Club unveil plans for selection of new badge

, 22 August, 38comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton have announced details of how supporters will be engaged to select the club's new crest for 2014-15 and beyond.

The club pledged to replace the existing, short-lived badge after the current season following an overwhelmingly negative reaction to the design when it was unveiled earlier this year.

New Director of Communications, Alan Myers, has been charged with steering the initiative to produce a new badge and Everton teamed up with the Liverpool Echo to announce details of the process that will culminate in the unveiling of the club's new identity in October.

Fans are invited to complete a questionnaire at www.evertonfc.com/crest to have their say on how they want the new crest to look and highlight which individual elements from previous crests are important to them. There will also be an option for fans to upload their own designs, sketches or make further suggestions.

Additionally, a series of focus groups will be set up with Supporters' Clubs, Shareholders, the Fans' Forum, the new Junior Fans' Forum, the Everton Heritage Society and the Everton Former Players' Foundation.

When the window for feedback closes on 15th September, Kenyon Fraser will independently collate all the suggestions, ideas and feedback from supporters. They will review, interpret and then create design options for the fanbase to vote on.

The final decision will then be hand over to Everton's fans to vote on a selection of designed crests which will be presented alongside a detailed explanation of how each one has been developed. The result will be announced on 3rd October.

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (38)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Derek Knox
1 Posted 22/08/2013 at 15:45:27
Lyndon. Why can't we just revert to the original badge?
Nick Entwistle
2 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:09:50
FFS. Design by consensus. All they need to do is bring back the last one, without EVERTON spelled out underneath. Kinda negates the purpose of the badge...
Andy Lockett
3 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:12:25
I think it’s fantastic that Alan Myers has set this up and through twitter at least, he seems to be a breath of fresh air in his communications with supporters.

My only gripe is the ’10 official versions of the club crest’ again promoted on the official website.
I’m not sure they were the official club crests and some were just what was used on the kits at the time.

The official crest has changed very little since the Theo Kelly 1938 one. Just have a look through your old programmes.
EG. Look at the programme from 1974 and compare it to what the website says was the ‘official crest’
http://www.evertoncollection.org.uk/object?id=796%20EFC%2f6%2f88%2f72&p=2&q=programmes#title

I hope we continue to keep it as close to the Theo Kelly original design as possible.

Ben Dyke
4 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:16:39
Nick that's a bit vindictive. Do we all get off on moaning round here. They get stick for the new badge and the process and now you put your boot in because they accept the error and introduce a wider consultation. No other club of our size would listen the way Everton has IMHO.
Nick Entwistle
5 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:19:47
Its true, I come to this site to moan two or three times a day. 4 on the weekend.

The consultation aspect, Ben, is a PR move that you may remember entirely absent when changing to the current abomination.

It didn't need changing yet they won't simply return to last season's as it shows-up the men is suits further.

As for the original point, design by consensus never works.

Richard Reeves
6 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:02:12
The club are coming out with this............

"Our previous crest was often misrepresented and suffered regularly from the omission of key elements such as our name and year of formation, and misuse of our club colours."

Surely EFC could of been incorporated onto the proper badge and simply change the colour back to royal blue without any light and shade.Barcelona have FCB along with other clubs that use their own initials so why can't we?

I also see the club are at it again with this gem at the end of the paragraph describing how fans feel about the proper badge,......

"To many fans, often appeared cluttered and outdated". How many is many?10-20 people? I don't know anyone that thought our old badge was cluttered.That was one of the things about the proper badge, it was NOT cluttered, it was simple in design but classy. Where other clubs have badges that really are busy and complicated in design like Coventry Sunderland, Newcastle etc.... Everton's has always been quite simple.

Harold Matthews
7 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:21:31
The name of the club is more important than anything else.
Craig Walker
8 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:25:19
Take the 1991-2000 version so we don't have that risible 'Everton' lettering which makes it look like it was defined by a 6th form media studies student. Add 9 gold stars in a circle around the badge. Easy to replicate. Defines our history. Job done. Gave the saved money to Roberto.
Brett Jonathan
9 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:31:16
As the owner of my own advertising and branding agency, this is all a bit surreal. Anyone knows this can't be done so quickly.
Whilst it isn't essential to spend years developing a new brand (although it often does), the timeline here is outrageous.
They intend to not only gather feedback, accept ideas, hold votes, focus groups AND actually design the new logo all within 42 days?

I don't ever want to see our club wrap something up so important that quickly.

41 days to completely design and develop our new club logo. 41 days!!!!!!

This can only mean one thing, The club have already designed the logo(s) for us to pick from. Done and dusted over the last few months.

Stop wasting time with the thought anyone has a choice and you can gather feedback and hit a logo in that timeframe. Just show us the new logo you have already designed and chosen for us.

Eric Myles
10 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:38:58
I get it to 38 days Brett, including the day it's announced.

But it's probably twice as long as the present Mickey Mouse Clubhouse logo took to knock together.

Brett Jonathan
11 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:44:39
My math is out indeed Eric. In my excitement to see if this could actually be true, I gave the club a few extra days. They could be crucial!
Brett Jonathan
12 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:46:10
Actually. Selection process starts on September 23 which suggest we have something to select from by then. That leaves the club less than one month to design this! Get cracking you idiots.
Nick Entwistle
13 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:48:58
Brett, I had said on a previous crest thread that a small number of people get paid a large amount of money to think that way.

Obviously someone was paid, or is paid a lot of money to think that we needed to change in the first place.

The Ferrari Daytona was designed in 7 days. The London Underground map was an un-commisioned design drawn up in Harry Beck's spare time. The entire British transport road signage was designed by an art teacher and his student (I think. Fans of Top Gear will correct me if wrong) without the need for any number of consultations it would take today.

And I think you may be right. They probably already know what they want and have a few examples to fit the upcoming public consultation process.

Barry Rathbone
14 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:29:48
Mad idea messing with the badge in the first place, aesthetics pale into insignificance against winning stuff and success.

What are Real Madrid, Barca, Juve or the Milan clubs badges like?

No idea!!.. but loads of kids buy them round europe and I'm damn sure it's their recent exploits and fame and naff all to do with the badge.

Why create bother for no good reason? - leave well alone put the old one back in there are enough problems without creating more.

I reckon nobs in suits and designer glasses smooth talked kenwright about artistic and design concepts and the daft prick loved every moment.

Discussing anything bar the harsh realities of Moyes shenanigans and fans getting onto him would have been manna from heaven at the time.

Rank amateur thinking.

Brett Jonathan
15 Posted 22/08/2013 at 16:52:56
I can design a logo in 2 minutes flat. Would I stake that work on a club's marketing and global profile worth millions (arguably)? Probably not.

The funny thing is - we are the club who takes an eternity to get anything done. Maybe the big folks upstairs can take a lesson from Everton's speedy design team! They get shit sorted quick!

Paul Mackie
17 Posted 22/08/2013 at 17:40:45
I see nothing wrong with a badge redesign, but I think putting it to popular vote is just going to prove why democracy doesn't work. The last thing the club needs is a bunch of armchair "brand experts" choosing a badge.

In my opinion the club should take on board fans feedback, work out what's important and then just pay someone to design something with that in mind and then us fans will just have to learn to live with it. There's nothing wrong with changing a badge to make it more appealing. The 91-00 and the 00-13 versions of the badge look horribly dated to me. The current one is also awful but I don't believe it's impossible to make a good one. The 82-83 badge is nearly spot on in my opinion.

Drew Shortis
19 Posted 22/08/2013 at 17:39:34
I happen to agree with the clubs decision to modernize the badge, but the one they come up with was poor and the consultation process was a farce. Many here complain about the poor commercial record of those running the club, but if we don't allow them to do their job we will never improve.

I love the old badge and have grown up jotting it in the back of my school books. However, it does look dated now. The shading looks terrible and the scroll is too intricate. I think the new badge retains the essential elements of the clubs identity, but it just needs to be of a much higher standard of finish. The current one does look like it was designed for Fisher Price!

Looking back at the clubs long history the badge has often not had the tower, laurels, motto or even the shield. If we want to be successful in the future we have to move with the times. I agree the current plan seems a bit rushed, but I think there were many good fan suggestions after the new badge was unveiled and there is no reason why we can't get it right in a short space of time.

Peter Truin
20 Posted 22/08/2013 at 17:48:32
Whatever the redesign it will have 'Everton' and '1878' on it,great..........
Mark Stone
21 Posted 22/08/2013 at 17:53:59
Barry ... whilst Real Madrid have always had a very simple logo, generally the clubs you have mentioned there have streamlined/simplified their badges in recent years, and added the club name and/or year in which the club was created in the badge. You have to wonder why they have done this given that they never have any problem selling shirts etc. I'd say most of them look just as 'cartoonish' as the current Everton one, especially the Italian ones.
Peter Cummings
22 Posted 22/08/2013 at 19:10:27
When I became an Evertonian way back when, there was no shirt badge and the kit looked like it came from a charity shop,but when they came up with the badge everything seemed to change,for the better, and the badge a 'must have' addition.

My attitude to the new version was 'If Its not broke don't fix it', given the overwhelming rejection of the present version I really don't see any changes required when we go back. One suggestion would be to see the addition of a small Blue Liver Bird at the apex of the shield to signify EFC's relationship to our great city

Lyndon Lloyd
23 Posted 22/08/2013 at 19:35:30
Derek: "Lyndon. Why can't we just revert to the original badge?"

Having gone to such lengths to justify scrapping the last one in favour of the much-maligned "beehive" badge, I can't see how the club can simply revert to the previous version, as much as I wish they would.

Robbie Muldoon
24 Posted 22/08/2013 at 20:03:56
People should like at how Crystal Palace rebranded their badge. They have 3 versions. One in a sheild, one out, and one for club merch. All brilliantly done. I just hope the massive Everton isn't on it (make it subtle!) and for me, the 1878 should never be split up and replace the wreaths. Keep the foundation date somewhere tiny.
Kev Johnson
25 Posted 22/08/2013 at 20:38:56
Dear editors,

I wish to bring to your attention the fact that the ad in the top right of the page (or, at least, my page) is currently for "Official Liverpool FC Membership". This strikes me as ever so slightly inappropriate. Perhaps you could look into this matter and consider removing the obscenity in question? Much obliged, kind sirs, much obliged.

Yours sincerely,

Kev Johnson (Everton fan)

Phil Sammon
26 Posted 22/08/2013 at 20:57:18
Mines something about older women looking for a date...and maybe more.
Kev Johnson
27 Posted 22/08/2013 at 20:59:50
Mine are usually, Phil. But the LFC atrocity has to go! Unbelievable!
Greg Dawson
28 Posted 22/08/2013 at 21:01:20
The club is making it very clear that we wont get the only badge back - every comunication from them talks about the problems about mis-representation etc. When the club cam out and said they were sorry and that there would be a process to select a new badge I was worried we would just get railroaded into going with some other daft option and I'd be surprised if that isn't their intention.

When they selcted this crayon-version that we're stuck with now, they would have had 3-10 different version submitted to them - so they already have the options ready to present.

Standard client-sales procedure is that you give the client 3 or 4 options, most of which are worse than the one you want them to pick. To all those who want to keep the old badge, I'd suggest you make Alan Myers aware of the fact that you want it included in the set of badges we can comment on.

By the way, I don't think I've seen that the club say that we get to have a direct vote on it. They'll take our comments and do what they want.

I'd be interested to see what the drop in sales fo club merchandize has been since this new badge has come out. I know of many blues who have refused to buy anything with it on.

Tony Draper
29 Posted 22/08/2013 at 20:32:12
For me, there are certain features which must be included, but most of all, this is not "An Everton Badge"... it is The Crest of Everton Football Club.

It is our banner, our standard, and a single glance at it should instill Everton, history and belonging, in the beholder. It should make the hairs on you neck rgid.

A few years back, I learned some of the "Baggy Green Cap" worn by Autralian Test Cricket players, FFS those buggers make their newbies realise what it stands for. The cap has a number in it, that tells the player how many have gone before. On the first day of a, Test, they all wear their "Baggy Green Cap", except the newbies, 'cos you do not get your cap for being picked, you get it for having played! You don't get two... you only ever get one.

I understand that Everton presently has a reputation for making great effort to make incoming players welcome, and Roberto has shown immense respect for the history of the club. Give the lads a Crest to be proud to play for — not a badge that's cheap and easy to print

1) The shield outline has to remain, I reckon the previous version was about right (the current one looks like one of my very earliest attempts... ie, shit, and the fatarse proportions suggest that we have slumped....ahem).

2) Rupert's Tower needs careful proportioning, get it wrong and we have a pencil stub, a "Guy Fawkes" rocket or a Beehive (as at present)......Despite the fact that the real thing does look a bit like a sandstone beehive (I drive past it frequently). Give it a bit of pomp and glory.

3) 1878, Just because that is when!

4) "Nil Satis Nisi Optimum" (Just because we live now in a society that is txt-spk obsessed is no excuse for the lowest common denominator, otherwise we'll resort to "FTRS LOL")

Things that could be altered...

1) The fire-escape: not real, not symbolic, not essential.

Things that could be included.....

1) Some symbol that only the original 12 Football League members can include. To commemorate our contribution and longevity in establishing this great game.

Matt Doyle
30 Posted 22/08/2013 at 21:13:03
Well since the club has chosen to consider fans' designs, may I chip in with my two bob's worth here (still work in progress):

badge design idea

All comments welcome!

Greg Dawson
31 Posted 22/08/2013 at 21:25:07
I see that they will take a direct vote on the badge. If you want the old badge back let them know that you want it included in the options.
Ross Edwards
32 Posted 22/08/2013 at 21:28:20
We'll still probably be ignored and they'll do something completely different. If they don't like our suggestions, they'll do something to suit themselves.
Ross Edwards
33 Posted 22/08/2013 at 21:29:53
Matt, I'd certainly take yours over our Sheriff's badge with an elf's hat on it any day.
Matt Doyle
34 Posted 22/08/2013 at 21:56:35
Thanks for the positive vote Ross!
Paul Ramsey
35 Posted 22/08/2013 at 22:17:37
The minimum requirement for the club crest is the inclusion of the the tower and the two laurels...after that they have some room for change. But, like many, I would like to see the badge shape and nil satis included also. I have no idea and it makes no logical sense to include EVERTON or 1878. Whenever people see the crest, it will be accompanied by the name in written or spoken word anyway and 1878 has only been recently added to the crest and seems to be the main problem they cite for causing bad reproduction.
Peter Truin
36 Posted 23/08/2013 at 13:45:48
Matt

If you could do something more traditional with the tower I call it a goer but currently it looks too much like the thing we have at present

Tony Draper
37 Posted 23/08/2013 at 16:05:07
Matt, my very first impression looking at your "work in progress" was that the word 'Everton' was being attacked by a genetically modified lobster.

I quite like the tower, but for some reason I'd like it to have a "slate look" roof.

You do retain the Latin motto and the less fussy riband upon which it appears is probably more 21st Century media-friendly and I suppose I could tolerate it, if I had to... but no Heraldic Shield, so I'm not happy.

The Tower, Heraldic Shield and Latin Motto — these features, in my opinion, reinforce our heritage as a football club with very deep roots, one which can proudly point to our contribution to the game worldwide

Also, our Chilean namesakes The Ruleteros, have the Heraldic Shield upon their badge in recognition of Everton, the fact that we inspired their foundation. They are our Blue Blood Brothers, let us never forget that (please).

The laurel wreaths are also symbolic of victory; in my opinion, removing them concedes the opposite of our motto.

Given a simple choice, I would return to the Theo Kelly crest, just with the word EVERTON in the same font as the latin motto above the shield, I feel that this balances off the image.

If the club wants a simple and easily printed "logo" for merchandising then why not do as they frequently do already — use the shield — or, better still, use the very first crest. The shield with EFC intertwined within it?

The club crest should be sacrosanct, immovable and revered.

Harold Matthews
38 Posted 23/08/2013 at 17:30:21
Tony. I'm glad you mentioned Everton de Vina del Mar, "The Ruleteros". Their plain simple badge design, as illustrated on Wiki, is the kind of thing I'd go for.... but that's me. An ex-professional artist and illustrator. My favourite Premiership design would have to be the vertical black, red and white FFC piece.

The history of Everton is locked firmly in my mind and no reminders are necessary.
That said, if twenty odd thousand fans want the history on display then that's the way it will have to go. It means everything to these good people, yourself included of course, and I hope satisfaction is eventually achieved.

Matt Doyle
39 Posted 23/08/2013 at 21:12:19
Sorry for slow reply here, been offline all day.

Thanks for the comments gents.

Tony 572 and Peter 485:

As much as I hold dear the original Theo Kelly badge as much as any Evertonian, I designed this firstly under the premise that the club simply won't revert back to it.

My main goal was to reconfigure as much of the original crest as possible into a self-contained graphic, eliminating the 'floating elements' which the club identified as problematic with the old crest, to maintain the essence of the original design without aping it, and to produce a graphic suitable for the club's branding purposes.

The club's current graphic involved squeezing what it (apparently, wrongly) deemed to be the essential elements of the original badge into the familiar shield shape in a 2D format, hence the loss of the wreaths and motto.

My design maintains what I have deemed to be the essential features of the original badge by organising them onto a 3D grid enabling appropriate emphasis to be given to each.


Sadly I don't think it's viable to reorganise all of the elements of the original badge including the name 'Everton' and '1878' into the original shield - something I'm sure the club has explored in the past, so unfortunately something had to give. The first Everton shirt I owned was the 84/85 Hafnia kit which feaured the tower and wreaths without the shield so maybe that has influenced this design. Given the choice between keeping the wreaths and motto versus keeping the shield, I'd choose wreaths and motto every time. I've not shown this design yet on a shield shape but the outline of my design is intended to maintain some of the character & curvature of the original if not the actual shape. I'll have to admit I didn't factor in the Ruleteros identity when I was working this idea through.
The 'Everton' font - I'm all for changing that, I decided to use the club's current font to maintain as sense of continuity in the branding. The 'Nil Satis' font is my own design but if I were the club I'd have a specialist typographer design all the lettering.
The style of the tower is a tricky one - you have to strike a balance between detail & simplicity. Too simple & it looks childish, too much detail makes the graphic more difficult to reproduce in certain fields - embroidery on shirts for example. I'll probably look into suggesting the mortar joint details - the 'slate roof' look on further revisions.
As for the old 'EFC' in the shield - I fully agree Tony, purely from a design point of view it's a much better graphic than the Theo Kelly badge. If the club decided to revert to this one I'd be all for it!

Matthew Williams
41 Posted 25/08/2013 at 17:07:58
Superb post by Tony Draper. Our crest is very important to all Blues, it should reflect our past & have something to show our longest top flight status on it too. Make it simple but classy like, no fucking cheapskate half-measures, like we have now!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb