Barkley makes England debut against Moldova

, 6 September, 160comments  |  Jump to most recent
Teenager wins first cap in 4-0 win
Phil Jagielka started in Roy Hodgson's starting line-up to face Moldova in this evening's World Cup qualifier at Wembley and Leighton Baines came on after half time to replace Ashley Cole but the headline for Everton was a first cap for Ross Barkley.

The 19 year-old made his debut with an hour gone and the Three Lions 4-0 up and narrowly missed marking the occasion with a goal.

It was the first time that three current Everton players have been on the field for England at the same time since 1988 when Gary Stevens, Trevor Steven and Peter Reid played against Russia at the European Championship Finals in Germany.

Elsewhere, Seamus Coleman and James McCarthy started for the Republic of Ireland but couldn't prevent Sweden running out 2-1 winners in Group D.

Nikica Jelavic, Kevin Mirallas, Romelu Lukaku and Steven Naismith were all named as substitutes for their respective countries. Mirallas came on for the Red Devils against Scotland and notched the second goal to put them 2-0 up while Nikica Jelavic played the last 11 minutes of Croatia's 1-1 draw with Serbia.

Later, Bryan Oviedo and Tim Howard faced off in CONCACAF qualifying in San Jose, with Costa Rica handing the United States a 3-1 defeat that postpones the Americans' qualification for next year's Finals in Brazil.

 

Reader Comments (160)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Rob O'Brien
2 Posted 06/09/2013 at 00:15:37
I can't believe Baines still not starting games instead of that over rated prick Cole.....
Albert Perkins
3 Posted 06/09/2013 at 00:18:09
Would love Ross to get some gametime. This is his breakthrough year and a new contract would be in order. Hey, I'm interested in watching England again.
Derek Knox
4 Posted 06/09/2013 at 00:22:03
According to Sky Sports News, Ashley Cole is preferred at left back, to our Leighton. Phil Jagielka is at Centre Back alongside Gary Cahill, and therefore our only representative, in the starting line-up. They did not mention who was on the bench, though, so there may be a place for Ross and Leighton yet.

We've got that many (Everton) playing for different nations tomorrow, which is good, but the downside is, that all the matches are virtually on at the same time. Will have to be doing a bit of recording, but then again they either flash the results up on screen, or mouthy commentators blurt it out, and spoil the surprise element, let alone your later enjoyment!

John Gee
5 Posted 06/09/2013 at 00:04:41
This is exactly the reason why England won't win the World Cup. Baines is a better player than Cole and his form and recent performances are better and yet he makes way. Jags and Lescott form a great partnership that's well balanced but Cahill gets the nod in Jagielka's position and has to move to a position that suits a left footer.

Gerrard and Lampard have proven for 10 years that they don't work as a midfield partnership but still get picked and the star striker has a strike rate and chance-conversion rate that would be expected from a League 2 side fighting relegation. Kyle Walker?? He's possibly the worst defender I've ever seen. He can't win the ball without fouling, how he doesn't get sent off in every game is a mystery to me.

I'm English but every game I ever watch, I can't stop myself supporting the other team. I'm sure Hodgson is an intelligent guy so maybe it's commercial/sponsorship pressure that makes him pick this team.

Supporting England is endorsing the farce that is the team selection policy which is just a slap in the face of the people who deserve to be there. Fuck them, I hope Gerrard breaks his leg as he's scoring 3 own goals.

Fucking clueless.

Colin Glassar
6 Posted 06/09/2013 at 00:39:08
I think Roy said the other day that both will play in a game. I thought it would be Leighton today and cashley against Ukraine.
James Stewart
7 Posted 06/09/2013 at 01:03:12
Yawn. No interest in watching England what so ever. Rotten from the core. They need to let go of the past players like Lampard, Gerrard, Cole well past their sell by date. Should blood some younger players who might actually be able to perform in a major tournament
John Gee
8 Posted 06/09/2013 at 01:53:42
Picture the scene: England training pitch Hodgson pulls Baines to one side and says "well done for being the best attacking left back in world football, congratulations on being more creative than £30-£40m play makers, kudos for your tireless running and tracking back. Now go and sit on the bench for not joining Man Utd"

"jags, come here boy. I know you're right footed but I want you to play on the left and provide cover on the left. I can't play Cahill there, he plays for a London club."

I remember Hoddle before the world cup in France said to Le Tissier "I'm putting you in the B team for a game, I want to have a last look at you before I name my squad". The B team won 4-1, Le Tissier scored a hatrick and set up the other goal. He didn't get picked! For those who may have forgotten, we went out on penalties while the guy who has a record of 47 goals from 48 penalties taken was sitting at home watching on TV. Until England pick the best players in their correct position and in form, it will be another 48 years before we win anything.

Derek Knox
9 Posted 06/09/2013 at 02:22:51
John (177)

It's nearly always the same mate, I think I'll watch the Republic game, there's two of ours there, who will play. Maybe have a little flick over to Scotland v Belgium where there could be three of ours playing, every so often!

Phil Sammon
10 Posted 06/09/2013 at 06:27:21
It's no wonder people get sick of following England.

Hopefully Baines is being tested in this first game, which many see as a formality, and will play in the real test - against some other shit team that we really should be pounding 6-0.

I don't understand England and what they're trying to do. Lambert, Gerrard, Lampard, Cole...even our very own Jagielka - these lads are noot going to win a World Cup. Can't we get some younger players in and give them a chance to develop?

I watched a bit of the U21's last night. Loads of them have just 1 or 2 caps and then have a few good club games and get dragged into the England setup. These kids should be playing together in the same team for 5 years between 18 and 23. Build a TEAM - not just a group of individuals. It hasn't worked for the last thirty years, has it?!

I'm watching Ireland.

Ray Roche
11 Posted 06/09/2013 at 06:44:04
England? I remember when Bobby Robson was manager and Everton were the best side in Britain. The England manager couldn't be arsed travelling to Goodison and didn't watch Everton live until the November when we went to Ipswich, despite the likes of Steven, Stevens, Reid, Heath etc. being in our squad. His eventual interest was forced by the media who revealed his lack of interest in Everton. Club before country? You bet.
Drew O'Neall
12 Posted 06/09/2013 at 07:05:45
Finally they are playing with a 'proper' centre forward (Lambert), against a bunch of weedy little midgets, and he drops the best crosser of a ball in Europe.. Staggering.

I get so frustrated by Baines' England outings because he gets in to a position to deliver, and England's minute forwards instantly vacate the box.

Phil Sammon
13 Posted 06/09/2013 at 07:18:18
Drew

Baines hasn't put a decent cross in for months.

And Lambert...good player, but where is he taking us? Everybody agrees we need a long term plan. But nobody is willing to initiate it.

Get the youngsters in and lets plan for 8 - 10 years time.

Peter Warren
14 Posted 06/09/2013 at 07:38:27
Totally disagree about putting youngsters in the senior side. Put the youngsters (including Townsend Wiltshire Stones and Barkley) in the U21 side, let them mature into playing how you want to play, and in a few years bring them all in to national side. No continuity, it's terrible
Phil Roberts
15 Posted 06/09/2013 at 07:43:07
Phil - but two of them months were June and July and he was sat on the beach
Barry Roberts
16 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:09:00
Whichever country starts the most everton players, that's the game I'll be watching.
Paul David
17 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:23:49
Cole over Baines? Punishment for not signing for Man Utd.
Matt Traynor
19 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:31:04
Colin #179, if what you say is true, then picking Leighton v Ukraine suggests to me that he's ahead of Cashley in the pecking order - Moldova should be a straightforward game, if there is ever such a thing with England.
Alan Newton
20 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:34:47
Personally, I'm not too fussed that Baines hasn't been picked to play. Less chance of one of those fiendishly freak injuries occurring that tend to spoil Everton seasons.... it would be just our luck if he got an injury after hanging on to him in the latest window. #Pessimistic
Ged Alexander
21 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:36:10
England? Sorry, nothing to do with me - Everton, then Everton again and then Everton. All I want is for the boys to all come home...
Alan Newton
22 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:36:10
John Gee #177 - spot on lad
Kev Johnson
23 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:28:22
Well, Baines or no Baines, I'll be rooting for England. I admit it, I'm an England fan. COYW!

It seems an odd selection, though, given the fact that SG and FL may not be able to manage two games in five days and it's the Ukraine match which really counts. Come to think of it, Wilshere is not 100% either, so I'd have rested him for the first game.

I dare say Lambert will get a goal against the minnows, but I don't think he's got what it takes to handle the game in Kiev. I'm also concerned about Walker at RB. The Cahill/Jags comb doesn't exactly fill me with confidence. Cole is a very good LB, even if he's not as good as Leighton, so no worries there.

Even though three of my grandparents are Irish, I don't really feel an affinity with the boys in green. Good luck to them, but I don't care if they win or lose. I don't bet, but if I did I would put a tenner now on Belgium to reach the World Cup semi-finals. A talented bunch, and no mistaking.

Alan Newton
24 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:40:54
And Ged #212 - I give up on watching or caring about England when they didn't qualify for the 1994 World Cup.... the team is fully of players I detest from clubs I hate, who are on far too much money, and only ever tap up our best. I'd be a hypocrite if I followed England under such circumstances
Iain Love
25 Posted 06/09/2013 at 09:46:40
Doesn't exactly fill you with optimism, although it's the 2nd game that's the hardest.

I'm bemused by the way someone has a decent game or two and is thrust into the senior squad without the chance of a game... surely Ross would benefit more by playing under 21 until SG and FL retire?

Anyway, all I'm really bothered about is our players come back uninjured.

Brian Denton
26 Posted 06/09/2013 at 10:11:50
Ged 212 - says it all. I lost interest in England as soon as I was grown up enough to realise that a shit Spurs/Man U/Liverpool etc player would always be selected ahead of a deserving Everton player. Not interested, won't watch.
Damian Halligan
27 Posted 06/09/2013 at 10:19:43
Glad Ross isn't playing. Don't want him injured or show cased. Let's enjoy his talent at Everton.
James Martin
29 Posted 06/09/2013 at 10:46:17
No England manager since Hoddle has had a clue. Until one of them has the stones to drop both Stevie Me and 'Lamps' then we won't win anything. They are two players who have relied on better players at their clubs to do the technical side of the game whilst they come in and have a woof from the edge of the box. Great to watch in the prmeier league but completely useless at internaitonal level. How Carrick and Scholes two of the best English midfielders of recent times who have dominated the premier league have continuously been overlooked for these two clowns is beyond me.
David Hallwood
30 Posted 06/09/2013 at 10:44:06
I'm alan newton(#211) I'd rather all our players were having the week off resting for the chelsea game, without the prospect of any of them picking up an injury. Sorry to be unpatriotic but I really couldn't give a flying one about the national side and if woy wants to pick cole over baines, I'm only sorry that he's still not managing the RS.
Barry Rathbone
31 Posted 06/09/2013 at 10:58:44
International football should be disbanded it is shite.

Just watching our man, Roberto Martinez, on SSN he looks like a man with the weight of the world lifted from his shoulders now the transfer battle is over.

So he should - he played a blinder and won.

Sin Miedo.

Shane Corcoran
32 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:09:52
Disband it cos you think it's shite Barry? I feel the same about Eastenders.

I get a certain rush before every Ireland game despite Trap's best efforts to drain every bit of enthusiasm out of us. I don't care if there are 11 Liverpool players involved. It's completely separate for me.

I remember watching an England game in a pub in Ireland and a United and Liverpool fan were cheering when players from their respective clubs got the ball.

Anyway, we'll soon be out I imagine, Trapp will be gone and we can build a new team around Clark, Gibson, McCarthy and Long.

Richard Reeves
33 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:25:10
Shane Corcoran (#240),

Spike Milligan summed up Eastenders perfectly on an episode of Room 101. Worth watching if you haven't seen it.

Matt Traynor
34 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:42:00
I'm with Shane #240. International football can provide entertainment. I understand where people are coming from about hating it, but not all of us who enjoy it are jingoistic drunken knobs either. I admit to enjoying games as a neutral more than the England games, but that's only for the same reason I don't enjoy derby matches either - too much tension around the game to be enjoyable.

I've been lucky enough to go to tournaments in Europe and Asia, seen penalty shoot-outs, finals, and really enjoyed the experience. I've always felt pride when Everton players are representing their country too, as it nromally means we've got a good one. I recall seeing Rooney's last kick of a ball in a competitive match as an Everton player - in Lisbon in 2004, but anyone who thinks he decided to leave as he was getting tapped up by the likes of Gary Neville and Paul Scholes is deluding themselves.

For me the best period was during the 80s - specifically the 86 World Cup when we provided almost half the starting England team. For reasons that have been done to death on here, it's a shame that HK (first incarnation) was unable to build from there.

Ian Burns
35 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:55:59
Watching the Ireland game me - want to see what McCarthy is like now he is one of ours and because he is "over the moon". Also of course be watching mustard.

Brian Harrison
36 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:50:52
Strange that a lot of football fans have little or no interest in how England perform. Yet most other countries their main priority is their national teams.
I cant agree with Barry about disbanding international football, the best football I have ever seen was played by the 1970 Brazilian World cup winners. I know people say how good Barcelona and Spain are but in my opinion Brazil were just breathtaking.
Peter Cummings
37 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:43:12
We all know how succesive England managers have treated Everton in favour of the 'luvvie' clubs, so no surprise there. We are seeing more and more London-based players, some of them picked after a couple of decent games for their clubs, being touted as 'world class' yet not performing for their country.

Another sore point is why every major sporting event has to take place 'dahn sahf'? Last month it was an all northern Charity Shield... yet Wembley had to be the venue with the massive expense to supporters involved, and only southerners having fairly inexpensive trips to watch England games, which should be spread around the country they are supposed to represent.

Eugene Ruane
38 Posted 06/09/2013 at 11:34:49
The only 'we' or 'us' for me is Everton, please don't assume otherwise.

International football gives me the screaming ab-dabs, as does the assumption that I should take 'pride' in somewhere, because I happened to have been spawned there.

I had no say in it, so what exactly am I supposed to be proud of, I have NO idea.

And if a country, why not a continent or a hemisphere?

Spain beat Argentina (weeping) "I'm SO proud of my hemisphere right now!" (waves flag with 'Go Northern!" on it).

Yes our species managed to get to the top of the food chain, but we're also the only mammal on earth that dangles tatty, stained, frayed two-bob flags from our houses.

(and before anyone mentions 'The Tatty-As-Fuck Cross Of St George Flag Dangling Toad', it's an amphibian, not a mammal).

James Fletcher
39 Posted 06/09/2013 at 10:49:54
Isn't the fact that he's saving Baines for the game against the Ukraine actually a massive compliment?
Gerry Quinn
41 Posted 06/09/2013 at 12:21:19
Went to all 3 matches at Goodison and 3 matches at Old Trafford in '66 and saw the best 3 teams in the world - but without doubt Portugal were something else. Eusebio, Torres, Augusto - wow, what football they played. Between them 14 goals in 4 matches, including a comeback from 3-0 down to win 5-3 with Eusebio "Tonto" scoring 4 of them. Fantastic footballing side. Even Hungary were a great footballing side, and Brazil too - whose players basically got kicked all over the Goodison turf. And then there was England? 3 utterly boring group matches and another yawn against Argentina (I'm sure even the referee had a cockney accent?). Finally they then had the cheek to switch the Portugal semi-final from Goodison to Wembley - for safety reasons. Safety reasons - my arse! Yawn of a team, apart from Bally (being as biased that I am).
One Ingerlund cap between Kendall and Harvey in the era of the Holy Trinity - WTF??? If they had of played for Spurs or Leeds, media darlings at the time, they still wouldn't have made Alf Ramsey's bloody boring team. They haven't changed style or attitude since - all talk and no walk.
Robbie Muldoon
42 Posted 06/09/2013 at 12:42:07
How good is this compared to Dour Davey Moyes:

"In any performance from a youngster I never focus on the mistakes. I value their reaction to the mistakes and their next pass, or next decision," - Martinez.

That's Roberto talking about John Stones. He's already done it with Ross Barkley. It's got the lad in the England squad already. For me, MOyes was a fucking dead weight on this club. Made up he's gone and Roberto is here.

Kev Johnson
43 Posted 06/09/2013 at 12:46:31
No one is assuming anything as far as I can see, Eugene (250). I've been on TW long enough to know that hardly anyone is interested in the national side - in fact, most are dead set against international football.

I feel rather the same about England as a nation as I do about Liverpool as a city - deeply ambivalent, basically, but with pride outweighing dismay. To quote the words of the seldom sung sixth verse of the national anthem: "Yeah-but-no-but-yeah-but, if you know what I mean".

Steve Pugh
44 Posted 06/09/2013 at 13:21:40
Robbie #257, apart from the fact that your post is totally irrelevant to the thread and looks like just another chance to dig at Moyes because you miss him so much. Isn't it virtually word for word what he said about Barkley?
Tony Dove
46 Posted 06/09/2013 at 13:37:29
Feel sorry for Jags as he will again be playing out of of position on the left side. He and Lescott are a more suitable pairing although I have nothing against Cahill
Eugene Ruane
47 Posted 06/09/2013 at 13:25:41
Kev (260) - "No one is assuming anything as far as I can see, Eugene"

Disagree - if there are people posting on TW about England and using the words 'we' and/or 'us' (nb: and there are), they are without doubt making an assumption.

Or to spell it out, WE (ie: you, me, all of us) are surely the 'we' they're referring to.

And if not - who are 'we'?

Or 'us'?

Type...stuff.


Paul Andrews
48 Posted 06/09/2013 at 14:08:36
James Martin 232,

It's because we as a footballing nation favour brawn over brains.
Lets play the power game instead of finesse.
Your comments re Scholes and Carrick are spot on.
Scholes the best midfielder of his generation ....Xavi " Paul Scholes the most complete midfielder of the last 20 years"
Carrick the nearest thing we have to Pirlo.

Your football knowledge impresses me more every time you post young man.

Ciarán McGlone
49 Posted 06/09/2013 at 15:07:17
I haven't had a national team since 1921...boo hoo..
Sam Hoare
50 Posted 06/09/2013 at 12:14:08
Club football and international football are totally separate for me and I will always support England in any sporting arena however depressing that may be.

I for one am very excited at the outside prospect of their being 3 Everton players in the England team if they make it to brazil. Wonder when the last time that happened was?

Steve Brown
51 Posted 06/09/2013 at 15:07:02
Picking a proper English centre forward is a good idea.

England have always looked better with a target man. Reminds me of Bob Latchford playing for England and he did alright!

Steve King
52 Posted 06/09/2013 at 15:31:53
If you think supporting England is depressing Sam you should try being Welsh!!
Our Manager cant even keep track of his passport!!
Harold Matthews
53 Posted 06/09/2013 at 15:27:20
Yes Sam. I think I'll go with you on this one, although I do get really frustrated when internationals and cup ties interrupt the league fixtures.

Stones had a great game last night. Not quite as dynamic as Shaw but couldn't be faulted.

Nick Entwistle
54 Posted 06/09/2013 at 15:52:56
Can't remember the last time I watched an England match that wasn't in a championship, and only then hoping they'd lose.

I may give it 20 minutes tonight (is it tonight?) but then remember my boredom threshold has been breached and turn on Storage Hunters instead.

Phil Bellis
55 Posted 06/09/2013 at 15:57:21
We lost the double in '86 beacuse of a meaningless international football match - stuff 'em!
Norman Merrill
57 Posted 06/09/2013 at 16:24:02
I hope Jags comes thru injury free, can't see Ross getting a game,
so my football watching tonight is The Belgian lads, versus Scotland. & what Seamus & McCarthy can do against Sweden.

Kev Johnson
58 Posted 06/09/2013 at 16:26:50
It seems to me that Welsh and Irish Evertonians generally tend to be fans of their national sides, whereas the vast majority of English Blues are exceedingly grumpy when the subject of England comes up.

I am myself an eminent psychologist, but it would take a man even more eminent and psychological to answer the question: why?

Phil Sammon
60 Posted 06/09/2013 at 16:42:36
Is it because you're a grumpy old git, Kev?
Paul Thompson
61 Posted 06/09/2013 at 16:35:03
The rash of 'I don't give a toss about England' posts every time there is a call-up is drearily predictable. What needs to be acknowledged is that Everton and other players do care about playing for their national sides, and that such progression (injuries aside) enhances their status and the Club's, their experience and sometimes, their expertise. The fact that various national managers have ignored particular Everton players does not alter that fact. Without too much expectation, I shall support England tonight, whilst looking out for our lads to play well in any national team.
Tony Draper
62 Posted 06/09/2013 at 16:55:46
Look Here Phil Sammon (305) !

Oh hang on there, I saw "grumpy old git", and instantly thought you meant me.

As you were.....carry on, but consider yourself warned

Raymond Fox
63 Posted 06/09/2013 at 17:21:18
With our Everton hats on, do we want our players to play in internationals?

If you include our foreign internationals you could in theory end up with only a few fit players for our next league match!

The old debate club v country?

Phil Bellis
64 Posted 06/09/2013 at 17:37:08
No debate (is there?)

Answer honestly
You can have one of....
England WC winners or
Everton League Champions?

Phil Sammon
65 Posted 06/09/2013 at 17:44:06
I'd take Everton as World Cup winners!
Eugene Ruane
66 Posted 06/09/2013 at 17:25:08
Paul Thompson (308) - "What needs to be acknowledged is that Everton and other players do care about playing for their national sides, and that such progression (injuries aside) enhances their status and the Club's, their experience and sometimes, their expertise"

Fine acknowledge away, but remember 'injuries aside' is easy to say, only if nobody gets injured (and like Phil Bellis, 288, I have a long memory).

Plus if our players were not selected, they'd be far less likely to have 'How would you fancy joining Utd?" whispered in their ear.

I'm serious - first thing I thought of when Barkley was called up was some twat sounding him out ("How much are you on!? Is that all!??")

Plus, imo, the problem with 'their status' being enhanced is that they appear much clearer on the radar and consequently are more likely to be poached.

Sorry, but I only have eyes for Everton and see few benefits to our players joining up with England

As for "The rash of 'I don't give a toss about England' posts every time there is a call-up is drearily predictable"

Maybe, but no more drearily predictable than a post saying it's all so drearily predictable.

Jamie Barlow
67 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:13:57
I'm with Nick. Storage Hunters all the way.
Eugene Ruane
68 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:04:25
Phil (324) "England WC winners or Everton League Champions?"

It could be Everton to beat Liverpool in a derby in the last game of the season, in a game that won't affect our league position - OR England win the world cup and hand on heart, I can say us to win the derby.

Maybe the only competition/game we could be in, that I'd even entertain the idea of forfeiting to give England the WC, would be the Brylcreem cup, but then just before I said "Ok!" I know I'd start to think of the appalling twattiness and gloating and flag-waving it would spawn (from people who actually despise football), then I'd think of how most of England despises our city and I'd say "Naaah, changed me mind lid, swear down"

Colin Glassar
69 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:37:23
Jags on the left side of defence for England looks really uncomfortable. I'd play him with lescott. Like John Gee said, Bainsey's probably being punished for not signing for man u.
Ross Edwards
70 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:37:18
Everton league champions anyday. The national team is a load of egos who think they are superior to everyone else, who play for themselves
Colin Glassar
71 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:43:20
I think I might watch the Scotland - Belgium games just to see how are lads (Lukaku, super Kev and Felli - still ours till he puts that red rag on) get on.
Derek Knox
72 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:35:53
Eugene ( 330 )

Just for my diary, when is the Brylcreem Cup this year?

Also, will follicly challenged players be eligible for this much awaited, and in my estimation, under-rated spectacle?

Come to think of it, we don't have any foll............... baldy bastards, oh yes we do our Tim Howard!

Tony Draper
73 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:47:09
Ross (335)
Only time England won the World Cup

Everton won the FA Cup
Englands stylish left back was a Blue
Labour Government

Following the win, Everton signed World Cup Final Man of the Match 21 year old "Red Headed Dynamo" Alan Ball


That'd do me !

Raymond Fox
74 Posted 06/09/2013 at 18:29:00
I don't know about everyone else, but I've wasted far too much of my life watching England fail miserably.

Were still as far behind the best footballing nations as we were 40+yrs ago, and for the same reason, ball control!

Oh yes, we can run all day and be aggressive eg Stuart Pearce, but still lack the basic skill.

Phil Bellis
75 Posted 06/09/2013 at 19:55:52
Mr Sammon,
Tshhhh boommm!

But remember this...no England team has ever won the World Cup without an Everton left-back

Errol Stafford
76 Posted 06/09/2013 at 20:37:53
As an Irish Evertonian, I've been watching James McCarthy with great interest during the first half against Sweden, and I must say I'm a bit concerned. Trapattoni has said before that he is a boy who needs to become a man, and I can see what he means. He doesn't impose himself like a midfield leader or playmaker should, he isn't looking to dictate the play or drive his team on. He seems like a passive player, happy to track back and hold his position and little more.

He has barely touched the ball, and doesn't seem to be looking to receive it. In fact, he seems to be taking up positions where he cant be given it. Glen Whelan, a carthorse, is much more prominent in the game and McCarthy looks a bit lost. He doesn't seem to have any great confidence, any bullishness - that self assured arrogance that top players have, he doesn't have that look in his eyes.

I know it's far too early to judge, and in an Ireland team that are much more direct than Everton under Martinez. However, for £13m, you would expect to get a player fully believing in his own brilliance. I'm watching Steven Defour, a few years older and more experienced, but much more imposing and confident. Surely such a player could have been bought for the same price as McCarthy?

Don't get me wrong, I really hope he will prove to be the player Martinez thinks he is and for that I trust Martinez. But the early signs aren't promising.

Roger Helm
77 Posted 06/09/2013 at 21:17:55
I'm sorry I can't watch the England game as Traffic Cops is on the other side. I'll catch the report later, but my only interest is whether our lads did well and didn't pick up an injury.
Andrew Cutler
78 Posted 06/09/2013 at 21:38:28
McCarthy looked very average...if that.
Kev Johnson
79 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:02:31
Well, the full 90 for Jags, 45 for Bainesy and 30 mins for Ross - he nearly scored too. Good to see three of our players representing England at the same time, and acquitting themselves well. Job done.
Kevin Rowlands
80 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:15:12
I think McCarthy should be judged on his performances for Everton rather than playing for a bog average Irish team who for the most part play hoofball from what I seen, going to trust Martinez on this one.
Eugene Ruane
81 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:02:59
Andrew (368) - Have to agree re McCarthy, he looked very..um..'boyish' and not at all with it.

Given the size of Fellaini, it was always going to be almost impossible to replace that kind of presence, but to get anywhere near it, this lad is going to have to work really hard to impose himself (and he'll need to concentrate a LOT more than he did tonight).

Hopefully it was just the end of a tiring week or...something.

Anthony McKeown
82 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:16:55
Andrew

Wind your neck in. Let the boy make his debut for Everton before making rash "I told you so" shite bullshit comments.

Si Cooper
83 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:06:44
Wonder if any of the Moldovan players had the good sense to secure young Ross' shirt?

The first full national shirt of a future football star would surely be a sound investment.

Okay, not everything happened the way he intended it but he must have been involved more than anyone else in the time he was on the pitch. He plays like a matador and glides past opposition players at times.

Jags was solid and dependable, but Bainesy seemed to be playing well-within his capabilities. Saving himself for the Ukraine match or just not risking a stupid mistake / injury in an easy game?

Tony Draper
85 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:40:18
Errol (360)
not wishing to personally run you down, so please consider

Trapattoni, so he's the next big thing in international football management is he ?
That's why he's managing Ireland ?
(I'm NOT disrespecting Ireland, but with a population of approx 5M never going to be a "World Power", this says considerably more about the aspirations of FIA that Trap)

IF the great Trap isn't sold on McCarthy, why pick him ?

The logic is so akin to the flawed "Moyesian" philosophy it's uncanny !

The manager IS the reason the player is in the team, not vice versa

McCarthy is 22

Better to be 22 and have room for improvement

Than 74 and not be able to bring out the best in a player

Robert Workman
86 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:34:27
Big dilemna. Trying to watch the David v Goliath match here on TV - Deutschland v Austria, whilst watching England via Internet.

So what is the problem? Well it is red v white in both games, but on one I am supporting red and in the other white. OK you got it.

Anyway the reason for breaking in to this thread is that I have seen the funniest thing ever on a football field. Football is not noted for massive amounts of humour - right? So this made it even more special.

This is what happened.
A German player was injured on the far side of the pitch. The trainer ran on and got half way across the pitch when he fell over.

Wait a minute - it gets better.
His 2 bags fly left and right of him, whilst he remains on the ground. Then, after what seems like a lifetime (seriously), he trys to get up - but falls over again. Then we are shown Lahm (right back, left back, whatever) running to the touchline with both bags. We never got to see what happend to the trainer!!!

I have to say that I missed this first time around, but the TV company obviously thought it worth showing again! Who said there was no such thing as a German sense of humour?

It was hilarious. Looked like the guy was pissed (well it was played in Munich!) and just pretended to be the trainer.
Honestly you couldnt make it up. What about the renowned German efficiency? No wonder Herr Lahm took over!

Paul Thompson
87 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:45:27
Three Everton players on the pitch for England is great for the club's reputation and visibility. The progress Ross has made this season is remarkable and he looked comfortable, showing his quick feet and thinking on a number of occasions.

As for the problem of our players being 'tapped up', (Eugene@327), as our current and previous manager have said, if you are good, other clubs will want you. It's a compliment and up to us to make it hard to tempt our best away. Not easy, but it can and is being done.

John Gee
88 Posted 06/09/2013 at 22:45:02
Si, I think Baines was playing within himself because we were 3-0 up but more importantly because I can imagine a half time talk about Welbeck being booked for nothing and Cole being on a yellow and Hodgson maybe saying "I don't want to lose my first choice left hand side for Ukrainian game."

Anyway, England will certainly win the world cup because we won 4-0...against Moldova. Lamps and Gerrard proved they can play together... Against Moldova. Welbeck looks like a future England superhero... Against Moldova.

Did anyone else notice Gerrard refusing to pass to Barkley on a couple of occasions when he was in a good position?

Paul Andrews
89 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:01:24
The rate Barkley has come on must prove to be an embarrassment to our former manager.
Ross would be on loan at Sc**thorpe if the ginger minge bag was still here.
Spragg Johnson
90 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:01:07
A lot of Toffee man love around for 'Loyal Leighton' ... How can you not love this guy? Cool as f@*k haircut, music tastes, and still a Toffee despite Gollum lurking. I know he'll get the reception he deserves next time out at Goodison.
John Gee
91 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:11:29
Paul 390, When you typed in Scunthorpe did you put those stars in yourself or were they automatically generated?

It brings to mind a story about Scunthorpe council's IT department putting a block on any external email that contained bad language (I don't know how this all works), after 3 months they wondered why they hadn't received a single external email. It turns out that they were automatically blocking because the email address contained what can only be described politely as the slang term for a ladies delicate flower.

LL, MK – not having a go at the site, I just like the logic loops. Gives us a reminder that automation is a human tool. Luddites rule!

Christopher Kelly
92 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:08:11
ROSS BARKLEY! THATS ALL WE NEED TO SAY!!!!!!!!!!
Tony Draper
93 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:31:26
Spragg

Is right !

Baines
Too cool for the fool !

Brent Stephens
94 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:26:43
John, apparently Nottingham used to be called Snottingham until the Norsemen (?) invaded and dropped the 'S'. Scunthorpe has always been relieved they never invaded their town. So the old story goes.
Tom Bowers
95 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:29:19
Great for young Ross. Give Hodgson his due he doesn't waste time giving players a chance. Lambert has done well and Ross had a good half hour.

Like many other ''little teams'' Moldova were easy pickings once the first goal went in but having said that Lampard was crap and despite his goal Gerrard wasn't much. I suppose both will play against Ukraine and we will see if they can rise to the occasion in that game but in my opinion both are on the down side as is Ashley Cole.

Walcott has speed but his decision making is awful at times.
It will be backs against the wall in Ukraine fear.

Brent Stephens
96 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:37:14
Ah! I typed the full name of Scunthorpe, no asterisks and yet it's come out with asterisks! Now didn't Michael have a pop at posters who used such asterisks, saying" if that's what you mean why don't you just spell it out?"?
Mick Doherty
97 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:18:49
Errol and Andrew, I would totally agree McCarthy was very poor, however, considering Trappatoni's only tactic was to bypass the midfield altogether and to try and keep the ball 'in the air' in a total hoof-and-hope debacle, it would be harsh to judge McCarthy on that performance.

I have seen him play a lot better for Ireland, generally in friendlies when Trappatoni allows footballers to actually play a bit of football, on the grass and everything, passing to each other and stuff. I'd completely disregard how he performs for Ireland, even Coleman seems to be shackled in the present Irish set-up, there is a demand from the Irish punters for a more progressive style of management, and Trappatoni will be out after the Austria game, so with a bit of luck they'll appoint someone with a modern approach which could aid the development of McCarthy, and Gibson might return once the 'prehistoric relic' is gone.

Carl Sanderson
98 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:25:41
John 386,

"Did anyone else notice Gerrard refusing to pass to Barkley on a couple of occasions when he was in a good position?"

I texted just that to my mate when it happened; he used to starve Baines of the ball when Leighton first got into the national side, too.

He is one tosser, him.

Brent Stephens
99 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:39:55
Hodgson is a crap judge of ability. He picked Ossie and now he picks Ross.
Brent Stephens
100 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:41:37
John, Carl. Yes, it struck me as well. Asterisks.
Carl Sanderson
101 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:41:12
Brent 404,

"Hodgson is a crap judge of ability. He picked Ossie and now he picks Ross."

Don't forget he picked that useless twat, Baines. And selecting Jagielka merely compounds his error.

Brent Stephens
102 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:45:09
Carl. Sorry, I'd forgotten how really crap Hodgson is. Well corrected, mate.
Dave Long
103 Posted 06/09/2013 at 23:34:08
Going back to the 70s, bob latch failed to get many caps despite being the leagues top scorer by a mile. Think he was kept out by Paul mariner!

Skip to 86 world cup, one of the best moments for me was Bryan robsons shoulder injury, forcing his dad bobby to select Peter Reid. Unfortunately Reid's ankle injury stopped him catching maradona from scoring that goal...following season he was out for ages.

England have previous on the subject of selecting everton players....I'm not old enough to judge Kendall and Harvey, can anyone enlighten me?

David Pearl
107 Posted 07/09/2013 at 00:47:22
I remember that perfectly Dave. More of an insult for me was Sharpy only getting 12 Scotland Caps
Karl Masters
108 Posted 07/09/2013 at 00:37:44
I went through a phase of loathing England and their so called superstars with self obsessed cocks like Terry, Ferdinand, Cole, Gerrard, Lampard, Rooney, Beckham and David James turning out and making us look like tossers to the rest of the world. Ably backed by I hate Scousers Neville and a new breed of money mad hypocrites like Lescott and Barry ( oh the irony!! ) it seemed impossible to relate to any of them.

The thought of an arse like John Terry holding the World Cup aloft made me feel sick. And those goons we had as Managers as well! Car flags during tournaments etc.Toe curling.

Nowadays, I suppose having a few decent Everton lads in there has softened my stance a bit and many of the cocks are off modelling underwear or are no longer part of the set up. We have a Manager who got shafted big time at Anfield and is actually quite a decent bloke. I can relate to the current team a bit more. More underdog and less me. me, me about the place. I'll be glad when Lampard and Gerrard lose their places and Baines is better than Cole so that wanker won't be around much longer. My interest is starting to increase again.

David Pearl
109 Posted 07/09/2013 at 01:23:43
Yep, even though I am English I have in the past been routing for ROI when Sheedy played against us and Scotland when they had blues in their team. The Beckham era turned out to be nothing but hot air. It would be something if Barkley continues his progression. We have a new crop of players coming through I hope they get their chance and leave the ego's at home.
Ian Hollingworth
114 Posted 07/09/2013 at 02:01:38
It always amazes me that football fans do not want to support the national team. By the way I think it is an English thing only.
All professional players want to play for their country. For me surely that tells you something?

As much as England frustrate me I support them fully and with pride they are my country and it has always been part and parcel of the football game to have internationals. Does that make me any less of an Evertonian? I don't think so!

Roman Sidey
116 Posted 07/09/2013 at 00:09:36
Phil, why doesn't everyone see what you and I see? When was the last time Baines put in a decent cross that we actually scored from?

On the choice between England winning the WC and Everton winning the EPL? As a non-Englishman, that's very easy to choose.

John Gee
118 Posted 07/09/2013 at 03:27:23
Roman, Lambert scored his first goal for England from a Baines corner. The last player we had who could put in a decent cross was probably Hinchcliffe who had big Duncan to aim for. Baines seems to be one of those players/men who doesn't quite have a handle on big their talent is. If he's coached right, I think you'll see yet another dimension to his play.

I've probably got this wrong, but if it was my team I'd have Baines playing left side of a midfield 3 because he's skillful, can pass, tackle and is perpetual motion incarnate in the Everton tradition.

Ray Roche
120 Posted 07/09/2013 at 08:53:20
Ian Hollingworth @ 435

"All professional players want to play for their country. "
Ian, that isn't really true. The likes of Giggs wouldn't bother playing for Wales in anything but an important qualifier, hence he won only 64 caps in 16 years, against Southall's 92 caps in 15 years. Amazingly, all the injuries that kept him out of Wales team had cleared up by UTD's next game. The difference is that Southall WANTED to play for his country, Giggs wanted to play for UTD. (he also wanted to play away, but that's another story) I think many players regard an International cap as a way of increasing their profile and their value and, consequently, a bigger pay packet.

Tom Cuffe
121 Posted 07/09/2013 at 08:56:08
Congrats, Ross, on your debut — nearly a goal as well to top it off.

It was good to see some of our better players getting a run out for their countries, hopefully it sharpens them up for the Chelsea game... and no new injury concerns.

Kev Johnson
124 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:15:42
Ray, Ian may have over-stated the case there - there are indeed some players who can't be arsed to turn out for their country - but you've gone to the other extreme with your suggestion that "many" players see an international cap as simply a way of upping their wages.

I don't know - because I can't see inside players' heads (as hard as I've tried) - but I imagine most players see it as a great honour to play for their country. The only reason they wouldn't is because fans are increasingly negative about the national side. Witness this thread!

Only last night I dreamt I was playing cricket for England. True! It was in a crucial Ashes test match in Australia. However, predictably, I was playing with a plastic bat and it turned into a standard anxiety dream. (There's a much longer version of this dream. If anyone's interested, send me a large SAE and I'll despatch a copy!) I think this proves beyond doubt that the desire to represent one's country runs deep. I rest my case.

Ged Simpson
125 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:17:25
I have to say I think internationals are, to most footy fans, a meaningless irritation that mess up your weekend. I have always seen England as a team designed to give the undeclass of Essex something to moan or cheer about. Thankfully proper footy back next weekend.
John Ford
126 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:35:46
Kevin, I have the same dream, only in mine I'm walking off to a standing ovation at Melbourne having scored 400 not out to win the ashes.

England won via their momentum last night. A very...er...English way to do it. They played the game at a tempo (when they were interested) which Moldova couldn't deal with. The problem is this demotes skill and thought. The number of occasions passes were missed or runs we're just speed over brains? It was dull. Good teams focus on possession, finding space, the timing of runs and accuracy. We are high quality huff and puff. Nowt more.

Im a casual England fan. I quite like the tournaments but these games are an irritation and get in the way of what really matters.

John Ford
127 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:44:02
I referred to 'we' when I should have said England.
Peter Mills
128 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:21:41
Everton could have won the World Cup in 1970 had Sir Alf heeded the advice from Gwladys Street - "Send our team to Mexico, hallelujah".

West, Wright, Labone, Hurst, Newton, Kendall, Ball, Harvey, Husband, Royle, Morrisey.

James Fletcher
129 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:45:03
I actually thought we were pretty good last night and could easily have won 5/6-0. Lambert looks to be a good addition and played some great balls, he seems to have a good head on him and linked up very well with Welbeck, just a shame he's 31.........

Also thought all the Everton lads looked good and was very pleased to see that Barkley didn't look at all out of his depth and played well.

Kev Johnson
130 Posted 07/09/2013 at 09:48:54
That's interesting, John. I suspect that 400 not out indicates your mental health is superior to mine, mate. I was 0 not out when I had to go back to the team hotel to get a new bat - that was in the middle of the innings, mind. Obviously, I couldn't find the hotel...

I disagree about the tempo thing, though. To me, whether it's Everton or England, I can tell within 5-10 minutes of the start if the team is going to play well - and it's all to do with whether or not we are playing with a high tempo. It ain't about huff and puff, it's about intensity.

Mark Taylor
131 Posted 07/09/2013 at 10:39:47
Just hope that Barkley doesn't become a victim of the one or two cap syndrome that seems to have become very common over the last decade or so.

Like others, I remain pretty indifferent to England and I think that is a legacy of too many tossers in the team; I positively did not want to see a man like John Terry raise a trophy. As it turned out, that so called golden generation proved to be the biggest bunch of over paid under achievers in football history.

Right now, I'd probably sooner see Belgium do well, partly because I think it is neat and quite sobering that such a tiny country should have a better team than we've got.

I guess if Jags, Ross and Leighton get more game time, I may show a bit more interest.

Just as a small aside, it must be one of the travesties of football, that Micky Arteta never played international football. Incredible when you think of some of the cart horses who've won England caps. Mind you, even Mata can't even get in the current squad, so there is to put it mildly, some serious competition.

Tony Dove
132 Posted 07/09/2013 at 10:56:39
Barkley was superb when he came on.He is in a different league than Wilshire although I think Wilshire is a decent player.
Brian Hennessy
133 Posted 07/09/2013 at 10:57:55
Watched the Ireland v Sweden game with renewed Interest following McCarthy signing. Very hard to judge any player based on the hoof-ball Trapatoni continues to play but was a bit disappointed with James.

He wasn't afraid to get stuck into a tackle but on several occasions he went missing when we needed someone to demand the ball and hold possession.

To be honest I would hate any Everton player to have to play under Trap they genuinely look terrified to pass the ball. Coleman thankfully seems to ignore Trapatoni's instructions and continued to play his usual game.

At least following last nights defeat our two Irish lads should have a new manager soon enough..

Kev Johnson
134 Posted 07/09/2013 at 10:53:23
I just don't get all this "I don't support England because X, Y and Z are tossers". You guys love it on the high moral ground, don't you?

Me? I support Everton because I'm from Lpool and it's either blue or red. It's merely a matter of circumstance. They're my team, so obviously I'm biased in their favour. That's it, really. I didn't choose to support them on moral grounds. I admire players because of what they do on the pitch. Beyond that, it's nowt to do with me. As an anology, I strongly suspect some of my favourite musicians are absolute nightmares on a personal level, but I don't care so long as they produce the artistic goods. I mean, I appreciate the fact that Bainesy seems like a decent lad, but it's emphatically NOT the point. If he wasn't, he'd still be a top footballer and I'd still cheer for him.

I find international football a welcome break from the petty rivalries of the Premiership. One thing I would say, though, was that it was better when the national team played around the country, as they did when the new Wembley was being built. That definitely made people feel a bit more that it belonged to everyone, not just Londoners.

Phil Sammon
135 Posted 07/09/2013 at 11:29:34
That's it for me Kev. If you want to start getting people living England again, lets have some games in the north. Old Trafford, St James' Park - we have some great stadiums up here. The Ethiad too I guess, although its much too sterile for my liking. And these stadiums might actually get filled - unlike Wembley fans who only turn up when they can be arsed.
Ian Burns
136 Posted 07/09/2013 at 11:33:09
Gerry Quinn - 256 - as usual late onto the site but just wanted to make a comment on your post. I was also at those games at Goodison Park and I also thought Portugal were incredible. I stood behind the goal where Eusebio scored his 4 goals against North Korea, including the pen. However, their number 6 Coluna ruined that World Cup for me as he kicked Pele all over Goodison Park and left him limping throughout the game (no subs then).

Why don't they play the international game on Saturday afternoon? I've got to mow the ruddy lawn now!

I was pleasantly surprised that the introduction of Barkley for Wilshere gave England a better look as he played further up the field and would have made even more of an impact if Gerrard had noticed he was actually on his side!

Roll on next weekend, when we can get back to normal.

Andrew Clare
137 Posted 07/09/2013 at 11:51:21
It is quite clear just from the short time that Barkley was on the pitch last night that he is going to be one hell of a player.
Which club had a bid for him turned down on deadline day?
He is already the hottest property in the EPL.
Mark Taylor
138 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:03:01
Kev492

I don't think it is unusual for football supporters to have relative indifference to the national team. A sizeable minority- and maybe a decent majority- care far more about their club than their national team. I'd far sooner we won the EPL, than England won the Euros for example. Obviously that isn't true in all sports- in cricket and rugby, I'd say the national team is bigger than the club/county- but it is common in football.

So the basic attachment that led you to Everton is not there in these cases. Hence you take a more dispassionate look at what you are being asked to support. And yes, it then does matter if the people you see playing are tossers. I don't see that as moral high ground, just simply not going out my way to support tossers.

Roman Sidey
139 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:08:30
John Gee, sorry I did mean and should have said "for Everton" when questioning Baines' recent crossing.I do agree with you though about him maybe being better suited to the left midfield than the left back.

Mark Taylor, surely Barkley playing in a qualifier rather than a friendly (a la Ossie) means he is seen as part of an overall plan and not just a chance to see how he goes. I might be wrong but I'd assume most of those one-hit-wonder England caps would be in friendlies?

Ian Burns
140 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:12:05
Kev/Mark, I can't imagine any true football supporter wanting to see England win the World Cup as against their club even so much as winning the Premiership and especially the Champions League.

However, Mark you make an excellent point in that would probably only happen in football as in all other sports, you would certainly wish to see your country succeed above all else. Having said that, it could be that any other sport to me at least, creates only a passive interest, so it could be if you are a rugby supporter for example, you may wish to see your club succeed more than your country.

EFC above all else.

Michael Winstanley
141 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:15:51
Kev. Your dream sounds great, is it online anywhere?
Guy Hastings
142 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:23:08
Ian 500 - it kills Gerrard to pass to an Everton player. His display on Baines' debut was a disgrace; hitting overhit/underhit paases and leaving him totally exposed by wandering infield. A classic display of how to make another player look crap. And now he's captain.
Ian Burns
143 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:32:03
Guy 512 - Gerrard scored a wonderful goal last night but I get so frustrated watching play for England. He gives the ball away so often with his 40 yard plus passes and when he does get one right the commentators are drooling all over him, forgetting the number of times he has already given the ball away with his Hollywood stuff. My wife hates watching England games with me because all I ever say is "he's done it again!"

Mind you, not that I am biased but I was drooling when Barkley was only looking for the ball - so maybe it's just the EFC in me.

David Hallwood
144 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:30:13
I'm not anti England or anti English in fact (somewhat perversely)I get a sense of pride when our players are picked; it's more a case of anti internationals, How many times have players come back from international duty with an injury, its just when it comes down to club vs country-club wins hands down.

I would rather Everton won the Johnson's Paint Cup or even the Wuffo Dog Food memorial trophy let alone the EPL or FA Cup than England win the Euros or world cup.

Ian Burns
145 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:39:42
David, one would hope EFC never had to compete in the Johnson's Paint Cup!! - Who holds the present Wuffo Dog Food memorial trophy, is that the trophy Moyes won?
Kevin Tully
146 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:39:34
The only thing BK watches is a £30m pound note running around.
Ian Burns
147 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:44:18
Don't be silly Kevin, ridiculous remark. He would tread on it, pick it up and give to RM to spend in the January transfer window. Or he might er . . .
Simon Jones
148 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:45:02
Did I hear on the commentary that Hodgson sees Barkley like a Michael Ballack type player? I was only half listening. I hope we have him on a water-tight contract with an enormous buy-out clause for when Chelsea or Manure come sniffing.
David Hallwood
150 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:42:53
A Wuffo Dog Food medal is the only won that Stevie G la hasn't got in his cabinet-oh and a Premier League Medal...erm and a World Cup oh and a Euro.

Slightly off piste; Belgium looked very good last night against an admittedly poor Scottish side. and Miralles taking his goal well. Over to the Rep of Ireland, McCarthy looked worryingly one-paced

Eugene Ruane
151 Posted 07/09/2013 at 13:00:16
Kev (492) - "You guys love it on the high moral ground, don't you?"

Eh!?

So let me get this straight.

You and others like internationals/England and view the whole thing positively. You're comfortable applauding 'X Y and Z' and feel patriotism is fine/good/whatever.

I (and others) on the other hand, post to say we find it all an annoying distraction, generally view the whole thing negatively and don't feel comfortable applauding X Y and Z (especially X as he is a real twat). And speaking for myself, I see patriotism as ridiculous.

Well that's fine then isn't it - simply..differences of opinion?

Erm. no apparently not.

It seems this is NOT good enough for you - because those who see things differently to you are (roll on the drums!) taking the 'moral high ground'.

Sorry but complete and desperate bollocks.

Tony Draper
152 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:54:21
Guy (512)
Ian (500)

"stevie g" quite clearly declined to pass to Barkley last night, once when that was blindingly clear not only the best option but a bloody good one. However, I was not just unsurprised, I actually expected that

Sadly this dimwitted behavior sums up so much of what is wrong with the England smug bastard old guard.

Trevor Lynes
153 Posted 07/09/2013 at 13:19:09
Barkley was NOT superb, but he was not overawed and wanted the ball.
He did some good things and some not so good but he reminded me a lot of young Rooney.
A bit raw but bags of potential..he wanted the ball and found space for himself quite well.
It was however Moldova we were playing and I will reserve judgement until he plays against top teams in the premiership and then it will illuminate his strengths and dare I say weaknesses too.
!!
But he is an exciting prospect as is young Deo.
Both are really confident.
Brent Stephens
154 Posted 07/09/2013 at 13:32:37
Barks passed to the opposition too often. But great he got a run. Good shot at goal he's got. Really looking forward to see him perform for us this season.

Stevie G, meanwhile... I too noticed his nasty streak re Ross. Canute of the highest order.

Kev Johnson
155 Posted 07/09/2013 at 13:15:11
Not at all, Eugene. My love of of football is amoral, and my affiliations to Everton and England are amoral. For me, sport is a holiday from morality - unless, of course, someone like Suarez bends and breaks the rules on the field of play, in which case he is unsportsmanlike and therefore, in purely, footballing terms, a bad 'un.

On the other hand, saying that you refuse to support England because - or, as you would put it, BECAUSE - Terry, Gerrard or Whoever is a twat is introducing morals into the equation - hence my allegation about "taking the moral high ground".

If people were to say "I'm just not interested in England, I don't feel an affinity with the country as a whole but I do with my city" or "It's too London based" or "I don't like the style of international football" then I could accept that. But, instead, some (not all) are implicitly suggesting that they choose their affiliation according to how well behaved the participants are, which is daft.

As for patriotism, no one has mentioned it. Well, you have, and you plainly don't like it. Fair enough. I'm pretty ambivalent about it myself. I wish there was a better version of it, because the existing one makes me cringe. Anyway, I don't classify cheering an England goal as "patriotic". It's surely an error to conflate political jingoism and supporting your home country at sport.

I've going out now - I have to patent the phrase "sport is a holiday from morality" and do one or two things in town - but am happy to continue to debate later...

Mark Taylor
156 Posted 07/09/2013 at 13:26:42
Roman 506
You're probably right about friendlies seeing most one or low cap candidates.

Actually there are quite a few Evertonian linked one cap wonders. There was Frannie Jeffers, Kevin Richardson and Michael Ball- all one cap wonders.

Actually, each might have had some reason to complain about not getting another chance/ Jeffers actually scored, Richardson featured in a 5-0 thrashing of Greece and Ball in a comprehensive 3-0 trouncing of Spain (them were the days).

For real one cap wonder fodder, you'd need to consider the likes of Michael Ricketts or Gavin McCann (who, you might well ask)

Graham Mockford
157 Posted 07/09/2013 at 14:00:40
Eugene #330

I'm racking my brains to try and remember the Brylcreem Cup. I have a faint memory of a one-off TV episode in the 70s where we were up against another side in a series of 'sporting challenges' including I think head tennis.

Am I completely deluded or can anyone fill me in? Google has nothing!

John Ford
158 Posted 07/09/2013 at 13:13:59
Kev J , Im finding that prescription drugs do wonders for the quality of dreams.

We still recognise endeavour heart and commitment over less 'butch' qualities. It's kind of the reason we'd even now prefer a defender be honest and kick the shit out of someone rather than just pull his shirt......which is what those sunny climate types do with their lilly effeminate ways. It harks back to muddy pitches and refs who perhaps appreciated a good old scrap. This aint the seventies but there's a residual legacy from those times.

England showed all the characteristics of why we will never win the world cup again. Missed passes, lung busting runs into poor positions, a lack of brains or finesse when in a tight position. I'm all for intensity but not at the expense of more important qualities. While we have knuckle draggers like Milner in the set up, we're surely doomed cap'tn.

Peter Mills
159 Posted 07/09/2013 at 14:43:48
Graham#548 - please let this subject drop. I'm just out of therapy after Mick Lyons celebrated a victory in this tournament by saying on national TV - "I'm made up, this is the only thing I've ever won". If my memory serves me correctly the RS had just won the European Cup.
Jackie Barry
160 Posted 07/09/2013 at 15:24:50
England will be better once the likes of Gerrard, Lampard and Terry have retired from football for good. While they have been good they most certainly were not World class stars yet they were treated as if they were.
Jackie Barry
161 Posted 07/09/2013 at 15:28:44
In fact I am going to add to that and say that Barkley will become a far more talented player than both Gerrard and Lampard in years to come, just wait and see.

As for McCarthy I would worry too much about the Ireland game, from the performances he put in for Wigan I think he will do well for us, I saw him doing a lot of chasing back and tackling, he also has a good pass on him. Good player.

Tony Cheek
162 Posted 07/09/2013 at 16:14:26
....and Fellaini subbed for Mirallas, who came on and notched...brill!
Ron Sear
163 Posted 07/09/2013 at 16:17:06
Ruddy hell, two weeks ago the odds on Barkley playing for England were 60 to 1 against and I was going to put a tenner on it but thought "no it's not going to happen". Damn!
Mike Powell
164 Posted 07/09/2013 at 16:38:45
I couldn't give shit how England get on, I am only interested in Everton. If it was a choice between England winning the World Cup or Everton winning a trophy, I'd take the Blues to win something all day long.
Ray Roche
166 Posted 07/09/2013 at 17:22:18
Kev Johnson @ 462

Kev, I still believe that there would be a long list of players who would decline the chance to play for England, and I include players from other country's as well, in a "means nothing" friendly in just the way that Giggs did if their club deemed it necessary. I also believe that if National FA's had to pay the wages of players for the time that the players spend on International duty during the duration of the Premier League then you would see a reduction in the "means nothing" matches and also a willingness to move the AFCON tournament to the close season. Don't get me started on Qatar...
As for looking inside players heads it would no doubt be a case of "Move along, nothing to see"....

Weren't you considered for England at one time? Around the time you dithered about signing a contract....

Gerry Morrison
168 Posted 07/09/2013 at 20:37:10
Mark 535
Colin Harvey only played once. I still can't believe that.
Trevor Lynes
169 Posted 07/09/2013 at 21:54:49
Gerry, there are 100's of top class players who never won International caps.
Don't forget that when Harvey won his only cap there were NO foreign players and every player who played in the top league was British.
It was much more difficult in those days as competition was fierce and every player WANTED to play for his country.
Nowadays there is a real dearth of British talent available due to the influx of foreign players and that is why so many mediocre players win caps !
Ray Roche
170 Posted 07/09/2013 at 22:36:30
Gerry, Howard Kendall and John Hurst didn't even get ONE cap!
Colin Williams
171 Posted 07/09/2013 at 23:27:08
With a bit of luck(no injuries) Ross will get 100 caps. He will also be a Top player within European football in 18 mths, why because he's got every attribute a top player needs, top talent end of!!!!
We have great potential within our squad and combined with some very special u21s, plus sprinkled with one maybe two signings,hopefully within two years and lots of belief from Robbie we will be a top four team.
The only person who can make this happen is our manager, with his philosophy, plus is "eye" for a player and trust in youth.


Raymond Fox
172 Posted 08/09/2013 at 00:49:17
Colin, you could be correct about Ross, a tad over the top maybe, but the problem could be how long will he be a Everton player?

Martinez has everything a great manager needs, buts let not expect too much too soon.

lets try to keep on an even keel, opinion seems to fluctuate on here from relegation to top 4 week on week!

Put me down as cautiously optimistic.

Steve Brown
173 Posted 08/09/2013 at 06:03:44
Exactly Ray 666, Howard Kendall didn't get a single cap while Geoff Thomas made 9 appearances and Carlton Palmer was picked 18 times. That's why I've got no time for them. Haven't watched them since Germany humiliated them in the 2010 World Cup.
Kevin Day
174 Posted 08/09/2013 at 07:48:29
Going slightly off key here, I decided to watch the RoI game against Sweden, in particular McCarthy. He had a relatively quiet, though steady first half, but the second half was very encouraging, pinging balls about, winning tackles, cross field balls to Seamus out the wing. He looked every part a £13 million player; we should all be optimistic about the season ahead.
Tony Draper
175 Posted 08/09/2013 at 08:00:15
Raymond (681)
Your "how long" concern is inevitable where talent is concerned

Wayne Rooney was on everyones radar as soon as he smashed in "That Goal" that ended the invincible Arsenal's 49 game unbeaten run

Tony Hibbert & Leon Osman have been with Everton since time immemorial without any recallable interest from 3rd parties

As you say, still early days for Roberto as our manager

Hopefully Roberto will gradually build a stylish & successful Everton squad that young Ross will want to be part of for all the right reasons for many years to come and will be viewed jealously by others

Very early days yet for both, but generally encouraging

Colin Williams
176 Posted 08/09/2013 at 13:18:11
Raymond, I do believe Ross has a great future ahead of him. Also, why "tad over the top" when you look at the 100 cap brigade recently, Gerrard (tosser), Lampard (fat and average), Beckham (one-trick pony), Cole (lucky).

Ross will put them to shame on sheer football ability and Gerrardknows it!! He is a jealous tosser who will not bother to support Ross and develop his game for England, as we all seen within the game, jealous bastard!

Yes, Robbie needs time to develop his own squad and targets for the future, but I believe there is so much in place in our great club now! Robbie has given us hope and belief to challenge the top four teams and compete within their back yard and take three points of them.

Phil Williams
177 Posted 09/09/2013 at 00:11:53
Newcastle misfit Dan Gosling is wanted on loan by Reading.

In his favoured midfield role I hope!!

Barkley or Gosling?

The grass is not always greener.

Chris Hannon
178 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:01:09
Osman Jagielka and Baines were the last 3 blues in an England pitch together a few months ago
Simon Temme
179 Posted 10/09/2013 at 13:33:48
Steve @687

The England team of 2010 World cup were the main factor in my disgust of "The Golden generation".

Terry, Cole, Lampard, Gerrard, Rooney (Witness his coments to camera about support) really hit home how deluded, selfish, greedy and arrogant the modern footballer had become whilst suckling on the golden teat of the EPL.

They are all still in the squad!! FFS.

It will take the Baines's and Barkley's of this world to " Wash all the scum of the streets" and that can't happen soon enough if I, as an Evertonian are going to invest emotionally into the national team.

Shane Corcoran
180 Posted 10/09/2013 at 14:17:23
Frank Lampard is not fat.
Ross Edwards
181 Posted 10/09/2013 at 14:16:40
"Don't forget he picked that useless twat, Baines. And selecting Jagielka merely compounds his error. "

Carl, you are talking utter rubbish. Baines useless? You need your head checking. He created the most chances in Europe last season. Hardly useless.

Don't ingore my comments either because it's becoming a little childish.

James Martin
182 Posted 10/09/2013 at 14:29:13
Ross I think Carl was being sarcastic. Someone had posted that Hodgson was a rubbish judge of ability because he picked Osman which conveniently forgot the fact that he has also selected Baines and Jagielka.
Ross Edwards
183 Posted 10/09/2013 at 14:42:23
Oh, Ok. Thanks James. Ignore that comment Carl. My apologies.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb