Everton vs Chelsea

, 13 September, 100comments  |  Jump to most recent
Match Preview

With the first international break of the new season out of the way, Everton's quest for a first Premier League win under Roberto Martinez returns to Goodison Park for a date with title-contenders Chelsea.

The Blues' first game in front of the home faithful ended as frustratingly as the following game in Cardiff a fortnight ago with no goals and big question marks over the ability of the team to create and convert chances.

In between, the closure of the transfer window and Martinez's deadline-day activity has seen Marouane Fellaini depart for Manchester United but the midfield bolstered by the arrival of Gareth Barry and James McCarthy and the addition of a genuine goalscoring threat in Romelu Lukaku.

Goodison will have to wait until the last day of the month before it will get it's first look at the Belgian striker in Everton colours as he is ineligible to face his parent club. With Darron Gibson unlikely to be fit enough to start in the next two weeks, both Barry and McCarthy will be in contention for starting berths in the intervening two games, though, as the Spaniard explores his new midfield options.

One of them, most likely Barry, will automatically take Fellaini's place in the midfield holding role, while one of Leon Osman, Steven Pienaar or Ross Barkley would have to make for McCarthy in the more advanced role if the Irish international is to walk straight into the side.

Osman's lack of impact in the opening three games would make him the obvious candidate but both Martinez and his predecessor have shown plenty of confidence in his experience and ability so it's hard to guess what he will do.

There is a more vexing question up front where Nikica Jelavic has struggled to pose a threat and Arouna Kone has exhibited a distinct lack of sharpness as Martinez has brought him in gradually this season. Certainly, the team looked more potent once the Ivorian had come on to replace the Croatian at Cardiff last time out and that alone may tip the manager in Kone's direction for the visit of Jose Mourinho's men.

Like the Blues, Chelsea are unbeaten so far this season but they have two wins on the board, both earned at home, and are sitting in second place, four points better off coming into the weekend. They're also the last team to have won at Goodison Park — their fortunate victory in December last year was the Blues' only home defeat last season.

In many ways, this game could be instructive in demonstrating where Everton are heading under Martinez. Though Lukaku will not be playing — it would be folly to depend entirely on him in any case — how the team approaches a fixture that has produced some stirring, determined dispays by the Blues in recent years will show whether they've lost any of the fire and drive that a home game against one of the Sky Four used to prompt under the old regime.

A win would certainly provide a catalyst to the slow start under Martinez, though, and set them up for the two upcoming trips to the Capital in the League and Cup.

Kick off: 5.30pm
Referee: Howard Webb

 

Reader Comments (100)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Sam Hoare
2 Posted 13/09/2013 at 07:16:17
Will be interesting to see how we do against the first team we have played that will come forward at us rather than primarily sit back. I have a feeling that Martinez will do better this season against the top ten sides than the bottom ten.

I expect only one or two changes and probably:

Howard
Coleman jags Distin Baines
Osman Barry
Mirallas Barkley Pienaar
Kone

McCarthy and Deulofeu to likely feature from the bench.

James Martin
3 Posted 13/09/2013 at 08:04:37
Really need the win here. A win and everything looks good going forward. Anything but and suddenly its difficult to see where we're going to get our first three points from. Will be interesting to see how our possession football stands up against superior opposition. It would be nice for once if we didn't hit every post going with Cech making save after save only for Lampard to score with their only chance of the game.
Phil Sammon
4 Posted 13/09/2013 at 07:58:55
I really hope Mirallas can up his game. We all know how good he can be but he's been very disappointing so far this season. He scored a good goal for Belgium the other day so hopefully confidence is high.

Kone is surely nailed on to start. I love Jela but I really struggle to see a future for him at the club. I think I'm one of the few people that has remained upbeat and confident about Kone despite a string of unbelievable misses against Stevenage. He's going to be a really good player for us.

Sam Hoare
5 Posted 13/09/2013 at 08:12:27
Phil, I think Kone is a lot better than he was against Stevenage but I wonder how much game time he will get with Lukaku now here? Unless Martinez changes formation or plays him out wide? Hopefully he does himself proud if he starts against Chelsea.
Dave Lynch
6 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:02:32
If Osman starts I'm turning the telly off.
Colin Williams
7 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:02:36
Sam, what has Osman done to justify his place in the team this weekend? On his performances this season, he should not be in the squad never mind the team. The top teams in Prem have all raised the bar this season and so must we! We can't afford average performances from players, we need a min of, 7 out of 10 performers, on a regular basis if we want to be competitive.

Kevin Tully
8 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:06:32
Just been listening to Alan Stubbs on Shoutsport, and he was chatting about Ross Barkley.

He said Martinez is letting the lad concentrate on the attacking side of his game, and Moyes wanted him to pay more attention to his defensive duties during a match.

He added that whilst Martinez is still settling in, he wants to put an emphasis on all our youth teams and first team having the ability to instantly change formation during a match. He wants all our players to be flexible, and have a better understanding - not a rigid 4-5-1 or 4-3-3 every game.

Kevin Jones
9 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:07:41
That's OK for you Dave, but what about us poor buggers with season tickets. How do we switch the game off?
James Martin
10 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:12:38
Colin, on the basis of what people have done to justify their place in the team this season, then you'd only have Howard, Barkley and Distin starting tomorrow. Everyone else has been below their standards this season including a few of the untouchables like Baines and Mirallas.

Osman showed what a good standard he can reach throughout the majority of last season. No one pipes up when he's playing out his skin though but are the first to round on him as a scapegoat if he has a bad game. Others, including our most recent departure, stacked up numerous bad games in a row but no-one said a word then they'd all be up cheering if he trapped a long ball on his chest.

Equally if Naismith had performed like Mirallas has this season I dread to think what people would say. Everyone should get a fresh start to bed into the Martinez's system but unfortunately the double standards of fans remains.

Kevin Tully
11 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:22:10
James, agree Mirallas has been very poor so far. No excuse, but I do wonder if half our team were preoccupied with possible transfers during the window.

Hopefully, we are now mentally prepared.

Colin Williams
12 Posted 13/09/2013 at 09:27:02
James, I agree partly with your views, but I feel that Ossie plays in a position where you can't really afford poor performances. All teams' priority is to control midfield areas to dominate the ball and I believe Ossie is not consistent enough any more to play this role. There are other players within the team at present who need to raise their game but I feel most of them give enough within their performance to keep their place at present.

I totally agree that certain players are untouchable, Baines, Mirallas, Pienaar and Howard. I just hope that Robbie sticks to his principles of playing the players in form! Rather than 'names' and seasons gone-by performances. Players work off performances, if they perform (and they know when they have), they should normally play the next game, unless Tactically we need to change, or injuries etc.

Jon Withey
13 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:04:48
Memory is fading a bit on the last two games but seem to remember that Deulofeu made a big difference in terms of genuine chances.

Dropping Barkley would be silly, he deserves the opportunity to play in big matches now.

Still think Jelavic will start and Kone will finish. Although, I assume we paid for Kone to play the whole game.

It would be nice if Mirallas turned up this time.

Sounds like Coleman is touch and go, I wonder if Hibbert will have to face his old foe!

Stick Anichebe on! Oh...

Jamie Barlow
14 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:06:56
I think Sam has it spot on with his team. Ossie hasn't played well so far but the same could be said for most of the team. Let's see how he does with Barry instead of Fellaini. Martinez said he won't rush McCarthy so I can't see him starting.

Up front is a difficult one. Both Jelavic and Kone look desperate for a goal. I'd go for Kone. Whichever one starts, let's hope they do well enough to keep Lukaku out. Not that I don't like Lukaku, I just want all our strikers fighting for a start.

Sam Hoare
15 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:26:55
Colin, read my post again. I didn't say who I wanted to play I said who I expected to play.

As it happens I don't think ossie has been any worse than the likes of Pienaar or Mirallas who everyone is happy to keep in the team. Starting McCarthy and Barry together would be quite a risk given their lack of time together.

Ciarán McGlone
16 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:29:12
"Osman showed what a good standard he can reach throughout the majority of last season"
----------------

Majority? MAJORITY? MAAAAJJJJOOOOOOORRRITY!!!!!

Absolute codswallop.

He'll no doubt start tomorrow, but to suggest he's 'shown' what he can do..is pious bull...the only thing he's shown is that he's been poor for the majority of his career at Everton. If people want to cloud their judgments with sentiment - then fine.

But stop offering these inflated and effuse opinions as anything other than mawkish sentiment.

He had a few great games last season...he also had quite a few very poor ones..with the rest meandering from plain average to not very good.

The fact is that we have midfield options now..and he should be the first out the door.

Mark Taylor
17 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:03:29
I had hoped that one small silver lining from the international break would be Kone getting game time with Ivory Coast. However it seems he didn't play and as far as I can tell, wasn't even in the squad.

One of the more perplexing issues since RM arrived is Kone's seeming lack of match sharpness/fitness, something Martinez has alluded to and seems sanguine about, almost expecting him to be fit.

The Ramadan excuse doesn't wash for me, although the fact his wife has had a baby might. But even then, footballers should be match fit at the start of the season.

If McCarthy's energy levels are OK after the pitch time he's had, I'd put him straight in alongside Barry. Osman's form has been lousy for a while now. I agree there is also pressure for some others to perform; Pienaar and especially Mirallas have had a poor start to the season. I hope Delboy gets a decent run out, not 5 minutes at the end. He'll be very fired up- this is the sort of high profile game that will get back to Barca- and he might be the kind of secret weapon that would help against one of the top 4 teams.

Ciarán McGlone
18 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:37:23
Starting McCarthy and Barry together would be quite a risk given their lack of time together.

------

Strange argument. How much time have Osman and Barry had together?

Barry Earley
19 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:30:02
I don't understand why people don't have McCarthy in the team but include Barry. Is Barry match fit? If so then I can see both starting.

The team I would like to see would be

Howard
Coleman, Jags, Distin, Baines
Barry
Delofeleu, McCarthy, Barkley, Pienaar
Kone

But playing against Chelsea with two new signings and two players making their first starts might not be considered too sensible.........

Duncan McDine
20 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:36:06
That is the team I would expect Sam... and probably the team I would like to see start the game. Lets not get carried away with how shite we've been on the 3 draws. If not for a dodgy non-penalty and an inch or so inside the post, we'd all be looking at how impressive Everton have looked controlling games.
Colin Williams
21 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:33:50
Sam, apologies! Although, why do you expect Ossie to play? Also, why can't McCarthy and Barry play together? Two top internationals, consistent performers who are highly respected in the game, one left footed and right, great balance to centre mid. One plays more offensive and plays a holding role, where is the risk?


Duncan McDine
23 Posted 13/09/2013 at 10:46:14
Not really a strange argument Ciaran. As you know, he didnt mean just the partnership between the two CM's. There aren't many managers that would risk two newbies alongside eachother in arguably the most important positions.
James Martin
25 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:06:08
Ciaran if you want to ignore the fact that Osman has been played out of position the majority of his career then fine. He had a few bad games last season but the rest were generally quite good considering a lot of them he played with Neville. I'm willing to bet that he won't be the first out of the door under Martinez because Martinez values technical skill rather than sheer brutish force. He's just a popular scapegoat and even when he's playing well dictating the tempo of the game the same morons will still bleet on as soon as he igves one ball away or will come up eith the popular refrain 'Is Osman even playing' depsite thefact he's had more touches of the ball than anyone else.

He was one of our better players last season. If people don't agree then fine, but there's nothing oversentimental about that.

Denis Richardson
26 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:00:10
I think McCarthy and Barry in the middle is our strongest pairing (when gibbo is out), but given they are both new to the club and have never played with each other, am not sure RM will start them both in the middle.

Barry is a nailed on starter - and should be given his quality and experience. After that I presume Osman is the only other candidate. Have nothing against Ozzie but would like to see him start less in the middle as he struggles to make an impact quite often and is a bit light weight.

Dont think people should be drawn on the 'must win' cliche for this game, we're playing the league title favourites afterall and its only the 4th game of the season! As long as we have a go and go for the win (and don't lose) I'll be happy. Would be made up with a win but a hard fought draw would not be the end of the world.

GK and defence picks itself, Barry and Ozzie probably in the middle with the rest as it was before. Can see Kone starting but between Jelavics' lack of confidence/form and Kone's lack of sharpeness, am not sure which one is better. I gues Kone will only get sharp if he plays so RM will probably start with him.

Just glad the proper football is finally back. And those clowns at Fifa should swallow their humble pie and give the '22 WC to someone else - winter WC in a country with the population of Birmingham, what a load of tosh!

Derek Turner
27 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:19:42
Kone DelBoy Barkley Mirallas Barry McCarthy Job done. 2-1, Mirallas '14, Barkley '84. Oscar '49.
Tim O'Connell
28 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:17:58
Assuming fitness of Shamus and McCarthy (if not Stones and Ossie replace them) I would be slightly more radical up front - Chelsea have a very powerful and solid defence and with both Jelly and Kone not firing yet, I would try for pace and guile (?) so have Miralles notionally up top with Dezzie wide - but them to alternate. So Potential team:

Howard
Shamus, Jags, Buzz, Bainsey
Barry
Peanuts, McCarthy, Ross, Dezzie,
Miralles

Kieran Fitzgerald
29 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:29:50
I think Barry will start. He has spent the last couple of seasons playing at the top level. Against Chelsea, he will be used to the pressure that playing this standard of team will bring. Ossie is going to be dropped eventually. If we have the replacements in Barkley and McCarthy then drop him.
Jon Withey
32 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:32:49
I doubt any of the title contenders would be devastated with a draw against Chelsea, even at home. Even a scoreless draw would be decent, if frustrating given the context of the last few games.

In some ways it's a bit of a case of 'Careful what you wish for' at the moment - plenty of people were more worried about defence than attack with Martinez and it hasn't really panned out that way. If we manage a clean-sheet against Chelsea, that's pretty encouraging.

Sam Hoare
33 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:42:30
Ciaran, 484, pretty sure you're being deliberately obtuse.

Colin, I'm sure they will both play together in time but right now it's a risk to start two people in such a crucial position who have barely had a chance to train with the team. I'm not sure Martinez will want to disrupt things so suddenly.

James Martin
34 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:50:04
Draws at home were never accepted on here against any opposition under the previous regime so there should be no reason why under Martinez it is any different. I expect Everton regardless of our team or who the opposition is to win every game at Goodison. I don't think there's any such thing as a decent draw at home especially not on the back of three draws two of which have been 0-0s in very winnable games.
Ciarán McGlone
35 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:47:18
James,

There's the use of that word again 'Majority'...Osman has not , NOT played the MAJORITY of his career out of position...

He may have started games on the wings under Moyes - but he never stayed there. He always drifted into the middle of the field - and guess what, he was pretty much as ineffective there as he was anywhere else..

I see you're also using the mitigation that 'he played with Neville'...I doubt even Clarence Darrow would be able to swing a jury in blaming Neville for Osman's poor passing, shooting, positioning and general wastefulness...

Kevin Tully
37 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:00:30
A few interesting facts (If you like that sort of thing) ;

The Toffees have averaged the highest possession figure in the 2013-14 Barclays Premier League season so far (64.1%).

Chelsea have won just two of their last 10 Barclays Premier League trips to Merseyside (W2 D2 L6).

Should Everton fail to win this match, it’ll be only the fourth time in the last 43 seasons that the Toffees have not won any of their first four league games of a season.

Everton have drawn their first three league games of 2013-14 – only three sides in Barclays Premier League history have drawn their opening four.

Romelu Lukaku was the only player in the Premier League last season to score 4+ goals with his left foot, right foot & head. However, he will be ineligible for this game against his parent club.

During his time at City, only Michael Carrick (8125) attempted more passes than Gareth Barry (7561) in the Premier League.

The Toffees have averaged 519 passes per game so far under Roberto Martinez in the Premier League – up from 416 per game last season under David Moyes.

Only West Ham (6) and Everton (5) have allowed fewer opposition shots on target than Chelsea (8) so far this season.

Roberto Martinez has won just one of his last 11 games as a manager in the Barclays Premier League (W1 D6 L4).

All 10 of the scoring opportunities Eden Hazard has created for his team-mates this season have come from open play.

I thought the shots conceded on target was an interesting one, considering we were supposed to be shipping goals under the new fella.

Maybe it's a criticism he was aware of before the season started?

Ciarán McGlone
38 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:04:08
Ciaran, 484, pretty sure you're being deliberately obtuse.
------------

Not in the slightest. I simply don't think your reasoning holds any water.

To suggest that McCarthy can't start with Barry because of lack of time together - begs the obvious question of how much time Barry's had with Osman.

If you wish to expand that to include the rest of the team, then fair enough - but my response to that would be this - what's the biggest risk - playing two players who haven't played together a lot - or playing a player who doesn't appear to be able to kick a ball this season?

I'd say it's the latter.

Phil Sammon
39 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:13:14
Eugene

I don't think Icke drawing an audience is indicative of a 'dumbed down' world at all. Look no further than Jeremy Kyle, Big Brother and X-Factor for that. Icke has some genuinely interesting things to say, but like I stated he is clearly off his rocker.

His research into The Club of Rome and the formulation of the myth of global warming is worth studying before you dismiss him as an idiot.

John Crook
40 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:08:31
Hope Coleman passes the fitness test. I have no confidence in Hibbert anymore. If Coleman was out, I would rather play Stones at right back which I suspect is what Bob will do as he seems to be biggin up his young players on a regular basis. I suspect the team for Saturday will be

GK Howard RB Coleman/Stones LB Baines CD Jagielka CD Distin HCM Barry RM Mirallas LM Pienaar CM Osman ACM Barkley CF Kone.
Subs: Robles Deulofeu Jelavic Heitinga McCarthy Naismith Stones/Hibbert.

Hopefully Kone has built up some more fitness since that awful Stevenage game!

Sam Hoare
41 Posted 13/09/2013 at 11:42:30
Ciaran, 484, pretty sure you're being deliberately obtuse.

Colin, I'm sure they will both play together in time but right now it's a risk to start two people in such a crucial position who have barely had a chance to train with the team. I'm not sure Martinez will want to disrupt things so suddenly.

Sam Hoare
42 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:24:52
Ciaran, if you think playing Osman is a risk, then fair enough... but to question why it is also risky to play two players together who have barely trained together or with the rest of the team is just nitpicking.
Norman Merrill
43 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:20:30
Should be a great game? The main department that requires 100% improvement is the finishing!!

I will leave the team selection to the manager, and hopefully the lads chosen will give the fans, something to shout about, Passing is all very well, but shooting is just as important, especially on target.

Mark Tanton
45 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:30:39
I will be very disappointed to see Osman in there on Saturday, but I think he will start - he is virtually un-droppable for some reason that only a tiny number of people in the world are privy to.

The rest of us, who bemoan his powder puff shot, his knack for missing sitters, his tendancy to be brushed off the ball when the wind picks up, and his recently dire passing, are having a go at him based purely on him being a local boy.

Bobby, please start Barry and McCarthy in the middle to protect Barkley more when he plays right up behind the forward. After three draws, things need a shake up and some new faces are absolutely required as quick as possible.

Ross Edwards
46 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:42:41
No Osman. Please.
Colin Williams
48 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:42:32
Sam, in my opinion Ossie's sell by date has long gone! End of! (And that is putting it nicely)
Also, please explain why 2 experienced Internationals! Can't play in tandom in c/m? I believe if they were both 18 and no prem experience you would have a point but one's 22 the other 32 both comfortable at International level and very good footballers in their own right.
Robbie Muldoon
49 Posted 13/09/2013 at 12:43:31
Chelsea look good for the league. As long as we put a good performance in, create plenty of chances, and control large periods of the game we can't complain. A hiding a bad performance would be the only reason to worry.

If we get a win it's time for everyone to start believing.

Jackie Barry
50 Posted 13/09/2013 at 13:08:07
Talk about his career all you want, I am talking about tomorrow I do not want Osman anywhere near the starting line up. There are 11 other team members who are in a far stronger position for the starting line up. For me he is currently the weakest link, "Leon, you are the weakest link, goodbye!".
James Martin
52 Posted 13/09/2013 at 13:35:12
Ciaran, Osman has only been given a run in the middle twice that I can remember. All of last season and for a spell in 07-08. Whatever your views on him drifting or not (he didn't always drift in field) playing a winger that's supposed to cut in is very different from playing a deep lying midfielder.

There'll never be an agreement on this because you'll only ever see the times Osman gives away the ball or makes a mistake. I tend to focus on how he can control the game when he's playing well. You can try and convince me otherwise but I don't agree he has poor passing or is wasteful. He takes shots, yes, a lot of which don't come off but that's a trait shared by the whole of Everton's midfield. I don't think he's wasteful in his passing – not as wasteful as a Fellaini type who played a lot of balls backwards.

Guess we just view the game differently.

Mike Green
55 Posted 13/09/2013 at 14:01:14
James #503 - there's a huge difference.

Moyes was putting the team he'd had 11 years to put together on the pitch, Martinez is putting a team out who he didn't buy and has known for about 11 weeks.

I love a win, would take a draw and be disappointed to lose at this stage of the Martinez era.

Drew O'Neall
57 Posted 13/09/2013 at 13:47:16
I think people are slotting McCarthy in too far forwards in their imaginery line-ups.

I expect to see him play the same position as Osman was last season which is in a traditional CM role (or could be considered (CDM in our line up).

I'm excited over the prospect of Barry and Gibson in those slots with their range of passing but think McCarthy will have a lot of game time due to Gibbo's injury problems.

Osman will probably be duking it out with Pienaar and Barkley for AM roles.

Drew O'Neall
58 Posted 13/09/2013 at 14:20:19
Yeah - I'm with you James Martin on this, Osman always looks to play and to affect and attack and naturally, when you have that mindset it won't 'come off' as often as when you spray it around the back.
Alan Smith
60 Posted 13/09/2013 at 14:17:45
I see Cairan is at it again.

All this anti-Osman bullshit! he's done his job in all three league games so far. He passes the ball forward more than McCarthy and scores more goals. He forced his way into the England side last season and his form tailed off. As have Baines and Mirralas this season.

He's also had far more better games than your fave Gibbo the snail. So why single him out? He will gradually be worked out of the team but only when Gibbo/Barry/McCarthy have earned it.

If anyone should be dropped it should be Mirallas or Jelavic.

ps: He has played in a midfield that dominated all three league games thus far.

Ciarán McGlone
63 Posted 13/09/2013 at 14:38:19
If anyone should be dropped it should be Mirallas or Jelavic

------------------------

Good grief... What has Mirallas or Jelavic got to do with an argument about our central midfield? This 'whataboutery' has no place in this particular debate...

If you want to discuss Mirallas or Jelavic, then fine. But it's a different bloody argument.

Osman has been poor in all 3 games this season, your revisionism on him 'doing his job' is frankly utter bullshit. That is... unless 'his job' is being utterly useless...

And Alan – I've asked you to stop making up things before to suit your opinions: Gibson is NOT My favourite. Please desist.

As for the nonsense about "passing the ball forward more than McCarthy" – I don't know where to even begin with that particular fabrication.

Lee Hind
64 Posted 13/09/2013 at 14:45:13
Alan Smith 538 - thank God for reason.

Really do not understand the level of some of the abuse Ossie gets on here - don't get me wrong, there are times he deserves a slating (as there are times Baines, Felli and in fact every other squad member has deserved one).

The argument that he is not a good player simply doesn't stack up given his range of PL experience and international call up.

For me, he's a good player who has bad days...and has had more as he's gotten older. I do hope that's not a crime or we are all in trouble....

David Booth
66 Posted 13/09/2013 at 14:39:38
Finally, after the acquisitions of Barry and McCarthy, can we have a team without Osman in it? Please.

Pity about Lukaku being unobtainable and we will miss Fellaini acutely for a game such as this, but let's not tackle Chelsea with 10 men.

At £12m or whatever, McCarthy is surely going to start and with all the eulogies in Barry's direction this week, him too.

The defence picks itself. Barkley seems to have got his name in ink instead of pencil on the team sheet at last, so I'd simply add Mirallas and Deulofeu (who looked fabulous when he made his debut), either side of Jelavic or Kone.

How anyone can propose that Osman gets a place is beyond me. On what grounds?

Who on earth would he replace - and to what benefit? Pienaar is much better than him in every sense too, let's not forget: gets stuck in, has some energy and drive and doesn't spend half the time on his arse with his arms outstretched.

I hope this marks a long-awaited shift in team selection, especially as Osman is habitually so dire against a strong team like Chelsea.


Paul Smith
69 Posted 13/09/2013 at 15:11:51
For the life of me, we cannot have a centre midfield pairing of Osman and Barry as neither of them can get round the pitch enough. So to me that means Osman dropping out and two new lads starting.

Both Mirallas and Pienaar have underperformed for me this season and are under pressure for their places from young Gerard but I don't feel this is the game to throw him in from the start. So here is my team for

Chelsea
Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
McCarthy Barry
Barkley
Mirallas Pienaar
Kone

David Booth
70 Posted 13/09/2013 at 15:05:21
Oh, and if Coleman in unfit and Hibbert starts as well...

Stones please from here onwards - not Chelsea (at Wembley) revisited!

Kevin Tully
72 Posted 13/09/2013 at 15:37:27
I think Martinez will replace Fellaini with Barry, and that will be the only change.

He knows he has to give the established order a chance to prove themselves, especially now, with added competition for places.

He will give them another three games, and then we may see major changes if the old guard don't perform.

Patrick Carty
75 Posted 13/09/2013 at 16:02:17
I am not an Osman hater but his time in the first team is up. Leon has given great service to the team but his form since last season has been dipping constantly, and it's time for fresh faces.

I think Gareth Barry is a shrewd buy, getting Lukaku on loan was great business but the jury is very much out on James McCarthy.

As an Irishman I have watched a lot of James and have not been overly impressed, but he is still young with a lot of Premier League football behind him, and I feel the players around him will only improve him. Good luck tomorrow, lads.

Robert Collins
78 Posted 13/09/2013 at 16:32:27
As far as I'm concerned, Osman, Peinaar, Miralles, Jelavic, Kone are playing like they're in an end of season game with nothing to play for. It's not good enough.

I'm pleased now we can put them under pressure to play, with the 3 new signings, there should be some fizz in the team now and especially with young Ross running around like his arse is on fire.

Good stuff!

Brian Harrison
80 Posted 13/09/2013 at 17:34:00
I think tomorrows game is our most difficult so far this season, but usually it is the difficult games that bring the best out of our teams especially at Goodison. When we play any of the top 4 at Goodison the crowd are always at their best and seem to push the team on to another level. I think for us to get anything out of tomorrows game we will have to play better than in our previous games this season.
Peter Cummings
90 Posted 13/09/2013 at 18:41:32
I have a feeling this will be another draw or Chelsea win (again). We never seem to get our act together against them in cup or league and of course we have our ''bogeyman' in Lampard to contend with. We could get a pen for a Terry handball or Ivanovic who doesn't take prisoners. A lot could depend on an eagle-eyed ref – not one who needs bifos! I will be watching the game live on Sportscentre Canada at 12:30pm. COYB!
Derek Knox
95 Posted 13/09/2013 at 19:20:34
Just been reading an article regarding Romelu Lukaku, although he is ineligible to play for us tomorrow, he nevertheless wants Everton to beat Chelsea.

The article also said that he was really happy to join us, and is convinced, despite many offers, that he has made the right one.

I may be a bit over-optimistic at this stage, but considering he was not a Mourinho signing, could there be a chance we could buy him for keeps at the end of the loan period?

I think a lot will depend on how we finish in the League, if we are knocking on the top table, there's every chance. We must start with a win tomorrow though.

COYB

Iain Johnston
101 Posted 13/09/2013 at 19:40:20
Can we discuss the Poles flipping now and the consequences of a depleted magnetic field causing us to all be fried by the intense UV?.
Derek, interesting point ref Lukaku, wonder if that is in RMs mind?. Yep, Kone for me tomorrow. I think the style Chelsea play will suit our new tactics. 2-1 for me.
Ged Simpson
102 Posted 13/09/2013 at 19:46:42
Word is it is just a phase that happens every eon. Like our league titles.

Kone and Jella

Lewis Barclay
103 Posted 13/09/2013 at 19:48:44
Wouldn't be hugely surprised if Deulofeu gets a start.
Ged Simpson
104 Posted 13/09/2013 at 19:56:13
Agree Lewis
Alan Smith
112 Posted 13/09/2013 at 19:58:05
Ciaran Mcglone and friends

Everyone knows Ossie will eventually be replaced, but to suggest he's played badly in the league this season is just plain wrong. According to SSN, Everton have had the highest average possession so far this season. I would say the job of any CM is first and formost to dominate midfield and get hold of the ball for the team. The evidence suggest he and Fellaini had done that.
Bear in mind Barry has not played this season and only 25% of Mcarthy's passes went forward in the prem last year, I'd be carefull what you wish for.

The witch hunt on Osman is totally unjustified when Jelavic and mirralas' form is taken into account.

Here are some other pearls of wisdom from the German and chums;

"Will never sign Lukaku" -cloud cuckoo land was a phrase used.

"Paying someone £100k would bankrupt us"- Barry?

"Increasing the wage bill by £3m a year would bankrupt us"

You also sung the praises of Medel who got no where ossie and got away with blatant pen.

before pre season you had no faith in Barkley and didn't think he was ready. But suggested Holtby, and sigurdson. Haha

You made out we would be lucky to finish top 10. Took the piss because I suggested top 6 if we kept Fellaini and signed Barry etc....you think Southampton and Norwich could finish above us and was crying about their great signings compared to ours.

Your nearly always wrong! In fact, if you told me my name was Alan Smith and that football was played on grass with a round ball I would not believe you.

Phil Sammon
116 Posted 13/09/2013 at 20:52:29
Alan Smith

Sorry, who said we were paying Barry £100k p/w?

I'll concede that I was one of those who thought we didn't have a chance of landing Lukaku, so credit where it's due to you on that one. I still think he's Chelsea's best striker. I'm baffled they've let him go.

Paul Lewis
126 Posted 13/09/2013 at 20:55:08
I think weve got to accept the fact Ossie is more than likely going to start tomorrow and partner one of the new kids in midfield with Barkley in the number 10 role.

While Ossie's not everyone's cup of tea including mine, he will put a shift in so lets get behind him. I'm really hoping Miralles and Pienaar put in a performance and one of Kone/Jelavic finally pull their finger out.
Ben Jones
136 Posted 13/09/2013 at 21:24:59
I think we have to face is we played Osman in this role, because we had no other options. With Barry, McCarthy and Gibson, he's only a squad player.

But he's not as bad as everyone says. It's typical over exaggeration. But his attributes just doesn't suit this deep role.

I see him challenging Barkley's spot. He's a lot better further up the field. But I think the days are gone where he's a first teamer.

But getting rid of him is too far. He's still going to be a useful squad player this season.

Harold Matthews
152 Posted 13/09/2013 at 22:43:48
Mourinho will make sure it's a test of physical strength in the midfield and our wingers, especially, will need to put in a full shift.

If Eto plays he go straight through the famous gap between the left boot of Jags and the right boot of Distin and we'll need a fast tank to stop him getting there. Unfortunately, I've searched our squad and can't find one.

Lloyd Brodrick
159 Posted 14/09/2013 at 00:43:46
Phil Sammon
"I'm baffled they've let him go"
It's interesting when you think about it. Have they let him go or can he do a job for them as well as us?
Top four side loans top striker to top 6 side. I don't think that Chelsea feel we can challenge them over the course of a season but we can hurt what they see as their main opposition especially if they bolster us with a very promising striker. Could be wrong but certainly improves their chances in winning the league.
Andy Crooks
160 Posted 14/09/2013 at 00:52:25
McCarthy should start tomorrow as should Barry. I would hope that whilst Barry has been out of the Man C team he has been training and might actually be fit enough to earn his vast salary. Osman will start and will play well. I expect us to win. I expect Kone to play and score and will back Everton in a goal rush plus.

Also, tomorrow I will probably lose my money and after MOTD will write an angry post calling or the sacking of Martinez.On Sunday, early, I will retract the post and call for Martinez to be given more time.

Finally, Ba would have been much better than Lukaku.

John Barnes
168 Posted 14/09/2013 at 05:02:04
You're right Wilf. How much is a pint of cider these days?
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
169 Posted 14/09/2013 at 05:23:56
Jamie,

I was a bit surprised when I logged on after a hard day at work to see quite so many deleted posts...

But rules is rules. I don't think these subjects were within Lyndon's expectations as outcomes from his Match Preview

So..., errr... stay on topic, please!

Jamie Crowley
170 Posted 14/09/2013 at 05:24:20
Michael / Lyndon -

I being "auto removed"

why? all I did was make a crack about this David Icke guy.

Whatever I did sorry...

Feel like I'm in Cold War Russia. Harmless comments now not allowing me to post?

Really?

Your site, your rules. But really?

Jamie Crowley
171 Posted 14/09/2013 at 05:27:19
Got it MK. Surprised you are awake. Cheers.

Staying on point. Loving Senor Icke...

Jamie Crowley
172 Posted 14/09/2013 at 05:30:46
Lastly...

I understand Mr Ruane is a rock star - and he is. There's not one post of his I don't enjoy thoroughly.

But why does his post stand (500) when off point when us lesser jesters get the same topical matter removed? Heck, his reference to 489 (Phil) has even been removed?

Keep that post, keep em all. It was simply a bit of off topic; tangent fun.(!)

One of the things I adore about this site is how it broadens my feeble American perspective - outside all things Everton. Please don't take that away...

Match preview: Everton 1, Chelsea 1. Hope I'm wrong. Hope I've not fallen foul of the moderators...

COYB

Ged Simpson
174 Posted 14/09/2013 at 06:07:19
Jamie - I think the stalinist moderators have a point.
Harold Matthews
175 Posted 14/09/2013 at 06:25:06
Jamie. With all this chat about Lizards, Icke and the paranormal, I imagine your surname scared a few people. Others would gain comfort from your initials.....Weird stuff.

As for the game. Well, they will definitely score so I hope Martinez wasn't kidding when he promised us an ultra sharp Kone round about now. We'll need two or three goals and I'm hoping he will be Man of the Match.

Tony Cheek
176 Posted 14/09/2013 at 08:41:07
Will be really disappointed if Senor Bob benches Barkley. He has to show us his balls are bigger than Moyses! Go for it, we are good enough.

We have spent eleven years showing too much respect for the Sky clubs! Today we can take a gun to a gunfight!!

Mark Tanton
177 Posted 14/09/2013 at 09:00:24
I cannot envisage Barkley being dropped, he just doesn't deserve it. My team has to be

Howard

Coleman
Jagielka
Distin
Baines

Mirallas
Barry
McCarthy
Pienaar

Barkley

Kone

Derek Knox
178 Posted 14/09/2013 at 09:20:41
Mark (707)

Hope that is the team, or, at least very close to what it will be. Reports are saying that Seamus could be doubtful, following the International match, I can only hope these are wide of the mark (excuse the unintended pun) . If we play Tony Hibbert instead, we have lost a lot and he will get destroyed for pace.

I hope young Gerard gets a chance, and I don't mean a cameo role towards the end, because, to Chelsea, he is a relatively unknown factor, and is well capable of springing a few surprises.

Really looking forward now, as it seems to have been an eternity since we last played.

COYB

Carl Sanderson
179 Posted 14/09/2013 at 09:25:40
I hope we win, obviously, although I am less than confident. I tend to see Chelsea as a higher-quality version of Everton: work-rate and organisation with talent on top of that. That is probably one reason for our modest record against them over the last 10 years or so.

After their spawny win last season Lampard described Everton away as one of the hardest games of the season. So if we were to lose today I hope that Chelsea will know they've been in a game.

Lewis Barclay
188 Posted 14/09/2013 at 12:51:51
How about:

Howard
Stones Jagielka Distin Baines
Barry
Coleman McCarthy Pienaar
Barkley
Mirallas

This would allow Martinez to change his formation to five at the back easily enough.

Ross Edwards
190 Posted 14/09/2013 at 13:35:19
Fair enough. Nobody's perfect. I get things wrong, you get them right. You are right, I am quick to tell people on here that I disagree. Isn't that what debate is?

If we all agreed with everyone else it would be a pretty boring existence on here.

Phil Sammon
191 Posted 14/09/2013 at 13:33:32
Hang on, Alan, reign in the gloating for a moment.

How have we increased the wage budget by £3M?

How much do you think we are paying Gareth Barry?

We've got £75k p/w off the books in Fellaini and maybe £25k for Victor - plus both went for inflated fees.

Had it not been for those sales do you really think we could have brought in Lukaku, Barry and McCarthy?

Your plan was to hang onto Baines and Fellaini, despite the latter clearly wanting away, and give them both £100k p/w.

How are you claiming vindication from those events? It was nothing like what you had suggested.

Harold Matthews
192 Posted 14/09/2013 at 13:00:13
Derek. I never worry about Hibbert. He's very quick, makes few mistakes and knows how to combine with Jags. Of course he doesn't give us the attacking talent of Coleman but the strikers will like the way he gets the ball across early. This hasn't been happening of late and is one of the reasons we score few goals.

I'm hoping Mirallis has a decent game. He's definitely a bit of a sissy and soon chucks in the towel against tough fullbacks like Enrique, but with Cole not being particularly physical he might have a good day.

Unfortunately, we're miles away from being a settled side but it's early days and, no matter how we fare today, we can only improve. That said, with all fingers crossed, I hope we win.

Paul Dark
195 Posted 14/09/2013 at 14:29:56
Osman should be dropped (from the squad); Jela should keep his place.
Alan Smith
196 Posted 14/09/2013 at 13:44:18
Phil your quite right I may be a little premature and gloating is poor form.

The accounts will come out at the AGM. I think most people will expect the wages to have increased given the ins and outs and the new contracts RM said he's going to dish out.

SSN reported Barry on £100k a week and city made Everton pay the lot as he's a free agent next year. It makes sense to give him it now as there is no fee. If we signed him for £2m and paid him £60k its the same cost as a free transfer and paying him £100k until 1st June. So I believe sky.

What do you think Baines will be offered? What's his wages market value?

"it was nothing like I suggested" ....absolutely correct. Unfortunately Fellaini wanted to leave. Nothing anyone could do about that. We're I think I'm right is that what I suggested would not have bankrupted us. That was the argument. I never said Fellaini and Baines will stay and will get £100k.

I look forward to the AGM when wages will have increased by more than £3m. That will be vindication, especially if we spend he rest of the Fellaini fee.

Here's another for you to rip apart but which I think is inevitable and why I thought it reasonable to offer Fellaini Baines that sort of money:

Within two seasons at least 10 clubs in the prem will have a player on £100k a week.

Richard Dodd
197 Posted 14/09/2013 at 14:28:25
I have a sneaking suspicion we shall see both Hibbo and Ossie in the starting line-up today. Not because Roberto sees them as part of his brave new world but more because he has great respect for our old guard.

I think he sees Stones much more as a central defender and, if Seamus is unavailable, he will take the safe option.

Who starts up front is the real poser with both Jelly and Kone coming up short so far. I suspect the first half will be Jelavic's.

Alan Smith
206 Posted 14/09/2013 at 14:48:52
I reckon a big game under the floodlights on telly is exactly what we need to kick start our season.

Terrible cliche but I'm really looking forward to the game COYB!

Ged Simpson
207 Posted 14/09/2013 at 14:52:23
Me too Alan. Strangely I don't expect us to win but am looking at how we develop. Always thought mid table this year but happy with new approach. Watch us next year.
Ciarán McGlone
213 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:24:01
Lukaku wants an Everton win - in his interview on the OS!

I love him already!

Ross Edwards
214 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:33:51
Hallelujah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Moyes has won at Old Trafford!!!

In other news, I'd like to see Deulofeu play today. He'd test Cashley more than Pienaar would usually. Mirallas and Del on the wings could create trouble for Chelski's defence.

We have to be sharp in defence because they will slaughter us if Hazard, Mata and Oscar are in form.

James Martin
215 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:37:22
I'd like to see that line up too Ross but can't see Martinez going for it. I think because of their strength in their midfielders behind the stirker Martinez will play Pienaar to cover those balls infield and try and push Hazard/Mata/Oscar wider. There's not a defensive bone in Mirallas and Deulofeu (yet) so playing both agianst arguably the best attacking midfield in the league would be dangerous. But hey maybe Martinez lives on the edge these days, we play both and win 5-0. Perhaps Moyes was aorund for too long.
Ross Edwards
216 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:41:01
Knowing Martinez and Mourinho's styles of play James, it will be like the Chuckle Brothers out there, "To me, To you, To me to you, Osman loses it"
Colin Wainwright
217 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:40:30
Taken a photo of this post to prove to myself that..........I did actually type it. Agree with Ross. Hope he plays Del in place of Pienaar. Nothing wrong with a kick up the arse.
Ross Edwards
218 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:45:06
I know it is a surreal experience Colin when someone agrees with me on here.
Mark Frere
219 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:40:34
Ross, Pienaar usually plays left midfield, so he will be facing Chelsea's RB. Just saying like
Colin Wainwright
220 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:46:49
Shit, that does sound like I was taking the mick Ross. I wasn't mate. I was referring to the many disappearing posts on this thread.
Ross Edwards
221 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:49:13
You're right Mark, but you know what I meant.

Del will threaten Ivanovic more than Pienaar would, and Mirallas will threaten Cole, so we can create chances for the front men.

The defence will have to be bloody good though today. Any slips and we could be battered.

Colin, don't worry, it's not very often that anyone agrees with me on here at all!

Mark Frere
223 Posted 14/09/2013 at 15:57:39
I agree Ross, our defence will have to be rock solid and our 2 defensive midfielders will have to do a good job. I think we will have more chances to counter attack in this game, so I hope Kone plays, his blistering pace could be key
Ross Edwards
224 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:06:16
Mark

Spot on. I will be very disappointed in Martinez if Osman, Pienaar and Jelavic play.

Del, Kev and Kone will be lethal on the break. More so than Pienaar and Jelavic.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb