McCarthy bid knocked back

, 1 September, 142comments  |  Jump to most recent
£10m offer short of Wigan's valuation

Everton have had a bid for James McCarthy rejected by Wigan Athletic.

Latics chairman Dave Whelan has confirmed that an offer of £10m, believed to be worth £7m with £3m in appearance-related add-ons, is nowhere near Wigan's valuation of the player. Media speculation, led by ITV Sport, suggests that Everton have come back with a bid closer to £12.5m.

With Marouane Fellaini looking increasingly likely to join Manchester United tomorrow, Roberto Martinez is in the market for a replacement and is following up his long-held interest in bringing McCarthy to Goodison Park.

Whelan confirmed earlier that he has been in discussion with a club regarding McCarthy today and comes as no surprise that the club in question is Everton.

Martinez knows the midfielder well from his time at the DW Stadium but could be forced to pay well over the odds for the 22 year-old given that he is up against the transfer deadline.  



Reader Comments (142)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tim Locke
1 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:34:01
Do we know how much it was for?
Andy Meighan
2 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:32:57
What was the first bid for McCarthy and why are we going back to Wigan. Didn't they get relegated.
Colin Wainwright
3 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:35:57
Good player. Nowhere near worth £15M.
Andrew Yates
4 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:36:00
Looks like an initial bid of £10m-ish Tim. Must mean Fellaini is pretty much done and dusted.
Paul David
5 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:39:31
Even though I like McCarthy it does annoy me that Martinez is just looking at Wigan players. I would have thought he would of had targets in mind from when he was still at Wigan that he knew he couldn't attract to the club but he's at a far bigger club now.
Dick Brady
6 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:43:19
We cannot play hardball with Man Utd over Fellaini and not expect the Wigan to do the same to us over McCarthy.

Is McCarthy worth £15 million? Probably not.

Is Fellaini worth £40-50 million? Probably not.

We all expect Man Utd to pay over the odds for Fellaini so its only fair we pay over the odds for McCarthy.

Sean Lloyd
7 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:46:36
I wish Whelan would STFU with his constant media leaking obsessions.
Jim Bennings
8 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:42:33
Yet again, though! what on Earth is the point in bidding £7 million plus add-ons knowing full well that Wigan are not going to sell him for any less than £15 mill?

We know Fellaini has gone, I am sad that I won't see the 'fro at Goodison anymore. An iconic figure who on his day and at his best was as dynamic and unplayble as Big Dunc in his first spell.

You would imagine we will make one more bid for McCarthy but I wouldn't hold my breath on it being their valuation of him. What are the odds on Fellaini going and us failing in bids to sign anyone to replace him, with McCarthy going to Newcastle or Spurs (they do love to collect midfielders)?

I am bracing myself for a typical Everton transfer deadline day and a long two weeks to follow before the Chelsea game. At least by making a good signing or two, it would ease the early season frustration starting to be felt already.

James Martin
9 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:44:18
Dear lord, an initial bid for this player for the same value that we sold Arteta for? By the time we buy him he'll be getting close to what Spurs paid for Modric or Arsenal for Cazorla. Considering Gibson was 500k and Coleman was 600k how is Mccarthy valued at 15 million? Both are far better players than he is.

Remember when ayoung Mikel Arteta strolled into Goodison and was just bending in free kicks all over the show and pirouhetting around Makele. is it really that hard to find a player of that sensational ilk rather than these poor imitations like Allen and McCarthy who just recycle the ball moronicly? Arteta was the last player at Everton with genuine end product.

Martin Handley
10 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:40:19
Player is decent and would be a good addition; if it's true we bid £10m, I would say that's a good offer and in truth probably the maximum he's worth.

If it's true that Man Utd have finally started bidding properly, we may just have some manoeuvrability in the market. If we are selling Fellaini, get it done early doors tomorrow and hopefully RM knows who he wants so we will have enough time to deal them in.

Mike Hughes
11 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:18
Second bid should be £9 million......
Michael Winstanley
12 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:49:11
I am an RM fan, I think he'll do wonders for us but another Wigan player? For how much money? I'm not so sure about this, yes he may be an honest footballer but we need a bit more than that.
Mike Rourke
13 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:49:47
Mike Hughes

With Luca Brasi in attendance...

Tim Locke
14 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:47:53
Colin is spot on he is a good player but worth no more that the sensible bid we have put in. Dick who is paying £40-50 for the big fella? We will be lucky to get £25. We should tell Man U where to go. The only reason for selling would be RM does not see a need for him, maybe we could see if Matta would want to come
Karl Masters
15 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:54
I am prepared to trust Martinez's judgement on the player, even though personally I can't what it is he rates about him.

However, the price is a joke. £10m is way too much. There must be better value elsewhere.

Derek Knox
16 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:34
Sean (099)
I'm surprised, no gobsmacked, that he never mentioned about his broken leg!
Brent Stephens
17 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:50:32
Is our bid derisory etc?
Mike Rourke
21 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:53:07
Tidy.

I hear that a lot with McCarthy. He's a 'tidy player'.

Tidy players shouldn't cost more than 5 million quid.

Tidy essentially means average

Leon Osman is a 'tidy little player'.

I heard someone, somewhere online state that McCarthy is "The next Roy Keane", so that is precisely what I will tell everyone I meet when they ask why we paid £15million for him...trouble is I won't believe a word of what I'm saying.

Karl Jones
23 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:56:46
Not another relegated failure..Evergan or Wigerton ?
Chris Jones [Burton]
26 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:49:28
The difference here is that while Manyoo's initial bid for Felli was less than we paid for him in 2008 (£15 million plus add ons), our bid of £7 to £10m for McCarthy amounts to several times what he cost Wigan when bought from from Hibs (£1.2m rising to £3m) in 2009!

Why do we always get the shitty end of the stick? If we had a line of credit, we could've bought McCarthy cheap before selling - in the way Spurs have already spent £110m of the £85 they were getting for Bale (yes I know the sums don't add up, but that's what Spurs have spent). Instead, because we have to sell to buy, the club selling to us screws us over.

Paul Ferry
27 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:57:12
An insulting and derisory and gobshite bid and I'll tell you one thing for nothing: that Martinez fella behaves in exactly the same manner as Moyes/Manure doesn't he Andy Walker? Disgraceful, shocking, inappropriate, unbecoming.
Kristian Boyce
28 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:54:41
Does RM actually have a scouting team??? If he does, are they only allowed to go in a 50 mile radius? Kone, Alcarez, Robles (technically) and now McCarthy, Ince & Barry. I was hoping for some gems from Latin America or Spain, but we're getting some uninspiring local plodders. Even our boy from Barca, I really doubt he had to do any scouting on that one as he's well known as an up and coming talent.
Mark Leicester
29 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:02:00
Well hopefully we give up and use the money elsewhere, however he will be an Everton player tomorrow, shame, think Will Hughes of Derby has much more potential.
Brent Stephens
30 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:02:29
What players are worth now is not directly related to what they were bought for.
Mike McLoughlin
40 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:10:29
Like the way Whelan plays hard ball. We could learn a thing or two there. The guys not worth more than £10 mil. I don't care if he is a box to box player and has pace. He is not proven.
Colin Glassar
41 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:15:13
Whelan has just said on radio Wigan pie that McCarthy is worth more than Bale and that if Everton don't get a move on Barcelona and Bayern Munich are waiting in the wings. Even for wooden leg Whelan that is a whopper.
Bill Gall
43 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:14:36
A number of weeks back, one of the questions I asked was one of the qualities that Martinez was given the Manager's job for was his extensive knowledge of the Europeon leagues and players.

Again it looks like he can not see any further than his old club who, as far as players go, did not have anything better than what we have.

Stuart Eaton
44 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:04:45
For god sake Martinez you now have more money to spend than Moyes ever has subject to MF going tomorrow, if Bill Kenwright lets you have it. Use it wisely in the areas we are desperate for a new player – like up front. Please surprise us with some unknown world beater for buttons.
John Ford
45 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:18:16
If Martinez sees this bloke as key to our future then let's get him in and get things moving. He looks a bit pink and fleshy to me, but we have to create in our managers image.
Phil Sammon
46 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:23:43
You know that Cedric fella from Real Betis? You know, the one that tore us to shreds in pre-season. €1.2M that lad cost!

What the fuck are we offering TEN MILLION POUNDS for a Wigan player for?!?!

Colin Williams
47 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:19:46
McCarthy! What have this guy done to deserve a £10M plus fee on his head?? This player has no CV to his name! This deal really does puzzle me. We ave very little money, spend it wisely Robbie!!!

Looking at Sky Sport thinking it's all a bad dream, why us!!!!!

Tony Twist
48 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:24:25
Whelan is a good chairman but we can not be doing business with him with so little time left, he will just mess us around and waste time. We need a quality central midfielder, McCarthy is reasonably good but not quality. We especially need a goal scorer but all I am hearing is central defender, left back, winger, we need a reliable goal scorer or it will be game over.
Mark Pierpoint
49 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:30:00
Stuart the sad fact is that we ain't going to get a bargain on 2nd september. I like McCarthy. I hope though that RM has a figure in mind, a bit like buying a house, and does not get carried away by going over it. Secondly, I hope he has another target who we can turn too if needed.

At the risk of criticism, I would prefer a Barry figure until January If it is a choice between that and a 20m bid for a McCarthy. A club like us HAS to consider sell on values if the business model is even to allow us to stand still.

Alasdair Mackay
50 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:29:49
I think McCarthy is a good player and will suit Martinez's style more than Fellaini does, but what I can see happening is us paying over the odds for McCarthy (£15m, when he's probably worth closer to £10m) and getting the bare minimum for Fellaini (£25m, when he's probably worth closer to £35m).

If we had better negotiators in the club it could be making a £15m difference.

James Marshall
51 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:34:45
£15m the day before deadline day/on deadline day? Sounds about right when when you think about it. Look at the fee's Spurs et al have been shelling out for players. McCarthy is only 22 as well so it's probably a sensible valuation in all honesty.

We don't want to sell Fellaini for anything short of about £25m up to £40m if you read peoples comments on here, so why should Wigan be any different?

James Marshall
52 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:59
Oh, and to add to that - didn't we pay £15m for Fellaini when none of us had even heard of him?!
Phil Sammon
53 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:34:13
Can we not turn our attentions to Europe, where quality ball playing footballers are available for peanuts.

I bet we could pick up Banega for £8M.
Fernandes?
Leroy bloody Fer - £4M!!!!

What are we doing?

Alasdair Mackay
54 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:03
And also - no-one else is in for him and his value is only going to go down while he's in the championship. If Wigan don't come straight back up he will go for £6-10m next summer and he'll still be 23.

I would sooner spend the £25m we will get for Felli on Barry on loan and a striker.

James Marshall
55 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:40:12
Martinez likes McCarthy = we'll buy McCarthy.

We've been linked all summer = it will happen.

We already bought a striker = we won't buy another striker.

Paul Andrews
56 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:39:04
James Martin,
102
Arteta a player with end product.
Can you name one defence splitting ball he played in his Everton career?
Because I am struggling to recall one
Phil Sammon
57 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:38:06
James Marshall

Spurs paid £11M for Erikson.

CL experience
Star player for his national team

We're forking out £15M for a Championship midfielder who took his side down there.

I have no problem with McCarthy. He's a good player. But can we have a little perspective here! £15M buys you top class players.

Kevin Tully
58 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:06
The whole Fellaini / McCarthy deals were probably stitched up days if not weeks ago.

I just think half of all these 'bid rejected' stories are peddled by the clubs concerned for the benefit of the supporters.

What is it about that lying, scheming, bullshitting actor that makes me so cynical?

"Of course you can have Fellaini - £22m, but at least let's make it look like we put up a fight."

Mark Pierpoint
59 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:39:58
That is a good point Alasdair. With Europe, Owen Coyle and the calibre of teams in the championship I would doubt whether they would be favourites to come back up. Think Newcastle may move for him also.

Some fans will be pleasantly surprised by him but we will still be lacking Fellaini's goals and physical presence if McCarthy comes in.

James Newcombe
60 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:44:05
Why didn't we follow up on Redmond? £2m rising to £3.2m looks like a bit of a steal now
Sam Hoare
61 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:40:07
This looks very poor value for money if we pay more than 12m for him. Eriksen was less than that. Surely Martinez scouts must be able to find a better European option for that much cash?
Brent Stephens
62 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:42:05
As above, £10M plus for a Championship player sounds OTT.

A striker is what's needed - we can hold the ball up all day.

Amit Vithlani
63 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:49
Whelan is canny. He knows Martinez needs a replacement and with MoFro's departure now a badly kept secret, has the upper hand.

For what it is worth, I would like to see Martinez walk away from this deal. McCarthy is not worth the money. Whelan may have saved us.

I do not know who we should bring to replace MoFro, but given it has been on the cards one hopes Martinez has done some research beyond the Wigan squad.

Andy Morden
64 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:42:14
Sadly Martinez has form for raiding his fomer club for his favourites.

Look at these super signings he made for Wigan:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/w/wigan_athletic/8136609.stm

http://www.theguardian.com/football/2013/apr/12/jordi-gomez-wigan-millwall-fa-cup

Jason Scotland and Jordi Gomez, shrewd moves there Robbie. I am hoping Kone and the probable signing of McCarthy pan out better. Please.

James Marshall
65 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:48:27
Phil, you're right but the price is inflated now because Wigan know we NEED the player!

We just have to suck it up same as Man Utd for for Fellaini - its a house of cards....

Craig Mills
66 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:41:15
I agree with you Alasdair, I see this a total waste of what will be 10m upfront with 2 to 3m in additional payments, what has he ever done to deserve that money !! Take Barry on loan for now and he will do a job alongside Gibson, Ossie, Barkley. If we are bidding 10m on anything it has to be a guy who can put the ball in the net, not someone who passes it 10 yards sidewards......
Greg Maddox
69 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:52:26
£13.5 mil??? Your having a tin barf ain't ya!
Andy Morden
70 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:53:03
Ha, Craig (183) if we really want someone who passes sideways we could also ask if we can loan Rodwell back from City as well as Barry!
Mark Frere
71 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:44:29
Weather we like it or not, Fellaini is going to be sold for £25 million and McCarthy is going to be signed for £13 million-ish. I just hope that lair BK stays true to his word for once and gives Martinez all of the money left. It wouldn't supprise me if the rest of the money vanished like it did from selling Arteta, Yakubu and Beckford. If the same thing happens again, there should be serious questions answered. The Everton faithful sit back too easy and take it up the arse!
Mark Pierpoint
72 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:53:05
http://theexecutionersbong.wordpress.com/2013/07/31/transfer-deconstruction-james-mccarthy/

worth a read. Not too positive a view though.....

Colin Williams
73 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:41:18
Can someone give me a good reason why he is worth £15m plus??

There are so many quality players out there worth half of what this numpty will cost. Kevin Reeves (chief scout) needs to get off his arse and find some bargains!!! I know this guy from the past, cocky so and so!!! Bigtime Charlie. Chief scout my arse!!!!

Let's just hope we have a nice deadline day surprise.

Mike Hughes
74 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:49:18
So we're Man Utd's bitches and Wigan's whipping boys.

An opening offer of £10m is not too bright.

I know we need to keep the faith and it's only early days and all that but stop talking to peg-leg now.

Not impressed. Happy to be proved wrong.

Sam Hoare
75 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:55:53
If Wigan stay in the Championship, as looks likely, they would be lucky to get more than £6m for him this time next year.

Look elsewhere, Roberto – don't give Whelan the satisfaction of calling the shots. I like McCarthy but there are plenty of good if not better players out there for less than £15m.

Kevin Tully
76 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:54:57
If we pay £13-15m, would it be a record for a Championship player?

If he was knocking in 30 goals a season, you could maybe begin to justify the amount. This would be madness to pay anything like the money being mentioned, especially for an ordinary midfielder.

Mark Jones
77 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:43:46
Moyes bought Cahill, Jagielka, Coleman, Gibson, Pienaar and Arteta COMBINED for less than we've bid for this kid.

On our budgets, we need to be clever in the market - bargains from the championship, underrated fringe players at big clubs, well-scouted foreigners, etc.

This is the exact opposite of that. This is us about to get bummed by paying massively over the odds for a player who, despite being decent, is no world beater.

If we have money to spend we absolutely must get value for it. But I fear this isn't going to happen - blowing £6m on Kone doesn't fill with confidence.

Craig Mills
78 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:51:42
Just told my 13-year-old son about the McCarthy bid being rejected, he said "Great — and we would be better off buying Shaun Maloney for £1m." I had to agree with him!!

I am starting to worry about RM's transfer targets, I really thought he would be more creative than this, it sounds like we will pay more for an average Championship player than Arsenal will pay for Cabaye and I know who I would rather have...

James Marshall
79 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:03:08
So the Bale deal is done, for £85m.

Now everyone else can get on with things......that's how it's gonna work, right?

Iain Johnston
80 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:49:46
Guy I work with is a Spurs Fan, He reckons they're open to negotiations for Siggursson & Holtby . Surely an inquiry for these players would be more beneficial? I would rather see players like these here on loan than spend £15m on McCarthy. Christ, I'd rather have Vaughan from Sunderland!!. There has to be equal or better out there for the price.
Mark Jones
81 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:06:14
Hitzlsperger, Naismith, Junior, McFadden, Stracqualursi, Drenthe, Dier, Gueye, Silva, Beckford, Senderos, Neill, Bilyaletdinov, Jo, Castillo, Jacobsen, Wessels, Van der Meyde, Ferrari, Kroldrup, Davies, Beattie, Bent, Rodrigo, Li Tie, Li We Feng...

I'd take McCarthy over any of those.

Mike Hughes
83 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:04:33
James #198

At least Levy is showing some business acumen, ambition and vision.

James Marshall
84 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:09:56
Absolutely, Mike. But we don't have a Bale to sell, we have a windmill in a gale and we should flog him ASAP and buy...err......someone else.
Colin Wainwright
85 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:11:58
Brilliant James. If you're not careful, Bill will offer you a job.
Colin Glassar
86 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:08:34
Brilliant post Mark J, to be fair one or two of those players could've come good given the chance e.g. Dier, Bily (played in his proper position), Ferrari etc... You forgot the likes of Jutkewicz, AJ, Gravesen II etc....
Sean Patton
87 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:08:10
Spot on there Mark

let Peg Leg Whelan stew in his own juices and leave McCarthy where he is get Barry in on loan for the season and next year he will be begging to sell him for 8 million.

Martinez should move on and pursue other targets but he wont.

Greg Maddox
88 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:07:34
Well said Kevin, this is a ridiculous price for on over rated over priced Championship player. We might as well dip into League 1 and see if we can snaffle up a player from there for a least £10 mil while we're at it!
Michael Kenrick
89 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:13:09
Mark Jones (#200) — Good memory... but what a scary list. Hall of Shame award! There've been a fair few rum ones, and no mistake! Well, actually they all turned out to be pretty horrible mistakes! No argument there!
Mike Hughes
90 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:13:06
James. Agreed - but a business brain doesn't cost anything. As a club we're not too blessed in that department. Whenever we're proactive it's over nonsense like the badge fiasco or the Martinez March. Not having a pot to pee in should make us harder business people, not rollovers.
Phil Sammon
91 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:15:55
The thing is, I think Whelan would quite happily keep McCarthy.

They say that if you stand still in football - you risk going backwards.

I say that if you go backwards - you go even further backwards.

Keep Fellaini & Baines till Jan and lets make a proper job of it in that window. Don't trade in our best players and throw the money at inferior ones.

James Marshall
92 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:18:19
Colin, I hear there's going to be an opening for a midfield enforcer coming up soon.....I'll dust off my Adidas Copa Mundial's and get my knees fixed pronto...
Eugene Ruane
93 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:58:00
Kevin (175) - Spot on.

Buying players, we will be shafted.

Selling players, we will be shafted.

This is a completely natural and normal state of affairs....if your club (as ours is) is run by a truly hopeless fucking clown.

Idiots make idiotic decisions (nb: that's kind of the biggest part of what makes them idiots) and any Evertonian with half a brain understands we're run by the king of the idiots.

We definitely have the right to be angry and/or frustrated but I can't see any reason for anyone to be surprised.

Colin Wainwright
94 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:22:34
Get your boots on lad (nice 80's ref. btw, had a pair of them)! As long as you've nothing to do with transfers, i'm happy.
Drew O'Neall
95 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:16:42
Can't help think £15m would go a lot further in Spain where the players play the kind of football RM wants to play and the clubs are all broke.

Our perennial link with Ever Banega wouldn't go a miss.

David Chait
96 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:21:56
Until the windows closed anything can happen... But it is promising to be as bad as any window as we ever had! We were all excited by the early moves and accepted a few Wigan lads upfront, thinking well that's the opening gambit and we should see more to come.

Nothing.... We are at risk of losing our 2 most important players and buying Wigan player #4... RM needs to change his mindset! I just can't believe this is the best we can do.... RM is meant to be some creative force, but his signings have been as uncreative as Moyes big signings being from Everton. Lets see how this unfolds... I hope my fears are unfounded!

Colin Williams
97 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:06:39
We will miss Fellaini Big Time!

McCarthy, what the fuck has he done to deserve a dream move to the greatest football club In the world????

What a load of bollocks!

Stuart Mitchell
98 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:27:34
Good young player with plenty of potential. Not going to set the place on fire like Barkley, but certainly an improvement on Osman and a want away Fellaini.

Gives us the much needed energy and legs in CM that we lack when playing Gibson/Osman.

Hopefully we will keep Baines and bring in another striker.

Peter Jones
99 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:03:26
I don't get the McCarthy valuation either. Martinez picked him up for £1M two seasons ago. How has value suddenly gone up 15 fold?

Good player. I like him. But I agree with the general TW sentiment that there is simply too much quality out there in other leagues to spend this kind of money for him if Fellaini is indeed gone.

Drew O'Neall
100 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:42
By the way... I'm sure all deals have been done and this is just being played out in the media to pull the wool over the eyes of the hapless fans. I mean, they all know each other, why on earth would Everton put in an offer which they weren't prepared to accept?

If they had any sense at all, they would be lining up, and making public, an alternative target... but of course they won't; they don't have one and even if it wasn't a con, they wouldn't be smart enough to negotiate properly.

Craig Mills
101 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:10:39
I honestly think most Evertonians would think Martinez a better man if he walked away from this one, 7m with add on's is about its limit, 13 to 15m not a chance, 15m+ and you have to ask if he is right in his head!!

Have I been watching a different team for the last 4 games, I see a team with or without Felli who retain the ball well and have enjoyed a high percentage of possession in all their games, however, in all games there has been one glareing, obvious to anyone, smack you in the face issue - WE CANNOT SCORE A FU@&ING GOAL

FFS we could buy a quality striker with this kind of money and the limit of our ambition is James bloody McCarthy

John Crawley
102 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:35:15
Apparently we have come back in with a second bid of £12.5 million.

http://www.itv.com/sport/football/update/2013-09-01/everton-return-with-second-mccarthy-bid/

Tony Fearns
103 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:31:12
He was valued at £500k 5 years ago when at Hamilton; now he's worth 30 times that.

What a joke.

Colin Glassar
104 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:50
Agreed Stuart. McCarthy has the potential to become a top player. I think Martinez wants him due to the fact that he would increase the tempo of our play. Felli (who I think is great) likes to bring the ball out and can slow the game down quite a bit. McCarthy is all about quick, neat passing both long and short. In other words, he doesn't dwell on the ball.

I think £10m is a fair enough price for him, maybe with add ons, if not I'd go abroad (Spain, Portugal, S America etc) and get a similar player only cheaper. In this respect I'm a bit disappointed that Martinez hasn't gone down this road.

Steve Pugh
105 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:24:15
The Scary thing is BK probably thinks he is being clever,

"Whelan wants 55% of the Fellaini money does he? Well I'll sell Fellaini for £20m then we can get McCarthy for £11m. That'll show old peg leg, £15m indeed...."

Peter Laing
107 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:34:37
Zaha and Ince were the top-rated Championship players from last season. If we are being linked with a £10 million plus Championship player, I would be looking at Ince over McCarthy any day of the week.
Drew O'Neall
108 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:42
By the way... I'm sure all deals have been done and this is just being played out in the media to pull the wool over the eyes of the hapless fans.. I mean they all know each other, why on earth would Everton put in an offer which they weren't prepared to accept?

If they had any sense at all they would be lining up, and making public, an alternative target but of course they won't, they don't have one and even if it wasn't a con, they wouldn't be smart enough to negotiate properly.

David Booth
109 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:45:29
£1.5m surely?

How the hell can we contemplate paying circa £15m for him?

It just does not stack up by any criteria or comparison – many of which are listed very clearly above.

If Martinez buys him and we flop, he will find Evertonians turning against him (and Kenwright) in their thousands).

Please god NO!

No, no, no, no, no, no, no.

Colin Glassar
110 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:46:05
The Daily Mirror (unofficial mouthpiece of Man Utd) are saying that Wigan have told us to "stuff" our £7m bid for McCarthy. The journo is evidently outraged that we made such a miserly offer after we rejected Man Utd's more than generous offer of £28m for Bainsey and Fellaini. He is in fact quite histerical and seems to be on the verge of having a fit. Whatever happened to fair and balanced journalism?
Andrew Cutler
111 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:07:54
I don't now enough about the market and available players in it to make an informed comment. RM earns about £40k a week to know these things. I think I will leave it up to him for the informed decisions.

(No disrespect to all the knowledgeable participants to this forum, who know more...)

Colin Leary
112 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:50:01
Lets do a deal for Rooney..no more wigan players please..we want winners.
Mark Jones
113 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:44:30
7 goals in 120 games for Wigan (thanks, Wikipedia).

25 in 141 for Felli.

This will further diminish our already lacklustre goalscoring threat.

Michael Brooks
114 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:50:24
Just so I know, whos Wigan's left back for when Baines is sold?
Matthew Williams
115 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:28:52
£10 million for McCarthy!!!... erm no fucking way! For that money we could have Joey Barton (DM), Andy King (AM) & Shaun Maloney (Better option from Wigan) & still have change for a pie, pint & fanzine.

Wasted opportunities yet again Blues!!!

Kevin Day
116 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:35:29
I've been searching every football transfer web page, and I cannot find one, not one scrap of a mention that Utd are in talks/ on the verge of signing Fellaini, after weeks of rumours, surely news such as this would be all over SSN and the likes. Right?
Robbie Muldoon
117 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:48:59
Initiate your brains before blurting out the 'another relegated player' line.

We're cherry picking from an FA Cup winning side is another way of looking at it, isn't it?

Robles is a back up keeper, come through the ranks with De Gea at Atletico and Spanish national sides.

Alcaraz was a free, just squad padding.

Kone, yes I'll agree this is worth scrutiny definitely.

McCarthy looks a solid British buy, crazy price though, but that's football today.

Kevin Rowlands
118 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:52:04
Paddy have now suspended all betting on Fellaini moving to........ MAN CITY!!!!

Hahaha — you ginger twat!

John Crook
119 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:57:00
Jermaine Defoe for me would be the perfect Deadline Day loan signing! He never starts at Spurs and , with a World Cup coming up, he needs to play every game. He knows where the net is and he is clearly better than what we have.

Bill, give your mate Daniel a call and get Defoe in. I, like everyone, is extremely worried about the fact that we couldn't score in a brothel at this moment in time.

Craig Mills
120 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:55:37
It could be as embarrassing as when the RS paid £18m for Henderson — but at least he came from a Premier League team!
Craig Mills
121 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:57:30
Agree John Crook
Colin Glassar
122 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:57:14
Kevin that's so funny (not really) if it happened. Teach that ginger shit a lesson. Tbh, I thought he might end up in spurs, they've only got 34 MF players.
Derek Knox
123 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:53:15
Michael (241)
Not sure, but he has a wooden leg with a castor on it, and can eat a pie at the same time, so he should be quite an asset!
Kevin Day
124 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:58:57
If we got Defoe in John Crook I think we would all be very happy.
Colin Wainwright
125 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:53:48
Peter Reid, signed from Bolton, never won a trophy in his life. Sharp, signed from Dunbarton, hadn't won a thing. Big Nev signed from who fuckin knows where..........you get my drift. Just because we're signing players from Wigan, doesn't mean they're not winners, or never can be.
Mark Jones
126 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:44:30
I'm concerned about it from a footballing perspective, first and foremost, but there's an important factor we're overlooking in these discussions.

The battle for money is a global battle for fans, sponsors and investors. Over the past three years or so, Fellaini has been the face of every major corporate manoeuvre we've made.

This is because he's the most recognisable, most marketable, and most valuable asset in our team. It's no different to why the top clubs always wanted Beckham (albeit on a smaller scale).

My point is Fellaini carries brand value for the club, not just playing value. McCarthy isn't a name that's going to get fans, sponsors and investors excited.

Who is our next most bankable asset? Oh yeah, that'll be Baines. Hmm.

NB. When I say 'investors' I don't mean the billionaire investors who are going to swoop in and buy our club - the majority if investment in football is not of this nature.

Karan Oza
127 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:08:47
Why is Martinez insisting on getting Wigan players back in PL? Does he want to get us relegated too? He's not woth 15 mil in my mind, and we can find better options (hopefully) with the fella money, or maybe even get a medicore mid and a good striker.
Phil Walling
128 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:05:00
I've not the slightest doubt we shall end up paying c£14M for McCarthy. RM probably sorted the deal out with his mucker Whelan before he joined us. The man is a fucking laugh of a manager !
Drew Shortis
129 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:00:49
I really rate McCarthy and think he would suit Martinez's new style of play. However the £15m+ Wigan value him at is just too much to spend on one player when we really need to invest the Fellaini money in two or three. I think the initial £7m we have bid is a fair price for him, so perhaps we could haggle over the add ons. If he really is as good as Whelan thinks they will get their money in time for their arrival back in the Premier League and we will be happy to pay the add ons as we will have a quality midfielder. If he doesn't work out then Wigan don't get the add ons but they did get a good wedge of cash for a player that proved to be over hyped! Seems a sensible solution to me.

Perhaps Martiez shouldn't become obsessed with one player and should broaden his horizons. I know for a fact that there are a number of quality players across Europe that would be available for much less. I would rather take a gamble on a few raw talents out there than blow the lions share of the Felli money on one guy. Look at Eriksen at Spurs. Yes they have more of a draw at the moment, but it does show that European teams will sell for less than British ones. Swansea have brought in several quality players from the continent for a fraction of what McCarthy would cost. Time to make use of your scouting knowledge Roberto!

Derek Knox
131 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:19:54
According to the Sky Sports News Transfer Centre, Dave Whelan is the chairman of Cardiff. Check it out. You would think they would at least get some of the more obvious facts correct.

They are also saying Mesut Ozil is on the verge of joining Arsenal after agreeing a fee with Real Madrid.

Daniel Lawrence
132 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:28:24
Oh we'll, we tried. Best off buying some blue gravel and lawn mowers.
Better still, a nice new shiny HD screen to clap Kenwright, next time his grid pops up.....
Anthony Flack
133 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:35
Kevin 248 are you serious - Man City or am I missing the point?
Kristian Boyce
134 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:13:59
£15M is an absolute farce. I think Whelan has forgot what division his team is in now. They're not PL anymore and cannot charge PL prices. Plus Whelan needs to check the kid's birth certificate, he's Scotish/Irish not English, so the crazy 'Young English Tax' that gets added onto all deals involving young English players doesn't apply. If Ince is valued at £8M then McCarthy would roughly be the same.
Ste Traverse
135 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:36:13
I'd love us to take Defoe, and would love Fellaini to go to City if we sell him.

Christ, it would be so sweet piss that twat Moyes off. His bug eyes would be popping out of his head!

Paul Thompson
136 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:59
Also not impressed. Overrated and over-priced player. There's far better out there for less money. Whelan must love doing business with us.
Chris Jones [Burton]
137 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:39:23
Well, if Fellaini does go to the Emirates, I can see a part-X involving Barry, Rodders and Lescott, leaving room for Baines to go to Manure. Two out, three in, and £10 mill off our overdraft.
Lee Jamieson
138 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:37:00
I think we have missed the boat as usual, spurs keep the Bale deal on ice until they make a few signings at a market value then make the official announcement that Bale is gone. We dither around saying Baines and Fellaini are not for sale when we know they will go, they sell on the last day and we pay way over the odds for a last minute replacement. I say bring Barry and another in on loan bank the money and give Oviedo,Stones or Garbutt a run in the team and lets look at transfers next August only in the first week not the last week.

Oh yeah and if we bank £40 mill doesn't that mean we are no longer in debt and a more saleable asset Bill !!!

Si Cooper
139 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:31:09
People going on about the other players we could have had, or possibly still could, are overlooking a few critical factors.

Getting new players in (beyond those bought with an initial limited transfer pot) has been contingent on selling one or both of our major assets. Until someone actually came in with a worthwhile bid all RM could do was make initial enquiries. His relationship with Whelan and McCarthy has probably enabled him to set up this deal as a guaranteed contingency move if Fellaini was indeed sold during the transfer window.

We were never in the running for some of the players mentioned because there was no need for a replacement and so no cash available.

Just because Spurs could wrest Erikson away with a paltry £11.5 million doesn't mean we could have engineered the same move for the same fee as he may have been happy to wait until January for a better offer / someone who could match his personal terms. The same probably applies to tempting the likes of Defoe away from London - they may prefer just to sit tight and take their chances.

I would hope other players (in a variety of needed positions) are currently being targeted but, even if we have to pay over the odds, it may be necessary to proceed with the McCarthy transfer just to ensure we aren't left with a gaping hole where our midfield should be.

Jamie Sweet
140 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:33:06
I really hoped Martinez was going to find us a Honduran wonder-kid for 250k who turns out to be the next Messi. Now I'm starting to wonder if his scouting team own a car, let alone a passport!
Anthony Flack
141 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:35
Kevin 248 are you serious - Man City or am I missing the point?
Colin Glassar
142 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:57:35
Martinez will sign Dave Whelan tomorrow.
Kevin Rowlands
143 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:01:10
Anthony, yes I am serious, there has been serious amount of money for Fellaini to join Man City prompting PP to suspend betting on it, if he leaves PLEASE let that be true!
Anthony Flack
144 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:11:59
Fingers crossed Moyes shifts to plan B and goes for Osman or Naismith - I will laugh my nuts off if he goes to Citeh.... - how about Rodwell back, I risk the ire of many but I would love him back!
Harold Matthews
145 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:03
This stinks of a long planned done deal between all four principals. Right now they're just acting out the script.

Of course, Roberto will go to the "right character" scenario to justify the price of the Wigan lad, who would be useful addition, but the £1.2mil Cedric fee brings things into perspective.

Mark Liecester. Good shout. Will Hughes of Derby is a certain future star.

Derek Knox
146 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:56:43
Jamie (#298)
Funny post mate, gave me a good laugh. The scouting team, being Eco-friendly do have a bike, fitted with stabilisers!
Brian Cleveland
147 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:41:40
I hear people saying higher price because McCarthy is British... but are we short of our quota? (Not even sure what the quota of home grown players is!)

If not, there is no need to go for him with an inflated price... like others have said, there seems to be better value to be had in other places around Europe.

It's also the embarrassment of becoming Wigan v2.... is there nobody else available at a better price?

Rob Smith
148 Posted 02/09/2013 at 02:23:56
Surely Roberto must be balking at 15 mill, he was signed in 2009 for 1.2mill, tidy little profit for a Championship club.
Peter Thistle
149 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:45:45
Martinez has not started out well in the transfer market. Totally uninspiring signings. Admittedly he hasn't had much cash to spend but surely he could have spent it more wisely. And ffs stop buying Wigan players.
Steve Pugh
150 Posted 02/09/2013 at 07:51:17
Just one permanent signing without a Wigan connection, that's all I ask. Just one, it isn't much....is it.......please, just one little player.....
Ajay Gopal
151 Posted 02/09/2013 at 07:52:05
If Fellaini really goes to Man City - even for the same price as what Man U are bidding - I would say, 'Well done, Bill' ! Serves Moyes right for dithering for so long. Anthony (321), Rodwell back would not be too shabby, but obviously wages would be a stumbling block. Rodwell really started to do well towards the end of last season. 20 million + Rodwell would be alright by me. With the remainder of the money + sale of Anichebe+Heitinga, get McCarthy in plus a proven goal-scorer from Spain/Germany. That would bring a lot of excitement back amongst the fans.
Ciarán McGlone
152 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:17:45
Fellaini isn't going to city..it was twitter nonsense..

Anyway, we can't really complain about Whelan getting the most for his player... That's exactly what we are doing with Fellaini - from the one person who wants to sign him..

McCarthy would be a better version of Gibson - a young Scott Parker In my opinion..and he may even be fit sometimes.. Then only problem I have with this is that it then makes the Gareth Barry deal somewhat puzzling..

If we get McCarthy then surely we need to be taking a creative midfielder into the club to sit alongside Barkley..

Mark Taylor
153 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:16:45
I'm beginning to wonder if Martinez is on a cut from Whelan for any money he sends back to his old club.

The only person who thinks McCarthy is worth £15m is Whelan, and even then, only when he is talking to Everton. Gustavo, a proven international with CL experience at a top club went for little more than that over the summer and others have posted equally good examples.

This is perhaps the most disappointing aspect of RM's tenure so far. I really hoped he was going to unearth a few gems from Europe, not buy up the players of a relegated club.

Lori Fekete
154 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:07:32
If Wigan is such a hotbed of talent, why the fuck did he get them relegated?!

Day one on RM's arrival, he would have been told;
-last season we had one of the best defensive records in the Premiership
-dominated possession and chances
-turned too many wins into draws
-DESPERATELY NEED A PROLIFIC STRIKER!

Well I'm glad he seems to have sorted that out

Brian Harrison
155 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:42:50
Obviously Whelan knows that his ex boss will pay whatever Wigan want, because he hasnt bothered looking at any other alternatives. We have heard for weeks that if Fellaini is sold then we will buy McCarthy, so Whelan just had to sit tight and he will get very near his asking price.

I cant see this signing or even worse the arrival of Gareth Barry putting bums on seats. I have seen tankers turn quicker in the Mersey than Barry cant think of a more uninspiring player we could buy. I often thought Fellaini slowed things down with Barry in the team he would make Fellaini look quick.

Dick Fearon
156 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:10:26
Old Bill could teach our Bill a few things about playing the transfer game.
Kevin Day
157 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:57:56
News now reporting at 12:26 that Wigan accepted 12.5 mill for Mcarthy
Harold Matthews
158 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:54:59
Whelan is now demanding £14mil. SSN
Will Leaf
159 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:04:31
The Marvellous Martinez, Master of Magic and Mystery, will now make the stain of relegation disappear by levitating most of Wigan back up to the Premier.
Paul Ferry
160 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:13:46
Peter Laing - 232: Zaha and Ince were the top-rated Championship players from last season. If we are being linked with a £10 million plus Championship player, I would be looking at Ince over McCarthy any day of the week.

How silly: McCarthy was not a Championship player last season so what exactly is the point of this utterly erroneous comparison?

Anything eh, anything to dirty McCarthy but this fantasy poke takes the biscuit.

McCarthy will be a great addition to our squad if he jumps ship and I can't wait to see Laing and the anti-McCarthyism lads and lasses eat their silly words.

James Stewart
161 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:41:04
Wigan are drunk if they think he is worth 15m. Neat and tidy player but a crab all the same and he won't be the creative link we are missing. Move on to other targets
Craig Mills
162 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:02:48
Sorry to say it but we have fucked up big time once again, if we put 14m into an average player from guess who - bloody Wigan. What are we thinking, what is Martinez thinking, we cannot hit a cows arse with a banjo in front of goal and yet all we are linked with are defensive midfielders and defenders.
Mike Hughes
163 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:48:50
Surely McCarthy is right at the back of the queue at that price?

In an hour and a half, Whelan's brinkmanship will go into reverse and the price will drop.

I'll be very disappointed if McCarthy comes in over £7.5m.

As others have stated, we need a striker.

If Vic to WBA falls through, that will be like a new signing...

(I'm on here because that Live Forum is doing my head in)


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb