disappointed to see many of you guys posting that you actually want to see both our top players hitting the bricks for big-bucks offers.

There doesn't seem to be any prospect of suitable replacements on the market; if we want a realistic chance of Europe, we must keep our prize assets at all costs.

Harold Matthews
90 Posted 21/08/2013 at 01:11:17
Kevin. His arms were quicker than his feet. During one particular incident Jags waved frantically for Coleman to pass the ball to Howard, which would have been suictde, but the irish lad took one look and went the other way. Seconds later, with the ball now safe, Coleman raced back to Jags and gave him a right rollicking.

Jags has always been one of my favourite players. His fearless, last-ditch recovery tackles are legendary. That said, his pre-season plus the Norwich game have shown him in a different light and perhaps the new tactics are causing problems. He's a massive player for us and I pray he is back to his brilliant best at the weekend.

Jack Cross
91 Posted 21/08/2013 at 02:30:36
So were are all the links RM is supposed to have with the continent? He hasn't gone outside Wigan yet has he? Oh sorry the 19 year old, who probably wont get a start.

As for McCarthy, I don't rate him at all.

If Feli is so good why hasn't anyone else come in for him? I mean he is like a last resort for Moyse. All his other options have failed. I don't care who buys him, if we get a good price for him.

It's a pity we couldn't have got Bonny, he showed what he's good at doing when he came on in second half.

Rob Smith
92 Posted 21/08/2013 at 03:18:13
After previous statements from Felli's management in other windows, it is quite strange if Felli wants away so bad to play Champions League footy, there isn't more pot stirring from them. Baines seems quite happy being a superstar at Everton, he is team fabric here, I would be more pissed if he left than Felli.

I also feel McCarthy is not value at 15mill and not nearly as good as Felli, 3 goals in how many games, nearly Osman standard. I would think if Felli does go, Martinez will have players other than McCarthy as his first choice.
Rob Smith
93 Posted 21/08/2013 at 03:57:08
Just as an afterthought, Tottenham look like signing Willian for 30mill, no premier league experience, 2 international caps. Not saying I wouldn't have him as an Osman replacement.

Felli, 6 years experience more international caps, release clause 23.5 mill, no bids, 1 bid since at 16mill. I realise Willian is classed as Attack Mid but Felli played that role pretty well for us last year, the value disparity amazes me sometimes, most times actually.
We seem to get beaten down to where some are saying sell for 18mill, Fuck that.... if Willian is worth 30 and McCarthy 15 then Felli is value at 26mill.

Rant complete.

Kristian Boyce
94 Posted 21/08/2013 at 04:18:56
I'm thinking that Baines & Felliani (if they actually leave) may not be the only two that follow Moyes out to Man U in the next year. If Coleman, Mirallas & Barkley all have big years, I could see OFM coming in for them. Coleman would easily get into their first team now, and Mirallas would be a cheaper 'Ronaldo' type player for them. If paper talk is true, Barkley has been a target for years, in the same way Rooney had been monitored before he broke into our first team.

On Moyes's current form, I'll be expecting a 60K bid for Coleman as he knows 'Everton Player Values'

Derek Knox
95 Posted 21/08/2013 at 04:22:39
Rob (#636)

I thought almost the same as you did; to be honest it is only in the last six months I have even heard of him. You are curious about the no-quibble price tag? Well, so am I; the only conclusion I can derive is that he is a Brazilian! Now, Brazil is a vast country and has undeniably produced some amazing football talent over the years.

Europe, and I include us, obviously, have this often misplaced conception that, if a footballer is from Brazil, he is assumed to be the best! This is reflected in the price but, more often than not, they are (apart from the oddball juggling trick) not a lot different than what we have over here. Oh and they are not too keen on the bad weather when it kicks in!

Paul Dark
96 Posted 21/08/2013 at 05:10:01
Why doesn't Moyes come and take the embarrassing liability that is Leon Osman off our hands? After all, he gave this dreadful player a two year contract minutes before he left, and he never dropped him.
Christian Watson
97 Posted 21/08/2013 at 10:40:10
I think Kristian Boyce has a point. Moyes knows OUR players better than he knows his own at the moment. he farmed out Ross Barkley last season to get him up to speed and Miralles and Coleman were his signings and as such, as we now know, the united move was at best 'pre meditated'
I think we can count on Moyes being a pain in the arse for months / years to come. United have an aging squad, Giggs, Evra, Ferdinand, Carrick etc so an influx of younger talent at a reasonable price would fit well with Utd anas I've said before this man knows, better than anyone, our finacial plight and as such he is bound to play on it!¬
Paul Sullivan
98 Posted 21/08/2013 at 10:51:59
Willian is a proven Champions League class act. Well "worth" 30m in the current climate of madness. He is a completely different type of player to Fellaini who has suffered an identity crisis due to his versatility and Moyes using him as a human totem pole onto which Jags was instructed to launch his 60 yard punts (that's how we beat United, remember).
Ian Burns
99 Posted 21/08/2013 at 11:36:44
I recommend the following link to my fellow Blues:

http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11065/8880873/robertos-rules

It makes very interesting reading and may give heart to some and be dismissed by others.

However, it is well worth a read, no matter what you read into it. Recommended!

James Marshall
100 Posted 21/08/2013 at 13:02:50
Alls fair in love & war. Why are people surprised that Utd want our better players? This was always going to happen and David Moyes knows Everton and Kenwright better than most.

He's the Man Utd manager now, the love affair with Everton is over and he has their best interests at heart - why would he give a damn about us now? It's business, and regardless of whether we feel hurt or cheated by te whole thing, it's just the way things are and were always going to be.

It amazes me that people are so up in arms about it - I (and many others) predicted this would happen the moment Fellaini's clause expired. Of course we were going to attract lower bids after the event. It's pretty standard practice.

Moyes knows we're skint, well, so does everyone else, but then where are all the other offers for our players? It strikes me that Utd (and Moyes to a degree) are simply playing the same game everyone else plays. It just feels worse because it's him.

Remember, this is the manager who was seen as extremely loyal to Everton, soundbites & all...well guess what, that loyalty now lies with Utd.

Alan Smith
101 Posted 21/08/2013 at 15:56:43
Kev Rolands 622

Read 618 again please. I wasn't saying we should sign any of those players, my pt was obvious I thought? We need to look further than Wigan if we have to replace Fellaini. We should have the money from his sale, or the £15m wheelan wants, to find a better quality player than McCarthy.

What don't you understand?

Also, jags was awful against Norwich. As usual he failed to judge the flight of any ball above waist height. He gets caught underneath long balls too often. An another obvious flaw to his game if you've bothered to watch him the last five years. He's terrible in the air and does not dominate the aerial duels.
By the way I'm a fan of his because as a man marker he's the best.

Drew Shortis
103 Posted 21/08/2013 at 21:47:07
Ian Burns 694
Good article there. Its good to see the statistics being used in a considered way to back up the theme of the article. I'm now feeling even more positive about the game, though still disappointed we didn't get all three points. I expect the defence to be much tighter against West Brom. If we can repeat that amount of possession and pass accuracy we will be in for a treat! I think Pieenar, Osman and Mirallas can all step it up a gear or two too.
Harold Matthews
104 Posted 22/08/2013 at 00:41:21
Alan Smith 762. Spot on mate. Excellent post. You're more observant than most.
Carl Rutherford
105 Posted 22/08/2013 at 12:18:17
Anybody seen this BBC article with quote attributed to Martinez

"If someone matches the valuation then you have to make a decision but that's not been the case."

Its hardly hands off our players, are we trying to encourage further bids for Baines and Felliani?

Full article

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/23791167

Harold Matthews
106 Posted 22/08/2013 at 14:09:36
Thanks Carl. What is the official Everton valuation they need to match?
Saegaran Kana
107 Posted 23/08/2013 at 02:05:56
Moyes trade mark.. leaves it too late. but to his credit I think he isn't really trying to signup our players hence the low bids. If i'm right, Moyes wants to hold on to his end of the parting agreement as with us.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb