Dramatic deadline day climax sees three in and two out

, 2 September, 875comments  |  Jump to most recent
Lukaku, Barry, McCarthy sign; Anichebe, Fellaini leave

James McCarthy: Arrives from Wigan for £13m

Everton's transfer window came down to the wire again with five deals coming together in a dizzying last hour that accomplished Roberto Martinez's stated goal of leaving the Blues stronger after the deadline than before.

Protracted deals involving Romelu Lukaku and Marouane Fellaini kept Evertonians guessing as the clock ticked into the final 60 minutes but a stunning twist to the former was followed by the successful conclusion of Manchester United's pursuit of Fellaini that paved the way for James McCarthy to sign from Wigan Athletic in a £13m deal.

In between, Gareth Barry also arrived on loan from Manchester City and late word came of West Bromwich Albion's capture of Victor Anichebe in a deal rising to £6m, leaving Martinez one player better off, reunited with McCarthy and still holding onto Leighton Baines (for whom a 15m offer was apparently rejected as Bill Kenwright stood firm on his refusal to sell the prized left back), and Everton basking in the glow of rare profit from the day's dealings.

The day began with a flurry of speculation that had a number of names linked with a switch to Goodison, among them Tom Ince, Feyenoord's Bruno Martins Indi and Chelsea's Ryan Bertrand but none of those rumours, together with a later story about an approach for Cagliari defender Davide Astori, came to fruition.

Meanwhile, the transfer that appeared most likely coming into the final day, that of Gareth Barry joining for the season, seemed to fall off the radar, particuarly when news exploded of an apparent £15m bid for Porto midfielder Fernando. Though the Daily Mail went as far as to say that the deal had been done, it transpired that neither the Portuguese club nor the Brazilian-born player were all that tempted by Everton's offer.

It wasn't until 7.15pm that the first hint appeared from Sky Sports' Mr Deadline Day, Jim White, that Everton had approached Chelsea about taking Lukaku on loan and by 8.30pm multiple media sources in Belgium were reporting that the striker was indeed bound for Goodison Park for the season.

That assertion was thrown into the air an hour later, though, when the BBC and Sky both began claiming that West Bromwich had also offered to take Lukaku on loan and that the Belgian had opted to return to the Hawthorns where he spent the whole of last season. By that stage, Anichebe was already in talks regarding his own move to WBA, Fellaini had formally submitted a transfer request and, with Wigan chairman Dave Whelan complaining on radio about Everton's unacceptable payment terms for McCarthy, it looked as though the Blues were in for a barren and frustrating end to the transfer window with two fewer players and no further additions.

That all changed with an hour and 40 minutes before the deadline when it emerged, again from sources in Belgium, that Everton had secured Lukaku on a season-long loan, for an estimated (but unconfirmed) fee of £3m.

Word quickly followed that Gareth Barry had arrived at Finch Farm to put the finishing touches in his own loan move from the Etihad Stadium — there is some conjecture how much the Blues eventually agreed to pick up of the England international's £120,000-a-week salary — and, 15 minutes later, that a fee had been agreed with the Latics for McCarthy.

Official confirmation of the incoming deals came shortly after the passage of the 11pm deadline, together with belated word that Fellaini had gone for £27.5m — a £10m profit on the midfielder that will see his former club Standard Liege collect £2m from a sell-on clause — and Anichebe had signed for West Brom, taking the Blues' estimated profit on the day to around £12.5m (when Barry's ~£5m salary is taken into account).

Addendum: How much of Barry's wages and how much Everton will pay for Lukaku remains uncertain, with estimates ranging from nothing to £6m for Barry and from £1.7m to £5m for Lukaku.

 

Reader Comments (875)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mike Hughes
2 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:47:10
I've decided that I'm going to enjoy it rather than dread it.

Bottle of red wine, panama cigar, pot noodle......ToffeeWeb and Radio 5 Live.

Live like a king, die like a man.

Christopher Kelly
3 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:50:01
Strikers please!!! Stop fucking around and get the right players in where the team needs help!
Drew Shortis
5 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:53:05
Diame, Defoe and a reasonably priced European midfielder would be a good start and would leave us change from the Fellaini money. Unless we can get McCarthy in for £10 I would look elsewhere. He can't be the only tidy passer in Europe, surely?
Michael Parrington
6 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:47:51
And someone who is capable of scoring goals?
Patrick Carty
7 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:45:26
We need probably four players to be honest. Two midfielders and two strikers. I think Barry and Ince would be good additions as I think Osman's days are numbered. I would sell Anichebe to West Brom. Kone and Jelavic look toothless up front so a striker is a must.
Frank Boyle
8 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:58:07
Mike Hughes, #292. That's the way to go!
Derek Knox
9 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:53:38
Hope the Ince link comes off, think he'd be a great addition,Martins Indi and Ryan Bertrand would be good too, but we could do with a striker.
Especially, as it looks like Vic could be moving too.
I just hope we get players that will benefit us, and not just numbers, and bench warmers.
Colin Glassar
10 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:00:40
You know how to live, Mike Hughes. What flavour pot noodle?
Lyndon Lloyd
11 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:01:03
I would be staggered if we don't sign a striker before the deadline (whether Vic goes or not) but I just don't see anything on the horizon in terms of rumour or speculation.

If Roberto has a plan to bring in a goalscorer, he is keeping his cards *very* close to his chest!

Mike Keating
12 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:57:55
Honda is still available and no one else is interested in McCarthy so why pay more than £10m?

And we rejected £3.5m for Anichebe - what do they think he is worth when nobody else is bothered?
Derek Knox
13 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:08:49
Lyndon, if push came to shove, and we manage to get Tom Ince, assuming we don't get the much needed striker, he could probably fill that role till January. I don't like the idea of getting players, and playing them out of position, but he is a speedy forward/winger, and can score!
All will be revealed anyway in the next 22 hours or so!
James Martin
14 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:20:27
Begs the question as always why do the clubs leave it right until the last day? Madness.

Big clubs have all summer tomake their moves and start the merry go round off but they try and nick players on the cheap so wait until the last day. You then get scumbag players not saying anything all summer then saying they want to leave on the llast day off the window. Teams like Everton then have to panic buy. Would be great for once to see us do business early and then shut up shop, start strong with a seettled squad and send out a statement of intent. Never happens though.

David Pearl
15 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:19:52
Obvious Fellaini doesn't fit into RM style of play so we need others that will. We can do a lot with the money if it's spent right but too much on yet another Wigan player. If we had not signed Kone we would have even more. I wonder if Johnny H will still be with us?

We are developing a young team with a few old guys thrown in - I don't mind us getting Barry, I think he will do a sound job and will let Del Boy, Barkley and Kevin do what they do best.

On a more important note; it must be Chow Mein flavour pot noodle... closely followed by chicken & mushroom (not that I can get in Toronto)

Jack Cross
16 Posted 01/09/2013 at 23:58:46
We should have asked for 25 million for Feli and Alex Buttner thrown in. He not in Moyes plans and a good left back.

Assombalonga from Peterborough certainly knows were the Goal is and only 20. Seen him play a few times good striker and could become great. Even his strike partner Tomlin, good in front of goal. Celtic tried to buy him earlier in season but got chased. Id have either of them in stead of the shite we have.

As for McCarthy, we'll end up paying the full amount and he'll be shite. I mean RMs Wigan players in, have been so successful so far haven't they? At least Moyes is going after star quality with Feli and Baines but all RM as got from Wigan as been dregs.

David Pearl
17 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:24:59
That could of been said James, by RM, that if any bid comes in for one of our players after a certain date it would be dismissed. Why not have our own transfer cut off... that would allow us to swerve all the bs that follows.
Jack Cross
19 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:32:36
Its obvious isn't it James, When you have clubs ,like us with no money, it makes sense to come in as late as possible. Especially when were connected to buying certain player's like McCarthy. I'm nearly as fed up with hearing his name as I am Bale. Or should I say that farce.

What's the difference between Moyes and RM? They've both gone back to their old clubs. Are either thinking of the opposition fans, not a toss.

One thing you give Moyes is he had an eye for good cheap player. So why hasn't RM scoured Europe pre-season with his connections. No in stead he goes to Wigan.

Kieran Kinsella
21 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:45:58
Fellaini and Baines out, Franny Jeffers, Peter Beagrie and Stephen Hughes in -- all on 10 -year "pay as you don't play deals"
Chris Jones [Burton]
22 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:31:23
Well, Joe Lovejoy in his report of our game at Cardiff in today's (i.e. Monday's) Guardian newspaper reports that Barry signed for us yesterday, so that appears to be a done, loan deal.

If only our negotiations with Manyoo were contingent on us getting a sensible deal out of Wigan for McCarthy... in which case with Wigan asking silly money (IMHO) we tell Manyoo, "Sorry, but we're not selling Felli if we have to spunk most of the proceeds on an inferior replacement. The deal is off!"

Then we can deploy Barry alongside Gibson (when fit) as DMs, putting Ossie on the bench, then have an attacking group of Barkley, Felli and Gerard behind Kone, who I think will be OK when fully fit and supported, with the presently misfiring Pienaar and Mirallas, plus Jelly/Victor on the bench with Ossie.

Ah well, dream on....

Robin Cannon
23 Posted 02/09/2013 at 00:59:25
McCarthy would be a good signing at a reasonable price. Our initial offer (7m up front plus up to 3m add-ones) is really the top end of what we should be paying, not an opening bid.

While obviously there are other factors like wages and competing interests, I really wish we'd make some actual offers for players like Honda, who are really a step up in quality.

And given our massive struggles up front, clearly a striker needs to be a major priority... And yet there aren't even rumors on that score. If United are so desperate for Fellaini, make it fifteen million plus Hernandez and reinvest the rest in a couple of other players. Really... anything that shows a bit of imagination beyond selling our best midfielder for a relatively small profit and then overpaying for a decent, but uninspiring, replacement.

Rob Smith
24 Posted 02/09/2013 at 01:07:26
Is Honda still available? does he want a move? Can't understand why he hasn't been chased more and surely a much better option than McCarthy. I wouldn't mind both, it just irks that we get screwed over transfers, he is a good young player but not a 15mill player.
Phil Gardner
26 Posted 02/09/2013 at 01:38:16
I'd love to join you Mike, but the way this club do business I'd end up eating the cigar, lashing the bottle at the radio and trying to smoke the noodley-fella......at 1am.....in tears!
Brian McGee
27 Posted 02/09/2013 at 01:30:46
I'm sorry but Martinez is showing us he hasn't a clue. His transfer dealings, apart from Deulofeu have been a complete shambles and with players like Barry and McCarthy now seemingly heading our way, the only way is down. As I stated in another thread, we need quality in both midfield and attack that will provide us with the missing cutting edge that we are crying out for.

I am glad to see some fans still recognise quality by calling for the likes of Honda to be signed, a player I have been advocating since the SA World Cup.

Contrary to what some may think, getting rid of Fellaini is completely the wrong move and so he will be clearly missed.

Kenwright and Martinez are intent on dragging the club down. The demise of the club is well and truly on.

Tony Rice
30 Posted 02/09/2013 at 01:52:42
Every transfer window is the same..... Love EFC to death ...but we have become a recurring joke. Tomorrow , we'll ( under )sell one or two of our best players , overpay for one or two inferior replacements.... and watch several wild rumors just not quite get done as time ticks down.
Harold Matthews
31 Posted 02/09/2013 at 01:30:17
Drew. Mix Diskerud of Rosenborg and the USA , 6' tall, passes like a dream and scores goals. "The Norwegian / Yankee Pirlo" would cost less than £ 2mil. Not sure but I think his " goals and assists" are on you tube. Sue Palmer, the Martinez PA, informed me that we were "aware of him", which probably means that BK, Whelan and Martinez are only interested in the remunerative McCarthy deal where they all make a few bob.
Graham Mockford
33 Posted 02/09/2013 at 02:39:36
I'm surprised at the negativity towards McCarthy. Young promising players tend to come at a premium because the chances are if they come good their value can increase dramatically.

Yes it is a punt for us as our funds are limited but I have always been impressed with him whenever I've seen him play. Mobile, energetic and tenacious. I think a combination of him Barkley and Barry in centre midfield could be quite a proposition.

If you offered me right now Fellaini for McCarthy +£10m I would bite your hand off assuming the £10m is spent on a striker.

Jamie Crowley
36 Posted 02/09/2013 at 03:04:02
Mike Hughes - you are, quite simply, the man.

Harold - before you lay thee down to sleep, pray the Lord Mix Diskerud to keep. And if you die before you wake, pray the Lord, Big Mix, to Goodison.

Amen.

Derek Knox
37 Posted 02/09/2013 at 03:00:51
Graham (#381)

I tend to agree that James McCarthy is a good player, but considering that Roberto, unearthed him from Hamilton (I think) for a fee around the £1M mark, and was no doubt instrumental in his development. I think the fee of circa £15m is bordering on the ridiculous, and largely fuelled by the greed of Dave Whelan. As many other posters have so succinctly said, the club could get two or three quality players for that.

At the end of the day, it is only Everton that have expressed a serious interest in him, so it's not that we are vying for his signature.

Unfortunately, due to circumstances beyond our control, it has got down to the last day and, rather than concentrate on this one deal, I would hope they will conclude some other deals before the deadline!

Matt Traynor
38 Posted 02/09/2013 at 03:10:28
Brian #371, I don't think there's too many who want us to "get rid" of Fellaini - certainly not at the price he's likely to go for. But he clearly wants to go, and would've jumped at the chance to join Man U at any time during his five years with us. As usual with Everton, it's sell-to-buy so someone has to go, and only he, Baines and Barkley have any real value.

If as the local press are reporting we are to lose Fellaini but keep Baines, I think many fans might think that that is probably the least-worst outcome.

Whilst we have carpet baggers for owners, every transfer window will be like this.

Derek Knox
39 Posted 02/09/2013 at 04:09:51
You know what I find strange, all the speculation over Fellaini, and possibly Baines, there has been no mention on Sky Sports at all.

McCarthy has been mentioned several times, and Barry too, but not a word about our two.

I know it's early hours of the morning now, but you would think a projected transfer, like that, especially with it being to Media darlings Man Utd would at least get a mention!

Harold Matthews
40 Posted 02/09/2013 at 04:29:03
Nice one, Jamie. We also both know that "Captain Fantastic" Michael Bradley is the ready-made, perfect replacement for Fellaini but he might be out of our price range.
Paul Ferry
41 Posted 02/09/2013 at 04:36:09
Are you like me counting down the minutes albeit with some trepidation until we see the mutants on Stoke Hill and, fingers crossed, one or two in by then.
Harold Matthews
42 Posted 02/09/2013 at 04:35:50
I'm not against McCarthy as a player. He's an excellent replacement for Gibson.

My conspiracy theory suggests that Whelan, Kenwright, Martinez and McCarthy are all playing to a script which was written before our new boss vacated his old office.

As for the Kenwright, Moyes, Fellaini script. Well, I guess it's right on schedule.

Brian Wilkinson
43 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:00:27
Stand firm, Everton, we know Fellaini will no doubt be a Man Utd player within 24 hours; ball is firmly in our court. Rather than the £25 million plus for Fellaini try and get Little Pea Chiquerito as part of the deal plus cash. I would bite Man Utd's hand off for Little Pea plus cash for Fellaini.

Christopher Kelly
44 Posted 02/09/2013 at 04:59:31
I'm sorry but when an England international becomes available, you should be grateful for what they can bring in terms of experience. He also just won the league 2 years ago as well. With Glass Gibson always one more week away, he's going to come in very handy.

However, goals are our obvious weakness (not a good weakness to have I must say) so hopefully we can address that in a surprise package.

Kristian Boyce
45 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:16:41
How much more bloody money are we going to give Wigan? Saw us coming for the Kone deal, and now £15m for McCarthy. Does anyone know if Martinez has shares in the Pie Eaters as he sure is making their bank balance healthy.
Bobby Mallon
46 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:38:09
Well this is it: last day to sell and buy. I love this day, very exciting. Can't wait. Hope we sign another striker and two midfielders. COYB
Tahir Abdullah
47 Posted 02/09/2013 at 05:40:13
The Telegraph reporting that a 2nd bid of around £12M for McCarthy has been rejected and that EFC are submitting a 3rd bid in the region of £15M. Me thinks Roberto must walk away from this one; I cannot see how McCarthy can be worth more than Christian Eriksen who Tottenham just signed? Market value for McCarthy as per Transfermarkt is around £7M.
Eric Myles
48 Posted 02/09/2013 at 06:17:22
James #331 "Begs the question as always why do the clubs leave it right until the last day? Madness"

Agreed, they should make the transfer window last 1 day only, it'd be much more exciting and less stressful without all the rumours for a month.

Paul Andrews
49 Posted 02/09/2013 at 06:53:54
Does anyone know what the current bid is for Fellaini? Differing reports,one saying it is £20 million plus add-ons to a total of £24 million.

Never liked transfer fees with add ons: win the CL = £2 million; win the league twice in your contract = £1 million; win the FA Cup = £1 million etc etc

Looking at the start Mr Moyes's Man Utd have made, I wouldn't be including any performance-related clauses into the fee...

Phil Sammon
50 Posted 02/09/2013 at 07:13:51
Lets just call it £24M, Paul ;)

But seriously...I'd give my hind legs to see us hang onto the lad until January - when we can pick up McCarthy for a fraction of the price. Make our interest known, get the kid unsettled - lets start being pricks like everyone else.

Who am I kidding? Tonight is gonna be a horror show.

Alex Parr
51 Posted 02/09/2013 at 07:59:57
Derek (#387) - I would hardly call Whelan looking for as much money as possible as 'greed'. Isnt that what we all want Kenwright to do? I want that clown to push for £30-40m for Fellaini. Its called driving a hard bargain. And you know what - we look likely to pay the silly money Whelan is asking - if I were a Wigan fan I'd be thinking very highly of him, far more so than as an Everton fan who knows that Kenwright is likely lubing himself up right now to take it deep and dry off Moyes and his Manc Mates.

Gareth Barry - a decent, solid signing, a recent international in a position we need to strengthen. On a loan, with Citeh paying the bulk of his wages. Sounds a sensible deal to me.

McCarthy - not massively keen, give the price. But if he comes I will trsu Martinez' judgment.

Honda - think most on here just throw that name in because a few have a good knowledge of him, rather than for what they know themselves. Unsure but would not be disappointed to see him.

Bertrand - no at £7m, half that and he might be worth a punt if Baines goes (which I don't think he will).

Would like to see a loan move for Lukaku as I think he has quality. A spearhead and ten times the player of Kone.

Anichebe - £3.5m is a lowish figure for him given he can be good on his day. Hes like Fellaini to me, does it when he can be arsed but looks slow clumsy and lumbersome when he cant. But sulks like a child aswell. £5m and I'd get rid.

Gutted the shite are after Sakho - like him. Well, I did...

Morrone - don't know enough about him.

More to follow!!!

Alex Parr
52 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:11:54
Oh - Tom Ince. No thanks. Massively overated and overpriced.

If Odemwingie is going cheap, I'd be tempted. But I'm not sure about him being a twat - but I do think what happened in January was a bit odd and I reckon old Wobble-Head Voldemorr-Redknapp the twat had more than a hand in that...

Barton - yes. But only on a free, cant afford to spend our limited budget on him given the reports suggest he was going for free last month.

On a wider note :

Ozil - quality.

De Maria - shite.

Kreamy Benzema - overrated.

Alex Parr
53 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:17:56
PS - I work with four Man U fans. One today who I was talking to, said he was amazed that Moyes now looks likely to pay more then the £23m supposed release fee for Fellaini. He couldnt understand why Moyes has left it so late and not just paid a sensible fee at a sensible time rather than try and save a few quid and end up looking stupid by paying more than the release clause. That from a Utd season ticket holder.
#dither
Steve Carter
55 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:46:16
We rejected £3.5m for Anichebe? We did whaaaaat?
Phil Sammon
57 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:54:48
@GuillemBalague: 2 European clubs wanted 2 enquire for Baines and Fellaini but were told not 2 try because they are set to to go Manchester United

------------

Yeah, why would we want to encourage competition and drive up the price.

BK you stupid arse.

Ciarán McGlone
58 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:01:40
De Maria - shite.

----------------

Words fail me.

Martin Hughes
59 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:14:49
I would be surpised if Jelly moves on, why else would the blues reject WBA's anichebe bid?????
James Marshall
60 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:16:08
Di Maria, shite? Real Madrid seemed to think he was pretty good when they paid £30m for him, Ciaran.

I'd also wager there's plenty of top clubs all over Europe that would take him today as well.

Words fail ME.

Tony Draper
61 Posted 02/09/2013 at 08:56:43
Keep Baines
Keep Fellaini
"Drear Davey, sod off, yours sincerely, etc"

Sell Kenwright
Bring in Dave "Wheel-on-me wooden leg wot I tragically broke at Wembley"

Bring in a striker and a deep mid

Business finished by 10am, thank you.

Ste McCoombe
62 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:16:39
Utd are apparently going to trigger ander Herrera's £31 mil release clause. How is he worth more than Felliani. I will be so pissed off if McCarthy is the alleged replacement. There is no way he is worth anything over £5 mil. Funny how Utd and Liverpool can play hard ball over Suarez and Rooney but teary bollocks Bill will cave in at anything for undervalued felliani.
James Marshall
63 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:23:47
Fellaini isn't that good, that's why. Have you noticed the queue of managers trying to buy him, the mass scramble for his signature? No, me neither.

He's an average player who was holding together an average midfield. If he was 4 inches shorter he'd be even worse.

I'm glad to see him leave.

Paul Andrews
64 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:23:31
Phil,

Lets just call it what it is.

Martin Hughes
65 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:28:10
Fellaini going, not really bother, Got young Ross on the books, I think we would be really lost without Baines
James Marshall
66 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:28:41
Oh and Ste, the technical reason Herrera is worth more than Fellaini, is his release clause is €36m.

Do your research son! ;-)

Dave Lynch
67 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:28:51
James.

I think Ciaran was trying to express his disbelief that Alex intimated he was shite.

Paul Andrews
68 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:33:10
Just seen a quote from Trappatoni.

"I want to hit McCarthy at times,he is so frustrating.He has unbelievable ability but won't let himself go"
Now that could be a manager giving a player a confidence boost.
But on the other hand ..............

James Marshall
69 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:41:41
After what Dave said, I want to hit myself at times.
Shaun Kinnair
70 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:37:35
I was talking my mate who's a Wigan season ticket holder at Wigan and he says "James McCarthy isn't worth half of £12 million he's quick but his passing lets him down and he goes missing in a lot of games". He's in a poor wigan side who went down last year, he may have looked good but look at the players he was playing with.

We don't need Wigan players we need players who are proven to be good.

I dread today as by the end of it, our team will be a lot weaker after it.

WE ALL KNOW WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN, AS IT'S ALL READY BE SORTED!!... were do you think were getting the money from to put a bid in for James McCarthy???

James Marshall
71 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:45:28
Shaun - we're selling Marouane Fellaini to Manchester United?

Just a guess, but y'know.....could be some truth in it.

You've written than like it's news to everyone!

Paul Andrews
72 Posted 02/09/2013 at 09:52:48
My own take on McCarthy is that he has stood still a little.
A year to 18 months ago I thought he would develop into a top class midfield player.
Now? I am not so sure
Shaun Kinnair
73 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:01:16
James - 461. Only just woke up, Marouane Fellaini off is he? No surprise there then... what stinks is a bid of over £6 million for a sub-standard midfielder in James McCarthy.
James Marshall
74 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:08:46
Don't forget Gareth Barry as well, Shaun....(who I actually think is a decent signing)
Ciarán McGlone
75 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:09:27
McCarthy is not sub-standard. I'd say 10 million is about right.. However I think we're well past that now..

You should see what the United supporters are saying about a 24 mill bid for Fellaini..exactly the same as the contortions on here about McCarthy!

James Marshall
76 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:18:01
I agree with Ciaran. McCarthy is a talented kid, who likely got a bit stale at Wigan - Trapatoni knows his onions so that quote from him holds weight.

He'll fit our style of play WAY more than Fellaini - I also agree that there aren't many Utd fans happy with signing the big haired Belgian either. Seems like a good swap for us if you ask me.

Am I the only person who's happy about this deal?

James Marshall
77 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:20:23
In other news:

Everton midfielder Francisco Junior has joined Dutch side Vitesse Arnhem on a season-long loan deal.

James Marshall
78 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:26:32
Conor McAleny is coming back as well. Brentford loan cancelled.
Darren Reeves
79 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:25:33
John Guidetti ??? Apparently a possibility of him leaving City. He got 20 goals in 23 appearances on loan at Feyenoord on loan last year.
Shaun Kinnair
80 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:27:23
Glad we got Francisco Junior of our books, he was terrible against Leeds in the cup.
Rob Pursglove
81 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:42:19
£6 million for Anichebe, surely we have to take that.
Milos Milenkovic
82 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:42:15
Oh Shaun, that was his first and only game. It's hard to write off someone after just one game. With that pattern, we would struggle to name 11 players.
Ciarán McGlone
83 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:47:00
I think 6million for Victor is good value for whoever gets him..he'll score plenty if played correctly..
Ash Coakley
84 Posted 02/09/2013 at 10:30:04
I for one love this deadline day, first time I expect more in than out. That said, here’s my Football Manager style shout on what I’d like to happen:

● Barry on loan (as seems a done deal);

● Jelavic off to whoever;

● Heitinga too (trim the wage bill);

● Ince in with Anichebe and Gueye as part of the deal;

● Fellaini for Ba, Moses and £15m;

● Sign 3 potentially decent players around the £5m mark each to swell the squad again - CB, CM and ST (Dier, Vossen, Marrone, Piatti or whoever fits RMs style of play)

I will be truely heartbroken if RM’s idea of strengthening involves replacing Fellaini with McCarthy and Barry with no other business... Furthermore, I REALLY don’t want to sell to Man Utd and if we are serious about the whole ’we don’t need to sell’ statement, we should tell the Mancs to piss off every single time they come knocking. They are our rivals and we should have some pride.

Phil Sammon
86 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:13:53
James Marshall

McAleny returned to us because he's broken his leg.

And Shaun - what an annoying comment.

We haven't got Junior 'off our books'. The kid has been loaned out to get experience and prove himself. Lets not write him off after one poor display.

Andreas Salomaa
87 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:09:57
Buy in james milner and chicorito from the reds and honda not mc plz need a striker and cm
Peter Thistle
88 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:21:35
If it was weeks ago I would have said sell him for 5-6 mill but now we have no chance of bringing in a replacement it would leave us too light, especially as he's probably better than both Jelavic and Kone.

Victor could be useful for them if used in a 2 up front system. He can't hack it on his own, just like any of the strikers that have been dying in Everton's 1 up front tactic for the last few years.

Brent Stephens
89 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:26:59
Phil "McAleny returned to us because he's broken his leg".

And to replace Jelli.

Shaun Kinnair
90 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:27:32
Phil Sammon - 490 - If Francisco Junior was any good, then Everton would have played him a little more than they have and they certainly wouldn't of sold him for next to nothing. Barkley is younger and he's made it. I hope he does well for his new club but in the time he's been at Everton he's done nothing special.
Ciarán McGlone
91 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:29:37
WBA looking Sessegnon....Him and McCarthy would have been very good complimentary additions to Barkley in our central midfield..
James Marshall
92 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:29:01
We may as well keep Victor and have three strikers that can't score goals, rather than just two strikers who can't score goals.

I forgot about the McAleny injury - like Brent says, still better than having Jelavic in your side.

Colin Williams
93 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:24:26
Shaun # 478 what are you talking about! He played 45mins! Ossie been shite for ten years. Also, there have been many more who have been very poor and have been given years of playing time!!! The guy is learning the game, what's their excuse?
Nicholas Page
94 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:32:04
sessegnon was caught pissed-up, driving his car around st. toons park......yes he's just what we need.
Fucking hell, we need to be aiming higher than this.
IF any sales go through ALL the money needs to be reinvested in the squad in quality players that will improve the playing side. Then add another £5-10m on top.
IF the money is not re-invested WE ALL should be asking our dear Chairman and Board where the fuck it is, and where the fuck it goes. I'm sick to death of the excuses and being treated like an idiot by a bunch of fucking clowns who are only in this to enrich themselves.
James Marshall
95 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:39:11
Take it easy, Nicholas.....it's not even midday yet.....the club has time to do some business....
Ciarán McGlone
96 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:39:45
As long as her doesn't drive his car around the pitch during the match I don't really give a flying feck...After all him and Pienaar could take turns..

Hes a cracking player.

Shaun Kinnair
97 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:42:26
Colin Williams - 503 - He's gone, end of story.
Matty Dawkins
98 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:44:20
I hope to Jesus he's got a striker lined up.
Nicholas Page
103 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:53:50
James, I will be pleasantly surprised if the club do ANY decent business today. However, by 10.30pm tonight I fully expect to be playing Blue Bill Bingo with the excuse-o-meter in overdrive.
Phil Sammon
104 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:59:02
Shaun

We've not sold him for 'next to nothing'. He's gone on loan. Stop talking crap.

James Marshall
105 Posted 02/09/2013 at 11:59:06
I do love a bit of deadline day paper-talk so I'm going to add some here...

Wigan and Everton have now agreed a £12.5m fee for McCarthy - now haggling over how the payments are made. Wigan was most of it up-front, Everton want to pay in installments of magic beans.

We're also asking for Zaha on loan as part of the Fellaini deal, which has been agreed at £24m.

Jim Knightley
106 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:09:07
Sessegnon has a genuine goal threat, which we need imo. But, he is too old for my liking. If Fellaini goes today, I think we need to invest in youth. We are not near Champions League football at the moment, so it makes sense to look to the future. I like the look of Ince, and would love Indi.

I wouldn't be adverse to an older loan signing though. Ashley Young is interesting... and I'd be happy for Barry to come, if City bankroll it aka Adebayor.

Ciarán McGlone
107 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:15:11
I wouldn't be too unhappy at

Barry..........McCarthy

............Barkley

As a central midfield...however i'd expect the rest of the money to go on a striker - rather than Ince..We have Mirallas, Oviedo, Delo and Pienaar all vying for the 2 wide positions...

Ste McCoombe
108 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:16:29
James, Herrerra's release clause is based on what his club see as his value. What I'm saying is that he is over valued and Felliani under valued but Utd still allegedly prepared to pay more for him that Felliani. Ps. I'm not your son. You should also know that mcaleny is coming back as he's broken his leg.

Conn Prosser
109 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:14:57
Barry is a good stopgap for sure.

That's interesting if true jm @ 518. Zaha could be another good er, stopgap.
I'll be gutted if we pay 12.5m for mccarthy though.

Regardless of cost, McCarthy era everton could be fruitful. He doesn't have to be better than felli for it to still be worth it, as long as the board take a step forward from felli's sale. Let's not forget Felli wasn't ideal looking for a while after he signed.

James Marshall
110 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:25:41
Agreed, Ste. Clubs valuations don't necessarily reflect what a player is really worth.
Jim Knightley
111 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:26:45
I think we need a striker, but I don't see us getting one with Jelavic, Kone, not to mention Anichebe vying for one position. I think Kone will be the number one long term...It's sad to say, but I don't think Jelavic has enough about him.
Conn Prosser
112 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:29:04
True jim.
Kone unimpressive it goes without saying, but we may judge better after a few more games.
Shaun Kinnair
113 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:32:27
Today of all days, I'd love for Bill Kenwright to be sold!!
Phil Walling
114 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:34:16
Anichebe for a pay rise after turning down WBA ? Bet he starts next game as our No.1 striker!
Tim Locke
115 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:42:57
Shaun - great idea, the only problem is his release clause.

If we sold Anichebe that would be a great window. Think the lad is ok when he plays but he spends most of his time in sick bay.


McCarthy looks like a poor verion of Rodwell, a player who we sold for £12?

James Marshall
116 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:47:26
We got more than £12 for Rodwell didn't we? That would really be a bad deal, even by Kenwright's standards.
Ste McCoombe
117 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:43:11
So depressing watching others club splash the cash whist we chase mediocrity. How come we are always so skint despite consistently finishing in the top 7. I really think there should be a real campaign to get blubbering bill out. That lot across the park wouldn't stand for this.
Derek Knox
118 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:46:09
Just watching the 'ceremony' of Gareth Bale's signing at Real. Does anyone think we will be having a similar, although 'scaled down' version at Goodison, for our new signings?

Tim Locke
119 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:51:19
James was £12 could rise to more but think he might need to play for that to happen. http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/19232773
Shaun Kinnair
120 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:46:29
I think some of the valuations on some players are crazy. If McCarthy is worth 14 million then Victor is worth 8. I've heard from some sources on the internet that were going to gazump Wigan in the race for Jordan Rhodes. I'd rather him to James McCarthy and then let Victor go.

Jordan Rhodes record.
2009–2012 Huddersfield Town 124 appearances - 73 goals
2012– Blackburn Rovers 48 appearances - 31 goals

Tim Locke
121 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:53:35
So deal is on:
BBC Sport chief football writer Phil McNulty
FELLAINI TO MAN UTD?
"I'm told talks between Everton and Manchester United are progressing and this deal should now be concluded successfully before the deadline, as most of us have expected.

"It is understood Fellaini has been given permission to delay linking up with the Belgium squad for their World Cup qualifiers against Scotland and Croatia to enable him to complete the transfer - once it's all been agreed of course."

Shaun Kinnair
122 Posted 02/09/2013 at 12:54:17
Cardiff City have been given permission to speak to West Bromwich striker Peter Odemwingie, does this mean the money from this could be added to the bid that was rejected to get Victor to WBA.
James Marshall
123 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:00:27
Tim - I was taking the piss, re £12, as opposed to £12M.....
Tim Locke
124 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:02:07
James fair enough.

Tot did the right thing in buying before selling, I would like to see us do something if we are going to lose players. If we are not going to sell then we should come out and say. Come on Bill get that cheque book out

Matt Traynor
125 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:07:50
BBC Radio 5 Live senior football reporter Ian Dennis on Twitter: "One to watch. Interesting call from Portugal. Everton want midfielder Fernando from Porto."
Stuart O'Malley
126 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:08:27
Who is this Fernando guy? And apparently Bruno Indi waiting to fly in once Felli deal done... going to be an interesting few hours!
Tim Locke
127 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:05:25
EVERTON KEEN ON FERNANDO?
BBC Radio 5 Live senior football reporter Ian Dennis on Twitter: "One to watch. Interesting call from Portugal. Everton want midfielder Fernando from Porto."
James Marshall
128 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:11:20
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fernando_Francisco_Reges
Tim Locke
129 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:16:39
FC Porto are not willing to sell Brazilian midfielder Fernando unless his buyout fee is paid, according to reports in Portuguese press.

A Bola reports that FC Porto want to keep Fernando as they still have not found a replacement of similar level.

The Portuguese club are thus willing to sell Fernando only if a club pay his 30 million Euros buyout fee, although his market value is estimated in 10 to 12 million.

Fernando has, however, expressed many times his intention of leaving FC Porto, as he hopes to move to more competitive leagues in order to increase his chances of getting called up for the Brazilian national team.

FC Porto could risk losing Fernando for free as his contract expires next year, but the player is not expected to force a move, despite his intention of leaving the club.

Brent Stephens
130 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:13:12
Some geezer on Sky saying Bill is the most passionate and most astute chairman. So I stand corrected. Sorry, Bill
Tim Locke
131 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:19:10
Brent was he quoting Moyes?
James Marshall
132 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:19:00
Another red herring then.....Fernand-NO!

Brent Stephens
133 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:18:40
So Fernando has only one year left on contract yet his club want Euro 30M?!
Brent Stephens
134 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:20:34
Tim, quoting Bill prob.
James Marshall
135 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:22:09
I'm off out for some lunch, I will expect all signings to be fully completed by the time I get back.
Tim Locke
136 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:23:43
James you going for 12 hour lunch?

Brent that makes even more sense

Conn Prosser
137 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:19:27
Seriously, Brent?

The Kenwright Out campaign has to focus on the media. If enough lovies tell him he's an absurd ponce running one of England's greatest clubs into dust, he might listen.

Steve King
138 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:23:37
From the Daily Mail:

"Everton have agreed the £15million signing of Fernando of Porto thus paving the way for Marouane Fellaini to join Manchester United"

Brent Stephens
139 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:25:19
Live Forum says it was Purslow, ex Liverpool MD and MU fan who said Bill was astute and passionate. Passionate I might just buy. Astute? Arsetute.
Robert Workman
140 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:07:08
Didn't realise Oviedo had gone. Just seen him playing bass gutar for "Queens of the Stone Age" on Youtube!

Yes, really............

OK, maybe it was "that" hairstyle that confused me!

Kevin Rowlands
141 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:27:46
Our striker situation is a big concern for me, Kone doesn't seem up to speed yet although I do think he'll come good, Jelavic has been yard dog shite for well over a year now, its no longer a slump, hes not good enough, and if we let Anichebe go were left with just these two, that's a worry.
Ste McCoombe
142 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:33:46
It beggars belief that transfer deadline day is in the same week as international teams are meeting up. Good planning by the powers that be. Mind you it seems like we are only interesting in selling international players.
Steve King
143 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:44:23
This Fernando thing seems pretty certain! Seen it in a few different places now. £15million.

Nickname: Polvo which means "Octopus".......hmmmmmmmmm!

Nicholas Page
144 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:39:58
"Liverpool have signed central defenders Mamadou Sakho and Tiago Ilori for a combined fee of about £25m, as well as signing Chelsea' Victor Moses on loan."

Questions:
1. where the fuck do they get the money from (3rd biggest spenders in prem history)?
2. why the fuck do players bother going there? same as spurs (who push the shite close on my utter hatred levels)...they buy all sorts year in year out, the players disappear/end up on loan/sold to shithouse clubs like stoke.

where did lewis holtby disappear to? they've bought another 8 midfielders this season. greedy levy

Nicholas Page
145 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:47:17
European football writer Andy Brassell: "Further to Ian Dennis's tweet (1305) on Everton looking at Porto's defensive midfielder Fernando, the Brazilian would be quite a signing. It's a mystery to many that the selecao have never capped the 25-year-old - and as to why Arsenal reputedly rejected the chance to take him for £10m earlier this summer, with his contract up next year.

"Whether Porto would let him go for that money at this late stage is another question - the club have previously indicated they would only do business for the €30m release clause in his contract.

"One who is on the way out at the Dragao is Juan Manuel Iturbe, with the diminutive playmaker set for a loan move to Serie A side Verona. Iturbe's move would carry an option to make the move permanent for €8m, says newspaper O Jogo."

BBC

Derek Knox
146 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:47:03
Steve (#569)

Sounds 'fishy' to me, an eight legged player from Porto! We're all on 'tentacles' waiting to see that one come off.

Gavin Ramejkis
147 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:40:56
Fernando is a defensive mid and doesn't score goals, wiki has his goal total since 2005 at 5, Christ even Anichebe scores more than that
Brent Stephens
148 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:53:13
Eight legs - you could pull a hamstring or two and still carry on. Not sure who'd sponsor him for boots though.
Brent Stephens
149 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:55:20
Would you get four yellow cards for an eight-footed tackle?
Denis Richardson
150 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:53:21
When was the last time we had Brazilian player?

(Note, am not counting OFMs Rodrigo signing - who I believe made 1 appearance off the bench before heading back to the amazon.....)

I'd sooner have him than McCarthy - and Ive never even seen him play!

Steve King
151 Posted 02/09/2013 at 13:59:11
Jo was the last one I think? He had two left legs!
Phil Sammon
152 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:01:10
Any move would be subject to work permit.

If its not exploding knees it's bloody work permits.

Dominic Pitt
153 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:07:12
Bloody 'ell ! An octopus in midfield with a team that plays crablike football. We need a very shellfish striker.( I'll get me coat)
Tim Locke
154 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:11:26
ALL ROADS LEAD TO GOODISON?
"James McCarthy has been given the day off by Wigan but at this stage Everton have not come back with an improved offer for the midfielder.

"There are, however, now suggestions that Everton are looking at other targets. A contact in Italy, tells me they are now interested in signing David Astori from Cagliari.

"That is unconfirmed but if they do want him, they don't have an awful lot of time to pull it off. My colleague, Ian Dennis has already reported interested in Fernando, another midfielder."

Brent Stephens
156 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:14:56
Guillem on Sky saying MU in for Herrera. Would put a stop to Felli?
Chris Jones [Burton]
157 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:02:19
Arsenal won't be competing for Felli's autograph. The Beeb reports they've agreed a £42.4m deal for Mesut Ozil.
Denis Richardson
158 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:11:39
Ah yes Jo – thanks Steve, forgot about him.

Just Googled to see where he is now. Seems to be doing a lot better since going back to Brazil. Playing with Ronaldinho and won the South American equivalent to the Champions League last season and is also now in the Brazilian squad!

Guess there was some talent there after all and the Premier League just was not his cup of tea.

Chris Jones [Burton]
159 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:15:35
BBC 14:14 "The Toffees have made an offer for Cagliari centre-back Davide Astori and the Italian club are "evaluating" the bid, according to Corriere dello Sport."
Chris Jones [Burton]
160 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:17:02
Why are we buying a CB? Is Johnny off?
Peter Jones
161 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:26:27
I think we're getting McCarthy AND Fernando from Porto for the price of Fellaini. If so, that's boss mode.
James Marshall
162 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:36:52
Why do I find myself so excited about us buying a player I've never heard of?

Deadline day is a funny thing.

Ciarán McGlone
163 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:22:00
WTF..a centre back..hopefully this is bollocks!
Paul Melarange
164 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:34:03
I thinks it's inevitable Fellaini will go. I just hope it's for upwards of £25 million; then, if we can get McCarthy and maybe a couple of loan signings, that's not too bad as long as Baines stays!

I just heard on Sky Anichebe's name getting mentioned... not sure which team though? I've ever been a big fan on Victor but last season he seemed to be getting it right and was in the team on merit.

Looking at the once prolific Jelavic's and Kone's performance in front of goal I wonder whether we should resist any offers for Vic for the time being as scoring goals seems to be a problem at the moment, unless a shock striker arrives before the deadline ends!

Up the toffees!

Mark Boulle
165 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:41:10
Perhaps years of hopeless transfer windows have just made me a hardened cynic, but does anybody else think this late move for Fernando might, in fact, be a way for the board to spend no money at all?

How, you ask? Well, he has never been capped by Brazil, so how on earth will he be granted a work permit?! I believe that relies on having played in a certain percentage of your country's recent internationals doesn't it?

Why do I think the club will give the impression of working on this deal, and this deal alone, until the bitter end, only for it to collapse due to work permit formalities as we successfully complete the sale of Fellaini...

Mark Leicester
166 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:45:13
What would a transfer window with Everton be without a race against time to conclude a deal, can see this Fernando deal dragging on and on and on.
Dan McKie
167 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:45:30
He has played in Portugal for 6 years, Mark. Surely he has an EU passport by now?
James Marshall
168 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:45:58
Mark - he's a Portugese national now so the work permit issue is much simpler.
Peter Jones
169 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:40:56
I'm guessing our tempo goes up?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnUn5nDzpJs

Mark Boulle
170 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:46:53
Dan #609 - if that's how it works then great, but if so why would there even be talk of a work permit hearing. Obviously with an EU passport he wouldn't need one...
Nicholas Page
171 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:45:16
Mark, because it's Everton and nothing is ever straightforward.

The club should not only be spending any fee received but also a portion of the increased TV revenue, and previous profits made from player sales.

The fact that we have to wait for a deal to be done shows you just how poorly run this football club is. And there is no way it will all get spent. Again.

Ciarán McGlone
172 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:49:58
Hold on..if we buy this Brazilian, McCarthy and Barry..that's effectively 3 deep lying midfielders...

Hmmmm... creativity please!

Mark Boulle
173 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:55:03
Has someone from here been in touch with the BBC by any chance?

BBC Sport chief football writer Phil McNulty
FERNANDO LATEST
"Some suggesting Everton's move for Fernando is a late long shot - cynics might suggest it won't be the first time that has happened."

Phil Sammon
174 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:49:24
I'd rather we spunk £25M on a guy I've never heard of than spend £15M on a guy I know isn't worth it.

Deadline day logic.

Ciarán McGlone
175 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:55:37
Having said that..this guy can fairly put a tackle in!!!!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnUn5nDzpJs

Robbie Muldoon
176 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:59:23
By the way, did you all know Martinez's philosophy on reinvesting the money when a star player moves on? 3 replacements. Yes, Roberto says when you lose an important player for a big fee the money needs to go to replacing him with 3 signings, one of which has to be a young player. Fellaini out, McCarthy, Fernando and ?

Nicholas Page
177 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:01:26
If McNulty carries on like that, he'll banned from Castle Kenwright.
Kevin Rowlands
178 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:18:39
Hahaha, just seen the chant for our new signing, 'there was something in the air that night the stars were bright...................'
Steve King
179 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:18:08
I hate to be pessimistic but I can see another "..there were complications and we just couldn't get it done in time...." quote from Bullshit Billy at 11:05pm!!

Really really hope I'm wrong!!

James Marshall
180 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:27:44
A bit of light relief.....

www.whatbaleearns.co.uk/

Denis Richardson
181 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:30:22
Tbh (and to allay my own fears a little) I just cannot see a situation where we sell Fellaini and only get Barry on loan as a replacement.

BK has done some dodgy things in the past but even the happy clapper brigade of fans won't stand for that – that would be a bridge too far.

By all accounts the Fellaini fee has been agreed and only personal terms need to be sorted out, which means it should be done as I cannot see it falling down for that reason.

Given that the whole world has known that Fellaini would go, it's a bit disappointing to see us not having our targets already sorted – or maybe they are/were and we're just going through the admin?

(I know – am in the land of hope and optimism at the moment... also getting f'all work done today!)

On another note, how can Real Madrid afford the money for Bale when it seems half their fans are unemployed? How else do 20k people get the day off to go to a player presentation?!?!

Ciarán McGlone
183 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:46:55
Dennis they've just recouped half the Bale fee from Arsenal...they'll make the other 40 mill in shirt sales and advertising in a month..
Lenny Kingman
184 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:48:55
£50 million the pair, so £40 million and its done. Come on loads of Wonga. Then to waste £13 mill on the Championship level player from Wigan. Will be rekindle his relationship with
Lenny Kingman
185 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:51:13
Martinez and forge on. Only time will tell. Ince might be ok for around £6 million. Could be exposed and found wanting at first at the top level however. Still the markets crazy who knows what will be paid for who, irrelevant of talent or no.
Gavin Ramejkis
186 Posted 02/09/2013 at 15:56:08
Denis interestingly enough the very same question was answered on the radio this morning, a three hour drive to work means I was listening, Real Madrid are global and make approximately 600 million euros a year profit, the fee for Bale and his 20 million euro a year wages are eclipsed within their profits, contrast to Everton and you realise just how shitethis club is ran and how much further it falls away year on year.
Steve King
187 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:04:19
McCarthy is a decent young player but no chance we should pay their asking price.
If Cabaye is only worth £15million there's no way that McCarthy is worth that!!
Why not go after Cabaye instead, show Alan Pardew that "we are a level above them now"
Steve King
188 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:17:09
I see Middlesborough are signing Jelle Vossen.........wasn't there a few TWebbers campaigning for us to sign him last year?
Chris Jones [Burton]
189 Posted 02/09/2013 at 14:47:05
Yes, the all-reliable Wikipedia says he "holds Portuguese citizenship after spending over five years in Portugal" and is set to play for their national team. So one would expect the permit to be little more than a formality. Then again, this is Everton we're talking about...
Chris Jones [Burton]
190 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:20:43
P.S. From his piccie on Wiki (like it?) he looks a lot like Carlton Palmer. I hope FFS he doesn't play like him!
Chris Regan
191 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:26:16
This was on the Beeb's website

according to Spanish football expert Guillem Balague, who said on Twitter: "United have offered 36m euros for Herrera. He will have to pass medical and United pay it all in cash but deal practically done.":

So Moyes an Utd can offer them that much up front but insist on paying Everton in dribs and drabs for the big fella.

FUCK OFF MOYES!

Adam Weight
192 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:53:16
This club is a joke at the moment, if we lose Baines and Fellaini and bring in McCarthy, Fernando, and some old fella on loan, where are we then? Even worse than the last three games...

Where is the striker talk, a REAL PROPER striker in the upper end of B+ range? (That's all we can afford lets be honest).

We waste money on Kone and now can't bargain for a decent striker. Leave Wigan alone RM, look somewhere else FFS.

Shaun Kinnair
193 Posted 02/09/2013 at 16:50:11
McCarthy deal is off, so reports are suggesting.... so are we going to sign anyone today? Apparently Wigan wanted money up front and we wanted to pay in installements.... TYPICAL!!

Hopefully the reason for our U-Turn is that were looking at better players than McCarthy!!

Adam Weight
194 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:00:32
That's Felli gone then....pic.twitter.com/rd49ulSAO7
Nicholas Page
195 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:01:46
peg-leg whelan looking for another pay day. can someone pls remind the arl windbag they got relegated.
Richard Carton
196 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:08:00
I honestly have not been impressed with Fellaini this season, He looks like a player who has done what he considers to be his bit for the club and wants his chance at a champions league club. I think he believes his media hype, and don't think he will be that badly missed. While im excited by this fernado rumour, it does concern me that he seems to be second to mcarthy on Robertos watchlist....Hopefully the addage "if you cant be good, be lucky" applies in this case
Richard Dodd
197 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:08:17
My last ever post.Apparently my grammar is not up to the high standard Mr. Kendrick expects.

News from the Wigan camp is that BK has refused outright to pay the percentage agreed between the parties some days ago in respect of the transfer of McCarthy to replace Fellaini in ONE payment.The deal is now dead in the water.

Goodbye and good luck to you all !

Adam Weight
198 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:11:56
This is upsetting, watching Arsenal linkes with Di Maria, Ozil (probably already signed him), Benzema, etc. And we're linked with McCarthy, Fernando and Barry.

Plus we are likely losing our two best players... how did this happen to the "Nil Satis Nisi Optimum" club?

Tony Fearns
199 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:18:20
The very reliable source on GOT has informed them Felli goes Baines stays and Fernando in.
Paul Melarange
200 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:20:46
It's saying on Sky that Belgian FA have granted Fellaini more time to join up with his Belgium team mates so I guess he will be leaving. I don't know too much about this Fernando but it's all about saving money, money money, and the winner takes it all — that's all the Abba songs I could think of!

I would have liked us to sign Ince but knowing our finances we would probably try and persuade his father to sign for us. Hopefully we won't lose too many top players tonight and get a few in to excite us otherwise it could be Roberto's Waterloo in a few months time! Over to you, Mr Chairman!!

Chris Jones [Burton]
201 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:20:41
Hurrah for BK and EFC...

"Everton reject £15m Manchester United bid for Leighton Baines. Chairman Bill Kenwright insists defender not for sale". So, either he stays of the Ginger one better start grubbing down the back of the sofa for a few million more!

Chris Jones [Burton]
202 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:30:26
Sorry, that was Jamie Jackson in The Guardian: http://www.theguardian.com/football/2013/sep/02/leighton-baines-everton-manchester-united
Derek Knox
203 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:29:48
I think the reporter for Sky Sports News, at Finch Farm, will have a Guinness World record beard, by the time there is any news!
Drew Shortis
204 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:24:15
So it looks like Whelan has priced McCarthy too high and the lad may well stay where he is for now. If we do get Barry and Fernando in then any remaining cash should be spent on a striker. With the TV money, leftovers from Fer and the wages saved from the likes of Fellaini, Neville and Moyes we should have a bit left in the kitty to top up the money we get for Fellaini. It makes sense to keep your cards close to your chest regarding your budget, but from a fans point of view it makes it very difficult to asses what sort of incoming transfers might be realistic. Who know if we have £15m or £2m left to spend?
Steve Higham
205 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:45:30
Fernando on his twitter has stated he is staying at Porto - another let down I think !!!!
Paul Andrews
206 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:46:03
Drew,

I can absolutely guarantee that we will spend less than we bring in on transfer fees

Bill Gall
207 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:15:09
How is it that all the players we seem to be after are all defenders or midfielders when we havent got a striker that is capable of scoring in a 12 and under game.

I can not believe that there is no money to buy at least a quality striker from Europe without puttiing the club in deeper financial dept.

B.Kenwright has made Everton a laughing stock in the premier with his renowned 24/7 negotiations with every other club knowing he will only buy cheap replacements after selling the clubs better players at less than their true value.

The supporters are expecting Fellaini to go and I expect other clubs who Everton approach for players will rub their hands with joy as they inflate the price they want for their player.

Kenwright take a long hard look at the clubs motto Nil Satis Nisi Optimum before you keep sending Everton on a downwood slope by turning it into a selling club with no ambition just to cover up your many failings as the clubs custodian.

Chris Jones [Burton]
208 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:50:11
Good point made in The Guardian:

"The whole idea of United offer a 'Package Price' for the Everton pair was idiotic from the start," writes David Hale a commercial economist. "The commercial logic in offering a combined price for anything is a direct acknowledgement that you are either looking for a discount over the individual valuations, or you are offering a 'persuasion bonus' by taking on board by taking an unsellable asset off someone's hands in order to get the other one. As the latter is clearly not the case here, then Everton would always have been stupid to accept any combined offer."

Hey, there's time yet, this is Everton after all!

Brent Stephens
209 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:51:14
Derek, that beard crack is so funny! I can just imagine seeing the beard slightly longer each time the cameras cut back to Finch Farm. Surreal.
Robert Workman
210 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:48:02
Its interesting to compare Martinez comments about the transfer window closing before a ball is kicked, with the response of ToffeeWebbers now to the failure of Messrs. Jelavic, Kone and Mirallas to find the net during the first 4 games of the season.

How many TWs were calling out for another striker to be brought in before the Norwich game?

I agree with Martinez about the earlier closure of the window and think that he is sticking to his decisions about which positions we need to strengthen overall, whilst believing that Fellaini was almost certain to leave.

Steve Higham
211 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:56:14
Fernando - the Eva Banega scenario all over again.
Shaun Kinnair
212 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:55:50
It's not look good at the moment for us, a number of targets have fallen short and I think a sub-standard midfielder called McCarthy for an unreal price of 14 million will be making a move to Goodison, with maybe with slow cart horse Barry making a season long loan switch as well.

BK has done us good style, I just hope there no late drama with Baines that would really be a nightmare!!

David Booth
213 Posted 02/09/2013 at 17:59:34
I hope our new manager appreciates that the priority, whoever leaves or joins the team, is for improvement - not just replacement (and certainly not potentially inferior replacement if the rumours are true).
Jim Lloyd
214 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:06:18
Where do these stories come from?According to Sky TV, Fernando was sitting in a London office getting a work permit sorted out and Martinez was with him!!!
Ray Roche
215 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:12:02
"Elsewhere, AC Milan chief executive Adriano Galliani is still working on reinforcing the team's defence. After offering Napoli Cristian Zaccardo in exchange for their captain Paolo Cannavaro only for that to be rejected, he has touched base with Cagliari again with a view to re-signing Davide Astori"
Adam Weight
216 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:10:40
We are in big trouble here, if McCarthy is the only fella coming in.

I would rather we left it and kept the money for a bigger player in January. I can't say I'm that arsed about Fernando, didn't know anything about him prior to two hours ago, won't miss him now.

I hope we leave that slow fucker Barry alone though.

Phil Walling
217 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:15:04
Picking up on an earlier post,do other Evertonians not find it strange that Martinez seems obsessed with signing midfielders rather than somebody to slot it in the onion bag?
Mark Boulle
218 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:20:50
Well, well, surprise surprise:

BBC Sport's Chief Football Writer Phil McNulty
EVERTON LATEST
"Sounds like Everton manager Roberto Martinez's journey to a work permit hearing to plead the case for Porto's midfield man Fernando was wasted. The word out of Portugal is that there will be no deal - a deal which also dependent on Marouane Fellaini completing his move to Manchester United."

Looks like it'll be Fellaini out and a massively over-priced McCarthy and maybe Barry in. Wholly unsatisfactory.

David Pearl
219 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:21:55
Bollox to this I'm going for a drink!!
Errol Stafford
220 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:23:05
Transfer business should only be done in order to strengthen a football club's squad, and on that club's terms, and as we've seen with Suarez and Rooney, one of the golden rules is not to help strengthen a rival club. So with the Fernando deal seemingly dead, surely we cant allow Fellaini to leave now without a replacement(and I don't count Barry as he's not good enough) secured first.
Surely only a complete imbecile would sanction such a deal.......oh wait.....
Phil Walling
221 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:29:10
Nice one,David. I'm pissed off with the whole saga,too. I'm off to Haig Avenue to see the ressies !
Jim Bennings
222 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:32:29
Looks almost certainly like it will now be a case of Fellaini out and nobody in with us missing out on Fernando and not willing to match Wigans value of McCarthy. Oh well Bill looks like we can keep the banks happy again this year eh lad?.

I wonder how much of the Fellaini money will myseriously go missing between now and January? Or no doubt we will get the old favourite line brought out that January is a hard time to find players.

Utter bollox from Everton yet again you have to say. We are meant to be happy with selling our talismanic top scorer and cult figure and not replacing him, because we keep Baines? Small club mentality with small club board members.
Ciarán McGlone
223 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:42:17
Holy good fuck...aparently the Fernando deal was a steaming pile of made up bollocks..

I can't believe I actually fell for it, and got slightly excited...I feel dirty and used!!!!!

Clive Lewis
224 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:51:37
apparently it we are signing Chiquitita as well as Fernando!
Paul Andrews
225 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:53:42
Ciaran,

Thats only the first grope.
You will feel fucked senseless at midnight when William pulls his usual stunt

Brin Williams
226 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:53:34
'My last ever post.Apparently my grammar is not up to the high standard Mr. Kendrick expects.
.....and good luck to you all'

Now I understand that today is an important day in the calendar of the transfer market - when we have many comings and goings.

I am however extremely saddened by the above comments by R Dodd
681.

I don't know what has brought this on but as Richard Dodd is a long standing and regular contributor to these TW boards I for one will be sorry if he is allowed to bugger off without some explanation of why 'Mr Kendrick' has been miffed.

Come on FFS let's have a bit of give and take - we're all grown up and there's so much shite posted that a little more, if indeed that was the case, won't go amiss.

Richard - stop messing about and get back in there mate.

Frida Ericsson
227 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:57:17
Martinez is surely not as dumb as many seem to think he is? What part of we need a striker does he not comprehend? We don't have the luxury of waiting for kone miss a lot and mr offside to score...3 games 3 draws and all 3 of them we should have won!
Mark Leicester
228 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:11:36
No fresh bid for McCarthy today according to BBC and Sky.
Clive Lewis
229 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:11:26
Lukaku ???? I would love this, Sky Sports hinting at this happening
Errol Stafford
230 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:11:31
According to SSN, Wigan have bid £6 plus add-ons for Jordan Rhodes, and Shane Long has left the Ireland squad to speak to Hull.....surely we should be in for one of these. Let Vic go to WBA and replace with one of these, ideally Rhodes. Wages wouldnt be a problem either. Wake up Bill!
Ciarán McGlone
231 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:14:49
How much did we sell doddy for?
Brent Stephens
232 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:15:36
What's Doody done? Seriously? Grammar?! FFS! After what is said on this site? Dont go Doddy.
Errol Stafford
233 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:15:37
And if we did keep Fellaini and Baines, and snatch Rhodes from under Wigan's nose, we would be sticking it to both Moyes and Whelan tonight. I don't expect it though.
Frida Ericsson
234 Posted 02/09/2013 at 18:57:17
Martinez is surely not as dumb as many seem to think he is? What part of we need a striker does he not comprehend? We don't have the luxury of waiting for kone miss a lot and mr offside to score...3 games 3 draws and all 3 of them we should have won!
Stephen Graham
235 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:25:32
Doddy, come home!
Joe McMahon
236 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:44:08
Another embarrassing transfer window, it's one after the other season after bloody season. I hate Bill Kenwright for what he has done to our club. 24/7 wow, watch this space, it just goes on.
When Mesut Ozil see's Goodison I presume it will be the first time he will have seen a wooden stand?
Steve King
237 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:53:49
I'll eat my left bollock if we get Lukaku!!!
Faisal Qureshi
238 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:51:05
I hate the transfer window. We are not very good and unfortunately
will not get anyone.
Kieran Kinsella
239 Posted 02/09/2013 at 19:58:39
Whelan has been clear about McCarthy's price all along so knowing that, why did we waste the weekend toying with him and then come in with a bid below what he asked for? Then we make a last minute bid for a player who as a $30million buyout clause who has no interest in joining us. It isn't incompetance, it's called Bill playing games as he always does with Rooney, Arteta etc even that Belgian fellow this time last year who we lost interest in as soon as the lock struck midnight. The club is an absolute joke and yet people will complain about the coach when we struggle. Fools.
John Ford
240 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:00:56
If we keep Fellaini/Baines and get Lukaku on loan I could live with that. The hullabaloo is bollox.
Ian Riley
241 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:08:09
I think we will break our transfer record tonight!
Callum McNab
242 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:20:06
Fellaini has put a transfer request in apparently. You watch he will go , and we will get no one.
Brent Stephens
243 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:23:50
Get on the live forumlads. It's better.
Bill Gall
244 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:21:12
Starting to look like what we all feared .Fellaini gone and no replacements coming in exept maybe on loan and that means they are unavailable against their parent club.

All clap when Kenwrights picture comes up on the big screen at the next home game.

John Malone
245 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:29:34
Why does it get left to the last minute all the time it takes the piss, why are we always left with the shitty end of the stick!

Bad bad management at board level, feel sorry for Martinez it must be dawning on him how much of crack-pot boardroom he's working with.

Have a look at Levy at Tottenham totally under control made Madrid wait until he was sorted I'm fully expecting us to lose Fellaini, Anichebe and only bring Barry in, what a joke for a new manager to go into a new season with his best player sold and no quality additions.

Kenwright out had enough of his bullshit!

Frank Crewe
246 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:46:36
@ John Malone.

It's a lot easier for Spurs to attract top players than us. They have a ton of money to spend. They're a London club and they have Europa league football. We on the other hand are a mid sized club virtually unheard of on the continent. We're in a provincial city and can barely scrape together enough cash to buy a bag of chips.

We get this at the end of every window. Ridiculous last minute attempts to buy players who wouldn't sign for us in a month of Sundays. So we turn to loan players and get screwed for overrated British players.

Kieran Kinsella
247 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:52:56
Well, to quote Ken Buckley "the board may have a difficult decision to make" come November. The decision should be, how to word a public apology for destroying the club before "Blue" Bill (ha - that nickname makes me cringe) resigns... but in reality he will probably fire Martinez and then bring in David Weir or Stuart McCall and give them a few quid of the Baines and Barkley money to sign "one or two" 30-something has-beens on 3 months loan contracts come January.
Kieran Kinsella
248 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:57:26
I'm now convinced that the "space" Bill told us to "watch" was the one between his buttocks.
Mike Hughes
249 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:55:10
I just hope I don't wake up to the news we've signed McCarthy for anything over £7.5m.

Checking the websites and live forums, this is a complete and utter shambles.

I hate to say it but Brenda has been a lot more impressive than our lot this time around. All down to Moyes / Fellaini saga I guess.

Loan deals are papering over cracks but I'd take that ahead of McCarthy at Whelan's quoted price.

Alan Smith
250 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:59:03
Anichebe goes for £6m and we get Lukaku on loan. Fellaini deal doesn't go through in time. And we use the £6m to get Barry as cover. This could be the best window we've ever had! Please dither Moyes
James Marshall
251 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:05:19
Well this is all rather questionable.

Lukaku? That would be great news.

Barry? Seemingly gone a bit quiet.

Fernando? Strange one what with the work permit hearing.

Ince? Not a word.

McCarthy? SSN say he's sitting at home, WTF does that mean?

Bill Gall
252 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:06:06
Wonder if Martinez made the comment that we would be stronger after the window closed meant we would be selling players so Kenwright could pay the banks and the club will save on wages.
James Marshall
253 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:11:30
Anichebe on his way to WBA - am I a bit behind?
Clive Lewis
254 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:11:22
This could be a nightmare they saying lakaku wants to go to the baggies on loan WTF?
Ralph Basnett
255 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:24:00
This is a dark dark day for Everton.

Lose Felli, have no replacement and every other club spending like it is going out of fashion!!!

What have you done to this once great club Mr Kenwright!!!!!

Once again, the laughing stock............

Raymond Fox
256 Posted 02/09/2013 at 20:34:30
Some of you lot take the biscuit, how long as Kone been on the field for us, 130mins and yet you say he's a write off.
How come he scored 11 in prem. and 2 in the cup last season for a team that you say were shit ?

Kone and Jellavic have both been crucified, but the've been isolated figures most of the time!
What about our midfielders, Barkleys scored 1, but Mirallas, Pienaar and Osman have all
blanked!
While the strikers rightly have to take some criticism, what about the above, the've hardly set the world on fire!
Fluke of a goal at Norwich to deny us a win, robbed at Cardiff and all the pressure against WBA. and yet its slash your wrist time already!

Callum McNab
257 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:27:10
Whelan on Talksport saying Kenwrong wants to do the deal for McCarthy over 4 years,absolute joke. He says he is going nowhere.
Shaun Kinnair
258 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:27:52
Were a joke of a club... Wigan rejected our bid as we wanted to pay instalments over 4 years...WTF!!!!! I don't like McCarthey anyway but Bill K thinks he's getting a sofa at DFS they way he's trying to deal
Neil Cox
259 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:31:02
Steve King @763

I hope we don't get him for your sake!!!

Frank Boyle
260 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:36:51
This looks grim!
Callum McNab
261 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:40:11
I know people will laugh, but I do think that the fraud squad should be called into are club now. They are robbing us blind. Extra £25 million and we are trying to do deals over 4 years. Sickening.
Tony Fearns
262 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:39:56
EFC, you are an embarrassment to the Premier League.
Bill Gall
263 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:35:24
Have been saying for over 2 weeks that if Everton sell their best players in the transfer window without having cast iron agreements to replace them it would be a disaster for Everton.

Mr Martinez welcome to the Everton way led by one of the most dispicable chairman Everton have ever had.

I hope after tonight you will be able to explain how Everton will be stronger after the transfer window closes.

Joe McMahon
264 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:46:30
I think Roberto may walk this week. Why do say many Blues still back this parasite Kenwright I will never know!
Trevor Lynes
265 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:40:26
I'm just watching virtually every club doing business and we are standing STILL! It's like trying to catch a gorilla with a butterfly net.

We are completely all at sea and whilst our lot are fiddling like Nero our rivals are busy strengthening their squads. Martinez does not realize the magnitude of the job he is expected to do.

Jim Knightley
266 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:48:54
Yes, Roberto will walk away from his contract...i'm sure.

For all that Kenwright has done, I really don't think Fellaini will be sold without a replacement lined up. But, barring a couple of miracles in the last 70mins, this has been a disgraceful situation. And it makes a mockery of having a timed release clause as well.

Alex Mullan
267 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:53:03
We couldn't sign a fucking birthday card!!

What the fuck happened Fernando?

Why the fuck are we bidding over 4 years for a player?

WHERE IS THE MONEY GOING BILL?

Someone should contact Panorama about this, there is no fucking way on earth this situation is above board.

Jim Knightley
268 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:51:40
Apparently Lakuku is potentially back on.
Jamie Sweet
269 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:01:52
Sky Sports News tweet: 'Everton haven't given up hope of signing Romelu Lukaku on loan from Chelsea.
Ken Finch
270 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:52:43
Been watching BBC coverage; best info on how deals done from Christian Purslow - ex red CE - where he's blown Dave know it all Whelan's comment about 4 year deals being unacceptable. Deals over 3 are a norm. He's also said some completions can be done very quickly.

However that may be helpful it still doesn't take away that EFC are woefully late and M Utd are stitching us up! It all hangs on Felli, that will go at the last minute and we will flounder.

Raymond Fox
271 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:57:00
Lakuku prefers to go back to WBA if he must leave Chelsea, is what I'm hearing on radio 5 Jim.
Jamie Sweet
272 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:04:57
Yet again we're being stitched up by Dithering Fucking David. Even after he's left us.
Alex Mullan
273 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:03:54
At least we held onto Hibbo and Osman, plus Anichebe looking like he'll stay now that our top priority striker has been signed by his suitors.

All we need now is Gareth 'turns as fast as a bottle of milk' Barry and its been a fucking great evening.

Peter Jansson
274 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:08:21
This is totally pathetic. It brings to light how Moyes runs his clubs now when he is at Man Utd.

Man U and Everton are so far the loosers on this transfer window. I see the same pattern here... Moyesy sickness?

1 hour to go. I'm not very optimistic about this.

John Malone
275 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:53:57
@ Frank Crewe

My point wasn't to highlight how more attractive and wealthy club Tottenham are than us but to highlight how poorly we are ran, I used to respect Bill Kenwright and honestly thought he was good for the club, now I think he is total clown who takesthe piss out of this great club in the way he does or should I say doesn't do business.

Why make bids on deadline day knowing we're not going to get them?
Why let Moyes run his contract down and take the piss?
Why if you know a player wants leave thrash out a deal at least a week before the end of the window?
Why make embarrasing offers in instalment payments for players?
Why conduct any business we do like complete amateurs?

Bill your past it, you and your cronies on the board are a joke, your making one of the oldest, greatest football clubs in England a laughing stock now do us all a favour sell up and piss off!

Darren Hind
276 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:10:07
Ssn keep contradictng themselves
Now claiming both deals are back on
Lizzie Bowers
277 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:13:16
Why is that Kenwright still in charge of our club? Any other team would have them out by now but not us... Get your heads out your arses — if it means boycotting a match, then do it!!! It's not kopite behavour — our club is dying on its feet.
Jamie Sweet
278 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:17:11
Pretty sure SSN manipulate the news to try and stimulate business for Sky Bet.
Si Cooper
279 Posted 02/09/2013 at 21:52:51
Thought I would stay away from it all and just see how it had all turned out a reasonable time before the 11 pm deadline. Some hope that anything would be sorted! What a shambles, made all the more embarassing by how the RS have got all their deals sorted without a single hitch.
Kieran Kinsella
281 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:17:18
I am getting a transfer myself until BK is gone. What is the point of supporting this team when this Reds fan is in control.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
282 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:16:25
Shows how touchy our thick-skinned Doddy really is, I guess.

Apparently being asked to put spaces after his full-stops and commas was a step too far!!! (Nothing to do with grammar, Richard!)

Darren Hind
283 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:27:53
Lukaku back on LOL
Jamie Sweet
284 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:25:01
West Brom break club record to sign Sessegnon.

Everton buy some new grass for their lawn.

Get this clown Kenwright out. It's embarrasing.

Bill Gall
285 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:28:09
You can just see what is going to happen with the Lukaku deal allegedly still on.

Everton fail to sign Lukaku as window is closed without an agreement.
Manchester Utd given an extra 24 hrs in the Fallaini transfer due to unforeseen circumstances.

Darren Hind
286 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:31:27
SSN now have us in pole position for his signature
Darren Hind
287 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:33:45
SSN now reporting Barry at finch farm -done deal
Jamie Sweet
288 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:38:42
Out of everything that is going on, getting a deal for Lukaku is the only one which will make me feel slightly better about the future. He is exactly what we need.
Colin Grierson
289 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:40:40
Lukaku come on you beauty!

If you build it they will come.

Chris Regan
290 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:40:38
Bill gall 843, where does it say Man Utd have an extra 24 hours? Why would they be allowed that, is it just because they are Man Utd?
Gavin Ramejkis
291 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:40:05
Everton fans are a bit like that bird in the English Patient, all alone in the dark in the middle of nowhere, guess what..................no one is coming

The club should just tell Fellaini its off because Kenshite's lies about Fernando fooled no one and he's ran out of porkies no one has heard before.

Ian Riley
292 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:11:10
What a mess again!

Why is our club run like this?

What goes on during the day?

If we don't sign anyone, I fear for the season ahead!

Oh, Barry in, worth the wait!


Colin Grierson
293 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:40:40
Lukaku come on you beauty!

If you build it they will come.

Kevin Jones
294 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:39:12
Gareth fucking Barry ffs. Surely he can't be to replace Fellaini, it's like replacing HP Sauce with that Daddies shite.

Lukaku now he is the real deal on the HP probably.

Karl Parsons
295 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:39:20
Our Club is a joke.

Do the Directors think a couple of dead leg loan deals will keep us down or satisfied whilst £25 million plus is banked in the black hole bank? They surely must be brought to bear for their continual mis-management of Everton Football Club.

I'm fucking furious... Less than 20 minutes left, you twats... sort it out or get out of our once-great Club.

Colin Grierson
296 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:44:49
The whole transfer affair has been orchestrated by the Mancs. This could go really well for us and Tiny Tears might need a pat on the back. Never thought I'd say that!!!
Ian Riley
297 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:47:43
I stll think we will get james
Colin Grierson
298 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:51:13
B INMAN
Just signed for Crewe!!

He's rubbish!

(Boom boom)

Jamie Sweet
299 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:47:23
I really don't understand why everything is left to the last minute every year.

It reminds me of my attitude to my school homework. Even if I was given a month to do it, I would leave it to the last minute and do a really bad fucking rushed job of it.

Difference is that I was a stupid school kid, and Kenwright is supposedly a businessman capable of running a multi-million pound organisation.

The sorry fact is that I was better at school than Kenwright is in business. (And I was absolutely shit at school!)

Colin Grierson
300 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:52:51
McCarthy in!
Si Cooper
301 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:51:06
Barry - at Finch Farm, McCarthy - apparently we have caved to Dave Whelan's terms, in 'pole position' to sign Lukaku even though he apparently favours WBA - can see him staying put at Chelsea.
Brian Hennessy
302 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:49:20
Five minutes to go, looks like Fellani def out, Barry in, McCarthy in and Lukaku in.
Ian Riley
303 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:50:52
Dear Dave,

We will pay 13 million over 25 years.

Best Wishes

Bill

Si Cooper
304 Posted 02/09/2013 at 22:55:33
So now we wait and see whether any of our business will be officially ratified! Haven't heard anything more about Fellaini for a while.

Do you think our lot realise the deadline is 11 pm not midnight?

Alan Smith
305 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:00:58
Great business! If them 3 have come in, we can give anyone a game! Hope Fellaini has stayed, just to piss Moyes off, and stand up to Man U for once! Well for 4 months anyway.
Michael Kenrick
306 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:03:36
What a performance!

Another dramatic masterpiece produced by Bill Kenwright Ltd.

You couldn't make it up...

Michael Brooks
307 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:05:18
Great business, are you sure? I really can’t see how any of the business done today is great for our once great club.
Colin Grierson
308 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:02:08
Barry
McCarthy
Lukaku

I'd be happy with that. Good business IMO.

Baines still a blue - best news of the day for me!!!

Paul Andrews
309 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:08:39
Colin,

£27 million in£13 million out.
We have had our kicks pulled down once again

Ian Riley
311 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:06:37
A royal performance from our chairman!

Lets hope we get them all.

Goodnight

Alan Smith
312 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:09:33
A genuine number 9, in the true Everton mould. Big powerful and good in the air. Happy
Si Cooper
313 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:09:44
Not getting (relatively) excited until everything is official.

Alan (#866) - that would bankrupt us! Imagine the Fellaini deal needed to be agreed before we could actually commit to anything.

Michael Brooks
314 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:09:48
I am happy Baines stayed but if you really think two in on loan, and a kid who has a lot to prove, then we are in more trouble that I imagined.
Brian Hennessy
315 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:12:21
What on earth was Moyes thinking of, he could have got Fellani for £23.5 million a month ago with the buyout clause and it now looks like he has paid £27 million. You couldn't make it up.
James Fletcher
317 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:16:29
Lukaku confirmed on his twitter feed...
Si Cooper
318 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:13:40
Paul (#870) - some more money coming in for Victor if his transfer to WBA is confirmed.

Some will be going out as fee for Lukaku loan though.

James Fletcher
319 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:17:00
Aaaaand Fellaini gone for £27.5m
Colin Grierson
320 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:12:47
Paul

I know what you're saying but I can't affect what happens with the money and its not worth me moaning about it.

I think McCarthy is a good player who will become a great player ( my opinion ) Lukaku is just what we need a great striker with loads of Goals in him. It's better than I expected anyway. I' m hopeful that we will do business in Jan if necessary rather than last minute!

27.5m for Felli. (28m for him and Baines!!!!!!) Moyes haha! Bellend

Brian Hennessy
321 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:16:06
Lukaku just tweeted he has joined Everton, excellent.
Si Cooper
322 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:18:34
Club have denied that our incomings were contingent on Fellaini deal being done; we must be awash with money! Better see some more players coming in in January then.
Frank Boyle
323 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:17:30
Dear Dave

I can get you into Panto as Long John Silver at the 'ippodrome and some of Betty's hotpot for your dinner.

Best wishes,

Bill

(mwah)

Alan Smith
324 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:18:34
Lukaku 18 goals last season. He's old enough for me....so is Barkley, so is Deulofue!

Coleman, Baines, mirralas, Pienaar, jagielka.

We're a top side. Should have kept Felli until jan, BK got no bollocks!

Phil Sammon
325 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:21:34
Paul Andrews

Having a bit of trouble here mate.

Can you just confirm, is £27M above or below £20M?

Mike Keating
326 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:19:08
Quite pleased about all this last minute activity but can't believe we allowed Whelan to get the max for a player no one else was interested in
We should have had more irons in the fire - what happened to our scouting crew?
I thought this was RMs strength
Paul Andrews
327 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:24:05
That would be because your a Yorkshire mingebag Phil and not at all accustomed to parting with your brass.
Si Cooper
328 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:21:49
So Manure are to pay £4 million more than they could have paid a month ago. Hmmm, maybe OFM realised he owed us something after all.
Paul Andrews
329 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:25:59
Did you say you we're 28 years of age Phil?
You should be out goosing and getting full of ale me wold mate instead of sitting in front of a computer. Hhahahahahah
Phil Sammon
330 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:27:23
Sorry Paul, that sounded rather like a bitter swipe, rather than the sincere apology you should be offering.
Paul Andrews
331 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:29:37
Phil,
Get out on the town me owld mate.
You are far to serious for a 28 year old.hahahahaha
Jon Ferguson
332 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:29:45
Paul - bad form. Just admit you got it wrong over the release clause and bd done with it. That last comment makes you look daft.

Does anyone know if Anichebe went?

Phil Gardner
333 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:22:57
Mike @ 292..... There's Chablis all over my radio but at least chewing this cigar is better than Steve @ 763's supper......have you got a light for this Beef and Tomatoe Potty?.........I
Colin Grierson
334 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:32:34
It looks like the paperwork didn't go through but the deal may be ratified by the PL. £5m apparently. Good luck to him.
James Fletcher
335 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:33:29
Jon - there's talk that not all the paperwork went through but it could still be ratified.
Paul Andrews
336 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:34:45
How did I get it wrong over the release clause Jon
Alan Smith
337 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:25:50
There's been a few people on here proved wrong tonight. More than a few.

Let's give Barry a chance. I rate Fellaini way above McCarthy but I'm getting right behind the lad now.

Our current back four with Barry and McCarthy in the middle is solid. With Barkley, Miralas, Deulofue, Lukaku, Kone, Pienaar to choose from in front, we can do well this season. COYB!

Callum McNab
338 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:25:31
Paul Andrews ,you forgot to mention the extra 25 million from the tv money. 6 million on Kone ,13 million on McCarthy . So that's 52.5 million in and 19 million out. 32.5 going into Billy liars pockets,or Bill Kenwright productions.
Phil Sammon
339 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:30:58
Paul Andrews
215 Posted 05/08/2013 at 19:13:15
Report abuse

So,
"Everton will be better off after the 15th of August"
Are you going with over £20 million Phil?


Haha, this is going to be beautiful Paul. I'm just reading through the 'Transfer Spin Again' thread. Theres quite a few of these quotes I'm looking forward to parading.

Paul Andrews
647 Posted 03/08/2013 at 18:18:27
Report abuse

Mike,
He will be sold for less than his clause fee.

It won't be just him "agitating for the move"

And this is another good one...

Paul Andrews
131 Posted 05/08/2013 at 13:18:16
Report abuse

We will know in a few weeks time. If there are no buyers at £23 million, there will be no buyers at a higher price.

-----------

Oh Paulie, you silly little sausage. It turned out you didn't jack diddly.

Peter Jamieson
340 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:35:09
If what I've read is true, at this hour, I think this has been a good day for us.

For once I don't feel like we've been caught grabbing our ankles or biting pillows, but actually done some good business

Peter Warren
341 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:33:51
£27-5 for fellain £4m more than release clause u have to say that was great business even tho I lived Fellaini. Good luck big fella but Barkley is the future! And a striker who bangs in goals yes yes yes !!!!!!
Jon Ferguson
342 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:34:41
If it does go through then we've made 32 mil and spent 12.5 mil.

I'm glad we've got McCarthy and Lukaku (even on loan) is great, not so bothered about Barry but he did win the league two years ago. I think we have probably improved the squad overall (it's amazing that we've kept Baines), but we have to spend the rest of that money in January.

Paul Andrews
343 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:36:57
Callum,

And still the sheep will flock to Goodison to worship at Bills shrine

Mark Taylor
344 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:33:26
Cold light of day, we have a negative net transfer spend of £12-15m in this window (depending on Anichebe) to go along with our already very large accrued negative net spend.

Granted that Lukaku is a coup, if it is true, but he is a loan not an asset. If anyone thinks RM will be given £20m plus to spend in Jan, they are on drugs.

I've no idea where this money is disappearing to, but we are categorically being asset stripped.

Brian Hennessy
345 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:35:33
Jon, It seems Anichebe arrived at West Brom at 10:50pm but his lack of pace meant he didn't reach the office in time to sign!!!!!
Alan Smith
346 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:35:57
If Paul has to apologise I want about ten.

Were are all those people who said we couldn't get Lukaku?

Paul Andrews
347 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:38:38
Did you report me for abuse on the occasions shown Phil?
Jon Ferguson
348 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:38:14
Paul - you misunderstood that the release clause was put in by Fellaini and his agent and not the club. You misunderstood that once the release fee expired it was beneficial to the club as we could hold out for more money and you wrongly predicted that we would end up selling for less than the release fee.
Phil Sammon
349 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:41:04
No Paul, I don't know if you know how copy & paste works mate.

Who was right Paul?

Me, Steve Pugh, everyone else on TW....or you and Eric Myles?

Toby Smith
350 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:39:23
For a change, I have to say Well Done Everton! Lukaku, Barry and McCarthy in Felli out. Do you really think Moyes would have signed Lukaku?...... No me neither! The only player that the ginger tosser could sign was Fellaini, a deal that was done months ago when Felli moved to Manchester, Nobody wanted to play for Moyes, Man Utd are on a downward spiral....... Moyes is out of his depth! COYB
Daniel Starkey
351 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:42:50
Best transfer deadline day we've had, I'm well pleased.
Paul Ferry
352 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:45:21
Not bad for the happy Hammers game;

Howard
Coleman
Distin
Jagielka
Baines
Barry
Mccarthy
Deulofeu
Barkley
Mirallas
Lukaku

Alan Smith
353 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:40:45
A top notch winger in Jan might be nice. Someone from Everton on the phone to SSN before saying we would have signed Mcarthy wether or not Fellaini left. As if!

If they're telling the truth we've still got £27.5m to spend.

Phil Gardner
354 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:44:08
One-leg Whelan gobbing off again I see.......that clown never learns it seems.
Ed Fitzgerald
355 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:40:32
We have done good business 27.5 for Fellani they bid that for both of him and Baines a couple of weeks ago the cheeky bastards. 5 million for Anichebe. I am delighted to get Lukaku on loan exactly what we need clearly Martinez rates McCarthy so we will have to see. I think overall we have strengthened the squad and done it with some dignity. Moyes looks like a bleeding chump in comparison.

Plus we have kept Baines best news of all.

Robin Cannon
356 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:44:21
Reasonably pleased with that deadline day. Very pleased with Lukaku, much needed. Even if it is a kind of bittersweet signing because it's one of those loans that has next to zero chance of becoming permanent.

McCarthy & Barry give reasonable midfield depth. Solid base to give Barkley good support in the attacking midfield role.

Ultimately disappointed to see Fellaini go, but not a bad price. Ditto Vic, if that's confirmed.

Big net transfer profit. We'll see how much, if any, might be available in January should we need a boost.

Gerry Western
357 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:43:20
What a roller coaster of emotions but well pleased with the outcome I'd believed we might get Barry and Mc Carthy but the addition of Lukaku was totally unexpected. Considering the business we have done over the transfer window it hard not to be pleased. Well done Roberto Martinez.
Alan Smith
358 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:47:54
For the sake of £4m I personally would not have sold Fellaini just to make Moyes and Man U look shite. The knives would be out now if that prick never made a big signing.
Paul Andrews
359 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:46:01
Phil,

I am 100% sure you know how copy and paste works mate along with all things in the same exciting vein.
I'll wager they are queuing round the block to get on the town with your good self.
Get out and about mate,get a few drinks down you,lighten up.
It's not all about sitting in front of a computer getting a little stiffy on because you "have proved some one wrong"
And with that little tip I bid you good night.Make sure you listen to my device young man

Peter Jones
360 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:46:48
Roberto is already a legend! Lukaku? Oh. My. God. With him in the squad, we could definitely get 4th. Guy scored 17 goals in 2000 minutes last season! Gonna miss Felli, but we've done about as well as we could have in this situation and I can't wait for the goals to flow!
Mark Taylor
361 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:50:36
Nope, it really does seem that people on here are resigned to us being a selling club......
Drew Shortis
362 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:46:25
I was so close to despair tonight that the final outcome has sent me into a state of euphoria. I wouldn't argue with those who point out the flaws in how our club is run or where the money is going to, but for one night I'm going to keep on beaming and enjoy the moment. Baines still with Everton, Coleman looking like a top quality fullback, a solid defence intact, a good quality centre midfield with some much needed depth, a very exciting attacking midfield with Barkley and Deulofeu. A front like with a top quality striker, if only for a year and to top it off we got one over on OFM! I'm looking forwards to this season again!
Paul Andrews
363 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:52:00
Your device.....my advice ;-)
Peter Warren
364 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:50:57
WE HAVE A STRIKER - yes !!!!!!!
James Martin
365 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:47:03
Not sure whether im pleased or furious at this deadline day. Got a great price for Fellaini and I think the incoming players will all help the team. On the other hand we've pocketed about 13-15 mill before we even get into where the fer money/tv money has gone. 3 Of the potential first team also don't belong to us and will need replacing after we've paid wages and loan fees for a year.
David Graves
366 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:55:41
Let's all have a party - Lukaku, Barry, McCarthy.
I thank you.
John Jones
367 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:53:14
So, all in all we have spent relatively well, however there are still some big questions to ask about the finances:

Income:

* Normal sky money
* additional sky money this year, rumored to be £40m
* Fellaini sale £27.5m
* Victor sale TBC

Outgoings;

* Kone purchase £6m
* McCarthy purchase £13m
* loan fees etc TBC

Balance:

* Do the Mathis once all has been confirmed with Vic and loan fees; I appreciate that there is the wages...but still Where is the money?
Could it possible that the board is trying to pay off the debts to make it more attractive to a buyer?

Craig Fletcher
368 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:58:16
Jesus Christ. Anichebe gone and Lukaku in (albeit on loan). How did we burgle that one?
Ernie Baywood
369 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:57:59
Wonder if we play Lukaku up top or on the left? Him and Mirrallas up with Kone could be pretty tasty.
Phil Sammon
370 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:55:47
Paul Andrews

Paul, I have a full an thoroughly enriched social life. I can assure you that my spending time on the internet on a Monday night is not in any way detrimental to my social standing.

So, Paul, who was right about the Fellaini release clause?

Dave White
371 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:54:15
It's midnight and I feel confident enough to say Baines is staying! Fucking awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Conn Prosser
372 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:55:24
The despair at 2245 had one thing going for it. A strong Kenwright out protest that would have been backed by the media and commentators. Now that argument has been watered down by some interesting signings. Very pleased with 27.5mill but that has been offset by the over-payment of McCarthy. A bit like selling your house at the top of a market, you still have to live somewhere. In Everton's case we moved to a crummy suburb called Wigan.

I'd like to think Lukaku chose us over WBA because we're a bigger, better club and not just because we were offering more money. Modern.Footballers.

Drew Shortis
373 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:01:10
We really need to take advantage now and push for that European place to replay Baines' faith / loyalty. Champions League might be tough with improved Spurs, Arsenal and Liverpool, but Lukaku will give us a chance.
Dave White
374 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:02:17
Well midnight on my laptop anyway : )
Alan Smith
375 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:57:45
Maybe the debts gone as well? -£15m net spend and £25m TV money. If not and we don't spend next window, the blue union may get another member.
Jamie Barlow
376 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:59:10
Poor form Paul.

£6 million for Anichebe. Wtf!!

Matty Dawkins
377 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:03:41
We've got to be happy with these deals.
Phil Gardner
378 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:02:58
£34m in.....£13m out........funny old thing that!
Phil Sammon
379 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:03:45
£4M more than the buyout! That's what Man Utd were waiting for.

Hahaha.

Drew Shortis
380 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:02:41
Just heard we got £6m for Anichebe. Great bit of business. I was always hoped he would put his strength to use and become an unplayable striker, but I feel he would always struggle to get into double figures. Best of luck to him at WBA!
Tom Dodds
381 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:55:49
So there we have it;
32.5 mill in
13 mill out.
= 19.5 mill change.
Best point to take on board tonight was Kenwrights insistence that they DIDNT need to sell Fellaini to buy Mc Carthy.
I can only hope that all the party goers on here tonight remember that 19.5mill (Plus,now) on January 1st.
Guy Hastings
382 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:01:34
Loan fees and the Wigan lad aside, that leaves us around £10m plus the Vic fee. Let's see what BK's got in the kitty come January.
Actually I'm pretty chuffed by tonight's dealings; just thought I'd put a sceptical TW spin on things.
Si Cooper
383 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:52:53
Apparently £6 million for Vic.... but we may be paying £120,000 a week for Barry! Imagine Lukaku loan fee and wages will be a tidy sum as well.

Really chuffed we got Romelu and will wait and see if our midfield is similarly improved with JM and GB.

At the moment it feels like we sneaked a win in injury time.

Mark Taylor
384 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:04:22
Alan the debt won't be gone. Someone is making (in this envirnoment) a very tasty 8% interest, all secured on ticket sales and TV revenue and based on a net balance sheet that assumed the whole club, including playing squad (and including Fellaini) is worth the pricely sum of £45m. Who in their right mind would give up that little earner?

We will not spend £20m plus in the next window. Come on, in your heart, you must surely know we won't...?

Alan Smith
385 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:03:11
Sky have just confirmed that Barry on £120k a week and Everton are paying the full wage. Who said wed go bankrupt if we paid Felli and Baines £100k?
Max Murphy
386 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:06:24
Would have made my day if we'd got rid of that useless tosser Jelavic
Jack Okell
387 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:06:37
The perennial debt must be getting low now. Bill said, in Roberto's first interview that any funds from player sales would be reinvested in the squad. It's not a simple case of 34m in and 13.5m out with loan add ons and structured payments. I will be severely pissed off if we don't spend a bit in January though.
Phil Gardner
388 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:07:22
£15-£20m in the bank, Guy. Dont forget Felli's wages and Vic's plus whatever the Oligarch and the Arab are having to stump up on Lukaku' s and Barry's wages sees Billy and the Board stashing the rest....we won't see any of it come January I reckon....
Frank Boyle
389 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:42:54
Jesus, this looks half decent!
Peter Jones
390 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:02:51
Funny how I don't see anybody talking shit about Kenwright.... After the TV deal next season, we may seriously have a 20-25M war chest for a midfielder and a striker to fill the Lukaku void. Amazing business done today. Proud to be an Evertonian.
Chris Stubbs
391 Posted 02/09/2013 at 23:56:35
We kept Baines. That is the best piece of news about this transfer window. However, we got 4 in prior to this evening, plus 3 more this evening and only had 2 out. I cannot remember a recent season when we had this type of activity during a transfer window. Question I keep asking is why we leave the bulk of this activity to the last minute of the last day.
Craig Fletcher
392 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:11:37
Max (959)...... really?
James Martin
393 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:15:06
Should take that 15 mill add in the Anichebe money and use it all for a down payment on Lukaku come the end off his loan period. Will be painful having a top striker for a year then watching him go back to Chelsea. When was the last time we actually had 3 first team strikers to choose from?
James Kirrane
394 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:15:26
Good to see the Toffees standing firm against Moyes and getting a decent 27.5 million for Fellaini and keeping Baines. If Fellaini requested a transfer he will also lose any loyalty bonus. Excited about Lukaku!
Phil Sammon
395 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:19:31
No way are we paying £120k for Barry. Dont believe that for a minute (at least not until I see it).

The guy is a back up midfielder.

Phil Gardner
396 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:21:35
I agree....Vic's fee = Barry's wages for a season....?
Dan Morris
397 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:19:31
Very happy with this window. Loved Fellaini and wish him well at United. Lukaku, made up with that one. The one I don't know much about really is McCarthy. Quick look around and came across this scouting report:

http://squawka.com/news/2013/06/03/why-everton-should-target-wigans-james-mccarthy-this-summer-transfer-scouting-report/2013060310235

Yeah I know it's just stats, I know it was for a different club, I know his team got relegated, etc, but reading that made me feel even more happy about the window and optimistic about us going forward. Yes I am optimistic and possibly being a bit naive, but that's what football is all about!!

Tom Dodds
398 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:16:46
There have been two bids from two top Prem teams this summer for Barkley, both rejected... but...
Anyone else think that getting Lukaku on loan was a bit easy for, at first, so it seemed, an outsider ??
Si Cooper
399 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:23:04
If Lukaku does the business for us it is highly unlikely that we will be the ones to prise him away from Chelski but he may help us to attract a decent young prospect next summer.

We now have the basis for a side with decent experience melded to some really exciting young players. Time for RM to show us what he is capable of with some top class players.

Craig Fletcher
400 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:27:09
Perhaps also, hopefully, the nett spend we've made on this transfer window will at least go partly to paying for a long-term contract for Bainesy now?
Drew Shortis
401 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:20:10
I can't believe we are paying Barry's full wages. When Gibson is fit surely he will be on the bench.

This transfer window has seen us improve upon the quality of our squad from last season, but with tree loan signings it is only a stop gap measure. It is imperative that Kenwright keeps his promise and allows Martinez to reinvest the money we have made in new players. If this happens we can look back at this window as a triumph. If the money evaporates we will be back to square one. January will be just as important. I hope we have learned our lesson from last time and back our manager!

Kieran Kinsella
402 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:23:26
Peter Jones

I will "talk crap" about BK until we see what becomes of the the 20million profit we made tonight plus the TV money. I am betting we'll never see it again and that next time we try to sign a player it's because BK did a cash-out refi on his car.

James Martin
403 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:32:28
Least thats the midfield sorted for the forseeable future. If Barkley and McCarthy progress like people think they will we could end up with some top players in the engine room. Would be nice to see an Everton midfield in the derby not being overrun by Liverpool's yarddogs for once.
Si Cooper
404 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:31:08
Maybe Citeh have waived any loan fee as long as we pay the wages, and / or it could be linked to a cut-price option to keeping Barry after this season?
Jim Knightley
405 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:15:05
Has Levy taken over?

A fee rising to 6mil for Anichebe...and 27.5 for Fellaini...

And Lakuku...im in dream land. 13mil to McCarthy looks better now, in view of the extra 4mil for Fellaini. And Barry is an extra number which we needed.

Miracle last hour. Baines has stayed...we got a striker far better than I expect most of us hoped, and whilst unfortunately losing Fellaini, have covered his loss (to an extent anyway).

And I reckon we will have 15mil to spend in January.

Mike Gwyer
406 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:16:36

Paul Andrews.

Why the bitterness to fellow blues who disagree with you and why your continued reference to applauding BK - as some sort of ponce bowing to their master.

I have never clapped BK and neither has any blue that sits near me or within ear shot. The clapping of BK, that you refer too, was orchestrated and was at the back end of applause for a true legend, this allowed BK time to pop his head up, smile and milk it. Being at GP obviously helps and if you were then you would have known that BK milked the opportunity.

So the work BK did today was almost worthy of applause - outsmarting Woodward and Moyes but losing his winning's (and boy were they nice winnings) to Peg Leg. One thing is for sure though, whilst BK is in charge I doubt we will deal with Wigan again. Anyways the manx twats will return, Barkley & Baines will keep Moyes knocking at the door.

Jim Knightley
407 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:45:56
Kieran... look what happened 18months ago... look what happened last summer...and this. I don't think we are in a position where we need to sell to survive now. Martinez will get 85-90% of the surplus, mark my words.
Ian Pilkington
408 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:45:56
Best news undoubtedly is Leighton staying. He must now be made the best paid player at the Club with a new contract that will keep the vultures away in January. Hopefully Moyes may be sacked by then anyway.
Alan Smith
409 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:32:08
£120k until June 1st is probably close to the extra £4m man utd paid above the release clause! We wanted 2 CMs in for the Fellaini fee, got one, plus one loan, so still have the same amount of cash left over for second player when Barry goes back to city.

Basically city wanted the full wages paid and Man U gave us the money to do it. So we got the fee we wanted and barry for nowt. Great negotiating by elstone an RM. Fellainis £90k a week off the books too, and he asked for transfer, which was probably our intention when we offered him his last contract. Every time we put a player on a new big deal, we sell him within a year.

Baines in the office this week, 'here's £90k a week son'. Sold next summer window on TDD, having been forced to ask for a transfer with an hour to go, efc pretending its because we can't the Shaw deal done. Next thing we get £16m for baines and buy Shaw for ten.

Back to this window though. I'm happy that most fans are wrong about this being a season of transition. RM is making 3 one year deals and therefore is concentrating on being successful now.

Jamie Barlow
410 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:43:27
I liked Fellaini. Top player. Good up top, good in midfield and good defensive midfielder. The problem was he could only play one of them at a time. £27.5 million for him and we sign a good striker, a good midfielder and a good defensive midfielder. All,three positions filled at the same time.

Martinez said we'd come out of the transfer window with a better squad and I agree that we have.

Maybe if Barry takes a cut in wages, he might stay beyond this season. I think he'll be free.

Lukaku might stay if he does well and Mourinho doesn't fancy him.

Moyes paid £4.5 million more than he could have for Fellaini.

I've felt a lot worse than I do tonight.

Rob Smith
411 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:51:09
Impressed for a change, when you look at the whole window we have not done to bad at all,plus Bainsey stayed. Pity that paulhino or whatever name it was from Porto didn't sign, Well done Roberto. Well done Everton.
Derek Knox
412 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:36:07
Why all the drama, nail biting, last minute will we, won't we ?

I take my hat off to Richard Dodd, who ( with inside info from Schh! you know who ) got this spot on to the exact fee ( £13M) over James McCarthy ! I know, as I type this, that Phil Walling, will be absolutely, over the moon !

The Royal A&E is trying to cope with suicidal Evertonians, who thought that no deals were going to materialise, and had once again been let down by the Board!

Not only did we manage to complete that, we secured Lukaku, (okay, cost a few bob for a loan) et al Gareth Barry !

We pulled a Derren Brown / Dynamo move, in the ultimate illusion, with WBA that they actually believe they have got a bargain, with Big Vic !

Fellaini to Man Ure for £4M more than the buy out clause, has all got to be good for us in the end !

Well done Doddy ! You're a star!

Andy Crooks
413 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:54:49
I said in another post that I feared we would be weaker by Tuesday. If we have McCarthy, Lukaku and Barry in, Fellaini out, we are much stronger. This will suit Roberto's plan much more. Fellaini wil mean a much more Moyes style at Mn U and the supporters will hate it. Seems like a good day's work.
Adam Smith
414 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:46:20
Well Santa didn't bring me Holtby, but I am bloody chuffed with that business today!

1 major caveat though - there must be money to spend in Jan or someone is taking the piss!

Scott Goin
415 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:56:22
Well pleased with tonight's action. It didn't sound like anything would get done. Was having deja vu.

We overpaid a bit for McCarthy but the extra £4 mill from Fellaini makes that a lot easier to swallow. I really do like McCarthy though. He's a good all-rounder who'll really help us in possession and defense.

The Lukaku loan is a sweet bit of toffee. He'll pay for himself just by getting us further up the standings. There's no chance of a permanent signing but he'll make this year's club a lot better.

There's no chance we're paying Gareth Barry's full wages without some other kind of financial reimbursement. He's free on a Bosman after this year so Citeh have almost no power. They either pay the full amount and have him sit in the stands or they take whatever we give them. I'm betting Sky is wrong on this one.

James Flynn
416 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:27:50
So, we can anticipate the trumpeted announcement of Baines's new contract, no?

If not, him gone, too, in the next window?

Raymond Fox
417 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:43:01
We now have a really serious team, and I mean serious, so can we get behind them in a proper manner, I'm pissed off with the amount of unjustified criticism some players attract on here, I have no doubt though by Tuesday (today) the same miserable gits will be spouting their senseless crap.
Give our new manager and players some slack, they deserve time to settle in, they are also due some luck in the next few games as they have had precious little in the first 3!
Alan Smith
418 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:06:42
We are paying it, definitely. We were desperate, needed cover and used his wages to get the extra £4m off Man U. We get him for free next year if we want him and he only gets £70-80k or whatever another mid table side will give him.

City would have kept him otherwise.

Alan Smith
419 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:12:55
Best squad we've had in the prem era by far. Every player is quality, even Naismith.
Vijay Nair
420 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:18:54
Anyone know if Lukaku will be allowed to play against his parent club Chelski (and likewise Barry against City)?

I'm guessing not...

Jamie Sweet
421 Posted 03/09/2013 at 00:52:40
Baines stays = Brilliant! The guys a legend!

Lukaku on Loan = Very exciting. Would love there to be an option to buy but assume not. Another hattrick against Utd would be nice!

Fellaini out = Disappointing but not unexpected. On the plus side, it seems like we squeezed as much money from Dithering Davey as possible.

McCarthy in = Huge potential. Already played over 100 Premier League games and can only get better. Looks like we paid top dollar but could prove to be a good deal in the long term.

Barry in = Solid. I think he'll suprise a few with the quality he brings. Not one to get the pulse racing, but a fine addition to the squad. A massive up-grade on Neville!

Anichebe out = Surprise! At one point tonight it looked like West Brom were going to sign Lukaku and Anichebe would be staying with us. Who got the better deal there? £5-6m was too good to turn down for a player who looks like he'll never quite live up to his potential.

Overall we do look stronger than we did 24 hours ago. Tonight went better than most of us feared.

Let's not let Bill get away with conning us in January though eh! There's still a lot of work to be done. COYB

Mark Taylor
422 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:14:52
OK so if I have this right, people think we've sold well (agreed) and have pulled a blinder in getting Lukako on a loan( also agreed), but while £33.5m is good selling business for Fellaini and Anichebe, people are clearly basing their satisfaction on the assumption that this money (or a majority of it) will be avaliable for net spend in Jan.

God alone knows why they think that. Transfer money banked during past windows that has been promised to be subsequently re-invested , never has been. This won't change now. We've just added roughly £15m negative net spend to our already substantial negative net spend in the past few years. The only people who have truly done well out of this window are BK and his band of asset strippers.

Now that the Arse have splashed the cash on Ozil, we might now even have the lowest transfer spend (i.e highest net negative spend) of all the Premier League- and probably quite a few in the Championship.

You could argue our squad is now a little stronger- it probably is- but it's based around 2 loan deals and just puts off the day of reckoning for a year- now does that sound like a Kenwright plan to you? I'm interested in sustainable, long term strategies, not quick fixes and kicking the can down the road.

Nicholas Ryan
423 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:21:21
Can we buy Daniel Levy from Spurs?
Christopher Kelly
424 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:41:14
Agreed Mark but happy for the night...

We can only hope the tv money will help. I've never believed a word from the man.

Garry Corgan
425 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:41:46
I wonder how these transfers came about, particularly Barry and Lukaku. On paper we have a good team today but I'm a little concerned that we now have three first team loaners. We can't build a good team for the long term on that.

Hopefully they'll grab a few points for us in the here and now but I do hope Martinez has long term replacements lined up and that Kenwright finds the cash to fund them.

Gareth Fieldstead
426 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:37:06
Great business. Our first 11 looks as good as anything outside of Chelsea and City. My only concern is how much money the club has brought in and will Martinez get to spend any in January. With additional satellite funds and the 15 million they made today, he should have 20 million plus. I wouldn't mind if it went off the debt but I just get the impression come January there will be money and the debt will still be 45 million
Gareth Fieldstead
427 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:46:58
That is meant to say no money and still 45 million of debt
Mark Taylor
428 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:47:59
Just a point to those who 'hope' that this money will be spent in January.

Aside from Vic, who brought in a late and (presumably) unexpected windfall, the Fellaini and McCarthy deals (and the fact that net money would be raised) have been public knowledge for some time now. Rather like the Bale deal.

If we had any intention of re-investing, we would have done what Spurs did and get the bodies we need ahead of time. Failing that, we would have had the deals to buy already lined up and just needing the ink. But the only one properly lined up was McCarthy and contrary to the pathetic call to Sky (from BK?), he was not going to be bought unless we sold Fella and as we needed to clear the best part of £15m on the deal, Fella's deal effectively set the price for McCarthy (or, you could argue, vice versa).

We had no intention of spending all that excess and we have no intention of doing so in January. I'd be surprised if much more than £5m was made available to RM, if that.

Sorry to rain on people's parades...

Derek Knox
429 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:43:29
It,s amazing how half an hour, at the end of the transfer window, can fluctuate, between a lynching mob mentality, to euphoric complacency, dangerous, I say !

Have we just papered over the cracks, till the next transfer window, or have we pulled off a major coup ?

I suppose the answer, will be dictated by the results the team achieve, between now and then. I think on the whole, we are stronger in theory, than at the start of the day, the manager at least has most of the players to effect the system that he envisages.

I am not sure, apart from identification of the targets in the transfer window, just how instrumental Roberto has been in their acquisition !

I am looking forward to the next game, and trust the injection of new blood and spirit will yield results!

Scott Goin
430 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:58:26
Ideally I'd put every bit of it into getting a good young striker. But however the extra money is spent should be good for the club. If a percentage of our debt is "bad debt", I wouldn't have a problem with paying that off. Add the increased TV revenue with a healthier financial situation and we might just entice a new owner.
Roman Sidey
431 Posted 03/09/2013 at 02:19:43
I think we should all be happy for at least a few days with what's just happened. We got rid of a player who wanted away. We got rid of a player who probably shouldn't even be playing professional football. We pretty much got an experienced centre-mid for free as his contract is apparently up at City after this season. We've got one of the leading scoreres in the league from last season for the year. McCarthy, I know very little about, and 13m for a championship midfielder seems pricey. Perhaps he will be excellent.

What needs to happen now is good squad management. I love Heitinga but I know not everyone does. RM needs to keep him happy though as next year Syl will be 37 and Jags isn't that great anymore either. RM also needs to nip in the bud this BS about only playing Gerard in the second half of the season as we apparently avoid paying his loan fee if he plays x amount of games. He could also stay an extra season, and I have a feeling come mid-May we're all going to be sad if he leaves.

On top of all that, Moyes has shown that he was/is a complete ditherer who couldn't run a decent transfer window if his life depended on it. And after the last two months, I think his stock has severely dropped and you won't see United supporters giving him much patience. I have a friend who said to me today, "Moyes is their worst signing since Veron." Pretty spot on. Whether you were MOB or IMWT last season, after the way he treated us with those bids last week you have to be pretty happy with how it's turning out there for him.

Peter Barry
432 Posted 03/09/2013 at 01:28:35
Never thought I would say this but that was a good transfer window for Everton. Kudos to the club for making OFM TGT pay £4Mil more than he would have paid if he had triggered the 'buyout' clause for Fellaini and Kudos too for making Fellaini hand in a transfer request thus negating his £1.5 Mil "loyalty' bonus too.

Getting shut of the 'falling over man' Big Vic for £6 Mil was good business too. Lukaku and Barry should be good additions and let's hope McCarthy lives up to the hype. I am betting the Mancs are non-too impressed with our dithering FM just now.

Paul Ferry
433 Posted 03/09/2013 at 02:36:05
Is this a record that silly hair has now been TWO deadline day panic buys - 27/5 still can't believe it?
Derek Knox
434 Posted 03/09/2013 at 02:27:37
Scott (005)

I must commend your sentiments, having, as we all are on here (well most) the interests of EFC at heart. The club has, probably, one of the best and longest running fan bases, in the modern game, but the fans 'did not' incur any 'bad debts' during that process !

That anomaly, lies wholly with the inept Board that run our club, we have been hoodwinked and generally treated as mugs, for as long as I can remember, and that has not been limited to my 50 years of support !

Therefore, why should the club be responsible for the shortcomings and inevitable greed of the Board !

Paul Ferry
435 Posted 03/09/2013 at 02:48:59
We can today put out a better team than this time yesterday and IF - IF - Teary Billy let's the net profit or the most part of it trickle over into the next window then we are in a much better position
Derek Knox
436 Posted 03/09/2013 at 02:47:58
Paul (008)

Shit ! You just missed being 007 by one post ! Probably me, not a bad transfer window on the whole, I know it's only early doors, but think we will be better, as a unit, with the changes we have made !

I had hoped, that we may have got young Tom Ince, and Bruno Martins Indi, through the door too, but I suppose in retrospect that's a bit too optimistic.

I don't know if you were on the 'live forum' (didn't see your name) but then again, you didn't miss much till the last half hour or so!

Roll on the next game, so we can see the new formation, inflict pain on Chelsea!

Paul Ferry
437 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:02:50
Hi Derek I tried but when I Iogged in for the forum I was told that my account was not eligible: emailed the editors but no luck/answer - thy were busy today or they hate me!

Agree one more would have been icing on the cake but contrary to my 4-00 central time gloom we did decent in the end - wow manure paid 500000 more for Felli than the original joint bid for him and Leighton

Paul Ferry
438 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:08:09
and six for Vic ....

A good day.

Jimmy Sørheim
439 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:07:17
Basicly I am happy that we got a replacement for Fellaini, both Mccharthy and Barry are great passers.
It is the goal scoring I am worried about.

But suddenly we get Lukaku, a future superstar on loan and I hope with an option to buy at the end of season.

Anichebe leaving was fair, and I have called for more of our aaverage players to be sold in order to get real quality in.

However we are only papering over the cracks up front with Lukaku, when he leaves again we are left even worse then ever before in the striker department.

Ross Kerry
440 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:15:42
Scott, I completely agree on the striker bit, and I am certain that will be Martinez view as well.
Attackers will prosper at our club with Martinez in charge, like defenders did under Moyes.
Viv Sharma
441 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:22:35
straight from the bbd:


It's worth remembering that two weeks ago Manchester United had a 'derisory' bid of £28m rejected from Everton for both Marouane Fellaini and Leighton Baines. That bid was £28m - today they've paid £27.5m just for Fellaini - 1-0 to Everton...

HAHA. Love it!

Viv Sharma
442 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:23:34
*That would be the BBC
David Ellis
443 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:18:39
Good business I think - not too sure about the details of the "loan" deals though as the information is unclear how much they will cost us. Assuming we have not paid insane amounts for one years service then I am very happy with the transfer activity.

One disappointing aspect is the continual whine about "where has the money gone Bill?" There is no mystery here. How hard is it to understand that most of the clubs revenue goes on players wages. Its in the accounts. Sensible posters keep repeating this again and again. There is no evidence that Bill takes money out of the club. He does have his faults but he is not an asset stripper.

The Fellaini money may or may not pop into some kind of transfer kitty. But if it does n't it will either be spent on operating costs (i.e. wages) or reducing debt - which is an entirely legitmate use of the money.

Derek Knox
444 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:09:54
Paul (#014)

I think we will be a 'better balanced team' . With a bit more creativity, distribution, and more importantly, end product ! Things change in football, as well as in life, we could end up holding on to Deulofeu and Lukaku !

Christ! (forgive me) you should have seen it before, I thought there was 'going to be a hanging' when our 'ever loyal brothers' thought there was no activity, 'in that there market' then out of the blue (forgive the pun) we got quality in, and offloaded Vic (still expect a comeback, Trading Standards on that one) and Fella with £4M extra off the Manure!

Probably bored your arse off, but I've had a couple of sherbets! Cheers mate!

Viv Sharma
445 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:24:54
That said though I have to say that I think we have been a little caught up in transfer fever.
I'm delighted with this as a whole but I fear in the cold light of day that we really should have been pushing much harder for more than what we got for Felli. I know people are saying it's good business, and yes, they wouldn't be too far off, but I think we should have said 35 or fuck off this late in the window because we had Manyoo over a barrel and only squeezed a little extra.
Heartbroken as I am to say bye to my second favorite player (fucking love you Bainsey! THANK YOU FOR STAYING!!!) I think he will be a huge success at his new home and as soon as that ginger twat gets the sack I'll be rooting for him to do well!
Viv Sharma
446 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:32:21
BUT... (I forgot to finish my sentence. That'd be the Pale Ale...)

But, class tho he is, Can Macarthy make a soft(ish) deal seem like a masterstroke by becoming a legend playing in a system that suits his style? Come on Jim, make us love you lad!

Also,

LUKAKU? You're fucking kidding me!!!!!!
That's the League and FA cup in our pockets then. Romelu, I love you already!!!!!!!

Eddie McBride
447 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:22:05
Just come home from work, and decided to catch up on things on TW.

I'm absolutely ecstatic about the Lukaku signing and fairly happy with the other buisiness that's been done. Obviously R M wanted Mc Carthey and I think he deserves our trust on that one

I would like to point out to the people who are working out how much money we have left for future windows. That they are not calculating in the millions we have saved by making the big hairy one put in a transfer request.

Jim Harrison
448 Posted 03/09/2013 at 02:06:47
£28 million more revenue this year.

Stick it in the bank, see how the team is doing in January. Decent chance of top 4, invest £10 to 15 million. If not hold on to the cash until next year. Qualifying for the CL proper via the play offs would generate around £10 million. The chances of getting out of the group stage first attempt are slim. There is no point blowing the cash for no future financial gain

John Gilfoyle
449 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:30:06
Did anyone see Jim White on the phone to somebody "high up" at Everton? Probably Bill. After the phone call, he stated that the McCarthy deal was in no way hinged on the Fellaini money, and would have been completed regardless. I found it quite odd as to why there was any need for that to be disclosed; however, if true does that mean we've got £30 million in January?
Ross Kerry
450 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:34:23
Derek you are deluding yourself if you think that we will keep either of these young loan players, unless they're a bit average. We will keep Barry though. We're not cherry picking from inferior clubs, we're looking for cast offs from richer quarters.

Fact is (barring loans), two players out and one in. We are right to be pissed off and suspicious.We are not right to keep on moaning about it without any action though.

The worrying thing about today is that Kenwright has strengthened his position whilst further decreasing the assets of the club. He is far smarter than he is given credit for.

The bullshit work permit hearing and Bruno Mars interest is just embarassing. Did it make any difference other than our perception of his supposed activity?

Richard De Sousa
451 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:46:47
I think we are all going to really miss the big fella (Fellaini).
We all now that Lakaku is going to contribute on top, but I believe McCarthy is the big haul here. This will eventually allow Martinez to employ the system that has caused opposition problems (i.e. 3-4-3).

McCarthy will be the engine that is needed in the middle to make this come off. Barry adds the depth and cover we badly needed.
Boys we hit the trifecta!
USA FAN

Ross Kerry
452 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:52:45
John, did you also notice how he was stifling his amusement during the phone call? Would he have the same face on if Arsenal were giving him a bit of info? It wasn't Kenwright on the phone to him, completely staged, but he was relaying information that had come from the club and it speaks volumes about where we are.
Derek Knox
453 Posted 03/09/2013 at 03:46:03
Viv (022/3)

I am glad we eventually got McCarthy in, but must admit, I was one of those who were saying, good player, but, nowhere near a £15M pricetag !

I still think that by the way, but luckily we gained, on both the sales of Fellaini and Anichebe !

I think you will see both the quality, and scope for further improvement, in him. We all liked Marouane, but he did alter the way in which we play.

With Romelou (doesn't look right) we will see an end product!

Steve Carter
454 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:24:33
Pretty good outcome, in all the circumstances. And, odd as it sounds, we have Moyes to thank for getting us a huge uplift on Fellaini. £6m for Anichebe. That had me rolling on the floor in gleeful paroxisms of laughter.
Tony Rice
455 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:25:24
Hopefully , everyone will give McCarthy a chance to bed in.....remember Fellaini was no great shakes when he started for us.....
Albert Perkins
456 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:22:15
I'm happy we have a striker! A real striker.

I also believe Kenwright meant what he said about his earlier bid for McCarthy. If we paid for him over 4 years we didn't need the Fella money. Of course, it was a rediculous offer that would never be accepted.

The naivety of that proposed deal is in sharp contrast to the amazing outcome of the evening's dealings as a whole. Upped the Fella money, got 5-6 for Chebe, got a mid and striker in at last doors, that left us in a reasonable position.

Go figure. COYB!

Nathan Goulart
457 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:35:24
Wow, for once I’m not totally depressed on deadline day.
Christopher Kelly
458 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:39:12
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xTpgAc20YPI

HE'S OURS!!!

Escaped by the skin of our teeth... We DESPERATELY needed striker competition.

Tim Kells
459 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:30:43
I think all this last minute madness has hoodwinked a few people. One of our best players leaves and is replaced by a championship player with potential and two loans who disappear at the end of the season. We have a net spend of -£20M despite being told that all the money would be re-invested and have spent just £6M of an additional £30M TV revenue.

Sorry for the cynicism but you'll see the usual excuses come out and this money will disappear as it has done in previous years.

Good luck to Roberto but how much better off could we have been if he'd been given all the money to spend. The Felli deal had been lined up for days so he would have had time to identify replacements. As the McCarthy deals shows we are an embarrassment of a run club at times. I.e. Offering to pay over 4 years, agreeing the fee on the last day and almost down to the last minute. Spurs with Bale on the other hand have shown how it should be done.

Rob Smith
460 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:49:55
Now we certainly do have more of a Roberto look about us, still think Moyes fucked us around until the last minute to block us spending to much of Felli cash.

We do look stronger, Lakaku, looked seriously good last year, with the expectation of Kone finding last years form as well, thats an exciting prospect.

Yes, the exciting ones are on loan but if they are able to keep us up in and around Europe, we don't lose Revenue from losing places in League, we have a squad big enough to keep us in cup runs.

Barry may stay with us if he has a good season and the other 2 are highly regarded but at their own clubs are down the pecking order, we have left over cash, this is a good squad, we maintain position win a cup, stranger things have happened.

Jamie Sweet
461 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:52:22
Lukaku is an absolute BEAST!

This is a player that uses his strength to great effect. I look forward to watching him bully defenses and notching a hatful over the next year.

Maybe Vic should have stuck around because he could learn a lot from our new Belgian lad.

Derek Knox
462 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:28:49
I can picture it now, Steve Clarke celebrated his 50th birthday, didn't want to make a big issue out of it, so invites Sky Sports and the entourage that comes with that, bottles of champagne(not the Bargain Booze variety) on show.

Once the cameras are off set," it's a shame to waste all this "( hastily and greedily opened bottles) so being conservative, and not letting it go to waste, the contents are imbibed.

Waking with the inevitable 'sore head' putting it down to the canteen coffee!

Realises it's transfer time "Oh shit, I need a straightener" discovering a few untouched bottles, decides to lubricate his 'dry throat' .

Steve (he says to himself 'act fuckin' normal') so he conducts business in the Window. '
Thank fuck that's over'

Thinking (as he is sobering up) he looks out of the transfer window, to view 'his newly acquired 'racehorse' only to discover, he had erroneously purchased a donkey!

Welcome to the Hawthorns Victor!

Conor Skelly
463 Posted 03/09/2013 at 04:55:52
Howard.
Robles.
Hibbert.
Stones.
Coleman.
Distin.
Heitinga.
Jagielka.
Baines.
Barry.
Gibson.
McCarthy.
Osman.
Pienaar.
Mirallas.
Barkley.
Deulofeu.
Jelavic.
Kone.
Lukaku.

Sorry, I’ve no paper and I just wanted to write the squad out because I’m only 10.

Peter Barry
464 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:04:18
Posted this on the Man U fans blog 'Red Cafe'.

'Welcome to the era of Dithering Dour Dave you Prawn Sandwich munchers. How does it feel to pay 4 Mill over what you could have paid at the start of the Transfer Window, with his 23.5 Mil buy out clause still operative, for Felliani 'cos Dave dithered, and how does it feel to have missed all your other transfer targets because of his dithering and penny pinching. You are welcome to OFM TGT Dire Davey (check on ToffeeWeb to see what those initials mean) . Man U fans my not be laughing but the rest of the football world is - at you not with you."

I was surprised at how many Man U fans agree with me.

Michael Parrington
465 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:15:01
Coming in £27.5+6=£33.5
McCarthy -£12.5. We've been robbed!
Lukaku -£3m ok you could argue that it's wages, but its really a fee
Barry -£6m same, it's wages or a fee depending on how you look at it

I make it that's £11.5 that should be available as a minimum, or £20.5 max to spend in January. Guarantee that it will be the minimum, or it will get lost with the Arteta money.

All in all good business today by Everton.

Dan McKie
466 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:09:52
So, we own one player less than we did yesterday, received £32.5 mil in transfer fees and paid out about half that, the other half never to be seen again, and some fans are calling it 'best deadline day ever'? Easily pleased, I say.

The wages won't have even gone up that much. Barry's will mostly be covered by Fellaini's if City are contributing; McCarthy was on £15k at Wigan, Vic was on £30k here, so that has likely covered that, so all we have is whatever we are paying Lukaku, which again may be subsidised.

Why people believe that the extra will be spent in January, or that it will take the debt down, is beyond me! Remember when we got around £18 mil received from Beckford, Arteta, Yak and Yobo, spent nothing, yet the £45 mil debt remained at £45 mil (still to this day if you believe reports)? Yet the happy clappers will keep on clapping because of the amazing non-deal of keeping our 29-year-old left back from the clutches of big bad Man Utd.

We probably struck a deal that we will roll over again for Barkley next summer in return for letting us keep our own player. Even if that is unlikely, we will go through it all again with Barkley next summer. Kenwright fucking out!

Ste Traverse
467 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:24:15
I wonder if the rest of the Fellaini fee will be available in Janaury or as usual will disappear into the Everton black hole?

Andrew Cutler
468 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:24:27
I am an ex Group Treasurer of a large commercial company. For those concerned at 'where excess monies go', let me say that balance sheets and cash flow statements (which obviously 'talk to each other and the P/L statement) will show exactly where money goes... hard to asset strip unless the accounts are unaudited or not audited correctly. Football Club accounts are pretty easy to follow if 'operational costs' are broken down into line items...and debt reduction is also simply observed.

Anyway, a good window after all eh lads?. I enjoyed immensely the last hour (9 -10 am New Zealand time). I learned a hell of a lot thanks to fellow forum posters. I was especially interested to find out about Dave Whelan's leg...it's injured.

Andrew Cutler
469 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:32:21
...Michael Parrington....Fellaini's old club get a couple of million...you have not accounted for that.
Craig Fletcher
470 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:29:56
Can't believe the conspiracy theorists here. We've lost four contracted players since last season (Neville, Mucha, Fellaini, Anichebe - Hitz was on loan) and bought four players in (McCarthy, Kone, Robles, Alcaraz). So, in terms of contracted players; nothing has changed in terms of numbers; whilst, arguably, the contracted players are of a better quality overall (save McCarthy for Fellaini; as McCarthy is of course an unproven entity with us).

Further, Barkley is now one of the first names on the team sheet, and Stones likely won't be too far away from first team action. And, we have added a mix of quality and experienced players in on loan with Lukaku, Deulofeu and Barry. All this after only three months into the new regime. Can't we at least enjoy the moment Evertonians, at least until kick-off vs Chelski! Today has been a good day.

Andrew Cutler
471 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:34:08
Fellaini's conduct through the whole process has been truly professional and considerate to EFC...he deserves our respect
Craig Fletcher
472 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:48:48
Andrew (049).... dead right re Felli. Even WBA showed Man U the classy way to do it - I can't recall any whispers of them interested in Sessegnon / Anichebe until they pulled off the deal. Baines, too, what more can you say. Model professional and legend.
Jimmy Hill
473 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:58:41
Well said Andrew 049 and Craig 050. I'd also like us to show a bit more class with regard to Big Vic. He did okay for us and deserves a bit more of respected than some people are giving.
Excited about the addition though. Baines is a major for us let hope that Moyes doesn't have another go in January
Ste Traverse
474 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:56:48
Is putting in a transfer request in at 8pm on deadline day really 'considerate'???

I don't wish Felli any ill luck but he looked after number 1.

Moyes tried to screw us by not signing him when he could have got him for £23.5m but has now had to pay £4m more than that. Ha ha, twat.

Kevin Rowlands
475 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:52:51
For all the shite we've had to put up with in previous transfer windows this one has turned out great imho of course, we've brought in Alcaraz, Robles, McCarthy, Kone, Deulofeu, Lukaku, Barry and lost Fellaini and Anichebe, and most importantly KEPT Baines. Anyone who thinks we haven't strengthened big time needs their head testing.

Count in the fact that Barkley is like a new signing because he was never played under the ginger genius (he preferred Phil fucking Neville). I for one am ecstatic. Oh btw, Andy Walker and co, can you please explain to us the logic of your hero paying £4 mill more today for Fellaini when they could have got him at his escape clause price just over a month ago?

Lyndon Lloyd
476 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:12:35
Ste, Fellaini submitted the transfer request at the behest of Everton, which was pretty magnanimous of him really as it saves the club a wedge that he would have been due in loyalty bonuses, etc.
Eric Myles
477 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:03:52
"Taking the Blues' estimated profit on the day to around £17.5m." and along with the additional £20m from the telly deal a very good day for BK and his friends.

"The Blues eventually agreed to pick up all of the England international's £120,000-a-week salary" so we've effectively paid £6m for a one-year loanee that's 31 years old and we shouldn't be signing permanently...

"Everton basking in the glow of rare profit from the day's dealings" — We always make a profit on our transfer dealings because we usually sell and don't buy.

Rob Smith
478 Posted 03/09/2013 at 05:52:40
Craig..my sentiments exactly, this is exciting, I think people are thinking oh but it's a loan not looking at who we loaned, we have swapped Anichebe for Lakaku, it may only be for the season but we don't have to take Anichibe back...i think the club met the target, top quality striker, midfield strength and a prospect from Barca the icing being Baines stayed...don't think we would have seen these players in under Moyes.

Eric Myles
479 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:17:22
Lyndon, weren't his loyalty bonuses reported on here to be due on 1 September?
Matt Traynor
480 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:20:18
Ste #052, the transfer will have cost MU even more, as with Fellaini having to submit a transfer request, it's likely MU will have been asked to stump up a greater signing on fee, and more of the agent fees.
Craig Fletcher
481 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:27:02
It could have been much worse; Ste. Thank goodness we don't have any Peter Odemwingie's.
Greg Mckerracher
482 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:31:41
What an incredible window. I cannot believe there is some negativity floating about. Lukaku could hit over 20 goals this season and Anichebe was absolute kack with a stinking attitude. McCarthy is extremely young/talented and is hotly tipped to turn into a "world class" prospect, in the same midfield as Ross Barkley? Our team structure seems to fall by the wayside when gibson is out, now we will almost always have Barry OR Gibson available to ping balls out wide. I would remind that last year we often saw Neville and Heitinga in that posiion. Our bench is also now crammed with players who can change games. We have the future of world class in Gerard Delafeu fom Barca as well. these 65% possesion Masterlasses are going to tun into 3 points every time. Oh, and the debt will come down and we shoud firmly be in the Deloitte top 20.

I can completely understand what Man U fans are feeling this morning, because I experienced that same anger every September for 11 years. I wouldn't swap Martinez for anyone right now. Legend.

Ajay Gopal
483 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:39:25
Great transfer window!
Conor (041) - I think you left out Alcaraz and Oviedo from your squad - also Vellios, if you would like to count him. I like what I see now.

Hope we can start toting up the points and moving up the table now.

I expect that Baines would be rewarded with a better contract.

The lad Tyias Browning seems to be making waves for the U21s (just read the match report on the OS).

Happy days ...:-)

Lyndon Lloyd
484 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:47:07
Not sure to be honest, Eric, but I think clubs have to honour loyalty payments for each year of a player's contact if they don't formally request a move.
Paul Gladwell
485 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:48:54
New contract for Baines now, made up with this for a change and so will the banks be.
Darren Hind
486 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:41:11
Not a bad nights work

So glad LL pointed to Fella's magnanimus gesture.

Dont get the joy at Vics departure as I believe he is heading in the right direction as Jelavic and kone go the other way. I expect him to score more than both of them this season. Still they are all in the 5m bracket which is where we seem to operate these days when it comes to strikers.

Super thread guys, with the exception of Peter Barry - posting on Man U sites ? WTF isthat about.

Toffee Webb Team - Take a bow guys, magnificent coverage of this deadline day

Ajay Gopal
487 Posted 03/09/2013 at 06:47:54
Genuinely feeling sorry for West Brom - not having a dig at Anichebe - I hope he does well under a new manager and a new set-up. But their fans must be feeling robbed at having Lukaku snatched away at the last minute. Romelu had nothing but good words for Steve Clark and their fans. Hope he does as well for us as he did for West Brom.
Brent Stephens
488 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:05:40
1. Looking solely at this season, I believe the squad is stronger than when the transfer window opened - new signings, regardless of whether loan or permanent (Lukaku, possibly Del Boy, possibly McCarthy, possibly Kone, possibly Alcaraz; Robles a bit better competition for Tim); increased use / potential of Barkley and Stones (and Conor, anyone?). Against that, the loss of Fellaini and Vic (the former more significant than the latter). On balance a stronger squad.
2. For the new use of Ross and Stones – well done, Roberto. For the new squad members – well done whoever "spotted" each one, whoever dealt with the negotiations, whoever ok'd the deal. (Conversely, if you think the signing was bad, the same people get it in the neck – but be consistent / fair). And I don’t really care how Moyes comes out of this – a mere side-show.
3. I don't know what financial surplus there is from trading in this transfer window. Can anybody calculate that (since the start of this window, including wages, loan fees etc)?
4. I don't KNOW what will happen to any surplus (though there will be various guesses – mine is that some will go on signings in January).
6. God knows how we'll now do this season. So many unknowns. Who will be able to adapt to Roberto's system(s) and how long will it take. Will Roberto be a one-trick (one-system) pony? Will individual signings work out this season (McCarthy, Barry, Delboy etc)? What happens in the January window (Jelli goes, for one?)?
But today, I'm back to feeling the same level of anticipation (sort of) as when we'd done the first dealings of this transfer window. Compared to around 9.00 pm last night, when I was positively suicidal with no signings yesterday, I now feel almost manic.
Brent Stephens
489 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:18:17
Darren #065 - what did PB post on the MU websites?
Phil Sammon
490 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:23:33
Eric Myles

Up early mate!

Would like like to formally tender your apology now, or shall we drag it out all day?

Ian Bennett
491 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:20:54
Lukaku, Barry, McCarthy, and 2013 ring fenced lawn mower parts budget in. Victor and Fellaini out.

On the face of it not bad. Only one of our players is a perm, so this will put pressure on a threadbare squad in the future. Loan fees look steep, just hope we can sign a couple more with the cash (and we don't get our pants pulled down). Can't wait for where's the Victor money Bill in January.

Fellaini clearly didn't fit the game plan that Roberto had, and £27.5m for a player who pit in a transfer request is no brainer, well it would have been if you could of signed him £4m less a month ago (Moyes you tit).

Matt Traynor
492 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:37:22
Ian #071, these clubs with the massive squads seem to be operating the loan system like an additional income stream to recover costs, especially if they are still paying a proportion of the players' wages.

If it's true that we're paying all of Barry's £125k / week then he's effectively a free transfer as he's in his last year - similar to Royston Drenthe (but hopefully without the attitude!)

Brent Stephens
493 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:41:13
Matt #072, maybe too early in the morning for me. But if a club is lending out in order to recover costs, I'm not sure why you say "especially"...

Wouldn't it be more like "but they'd be recovering less of their costs, if they are still paying a proportion of the players' wages". Maybe I misread!

Rob Smith
494 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:34:52
17 goals for WBA last season, can't stop smiling, 6th highest in PL more than any Chelsea striker....and they loaned him to us, this guy is top shelf, may end up being the best bit of business even as a loan.
Lee Robinson
495 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:44:55
Absolutely fantastic business!!

I honestly couldn't be happier.

Really can't understand the negativity on here sometimes. We have dominated the first 3 games, I haven't felt that comfortable watching us away from home for god knows how many years against Cardiff. There was only going to be one winner, if that was City and we put one of those chances, away everyone would be creaming themselves.

We are one flukey equaliser, a lick of paint and a nailed-on penalty away from having 9 points, through in the cup, an excellent transfer window and the emergence of the most exciting English midfielder in years as someone to build the team around. We are controlling games, the only thing missing is a striker, we have been creating the chances.

Give it a season or two and Martinez will have the chance to fully implement his team, very exciting times ahead it really beggars belief why there is so much negativity about RM and the way we've played so far.

Matt Traynor
496 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:51:10
Brent #073, early for me and not had my coffee.
I just find it wierd that (example) a player is on £100k a week. A club pays half his salary to loan him, but pays a £2.5m loan fee as well. So, paying £100k a week then? Maybe it's an accounting thing, increased income as opposed to reduced costs.

I'm sure this whole loan fee is a recent thing.

Barry Rathbone
497 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:23:42
At last we are working the system.

It is entirely missing the point whinging about loan deals we cannot compete for normally.

It is long overdue the realisation a huge pool of quality players are idle at the "buy all" clubs - there is gold in them there hills.

The board is what it is, and yes it's a pisser, but far better we stop kidding ourselves about the final piece of the jig saw being a tantalising "x" million pounds away.

We don't live there anymore and haven't for many years we are "Del boys" - charmers fighting the odds.

If we must live in a council flat with a reliant robin for transport let's keep trying and have an adventure on the way.

"This time next year......"

Brent Stephens
498 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:58:22
Matt, Thanks. I see the point.
Andy Walker
499 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:00:28
Credit were credit due, excellent signings and to get £27.5m for Fellaini when his buy out clause was £23m two weeks back and no other teams were bidding is a smart deal by BK.

Feli was never going to fit in with high possession style football, McCarthy a much better fit. Lukaku top draw I hope.

Kieran Fitzgerald
500 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:34:53
Eric @055, very good point about Barry. Net transfer profit or not, 120,000 a week for a player who is deemed by all to be cover seems silly.It's a lot of money for one season. If he has a great season, City will want him back. If he is shite, it will be money wasted.

We are meant to be watching every penny, not spunking it away in desperation. Was there no one else out there who was available to buy for the same money?

In terms of other players, will Baines now want a pay rise? Will Pienaar? Will Mirallas? How do you explain this to them?

Dan Nulty
501 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:47:42
Out:

Fellini 27.5m 80k per week saved 4,160,000
Anichebe 6m 35k per week saved 1,820,000
Neville saved 60k per week 3,120,000
Mucha saved 20k per week 1,040,000
Hitzlsperger saved 20k per week 1,040,000

Spent:

Fellaini 2m to standard liege
Kone 6m 50k per week 2,600,000
Alcatraz 40k per week 2,080,000
Robles 1.5m 20k per week 1,040,000
McCarthy 13m 60k per week 3,120,000
Lukaku 3m 60k per week 3,120,000
Barry 120k per week 6,240,000

In: 33.5 million
Saved: 11,180,000

Out: 25.5 million
Spent: 18,200,000

These are very rough figures but by my reckoning we have basically had a window of status quo situation.

In my view if you look at the changes in the squad we have come out of the window stronger than when we went into it and with no cost.

Those whinging about the TV money, we don't really have it yet, plus the extra money would be better paying down the debt to make us a much better proposition for a potential buyer of the club surely? After all we all want penniless Bill out, the sooner the debt goes down the sooner we could be bought. This window goes to show what can be done if you are sensible and have a plan, just realised I've not included delefeu in above figures either. Moyer should be praised by us for dithering otherwise we'd have 4 million less!

All in all I am looking forward to the next few games!!!!

Nick Entwistle
502 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:04:59
What the hell? £9m - N I N E M I L L I O N P O U N D S - on two players with season long loans.

Lukaku is justifiable if he nets us 15-20 goals, but Garath Barry and all his £6m wages? May as well kept Hitzlesperger.

McCarthy is a wait and see. I can't say we are stronger this morning compared to yesterday - only for those potential goals.

This summer has seen a lot of average arrive. A lot of average for a lot more money than we would normally spend.

Lori Fekete
503 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:13:42
Overall Happier now than I was 24hrs ago.

Got in a much needed striker, Kept hold of Baines and strengthened midfield.

The board actually played the whole Baines & Felliani well

My only problem is that I don't really care if we've made a net profit in transfers or not. With all the extra TV money I'd have love to have seen us at decent money for a proven goal scorer, which has always been our missing piece.

Lets see how this work in progress season pans out

Nick Entwistle
504 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:21:30
Howard
Coleman Jags Distin Baines
Barry McCarthy
Mirallas Barkley Pienaar
Lukaku

Looking at it that way... the first XI becomes more interesting. I rate Gibson more than Barry, but with his wages don't need to be justified in comparison. Bench.

Craig Fletcher
505 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:16:08
Agree about the Barry wages; excessive considering the role he will probably play in our squad (perhaps only a fill in when/if Gibbo is injured). I just wonder if the powers that be decided that Barry's wages were justifiable given the extra 4m we snaffled out of Man U for Felli? Who knows.
Andrew Cutler
506 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:22:39
@ Ste Traverse 052...mate, why did he put a transfer request in? Because it was saving EFC money on the deal...2million quid in loyalty payment...he did it for us !!
Andrew Cutler
507 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:24:53
...and Ste...it wasn't Assad who dropped the chemical shit...fyi
Terry Davies
508 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:23:21
Come on people, stop all the negativity and get right behind the Team and Manager. I for one am pleased, especially as I was becoming more and more depressed up until 10.45pm.

By the way I know what OFM is but for what do the letters TGT stand?

Andrew Cutler
509 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:25:52
...and Craig 085...think the salary is in lieu of loan fee...I stand to be corrected though
Phil Roberts
510 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:18:47
and as at the end of the season this will be seen as one in and two out. So please do not think this is strengthening the squad - in the long term it is weakening it.

And Lukaku in means both Kone and Jelavic competing for the bench and no Vic.

Fellaini out means McCarthy in and Barry as cover for . . . well given the last 3 games Gibson who didn't play anyway. So toffeewebbers may get their wish and maybe the bench for Pineaar and/or Osman so we can play them and Gibson and/or Barry because Barclay, Miralles and McCarthy are shoe-ins.

And the question - Fellaini worth double the money of McCarthy and Vic for 6m is worth 1 season of Lukaku?

Phil Sammon
511 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:24:31
Where has it been reported that we are paying all of Barry's wages?
Darren Warkcup
512 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:22:57
I have no hard evidence but to me the fact we are reported to have paid all of Gareth Barry's wages would suggest that this could be viewed as a 'transfer fee' to Man City and that they will not resign him with EFC having first refusal. It may well be that he signs a contract with us at the first opportunity which I believe will be January. as I say no hard facts but just a guess based on the fact this is so out of character for a normal loan type deal for us. Overall a good window and hopefully a few more of our long term targets will see their contracts run down a bit more by January and we can strengthen again with actual signings when a deal is more to our budget/suiting.
Kieran Fitzgerald
513 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:14:43
Nick, I was thinking the same about Hitzleberger. There must have been other players like him out there again over the summer. Surely we could have gotten someone in who could have provided cover while we matured the younger players and allowed McCarthy and Barkley the chance to fully bed into the starting eleven. It would also have filled the hole left by Gibson's injury.

Dan, the cost is that we now have a player on 120,000 a week when our top earners were on 75,000 a week. Baines, for all his professionalism, must be seething at the fact that not only has his preferred move to Utd disappeared, he now has to sit in the same dressing room as a new and bit part player earning 45,000 a week more than him.

Also, when Gibson is fit, who do we play. Our first choice defensive midfielder or the guy on 120,000 a week.

That wage packet will be used as a stick to beat the Board, Martinez and Barry with by the fans, the media, and other players in the squad unless Barry turns out to be the signing of the century.

In ways, I would have preferred if we had taken 20m for Felliani a week ago and then used the money properly in the time we had. It sounds like heresy I know but panic deals on the last day of the window takes some of the gloss off the extra cash we got for Felliani. Offering Barry those wages smacks of desperation.

Brent Stephens
514 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:25:42
Dan #081. Thanks! That's really helpful. Did we also pay a loan fee of 2.5M for Barry?
Jon Withey
515 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:15:47
It's pretty clear that wages are becoming more significant. Someone was saying Bale on 300k a week for 6 years > 90 million on top of his fee !

Lukaku for 60k a week seems good business to me. Not sure what there is to complain about. Just a shame he isn't permanent.

Barrry is expensive for a 'free' but there's no doubt that we need him and it's pretty low risk.

Definitely a bit of expectation on McCarthy at that price but it's a pretty exciting young midfield imho.

I think most importantly, in a world cup year, we've got some hungry players in Barry and Lukaku.

Gonna miss the big fella but keeping Baines was vital.

Dan Brierley
516 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:04:21
Paying Barry's 120K a week is going to eat into anything that was available for January. United won't have paid for Fellaini in one hit, it will be staggered payments over 5 years based on appearances and success similar to the Rooney deal.

Mcarthy for Fellaini is still not something I am able to get my head around. I am truly gutted we won't be seeing Felli's majestic control at GP anymore. But happy to give the lad a chance, even if it does mean we have 4 ex-wigan players on our books which is something I am less than thrilled about. Lukaku is exactly the type of striker we need, but a loan deal is very short thinking. And if he plays well, we won't be able to afford him anyway come end of the season.

Barry Rathbone
517 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:32:14
Kieran, but we are desperate and have been for eons surely this isn't news.
Steve Ferns
518 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:33:17
Too many messages to go through them all, but it seems from reading the last few, that people don't realise that Barry is out of contract at the end of the season. That means we can persuade him to stay here and to take a pay cut, we would not have to pay city a penny for the transfer then. It's the same situation we were in with Drenthe. Also how do we know that he's not already agreed to waive part of his wages in order to join us and get first team football in a World Cup year.

The board get a lot of criticism on here. Not least from myself. I have to take my hat off and say with regards to Fellaini, they played it perfectly and got top dollar. Hopefully Baines is now going to stay beyond January.

Ross Kerry
519 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:35:26
Eric Myles, presumably no further explanation is required of release clauses? Even for Moyes I think the penny has now dropped.
Andrew Cutler
520 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:27:16
@ Darren Hind 065...well said mate. Kudos to TW site engineers...well done... I kept up with how Dave Whelan's bad leg was progressing second by second...he broke it, did you know?
Dan Nulty
521 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:32:31
I see what you are saying Kieran, but with Gibson being injury prone it would leave only McCarthy and heitinga being able to play in def midfield, if McCarthy got injured then we'd be left with only johnny, which would have been a nightmare. It was six of one half a dozen with Barry, we could have paid 2 million to city and signed him on 80k per week, at least this way if he is shite we can just get rid at the end of the season. Could be one of the shrewdest signings of the window, hopefully
Brent Stephens
522 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:33:30
Phil #090. If you're going to talk about the strength of the squad at the end of the season, then you have to factor in what happens in January. So we don't yet know what the numbers will look like in June.

In any case, it's also about results THIS season. That set of dealing leaves me feeling reasonably confident in terms of squad. You have to accept that we are now a club that has to wheel and deal from window to window and feed of the bits.

Brent Stephens
523 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:39:10
Phil #090.

Vic £6M in. But Lukaku is not £6M out is it?? Dan #081 seems to think only £3M.

And are you implying Vic is as good as Lukaku?

Ian Burns
524 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:36:10
Sat on TW Live forum from 9am through to midnight yesterday. Desperation grow during the day and only the company of the guys on TW kept the depression at bay.

We (me included) give BK and his board hell the way they act as custodians of our club - but that last 15 mins before 11pm was such an amazing relief - Barry in; McCarthy in; Lukaku in - it just didn't stop - then 27,5m for Fellaini (4m more than the buy out clause); and old Vic at 5m, you have to at least give credit where it is due. BK was the factor in the Lukaku bid but that doesn't change the overall feeling of the past years under his leadership but this morning I will for one time say "well done BK and the staff - not the best business but saving business at the last minute will do until January".

Phil Johnson
525 Posted 03/09/2013 at 07:30:11
Re the money. It does not disappear, it goes on wages and servicing debt (not paying off). We spend more on wages than we earn, so we have to balance this off with transfers.

I'm not saying that its right we are in that situation, but its true.

Is it BK's fault that we don't have enough revenue coming in to cover the wages. Absolutely.

But the money doesn't disappear

Tony Draper
526 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:40:37
Steve Fearns 098
There were a a fair few references yesterday to Barry voluntarily taking a wage cut to ensure that he could join us
I haven't seen any of this substantiated anywhere and I don't think that is likely to be forthcoming now either
Ross Kerry
527 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:42:56
Better personnel in during the window than out overall, but no doubting that we sold two and bought one yesterday and that he value of the Everton squad has reduced.

Yes we do have to wheel and deal as a club but there have been assurances given that would suggest that Martinez must now be given money to spend in January so lets see.

Roger Helm
528 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:41:39
Best transfer window I can remember. Fellaini is a good player but hasn't looked interested for a while now. I think MU will not be too happy with him jogging about the pitch like he does. Two goal-scoring strikers, an ex-England MF, one of the best young midfielders in the country, an exciting young winger, cover at GK, and CB, Baines still with us, a move for Victor - well done Martinez! We are well behind the top 5 or 6, but a Cup is definitely on this season.
Paul Mackie
529 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:47:13
Lukaku is a good bit of business (even if it also confirms that Chelsea don't see us as anything like rivals) but I have real doubts over McCarthy. As for Barry, if it's true that we're paying him 120k/week then I have to question whether it's worth it. Massively over-rated and will unsettle our better players, particularly Baines. Good luck getting him to sign a new contract for less than what Barry is getting.
Jon Withey
530 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:42:51
To me its a squad that can make Europa, whether it does, we'll have to see.

The Fella deal seems about right for both parties. I'm surprised there wasn't competition for his signature, he's a match-winner at any level and is worth a place or two in the league.

Brent Stephens
531 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:49:30
Roger, I'm very far from a fan of Billy Boy, far far from it. But does Roberto take credit for all that? Let's have a wee bit of honesty.
Dan Nulty
532 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:50:09
Brent, I think he is including his wages. My figures are only guesses as don't have exact wages but looks to me like we've spent as much as we saved and got in, better squad and better back up personnel. Great great work.
Paul Andrews
533 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:49:56
Mike Gwyer,

It is because of fans like yourself that Bill gets away with it year after year.
A surplus of £20 million not spent ( after promising the manager ALL of transfer incoming fees for players)and you say he deserves to be applauded.
To everyone saying stuff like"great bit of business to get £6 million for Anichebe"
Remember you are football fans not club accountants

Brent Stephens
534 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:54:40
Dan and Phil, I stand corrected on Lukaku's costs. Sorry.
Kevin Tully
535 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:43:44
People are getting a little mixed up between a loan for an 18yr old reserve and a loan for a £10m rated player.

Loan fees are now the norm for clubs who have invested millions in first team players.

Alex Doyle
536 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:52:43
Have to give credit where credit is due. Kenwright has done very well to get a great price for Felliani, keep Baines and get a fine acquisition in McCarthy. I think the loan deals are shrewd and we have guaranteed goals and a cutting edge to our front line. Well done.
Bob Parrington
537 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:52:09
$120k per week for Barry is f***ing ludicrous. The whole industry has gone mad!
Joe Bibb
538 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:29:33
To the guy who has to eat his 'left bollock', try a glass of Chianti with it and remember it isn't the end of the world. Dixie only had one bollock and he did well.

To those who are not impressed with the loan signings, I say go back to when Moyes brought in injured players on loan who never ever kicked a ball for EFC: Gardner etc.

I am pleased as well that the 'Incredible Sulk' Victor has gone. He was upset that maybe one hundred fans out of 40,000 gave him stick. He never celebrated a goal as he had this 'Mood' thing going on with the fans.

I am happy with everything. I am happy that Roberto has now started to rebuild our team.

Dan McKie
539 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:53:00
Phil Johnson #105, the club have been banging on all summer about not having to sell. We have had Martinez tell us that we are "very strong financially", yet what you suggest is that we needed to make the millions in profit this window, to keep our head above water regarding wages and debt servicing. How do you explain that?
Kieran Fitzgerald
540 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:48:28
Dan, I genuinely hope that the Barry deal works out. If I'm being objective, he must have a certain level of quality in him considering his career to date. He may also want to prove City wrong. Signing Barry to play as a defensive midfielder could solve our problems in that position, considering that Gibson is injury prone. If Barry plays well, considering it's a world cup year, and he settles at the club, we could get to sign him for nothing in the summer. That would counter balance the wages.

Rob Smith
541 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:30:54
Even if we were paying all of the wages, which I have read differing reports on, I don't think we would be if we pay a loan fee. If and it is an if, they keep us around 6th or higher, which is a possibility, they offset some of their cost by us finishing higher for a bigger purse. I am not sure what the difference is money wise but it must be a reasonable amount between 6th and 10th say.

If it is there to use, use wisely and to advantage, as Barry R. said, a lot of very good players sitting idle at the buy all clubs, do those players feel good about that in a World Cup selection year, the majority not I would think.

Unless we get the mystery billionaire buyer, we have to compete as best we can, if that means utilising the loan market so we finish in and around Europe places, keeps us in the spotlight, helping sponsorship, I'm for it.

Mac Lloyd
542 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:54:48
For once let's give Blue Bill and the board a bit of credit, getting £27.5m for Fellaini when he could of gone for less on a release clause in July (and January) is a good bit of business for us and a terrible mistake by Moan U. I'm not that gutted to see him go and made up that Bainesy stayed. He's too inconsistent for me, on his game he's a real player but there have been too many games where he's gone missing and seemed disinterested. He'll also guarantee them at least one suspension in a season. If the mancs think they have another Roy Keane, they have half the player.

There is no way we'll be paying all of Barry's wages, loan deals just don't work like that and I think he'll give Barkley some much needed experience to lean on.

Come on lads, say well done, even if it is through gritted teeth.

James Fletcher
543 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:03:27
Personally I'm happy with how the window went for us. It'll be interesting to see if RM gets any of the surplus to spend in January as we still really need another striker.
Ross Kerry
544 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:05:27
Mac Lloyd, getting £27.5M is only good business in the transfer market if it then gets used to strengthen the team. As yet it hasn't been so can we delay the "well done Bill" until it is?
Rob Smith
545 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:08:52
Also worth noting most Chelsea fans are pretty pissed Lakaku was loaned out again.
Garry Martin
546 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:06:56
I am very satisfied with the way transfers ended up for EFC. £6 miilion for Vic & £27.5 million for the big fella is absolute good buisness.Can't help but feel sorry for ginger bollocks at OT though......what goers araound comes around !.
Matt Stephens
547 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:01:52
£120k per week is mad but people still pump sky full of money to watch the games.
One Man Utd fan I work with pays £90 a month on sky TV!

It wont change till people wise up.

Lenny Kingman
548 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:07:52
I think United's interest in Baines wilted somewhat when Evra started to play like he meant it. Thus leading to the derisory offer for the Blues left back.

They will probably be back in January if Evras form dips in the meantime. Which is likely now the heat is off.

Ken Crowther
549 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:58:06
Brent Stephens #067, did your mother walk with a stutter and talk with a bit of a limp, if so, I THINK YOU'RE MY LONG-LOST LOVE CHILD. As usual, you got it spot on.

Doubters/worriers/pessimists - for Christ's sake don't be worrying about what happens "at the end of the season", that's 35 league games in the future.

If you'd told me, at 9pm last night, that this would be the outcome, I'd have patted you on the head and bought you a pint (or a lemonade).

Enjoy!

Tony Draper
550 Posted 03/09/2013 at 08:46:18
ToffeeWeb Crew as others have already said "Thanks, great job yesterday", a good shift, all your hard work much appreciated.

I normally detest TDD but somehow, here with TW it was far more bearable. OK the banter was immense (utterly surreal at times) and the outcomes were not the utter depressing disaster I was anticipating.

Marouane Fellaini requesting a transfer was very much in Evertons favour, and his twitter at about 7am this morning was warmly appreciated
"Marouane Fellaini ‏@FellainiM 2h
I just want to tell you: THANK YOU Everton and all the Evertonian fans for all these last years. @Everton"

Good incoming deals, but the real deal Lord Leighton of Baines, styel and dignity from a terrific player. Pay up and stuff a proper rewarding contract into his hands without delay please Everton.

Ciarán McGlone
551 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:11:38
Given the potential situation at 10.30 last night..where all our targets had disappeared I can't help sigh with relief..

We've added a very good striker...and our midfield looks more balanced with Fellaini out and McCarthy and Barry in..

However, it's clear that the TV revenue disappeared a long time ago and the McCarthy purchase WAS contingent on selling Fellaini..

I can't believe Moyes blinked first and paid 27.5mill..however I doubt any of the balance money will ever been seen again..
Our wage budget should be down, and Martinez spent half of what we've recouped despite the usual bollocks from Bill - same old Everton.

But I honestly think we're a better team..

Sam Hoare
552 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:19:41
It certainly looks a lot better this morning than it did when I went to bed around 10.30pm last night!!

Fellaini- we will miss him alot as he was comfortable our best ball winner and most disruptive player. 27.5m is a pretty strong fee for him and his transfer request was handy too.

Anichebe- Always had a soft spot for him and hope he does well at WBA. Think I would have preferred to sell Jelavic but 6m is a good fee.

Lukaku- Obviously the most exciting. Has everything a striker needs and showed he can do it last season. Should score 15+ goals for us if given decent service.

McCarthy- A good player but an inflated fee. Will need to work on his creativity to justify the sum but i'm looking forward to seeing him play and he will give us energy and a quicker tempo in the middle. Pass the ball forward James!

Barry- Solid pro but I really hope we are not paying 120k per week as that would be a serious waste of the money from the anichebe sale. A similar player to Gibson who has been a regular for Man city for the last 2 seasons and I think not let us down in the middle.

All in all I feel like we all well stocked for this season but still need a permanent striker and midfielder, when lukaku leaves and Barry leaves/retires.

Shame we missed out on Fernando, would have preferred him to McCarthy I think.

David Ellis
553 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:09:38
Phil Sammon
I just can't understand this release clause thingy - can you explain it again??? Moysie
Simon Österhof
554 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:31:30
Are we really picking up all of Barry's wages? That just seems insane to me.
Richard Lyon
555 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:27:46
Just got the breakdown of the Anichebe deal. Four million plus a million for every goal he scores, so a maximum of six million!!
David Ellis
556 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:37:15
Simon
I agree it would be very odd to pick up all of Barry's wages. However I have scoured the internet and found no confirmation of this. I doubt we will ever know. However "loans" and "frees" are no longer free so we should not be surprised at paying a fair whack one way or another.
Michael Parrington
557 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:35:09
Andrew 047... right you are, forgot about compensation to Felli's old club.

Having a look at the overall squad I think that we will be in better shape than we were a day ago. Still cant believe we are paying so much for Barry though. Perhaps that was agreed before we knew that we were going to secure McCarthy.

I had a look at McCarthy in a game against Man U last year. He looks similar to Gibson in many ways, and obviously knows the Martinez game plan of kick the ball sideways or backwards when past the half way line :)

Alasdair Mackay
558 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:31:31
I'm happy about McCarthy and Lukaku. I'm indifferent about Barry. £120,000 a week effectively makes him a free signing, as his contract is up at City at the end of this season. I only hope that if we do sign him next summer we don't pay him that much money permanently.

We also apparently had the £10m offer for McCarthy to spend anyway, plus £6m from Anichebe (gutted to lose Big Vic) and the £27.5m from Fellaini means that Martonez had a working total of £43m. In total we have spent £13m on McCarthy, taking it down to £30m. All that's been taken off that figure is the loan fee for Lukaku (£2m) and the £5m for Barry's extortianate wages.

That means we have over £20m for January. I know he won't get it all, but if we don't spend at least £10m where it's needed I will be upset.

Ste McCoombe
559 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:36:31
Blubbering bill is quids in. £120k a week for Barry and 2 loan deals - what a joke.
Scott Hamilton
560 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:39:24
I keep chuckling to myself when I think about the £6m-ish we're getting for Anichebe.

When you think that we got Cahill for £1.5m, Arteta for £2m and Pienaar (first time around) for £2m...

...fuck me, £6m!

James Marshall
561 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:39:21
For once we've actually done some good business in my humble opinion.

Selling Fellaini for £27.5m which I believe is a lot more than he's worth, was a masterstroke - and floggin him to Utd even better. All he'll do is slow them down even more, and they'll end up sticking long balls at him as he plays behind RVP eventually. Priceless. The Utd message boards are AWASH with disgruntled Utd fans pissed off at both the fee, and the fact they bought what they're all calling a 'second rate' player!

Marvellous stuff, and I for one, agree with them - there's no way he's top quality Champions League team standard, no way. Best bit of business Kenwright has EVER done.

As for our signings: McCarthy for roughly £14m is a fair price for a very talented 22yr old. Trappatoni rates him massively, and for me that's more than enough. The Trap knows what he's talking about when he opens his...err....trap. I believe this kid will do really well for us, and be the engine room people have been calling for for years.

Lukaku is a class act, the new Drogba? Possibly, he's certainly big & strong enough and the kid knows where the goal is (it's at the end Jela!!). With the service we've put in in the last three games, Lukaku would have bagged a few no question - this guy will score lots of goals.

Barry, another shrewd bit of business, even if we ARE paying his wages - he's contracted to Man City and if his wages are £120k a week and City aren't prepared to pay them, well we have to. Solid pro, left footed, will give us good balance in midfield and he a guiding hand to Barkley & McCarthy.

Selling Anichebe for £5m?!? Amazing, I was ready to head over and drive him to West Brom myself late last night! I kinda liked him in a lot of ways (God loves a trier) but he'll never score enough, and the Goodison pitch has taken enough of a beating from his frustrated fists - I just hope the Hawthorns ground-staff are ready for him.

Paul David
562 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:41:25
Barry - All depends on how much we're paying him if this is a good signing or not. We badly needed bodies in the middle though.

McCarthy - A good player and happy we bought him but £4m more than we should have got him for.

Lukaku - Most exciting signing of the window, should bring us goals.

Fellaini - A top player, we will miss him but we all knew he would go and we got a decent price for him.

Anichebe - If this was the only player we bought or sold all summer then it still would have been the best window ever but to actually get £6m is a dream. My most hated Everton player ever, over the moon I wont have to watch this fraud no more.

James Morgan
563 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:14:41
I'm chuffed we got these lads in, especially Lukaku, but I'm wondering where the remaining cash will go.
Anyway, I'm already playing football manager in my head, and my team would look like this:

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
Barry/Gibson McCarthy
Barkley
Kone Lukaku Mirallas

Subs: Robles Heitinga Barry/Gibson Oviedo Pienaar Vellios Jelavic

Steve King
564 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:52:31
So now after everything else he's done Kenwright has forced me into eating my left bollock!!
Fuckin Livid!!! Haha
Barry Rathbone
565 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:46:16
What I like is there seems an aim at improvement, an attempt to get up off our collective arses and do away with the aimless drifting of recent years.

Moyes by contrast continues in his usual mood killing way, he's getting a right hiding from Utd fans.

Roger Helm
566 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:48:46
Brent I agree BK deserves credit for getting a good deal on Fellaini, provided the remainder doesn't all go back to the bank. But Martinez surely decided on the acquisitions. Delafeu is contractually guaranteed to play in at least half our games, and the whole balance of the squad seems more attacking. We have the best possession stats in the PL, so now we have more ability to convert chances we are definitely in a better place.
James Marshall
567 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:54:32
Nicely put, Barry. Positivity is the name of the game after the dour years.

I've not felt good about the Martinez appointment, but now we've got rid of the hairy Belgian and bought some players who can play the ball, pass it around and someone who can score goals, I feel much better about the whole affair.

Trevor Powell
568 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:50:03
Nice to see that Fellaini had to put in a transfer request to move and lose his slice of the fee. About time these players learned that they are so privileged to be doing the job they profess to love and then get apid a king's ransom to do it when most of their wages comes from hard-earned money from the common man. No Everton player should be allowed to plead to be let go to another club while on contract without having the bottle a to put in a transfer request. I am pleased the club stuck to its guns on this and it would therefore logical to assume that Baines did not put in a transfer request.
Paul Dark
569 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:56:07
Lukaku, good, very good. Barry, bad. McCarthy overpriced.

Really sorry to see Marouane go; Victor is better at present than Kone.

I really hope Martinez forgets Wigan now; the players he has bought from them are nothing special and they are a horrible club to do business with (like Man Utd and Spurs).

Without doubt, Lukaku is the best of the 'signings'; I just hope he banishes Osman from anywhere near the first team.

Colin Glassar
570 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:50:59
I'm totally shattered after last night. It's like being on the big dipper being an Evertonian. At 10pm I was in the depths of despair, an hour later I was doing a Holloway jig.
I think we came out of this well. We will make almost £40m on Vic and Fellaini and I think we are only paying half of Barry's wage and it's also linked to the amount of games played. So we lost our big Belgian and a fringe player and got in one of the brightest prospects in the country (McCarthy), a vastly experienced holding MF player (barry) with the leadership skills we have been lacking since Nev left, and one the prem's most explosive players (Lukaku) who will bang in the goals and give Jelavic, Kone and Vellios a kick up the arse.
As I've said/predicted before, we will draw our first four games then batter WHU and go on a roll. We will have a very good season IMO.
Ciarán McGlone
571 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:59:09
There's absolutely no evidence that we're paying 120k a week for Barry...In fact i'd say given our finances, that its pretty much guaranteed that we're not!
Tony Fearns
572 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:54:13
Obviously Lukaku was told he was going to Everton as he wanted to go to West Brom. I just hope he doesn't sulk.
Ciarán McGlone
573 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:01:57
I really hope Martinez forgets Wigan now; the players he has bought from them are nothing special and they are a horrible club to do business with

---

Yeah, and I hear we're a straightforward enough club to deal with... how many clubs have an embargo on us now?

Brent Stephens
574 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:58:19
Ken - a lemonade would do me! Glad somebody else is reasonably content.
Kieran Fitzgerald
575 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:58:51
I've always had a soft spot for Vic as well.I always wondered what you would get from him if he actually got to play thirty games a season. If e had sold Jelavic and gave Vic his place, I don't think I would have been too put out. But maybe Jelavic just needs a goal. Hopefully the extra variety in midfield now will provide him with the chances.

In ways Vic's physical presence suits a club like West Brom. In other ways though I don't think he'll get the same service as he would with us. I hope he does well.

Another potential misfit I will be keeping an eye on is Stephen Ireland. Mark Hughes took him on a free. There is a quality player in him somewhere and being Irish myself, I will be interested to see if Hughes can get the best out of him the way he did at City.

Kevin Tully
576 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:51:41
This window seriously disrupted our preparations, and the start to the season. Now we have our squad, players have to focus on keeping their place in the side, as there is competition for places in the starting 11 for the first time in a decade.

We all heard what Ossie had to say, he was more or less guaranteed to start each week, no matter how he played.

I am going to forget about the finances involved (until January) and just be happy we are much stronger than we were in August.

Barkley has been the highlight so far, let's hope we can now start to move the ball a lot quicker through midfield with McCarthy & Barry, and play some exciting football.

Loved Fellaini as a player, but I do think he held the ball up too much sometimes, slowing our play, definitely more suited to a Moyes type gameplan.

He did however conduct himself with honour during this whole saga, never once going to the press moaning, or have his agent sending messages through interviews - he leaves the club on good terms.

Andrew Ellams
577 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:07:43
Brent, I am pretty happy overall. Lukaku is quality, shame we only have him for a year, McCarthy I think will allow us to step up the tempo for the passing game that Martinez seems to want and Barry is a quality, experienced player who will slot in nicely during Gibson's holiday breaks.

On top of that we have cash in the bank that I reckon will help us but a quality replacement for Distin in January

Brent Stephens
578 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:05:08
Roger #149 I agree entirely that Roberto is probably the one to get the praise for saying who he wanted.
Denis Richardson
579 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:16:47
Fantastic news.......Lukaku in for the season and we FINALLY get rid of Anichebe, 5m reasing to 6m - wtf! I never have to see that sulking knob in an Everton shirt again!
Fellaini gone for 27.5m when manu could have paid 23.5m before his clause expired - the same clause that OFM helped to insert! Hahahaha - I see the panic buying has spread to manu.

A certain Leighton Baines still at the club - get him a new extended contract asap, this lad should be playing his terstimonial 3-4 years time.

And we have Barry and MCarthy in as two new CMs.....could this mean that Osman finally gets a few games on the bench to rest and not have to start as much?

A great day for Everton fans, a great day in the transfer window and a big thankyou to RM - no more hoofball with Fellaini playing up front. I still cannot believe that Fellaini will be wearing a manu shirt - just doesn't seem like a Manu player to me.

Also a big thankyou to OFM - really showed his transfer 'nous' there!

So in total about 32.5m coming in and 13m going out for a net 19.5m up in one day (less loan fees for barry and lukaku). Mmm wonder what all OFM loving 'net spend' merchants have to say about that?

Heitinga still there but cant win them all - big Vic going more than makes up for it.

Let the season begin!

COYB

Colin Glassar
580 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:12:48
Kevin, I hope Fellaini gets a good reception when he returns with the mancs. Like you said he's acted properly, he's never pretended to be an Evertonian and we've gotten good money for him. Good luck to the lad but it already sounds like ginger will have him playing all over the place rather than in his prefered role but that's up to them now. Anyway, he will probably be working with fergie by December.
Andrew Ellams
581 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:15:42
Paul David @ 145, not sure how long you have been an Evertonian but if Vic is your most hated player ever then probably not very long
Ian Burns
582 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:12:47
James Marshall - 143 - great post James - says it all and I agree 100%. Wish I had written it!! - Well done.
Sean Picton
583 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:14:00
I still wanted fernando haha! But if we got him I would have wanted another -like thrnfeyernoord defender.
Would be interesting to see if there is a buying clause for lukaku and that's why we didn't use the rest of Fellaini money. For sum reason these big teams prefer 'stars' like etoo etc who are past it rather than the lukaku and bentekes of the world.
I was very surprised heitinga stayed and I'm happy Vic has gone - he will do better there I think.
Barry will prove to suprise a LOT of people as Gibson did when he signed.
Baines staying was excellent news and we got a good fee for Felli.
Could be an interesting January.
Lukaku is going to be a revelation and although he is only for a yr, he is the biggest name we have signed for years.
Can't help but think that Moyes would not have secured these signings.
Ken Crowther
584 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:06:14
James Morgan #146 - you're not giving Del Boy a game then?

Roger Helm #149 - Del Boy isn't "contractually guaranteed to play in at least half our games" that would be suicidal - as I understand it the agreement is that if he starts more than 50% of the time we get a very much better deal financially.

Ciarán McGlone
585 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:20:54
"Kevin, I hope Fellaini gets a good reception when he returns with the mancs"

-------------------

Why should some pampered ex-player get a good reception when he comes here with a team we despise?

And what do you mean he's acted properly? He's been saying all sorts of crap to the press for years about leaving..

He's given us half a season of decent football in 5 years..FFS..I hope he flops like Klinsmann and Moyes looks even dafter than he does today..

Ian Burns
586 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:23:52
Transfer deadline day, just got better

CRACK OPEN THE COENTRAO?
Daily Telegraph's Mark Ogden: Fabio Coentrao to Man United is off. Paperwork not done. Real failed to sign Guilherme Siqueira in time to sanction Coentrao loan to United.

Craig Fletcher
587 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:17:56
Well said Colin. And hopefully Felli will start for the Mancs rather than making a Moyes-esqe 85th minute substitute appearance, with the Blues 4-0 up.
Colin Glassar
588 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:21:35
I think we might get Lukaku on a permanent deal in the summer. Jose doesn't loan out his best players he keeps them and develops them himself. I can see the special one changing all his forwards (Torres, Lukaku, Eto, Ba) next summer and bringing in new players. £20m plus add ons should do it.
I can't wait to see Lukaku, Gerard and super Kev terrifying defenders this season.
Paul David
589 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:24:57
Andrew 167

I've been a season ticket holder for 20 years, I didn't say he was the worst player ( he is right up there though ) but has there been a less likeable player in that time?

Tom Evans
590 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:26:19
Made up regards Lukaku but can't help wondering if after being allowed out on loan for a second season. he wont be thinking about a career away from Chelsea.
If he plays like he did for WBA lets make him ver welcome and see if we can sign him permanently.
James Morgan
591 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:30:59
Ken, I forgot young Del!
Swap him for Vellios!
Gary Carter
592 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:49:16
More asset-stripping from Kenwright.

For me, it's two out for over £30M and one in for only half of that. The balance will now disappear before the next window in which we will probably sell Baines. Barry is a half-decent stop gap, Lukaku is good but needs to be loan to buy... and McCarthy was massively overpriced.

Iain Love
593 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:37:56
A Decent striker!!!! Fantastic.
Tommy Davis
594 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:15:42
A little off topic here, but I noticed the U-21's beat Reading 3-1 last night, apart from getting back to winning ways, which included a brace from Chris Long again, Shane Duffy played his first game of the season for the youngsters, I was under the impression that he was loaned out, according to some reports on TW chat?!? Can anyone confirm either way with Duffy??

It is very possible he will be needed at some stage of the season, due to injuries, or perhaps RM doesn't think he's at the level he needs to be at................yet?!? If this was his first game of the season, was he out on loan & returned, or has he been injured?!?

After all the shenanigans of yet another late late drama in the TW, why oh why, would EFC have waited till AFTER the 11th hour, to finally bring in some of the players, RM wanted?!? Surely it can't have been getting top pound for our 2 outgoing players, could it?!? Was it down to purely not having any money, till the 'Fro was gone (Good piece of business ultimately, though still saddened somewhat at his departure, yet inevitable for progression of RM's squad) Either way, the deals got done, with most astounded at us getting around £6 Mill for Vic A & a lot of us ecstatic, receiving £27.5 Mill, plus further add ons for Felli, after OFM put a bid in, only 10 days, or so ago, for BOTH Felli & Bainsey for that amount & he ends up having to drop almost £30 Mill on Felli alone..................why, cos Everton Football Club don't sell players cheap, do they Mr.M?!? :-))

Mike Hughes
595 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:18:59
Despite a mindset of planning to enjoy last night, I ended up switching everything off at around 9.30pm when it looked like things were going tits up. Switched back on at 11.30pm for an update.

My take:

Fellaini - 27.5m is a reasonable deal and at least above the threshold figure quoted. We didn't get mugged.

Baines - the fact that he is still here is the big news of the night. Very happy with that.

Lukaku - Very happy. We had to fork out on an expensive loan signing and he at least is capable of banging them in. We'll need him to the way things have been going so far. Also may put pressure on Jelavic to up his game. But is he capable?

Barry - expensive but required bit of steel given Gibson's fragility and Fellaini's departure. A welcome addition.

Anichebe - I hope he likes running his fingers through the grass of the Hawthorns as much as he did at Goodison Park. A good deal (mind you, I have this funny feeling he's going to transform into a half decent 12 goals a season man!)

McCarthy - I hope the lad turns out to be a great success. But £13m is almost double what I feel is his worth. £7.5m tops. We were mugged again by media darling, Long John Whelan. (I have this image of him being wheeled into the studio rent-a-gob style).

Slightly positive this morning. MInd you, from the perspective of players being assets we have a short-term outlook with the loan emphasis. Jury's Out overall. They have to gel quickly on the pitch. Results are what matters now because we need to start motoring up the table if it's not to be a season of mediocrity.

Kev Johnson
596 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:26:48
I'm not sure about that, Colin. Off the top of my head I can't think of anyone Mourinho has developed. He generally likes fully-formed already-developed players, even if they're a bit older. He sends young players out until they're ready to properly contribute. I would expect him to recall Lakaku at the end of the season. He definitely has a touch of the Drogba about him, so I'd have thought he was up Jose's street. Terrible, terrible penalty in the Super Cup final, but otherwise impressive. I don't think he wanted to go out on loan again, so I hope his attitude is OK.

Barry is under-rated in my opinion. He's a very useful player. Extremely slow, but if he plays deep that shouldn't be a problem. A leader, too, which will be useful for us.

McCarthy? I can't see what all the fuss is about, but fingers crossed, eh? He'll get the ball circulating quickly, for sure, and I expect him to pick the ball up from the centre backs as a matter of course. It's too much money, but hey-ho.

I shed no tears for the departures of MF and VA. They didn't fit in with RM's vision and we got good money for them. I am exultant that we kept Baines. Great news.

John Gee
597 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:20:29
2 loanees, relegated midfielder, one if my favourite players gone, Anichebe shipped out, stitched up MU on fee, Baines staying, no Holtby bid. I'm not sure if it's all good or all bad. The last time I was this confused I'd just woken up with a massive hangover in Thailand and the woman laying next to me had a...., well anyway, strange window.
Ross Kerry
598 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:49:40
Can we get release clauses put into all our players contracts?

£1M for Osman? With Moyes cock-up inflation that should end up fair.

Brin Williams
599 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:11:03
Like most of us I've probably stayed up too late, spent far too much time on my PC and watched with awe and amazement at the way this transfer window has played out.

This particular thread should be preserved for posterity and brought out every now and then as an example of what Evertonians are all about.

It has everything, that you would expect in a soap opera. It has had us cowering in fear, standing on the table cheering, sitting on the edge of our seats, ridiculing the management (as usual), doing maths 27.5 + 6 - 13 (120K x52) = 7/8th of fuck all.

Goodison has on it's outside a time line of famous comings and goings, it also has it's Hall of Fame.
ToffeeWeb has all of these in abundance and if MK & LL only had the time to pull out the gems of this thread they could probably sell the whole shebang to Uncle Bill to make a musical.

Absolutely brilliant - keep up the good work.

Oh and Doddy get your effin commas and s p a c I n g right - cos that what seems to have got up 'Mr Kendrick's' nose.

Colin Glassar
600 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:44:27
Ciaran #171, he never hid the fact that he wanted CL football, never pretended to be a blue and never made a fuss and was very popular at the club. I like to believe that we are fair and knowledgable fans and we show him our appreciation for his years of service (he posted a big thanks on Facebook to all Evertonians). We got good money for him so, personally, I've got no complaints.
Ian Burns
601 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:50:37
Well said Colin - 189 - being a blue is also taking on board a history of fairness.

John, that lady in Thailand who you woke up with a strange window? Never mind, I'm not sure I really want to know!!

Phil Walling
602 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:14:26
After the excitement of yesterday-never have emotions swung one way and the other so dramatically-I have decided to shake off my anti Martinez feelings and give the guy a fair crack of the whip.

All in all, I think it was a good day's work on BK's part and whether the £6M outlay is a loan fee or Barry's wages is totally academic. He is a good player and better than anything we had for the role he will play.

Having vowed never to mention Wigan again, I welcome McCarthy and wish him well. I think DW played BK like a fiddle but perhaps they have both learned something from the experience.

Lukaku is a most exciting prospect and should be a great improvement on any other recent striker we've had.

COYB

Ben Jones
603 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:49:08
We're not paying all of Barry's wages!!!!!!!
Its probably about half, so were paying him 60 odd grand per week.

And the the loan fee 2.5 million? That seems ridiculous seeing he has a year left, and he's 32. I'd also suggest that's a load of bollocks too.

James Fletcher
604 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:44:25
Anyone know if there's a purchase clause in the Lukaku loan? If so then I will be ecstatic.
Colin Glassar
605 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:57:12
Nice to hear your optimism Phil. Ladbrokes have done a really good analysis on our dealings, it's worth a read.
James Marshall
606 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:55:29
All the talk of the fee for McCarthy being too high, look at it this way:

He's 22, very much up & coming, and still learning. He'll keep us ticking over nicely, he's energetic, good engine, can put in a tackle, and pass the ball. He's economical in what he does, and will fit the new style of play perfectly. This is an overstatement, but he has a touch of Xavi about him in the way he plays - doesn't always do the most noticeable things, but keeps the ball moving, works opposition players, finds space really well and has an eye a few moves ahead - it's an innate talent.

Of course he's not in Xavi's class, but he has the attributes. He takes the ball well, his first touch is really good and he moves away from players with it. Very much a modern-day midfield player, unlike the Osman's of this world who aren't.

Watch him blossom with Barkley in the middle of the park.

Kev Johnson
607 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:05:46
Excellent analysis of McCarthy (and Barry and Lakaku) here: http://theexecutionersbong.wordpress.com/author/theexecutionersbong/

I wonder what shirt numbers they'll wear? I suggest McCarthy 16, Lakaku 17, Barry 18.

David Ellis
608 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:35:10
Not all ex Wigan players are average. Step forward cult hero Leighton Baines. We now have 5 in the squad.
David Munro
609 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:02:48
Damn — we are a difficult bunch to please sometimes. I am honestly happy with every piece of business we did in this window and on Deadline Day.

A strong reserve goalkeeper, a defensive reinforcement, and a proven goalscorer for a poor team (although out of touch at the moment).

Then ANOTHER proven goalscorer, an experienced midfielder and an exciting up-and-coming midfielder!

For what, a targeted midfielder with a short fuse and a striker who spent all his time on the ground. With money to spare.

Did I miss something? Oh and we kept Bainesy! And made MU look like right tossers.

Transfer win!

Ciarán McGlone
610 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:02:29
We got good money for him so, personally, I've got no complaints

-------------------------

Neither do I. I simply don't understand why you want to cheer him.

He plays for another team and a team that deserves nothing but derision from EFC..

Some people treat these players like they're relatives...

Baines on the other hand...

Nick Entwistle
611 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:19:24
The most annoying thing about transfer deadline is that we have 11 days to wait until the next match. I have as much interest in England internationals as women's football.

Presumably Lukaku won't be lining up against Chelsea. Jelly's last chance to shine.

Phil Walling
612 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:20:29
David @ 197: Why not suggest to DW that we take them over as a nursery club and have first call on all the gems they unearth?
Gavin Ramejkis
613 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:20:37
Ian #172 that very same news made breakfast this morning very enjoyable, dithering mingebag rests his hopes on one signing he could have had cheaper weeks before, no one wants to sign for him even at the theatre of wet dreams
James Martin
614 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:15:31
Colin both Fellaini and Baines were in exactly the same position going into the final week of the transfer window. Both apparently held ambitions to play at the highest level.

One of them gave us everything against Cardiff, one of them didn't look bothered.

One of them turned up to international training, one of them contacted his manager and agreed time off in advance.

One of them hasn't mouthed off about wanting to play for a big club whilst he's been here, one of them has most transfer windows

One of them didn't push for a move on transfer day, one of them handed in a transfer request.

One will get a standing ovation on Saturday, the other will be jeered (at least by me) whenever he comes back.

Fellaini quite easily could have remained an Everton player yesterday but he actively pushed for a move. He wasn't sold against his will and left like some sort of martyr. There's having ambition to play at the top level one day and then there's doing everything in your power to force through a move.

So to agree with Ciaran he'll get nothing but derision from me unlike some of the other players who have left our club under better circumstances in recent times.

Dan Nulty
615 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:39:41
There is no balance to come in January, the money has all gone on the transfers and extra wages. Hopefully the TV money will be used to reduce debt.

Fellaini and vic would have scored 15 goals between them this year, Kone, lukaku and delefeu should hopefully score ten more than that between them and hoping Mirallas scores lots more than last year. I am feeling really positive this morning and with debt reduced if we don't spend in January I will be hoping we may attract a decent buyer so we can say bye to bill. Be positive, stop with the negative blinkers on and look at our squad at the end of last season compared with today, who cares if we have loaned players, as long as they positively effect us this year they will pay for themselves.

Phil Walling
616 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:33:19
James: Not worth getting excited about. Nearly all these guys are mercenaries,plying their trade around the world to the highest bidder.Quite happy to forego so-called loyalty bonuses providing the club they go to makes up the difference.

When you get a new job,I doubt if you give much thought for the firm you left so why should these buggers be any different.Every man for himself-that's the world we live in.I'm afraid.

Just don't fall in love with footballers. Easy to avoid the heartbreak.

James Marshall
617 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:41:09
Why are they mercenaries? Everyone looks for the best deal they can get, no matter what their profession and everyone chooses what's best for them, given the options available. That's human nature.

I don't buy into the mercenaries argument - in the past when I've been offered two jobs, I weigh up the pro's & cons of both, and that includes the money, then make a decision that suits me and me alone - nothing wrong with that.

Ross Kerry
618 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:39:23
Dan Nulty, how do you arrive at the conclusion that the money has all gone on transfer fees and extra wages? Those numbers surely do not add up.

Yes we did well on the day yesterday but Kenwright must be held to account by Everton fans for promises he has made publicly, and lofty expectations of his own manager that he has gone on record with. Why would anyone who would like to see him gone also be so keen to let him off the hook?

Nelly Verdonghan
619 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:08:47
I have’nt read all of the post for obvious reasons...but I for one am VERY happy with our dealings yesterday.

Barry will add a wealth of experience to our midfield when called upon which can obviously assit in the developement of our up & coming players such as Barkley,Deloufeu, Coleman, McCarthy

McCarthy has a growing reputation within the game despite being only 22yrs old and is a player Roberto ovbiously knows well and trusts.

Lukaku...if he can produce what he did last season for us then it just might get us that trophy we’ve been craving for the last 11+ years....got to admit never saw this one coming at all but so so glad it has....my heart was in my mouth at 10.55pm last night with all the shinanigans with West Brom and I actually punched the air when it was confirmed...I have’nt done that for many years about a new signing...but let’s try and not put to much pressure or expectation on the lad as he’s only 20yrs old...let’s just keep our fingers crossed and hope he delivers like he did for West Brom.

Equally as important for me is that we kept Baines...who at the moment must be the best attacking left back in Europe...I’m not too concerned about Fellaini going and the fee is a pretty good one.... yes he did a decent job for us but he was always going to move on at some stage and I got the impression (despite what he might say) that deep down he didn’t think Everton FC was big enough for him (or his Dad). I always felt he was a bit of a loose canon and for me gave away far to many unnecessay free-kicks and picked up far too many needless bookings (and suspenions)...we proved last season (when he was suspended yet again) that we can live without him so good luck Big Hair you leave with my best wishes (but no good wishes for Man Ure & TGT)

James Martin
620 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:49:15
Ross I would be surprised if all of that 15 million became available in January. apparently we might be paying all of Barry's wages which equates to 6 million a year. There's also a rumoured loan fee for Lukaku anywhere between 3-5 mill, with Macarthy's wages on top lets call it 10 million for this year. Add that to the 13 for Mccarthy and the 6 for Kone plus the other wages and loan fees then your're looking at 30 million. We got in 34 yesterday and made savings on Fellainis and ANichebe's wages. As usual there's been absolutely no investment in the team that hasn't been funded by sales but neither is there a huge windfall I don't think. I'll be surprised if it isn't the usual buy to sell or loan player in January yet again.
Andy Boyer
621 Posted 03/09/2013 at 11:54:24
Overall I am very happy with the business we did although the sale of Fellaini has me conflicted, not because he's gone but because it meant that Moyes and his cronies actually signed a player and avoided outright embarrassment.....

Which brings me onto my actual point which is that personally if he had stayed as manager I just couldn't see BK backing Moyes the way he back Martinez last night.

Something happened between them a while back I think but say what you want about BK he does conduct himself in a gentlemanly fashion and the whole Moyes end off at our last home game of last season sickened me to the pit of my stomach but I can see why BK did it, it underlined all the class that we as a club behave with, compare that to the way MUFC have been bahvig and it's there for all to see.

Last night underlined one simple fact which is that as a club we will no longer be dictated to or bullied into submission by the likes of MUFC and I am very proud of the way both RM and BK went about their business.

We are stronger and more competitive than before, we have added experience and a bit of steel in Barry, we have added sheer power and ability in Lukaku (please say we have an agreement to buy...!?!?!?!?!) and we have added passing ability and skill in McCarthy.

Well done to all concerned.

Mark Taylor
622 Posted 03/09/2013 at 09:31:47
Andrew 046

The act of preparing audited accounts do not preclude the enterprise from being asset stripped. What an very odd thing to say, especially if you are a Group finance guy, given there are so many examples of precisely this strategy out there. It's how a lot of takeover entrepreneurs make their money.

We are categorically being asset stripped. Look at it as the opposite of investment of which there is none, as surely you would accept. We have in this window and in past windows, a negative net transfer spend. The surplus people are talking about, £20m or so, won't be spent in the next window.You would need a lot of faith to believe otherwise.

It is a moot point whether the current asset stripping is/will work out well for the shareholders. At present, it does not look too bad for them. As you say, two unanswered questions are who is the lender earning a handsome 8% securitised loan and what is covered by the £23m of 'Other operating costs). Neither are spelt out in the accounts.

I could more easily accept our shareholders hollowing out the club if they didn't claim to be doing otherwise. If we are to believe the person who called Sky on air last night really was Kenwright (or someone who speaks for him) why make the claim that the McCarthy deal did not depend on Fellaini? That implies we had a further £20m plus to invest in the current window. Since selling Fellaini was hardly a bolt from the blue, it beggars belief that we could not have had more advanced deals lined up than for example, the Fernando deal, which appeared to be made on the day itself.

In the very short term, I think our squad position has improved. I can understand why people are excited about getting a striker as good as Lukaku, even if only for a year. I think Kenwright has sold very skilfully, getting a fair price for Fellaini and a very fair price for Vic.

But as I have repeatedly said, my horizon is longer term and there, things look more desperate than ever. We do not have a strategy. We are just kicking the can up the road.

Ross Kerry
623 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:08:43
We have also removed Mucha, Neville and Htzelsperger from the wage bill, as well as Moyes' own ludicrous wages. Kenwright also promised additional funds as well as all transfer proceeds to his manager when he was presented to the media so there is a discrepancy that should mean that Martinez does not need to sell in January in order to buy.
Do you think we are shelling out over £10M for Lukaku and Barry for one year? I doubt that.
Amit Vithlani
624 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:02:39
Nick 201

I think Kone needs to start vs Chelski to see what he can do. He should be fit by now. I also think Jela's days are numbered and we may well see him go in the next transfer window

James 204

For the Manure game, I will reserve most of my ire for OFM. MoFro simply behaved to form and nothing in his actions was surprising. Whereas the behaviour of OFM in trying to unsettle our best players and obtain them on the cheap was truly needling; no one knows better than him the effect an unsettled player has on a team (6-1 v Arsenal a few years back)

Colin Glassar
625 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:04:15
James, the big difference IMO is that one of them is a local lad while the other had no emotional feelings towards the club or city. I won't be cheering him on but I certainly won't be booing him every time he touches the ball. He's gone and he's finished as far as I'm concerned, no feelings either way. He's not Rooney who left us gutted or Baines who I was dreading to see leave. He is just another ex Everton player who gave me a lot of pleasure watching him play.
Andrew Ellams
626 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:18:08
What has Fellaini done wrong? Moved clubs, it happens people. I'll be stunned if the transfer request wasn't handed in at the request of the club as a way of making him waive his loyalty bonus.

Bale refused to attend training, Suarez sulked like a 3 year old and countless others have behaved equally poorly. Don't give me the uninterested shit, that's just how he plays and has looked like that for 5 years good and bad.

Mark Taylor
627 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:07:00
Sorry if I come across as the naysayer this morning, but just telling it how I see it.

While I do think we have sold very skilfully, the financials on what we have acquired might be less appealing.

I think we have payed top dollar for McCarthy if it is £12m or more. If we are paying Barry's £6m wages in full, that is appalling negotiation. He is a net liability to City not an asset and would be(or should be) desperate for a decent chance of first team football in WC year, and willing to adjust his inflated wages accordingly.

And while Lukaku is a truly exciting addition (and I think Chelsea are misjudging matters in letting him go from a playing perspective), from a financial perspective, it's a great deal for Chelsea, if we are paying them £5m. It means they get a good % of his transfer fee repaid, they know he will be a regular and we will likely have advanced his value and ensured he plays in the WC- possibly enhancing his value even more.

I think there is zero chance of us having a buy clause in the contract (and certainly not one we could afford). More likely is us giving them first refusal on Barkley.

Still, for this year at least, we are better off than where we started, if you did a balance sheet of players in/out. I know this is beyond most fan's horizons, but 2014/15 might be a lot tougher.

Colin Glassar
628 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:27:20
Thanks Mark, that has cheered me up no end.
Gary O'Connor
629 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:38:53
The fact remains that there has been no investment by the Everton board for Martinez contrary to Kenwright's pronouncements on his unveiling.
Dan Mcdonnell,an Irish journalist,was with Whelan on Monday when he received a call from Martinez and subsequent to the call was told by Whelan that money was tight at Everton. Again,this is contrary to the lie yesterday that Mccarthy's signature was not dependent on the sale of Fellaini.
Nick Wall
630 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:41:26
Credit where credit's due. Kenwright has played a blinder over Baines and Fellaini. According to the Mirror, his brinkmanship extended to rejecting TWO offers for Fellaini from United during the final hour of the transfer window ! The Mirror also state that Chelsea will be picking up half of Barry's wages - has there been any definite confirmation on this one way or the other ?

http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/transfer-news/manchester-united-transfers-marouane-Fellaini-2246496

Brent Stephens
631 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:47:32
My Guardian (newspaper, that is) says no sell-on clause for Lukaku.
Tony Dove
632 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:45:12
Doesnt anyone go to bed these days.
Good luck to Fellaini, certainly no need to be critical of him.Lukaku
looks a great deal .Dont know much about McCarthy but unlike
Fellaini[not his fault] he will have the same role week in week out.Barry also a good deal as he will make Gibson look a bit quicker.
Milos Milenkovic
633 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:46:02
Is there a possibility to know how much we are paying of Barry's wages from some official source? 120.000 would be total insanity. We already spent 6 mill on 30 years old Kone, which is already very problematic business, but this one would be complete madness.
Andrew Ellams
634 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:50:24
Gary @ 222, probably correct but don't believe everything hopalong Whelan says and he if BK had any bollocks he would kick his crippled arse for make a comment like that about another club to a journalist
Phil Sammon
635 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:52:26
Nick Wall

That is astounding business by Kenwright if he's convinced Chelsea to pay 50% of Barry's wages.

Steve Jones
636 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:50:48
Nick @223 - If Kenwright has managed to get Chelsea to pick up half of Barry's wages for us then I'll never have a bad word to say about him again! City are paying half and Chelsea the other half!

In all seriousness though I'm happy with how things panned out, happy with the signings and I think overall our squad has more depth and once players settle in we'll see better football with the points to show for it. There were a few on here who said we'd get less for Felliani when the clause expired which never made any sense, getting an extra £4m for Felliani and getting him to put in a transfer request saving us at least a other couple of £m along with getting upto £6m for Anichebe is pretty good business I think.

Craig Walker
637 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:33:55
Went to bed at 10.30pm last night completely pissed off. All of our targets were dead ends and Fellaini was off to United.

Think we've done good business and the team is far stronger under RM.

I'm not the biggest Barry fan but if you look on him as an upgrade to Phil Neville then I think he can offer us experience, a winning mentality and decent ball distribution. The latter is something that Pip could never do. I agree that his wages are extortionate but I'm afraid that sometimes we need to pay ridiculously or we'll be completely left behind. How many RS players have been signed down the years on 100k+ a week and been flops?

I think Kone will prove better than Big Vic in the long run and their respective fees effectively cancel one another out.

One of the best things RM has done is give the youngsters a try. Barkley, Stones and Deulofeu would never have been given game time under OFM. Scared a bit that Barkley could well be our next jewel and the source of next season's transfer window tabloid rumour frenzy. That's a worry for another day though.

I was born and raised in Wigan and my mum still lives there. I've got a few mates who are Latics fans and they were sorry to see McCarthy go. All of them think he has the attributes to be a great player at Everton and that RM did really well managing him. Would like to see him in the team ahead of Osman.

If Lukaku can convert a decent percentage of the chances we'll create then I think we can do okay this season. I'm not sure where this leaves Jelavic but someone breathing down his neck can only be a good thing.

The biggest cause for celebration for me though was the retention of Baines. I'd genuinely be sorry to see him go. Fellaini served us well and I hope he gets a decent reception when he returns to Goodison but I don't think he'd be as bigger loss as if Leighton went.

The one thing about RM is that I think he'll pick his team according to the opposition. I see all of the squad playing a part this season.

For once, I think BK did okay last night but I'll be watching with interest what happens in January.

COYB.

Gary O'Connor
638 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:58:15
Andrew, he actually took the call in front of four journalists. I know Whelan is not trustworthy but I am more worried about the lies constantly emanating from Goodison.
Mark Taylor
639 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:47:06
Colin, I was picking up James' figures earlier on the numbers. Hopefully he is wrong and we are not picking up all Barry's wages and paid a £5m loan fee, but (not suprisingly) there aren't any sources spelling it out.

Incidentally, I agree with you re Fellaini going. I've no problem selling players to re-invest- just that for all the hot air, we don't normally do so. I've no bad feelings to him at all.

Actually, I don't share the bad feelings to OFM. Without any real financial support, he delivered excellent results over his time. Sadly, I doubt RM will exceed them. Obviously, he will tend to come back to his former club for players, just as RM has done to Wigan. Yes he was trying to screw us on the fee but that's his job now- or the MU board. That's how the world works, why would he do any different?

As it happens, his brinkmanship has well and truly exploded in his face and he, or they, look very stupid in not activating the release clause.

Jim Knightley
640 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:03:00
Come on guys, of course we are not paying all of Barry's wages. 120,000 a week?! us? He is surplus to requirements at City, and they wanted a buyer but couldn't find one. As a consequence letting him go to us on an Ade type wage deal made alot of sense...I'll be amazed if we are paying more than 70,000 a week for him, and I doubt we paid a loan fee either.

Let's use the money from last night in January to get some more youth into a team. I would love us to take a look at Holtby again. I also think a young cb is a necessity.

Robin Cannon
641 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:01:59
Overall it was a decent transfer deadline day. Which, from an Everton viewpoint, makes it bloody amazing compared to what we usually have to deal with.

While I definitely worry about the short-term I am of loans (we're not gonna get Lukaku permanently, however important he becomes), if they can push us on significantly this season then may be worth it.

Also, I'm pretty sure Barry is here to start. No real benefit to his moving in WC year unless it's to get regular football, not for us to pay that much for a reserve. Understandable, I think. To me, watching the pre season friendlies in the US, Gibson didn't actually look that comfortable with the new style of play.

I expect McCarthy/Barry as our deeper midfield two, with Barkley in the attacking role. Which actually is pretty good.

Max Murphy
642 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:02:23
Craig (#965) .... no, not really. My posting was a complete ruse. It was designed to ellicit fatuous comments from the more moronic contributors to TW.
It appears my experiment was a resounding success.
Ciarán McGlone
643 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:07:33
There were a few on here who said we'd get less for Felliani when the clause expired which never made any sense,

-----------------------

Steve,

It made perfect sense. It was a matter of opinion on who would blink first..given BK's history I think we can hardly be criticised for suggesting that we'd accept less than 23 for Fellaini...

As it stands, we've pulled Moyes pants down...Who in their right mind would put BK down as a shrewd negotiator - certainly not me..

However, we are yet to see the terms of the deal..no doubt it'll be 10 million up front and the rest on the drip...and aforesaid drip to include selling us Phil Neville again..

Andrew Ellams
644 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:12:22
Gary absolutely, but they are our problems to discuss in public or not as we choose and not his.

He is the man that pushed the club towards relegation with his budget cutting that meant Martinez had to make more severe cuts to his playing staff than Moyes ever did

Jim Knightley
645 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:07:07
Gary, we hardly time to invest money from Fellaini did we?

Prior to yesterday, we had probaly spent around 8-9mil on Kone, Robles, Def and Alcatraz in terms of loan fees, transfer fees and signing on fees. Plus Martinez's signing on fee. It's not good enough, but it's certainly better than it was a few seasons ago. I genuinely believe we are in a position now where we do not have to sell.

And of course McCarthy was dependent on Fellaini. We all know our financial position. But that we attempted to get him via installments, suggests there was a tiny bit of money there before the Fellaini departure.

Unfortunately, those above us, and immediately below us, outspend us, and will continue to outspend us. But, we've a good unit, and I think we will end January with a better squad than we ended last January with. I'm looking at this window as a big success, because whilst I'm sad to see him go, Fellaini's departure was inevitable...as stated in numerous threads before, I advocated selling him earlier in the window because he is the type of character who would request a transfer late in the window, whereas Baines isn't.

Ed Fitzgerald
646 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:11:24
Mark Taylor

Mark, What you cannot say at this stage is whether Martinez will do better than Moyes did Everton. Neither you or anybody else knows this at this stage. I would not classify Moyes tenure at Goodison as excellent to me, excellence would confer that we were regulalry in the mix for the top four and god forbid won something. I do think Moyes for the most part did a good job at Everton but that in his last few years he went a little stale and I was frustrated by his negative approach in many home games. He did get 11 years to get this right! I will settle for half the time for Martinez with some attractive football plesse and a trophy or two.

I think Martinez has just had a better transfer window than Moyes ever had and handled himself really well.

Kevin Tully
647 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:21:30
Do any statto's know if £13m is a record for a player from the Championship?

(Not saying it's a good thing, just curious)

Andy Whittingham
648 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:27:40
Wasn't Zaha about £15m?
Ian Burns
649 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:24:23
Well said Ed - 239 - some excellent comment on here this morning - as always a great read.

Mark - may I ask a question with regards to your own post on the accounts

. . . .two unanswered questions are who is the lender earning a handsome 8% securitised loan and what is covered by the £23m of 'Other operating costs). Neither are spelt out in the accounts.

As a shareholder, do you not have the right (indeed a duty these days) to know who is receiving the 8% interest payments and shouldn't the 23m of operating costs be clearly identified by the auditor and released to the shareholders?

Paul Melarange
650 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:24:40
Although it's disappointing Fellaini went, it's not a surprise; the funny thing is Moyes could have triggered the get-out clause 2 weeks ago and has paid £4 million extra! I'm made up we stuck to our guns here and also Baines stayed put!

I'm pleased with the incoming players, especially Lukaku, who scored plenty of goals on loan at West Brom. And we get £5 million for Victor who, apart from last season, has never looked a Premier League player.

Barry and McCarthy are decent signings and we have £19 million in the pot for January... or is that me being too optimistic and it will vanish in to the big black hole that other money went in??

Quite pleased overall with how it worked out yesterday; Up the Toffees!

Paul Martin
652 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:22:23
So happy we finally have a striker who actually knows how to score goals, even if it just for the season. Been trawling on a few Chelski forums and they are pretty pissed off Mourinho has let him go.

As our chances of signing Lukaku permanently are somewhere between a cat and a snowball, is it so unrealistic of me to think that in 12 months time a certain Mr Rooney may make a shock return?

If he refuses to sign a new contract, £8-10m would be a fair price for a 28-29 yr old with a year on his current contract.

Wages might be a stumbling block though, but im still having a sneaky tenner with the bookies

Harold Matthews
653 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:23:02
McCarthy and Fellaini went according to the script but the Lakaku and Victor deals were bolts from the blue. As for Barry. Well, I've always viewed him as someone I'd rather be with than against. We badly lack an "on the pitch leader" and he would fit the bill.

Disappointed we haven't properly replaced the big fella but am content to let Martinez carry on with whatever he has in mind .We still lack an athletic specialist DM and hope it doesn't cost us.

McCarthy seemed expensive but Martinez obviously sees him as a future star and he might prove to be a bargain.

The best deal was keeping Baines and hopefully the presence of Lakaku up front might stir Pienaar and Mirallis out of their general slumber.

All in all, not a bad night.

Ross Edwards
654 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:34:58
I think I will be handing over some money shortly to someone, because I can't keep my mouth shut can I, James Marshall?
Kevin Tully
655 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:33:49
Good one Andy - just looked at Zaha and it was a £10m with a further £5m due on appearances etc..

I wonder if we structured a similar deal for McCarthy? Can't see it being £13m with no clauses.

Denis Richardson
656 Posted 03/09/2013 at 12:39:04
Mark - the fee for Mcarthy may look too big but at the end of the day he's only 22. If he improves as expected by both club and national manager, then we should be able to get back most of that fee if we sell hijm when he's 25/26. Fee wise am happy with Mcarthy.

As for Barry, the guy is in the last year of his contract so we can presuambly arrange to sign him permantently in Jan, assuming he does well. He wont be earning anywhere near 120k in his next contract. Even if we're paying his contract in full, given there was no loan fee to city, we may be paying too much, but not that much. He will also be a hell of a lot more consistent than Gibson and may actually last more than 10 games without injury.

Martinez now has a very decent squad and has bought some time to find players for the future.

Lets hope Lukaku has a season like last year and we get two very decnt cup runs. League wise I think we'll finish 7th. The likes of Spurs, Arsenal, RS and Manu are too strong, winner will be city or chelsea imo.

One thing to look forward to is that I strongly believe manu will have a fight on their hands to finish in a CL place this year - nevermind winning!

Stuart Eaton
657 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:35:38
Thank god the window has shut and with 45 minutes to go we were looking like it was going to be the same old story but thankfully it wasnt.

I like the way Martinez has kept the £20 mil left over from the sale of Felliani and Anichebe for January to add a few more new faces.

Okay, I am dreaming — divide it by 10 maybe.

Harold Matthews
658 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:35:49
OK OK Just noticed it's not Lakaku...it's Lukaku.
Conn Prosser
659 Posted 03/09/2013 at 10:57:38
Can someone please talk me down.

This transfer window is closed only when Baines signs a new lucrative contract. Until then I strongly fear that Fellaini's 'wonderful' transfer fee is linked to a paltry swoop for Baines by Man Utd in January.

This isn't over; the Mancs know what they're doing, as does Moyes of our books. Never forget, Bill Kenwright is a scheister of the highest order.

There will also be no more funds left over in January, as accounted for by Dan Nulty's excellent summary of our P&L this summer.

Ross Edwards
660 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:44:49
We can just call him Rom, Harold. It will make things a lot easier for us all.
Gary O'Connor
661 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:33:26
I think we did good business yesterday overall. Mccarthy is exactly the type of midfielder we needed,although the fee was high. He is durable, tactically aware and most important the right age. By all accounts his major problem is confidence but instilling confidence seems to be a strength of Martinez. I still feel that the timing of the Fellaini deal did not matter in terms of reinvestment as that money will not be seen again. If everyone knows our financial position why the constant spin and lies. We are a feeder club for the big boys at this stage and no matter the business done yesterday the board are still a disgrace.
Anthony Lamb
662 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:40:58
This thread is really amazing. It seems that the overwhelming majority of comments relate to things that I am sure very few — if any — have absolutely any definitive knowledge of whatsoever. Namely the terms of contractual deals involving the players and the clubs concerned.

On the other hand, the abilities of particular players; the wisdom of the signings; the implications for team selection, formation etc — that is another matter... After all, these are things that we are all absolute authorities on, aren't we... So let's have more of the latter and put this other crazy guesswork to bed eh!?

Steven Scaffardi
663 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:50:44
Despite the cost for McCarthy, I'm really pleased we've got him. I listen to The Times podcast quite a bit, and Gabriele Marcotti was forever singing his praises, and would often say he was good enough to play for the top 4. I haven't seen enough of the lad myself, but if he is as good as they rave about then we've got ourselves a really good little player.
Darren Gough
664 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:51:01
Most positive transfer window in yonks.

Attacking class in, experienced campaigner and trophy winner, promising prospect, Baines kept and Fellaini oversold to United.

Don't understand the "but they're only loans" comments. So what? Contracts mean little in the real world, and any of our players could go elsewhere in any transfer window. If the loan players help bring us a trophy, our best Prem league finish or something better than we've had under Moyes and then leave - what's wrong with that? History will show only the result.

My main happiness comes from the fact we didn't end up signing 17 "backup" keepers.....

Bob Skelton
665 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:16:38
Went to bed really unhappy, hating BK and everyone associated with the transfer farce that appeared to be unfolding (10:30 pm). Woke up at 3:00 am and checked all of the sports outlets. Started smiling. 3 good signings, especially Lukaku - we've needed a proper centre forward for years. All that possession no end product.

Was impressed by how Fellaini conducted himself, great professional who I will miss, Anichibe not too bothered about (fear for WBA now) and I have nothing but praise for Baines. He never agitated for a move and in my opinion is a true Blue. Please give him a new contract he deserves it. He stands out amongst a sea of greedy mercenaries.

I'm a bit ambivalent towards Moyes. I'd like to believe that he deliberately fouled up the transfer so that we would get the extra £4.5M and is really helping his former club but then I remember all of our last day transfer shenanigans and I think its just the normal way he works.

A happy Blue boy.....

Kev Johnson
666 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:02:04
Amongst all the transfer to-ing and fro-ing, we've also caught a glimpse of the new third kit, which I really really like!

Can we have a new thread on this please Mr Kenrick, sir?

Nelly Verdonghan
667 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:51:34
Everybody seems to be forgeting that it was widely reported over the weekend that Barry was prepared to take a wage CUT to come to us... so I doubt very much if we’re paying his £120k a week.
Phil Sammon
668 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:05:02
Me too, Kev. Very nice.

Although it could be problematic having three rather blue kits.

Niven Teh
669 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:08:59
Is Lukaku allowed to play againts parent club Chelsea?
James Marshall
670 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:07:28
The rest of the footballing population seems to think we did extremely well yesterday, so any dissenters would appear to be in the minority. I'm on the side of the fence that actually gives a bit of kudos to Kenwright & co today.

They stood their ground and made the right choices for a change, and just for once it feels as though we've improved our squad.

We have 7 players in, 2 out, (3 if you count Junior, I don't), we held Man Utd to ransom over Fellaini, and drafted in a quality striker. What's not to like?

Andrew Ellams
671 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:11:11
Perhaps the answer to the Barry salary question is we are paying 100% of his reduced wages
Christopher Kelly
672 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:12:24
Still can't believe we got up to £6m for Anichebe!

Has to be one of the best pieces of business I've seen in a while.

The Fellaini deal is good too but % wise he was dealt probably 10% over tag.

Mark Taylor
673 Posted 03/09/2013 at 13:54:01
Ian 242

Depends on how big your shareholding (and possibly, the articles) but if you own less than 5%, you basically have no rights. In essence, you just get sent the company info and have a right to vote on resolutions (articles allowing) but not to put forward one.

Obviously you also have the right to any dividends and the basic right of not being treated unfairly with regards to your investment.

Graham Cass
674 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:19:10
I think Bainesy should get a standing ovation at the next home game, must have been tempted but didn't push for a move. True pro. Loyalty means a lot.
Ian Burns
675 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:23:19
Thanks Mark, the explanation is appreciated.
Mark Taylor
676 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:21:20
Denis249

I would take 7th right now.

As I've said before, I think we are stronger now in player talent than before the season but if I am to praise our board's negotiation skills for selling, I'm sticking with being critical over the buying skills- but that is assuming we really are paying all Barry's wages and the big loan fee. I'd actually be suprised if we were, it was another poster's claim.

I think my biggest criticism was that if McCarthy was going to happen anyway (as the club seemingly claim), how come we had no other purchases lined up for the Fellaini money? Fernando looked like a last day bit of hedging in case Whelan said no. I don't believe we were in to buy anyone else.

James Martin
677 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:22:29
Is this what a proper squad looks like? First time I've seen one of these in years. 22 first team players with youth supplementing them

Howard/Joel
Coleman/Hibbert Jagielka/Heitinga Distin/Alcaraz Baines/Oviedo
Gibson/Barry McCarthy/Osman
Mirallas/Deulofeu Barkley/ Naismith Pienaar/Gueye (ok ok..)
Lukakau/Kone/Jelavic

Maybe another left sided player was all that was missing for a perfectly balanced squad. Martinez has clearly addressed the problem we have always had in that our squad has been too small. Yes, he's raided Wigan but in Alcaraz and Robles we picked up two quality players for very little indeed to bolster the squad.

Getting two players of similar quality could well have blown a lot of our transfer budget. He's basically swapped Anichebe and a million for Kone (we all would've, regardless of how he's done in his first three games), Fellaini for McCarthy and £15million, and Lukaku, Barry, Deulofeu, Alcaraz and Robles in for practically nothing. Good business in my eyes and this squad looks a lot healthier now. Now hopefully the whole team wont fall apart if we get an injury to Gibson or Pienaar like it used to...

Ross Edwards
678 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:34:58
I think the people who moaned last night about McCarthy and Barry aren't looking at the bigger picture. We have much more depth in the middle than we did previously.

Robbie wasn't wrong. He said that we would end the window in a stronger position.

Kevin Tully
679 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:37:58
From F365 winner's section ;

Everton
A brilliant deadline day and an impressive transfer window overall. It seems a long time since those early fears at Roberto Martinez signing three of Wigan's relegated squad.

The fourth such signing, James McCarthy, is clearly worthy of a place at a Premier League club and Everton will probably look at their £13million investment as a figure they can double in a few years' time should the midfielder continue to develop at the current rate. The Romelu Lukaku signing is the real gem, though, and the striker's arrival will prove crucial in the Toffees improving their fortunes in front of goal. He is a player who can get results in the short term while Martinez keeps one eye on the long-term transition to his preferred playing style.

A loan deal for Gareth Barry is another astute piece of business while Gerard Deulofeu is an exciting wildcard from Barcelona. And all for a net profit after Manchester United and West Brom went silly on Marouane Fellaini and Victor Anichebe.

Gerry Killen
680 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:40:28
Thanks, Bill and Roberto; great deals... Well Done, Blues!!!

Good luck to Victor and Felli, they served us well, but time time to go. We have got a stronger defence and goal-hungry forwards — brilliant!

Just one thing: I believe the window should close on the First of July. The way things are now, clubs are mortgaging their future with over-priced players, the main people who benefit are the agents and the banks!

Dan Parker
681 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:39:27
I have to same I'm chuffed with the window. Whilst we'll miss Felli, he did start to look dis-interested and he's been discussing his 'future' for a couple of seasons now. Good business selling big Vic after a series of failed opportunities to impress. Martinez starting to bring in his own players and beefing up the squad size.

I was worried we'd lose Felli and have a huge gap in the team, BK pulled out a whopper and signed a few players.

And we kept Bainsey.

Excellent stuff.

Now the hard part, turn those signings into goals and wins...

Matthew Leighton
682 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:37:41
Does anyone know if Gareth Barry can play against Manchester City? Similarly Romelu Lakaku against Chelsea?

Sorry to be pessimistic but I bet they can't so anymore than 2 points from four fixtures and we will have had a touch.

I still have concerns we are picking up the scraps from other current Premier League sides or ex-Premier League sides. It's not too many years ago when we were on a par with Spurs, now we seem to be compared with Norwich, Swansea, Cardiff, West Brom et al.

It would have been nice to get our business done earlier. I'm not convinced we have / had the cash other than the five million we spent on Wigan's elite before we saw the money for Fellaini. Now that there's a chunk left over, I suspect that will vanish into thin air and we may end up losing Baines in January when the window opens again.

Simon Smith
684 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:49:00
Usually as a rule loan players cannot play against the club that they are on loan from.
Think it something to do with the leagues rules, but might be wrong
Paul Ferry
685 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:25:48
You would not have expected to be reading this at 10-00 last night eh?

http://news.ladbrokes.com/en-gb/football/premier-league/everton-show-other-prem-clubs-how-deadline-day-should-be-done_170747.html

Some of the Doubting Thomas's on here sometimes seem to have the appearance of just wanting to be well Doubting Thomas's so kudos to Phil Walling.

We are a stronger outfit this minute than we were this minute yesterday; Felli handed himself well when all is said and done and he was never going to fit into new styles (and for once we bartered and battered the red devils: £500k less than the joint 'derisory offer' — deary me).

All the best to one and all.

Ken Crowther
686 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:10:39
Staggered at how many of you blokes "went to bed at 10:30pm", you're either very young or very, very old!
Ian Gallagher
687 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:37:06
I have been supporting Everton for 29 years, and have been following this website for as long as I can remember having the internet. Over the last few years, I've become frustrated at the negativity that exists on these message boards, but I've always respected the opinions of the many genuine Evertonians on the site.

But right now, I've had enough of this bullshit, some of the comments I've seen over the last few days are quite frankly the most stupid things I've ever read!

Fellaini quite clearly wanted to leave the club, and the fact that we sold him for £4M more than his release clause is a brilliant bit of business, and allows us to close the transfer window with 1 starting XI player sold and 7 brought in! What do you people expect from the club???

Comments such as "Kenwright and Martinez are intent on dragging the club down. The demise of the club is well and truly on" are so fucking stupid that they make the majority of toffees look like absolute retards! Get a grip, get behind the team, and put your energy into actually supporting the boys on the Goodison pitch!!

Ben Jones
688 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:53:25
I think the Barry signing is understated here.

Because we don't have a proper holding midfielder at the moment. Barry can be that player this season. And then it means Osman wont play that role, and can play further up the pitch where he is far more effective.

McCarthy has good traits about him. What I like about him is he does not have many weaknesses and he's got great energy about him. What I'm worried is that he should be dominating games more, and I hope Martinez can coax that out of him. He has the potential to be our new Arteta.

Gibson to come in, and our midfield looks particularly strong. It's going to be interesting what midfield is picked for the Chelsea game.

Kevin Rowlands
689 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:02:19
Jim Knightely #233, you mention in the post that you believed a young CB was/is a necessity, I think you'll find that we already have one mate, his name is John Stones, he's going to be a big time player.
Nelly Verdonghan
690 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:01:08
Ben #284..."...Because we don’t have a proper holding midfielder at the moment. Barry can be that player this season. And then it means Osman won’t play that role and can play further up the pitch where he is far more effective...."

Perhaps it means that the role Osman will play most feffectively is that of substitute...IMO Ossie has been a good servant over the years but with his last few performances it is clear to the majority that he should be used as no more than a squad player

Sam Hoare
691 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:05:37
The only trouble with loans is that you can pay a lot of money but not have any asset at the end of it. Reports vary but some say we are paying all of Barry's wages, about £6m and that we paid Chelsea a £5m fee for loaning Lukaku.

That's potentially £11M on two players who may not be here next season which places a lot of pressure on them to do well. Not complaining but just shows where some of the money from the Fellaini sale may be going.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
692 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:04:58
Ian (#283), It's a bit of an over-reaction to say someone who makes a comment you disagree with is making the majority of toffees look like retards.

If you've really been reading this site all that long, you should know that Evertonians do not all think the same about anything. If you are going to post, at least please have some respect for that.

Challenge the false thinking by all means and state your case, but don't descend into name-calling, please.

Tony Draper
693 Posted 03/09/2013 at 14:46:31
Just read that OFM's attempt to bring in Coentrao did not go through, meaning the signing of Fellaini was the only big signing at OT during the window.

All the more thankful that the consummate professional Leighton Baines remains an Everton player. Now definitely get a contract worthy of him signed up with immediate effect.

Colin Glassar
694 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:13:14
I agree with Ben Jones, the signing of Barry could be very important. He goes about his game in a silent, effective way. He breaks up the opponents play and can start counter attacks. He's not flashy but he is effective and he's been highly thought of by many of the country's top managers over the years and has played under O'Neil, Hughes, Mancini, Sven, Roy, Capello and now under Martinez. Remember both fergie and Benitez were also after him so all these people must see something special in him. Like I said, he could be the catalyst in our MF.
Gerry Quinn
695 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:08:03
Well said Ian Gallagher #283 - totally agree.

Good to see that there are those that support their team and management with a truly positive mindset. For example, the Live Match Forum seems to bring out some of the most negative comments - some to the stage where I sit back and wonder how people actually get on in their day to day lives as they seem to be so negative and depressing. Last season it got to the stage, on more than one occasion, that I typed a "Karma " towards the end of the match when we may have been 1 down. Despite the waves of abject negativity, in my mind we will never be out of it.

Brighten up and never forget that we ARE Evertonians, and we should be proud of that.

Graham Mockford
696 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:11:49
I missed all the drama of last night due to being on a delayed flight in the US. When I finally connected I was genuinely surprised and happy especially as when I boarded it was looking like a typical transfer deadline non-event.

Whichever way you want to look at it, I think it is hard to argue that the squad is not stronger today than it was yesterday. It also seems we have brought in three players who will fit into the Martinez style. McCarthy has been playing it for a number of years, Barry is a solid dependable pro who is a genuine holding midfield player who was good enough to win a PL and get capped by numerous managers (a new Phil Neville!!) and most importantly a centre forward who offers movement, pace and power which we have sadly lacked.

Add to this we got top dollar for both Vic and Fellaini and I may be in the minority but I genuinely don't think we have overpaid for McCarthy. Don't forget, if he does prove to be a quality PL player, being only 22, he could be worth an awful lot more in two or three years time. That is why promising young players attract a premium. You are effectively investing in their future potential value, whereas someone like Fellaini at 26 has reached their maximum value.

Christopher Timmins
697 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:17:03
Martinez has performed well in his first transfer window as manager of Everton.

McCarthy and Barry strenghten the mid field sector and Lukaku a major plus upfront.

The departures went for big money and the both gave the impression on occassions that they were not all that bothered.

The Wigan cup tie last season was probably the end for the Belgium midfielder.

Stronger now than at the end of last season. Lets turn it into results on the pitch.

Nelly Verdonghan
698 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:14:47
Can’t understand why so many of being critical of yesterday’s deadline dealings....I’ve never been a lover of Kenwright.... in fact I’ve posted some very harsh things about him on here but can’t critise him for yesterday

As for Martinez...he’s trying his best to get the team to play attacking football and to get as far away from HOOFBALL (a la TGT) and a style of play that won FUCK ALL in 11yrs...obviously he has noticed that there has been no end product from either Jeli or Kon’ead up to now, so what does he go and do....only goes and gets potentially the best young striker in the Premiership and off loads Big Vic to boot...what’s to critise

So for all you doom & gloom merchants...stop fuckin moaning and just enjoy the fact that we have made 3 very good signings...off loaded one player who obviously no longer wanted to play for us and another who was absolutely shite..and made a tidy profit in the process !!...there’s just no pleasing some people.

Yesterday also proved that TGT is very much out of his depth when it comes to being in charge of Man Ure’s transfer dealings....hope he runs them into the ground...hahahaha

Ian Burns
699 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:27:50
Well said Mr Kenrick - 291 - We Evertonians are passionate with often strong but healthy differences of opinion. The word "retard" doesn't belong on this site, particularly in reference to fellow Evertonians who are expressing a feeling for the good of the club, even if some of us may see their point of view as in opposition to our own.
Kevin Tully
700 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:32:02
Only 17 weeks until we can do it all again!
Denis Richardson
701 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:51:29
Fook - just realised there are no games this weekend!

Bollocks!

Oh well - at least RM has a few days to bed in the new non-internationals.

Kevin Rowlands
702 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:50:32
Sporting life have a good column up right now on the winners and losers in the transfer window, they have us and the RS both in the winner column and the ginger genius well and truly in the loser column, to be honest if I was a Man Utd fan I be fucking furious that we paid 27 plus for Fellaini when we could have got him for 23 only a month ago, how that was allowed to happen beggars belief.
Ken Crowther
703 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:45:34
Ian Gallagher #283 - Well said.

OK, presumably Michael's word of censure was aimed at the use of the word "retard", a censure which I don't really understand; but I suppose is part of he broad spectrum of political correctness (which I don't understand either) - it must be my age.

Well supported by Gerry Quinn #295 - respect!

Whaddya know, there's me doing a bit of 'street', perhaps I'm younger than I thought.

Ian Burns
704 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:00:11
Ken - 309 - Nothing wrong with the opinion of Ian 283 and nothing wrong with Gerry's support 295 - their opinions (and your own obviously) are valid and carry opinions which many on here would support - it is the word "retards" which is offensive, politically correct or not.
Anthony Flack
705 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:01:22
James 271 - looks a bit light on strikers, maybe Vellios as well, could Kennedy come into the frame. I suspect we will see Miralles pushed forward if we get injuries - maybe even Gueye who I am surprised was not moved on.

PS re. Ian (283) I have been called a "cXnt" on here and that was not censured - I think Ian's points are well made as is Michael's gentle guidance.... - message just as strong without resort to risque non PC language - "thick bastards" might have been fine ....!!!

James Stewart
706 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:08:41
If we are paying all of Barry's 120k per week wages that is anything but an astute signing in my opinion. Thats a complete waste of resources.
Harold Matthews
707 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:58:00
Tony D. Agreed, Baines was the big one for us. For DM it was Rooney.
Ken Crowther
708 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:07:31
Ian #312 - I bow to the apparent consensus that "retard" is unacceptable.

In my primary/junior school (Banks Road, in Garston - 1945/52 ) we had a section for 'non-standard' kids. Children who were 'challenged' in all kinds of ways. They were referred to, universally, as "the Special School". Would that be more acceptable?

James Marshall
709 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:14:56
James - Gareth Barry agreed to a cut in wages to join us so even if we're paying 100% of his wages, it's not £120k a week.

Nobody anywhere online or at either club, or the player has said we're paying him £120k a week.

John Crawley
710 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:07:47
Sam 290 - I agree with your comments regardings Loans, certainly not the way to go in the long term. I would think Anchibe's sale has effectively paid for Lukaku's loan fee and a bit of it towards Barry's wages. I heard that City are paying a third of them.

Being positive about it I would hope that the loans signings give us a bit of time to line up permanent replacements with the balance of the Fellaini money either in January or next summer. On a footballing basis I think Barry & Lukaku will prove to be good short term deals. Hopefully in a year or so maybe Lundstram will be ready to break into the first team like Barkley has done this year. On balance you would have to say that the squad is stronger than it was when Martinez took over BUT Bill has to cough up the rest of Fellaini's fee to Martinez in January or next summer.

James Marshall
711 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:19:38
John - Barry will be out of contract when his loan expires with us. In fact his City contract expires in June 2014 so he might well stay with us for free.

Lukaku for one season, is worth Victor for 5, easy!

Lakovos Lasonidis
712 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:42:47
Just informed, and I have to say by reading this blog I get the best information there is! coloured and biased - just the way I like it!
Anichebe - I am speechless with this one, top piece of business! 6 mil? let's keep it between us...
Barry - I believe he will be helpfull, not very excited with this one, but I hope he will prove me wrong! If we pay all his wages it would be criminal though...
Lukaku - to bad he is on a loan, He will be our main striker I think. Makes Kone signing look a bit of a failure...
Mc carthy - a lot of talent, a lot of potential...a lot of money! Personally I would preffer fernando but who cares? again I hope he will prove me wrong
Fellaini - He was destined to go, good transfer sum( fuck off Moyes!). If we kept him I believe he would never play 100% again for us
Robles - Better than mucha, I don't know if he is good enough for 1st, maybe is too soon, but I like howard feeling the pressure...
delofueu - Top player, as with lukaku, it is a pitty he is only on loan...
kone - it will be hard to convince me that 6 mil were well spent...again I hope he will prove me wrong...( high hopes I have it seems...)
Alcaraz - Can't say a thing! No comment yet!

All in all it was an interesting transfer period...I would love honda, fernando and indi, it would be great! Honda especially because after arteta we are in pain in the creativity area.It seems we are stronger than we were before but this has to be shown in the grass...
If only delofueu and lukaku were permanent...i would be on the moon!
I hope (again) that there will be money for a top transfer in january.
Good luck to all of them and stay healthy!

Andrew Ellams
713 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:31:01
McCarthy's fee can be judged in May. If he is garbage then we can maybe point fingers, if he looks like he is going to be the business(still need to remember his age) then he may look a bargain
Jim Knightley
714 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:40:15
I like the like of Stones Kevin, but he is very young, and at the end of the season Heitinga will go, Distin will be 36 and likely retired, leaving us with Jags, Alcaraz, Stones and Duffy... well below the necessary standard imo. I thought Alderweireld could have been an answer, but we will have to look elsewhere now.
Tony Draper
715 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:19:54
Kevin Rowlands 308

Good heads up on that Sporting Life article, thanks

I agree with a great deal of the content, interesting odds they tagged onto the clubs they'd analysed

The BBC Article on mufc's failed signing of Fabio Coentrao (http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/23941584) is only of interest for the probable return of mufc for Leighton Baines but has links regarding their "under performance" this window (one from "The Guardian" and one from a "vile tory rag").

Two papers with widely different attitudes normally, but reading both it's very difficult not to hear the (predictable) sharpening of knives if an ex-Everton employee struggles at OT.

The comments regarding Everton's transfers are likewise encouraging.

I cite these 3 articles not solely to take vicarious pleasure in anothers lack of success (note I hesitate to class as failure), but because as Harold M (319) astutely points out mufc wisely retained Wayne Rooney. Itself a particularly good piece of business for which dm & mufc receive little acknowledgement

Harold and I are in clear accord that retaining Baines was good.
Securing him with a "rewarding" contract well beyond the next few transfer opportunities is now "To Priority".

The Coentrao failure only accentuates the determination and speed required to secure Bainesy, or this matter could soon return to bite hard !

Kevin Rowlands
716 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:35:07
Without doubt the strongest squad we have ever had in the premiership, personally I'm not going to worry about whether some of them are loans, just enjoy this season watching them, a priority I hope will be signing Baines to a long term improved deal in the next few weeks, that would be great.

On another note, with Utd being a publically traded company surely somebodies feet are being held to the fire today after signing Fellaini for 4 million more than you could have got him only a month ago, I wouldn't be surprised to see that Woodward fella being out of a job real soon.

Tom Evans
717 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:36:57
Ken #282. In my case it was like a mother calling her lad in for his tea, or should I say, screaming at him.
In my case it was my missus who to be fair, had not seen a great deal of me from 0730 that morning as I was more or less glued to the seat I am in now. Discretion being the better part of valour, I conceded, switched my PC off then went and put SSN on, and told her to fuckoff to bed!!
Colin Glassar
718 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:35:16
Dennis #307, how many non-internationals do we have at ff this week? Hibbo, Gibson, Alcaraz, Ossie, Barry, Robles? Not even enough for a five-a-side methinks.
Ian Burns
719 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:40:09
Ken - 321 - I wasn't trying to be censorious - who am I to be a policeman on this site? - I was only trying to point out we are all Evertonians in healthy discussion with differences of opinion without anybody having to feel offended.
Tony Draper
720 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:43:38
* meant "Top Priority" sorry !
Richard Reeves
721 Posted 03/09/2013 at 15:45:17
It was inevitable that Fellaini would be sold at the last minute with McCarthy and a couple of loans coming in along with a large amount of cash being recouped and going God knows where but that is another story.

I was surprised but happy to see Baines stay, I did think he would go as well and although I wouldn't have a problem if he was sold as long as Martinez could have the money to spend on his targets I know there would be very little chance of that happening so this is the best result in my opinion.

I'm glad we got McCarthy, I reckon he's so important to how Martinez wants us to play, keeping the ball on the ground, short passes, composed when under pressure and in tight situations and isn't afraid to get stuck in and break up play, I think he'll be good for us. Lukaku was a bit of a surprise but a very good addition,Martinez definitely identifies positions that we are weak in with the goals department being probably the most important due to the lack of goals so far and the sale of Fellaini (which would loose us maybe 10 goals a season).I'm just hoping Lukaku has a great season and finds it impossible to want to play for anyone else after being with us,maybe there would be a chance of us signing him,what with Chelsea's money and hopefully more glamorous targets.

I wasn't to bothered about Barry when there was all the speculation but maybe he is important due to his experience,it's just that the last few occasions I saw him play I thought he looked very slow and way past his best.

Oh... yeh, I almost forgot, selling Anichebe was another positive and forward step from our manager, but everything he's done so far has been positive and progressive, I'm loving what he's trying to do. Our defence is quite tight and we're dominating games it terms of possession, if we get the strikers on form, then we'll be a real threat to anyone.

Overall, I think we've done good business but only because of the players that Martinez has identified, the last minute dealing so that money can be held back just leaves a bit of negativity to what has been mainly positive.

Drew Shortis
722 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:30:07
Looking at this summer as a whole it is very clear that we have a much stronger set of players and possibly a much better team as in the correct players for the system. I worked it out on a like for like basis.

IN: Roubles OUT: Mucha
IN: Alcaraz OUT: Neville
IN: McCarthy OUT: Fellaini
IN: Barry OUT: Hitzelsperger
IN: Kone, Deulofeu, Lukaku OUT: Anichebe
RETAINED: Baines
PROGRESSED: Barkley

As you can see there has been an increase in quality in nearly every position, plus we have two extra attacking players and Barkley who is being given a chance, so the numbers are better too. There is talk of Deulofeu's loan lasting past this season, and if Barry does well he can stay on for free.

The biggest task for Martinez now will be to find a striker to take over from Lukaku next year. I hope Kenwright keeps his word and gives Roberto all of the profits from the transfers to re-invest. If we can make the most of Deulofeu and Lukaku and grab a European spot we will be a much more attractive destination for potential recruits.

After several weeks of anxiety I'm feeling positive again. The loss of Fellaini is nowhere near as painful as I had feared and to get the striker we so desperately needed is the icing on the cake. Well done to the Board, keep this up and you might win over the sceptics. Might!

Gerry Quinn
723 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:47:08
Sorry guys, although I agreed with Ian #283, I did forget to add that name calling on here is extremely childish and unnecessary, and I totally agree with MK for reminding all and sundry of it. We can all agree to disagree, but leave the playtime antics behind, please.

Now, who's for a game of footie?
Bagsie I am Lukaku...

Andrew Ellams
724 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:53:20
Stones is top quality and will be pushing for a regular place sooner rather than later. I reckon any cash left over from yesterday that will be available in January will be spent on finding him a long term defensive partner.

This is all about baby steps right now and a couple of handy loan deals that help push the team forward in the meantime is no bad thing.

Colin Glassar
725 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:56:32
Is it true the Saudis have bought Sheffield united? If so, wtf!!
Derek Knox
726 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:48:09
Kevin (#334)

It is quite possible that ' Edward Woodward ' could and should be 'equalised' over the Fellaini deal. Something tells me that Moyes was very much to do with the lateness of the deal too. After all, he has got 'previous' with his dealings when he was with us. I don't know if it was his smugness, or he actually thought he was some sort of master tactician, but either way it has backfired, both on him and Man. U.

It is hardly surprising, that their fans are not too happy, and already lamenting the loss of SAF.

Tony Draper
727 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:55:32
Good posting Drew (341).

The closing sentiment ?
Erm ......think you might wanna "chew on that particular lump of gristle".

Gerry Quinn
728 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:59:00
Colin, I posted on this earlier, and then looked it up on local Sheffield sites. Apparently this Prince has been connected with Sheff Utd for about 10 years, so it is no surprise that he is now into spending money on them. Well done, and good luck to Davey Weir, his team and their long suffering sets of fans. have no issues with that takeover, and can see why we weren't in with a shout on that one.
Kevin Day
729 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:55:09
I've not read all the posts on this thread, just don't have the time, and I'm sure it's already been said, but Baines has been totally amazing throughout the whole transfer window, there was a point last night where I thought to myself, if he puts in a transfer request through lack of ambition from the club then I really wouldn't of blamed him at all. Top top man!
Brent Stephens
730 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:55:09
Drew - and I would add COMING THROUGH THE DOOR - Stones.
Colin Glassar
731 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:01:52
Fair do's to them Gerry, I just can't understand why nobody is interested in even investing in us.
Brent Stephens
732 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:03:31
Derek, papers say it was more Woodward to blame.
Gerry Quinn
733 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:05:04
I am madly interested in investing in us, Colin, but am flat stone broke 24/7!
Bill Gall
734 Posted 03/09/2013 at 16:58:05
Happy but suprised at the outcome of the transfer window.

As expected Fallaini left but pleased we kept hold of Baines.

Hopefully the profit from our outgoing players does not disappear down the black hole and funds are available in January if the team needs strengthenig.

Gerry Quinn
735 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:06:50
Lukaku told the Belgian press: “I’m really happy with this transfer to Everton. I don’t know who has told the press I was unhappy with this loan.”

“It was a crazy evening. Different clubs called me and I had to take the right decision. Roberto Martinez called me for 30 minutes and explained me what he expects from me. I decided that Everton was the best choice. A more prominent club than West Brom where I had a good time. Also (Jose) Mourinho talked to me, but what he told me is confidential.”

Make you wonder what Mourinho had to say about Everton?

Barry Rathbone
736 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:11:00
Jose loves us and hates the RS, probably told him to come here and twat the RS in the derby.
Lakovos Lasonidis
737 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:09:57
I totally agree
Kevin Day
350
Lakovos Lasonidis
738 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:12:41
Out of place comment but nice third kit...
Tony Draper
739 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:06:22
Brent (354), I also read that Ewar Woowar (old joke I know but still makes me laugh) is highly trusted by the Glazer family. EW's previous role has been bringing money in rather than spending it.

Also, it appears that it was EW's recommendation that mufc not continue to pursue Lord Leighton of Baines as well as Fellaini for risk not acquiring either player.

Other articles are far less complimentary and virtually accuse the pair of them as borderline incompetent tightwads.

Keeping the massive steamroller that is mufc public opinion happy ?
(Remember these people CHOSE mufc in order to become associated with eternal success and instant gratification, not because they want to wait through the lean years !).

Different scale I know, but Allardyce at barcodes ?

Bad starts take some serious mending and are rarely forgotten, by capricious fans.

Let's see how long "The Theatre of Prawns" stand steadfastly by "The (badly) Chosen One" ?

Kevin Tully
740 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:04:41
There is really only Baines & Jagielka who are guaranteed a start with the current squad. We have been crying out for some competition for places, especially in midfield.

Heard a player saying today that they train harder, and it's more enjoyable when you know you have been chosen to play because of the effort you have made in matches & in training.

Once OFM found players who he was happy with, he would stand by them no matter how they performed. He was very reluctant to freshen the squad, as any sales were forced upon him.

I can't see him flogging Anichebe and bringing in Lukaku, can you?

Over to you now Roberto.

Colin Glassar
741 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:19:23
Jose told Lukaku that Martinez plays football, Clark playes Moyesball. Joking aside, Mourinho probably thought a different philosophy and style would help him improve his game. Weren't we linked to Lukaku about three years ago when he was still in Belgium? I think Felli and Mirallas might've had a word with him as well. Felli has spoken very well of us today.
Ross Kerry
742 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:26:00
The loans show that Chelsea and Man City clearly discount any possibility that we might challenge them in the league. I say we will, partly to avoid being reprimanded by better Evertonians on this site for not getting behind the team, and I wonder if the loan agreements can be withdrawn when we're pulling clear of them? Now it might be that they can both join us in the CL places, but if we can only get fourth and either were chasing us in fifth is that something they could do?
Brent Stephens
743 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:25:05
Tony #365 "Let's see how long 'The Theatre of Prawns' stand steadfastly by 'The (badly) Chosen One'?"

Haven't laughed so much since... well, last night.

Brent Stephens
744 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:29:40
Kevin #366. And Coleman also a guaranteed starter?
Wayne Smyth
745 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:23:31
Drew(341) pretty much nails it for me.

Please recall recent transfer windows when our loans have consisted of McFadden, Straq or Hitz.

Lukaku and Barry are significantly better than what we have, we've lost a moaning player who was looking for a way out and gained an upcoming youngster who will be in our midfield for years to come.

Anichebe was a great piece of business. Although he improved last season, he was still way short of where he needs to be.

If all that wasn't good enough, hopefully RM will have 10-15M more to spend in Jan and will be able to take his time over who he gets. The fact we were after the superbly rated Fernando gives me a warm feeling that RM is looking at the correct calibre of players to bring in.

Carl Sanderson
746 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:30:30
Drew 341:

Not a bad analysis, that. The comparison between McCarthy and Fellaini is problematical since they are not like for like. McCarthy will be suited to Martinez's system in that he will be more useful in mopping up when we are hit on the counter.

I remain of the view that Barry is an overrated, over-aged, overweight crab.

Tony Draper
747 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:31:06
Brent(369)
I agree, last night was a proper laugh
The "Dave Whelan Pantomime" was just choice
The "Tin of Ronseal" sealed the deal.......I'm stll laughing every time I think about that !

My mate is a diehard Citeh fan and he says Barry "makes a difference".

Same guy (knows bugger all about music) also reckons that the Citeh fans have a new song based on "Wonderwall" ! TBH the original lyrics look like SAF wrote them to sing to dm with hardly a word needing altering as they stand !

Killer line:
"And after all, you never won fuck all !"

Mark Taylor
748 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:22:40
As one of the chief naysayers on here, just to be clear, I think the short term squad quality is much improved. The post by Drew 341 is a good summary and although I'd have the direct comparisons as Barry to Neville and Kone to Vic, then it is pretty clear we are better than we were, if we accept that we had basically lost Fellaini a while ago.

If Lukaku had been a permanent signing for the £18-20m he apparently would fetch, then it would have been a superb window for us short or longer term and I'd have far less to criticise. As it is, the basic fact is we've banked another very large wedge and that is what hacks me off, especially when the board and Chairman are currently claiming they aren't doing this.

John Crawley
749 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:22:15
Brent 354 - that's because Moyes is briefing them! Sam Wallace wrote an article in the independent backing Moyes's stance on bidding for Fellaini and Baines. In that article he stated that Moyes & Woodward both thought they could get Fellaini for less than his release clause. The pair of them made a serious miscalculation, as did some of the people on this site! So much for their weekly talks, I do wonder if that was just bullshit on Moyes's behalf.
Kevin Tully
750 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:40:03
Don't know Brent, from what I have seen from Stones, he could be pushing Seamus in 6 months if he doesn't keep his form up.
John Crawley
751 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:42:34
Mark - I agree with that. I think we should have been looking to sign somebody like Lukaku for £18-20 million. That would have shown some ambition with a minimal positive net spend. As it is we have brought in more than we've spent and had an extra £20 million tv revenue.
Colin Glassar
752 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:43:47
Does that mean Sam Wallace won't be getting his brown envelope from man u, John? He was very vocal backing the mancs getting both our lads on the cheap saying we were being ridiculous asking for more money. Well Sam Wallace, I have lost all respect for you. You are nothing more than a mercenary.
Tony Draper
753 Posted 03/09/2013 at 17:45:36
Carl 373
My reading of Brent's comments weren't that McCarthy for Fellaini was a better vs worse comparison, more of a.......one in one out

Completely accept that Fellaini has loads more about him in several midfield (or even target) applications and lent himself to wherever he was played.

McCarthy is 22 and has played for Roberto for 4 years
Fellaini is 26 and has played for dm for 5 years

If Roberto is as confident about McCarthy as dm is about Fellaini then "Old Ronseal Legs" agreed price could look like "chocolate dubloons" in 4 years time.

If
Bloody dangerous word that...

James Marshall
754 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:00:48
Gerry #342

Can we play 3 & in? Baggsy I'm Hibbo.

Gerry Quinn
755 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:06:38
Hah, James, so what you are saying is you do not want to go in goal - ever!
John Crawley
756 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:08:17
Colin - he definitely had an agenda the way he wrote those pieces during the summer and was obviously being briefed by Moyes. In the pocket of Man United - I'd say so!
James Marshall
757 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:14:45
How dare you! I was thinking it might be the only time we get to see a few goals from the goal-shy fullback!
Ross Edwards
758 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:18:56
With my godawful football ability I'll be Naismith.
Carl Sanderson
759 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:00:42
Tony 386,

Yes, you may have a point there. Drew says there has been an "increase in quality in nearly every position": Fellaini/McCarthy may be the implied exception.

Derek Knox
760 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:06:07
It's funny I have just been going through the posts, leading up to the closure of the Transfer Theatre, the comments are humerous where a lot of TWers, were believing, as did most of us, that Mother Hubbard got more from the cupboard, than it looked like we were going to get.

Anglo Saxon expletives in abundance were being directed towards the Board.

The window being almost shut, and we receive the breaking news, Barry in, McCarthy in, and we're just hearing that Lukaku has chosen Everton over West Brom !

Arch enemies to heroes with a trio of masterstrokes, Priceless!

Colin Williams
761 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:07:39
Excellent deadline day performance by our chairman and manager. There is one position that we need cover for, left sided centre- half. This would give us the right balance if and when It is needed. Having two right-sided c/h does not give us the balance needed, esp when playing out from the g/k.


Bill Griffiths
762 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:36:33
Seems to me RM must have been greatly influential in persuading Lukaka to come to us. From comments being made last night I presumed he would be going to West Brom but obviously RM must have really sold EFC to him. Like others on here I await the January window to see who the excess funds we are in receipt of are spent on.
Tony Draper
763 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:33:39
James (397)

Who can tell ?
Maybe Roberto can turn the "possession retaining" Hibbo into a "free-scoring" legend before the the twilight of his "Career of selfless dedication" ?

"For it happens twice within an hour which has not occurred for a thousand years"

Lewis Barclay
764 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:45:16
And now, thank goodness, the season can begin.

Howard.
Robles.
Hibbert.
Stones.
Coleman.
Alcaraz.
Distin.
Heitinga.
Jagielka.
Baines.
Barry.
Gibson.
McCarthy.
Osman.
Pienaar.
Mirallas.
Naismith.
Barkley.
Deulofeu.
Jelavic.
Kone.
Lukaku.

Roberto, please find a team inside that lot that can do the following:

Beat the RS home and away, beat Manure at home and no less than a draw away. Beat Arsenal for once!

I'd be happy with that (and a cup and a Champions League place)

Jim Lloyd
765 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:43:02
I think we had a good transter window..eventually! I think the difference tonight was Martinez

It seems he spoke to Lukaku for half an hour and really impressed him. If he's quoted correctly, Lukaku is looking forward to playing with us.

Martinez has identified (admittedly potentially) a great talent in McCarthy, and got him.Some who say "He isn't worth the amount" Howdo you know until we've had him for a year or two

He's also got Barry in who will, I think, serve us well for a year, or more.

An, most importantly, I think he's told the tearie feller, just exactly what hew ants to see at this club. And I think he'll do his best to make sure its provided.Great stuff Martinez

Derek Knox
766 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:46:48
Tony (#409)

I have to agree that Roberto has pulled off a few pieces of magic in his relatively short tenure. Whether this stretches to water into wine (I can do the reverse of this) even I have reservations.

As regards the transformation of Hibbo, well you can't polish a turd, but you can varnish one. ' Ronseal ' anyone !

Ian Bennett
767 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:51:32
I would think he would go with:-

Howard
Coleman
Baines
Jags
Distin

Barry
Gibson
McCarthy

Mirallas
Lukaku
Kone

The three midfield have a decent range of passing and would fit in with Barkley as required. For me big questions over:-
Heitinga
Jelavic
Osman
Pienaar
Naismith

Duncan McDine
768 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:59:45
Even by TW standards, calling Hibbo a turd is lower than low.
Dean Adams
769 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:52:11
£120k a week! Wow Barry ain't worth that much.
Drew Shortis
770 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:49:32
Carl Sanderson 373
McCarthy will take over Fellaini's place in the team, but he is obviously not a like for like signing. This move is all about altering the style of play at Goodison. I was, and still am, a big fan of Fellaini, but I'm not sure he really fitted in to Martinez's system. Clearly most effective as an advanced midfielder, but this looks like Ross Barkley's spot now. I think he was less suited to the defensive midfield role than he liked to think he was, especially in the new system. I think McCarthy will slot in perfectly and we can use the balance of the money to strengthen elsewhere in January or next summer.

Making a bid to take Lukaku on a permanent deal would make sense for us, but I don't think Chelsea would sell him unless a mega money bid came in and we just don't have that kind of cash. After another great loan season he will be back at Chelsea as a polished diamond to take over the Drogba role. I'm just glad he / Chelsea chose us as his potential goals could give us the boost we need to get into Europe and attract the kind of striker we will need to take over from him. Good business for Lukaku, Chelsea and Everton!

Gerry Quinn
771 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:05:13
Ouch, Derek # 415 - a bit out of order towards a genuinely honest one-club pro who has played more than 300 games for Everton and played all of them with his blue heart. I know we all take the mickey out of him at times, and Osman, but that's really borderline...
Paul Ferry
772 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:58:11
How's about this Lewis - if all fully fit:

Howard
Coleman
Distin
Jagielka
Baines
Barry
McCarthy
Pienaar
Mirallas
Deulofeu
Barkley
Lukaku

Robles
Stones
Alcaraz
Heitinga
Gibson
Jelavic
Kone

Drew Shortis
773 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:13:49
Paul 421
The old 4-2-4-1 formation! That extra man could give us the edge ;)
Phil Walling
774 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:53:30
The old adage that all managers are always' three players away from having a good team'still holds good on ToffeeWeb as multiple posters demand that BK makes available the balance of his summer dealings for January purchases.

Now much as I like playing Football Manager, don't you think the time has come when we should look forward to seeing what the new manager can do with the very considerable resources he has at his disposal before we start screaming for even more new blood.

That way,we might see the Club moving nearer to financial stability-another goal we all harp on about?

Duncan McDine
775 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:14:23
Like the line up Paul, but unfortunately the ref tends to count how many players are on each team
Sean Kelly
776 Posted 03/09/2013 at 18:59:56
Haven't stopped laughing at the Mancs and Moyes all day. Fellaini is deluded to think they are the biggest club in the world with that gobshite in charge. Just seen they signed some kid. The poor sod won't get a chance with the ginger minge in charge. I can't wait til we get to March or April and we are looking down the table at Man Utd and Dithering Dave. I think Billy Liar's new comedy show is on in Manchester.

Hey Billy, we will be watching you and that spare change you have after yesterday. Use the money to reward Baines and get a left-sided centre-half, you tight git!

Paul Ferry
777 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:16:14
Crap Drew - 422 - thanks - sorry - allowed 7 on the bench right?

Howard
Coleman
Distin
Jagielka
Baines
Barry
McCarthy
Mirallas
Deulofeu
Barkley
Lukaku

Robles
Stones
Alcaraz
Gibson
Pienaar
Jelavic
Kone

Paul Ferry
778 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:19:44
Good point Duncan!

We might get away with it however if we have that bald twat
from the Cardiff game as he got just about everything else wrong!

Phil Walling
779 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:20:46
Paul,I don't think Everton will line up anytime soon without Ossie being at least one of the eighteen.
Alan Smith
780 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:15:45
Hibbert and Osman are both quality premier league players. No one has an easy gane against Hibbert.

Osman has looked bad when he's been asked to play out of position wide, or flogged to death like last season when he needed a rest. He's done well so far under RM, we've dominated possession in each game. It's no shame if Arteta, Felli, Rodwell, Barkley and Barry are slightly better considering your giving away two stone and aren't blessed with pace.

Two very good squad players in my eyes. If ossie and Barkley swapped roles the last three lgu games might have been wins. But like most evertonians and probably Moyes, RM wouldn't risk Barkleys inexperience in CM.

Vince Hindson
781 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:27:04
753 responses. Is this a record?
Paul Ferry
782 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:31:32
I think you're right Phil - 430 - that was my preferred line-up as - I think you disagree - I've come to the end of the line with Parbold's finest. He is still a model-pro and has something to offer but I think it will be elsewhere this time next year.

To be honest not including Heitinga caused me a little more concern but Gibbo is better when fit in the holding role and Alcaraz I think based on little to be sure is a better central
defender.

Ian Burns
783 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:34:12
Vince, now 754 - we are all still in shock over last night. I spent 15 hours on TW live forum last night (I know get a life - I will after this), it was brilliant company; a roller coaster of a day; an utterly awful evening until 10,45pm - so we are making the most of it!
Paul Andrews
784 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:35:44
To be fair to the chaps....Phil Sammon & co I didn't see that one coming.
£27 million ? Well in lads
Ian Burns
785 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:35:44
I would like to qualify my last post - awful evening kept going by the brilliant guys on TW - it was a laugh - brilliant
Drew Shortis
786 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:31:36
Phil Walling 423
The point is in 12 months time when Lukaku departs us we don't want to be in West Brom's position and be replacing him with a £6m Victor Anichebe type! We all now know there is money left from what Kenwright has said at the Martinez unveiling press conference, what was said last night and the net profit we made. Also if the TV money is factored in as it helps balance the books we are right to expect more investment from the transfer profits. We shouldn't allow this money to vanish without a fight!

I'm more than happy to congratulate Martinez and the board for their work this summer and enjoy the fruits of their labour, but we must always keep one eye on the future and strive for more!

Barry Lambert
787 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:13:31
The smallest book in the world,' The Power Of Positive thinking ' by Ross Kerry . I dread to think what you would be saying if we hadn't made these deals .You are a well informed Everton pundit but come on Ross give us a smile .
Drew Shortis
788 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:39:15
Phil Walling 423
Missed your last sentence. I agree financial stability is essential, especially if we want to attract new investment, but can't the new TV deal balance the books enough so that we are not forced to sell and if we do choose to sell we can expect the money to be ploughed back into transfers? I will be interested to the the clubs finances next time round to see how we have improved.
Phil Sammon
789 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:44:54
Thank you Paul.

Glad it all worked out nicely for us. I still can't believe we got that amount!

Oliver Kearney
790 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:42:21
I have to say even when it looked like we were going to sign nobody, I was still in floods of tears thanks to some of the hilarious posts lastn ight. Highlight being the stick Peg-Leg Whelan was getting when McCarthy looked off.
Paul Ferry
791 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:39:32
Drew -438 - agree that while the immediate short-term and climbing the table and adapting to new styles and formations is utterly crucial, the longer - 2014/2015 - term is equally significant and, needless to say Bobby and the gang will be planning for both.

What if:

(1) Barca-del stays for another season - likes it - and Barca get in three or four more world class creative forward looking players and Del slips down the pecking order

(2) A striker-rich Chelski let us buy Lukaku and - big and - we have the dosh

(3) Barry makes himself utterly indispensable and signs on a free with two more decent years ahead of him

(4) I feel on safer ground here - McCarthy turns out to be a pure gem and we begin to think of him as one of the players to build the future around

(5) Barkley continues to develop and prosper and we don't sell him at least for two years perhaps three

(6) The dye has now been cast and Teary Billy will cough up future sponds where available - including the lion's share of Sept-2 profits - to strengthen us in 2014

I'm sorry - all ifs - and if is one of my least favourite words but wouldn't it be nice?

Phil Walling
792 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:41:48
I get your point,Drew, but it is imperative that the Club makes inroads into the enormous debts. Of course, if they bothered to explain some of what they do to us fans rather than hiding it in 'other operating costs,they might get an easier ride!
Mike Green
793 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:54:06
Paul Andrews #436 - said like a gentleman, good for you.
Mark Frere
794 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:50:54
I'm very happy with how our squad looks for this season, I don't think there will be any big money arrivals in January. TBH, we don't need to be signing anyone else this season. The extra funds we have aquired should be used to bring in permanent replacements when Barry, Deulofeu and Lukaku loans have ended.

At the moment we just about have cover for every position on the pitch. We can even field a complete resereve team which can match a few PL teams:

Robles
Hibbert Stones Heitinga Alacaraz
Deulofeu Osman Barry Oviedo
Kone Jelavic

Drew Shortis
795 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:53:28
Paul Ferry 447
That all sounds great to me. I'm an optimist and you never know what's around the corner.

For me the best case scenario would be:

- Martinez's new system takes off and we qualify for Europe next season.

- Delboy fulfils his potential and Barcelona seeing the benefits of another loan deal that will give his European experience loan him to us again for another season. Others may also be given a chance.

- The money we have left over now is spent on an adequate replacement for Lukaku who has just smashed in 20+ goals to help us reach the CL spot.

- Players like Barkley and Coleman can see the progress we are making and we enjoy the football and are not tempted when the top teams begin to circle.

- Seeing all this progress on the field and a healthier balance sheet an investor decides to come on board, giving Everton the financial clout to compete with the big boys.

- We buy Anfield, demolish it and put up a shiny new blue stadium in its place.

- Everton splash out a world record transfer for a top striker, Roy, from The Rovers.

I'm willing to dream. The first step is to turn all this optimism into results. Hopefully the morale boost amongst us fans will transfer to the players and we will turn possession into goals. At least we have the 'Beast' up front to do make this part of the dream a reality.

Bill Gall
796 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:21:26
Like many other supporters I sat most of the night at my computer gnashing my teeth and cursing at what seemed a lack of effort by Everton.

Allthough it worked out in the end,do people think Fellaini only asked fot a transfer late on because it looked that there was a lack of ambition by Everton.

Hopefully Mr.Martinez is now aware of what the squad is and can fully intergrate them in his system without being under a cloud not knowing who was coming and who was going.

The players coming in look good but personally I prefer players to be under contract to Everton and not on loan.

If Everton are paying the wages of the players on loan and also probablyhaving to insure them, they should be allowed to play in all games and not excluded from the team against their parent club.

Peter Jones
797 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:56:45
Paul 447- I definitely think we have a shot a Deulofeu in a couple years time. Where is he going to play at Barca when they already have Alexis Sanchez, Pedro, Neymar, Messi, Afellay, and Tello? It's a fair question. And like you said, that's if they don't sign anyone, which for a club of that stature, is highly unlikely. The kid is only 19 and by the time he's 21, he'll want to be a regular starter to prove his worth. Pienaar is getting up there in age and Deulofeu could literally walk right into the team after peanuts is done with the game. But will we have enough to get him? As for Lukaku, I honestly can't believe Mou let him come here for one season, let alone potentially sell! The difference he made at West Brom was immense. They were a relegation threatened team to start the season and solely because of him, they finished 8th. I don't want to jinx anything, but we did finish 6th w/o him, Barkley, Kone, or Deulofeu last season. Fellaini is a big loss, but champions league league qualification isn't unrealistic with the kind of goal threat our frontline now possesses. I joked with my friends long before Lukaku arrived at Everton, that we would challenge for the title with a striker like that. Let's see how far off I was ;)
Phil Walling
798 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:08:16
Bill, it's well chronicled that Fellaini was due a loyalty payment on 1 September which he forewent by 'asking for a move'. He was then able to demand its payment by his new employers. He was always destined to follow 'his master' to OT.

Of course,we would love the loanees to be 'ours' but for now.......

Andy Walker
799 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:14:10
Bill 461, Feli asking for a transfer is just part of the negotiations to make the deal go through (Feli probably didn't even know he asked). It make the deal easier to finalise quickly as he waves rights to bonus and signing on fees etc. Feli will no doubt be compensated in some other way by Man U so its just a way to sweeten the deal for BK.
Matt Smith
800 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:04:28
First time in over a decade I have felt good about an Everton team and we haven't won anything.

RM has wiped out the Moyes tenure memories in a day.

Even when we won under Moyes it felt like painting by numbers.

Andy Walker
801 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:17:23
This is the best transfer window I can remember. We stuffed Man U for £4m, incredible, then we got £6m for Victor, staggering, that's a £10m bonus in my eyes. He gets so much stick and disrespect on here but BK delivered big style.
Kevin Tully
802 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:11:26
Don't think we should be looking at the Barry deal as a loan like Lukaku.

He can actually sign a pre-contract agreement in Jan if impressive enough. He could quite easily give us another 2 seasons at the top level beyond this one, don't forget, Giggs is playing at 40 for the cahmpions.

Phil Walling
803 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:24:03
Kevin, in a Sky interview this morning ,he indicated that he had come here for more than one season. Like you, I think they'll stitch a deal up come January.
Bill Gall
804 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:17:56
Andy, I suppose the way to sweeten the deal for BK was negotiated in their weekly phone calls to each other.

On the loanees comments I think both Barry and Lukaku are excellent players for Everton. It just annoys me that they are not allowed to play in all games.

Gerry Quinn
806 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:30:38
Bill Gall #461

If Everton are paying the wages of the players on loan and also probablyhaving to insure them, they should be allowed to play in all games and not excluded from the team against their parent club.

I sort of agree with you, but there could be serious implications. Example, if Everton were to play Chelsea with a League title hanging on it (please happen!), or a semi-final Cup match, it would be unfair to expect the player to commit to one team - especially regarding the fact that he would be returning to that original team to play for them in Europe.

Difficult to assess really, but that is why the rules are in place

Lewis Barclay
807 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:20:28
I think Barry will almost have to play - we can't be paying £120k a week to a player who doesn't play at all or sits on the bench - I also think that this will mean that Barry will be enemy number one as soon as he shows any lack of effort. Luckily I don't think he's that kind of player - I also think that he will help Barkley improve no end, by protecting his play and probably coaching about being the kind of player to represent his country at top level.

I also think that Lakaku has a chance at getting more goals than he did last year with good service from our unquestionably talented midfield.

What is really exciting, is that I think we have the potential to roll out a great cup squad for both the cups.

I think Martinez is really thinking here and starting to develop a team that can play the way he wants them to, consistently (and that's what OFM couldn't achieve, consistency).

My first visit of the season to GP comes vs Chelsea, where I'd be happy getting a point. But, with the squad we have, I'd really expect us to push on now and none of this "top half of the table" bullshit. We really should be pushing for a European place in the Premier League.

Graham Mockford
808 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:48:05
Lewis #488

How do you know we are paying £120k pw?

Kunal Desai
809 Posted 03/09/2013 at 20:55:32
How about getting Hitzlesperger out of retirement. Aged 31 retired.
Phil Walling
810 Posted 03/09/2013 at 21:06:55
What for?
Kunal Desai
811 Posted 03/09/2013 at 21:07:37
Sarcasm Phil, Sarcasm...
Chris Jones
812 Posted 03/09/2013 at 21:05:17
Overall, I'm feeling pretty positive. A couple of thoughts though:

1. McCarthy - quit moaning about the fee, he cost less than that unknown Belgian who we just sold to TGT for 27.5 million.

2. Barry's wages: as above - quit bloody moaning. None of us know what proportion of them we are paying, but do you honestly think that the club would screw its wage structure for a 32 yr old and risk pissing off the other senior squad members for a loanee?

3. Loans in general - yes, they cost a lot of money, but if that investment helps us achieve a higher league position than we would've achieved without the loans then it isn't that bad a deal is it? That higher position may also make us a more attractive proposition to future transfer targets.

We've got a new regime who are trying to impose a change in playing style. Sorry for the example, but compare us to what happened when Brenda took over across the park. Similar story (albeit with more money). They looked bloody shaky for months, played good football in patches, but then started to gel (unfortunately). As hard as it is, we need to give Roberto at least a season, probably longer. Have faith. We are Everton.

Phil Walling
813 Posted 03/09/2013 at 21:15:15
Hitz was a good player in his time.Never understood why he left Villa so early.
Barry Lambert
814 Posted 03/09/2013 at 19:13:31
The smallest book in the world: "The Power of Positive Thinking" by Ross Kerry. I dread to think what you would be saying if we hadn't made these deals. You are a well-informed Everton pundit but come on, Ross, give us a smile.
Franny Porter
815 Posted 03/09/2013 at 21:51:53
See the doom mongers are out in force again. Every year after the window we have a 'financial expert' telling us "20** is gonna be a tough year, asset stripping blah blah blah". When in actual fact our squad looks much healthier to me than it did last year when we were told the same thing, and will probably be better again next year.

Also, as an aside, there is no fucking way we are paying "Gaz Baz" over 100k a week. No fucking way. So stop saying it.....

Ross Edwards
816 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:12:28
Paul Ferry, I forgot to say, happy birthday to you sir. Hope our deadline day signings were good presents for you.
Ross Edwards
817 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:15:50
Is it your birthday today isn't it Paul?

I hope it is anyway because if it isn't I've made a right muppet of myself!

Mark Frere
818 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:19:48
Nothing new there then Ross
Mike Hughes
819 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:24:04
The more I think about it the more positive I'm starting to feel.

Our first team now looks pretty damn good.

Howard
Coleman Jags Distin Baines
Mirallas Barry McCarthy Pienaar
Lukaku Jelavic/ Kone

Subs: Deulofeu, Hibbert, Heitinga, Osman, Oviedo, Naismith......

When's the derby?

Ross Edwards
820 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:32:00
Getting the claws out there Mr Frere.
Mike Bird
821 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:44:17
I was very pissed off when RS beat us to Moses, but IMO we got the better deal.
Jamie Sweet
822 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:49:28
Looks good Mike #568. Even though you (I assume) forgot about Barkley!
Bill Gall
823 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:33:52
Gerry #481

I understand that is why they make these rules up as per your scenerio.

What if Everton get in the F.A.Cup final and we play Man City. Barry plays in every round but cant play in the final against the club who want to sell him and he has little chance of being in the team or on the bench.

As for Lukaku we call players mercenaries but clubs are just the same and there are no gaurantees whith Marino at the helm he will not be sold next summer.

Nicholas Randall
824 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:34:26
What is TGT? I am too tired to work that one out.
Noel Early
825 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:54:03
Keeping Baines was amazing, we just could not replace him. Losing Felli is a loss but did great getting that figure for him. And people saying we overpaid for McCarthy will not think the same when they see this lad every week. The lad is a powerhouse, box-to-box midfielder who will be worth £30M in 2 years time, I have no doubt about that.
Paul Ferry
826 Posted 03/09/2013 at 23:17:01
Cheers Ross see other thread -
Ross Kerry
827 Posted 03/09/2013 at 22:57:47
Barry (@439 and again at 515) I'm really trying! I predicted CL football for us next year (@ 368), isn't that positive enough for you? What more could you possibly want?

OK, I'll give it a go
1. Hibbo will score this season
2. Kenwright will find £30M in the next window and actually increase the squad size.
3. No more incoming players will have any association with Wigan.
4. The pies at Goodison will introduce real meat as an ingredient.
5. We'll beat the shite home and away (obviously).
6. Gerrard will actually cry at the end of each derby game.
7. TV pundits with any affiliation to the shite will be sent to Talksport for their sins.
8. Natalie Sawyer will get them out when we sign Rooney this time next year.
9. The new badge will be universally loved, it will be traditional, modern, bold, and subtle.
10. Moyes will remain at United for a trophyless decade, before marrying Round and then moving on to manage the shite.

That was therapeutic.

Chris Jones
828 Posted 03/09/2013 at 23:26:02
Nicholas #588. It stands for "that ginger tit". Sorry, saw the term last week and it made me giggle in a rather unmanly way all day.
Ross Kerry
829 Posted 03/09/2013 at 23:48:30
I've changed my mind. There's no hope for those pies.
Carl Sanderson
830 Posted 03/09/2013 at 23:57:31
Phil 511,

His knee fell off.

Eric Myles
831 Posted 04/09/2013 at 06:03:54
Ross, no need to explain to me how a release clause works, I was one of the few that correctly stated that we would receive no bids for Fellaini while it was active and would receive lower bids for him afterwards.
David Ellis
832 Posted 04/09/2013 at 06:45:00
Yes Eric - but what did any of those bids or non bids have to do with the release clause? I and many others could not see the link. If a club wanted to make a bid below the release clause they were able to do so both before and after it expired. The fact that no bids were made until after it expired has nothing to do with the existence of the release clause.

As we now know the Mancs were shopping elsewhere at the time.

Ray Roche
833 Posted 04/09/2013 at 07:22:10
David, I thought that the release clause meant that Everton would be obliged to notify Fellaini IF an offer activating that clause was received, if the offer was below it, then they need say nothing. Accrington Stanley could have offered £100k but it would mean nothing, however, if they'd offered £23.5m we'd have had to tell Fellaini and his dad. And watch them ask "Who are they?"
Jamie Barlow
834 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:08:24
I thought the clause was that we couldn't refuse the transfer if a Champions league club offered the full amount. We didn't just have to let Fellaini know about an offer.
Jamie Barlow
835 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:14:42
Did we get £27 million for Fellaini? Some papers saying they only paid £23.5 as Moyes wouldnt budge with the price and Fellaini lost £4 million after putting a transfer request in.
Drew Shortis
836 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:13:23
I don't want to live in the past forever and keep on bringing up OFM, but after the way United went about the pursuit of Baines and Fellaini isn't it satisfying to see the headlines about their disastrous, farcical and shambolic transfer window! I have to agree. With all the resources they have at their disposal I can't understand why they left it so late and tried to do things on the cheap. They still have a quality squad with the likes of RVP, but in the past Fergie always reinforced after a successful campaign.

Its very encouraging to see the media praising Martinez for his dealings. The last hour of that window felt like extra time in a cup final that we were being battered in, then in injury time we came from behind and won the game. I can't ever recall celebrating like that for anything other than a game. The whole drama was made even more enjoyable with the witty banter on the live forum. I was laughing for most of the evening although it was often hysterical laughter born of despair! Going into work yesterday morning and being congratulated by my colleagues was a new experience for me too!

David Ellis
837 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:32:01
Ray and Jamie
It depends how the clause is worded. But in Fellaini's case it was reported that we would have to sell him to a club that met the release price, if Fellaini wanted to go (and could agree personal terms).

In Suarez's case it seems that the Dark Side only needed to notify him of any bids above the "release" price. So not a release clause at all in his case.

Denis Richardson
838 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:35:29
I read already today that OFM is looking to rebid for Baines in January. Does this guy not get it - HE'S NOT FOR SALE!

BK and RM need to get Baines a new contract asap and tie him up for another 4 years at GP. Then if Manu come back for him the price is 35m - cash up front.

Manu are really getting desperate and there are rumours that RVP is not happy with the management - thank god we've not got RM.

Phil Sammon
839 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:34:55
Almost spat my Cheerios out reading that post from Eric Myles.

Dear lord! Show a shred of humility and concede you got this one wrong.

Colin Glassar
840 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:36:58
The pro-united media are going into overdrive to cover up the mancs incompetence in the TM with stories about the price for Fellaini, trying to put the blame on Woodward, saying that OFM will deffo get bainse and Herrera in January, one even claimes today that Moyes hasn't had enough time to settle in yet so it's unfair to blame him for this fiasco. Iis all bullshit!!! We screwed he mancs over Fellaini and dio make them pay over the odds for him. As I said a few weeks ago, RVP is already pissed off with ginger and Rooney is not happy either. There's trouble at mill lads, so expect the manc PR dept. to go mental and lie out of their arses over the next few days.
Tony J Williams
841 Posted 04/09/2013 at 08:37:36
Christ, who gives a flying fuck about the release clause and the "I told you so" bollocks?

He has been sold and it seems for over the clause amount and no amount of discussion will change that.

Kevin Tully
842 Posted 04/09/2013 at 09:11:31
What about the sanity clause?
Paul Andrews
843 Posted 04/09/2013 at 09:19:31
You will have to wait until Dec 25th Kevin like everyone else
Chris Ashton
844 Posted 04/09/2013 at 09:12:08
I am going to sound like a miserable sod but I do not take much joy out of the window closing, in fact I can't help but think 'this time next year'.

Look, the team is better this season, and will be much better to watch potentially. I had no hope of european competition this season via the league so wherever we end up I will be happy. All I wanted from this season is adapting to change and playing a little more enjoyable football, plus hopefully not tuning on the united/chelsea/liverpool/arsenal game and immediatly know we arent going to win this.

Reading the twitter comments on monday night they seemed to go from complete hatred to complete joy in the space of about 20 minutes. I was wondering why? This time next season you could be looking at Delefleu, Alkaraz, Lukaku and one of our current players (at least 1) not being at the club. Kone will be turning 31, Barry who will sign a new contract with us will be 33 and osman, hibbert, Distin will all be another year older. Looking at the squad, we need potentially 7-8 new players NEXT season to balance this up as well. The board have shown their cards as sell to buy and even wait until the last minute to make money disappear. By my count, including the extra 20 we have made 33 million vanish in potential transfer funds. I will be very suprised if the money gets reinvested in the next 12 months.

The question really will be, what are we going to do next summer? We are going backwards and as melodramatic as this all sounds I really fear for the club now. If that 13 million had signed 2-3 young players just to counter balance the above then I would be happy. As it stands though we are going to be decimated by next summer and will have to lose Mirrallas/Barkley/Baines just to sure up the rest of the squad.

Fans say Kenwright got his decisions right but right now, we have lost 6 CONTRACTED players and loaned 3 players to replace them, 2 of which we have no chance of signing. SO forgive me for being cynical but we could have loaned Messi himself but it would not change the fact the squad has been decimated again under the smoke and mirrors.

To sum all up, my answer to all of this would be become barca. We are skint, we knew it before and it stays true now. Why don't we stop managing the younger players and coach them in Roberto's way? If the 14 year olds player the same football as the 16-18 year old and the first team it will be much easier to spot players who will make it. We can then push for them to get involved in the first team when ready and therefore know 2-3 years before hand if a player will make it here. It is what Barca do and that is why they can identify players so much more efficiently than most. One simple change like this would pay off long term, as when we are clearly ran into the ground by the board we can push younge rplayers into the fold and they will know exaclty what to do. Here's the kicker as well, it would cost nothing to us to do this, all it will cost is 3 years, which is well within Roberto's contract.

Ciarán McGlone
845 Posted 04/09/2013 at 09:09:27
I think we had a good transter window..eventually! I think the difference tonight was Martinez
----------------

I think this is the key in all of this..

All the reports I've heard in respect of the Whelan dealings - was that it was Roberto on the other end of the phone..Now Lukaku tells us Roberto spent half an hour with him on the phone...

It looks like the muted praise for Kenwright is again, and as ever, misplaced!

Kenwright was his usual slimey self...Imagine if we'd actually spent all of the money coming in (as was promised) and bought Fernando as well..

Ciarán McGlone
846 Posted 04/09/2013 at 09:33:04
Paul Ferry -

Howard
Coleman
Distin
Jagielka
Baines
Barry
McCarthy
Mirallas
Deulofeu
Barkley
Lukaku

Without a doubt that is, in my opinion, our strongest first XI..lets just hope Martinez resists the temptation to stick Osman, Pienaar and Naismith somewhere in there..

Andrew Cutler
847 Posted 04/09/2013 at 09:49:17
Mark @213...I did not say asset stripping was not occurring. What I said (or indicated), was that financial statements would display the occurrence of such. Cash can well leave a balance sheet via expenditure items(obviously), or dividend payment, capital expenditure or debt repayment. Regardless, it can be tracked. Movement in shareholder equity can be a beacon/ smoking gun So, to iterate, cash flow statements, P/L and balance sheets will illustrate. NB : I accept that obfuscations often occur, and I have not studied EFC's accounts (got enough on my personal plate!).
Denis Richardson
848 Posted 04/09/2013 at 10:04:00
Jeez Chris 688 - you really need to find some joy in supporting the blues when things go well, otherwise why bother? I'd hate to think what your day is like when things don't go well..

I follow your logic to an extent but we had the same issue last year (numerous players either on loan or in the last year of their contract and/or getting towards retirement) and we're still fine today - thanks to some great transfer work by RM and (I say this grudgingly) BK..

As for next season; Delboy, Lukaku and Barry's loans will be at an end. We will probably sign Barry for another year or two on a free (he has 2-3 years left in him) and have an option to buy Delboy. Lukaku will probably not stay but we still have the ability to bring in other loan players if needed.

As for contracted players. There are 100+ players on a 'free' at the end of every season - in the premiership alone, nevermind across Europe and in lower leagues. I have confidence that RM (if needed) can find players to bolster the squad and some cheap european imports.

As for our current squad, the likes of Barkely, Stones, Coleman, Miralas, McCarthy, Roubles, Gibson, Oviedo, Jagielka, Baines etc are all in their 20s I believe, with many in their early 20s (or teens in RB's case) so no panic there as far as the spine of the team is concerned. Howard is a GK and has many years left too.

We will free up wages for new players next summer when the likes of Heitinga, Distin, possibly Jelly, Gueye and Naismith leave...Osman and Pienaar can still be squad players for a year or two. Hibbio's days are numbered but we have Coleman and Stones at RB already as it is - so not panic tehre either.

Basicaly mate sit back and (hopefully) enjoy the next few months and worry about next season.......well next season, or at least next year.

For the time being look forward to finally having a top class forward grace GP - not had one since the Yak (first year with us).

We're good to go till the next silly season in Jan.

Dan Nulty
849 Posted 04/09/2013 at 10:18:56
Chris, I agree with your sentiments to a certain extent, I'm not sure there is missing transfer funds as the funds have been spent in loan fees and wages.

I think that the barca plan you lay out is precisely what the plan is, given he brought the academy coach with him.

I agree that players are ageing, distin is close to being past it admittedly but with ossie and hibbo we have ready made replacements in Barkley and stones. Players These days are playing longer and longer due to the way they look after their bodies so I am not overly concerned about Barry and Kone. I think we also have to think short term as well though, signings like we have made improve the team and will allow us to hang on to the coat tails of the top six who are spending serious cash. Lukaku could be the finisher we have been missing, I have never seen us have stats like we have these first three games, we have just missed someone to get on the end of chances.

Keep positive mate, we have a better squad, we have good young players in the u21s, more money coming in this season and a manager who wants us to play football. I will enjoy it more this year and hopefully if romelu does bang them in I'll be far less frustrated.

Chris Ashton
850 Posted 04/09/2013 at 10:46:37
To be honest I am probably thinking about it too much but if there is one thing I have learned over the past 4 years is that the club will not 'get better' where we are.

As for this season , I am going to enjoy it because my expectations were not too high to be begin with. I was only 7 when we won the F.A Cup so I do not have vivid memories of it so I am part of the generation who grew up with Royle/Kendall/Smith Era. I think a geordie recently said it best when he said ' I just want us to have go, we don't win anything and probably won't for a while yet but at least go at teams like chelsea and arsenal, I would rather go down swinging than just standing there'. Therefore I want us to simply go out this season and not worry about places or europe, just beat the team in front of us starting with Chelsea. I think with the players we have signed we are better off. Man for man Robles is better than Mucha, Barry is better than Hitz and Neville combined. McCarthy the jurys out on over Fellaini, Delafleu Kone and Lukaku are better than Anichibe and Macaleny. So that is what I meant when we will be better this season.

Ciarán McGlone
851 Posted 04/09/2013 at 10:59:14
Chris, I agree with your sentiments to a certain extent, I'm not sure there is missing transfer funds as the funds have been spent in loan fees and wages.
--------------------------------------

Wages are accounted for by those who have left..in fact our wages bill should be down.

We spent 13 mill and took in 33 mill...even if we took 5/6 mill for loan signings and 2 mill for Liege - that's still around 12 million on the balance sheet. That's before we even contemplate TV money..

I'm happy for the excess to go towards servicing the debt - if it gets rid of Kenwright in the long run.. What i'm not happy about is more bullshit from Kenwright about all of the incoming money going to Martinez..

If Kenwright was Mute we'd all be in a better place.

James Fletcher
852 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:07:54
Denis, do you know for sure that we have a "buy" clause in Dolly contract? If so any idea if it's in our price range?
Chris Ashton
853 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:26:36
The below is taken from the bbc site a few moments ago, it is nice to see Kev wanting to add quality to the team as much us.

Everton forward Kevin Mirallas reveals how he helped persuade Belgium team-mate Romelu Lukaku to join the Toffees on a season-long loan from Chelsea.

"I was with Romelu in his room at the team hotel on Monday and I only left when I was sure he was joining us," Mirallas tells Everton's official website. "I was surprised to learn we were in for him, because there had been no inkling, but once I got word, I really went to work."

John Pulman
854 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:31:39
Super-Kev. Give that guy a new contract. Head of Player Aquisition sounds good.
Dan Brierley
855 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:22:39
James, Martinez himself said there is no 'option to buy' clause in Del Boy's contract. Similarly with Lukaku.

The point is though, if they have good seasons we wouldnt be able to afford them anyway. Transfer fee's perhaps with some borrowing, but paying the same wages as Chelsea or Barca is a definite no.

Watching Gareth Barry's interview where he is nearly crying as City have fucked him off was also annoying for me.

Even if I enjoy the performances of our three loan players this season, it will still be soured knowing that these lads are only here to prove a point to their own clubs. Call me old fashioned, but I prefer seeing players here that just want to play for Everton. I liked seeing the loan players like Pienaar, Yobo Arteta, the Straq who's only wish was to play with us permanently. They were here on loan to impress EVERTON, not to show to their own clubs that they are worthy of the first team place.

Loaning players might help us in the short term, but as I have said before, it is hindering the progress of our youth players such as Conor Grant or Matt Kennedy.

James Fletcher
856 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:49:07
To be honest I'm hoping Chelski get Rooney in the next window and then don't feel the need to keep Lukaku, and that in his time at Goodison Rom has fallen head over heels in love with the club and pushes through a transfer...........

I envisaged him being first choice at Chelsea this season so it's a little odd that he's been loaned out again, maybe Mourinho isn't a fan?

James Stewart
857 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:56:28
Anyone else see the piece in the paper about how United only paid 23.5m for Fellaini...

Fellaini agreed to hand in a transfer request and forego a loyalty payment of 4m. Thus Billy liar was allowed to call the deal 27.5m.

Whole thing stinks!

Andrew Cutler
858 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:58:55
I believe there is dispute as to whether Manure paid 23.5mio or 27.5mio. I think it is the former, but the fact that Felli requested transfer 'saved us' 4mio in loyalty payment. Regardless, it amounts to an effective 10.5mio cash gain vs the McCarthy purchase.
Andrew Cutler
859 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:08:12
...lol@James 730...we had the same thought at pretty much the same time. Have to take issue with your Billy Liar call though. Declaring it at 27.5mio makes it even more transparent in terms of 'following the cash'
Vijay Nair
860 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:10:40
James, Alan Myer has gone on Twitter to refute that 23.5 mil claim:

http://m.espn.go.com/soccer/story?storyId=1543628

Chris Jones [Burton]
861 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:13:24
I think in this case, given the meejah's tendency to try and present everything in nice and simple terms, there was no deception on BK's part; it was more a case of the papers finding it easier and more succinct to say "£27.5m" (the net worth to Everton) rather than "£23.5m, but worth a net £27.5m to EFC because MF handing in his transfer request yadda yadda yadda yadda... yadda yadda yadda yadda..."
Kevin Tully
862 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:17:54
Just read that Vijay, Myers says; " For those asking: No Felli did NOT pay £4M of the transfer fee! The buying Club will pay £27.5M"

Couldn't be any clearer really.

Chris Leyland
863 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:26:12
As to whether United paid £27.5m or £23.5m, you will recall that the much-derided Richard Dodd was on here a few days ago before any of the deals were done saying that Kenwright had agreed with Whelan to pay 55% of what we got for Fellani to Wigan for McCarthy.

55% of £23.5m is £12.9m whereas 55% of £27.5m is £15.m.

Everton claim to have paid £13m for McCarthy whereas Wigan are saying Everton paid £15m

John Keating
864 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:33:31
By the time agents fees are factored in I don't think we will be as well off as we think.
I'd really like to know exactly how much is both Barry and Lukaku costing us, just in wages per week !
James Fletcher
865 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:09:58
They paid £27.5 but Fellaini agreed to drop his wages to make the difference
James Stewart
866 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:45:00
Barry is costing us 120k per week.

I imagine Lukaku will be on around half that but with a reported loan fee of around 3m-5m depending on what source you read.

James Stewart
867 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:49:05
I would be very surprised if they paid us 27.5m

No one has more media stooges in his backpocket than BK.

Malcolm Bell
868 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:55:10
Apparently, Lukaku was in Seattle this summer with Chelsea and visited the Seattle Seahawks American Football team. The coaches gathered around him and asked, "Do you want to play for us?"
Paul Turner
869 Posted 04/09/2013 at 12:55:53
Just noticed that Momo Sissoko is a free agent having terminated his contract "by mutual consent".

28, experienced... worth EFC looking into possibilities? I seem to remember we were linked with him before he went to the Dark Side...

James Flynn
870 Posted 04/09/2013 at 13:24:52
Well, I thought if Fella and/or Baines left, that was it for improving on last season's 6th place and we were officially in re-building mode. But with the add-ins in the 2 places we really needed (Lukaku the coup), it's still on for me to charge up the last two table positions into the fun zone.

Yes, lots of transfer activity around and above us, but they have to play 35 more games just as we do. In addition, it seems to me the league is the strongest, top to bottom, it's ever been. Tougher on us, yes, but tougher on everyone else too. Who knows what might happen.

Denis Richardson
871 Posted 04/09/2013 at 13:38:34
Sorry my apologies, we don't have an option to buy Delboy - we just get the loan fee waived if he appears in more than 50% of our games.

Still, if he's not good enough for Barca's first team (highly likely given their squad), we may get him for longer.

Ciarán McGlone
872 Posted 04/09/2013 at 13:17:12
"Barry is costing us £120k per week."
--------------

Any evidence of this?

Phil Sammon
873 Posted 04/09/2013 at 14:16:09
Some right old bollocks being spouted on here today.

1. Barry is not costing us £120k p/w

2. Man Utd have paid £27.5M for Fellaini. He has not 'made up' anything. He would have been due around £4M as a bonus payment - which he has foregone by submitting a transfer request. That has nothing to do with the transfer fee.

Chris Jones [Burton]
874 Posted 04/09/2013 at 14:41:04
Unless... Manyoo paid us £23.5m AND gave Felli his £4m, which we would otherwise have had to find. That we we get £23.5 and Myers is still speaking the truth when he says "The buying Club will pay £27.5M". Weasel words, but this IS football!

And as I said earlier, it's easier for the meejah to simply say he cost £27.5m and leave it at that!

Jackie Barry
875 Posted 04/09/2013 at 14:50:34
They will pay 27.5 million an Fellaini has waived his bonus, it's simple, Man U were getting desperate and had to pay our asking price. Most of us always said we would command a higher asking price once the transfer clause expired, it simply wouldn't benefit the club otherwise. Fellaini thought for sure somebody would come and buy him during the time the clause was in affect, he thought he was that good. His only problem was that while he is a very good player he just never turns it on enough to have club queuing round the block for his signature.
Phil Sammon
876 Posted 04/09/2013 at 15:03:54
Chris Jones

No.

Man Utd paid £27.5M to Everton.

Fellaini's £4M was paid by neither club. He did not receive that fee.

So Alan Myers is not weaselling around anything. He's just laying down some simple facts.

Tom Dodds
877 Posted 04/09/2013 at 15:09:16
Logically our next step will be to secure Baines on a new contract given Moyes's failure over Coentrau etc...? Thus preventing any further January angst.

Obviously any other club would've been doing this logical progressive step as we speak??? If they don't count on it that Baines is going.

Paul Ferry
878 Posted 04/09/2013 at 15:44:37
Yet more misinformed twaddle or at the very least speculating in the dark and two for the price of one:


James Stewart - 748 - 'Barry is costing us £120k per week'

He is not, and anyway, how can you be sure? Show us the pure diamond evidence to seal it.

James Stewart - 749 - ' I would be very surprised if they paid us £27.5m'

Why? You have zilch grounds to say this except for quashed silly little journo tosh.

Dan Brierley
879 Posted 04/09/2013 at 11:57:42
Paul Ferry, and what evidence do you have that he is not costing 120K? My guess is you are basing your opinion on what you describe as 'quashed little journo tosh'. Asking someone to prove something, when you can't even prove your own statement is a bit ridiculous.

I don't see us paying 120K, simply because we couldn't bloody afford to. But the only fact is, that nobody on here knows no facts! So less of the hypocritical put downs for people speculating, just because it doesn't match your own speculations. Disagree by all means, but don't try and insinuate you know any facts, as you clearly don't (myself included).

Phil Sammon
880 Posted 04/09/2013 at 16:57:43
But Dan, you said it yourself, Everton can't afford to be paying players £120k.

As if we are going to be paying him £50k more than our highest earner!

I'd hazard a guess and say we're paying half of it.

Dan Brierley
881 Posted 04/09/2013 at 17:01:29
Phil, thats the point mate. We are all guessing. Perhaps we are paying 10%, perhaps we are paying 100% with a written agreement that another City player will join us next season. Who knows? None of us.

Steve Bell
882 Posted 04/09/2013 at 16:55:56
I wish people would stop all the speculating, what we paid, how we paid, who's being paid what, who received what.
The fans, the press, nobody knows the facts. Smoke, mirrors, financial wheeler dealing, figures massaged to fit the bottom line. It's all part of the game of football, (unfortunately).
So lets just get on and enjoy the moment (and there are few of those lately).
Dan Brierley
883 Posted 04/09/2013 at 17:12:16
Steve, what evidence do you have that there are moments to enjoy? Utter speculation.
Paul Andrews
884 Posted 04/09/2013 at 17:15:54
Phil Sammon,,


Lets not be too hasty here.
Looking at the £4 million deduction from the transfer fee I was right all long.

Paul Ferry
885 Posted 04/09/2013 at 17:12:22
Dan Brierley – anything for a little squabble eh! – the point was not to establish a figure (as that is not yet known to us) but to question as many on here have done this belief trotted out by more than a few – and still trotted out – that Barry is picking up the same wage and we are picking it up for him.

You somewhat laughingly tie yourself up in knots: "Asking someone to prove something, when you can't even prove your own statement is a bit ridiculous. I don't see us paying £120k, simply because we couldn't bloody afford to."

Nice one! As I said: anything for a little squabble eh!

I think when all is said and done that there is absolutely no doubt – as you yourself say – that we are paying anywhere near £120k (and also that City are picking up a quota of it).

So here's the question: What was the point of your post? The only thing I can think of is leaping into the fray in your petty way to have a dig at me... which, as night follows day, you appear to do whenever your mince pies catch a post from yours truly. Otherwise, a pointless post.

Get personal – one of them.

Dean Adams
886 Posted 04/09/2013 at 17:10:27
Ciarán McGlone 691

I would agree 100% with your first team. (Thats a first, maybe RM is having a good vibe for the club!!)

Phil Sammon
888 Posted 04/09/2013 at 18:13:46
Paul

Haha.

I'm not biting.

Colin Glassar
889 Posted 04/09/2013 at 18:33:10
I said las night, and restated it this morning, the mancs PR dept. are trying to whitewash their fiasco by spreading lies that EFC will only receive the £23.5m buyout clause. That is utter tosh!! They will have to pay £27m plus £4m in add ons for Fellaini. We took them to the cleaners and now they are using journos on their payroll to try and save face. This just gets more embarrassing them as they dig themselves into a bigger hole day by day.
Paul Andrews
890 Posted 04/09/2013 at 19:19:58
Good for you Phil.I reckoned you would :-)
Colin Glassar
891 Posted 04/09/2013 at 19:33:09
Just seen Butner's and Coentrao's agents having a go at Moyes for his incompetence regarding his handling of both players. Like I said earlier today, there's trouble at mill. RVP, Rooney and Evra are all pissed off with him. Now you can add Butner to that. Good start ginger.
Adam Luszniak
892 Posted 04/09/2013 at 10:00:27
Chris Ashton just because you have capitalised certain words in your post doesn't make It anymore true. How is selling two players 'decimating' the squad? Your assertion ignores the young players coming through such as Barkley and stones. We have players like junior out on loan who may come good in seasons to come. Yes, we have a small squad and yes, the average age is somewhat older than I would like it. However, like it or not we do not have enough money to do anything other than buy a couple and loan some more, and that is exactly what we have done. Felliani was worth selling and Mcarthy I hope will be an excellent midfielder. As others have stated when we sell him we will likely make a bundle. Barry Is old but he will bring much needed stability to midfield. We still haven't seen this team play three at the back with Alcaraz out injured, and he too can add something new I'm sure in terms of linking defence to midfield. Lukaku yes is a loan, but it's bloody Lukaku for god's sake. All respect to victor but he isn't in the same league. I don't see how people can be pessimistic about this. Yes, we would all like these signings to be permanent, but we have to be realistic. I bet WBA fans would rather have Lukaku on loan for another season than Vic permanently.
Barry Lambert
893 Posted 04/09/2013 at 19:51:32
Ross (#604) — Brilliant!

That's more like it. Great post.

Keep up the good work.

My very best wishes to you.
Kieran Fitzgerald
894 Posted 04/09/2013 at 19:45:05
I don't think the age of the squad is any worse than it was in May. I think there is actually a healthier mix than there was at the end of last season.

Delboy, although a loanee, will get games this season. I wouldn't be surprised if we had a chance to sign him next May.Barkley and McCarthy will be first team regulars by the end of October, never mind the end of the season. Coleman is under twenty five and a regular. Lukaku is in his early twenties and will get a lot of games this season.

Osman will get fewer games, and Stones will probably go above Hibbert in the pecking order as the season progresses.

At the end of the season, I can see Osman, Hibbert, Pienaar and Heitinga possibly all leave for a transfer fee, if not at least two of them. This will lower the age profile even further. This is due in part to the positive transfer policy this summer in recruiting younger players to fill the gaps and the development of Barkley.

Jamie Sweet
895 Posted 04/09/2013 at 23:03:54
So if Utd paid £27.5m AND Fellaini saved us £4m with his transfer request, can we technically call it a £31.5m deal, or am I just getting confused by all of this?
Jamie Sweet
896 Posted 04/09/2013 at 23:55:39
Also, I'm not so worried about the "ageing squad" issue now.

If you look at our 25's and under, we're starting to have quality all over the park with the likes of Robles, Coleman, Stones, Mirallas, Barkley, McCarthy, Oviedo who are Premier League ready now, plus a number of the U21's who are starting to develop very well too.

Throw in Duffy, Garbutt, Lundstrum and Vellios in with the above and you've got a pretty decent and balanced young team there.

Eric Myles
897 Posted 05/09/2013 at 01:52:31
Exactly Ray #666 It’s not a difficult concept to grasp at all is it? Although there are some on here that deny the reality even though that is what actually happened as a minority of us correctly said.

Phil #675 Your Mum should be giving you something healthier than Cheerios before sending you off to school.

Vijay Nair
898 Posted 05/09/2013 at 02:42:46
Not really Jamie (938).
We're not losing the 4 mil, but neither are we gaining it.
Drew Shortis
899 Posted 05/09/2013 at 19:52:50
Interesting article about Barry here from the perspective of a City fan blog: http://espnfc.com/blog/_/name/everton/id/1459?&cc=5739

I must admit that I don't watch too many City games and when I do my eye is drawn more to players like Toure and Silva. From what I'm hearing Martinez may well have made an excellent signing hers, if not an eye catching one.

Colin Glassar
900 Posted 05/09/2013 at 19:57:11
I've read a few drew and a lot of city fans are disappointed. He did the silent work, nothing fancy but effective. He was the one who allowed Toure to go marauding upfield. As per usual, another English player has been sacrificed to make way for a fancy dan foreign player that's why I said on another thread, we should go and poach all the unhappy English players languishing in the reserves or on the bench of other teams.
Drew Shortis
901 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:44:52
Aother interesting article about the new signings and the new system:

http://eplindex.com/39276/everton-transfer-report-analysing-barry-mccarthy-lukaku.html?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb