Martinez unaware of improved offer for duo

, 29 August, 80comments  |  Jump to most recent
Negotiations are in Kenwright's hands

Roberto Martinez admits that the decision over whether Marouane Fellaini or Leighton Baines will be sold and for how much will ultimately rest with Bill Kenwright.

Media reports tonight claim — the breadth and timing of the bulletins suggest it comes from Goodison Park — that a new £36m offer for the duo has been rejected by Everton but Martinez was not in a position to confirm or deny the speculation after telling the Chairman that he doesn't "want know anything that's going on, I only want to know the final news if there is anything."

The Spaniard's frustration at the whole transfer window process and its impact on his preparations for the early games of the season has been evident and he hinted again at the complications inherent in the history between Kenwright and David Moyes as the ex-boss tries to lure away two of his former players.

"I have had enough of 'he said this, he said that'", Martinez is quoted in The Guardian. "This is a really sensitive situation because you're talking of a chairman and previous manager who had a relationship over 11 years.

"A lot of things have been said in public and I don't want to be part of that. I'm out of it. But I have never had any instruction that anything has changed [with respect to Fellaini and Baines]."

The 40 year-old reiterated that Baines has not instructed Everton to come to an agreement with United over a deal that would take him to Old Trafford but was pragmatic about the fact that things could change between now and the 2nd September deadline.

"[W]hatever the players say in a different situation or environment could change," he said. "All I can tell you is that Leighton is an Evertonian and very thankful for the opportunity Everton gave him.

"And if he has a club like Manchester United interested in him, it's a football compliment and we will take it like that. Then if things are not right, they are not right. Sometimes the club needs to be respected in that way."

Martinez, meanwhile, continues to look at ways he can strengthen his squad before the window slams shut, saying last night that he is actively trying to get one or two players in.

He suggested that informal contact has been made with Wigan chairman, Dave Whelan, about James McCarthy, although it is generally accepted that he would not be able to move for the 22 year-old midfielder, rated at £15m, without the funds generated from the sale of one of his more saleable assets.

"I've had conversations but not in a formal way," said Martinez who is also being linked again with a loan move for Gareth Barry, although a compromise over his £120,000-a-week salary would need to be reached.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian



Reader Comments (80)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Neil Quinn
1 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:12:53
Hmm - the Mirror are reporting that we are demanding £50m.
That means we'll settle on £40m.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/baines-Fellaini-transfer-manchester-united-2236409

James Marshall
2 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:17:41
If this bid is true, then I reckon it's only a matter of time before the club accept a bid. I just hope we have a few replacements lined up before Tuesday.

I think we all know they'll sell at the right price, and rightly so.

We should cash in and buy.

Derek Knox
3 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:11:09
It seems from this Lyndon, that the ball is in Bill Kenwright's court, that tends to worry me. We will be lucky, if a deal is reached, to know what one, or both has gone for.

The timeline is also a worry, although, I suppose we all expected this. so it should not be a surprise.

As long as Roberto is given the proceeds,and has the targets, and the time to complete them, I suppose we will be happy to an extent.
Tony Draper
4 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:12:39
"James McCarthy........ rated at £15m"
Erm really ?
Rated at £15M+ by Wigan Athletic's own Dave ("mind the leg, it still hurts from Wembley, but I never mention it") Whelan

Other notable "Peg Leggers" may also include:
Captain Ahab, his personal excessive over valuation of a white whale proved ultimately both frustrating and destructive

Lyndon Lloyd
5 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:26:06
Derek, realistically, both have their price and if it's met, they will go.

I still think it'll be Fellaini and not Baines for a price more or less matching the £23.5m release clause but United have to disclose the fee to the New York Stock Exchange so we'll likely know the details.

From the hints from Martinez above, it looks like McCarthy would be the replacement with perhaps a loan or two to pad the squad before the deadline.

Karl Masters
6 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:23:46
Do you know what I don't like about any if this is that it seems Kenwright and Moyes enjoy some cozy relationship out of public view and Moyes is the puppeteer.

FFS Kenwright! Moyes is now your enemy and an unprincipled one at that, representing a Club and supporters that take great delight in lauding themselves over the City of Liverpool.

Those eleven years have gone now. Fuck him off and support your current Manager!

Iain Love
7 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:27:40
£40M? I'd be happy with that, a new manager needs to get players that fit the system he wants the team to play in. Rather than wait for a season or two for that to happen, that money would be a great start. The last three games have proven that we need to change some of our personnel.
Patrick Murphy
8 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:32:48
I agree with you in theory Karl, but BK knows which side his bread is buttered and always has; seeing as Moyes is the only manager who has taken an interest in Fellaini at least publicly, and the fact that Fellaini has been after a move since the start of last season, it is in BK's interest to stay onside with DM. The last thing that BK will want to do is to go to war with Moyes as if anyone knows where any skeletons if there are any are buried it will be the canny Scotsman.

I think that we can say goodbye to Fellaini, regardless of how much we get for him. Baines is harder to call, Roberto has intimated that contracts for players will be discussed after the window is shut, which is a little strange but I suppose it negates the possibility of Baines rejecting a new offer before the window closes and then moving late in the day, but could open the door to him leaving in January.

Karl Masters
9 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:43:19
Yes Patrick. Moyes will be lurking till the day they sack him.
James Stewart
10 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:06:24
Barry is a yard dog and not a very good one at that. We should not be signing players of his age anyway. Definitely don't want him.


McCarthy I would take but 15m is unrealistic.

Liam Reilly
11 Posted 30/08/2013 at 00:57:24
I like McCarthy, but 15 million? Not a. Chance. RM needs to widen his search for better value.

We're goona be fucked by Moyes at 10 to 12 on TDD and worse still, will have to listen to his shite hour after hour following Natalie Sawyer n the Scot.

Hos time will come

Rob Smith
12 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:14:31
I think all the Baines talk is bullshit, Felli maybe, do a deal quick though ffs. I will weep if we pay 15 mill McCarthy, surely there is better for less, which allows us to possibly add 2 or 3 with Felli's money.
Nicholas Ryan
13 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:28:37
Holtby and Siggurdson available on loan from Spurs...could do worse.
Mark Taylor
14 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:33:50
Pontius Pilate like, it looks like RM is washing his hands of this. On another thread, people have said he has spoken openly and made his position clear that there is no need or desire to sell, but it is ever clearer that his position doesn't count and he will take the hand dealt to him by BK and like it-or bugger off.

If RM buys McCarthy for £15m, I will lose all connfidence in him. McCarthy is an OK player but only Dave Whelan thinks he's worth £15m- and even then, only in public. Surely RM's horizon stretches beyond his former club, now grafting in the league below?

If we sell Fellaini, we should be shopping at Harrods, not Lidl.

Jackie Barry
15 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:42:51
Moyes will be lurking toll the day they sack him and then BK will sack Martinez and hire his beloved Moyes back in the Goodison hot seat. All will be forgiven and the love story will continue. I can actually see this happening.
Phil Friedman
16 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:51:13
If both go, the season is over before it really starts. We won't get anyone in that will replace the offensive power that they supply. Where will the goals come from, other than Ross? Kone? Please. If this was late July I wouldn't worry, but to muster decent replacements at this late stage is not doable. (I would take Siggurdson if available at the right price, but again we are settling for the unwanted.)
Patrick Murphy
17 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:45:39
Genius of the highest order should be recognised and applauded

1. Get your employee to put in a ridiculous offer for your prize assets that nobody would take seriously.

2. Leak it to the press that your former employee has dis-respected the business.

3. Tell your current manager to tow the party line and that the business is not interested in selling at that price.

4. Get worried as your new honest guy manager begins to believe
what you have been telling him.

5. Phone your mate and tell him to increase the offer, but not directly, but through other avenues.

6. New manager gets tired of all the shenanigans and says he will concentrate on doing his proper job.

7. Put price tag on the assets and know that one can be sold now for a bit more than the original asking price

8. Hope that the replacement(s) your manager has his eyes on are sold before he has the chance to buy them.

9. Money will be there when the next window of opportunity arises

10. Sell the second asset when the new man comes back for cash and hey presto! half the money from the assets has been saved and then try and persuade the new guy that this window is not the best time to be buying new items, much better to wait until the summer.

There you have it the 10 commandments of a Genius.

Rob Smith
18 Posted 30/08/2013 at 01:58:03
Holtby did score a cracker this morning, we were interested before he went to Spurs, signed for peanuts didn't he?

If Marrone is £7M and McCarthy £15M, the market is fucking kidding. It would be nice to get McCarthy and Marrone for £7M each and add another striker.

Andrew Cutler
19 Posted 30/08/2013 at 02:04:12
Sheesh Jackie (639)...have a lie down. I am a bit of a conspiracy theorist but really!!..your thoughts must be a torment
Tony J Williams
20 Posted 30/08/2013 at 02:05:48
All it would take is for Martinez or the lying sack of shite to come out and say it's too late to get replacements so Fuck off. It really is that simple.

Cue usual last minute dealings where we never see the money again.

Peter Thistle
21 Posted 30/08/2013 at 03:13:26
Bang out of order to take 2 of our players so close to the deadline, gives us no chance to replace em. Hope Kenwright takes that into consideration before seeing pound signs in his eyes.
Lewis Barclay
22 Posted 30/08/2013 at 03:15:59
£40m+? Take it, congratulate both players, thank them for their service and wish them the best against every other team in the league.

What worries me is, like the Bale money at Tottenham, we should already have spent the money on a forward, creative midfielder and defensive midfielder and a young, decent left back as backup to Oviedo.

Don't see it happening though, especially if RM is saying he doesn't know what's happening.

Nathan Goulart
23 Posted 30/08/2013 at 03:42:38
Just like Moyes to wait till the end of the transfer window to do signings.
Michael Parrington
24 Posted 30/08/2013 at 04:31:54
Can't wait for the 3rd September. The way this whole system works only helps create instability and absolutely favours the wealthier clubs.

Worse of all it's like a license for papers to print whatever rubbish they feel like, mostly with no more qualification than 'my mate down the pub who's second cousin is a friend of the girlfriend of player x says he's moving to xyz'...

If we loose players on the last day then we'll struggle this season. We should be trying to strengthen the squad.

Peter Barry
25 Posted 30/08/2013 at 04:34:16
This is all lining up to be a typical BK scam. He will drag this out until the last minute then sell both Baines and Fellaini to his 'buddy' Moyes for a knock-down price. He will then squirrel away the money, never to be seen or heard of again, as it will be 'too late' to get replacements and Everton will once again have been shafted by an unscrupulous Liar and a Deceitful Disrespectful Jock.
Paul Ward
26 Posted 30/08/2013 at 04:44:59
Patrick Murphy (644), you are absolutely spot on. Why can't other Evertonian's see what Kenwright is about. To add to your comments what has happened to the new ground he was looking at when the rat was cornered into the AGM.
Craig Fletcher
27 Posted 30/08/2013 at 05:05:25
We're getting monumentally screwed with the transfer window closing only a couple of days away. I think our best option, at this point if at all possible - if Baines/Fellaini really want to go, let them go in January - gives us time to scout replacements while screwing Man U for the best possible price we can. If we let them go before September 2; given the time it takes to find and "bed in" replacements; it could be a tough next four months. That all being said; ideally we should have prioritized re-signing Baines on a long-term contract two months ago.
Eric Myles
28 Posted 30/08/2013 at 05:54:21
"Roberto Martinez admits that the decision over whether Marouane Fellaini or Leighton Baines will be sold and for how much will ultimately rest with Bill Kenwright."

It's a done deal then, both players will put in a transfer request at 11pm on deadline day and be gone for 30 mill.

ooops, our deal for (insert name of world class player we have no hope of signing) fell through because our fax machine ran out of paper at 5 to middight and the shops were shut so we couldn't get a refill.

Mark Tanton
29 Posted 30/08/2013 at 06:11:43
This is why I worried when we made such a fuss about "not selling". It is highly likely we will sell and then we just look like dicks, as usual.
Paul Andrews
30 Posted 30/08/2013 at 06:16:32
Serious undermining of the manager here.
Treating him like an outsider in negotiations.
Harold Matthews
31 Posted 30/08/2013 at 06:21:20
The trouble is Patrick. You could be right.
Brian Cleveland
32 Posted 30/08/2013 at 06:34:07
"This is a really sensitive situation because you're talking of a chairman and previous manager who had a relationship over 11 years."

I really don't like this. It smacks of exasperation.... I think RM feels that he is not getting a say in matters and that OFM still has more pull at Goodison than he has.... it's like he is in the dark and all the phone calls are between BK & our now disrespectful and disrespected former manager. He is left out of the loop and feels helpless....he is not receiving the backup from the chairman he should have and.....if that is the case, in his position I'd quit.

It's a farce that Moyes still appears to hold sway, and I'm really pissed off with this crap.

Paul Andrews
33 Posted 30/08/2013 at 06:46:47
Brian,

I don't think many managers would put up with the crap Kenwright gives out.
One or two would keep schtum in return for the financial rewards,but I reckon Martinez will be a different type of man.
Already he has let the fans know he has nothing at all to do with the deal.

Steve Pugh
34 Posted 30/08/2013 at 07:47:20
If any of the above happen then we need to stop being the nice, well behaved Evertonians and start a proper campaign to get rid of the board.

This has gone on long enough.

Carl Reid
36 Posted 30/08/2013 at 08:22:14
On the other side this shows kenwright as he is a complete horror for our club. I for one will refuse to attend Goodison if two of our best players leave and kenwright remains as chairman. Ambition david I even hope the laughable lot beat you lot for the first time in my life. Frauds.god help Martinez with these two around
Steve Guy
37 Posted 30/08/2013 at 08:35:42
Looks like RM is quickly finding out what the word duplicity means. BK and OFM. I wouldn't trust either of them. OFM claims he talks regularly to BK. that must be nice for RM. Wonder if RM will walk ?
Ross Norman
38 Posted 30/08/2013 at 08:50:22
I’m still baffled to how McCarthy could be valued at £15 million yet Ajax only want around £12 million for Cristian Eriksen.
Dave Lynch
39 Posted 30/08/2013 at 09:13:46
I posted on here a few years ago that I would never attend Goodison again while Moyes and Kenwright where at the club.

One down; one to go. (I did falter once for the Bolton game where Howard scored and am I sorry I did.) Kenwright has the morals of a rattlesnake and I posted a week or so ago that I thought he had upset Roberto already.

I firmly believe my hunch to be true and the best thing Roberto could do for the club is to tell BK to fucking stick his job and walk. Then tell the papers exactly why he's walked.

This club cannot keep going the way it is, it is run on a tissue of lies and smoke and mirrors. My heart bleeds for every fan that is taken in by BK and his bullshit.

Enough is enough...

Carl Sanderson
40 Posted 30/08/2013 at 09:18:27
Ross 723,

Four reasons: firstly, he's a "proven Premier League performer"; secondly, he's British; thirdly, Wigan will know we have the Fellaini money and will hike up the price; and finally Newcastle are also interested.

Carl Sanderson
41 Posted 30/08/2013 at 09:23:34
Dave 731,

"My heart bleeds for every fan that is taken in by BK and his bullshit."

My heart doesn't bleed for them; far from it. How much more evidence do they need that he is a snake-oil salesman than KD, DK, Rooney, NTL and FSF? How stupid do they have to be to applaud his mug on the screen after that lot?

Oh, for a Daniel Levy!

Jon Withey
43 Posted 30/08/2013 at 09:48:07
Regarding BK, I'm not one of those that comes on every post and complains about him.

That doesn't mean that I'm a supporter. It doesn't mean I desperately want him to stay in the face of serious 'investment' (there is surely no such thing in football - investments make money).

It's clear that we don't have money and that there aren't brilliant plans to get any. The board gets a 'C', Must do better. To get an 'F', I think relegation would be in order, so let's see.

If there is some mega-rich die-hard football fan who wants to throw money at the club, great.

Barry Rathbone
44 Posted 30/08/2013 at 10:19:41
Well said Roberto a none too subtle shot across the bows of the 2 charlatans (DM & BK) who put us in this position.

About time someone officially got narked about these 2.

If Kenwright doesn't play this right he's right in the shit - RM REALLY is a man of principle and the 40 pieces of silver Moyes took to keep his gob shut won't work with him.

Pull your finger out kenwright either top dollar or tell Moyes to fuck off - not " sorry no deal" - a straight "FUCK OFF!"

James Marshall
46 Posted 30/08/2013 at 11:18:32
Why are people surprised this is happening now? This was ALWAYS going to be what happened - it happens every transfer window. All clubs wait till the end to do their business and I would be really really surprised if we don't have contingency in place in the event of one or both of them being sold.

There have been continuous reports of players we're interested in, in the event of these two being sold, so hold your horses and take a look at the situation.

It's not news to anyone that Utd are interested in Fellaini & Baines, nor is it news to the players themselves - they've both been pretty quiet on the issue and handled it quite well in my opinion. Neither has agitated in the manner people like Suarez have in the past and every player has his price.

They both want to leave, Fellaini especially and good luck to him. He's never made any secret of his desire to play for a Champions League club, and we'll never give him that. If we keep him, and particularly him, then we'll have a player who's not happy or motivated to play for Everton and that doesn't help us at all.

Selling him helps us.....as long as we have some replacements lined up....

As for Baines, I wouldn't begrudge him a move to Utd either and it's good business at his age, even though we'd miss him more than Fellaini.

£40m seems like a fair price for the pair of them to my mind.

Ian Burns
47 Posted 30/08/2013 at 11:45:12
James 778 - an excellent and well written post.

Although you have given a well-reasoned argument/comment, the problem is all about timing. There may be differences of opinion on this site as to whether or not we should take the money or keep the players and it would appear to me that as long as "acceptable" replacements are brought in, then your argument holds water.

The problem is timing. If we did get 40m at midnight on the 2nd September, would you still be happy in letting them both go?

It is all about timing and that unfortunately, is only one man's call who is dictated by the debt he has put upon the club.

James Marshall
48 Posted 30/08/2013 at 12:04:24
Exactly, Ian. We'd need the deal done before the deadline otherwise we're stuck with a squad short of two key players. It's all in the timing, and with 3 days left if it's going to happen, it needs to happen ASAP.

If it's left until the deadline, then no, I agree it would be hugely detrimental.

Fellaini needs to be sold now - if we wait till January or the end of the season, we lose our bargaining position because his contract will be down to one year left, and we all know what that means.

Peter Cummings
49 Posted 30/08/2013 at 11:52:51
If the negotiations "are in Kenwright's hands" as reported, then it's game over, maybe leaving the club with a few million to spend, but on who?? The whole saga stinks, the manager obviously frustrated, the team affected, and, of course, the fans completely ignored.

We are the only club in the Premier League seemingly unattractive to potential buyers and the big question is Why? The only person to blame for the fiasco is Kenwright with his penny-pinching and reluctance to agree to a financial takeover by so-called 'interested parties'.

James Stewart
51 Posted 30/08/2013 at 12:36:49
@723

Thinking the exact same.

Capoue 9m
Cristian Eriksen 12m

Both top class players. Eriksen is absolute quality and made a mug out of United's midfield.

McCarthy 15m. Yeah right.

James Stewart
52 Posted 30/08/2013 at 12:39:58
As for crocodile tears Billy Liar, he will be trying to do the deal as close to the deadline as possible!
Steve King
53 Posted 30/08/2013 at 12:42:25
James Marshall,

I agree..... except Fellainis contact runs until summer 2016, and there is a world cup next year. If he plays well in Brazil then we may well be able to demand a lot more money for him.
We need to play hardball with United and get what the player is worth, its their own fault for trying to scam us by letting his clause run out.

James Marshall
55 Posted 30/08/2013 at 13:08:44
Oh, my mistake on the contract length.

That clause wasn't worth the paper it was written on anyway. It was never going to be met, and always invited lower bids after the event.

Flog him by end of tomorrow, and get some more players in, I reckon.

Paul O'Hanlon
56 Posted 30/08/2013 at 13:15:30
If this deal was ALWAYS going to happen, why haven't we bought replacements BEFORE the sales as Spurs have done with the Bale money?

We could either take the money from the additional TV revenue (even if it's ear marked elsewhere, it could be replaced after the sale) or one of our rich (but tight fisted) shareholders could loan the club the cash, seeing as they know they'd be re-paid within weeks.

Paul O'Hanlon
57 Posted 30/08/2013 at 13:32:01
Answer: because Kenwright's in charge of the negotiations
Brian Harrison
58 Posted 30/08/2013 at 13:51:54
I don't see how a manager can adopt the attitude of I am not getting involved and will wait for the chairman to tell me when its all over. Surely the manager should know exactly what sort of money the club will accept for one or both and should be negotiating with potential players he wants. Otherwise Man Utd will tie up the deal with an hour left of the window leaving our very lightweight squad even lighter both in quality and numbers.

So RM instead of burying your head in the sand you should be the one who is calling the shots on both outgoing and incoming players, and if you are not strong enough to do this then you shouldn't be manager of Everton.

Ian Burns
59 Posted 30/08/2013 at 14:05:12
Does RM know this site exists and if so does he read it so he can get a true and informed opinion from True Evertonians?

BK obviously knows it exists but does he ever have the courage to read it or are the comments so close to the truth it actually turns his crocodile tears into real ones, knowing he is not loved by all Evertonians?

Jamie Barlow
60 Posted 30/08/2013 at 14:03:57
Brian, I would imagine Martinez has put a price on both heads and doesn't want to know about any bid unless they meet his valuation. Seems reasonable to me.
Brian Harrison
61 Posted 30/08/2013 at 14:13:03
Jamie, you may well be right and he has put a price on both players but as the window gets closer to closing how does he know if he will have £23 million or possibly anything up to £40 million to spend seeing he doesnt want any involvement in the deals. I am sure his old mate Dave Whelan will be delighted the later the deal is done then he has more chance of getting his crazy valuation of McCarthy as we will have very little time to look for alternatives. I don't believe that Spurs are interested in McCarthy, maybe dopey Kinnear will pay his asking price as they are desperate.

When Utd first bid for Fellaini and Baines RM should have spoke to his chairman and both players and made his mind up which he was prepared to let go and for how much and then tell Utd the deal had to be in place 2 weeks before the window closed.

Richard Reeves
62 Posted 30/08/2013 at 14:57:13
Jackie (#639), I can as well, I've mentioned it a few times since Martinez has been appointed and was one of the reasons I gave to not wanting to go to the final home game and applaud Moyes on his send-off.
James Marshall
63 Posted 30/08/2013 at 15:16:20
Why are you asking those questions about what Martinez knows, and how much he's having to do with the transfers? Do you honestly think that what you read/see on Sky Sports news is the whole story?

Come off it.

Brian Harrison
64 Posted 30/08/2013 at 15:20:31
James the reason I am asking what RM knows is not because of SSN but because of what he said in the article above. You reckon he has contingency plans I hope your right, but I still say he should have had this sorted one way or another by now. I mean the other lot said Suarez isn't for sale and despite him virtually asking for a transfer he is still there. Man Utd said Rooney wouldn't be sold and it looks increasingly likely that he will stay. So maybe we needed to be as definite about our players, instead of saying the offers were derisory which have been interpreted as we are Everton of course we will sell but not at those figures.
James Marshall
65 Posted 30/08/2013 at 15:33:05
It's all conjecture of course, Brian. The Rooney thing was a massively different issue - he's a part of the Manchester United global brand & marketing machine so there was no way he was ever going to be sold, in my opinion.

Suarez agitated for a move and the RS refused to budge on principal.

Everton and our two players? No agitation from either player, and no branding nonsense to deal with. To my mind our transfer dealing for these two is a lot more straightforward and if (IF) internally either of them has said they want to go (see certain paper talk) then we should (and possibly are) entering into negotiations.

What Martinez says publicly is almost without question not the full picture. You've seen as much of him as I have, and he could quite easily be a politician, the way he quacks on avoiding questions, blustering on about nothing for 10 minutes at a time. I don't pay much attention to the things managers say!

As for Kenwright, well we all know he always speaks in tongues....

I think it's clear that the message from Everton is exactly what you've described - we'll sell at the right price.

Mike Knowsley
66 Posted 30/08/2013 at 15:37:28
I really wish Kenwright would go on SSN and say 'this is our asking price for both or each of the players in question and it's non-negotiable, so don't bother calling with any offers!' Debt ridden United are playing hardball over Rooney, so do the same. F**k me did I really just say all that bollocks....of course Kenwright will sell and below the players' valuation, just look at his deadline day track record. It'll be a miracle if Bainsey and Felli are still BlueBoys' come Tuesday morning. I hate to say this but Kenwright is poison.
James Marshall
67 Posted 30/08/2013 at 16:06:51
Why are you blaming Bill Kenwright for Man Utd making bids for our players that don't meet the clubs valuation of our players?

That doesn't make any sense?!?

Callum McNab
68 Posted 30/08/2013 at 16:29:14
The word puppet comes to mind with Martinez. Kenwright is going to love him. God help our club.
Ross Edwards
69 Posted 30/08/2013 at 17:58:10
Negotiation rests with Bill. I can't think of anything worse frankly. Open the door to your left Felli and Baines and get in the taxi. OFM is waiting.
Paul Ellam
70 Posted 30/08/2013 at 18:10:22
For me, we should have agreed to sell Fellaini early in the transfer window (if we were actually going to sell him) and used his money to buy or loan in the likes of Capoue/Fer/Ericksen/Sinclair/McCarthy and Vossen/Pelle/Bony.
We have already missed out on most of those players and if we sell Fellaini now there won’t be much left of any decency to spend his money on!
I think we have once again been inept in the transfer dealings.
Mike Allison
71 Posted 30/08/2013 at 18:26:49
Paul, nobody bid enough money early in the window. We even set a release clause with a time limit, so we did our bit, it still didn't happen.

My issue is that we CANNOT possibly sell BOTH players. I've said for weeks that I'd accept Fellaini leaving for the right price if three quality replacements came in - a ball-winner, a playmaker and a winger/creative attacking midfielder.

Leighton Baines however represents everything good about football and Everton football club in particular. He's not just the best left-back around, he's a footballer to be proud of. The thought of him wearing a Man United shirt being cheered on by all those clueless plastic fans everywhere in the world who simply do not understand what being a football fan is, well that makes my stomach churn.

If Fellaini goes, we cannot possibly need to sell Baines as well.

Geoff Freeman
72 Posted 30/08/2013 at 18:53:13
Paul we might have sold him early in the window if anyone had made an offer for him
Brian Harrison
73 Posted 30/08/2013 at 19:00:08
I am beginning to wonder if we are a club with no greater ambition than to produce players for the top clubs, that enables us to still exist in the Premier league. We have sold Rooney and now the possibility of our 2 best players also going to Man Utd, and Rodwell going to City. So we have stopped being a club that have genuine aspirations of challenging the top 4, I mean if we are always selling our best players how can we possibly hope to challenge for Champions league places.

I know it was always going to be difficult with our measly transfer kitty to do this but now it just seems light years away. I think our loyal fan base will start to ebb away and who can blame them, even the most optimistic fans will start to think we are going nowhere. How long will we be able to hold on to Barkley next summers transfer window possibly.

Brian Harrison
74 Posted 30/08/2013 at 19:00:08
I am beginning to wonder if we are a club with no greater ambition than to produce players for the top clubs, that enables us to still exist in the Premier league. We have sold Rooney and now the possibility of our 2 best players also going to Man Utd, and Rodwell going to City. So we have stopped being a club that have genuine aspirations of challenging the top 4, I mean if we are always selling our best players how can we possibly hope to challenge for Champions league places.

I know it was always going to be difficult with our measly transfer kitty to do this but now it just seems light years away. I think our loyal fan base will start to ebb away and who can blame them, even the most optimistic fans will start to think we are going nowhere. How long will we be able to hold on to Barkley next summers transfer window possibly.

Mark Taylor
75 Posted 30/08/2013 at 19:09:58
James

The issue is not about selling these players- if the price is good enough that can be good business and a means to build a stronger squad.

The issue is how the proceeds are deployed. What many of us are preparing for and believe is inevitable, is BK selling one or both on deadline day then claiming we just missed out on buying x world class replacement because- well pick an excuse but I liked the earlier poster saying it would be because we ran out of fax paper at 5 to midnight. Then the money disappears into the financial black hole we seem to have.

If we sell both, we may well get McCarthy for an absurdly inflated fee plus maybe a crappy loan signing, which will be almost as bad.

If BK yet again screws the club, I think this time, he truly will be crucified and deservedly so. I don't think RM will be blameless either- it's all very well saying some of the things he has about keeping the players, the mock anger etc, but if things end up as I describe, his position isn't going to look too clever either. In fact, assuming he isn't playing along with all this and trying to give his own former Chairman another nice present, he would be wise to consider his position, assuming he is a man of principles.

If I'm proven wrong and they either stay or, more likely go, but we then produce with a flourish the quality players at reasonable prices that BK has skilfully lined up as contingency, I will happily eat my words- but I think the pigs will be flying at the same time...

Paul Rimmer
76 Posted 30/08/2013 at 19:18:14
I was thinking the same Brian. Rooney, (possibly) Baines, Fellaini, Lescott, Rodwell, Arteta, all playing for CL clubs - that's over half a team! We spent about 30 million to get these in and have received 77 million before any money for Baines / Fellaini. Two questions : where is the ambition and where is the money? I can only think of West Ham who've sold a better team of players that are still playing at the highest level and they will eclipse us when they move into their stadium. The incompetence of our Board is incredible.
Paul O'Hanlon
77 Posted 30/08/2013 at 19:33:53
Paul (970) - West Ham's a good example of a club consistently selling their best players, but how many times they've been relegated whilst selling those players?

If we start selling our best players without replacing them (which has been suggested on another thread to pay off part of the debt) we'll be relegated within 3 seasons.

Paul Rimmer
78 Posted 30/08/2013 at 19:44:46
I agree Paul, 972. We need to reinvest but the level of reinvestment seems to be diminishing year on year. We'll probably finish mid-table this year and we'll see what ambition we have next summer. I gave up my season ticket this year as the Premier league is so predictable/ money driven. Whilst our board don't invest in players we won't ever finish higher than 5th.
Harold Matthews
79 Posted 30/08/2013 at 21:25:05
This McCarthy business has a peculiar smell about it and I'll be annoyed if we sign him for an inflated fee,enabling pegleg Dave to slip a few nice presents here and there.
Why no interest in better players at half the price? This "right character" excuse is a feeble smokescreen for long planned done deals.
Robin Cannon
80 Posted 30/08/2013 at 22:09:24
Got to concur with the feeling that this is the worst time to sell, when we don't have time to really do anything prior to the window shutting.

Although, of course, it's the best time for BK to sell because, well, we don't have time to really do anything prior to the window shutting...

I'm also concerned by the McCarthy chatter. I think he's a decent player, but overpriced. More importantly, it kinda worries me that if we did approach him then it means that outside of one player on loan, the only source of new players that Martinez has apparently approached is the club he just left.

That might make sense if he'd left an overachieving and exciting Wigan squad, but despite the FA cup win, that's not really the case. I don't think their quality warrants going back for four players from their squad - and it kinda makes me think about how widely Martinez had been looking.

James Marshall
81 Posted 31/08/2013 at 00:17:47
Mark#968

Exactly. You're right about where the money goes and the timing, which is the same as I said in an earlier post.

As long as the money is spent on good players. I agree with you. If not, then one can only assume it's being used to service our debt.

Or Kenwright is building himself a castle.

Raymond Fox
82 Posted 31/08/2013 at 00:28:38
Harold I seldom differ from your view, but I don't think Whelan needs more money, although he won't refuse any extra!

RM, is asking for criticism returning for more Wigan players, but he must be confident that McCarthy will cut the mustard. He is only 22 and an Irish International, who is highly rated by Trapattoni. What we rate him at is subjective, but I think we should back Martinez till/if it goes pear-shaped.

Paul Ward
83 Posted 31/08/2013 at 03:51:12
Why are people asking what kind of club are we? The answer is simple: we are Bill Kenwright's club.

I see the word 'negotiation' quite a lot as well. Well, the probability is our supreme dictator has already agreed the price for Baines and/or Fellaini and the outcome will be announced on the final day. An other stage-managed show by BK.

His last classic was to bring Leroy Fer over to send him home again. I do feel sorry for Martinez because, like many on this site, he has taken BK by his word; he will soon realise it is false. With Moyes and BK, it was an arrangement of convenience.

Ross Kerry
84 Posted 31/08/2013 at 04:39:02
Paul, this is not news to anyone. What's your solution?
Ken Crowther
85 Posted 31/08/2013 at 13:57:41
I've just read quickly through this thread, and can't see any mention of what I think are the salient points in the Felli situation.

1. We are told that he has said he wants to go.

2. Nobody seems to have offered the release clause money during the early part of the window.

3. When the next window opens (1st Jan 2014?), the release clause kicks in again.

4. Therefore it makes plain common sense to get the best deal - over and above the £23.5m or whatever - now; because he's going early in 2014 whatever happens.

5. Since Bill, Bobby, Enstone, whoever are perfectly well aware of this situation, I believe that today will be Felli's last match for us. I think that he's been a great buy for us and wish him well, and my only real concern is who we get in as replacement(s).


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb