Rumour Mill: Fellaini deal agreed with Manchester United

, 1 September, 359comments  |  Jump to most recent
Transfer Deadline Special Edition

With tomorrow's 11pm transfer deadline approaching, rumour and speculation have gone into overdrive with all signs pointing to Everton relinquishing hold of Marouane Fellaini following a decisive bid from Manchester United.

Sport Wereld in Belgium are seemingly confirming well-placed sources on Merseyside that the midfielder will make the switch on Monday in a deal worth €28m (~£24m).

Alan Nixon in the Sunday People claims that the agreement is a £36m deal where the Blues have asked that a season-long loan arrangement for England U21 starlet Jesse Lingard be included in the deal. That fee and the Lindgard aspect are believed to be well wide of the mark (perhaps Mr Nixon was inferring Lingard on loan represents some level of remuneration for Everton) but a number of media outlets are reporting that Fellaini will be leaving Everton before the deadline.

Rumours had been circulating on Saturday that both Fellaini and Leighton Baines would be moving to Old Trafford for a combined fee of £45m but there has been no reliable word so far to confirm that assertion.

Nevertheless, James McCarthy is hotly tipped to be brought in as the Belgian's replacement for a fee of around £13m, while Gareth Barry is believed to be coming in on loan from Manchester City.

They are not the only players being linked with late moves to Goodison in the notoriously unreliable Sunday papers. The Mirror suggest that Roberto Martinez is also looking at drafting in Feyenoord's £10m-rated centre half Bruno ­Martins Indi and Ryan Bertrand for £7m from Chelsea as a replacement for Baines at left back. According to a separate report from the same newspaper, Everton are also pursuing a loan deal for Victor Moses but Liverpool look the more likely to tie up a deal for the Chelsea forward.

 

Reader Comments (359)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tom Owen
1 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:06:36
Alan Nixon does talk a lot of shite to be fair!

I'd say we will more likely get £26M plus add-ons.
Matt Muzi
2 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:01:48
It's looking almost a certainty that he's going, the timing is a joke, but most of us have known that he was going to go this summer. can't see us getting more than 28 though and if an awful lot of reports on various sites are accurate we lose 20% of what we sell him on for to Standard Liege.

Personally I'd like to push for Powell to come for a season loan as part of any deal, I can't see him getting many games and he looks a decent player.

I would like to see more than just McCarthy coming in, Barry in my opinion is a bonus player and not long term. I'd like to see another CM coming in on a permanent deal.

I also hope we can bring Moses in on a season loan, because if anything the last few games have shown is we have got a serious issue up front!!

Colin Glassar
3 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:12:10
Who's this Bruno Martins we are linked with? Isn't he a singer?
Robin Cannon
4 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:21:28
We shouldn't be asking for loan players. If players are gonna be part of the deal then it should be permanent deals for good youngsters.

Given our apparent inability of our strikers to score in a brothel I'd be tempted to ask for something like 15 million plus Hernandez.

Andrew Cutler
5 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:42:31
@ Colin 570...Bruno Martin the singer is coming to play for Everton? Is he any good ?
Derek Knox
7 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:29:45
Colin (#570)
Bruno Martins Indi is a Portuguese born player who has now got Dutch citizenship, he is a defender who can play Centre Half or left back. He may be okay on the karaoke, but I've seen him a couple of times playing for the Under 21's, and he looks pretty good.

I can't see this £36M figure being mentioned, considering the mingey offers they have put in up to now. We could certainly do with a striker as part of the deal, or acquire one with some of the proceeds. Then again it's last orders once again leaving us little time, although they must have targets lined up.

Anyway, not long now, all will be revealed, just hope we don't get left high and dry!
Ross Kerry
8 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:44:31
£36M for Fellaini? I can't help feeling this is not accurate.
Carl Sanderson
10 Posted 01/09/2013 at 01:48:28
Just read the text of that article. What a crock of shite. Fellaini will probably go, yes, but does Martinez really need to "plead" for "one last performance"? Did Fellaini "agree" to play against Cardiff?

I think not.

Alan Nixon - gobshite journo par excellence

Anto Byrne
11 Posted 01/09/2013 at 02:32:28
£25M for Felli and £15M for Baines.... £40M. Can we not start the rebuilding with that money?
Rob Smith
12 Posted 01/09/2013 at 02:34:09
Wigan won second game in Championship, now 8th, not much mention of McCarthy bossing the game. How much is he worth? Nowhere near £15mill.

If Felli goes, we will need more than McCarthy to save our arse.

Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:01:14
£36million????

That adds credibility to the story, doesn't it?

Chris Cook
14 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:24:20
Luke Shaw to replace Baines is the only person I'd be happy with.
James Stewart
15 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:29:54
Don't want Bertrand, Barry or Moses. Not good enough for EFC! We need pace and creative quality in central midfield. And an actual striker would be nice.
James Stewart
16 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:32:41
To pay more than Spurs paid for Eriksen (£11.5m) for McCarthy would be absolute insanity
Ross Kerry
17 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:34:57
The article that I originally commented on has changed from Fellaini to go for £36M to something much more ambiguous.
Harold Matthews
18 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:41:20
Spurs might be in for Baines.(radio rumour).
Derek Knox
19 Posted 01/09/2013 at 03:51:55
Harold (#609)
Hello mate, I can't see him going there in all honesty.I was hoping we might get Tom Ince, as it looks like Moses is going to Liverpool. I don't know what's happening with Baines, I heard that should he go, we were in for Izaguirre from Celtic, would like young McCarthy but not at the stupid money they are talking. I know, I know, it's another Wigan player, but we've got to keep Phil Walling happy, if nothing else!
I think we should get someone who knows where the goal is, and doesn't suffer from amnesia.
Gareth Fieldstead
20 Posted 01/09/2013 at 04:37:43
Do Leige really get 20%? So we would end up with around 6 million profit? Doesnt anyone else think this is garbage for one of the best midfielders in Europe? I know he is a different position but Fellaini is only worth a third of what Bale is going for? Sorry Moyes should have been told where to go. Genuinely hope we sign Ince, McCarthy and Barry.
Ingi Eyjolfz
21 Posted 01/09/2013 at 04:42:43
To be honest I cannot understand when people say Fellaini doesn´t play well anymore, he´s bossing the DM role Martinez set for him, our problem isn´t winning the ball or stopping the opposition and that´s because of him for the most part. Our problem is scoring bloody goals. We should be selling our useless strikers instead.
Peter Thistle
22 Posted 01/09/2013 at 04:55:41
If McCarthy is so great why has no other club been in for him ? Seems like another Kone, only Martinez rates em, nobody else does.
Zachary Tanner
23 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:01:42
What happened to our interest in Luca Marrone? Sounds like he'll be leaving Juventus, just a question of where... If we do sell Fellaini we'll need more than just McCarthy in, we'll also need to find a defensive mid to replace the big guy. For as much as we've all complained about our lack finishing these past 3 games, Fellaini has been instrumental in our bossing the game.
Paul Ferry
24 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:33:23
Gareth Liege get a percentage of the profit we get off Felli, not the fee.
Denis Richardson
26 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:38:05
Tbh, Fellaini wants to go so there's no point in trying to stop him, just get as much from manu as possible so the price is fair.

Anything around 25m is fair in my opinion, given that the clause he had was supposedly 23m. If we can get a player or two on top that would be a bonus. Hernandez on loan would be fantastic although am not sure he can play the holding role by himself.

Another day and bit and this whole saga and we can finally concentrate on the season.

Brett Jonathan
27 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:42:15
This whole 36 million figure is everywhere.
Have a knot in my stomach waiting to hear it is true - and it includes Baines...
Tony Draper
28 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:26:38
Gareth 616
As I understand from a recent posting here Liege would get 20% of any profit that Everton were to make for Fellaini

Personally, I'd far far rather we kept both him and Bainsey, they're class and we won't be able to replace like for like or better

Mark Tanton
30 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:50:36
We are all desperate for some pace, some new faces in midfield - well as usual at Everton you only get new faces in by cashing in on older expensive faces unfortunately. So let's the bite the bullet today and let Martinez put his contingency plan into effect. I predict two or three out and three in.
Jamie Crowley
32 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:52:16
I've seen this coming for weeks. Everyone has.

So why do I feel like I've been punched in the gut?

In my 7 years of following / supporting / being absolutely obsessed with Everton Football Club I don't think I've ever seen a better player wear the royal blue jersey.

If not Felliani than who? Arteta? Possibly. Cahill? No...

7 years... please name me a better player.

This stinks.

I'm going to really, really miss the fro.

I pray this is tabloid shit. But I know better...

Harold Matthews
33 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:02:55
OK Derek. Don't know anything the Celtic lad but I'd like a strong fast leftfooter with a hungry attitude.
I'd also like to swop Pienaar for Kim, the Cardiff lad, who is probably better than McCarthy. Yeah, the Wigan spraycan is a decent player but the proposed fee stinks of money in everyones pocket.....and I do mean everyone.

Of course, none of these guys can hold a candle to Fellaini and Baines and a dip in quality is the last thing we need.
I mentioned Pienaar earlier because of a moment when he smiled and slowly strolled to retrieve the ball for a throwin. Time was running out, we were desperate for a goal and he looked as though he couldn't care less.

As for the goal famine and overpassing. With the whole universe talking about it surely something will be sorted.

Rob Smith
34 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:59:19
Personally living in fantasy of course. Rooney for Felli. Sign McCarthy or Marrone, tell Wayne he has big shoes to fill, tell Osman he has a big bench to fill.
Really, watching Rooney lately, slot him into Osmans Pos, keep everyone else, I would be confident of top 6,
Martin Mason
35 Posted 01/09/2013 at 06:05:15
It's very sad to see Everton's reduced status now as a club that finds value and sells to the big clubs. Tragically sad for me to see us selling our best players as again it shows our enfeebled state and you can't improve by selling your best players.

Whatever happens, Everton are reduced by the selling of Fellaini; he is a very good player but sad though it is we can't keep players of his stature at the club. Manchester United will improve with the purchase and we will become more and more Wigan rather than a top 6 club.

The gap between us and the top 6 is now becoming a chasm because, as we sell, they are buying and this includes Liverpool who I can't see us getting within 10 points of this year. The euphoria of a new manager and a small flurry of transfer activity has for me changed to a sense of despair.

Ste Traverse
36 Posted 01/09/2013 at 06:21:45
Can the whoppers on here who have been banging on about this McCarthy over the last few weeks please tell us why they wasn't rabbiting on about him as a potential signing at the end of last season when he was part of the side which took the Pie Eaters down.

Encouraging us to sell one of the best midfielders in Europe and replace him with James fucking McCarthy who is currently doing nothing in the Championship.....do me a fucking favour,

Sean McKenna
37 Posted 01/09/2013 at 06:30:54
Haaaaa... clearly the people who say James McCarthy is shite only watch Everton FC. For me, he is a class player full of energy pace and can pass and shoot, a proper box-to-box little gem; however, £10 mill should be the max.

The reason he isn't pulling up any trees in the Championship is because Wigan are back to long-ball tactics under Coyle.

I know... let's sack Robby, I mean all this pretty passing is crap isn't it. Let's get Tony Pulis in, buy Peter Crouch, and hump the ball all day. I'm sure every fan wants to watch that!! The mind boggles on here. All we need is a finisher, end of.

Sam Hoare
38 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:08:54
James Stewart 606, bang on. If we pay 12m for McCarthy, a decent prospect who keeps things ticking along, while spurs paid 11.5m for eriksen, a highly sought after youngster with real creative brilliance it will not look like value for money!
Karl Jones
39 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:19:06
Everton will always sell their best players until Kenwright the dreamer sells the club.
Carl Reid
40 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:21:45
May I ask Toffeweb in what planet do you sell your best resources in order to improve and no mention of the parasite behind all this, the so called Evertonian Kenwright. Its only eight weeks ago that he was extolling Roberto and telling us we would we would see Champions League yet he has not backed the man one iota and has actually undermined him by dealing with that thing (Moyes). A man who publically imformed our fans that the players they have paid to watch cannot cannot be competitive until they leave Goodison to futher careers at more ambitous clubs.
Nah not for me. Kenwright is now publically telling each and every one of you that Everton is his to do as he pleases and taking fans as only Newcastle seemed to do. I for one would rather sit in a smelly ale house with a dodgy satellite before Kenwright sees a penny of my very hard earned money. Brought up on Everton with a family obsessed by them. 43 years watching never again whilst Kenwright is there. When did we all become so lemming like?

Mark Tanton
41 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:49:26
Planet Everton Carl. Have you been in a coma? We've gotten ourselves into the top six, and qualified for the Champions League too on this model. We buy young prospects and we sell them at profit and then we scout new younger prospects again.

Is that so hard to understand? It's shit, but it's reality. We can survive and compete only by doing this. We'll move forward on the Baines/Fellaini money and that will be the end of it.

Daniel Lawrence
42 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:57:01
The only team's fans in the league that will see a top 10 finish as progress having finished sixth last year.
As mentioned at the start of the window, the only certainty was we'd show a profit on transfers out. Clap Clap Kenwright
Mike Hughes
43 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:52:53
Frustratingly it'll be an undisclosed fee thought to be around......£24m

No more Wigan players for me. As others have stated there is little value there.

A centre mid and striker are a must. However, no time so panic buying / loan deals.

Hope I'm wrong but, on prospective transfer market dealings, we're a long way off top 6 and seemingly going backwards.

Simon Österhof
44 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:02:31
It seems to me that we need a striker even more than we need Fellaini, but perhaps that's just me trying to soften the blow of losing him. It certainly feels like there is no possible outcome of this transfer window that'll feel like an improvement.
Kevin Day
45 Posted 01/09/2013 at 07:50:04
You've only got to look at how Daniel Levy has been treating Real Madrid over Bale, he has had them running around in circles.

And we are lumbered with Bill Kenwright, who lets Moyes dictate to him what he should do with Everton players, the whole thing stinks, Levy has made Madrid wait until AVB has been able to get his replacement players in before letting him go.

We all know this Fellaini deal will not go through until there's minutes to spare while we end up with the scraps on the table.

How have we become like this?

Carl Reid
46 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:11:27
Clap clap Mark?My god are you Uncle Bills dad by any chance. The mans a parasite and btw we didn't have an AGM for four years so who actually knows. Your point re Champions League. He should have sold then. But hey Nil Satis Nisi Optimum mate. Or is that financially unrealistic to you lot?
Joe McMahon
47 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:23:04
James Stewart (605) You've gotta wise up. EFC are not a power anymore (we should be). We can't pay big wages, the stadium is a joke and we have the likes of Osman and Jelavic in our starting 11. Our success is in history only, the Bill Kenwright years have only carried that on (and worse). If Liverpool want Moses they will get him (he is a good player) look at their activity this season. EFC will have to made do as usual.
Peter Barry
48 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:28:47
Stand by for the "We tried to spend the Fellaini/Baines transfer money but it was too late" announcement from Billy Liar — or maybe he will try to make Martinez the fall guy.
Peter Barry
49 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:33:08
Oh and of course the 'Ring-fenced until the January window' bullshit too.
Paul Low
50 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:12:13
Mike. With the cash the top 6 have spent and are spending, we are miles behind them now anyway and there is nothing we can do about it. We have to wake up to the reality that money rules the game and we don't have any. Finishing seventh and aiming for a cup is our level until we get serious investment.
Joe McMahon
51 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:40:57
Mark Tanton - we never qualified for the Champions league, we went out at the qualifying stage. We then automatically went into the Uefa cup where we got hammered by Dinamo Bucharest 5-1. So yes glory days indeed.
andrew jones
52 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:44:06
Expect Man U will get Fella for a lot less than we expect. It hurts me to say we are a selling club. I recall BK saying Martinez had cash to spend and any money from sales would be ploughed back in the squad! Yet again it's the 11th hour literally! And we haven't really invested. given up trying to understand EFC transfer budgets other than the pot is empty yet again!I fear the worse we receive £36m for Fella & Baines and spend half, the rest services the debt and we buy another Wigan player plus a season long loan (s). We need a striker as what we have doesn't look up to it. No way to build a future for this great club with loans and uncertainty would rather youth.
Expect BK to throw a few lines about investment soon just to placate fans. Nevertheless this is Everton so COYB!
Andreas Salomaa
53 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:08:00
BUY IN HONDA NOW MUCH BETTER AND MC OR BUY JAMES MILNER LOAN CHICORITO FROM THE REDS FELLAN FOR 25€ AND CHICORITO NEED A STRIKER NOW!!!
Anthony Flack
54 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:11:22
Feels to me that this is all going to be
Lewis Barclay
55 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:12:58
Bertrand would be a great purchase I think.
Anthony Flack
56 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:11:51
Feels to me that this is all going to be disappointing unless we pull out of the bag something very exciting and surprising. Probably McCarthy is a decent player but seems to invoke a half hearted reaction amongst us lot a bit like Kone has. Ironically I think Man U fans will react in the same way to Fellaini. I think he would shine there and the press will crawl further up Moyes arse.

Not sure who there is that ticks the right boxes, we need to get a striker singing and create some excitement and drive.

Fingers crossed

Mark Dunford
57 Posted 01/09/2013 at 08:58:02
It is simply naive to expect Fellaini to remain an Everton player. He has been a good servant to the club in the past five years or so, yet he has been consistently linked with moves to a Champions League team and it was no surprise to learn of a clause in his contract allowing him to move on if the right bid came in. The puzzle here is that it has been allowed to drag on till the end of the window and he seems to be going for the trigger amount. This may be down to Utd trying to lever a more favourable deal but they have failed to do so.

The main thing now is to reinvest the money wisely. To my eyes the midfield lacks a player with guile and vision so I'd say McCarthy is a good signing - someone in the Arteta mould who passes forward. I also think we need a defensive midfielder who can play the central holding role with authority. All the other midfielders are problematic for different reasons - Osman (age), Barkley (raw and unproven), Lundstrom (untried) and most worryingly Gibson (fitness). We need to resolve this before it turns into a serious problem. Heitinga might offer something if he regains his form but he may well leave in next day or so. Up front is another priority and it is a shame that Moses has gone. Kone has started poorly.

Baines's position is hard to call and, despite the rumour mill, he may well stay. We seem to have good cover at left back with Oviedo ready to step up and Garbutt waiting in the wings so I'm not sure we need a signing now. Having said this, I still think he would be a massive loss but there isn't an obvious replacement. Is Chelski's reserve really a better prospect than Oviedo?

Marc Sansum
58 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:19:02
Mccarthy is doomed from the start, no matter what fee we agree. Majority of fans don't seem enamoured with him.
Only watched a couple of youtube clips, and he looks a bit like a younger, quicker version of Gibson. Very tidy and busy, but he's not the creative midfielder we are craving. Unless its Mccarthy and another that we are unaware of........
Ian Glassey
59 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:12:45
Can we not take the money and buy Wigan F.C.
Ajay Gopal
60 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:22:52
I would be ecstatic if Chelsea would trump Moyes and go for Fellaini - and as pasrt of the deal, loan Torres for 1 year. McCarthy & Marrone from the Fellaini money would be alright for me. Not a bad end to this whole sordid saga.
Tommy Coleman
61 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:31:06
Let the insanity begin. .. I might just switch off all media outlets until Tuesday.
John Crawley
62 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:34:03
With the clause in Fellaini's contract it was inevitable that he would go at some point. The problem here is Kenwright and the rest of the board. They should have backed Martinez and done what Levy has done at Tottenham, sign the players we want to replace Fellaini first before selling him.

I feel sorry for Martinez in all of this, he has had no backing from Kenwright or the board and had clearly been hung out to dry. The ownership of the club is the real problem and until that is resolved we are going nowhere, no matter who the manager is.

Paul Rimmer
63 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:38:13
It'll be a busy time for Everton over the next few hours. I think Anichebe will join Fellaini as outgoings and we'll bring in McCarthy, Ince and Barry. I hope Baines stays but it depends how much Man U offer.
Steve Guy
64 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:34:59
Selling cheap and buying over the odds is how this all feels. All left to the last minute as per usual. Don't forget to applaud the Dear Leader for another great contribution to the slow decline of our Club.
Carl Sanderson
65 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:40:02
It is notable that Fellaini's dad has shut his great, cavernous gob over the last few months. To me that suggests that the lad is finally on his way.
Tom R Owen
66 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:47:58
Steve 658
We are all singing from the same hymn book!
The man is destroying OUR club
Callum McNab
67 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:40:30
John Crawley, we are going nowhere anyway. I watched Martinez after the game last night and it was the same speeches he gave for Wigan last year. Complaining about the ref, just needed a bit of luck. He has been hung out to dry by Billy Liar, but it's up to him to stand up to the crap house. He is Billy Liar's dream, doesn't want to get involved with any dealings. God help us.
Ian Glassey
68 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:43:51
Spot on John 682.
We will be in this state every transfer window untill that slimeball of a chairman leaves this club. He got far more backing off broken leg Dave than he will get off Bullshit Billy..
Ian Glassey
69 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:43:51
Spot on John 682.
We will be in this state every transfer window untill that slimeball of a chairman leaves this club. He got far more backing off broken leg Dave than he will get off Bullshit Billy..
Paul Smith
70 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:42:58
Feel sorry for RM in this. BK, no where to be seen, especially after all his guff about money to spend and now even Sharpy is having a pop, Knob.

Seems some are traumatised by the loss of Moye's and I don't mean just the fan base.

The next 48 hrs should be very interesting. I for one am willing to back RM, I like the guy, he's a welcome change. But it's not me that matters, it's the people at the club.

Terrible comment from Graeme Sharp If it's true, BK's mouthpiece.

Carl Sanderson
71 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:44:39
I actually think McCarthy would be a decent player in Martinez's system. He gets around the pitch really well, works bloody hard and can see a pass.

For all his skills, Felli can be a bit of a stroller, which can be fatal when one of our attacks breaks down. McCarthy would reduce that possibility.

Not for one second am I suggesting that McCarthy is the better player, merely that he would be more likely to make Martinez's system work.

Ian McDowell
72 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:55:06
Another disastrous transfer window for Everton.

Wish we had someone like Levy. He has played hardball now over Berbatov, Modric and Bale and got fortunes for them.

John Crawley
73 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:56:29
Paul - what exactly did Graeme Sharp say about Martinez?
Joe Bibb
74 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:55:01
Let Fellaini go. He is another one who has ideas above his station. Pienaar was the same but he too was found out at Tottenham and we foolishly brought him back. Arteta is another one who thought he was a star but he he has not been brilliant at Arsenal despite his injuries.

Sell anyone who wants to leave. Build a new and exciting Everton. It's time to leave the Moyes era behind.

Eugene Ruane
75 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:35:02
Over the past couple of weeks I've read many posts on TW along the lines "Fellani is a big plant-pot, not arsed if he goes etc" and others (like me) expressing the view he's a very effective player and that him going will have a big (negative) effect on us.

Both views fair enough I suppose - we're all allowed to rate (or not) who we want to rate and it's clear supporters see the game/players differently, so not surprising opinions can go from 'he's great' to 'he's cack'.

For me what IS beyond dispute is that the timing of this and the way it has been handled has been (and is!) a complete and utter fucking disgrace.

Weeks and weeks to get it sorted out one way or the other and (if it goes through) it will happen practically on the last fucking day!!?

Maybe the deal isn't done as I write, but no matter, imo, should anyone feel like giving Moyes a warm hand on his return to Goodison, you'll deserve your wrists breaking.

Man Utd and David Moyes have shat all over Everton Football Club in the last couple of months and anyone who can't see that is deaf, blind and stupid.

As for Kenwright, he has been...well...Kenwright.

Ian Glassey
76 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:55:32
Graeme Sharp should be laying the blame were it belongs, in the boardroom.
But then he is looking after his job. Oh and what a great job of being a manager he made. Just shut up Sharp..
Nick Entwistle
77 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:04:03
If he goes - IF! Then why wait till the last hours of the clock? There must be, surely, a deal in place elsewhere to have a replacement come to fill the hole.

If its McCarthy then I'll eat my sofa.

Michael Parrington
78 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:04:00
BK will cash in on Fellaini at the 11th hour... 'Oh no' he'll quip, there's no time to sign anyone... Don't worry though you'll get the Fellaini money to spend with the Arteta money...
Mike Gwyer
79 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:33:07

So sick of being United's bitch - once this shit is all over then we can just sit back and watch BK deal with Barkley, and no doubt Moyes smirking in the background (he really is a fuckwit, but he knows how to take advantage of the financial issues this great club has - how BK even talks to the twat is beyond me).

McCarthy (Martinez had better be right about this boy) or fucking whoever we buy for CM is not the only problem, we need a striker big time because I'm sick to death of watching Jelavic play, he is so fucking shit, crap and wank that its not even an argument.

Yet the worse bit is losing Baines, this will be the killer - our left side attack has been our powerhouse for the past 4 seasons. No way will we replace like for like. How can BK continue to let this club be a fucking bitch to Moyes and his club. I would prefer to let Baines contract run down and continue to play him for next two years. It would be fucking worth watching that ginger twat moan like fuck.

I have seen dark days of the 90's and I can assure you no one at Goodison really gives a fuck - it definitely ain't BK. We were cramming almost 40 thousand into relegation battles against the powerhouses of Coventry and Wimbledon. The atmosphere was electric and believe me the games were end to end battles.

So almost 20 years on we are now just Manchester United's fucking bitch and any player, manager, assistant manager, trainer, coach or tea lady that we produce, that is worth a light, will end up at Old fucking Trafford. Well they can just fuck right off.

Alan Humphreys
80 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:54:19
What's Fans liaison officer/Kenwright mouthpiece said Paul ?

Other than his usual drivel ?

Phil Sammon
81 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:09:46
Sharpy de-FIN-ATE-ly talking more shite. Surprise surprise.

Gone from a real legend of a lad into the club's puppet. He's done the old 'reverse Pinocchio'.

John Crawley
82 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:09:26
Eugene completely agree, it's pissing me off no end how this has been dealt with by Moyes, who has proved himself a complete hypocrite. However Kenwright could have put a stop to all of this. All he had to do was say the deal needs to be concluded before the season started and after that we will not be selling. I'm sure he could have told Moyes that in one of his regular weekly phone calls!
Ged Simpson
83 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:17:01
What did Sharpe say ?
Paul Gladwell
84 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:15:47
He was slagging Barkley off as well yesterday saying he had a poor game, the lad was head and shoulders our best player.
Ian Glassey
85 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:11:44
Just read on one site that we have had a bid for McCarthy knocked back
yesterday £10mill in installments, there must be a dodgy knee in there
somewhere..
Ged Simpson
86 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:19:23
I was off football radar yesterday - trying to catch up - What did Sharpe say ?
Paul Gladwell
87 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:17:50
Very critical of Martinez before game too as he was before he became manager then changed his tune and became all nicey nicey back tracking, what else has he said?
Gary Leonard
88 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:27:37
I hope that we get cash up front and that it's not blown on over-paying for some second rate replacements. £8M max for McCarthy. I'm not saying he's second rate, but he's not (yet) worth £15M-£20M. It's not worth selling them unless there is a real benefit for Everton. Bearing in mind the cost of replacements, it is almost worth running down their contracts unless we get a good price for them. I'd also rather we hung onto the money until January, rather than make some bad rushed deals now.
Andrew Presly
89 Posted 01/09/2013 at 09:45:03
In terms of value, if unknowns like Fernandinho and Wilian can fetch £30m each then that is at least what Fellaini, an in-his-prime, proven performer at PL and international level, should cost. Eg, how much will Man U value him at after a decent first season / World Cup and bigger fish like Real Madrid inquire? £50-£60m no doubt.

In terms of replacements, if as suggested the money in goes on 2 Championship players (McCarthy, Ince) and Gareth Barry well that sounds like the road to mid-table mediocrity to me...or worse. No goals in the team as it is yet we're selling last season's top scorer at a knockdown price?!

We're a big club not acting like one yet again and it's squarely Bill's fault. Even Moyes' unforgivable antics aren't putting him off doing this deal he's been pushing since the Martinez press conference. Where is the pride? The fans still have some even if he doesn't. Your behaviour on this has been shameful, Bill.

More importantly, where is the TV money? We lost several high earners from the staff and player's wage bill this summer with just a few Wigan guys and a loaned youth prospect in return so even without sales there should be significant money to spend? Where is it and why with 2 days left in the window are we in this position yet again?

Kenwright is the reason for both these issues, as always, and the end of the Moyes tenure should ideally see the back of Bill too.

Like Moyes, no trophies on his watch, out of ideas, repeating the same mistakes again and again but too stubborn or stupid to ask anyone for help or try something different ie, how about not selling the team's best players all the time, see how that goes....if we need to pay off some interest on the debts fine, sell fringe players contributing nothing like Heitinga (leaving on a free next summer?!), Gueye or Naismith.

Kenwright, put the club up for sale at its market value and let someone else have a go. How long can this go on? We're going nowhere.

Tony Cheek
90 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:29:08
I will miss him, but really hoping that Baines is not in the same deal. What a prick Moyes is, with all the players he could have strengthened with, he has to come for our best two. Hate the man!
Yesterday we watched Fellainis last game for Everton, not his best, but a very important input in midfield. But we also saw the worst of him as he tried to put his elbow through Campbells head ( Does anyone think he might get banned for that)?
Great player, but real arsehole, always seemed really arrogant when interviewed.
Hope we get a strong replacement, Barry would do for me!
Andrew Presly
91 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:36:22
Sharp - we would've won that match under Moyes.

Silly on a few levels.

Tony Cheek
93 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:37:30
.....and I bet the first time he scores against us, it will be badge kissing and chest thumping in front of our fans!
Paul Gladwell
94 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:38:16
Tony, agree, also very arrogant and could never give a minute when I saw him in the lounges after getting MOTM always in a rush to piss off unlike Jags and a few others I saw, what's the bet he will do one of those elbows in a big Euro tie?
Paul Gladwell
95 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:40:32
Andrew, sums him up, I heard a similar shout in the crowd at Norwich, you know the same ground where we were 1-0 up and lost in last few minutes, can people not feck that fella off, he's gone and is now shitting all over us, lets get behind our new manager, he has come in, trying new ideas and each Friday before all our three games has had to put up with all this transfer shit, surely that alone warrants some respect from these moaners.
Phil Rodgers
96 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:44:29
Norwich paid about 3 million for that Redmond! Dropped a bollock there if you ask me.
Sam Higgins
97 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:46:28
I think ill be listening to Enya's greatest hits on my iPod come Monday evening... Let the entire debacle wash over me in a wave of dreamy bliss!!
Sam Higgins
98 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:46:28
I think ill be listening to Enya's greatest hits on my iPod come Monday evening... Let the entire debacle wash over me in a wave of dreamy bliss!!
Gary Leonard
99 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:43:56
I don't want to put our club down, but this deal says a lot about Moyes... There is no indication that Mourinho, Villas-Boas, or managers from any of the big European clubs that MU are in competion with, are interested in MF. He doesn't seem to be able to do the 'big' deals.
Sam Fitzsimmons
100 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:29:59
This is sort of off topic - but if and when Felli goes to Manu who drops out of United's current starting 11 to accomodate the big lad. Carrick, Cleverly?
Gary Leonard
101 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:51:45
Still sorry to see MF go though. He is quality.
John Crawley
102 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:59:30
Sam 739 - Rooney!
James Martin
103 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:54:51
We should be rejoicing that he might be going. We can sort out our midfield problems once and for all and get the goals flowing whilst Fellaini can go and clog up/slow down someone elses midfield.

I can picture it now, Carrick releases Fellaini into space with the Old Trafford faithful exhorting him to carry it forward. After two painfully slow strides with the ball, he comes under pressure, retains possession through a mixture of elbows/his hair in the players face, and lays off one of his classic foot rolled over the top of the ball backwards passes to the full back immediately putting him under pressure leaving him with no option but to hoof it. Fellaini then spends the next 10 minutes made up with himself that he kept possession, whilst a moronic section of the Old Trafford crowd fall in love with him because he's a bit feisty and has got boss hair and passes it really slowly because he's got so much class.

If Moyes drops Carrick for Fellaini that will be the death knell of any chance United will ever have of winning the title.

Richard Dodd
104 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:55:55
Felli picks up his latest loyalty (?) bonus today at noon and is then free to sign for Manyou for £24.Whelan waiting at the door to collect his 55% (£13M)and hand over McCarthy.

Deal done days ago but held up by that bonus clause.

Sharpy on the carpet this morning and may soon be unemployed.

Rob Prince
105 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:56:12
Sorry to see him go too. Great player- but the inevitable is about to happen. Let´s be perfectly honest too, he does NOT fit into Martinez´style of play, and has been virtually ineffectual so far in the games we´ve played. He should be as we all know, played in an advanced role almost a striker chesting down long balls on the edge of the box or flicking on long balls. generally making a nuisance of himself int he opponesnts box. My view is that Martinez has known all along that he´s going so has refused to play that way in order for the players to get used to the system.We must get an Arteta style midfielder for this new system. That Gary Medel looked good he would have been a good signing. Shame how even clubs like Cardiff are taking the piss out of us these days. Sell Jelavic to Hull or Crystal Palace or someone, bench Mirallas as he´s been awful and play Delofeu, give Vellios a go? or sign someone like Defoe. Drop Osman as whatever he is he is not a deep lying midfielder as he´s been deployed recently. Keep Howard Distin and Jags in the team. Don´t be afraid to drop Coleman (he was gash yesterday) and FFS Roberto don´t be afraid to mix it up! make early substitutions not 5 mins at the end. Drop players who are crap and eb a bit more canny all round
Steve Pugh
106 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:52:29
If they go and the money isn't reinvested in players then Kenwright must be held to account. The TV money has, apparently, already gone to service the debt and he promised, for what it's worth, all money from sales would go to Robbie.

Too many supporters have let him get away with too much for too long, if this becomes another in the long list of Bull then we need to stop being the well behaved Evertonians that the word thinks we are and really start going after the board. Regardless of what the team is doing on the pitch.

Colin Glassar
107 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:51:09
Reading the Sunday Express today makes for dire reading.

BK will accept around £40m for both players his reasons being; A) he's still deeply in love, and in awe, of his darling David. B) He thinks it's unfair to deny both players a chance of a 'dream move' to BK's real team I.e. man u. C) The banks want the money so Martinez can consider himself lucky if he sees half of any sale.

Ladies and gents, BK's like a disease in our club and we will never move forward while he's in charge.

Sam Fitzsimmons
108 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:04:22
John 742 you may not be that far off the mark. No doubt the undercurrents between DM and Rooney still exist and DM is clearly besotted by Felli - so here's the scenario - maybe Rooney will go of to chelski before the transfer deadline. Torres on loan to Everton to solve our striker problem, Jelavic to Liverpool to replace Suarez who is snapped up by Spurs to replace Bale.

I should work as a football correspondent for the mail
Paul Smith
109 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:05:57
John @700

Apparently someone on a thread yesterday said "sharp said we would of won that game if DM was in charge".

Granted not an OS announcement - that's why I added the caveat if. But if true it's an interesting remark to make from someone so involved in the club.

Rob Smith
110 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:52:06
Mike Gwyer - Legend! How fucking true, shabby treatment.

Eugene - it is a gut sick feeling picturing a midfield minus Felli, sold at the last hour, without replacing, anyone will go through us like butter, no one else disrupts opposing play like he does, maybe BK is looking at cloning Osman with the Felli money, fucking scary.

As Ste also said James Fucking McCarthy that is not a replacement, he has hardly been mentioned in any match reports I have read on Wigans games.
I really thought Martinez might have connections similar to Laudrup, Michu types maybe not for 2mill but around 5 to 7 mill McCarthy for that money not as a Felli replacement but certainly as someone who could keep improving. We won't be bossing anyone with McCarthy and Osman as first choice.

Barry Rathbone
111 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:56:03
Terrific ruse in my book.

Obviously lulling utd, city, chels etc into a false sense of security by appearing to weaken the side.

Can't fool me ...... clearly a few new signings earmarked to join Delboy and Barkley blindsiding them all to win the treble in style.

Can't wait.

Kunal Desai
112 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:52:13
I've said it time and time and time again, the only way change will take place at this great club, is where the match day goers get involved. Protests in masses, even if things have to get ugly for Billy Boy, if that's what it takes for him and his pals to get the fuck out of Everton and sell up then so be it. Otherwise we keep putting up with this sort of shit every transfer window for the next decade or two. It's quite simple, the fans NEED to make change happen, no one else will change it.
Danny Hughes
113 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:10:09
Gareth Barry is way past his best. Even when he was at his best, he was crap, his legs went years ago. What about Holtby or Sigurdsson? Don't really want McCarthy either, he's no Felli, is he?

Come on, we sell Felli and Baines and bring in who they're speculating, then I fear for us this season. No investment again, season on season, and we put up with it. We are a joke.

Colin Wainwright
114 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:12:30
It was always going to be hard to replace Fellaini, near impossible with only one day of the window left. Despite the dwindling number of blind men who can't (or wont) see what he brings to the side, I think most Evertonians can see we'll struggle without him, but if he's going, get it sorted today. Have to say though, this has all the hallmarks of a Bullshit Bill special (Rooney, Arteta.....).
James Marshall
115 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:11:51
James Martin#743 - Quality post mate, and exactly what Fellaini is all about. Windmill in a gale as someone once said, and I'm equally as happy to see the back of him.

Take the money & run, buy someone more dynamic who won't slow us down all the time. McCarthy is quicker, and likely to fit the Martinez way of playing that we're currently not very good at.

Colin Glassar #747 (and others) - I don't understand why all the ill will towards Bill Kenwright regarding these transfers at all? How on earth is it his fault that Manchester United want to buy them?

A) In love with Moyes? What on earth are you talking about?

B) BK's real team, Man Utd? What on earth are you talking about?

C) We have large debt to service. And?

You may blame Kenwright for certain issues surrounding the money side of things, but there's more to EFC than one man, Colin - there's an entire board not just one person to blame for the financial state at Everton, and besides, what has any of that hatred of one person go to to with us selling a player to Manchester United?

Clubs sell players to each other all the time, and every player has his price. Fellaini wants to leave, Man Utd (and ONLY Man Utd) want him, so why not sell him? He's not going to want to play for us any more anyway and we've had a few decent years out of him, so what's the big deal?

Why would we want to keep a player that doesn't want to play for us any more? Good luck to him, he's never made any secret that he wants to play for a Champions League team, and that we ain't.

This has bugger all to do with Bill Kenwright, I don't get why so many people are blaming him for any player wanting to leave.

It's just weird, fuzzy-logic.

John Crawley
116 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:14:31
Thanks Paul - very poor comment by Sharp in the context of what has been going on. Steve - 746, agree completely; Kenwright and the way the club is being run off the field is the real problem, fans need to start putting pressure on the board to go.

After Kenwright's comments at the press conference if Martinez doesn't get all of the proceeds and was to resign over all of this I wouldn't blame him.

James Marshall
117 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:24:03
Disclaimer: McCarthy is far from being my choice to replace him I should add, and if we don't have replacements lined up then this deal is a farce and some of what I've said above should be disregarded!
Mark Tanton
118 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:25:13
Doddy, I always find your comments interesting... Is Sharpy being carpeted for his comments regarding how the previous regime would have won yesterday?

I think that is fair enough and an indication that Kenwright backs Martinez - as he should.

I just he backs him in the way the other nineteen chairmen seem capable of, with some money.

Sharabi Singh
119 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:30:32
As usual, Kenwright won't give a toss what the fans think and he'll sell Fellaini regardless. All RM can do is invest what he's given from that arsehole.

We've only ever needed a decent striker at this club, I thought Jelavic was the man but clearly he's not. RM, if you read these columns, invest the lot in a top forward.

Colin Wainwright
120 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:24:53
How do you know he wants to leave James?

As the Chairman of the board of directors and the man responsible for inviting our infamous missing director, Robert Earl, (or another "friend" of the club) to purchase shares and cement his majority shareholding, when he patently did not have the finances, ability or plain fucking intelligence, to run a premier league football club, he is very much to blame. This is not even taking into account his continuing cosy chats with our ex-manager, a man who at present, is in the process of trying to buy one (maybe two) of our best players on the cheap.

John Crawley
121 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:27:41
James 761 - You are correct in that the whole board is responsible and not just Kenwright, but he is the chairman and the public face of the board so he is going to get the majority of the blame. The situation with regard to Fellaini and his sale at the last minute are however down to Kenwright.

The reason why that clause is in his contract in the first place was because of our weak bargaining position at the time of contract negotiations. That weak bargaining position was caused by our poor financial performance off the field, which led to the banks appointing a member of staff to work at Goodison and to insist that players were sold to reduce the debt that had been accrued. Whilst not Moyes's biggest fan the simple fact is that if the club had performed off the pitch to the same level that Moyes performed on the pitch we wouldn't be in the mess that we are in financially. That is down to Kenwright and the board.

So yes Kenwright is not responsible for the player wanting to leave but he is responsible for the context in which he leaves, i.e. the amount we have to sell him for, the lateness of the sale and the failure to back Martinez to get the replacements in for him BEFORE he is sold. Those conditions are all a reflection of the poor financial state of the club and that is solely down to Kenwright and the board.

Gerry Western
122 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:16:38
Make no mistake Fellaini will be a huge loss and to compound the problem we're quite likely to sell him below his true value. With little time to find a replacement I suspect we'll be expected to pay well over the odds for whoever it may be. Most clubs would factor this into the selling price and if need be refuse to sell if an adequate replacement cannot be found but it would seem that BK and that ass hole(OFM) are busy negotiating with RM totally out of the loop and this in itself is a disgusting state of affairs.

It will be interesting to see what sort of price Dave Whelan will be seeking this close to the window closing, expect to see some hard nosed dealing here as one would expect. The truth is we'll need two replacements to cover for the loss of Fellaini such is his impact on our performance. The one I feel truly sorry for is RM, he's pretty much been told he's got no control over transfer policy and has been hung out to dry by BK, for a new manager that must be sole destroying. Lets hope the fans continue to get behind him as he needs and deserves our support.

Colin Wainwright
123 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:39:21
Well said Gerry.
Mark Fitzgerald
124 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:20:46
I wish they'd just get the deal over with ASAP. Seems clear that something will happen, perhaps both going. But whatever way you look at it, this will hugely weaken the team, taking perhaps our two most influential players. I understand the reality of doing the business but the money (whatever the true figure will be) must be invested wisely. Calls for a creative CM are spot on. Personally I like McCarthy - at a realistic price that is not double figures. But he's not the type of player who will dominate the midfield. Surely we could pick up an established international CM from the continent for the money that is being mentioned here. And secondly we have seen proof that pacey attackers who run at the opposition are a must. Deulofeu's cameos have shown this, Redmond at Norwich has shown this, Hazard, Ben-Arfa, etc. Could do with someone like this until Mirallas emerges from his slump. Up front is another obvious concern and an extra defender if Baines goes. So, four quality signings required. Is that too much to expect from the money we receive?
James Stewart
125 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:33:45
McCarthy is all well and good providing the price is realistic. Again Spurs got Capoue for 9m and Eriksen for 11.5m which is amazing business. They will challenge for the league with that team.

McCarthy is not the one who will unlock defences though. Most of that was down to Maloney or McManaman at Wigan. We still need a no.10 creative player as well as McCarthy.

Mat Fearon
126 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:41:17
James (743). You are right, we will not miss him at all will we. Top scorer last season, can play a holding role in midfield, or in front of defence, fantastic in the air and the one that adds some real bite to the midfield.
What on earth are you on about?
Ged Simpson
127 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:38:18
"he's still deeply in love, and in awe, of his darling David"......"DM is clearly besotted by Felli "

Despite the state of the game and our club - nice to see there's such love in the air

Matt Traynor
128 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:34:00
Mark #764 I'm with you - since decamping to Leigh and apparently ending his hero-worship of all thinks Bill / DM, and instead offering the insgihts "from the shop floor" his posts have become readable again! Even if they are generally delivering bad news...
Paul Gladwell
129 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:47:58
For those saying we need someone with that killer pass we have him (Barkle) and he did a few killer passes yesterday only the end product was embarrassing.
Carl Sanderson
130 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:44:16
Mat 778:

Exactly. No disrespect but I couldn't believe James's post. This double deal is going to tear the heart out of the team. We won't be finishing in the top six this season, that's for sure.

This is all happening because Bullshit Billy and his acolytes have put the club in such an appalling financial state. Their disgraceful incompetence means that we will never be a big club again. Thanks, Bill, you luvvie gobshite.

James Marshall
131 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:52:27
All reports talk about Fellaini wanting to leave, Colin and he has always stated he wants to play for a Champions League club so surely he DOES want to leave? Why would that stance change now, especially as how a Champions League club are trying to buy him? It all makes sense in that regard that he would still want to go, don’t you think?

He’s been with us a few years, and he knows Moyes well (obviously) so it all fits perfectly for him. Manchester United are also a much bigger fish than us, so I don’t understand why anyone has a hard time thinking anything other than Fellaini would want to go there.

As for the last minute sale – it always happens with the transfer window, and that’s not Kenwright’s fault either. He held out for more money, which as long as it goes back in and we buy replacements before end of tomorrow, to my mind, is the right thing to do. All clubs do it, not just ours.

The clause was a red herring in my opinion – pointless and was always going to invite lower bids once it expired.

You and John are both talking about things that may or may not happen, so I would say that if (IF) this deal happens and we don’t buy any replacements, then Kenwright AND the board are accountable.

If we sell and buy, then at that point, surely we would have nothing to complain about regarding this transfer? It’s clear you guys are also taking this a lot further and talking about the wider issues of club management at board level, whereas I’m really only interested in these transfer deals.

Mat Fearon #778 - I haven't said we won't miss him, but I do believe he's not going to fit our system any more, so while you make good points about him LAST season, I don't believe he'll be anywhere near as effective for us THIS season.

James Marshall
132 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:54:34
Oh and Mat - with regard to him being top scorer last year. He never should have had to be top scorer. That in itself is a damning indictment of the way we played last year, that a defensive midfield player should have to stand up and become our highest scorer. That's what strikers are for.
Ross Norman
133 Posted 01/09/2013 at 10:43:27
I fully agree with you James (606), how on earth can McCarthy be worth more than Eriksen? I’m fuming that this deal is only be done now; the majority of potential targets are gone to other clubs. Wonder how Eriksen and Capoue would have done in our midfield opposed to now strutting their stuff at Spurs. Now Moses might be joining Liverpool instead of us.

Bruno Martins Indi is a player who could be a very valuable player to us for the foreseeable future if he was to join. He reminds me of a younger Distin and considering the Fountain of Youth is yet to be found he could end up replacing him in the future. Sadly do we have the money to buy him?

Andrew Cutler
134 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:55:31
@ Gerry 772 "for a new manager that must be sole destroying".
....a case of "these shoes were made for walking"...???
Mark Tanton
135 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:01:08
I think McCarthy and Ince would move the club in the right direction and be a continuation of long existing policy - selling our most saleable assets and replacing with cheaper, younger and where possible, British talent. I also think Barry would add some presence and gravitas to midfield, and be a good influence and teacher to Barkley.
James Marshall
136 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:01:07
The deal is only being done now, because the right bid has only been offered now!

Did anyone see a queue of clubs trying to buy Fellaini earlier in the summer!? I don't exactly see a line of managers clamouring for his services....

Ged Simpson
137 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:58:30
"which as long as it goes back in and we buy replacements before end of tomorrow,"

That is the key though. Confident that we will be as good ? I'm not.

Carl Sanderson
138 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:01:14
James,

"that's not Kenwright’s fault either. He held out for more money, which as long as it goes back in and we buy replacements before end of tomorrow, to my mind, is the right thing to do"

The longer he holds out for more money, the less time will be available to buy the replacements - and so the more expensive they will be.

Colin Wainwright
139 Posted 01/09/2013 at 11:57:43
Discounting what the player, or his old fella, have said last year or the year before, he has not given any indication publically that he wants to join Utd. This might change over the next 24 hours but all we have to go on are unreferenced reports from lazy jounalists.

Kenwright and his board do not have (or will not provide) the finances the new manager needs to strengthen the squad, whilst keeping Fellaini (and Baines?). I hope, as you do, that any money from the sale, if it happens, is ploughed back into the team, in this window. Given Kenwright's previous, I have my doubts.

James Marshall
140 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:05:57
Exactly, Ged, it IS key and it's key to all my posts!

I don't think we're THAT good WITH him in the Martinez team.

Ged Simpson
141 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:04:37
James 783 : the error is that holding out for the best deal right until last minute will probably cost us places in the league and we will not be as good as we could have been if he had sold him earlier and given our manager some chance to make his mark. So - sod the team - just about cash. Poor long term strategy.
David Hallwood
142 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:08:40
Agree about the comments made earlier about Daniel Levy, in that he has brought in Bale's replacements before the Bale deal has been finalised. The world and his mother has known for some time that Fellani was on his way, so instead of waiting for the last minute Martinez should have been allowed to spend 15-16 million, instead it will be yet another supermarket sweep.
James Marshall
143 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:13:48
Colin#793

It's a fine line - if Fellaini had come out and stated he wanted to leave, then he could look like an agitator in the Suarez mould. Many people would have complained about that.

Personally I prefer that he hasn't and that it's been kept (as best as could be) in-house without too much fuss and paper-banter between player & club.

Of course, there is no perfect way of dealing with any of this, I just think that all players have a price, and ultimately clubs have to sell them at some point.

Carl Sanderson
144 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:09:31
Ged,

"Poor long term strategy."

This phrase is Kenwright in a nutshell. What is the Board's stated ambition? Where do they hope to be five years' time? What is the implementation plan? How do they plan to grow the Club financially?

These transfer windows typify Everton's approach to its money. It is a hand-to-mouth existence and that is in the richest league in the world.

Given the media obsession with football I find it incredible that this has not been investigated in any depth.

James Marshall
145 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:19:32
His long term ambition is to sell the club to a billionaire of course, Carl!
Tony Fearns
146 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:21:59
Carl, we are a Premier League club in name only. These clowns in charge have no ambition whatsoever.
Andy Meighan
147 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:24:07
I'm with an earlier post, we should be looking to get rid of them shite strikers we've got. I'll guarantee Anichebe, Jelavic and Kone (got to be given time) will not get 15 league goals between them. That's the problem position that has to be addressed ASAP.
Steve Pugh
148 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:18:03
Obviously just paper talk but Palace have bid £5m for McManaman, is McCarthy three times as good, or even twice as good? I don't think so.

James Marshall, why are you still bleating on about lower bids after the clause ran out, the latest bid is £24m that is higher than the clause. I had hoped that all the stupidity about the clause would have gone now.

Colin Glassar
149 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:25:13
I can't believe I'm saying this but I hope the rs batter the mancs today, just to see OFM dig himself into a deeper hole.
Brent Stephens
150 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:28:36
How does Bill sell Felli more quickly (well before the end of the window) when fans are saying tell MU to f off with their insulting etc bid? And when he has no other bidders to use as a lever against MU?
Gavin Ramejkis
151 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:37:03
Would those bastards have come sniffing if Kenshite would have hadd the stones to report them for their illegal approach for Gollum? Fucking doubt it, agent Kenshite does it again
James Marshall
152 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:38:20
Steve (#806) – regards the clause: I was just responding to someone else who mentioned it mate.
Ged Simpson
153 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:38:11
Brent : I refer you back to 796. No planning. They should have asked Felli his intention and then acted. To hold out for £1 or 2 m more and leave the manager with no ability to make his mark and bring in players is stupid and short sighted.
Brent Stephens
154 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:42:48
Ged, I'm genuinely interested in how that might have played out. Are you talking before or after the release clause ran out?

Let's say you mean after the clause ran out. And let's assume Felli said he wanted to go. What should Everton have done then? What bids did we have at that time (immediately after clause ran out)? What was the highest bid? Should we have taken that? At what points did increased bids come? And at what price and when should we have accepted?

That's a genuine question, Ged, not an argument as such from me.

Christian Watson
155 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:38:26
Colin Glasser under NO circumstances should we ever hope lfc win any games no matter who the opposition. I'd personally support al queada if they were playing the red shite.

As for this transfer window fiasco. I and I'm sure most of you realized a while ago Baines and or Fellaini were off so whilst disappointing it's not exactly a suprise.
However the transfer deadline often delivers a few shocks as the clock ticks down . . . . . . . .Am I the only one worried about the asset that is Ross Barkley???

James Marshall
156 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:48:57
We've only had one bidder, Man Utd. Our bargaining position on this isn't exactly a strong one. It's not easy when you have no other club to play them off against. They bid, we accept or not, and that's about it...
Alan Smith
157 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:46:14
If they're only going to pay £1m more than the release clause, there's no point selling him. Keep him till January, when McCarthy will be less as Wigan get desperate, or we scout someone better. We will have a settled side too, not trying to bed in new players through September.

We could still get Barry in on loan and a wide player/striker, knowing Man Utd will be activating his clause come January.

James Marshall
158 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:52:58
Alan - by that logic, how would selling him in January help to keep the side settled? That would seem like an even more unsettling thing to do to a team that had been playing together for 5 months rather than one that's been playing together for 3 games this season.
Colin Wainwright
159 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:49:12
They should have put a price on the player as soon as Utd shown an interest, told them he would not be sold in the final week of the window and stuck to it. This is all on the premise that Moyes didn't know that Kenwright hasn't got a pot to piss in, and we're not run by incompetent eejits, which makes it all irrelevant really.
Colin Glassar
160 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:53:01
Christian, it goes against every fibre in my body but my 'dislike' of OFM is such that I am prepared to bite the bullet, for the first and last time in my life, and hope the rs win today. I'd still hold out for £50m but knowing our chairman we will accept the "insulting and derisory" original £26m offer and Martinez will get £6m of that.
Colin Glassar
161 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:09:31
Greg O'keefe expects Fellaini to leave and Baines to stay. I can live with that.
Errol Stafford
162 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:54:47
What am I missing here... we are possibly about to sell our two best players for less than they are worth, to a man who has been taking the piss out of us for months, and in the process weakening our team and strengthening his. Even if we re-invest every penny, there is no guarantee it will make us stronger.

Sure, that is the only aim we should have: to strengthen Everton and try to achieve more. It seems that Kenwright sees us as existing merely to serve and strengthen Man Utd. Where is the ambition? He says there is no bigger Evertonian than him. Then why is he not trying to win the league, as I know if I was in charge that would be my aim, not to be bending over for the likes of Man Utd.

We are not inferior to any other club and should not be acting in this pathetic manner. Kenwright should being putting Everton first, not the players, not Man Utd and most certainly not that snake Moyes. If he is such a good actor, why doesn't he string Moyes along unless tomorrow night, and then do a Fer on it and pull out of any deal, leaving Moyes up shit creek, much like how he left us? Come on Bill, grow a pair and restore some pride in The Merseyside Giants, Everton FC.

Marc Sansum
163 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:58:31
Eriksens in his last year of his contract, so could effectively leave for free next season, and I assume had told Ajax he wanted to move, hence the cheaper price.
Hense keisuke Honda being touted at £5m (what a bargin - if only he wanted to come to us).
Colin Glassar
164 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:18:35
Errol, you are spot on but the sad truth is, we have a feeble chairman, a nonexistent board, and the banks who have the final say, apparently, on our transfer policy. Until we rid ourselves of these parasites we will never be anything more than a feeder club for the teams above us, especially the mancs as we seem to have a special relationship with them.
Harold Matthews
165 Posted 01/09/2013 at 12:04:35
After watching Mirallis recently, it's easy to understand why Martinez wants players of the right character. Pienaar is just as bad. Never out of 2nd gear and dawdling along with a smile on his face when time was running out and we needed a goal. Where are the tough no nonsense leaders who will shake these guys into action? None are scared of the manager or captain. In fact, it seems that Osman is the only one to dispute dodgy decisions.

As for bringing people in. I'd have Kim like a flash. MOM for me yesterday and what an attitude. Michael Bradley of Roma, Lewis Holtby and others of their class are just a dream with BK at the helm and I'm willing to support anyone Martinez considers suitable. Right now I have no other choice.

Brent Stephens
166 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:29:42
Off topic but just watching before start of RS/MU game and minutes applause re birth of shanks (I think). What is the game coming to when an opposition side has to stand there while that goes on.
Ernie Baywood
167 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:33:09
Madness in my opinion. Utd players applauding the would have been birthday of an ex manager.
Tom R Owen
168 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:27:59
Errol
I have said for years Kenwright is a fantasist
He lives in a world where he thinks it is still the 50s and he is the scruffy kid in the pen watching the Dave Hickson.
From Kings Dock to the NTL deal and Fortress Sport the guy is a liar who will bring this club to its knees- we are close to it now.
I hate the gutless twat with a passion
James Stewart
169 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:31:09
Spurs closing on Ince now according to sky. How many bloody players do they need!
Errol Stafford
170 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:37:35
Any deal now should only be on our terms, for the betterment of EFC.
If not, we might as well pack up and let the clubs who play the sport to win, get on with it. As much as I despise the RS, and while they are deluded in the extreme, at least they always perceive themselves as equals to Man. Utd., Arsenal etc, even with inferior teams, and they always talk themselves up as such. This gets through to the fans, media, players and opposing teams, and invariably helps them achieve better results than they might otherwise. They would NEVER sell to Man. United so WTF should we? Us, on the other hand, continually downplay our stature and don't promote the club as "we might not have as much money as the others but we are still one of the elite clubs" type ethos. But sadly that has been lacking for years.
Marc Sansum
171 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:50:47
spurs are going for the 1-9-0 formation this season
Mark Taylor
172 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:14:54
Here we go, ever closer to the final denouement.

Fella and Baines out, McCarthy and Barry in plus maybe Ince as well, if BK senses there will be a lynching if it's just the first two.

Either way, it categorically weakens the squad and god knows, it can't take being weakened any further if we are to have pretensions of top half, let alone top 6.

There is still a bit of me that hopes that we raise £40m plus and that all is re-invested (and not on overpriced players like McCarthy-there is some excellent quality out there around the £15m mark, albeit less so for strikers).

But that little bit of me is down to about 1%. There has been a sense of inevitability about this for well over a month now.

Mark Pierpoint
173 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:42:04
Lets get it sorted now I say. I think McCarthy will improve the team, but I agree totally that we are lacking a general in the middle of the park. Osman tries but is a peripheral figure most of the time. I for one am not too worried about Fellaini leaving a gap in the midfield, I agree he is very pedestrian and whilst he retains possession and wins possession well his lack of mobility and dare I say passing makes him a luxury we can't afford in the centre. At united he will be able to play to his strengths and have others (Carrick etc.) make up for his weaknesses. We HAVE to sort out the goals though without Fellaini. Jelavic could still be playing now on his own and wouldn't have scored.

Would have loved a move for a Capoue figure. He would have added the bite to the midfield. Think Gibson will make a difference when he is back but how long until his next injury?

Paul Gladwell
174 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:58:46
Richard Keys just claiming Gareth Barry is Cingular to us now, be a good start in my eyes, a couple more and we can all start getting on with the season instead of putting up with all this shit
Marc Sansum
175 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:01:29
Some clips of Mr Mccarthy

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCxji7TyAQU

Darren Robinson-Cooke
176 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:59:51
Just watching the red shite against the other scum and it pains me to look at their style of play and see that's what we need to become. They have everything we need in their side: pace, creativity, power, goalscorers and most importantly options.. As well as financial backing from the board! Also see Moses is there as well.This looks like yet another trick we could have missed when it is evident more than ever... for fucks sake Everton!!!
Carl Sanderson
177 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:05:07
Paul 843,

A painfully slow, mediocre member of the over-30 mob with nothing whatsoever to recommend him? Barry signing for us does not represent a good start.

John Audsley
178 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:09:31
Barry is an experienced pro who can sit in front of the back 4 and he is the kind of player we have been really missing.

Is he world/top class??? No; but on loan for a season he can only add to the squad.

James Marshall
179 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:08:44
I think Gareth Barry will be a good player for us - a useful foil for Barkley and could be the player to usher Osman out of our midfield - that should please a few people.

Gibbo, Barry, Barkley, Mirallas in midfield? Kone up top on his own, with Baines (cough) and Coleman wingbacks, Jagielka, Distin and Heitinga (cough again) at the back....

Could make us a bit more stable in the middle and Barry can at least pass the ball..

Sean Patton
180 Posted 01/09/2013 at 13:58:55
McCarthy wont improve the team how anyone thinks that replacing last seasons top scorer with a £15M crab is a good move is beyond me.

I guess the silver lining could be that when we slip down the table the focus should hopefully fall on Kenwright and the board instead of the manager.

Harold Matthews
181 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:12:02
The crowd are refereeing the game across the park.
Tom Bowers
182 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:03:13
Going to be a hectic 36 hours with all the usual bogus reports.

Frankly I don't want anymore Wigan players. With Alvarez unfit and RM Saying Kone isn't fully fit what next.
We need an established strong quick midfielder to compliment Barklay not small ineffective tacklers like Pienaar and Osman.Jelavic is slow and should be traded as his bolt is shot.
Miralles has skill but cannot tackle back.
Without a positive move by Monday night it will be another long disappointing season for the Blues.

James Marshall
183 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:13:23
Carl, it's a loan, at a reduced rate in wages. Not so bad really...
Paul Gladwell
184 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:13:44
Carl to me he is a better option than Osman and the other waste if space Gibson, so to me that's a not too bad start.
Hibberts dad just said Fellaini deal getting confirmed at 5 and there could be a twist in the deal, but I've heard these things before.
Mark Tanton
185 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:16:54
Spurs' interest in Ince proves their transfer policy is as much about preventing others strengthening as their own squad. Bale delay is all about mucking up everyone's transfer window. Barry would be a good signing in my opinion.
Carl Sanderson
186 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:16:44
James,

The cost is not the point: he's shite.

Sam Hoare
187 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:16:54
What about Kagawa and Hernandez on loan from Man Utd? Not being used much there!
James Marshall
188 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:19:53
I'd rate Barry over Osman, Carl. Gibbo is also made of glass so we need experienced cover.

Kagawa and Hernandez are going nowhere, but there is talk of Jesse Lingard as part of the Fellaini deal.

Carl Sanderson
189 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:19:11
Paul 853,

Are you saying that Barry is a better player than both Osman and Gibson? I can't agree with you there, fella.

Paul Gladwell
190 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:23:21
Osman yes, Gibson similar only Gibson is a waste of space that's why Fergie got rid, we need something solid in there and Barry is mate in my eyes.
Mark Frere
191 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:14:32
This would be a fantastic outcome if it actually happened:

Players out:
Fellaini
Baines

Players in:
McCarthy
Bertrand
Martins Indi
Ince
Barry(loan)

This would considerably lower the average age of our squad and add strength and depth.Unfortunetly though, I feel things won't turn out anywhere near as rosy as that.

Mark Taylor
192 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:19:35
Sam 856

That idea would be my 1% hope (i.e great but very unlikely). We get £25m plus Chico for the two. Less convinced we need Kagawa.

Then bring in Bertrand to replace Baines (and give us an option on left mid if Oviedo cuts it at LB) plus bring in the central midfielder we need so badly for £15m or so- but not McCarthy at that price.

Throw in Barry as back up on a loan deal and that will be good business, of the type Levy routinely does at Spurs.

But we won't be doing this. £15-20m of any sale will go into our financial black hole, never to be seen again.

David Heaton
193 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:17:55
Take the forty odd million for them and build a new ground in Walton park, hang on mid table for a season or two, then push on with a new ground, a good manager that's getting the best out of our youngster. Get into Europe, win the Premier League...

Hang on I must be dreaming this. If we had management with a serious forward looking plan it could just happen but stumbling along finishing mid table and not winning any cups is getting a bit boring.

Errol Stafford
194 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:22:22
I'd have young Jonny Williams from Crystal Palace, we need young hungry players with pace and desire, not washed up multi millionaires like Barry who have nothing to motivate them. £30m should buy the likes of Alderweirald, Ince, Williams, Jordan Rhodes. Won't happen though. It's a sad state of affairs when Chelsea and Spurs can buy players who would improve our team and then loan them out (Atsu and allegedly Ince). Where is the money Bill? Actually, where is Bill?
James Stewart
196 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:27:22
Bertrand and Barry are shite don't want either of those
Sam Hoare
197 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:24:38
I think Barry will be useful. He's never relied on pace but like Gibson is an intelligent passer of the ball who reads the game well and can shoot to good effect. He will give 110% to try and make the World Cup squad.

Not a world beater perhaps but a very solid and experienced player in a position we are very short in.

Gavin Ramejkis
199 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:29:17
James #816 remind me again how many teams have bid for Galen at Spurs? Oh yeah that'll be just the one, that really made Levy's job of demanding top whack more difficult didnt it?
Steve Pugh
200 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:28:49
FFS Sky Sports have us looking at Balazs Megyeri, a goalkeeper. Do we really need another goalkeeper?
Carl Sanderson
201 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:27:54
Paul,

As a confirmed Osmanophile I don't expect to agree with you on Osman.

Gibson is the more debatable one. I think he has a better passing range than Barry; he has a good dig on him; and he is a lot younger than Barry. On the other hand Gibson appears to be made of papier mâché yet always seems to be carrying quite a bit of weight.

Paul Gladwell
202 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:33:31
He is never there when we need him Carl,a very good player but you wonder if his lifestyle has something to do with it too, ginger shithouse used to always comment on the need to kick him up the arse, a professional footballer who needs to be motivated.
James Marshall
203 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:48:52
Gavin #870 - what? Who the hell is Galen? Sorry, I have no idea what you're talking about mate!
Mark Pierpoint
204 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:54:22
Liverpool looking at getting in Moses, Sakho and Illori. Around £28m. This from a board who are supposedly quite conservative in their spending. Falling and falling behind here. £6m all season. We are having a laugh.....
James Marshall
205 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:58:06
They also have Victor Moses sitting in the stands with Sakho and Illori.

I've never heard of the latter two BTW.....jus sayin....

Ciarán McGlone
209 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:10:45
Where's this talk about Bertrand coming from?

He's a cracking player... I doubt Chelsea would let him go..

For those offering a prognosis on our season without Fellaini...Can we not see who we bring in before we starting sharpening the knives?

If we get McCarthy and a creative midfielder to sit beside Barkley – I actually happen to think we'll be a better outfit.

Barry Rathbone
210 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:14:12
James, "Galen" is one of the apes from the film "planet of the apes" - he is a distant cousin of Bale.
James Marshall
211 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:19:02
Oh, thanks Barry.

Well then the answer is finances. Not many people have the kind of money Madrid have to offer for one player. Madness.

James Stewart
213 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:22:26
Sakho is quality. A younger version of Distin. Good signing by RS for once
Kunal Desai
214 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:26:30
No wins for the Ginger Jock at Anfield now for 12 years.... hahaha!
Mark Tanton
217 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:28:22
Can we please go up against Spurs for Ince? He needs football and we can give him it - he gets good advice from his father and I think we could beat them to it if we wanted him.
Sean Lloyd
218 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:30:06
Can see efforts for Fellaini increasing after that gutless performance in the centre of their park..
John Audsley
220 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:09:31
Barry is an experienced pro who can sit in front of the back 4 and he is the kind of player we have been really missing

Is he world/top class??? No but on loan for a season he can only add to the squad

Andy Meighan
227 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:33:20
I can't believe no one is talking about getting a quality striker in ffs can't anyone see if we don't sign one. We are badly going to struggle this season Anichebe, Jelavic and Kone have got to be 3 of the worst finishers in the league then again you only get what you pay for and I'll guarantee they won't get 15 league goals between them all season.

This is a problem that needs to be addressed immediately and if the manager can't see this then fuck me were going to be in shit strasse. We look as if we're going to get good money for Fellaini and Baines so let's hope he just uses it wisely.

As for Kenwright, I'll give him a few bob he wasn't wrong was he. 6 million, what an insult. The likes of Cardiff Norwich Swansea Soton outspending us breaks my heart it really does. The sooner this fraudster fucks off the better. Unfortunately for us it looks like he's here for the long term. What a joke.
Tony Draper
229 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:42:02
Patrick 911

Brendas Girls can now go on to lose every week, that wouldn't crack my heart

I am entirely happy at gollum continuing in this vein, he never got Everton a win there did he ?

Carl Sanderson
230 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:51:05
Slightly off-topic but I think this Arsenal-Tottenham game should be very interesting.
Tony Draper
231 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:52:09
Hmmmmm
Mysterious didn't see post 911 as either abusive or nasty Patrick, wasn't my flavour of ice-cream, but not under any reasonable condition was it offensive
Patrick Murphy
232 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:56:52
Well I'm not happy to be 7 points behind the Dark Side this early in the season, but each to their own I suppose.
Raymond Fox
233 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:15:37
Errol 827.

Sorry mate, your deluded when you say were a giant club now. We are as far as football history is concerned, but our team has to compete in the present. As things are now, I'm sad to say we have to accept that we can't logically expect to be classed as elite; it's a league where 'money rules ok' and we haven't enough of it, it's as simple as that.

We live in hope that we can keep defying the odds and be overachievers! But, make no mistake, we have the potential to be a giant again, but it's going to take investment on the scale of a Man City or Chelsea even RS, we need a new ground and enough cash to spend so we can compete with the usual suspects!

It pains me to write the above, but I'm afraid its the truth.

Colin Glassar
234 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:00:50
We are only a point behind ginger and his mancs.
Gavin Ramejkis
236 Posted 01/09/2013 at 15:59:14
James #880 obviously betraying your age, Galen was the character played by Roddy McDowell in Planet of the Apes - Gareth Bale.

You said in your earlier post that as Man Utd were the only bidders, we were stuck accepting their offer, a nonsense.

Charles Brewer
237 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:04:21
Just followed the Anfield match. If Moyes can't get them to up the offer for Fellaini to 50 million then he's already marked for the chop.

ManU sounded pathetic, and the RS parked the bus- at home!

If we had had a version of RvP in the middle up front then I am confident we'd have 9 points by now. Manchester United desperately need a combative commanding midfielder. They have 24 hours to get one.

Kenwright should not let hm go for less than 60 million (it is 10 minutes later than when I began). Another 40 for Baines, if they are interested.

From what I could discern, ManU are in deep trouble. Let's make them pay very very dearly to get out of it.

Jackie Barry
238 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:06:32
I really don't care where the RS are, my brother can say look at the league and I will say "Well done". The simple fact is they are not going to win the league, deep down they know it. My concern is where Everton are going from this point forward, I think under Martinez we can be a success and I do think we will be closer to the top than the bottom come the end of the season. As for Moyes well, all I can say is good luck to him because he has one heck of a job in is hands, what are the odds of them not even finishing in the top-4?
Matt Traynor
239 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:11:26
Gavin #925 - Galen is a bit harsh. He's a dead ringer for Marlon Dingle though.
John Gee
240 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:01:15
Football clubs need to be financed and ours isn't. The board should be pumping money into the club otherwise what is the point if owning it. The £25m extra revenue should be just the start of our spending. They're sitting idle while we slip further and further back. It's time for a change. It's time that someone owned Everton who had some pride and some balls.

Btw, it was fun watching MU chasing a goal for 92 minutes and failing. I bet SAF was sat watching that game shaking his head like he was watching the fastest game of tennis in history. Hahahaha.

Colin Glassar
241 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:14:20
Charles, have you noticed how RVP has struggled in the last two games? Is the ginger Svengali starting to work his magic on another good striker?
Gavin Ramejkis
242 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:14:59
Matt don't be daft, Marlon Dingle is Osman, and Hibbert is Vlad Putin
Mark Taylor
243 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:05:22
Someone said, where's the talk of Bertrand coming from. I mentioned him- if Baines goes, we'll need to replace him. There has been some coverage about him wanting a move. He won't get much game time at Chelsea.

And given this is World Cup year, that would be the clue to my idea of a transfer strategy. Figure out what you need (LB, CM enforcer, playmaker, Striker), then get a list of all those with decent aspirations of getting into their nation's squad for Rio, but playing for a club where there is a lot of cover for their position and limited game time in prospect.

Granted, players want CL, which we can't offer, but we can offer big wages by general comparison to elsewhere in Europe/the world and most critically, regular first team football in one of the yawning gaps we have. In World Cup years, that could look very appealing for players who might be on the fringes of their national squad, and can't afford to spend the coming months unseen.

Does BK have the wit (or indeed intent) to arrange our strategy along these lines? I don't think so.

Dan Brierley
244 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:07:13
This is getting seriously depressing now. Three games in, and there does not seem to be any light and the end of this tunnel for the foreseeable future.

If Felli and Baines go, not only does it take away our two best players, the impact on the rest of the squad is also going to be tough. Especially players like Barkley, will be thinking 'what is the point of staying here?'. Had we managed to get some decent points on the board, it might have taken the sting out of anybody leaving. But losing the two best players whilst sat in 15th with the next 3 games being much more difficult than the first three, does not bode well. Especially when our manager seems completely unable to look any further than his former team for players.

John Audsley
245 Posted 01/09/2013 at 14:09:31
Barry is an experienced pro who can sit in front of the back 4 and he is the kind of player we have been really missing.

Is he world/top class??? No... but, on loan for a season, he can only add to the squad.

Dick Fearon
246 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:03:06

Why has Osman never been mentioned as a transfer target for Moyes or in fact for any club on the face of the earth?
Moyes who never wasted an opportunity to praise the little bloke and always put Leon first on the team sheet has shown not the slightest interest.

Thats a pity.

Chris Beech
247 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:24:33
Here's an interesting stats comparison of McCarthy and Utd's Michael Carrick. http://eplindex.com/35306/young-michael-carrick-market-stats-comparison.html
Tom Bowers
248 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:16:23
Having watched Everton huff and puff against 3 very average teams, it's obvious they do not and will not have the personnel to be anything but average themselves. The top six big money clubs have the power to keep them a step above everyone else and that includes Redshite who are still bringing in new players even though they didn't sell Ratboy.

Everton know they have to sell Fellaini to bring in anyone of class but, unless they have an iron in the fire, they may lose Fellaini and have no time to get anyone. Make no mistake: Fella's assets will be sorely missed as it has only been his offensive assistance that has carried Everton over the last two seasons. When he has to play deep, Everton struggle.

Mark Taylor
249 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:29:02
Dick,

Wait till tomorrow. After today's defeat, OFM is going to make a desperate last minute £30m swoop for Osman and Big Vic....

Jim Hillier
250 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:33:33
Mark, two that would fit your description perfectly would be the big Fella and Baines at Man Utd. I think they'd be mugs to go. But then I said the same about Rooney a while back, and to be honest, about Alan Ball, so what the fuck do I know.
Charles Brewer
251 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:37:36
Colin #932. Yes, it's very odd, because the ManU teams have been pretty much the same ones that RvP was with last year. Hmmm, now what has changed?

I now have very mixed feelings. Do I want to laugh like a drain at the spectacle of ManU making some desperate last minute offer because they see mid table financial oblivion this year, or do I want to see panic setting in down the East Lancs Road?

It is a very odd start to the season, where very dominant performances by Everton have got nothing, while lower table garbage like the cannibals down the road have managed, by a combination of penalty misses, nicking one and parking the bus, to get a full set of points?

If I didn't think that the combination of shocking refereeing (actually, David Moyes will at least have found that consistent, Marriner was dreadful) and horrific luck was a permanent feature of Everton's makeup, I might be quite confident.

And my biggest worry, Wigan-style shipping of goals, hasnt even looked a possibility so far...

Jim Hillier
252 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:47:28
If the pair do go, hope both get broken legs on international duty. Bitter? What do you mean?
Colin Glassar
253 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:49:59
I still have hope that Bainsey will stay and wenger will have a nervous breakdown and offer us £40m for Felli. I'd rather the big fella went to arsenal then to yernited if he has to leave.
Richard Dodd
254 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:48:56
Gavram,you are as confused as ever. SAM Dingle is Ossie not Marlon.
Always see you as Zac!
Drew Shortis
255 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:39:33
I wonder if Jordan Rhodes has been considered as a potential striker. He is only 23 and hopefully he would be available at a reasonable price. Blackburn paid £8m for him. I guess if no Premier League teams have picked him up he is no RVP, but his goalscoring record is very impressive. I must admit that I haven't seen him play much, but his two goals yesterday are just the kind of thing we are lacking right now. How many times over the past few games have we needed someone to gamble with a run to the far post to tap in a cross. Would he have buried the two chances Kone had against Stevenage? Just an idea.
Harold Matthews
256 Posted 01/09/2013 at 16:14:54
We are lacking fighting spirit and attitude. We accept all decisions with peaceful serenity. Is this a reflection of the manager and the captain, two very nice chaps indeed?

All the top teams in world football give the officials a hard time because they know that, over a season, it will earn them a few extra points. During his time at Barcelona, Guardiola made it a deliberate tactic and we all know about Mourinho, Fergie, the Germans and that mob across the park.

The Premier League is not the League of Gentlemen. Let's get up and at 'em like the Dogs of War or we will be launching the lifeboats before Christmas.

Gavin Ramejkis
257 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:03:00
Nice one Doddy, does that make you Gordon Brittas but on the bins?
Patrick Murphy
258 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:06:32
Harold you do have a point, but if we start haranguing officials we'll just pick up more bookings and more suspensions, as Barkley did yesterday for dissent, it really does depend on who you play for.
Errol Stafford
259 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:06:42
Just heard OFM's post match interview, identical to his usual excuses after we narrowly lost to Sky 4 teams: very pleased with the performance, played really well, just caught out by one piece of unfortunate defending, I'm happy with the squad we have and if we don't add to it we'll go with what we have. We must stand firm and make them suffer on Fellaini and Baines, as they are an RVP injury away from a crisis.
Thomas Windsor
260 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:10:06
If both these players are sold, so be it, but if the manager is not given all of the money to spend on new players, what is the point of us fans going anymore?

Kenwright and the other owners have taken us for a ride long enough — it's time to either protest by not going, or at the match itself.

David Booth
261 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:19:17
Fellaini out and McCarthy and Barry (loan) in...

And Osman still in the starting line-up...

One begins to admire what that twat across the park is doing!

Patrick Murphy
262 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:23:46
David how much money has that manager had to spend in his time there? Bit of a difference and I'm not sure why we see them as a yardstick when they spend more money in a single window than our net spend for the entire 21 years of the PL.
Phil Sammon
263 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:23:18
Can't be doing with this 'OFM' bollocks.

The dickhead's name is David Moyes.

Grow up.

Peter Laing
264 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:17:20
Root cause analysis needed why Everton once again enter the final day of the transfer window and have its best players picked over like a vulture does to a dead carcass. Where is O'Keefe et al asking questions of Kenwright and Elstone as to why Martinez has not been backed as promised with the funds to strengthen the team ? Kone for £6 million on the drip and we sit here playing football manager talking about shit permutations of who could replace Fellaini and Baines whilst Kenwright continues to take the piss out of Evertonians mentality.
Andy Walker
265 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:27:55
Makes sense for Feli to go, but not Baines hopefully. Feli is not a natural fit for the high possession style and the added dimension he used to bring us by being able to play up front with a more direct style is not something RM cleary wants to use - think it would have got us a win this season if he had though. So get rid and let him spend the cash on the style of player he needs.
Paul Andrews
266 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:36:56
Well said Phil.
Always best to call a c**t a c**t.
Errol Stafford
267 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:45:22
Ive been calling him That C**t Moyes for weeks now but don't like using expletives on forums so will TCM do instead of OFM?

We can agree that he is a c**t

Andy Walker
268 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:51:43
Let it go FFS.
Brian Williams
269 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:54:47
Forgive me I've been away on holiday.

What the fook does OFM stand for anyway?

Mark Pierpoint
270 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:54:48
Agree totally Phil Sammon. Irritates me too.
Brent Stephens
271 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:56:55
So we grow up by going from "OFM" to "c***T"?
Colin Glassar
272 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:59:19
Ginger twat is far more appropriate.

According to Richard Keys the Barry loan deal is done.

Brian Williams
273 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:59:12
Ahhhhhh what does OFM stand for??????
Brent Stephens
274 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:02:43
Our Former Manager, Brian
Brian Williams
275 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:03:18
D'oh!..............Thanks mate. Now I know why people are getting fed up with seeing it in print....
Adam Smith
276 Posted 01/09/2013 at 17:56:27
I see that Richard Keys has tweeted that we have agreed the deal for Gareth Barry - God help us!

The size of him makes me think that Barrel would be a more appropriate surname.

Says a lot about the lack of quality in our midfield that a 33 year-old fat bastard who can't run actually represents an improvement!

Surely there are better options - HOLTBY, HOLTBY, HOLTBY - for fuck sake I wish they could see this!

Brian Williams
277 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:05:05
Getting back on topic:
Does anyone else not remember Kenwright saying that Martinez would get every penny he raises from sales for new acquisitions? I know he's not to be trusted but I'm sure I remember hearing that on the first press conference when Martinez was hired.

Also. If the Fellaini deal was done why has the club not announced it? No point in not doing so other than trying the old "we didn't have time to spend the money by the time the deal was done."

Antony Matthews
278 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:04:27
Can't see Ince going to the Spuds. Like his Father said " he's not going anywhere to sit on the bench". So it could be us or Newcastle me thinks.
Rob Pryor
279 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:04:41
Don't worry Brian, I only worked it out a couple of weeks ago. "Old Farty Mouth"?...No. "Off, Fuck, Moyes"?...Doesn't really work either.

Then one day... DING!

Garry Martin
280 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:07:25
Dithering Dave was always going on about not having money to spend well, he hasn't really made any signings so far.... what's the problem Dave?

ps: Can anyone tell me what OFM means ?

Colin Glassar
281 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:10:10
Brian, didn't Elstone say when Martinez signed that there were funds available for him to spend? What? £6m? No wonder they treat us like morons when we accept every word they say with resignation.
Paul Andrews
283 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:23:20
Mr Chairman promised him ALL incoming transfer money to spend.
But then again Mr Chairman is a fucking liar
Tony Draper
284 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:15:21
Garry @986

OFM Stands for One Fuckin Mingebag.

Clearly the *ahem (laughter stiffled)* "Money" which he had available as Everton Manager and the "Billions" available in his current role as SAF's able bodied puppet he considers to be coming out of his own pocket!

One Fuckin Mingebag... You reap what you sow gollum
You reap what you sow

Great result at Anfield for a change!

Signing on by Xmas!
You'll be signing on by Xmas!

Derek Knox
285 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:29:07
Antony (982)
I think, and hope you are right on this one, he is intrinsically a winger, but with his speed and scoring ability, he could be employed as an out and out striker.
I have a sneaky feeling, and if you listen to what his Dad was saying, after the match against Watford, we could be a contender!
He is young, mobile, keen, seems to enjoy playing, and could be the start of the new Everton, along with the likes of Barkley, Stones and company.
Not all doom and gloom!
Richard Dodd
286 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:39:58
Hey,Gavram,most see me as a Robert Redford lookalike circa 1973.I couldn't possibly comment !

Think I should take the blame for the OFM nomenclature as I could no longer bear to time the name of my yesterday's hero.

Howard Meakin
287 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:44:53
Adam Smith
(980)
Absolutley brilliant. I nearly swallowed my teeth when I read your comment, And I don't have dentures. I'm still laughing now nice one mate.
Phil Walling
288 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:48:10
I don't think Kenwright ever said any such thing.His announcement of the appointment said he'd 'promised Roberto a FEW BOB' He'll no doubt deliver on that undertaking!
John Crawley
289 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:42:09
Let's hope the deal hasn't been done already because after today's performance surely we can squeeze out a few more bob from Moyes!
Brian Williams
290 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:55:33
Phil, I distinctly remember Kenwright saying Martinez will get ALL the cash raised from player sales for new players.
Anyone else remember that?
Brian Williams
291 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:58:00
Here's the quotes:

"We are desperate to find new owners and new investment, but he will get support from everyone at the club and all the financial support," added Kenwright.

"By that I mean if he sells someone, he won't get 80 per cent of that, he'll get 100 per cent.

"Plus he has a certain amount of money for the transfer window which David was going to have.

Mark Tanton
292 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:00:32
Well maybe Kenwright was all smug at managing to secure £6m for Roberto, and thought it made him some kind of hero.
Ian Burns
293 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:12:48
Just spent the past hour catching up and reading this post and comments. Brilliant - I just love TW.

I am now going to get me gin and get drunk until Tuesday when this is all over.

Before I go and hit the bottle, I will tell EFC's fortune:

Baines and Fellaini out;
Barry and McCarthy in;

However, I wish that read;
BK and Board out;
Levy and Board in.

Time to get drunk and hibernate for 36 hours

James Marshall
294 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:59:38
Gavin#925

Not betraying my age (currently into my 41st year FYI), just didn't twig as to your reference, re Bale looking a bit chimpy.

As for my other comment - I don't think there's really a direct link between Real Madrid being the only club offering Spurs close to £100m for Bale and Utd offering us about £23m for Fellaini.

What I said was that as Utd are the only bidders, then we don't have anyone to play them off against - not that we HAVE to accept their bid.

I don't see anyone matching Madrid's Bale offer, or upping the stakes there either, do you?

Ross Edwards
295 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:59:22
A striker is needed. I hope we don't blow vast amounts on McCarthy. We need someone like Defoe and Holtby.
Colin Wainwright
296 Posted 01/09/2013 at 18:58:04
I remember that Brian. Doesn't mean anything. He's a lying bastard. This is from the same gobshite that brought us "Goodison will fail its safety certificate", "the money is ring-fenced", and who can forget his astonishing performance in "the Arteta money will be available for David in January".

He. Is. A. Fucking. Lying. Tit.

James Marshall
297 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:08:43
I just had a read through this thread, since I've been out this afternoon, and can I say three things:

A) Thank you to various people for explaining what OFM means.
B) Can you stop saying it.
C) How come Richard Keys has all the inside info?

Brian Williams
298 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:08:07
Oh I know he can't be trusted Colin and IF we do sell either one or both of Baines and Fellaini and he then DOESN'T make every penny available I think Martinez will have a very early realisation of what he's let himself in for.
I, personally, have a sneaky feeling we won't sell either of them before the window closes....or is that just wishful thinking?
Matt Stephens
299 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:01:28
DW on talk sport right now confirms WE are in talks for James McCarthy
Tony Draper
300 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:07:01
014 Ian Burns

Yes

Utterly

Completely

Absolutey

Phil Walling
301 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:01:17
Honestly not seen or heard that before,Brian, but I guess we shall have to wait until Tuesday morning to see if the sums add up.

Whatever comes in,I suspect most of whatever's spent will find its way to bloody Wigan !

Tony Draper
302 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:11:32
And Ian

36 hours of Gin ?
Me too

Meantime I hope and pray that "Lord Leighton of Baines" and "Marouanne of Belgium" remain in "The Most Royal of Blue"

Chin chin !

Phil Walling
303 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:14:03
Fuck me ! I think they must all be in the same swingers' circle !
Colin Wainwright
304 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:14:48
Brian, I sincerely hope you're right.

Matt, Dave Whelan is the only man alive to match Kenwright in the bullshit stakes.

Phil, give up the Wigan shite. Its making me want to chew my own fucking arm off, for christ sakes.

Matt Stephens
306 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:19:23
Cant see why he would lie about us in talks to buy him?
Colin Wainwright
307 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:21:33
To maybe force a bid from someone else. I don't know, he's a dodgy bastard and I don't believe a word he says.
Mike Rourke
308 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:13:44
Jeez if we really have let him go for £24 million then I guess that means we blinked first.

After today it would have been name our price time.

£40 million for Fellaini or fuck right off and sign Castillo and Count Straqula you miserable, useless twat. ( and to think I used to refer to him as Moyesy ).

John Crawley
309 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:22:43
Matt 030 - he wouldn't, its obvious we are talking to them about McCarthy and haggling about the fee, maybe they are taking that into consideration when agreeing a figure with Man United for Fellaini?
John Crawley
310 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:25:16
Colin - didn't you hear Owen Coyle's comments as well about Martinez talking to Dave Whelan and the Wigan Chief Exec about McCarthy? Also Martinez has confirmed he has had talks but not made a bid.
James Marshall
311 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:27:15
£40m for Fellaini is the funniest thing I've read on here today!

Nice one, Mike..

As for McCarthy - well he's younger, quicker, more progressive, plays it simple, can pick a pass, tackles back, full of energy, good engine and would shore up our midfield nicely. He's much more a Martinez type player than Fellaini ever will be.

Good video of him here against Utd (I know, anyone can look good on YouTube): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dCxji7TyAQU

Carl Reid
312 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:22:02
Thomas post 955. Im not bloody going!
Richard Dodd
313 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:29:23
Whelan told BK last Wednesday that he would expect 60% of the Felli money for McCarthy. BK said no more than 50%. The pair settled on 55% – all that remains is to discover what BK can get for the Belgian.

No shit!

Colin Wainwright
314 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:27:55
I haven't tbh John and it may well happen. I just think Whelan's an untrustworthy right wing scumbag. And that comment from post 031 was the least important. Arm is half off here!
Ste Traverse
315 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:26:54
Oh how I would love us to agree a deal with the Mancs and then BK pull the plug on the deal at the last minute leaving twat Moyes in the shit.

I know he wouldn't do that though.

I can't stand Kenwright, but he would earn a little bit back if he did this.

Colin Wainwright
316 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:33:39
027 not 031
Peter Laing
317 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:37:05
Richard, you seem to be well posted with your sources at Everton, have you heard if we are getting a forward in as we are fucking useless in front of goal ?
Mike Rourke
318 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:31:48
James

Where else is the new United manager going to go?

He is in a hole.

He has to sign someone.

Anyone.

But he's a ditherer.

He trusts Fellaini

And everyone else has said no.

Time's running out.

They just lost to Liverpool.

He's thinking 'Oh shit, Oh shit, Oh shit'

As I said, we can name our price and I bet ginger bollocks pays it...and if by some miracle he doesn't we can comfortably wait until the next transfer window to give the 'fro away

Ian Burns
319 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:35:17
Tony - Cheers; clink; hic - may we both wake up to an early Christmas present - you never know? - Nah, I don't believe it either
Richard Dodd
320 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:38:56
My source is at the Wigan end,Peter.
Peter Laing
321 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:40:36
Nice one Richard, do you pay him in pies mate ?
Brent Stephens
322 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:42:56
That narrows it down, Richard.
Ross Edwards
323 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:42:14
Adam Smith, sorry I was a bit slow in responding on the post match thread about Myers' email address but it is this:

alan.myers@evertonfc.com

All of the staff at the club have this address structure.

Vince Furnier
324 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:40:38
Doddy 038, I've always valued your opinions. But you've put your bollocks on the line on this one.

As an aside – it will be interesting to see where both you and Marshy sit viz-a-viz Marintez.

Ross Edwards
325 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:44:46
It's Whelan isn't it Richard?
James Marshall
326 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:45:26
Mike - Moyes doesn't decide how much Utd pay for players. Man Utd decide. That's not how football transfers work.
Vince Furnier
327 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:45:40
By rights this should be post 052, but for some reason I continue to be censored.
Antony Matthews
328 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:37:46
And Derek (002), he will provide competition for Mirallas who needs a rocket up his arse.
Peter Laing
329 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:47:25
You're right James, Man Utd corp always decide what they are going to pay for a player, even when he belongs to Everton. Mr Kenwright valued Rooney at £50 million, we got £10 million up front the season he signed for them and the rest of the £20 million on the drip and Man Utd cast-offs in return.
Colin Wainwright
330 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:51:25
Kenwright did not value Rooney at £50M. Kenwright valued Rooney at whatever Utd were willing to pay. Kenwright said Rooney was valued at £50M.

Different things.

Phil Sammon
331 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:56:05
I find this 55% talk from Doddy annoyingly believable.
Mark Pierpoint
332 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:57:20
Juliet Ferrington of BBC5L says we have had a bid rejected for James McCarthy. She seems to be in the know on Wigan as well.

https://twitter.com/juliette_grace

Mark Pierpoint
333 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:01:23
......So does Stan Collymore on TALKsport
Mike Gwyer
334 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:25:32

Well well - has BK grown a huge pair of hairy one's and told twat ass Moyes to fuckoff and get real, rumour is rife that the best left back in the world, our man LB, is staying with the blues. Felli has gone.

Additionally, McGeady coming to GP definitely has some truth to it.


Tommy Coleman
335 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:04:19
Man Utd's defeat today has just added an extra £5m each on our players as Desperate Dave is gasping now.
Mark Tanton
336 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:05:55
I know he's a millionaire and living the dream, but is this a bit hard on Baines, if he stays and Fellaini goes? This probably represents Baines's last chance to join Man Utd, and a last shot at medals before he's thirty and past it.
Phil Sammon
337 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:07:55
Wash your mouth out, Mark Tanton.
Ian Burns
338 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:09:25
Mark -- 064 - I was enjoying me gin and reading TW then your post came up and I nearly spilt a posh drop.

Baines is playing for the best club in the world - which he supports by the way - is getting extremely well paid and the only EFC will EVER win medals is by making sure such wonderful players STAY at EFC!

Andrew Ellams
339 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:08:49
Ste @ 40, if that happened I reckon we could declare some sort of BK amnesty on here. Short term only obviously
Colin Wainwright
340 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:14:11
Well said Ian. FFS Mark!
Mark Tanton
341 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:15:32
I had a feeling I was thinking outside the box on this one... Hmmmm, how to win some credibility back... I know. What a CUNT Moyes is hey?!
Colin Wainwright
342 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:17:06
Well said Mark.
Derek Knox
343 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:04:54
Mike (062)
I sincerely hope you are joking on McGeady, he's one headless chicken!
Ian Burns
344 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:19:42
You are forgiven Mark
Alan Smith
345 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:47:04
If his buyout clause is £24m in jan, are we going to let him go for £25m now just to gain £1m? so we can buy shite that can't get in the spurs side or more Wigan players?

The people on here going on about Holtby need to have a word with themselves. They were mentioning Medel the other day too, totally outclassed by ossie and 'inconsistent' Fellaini.

Every evertonian should be putting pressure on BK to tell man utd to fuck off. We can't replace Fellaini with anyone half as good and its also now a matter of principle and pride.

You can keep your £25m, your Holtbys, your medels, your sigurdsonns, your mccarthy's and fuck right off. Only a total helmet would think they could replace a unique DM that scores 10 per season, valued at £25m and wanted by Man U, with average shite like that. But then again some think Gibson is quality.

We deserve what we get I'm affraid. The most pessimistic undemanding fans in world football. Half can't even recognise a good player when it's staring them in face, is 6ft 4, with a twat of a hair do, finishing leading scorer! Loads didnt even want Barkley in the team before the start of season;

"He might give the ball away" moan, moan.

Surely we can go with what we've got now till jan. play Deulofeu and Kone, get Barry or another loan as cover, then re-assess the situation next window. Tell Fellaini its too late, and Moyes is a c**t. If he wants him this late it's £30m up front.

Colin Wainwright
346 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:27:49
Alan Smith. Agree with every word pal.
Robbie Muldoon
347 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:16:39
We need a striker... Imagine Negredo up top... yeah but a realistic Home and Bargain version from somewhere abroad.
Ross Edwards
348 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:31:02
Alan, you rate Osman over Holtby? Have a word with yourself mate.
Colin Wainwright
349 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:31:55
Don't think that's what he was saying Ross.
Alan Smith
351 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:35:46
He will bend any comment and put words in people's just to win an argument.

I'd play Fellaini and Barkley CM as you well know. Gibson and Barry as cover. So ossie is a good 5th choice don't you think?

James Martin
352 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:34:28
Alan do you not think Gibson is quality? Take a quick look at the results with him in the team and the results with him out of it. When he comes back Osman and Fellaini will move aside for him because regardless of hair dos, media profiles, headed goals scored, Gibson is more important to Everton than either of the other two. Had he been fit we would not be on three points now.
Tim Locke
353 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:34:48
Alan good points, would you think selling the big fella and buying Deulofeu would be a good move?
Mike Hughes
354 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:28:50
Off topic but I see Real Madrid have signed Gareth Bale.
They kept that one quiet.

Perhaps BK can pull one off under the radar like that tomorrow......no hype, no publicity, just big money down and shake on it..... the start of our Galactaco Era.

This time tomorrow we might all know who it'll be......exciting times......


Mike Rourke
355 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:24:21
James

We may like to think that multi-million pound transfers are handled by slick-suited corporate types who know the value of a pound.

Experience tells us they are a bunch of loons who put everything off until the last second before running around like blue arsed flies panic buying everything in sight.

Players moving on at over-inflated prices happens every window. Andy Carroll anyone?

Point is that as I type Moyes is almost certainly in the ear of that Woodward fella screaming 'Get me Fellaini, just get him".

They have a relationship to get off the ground, so far together they have failed to secure a single high profile signing, losing to The Shite winds up United fans immensely. This is now officially a bad start , so as much as they may be loathe to pay over the odds the fact is Moyes really WANTS Fellaini, infact he fucking NEEDS Fellaini, so over the odds is the going rate to you mate.

If our transfer negotiators can't see all this and twist it to our advantage then they are officially hopeless.

If we have to gift away our best player for low 20 millions then do it in January - it's World Cup year I can hardly see a sulky drop off in performance happening.

In conclusion the club would be mugs to let him go at the suggested price - which is precisely why I bet he goes for the suggested price.

Colin Wainwright
356 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:44:45
"Had he been fit we would not be on three points now. "

Just destroyed your own argument in one sentence. Even though it was shite to begin with.

James Martin
357 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:50
How has that destoryed my own argument Colin? I argued that Gibson is crucial to Everton and is a quality player and then followed that up by saying I believe we'd have more points if he had played our first three games. How is this a contradiction? Do you not think Gibson is a good player?
Mike Gwyer
359 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:31:42

Alan Smith.

You the fucking man and spot on. Felli took teams apart on his own, battered United last season and took City apart in their own backyard. He also had the Arsenal boy Wiltshire wanking himself last season thanking fuck the ref was on their side.

His bad ones were when he didn't give a fuck, when fellow players were below his standards - you could almost hear him say fuck it I'll play at your level. Moyes knew what he doing with the joint bid, ensuring that the focus was taken off his pursuit of the big man. Moyes has done his job to perfection - around 25M I believe. Well, now we will have the Manc twats constantly reminding us that they stole our best striker and centre mid for next to fuckall - well, I'll fucking tell them we threw in the manager as a freebee.


Colin Wainwright
360 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:51:23
Gibson is a good player. Gibson is also never fit.
Alan Smith
361 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:42:47
James

I've always thought that a bad argument due to the amount of other variables that affect a football match. You don't play the same team every week under the same conditions. And RS results have been better without Suarez. We were better with Neville a couple of seasons back.

He scores less than the other two, is not as skill full and looks slow to me. However he has great vision and a good right foot and as I said I would play him above Osman. But for me Barkley is the complete player with everything in his locker and Fellaini is the best DM in the Prem. play miralas Pienaar Deulofeu and Kone in front of them two, and we've got nine pts now.

Tim

Absolutely no chance Barca would sell, hes obviously a talent and they don't need the money.I'm worried Deulofeu is on the phone telling them about Barkley! But I probably would, if it was an option. Would you?

Well said mike

Gavin Ramejkis
362 Posted 01/09/2013 at 19:39:30
Doddy, Redford made The Sting in 73 reverse the film role and you have been stung for years by Gollum and Kenshite
James Martin
363 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:55:56
'Fellaini is the best DM in the prem' - He really really isn't. For a start Gibson is better than him which is why successive managers have played Gibson holding mid rather than Fellaini. Even Osman has sometimes dropped behind Fellaini in the first three games and he's awful in that position. Fellaini does not have the positional intelligence to play holding mid, he sits too far back, doesn't track runners and just chases the ball like a headless chicken. Him and Rodwell was a brainless partnership that yielded the rubbish results that come from playing two players without footballing brains in the same midfield.

Gibson is crucial to our transition from back to front. We just look a weak mess when he isn't playing and we move the ball too slowly. To be hoenst I don't care how many our defensive midfield scores. Fellaini got his goals from an attacking position, he hasn't scored yet this seaosn from his defensive role. Gibson has a great positional sense so is always in the right place to intercept passes and track runners. Fellaini always looks like he is doing lots but is just chasing shadows.

The evidence is right infront of your eyes every week. Fellaini without Gibson = a bad Fellaini performance and usually results in Everton not winning.

Bill Gall
364 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:26:51
All the players we seem to be signing are defenders or defensive midfielders yet we do not have any player who is capable of putting the ball in the back of the net and leading the line.

Allthough it seems it is going to happen I feel it will be a mistake to sell either Baines or Fellaini in this window.

There are allready a number of supporters on this thread starting to doubt Martinez even though we are unbeaten and only 1pt behind last years champions.

If one or both are sold with little time to replace them Martinez is going to have to go back to square 1 to bring other people in who do not have the same skill set.

The best scenerio I see is to get Barry to help in midfield start Anichebe and say you are 1st choice and assess in January our progress.

I may sound like a broken record but I do not believe it is possible to sell your best players and improve the team with new recruits that may not perform as expected.

Do not sell Baines or Fellaini.

Mr Kenwright take a look at the Everton motto Nil Satis Nisi Omptimum and stop making Everton a selling club to pay for your poor leadership as the clubs custodian.

Colin Wainwright
365 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:04:09
"'Fellaini is the best DM in the prem' - He really really isn't. For a start Gibson is better than him which is why successive managers have played Gibson holding mid rather than Fellaini. "

Which is why Utd, who sold us Gibson, are in the process of signing Fellaini.

James Marshall
366 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:10:11
Mike #094

Exactly, and it's Woodward not Moyes who decides how much they pay, right? Moyes has input but he's not the money-man....

Colin Wainwright
367 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:07:04
Also James, you're always quick to point out Fellaini's poor games (which every player suffers), yet when he plays well, you're strangely silent. When he signs for Man Utd, i'll look forward to your tactical deconstruction of why Titus Bramble or some other useless git has just walked through our midfield.
Colin Glassar
368 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:44:02
Two things; Moyes is desperate to sign somebody, anybody, so we should squeeze every last penny out of him for Fellaini. We need to be careful with wooden leg Whelan. If we get £25m plus for Felli he will try and get at least twenty million for McCarthy. Billy liar needs to be strong on this but we all know he's a weak kneed wimp and will probably end up selling Felli for £15m and buying McCarthy for £20m. Man up billy boy or you will get screwed once again.
Brent Stephens
369 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:14:33
Why does Jake the Peg need to know what we sell Felli for? We don't have to tell him.
Mike Rourke
371 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:15:26
James

I think it would be extremely naive not to imagine that Moyes told him the starting price and to take it from there.

So yes, Woodward is now caught between getting the player for Moyes and looking like a canny wheeler-dealer to the Glazers.

I don't know who at United gives the final say on maximum price limits but from the little I know of United it appears that that is the job the Glazers hired Woodward to do.

He is therefore in the position that if he doesn't secure the player Moyes desperately wants and knows will come then he looks like a prize twat. He should also know that if this start goes from bad to worse then Moyes, being the scrupulous fellow that he is, will be hanging it around Ed's neck for failure to deliver the players he wanted.

I appreciate I am only hypothesizing, but I don't imagine I'm a million miles off.

Infact I'm sure it is similarish ( is that a word?) scenarios behind every over-inflated panic buy.

Again, if our transfer negotiators are not savvy to this and don't use it to our advantage then what bloody good are they.

We don't have to sell him, so lets bleed the fuckers we have absolutely nothing to lose by holding out for a colossal amount.

Carl Sanderson
372 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:08:26
Stan Collymore reckons City are in for Fellaini. (If this has already been posted then apologies.)
Phil Sammon
373 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:11:11
That would be bloody brilliant, Carl.
James Martin
374 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:24:26
Colin I gave him the credit he deserved for his performance against Man U but frankly he has never matched that standard since. He did in fits and starts but we're talking about a handful of games in a whole season when he's at his best.

Our midfield is getting walked through anyway at times, Norwich did it and so did Stevenage.

Like everyone was saying when Moyes was leaving, he hasn't won anything with us so why is everyone scared of a bit of change? We weren't rubbish before Fellaini came and we won't be after he's gone. The real loss to this Everton team was Arteta. He embodied the School of Science, Fellaini doesn't.

Colin Wainwright
375 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:55
I agree James. Given the funds to buy the right players, we'll be fine. You obviously don't think Fellaini brings anything to the team. That's fine, your opinion. I, on the other hand, think that we have no chance to bring to the club, with only one day left of the window, the talent needed to fill the gap left by the afro'd one. McCarthy, good player that he is, is not going to do it.

We weren't rubbish before Fellaini came mate, and you're right, we wont be rubbish after he goes. I think we'll be weaker.

Colin Glassar
376 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:53:35
24 hours to go gents. Can't we lock BK in the bog until this time tomorrow so he can't do any more damage to our club?
Drew Shortis
377 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:47:30
I despise Man City after the Lescott saga, but I would gladly sell Fellaini to them at this moment in time. I can't believe it has taken Man Utd so long to come in with a sensible bid. To see their bid fall flat on its face at this stage would be a joy to behold, especially if City were willing to outbid them to get the deal done! Wishful thinking of the highest order?
Ste Traverse
378 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:59:52
I'm with you totally Drew.

I loathed City after our dealings with them over Lescott. But would rather sell to them now to simply piss off the now despised ginger,miserable jock.

Plus City are more likely to pay top dollar.

Peter Barry
379 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:19:39
Sell Fellaini to anyone but disrespectful deceitful lying Man Utd and TGT.
Rick Cole
380 Posted 01/09/2013 at 05:56:37
I have read £36 mill plus Jesse Lingard. It would be a shame to loose the Big Fella, but he is a bit of a dick, and Lingard looks a quality young player.
Matt Smith
381 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:03:32
If MF is that good, why aren't Arsenal, Chelsea or city interested?

Reason: a good player but nothing special — why would you pay £20 millon for a defensive midfielder who scores the odd header?

Jimmy Sørheim
382 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:05:25
I think we are letting Uinted off very easy here. Something stinks from Bill and Moyes and I do not like it.

Why not place a fixed price tag like 28 million and be done with it, United can afford it.
Perhaps Bill is afraid his value will sink when his contract runs down.

Either way we are being held for idiots here, Fellaini is easy worth 28-30 million when you look at Bales price tag.

The longer we wait the better the deal we get, Moyes is desperate now, I can feel it, why not play hardball and be a perfect bastard to him like he was to the whole club????????????????

Bill surely forgets fast doesnt he.

24 million is at least 4-5 million lower then his real value. We simply can not afford to give hand outs like we did with Yakubu to Blackburn.

I do not care if there is a transfer request, Bill still has the power to put the right price on him and if he doesnt then clearly there is still a collusion between the two arseholes , Bill and Moyes.

The fact they are still talking on a weekly basis should tell you all that Bill Kenwright is a shitty Chairman for Everton.

What would have happened iof this was done in the finance market?
Two closely linked people at the top who work in different companies concluding and discussing deals with each other behind closed doors.

The media would have blasted them, why is nobody reacting to this, I just find it disgusting.

Richard Tarleton
383 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:20:40
It'll go through without doubt , at five to eleven, then Bill can keep all the cash.
David Johnson
384 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:23:14
I’ll be made up to get shut at that price. Even I can pass the ball sideways.
Frida Ericsson
385 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:55:23
i thought felliaini's release clause was 25 million?
Frida Ericsson
386 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:55:23
i thought felliaini's release clause was 25 million?
Lee Mandaracas
387 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:19:12
Fellaini's release clause was for £23.5m but that expired on 31st July. Therefore, after that date we could charge what we liked and I think (especially given the rumour the release clause reactivated in the January window - unconfirmed) we did pretty good business. I am very happy at £27.5m and £75k per week of the wage bill freed up to go towards the replacements - plus Anichebe's £6m from WBA and £20k p/w saving.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb