Season › 2013-14 › News
Are Everton FC silencing dissent?
» Read the full article at The New Statesman
Reader Comments (130)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 07/09/2013 at 08:10:20
http://www.theifo.co.uk/adjudications.html
The club claim that I caused havoc in the Megastore on June 27th 2012, 'staff fearful', etc. See Paragraph 7 of the IFO report.
This is a lie, haven't been in there for well over 10 years!
Kitbag have written to me stating that they have no record of any incident on that date. CCTV footage not kept!
Shameful way to treat fans, we know who was behind all of this.
3 Posted 07/09/2013 at 10:54:05
4 Posted 07/09/2013 at 11:41:41
As someone who works in the same sector as yourself I consider the manner you have been treated by the 'peoples club' as a disgrace. I have no problem with football clubs getting involved with education but have a huge problem with the concept of 'free schools' and I am saddened that Everton chose to go down this route rather than work with local schools to help imrpove provision.
Another example of the club not really connecting with the community and fan base it is meant to represent.
5 Posted 07/09/2013 at 12:25:01
Richard, what are we missing here? There must be a reason why the club have treated you so badly, I'd be interested to read your thoughts.
6 Posted 07/09/2013 at 14:22:22
And, if they are not free to express their view, are they to be subjected to lies, misinformation and character assassination?
I find the whole incident regarding Richard absolutely disgraceful. Free Schools or not — just the fact that an individual can be singled out like this is abhorrent and surely cannot be allowed to happen.
7 Posted 08/09/2013 at 19:40:06
This slur placed upon him by Paul Tyrrel and others is an absolute disgrace, I do not agree or disagree with his beliefs regarding Free Schools, but as a man, I know he is completely innocent of all accusations that the club have slandered him with.
Makes me ashamed of EFC.
Good luck in your ongoing fight to clear your name Richard, you have my support.
8 Posted 08/09/2013 at 22:51:37
I sounds like our club has realised its hold of us and thinks it can do what it wants without any kind of repercussions.
This is all very cold and corporate like by the "Peoples Club".
I wonder if the club actively keeps a blacklist of anybody disagreeing with its policies?
9 Posted 09/09/2013 at 06:10:04
10 Posted 09/09/2013 at 08:01:45
12 Posted 09/09/2013 at 08:05:13
Everton are saying that he is not banned from the ground; if not, has Richard been to a game since to test that? If not why not.?
Surely despite his view on free schools, which in my opinion are a good thing, and his opinion on them to me seems deep rooted in the militant past, is it that his approach and his actions are not too dissimilar to the anti-capitalists of the past that so blighted our city's reputation?
I believe this is blown out of all proportion and Richard needs to assess and admit his actions – whilst in his opinion acceptable – were not to somebody else.
13 Posted 09/09/2013 at 08:18:03
Everybody has the right to protest and we should respect everybodys right to do so and on this I back you but other than that this is a political statement against free schools so I would suggest you lobbying government officials as opposed to EFC. Im afraid BU is backing a lost cause on this and they shouldnt allow themselves to be dragged in to this debate.
Richard, maybe you can protest about the current school system as average ability seems to be best practise these days and teachers are more concerned about ticking boxes than a childs progression hence pupils at lower and higher ability are left to fend for themselves.
People in glass houses shouldnt throw stones, but thats just my opinion and I back EFC on this purely because one of those people you abused over the phone is a close friend, two sides to every story Richard!
14 Posted 09/09/2013 at 08:38:12
15 Posted 09/09/2013 at 09:04:10
I'd be keen to hear more about this 'abuse' your friend recieved.
As far as I can tell Richard Knights rang up EFC and made his views on free schools known. So because he's spoken to the wrong person he deserves a lifetime ban from the terraces?
I don't know the ins and outs but it sounds like bollocks mate.
16 Posted 09/09/2013 at 09:07:18
Splinters in yer arse, desperate bollocks (as our own resident poet would say)
How about evaluating the facts at hand?
It's clear from the facts that Mr Knights is being/has been treated pretty shabbily by the club..
Politics permeates every level of life..It's a pile of bollocks response to tell Mr Knights to go to westminister with his concerns. The free schools shambles should be taken to those who perpetrate it..including the current custodians of EFC
17 Posted 09/09/2013 at 09:27:38
What about the abusive calls? Do you know Richard?
Where you there? Backed by the Blue Union? Where do you get your misinformation from?
The Blue Union supports many causes as Football Fans; Irrespective of political beliefs, if a fan was being treated as disgracefully as Richard, I for one would support him.
That post of yours is as bad as the treatment the club has given to him.
Obviously, all calls will be recorded I presume, and you will've heard the abusive call yourself. Otherwise, it would be pretty foolish to come on here and accuse someone of making abusive calls! Wouldn't it?
18 Posted 09/09/2013 at 09:34:18
Yes politics does permeate every walk of life – and I think your post is an example of that. There are no "facts" at hand. All we have is hearsay. Anyone who expresses a firm view on these "facts" may end up looking very silly if the full story comes to light.
Don't get me wrong – Richard Knights may have been very badly wronged by the club. But I feel your view is coloured by your political views on the underlying subject – i.e. free schools.
19 Posted 09/09/2013 at 09:55:40
There was one visit to the Everton Reception at the Park End June 27th 2012, a visit that lasted for about one minute. One other phone call is cited by the club but not to the police.
Naturally you would think that any organisation that wanted to 'protect' its staff would write to the person concerned? So in September 2012, three months later the police knock on my door and serve me with a Recordable Verbal Warning. Then in October 2012 I'm threatened with a High Court injunction and massive court costs that could have bankrupted me. Finally my season ticket is withdrawn.
Also there is the strange case of my 'visit' to the Everton Megastore June 27th 2012, staff left 'fearful'. Testimony given to Merseyside Police is completely different to the solicitor's letter I received. This is lies. Kitbag have no record of any incident on that date. To repeat, I haven't been near the Megastore for well over ten years.
In the letter removing my season ticket it was stated that a BBC journalist had complained to the police about my conduct. Another lie. I have a letter from the BBC refuting this.
This campaign was orchestrated by one individual no longer employed by EFC.
20 Posted 09/09/2013 at 10:00:50
As for your claims of abusive phone calls it adds nothing of substance to the issue at hand.
Here is the crux of the issue, Alan, prove that Mr Knights verbally abused and threatened the staff of Everton One the most serious charge against him. If you can not do so and as you have already avoided it, I don't believe that you can and neither can the club. CCTV Alan go get it your a club official. Making an unsubstantiated smear in place of hard evidence is disgraceful and you should know better.
21 Posted 09/09/2013 at 10:09:09
Did he cause havoc in the megastore on the date in question?
Did the club accuse him of the above?
Does Mr Knights oppose free schools?
Have Everton proposed a free School?
Did the club remove his season ticket?
Are those not facts?
Yes, you are looking rather silly.
22 Posted 09/09/2013 at 10:19:38
25 Posted 09/09/2013 at 10:46:31
This must be the most bizarre post I've ever read on ToffeeWeb. Your claim that Richard has made a succession of abusive calls to Everton is outrageous as Richard appears to have no knowledge of this, its not mentioned in the IFO report — in fact, nobody appears to have any knowledge of it.
Having had the pleasure of meeting Richard on a couple of occasions, it certainly doesnt appear to fit the image you are met with. Richard is quiet, well spoken and very intelligent.
You must elaborate on your claims, who made them, who told you or is the truth simply you are just once more allowing your prejudices to accept and repeat desperate claims which have seen you made a fool of before?
26 Posted 09/09/2013 at 12:21:16
It's a slimy, I'm taking my ball home, attitude. Just because he is against the free schooling, it has nothing to do with the match, but Everton still ban him. Why?
It's the old, you hurt me, I'll hurt you routine, which is disgraceful. I see the Ombudman did fuck all, as usual!
27 Posted 09/09/2013 at 12:26:05
To deal with your semantics perhaps I should re-phrase to say on the key issues all we have is hearsay. You ask did Mr Knights cause havoc in the megastore? Answer - I don't know.
The best evidence I have is that he did not - because Mr Knights has said he was not even there. But is that sufficiently probitive - it is not. If I met Mr Knights in person (and also heard the Everton FC side) then perhaps it would be.
I am not sure what is wrong with that point of view. Or how that appears foolish.
28 Posted 09/09/2013 at 12:48:06
-------------------------------------
Semantics?
Is this slight of hand for - 'what I said was totally incorrect and I will now attempt to obfuscate the issue some more'?
It's quite clear that there are 'facts at hand'.. and rather pertinent ones at that.
29 Posted 09/09/2013 at 13:05:15
Did he cause havoc in the megastore on the date in question? I don't know. He says no, club say yes. No facts available - one party's wprd against the other.
Did the club accuse him of the above? Yes
Does Mr Knights oppose free schools? I believe so
Have Everton proposed a free School? Yes
Did the club remove his season ticket? Yes
Are those not facts? The last four constitute fact as far as I am aware. None of us, expect Mr Knights and the club/staff at the megastore know the answer to the first one.
Yes, you are looking rather silly. No he's not, you are.
30 Posted 09/09/2013 at 13:20:06
31 Posted 09/09/2013 at 13:58:24
In October there is a witness statement dated June 27 2012 from an Everton security guard Peter Calloway alleging that, that I was irrational and aggressive to the point of causing the ladies in question [Megastore staff] to be fearful of what I would do next, hence the need to call security. This allegation is repeated in the Independent Football Ombudsman adjudication. Strange to say no CCTV footage of this 'incident' was kept, so after 30 days it was wiped.
Strangely in the police enquiry December 2012, the allegation is that I was followed in to the Megastore, asked questions of the staff was asked to leave and complied.
You don't need to be Hercule Poirot to realise that someone is lying and here's a massive clue - it isn't me. Because, to repeat again, I haven't been near the Megastore for well over ten years.
32 Posted 09/09/2013 at 13:18:49
David 835, your first statement just sums up the nature of such debates maybe you should get Len from Unite to join you and march on the club, but then again he is a RS. The person I know doesnt work in the merchandise arm of the club, I have known this person over 20 years and they recalled the “phone conversation” and because they worked for the club he chose to direct his disagreement at them about free schools.
As I said before, Richard has every right to protest against free schools but in my opinion thats better addressed at the people who created the legislation not those that act upon the laws made. Evertonians lie both sides of this debate and again in my opinion this has been taken up by the do-gooders as it fits their agenda, this is a political motivated dispute on Richards part and he is old enough and clever enough to be aware of how far he can push people. Have EFC gone too far, possibly, but Im sure it was Richard aim to rattle their cage too.
33 Posted 09/09/2013 at 14:07:09
We were promised a 'landmark' establishment, with over 120 pupils and in two years time 300.
The reality? Still stuck in the Liverpool Community College. The school won't even answer simple questions like – how many pupils do you have?
The salary of the Principal? This is taxpayers' money – no answer.
34 Posted 09/09/2013 at 14:15:40
"Evertonians lie both sides of this debate and again in my opinion this has been taken up by the do-gooders as it fits their agenda, this is a political motivated dispute on Richards part and he is old enough and clever enough to be aware of how far he can push people. Have EFC gone too far, possibly, but Im sure it was Richard aim to rattle their cage too. "
The final line here is quite revealing, coming as does from a club employee, and it supports the claim of the New Statesman article. Everton don't like those that rattle their cages.
35 Posted 09/09/2013 at 14:21:54
36 Posted 09/09/2013 at 15:21:16
If Richard is certain that a former employee orchestrated the entire charade, then perhaps he should name who that was and what evidence he has for that.
I don't know what on earth Everton are doing getting involved in setting up a free school, by the way.
37 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:09:05
38 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:04:27
With that being said, Richard why is the whole thing just blown up like this? From what I understand you oppose the free school, that is as far as my knowledge goes on the matter. I am not sure why you would oppose a free school but I will accept you are much more knowledgable on the subject compared to myself.
The point I am trying to ask you, out of complete curiousity is why have the club took a vendetta out on yourself? What did you actually do (not the alleged which I do believe did not happen), but what action did you take to basically get the afore mentioned public relation member to paint you public enemy number 1?
39 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:26:06
40 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:36:45
You have listed the facts that are not disputed by either side.
The issue is over the facts that are disputed - i.e. the first one on Ciaran's list (and there are others not on that list).
So how is it silly to reserve judgement?
I acknowledge that Richard K may well have been badly wronged here, but I think it is wrong to harangue those who don't automatically voice support or take it at face value.
41 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:21:38
You regularly talk a lot of shite on here.
You have surpassed yourself in post 823
42 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:50:56
I'm agreeing with you at 851
My post is a copy and paste of Ciaran's questions with answers. If you read it back you will see I have answered point one by saying ' I don't know. He says no, club say yes. No facts available - one party's wprd (sic - word) against the other. If you read my earlier post I have said that judgement should be reserved until everyone knows the facts (not one persons word against another).
43 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:41:14
Richard, this is a political argument that you are passionate about and you are using the club as a platform to voice your opinion; good approach to get air time but dont be surprised the club dont agree with you.
David, I have no idea what happened at the store, I wasnt there and neither was the person I know. On CCTV its not unusual to delete after 14/30 days, it depends whether you back up daily on the main server, normally if you have an incident you burn it on to a CD or save it but it's possible they dont have a copy. It's all down to what system you have and how much you have paid for it.
Richard, are you saying you have never phoned the club to voice your disagreement about free schools?
44 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:57:12
Why did you put (sic word) in your post instead of just changing one letter,p to o?
45 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:58:33
June 21st 2012 letter from Bill Kenwright encouraging me to raise concerns about the Free School.
June 28th 2012 letter from Denise Barratt-Baxendale declining an offer to provide a speaker at a public meeting.
July 5th 2012 letter from Robert Elstone, we've had the consultation no more debate about the Free School.
No mention of staff being 'fearful' or 'intimidated', if this was the case why not write to me in June or July?
What happened was that a former employee of LFC decided to use the same dirty tricks. Police visit, court injunction, season ticket withdrawn.
Shame on Everton.
47 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:00:50
The question is if you voice opposition as an individual against anything to do with the Club should you have your season ticket taken away and banned by the Club ?
Should you have second hand nameless people making accusations that can't stand up to scrutiny?
Alan Williams if you do actually know "several" staff who received abusive and political calls from Richard Knights surely it is your duty to encourage these "several" people to come and prove that Richard Knights is a liar?
Based on past history of my beloved Club I am afraid to say that I doubt Mr Knights is the liar!
48 Posted 09/09/2013 at 21:44:46
49 Posted 09/09/2013 at 21:45:58
50 Posted 09/09/2013 at 21:46:30
51 Posted 09/09/2013 at 21:52:52
Alan, I have been reading this thread and I can't see evidence of Mr Knights lying apart from your mate telling you something.
52 Posted 10/09/2013 at 09:28:49
------------------
Ok David...
Here's another few facts.
Have the club provided any CCTV of this 'havoc' created in the megastore?
Does the Megastore have CCTV?
Has the club representative who was involved in this (i.e the former communications director) been subsequently removed from his post?
Has said person been previously implicated in political espionage at a previous club not so far away?
Need anymore facts?
53 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:08:32
I was concerned that since Friday, with a total of only eleven responses, Richards ongoing plight was flying under the ToffeeWeb radar, that the recent endless, perhaps even mindless, preoccupation with “OFM” [FFS], the amateur badge competition and the peoples clubs latest phoney strategy of tediously passing themselves off as a fan friendly, approachable organisation had rendered the readers and writers of ToffeeWeb preoccupied and oblivious to the real deep-rooted problems at Everton; how misplaced my concern was and how thankful Richard should be for your intervention.
Remind me never to tell you anything in confidence though, Alan, you appear unable to hold your own water! Two years ago on TW you spilt the beans after your contact at Everton informed you of what was meant to be a private and highly confidential meeting between KEIOC and Everton; now, albeit unknowingly, youre defaming Richard Knights by stating that hes made abusive telephone calls. I have no doubt whatsoever that your contact has told you this story and that youre simply repeating what youve been told, but perhaps you could have phrased it as a question rather than fact as it is readily demonstrable that the truth and Everton arent exactly what you would describe as close friends. Lets never forget — this is the football club that happily told their fans and their shareholders that a £52m subsidy was being provided by Tesco towards the cost of building a stadium before a government inquiry established that not a single penny was being provided.
Alan, I dont know where you get that the Blue Union are backing Richard so your advice is misplaced; although they are supportive, they are no more than an organising body that the club are paranoid about. Its KEIOC that is backing him and, more than most, Im right with him because personally I despise all forms of corporate bullying which in my opinion this clearly is an example of.
Having accompanied Richard to many meetings with the police and the media, the latest being a lengthy meeting with Merseyside Police on Friday afternoon, I can say that Im fully conversant with Richards situation and Im happy to explain a little more; the facts are there, you just need to know where to look — the devil, as they say, is in the detail. Having said that, even though Everton has provided a plethora of information to the police, following the IPCC complaints on this matter being upheld, and to the IFO along with a comprehensive timeline of all alleged events that was provided by the solicitor acting on Evertons behalf, believe me, they have thrown the kitchen sink at Richard in an attempt to portray him as a lunatic and undermine his version of events. Yet I can say with some confidence that no allegation regarding abusive telephone calls has ever been made by anyone; but I suppose as the net closes the desperation increases?
Early in this thread, John Keating [#563] and then in his later post [#920] hits the nail on the head, this isnt about free schools; this is about freedom of speech, the right to protest and the right not to be bullied. Just to be clear, my own opinion is that EiTC can have ten free schools if they want as, whilst sympathetic to Richards views, in common with what is probably the vast majority of Evertonians, Im pretty much ambivalent on the whole subject. I also believe that people have the right not to be harassed at their place of work and this whole sorry episode does a disservice to those who are genuinely subjected to this.
For the avoidance of doubt, what happened to Richard was that — several months after an alleged series of incidents took place — he was visited at home one evening by a constable of the Football Intelligence Unit. The officer informed Richard that he had been accused of the harassment of the Free School principal, Adrian Packer, and despite Richards protestations, that he had met this gentleman only once for about ten seconds at a public consultation, Richard was issued with a recordable verbal warning for harassment.
Its important to understand that the polices own guidelines specify that complaints such as this should be investigated prior to the issuing of any warning and that, for harassment to take place under the Protection from Harassment Act 1997, a “course of conduct” should be established.
Richard complained to Merseyside Police, believing that the warning should not have been issued, and later to the Independent Police Complaints Commission, who incidentally upheld his complaint. This resulted in a superintendent conducting an internal investigation which unsurprisingly found that the police had acted correctly in issuing the warning. Im being slightly disingenuous saying 'unsurprisingly' as it was in fact very surprising...
Firstly, if you read Section 6 of the IFO report, it explains that the warning was issued on the 17th of September, whilst in Section 7 of the same report, it explains that the police witness statement from the complainant is dated some ten days later, on the 27th indicating that the police couldnt have investigated the complaint prior to issuing Richard with the warning. In addition to this, the superintendents report establishes that the only time Richard met the complainant was at a public consultation, so hardly proof of a course of conduct amounting to harassment.
This lack of evidence, however, didnt prevent the superintendent from conducting a thorough investigation, his report contained an ad hoc retrospective inquiry which embraced the additional allegations, namely the alleged events in the megastore, which was relied on in its conclusion.
The crux is that, astonishingly, now that Richard has additional evidence which confirms why no CCTV of the alleged incident at the shop exists, because nothing happened, confirmed in a letter from Kitbag, the police now refuse to reinvestigate as theyve now decided that this incident along with all the other claims doesnt form part of the original harassment complaint — despite being relied upon in the superintendent's report to establish a course of conduct — and theyre going to do nothing until the IPCC appeal findings are known.
All that Richard has asked is that the police obtain the alleged contemporaneous report from an Everton employee that, despite the police formerly relying upon, they have never actually seen — nor has anybody else including Richard who has been denied access under legal privilege. This about-turn by the police can only lend weight to Richards original argument that the warning should never have been issued in the first place — an event which initiated subsequent actions by Everton. It could be argued and some may see that the warning was the first step of an intended sequence of events which was little more than a device to obtain an injunction against Richard to silence his criticism of the Everton Free School project. Such devices have been used at other football clubs.
Richard has been portrayed as a bit of a lunatic; nothing could be further than the truth — hes a quiet, intelligent person able to articulate an argument that the staff of Everton and EiTC appear unable to counter. My own opinion is that Richards attitude, during what is clearly behaviour designed to incite a reaction, should be applauded. Amongst many things hes had the police knocking at his door, hes been in receipt of a bullying letter from a solicitor, hes been told privately, in writing, that he was banned from Goodison whilst publicly Everton attempted to deny this, hes had his season ticket removed after 50 seasons watching Everton, he was denied access to the supporters liaison officer and had offers of meeting with the club unexplainably cancelled as outlined in the IFO report. During this time hes steadfastly continued to protest his innocence and collect evidence to prove so. Others have been sacked! He's also the only person whose story has never changed from day one.
Its encouraging that Merseyside Police, perhaps beginning to realise theyve been lied to and are not there to do a private companys dirty work, have now written to the IPCC supplying them with the letter from Kitbag, the threatening solicitors' letter, the IFO report and a description of Richards contention that lies are being told and evidence is being withheld from the police.
Its a couple of hundred years since Scott wrote the famous lines, “Oh what a tangled web we weave, When first we practise to deceive" ... yet it is just as relevant now as it was then, in fact Id go further, with modern day technology its more difficult to lie about where somebody is or isnt. Ill leave that one there for the moment, I'm sure you can work it out.
Theres no doubt in my mind that the club have acted unprofessionally. Before all these allegations began Richard had written to the chairman, Bill Kenwright, over his concerns about the free school project; his response applauds Richards attitude and tells him to meet with the people concerned, the people who then refused to do so and answer his questions.
No matter how much of a pain in the arse Richard was or wasnt over the free school, I think everyone would agree that Everton should have acted in a far more professional manner. Personally, I would have complied with the chairmans instructions to meet with him and I would have answered his questions over the public money that EiTC are in receipt of — after all, we want transparency dont we? Or is that reserved for only when its convenient? I would have invited Richard in on a weekly basis if necessary and asked him questions and tasked him to supply as much information as possible; then I would have passed him to the Supporters Liaison Officer, who, under Uefa guidelines, is meant to be there for that specific purpose. But of course you cant when you simply appoint an existing employee in a PR capacity you have to take steps to avoid any possible contact which would show that youre paying lip service to a Uefa licensing requirement. Everton arent alone here, the Premier League have allowed all clubs to do the same; its all part of appearing to comply with the fan engagement programme whilst really treating fans with contempt unless theyre singing from your hymn sheet.
The sad thing about this whole sorry episode is that theres an inevitability as to where this is all going to end up and its going to be very very damaging and yet it is all so avoidable. I wonder what people associated with those behind this bullying, those involved and those whove condoned it, will do? The mayor is an ambassador of EiTC and is on record as saying he wont be associated with any company involved in bullying, yet Everton has a hidden record of this involving staff suspensions and worse. I wonder what the Deputy Chief Constable of Merseyside will think when its shown that the organisation hes a trustee of is involved in lying to his force to bully an individual?
A sad tale, we expect better, but — if Im honest, after everything that has happened in recent years — is anyone really surprised?
54 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:25:44
55 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:00:28
Has anybody else that speaks out against the club been refused entry to the ground?
56 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:41:28
I said on a thread earlier in the year that I thought that in this particular incident the club had used a sledgehammer to crack a walnut, there is nothing to suggest otherwise in terms of evidence now.
Every football club has the right to withdraw a season ticket from an individual or group if it deems the action appropriate, but you would hope that a club which professes to be "The People's Club" would ensure that it stated sound reasons for doing so and had irrefutable evidence of wrongdoing by the offenders.
Also if a former employee has been guilty of using the club to further his own individual political agenda, the club should reinstate Mr Knights's season ticket and issue a formal apology to him.
.
57 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:50:32
You're surprised political espionage at the club is given a thread of it's own?
Really?
Colin - thanks for the post. I think we can all see what's going on here..
Disgraceful that this has happened and disgraceful that others think it's a non-story.
In NI you have to consent to an informed warning – personally I'd have told them to stick it...
58 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:59:27
A fan has been given a warning from the police and it looks like it has been done with no actual evidence against said fan.
Interesting post by Colin and very revealing.
59 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:16:45
ToffeeWeb is a fans forum dealing with all aspects of us, the supporters. Richard Knights is a long term Evertonian who has been treated disgracefully by your Club.
Please tell us what topics we can and cannot post? If you think the topic is irrelevant then don't comment and shut the fuck up!!!
60 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:31:06
We can't all be happy and pretend that these dictatorial morons aren't ruining the club when we are so aware that they are.
61 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:33:09
62 Posted 10/09/2013 at 13:06:03
Richard deserves his season ticket back at the very least.
Dan 989 - Garbage, utter garbage
63 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:54:19
It is symptomatic of the organisational culture of a business that is insular, defensive, operating in a state of permanent paranoia and is insensitive/borderline hostile to the customers it is meant to serve. That culture only develops as a result of weak leadership.
65 Posted 10/09/2013 at 13:44:28
Time to move on, Mr Knights.
The IFO is aware that the misdemeanours and behaviours which the Club believes justified its action technically occurred outside Goodison Park itself. However, the IFO finds that it is not unreasonable for the Club to take account of actions and behaviour within its wider sphere of influence.
The complainant was not deprived of his season ticket because he had breached the ground regulations, but because his over forceful and aggressive demeanour gave rise to fears for the safety of Club employees. The Club is willing to renew a dialogue with the complainant, subject to him moderating his attitude, and the IFO hopes that it may be possible for one who is a loyal Everton fan to be fully readmitted to the Everton community.
66 Posted 10/09/2013 at 13:38:28
If you look at my post, I have never ever mentioned any of the disputed incidents you and Richard mention; I have no evidence either way. I know several people at the club and in the football finance world and I could tell you a lot more but I would never compromise them by going too far. I think youre being a bit disingenuous with your comments about telling truths, you also fail to mention that I have been fairly spot-on when I have ever hinted to certain things going on.
I dont post very often but on this subject I honestly feel it's political and should be treated that way. Like you, Im not interested in the free schools too much but the concept in principle seems good so – other than being concerned for my sons education (thats another story) – I tend to take a back seat.
My gripe is, yes, you may have all the statements lined up in a neat line but it doesnt tell the full story based on what I have been told and as I wasnt present I will leave it there. If you (KEIOC & BU) continue to be the no win, no fee brigade for every dispute that is held against the club, its business and charity, in my opinion your good intentions are being taken advantage of and eventually it will dilute what you set out to achieve from the outset.
Dont be fooled by the "wronged Evertonian" line — Walton Prison is full of them!
67 Posted 10/09/2013 at 15:09:00
The remarks about merit and coincidence are plain mean; the best spin would be that they are misguided myopic fawning.
Oh by the way, Dan Brierley, Richard Knights was not the first person to comment on this thread.
68 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:00:10
I can't name names but someone I know told me we just failed to put the Messi transfer papers in time on deadline day. We won't be pursuing him in January.
Again not naming names but it was the same guy who said Saddam had weapons on mass destruction.
Now I don't post too often either but I can assure you my sources are 100% kosher.
Regardless of the fact that no weapons of mass destruction were found and that Messi denies he almost signed for us I do not believe any of it.
69 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:00:10
I can't name names but someone I know told me we just failed to put the Messi transfer papers in time on deadline day. We won't be pursuing him in January.
Again not naming names but it was the same guy who said Saddam had weapons on mass destruction.
Now I don't post too often either but I can assure you my sources are 100% kosher.
Regardless of the fact that no weapons of mass destruction were found and that Messi denies he almost signed for us I do not believe any of it.
70 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:00:10
I can't name names but someone I know told me we just failed to put the Messi transfer papers in time on deadline day. We won't be pursuing him in January.
Again not naming names but it was the same guy who said Saddam had weapons on mass destruction.
Now I don't post too often either but I can assure you my sources are 100% kosher.
Regardless of the fact that no weapons of mass destruction were found and that Messi denies he almost signed for us I do not believe any of it.
72 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:01:40
For example the BU, KEIOC members seem to be much more vocal than a single man arguing against free schools, some even heckling the chairman when he got out of his car and organising mass protest. Are they all banned from GP?
As always, debate is about balance. Not just about putting the side across that suits your agenda or particular viewpoint. I am trying to understand why this guy was singled out, as it sounds ridiculous to suffer a lifetime ban for calmly disagreeing about a free school, when others do a lot more and seemingly do not get banned.
73 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:33:31
Probably not.
They did show a touch of pomposity
74 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:35:33
This really is a great opportunity for the club to build bridges and say to Richard that he can have his season ticket back. Mind you, while Richard is banned, he kinda serves as a warning to others about what will happen if you challenge to club too much.....
Editorial Team
75 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:09:19
"I am amazed that this subject would merit it's own thread,"
It should need no explanation... but obviously in your case it needs spelling out again. This is an Everton website for Everton fans to discuss Everton-related topics. The way it works is people post articles or talking points related to Everton, and we track news on the web for Everton-related material. Every day, we try to put one or more items following the above paradigm. It's what keeps the website alive and relevant to those who read and contribute.
So, when an Everton-related article appears in a national organ of the media, in this case New Statesman (admittedly not one of our regular sources), its selection as a media item under our category "Elsewhere on the Web" would seem to be a no-brainer. Your contention that this represents someone being given a soapbox is simply mystifying at best. The article came to our attention in the usual manner; any other suggestions or inferences are well wide of the. mark.
As for your final comment, it should surely be enough for concern as an Evertonian that one person has their season ticket removed and is excluded from Goodison Park? I don't understand why there is always this need to broaden the discussion and find other examples for comparison. This is clearly a one-off case that can be assessed on its 'merits' — although that is painfully not the right word for this fiasco.
If Colin is right (thanks yet again for taking the time to pen such a clear and comprehensive account), this will not go away, despite Tyrell's departure, which is a pity. Clearly it has become a monster that might be a little too difficult to just brush under the carpet.
77 Posted 10/09/2013 at 17:14:26
79 Posted 10/09/2013 at 17:49:25
81 Posted 10/09/2013 at 17:46:27
Colin's post at 985 helps put some meat on the bones, but after reading the IFO report there are a couple of questions that remain outstanding.
It seems that Richard's alleged bad beahviour began in June when it is alleged Richrad spoke to the Chief Executive of EiTC and was "out of control, shouting in the face of the CE and invading her personal space", (21st June).
On 27th June it is alleged Richard visited the club and spoke to the Receptionist and tried to look at her computer before going to the Megastore and causing concern.
Now the point about looking at the computer seems a bit pathetic to raise, and Richard's account as to the Megastore incident is clear (wasn't there and haven't been for ages).
It then all seems to go relatively quiet until 11th September when it is alleged that Richard visits the school and goes to the 3rd floor and becomes aggressive and threatening. There is no mention of whether children are present.
I may have missed it but I can't see what Richard's response is to the 21st June allegation and the 11th September allegation. I would be interested to know as it would inform the debate.
Are the allegations true, completely made up (like the Megastore incident) or based in fact but exaggerated by the Club?
I suppose my point is that if Richard was "out of control shouting in the face of the Chief Exec" on 21st June and then wondered into the school onto the third floor and was aggressive and threatening then the Club may well have a point. In those circumstances it might be reasonable for them to feel they should act to protect their staff. However if those allegations are not true then it looks like Richard has been "picked on".
Can anyone comment on what actualy happened on 21st June and 11th September?
82 Posted 10/09/2013 at 18:12:08
Suggesting that fans get banned for having peaceful debates seemed wide of the mark, and not something I have personally come across before. Even more so when you consider that law enforcement have also investigated, along with an independent panel who seemingly would have nothing to gain by covering up the truth? Something seems very odd.
Call me cynical, but I can't help wondering this would even be discussed if, for example, our club had been taken over by someone else in the last six months?
84 Posted 10/09/2013 at 19:20:34
September the police arrive issue a Recordable Verbal Warning.
October threat of court injunction.
Is this any way to treat a fan?
Don't be under any illusion if the club get away with this any other fans who dare to question will get similar treatment.
85 Posted 10/09/2013 at 19:23:35
I don't know what you're on but I'm glad I'm not on it. A long-standing Evertonian gets involved with the Club over something the Club are doing. The Evertonian in question has his season ticket taken, refused entry to the ground and persecuted by the Club.... And this is NOT an Everton related story??????
Jesus wept!
Law enforcement investigating things — where have you been for the last 50 years. One word springs to mind — Hillsborough.
Stop posting, Dan, you're making yourself look a right arsehole.
86 Posted 10/09/2013 at 19:30:32
December 2012: police enquiry – completely different accounts by Everton staff of the events.
For legal reasons I can't go into all of the details.
The Megastore: complete lies, never been there for over 10 years.
Letter from Kitbag: no record of any incident June 27 2012.
Why spend all this time and money? Paranoia?
87 Posted 10/09/2013 at 19:13:15
Itd cynics like me and it seems the majority on here who have deep-seated doubts and suspicions about institutions and people with any sort of power like, for instance, Everton Football Club.
In all walks of life institutions involve themselves in deceit, cover-ups, suppression, manipulation, and out-out-and-out fabrication for one end only: to whitewash themselves and to tar and feather dissent.
Are Everton likely to be immune from this sort of behaviour in all aspects of its operations – and here by Everton I dont mean the personal the lifeblood fans but the impersonal chair and board who happen at any one point in time to run the club: NO!
,
You – Brierely – display absolute green faith in the system/club that in your perspective is not culpable; you shift the burden to the so-called ‘troublemaker, a single individual who must answer questions – its a classic situation: institution v individual and my-oh-my the Briereleys of this world aim all their arrows at guess what the individual who is put under the microscope not guess what the institution.
This could have come out of the mouth of a 1980s Thatcherite minister:
‘Suggesting that fans get banned for having peaceful debates seemed wide of the mark, and not something I have personally come across before. Even more so when you consider that law enforcement have also investigated, along with an independent panel who seemingly would have nothing to gain by covering up the truth?
Get this: law enforcement has investigated so this therefore in this lemming-like world-view adds validity to the club stance; because the wholly above-board and squeaky-clean agencies of law enforcement have ‘investigated with their well-know historic pedigree for fairness and balance and due procedure in all cases the onus to explain is on the individual not the institution who are now clearly the victims: bless, poor Everton.
But to make matters worse Dan Green sorry Brierley while on the one hand pleading for more information – from and on the individual needless to say – on the other misrepresent what we have seen unfolding in a shall we say EFC way: the police have investigated – erm Brierley have the decency to read through Colins top-drawer post where you will see that your beloved law enforcement are now putting a quite different spin on things that guess what actually seems to put the individual rather than your institution in a better light.
What lengths will you go to or depths will you descend to DB to continue to wage your crusade on behalf of any sort of establishment – a football club or its ex-gaffer or law enforcement?
We can only lifts arms in grateful thanks that you are always – always – in a tiny minority when you ride your high horse onto these boards.
And this by the way – Williams (34 – is fucking disgraceful:
Dont be fooled by the "wronged Evertonian" line — Walton Prison is full of them!
88 Posted 10/09/2013 at 20:12:32
Personally I have known Richard since the mid 80s. He has always struck me as an intelligent, passionate and articulate gentleman. I haven't always seen eye to eye with him and have had many disagreements with him over the years, however he has never displayed any of the traits levelled at him by his detractors.
The allegation that this is Political is laughable, of course it is. Free Schools are one of the mainstays of the Tories agenda. Everton Football Club via Everton in the Community have entered into the Political arena once it became a Free School.
Alan, your currency appears to be hearsay and innuendo. Lets just deal solely with facts and evidence. To the best of my knowledge the Club have been unable to produce any supporting evidence whatsoever to substantiate their accusations.
Dan, you ask on a couple of occasions now about other fans facing similar sanctions for speaking out. Maybe Colin Fitzpatrick was been far to courteous by not putting you straight, I will.
Both myself, Colin and others have had, and continue to have sanctions imposed on us. Restricting us from various parts of the ground and other facilities. I have also been denied the opportunity from fully function in my role as an elected representative of the Shareholders Executive Committee. How many examples do you need ? Surely one is one to many.
The only thing for certain, JUSTICE is coming. When it comes I will be proud to have stood shoulder to shoulder with Richard. WHY, you may ask. Because he has right on his side.
89 Posted 10/09/2013 at 21:42:02
Are you able to say what happened on 21st June and 11th September?
You've been clear about the Megastore incident, and for what it is worth I believe you when you say that you weren't there on the day that they say you were. But I don't know what you are saying about the incidents on 21st June and 11th September.
Whatever has gone on, it all seems to have got a bit out of hand and I hope it gets sorted for you sooner rather than later.
90 Posted 10/09/2013 at 19:20:25
Knights can't even answer a simple question like Have you been to any games at Goodison this season? I and most people know the answer he is not prepared to give.
This statement sums it all up for me.
"Call me cynical, but I can't help wondering this would even be discussed if, for example, our club had been taken over by someone else in the last six months?"
91 Posted 10/09/2013 at 22:00:37
He has had ample opportunity to answer this question and mine also, even Fitzpatrick wont answer for him on these two maybe Kelly can.
92 Posted 10/09/2013 at 22:04:52
September 11th I visited the Everton Free school to ask of they had received a letter, I spoke to the receptionist for about a minute.
On every occasion I have requested CCTV footage or phone records, curiously it hasn't been kept. If there is a problem you keep a record.
94 Posted 11/09/2013 at 00:04:09
Its good that people, particularly Simon Lloyd, are taking the time to read the IFO report and are beginning to question the dissimilarities and discrepancies between what they, the IFO, are reporting and what Richard claims.
This reports usefulness as a piece of adjudication is perhaps not what you think; as far as Im concerned, its only useful as an official record of what Everton has said about the behaviour of Richard Knights... its the same as the solicitors letter which caused Richard and his family so much distress.
I think its worth mentioning that the previous incarnation of the IFO, the IFC, the Independent Football Commission, was widely criticised so the Independent Football Ombudsman replaced it five years ago. Unfortunately the same people who formed the IFC form the IFO, two unpaid old duffers whose main aim appears to be a nice jolly and an even nicer lunch, they are constantly being criticised as you can see here, http://www.imusa.org/newsarticle.php?id=306.
Reading the IFO report, you can only be left incredulous at the sheer buffoonery of paragraph 24 where the IFO state, “The IFO must make clear at the outset that the question of the veracity of the statements in the solicitors letter of 2 October, when considered against the account given by the complainant, is not something on which the IFO will make a determination, because the events leading to the issue of a police recordable warning to the complainant are the subject of an ongoing complaint under consideration by the IPCC” but then they do exactly the opposite in their conclusion and determine that the claims of Everton and Everton alone are truthful when they state, “the IFO finds that it is not unreasonable for the Club to take account of actions and behaviour within its wider sphere of influence. The complainant was not deprived of his season ticket because he had breached the ground regulations, but because his over forceful and aggressive demeanour gave rise to fears for the safety of Club employees." Unbelievable.
The question of the ban from the ground and its current status is equally baffling. The former Director of Communications claimed on Twitter that, whilst Richard had had his season ticket withdrawn, he denied Richard had been banned which prompted KEIOC to publish the relevant excerpt of the letter which clearly banned him from Goodison Park. The IFO quaintly claim in their report that "there was some confusion as to whether the complainant was banned from the ground"; heres the relevant excerpt, you decide:
“In addition, the Club has formed the view that your conduct over several months, being such as to require a Police Warning Notice and threat of civil injunction, amounts to inappropriate behaviour as referred to in our Match Ticket / Season Ticket Terms and conditions. Consequently I hereby inform you that as of todays date, your season ticket has been cancelled and the club intends to exercise its entitlement under our Ground Regulations to refuse you admission to Goodison Park. As you are no longer the holder of a season ticket and do not have a customer number, Everton will not communicate with you under our Customer Charter provisions, as it is no longer part of our statutory obligations. For the avoidance of doubt, if you attempt to contact any members of Everton Free School, Everton Football Club or Everton in the Community in future they will be instructed not to respond to you. Any attempted communication will be considered further harassment in light of the warning provided to you to date not to make further contact and the Police and our Solicitors will be contacted with a view to protecting our staff.The report from the IFO is so limp it could have been written by Nick Clegg, they have arses like hot cross buns until they inevitably side with the club despite a total lack of any evidence whatsoever.
Yours sincerely
Paul Tyrrell
Director of Communications”
To cut through the bullshit, in my opinion, what has happened here is that EiTC, wanting the kudos and PR opportunity of holding a consultation exercise, wouldnt answer legitimate questions at that event and didnt want to comply with the request of the Everton chairman that they meet with Richard to discuss his concerns. Some smart arse took over and employed a device with which they were familiar and it ultimately backfired spectacularly as Richard hasnt rolled over and tugged his forelock.
Before this gets too damaging, someone from Everton needs to grow a pair, seize the initiative and make an unreserved apology to Richard as it is evident that, if anyone has been harassed, it is him — hes not the perpetrator here, hes the victim.
Alan #034, Im not being disingenuous, far from it, I did say that you are no doubt just repeating what youve been told but, whilst you cant prove what you said is true, I can prove it is untrue as you see Richard has long since submitted a Data Protection Act request and, if there had been internal complaints about Richard making abusive calls, they would have been identified; they werent.
For further reading, Id recommend this to discover what is going on at all clubs:- http://www.spiked-online.com/newsite/article/11063#.Ui-kKsZwqSo
You may also want to consider this: did Michael Howard complain to the police when Paxman repeatedly asked him the same question over and over again because he wouldnt answer his question? Of course he didnt, hes a grown up. http://youtu.be/Uwlsd8RAoqI
95 Posted 11/09/2013 at 00:11:31
As for that ridiculous statement you quote from Dan Brierly, what exactly is it with this inability to deal with the real world? The club has NOT been taken over in the last six months (these events date back over a year, btw, so I'm not even sure I grasp the relevance of this fantasy), the subject is alive in the here and now and is being discussed because it has merit and it continues to drag on unresolved.
Do you resort to a ridiculous fantasy because you cannot grasp what is really being discussed here? The club is still owned by the same owners, the current 'custodians', and has been for the last 12 years. And a paying member of the Everton fraternity had his season ticket revoked on what appear to be largely trumped up charges. Try to focus on that.
96 Posted 11/09/2013 at 00:12:19
How low and stupid do you want to look — why not ask the out-of-work to get on their bikes and damn well find work, the lazy fucking bastards, eh?
All we need to know about your state-of-mind is contained in this worthless dogsbollocks doggerel: "guy's guilty as charged in my book and no doubt many more considering the lack of any other opinion on this thread."
Let's go over that again: Landon can impute opinions from silence; ladies and gentlemen, Landon can twist things so much in his petty ideological fog that the absence of opinion on something is now — get this, wait for it, hang on, it's coming... EVIDENCE of something!!!
Dear Lord!
How low will you go Landon? 106 is a disgusting post; I wish it did not exist here on these blue boards but it does. Yes, I have rose-tinted images of Evertonians but you Landon bring me firmly back to earth with a volcanic bump.
What you say in your snide and nasty little post is beneath contempt; keep scouring the FOX-NEWS gutter for your life-lessons.
97 Posted 11/09/2013 at 00:15:25
It might just have been me thinking this, but I think it explains why there were so few comments initially.
With regard to the subject matter, if what Richard says is true, then what a shameful episode it has been. Certainly, as fans we should all wonder what if it was us? Are our names being noted down for commenting on this site for example?
Obviously most of us can only form an opinion on what we do know. As the Club has a somewhat murky record where the truth is concerned as demonstrated by the Kirkby stadium saga, and eventually proven at the Public Enquiry, and Richard has no such baggage, I know who I am inclined to believe.
On a wider note, it has been interesting to see that a number of posters have appeared again who vehemently back the Club to the hilt come what may. Dan Brierley seems to love a pompous comment, Alan Williams appears to have been a bit naive in this thread, but Paul Landon seems to have some personal issues with KEIOC. Almost as if he was a Club employee or acting on behalf of one.
I don't know any of these people, I just want a successful team on the pitch, backed by a fan friendly organisation off it. I'd say it's what 99% of us want and I still have this child like vision of it happening, but the more I see of incidents like this, the more I doubt it will ever happen.
98 Posted 11/09/2013 at 02:03:40
I have an opinion that is not of the club being against every supporter, nor do I agree that letting this monster go would lead to others being treated in the same way. You get treated based on your actions and behaviour, I am afraid, and Mr Knights has to be guilty of something.
The union pathetically jumped on the cause of idiots at the Sunderland quarter final – idiots who I witnessed brought shame on our club that night. The Blue Union jumped on the bandwagon and achieved nothing as I told them they would not, the same here bandwagon activity to discredit and gain Kudos which they will never get as long as they exist in my book.
99 Posted 11/09/2013 at 06:11:06
I wouldn't call you cynical
I would call you an idiot of the highest degree
100 Posted 11/09/2013 at 06:26:06
101 Posted 11/09/2013 at 06:05:37
One one hand, we have the detailed and substantiated accounts provided, Colin, Dave and Richard himself - Not to mention the character references from people who actually KNOW Richard.
On the other hand we have the equally compelling "somebody told me" evidence offered by A Williams... and who could fail to be swayed by Paul Landon's "guilty until proven innocent" offering?
Hmmm... tough call
102 Posted 11/09/2013 at 06:33:50
103 Posted 11/09/2013 at 06:40:15
105 Posted 11/09/2013 at 08:16:37
Everton are supporting this good intent.
However the funding for these schools comes out of local educational budget and existing teaching unions don't like that. It is difficult to imagine that unions would be against educating kids with problems so their objections must be based around getting new money put into the educational system. Hey Presto! a 'unions fighting the tory government' debate.
http://www.sec-ed.co.uk/news/everton-free-school-faces-community-opposition
Richard is apparently the Chair of this opposition (and nothing wrong with that).
Conclusions? Politics are at the bottom of this. Whether or not there were any grounds for Richards season ticket to be removed revolve around various peoples different versions of what went on. Do the club have the legal right to do this? Probably. Was it 'fair' that they did so? We could debate for ever. Is it fair that a group of teaching unions object to an effort to educate kids with difficulties with the educational system based on how it is funded and the political colour of the proposers of the system?
106 Posted 11/09/2013 at 09:15:18
--------------------
Knob.... (Sorry Ed's – but this is the most effort I'll allow myself a to muster for this cretin.)
107 Posted 11/09/2013 at 09:28:27
We were promised that the Everton Free School would be a 'landmark', with 120 pupils and 300 in two years time. How many pupils are there? They refuse to say, judging by the photos about 30.
Maybe people should look at the website http://www.evertonfreeschool.com/
Start of the school year and nothing.
We do have something called free speech and the football club are trying to suppress it. It's all part of the bunker mentality - 'if you aren't with us you are against us'.
108 Posted 11/09/2013 at 09:18:15
Everton are supporting this good intent.
---------------------
I don't think you really understand the issue of free schools.
It's nothing to do with kids who don't go to school.
It's about taking money that should be going towards improving our existing school stock and allowing any old Tom, Dick or Harry to set up a school without the controls that exist within the local authority system.. It's about private commercial interests and competition - a pernicious Tory ideology that has already created an elitist education system.
If you're going to give a Tory policy the thumbs up - at least find out about it first.
109 Posted 11/09/2013 at 09:59:23
The young man at Yellow House who was interestingly called a "knob" by some educated TWebber - - who has Aspbergers - - was told to apply for a place at EFC Free School by The Job Centre.
I advised him against it but he was worried about his benefits. He was treated shabbily and unpleasantly to say the least.
I am loathe to write too much here, I am busy with excluded young people today including the young man mentioned.
But if anyone wishes for more information contact me via our website - - www.yellowhouse.info.
Co-incidentally - - although I mentioned the unpleasant character who called a young man with disabilities a "knob" at the same time Kevin Tully a regular on ToffeeWeb sent a donation to Yellow House for our continuing work with such excluded young people.
Unlike he Free School, I Founded Yellow House myself and run it outside "the system" and certainly do not co-operate with phoney so called "back to work" programmes which in many instances I consider to be slave labour and it is open a free to all young people and support from people like Kevin is fantastic and welcome and reminds me how great the majority of Evertonians are and the generosity of TWebbers.
God Bless Evertonians said Tiny Tim (Cahil).
110 Posted 11/09/2013 at 10:19:57
Please extrapolate on the 'knob' thing...as I have called someone a 'knob' on this thread I can only guess that's aimed at me...
113 Posted 11/09/2013 at 10:29:07
114 Posted 11/09/2013 at 10:49:57
116 Posted 11/09/2013 at 11:32:52
Apparently, you don't necessarily need to be fully teacher trained to teach at one!
They are free from local authority control but are now under a more centralised, state control.
117 Posted 11/09/2013 at 11:49:23
don't lose sight of the main issue.
It is not being for or against Free Schools.
The issue is about whether our Club have a right to pursue a vendetta against anyone who opposes their view whether it be football orientated or other.
Freedom of speech is the issue.
118 Posted 11/09/2013 at 11:57:41
Free schools are not an attempt to offer an education to kids unlikely to attend existing schools, they are in general simply schools that are essentially private enterprises which instead of being funded privately by their owners they are being funded by public money extracted from the local education budget.
What youre describing isnt free schools in general – youre talking about the Everton Free School which has been set-up to specifically target children who have been excluded from mainstream education for a whole host of reasons but excluded children is what they are, they are difficult to educate. Why do Everton target these kids? Because the funding received is double what they would if they ran a free school for ordinary kids.
119 Posted 11/09/2013 at 11:24:00
120 Posted 11/09/2013 at 12:48:09
121 Posted 11/09/2013 at 16:50:34
I'm away now for 2 weeks and hope that this has been sorted out when I get back, with an apology for Richard and his season ticket back.
Paul Landon, that is the worst post I have read on here. No evidence from you but guilty because the clubs says he is — and we all know the club would never mislead the fans.
122 Posted 11/09/2013 at 17:04:03
Dear Mr Knights,I acknowledge your email of Monday to our Chief Executive.
It would appear that you have misunderstood, misinterpreted or misconstrued the adjudication of the IFO.
His communication to you, copied to the football club, stated: "I can only conclude that you are the author of your own misfortune and that in order to avoid further escalation of the situation (for example, a civil injunction to restrain your behaviour) you must modify your behaviour to an acceptable level... the club have not gone as far as they might have done in withdrawing your privileges.
"I hope you can accept that you need to modify the behaviour which has given cause for concern and show some contrition for it. In that context, the Club have told me they would be happy to meet with you to discuss how you can support the Club in the future."
It is clear there is no agreement, as you inaccurately claim. We indicated to the IFO that if you moderated your behaviour, we would be prepared to meet with you. Sadly, since we made this offer in good faith, there has been absolutely no sign of improvement at any level. In fact, your attitude towards the football club, and Everton in the Community, has actually deteriorated further. You have also shown no contrition or willingness to move forward.
Until you have exhausted all of the numerous routes of complaint which you are attempting to levy at the football club you say you support, it would be inappropriate and incongruous for us to agree to engage with you.
Should you wish to buy tickets for home games at Goodison Park, you may do so - without any purchase credits or history being recorded. Buying tickets for Everton games will give you no right to contact the football club as a customer.
We will only consider reactivating your customer reference number when we are satisfied that you will not use it for malign purposes as you have done in the past.
If you wish to purchase a ticket for the Wigan game for yourself, kindly inform me via this email address at your earliest convenience and I will arrange it. Do not either attempt to contact our Box Office or access on our online ticketing purchasing system. In future, should you wish to purchase any other tickets for you to attend home games following the Wigan tie, please give me at least seven days' notice.
I would also like to take to this opportunity to reaffirm to you that any contact you wish to make with the football club should be made directly to me and no other members of staff at either Everton FC or Everton in the Community.
Please do not attempt to contact our Chief Executive again on any issues. Should you again contact Mr Elstone and any other member of staff and not me; we reserve the right not to respond.
Paul Tyrrell
Director of Communications.
123 Posted 11/09/2013 at 17:16:55
124 Posted 11/09/2013 at 17:18:17
Almost funny if it hadn't already obviously placed great personal strain on you. Everton — cut through this disgraceful episode and apologise.
125 Posted 11/09/2013 at 17:21:42
The one thing that your post above demonstrates are the methods used by the now departed wretch Tyrrell. In a not dissimilar way to the way he abused dissenting fans at Anfield in his previous employment he attempted to marginalise and isolate supporters, then divide and conquer the fan base and turn fan against fan.
To deny fans the oxygen afforded by publicity and the right to reply and the right to appeal. All classic tools used by despots. In order to silence Richard, the ultimate sanction had to be used. The removal of his Season Ticket.
This was key to the whole fiasco, not because it would deny a 50-something lifelong Evertonian Season Ticket holder the opportunity to follow his beloved Club. NO, not all. The sole purpose of removing Richard's Season Ticket was to ensure that he no longer had a Customer Reference Number.
For any supporter to lodge an appeal, using the Club's own procedures, it would be necessary to quote your Customer Reference Number. No number; unfortunately no appeal.
Hopefully, common sense will prevail: give Richard – or any other fan for that matter – the right to a hearing and the right of an appeal. Surely with a new Director of Communications in post, it would be the ideal opportunity to right a wrong.
In the next couple of weeks, the first anniversary of your ban will pass. How ironic that this unjust, unfair and inappropriate action will last longer than the perpetrator's tenure. Good riddance, says I.
JUSTICE is coming!!!
126 Posted 11/09/2013 at 18:21:09
Always talked about The Blues. Hope you are well. Have a look at our website: ww.yellowhouse.info.
Be nice to meet up again. Best wishes,
Up The Blues.
128 Posted 11/09/2013 at 18:26:22
I was personally surprised to see a subject like this put up for public debate, as it seems a number of normal people outside of the Everton board room have made complaints about how they felt his behaviour was unacceptable. I can fully accept that the board may be involved in some kind of conspiracy, but I find it hard to believe that just normal people working in a school, reception or shop would make situations up.
Simon Lloyd has clearly asked Mr Knights to explain what happened above, which for whatever reason has not been answered. Some people will fully believe Mr Knights's position based on the fact they are conditioned to thinking that the board is wrong on every single thing they do, and are wrong by default. I think there are many people like myself that do not subscribe to that thinking.
And I do freely admit that due to previous incidents where I have had my own credentials as an Evertonian questioned, as soon as I saw certain names posting on this thread, I immediately adopted an overly negative stance. I am happy to admit I was wrong and apologise for my initial attitude, as the majority of people contributing to the discussion are doing so in a constructive way. It's a pity we still have a minority that can only contribute with personal attacks.
If I am honest, I think something has happened (possibly Mr Knights has even offended someone without realising it) and it seems to have been blown out of all proportion by the club, resulting in a ban. I think the way forward hinges on the outcome of whatever appeals or inquests are currently ongoing. Hopefully the outcome is that if the guy is proved to be at fault, he apologises and hopefully gets his ST back. Conversely, if the club is at fault, those who lied are disciplined, and also held accountable for perverting the course of justice. It will then be down to the club for making it right with Mr Knights himself, and the rest of the fanbase by making sure this cannot happen again.
129 Posted 11/09/2013 at 19:02:15
Remember when you threatened to confront Dave Kelly? Did you? Or did you bottle out of it?
130 Posted 11/09/2013 at 19:05:37
I have tried to keep away of this thread - far too complicated an issue for a simple fellow like myself - but.
Reading most of the other posts yours seem to stand out as being totally opposed to this chap RK - can I please ask you to clarify your reasoning for opposing the majority - e.g.. are you in any way a representative or mouth piece for the club?
Just asking
131 Posted 11/09/2013 at 19:06:52
Whatever happens to a supporter of Everton, good or bad is always a topic of discussion, and this disgusting treatment of Richard is something we shouldn't just sweep under the carpet.
Kim Jong Assad Gaddafi Bill, the hated dictator of Everton FC.
132 Posted 11/09/2013 at 19:19:38
133 Posted 11/09/2013 at 19:28:17
Everyone on here has adopted the stance that Mr Knights must be right, I have chosen the opposite view, compounded by the involvement of Kelly and union activists who are just looking for causes, completely off the agenda they originally set out to achieve.
They are not the voice of Everton fans and never will be. Is it just a coincidence that Kelly, Fitzpatrick are all pals of Mr Knights.
134 Posted 11/09/2013 at 19:15:29
135 Posted 11/09/2013 at 20:03:08
Can I just ask, Richard, why haven't you approached the Liverpool Echo over your situation? They appear very willing to take up the cause of other fans who have been mistreated, such as can be seen here: http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/leaked-list-compared-liverpool-fc-4025956
Or is it the case that only Liverpool fans are afforded the exposure of the free press in this city?
Dan Brierley, I think it's best that you don't try to write clever posts because you're not. I agree with your final statement that it will be down to the rest of the fanbase to make sure this cannot happen again, but that won't include the likes of you; it never has and it never will.
136 Posted 11/09/2013 at 21:22:58
137 Posted 11/09/2013 at 22:10:48
December 2012Hi Richard, following your e mail of the 18th in connection with the withdrawal of your season ticket. Having discussed this issue at last nights fans forum meeting, the forum members have decided that as a "one off", a few members and myself will meet with you to listen to your views on this matter only. So if you can contact me and we can try to arrange a mutually agreeable time for this informal meeting to take place. We will select the venue and the meeting will be attended by a couple of forum members, myself and you as an individual. no other 3rd party will attend. So I will await your reply. This issue was not an agenda item and will not appear within the meeting notes .
Tony Bott fans forum chairperson...
138 Posted 12/09/2013 at 01:44:27
What Ive discovered is that I think Richard Knights has really been a thorn in the side of a few people involved in this free school, hes exposed whats been going on and made them look foolish, particularly the guy who made the complaint to the police about him, as you can see from this article here http://gu.com/p/3amm5/tw where his lies have been exposed by a Department of Education email to Richard.
Looking at the Free School website, I believe Richard has a point; theres something wrong, a new term and nothing... whilst every other school, free or not, is shouting from the rooftops.
It looks to me like a personal vendetta and the unfortunate presence of Paul Tyrrell combined to stitch Richard up like a kipper and the rest of the failure brigade at Goodison involved in this are doing what they always do: cover up their own incompetence.
Its political and its personal — but it has nothing to do with going to the match and his season ticket — thats just victimisation.
As for this IFO business, after reading what theyve said to Richard, that “you are the author of your own misfortune and that in order to avoid further escalation of the situation (for example, a civil injunction to restrain your behaviour) you must modify your behaviour to an acceptable level... the club have not gone as far as they might have done in withdrawing your privileges” only to later claim in their published report that they wouldnt determine the veracity of Evertons claims against Richard Knights, KEIOC should do exactly the same as the Man Utd fans, write to the IFO and tell them never to darken the door of Goodison ever again, they are a disgrace.
139 Posted 12/09/2013 at 05:42:15
I have seen Bill Kenwright's letter to Richard, and Bill gives him good, sound solid advice. Maybe you and people like you need to take the personalities out of an issue and judge each case on the available facts rather than the personality.
Unfortunately, Richard became a victim of a serial Bully. Paul Tyrrell was brought into the Club to firefight fan dissent. Sadly this "Red Adair" failed miserably — only adding fuel to the fire.
140 Posted 12/09/2013 at 12:33:49
Is that aimed at me Peter? Care to explain?
141 Posted 12/09/2013 at 13:23:12
"It is reported that 250,000 children leave state schools without a C grade in English or maths, so I am sure the Everton free school will have no difficulty doing what the state finds difficult to do, educating all young people properly."
What makes you so sure Steavey, that unaccountable private organisations can achieve this? Do you not see the irony in your criticism of state education whilst supporting a private, commercial, right wing ideology, which is part-funded by money, much needed money........from the state education budget?
.....Or do you just not have the slightest fucking clue what you are on about?
Editorial Team
142 Posted 12/09/2013 at 14:29:54
I think he may mean Alan Williams.
143 Posted 12/09/2013 at 14:35:05
Then they need to ask him about his evidence to Merseyside Police in December 2012 and that the June 27th 2012 witness statement does not appear to have been shown to the police.
They also need to contact Kitbag (the owners of the Megastore) who have no record of anything happening on that date.
The Independent Police Complaints Commission do have a backlog of cases, but they will get round to investigating it eventually.
If you tell blatant lies there will be consequences.
Alan Myers - this is a PR disaster waiting to happen.
Plenty of people are willing to make a stand against bullying and intimidation - I'm one of them.
145 Posted 12/09/2013 at 17:26:19
146 Posted 12/09/2013 at 17:44:10
147 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:43:08
http://news.sky.com/story/1141071/china-threatens-jail-over-online-rumours
over the Chinese threatening people who are critical of the regime with gaol......we must be practising for a Chinese takeover...most probably be a takeaway!
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 07/09/2013 at 06:48:36
And perhaps implement a change in the club's position?