Season › 2013-14 › News
McCarthy bid knocked back
£10m offer short of Wigan's valuation

Latics chairman Dave Whelan has confirmed that an offer of £10m, believed to be worth £7m with £3m in appearance-related add-ons, is nowhere near Wigan's valuation of the player. Media speculation, led by ITV Sport, suggests that Everton have come back with a bid closer to £12.5m.
With Marouane Fellaini looking increasingly likely to join Manchester United tomorrow, Roberto Martinez is in the market for a replacement and is following up his long-held interest in bringing McCarthy to Goodison Park.
Whelan confirmed earlier that he has been in discussion with a club regarding McCarthy today and comes as no surprise that the club in question is Everton.
Martinez knows the midfielder well from his time at the DW Stadium but could be forced to pay well over the odds for the 22 year-old given that he is up against the transfer deadline.
Reader Comments (142)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:32:57
3 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:35:57
4 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:36:00
5 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:39:31
6 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:43:19
Is McCarthy worth £15 million? Probably not.
Is Fellaini worth £40-50 million? Probably not.
We all expect Man Utd to pay over the odds for Fellaini so its only fair we pay over the odds for McCarthy.
7 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:46:36
8 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:42:33
We know Fellaini has gone, I am sad that I won't see the 'fro at Goodison anymore. An iconic figure who on his day and at his best was as dynamic and unplayble as Big Dunc in his first spell.
You would imagine we will make one more bid for McCarthy but I wouldn't hold my breath on it being their valuation of him. What are the odds on Fellaini going and us failing in bids to sign anyone to replace him, with McCarthy going to Newcastle or Spurs (they do love to collect midfielders)?
I am bracing myself for a typical Everton transfer deadline day and a long two weeks to follow before the Chelsea game. At least by making a good signing or two, it would ease the early season frustration starting to be felt already.
9 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:44:18
Remember when ayoung Mikel Arteta strolled into Goodison and was just bending in free kicks all over the show and pirouhetting around Makele. is it really that hard to find a player of that sensational ilk rather than these poor imitations like Allen and McCarthy who just recycle the ball moronicly? Arteta was the last player at Everton with genuine end product.
10 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:40:19
If it's true that Man Utd have finally started bidding properly, we may just have some manoeuvrability in the market. If we are selling Fellaini, get it done early doors tomorrow and hopefully RM knows who he wants so we will have enough time to deal them in.
11 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:18
12 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:49:11
13 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:49:47
With Luca Brasi in attendance...
14 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:47:53
15 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:54
However, the price is a joke. £10m is way too much. There must be better value elsewhere.
16 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:48:34
I'm surprised, no gobsmacked, that he never mentioned about his broken leg!
17 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:50:32
21 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:53:07
I hear that a lot with McCarthy. He's a 'tidy player'.
Tidy players shouldn't cost more than 5 million quid.
Tidy essentially means average
Leon Osman is a 'tidy little player'.
I heard someone, somewhere online state that McCarthy is "The next Roy Keane", so that is precisely what I will tell everyone I meet when they ask why we paid £15million for him...trouble is I won't believe a word of what I'm saying.
23 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:56:46
26 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:49:28
Why do we always get the shitty end of the stick? If we had a line of credit, we could've bought McCarthy cheap before selling - in the way Spurs have already spent £110m of the £85 they were getting for Bale (yes I know the sums don't add up, but that's what Spurs have spent). Instead, because we have to sell to buy, the club selling to us screws us over.
27 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:57:12
28 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:54:41
29 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:02:00
30 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:02:29
40 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:10:29
41 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:15:13
43 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:14:36
Again it looks like he can not see any further than his old club who, as far as players go, did not have anything better than what we have.
44 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:04:45
45 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:18:16
46 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:23:43
What the fuck are we offering TEN MILLION POUNDS for a Wigan player for?!?!
47 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:19:46
Looking at Sky Sport thinking it's all a bad dream, why us!!!!!
48 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:24:25
49 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:30:00
At the risk of criticism, I would prefer a Barry figure until January If it is a choice between that and a 20m bid for a McCarthy. A club like us HAS to consider sell on values if the business model is even to allow us to stand still.
50 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:29:49
If we had better negotiators in the club it could be making a £15m difference.
51 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:34:45
We don't want to sell Fellaini for anything short of about £25m up to £40m if you read peoples comments on here, so why should Wigan be any different?
52 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:59
53 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:34:13
I bet we could pick up Banega for £8M.
Fernandes?
Leroy bloody Fer - £4M!!!!
What are we doing?
54 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:03
I would sooner spend the £25m we will get for Felli on Barry on loan and a striker.
55 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:40:12
We've been linked all summer = it will happen.
We already bought a striker = we won't buy another striker.
56 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:39:04
102
Arteta a player with end product.
Can you name one defence splitting ball he played in his Everton career?
Because I am struggling to recall one
57 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:38:06
Spurs paid £11M for Erikson.
CL experience
Star player for his national team
We're forking out £15M for a Championship midfielder who took his side down there.
I have no problem with McCarthy. He's a good player. But can we have a little perspective here! £15M buys you top class players.
58 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:06
I just think half of all these 'bid rejected' stories are peddled by the clubs concerned for the benefit of the supporters.
What is it about that lying, scheming, bullshitting actor that makes me so cynical?
"Of course you can have Fellaini - £22m, but at least let's make it look like we put up a fight."
59 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:39:58
Some fans will be pleasantly surprised by him but we will still be lacking Fellaini's goals and physical presence if McCarthy comes in.
60 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:44:05
61 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:40:07
62 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:42:05
A striker is what's needed - we can hold the ball up all day.
63 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:36:49
For what it is worth, I would like to see Martinez walk away from this deal. McCarthy is not worth the money. Whelan may have saved us.
I do not know who we should bring to replace MoFro, but given it has been on the cards one hopes Martinez has done some research beyond the Wigan squad.
64 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:42:14
Look at these super signings he made for Wigan:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/w/wigan_athletic/8136609.stm
http://www.theguardian.com/football/2013/apr/12/jordi-gomez-wigan-millwall-fa-cup
Jason Scotland and Jordi Gomez, shrewd moves there Robbie. I am hoping Kone and the probable signing of McCarthy pan out better. Please.
65 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:48:27
We just have to suck it up same as Man Utd for for Fellaini - its a house of cards....
66 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:41:15
69 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:52:26
70 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:53:03
71 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:44:29
72 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:53:05
worth a read. Not too positive a view though.....
73 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:41:18
There are so many quality players out there worth half of what this numpty will cost. Kevin Reeves (chief scout) needs to get off his arse and find some bargains!!! I know this guy from the past, cocky so and so!!! Bigtime Charlie. Chief scout my arse!!!!
Let's just hope we have a nice deadline day surprise.
74 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:49:18
An opening offer of £10m is not too bright.
I know we need to keep the faith and it's only early days and all that but stop talking to peg-leg now.
Not impressed. Happy to be proved wrong.
75 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:55:53
Look elsewhere, Roberto – don't give Whelan the satisfaction of calling the shots. I like McCarthy but there are plenty of good if not better players out there for less than £15m.
76 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:54:57
If he was knocking in 30 goals a season, you could maybe begin to justify the amount. This would be madness to pay anything like the money being mentioned, especially for an ordinary midfielder.
77 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:43:46
On our budgets, we need to be clever in the market - bargains from the championship, underrated fringe players at big clubs, well-scouted foreigners, etc.
This is the exact opposite of that. This is us about to get bummed by paying massively over the odds for a player who, despite being decent, is no world beater.
If we have money to spend we absolutely must get value for it. But I fear this isn't going to happen - blowing £6m on Kone doesn't fill with confidence.
78 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:51:42
I am starting to worry about RM's transfer targets, I really thought he would be more creative than this, it sounds like we will pay more for an average Championship player than Arsenal will pay for Cabaye and I know who I would rather have...
79 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:03:08
Now everyone else can get on with things......that's how it's gonna work, right?
80 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:49:46
81 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:06:14
I'd take McCarthy over any of those.
83 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:04:33
At least Levy is showing some business acumen, ambition and vision.
84 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:09:56
85 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:11:58
86 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:08:34
87 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:08:10
let Peg Leg Whelan stew in his own juices and leave McCarthy where he is get Barry in on loan for the season and next year he will be begging to sell him for 8 million.
Martinez should move on and pursue other targets but he wont.
88 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:07:34
89 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:13:09
90 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:13:06
91 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:15:55
They say that if you stand still in football - you risk going backwards.
I say that if you go backwards - you go even further backwards.
Keep Fellaini & Baines till Jan and lets make a proper job of it in that window. Don't trade in our best players and throw the money at inferior ones.
92 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:18:19
93 Posted 01/09/2013 at 21:58:00
Buying players, we will be shafted.
Selling players, we will be shafted.
This is a completely natural and normal state of affairs....if your club (as ours is) is run by a truly hopeless fucking clown.
Idiots make idiotic decisions (nb: that's kind of the biggest part of what makes them idiots) and any Evertonian with half a brain understands we're run by the king of the idiots.
We definitely have the right to be angry and/or frustrated but I can't see any reason for anyone to be surprised.
94 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:22:34
95 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:16:42
Our perennial link with Ever Banega wouldn't go a miss.
96 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:21:56
Nothing.... We are at risk of losing our 2 most important players and buying Wigan player #4... RM needs to change his mindset! I just can't believe this is the best we can do.... RM is meant to be some creative force, but his signings have been as uncreative as Moyes big signings being from Everton. Lets see how this unfolds... I hope my fears are unfounded!
97 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:06:39
McCarthy, what the fuck has he done to deserve a dream move to the greatest football club In the world????
What a load of bollocks!
98 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:27:34
Gives us the much needed energy and legs in CM that we lack when playing Gibson/Osman.
Hopefully we will keep Baines and bring in another striker.
99 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:03:26
Good player. I like him. But I agree with the general TW sentiment that there is simply too much quality out there in other leagues to spend this kind of money for him if Fellaini is indeed gone.
100 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:42
If they had any sense at all, they would be lining up, and making public, an alternative target... but of course they won't; they don't have one and even if it wasn't a con, they wouldn't be smart enough to negotiate properly.
101 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:10:39
Have I been watching a different team for the last 4 games, I see a team with or without Felli who retain the ball well and have enjoyed a high percentage of possession in all their games, however, in all games there has been one glareing, obvious to anyone, smack you in the face issue - WE CANNOT SCORE A FU@&ING GOAL
FFS we could buy a quality striker with this kind of money and the limit of our ambition is James bloody McCarthy
102 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:35:15
http://www.itv.com/sport/football/update/2013-09-01/everton-return-with-second-mccarthy-bid/
103 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:31:12
What a joke.
104 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:50
I think £10m is a fair enough price for him, maybe with add ons, if not I'd go abroad (Spain, Portugal, S America etc) and get a similar player only cheaper. In this respect I'm a bit disappointed that Martinez hasn't gone down this road.
105 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:24:15
"Whelan wants 55% of the Fellaini money does he? Well I'll sell Fellaini for £20m then we can get McCarthy for £11m. That'll show old peg leg, £15m indeed...."
107 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:34:37
108 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:29:42
If they had any sense at all they would be lining up, and making public, an alternative target but of course they won't, they don't have one and even if it wasn't a con, they wouldn't be smart enough to negotiate properly.
109 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:45:29
How the hell can we contemplate paying circa £15m for him?
It just does not stack up by any criteria or comparison – many of which are listed very clearly above.
If Martinez buys him and we flop, he will find Evertonians turning against him (and Kenwright) in their thousands).
Please god NO!
No, no, no, no, no, no, no.
110 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:46:05
111 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:07:54
(No disrespect to all the knowledgeable participants to this forum, who know more...)
112 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:50:01
113 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:44:30
25 in 141 for Felli.
This will further diminish our already lacklustre goalscoring threat.
114 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:50:24
115 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:28:52
Wasted opportunities yet again Blues!!!
116 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:35:29
117 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:48:59
We're cherry picking from an FA Cup winning side is another way of looking at it, isn't it?
Robles is a back up keeper, come through the ranks with De Gea at Atletico and Spanish national sides.
Alcaraz was a free, just squad padding.
Kone, yes I'll agree this is worth scrutiny definitely.
McCarthy looks a solid British buy, crazy price though, but that's football today.
118 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:52:04
Hahaha — you ginger twat!
119 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:57:00
Bill, give your mate Daniel a call and get Defoe in. I, like everyone, is extremely worried about the fact that we couldn't score in a brothel at this moment in time.
120 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:55:37
121 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:57:30
122 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:57:14
123 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:53:15
Not sure, but he has a wooden leg with a castor on it, and can eat a pie at the same time, so he should be quite an asset!
124 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:58:57
125 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:53:48
126 Posted 01/09/2013 at 22:44:30
The battle for money is a global battle for fans, sponsors and investors. Over the past three years or so, Fellaini has been the face of every major corporate manoeuvre we've made.
This is because he's the most recognisable, most marketable, and most valuable asset in our team. It's no different to why the top clubs always wanted Beckham (albeit on a smaller scale).
My point is Fellaini carries brand value for the club, not just playing value. McCarthy isn't a name that's going to get fans, sponsors and investors excited.
Who is our next most bankable asset? Oh yeah, that'll be Baines. Hmm.
NB. When I say 'investors' I don't mean the billionaire investors who are going to swoop in and buy our club - the majority if investment in football is not of this nature.
127 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:08:47
128 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:05:00
129 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:00:49
Perhaps Martiez shouldn't become obsessed with one player and should broaden his horizons. I know for a fact that there are a number of quality players across Europe that would be available for much less. I would rather take a gamble on a few raw talents out there than blow the lions share of the Felli money on one guy. Look at Eriksen at Spurs. Yes they have more of a draw at the moment, but it does show that European teams will sell for less than British ones. Swansea have brought in several quality players from the continent for a fraction of what McCarthy would cost. Time to make use of your scouting knowledge Roberto!
131 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:19:54
They are also saying Mesut Ozil is on the verge of joining Arsenal after agreeing a fee with Real Madrid.
132 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:28:24
Better still, a nice new shiny HD screen to clap Kenwright, next time his grid pops up.....
133 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:35
134 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:13:59
135 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:36:13
Christ, it would be so sweet piss that twat Moyes off. His bug eyes would be popping out of his head!
136 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:59
137 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:39:23
138 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:37:00
Oh yeah and if we bank £40 mill doesn't that mean we are no longer in debt and a more saleable asset Bill !!!
139 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:31:09
Getting new players in (beyond those bought with an initial limited transfer pot) has been contingent on selling one or both of our major assets. Until someone actually came in with a worthwhile bid all RM could do was make initial enquiries. His relationship with Whelan and McCarthy has probably enabled him to set up this deal as a guaranteed contingency move if Fellaini was indeed sold during the transfer window.
We were never in the running for some of the players mentioned because there was no need for a replacement and so no cash available.
Just because Spurs could wrest Erikson away with a paltry £11.5 million doesn't mean we could have engineered the same move for the same fee as he may have been happy to wait until January for a better offer / someone who could match his personal terms. The same probably applies to tempting the likes of Defoe away from London - they may prefer just to sit tight and take their chances.
I would hope other players (in a variety of needed positions) are currently being targeted but, even if we have to pay over the odds, it may be necessary to proceed with the McCarthy transfer just to ensure we aren't left with a gaping hole where our midfield should be.
140 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:33:06
141 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:35
142 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:57:35
143 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:01:10
144 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:11:59
145 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:32:03
Of course, Roberto will go to the "right character" scenario to justify the price of the Wigan lad, who would be useful addition, but the £1.2mil Cedric fee brings things into perspective.
Mark Liecester. Good shout. Will Hughes of Derby is a certain future star.
146 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:56:43
Funny post mate, gave me a good laugh. The scouting team, being Eco-friendly do have a bike, fitted with stabilisers!
147 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:41:40
If not, there is no need to go for him with an inflated price... like others have said, there seems to be better value to be had in other places around Europe.
It's also the embarrassment of becoming Wigan v2.... is there nobody else available at a better price?
148 Posted 02/09/2013 at 02:23:56
149 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:45:45
150 Posted 02/09/2013 at 07:51:17
151 Posted 02/09/2013 at 07:52:05
152 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:17:45
Anyway, we can't really complain about Whelan getting the most for his player... That's exactly what we are doing with Fellaini - from the one person who wants to sign him..
McCarthy would be a better version of Gibson - a young Scott Parker In my opinion..and he may even be fit sometimes.. Then only problem I have with this is that it then makes the Gareth Barry deal somewhat puzzling..
If we get McCarthy then surely we need to be taking a creative midfielder into the club to sit alongside Barkley..
153 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:16:45
The only person who thinks McCarthy is worth £15m is Whelan, and even then, only when he is talking to Everton. Gustavo, a proven international with CL experience at a top club went for little more than that over the summer and others have posted equally good examples.
This is perhaps the most disappointing aspect of RM's tenure so far. I really hoped he was going to unearth a few gems from Europe, not buy up the players of a relegated club.
154 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:07:32
Day one on RM's arrival, he would have been told;
-last season we had one of the best defensive records in the Premiership
-dominated possession and chances
-turned too many wins into draws
-DESPERATELY NEED A PROLIFIC STRIKER!
Well I'm glad he seems to have sorted that out
155 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:42:50
I cant see this signing or even worse the arrival of Gareth Barry putting bums on seats. I have seen tankers turn quicker in the Mersey than Barry cant think of a more uninspiring player we could buy. I often thought Fellaini slowed things down with Barry in the team he would make Fellaini look quick.
156 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:10:26
157 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:57:56
158 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:54:59
159 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:04:31
160 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:13:46
How silly: McCarthy was not a Championship player last season so what exactly is the point of this utterly erroneous comparison?
Anything eh, anything to dirty McCarthy but this fantasy poke takes the biscuit.
McCarthy will be a great addition to our squad if he jumps ship and I can't wait to see Laing and the anti-McCarthyism lads and lasses eat their silly words.
161 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:41:04
162 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:02:48
163 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:48:50
In an hour and a half, Whelan's brinkmanship will go into reverse and the price will drop.
I'll be very disappointed if McCarthy comes in over £7.5m.
As others have stated, we need a striker.
If Vic to WBA falls through, that will be like a new signing...
(I'm on here because that Live Forum is doing my head in)
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 01/09/2013 at 20:34:01