Everton begin crest consultation

, 27 August, 65comments  |  Jump to most recent
Questionnaire launches today at evertonfc.com/crest

Everton launch the consultation process today that will give supporters the chance to help shape and select the new official crest.

From today, Evertonians can complete an online questionnaire to provide their thoughts on how they want the new crest to look and also apply to join one of a series of focus groups taking place at Goodison Park.

Plans for how the next crest will be designed and selected were announced last week with the extensive consultation process allowing every supporter the chance to have their say.

In what is a first for the club and a move that is illustrative of Everton's commitment to embracing feedback from its fanbase, supporters will also be able to choose the final design that will be used from the 2014/15 season onwards through an online vote.

Director of Communications Alan Myers, alongside the Club's Senior Executive Team will oversee the entire process with key independent support from Liverpool-based agency Kenyon Fraser.

There are various ways that supporters can get involved in helping to shape the new crest design. They are:

• Online — Supporters can complete a questionnaire at evertonfc.com/crest from today to provide their feedback on how they want the new crest to look and the importance of the individual elements from previous crests. There will also be an option for fans to upload their own designs or sketches.

• Focus groups — A series of focus groups will be set up with representative supporter groups such as Supporters' Clubs, Shareholders, the Fans' Forum, the new Junior Fans' Forum, the Everton Heritage Society and the Everton Former Players' Foundation. Supporters can also register an interest to join a focus group about the new crest at evertonfc.com/crest.

Evertonians will have the chance to submit feedback until Sunday 15 September. Independent of the Club, Kenyon Fraser will collate all the suggestions, ideas and feedback from supporters. They will review, interpret and then create design options for the fanbase to vote on.

Supporters will then have the power to make the final decision when the newly designed crests are presented alongside a detailed explanation of how each one has been developed.

Every Evertonian with a registered customer number, based on ticket purchasing or membership — an estimated 300,000 fans — will be asked to select their favourite design at evertonfc.com/crest.

The results of the vote will be revealed on Thursday 3 October and the new Club crest, shaped and chosen by Evertonians, will appear on all media, buildings, merchandise and, of course, the famous Royal Blue jersey from the 2014/15 season.

Myers said of the process: “I know the fans have been awaiting details of the process to choose the new crest and from listening to them it is clear that they have many ideas on what they want. We will consult with all Evertonians and the crest will be the fans' choice.

“The process allows fans to tell us what they want in their new crest so that a number of options can be created and they can select the best one.

“The 2014/15 crest will be the people's crest, make no mistake about that. All I ask is that the fans trust me, as an Evertonian, to deliver it to them. Every single supporter may not get exactly what they want but they will have the chance to give their input and shape the crest. We will do this together because ‘We are Everton',” he added.

Quotes or other material sourced from Everton FC



Reader Comments (65)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Eric Myles
1 Posted 27/08/2013 at 06:02:08
"Every Evertonian with a registered customer number, based on ticket purchasing or membership — an estimated 300,000 fans — will be asked to select their favourite design at evertonfc.com/crest."

Where do they get the 300,000 fans from?

Where's the questionnaire? It's not at the link provided above?

Phil Sammon
2 Posted 27/08/2013 at 06:36:57
ST holders, Evertonia members...basically anyone who has ever bought a ticket has been allocated a number.
Eric Myles
3 Posted 27/08/2013 at 06:51:29
So are they counting repeat purchases as multiple fans?

Or is that 300,000 over 1 year? 5 years? etc.?

Colin Glassar
4 Posted 27/08/2013 at 07:56:53
I'd rather be consulted over BK's handling of the club, and its finances, and his position as eternal leader.
Phil Sammon
5 Posted 27/08/2013 at 08:08:40
When you buy a ticket (certainly over the phone) they always ask for your customer number or failing that your name and address. So by buying a ticket over the phone you are concenting for them to form an account with your name on it. So no, one ticket, ten tickets, it doesn't matter - you only have one customer number.

I can only imagine they're doing it this way so non-Evertonians can't vote.

Thomas Lennon
6 Posted 27/08/2013 at 08:29:33
The club have been collecting supporter demographics for a few years now which means we now have some decent figures on which to base our claims of numbers of active supporters, potential demand for season tickets/merchandise/marketing returns/saleability of the club even. They were late doing this compared to other clubs (started 2007-9?) but fair do's its is bearing fruit now.

Back in 2010(ish) Elston mentioned that we had had 90 000 people attending the match over the course of one season. That we now can refer to 300 000 is excellent news. Can we fill a 50-55 000 stadium with no restricted views? Probably.

Colin Grierson
7 Posted 27/08/2013 at 09:22:49
I just completed the survey and I wasn't prompted to log in to the site or enter any membership number.
Trevor Thompson
8 Posted 27/08/2013 at 09:45:09
Not sure if Michael or Lyndon have completed the survey, but there's an opportunity to upload an image or sketch as an example of how we would like the crest to look like. I wonder if it's possible for them to upload the crest they have for this website, as I think it's a great example of a traditional crest with a modern feel.
Drew Shortis
9 Posted 27/08/2013 at 09:23:18
Interesting survey. Its clear where they are trying to go with the badge thing and I think they have the right idea. Now they just need to get the execution right. Instantly recognizable, simple but incorporating the key elements of the clubs identity. For me the key elements are the tower, name and 1878 all contained within the shield. If they can find a way to include the laurels and motto without making the shield look cluttered then great.

Personally I'm happy with the concept of the new badge, but the execution is sloppy, the shield is too fat bottomed and the tower is too cartoony giving it a distinct Fisher Price feel. Scale down the size of the name and tower and put 1878 within laurels and the only thing missing is the motto. This has only featured on four of the clubs ten badges and whatever happens it will remain the clubs motto. If this is the one compromise we have to make for a modernized badge that fans can accept and the club can use in its commercial plans then surely we have to go with that.

Steve Birch
10 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:00:30
Here's a link to the questionnaire for those who need it: http://www.evertonfc.com/questionnaire

If they redesign the tower, get rid of 'Everton' from the shield (EFC would suffice) and add the motto then I'd be happy.

Phil Walling
11 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:01:01
When they asked.Roberto , I hear he suggested replacing St.Rupert's Tower with Wigan Pier !
Gerard Cole
12 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:08:01
Just did the survey. Quick and easy. only takes a few minutes. Great way of getting fans thoughts on new design.
Eugene Ruane
13 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:18:17
What was the thread where some TWers posted designs?

There was some fantastic ones there - seem to remember a couple that were real class.

Mike Rourke
14 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:15:54
Well, that all seemed along the right lines, thoughtful and pertinent questions that will no doubt see us end up with a logo that incorporates a masturbating red badger.

What surprised and pained me somewhat was that, after careful consideration, two of my three favourite badges belonged to West 'Aaaam and Spurs.

Matthew Tait
15 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:23:18
The main post seems to have gone, but some good ones in comments in here.

Especially the top one in Lyndon's post at 957, something like that would be ideal. Even something like the Everton version of Arsenal's badge at 881 isn't bad.

Tony J Williams
16 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:24:12
Completed the questionnaire and went back to see if I could do it again. I could.

Could do this as many time as you want I suppose and doesn't stop dickheads filling out stupid ones.

James Marshall
17 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:35:42
There doesn't appear to be any sort of login required, which leaves this open to abuse surely?
Mike Keating
18 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:32:53
Perhaps Kenyon Fraser need to register on ToffeeWeb
They would get a pretty good idea of what the real fans are thinking and it would demonstrate to the Club that we are more than a bunch of moan arses.
Pity they didn't think of this a year ago
Mark Eccles
19 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:35:31
For me its got to be 1938, one that would look brill on a Everton jersey and on stadium and merchandise. What one would you pick out of the examples given?
Jon Withey
20 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:59:53
Would like to see the match-goers and season-ticket holders given a greater say than the internet if possible.
Eugene Ruane
21 Posted 27/08/2013 at 10:36:52
Tony (332) the whole thing unnerved me for a few different reasons.

One being that apart from West Ham's badge, I thought the others were shite and didn't have a 'third favourite'.

I put West Ham, Huddersfield and Burnley - NOT because I think they're great crests, but because they're the least not 'modern and my feeling is our board would basically love an Everton version of a McDonald's logo and to be able to say "You chose it!"

As for the logos bit, that scared me most.

They're logos ffs, I don't HAVE 'a favourite' (or a second or third favourite) and there wasn't the facility to say 'hate them all' and move on.

The further I went through it, the more uncomfortable I felt and I'll say it now - I think the format has been set up in such a way the skew things a certain way.

It reminded me of them trying to choose the colour to paint their hut in Auf Wiedersehen Pet.

They all choose a different colour for first and second choice, but for third choice, 2 of them choose pink.

When pink is announced as the winner Dennis says "So everyone gets what nobody wants?"

Neville (who devised the scheme) responds lamely "Well...that's democracy man".

The 22,500 who voted with their online protests were disgusted that 1) The new crest was an abomination that looked like a (Fisher Price) logo and 2) That the history (ie: latin) had been chucked in the bin.

All that's needed is the right brief, a few new designs by professionals and a vote on a favourite.

I hope I'm dead wrong but nobody can say I'm not justified in being nervous, or in not trusting our board to do the right thing.

James Marshall
22 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:17:43
It's no great surprise that it's skewed toward whatever the club's agenda is on this. I agree with Eugene (again) that the questionnaire is badly loaded, and I hated having to choose a 'favourite' logo such as the evil McDonalds or Nike.

I almost stopped at that point.

They've set it up so that they get a simple, modern design as close to the one they already have, or in fact... the one that they already have.

I share this nervousness.

Matthew Tait
23 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:16:57
I guess this is the thing Eugene. I doubt we all agree on what the 'right thing' actually is.

Some people would like to keep the previous badge, maybe with some tweaks. Some people would like a more radical change. Many think it's crucial that certain elements of the design are retained - the NSNO, or the wreaths, or the 1878, or the club name - but we don't agree on which.

Personally, I'd be fine with a very simplified design, just with the tower (not the ugly new one) surrounded by large wreaths, and EFC or Everton FC underneath. Like the one in comment 957 in this thread (forgot to add it in my last post!): http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/12-13/news/24760.html

But I know that a lot of people would like a more traditional shield-type design, think it's crucial that the NSNO banner is there, etc.

Maybe in the end, if the quality of the design is good (unlike this year's one) then any of these ideas could work.

Mike Rourke
24 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:29:54
For those that are good at this kind of stuff can anyone stick the 1991-2013 Tower into the 1983-91 badge.

Maybe tidy up the laurels too.

For me that would be just about perfect

Peter Jansson
25 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:41:42
To be honest, I think the new logo actually is a nice logo. I can't see the problem with having that logo. What is so bad about it?

It is easy to remember, it is clean and fresh and it has got nice colours.

What would you have said if we went back to the seventies logos? The last time we won the league we had a pretty ugly logo.

Brent Stephens
26 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:47:07
I haven't looked at the survey yet but I'm thinking that if there are several designs to choose from, and the facility to add your own, then EFC might have been pretty cute about this. i.e. a minority might just go for the this season's design but with so many other designs to choose from the remaining majority of votes get fragmented so that the largest vote for any design other than this season's might end up smaller than the "minority" vote for the current crap.

Bloody first past the post. Whatever happened to the alternative voting system?!

Phil Sammon
27 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:56:04
This is just a consultation according to Alan Myres. The vote itself will just be for Evertonians.
Fred Barber
28 Posted 27/08/2013 at 11:52:43
Eugene, it was Barry who devised the vote and said that democracy but I'm nitpicking. Everything you say is spot on. I heard Alan Myers on the radio and it struck me that they're going to put a bunch of hideous designs knowing that the least awful will be the one picked and the one they want. Then they can say we picked it and for that reason I'm not filling in the form.
Conn Prosser
29 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:08:16
Who gives a fuck about the logo. Do the lads wearing the thing play football well? Move on.
Paul David
30 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:07:52
I agree with Eugene, the questions seems to be steered towards the answers the club wants. When the club unveiled the badge, someone on TW put up a dozen or so alternatives with in a couple of days. The club could have put up 20 badges, then the most popular 6 go through to a second vote.
Matt Traynor
32 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:14:57
Conn #363, good point. Who gives a fuck about our useless board and their inability to either sell us or improve our finances? (I see Man City are now looking to buy a team in the A-League to expand their reach). As long as we play well.

Dilapidated stadium with little ability to allow us to maximise our revenues (which would support team building)? Couldn't give a shite, as long as we play a bit.

I can sort of see why they went for the logo they went with - it does fit with the "globalisation" of the game, were history, and tradition and especially latin don't count for shit with the fans in Asia wearing Man City shirts (who 2 years ago had a Chelsea shirt, and 4 years ago had an Arsenal shirt). But the way they went about it was, well, unsurprisingly typical.

I wonder how this announcement will go down well in the US, where NBC - themselves rebranding to NBCSN, have plastered our logo all over the place (trains, taxis etc!)

Tony J Williams
33 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:26:52
Amen Phil.

I'm definitely with Eugene on this, West Ham was my first choice too, I struggled after that one and ended up going with QPR.

It does seem that the questions are very leading, I fear they are leading the answers to simplicity, not to what it represents

Tom R Owen
34 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:25:38
This is a complete joke!
Kenwright is like a combination of a North Korean dictator and the roman emperor who fiddled whilst Rome burned!
As Matt says who cares about a new crest when there are far more important issues.
The man is a disgrace
Eric Myles
35 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:25:30
So over how many seasons have they sold tickets to 300,000 different fans do you think? Sounds like a PR number to me.
Raymond Fox
36 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:30:08
Phil, have been to the doctors yet with your affliction?
Conn Prosser
37 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:32:45
No you're right phil. We really taught the board not to mess about with inconsequential aesthetic bullshit. They came back, cap in hand, ready to spend fucking thousands on consultation, coordination with a cross-section of fan groups, branding experts, designers, reprinting etc etc, because we didn't like it. As for running the club in to the ground, the board are more-or-less unaccountable. How can this situation be changed? Far more important than the badge.
Eric Myles
38 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:39:37
Thanks for the link Steve #319, that link works
Tony J Williams
39 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:54:42
Conn, it can't be changed by internet ranting or naval gazing. Only a buy out can do it. No marches or rallies either.

We can voice our displeasure with the board but ultimately it means nothing.

Chris Rudd
40 Posted 27/08/2013 at 12:59:32
Agree with several posters above that the questions are very 'leading' and aimed at steering the vote a certain way. In my opinion they're desperate for 'heritage with a modern twist' to come out as favourable with a slant towards the 'visually simple'.

This could mean so many different things, visually and be open to 'intended misinterpretation' which the club can happily post rationalise with carefully selected comments from fans.

Personally, I don't want us to look old fashioned but I still want us to look like a traditional football club not a ' franchise or brand' - particularly unhappy to see McDonald's logos and the like even referenced!.

It's easy to say which 'elements' we want retained but gathering them together in a striking, cohesive whole is a job for professionals - I fear the 'vote for your favourite' strategy may end with a 'committee built camel'.

Also, as a creative who's seen this happen many times, I'm very concerned that they'll give weeks to the questionnaire and consultation stage and then the designers will get just a week to put 'something stunning' together.

It's vital that the final execution is put together by someone not only with a clear vision but also the required level of skill and expertise, not the chancers who put the 'Fisher Price' version together.

Fingers crossed but apprehensive.

Phil Sammon
41 Posted 27/08/2013 at 13:15:27
Eric

Like I said, it's not 300,000 fans per season. It's 300,000 customer numbers that have been assigned since their introduction in 2008 (or around then).

I don't think anyone is saying that the badge is more important than the long term future of the club. However it's release brought about thousands of complaints so obviously people do care. We want the badge to suit the club and it doesn't have to be a massively expensive process. If the club hadnt got it so monumentally wrong first time around them all this wouldn't be necessary.

Those protesting the badge should be praised for actually making a difference. If there was a similarly large-scale protest against the board then perhaps it might be reported that 'Our Leader' isn't all he's cracked up to be.

Eugene Ruane
42 Posted 27/08/2013 at 13:08:36
Conn (380) - "As for running the club in to the ground, the board are more-or-less unaccountable. How can this situation be changed? Far more important than the badge".

Of COURSE there are more important issues than the badge/crest, but that is what THIS thread is about.

If you want a thread along the lines "Kenwright is an egotistical, spoofing shit-bag snake-oil salesman and his board are a bunch of self-serving slippery fuck-witted con-men" - then have a look at some of the other letters/columns/articles on TW, or better still, start one yourself.

(although maybe change that title as I've used it before)

And please, no more 'move on', it means nothing unless specifying to what or to where and makes you (anyone!) sound like a some bent politician on Question Time whose argument is falling to pieces - "Look, these are not the important issues, we need to forget I was caught fiddling my expenses and nobbing two hookers while snorting beak off their tits and....move on".

It's like a 6 year-old saying "Stop talking about what YOU want to talk about and talk about what I want to talk about!" (to which my personal response would always be, 'get fucked you little cun..!')

Kevin Tully
43 Posted 27/08/2013 at 13:26:41
BK & RE Transfer budget meeting No. 224 - Elstone: "Bill, If we don't sell anyone, we will be outspent by almost everyone in the the division for this summer, even Hull & Cardiff FFS! Y'know that BU mob will be right on to this?"

Bill: "Never mind that, let the soft bastards pick the new badge for next year, that'll shut them up for a while. Have you sorted the bouncy castle & march for Roberto yet?"

Rupert Sullivan
44 Posted 27/08/2013 at 14:34:58
It is unfortunate I think, that a club which indulges its fan base as Everton are seemingly doing via the crest consultation process can find themselves in a position of lose-lose. However, I think that in this case, that is exactly where Everton FC find themselves.

Having shot themselves in the foot with the image re-branding, like all organisations conscious of their external image they have tried to take the negative and turn it to a positive – asking the very fans who complained to contribute. This activity, where properly done represents the perfect opportunity to ask the fans only the questions you want to ask, and to elicit only the answers you want – thus asking your fanbase to validate the decisions you have already made!

A quick look at the questionnaire on the EFC website suggests to me that this is what EFC have done - and although I disagree with this as a valid process, I find myself actually admiring the fact that it has been done well. We are being asked to order our priorities for the elements of a crest – allowing EFC to justifiably say that '90% of you indicated that the motto was the least important part...' We are further being asked to identify with a non-EFC logo, and they have chosen the logos very well indeed, selecting shiny, modern, simple logos and comparing them to complicated and ugly logos.

All in all, we are being led by the hand to confirm that a new crest should be simple and should not contain all those complicated bits that have already been removed. Like I said, for once it is well done to the EFC marketing team...

Except...

Have you tried to see how many times you can contribute? Have you checked to see if you need to be logged in to the EFC website to complete the survey?

This survey – ostensibly for Everton Fans to complete, can be completed by anybody, and as many times as they like. There are no checks, no need to log in, no captcha to stop bots from reporting answers.

At whom therefore is this survey aimed? Are Everton aiming at EFC fans or at anyone who has an internet connection and 2 minutes to spare?

Please Everton, try to do something wholly right – if anyone can complete this survey and as many times as they like, what fucking good is it?
Karl Masters
45 Posted 27/08/2013 at 14:51:18
What annoys me about this is that those badges are SHIRT badges, NOT the Official Club crest.

The crest has always basically been the one portrayed as 1938. Sometimes it's been portrayed on the shirt, sometimes it hasn't.

Just keep the Club crest as the original ( the 1991-2000 shirt badge basically ) and design a new badge for the shirt. Funnily enough, the shirt badge I like is the one that only lasted for one season, 30 years ago, designed by Umbro and replaced by Le Coq's version when we changed kit supplier in 1983.

Like the Kirkby vote, the wording of the questions can easily skew the survey. So, yes I am a bit nervous about how this will end up.

Brent Stephens
46 Posted 27/08/2013 at 16:36:35
Noticed that the giant crest on the side of the Main Stand at the Park End includes NSNI.

Eugene Ruane
47 Posted 27/08/2013 at 16:23:22
Rupert Sullivan (405) - "This activity, where properly done represents the perfect opportunity to ask the fans only the questions you want to ask, and to elicit only the answers you want – thus asking your fanbase to validate the decisions you have already made!"

Exactly and believe me, EVERY word will have been considered and debated.

Basically it's sleight-of-hand.

I mean imagine if I wanted the badge to be (more or less) as it was and I put forward the following survey - it would, on the face of it, just be asking for your preferences.

Nevertheless it is DEFINITELY skewed to obtain the result I want.

Do you think the historical latin motto is A) Important to show our heritage, or B) Old fashioned?

Do you prefer A) The traditional Everton laurels, or B) No laurels?

Would you like to A) Keep the design of tower as it has remained virtually unchanged since 1938, or B) A new modern shape?

Here are some logo's (same logos). Do you find them A) Cold, corporate, associated with greed, or B) Great, love them.

Etc etc.

Robert Penlington
48 Posted 27/08/2013 at 16:54:32
Colin Glassar #294 ' I'd rather be consulted over BK's handling of the club, and its finances, and his position as eternal leader'

Totally agree Colin.

Where's the £24M TV money Kenwright?

Rupert Sullivan
49 Posted 27/08/2013 at 16:56:24
Eugene (434) - of course, and I even have a grudging respect for that. I would expect it given the club, league and money involved. (Had they not done that, I'm sure someone would have accused them of naivety.) What I don't understand however, is how they can allow open access to this 'survey' to all and sundry with no checks to prevent re-submission or bots. I don't understand; not because an open survey is easier to manipulate - this allows EFC to add as many responses as they wish after all - I don't understand because basically now anyone who disagrees with the final result can attack the format of the survey - I mean, why would an Evertonian want their club crest to be designed by a Tottenham fan?!? Nice one EFC!

Hey ho - I suppose by now we should expect better.

James Marshall
50 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:04:20
So we're pretty much universally agreed then? The questionnaire is fully loaded and ultimately a bit pointless. The board will basically get the answers they want, we'll be told to kick-back as we've had our say.... and they'll continue to go with the new crest they've already implemented.

What a surprise.

As someone said above, now (or in a year) would be a really bad time to change things, especially given that we're plastered all over the US and our presence there appears to be a huge part of the PR push.

Oh well, at least we're playing sparkling football and winning games...

Mike Allison
51 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:12:04
The final question of the survey sums up the basic problem.

The club wants a corporate logo.

We want a football club's badge.

These are not the same thing.

Karl Masters
52 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:53:15
I don't see why they can't keep the 1938 badge and use it on buildings, shirts, stands, souvenirs etc and have a corporate logo they use as and when required. Adidas use two different logos, the original trifoil and the more recent sloping three stripes and they don't have an identity issue do they?
Harold Matthews
53 Posted 27/08/2013 at 16:52:04
Karl. Good point. These are official crests.
Does the shirt badge have to be an exact replica? I was very fond of the crest which has recently been replaced but never liked it on the shirt.
Ross Edwards
54 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:04:41
"Kenwright is like a combination of a North Korean dictator and the roman emperor who fiddled whilst Rome burned!"

Kim Jong Nero Bill! Throw Caligula in the mix. He thought he was loved by everyone as well.

Mark Taylor
55 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:03:14
In my experience, enterprises that fiddle around with their logo are often doing so as a kneejerk reaction to other more fundamental problems, which certainly aren't going to be solved by designing a new 'look'. It's a case of fiddling while Rome burns and is often the precursor to the enterprise going bust.

In our case, I hope it isn't just a 'bread and circuses' distraction, while Bill sells Fellaini and shovels most of the proceeds into our financial black hole.

As an aside, I agree with other posters that a badge and a logo are not the same thing. Nor did I think the survey was especially helpful in asking for opinions on logos not even remotely connected to the task in hand. Everton are a founder member of the league so history and heritage is a major strength. That would not be at all the case for brands like Apple or Nike, whose logos are excellent, but irrelevant to our position.

Tony Draper
56 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:52:59
Everton's club crest is an expression and summary of what we are and where we came from

It needs to evoke Everton for Evertonians and for our opponents too

And though I always enjoy and respect the overwhelming majority of what Harold says (and take into account his professional eye as an artist), I don't agree with a shirt badge being different to the club crest, for me they are identical

A merchandising badge ? Fine, that I do agree with and in fact think that the 1920 Crest is almost perfect in that regard because it is much more versatile, and although the merchandise is official surely it is not in the same league as the treasured "Royal Blue Jersey" ?

Anthony Manning
57 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:14:10
I wouldn't mind the liverbird being added, it's a global image from a global city that our club is from, not the version LFC use but are own version and before people have a pop check the history books we used the bird first.
Mike Green
58 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:16:42
The club are damned if they do, they’re damned if they don’t with an exercise like this, but I’m with Eugene and many others that it feels like something’s a little rotten in Denmark here.

There’s a definite feel of “rigged” about it to me. Why?

As I went through the questionnaire I had the unnerving feeling that my answers were on paper voting for the “new crest”, but I don’t like the “new crest” so how does that work….?

I went for Wolves and VW for their “Simplicity”, “Instantly Recognisability” and something else I cant remember – all of which I could see a marketing executive grinning and saying to me “See, that’s what we’ve done with the new crest, can you see it now….? We were right all along…thank you for eventually agreeing with us….don’t worry, it was just a reaction to change….you’ll get used to it and like much more than the last crest once you do….trust us…”

It feels like the design agency have had a right kick in the nuts from the backlash, the club have said to them “earn your fee and sort it” and they’ve gone “right we’re going to have to spell it out to this lot Janet and John style…..but lets be right, this is Round 2 and we’re going to bill you again Bill…our expertise doesn’t come for free…”

I’m no graphic designer / marketing guru but the biggest reason I’m uncomfortable with it is the timescales set by the club.

The process starts today, consultation ending in roughly 3 weeks.

A week after that the designs are announced ready for the vote, which lasts a week.

Two days later the new crest is revealed.

All seems very quick to me, as if in the background the options are already set, just a few things can be added here and there depending on our answers if they fit into what the club are looking for.

I think we will inevitably be voting for one of a number of crest in just over a month, already pretty much determine now, none of which really meet what anyone wants and none of which we can object to to the same extent as the last offering because a) we were consulted and b) 8 out of 10 respondents said at this point of the questionnaire that……they wanted simplicity….

I just want them to get it right, and though I enjoyed doing the exercise, I decidedly felt that I was being “played”. Roll on 23rd September and we’ll see what they put on the table……

Damned if they do, damned if they don’t, but if they put 6 abominations on the table we shouldn’t settle for the “least worst”.

By definition – only the best will do.

Anthony Washington
59 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:55:37
One thing I would like adding to the shirt (underneath the badge) would be the number of the player to have represented Everton in chronological order like they do in Cricket (if this is possible at all). This to me would add to the pride of playing for Everton and would also be a unique feature.
Keith Edmunds
60 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:37:18
I'd be interested to know which of the other clubs badges were favoured.

I went for Arsenal.

Sean McCarthy
61 Posted 28/08/2013 at 02:37:34
Brent #429.... is the Latin motto so important to you that you abbreviate it to NSNO??

Jamie Sweet
62 Posted 28/08/2013 at 02:23:35
I completely agree with many views above - the questionnaire has been designed to provide the answers they want to hear.

They start with all the right questions regarding the heritage of the club and what is important to us... only to then skew the final collection of questions towards logos that have "simplicity" and are "instantly recognisable" like the Nike swoosh.

"After consulting 300,000 Evertonians, via a series of very leading questions, we can only conclude that the type of logo they really want, is the one that we've just nailed to the main stand."

Mike Green
63 Posted 28/08/2013 at 07:17:43
Jamie #700 - your final paragraph sums it up perfectly, nice one.
Harold Matthews
64 Posted 28/08/2013 at 17:14:33
Tony D @ 521. It was just a thought tossed out to catch a reaction.
My training and experience in this field would not go down too well with the majority of fans because my first venture into the design world taught me to never give anyone a choice. Not even the choice of two. It leads to chaos.
However, the new Everton crest was a different scenario because the people most effected ..ie..the fans, did not request it. Some "not very wise" person took a chance and it backfired.

Eugene, Mike, Jamie and co are right of course. Apart from the dodgy questionnaire, there are persuasive snippets and photos all over the place. It's their job. It's what they do.
Personally, whatever the outcome, I will be supporting the most popular crest.

Eric Myles
65 Posted 29/08/2013 at 06:10:51
Brent #429, did the useless lumps spell it wrong?
Matt Traynor
66 Posted 29/08/2013 at 06:49:00
Eric #153, if you somehow have one of our old Salmon Pink / Blue striped away shirts from the early 90s, take a close look at the spelling of the motto...

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb