Barkley gets first senior England call-up

, 27 August, 118comments  |  Jump to most recent
Ross Barkley has been rewarded for his impressive start to the 2013-14 Premier League season with a call-up from Roy Hodgson to the senior England squad.

The 19 year-old will join teammates Phil Jagielka and Leighton Baines for the upcoming World Cup qualifiers against Moldova and Ukraine.  



Reader Comments (118)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brent Stephens
1 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:54:25
Well done, lad. I saw him last season in U-21 games as well as limited time in 1st XI and didn't think he was quite ready. Suddenly very excited by the prospects.
Garry Corgan
2 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:56:37
Well done to Ross but surely this is an indictment of how much of a state English football is in ... A couple of good games and an impressive goal and you get a call up.

Ross could be a massive England player in future but it's sad that, as a country, we have so few experienced, top-level, world class midfielders.

Brent Stephens
3 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:59:34
Garry, you are only allowed to say that if it's Ossie being called up.
Ross Edwards
4 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:00:09
Congratulations Ross.
Matt Traynor
5 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:01:10
Great, will add a couple of £m on to his price as he's no doubt tapped up in that dressing room. £2m extra if it's Arsenal. £20m extra if it's Man U. Mind you why would he go and play for someone who never thought he was good enough last season? Or was that a ploy to artificially deflate the fee!

All joking aside, I hope he gets a game, and plays well. If he links up well with Rooney that will have the pundits going into over-drive.

Mark Rankin
6 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:04:44
Madness
Bill Gall
7 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:02:07
Congratulations Ross glad al least Englands manager is aware of what an impressive young player you are.

Glad OFM not england manager.

Phil Sammon
8 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:56:55
Well done to the kid, but I can't help be a little depressed. One good game and you're in the England team it seems.

It just seems so ill-planned. We hand out debuts to 19 year olds and 31 year olds. Shouldn't we be building for the future, rather than cobbling together players like we have done for decades?

If you're going to pick the next generation then surely they should all be coming into the team and playing together - not just the two lads who've played well the previous week.

Barkley, Stones, Townsend, Phil Jones, Smalling, Sturridge, Oxlaide-Chaimberlain, Wilshire...these are the players we should be looking to. Write off the next tournament as experience for these guys and plan for the future.

Gerrard, Lampard, Terry, Cole, Johnson, Rooney - this lot have had their chances and blown them.

Move on!

Raymond Fox
9 Posted 27/08/2013 at 17:59:49
My thoughts exactly Garry.
I'm very pleased for the lad, and he will be a top player one day, the call-up is probably to give him a taste of the senior England set up.

I just hope it doesn't turn his head too much, I'm sure RM will keep his feet on the ground and tell him he's some way to go yet.
Too soon for me.

Tom Bowers
10 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:07:01
Give Hodgson his due he gives players a chance instead o the same old brigade being picked game in game out.
Players like Lampard, Gerrard and Barry have had their time and to be quite honest I don't think any of them performed at England level as consistantly as they did at club level.
The new lads such as Cleverly, Wilshere and now Barklay are going to be the young guns for the next world cup finals.
I am not totally sold on Welbeck being international class but like the fact that Lambert is getting another chance despite his age.
Would have liked to see Stones get a shot at right back as Glen Johnson is very suspect.
Derek Knox
11 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:00:05
Just imagine if he had scored a hat trick at Norwich Garry, he would no doubt, not only be gaining his first senior cap, but be getting considered as captain. I am really happy for the lad, and wish him well.
Slightly off thread, but it is similar to the situation with Gareth Bale, he is doubtless a good footballer, but basically he has had a great season, and scored some brilliant goals. Now he is on the threshold of becoming the World's most expensive transfer to Real Madrid.
Funny old game!
Harold Matthews
12 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:04:21
He's now where he belongs. Overcoming a triple legbreak to now being in the full England squad is a massive achievement and a measure of his character.
Makes me proud to be blue.
Dick Brady
13 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:19:04
I agree 2 games and he gets on England call-up? Because he inspired Everton to two shite draw's against relegation tipped teams?

Don't get me wrong the lad might have a great future ahead and in the 2 games he's been one of Everton's better players but still all this shows is how desperate England have become for players.

I fear all this call-up will do is fasttrack Barkley to a big move to City or Utd. (Probably City because Moyes was never that big on Barkley).

Paul Andrews
14 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:18:08
An absolute certainty to be a top class midfielder in the near future.
Why not give him half an hour,the lad obviously knows how good he is.
Imo the better the standard of his team mates the better he will express himself.
Imagine a partnership of Ross and Wiltshire in the future.
Good on you kid,you have been released from the shackles of the mingebag.
Go for it
Ross Edwards
15 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:25:55
You never stop do you Dick? We know you are disappointed about our start, but you don't have to go on and on, and on about how bad it is.
Ciarán McGlone
16 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:26:46
silly decision.
Paul Andrews
17 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:27:33
You are right Dick.
Lets put him in the reserves and play all the games behind closed doors
Kieran Fitzgerald
18 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:27:23
Phil Sammon, that would be the obvious and sensible thing to do. France did it, Germany did it, Spain did it. England will always have enough quality, and a decent seeding, to get them to a tournament. Forget all the chest thumping nonsense about winning the next tournament and just develop a proper squad.

Dick Brady
19 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:29:13
Ross there aint no certainties in football.

Go ask Francis Jeffers about his career. Or his mate Michael Ball.

In fact go ask Jack Rodwell how his career is doing.

Raymond Fox
20 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:27:32
By the way Dick, last year West Brom 8th and Norwich finished 11th in Prem.+ they have strengthened well this year!
Hardly relegation material.
Tony Draper
21 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:25:24
Very proud that once again Everton have a youngblood in the England squad

New manager brings new luck and opportunity.

I'd really like Ross to be dishing it up regularly in our Royal Blue Jersey, but it will be great experience and can only add to his learning. Contrarily, I hope that he doesn't get a game. That will keep him hungry and fire his determination for Everton.

Proud for you Ross son, keep up the good work

Mark Frere
22 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:23:55
An absolute pathetic decision from Hodgson. Barkley should be left alone to establish himself as a first team regular for us.

What ever happened to players earning the right to wear the England shirt? Young players get too much money too soon, and they get called into the England senior side too soon - this all leads to a player thinking he's made it before he actually has.

Don't get me wrong I think Barkley has an incredible future ahead of him, but FFS! Leave him to develop.

Nick Entwistle
24 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:31:44
Good for him. But I don't understand 19 year olds being called up for England. Unless you have Rooney like talent of course.

There's a litany of young kids called up for England, they're already millionaires, famous around town, and think they've made it.

If players are held back from international duty until they've put in a solid four or five years of quality in the PL, which is a higher level, then they know they've earned their place.

All this does is allow some players to think they've made it with club England and the usual dross follows where they can't be arsed in friendlies and wilt in the championship tournaments.

Paul Andrews
25 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:36:02
I remember another 18 year old who made his debut for England.
Fucked his career right up.
Wayne something or other?
Dick Brady
26 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:35:42
I don't get why Roberto is so obsessed with signing a midfielder.

It seems likely that Roberto will bring in McCarthy or Kuzmanovic or Marrone.

So once you have Gibson fit and the new midfielder signed where does that leave young Ross?

On the bench waiting for Gibson to get injured and hoping he gets the nod ahead of Osman?

Dick Brady
27 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:39:50
I totally agree Paul. Wayne Rooney is half the player he should have been.

When he left Everton Wayne Rooney was tipped to be the best player in the world.

He's good but its laughable to think of him in the same class as Messi, Ronaldo or even Bale.

I totally think Wayne Rooney got everything too young and he's half the player he should have been.

Dick Brady
28 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:39:50
I totally agree Paul. Wayne Rooney is half the player he should have been.

When he left Everton Wayne Rooney was tipped to be the best player in the world.

He's good but its laughable to think of him in the same class as Messi, Ronaldo or even Bale.

I totally think Wayne Rooney got everything too young and he's half the player he should have been.

Ross Edwards
29 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:41:55
Gibson is injury prone, Osman is crap, we need depth in the defensive midfield position Dick. Plus, if you hadn't noticed, Moyes is sniffing around Fellaini.
Paul Andrews
30 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:44:08
Dick,

Bollocks my friend.
Best English footballer since Paul Gascoigne.
Absolute genius

Andy Crooks
31 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:47:04
Sir Alf Ramsay is spinning in his grave.
Dick Brady
32 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:47:11
Paul

TWO World Cup. Not a single goal.

At least Shearer and Lineker picked up Golden Boots.

Ross Edwards
33 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:46:25
Maybe Rooney was unfortunate in the fact that his career coincided with the rise of Messi, Ronaldo, Barcelona and players like Neymar.

Rooney would grace any team in the world right now. Just that no one wants him.

Ross Edwards
34 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:48:32
Dick, you say that, but Messi under performed massively in the last World Cup.
Dick Brady
35 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:50:42
Wayne Rooney is a good player but at no time in his career has he been considered the World's Best player.

You cannot put him near the class of Messi, Ronaldo, Neymar or Bale. Even Robin Van Persie makes Rooney look average.

Go back to the 16/17 year old Rooney who played for Everton and its criminal how much potential Rooney never fulfilled.

Mark Jones
36 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:55:56
As much as I love Barkley and think he'll be a top player in future, it highlights how weak England are right now that a massively inexperienced player has got a callup for World Cup qualifiers based on the last three weeks. It used to take players years to play their way into an England squad.

On another note, my predicted team for Stevenage: Robles, Hibbert, Stones, Jagielka, Oviedo, Osman, Heitinga, Deulofeu, Naismith, Anichebe, Kone.

Jamie Barlow
37 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:58:32
Bale shouldn't even be in that list of players Dick. The games gone fuckin mad with the amount of money being spent on him. I hope he turns out to be shit.
Brent Stephens
38 Posted 27/08/2013 at 18:57:50
Dick #481 "Because he inspired Everton to two shite draw's against relegation tipped teams?"

The draws might have been shite - you saying Barkley was?!

"I fear all this call-up will do is fasttrack Barkley to a big move to City or Utd. (Probably City because Moyes was never that big on Barkley)".

Bit of a contradiction, there? He's shite but MC would buy him!

Ross Edwards
39 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:02:12
Spot on Jamie. If Bale is worth £86 million, that must make Messi worth over £200 million. Bale has had 2 good seasons in his career. It's disgraceful.

How much do you think Maradona and Pele would be worth today? I believe well over £300 million.

Dick Brady
40 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:05:14
Brent

Man City bought Rodwell and he's shite.

But no I think Barkley has been one of Everton's better players so far and I think he has potential to be a great player one day.

But England call-up after 2 games? Laughable.

Ross Edwards
41 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:09:03
Well, Dick, Hodgson managed the U21s against Scotland, where Barkley was impressive, so he must see something in him.
Brent Stephens
42 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:11:09
Dick #516 - MC bought Tevez, Silva, Aguero... and they are shite?
Ross Edwards
43 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:13:20
He said Rodwell was Brent, not City.
Brent Stephens
44 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:13:57
Ross, his initial post made no ref to Rodders. He said all this would fast track Ross to a "big move" - to MC or MU.
Paul Andrews
45 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:16:39
Wayne Rooney only the fifth best player in the world?
Fuckin no mark
Jamie Barlow
46 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:17:31
I've no idea what they'd be worth Ross. I reckon I must be worth at least £2 million though. He isn't 43 times better than me.
Dick Brady
47 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:44:33
Paul

Rooney isn't the fifth best player in the world. He's not even the fifth best player in the Premiership.

I place Rooney Top 20 in the Premiership, Top 50 in the World.

Dick Brady
48 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:44:33
Paul

Rooney isn't the fifth best player in the world. He's not even the fifth best player in the Premiership.

I place Rooney Top 20 in the Premiership, Top 50 in the World.

Ross Edwards
49 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:48:03
List the players above him in the PL Dick.
Patrick Murphy
50 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:48:49
Dick who are your top 5 Everton players? Which is the best game you have attended? Who scored the goals in that remarkable comeback at Selhurst Park? Have you ever been to Instanbul?
Bill Gall
51 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:28:07
I can not see why people are saying it is to soon for a England first team call up when he has played at every level for England before.

How many players, x players,managers and supporters have stated what an exeptiomal talent this boy is.

Naming other young players who have not lived up to expectations before does not mean he is going to fail.

What this call up will mean is a chance to get experience in the England set even if he does not play in the upcoming games.

As far as Everton goes I believe RM will not play him in every game but he will play in over 75% of games and speculating that he will be dropped to the bench if certain players are fit or bought is simply ignoring the talent this boy has.

Everton are deviod of midfield talent and Ross is definitely a player who can be a big part of solving this.

Colin Glassar
52 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:47:00
No wonder England will never win anything. He's played twice in the prem this season and he's called up already. If he plays and doesn't do well then the southern press will rip him apart like they did with Bainsey. Remember the lies they spread about him being a homesick baby? I'd rather Ross learnt his trade with us and the U21's first before being thrown to the wolves.
Brent Stephens
53 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:52:31
Colin, he won't start the game or even get a long time on the pitch, surely. Won't it be just to slowly ease him in?
Colin Williams
54 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:36:54
Dick-516 your talking a load of shit! If your good enough, your old enough!!!!!
Ross may have only had 20 prem games and two this season but the lad is a huge talent and all top coaches/ managers dream of finding players of his talent.
The England manager is a top coach and coached all over the world and he knows when he finds a special talent. Instead of moaning and talkin bollocks, you should be chuffed to bits about this special talent developed in our fantastic academy.
Let's just hope we can build a team around all our talented players and progress into the champions league.
Paul Andrews
55 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:55:51
Dick,
Go on then name the 19 in front of him in the prem?
Colin Glassar
56 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:55:22
Brent I get your point but I distinctly remember Baines, Jagielka and Rodwell all being picked on by the media when they first joined up with England. The insinuation being that by playing for Everton they were somehow, not good enough. Tony Cascarino was one pundit who constantly complained about Baines and Jagielka not being int'l standard.
In the case of young Ross I would definitely prefer to protect him for another season if we are not careful, all the daily rags will be linking him with their beloved top four teams before long.
Peter Jones
57 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:56:32
Congratulations Ross! No way he drops to the bench for Osman now when Gibson returns, which should be enough to get a standing ovation from ToffeeWeb regulars.
Paul Thompson
58 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:59:38
It does seem a bit premature, but Hodgson saw him close up recently when he managed the under 21s against Scotland in which Ross was outstanding. I think that Hodgson sees Ross as the kind of player who can make things happen, which is vital at international level, not one of the journeymen who get occasional call ups and never seen again (including Osman, unfortunately, though he did ok). He won't start of course, but may get off the bench if England are desperate and need that 'something' to happen.
Brent Stephens
59 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:03:32
Colin G - yes, I take your point about the media knives. Though your last bit implies the reverse - that he'll do so well that they'll start to link him to top 4? The latter I wouldn't mind.
Ian Butchard
60 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:18:05
It's ridiculous, hopefully he is just there to gain some experience, and wont be considered for the team/bench
Raymond Fox
61 Posted 27/08/2013 at 19:52:08
As far as Rooneys concerned, which other world class forward does as much tackling back as Wayne has always done?
He must have saved England from conceding many goals and Man Utd, god knows how many.

The guys his own worst enemy, hes probably that knackered with all the running around, that he cant always do himself justice when in front of goal!
His all round contribution is great for any team he plays for, a move to another club with a manager that would advise him to concentrate on attack, would do him a world of good.

John Malone
62 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:10:37
Only concern is it might get to the lad's head, just hope he takes it as reward for his good performances an it spurs' him on to perform well every week. Hope he does well if he get's his chance but fingers crossed he doesn't score can't imagine the media hype and attention he'd get.
Paul Gladwell
63 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:17:05
Too early or not he can only learn from this experience, that's what we have been crying out for haven't we, getting the lad used to the top level?
Colin Glassar
64 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:24:44
Brent, my point being if he goes to one of the manc clubs or Chelsea then he has a god given right to be in the England squad, a la Wilshere, and any mistakes made he is forgiven. Playing for non-fashionable Everton I'd he makes a mistake they'll crucify him. I remember one of Bainsey's first games for England when gerrard left him continuously exposed and the pundits all tore him apart. It wasn't a case of Stevie me not helping Baines but Baines being a crap LB who wasn't fit to lace Ashley's boots.
Phil Sammon
65 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:24:54
I'll have a go Paul...

No particular order.

1. Van Persie
2. Aguero
3. Bale
4. Suarez
5. Yaya Toure
6. Hazard
7. Mata
8. Silva

That's about it for 'certs'. Difficult to compare defenders obviously but I'd have Kompany in there.

Paul Andrews
66 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:48:44
I wouldn't take any of them in front of Rooney Phil.
On all of their best days,he does them all.
Barry Lambert
67 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:15:58
Well done, Ross. Good luck to you. A bit surprised but what the hell. As usual the same contributors post objective and intelligent comments. On the flipside we get the same prophets of doom posting their same old negative crap.

Yes everyone's entitled to their opinion which validates the point of having a forum but just be proud for the lad and the club. Stop bleating about who you think is going to come in for him. Would you prefer him to play crap to avoid outside interest? Would you have preferred Fellaini and Baines to play with their boots on the wrong feet?
This selection will do the lad's confidence a power of good. Something that two-faced Judas would never have given him. You have to give genuine talent playing time. You have to let them make mistakes and learn their trade. RM's rose-tinted glasses can't hurt his cause either. This boy has enormous potential. Enjoy it!

Ciarán McGlone
68 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:54:01
Agreed Paul..There's very few premiership players who I'd take above Rooney - in fact, only one that springs to mind is Thierry.
Tom Winek
69 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:49:56
I'm with Dick. He's top 15-20 at best. Media love him. He's never backed up his reputation consistently. Had the odd exceptional season but mostly average for a forward playing at the best team in the league over the last 10 years. Runs a lot though I'll give him that.
Phil Sammon
70 Posted 27/08/2013 at 20:59:02
Really?!

Wow, fair enough.

I like Rooney but I agree with Dick to some degree. He certainly didn't turn into the type of player I thought he would when I first saw him. When he was 16/17 he was driving past players, throwing grown men off the ball. Nowadays he barely takes a man on. Perhaps it's where he's asked to play. He doesn't suit this quarterback role he quite often takes up. I think the best thing for him would be to move to Chelsea and get back that fire in his belly. Get him up front and terrorising defenders.

Nick Entwistle
71 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:06:14
Nah, he's a tub of ice cream. At his age he should be doing what we all expected, but its like he's taken on the Pirlo role 6 years too early. The last time Rooney went past someone was in his Range Rover. Shit joke. Sorry.
Brent Stephens
72 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:12:00
Colin G - ah, ok, I see what you're saying about media and top 4. Too true.
Paul Andrews
73 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:14:33
Nick,
If he's a tub of ice cream you are a Cornish Mivvi
Steve Guy
74 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:17:14
There are some right negative bar stewards about ! This is brilliant !!! Ross B was held back by a career threatening injury and clearly has had the mental toughness to come out the other side. His conduct off and on the pitch has been exemplary. Roy H clearly sees him as one for the future in which case he needs to be eased into the international scene at full level. It's not as if he has never played International football and has excelled at each level. We now have three England internationals at the club ( four if you include Osman's cameos. Virtually all our players play for their respective countries. The future in this regard is rosy.
Steve Guy
75 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:17:14
There are some right negative bar stewards about ! This is brilliant !!! Ross B was held back by a career threatening injury and clearly has had the mental toughness to come out the other side. His conduct off and on the pitch has been exemplary. Roy H clearly sees him as one for the future in which case he needs to be eased into the international scene at full level. It's not as if he has never played International football and has excelled at each level. We now have three England internationals at the club ( four if you include Osman's cameos. Virtually all our players play for their respective countries. The future in this regard is rosy.
Tony J Williams
76 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:24:05
Made up for the kid but it's a bit daft that he has a call up after two games, especially considering that if Gibson was fit he probably wouldn't have started.
James Stewart
77 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:18:27
If your good enough your old enough. It's about time an England manager starting picking youth and having an actual progression of players from the u21's to the full side.

I fail to see the point in picking players like Osman or Lambert now. It's not like they will be any use in 2/4 years time.

Jim Knightley
78 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:26:13
I think more than 10 players out performed Rooney last season... his one good season, and then one less so pattern, is not indicative of a truly world class player. When did Messi, or Ronaldo, or Iniesta have a bad season? or even the likes of Fabregas and RVP. And as for him being the best player since Gascoigne...has he been better than Gerrard really? and Lampard? and Cashley?

Personally I think this is mental. I expect he will sit on the bench, and get to meet the players. Will be nice for him though. I've problems with his naivety, which I believe will rear its head again soon, but he has been superb for us in the first couple of games. Really bodes well for the long term.

And Lambert is picked, because he should be part of our squad at the world cup. There's alot of references to the 'if you are good enough, you are old enough' mantra on here, and I think 'if 'you are good enough, you are not too old' should similarly apply. Di Natalie has proved that, and, rather unbelievably, Luca Toni did too at the weekend.

Phil Sammon
79 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:29:17
I've heard people say things like, "Lambert deserves hi call-up."

That says it all for me. England caps are now awarded simply to players who have had a few good games. Instead of looking at what these players 'deserve' how's about we start acting in the best interests of the English national team. We are not going to win anything for at least 5 years so why not start looking ahead and planning for the future. Out with the old, tried, tested and failed lot and lets start again.

Jamie Barlow
80 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:36:09
I think it's great for the lad but i'd rather none of our players played for their countries to be honest. Not because they're not good enough. Purely for selfish reasons.

We could have 3 Everton players on the pitch at he same time for England. I wonder when that last happened.

Phil Sammon
81 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:42:35
And as for Roy picking players on merit...how on Earth has Ashley Young got in the squad?
Colin Glassar
82 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:48:16
I can't find a Stevenage thread so here goes, I see the rs are suffering against notts co. So we'd better not take Stevenage lightly then.
Phil Sammon
83 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:42:35
And as for Roy picking players on merit...how on Earth has Ashley Young got in the squad?
Kieran Fitzgerald
84 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:49:47
Paul Andrews, what's a cornish miwi and should I mention it in front of the in laws?

On a serious note I think that Rooney never fulfilled his full potential. Van Persie is carrying that Utd team at the moment, not Rooney. Rooney's head hasn't been right in years. Imagine how petulant he could have become if he didn't have Ferguson to keep some kind of manners on him.

Dick Brady
85 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:42:15
I never said Wayne Rooney was number 20. I said he was in the Top 20. He could be 17 or 18 or even 14.

But there are definitely 10 players better then Wayne Rooney in the Premiership.

In no particular order, Premiership players who are better then Wayne Rooney.

Gareth Bale, Robin Van Persie, Luis Suarez, Nemanja Vidic, Vincent Kompany, Jack Wilshere, Juan Mata, Eden Hazard, David Silva, Oscar & Christian Benteke.

Then you have players like Steven Gerard and Frank Lampard who are past their best but for most of their careers outshone Rooney.

Is it too early to call Roberto Soldado? He hasn't even kicked a ball but Willian is gonna be better undoubtedly.

You know its a tough call but possibly even Leighton Baines.

Phil Walling
86 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:59:17
Dick,at least you could be modest enough to say all that was 'in your humble opinion'!
Alan Smith
87 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:54:13
I just pray he has a bad season, plays like Pirlo, scores 16 goals in 37, and wins the prem. It might be really bad and he'll go on to only score 8 in his next 11 England games.

One thing is certain though, hes miles better than Gibson and its a great experience for the lad. Its a shame some might miss his debut as theyll be watching Belguim hoping Fellaini plays shit.

Dick Brady
88 Posted 27/08/2013 at 21:58:16
On a World stage you would add to that list Messi, Ronaldo, Xavi, Iniesta, Casillas, Sneijder, Ozil, Ibrahimovic, Robben, Villa, Kaka, Fabregas, and Neymar.
Alan Smith
89 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:13:00
Non off them players, even Messi, has lit up an international tournament like Rooney did as an 18 year old. Its Ronaldo, Messi, Bale then Rooney for me.

His pass for that Van Persie volley against villa, that tackle last night in the full back position, overhead in the derby, goal on everton debut, hat trick on man utd debut, his volley against Newcastle. The lad can do everything, the most complete player ever.

Si Cooper
90 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:17:15
Wilshere, Vidic, Kompany, Oscar, Benteke - better than Rooney!?!?!? That is ridiculous.

And some of the others listed are debatable.

Hodgson seems to like getting the youngsters involved early doors, presumably in preparation for when they are fully established. Good luck to the lad; don't see him getting much game time for now but it will be a good experience for him.

Phil Sammon
91 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:30:31
Alan

Dick's entire point was that for such a fantastic 18 year old, he hasn't gone on to be the player he could have been.

His pass to Van Persie is a bloody ridiculous thing to bring up. 99% of strikers would have brought that down and held the ball up. The pass would never have got another mention. Rooney is fortunate to be playing with just about the most technically gifted player ever to have graced the Premier League.

A very good player, but could have been so much better.

Matty Dawkins
92 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:43:17
I want him nowhere near those arsewipes in that dressing room. A very unhealthy clique.
Barry Rathbone
93 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:40:39
Although english football is at the lowest I've ever seen (55 yrs) still pleased for the lad.

(We all know it's a double edged sword though)

Eddie Tully
94 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:52:49
I'm over the moon for young Ross, he is indeed a very talented player.
Why anybody who's seen him playing regularly would doubt this, I'll never know.

Dick, a lot of your posts are preposterous, are you aware of that?

As for Rooney, he was the best player on the pitch last night in my opinion!

Jamie Barlow
95 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:02:03
‘I look at Ross and you tell me what weakness he has. He hasn’t got one,’ said Martinez. ‘He takes in information, which for a young lad is incredible. He can use both feet, he can switch the play, he has a range of passing and can receive the ball in any area.

‘He has a great shot and has incredible energy. He reminds me of Michael Ballack. When Ballack was younger, nobody knew what his best position was; could he be a sitting midfielder, an attacking midfielder or play up front? Ross is that impressive.’

Bill Gall
96 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:48:51
Why are people talking about Rooney this is a person who sh-t on Everton and any comparison to R.Barkley is way off the mark.

Barkley plays in a differant position than Rooney and due to injury missed a couple of seasons in his development.

The stage in his career he has now reached is a testement to his character and the next step up to the Engllish team I believe he will have no problem using it as the next stage in his development as a established international

As far as his present form goes his selection warrents it.

Seeing some of the other players selected it is them that suprise me being selected, if the selection is for how good they are playing.

Billy Fisher
97 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:09:24
465? as he said
Jim Knightley
98 Posted 27/08/2013 at 22:59:50
Phil...Wasn't Lambert the highest scoring Englishman in the league last season (or at least thereabouts...)? with 15 goals? Personally, I hope we attempt to win the World Cup, rather than looking to the future. Just as I hope Everton will put out a team to win a cup, rather than tons of youngsters who will perform less effectively.

And Rooney has performed very poorly at recent summer tournaments...and how are summer tournaments a barometer of greatness? Are Bendtner and Milan Baros superstars because they've performed well in a summer tournament? Bizzare suggestion.


Rooney has scored above 20 goals twice in the Premierleague... despite playing for the best team in the division. He may be creative, but he is a form player, who too often goes through extended bad periods. I think that he is a top player when playing through the middle, and if he moved to Arsenal or Chelski could reestablish himself as a top player. But he is consistently overrated because he is English. If he was Argentinian, or Italian, or Bulgarian we would not praise him so.

Kevin Rowlands
99 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:10:24
Don't want to piss on the parade but if we don't get serious investment in the next 1/2 seasons we will not hold on to him, the lad is going to be world class, I think i'll enjoy him in an Everton shirt while I can, well done Ross! also a question to the Moyes apologists, he's played all pre season and the first two games and been outstanding so good that he's made Woys 1st team England squad, why in arguably our biggest game of the season last year(wigan 1/4) was Phil fucking Neville 'running' our midfield and Ross warming the bench? still pissed off about that!
Alan Smith
100 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:04:01
PHIL 623

I actually agree with you and Dick to an extent. At 18 he was playing better more dynamic football, better even than Ronaldo. But he matured slowed his game down to play the no 10 role ferguson, the media and countless England managers asked him. And still scores 0.44 gaols per prem lgu game. And he does that role as good, if not better than Scholes. People rightly love Iniesta, imagine Rooney playing for Barca or Spain.

"Ridiculous to bring up that pass"???

Everyone who saw it thought it was great pass and its what you come to expect watching Rooney. He can pass a ball as good as anyone in world football. Great come back though...are you saying hes not got great vision, awareness and a good passer?

Kev Johnson
101 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:26:21
I was thinking Ross would opt to play for France. Like his dad, Zidane.
Alan Smith
102 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:26:33
Wayne Rooney

Were did all go wrong? You've played for the best team in England for the last 9 years, closing in on Booby Charltons goals record, won countless trophies, and miles better than any other Englishman. Your going have to go to Chelsea and earn £250 000 a week, because the most technically gifted player of all time(according to phil sammon) plays up front. And Utd only want you to be their no 10, main playmaker. Give all your medals away you underachiever.

PS Dont be showing your Grandkids your overhead kick in the derby, hat trick on champ lgu debut, your goal against Arsenal or that volley versus Newcastle. Anyone can do them, just like your passing, its only because Van Persie is up front.

Now thats ridiculous...just like watching Belguim when England are on!

Graham Mockford
103 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:42:01
I am pretty sure Ross won't get a sniff of a game in either of the qualifying games. I suspect Hodgson wants him to experience being in the squad and get a chance to see him at closer quarters in training, see if he is made of the right stuff.

If that is the case it seems a sensible thing to do with a young promising player who has come through all the England age groups. If he resorts to playing him then it would indicate how desperate our national team really is.

Jim Knightley
104 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:52:14
Your bias is fantastic Alan.
Ernie Baywood
105 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:55:38
The pass to van Persie was great but hardly the kind of thing no-one else can do. Jags hit two better balls to Fellaini and Jelavic at the weekend.

For me, Rooney hasn't hit the level he could have. That's mainly been due to fitness and discipline. Which makes a mockery of the "SAF is the best manager for a young talent" stuff that was bandied around. Of course he's had an excellent career but he was a truly exceptional player.

On Ross' call up. This is just to give him a taste. Maybe Hodgson even spoke to Martinez on Saturday and asked if he thought it would benefit him? England can't just expect the clubs to develop talent for internationals - they should play their part too.

Michael Winstanley
106 Posted 27/08/2013 at 23:59:31
Kev. It's like they can't hear you or something???
Alan Smith
107 Posted 28/08/2013 at 00:56:24
Jim665

Bias to Rooney? He left Everton and kissed the utd badge at Goodison.

Maybe Rooneys a great player and I can admit it even though he let Everton fans down.

No I've changed my mind, jags can pass ball as good him, he's shit. Thanks Earnie, I nearly missed that.

The problem with some haters, is if a player does something exceptional for Everton (rooneys debut, Fellaini v man utd, rodwells goal v utd) and they don't do it every match, then they're inconsistent. Truth is the exceptional thing should be considered a bouness, not there job. And in Fellainis case the witch hunt is Plain mad as he is a DM not a target man. He's unbelievably consistent at showing for the ball, keeping possession, working hard and tackling. Rooney is ridiculously consistent at creating chances, making good passes, scoring goals and working hard for the team. His game isn't about scoring overheads every week and Fellainis isn't playing as a target man. Having balls played up to his chest with his back to goal. Don't think they teach that style on the continent.

Some criticised me when I said Barkley should start. All this bollocks that he'd give the ball away. Like Osman and Pienaar do 9-10 times a game. More Everton negative logic. Shit players give the ball away more than good players, age is nothing to do with it. Ask wilshire, fabregas and erm Rooney.

But look I'm wrong, Moyes is wrong, ferguson is wrong, mouriniho, Capello, hodgeson,

Fraser Auld
108 Posted 28/08/2013 at 00:37:16
Tell you what, no way would this have happened if that ginger tit was still in charge.

Martinez has started Barkley last two games as the attacking midfielder behind the striker - makes best use of his ability. Davey never liked playing ball players in that position, he always wanted a hard working target man for that role - witness years of Cahill followed swiftly by Fella.

Martinez has come in and given the kid confidence, he has also had the balls to start him two games in a row in a very important position for the team and surprise surprise Ross plays well and looks like he might become the player we all hope he will become. Credit to Martinez IMHO.

If OFM had still been here he'd have been giving it "i'm sure Ross Barkley will be a very good player one day but he's not ready yet, he missed a year of his development with a bad injury and still has a lot to learn, mistakes lose you games in the Premiership yadayadayada (insert further predictably negative platitudes here) ..." The fleeting glimpses of Ross in the first team would have seen him popping up on the left of midfield, the right or maybe as one of the central two (if Ossie or Gibbo got injured or to give one of them a rest).

Bottom line, glad Moyes has gone, he never trusted young players and I think Ross (and our other young players for that matter) have got a better chance of developing and fulfilling their potential without him and his negative shite.

I wonder how Jack Rodwell would have turned out if Martinez had been here when he first came through. I seem to recall Jack coming through at 16 years old as a centre-back and all the hype being that he was the new Rio - Bet Martinez would have had the balls to play him at the back at a young age if he thought he was good enough, he might have turned out to be the international defender that all the hype was about...instead of the crab-like midfielder Davey tuned him into because he was too scared to play him in the heart of defence.

Could go on, Coleman another example, should have been given a shot at right back when he returned from Blackpool, he'd have become the player he is today more quickly. His natural position was right back, he had always played there up to the point of his introduction to the first team, whereupon Davey shits it and decides to play him for two years as a right midfielder. He only finally got the chance of an extended run at right back once Neville's legs had completely gone and Hibbert was injured long term. Result? Shock horror, after a few teething problems, Seamus goes on to look like one of our best players.

Oh, and well done Ross Barkley by the way!

Harold Matthews
109 Posted 28/08/2013 at 01:27:54
Alf Ramsey picked a little Blackpool 19-year-old to play against Yugoslavia in 1965, so I doubt he'll be spinning in his grave, as someone suggested.
Michael Kenrick
110 Posted 28/08/2013 at 02:13:33
Did he have red hair?

Or don't we care...

Jim Knightley
111 Posted 28/08/2013 at 02:16:46
Alan...what are you talking about? How does 'But look I'm wrong, Moyes is wrong, Ferguson is wrong, Mouriniho, Capello, hodgeson,' back up your point? I'm not (or others ostensibly) claiming Rooney isn't a good player...he obviously is. But I'm not in agreement with your fetishisation of the man. And I think it's fantastic that you state that Rooney's game isn't about overheards. in a post after your refer to his overhead as a form of valorisation for your argument. Being world class is about consistency...

And Rooney has proved inconsistent too often. His record is very good for United, as it should be. He did join for near on £30M after all, in a period where prices were not as high as now. United have also been the best team, in general, in the league since he joined, and he has played with great players, and often been on free-kicks and pens. But is his record, and his general level of performance as good as Henry's? or Nistelroy's? Or RVP's? Or Messi's? Or Ronaldo's? if Suarez stays, his will be better too imo. Rooney is a good creative player... but again, he is overrated. It's as if no one else realises other players pass well as well. Watch Fabregas and Iniesta... they are passers of the ball. Rooney is very good, and one of the best players to grace our national stage in the last 20 years...but he is no genius.

And I think it's brilliant that you bring Wilshere up in a discussion about giving the ball away. I don't suppose you saw one of Wilshere's early games for Arsenal against West Ham, prior to breaking through into the team some time later? He gave the ball away in several dangerous positions, cost Arsenal a goal, and was consequently loaned out. As I brought up on this forums during last season, Barkley reminded me of a younger Wilshere. Talented but naive, and therefore I advocated his departure on loan to a Championship side to gain experience. He got that, and is benefiting from that now (Although I did not expect him to be ready for the first team till Jan at least). So think of that before you get on your high horse... and bring up Wilshere, who you clearly did not watch in his early days.

And Fraser... Barkley is playing now because Gibson got injured. It is out of necessity, just like when Moyes put in him against QPR a couple of seasons ago. And Moyes brought, and developed Coleman... I've no idea why you are bringing him up as a negative? Try taking the anti-Moyes specs off.

Harold Matthews
112 Posted 28/08/2013 at 01:50:34
Alan Smith. Excellent stuff. Your rapid fire, Bren gun delivery can often hide the fact that your judgement of a footballer is far ahead of all the other Toffee Webbers put together.
Some I thought were knowledgeable have increasingly continued to disappoint. Their posts I now ignore. As the Tibetan monk would say..."Eyes that see with partial vision would not truly recognise different levels of talent even if they look for a thousand years."

So keep up the good work Alan. Continue to see thing others don't.
Beware the big egos who think they know better. They don't.
Conversation with these people is a waste of time and energy.

Peter Jones
113 Posted 28/08/2013 at 02:48:57
I died laughing at Wilshere > Rooney. Kill yourself?
James Stewart
114 Posted 28/08/2013 at 03:06:43
"Willian will undoubtedly be better than Rooney"

What have you been smoking Dick? Willian has never hit 10 goals in one season and only has 40 in his whole career. He is about as prolific as Vic.

As for some of your other suggestions Wilshere, Hazard, Solando... Ridiculous. They have barely played half the games Rooney has yet alone matched his goals.

Jason Dunne
115 Posted 28/08/2013 at 03:21:56
I'll never forgive Rooney for going to Manchester and I slag him most chances I get but the top 50 shouts etc are embarrassing. I know he's been made help out a week United midfield of recent years but to not see he is one of the best around is plain ignorance.

Maybe the 16 year old Rooney seemed to have more potential because you's were watching him through the blue haze, at the time.

Paul Andrews
116 Posted 28/08/2013 at 05:58:42
Dick,

So he is in the top 11 then?
If you can't name 19 better players than him you are just pulling any figure out of the air to try to prove your point.

He is a 1 in 2 striker over his career at Utd,a 1 in 2 striker who creates goals,fills in in midfield and the wide positions,wins tackles in his own box etc etc.
He will more than likely go on to be Utd top goalscorer of all time beating Charlton,Law Best etc and you say he is not an all time great?

Steve Pugh
117 Posted 28/08/2013 at 09:52:48
Maybe what Rooney had when he was younger wasn't potential, that was his skill level, it happens.

Would Coleman have become the player he is now sooner had he been started sooner? Not necessarily, maybe he was developed at the perfect rate and that is why he is the player he is today.

If Ross (Barkley not Edwards) is good enough to play in the first team now why was he left on the bench in April? Because he is a better player now than he was in April.

David Moyes is a Ginger haired twat of the highest order after what he has done to our club, but some of the things he is criticised for are just pathetic. Having been guided by Moyes Coleman has become a brilliant player, would he have played had Hibbo not got injured? we don't know. Barkley has also developed under Moyes as is a brilliant player, would he have played the first two games under Moyes? we don't know.

A lot of young players have come though our club during Moyes tenure, a lot of people have criticised him for not playing them more. Now they've moved on, how many would you want back in our squad?

James Marshall
118 Posted 28/08/2013 at 10:13:42
re Alan Smith #678

Some of what you say is true, better players give the ball away less, and part of the reason for that is (hugely) to do with first touch, and the way a player can take himself away from an opponent before he's even moved.

Giving the ball away for a lot of players is also about being strong in the tackle, and not just about passing the ball to an opposition player.

I just had a look at some stats for Osman & Pienaar from last season, and Osman actually keeps the ball pretty well, with 89% passing accuracy, Pienaar at 83%.

Their problem is being dispossessed in the tackle which is obviouslly more to do with being a bit weedy, rather than being crap at passing. Osman only won 56% pf challenges and Pienaar even less at 54%.

The point you make is quite right though, because talent and awareness is what takes a player away from a marker and the best players get involved in less tackles, meaning less chance for them to lose the ball.

When you look at the top/top players like Xavi, Iniesta, Messi, Fabregas, Rooney, even Wilshere, they play away from their markers and get less involved in the physical side of things so lose the ball even less. Plus as you say, they can pass better.

Osman and Pienaar are not in that league, and they're both lightweight so they lose the ball two-fold.

Barkley has that golden first touch, and ability to get away from players before they can get close to him, and that for me is key.

Fraser Auld
119 Posted 28/08/2013 at 12:15:07
Jim Knightley 694 - I don't wear specs, anti Moyes or otherwise. I accept my original post creates that impression but in my defence, when I posted that i'd just got in from the pub after a few too many vodka/lucozades so my language was probably more inflammatory than it needed to be.

Moyes was a good manager, don't get me wrong, the best I've seen since I started supporting early 90s but, like all managers, he was better at some things than at others. In my opinion, and it may only be my opinion, one of the things he wasn't particularly good at was developing young players, particularly a certain type of player. He didn't trust young players and his soundbites in the media whenever asked about young players were negative and did not offer any encouragement. He was from the school of Break Them to Make Them, again in my opinion.

Why am I bringing that up in a "Barkley gets first senior England call-up " thread? Well, simply because as I said in my post, I don't think Barkley would have got a call up, at this point in time, if Moyes was still in charge.

There was an interesting piece in one of the papers two or three weeks ago, can't remember which one but it was definitely quoted on this site, about the difference between Moyes's approach to young players and Martinez – in a nutshell, Moyes wanted to see discipline first and foremost and wouldn't tolerate mistakes whereas Martinez was more concerned about ability, what a player could do and how they reacted to mistakes.

I prefer the Martinez approach to Moyes; you might not but I do. Play a kid in their best position, give them a chance, confidence and encouragement you will get the best out of them (although of course that doesn't necessarily mean the player will make the grade, at least then you've given them a chance and are in a better position to judge).

In my opinion, Barkley was crying out for a manager with that approach, a manager who would give him confidence, tell him what he was good at instead of focussing on what he wasn't good at. Funnily enough, as soon as we get that manager, Barkley looks very good and gets an Engand call-up, shock horror...

This leads on to the point you make about Gibson being injured and the assumption that Moyes would have done like for like with Martinez. With respect, I am utterly unconvinced that, had Moyes still been here, Ross would have started the last two games – regardless of the injury to Gibson. I am possibly even less convinced that Moyes would have played him in the position where Martinez has, the position that looks to make best use of his natural talents, as I said, Moyes liked a target man for that role.

Again, I simply don't agree with you that Martinez is only playing Barkley out of necessity. Even once Gibson is back, I think Barkley will start matches; he won't start every week, of course, but one thing I am sure of is that he'll see a lot more game time this season than he would have done under Moyes.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb