Season › 2013-14 › News
Kendall says Fellaini won't improve Man Utd
Howard Kendall doesn't think Marouane Fellaini will improve Manchester United. Moyes didn't know where to play him and "he plays it easy; he's too safe with the ball — he doesn't hurt the opposition with a pass."As reported in the Daily Star on Saturday, Howard Kendall said of the Fellaini deal: “Moyes wanted him and got him but I don't think he'll improve Manchester United.
“To start with, where do you play him? David talks about his versatility — he can play in the centre of midfield, off the striker or in a holding role in front of the back four.
“But if you are buying a player, you put him where you want him to play and I haven't got a clue what his best position is.
“I appreciate the lad. He's got presence because of his size and he's dangerous at set-pieces.
“But he floats — he plays it easy. He's too safe with the ball for me — he doesn't hurt the opposition with a pass.
“I would put that deal down as a good sale by Everton at that money."
Quotes or other material sourced from Daily Star
Reader Comments (62)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:28:07
3 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:31:19
4 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:30:37
5 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:33:47
We haven't really witnessed him in another type of team, Man Utd like to break out quickly, looking to get it out wide, so Fellaini won't be playing in a forward position for them.
I think Howard has nailed it, he won't be half as effective for Utd as he was for us.
6 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:03:50
Not a great passer or very skillful but he didn't have to be in the role he played for us. I get a feeling he will be found out at Man Utd, on a bigger pitch and against better opponents in the CL. The Man Utd fans won't be too long getting on his back if he doesn't perform.
In a way, I am glad to see him go because now we don't have him to lump it forward to and we will have to start playing this new style quicker and more effectively. I am curious to know what McCarthy's role will be and I still think we need Gibson back in the team.
Personally I would have Gibson & Barry as the two defensive midfielders with Pienaar, Barkley & McCarthy behind Mirallas & Lukaku. I think Mirallas will be more effective there than on the wing as this is where he scored most of his goals for Olympiakos... Much as I love Ossie, I think he has become too slow, still a great player to have in the squad though...
7 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:15:37
9 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:23:33
Is that a nom de plume for the Ginger Mingebag ?
10 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:26:19
11 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:11:30
This was really a desperate and silly signing by DM in my opinion. I think Fellaini will be very much a squad player for Manure, but £27.5 million is such a massive fee to pay for a mere squad player.
Fellaini is not at the standard of a title chasing team IMO, but I suppose we could say the same thing about many of Manure's players ie: Cleverly, Young and Kagawa.
12 Posted 09/09/2013 at 17:40:46
Fellaini or not I think it's going to be tough going for Man U this season and the expectation, not to mention the business plan, is much higher there than it is here. Their No1 priority is CL football season on season. No2 is at least one cup per season. I doubt they'll put up with 11 cupless seasons like we did.
I think Kendall is right. Fellaini will always be a square peg in a round hole wherever you play him.
13 Posted 09/09/2013 at 18:09:44
HK is just giving his views on MF and what he may or may not give to his team, nothing to do with the respective merits of either manager. You have an agenda regarding RM and any excuse is used by you to keep that agenda running at full tilt.
HK's views on a players strengths and weaknesses are to respected as he won things at Goodison, if RM has the same eye and belief as Kendall I will be more than happy. Am I correct in thinking that you believe our new manager to be nothing more than a con man?
14 Posted 09/09/2013 at 18:13:36
15 Posted 09/09/2013 at 18:21:29
Who was that against?
16 Posted 09/09/2013 at 18:28:42
17 Posted 09/09/2013 at 18:35:53
I think Keith is confusing 'inside the box' with 'outside the box' and Fellaini with Coleman.
Other than that he's still talking nonsense.
18 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:03:33
19 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:14:51
20 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:16:08
21 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:29:20
I completely agree with you
But OFM wouldn't know a prize striker if they'd just knocked in 20 last season
RVP must be working on his tracking back as we speak
"dearth maul" will have that "lazy waster" back in the 18 yd box for every set piece well before as Xmas.
22 Posted 09/09/2013 at 19:56:14
After paying a big fee and being DM's only summer signing, Fellaini is under a lot of pressure to perform because his success or failure will be perceived as DM's success or failure.
Here's how I think it'll go... Fellaini will play a defensive midfield role. If MU are losing or drawing with 20 minutes left he'll be moved up front. Their fans will complain that Kagawa isn't getting game time, they'll wonder why Rooney is getting subbed, they'll start asking questions of why Giggs is picked for every CL and league game and then, one day, after a boring nil-nil on Sky super Sunday, Gary Neville will be stuck for something to say and it'll skip out... "Moyes ruins strikers". I'll give it to the end of October.
23 Posted 09/09/2013 at 20:22:14
24 Posted 09/09/2013 at 20:31:47
25 Posted 09/09/2013 at 20:35:22
To be honest Moyesie Bugger Hall didn't want to sign for you either!
26 Posted 09/09/2013 at 20:50:21
27 Posted 09/09/2013 at 20:35:50
28 Posted 09/09/2013 at 21:21:49
Paul Dark: reading between the lines like Ray Charles chopping up coke on a copy of 'The Cat In The Hat'. Howard Kendall on the guy he supposedly doesn't rate:
“I think he will do an excellent job. The job he did at Wigan, keeping them in the league for so long, and the attractive way he plays football, Im sure the fans will like that. Hes on the back of an FA Cup win as well."
“Ive met him a number of times and he is a true gentleman. Im sure he will do well.
“I have been impressed whenever Ive been in his company".
29 Posted 09/09/2013 at 21:17:49
30 Posted 09/09/2013 at 22:52:56
31 Posted 09/09/2013 at 23:20:21
Gentlemen do not necessarily make great managers (Howard excepted).
Patrick: I do not think Robbie la is a con-man - ... more a con-man with a decided penchant for relegation.;-)
Seriously though: I hope he does well - but words do not maketh the man(ager). Let's wait and see.
32 Posted 09/09/2013 at 23:39:12
We will miss him far more than most of you give him credit for not least his goal and assist contribution.
Not bad for a player who likes to play it "safe" huh.
33 Posted 10/09/2013 at 06:52:39
Carrick will love having him alongside and when he goes forward and commands the attention he ALWAYS warrents, People like RVP and Rooney will think its Chrimo
I think TGT just put himself back in the title race
34 Posted 10/09/2013 at 08:05:41
35 Posted 10/09/2013 at 08:20:41
36 Posted 10/09/2013 at 09:10:05
37 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:09:27
Fellaini is one of the most under-rated mids in the division...I see people on him criticising him for his inconsistency, and I would if they have.been watching the other 'top' cms in this league? Yaya is universally applauded, but Fellaini has been better Yaya over the past year. He is not a Fabregas, but then Fabregas' are seldom found, and a Fabregas would have cost 40million. I think he will do well at United, if they give him time, but whatever happens, 27.5mil is fantastic business. If we are careful with the money, we can really improve the squad, and hopefully bring in a couple of exciting young players (to go with the exciting loans). I would love to see us rescue Holtby from the Spurs bench, and show them what a good player they are wasting.
38 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:19:33
39 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:36:05
40 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:43:25
In a better team he will improve, he is strong, skillful, can keep possession, score goals, win the ball, great control and can be a nasty bastard too if needed. Man Utd don’t have anyone like him, their midfield has been lightweight and Cleverly just ain’t a title winning midfielder. He will do well and we will miss him.
41 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:55:37
42 Posted 10/09/2013 at 10:55:30
43 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:22:20
Fellaini wasn't fit to lace Arteta's boots. Arteta had absolutely everything. Technique on the ball, tactical acumen, a passing range long or short, dead ball expertise, and quite simply flair and outrageous skill. He could control a game from the middle of the park or waltz down a wing. I remember osme games where the opposition fullback would just retreat uinto his own penalty area because Arteta was just pulling him apart and he wasn't even that fast. Even shorn of his pace and strength now post injury he is still a crucial cog for Arsenal and highly rated by their fans. Before that fateful day at Newcastle he was simply the best player we've had at the club since that one season from Kanchelskis. We haven't replaced him since.
Arteta used to get me out of my seat every week, Fellaini's done it once or twice at Man U at home and Fulham away last season. A bit of chest control or a power header here and there is noting compared to watching an embodiment of the school of science in full motion. His strike against Fiorentina is still my best Goodison moment, we went on to lose but that moment was everything that was good about Everton before Fellaini arrived and slowed everything down. That cup run was full of great goals at pace from distance with loads of free running in midfield. Seen any of that since?
44 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:28:12
If Kendal doesn't think Fellaini will improve United, then he hasn't seen the other midfield options play. Cleverly? Anderson? Fellaini is on a different level.
45 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:32:36
Fellaini and Arteta are different players. They are not suppose to do the same job. If you base your judgement of the two on a passing game, Arteta wins hands down. If you base it on the ability to physically dominate a midfield, Fellaini does. The point is that Fellaini will play next to carrick (their arteta), and not instead of him.
And Cleverley is one of the most overrated players in this league...purely because he is English. He will be at a Sunderland or Fulham soon enough. Carrick was brilliant last season, Cleverley was not. And in case it escaped your attention, he started less than half of United's league games last season. He is a representation of the kind of mediocrity which costs the English clubs in Europe last season, and which would have led to United falling way short of last years exploits, without reinforcements.
46 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:30:36
Hmmmmmmmm.
Toure might not have had the best season last year Jim...but Fellaini's been hit and miss for 5 years...he'll flop at United. He will slow down their pacey attacking football. If Moyes starts him ahead of Kagawa or Rooney then he'll be crucified - and rightly so.
47 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:41:59
I don't see why they shouldn't be compared. They both often sat next to a holding midfielder in the centre of midfield. You are right in that they are completely different players but ultimately their job was the same. Run the midfield, create goals, protect the defense like all midfielders do. I think Arteta was better in all respects.
I think it depends on how you want to build a team. I think Fellaini would have been perfect for Mourinho's Chelsea team. They used to crush the middle of the park and the threat came from outwide. Fellaini bombing into the box with Lampard looking for Drogba's knockdowns would have worked great. At Everton though Pienaar Arteta Osman and Baines were all intelinking pinging balls to each other and then there was Fellaini looking out of place trying to muscle people over in midfield. It just didn't work. You either go for one or the other but not a bad blend. Hopefully Martinez can now build a team that wants to play through teams properly rather than trying to control midfield by knocking over opponents.
48 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:57:26
Wilshere > Barkley (for now) > Cleverley > Henderson > Shelvey
The bottom two aren't really international standard. I don't think Cleverley is the next best thing or anything but whenever I've watched him he's played quite well for Man Utd and keeps things moving fluidly going forward – something Fellaini doesn't do. He does a lot of work so that Carrick can sit easy and hit the killer passes. Maybe Fellaini can do something similar. I don't really care. it someone else's midfield to try and balance now with him in it not ours.
49 Posted 10/09/2013 at 11:55:48
Or does RMs new style include rush goalie?
Sorry just joking/ being a bit pedantic, agree in principle although I think McCarthy is more CDM or box to box rather than a ACM. Think McCarthy, Barry and Gibson will compete against each other for the 2 DCM spots - although with Gibsons injury record, not sure there will actually be much competing...
Always have time for HK and agree with his Fellaini comments. Good player that he is I jsut don't see how he'll fit the manu system, unless Moyes plans on playing him behind the striker again. Cannot see the manu fans, nevermind the likes of Rooney and Kagawa, being too impressed with that!
Not sure about "i knew for certain Moyes would end up at United", as he states in the full interview - hindsight's a wonderful thing sometimes....
50 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:03:45
We are taking about Man U now, so I wish them ill (apart from when they are playing the redshite)
I doubt he will fail miserable, as he will have a better quality of players around him and he is a great player.
51 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:16:38
52 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:17:18
I hope he's found out and that the likes of RVP et al revolt and say they want a proper world class manager, to manage what was formerly a world class football club.
I would love it if they didnt manage CL qualification this season.
53 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:28:08
I personally think you can mix and match players. I loved Bayern last season, because I think they perfectly coalesced a direct and passing style, and were able to mix up their football. Of course Fellaini's passing game needs to be improved, but I think he can give the ball to better passers when he needs to. And Ciaran, Fellaini won't play instead of Kagawa or Rooney. They will both fight for a second striker/amc role with Welbeck imo. And Kagawa will never play deeper with Carrick because of the obvious defensive shortcomings. Personally, I think Kagawa should be accommodated in the team, in whichever may possible, as I think he is an incredible player (Possibly from the left, unless Nani returns to form). But I expect he will go back to Borussia long term, because of how highly Klopp rates him. Although that will be complex, in view of the goal threat mkhitaryan offers. Looking like Kagawa will be wasted though, which will be a shame for United and the league
54 Posted 10/09/2013 at 12:53:44
I support Everton and care about Everton. The only time I will waste emotion hoping United lose (including Moyes and Screech) is when they come to Goodison or we go to Old Trafford.
55 Posted 10/09/2013 at 13:53:49
They wanted (maybe needed) Ronaldo or Bale, or plan B of Fabregas and Thiago, then Herrara or whoever. They ended up with a very good player from a side that finished 6th. Added to this, their competitors for the league last season didn't bother turning/played manager roulette/forgot about defence/forgot to buy a January striker. Those mistakes are not going to be made this season. And...and...and... They've just bought a player who their head coach has said about "you can bang it to him anywhere on the pitch."! It's hardly Cantonaesque is it?
"when the sea gulls follow the trawler, it's because they're too scared to fly above Old Trafford because Vidic is banging it to Fellaini."
56 Posted 10/09/2013 at 15:08:52
Windmill in a gale as someone brilliantly said on here.
Never plays a killer pass, lacks pace, stumbles into tackles, elbows flailing. Yellow cards for getting angry and lashing out, headbutting people etc.
Square peg in any round hole you care to put him in.
I can't help but think he'll he ineffective for Utd and will slow them down and disrupt their play as much as he adds to it in other ways. Yeah he'll bag a few important games, and be 'unplayable' here & there, but ultimately he's neither one thing nor another.
He's (weirdly) a utility player in many ways and not even he knows where he should play.
Granted, he's always going to cause problems and be a handful, but he isn't what Utd need and we've done well to utilise him for 5 years and flog him at an inflated price.
"Bang it to Fellaini" Hahahaha!
57 Posted 10/09/2013 at 15:38:51
58 Posted 10/09/2013 at 15:58:14
Personally I find that having a broader view, and wider discussion about football, football clubs, players, officials, issues surrounding the game as a whole really interesting and stimulating.
I've always thought that was the beauty of football, that you could talk about so many aspects of it with just about anyone that's into it.
Each to their own I suppose.
59 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:08:25
I just don't see that same sort of dialogue on here with the obsession about United's new manager.
60 Posted 10/09/2013 at 16:17:05
I'm not sure people are obsessed with Moyes, but they do still like to discuss him after 11 years as our manager, and we all like to listen & discuss what Howard says, right?
61 Posted 10/09/2013 at 18:07:39
It's the same as women, I talk to women all the time, lots of friends that are women...but passion is reserved for the wife.
62 Posted 10/09/2013 at 18:26:45
65 Posted 12/09/2013 at 11:34:45
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 09/09/2013 at 16:22:13
It's all about respect, Howard, and I know that you understand. Moyes never did - and never will (and therefore the perfect Man Utd manager)!