Fantastic first win for Roberto

, ToffeeWeb Match Reports , 14 September, 290comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 1 - 0 Chelsea
Roberto Martinez surprised a few observes with a rather conservative line-up, only Gareth Barry of his new acquisitions starting in a side that included the likes of Naismith, Osman and Jelavic — all rather ineffective thus far this season. Gibson and Alcaraz aren't yet fit, Lukaku is ineligible,and Kone and Pienaar are both missing from the squad. But at least Ross Barkley made his fourth start of the season, allowed to play with much more attacking intend under Martinez — According to Alan Stubbs!

Everton started in confident style, continuing the comfortable possession play and slow build-up from the back but nothing came of it and Chelsea were the first to mount far quicker and more dangerous attacks, wining the first corner, then Eto'o heading over.

But it was Naismith who broke well down the right and picked out Jelavic but the lack of pace on the ball meant an easy save for Peter Cech. More good work by Naismith won a corner but the ball was played all the way back to Howard!

Osman squandered simple position but Barry was there to mop up, the City loanee settling in instantly and showing some much needed composure in the middle. Everton were doing more than holding their own, playing well in the centre of the park, but as ever, creating that final threat on goal was not really happening, with Jelavic lacking the strength and guile to evade his marker.

Howard produce an unbelievable error, PATB, gifting the ball to Hazard, and Barry saved Everton blushes with a brilliant block to incredibly prevent Eto'o scoring an easy open goal.

Mirallas switched over to the right combined woth Coleman and Naismith, making a great play and picking out Naismith whose shot should have been better, under pressure from Luiz.

An absolutely brilliant save by Howard off Ramierz saved another seemingly certain goal, Naismith then breaking quickly but halting and making the most dreadful of passes to ruin what should have been an incisive counter, putting the Everton goal under more pressure again.

More danger, as Schrurle scooped an easy goal shot well over the bar after Baines had stalled. A good free-kick opportunity was then wasted with an awful pass from Osman, and again, more pressure with a free-kick for Chelsea, Barry fouling again. Ivanovic glanced the delivery over the Everton bar, a Chelsea goal only a matter of time...

Everton had played quite well in the first half, but with precious little in the way of threat on the Chelsea goal; possession only pays if you actually hold onto the ball and Osman was perhaps the worst culprit, putting Everton under increasingly heavy pressure approaching the break, Howard's goal leading a charmed life under some serious Chelsea chances.

But, in the added minute before the half-time whistle, the patient passing approach finally paid off after a good interception by Naismith. A neat move with some concise passing was fittingly finished off by Naismith after a superb cross from Osman to Jelavic, heading back over Cech from the far post, set up a lovely easy header from 2 yards for the other half of the ex-rangers pairing to put the Blues into the lead at the break.

No changes at for the second half, with Moruinho delaying his players' return to the pitch for a couple of minutes. Baines this time gave the ball away and Schulre seemed to have clipped his shot easily over Hoard but thankfully into the side-netting.

Some shocking sloppy stuff at the back saw Distin roill the ball needlessly out of play, Mourinho's mind-games having seemingly done the trick with Everton looking simply terrible, Eto'o getting in a shot that Howard blocked well, and thankfully no-one following up. Everton were pinned back for 5 mins before they briefly got the ball forward, such was Chelsea's pressure and dominance.

Naismith got into a great position to set something up but his scooped choip for Jelavic was all wrong, Then Jelavic had a chance in plenty of space off a great ball from Barry but the Croatian's header was very poor. Everton were having to work very hard in defence and Mourinho made a couple of early chances, one being Everton's nemesis Lampard.

Barkley had been quiet but he did get free down the left, however his forward ball was given just too much weight. He had a chance to carry the ball forward through the midfield but again his decision-making was wrong, losing possession instead of making the pass. And yet again, trying to be too clever, and ending up fouling Mikel, James McCarthy then came on for Jelavic, with Mirallas moving up front.

A final change for Chelsea, with Torres on, throwing the kitchen sink to try and get back into this game with 20-odd minutes left, an excellent contest in prospect.

Hazard blocked Mirallas, and a great free-kick opportunity had the crowd well up for something from Baines but it was a low strike by Mirallas, saved at the post by Cech, and a handful of Everton corners followed, but no chance developed.

Osman agian gave up possession cheaply in tthe danger area but McCarthy and Naismith rescued him. However, Chelsea were piling it on thick. Barkley seemed to have space for a shot but he could not dig one out and the ball was right back in Howard's area, as the pace and intensity of the game accelerated even more.

A tremendous cross by Eto'o and Howard having to pull out all the stops. Barkley and Mirallas forced the pace down the left, the Belgian putting in a fearsome shot that Cech blocked away.

What looked at first like a clear penalty but Coleman was adjudged to have been fouled by Hazard fractionally outside the Chelsea area but Baines powered the cross way tooo far to the back post, with 10 mins left.

Luiz, dragged Mirallas back, but it was in the middle of the field and Howard only gave a yellow, with Goodison howling for the red card this disgustingly cynical foul by Chelsea. Naismith then fouled but it was no threat and Barkley looked to break but yet again he played it wrong, showing too much to the Chelsea defender.

Barkley again got a chance to run forward, so tired, but he drew the foul in a wonderful position. Naismith was then withdrawn for Stones as Baines lined up the free-kick and clipped it off the top of the Chelsea angle! Chelsea were quickly back the other end but into added time and still Everton resisted with tremendous passion and commitment. Mirallas won an excellent handball off Luiz, and Mirallas was then swapped out for a cameo from Deulofeu (why so late?!?!)

Everton kept playing up as they could, running down the seconds of added time, Osman getting a great chance but his shot was awful, spooned over. The last Chelsea attack petered out and Goodison Park erupted with joy and relief in equal measure — an excellent first win for Roberto Martinez.

Everton: Howard; Baines, Jagielka, Distin, Coleman; Naismith,Barry, Barkley, Osman, Mirallas; Jelavic.
Subs: Robles, Heitinga, Oviedo, Deulofeu, McCarthy, Gueye, Stones.

Chelsea: Cech, Ivanovic Y:65', Cole, Luiz Y:78', Ramires, Mata (57' Oscar), Mikel Y:86', Schurrle (57' Lampard), Hazard Y:80', Terry, Eto'o.

Kick off: 5:30pm
Referee: Howard Webb

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (290)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ciarán McGlone
1 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:35:17
Naismith and Osman in the starting eleven apparently...

Sigh.

Barry starts... McCarthy on bench.

Ciarán McGlone
2 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:38:11
Pienaar not in the squad..
Ciarán McGlone
3 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:39:28
Naismith and Osman start
Colin Wainwright
4 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:40:15
Not in the squad! Strange one that Ciaran. What the fuck's happened there?
Ross Edwards
5 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:41:19
No forward on the bench. What the hell is he playing at?
Ross Edwards
6 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:42:32
No Kone either.
Mark Frere
7 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:41:40
Fucking Naismith! I despair, I really do!!!! Just hope he gets a knock early on that keeps him out of action for a few months. I wouldn't pay him in brass buttons.
Mark Frere
8 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:44:12
Kone and Pienaar must be injured Ross
James Martin
9 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:44:21
Without Pienaar, Mark, we've got the sum total of about two options for the left wing, one of which is a kid from Barcelona so I wouldn't be wishing injury upon anyone really.
Ciarán McGlone
10 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:44:10
Martinez claims to be an exponent of the beautiful game – but appears to see something in Naismith that merits his inclusion... I don't understand it.

As for the Osman thing...

Ross Edwards
11 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:45:34
Mark, I Feel a horrible, sickening taste of deja vu harking back to the Walter and Moyes days. This is a KITAP1 team if I ever saw one.
Ciarán McGlone
12 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:46:28
If Pienaar's injured then Oviedo is the choice... not Naismith.
Mark Frere
13 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:46:10
Martin - Oviedo and Deulofeu can play there! They are both ten times the player Naismith is.
Mark Frere
14 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:48:16
I agree, Ross, this is about as uninspiring as it gets. Chelsea must be licking their lips.
Trevor Lynes
15 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:54:38
They must both be injured.
I cannot see any other reason for their omission unless perhaps disciplinary ?
Roman Sidey
16 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:55:51
Thought Oviedo would be an obvious replacement for Pienaar.
Simon Hughes
17 Posted 14/09/2013 at 16:56:13
Jesus Christ, sorry to say this guys but this is a relegation scrap for us. Little height and can't see much fight in that midfield!
James Stewart
18 Posted 14/09/2013 at 17:07:00
Was looking forward to the game. Not now I've seen the teamsheet. Jelavic, Osman and Naismith. Sigh....
Paul Andrews
19 Posted 14/09/2013 at 17:19:48
Mark Frere,

You hope and EVERTON player gets a serious injury ?
Fuckin disgraceful that

Danny Broderick
20 Posted 14/09/2013 at 17:21:44
Has anyone just seen the 3 stats they produced on Everton on Sky? Apparently we have had the most possession, 3rd most assists - what was the 3rd stat that we were top of the league for?
Neil Adams
21 Posted 14/09/2013 at 17:23:26
Personally would have liked to see a 4-3-3 with McCarthy, Barry and Barkley in midfield, Coleman and Baines bombing forward to support Deulofeu, Jelavic and Mirallas. I guess that might happen if we are 3-0 up at half time.... some hope!
Peter Foy
22 Posted 14/09/2013 at 17:30:08
Worried
Nev Renshaw
23 Posted 14/09/2013 at 18:16:30
Mark 823 your mate Naismith has just scored. And as for you Simon 833 you're one defeatist , relegation scrap 4th game of the season? Bloody hell.
Charles Brewer
24 Posted 14/09/2013 at 18:16:10
HT: Jelavic/Naismith combination 1 - Russian Mafia Scum 0

And amusingly, it was "England's best left back" from whose side the cross came! Sky commentary appears that be that Everton should not be contesting this match.

Cole really is crap!

Jim Harrison
25 Posted 14/09/2013 at 18:19:17
Even before he scored I thought Naismith had been playing well, much better than last year. Would like to see a few more runs with the ball, not just passing. Shake it up a bit
Timothy Sebastian
26 Posted 14/09/2013 at 18:21:07
I'd stop all this criticism of Naismith. He's a lot better than most think. He's starting to get into his rhythm and turning out to be a good little player. Coyb
Nev Renshaw
28 Posted 14/09/2013 at 18:20:27
COYB
Paul Mackie
29 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:23:58
Some humble pie needed to be eaten in this thread as Naismith had a great game today, not just his goal but all round. Not as good as Gareth Barry though. He looks like he's been playing for us for years the way he fit into the team today.

Barkley needs to be less selfish and less flashy. There were times today he attempted passes or dribbles which failed spectacularly when he could have made a simple move that would have kept us possession. At times he looks amazing though.

Osman shouldn't start any more. Brushed off the ball too easily and his passing was pretty crap today.

All in all, a great performance, although I still feel we're lacking threat in the final third. I'm hoping Lukaku is the answer.

Dave Lynch
30 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:26:35
That was a magnificent win. Barry was awesome especially having to do the work of 2 as Osman was shite first half and not much better 2nd

Good to see we still tried to put the game to bed 2nd half and still have some attacking intent.

Keep it going lads and we'll be ok this season.

Alex Mullan
31 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:26:34
Ciarán McGlone,

"Naismith and Osman in the starting eleven apparently...Sigh."

"Naismith and Osman start"

"If Pienaar's injured then Oviedo is the choice... not Naismith."

"Martinez claims to be an exponent of the beautiful game – but appears to see something in Naismith that merits his inclusion... I don't understand it.
As for the Osman thing... "

How would you like that humble pie served?

Ross Edwards
32 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:25:17
Well, I take everything I said back pre kick-off. I will duly eat humble pie, and I will invite Naismith, Osman and Martinez to throw humble pie in my face too.

Fantastic. We're on the March with Bobby's Army!

Who needs Fellaini and Moyes, we've got Barry and Bobby!

Mourinho's first PL defeat since September 2007.

Colin Wainwright
33 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:29:48
Havin' that! Fuckin' great stuff. TBH, when I seen Naismiths name on the teamsheet, I feared the worst, but delighted with that. Good lad.
Barry Rathbone
35 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:31:10
Ha! those of little faith.

Well in Bobby and the boys.

Eugene Kearney
36 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:29:32
Great win, but to quote three words from this report;

WHY SO LATE?!!

Ross Edwards
37 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:35:01
I must admit Barry, when I saw the team sheet, I was worried, but I've been proven wrong, and I will eat my humble pie right now.
Michael Kenrick
38 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:30:13
That was a tremendous result, exactly the kind of game where an equalizing goal was a bang-on certainty under the old way of doing things...

But not under Roberto! We were perhaps a little lucky not to pay for some horrible mistakes... but it's the result that really matters and I am so made up for Roberto Martinez.

It was somewhat ironic that the three supposed weak links — Osman Jelavic and Naismith — combined for what was actually a very well-constructed goal.

Just such a pity Ross Barkley couldn't dig one out, but at least he had me screaming encouragement — something I have not felt compelled to do for a very long time watching a previously turgid and uninspiring Everton.

Onwards and Upwards!!!

Andy Walker
39 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:31:53
That was a fantastic result well done lads!

We were lucky not to concede in the first half and the pass pass pass bollocks nearly cost us. Second we seemed to play on instinct and played much more like Everton of old, fast, passion, direct and effective. The long ball came back the passing around at the back disappeared, we had less possession than the opposition. The crowd to up and the result a win!

Was it the players playing on instinct in the heat of battle or was it a tactical decision to change the style of play by RM? Mmmmm

Andy Crooks
40 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:32:40
Naismith Man of the Match. A good response from a decent player who has come back from a serious injury. Some posters really don't know what they are talking about.

There's more to Roberto Martinez than I ever thought. Steel and style.

Drew Shortis
41 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:28:03
I love all the comments at the start of this thread slagging off Naismith. What he lacks in skill he makes up for in effort and determination. Useful man to have in the squad, but looks about as skillfull as Hibbert most of the time and should only play if we are short. Still, respect to him, he was in the right place at the right time to win the game for us.

Barry had an impressive debut, especially his block against Eto'o on 28 mins, without which it would almost certainly have been a Chelsea victory. I think he will boss the game against weaker opponents. McCarthy showed some good skill once he came on. Barkley was a real handful again. Jelavic did well for the goal but looked way out of his depth for most of the game and Mirallas looked twice the striker once he took over up front. Everyone else preformed well and gave 100% for the team., Very pleased with the commitment shown.

Its still early on in the season, but I think its safe to say those who expected the collapse Everton's defence under Martinez were misguided. The system needs a bit more time to really be natural to all of the team, but they are giving it a go. The spirit is clearly still there. I look forward to the next match with McCarthy, Pienaar and Lukaku taking over from Osman, Naismith and Jelavic. Another great day to be a Toffee!

Drew Shortis
42 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:42:18
Andy Walker 855
As Chelsea upped their game second half and piled on the pressure we had no choice but to play on instinct. There was little scope for passing across the back line with opposition attackers closing the ball down. Martinez's philosophy isn't all about keeping possession at the back, and when Barry and McCarthy are in the middle I expect to see us being much more positive with our passing. When faced with the quality of Chelsea we had little choice but to baton down the hatches and hang on. I'm sure Roberto would have been more than happy for us to dominate possession when 1-0 up and frustrate the opposition, but that was not an option in the second half, I guess Roberto has to adapt to us as much as we do to him!
Anto Byrne
43 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:37:29
Loved it and we are still unbeaten. Im sure Martinez shape the team and seems keen to give the kids a run. Coleman was excellent. Can't say I missed Fellaini at all.
Paul Ferry
44 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:51:18
Now that was 100 per cent impressive on so many levels:

(1) Barry: what an astute piece of business that was! MotM on his debut! So solid, so comfy on the ball, so measured, I think he gave the ball away once not long before injury time – class.

(2) Lukaku: we have him waiting in the wings.

(3) Mirallas up front: me and others have been shouting for this for a while now; hold-up play outstanding; the last half-hour was critical and Kev was as important as anyone – and what a shot that was – that dinky touch for the handball in added-on time! And what a sub by the way!

(4) Imperious Distin!

(5) Attacking at home when 1-0 down!

(6) Timely smart subs!

(7) Keeping someone up when we concede a corner!

(8) Ross Barkley: my-oh-my – the point, ex-gaffer, is to play him and let him do the talking on the pitch: hope you were watching with a little green envy coz you did not play well at all today.

(9) Pats on the back for two I often say I don't want to play: Ossie and Nais.
Credit where credit is due.

(10) 3 clean sheets on the run and who were they – the naysayers/teary Moyes lovers – who worried about defence under Bobby: guess what 1-0 up and we defended better and attacked better than said ex-gaffer would ever have done.

(11) Any fool who still clings to the doubting Bobby position well!!!!!!! Jeez didn't we all put our hands up in the air in despair when we saw the starting 11 but jeez it worked! How many of us have been saying Everton is not Wigan to those soothsayers ranting over and over again about relegated Wigan and that Bobby is now at a better place where his nous can thrive – I rest my case.

(12) Indulge me one more time: Barry – absolutely outstanding! Martinez – absolutely outstanding!

David Graves
45 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:46:47
Benefit of hindsight is easy but Simon Hughes - "relegation dogfight" ? Fool.
James Morgan
46 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:46:41
Great result! Hopefully this will spur us on now, especially with some faces to return. Barry was immense and Barkley showed his class and fearless nature. I love seeing him run at players like he's been doing it for years, he just needs to hone his final decision making.

It was good to see resolute defending under pressure, Wigan defending today was certainly not! I think generally Howard Webb had a good game, maybe should've red carded Luiz but overall I can't complain.

Onwards and upwards!

Ross Edwards
47 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:56:16
I also feel a bit of a fool David, but I usually do all the time on here.
David Graves
48 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:53:38
Sorry to misquote Simon. He actually said we are in for a relgation scrap.
Zia Mao Chong
49 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:46:04
I thought Naismith put in a fantastic shift today. Lost count of how many times he tracked back to help out the defence. Made a lot of good interceptions too. Stop slagging him!!!!
Jamie Yates
50 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:43:55
Not a bad performance that considering we're only four games into a new era. The visible differences in shape, rhythm, set pieces, etc. make for interesting viewing after so long playing the same old way win, lose or draw. Nice also to see us at least attempting to revert to something along the lines of the genuine (i.e. pre-Dogs of War) traditions of Everton Football Club in terms of passing the ball.

Otherwise it's really pleasing to see Martinez giving Barkley a proper chance - especially against that opposition - and not just immediately hauling him off for making mistakes in possession. Here's hoping this run in the side works wonders for the lad's confidence. On top of that McCarthy looked busy when he came on and even that carthorse Barry looked half decent - another left foot in the team will come in handy too.

Chuffed to bits with that.

Mike Green
51 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:54:51
Thought the back 4 and Barkley were great and what a debut from Gareth Barry.

Get a full first team clicking under our new man and we will tear some teams a new one - and do it playing the beautiful game. We rode our luck but completely threw title contenders off their stride, making them resort to dirty tactics.

Bob Martins Incredible Football Diamonds.

Awesome.

Paul Dark
52 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:58:06
Great result.

Barry was great!

Is Schillo injured?

Osman was an embarrassment, as ever, utter embarrassment.

David Graves
53 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:57:34
Ross you've said you'll eat humble pie. No more self flagellation required.
Ben Dyke
54 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:55:04
You couldn't really ask for more than that from Everton today. Dogged, passionate, great team ethic and flair as well. Let's hope that knocks any after effects from first 3 games out the system and its onwards and upwards!

And doesn't it just feel amazing when we beat one of the big fake teams! YESSSSS!

Paul Ferry
56 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:00:20
Oh meant to add: was that not a special Old Lady day — the atmosphere and the noise was just brill so a big thanks to all of you on here who were there!!!!!!!!
Darren Warkcup
57 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:01:43
Great performance a bit loose at the back early on but as soon as we scored a great all round team performance really dug in and earned a great win. Over the moon with it come on you blues.
Jamie Yates
58 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:01:04
This has more than likely already been covered in depth this season, but how refreshing is it to see someone left up front when we're defending corners?
David Graves
59 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:00:54
Paul, I disagree that Osman was an embarrassment. In the last 30 I thought he came into the game. Once McCarthy fits in, there maybe a role for Osman to come off the bench. I agree that Barry was top class though. What a pro.
Scott Robinson
60 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:59:21
What can we say? Unbeaten in 4 games, 3 clean sheets and a backs-to-the-wall performance against one of the best teams in the league. Perhaps the glass is half-full now, it seems, for all the RM doubters and pessimists?
Al Reddish
61 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:00:11
On that showing, it's upto players like Pienaar to up their game to get on the team sheet, just like Naismith has done.... for now.
Derek Knox
62 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:02:09
I must admit, it was a bit 'backs to the wall' in the second half, but feel this will be a huge boost for the side.

West Ham away next, and Lukaku eligible.

Is Lukaku cup-tied for Wednesday against Fulham?

Andy Walker
63 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:56:10
Drew, you are absolutely right: when faced with the quality of the opposition, we have to play like we did. We haven't the technical quality of players (enough of them that is) to take on a team like Chelsea at their own game when they are losing and decide to up their game. We react to them; that is, our players' instinct takes over and the players play to their strengths – not some artificial coached way of playing.

I just hope RM can see that this is how we need to play, we are so much more effective when we cut out the fancy crap at the back. Today was such obvious proof of this. The crowd thought so too, you could hear the boos in the first half when we refused to put a free kick into the box. Second half was a world away.

Jamie Yates
64 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:04:03
...and finally - THREE clean sheets on the spin in the league for Wigan Reserves?!!
Andy Peers
65 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:05:40
If Liverpool lose on Monday we will be the only unbeaten team in the league.

Barry was Man of the Match for me.
David Greenwood
66 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:04:42
Brilliant win, really pleased.

The team spirit looks fantastic, onwards and upwards we go.

All were good, Barry exceptional.

McCarthy will start before Ossie next week, Lukaku for Jela, making us even stronger.

Gary Reeves
67 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:02:43
Great stuff; the season starts here...

One concern though: Barkley, when he hasn't got the ball, is a million miles away from being a top player. His closing down, tackling (or even just making it awkward) was genuinely school playground standard. We can't afford to be giving him an out-and-out midfield berth at that rate... Dangerous WITH the ball — I'll give him that.
Peter Cummings
68 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:56:17
I stand corrected, chaps; a really great performance considering both our 'whipping boys' were included. Naismith had a stormer apart from the goal and Ossie was quietly efficient against the bully boys from the Bridge. Why two of theirs weren't sent off for 'professional' fouls was a mystery... but oh I forgot — they play for Chelsea and the 'Great One',

I've got to give credit to Webb on the day, though, he had a very good game for a change. I said a draw would have done us but, silly me, thought we'd lose... I just wish Ross Barkley would stop overdoing things; he needs to steady down and think a bit. Overall, a great day for Evertonians

Mark Taylor
69 Posted 14/09/2013 at 19:59:10
So since we've won, it's as good as any time to talk about the bad bits as well as the good bits. But let's do the latter first.

Biggest plus was Barry. Very classy, plenty enough to cover the obvious lack of pace. Also Barkley. Yes he gave the ball away a fair bit but if he is pushed up the pitch, that matters less and he has a special ability to make something happen. For that, I don't mind if what he tries sometimes doesn't come off, he can create something out of very little. Defence was reasonably solid, except for a bit of headless chickens in the last 10 minutes and Baines was better than recent efforts. Mirallas was also much improved and offered an interesting option as the head of the attack after Jela went off.

The less good, albeit not terrible. Credit to Naismith, he works his socks off but he is frankly lacking both pace and technique. There was a moment in the first half when Mirallas released him one on one. Someone like Delboy or Kev himself could have caused potential havoc but Nais just hasn't got that sort of cutting edge. Osman was much improved and offered some clever passing but again, he looks lightweight in a defensive role and looked shot in the last 20 mins. He should be a useful squad player, no more, and is probably most useful in the Barkley role, maybe as a replacement (let's not make the opposite mistake with Ross and burn him out)

Didn't see enough of McCarthy to say anything, still less of Delboy, though he still had time to set up a good chance for Osman. Jela, despite his hand in the goal, still looks well and truly out of sorts, but at least Lukaku can now come in.

I've no idea why Kone isn't fit still. What's wrong with him?

Colin Glassar
70 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:07:10
Doubters/haters etc... Don't like to say it but, .........I told you so!!! I did have our first 4 games down as draws with our first win coming against WHU but today's performance was just what the doctor ordered. We now kick on from here and come May I've no doubt we'll be right up there challenging for one of those CL places.
Mike Green
71 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:14:17
Derek #878 — I'm fairly certain he's free to play for us in all competitions.
Zaid Omar
72 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:03:15
Huge win, especially from a confidence perspective ... Martinez and Everton really needed that!! I thought Garth Barry was immense and he brought a lot of composure to our midfield.

As for Leon Osman, the less said the better... He was shocking.

Mark Taylor
73 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:16:06
Forgot to add, with a note of realism, on 8 out of 10 days, Chelsea's shot count would have given them at least a couple of goals and victory. On balance, they were the better side.

On the other hand, a few years ago, we never looked like we believed we could beat a top 4 side, no matter what happened. Now, we do.

Colin Glassar
74 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:19:47
Mark, remember the lads ( barry and mccarthy) have only been together since Thursday. Once they, and Lukaku, click we will have something special.
Barry Rathbone
75 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:05:13
Just good to have faith in the manager again we can all opine on players and tactics etc but Bobby is showing he is better than any of us armchair boys – just as it should be.

He gets Barry in from City, picks Naismith and Osman – three decisions I thought "Oh aye, this looks shite" and BANG! Jose and the billionaires get their pants pulled down.

Fantastic stuff – with his transfer dealings he's made a cracking start you know.

Don't expect this stuff all the time but deffo getting the faith back.

Chris Ashton
76 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:13:54
I only saw the last 30 minutes but my god we were fantastic. Defensively we were great. The passing in the middle when coming out of attack was great and the long ball to Mirallas immediately put Chelsea under pressure and drew fouls.

What I saw was a team that could potentially have a great season and with the right backing could really develop. Martinez got decisions spot on all over the park so, if he learns and grows like this, then he could back his potential.

Look at it this way: we beat Chelsea tonight. Next week we could have Koné, Pienaar, McCarthy, Lukaku, Gibson & Alcaraz all to come into the squad. All first-team players and all can do a job. The standard is set now — let's keep this going!

Mark Frere
77 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:18:47
Absolute fantastic result. This should really kick start our season. What a performance from Barry. I was very critical of the team selection before the game, and I still haven't changed my opinion about Naismith - he's fucking shite. Thanks for the goal and performance today though Mr Naismith.

I'm a little ashamed of myself for wishing injury on Naismith before the game, I guess my frustration got the better of me.

Joe McMahon
78 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:22:06
Barry was very, very good today... as was the team spirit. Osman just isn't the standard required anymore (was he ever?). It's incredible to think that's the fist match Barry's played all season. A very experienced good player like Gareth will be good for Barkley. Fingers crossed he stays fit, as we cannot keep waiting for Darren Gibson to be fit.

Roberto's now got his first win, and we have Lukaku to look forward to... le'ts enjoy the ride!

Trevor Lynes
79 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:12:44
Barry more than makes up for the absence of Gibson, and Naismith really surprised me with his display, it happened to be his 27th birthday too!

Both commentators had praise for Barry and ... Osman so obviously he does far better to the trained eye than you think.

Jelavic tried very hard and his excellent header set up the goal but he cannot play as a lone striker. He needs a partner – otherwise the ball comes straight back. Pienaar and Kone both had injuries to add to Gibson and the birdman.

I hope that Lukaku is tried in the next game as he has more physical presence and may well prove to be an excellent partner for either Kone or Jelavic in home matches. Barry has played himself into being an automatic choice next week and the defence picks itself.

I'm still concerned that Chelsea created so many chances (all missed) but we will not come across a better side this season. At least our bench looks a lot stronger; once all the squad are available, I look forward to a successful season.

Daniel A Johnson
80 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:32:36
No goals conceded in 270 mins of footie, so much for Martinez knackering our defence.
Chris Leyland
81 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:25:49
I thought Osman was okay today. He gave the ball away a few times but then so did Barkley on occasion too. And I seem to recall Osman had something to do with the goal too with his cross. Still, the 'experts' on here who tell us that Osman and Naismith aren't Premier League-standard footballers obviously know more than the two Premier League managers who have picked them to play at this level. It is strange that with only 9 Premier League standard players we managed to beat one of the favourites to win the league.
Roman Sidey
82 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:16:03
Between Barry, Naismith and Howard for best-on-ground, however, the HB (Hindsight Brigade) are laying it on a bit heavy. Hands up everyone who was confident Naismith could do the job he did today?

His goal aside, and I'm going to slap my own wrists for sounding like Moyes here, his defending was great. Dispossessed Chelsea at least a dozen times down back. Well done, now keep doing it.

Barry was just superb, and as has been said, looked like he has been playing for us forever. To me, though, he looked like he was playing for his career, and, if he truly is being paid 100k+ per week, he is trying to give the club and fans the best value for money.

Funny thing, we had two Rangers supporters sitting behind us in the pub, and when Naismith scored, they wouldn't shut up about how fantastic he is and how they gave him to us. We turned around and asked them if he took a year to play well for them too.

Phil Rodgers
83 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:43:49
Get off Osman's back. He was excellent.
Paul Smith
84 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:39:32
Good stuff, well done boys.

Only gripe: maybe McCarthy could have started instead of Ossie. But, admittedly I was one of the doomsayers when I saw the team sheet, so wtf do I know.

Happy tonight.

Robert Workman
85 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:22:03
Barry MotM without question. A City fan was moaning on BBC Sport that they could have done with him today.

Well I reckon Chelski could have done with Lukaku (Eto'o and Torres were useless - were was Ba?). It felt like, although we couldn't play him, by just having Lukaku here we prevented Chelski from playing him.

Loved to see Mirallas up front - what a transformation! Also loved the last minute substitution, bringing on Deulofeu – it would have been so easy to bring on Heitinga. Different manager – different strokes from different folks!

Robbie Muldoon
86 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:46:36
NOW WILL YOU ALL BELIEVE! ROBERTO KNOWS HIS SHIT!
Col Noon
87 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:45:24
What a win and performance that was. The team as a whole were brilliant and deserved the win for the way we stuck at it and worked for the entire 90 minutes. We are looking a lot less likely to conceded now because we are more careful with the ball. Defending "properly" isn't Always kicking the ball as far away from our goal as possible and last ditch tackles. We will become a far better team as a unit under Martinez and we will use the ball better in tight games. Gareth Barry superb. Well done blues.
Mike McQuaid
88 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:35:49
Had to make do with Talksport. Commentary was OK, but at half-time all we got was Adrian Durham, who never has a good word to say about us, discussing with a bookmaker the odds on Chelsea winning 2-1! Shoddy stuff and blatant advertising. I would much rather have listened to Collymore's analysis. Or even Alan Green!
Geoff Edwards
89 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:52:32
Good result. Re the hoofing, I am no Michael Cox, but it did seem that Chelsea's forwards (i.e. their front 4) was instructed to press our defenders as soon as they got the ball, which led to them having far less time on the ball and therefore being forced to hoof. I don't think it was a strategic thing on our part.
Faisal Qureshi
90 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:24:45
With players, it is all about how you are managed. I think Martinez knows how to get the best out of his players and the results will be surprising.

Let's hope that we get a passing game and some beautiful football that some if us saw in the eighties!
Tony Draper
91 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:48:06
That was fuckin' great !
David Hallwood
92 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:51:18
It isn't a TW thread unless abuse is thrown at Ossie. He was playing to orders protecting the back four, a role that he isn't comfortable with as he's a attacking mid, but he played really well and Chelsea's much vaunted and expensive) midfield was nullified with very little going through the middle.

Obviously he won't be playing there when Gibson's fit and McCarthy's up to speed but credit where credit's due boys & girls. Sometimes football's about hod carrying – unglamorous, not easy on the eye, but playing a top team like Chelsea essential.

Sam Hoare
94 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:50:24
Delighted for RM and the boys and in particular Naismith. I'm not sure he will be a starter once everyone is fit but he's much better than the pastings he has been given on here and his work rate and defensive work deserve some credit.

A huge 3 points that turn a very mediocre start to the season into a much more positive one.

With lukaku to hopefully add potency up front and the likes of McCarthy and Deulofeu chomping at the bit there is much cause for optimism. Still early days though.

Mike Corcoran
95 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:51:56
Garry Barry oh oh Garry Barry (to Louie Louie )


I now curl up into a ball to minimise the pain of the blows

Patrick Murphy
96 Posted 14/09/2013 at 20:48:13
As some other posters have mentioned I was very concerned when I saw the teamsheet at the start of the match, I couldn't see how we could get 3 points from this game with that starting line-up.

But Everton being Everton that is exactly what they deserved. We may have ridden our luck on more than a couple of occasions but to be fair to the team there hadn't been much luck in evidence so far this season, so a bit of payback for the hard-working Blues.

The first half was more akin to a European Tie than a Premier League fixture which in some ways is both a compliment and a chastisement to our current crop of players.

Second half was more akin to what we have become used to in the last few seasons at Goodison with a backs to the wall, they shall not pass mentality. It's good to see we haven't lost that oft heralded team spirit, but there was also a hint of the intelligent play which we hopefully will see more of in the coming months. I'm pleased that RM was given a role on his own up front, because that is a position in which he can do real damage, especially in comparison to Jelavic, who works hard but really doesn't seem to have the necessary ability to play in the PL.

I think the best thing about today was the composure we showed in defensive situations, there weren't that many occasions when we panicked and that has to be a good thing for the long-term. Getting that first win of the season is very important and let's hope it is the first of many in the upcoming months.

When is the last time Everton had 5 full England Internationals on the pitch prior to today? Baines, Osman, Barry, Barkley, Jagielka

,

Denis Richardson
97 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:12:42
Awsome win, and a clean sheet! Thats 3 clean sheets in a row and one of only 2 undefeated teams in the league so far.

Significant boost in fire power to come in as well in Lukaku - season is well and truly off the blocks. Fantfookingtastic.

Although he had a hand in the goal, think McCarthy will be able to take the place of Osman sooner rather than later in the starting XI.

Get in!

Andy Walker
98 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:08:33
As I said a fantastic result but please let's not forget what happened up to 44min. We were crap and lucky to be 0-0, we were only not loosing because Chelsea players couldn't finish off all their chances.

So why were we so crap in the first half? Because we were playing the tippy-tippy shit RM is obsessed with. It changed in the second half because we played in a different style, an Everton style, I think the players stopped over-thinking every pass and played on instinct and it worked, it got the crowd up and we slugged it out, our direct style v Chelsea's passing. And that's what we're good at, Roberto.

This is what was posted just on the live forum, unedited, just before we scored, none of which were my posts, lest we forget;

18:15:48 Can't help but think that we're fanny'ing around for the sake if it and missing genuine chances to get the ball in the box.
18:15:43 It's not all down to Osman, but we can't carry him in centre midfield any longer. I would rather have Oviedo running around causing trouble right now, doing all the grunt work and allowing Barkley and Barry more time for craft.
18:15:37 To be fair a Chelsea goal has been coming. We are too open at the back and non-existant in attack. We wont score playing like this.
18:15:29 No, stop Dick. Positivity.
18:15:20 FFS we really need to change this
18:15:13 Need to get in H/T and sort this out RM
18:15:10 Jelavic couldnt score he if walked into a Thai whorehouse with a thousand dollar bill stuck to his forehead-get shut.
18:15:02 It's only a matter of time I feel.
18:14:58 Howard Webb arselicking Chelsea again
18:14:56 Dick Moyes is a total tosser; stop slagging off Martinez. Today Moyes had to depend on a poor refereeing decision and having a one man advantage to beat Crystal Palace FFS. His sides used to be better than our current one my arse
18:14:38 You said it, Tony Steele. This is an identity-less EFC at the moment.
18:14:35 Distin solid, Jags gone missing a few times !
18:14:33 Don't fret Rahman, he misses you too.
18:14:33 Well if Sky say so....must be....
18:14:23 Mata square head
18:14:21 You're right Dick. Ossie has been more involved than Barkley. That isn't a good thing though.
18:14:21 for a team who should be playing possession football we're giving the ball away a lot
18:14:18 I think Everton's problem's run deeper then substituting Leon Osman. Why can't we fucking score a goal????
18:14:11 bring on the strikers in the second half! Oh hang on....
18:14:10 dull game
18:14:01 Harsh John G and completely justified !
18:13:51 I really miss felanni
18:13:40 Really hope we don't concede as we certainly don't look like scoring.
18:13:40 Just want to get to half time and get someone on for Osman.
18:13:40 I certainly agree I'd like to see the other new boy second half Jimmy
18:13:39 Chelsea haven't been this comfortable at Goodison for years.

Derek Knox
99 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:10:12
Some very good and valid points there Patrick (912) like you say we did have a tad of luck, but we have had none so far. The big plus that will, hopefully, stem from today, is the effect, the result, will not only have on us, but the other teams in the Prem.

Also, that we have achieved this without our strongest combination. I wouldn't mind betting that Lukaku, felt somewhat chuffed, as he did tip us to beat Chelsea.

I just hope, come the end of the season, he says he wants to stay with us. ( A lot of hope, I know, but could it be Champions League?)

Ian Butchard
100 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:19:03
Great result and great debut from Barry.
Mark Taylor
101 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:04:38
A word on the Osman conundrum- is he good or is he shit?

First off, at least one can consider the possibility of him being good; there is some proper talent there in a way that I don't think applies to, for example, Naismith, who doesn't usually get into the worst Scottish side in living memory.

I am- or have been- an Ossie fan. He offers subtlety and penetration and probably has the best vision of any of our recent midfielders, which goes some way in compensating from the obvious lack of any pace. He was fantastic for us for most of last season, but trailed off towards the very end. He won a justly deserved cap and did not look at all out of place- in fact had he held his domestic form, I though he did enough to stay in the squad. He's an excellent link player.

But it did trail off last season and this season has been poor. I agree with another poster that his current role does not play to his strengths. He just isn't made for a defensive midfielder role, he lack the necessary dynamism.

As I said earlier, he was better today and made several telling contributions but I think his legs are starting to go and he looks very laboured towards the end of the game. I don't think we can afford two like that in central midfield- Barry is neither pacy nor dynamic- and on the evidence of today, Ossie is not as effective as his counterpart (who I though was superb today, the glue that bound us).

I think he's good- but not that good and not good enough now the engine is failing. I think we'd be better looking for 30 minute cameos, or to give Ross an occasional rest.

Andy Crooks
102 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:10:18
Mark Frere, Naismith had a fine game against the best side in the premier league. To describe him as shite makes you look foolish and narrow minded. Roman, it's not hindsight, I've always thought the criticism that Naismith receives is unfair.Both Moyes and Martinez seem to rate him; he's no world beater but his very best is pretty good. His contribution depends on work rate and is unsustainable every week so, no doubt Roberto will drop him when necessary.

Our future, in my view, depends on Martinez getting the very best from every player The performance of Naismith suggests that he will do this.

Colin Grierson
103 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:18:54
Great result!

Mirallas was poor first half. Jelavic was poor too. Barkley gave the ball away loads and his decision making was late. However, I'm not moaning — my aim is to point out that there are always players who have negative aspects to their game. I watched the game with a view to see the positive touches that Osman made just to make sense of the abuse he receives on TW. Both Mirallas and Barkley lost possession more than he did and he made more interceptions than both of them as well.

It's easy to see his weak points and to lambast him. Give him a break; he's been and is still a great asset to our club. When Roberto decides he no longer has a place in the side, then I for one would shake his hand for the effort and skill he has brought to the shirt. There's been plenty you couldn't say that about! Have some respect.

Mike Manchester
104 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:05:16
Just want to say I had faith in Steven Naismith, in my eyes he has done well when hes played, not the most talented but he puts in 100% every time, he's reasonably strong and has the knack of being in the right place at the right time as he proved again today. But then I also rate Ossie so maybe I'm wrong.

(Jelavic is still embarrassing.)

Dave Rinehart
106 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:29:10
Great result and very pleased with how we pressed the entire game. Barry was great. I have to say that while Naismith's goal was a pleasant surprise, his passing was terrible. I lost track of how many times he turned the ball over on poor passing, I don't see him fitting in to RM's style of play.
Mike Green
107 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:30:42
Andy #918 - I hate to say it but Mark Frere IMO is right, Naismith was woeful for large parts of the game, so bad in fact that I thought 'he'll go and score after what I've been calling him for the last 20 mins....'

I cannot knock his work rate and commitment, it was fantastic, but the quality just isn't there.

He did, essentially, win the game for us though – and for that he most definitely has the last laugh.

Mike Green
108 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:30:42
Andy #918 - I hate to say it but Mark Frere IMO is right, Naismith was woeful for large parts of the game, so bad in fact that I thought 'he'll go and score after what I've been calling him for the last 20 mins....'

I cannot knock his work rate and commitment, it was fantastic, but the quality just isn't there.


He did, essentially, win the game for us though - and for that he most definitely has the last laugh.

Mark Frere
109 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:28:28
Andy Crooks

I think you're the one who is being narrow minded. We should always look at a player's contribution over a number of games. Naismith's performance today was the exception not the rule, the jury is still out for Nais as far as I'm concerned.

Danny James
110 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:04:28
Barry is the perfect guy to have around young midfielders like Ross and McCarthy. He was excellent. Add Lukaku in the mix and we will look impressive.

I hope we get Barkley signed on a long-term contract before the hype takes over him. We don't want to go into next season with him just having 2 years left.

James Martin
111 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:15:57
Incredible how Osman Naismith and Jelavic are apparently all sub standard yet we still managed to win with 8 men against one of the best sides in the league. Osman got through loads of work today from a defensive point of view. If he was as bad as people are making out then we wouldn't have won. The tactical discipline of him Barry and McCarthy when Chelsea were attacking in the second half was excellent. Some people will never be happy with him because they're always looking for something to moan about.

Fantastic perfromance from ALL of the lads and a great tactical match from Martinez. The players showed their flexibility in the second half to adapt to Chelseas substitutions and limited them to very few chances. Great to watch us showing so much composure.

Derek Knox
112 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:32:48
Colin (919 & 921)

You had me scratching my head at one point there mate, the only thing that was going through my thoughts- wtf has (Star) Anise (cooking spice) got to do with Ossie?

After all, we have just got rid of 'Ginger'!

Kevin Rowlands
113 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:43:54
Good performance against a team that will probably win trophies. Whatever you think about Naismith (I'm not his biggest fan), he is excellent in the air for a small fella,

I watched the Man Utd game this morning and Fellaini's debut, he was okay but apart from his aerial presence, I honestly think we've strengthened by replacing him with Barry/McCarthy. I've got a feeling we're going to give someone a real pasting soon.

Raymond Fox
114 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:47:30
Where's my mate Phil!
Gary Reeves
115 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:48:43
Mark Taylor#917

Osman offering us penetration? ... Can't really add to that.

Phil Sammon
116 Posted 14/09/2013 at 21:47:23
Just got home from the game...and WHAT a game. That was a cracker.

Barry and Naismith were unbelievable. Mirallas dug in too and put in the sort of performance we know he can. Barkley again was very good. His positivity in central midfield is so refreshing. When was the last time we had a centre mid who can carry the ball and take players on?

I think was the first game I've ever seen where Osman got better as the game went on. First half he was worse than awful. Dwelling on the ball and countless misplaced passes. Second half he was better and actually looked like he belonged on the pitch.

Naismith has a better spring than Tim Cahill. He just does not lose a header. Cole, Luiz, Terry, he won aerial battles consistently against the lot.

McCarthy is quick isn't he?! The boy gets around the pitch like Ramires. Promising.

Last word reserved for Barry. Class, just class.

Drew O'Neall
117 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:03:23
4 posts at the beginning of this thread from Ciaran McGlone decrying the selection of Leon Osman and Steven Naismith.. Let's hear you ponder something positive rather than bashing away at your old hobby horses time and again. Both were superb today.
Phil Sammon
118 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:19:53
Drew

Very easy with hindsight mate. Neither deserved to start today on previous showings.

Callum McNab
119 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:13:13
It was wonderful to see the ball going from box to box on the deck again. Credit were credit was due,I thought Naismith was fantastic today,but Barry was something else. It will only benefit Barkley playing along side Barry each week.

Coleman has made the right back position his own. I don't think I've seen a player mature so much as seumus in just over a season. Distin still looks uncomfortable on the ball,but the defence is starting to work well together.

Sadly ossie's days our coming to an end,he cannot play more than one half effectively . But it was a great game,and a fantastic win COYB.

Daniel Lawrence
120 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:32:36
Barry and Lukaku, (hopefully) are what we've been looking for for over five years. It's taken Martinez a couple of months to realise what Moyes never did.
Andrew Cutler
121 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:43:42
I am imagining Phil Walling will not be too happy.
Eddie Tully
122 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:42:56
There were quite a few people slating Roberto before kick off, but I have to say these particular pearls of wisdom really do take the biscuit!.

Moyes used to take loads of stick for picking players like Naismith, Neville and Osman over the youngsters but Naismith and Osman playing today in front of McCarthy and Deulofeu says all you need to know about Martinez.

Dick Brady - 17:10:55

Gavin Ramejkis
123 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:41:16
A great game of football to watch today from a spectator's perspective, gone was the tiresome score and park the bus and keep on playing, a solid team performance from possibly the best footballing side in the league at present.

I'll hold up my hand and say just as I was wrong on Gibson before him, Barry really impressed today with his contribution, more so because he hasn't played a game up to today. Even Naismith put in a decent shift. The old lady was rocking with that game, long live football the way it should be played and not the shithouse dross we were spoon fed for years as the only way possible.

Looking forward to seeing our other new boys coming on soon, onwards and upwards. It's like a huge weight has been lifted off the club.

Nick Armitage
124 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:44:41
Barry was the midfielder that we have been lacking for 10 years. It was a Bracewell like performance, box to box, great passing and always in the right place.

As for Osman, whoever is slagging him off has not played the game. He was always looking for space, always able to receive a ball and yes, he did give the ball away a few times, but so did a players out there earning £5M a year. That game was played at a right frenetic pace and mistakes were inevitable.

However Naismith was poor, his passing is as bad a Phil Neville's even when he has time and space. We have far better on the bench than him.

Phil Sammon
125 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:50:50
Absolute crap that last point, Nick. He was outstanding today and did enough to shut his critics (me) up for at least 24 hours.
Mark Griffiths
126 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:38:56
Great result today and eat humble pie as I thought we would be well beaten. Never noticed this before but does anyone else think Barry looks identical to (Jack Sheppard from lost)?
Kevin Jones
127 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:43:44
Well, what game that was. May I take this opportunity to unreservedly apologise to Gareth Barry, for the negative remarks about him l put on ToffeeWeb the day he signed. How cool was he, it looked like he'd been wearing the Everton shirt for 20 years.

Just also like to say well done to both teams and the ref today. Great game played with a lot of passion and drive from both teams and officiated in a cool calm collected way by Howard Webb.

My voice is still hoarse from the singing at the end, nothing a few Southern Comforts won't cure.

Once again, great game and well done to all involved.

Barry Rathbone
128 Posted 14/09/2013 at 22:58:10
Just laughing at Jose on MotD saying our goal was their mistake..... absolutely sliced and diced them with clever incisive stuff and umpteen people in the box.

Might book him for the kid's birthday party.

Phil Sammon
129 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:05:36
Me too Barry.

I can't believe they didn't show David Luiz's stone-wall sending off in the match highlights.

Gary Reeves
130 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:05:59
Nick #940.

Well, I've played a bit of footy in my day, Nick, and that's EXACTLY WHY I don't rate Osman.
Kevin Freaney
131 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:22:57
Barry was spot on today. If he continues like that he'll be a great transfer move. I had my doubts before the move but he looked class. Barkley can be frustrating, he needs to be more aware of whats around him, but he looked good today although I thought he looked tired towards the end and should have come off. Mirallis was top class up front. He ran that Chelsea defence ragged when we needed it most in the last 20 minutes, keeping some pressure of us.

Now the negatives. How the hell is Osman still getting a game? For a midfielder who can't pass he plays way too much. It's so frustrating to see us break and then Osman plays it straight to an opposition player. He should be benched. And I'll never be 100% comfortable with Howard in goal. He makes some very stupid mistakes and they cost us last season. Today he basically passed to a Chelsea player in his own box. Thank God for Barry. He needs to be replaced if we want to move on as a team.

And a surprising positive. Naismith. Despite his inability to pass he got in some great positions and helped the defence out immensely in the 2nd half. He looked like the player he was in Hibberts testimonial. Which doesn't bode well for me as I have a £10 bet with the girlfriend that he won't hit 10 goals this season!

John Ford
132 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:19:44
We played with heart and some quality today. Looked at objectively we were second best overall, but how many times in the last few seasons have we been the better team and failed to win, Cardiff is the most recent example.

Confidence is priceless.

Christopher Kelly
133 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:21:36
EXCELLENT WIN!!

For those Moyes apologists, we've been saying for 6 years that we needed a change. What a breath of fresh air. My lord look at the YOUNG TALENT we all of a sudden have. INCREDIBLE. Stones coming on, McCarthy and Del boy! too excited for words.

Couple of thoughts:

Gareth Barry was MotM no questions asked. Smart on the ball, brilliant positioning and I bet a huge locker room presence. Gibbo who??

Naismith, great goal but again he and Osman and now Jela just have to hit the bench.

Naismith can come on as an impact, dogs of war type extra layer of defense in the 75th minute. Huge goal but many missed connections costing us at least 5 chances.

Osman now has to be behind McCarthy, Barry and Gibbo when fit. Abysmal defending and should know better than to be so slow with his link up play.
Jela – God bless him but never again. He tried so hard today (knowing Lukaku is breathing down his neck) but alas, he's just NOT GOOD ENOUGH for our team anymore. Cash out for £5m and thank you! With the strikers we have, we need a 5'-10" quick, athletic guy who can head and make quick, darting runs.

David Graves
134 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:20:27
Nick @ 940; Osman was great, Naismith was poor and Barry is "box to box"? If I disagree with these 3 points does that mean I've never played?
James Martin
135 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:29:53
Ridiculous MOTD coverage, Hansen practically had to choke out that we played well then they just indulged Jose's bitter sour grapes whilst making out that we had one chance in the whole game.

What word did Martinez use to describe the Osman-Barry combination? 'Outstanding' - obviously none of it is down to Osman of course, same way none of the good play last year was down to him. He was up against some of the league's best players in that midfield and he played fine but for some on here he has to be at his best every single week otherwise he gets a load of abuse - ridiculous.

Brent Stephens
138 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:40:17
Barry immense. Nais surprised us. Ossie surprised us. Good looking defence. Mirallas back to form. Jelli is broken.
Christopher Kelly
142 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:47:24
Maybe Osman and Nais and Jela are NOT bad players. maybe they're good players even. The problem is they are not good enough for us anymore
Brent Stephens
144 Posted 14/09/2013 at 23:49:29
Prediction - Ossie will start in the next game.
Nick Armitage
151 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:10:05
I didn't say Osman was great, he certainly wasn't... but he was nowhere near as bad as you lot are making out. It was Osman who picked the space and crossed for the goal. Yes, he is slow and weak but I would have him in the team any day over Phil Neville.

As for Naismith, he is not good enough for a club at the business end of the Premier League. Same applies to Jelavic.

Ernie Baywood
152 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:36:00
Issue was awful first half. Caught in possession far too often.

Pleased for Naismith. Nice to see a guy who works as hard as he does get some reward. The sort of guy you need in the squad, just not as a regular. His weaknesses are fairly evident.

Not sure if its been mentioned yet but I thought Mirrallas looked really dangerous when he went up front. You don't need to be physically huge to play as the 1 in a 4-5-1. He gave Chelsea's CBs a rough time and his hold up play was excellent considering how isolated he was. Lukaku means we probably won't see that again but it's still worth keeping in mind.

Ernie Baywood
153 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:41:36
Issue = Osman!
Christopher Kelly
154 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:36:14
Phil Neville shouldn't have been anywhere near the first team the past 2 seasons. Comparing Osman with a cart horse will not make him look a thoroughbred..

We've def suffered from nepotism issues the past years I must say.

Definitely some nice plays from the little guy. Barry replaces the composure and experience in the middle tho and McCarthy replaces the simple yet smart "sprayed" passes. Hopefully some neat through balls to Barkley mixed in as well.

Brian Hennessy
155 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:33:42
Thrilled with the win today. As an Irishman have no problem at all saying that England's Barry and Barkley were the two best players on the pitch for either side.

I have thought for a long while that Mirallas would make a super striker and he looked excellent up there today.

While I always knew that McCarthy has a decent creative side to his game, I have to say having looked very closely at him in this weeks two Ireland games and his time on the pitch today, I think I under - estimated the defensive side of his game. His positioning sense and tackling meant Chelsea never looked like getting at us through the middle and they eventually resorted to trying to go wide.

All round a positive day and with the options on the bench and Gibson on the mend all looks bright......

Paul David
156 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:46:58
Osman was poor in the first 20 mins then average for the rest of the match.

Naismith might have scored but that doesn't alter his over all performance, he is shite.

Kevin Rowlands
158 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:02:06
Osman had me screaming at the TV in the first half but give him credit he was a lot better 2nd half, Barry outstanding, Naismith is a good squad player plus he's Cahill'esq in the air for a short player, I'm deffo in the glass half full crowd with this team and squad, haven't been this excited about an Everton side since the mid 80's, yes I'm an old twat!
Nick Entwistle
159 Posted 15/09/2013 at 00:56:48
That the side were able to play to a tempo and put in some fight in the second half was great to see - which had been sorely missing in all games until now.

On the negative, my view is that be it Chelsea or Stevenage, the games will pan out the same. Was before the match still is. We'll play predictable stuff, stay solid but allow the opposition to play well. Games will always be tight and approaching tedious.

Still, one point from top 4!

Viv Sharma
160 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:09:29
Now THATS how you should celebrate a good win. Hats off to you Mr Tully! Another Scotch for that man
Phil Sammon
161 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:17:13
Paul David

Just the sort of narrow minded shite you see all too often on these pages. Naismith has been utter garbage this season and didn't deserve to start today. However, having been given the opportunity he grabbed it with both hands and was pipped to MOTM only by an excellent performance from Gareth Barry.

The guy lacks quality at times - but credit where credit is due. Guts and determination won the game today and Naismith has that in abundance.

Paul David
162 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:25:31
Phil

Is it the just the goal that turns his performance into a good one or do you think he played well even if he hadn't scored?

I seen no difference in Naismith today than in any other game he's played. He was terrible with the ball today.

Christopher Kelly
163 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:27:26
A broken clock is right 2x a day. Naismith is an ok player who had a great couple of moments. End of.

An honest player and nice lad. However, we need to be moving away from players like these and for once in a very long while, I Think we are! Have another drink boys and enjoy this win.

Ernie Baywood
164 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:38:59
Paul 988, no it wasn't just the goal. He ran his socks off and in the second half won the ball time and time again tracking back. He also used the ball pretty well when we were pegged back. Didn't just blaze away - tried to get us on the move.

He had a couple of sloppy moments in the first half, but overall I thought he was excellent.

Phil Sammon
165 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:40:05
Paul

His goal has little to do with my appraisal. I know what you are getting at, Paul, I am not saying he is a top player. In fact I turned around and told a complete stranger to 'fuck off' after he told me Naisy was starting today. He misplaced a few passes, fair enough. But he battled like a lion today, won literally millions of headers and bagged the winner.

I just don't know how you can slate the guy on today's showing.

Paul David
166 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:43:33
Well we'll see what people make of his performance next week when chances are he won't score and he gets slated. He will help out the defence, win more headers than he should do but offer next to nothing as an attacking threat and he is suppose to be an attacking player.
Phil Sammon
167 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:58:39
Paul

Are you reading my posts or just making up what you think I might say?

This isn't about next week, this isn't about two weeks ago, its about today and how he played. He's been below Everton standards in the past, he probably will be in the future...but today he played well and doesn't deserve the shit you're throwing at him!

'offer next to nothing as an attacking threat and he is suppose to be an attacking player'

......errrr, he fucking scored and won us the game.

Derek Knox
168 Posted 15/09/2013 at 02:08:28
Phil (994)

As an 'adopted' scouser I have supported Everton for near 50 years now, hailing from Scotland originally, I obviously keep close tabs on my National side. I can only concur with what you say about Nais, he will always work like a Trojan for the side. I like the lad, and although admittedly, he has had some below par performances, in the past, this is mostly attributable to him being played out of his natural position.

The ' Ginger ' being one of the worst for starting it off ( gollum faced prick) I know he was intrinsically out of position today, and had injuries, not dictated otherwise, he may not have played.Fair play he did his best, in a blue shirt, and turned out to be the 'matchwinner'

Couldn't really fault any of the lads today, against the favourites to be Prem. Winner!

Rob Smith
169 Posted 15/09/2013 at 02:05:19
Geez ...We beat Chelsea, 1st win for season, 3 points, move upwards on ladder but the haters still hate. I'm not Naismith fan nor Osman for that matter but credit where due. He set a goal up on a platter for Jelli in the first 10 mins, scores the winner, played well, he stood up. Osman on the Other hand was Osman. We should be smiling at how easily Barry slipped into our team and controlled our midfield, saved a goal...to old...to slow..?

Sooner or later you haters will have to smile.

Paul David
170 Posted 15/09/2013 at 02:10:08
Phil

If you look at the time of that post it was written at the same time as yours so it was in response to Ernie not you. It does matter how he plays next week cos he puts the same type of performance in every time he plays but I bet no one will be praising him next week if he doesn't score. If you only want to talk about how he was today then I seen a honest player try his best, help out when we were under pressure, win a lot of flick on's but failed to create chances for others, in fact was to blame for a few good moves breaking down with his poor passing.

It does sound stupid saying a player offers nothing in attack after he's scored the winner but the law of averages says he will score from time to time, he might offer more if he was played in his proper position but his touch and especially his passing would be terrible.

Roman Sidey
171 Posted 15/09/2013 at 01:20:19
Andy Crooks, I still think the criticism is fairly valid, although it seems that Naismith has a knack of popping up in the big games. For a player like him to have two goals against Chelsea and a derby goal is, in itself, quite a thing.

Also, Phil Sammon touched on it, but with Luiz' yellow card, can someone tell me if it is a written law or just a general common understanding that if the last man in defense for the 'keeper fouls an attacker it is a straight red? I always thought it was up to the ref's discretion, but a mate with far more football experience told me it is stone wall red.

Phil Sammon
172 Posted 15/09/2013 at 02:42:08
Roman

I believe the wording is that it's a red if you 'deny a clear goalscoring opportunity.'

Ok, Mirallas was 50 yards from goal, but Luiz was the last man. It was certainly a clear goalscoring opportunity.

Paul

Your comment in #975 - 'Naismith might have scored but that doesn't alter his over all performance, he is shite.'

There's no way of dressing it up. You were talking about him being shit today, which he was not.

Your claim that his goal is simply relative to the law of averages is both ridiculous and irrelevant. We are talking about an isolated game here. If he'd have bagged 8 goals today would you still say he played shit this week because he played poorly last week?

Stephen Scofield
173 Posted 15/09/2013 at 02:41:42
I for one said that Barry was an excellent addition and I was not disappointed; he looked like he had played for Everton for years. His interception to stop the goal was magnificent and definitely showed he has pace when needed.

Mirallas was immense too. His wok rate above reproach, his skill, elegant.

Osman, someone I thought was best a bencher, played well; I'm sure someone else could have done better but was happy with his shift.

Naismith. I sent think I've seen him play from the start before, but I was very impressed. He deserves another start after that excellent display. I think he has been unlucky only coming on as a sub mostly and not having the time to produce such a display.

Jelavic looks unfit, but that head back was beautiful. I hope he gets more first team football. He may not score but he does well with the assists.

Jagielca was faultless and am so glad none of the big four have been after him, best centre clack in the league.

Distin. A genius in defence and he tackled excellently for the Oscar claim force penalty.

Howard, shocking. But that was alone off back performance I think we can all get over. Do with mucha was still here, he played well last season.

Berkeley. He was excellent. But did run too much with it. He needs to learn to not be as shellfish.

Stephen Scofield
174 Posted 15/09/2013 at 03:07:27
God damn my phone butchered that response!
Drew Shortis
175 Posted 15/09/2013 at 02:55:52
I really like Naismith for his attitude and wholehearted commitment. Today showed that these attributes can pay off. However he has very little technique, passing ability or composure. To be fair he has been played out of position throughout his entire time at Everton and I admire the way he comes out and gibes it his all when you see so many other players sulking.If he got a run up front we may see more of what he is capable of, but this is unlikely to happen with three out and out strikers ahead of him.

In hindsight I would have preferred Naismith as the lone striker in place of Jelavic and Deulofeu on the right, Without his first touch finishes Jelavic offers very little to the team. At least Naismith would run his heart out and perhaps that effort would result in a few more goals like the one today. I was puzzled why Jelavic was starting ahead of Kone until I saw the news about the injury. Thankfully Lukaku will be available next time out, but if we are without him I think Mirallas should be given a go up front. He has pace, dribbles well and can shoot. When he went up front today his positional sense was evident.

Ernie Baywood
176 Posted 15/09/2013 at 06:00:42
Phil, ref's apparently follow the 4Ds to asses whether an obvious goalscoring opportunity was denied.

Distance from the ball (or likelihood of the attacker getting to the ball)
Direction of play (ie you must be running at goal)
Defenders between offence and keeper/goal (must be none)
Distance between the offence and the goal

Obviously this foul was about as far away as you can get from the goal which is what saved Ivanovich.

Doesn't stop it being a bullshit decision generated by a need for referees to be consistent, rather than delivering common sense but subjective decisions. Mirrallas was away, it was deliberate, Ivanovich knew exactly why he did it. If you let the ref use sense he sends him off. For me, it's far worse than the accidental ones by the last man such as Digkachoi (spelling will be wrong) on Young at lunchtime.

Jim Lloyd
177 Posted 15/09/2013 at 07:15:51
Just read some early posts on here. I have to say, that Mark Frere; You would like to see an Everton player badly injured??? That is a fucking awful thing to say.

As it is Naismith played a good game, he won most headers against there defenders, put them under pressure byu his challenges and generally speaking put a good shift in. Fer fucks sake don't ever be wishing an injury on an EVERTON player.

Darren Hind
178 Posted 15/09/2013 at 06:52:26
He He Ciaran

I was nodding in agreement at your first post as I left for the game - Great to be wrong isn't it.

I don't get the people claiming we are playing with more style this season. I suspect they are desperate to be proved right and believe if they keep saying it, people will believe them. This time last year our football was light years ahead of the stuff we are seeing now and anyone who watches Everton regularly and judges fairly knows it.

Some big positives though, this was a good Chelsea and it's reassuring to know a Martinez team can be so disciplined (not as some believe, a crime) Barry was immense and we still have better players to come in.

I feared Robbie may send his boys out on suicidal cavalry attacks, but if anything he has gone the other way. He's close to finding the right balance and if he can somehow find a way to giving his full backs the same freedom to bomb on they have enjoyed in recent years, we might just be in for one hell of a season

Early days, but highly encouraging

Mike Green
179 Posted 15/09/2013 at 07:48:28
Roman / Phil and thanks Ernie for the 4 D's - very interesting!

I thought it was a red, an incredibly cynical foul and Luiz knew it.

Also, Mikel should've gone. Webb motioned to book him, realised it was Mikel and that he was already on a yellow and pulled his hand away from is pocket.

We could've scored more if it wasn't for Chelsea's dirty tactics but Webb didnt have the stomach to punish them properly for them.

All the more kudos to the brilliant, battling Blues! :)

Charles Brewer
180 Posted 15/09/2013 at 07:38:13
One thing about Luiz staying on, the "Special" (is that as in "needs" or "brew") one (and Handball Hansen) couldn't make out that was "the only reason Everton won".
Drew O'Neall
181 Posted 15/09/2013 at 07:59:21
I know they say football is all about opinions but I can't understand the opinions of some who say they watched the game.

Osman was apalling for his first three touches where he gave the ball away cheaply I grant you..

..After that he was superb.. He put his tackles in, was all over the pitch and did the difficult stuff in tight spaces at the other end. He is a rare positive, technical, balanced player with good awareness - he slotted in Coleman (I think) beautiffully in their box in the second half with a right to left shimmy.

Barkley is becoming an absolute beast and making Moyes look like a bit of a mug for not using him, get him signed up to a long contract (with no release clause) quick because he's is only going to get better.

Brent Stephens
182 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:19:23
Drew, absolutely agree on Ossie and Barks.

I think those first three bad touches by Ossie just made people's mind up about how he was going to play the rest of the game - except he didn't play the rest of the game that way, in my mind. I predicted he'd start in this game, despite not playing well in first three games. I predict he'll start in the next game. Roberto sees something and I don't think he's a mug as well as Moyes, as well as Hodgson.

Lewis Barclay
183 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:07:25
Travelled up for the game for the first time this season expecting a draw at best. Was expecting worse when I saw who was starting.

My observations:
Naismith worked his socks off and deserved his place, given injury to Pienaar meaning Mirrallas had to switch sides, but should go back to the bench when Pienarr is back.
Osman gets too much grief but can be a bit Jekyll and Hyde, I'd like to see Mcarthy get a go for a bit.
Jelavic, sadly even the great assist for Naismith's goal doesn't cover up another lacking performance. Lukaku has to replace him for the next fe PL starts, use him in the cup games.

Lastly, I thought Baines looked a bit quiet going forward without Pienaar, again. I'd be keen to see Oviedo come in at left back with Baines in front of him for maybe the last 30 mins of the West Ham game.

Mike Walker
184 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:32:28
Osman out — he's too slow and cannot put a pass together. Barry was outstanding, just what we need. We're starting to look good... BUT let's see next match with a striker that CAN put a ball into the net????
Brent Stephens
185 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:40:14
Lewis, re Baines quietness during the game. I wonder if Roberto's tactics were more about using Nais's height on the right against wee Cole. So working the left flanks, against a cracking player in Ivanovic wasn't going to be the main route? Hence the million headed flick-ons by Nais (count them!).
Phil Gardner
186 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:28:21
Andy Crooks @918 is spot on. I have several Rangers mates who were far more upset at losing Naismith than they were at losing Jelavic. Bearing in mind that the lad came to us on a free for cheap wages and still recovering from a serious knee injury, he was always going to need time and games. His all round performance today was excellent and if Mirellas had his 'work ethic' he'd be twice the player. Hopefully he can kick on now, his post match interview was excellent and the lad obviously appreciates this great club and supporters. Mark Frere wishing an injury on him is shameful imho......
Lewis Barclay
187 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:49:04
Brent @038 good point, but Naismith is the same height as Mirrallas, surely KM is the stronger player? Both are only bit taller than Cole. I guess Naismith is better in the air though.
Paul Andrews
188 Posted 15/09/2013 at 09:00:39
Brent,

Is that literally millions?

Carl Sanderson
189 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:57:17
Well, I was wrong, I am glad to say, about Gareth Barry. What a performance. If he can keep that up for the whole season he'll go to the World Cup, no question.
John Crawley
190 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:54:43
Nick 940 great comment about Barry and Bracewell, I was thinking exactly the same thing as I was watching the game. Like Bracewell he slotted into that Everton midfield in his first game and looked like he had been playing there all his career. Like Bracewell he does the simple things really well and adds a solidity to our midfield. One things for sure if he has half of the influence that Bracewell had in his debut season then Barry and Everton are going to have a great season!
Alan Smith
191 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:54:19
Not long before someone says they have a great understanding. Look at the goal.

Should Naisvic start next week with Bainaar on the left and Miraman down the right?

Mark Jones
192 Posted 15/09/2013 at 09:29:10
I'm fairly new to this forum, but I can't believe - after a brilliant win like that - most of the comments on here are about who are our worst players and who doesn't deserve to play.

The winning goal vs Chelsea was Osman to Jelavic to Naismith - three of the four most criticised players on here (Heitinga being the other) - and, whilst a single moment or a single game doesn't make a player, bear in mind these are players who are selected regularly by Premier League and International level managers over several years.

Yesterday was an occasion to savour and the fans in the stadium played a huge part in it. Same atmosphere against Newcastle in two weeks please! COYB.

Steve Brown
193 Posted 15/09/2013 at 09:34:40
Drew #033 I totally agree, Barkley's just getting better and better as his confidence grows. Please though, Ross, after you've twisted and turned their defenders so many ways that their undies are in a knot... Shoot!

Sam Hoare
194 Posted 15/09/2013 at 09:40:23
That chelsea team will most likely be champions in my opinion and I'm still feeling very happy this morning.

Will be interesting to see if Martinez wants to change a winning team at West Ham. I suspect Osman will start again but Lukaku may come in for Jelavic who, despite his great assist, cannot offer quite as much I suspect.

Jim Lloyd
195 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:49:33
Brent, I'm not sure that Naismith is that tall, he only looks about 5'9''. I also thought he did well in headers against most of their defence.

I think Baines probably did miss Pienaar but mainly it was the pressure that Chelsea applied that also contributed to his not having so many forays forward

Jim Potter
196 Posted 15/09/2013 at 09:59:37
The "Naismith and Osman are crap" brigade need to occasionally give these guys a break.

When they contribute and play well in a sound team performance - it should be fair dues. Otherwise you sound as deluded as the "Bobby's teams can't defend and we're getting relegated" bunch.

Three draws that should have been wins followed by a gutsy win against a billionaire team - not too shabby in my book.

Andrew Clare
197 Posted 15/09/2013 at 08:23:26
Great result. The team fought really hard for the victory.
For long periods we were really under immense pressure which saddened me as we looked like the plucky little underdogs battling against the imperious giants who were full of top class players from a different level.
What happened to Everton? We were once imperious giants full of top class players.
Good luck to the team and Roberto Martinez I hope he can take us back to the top where we belong.
Thomas Windsor
198 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:18:31
We got the win – that's what counts, maybe a draw would have been fair but we should have easily beaten WBA so it has balanced out.

Over the coming weeks, Martinez will be chopping and changing the team to see who fits in and who does not. I thought Osman played well yesterday myself, as did Man of the Match, Barry.

James Martin
199 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:26:39
If everyone took a quick look at Sky Sports you'd be surprised to see which much derided diminutive Everton midfielder came on top of the Everton stats for passes, tackles and interceptions. I know how much everyone on here loves some good stats.
Clive Rogers
200 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:12:19
Just read that Chelsea can recall Lukaku. Didn't realise that. Not good.
Ajay Gopal
201 Posted 15/09/2013 at 06:54:56
Based on that performance, I don't think anyone should walk straight back in to the XI next week, barring injuries. Lukaku and McCarthy may get a look in at the 60 min mark replacing Jela and Ossie. Then, Delafeu in the last 15 minutes for Barkley or Mirallas.
Jon Withey
202 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:39:18
Good result and a fine performance. Chelsea were a bit off but at times we caused them real problems.

What encouraged me most was the amount of options we had from the bench. Bringing McCarthy on made a difference I thought, even Deulofeu made a great pass within 2 minutes and Stones is classy. Kone, Pienaar and Lukaku, Oviedo, Heitinga, Hibbo and Robles aren't bad to have as back-up either.

Barkley is my new favourite player though, I was shouting every time he got on the ball.

Interesting how Baines was concentrating more on his defensive game too, he only really started attacking at the end.

Watching Ashley Cole being dragged off was funny, even if I misread it (was he injured ?).

Jon Withey
203 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:48:13
Naismith looked a different player too, quick down that right wing at times and a defensive pest, he saw/got a lot of the ball.

More than anything, the amount of abuse he gets, he's got a decent mentality to keep at it.

Tony Draper
204 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:43:41
Naismith & Osman
Not world beaters either of 'em

But I'll stand here and remind "the old school" of Richardson & Harper

GLUE
Glue in the squad,
footsoldiers,
effort
train hard
no offield stupidity
no "Me ! Me ! Me ! " ego to be fed
"Gimme a jersey, and I'll go and play"

Any that didn't see the HK 80's Kings need to go n learn, all that did need to recall, and fully

Big Nev rated Harper n Richardson
Big Nev doesn't and never did make compromises

Go learn and stuff

Come back when, or even . . . .
"If you know your history !"

Peter Warren
205 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:13:17
Gareth Barry is a blue is a blue is a blue Gareth Barry is a blue ..... he hates Kopites!!!

Great exciting game made up with the win and still recovering after a heavy night

Raymond Fox
206 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:27:30
I'm confident that we will now go on and have a good season.
RM has a very very strong squad to pick from, and can now choose a team suited to any tactic or situation.

At the start of the season I thought top 4 was a pipe dream, but @ 20/1 I now think they are worth a small bet at least, a tough ask maybe but definitely possible after that brilliant transfer window.

Chris Cumisky
207 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:12:04
Ross, if you feel stupid a lot of the time on here, why do you bother posting utter shite, is it your ego mate?
Mark..the jury is out on you never mind Naismith, whoppers.
David Donnellan
208 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:55:40
Excellent result! 1 of 2 unbeaten teams in the prem (come on Swansea!), 3 successive clean sheets & still in the league cup. Not bad for a team in transition. Martinez wasn't my first choice, but I think he is doing a very good job thus far & long may it continue.

Mourinho is such a sore loser, I could guess what he was going to say before his interview. Our goal was a Chelsea mistake? We could all say that, if we analyzed their chances deeply enough. A lot of the chances that he alludes to, could be attributed to our sloppy defending at times & their best chance was from an individual error from Howard. In his interview, he made it sound as if we just parked the bus & didn't play, that is not the game I watched.
As for motd, disappointed with their assessment & I too found it strange that Luiz's challenge wasn't even shown, yet, over analyzed, Distins challenge on the edge of the area, to ascertain whether it was a penalty or not. Personally, I didn't think it was a foul, I thought Oscar was on his way down before any contact.

I can't wait for the next game now, COYB!!

Phil Sammon
209 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:11:35
As an aside, how good is Eden Hazard?! Unbelievable player.

If Mourinho drops this silly little grudge he has with Mata then I honestly think we've beaten the champions yesterday.

Joe Bibb
210 Posted 15/09/2013 at 09:53:06
Great win and the lad who wasn't ready to play yet, Barkley was again a star.

Maybe now the Moyes lovers will see how that man held EFC back. Within 3 months of Moyes leaving Barkley is an England International and getting raves reviews.

Martinez has given us Everton back after 11 years in the wilderness.

Anthony Flack
211 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:46:48
Lots of posts here as one would expect. Great game and brilliant win.

1. First if all the rarest of rare our managers tactics before and during the game were brilliant.

2. Naismith doubled up down the flank to break up there play again and again. This was essential

3. Pushing Mirralles up front was brilliant. Stretching their defence who cacked themselves from that point. Moyes would have brought Heitinga on at that point and camped on the edge of our box drawing or worse ....

4. Naismith was excellent. He defended very well and gets in good positions in the opposition area. He is limited when he has time and space in front of him seeming to panic and fluff the incisive killer pass or obvious shot. I do not dislike him but not quite good enough and will suffer some criticism unless he improves

5. Jelavic works hard but to stare the clucking obvious does not seem to have a goal in him. Great assist.

6. Osman for me and I do not care about the stats looks like a little boy trying to get the ball off the big boys. He is I think and hope either going to recover his form or drop down the ranking.

Coleman Jags Barry outstanding.

On last leg of shit train ride home and thanks to my sister for the spare ticket and the great family in row O seats 100 odd upper Bullens for being such a good laugh.

Peter Mills
212 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:25:25
Tony#089 - Excellent post. Add Sandy Brown to your list of noble foot soldiers. Too many people forget that sport is about attitude as well as ability.

I thought we were fortunate to win yesterday, Chelsea could have scored 4 or 5. Some of our players made mistakes during the game (often as a result of trying to do something creative). Was I bothered about any of that during the last few minutes at a rocking Goodison as we defended a lead but still tried to break forward? No chance. This was a much-needed win, hopefully it will give the team's confidence a big boost.

Anthony Flack
213 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:38:52
Re. the Lukaku could be recalled. I thought premier league regulations precluded players being recalled during season long loans. Might be wrong but cannot remember it happening before.

Anyone know for sure?

Anthony Flack
214 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:44:48
Tony Draper 89 just just spotted your great post. Fair and very true also very true for all walks of life not just footie
Terry Davies
215 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:21:48
I've watched every Everton game this season, including all the pre season games and I must say Naismith has been a revelation: he's consistently played well and the change from last season is amazing. I think he will be a very good squad player.

Barry didn't surprise me at all; he did exactly what I expected i.e. played a blinder. Great CM, calm, good passer and can defend. Don't forget he started life as a centre half at Villa.

Presume Piennaar was injured but would love to see Deulofeu given a run instead of Osman.

Phil Sammon
216 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:41:11
Call me greedy but I like my Everton players to have both attitude AND ability. Jags, Distin, Coleman, Baines, Barry, Barkley these lads have both those attributes.

Naismith played very well today. No arguments there.

Osman was terrible in the first half. The amount of misplaced passes. I can tolerate misplacing a difficult pass, but we are talking 10 yard balls here - repeatedly given away. I like Osman and couldn't praise him enough for his great form last year - but these first few games he looks frighteningly off the pace. As I said earlier he did grow into the game, which was pleasing, but I think it's time we looked at him starting games every week.

Phil Sammon
217 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:51:12
We have paid a fee to loan Lukaku. He is not available for Chelsea to recall.
Jay Harris
218 Posted 15/09/2013 at 10:28:36
Which Everton player has played every minute of every game in a 4 match unbeaten run?

Colin Glassar
219 Posted 15/09/2013 at 11:58:30
Phil, in all fairness to Ossie OFM played him all over the place but even CDMFis a new one for him. He's played on the wings, the number 10 role but his new position is totally unsuitable to his talents. Despite this he still has a go but once McCarthy settles down, and Gibbo returns, I doubt we'll see Ossie play that role in the future.
Paul Andrews
220 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:01:49
Phil Sammon 121,

Spot on there re Ossie.
He looked very weak in the first half,easily brushed off the ball and conceding possession several times.
Got better in the second half.

Paul Dark
221 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:25:24
Osman must be dropped from the squad. He is shocking and a terrible liability.

Terrible player who puts the whole team under constant pressure.

Ernie Baywood
222 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:30:03
On Cole coming off I assumed it was tactical and thought at the time it was a mistake by Mourinho. Nais gave him a working over but once that change was made the flanks opened up and suddenly Baines and Coleman were marauding forward. We need to figure out how to get them doing that more - Baines in particular has had no space to move into this season.

Watched MOTD. Can't believe the Luiz fouls didn't get a run. Neither did the foul on Coleman did it? I'm convinced it was in the box.

Is there a clip of those incidents on the net anywhere?

Mal Christopher
223 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:40:28
Why all the focus on Osman, we won, remain unbeaten but still silly people focus on the negative and miss the positive. Its laughable really.
Phil Sammon
224 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:46:37
Ernie

I can't believe they didn't show either incident. I was convinced the Coleman foul was a penalty at the time. I recorded the game and re-watched it. It was about 10 yards outside the box! Some ref I'd be.

Ernie Baywood
225 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:51:48
Really? Me too, then. Though I doubt they'd let me ref too many Everton games,

Found the Luiz incident... http://www.101greatgoals.com/blog/last-man-david-luiz-chelsea-hauled-down-evertons-kevin-Mirallas-on-the-halfway-line-only-a-yellow/

Mikel isn't covering in my view.

You see from the first clip where he is when Mirrallas hits the deck... a couple of metres behind. Then in the next clip you see how long the fouling went on - practically from the moment the pass was played. Mikel must have been 10 or 15 metres behind when Mirrallas took off. Michael Owen disagrees with me though.

Dan Brierley
226 Posted 15/09/2013 at 12:57:27
Excellent result, from a well worked goal. Still concerned regarding the 'keep the ball at all costs' mentality inviting unnecessary pressure. It won't be long before teams start playing high lines against us knowing that the boys are going to try and play it out from the back. I am not saying we should hoof it out every time, but there has to be some common sense applied.

I thought it was Barkley who was guilty of giving the ball away most yesterday. No doubt he is going to be a top player, but he needs to remember you cannot take the whole team on every time. But this is something that will come with experience and maturity.

Thought Barry did a great job for us, in a position where we vitally needed someone. My main concern now, is that we seem to have quite a few players that can do this centre midfield role (Osman, Barry, Gibson, Mcarthy, Naismith) but we seem to have no 'creative' player in our ranks in that position that can unlock defences or exploit gaps. I saw Jelly working hard yesterday, but nobody had the vision to pick him out when he was in good positions. Is Mcarthy going to be able to fill those shoes?

Sean McCarthy
227 Posted 15/09/2013 at 13:09:34
Mark Frere and Ross Edwards have you finished eating your words yet????

Michael Winstanley
228 Posted 15/09/2013 at 13:12:24
Some observations from yesterday.
Naismith played well, provided cover for Coleman and broke up countless attacks. He's played really well pre-season and took his chance today in Pienaar's absence.

Osman played okay, did some good things but think McCarthy is more mobile and better at the defensive stuff.

Barry. Class. Hope we can keep him.

Mirallas played better up front than Jelavic, I'd start him as the main attacker rather than out on the wing.

Barkley. Watching the games this season he is following his managers instructions, he's not about tracking back. And the ball for Mirallas where Luis put him n the deck, what a pass. The lad is only going to get better.

Del Boy, he'll be staking a claim for a starting spot sooner rather than later. He's another like Barkley, a player.

A mention for Stones, what an atmosphere to step into. What message must that send to the squad.

Thankfully we won't play Chelsea every week, they are very good and potential champions.

Carl Sanderson
229 Posted 15/09/2013 at 13:01:53
Paul 139,

Watch the game again. Osman played really well in the second half.

Andrew Clare
230 Posted 15/09/2013 at 13:30:00
Chelsea will win the league and I agree Hazard is a tremendous player.
I think we will do very well this season and hopefully as time passes and the new players gel into the team we will have more of the ball in games like this.
I hope Lukaku scores freely as our strikers are dreadful.
Also agree with the person who says that we lack a playmaker.Arteta was never replaced.This could be the main reason why our strikers look so bad.In the January window a creative midfielder should be our number one priority.
Drew Shortis
231 Posted 15/09/2013 at 13:44:09
Phil Sammon 122
Good point Phil. I did panic a bit when I read Lukaku could be recalled as another season of Jelavic bumbling around up front fills me with dread! He really isn't up to the task. I think he may do better with a partner, but he is not cut out to be a lone striker!

I don't think anyone would question Naismith or Osman's commitment to the cause or their effort, but they are both being played out of position and neither is good enough for the role they are being asked to play. Ossie played his heart out yesterday, but he loses the ball far too often and puts the team under a lot of unnecessary pressure. McCarty will do much better in the central midfield role and Osman can be employed further forward.

Naismith had a very good game yesterday, but he reminds me more of Hibbert than he does of a Trevor Steven. He had several opportunities to pick out a team-mate on the counter attack and consistently picked the wrong pass or over hit the pass. This has been the case in most games I have seen him play in. I understood why he was selected yesterday with Pienaar being out, but if we are going to play him he should partner the striker.

I appreciated the way both Ossie and Naismith played yesterday, but when everyone is available thy both need to be on the bench. There is no room in top flight football for sentiment!

Paul Dark
232 Posted 15/09/2013 at 14:28:02
The problem with Osman and Naismith isn't their commitment, it's their levels of skill. They aren't very good footballers.

If we are to achieve anything, Osman must be nowhere near the first team - not on the bench, not in the squad and not at the club. He puts too much pressure on the defence. The second half yesterday possibly aside, he's been the opposition's man of the match in every game we've played: when we have men committed forward he launches a counter-attack for the opposition, with consummate ease and regularity.

He's an utter liability.

John Ford
233 Posted 15/09/2013 at 14:37:44
That's the first time I can remember anyone suggesting Osman doesnt have skill. There are other qualities he may not have in abundance but to say he lacks skill seems way off the mark.

If I were a football magician, I might grant him a bit more strength and speed. Skill is one quality he doesn't lack.

Clive Rogers
234 Posted 15/09/2013 at 14:41:50
Phill, 122

Ta for that. I'll sleep tonight.

Carl Sanderson
235 Posted 15/09/2013 at 14:41:31
Paul 171:

"The problem with Osman and Naismith isn't their commitment, it's their levels of skill. They aren't very good footballers."

I agree with you on Naismith. He's a work-horse with the odd goal in him. He can "do a job for the team", as the phrase is.

On Osman your post is unutterable bollocks. The player has a superb first touch; he can see a pass; and did you see him winning balls in the air in midfield yesterday? Fifty-odd career goals in one of the world's hardest leagues speak for themselves.

If you believe Osman is not a skilful player then you need to think again, seriously.

Gary Reeves
236 Posted 15/09/2013 at 14:53:48
Well Carl, you're obviously pro-Osman, but I (like many others) aren't (and never have been) convinced. We pays our money, we has our say.

You said in an earlier post that Osman played well in the second half. Would you at least agree that he was extremely lucky to come out for that half?

Paul Dark
237 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:14:02
Carl: skilful players don't give the ball away repeatedly to opposition players.
Carl Sanderson
238 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:26:23
Paul,

Yes they do. Ross Barkley did it quite a few times yesterday. Still a great player.

Paul Dark
239 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:32:25
You aren't comparing like for like. Osman gives the ball away constantly when under no pressure whatsoever. He is the ONE player who puts the team under pressure most with misplaced passes, missed tackles, fouls etc. These are not the actions of a good footballer, in my view.

Your standards for what is required at Everton are clearly different from (lower than) mine.

We shall disagree.

Mark Tanton
240 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:37:01
I can't believe there are people who thought Osman played well yesterday, and warrants a place. Barry has made himself un-droppable for West Ham, McCarthy surely won't sit on the bench for £13M under his old manager and mentor. Still, knowing Osman's knack for being named in the starting eleven, someone else will probably make way; or we'll just field 12 men.
Mark Tanton
241 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:39:14
And yes, he is skilful, not compared with Wilshere (although Wilshere ironically played very similarly to Osman against Ukraine) or Barkley.

He also has the physique of an asthmatic 12-year-old with self-esteem problems. I worry when he tries to kick the ball sometimes, that he might hurt himself; I feel that about Pienaar too sometimes.

Carl Sanderson
242 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:44:45
Paul,

"You aren't comparing like for like." You referred to skilful players. They are both skilful players.

The trouble is that some people allow their prejudice against Osman to blind them to his good performances. Even a confirmed Osmanophile like me can see that he is in the twilight of his career. But to say that he is not a skilful player is just plain wrong.

Ciarán McGlone
243 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:44:39
Drew et al..

I don't really understand all this 'humble pie' 'I told you so' about Naismith and Osman.

My posts at beginning of this thread are simply my opinion that neither player should be in our starting XI... Their performances yesterday did not change that opinion.

In fact the performances of Barry and Mccarthy when he came on, have only vindicated my opinion in regards to Osman.

Naismith should be commended for the goal and all his hard work(especially his defensive play)..similarly Osman. However I saw nothing in their performances yesterday to justify this gloating. Naismith simply doesn't have the technical ability to fit into our team - some of his offensive play and passing yesterday was embarrassing - especially considering we are looking to be at the buisness end of the premiership.

Anyway, great win...and a thoroughly entertaining match (something which was a rarity under our former manager).

When Martinez eventually figures out our best eleven, we'll be a handful for any team in the league. Today was not our best eleven - but we are getting there..

Carl Sanderson
244 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:49:58
Mark 198:

So Barry is undroppable after one good game, but Osman shouldn't be in the team despite a really good second half performance? Right-ho.

Your critique of Osman's physique, as well as being no funnier than a cold sore, does you no credit. The one thing you shouldn't blame Osman for is his lack of stature, although it doesn't seem to stop you from trying.

Mark Tanton
245 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:57:02
Well Carl if you read what I said he is clearly undroppable for the West Ham game. Or would you drop last week's Man of the Match?
Anthony Flack
246 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:57:19
What a funny game it is – someone suggested watching the game again as in the second half Ossie played really well. I thought he died on his feet from the 65 minute onwards – and nearly fell over when he should have scored at the end!
Harold Matthews
247 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:59:18
Paul Dark. Get a life.
Mark Tanton
248 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:59:49
Careful Anthony, someone will mention he's an 'England international' soon.
Brian Harrison
249 Posted 15/09/2013 at 15:34:46
Great result, and now the first win is under our belt against a very good side that to be honest wasted a lot of chances. Although in our previous games we have been the dominant side, yet failed to come away with the wins our play probably deserved. What I found very interesting about yesterdays game was that every time we had a goalkick Distin and Jagielka took up their usual positions since the start of the season, which is both defenders being on either side of the area between the edge of the area and the dead ball line. That carried on until we nearly conceded a silly goal when Howards goalkick to Distin was passed back to Howard who again tried to find Distin and only found a Chelsea player inside our box. From that moment on no goalkick was played to Distin or Jagielka but instead played long to Naismith which made sense as he had the beating of Cole every time in the air.

Now who made the call to abandon this suicide tactic was it RM or was it the players, whoever made the call lets hope that commonsense prevails and we try to vary how we get the ball back into play from a goalkick. I did hear RM being interviewed after the game and he did say that we tended to overpass in certain areas maybe he was talking about the same situation. Just because sometimes a long ball is the best alternative it doesn't mean by playing it at times means you have given up your footballing philosophy. I know it is often said that RM is trying to introduce a Barcelona style game to Everton and there is nothing wrong in that approach but every time I have seen Barcelona they play a very high tempo game with very few passes exchanged between the back four.

Carl Sanderson
250 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:03:28
Mark 210:

"Or would you drop last week's Man of the Match?"

No. But I wouldn't drop Osman, either; I believe he will be a good fit for the West Ham game.

Mark Tanton
251 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:10:11
He's far too comfortable, and his sharpness has gone through being Moyes's regular pick for so long. He deserves dropping for his performances over an extended period of time, and I thought he gave the ball away far too often again yesterday.

I hope McCarthy replaces him sooner rather than later.

Paul Dark
252 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:19:30
222: Mark, pleased there's someone who actually watches. From my seat, it was another unacceptably shocking performance by him.

Still, on a much brighter note, once he's out, we have many options. I'd love to see Lukaku play alongside Jelly, especially at home against the lesser sides.

Anyone know how long Pienaar is out for?

Ciarán McGlone
253 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:15:33
"someone suggested watching the game again as in the second half Ossie played really well. I thought he died on his feet from the 65 minute onwards – and nearly fell over when he should have scored at the end!"
---------------

I agree. Thought he looked like he'd run a marathon... He looked better in the second half because he had less of the ball. The first 20 minutes of the second half, Chelsea owned the ball..

Carl Sanderson
254 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:37:09
Paul 225:

"222: Mark, pleased there's someone who actually watches"

You mean you're pleased that someone else shares your ignorant and prejudiced view.
Well, the like-minds can chum up all they want. I prefer to trust my own judgement, as well as that of two Everton managers and the England manager.

Paul Dark
255 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:50:08
Carl: you sound very pleased with yourself.

Have a good week-end, mate.

Oh, and my regards to your chum, Woy - a truly great man ... ;-)

Carl Sanderson
256 Posted 15/09/2013 at 16:52:34
Paul 239:

Well that told me, didn't it? What can I say - I'm just no match for your untamed wit.

Over and out.

Paul Dark
257 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:04:18
Sad that (some TW) Evertonians try to stop fellow fans trying to express their opinions if they disagree.

I think Osman is a shite player; it isn't a crime to think so, you know. Sheesh ...

Carl Sanderson
258 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:08:38
Paul,

"Sad that (some TW) Evertonians try to stop fellow fans trying to express their opinions if they disagree."

Where has that happened? Just one example will do.

Gary Reeves
259 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:09:03
Carl, I don’t know anyone who rates him. We don’t say it for the argument or to be controversial (or because we don’t like the lad). We say it because we have the interest of our team at heart.
David Chait
260 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:21:08
I'm only going to note my positive takes:
Naismith was there for every pass coming out the back an dbroke up play continuously...
Osman was a creative outlet throughout the 2nd half and was calm in possession
We didn't have 11 players back for corners
And most of all!
The subs didn't have a 5 minute tactical talk when there were only 3 minutes left of the game! Geez that drove me insane!
Phil Sammon
261 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:12:29
Carl

Hodgson picked Osman because he was in fine form. He's also dropped him now because he is in poor form.

I like Ossie and appreciate the many good qualities he has, but you just cannot overlook the amount of misplaced passes of late.

It's not about bashing the lad, it's about what's best for the team. Everyone makes mistakes and deserves evaluating after every game.

Carl Sanderson
262 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:26:52
Phil,

Obviously it is all about opinions, as they say. But there's expressing an opinion and there's vulgar abuse ("asthmatic 12-year-old", etc.). And the fact that lots of people believe Osman is a poor player doesn't make it true. I know loads of fans who rate him.

To paraphrase Voltaire I disagree with all the shite that Paul and others write about Osman but they are well within their rights to write it. This gives the lie to Paul's odd assertion that I am "trying to stop" him from expressing his view.

My last word, for what it's worth, is that it will be a sad day when Everton FC can't find room for a player like Leon Osman.


Mark Tanton
263 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:38:32
It'll be a red letter day, not a sad day. You can get all misty eyed Carl and claim the moral high ground, but the very fact Osman divides opinion so much signals his place in the side is controversial and disputable. I don't see why a team such find room for anyone who isn't up to it.
Ciarán McGlone
264 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:46:01
Carl..

Do you think Everton would be a better team with McCarthy in place of Osman?

Carl Sanderson
265 Posted 15/09/2013 at 17:46:06
Mark

"It'll be a red letter day, not a sad day. You can get all misty eyed Carl and claim the moral high ground."

Your first sentence betrays your disgraceful ignorance of Osman's qualities.

The second sentence makes no sense. I claim no moral high ground. I merely offer my honest view of what Osman brings to Everton, expressing it in what I hope is a concise and polite way.

Other posters have resorted to cheap shots, snidey asides, ad hominem abuse and a paranoid assertion that I am attempting to gag them. That's a matter for them; their opinion on Everton is important to me but the rest of the shite just bounces off.

Carl Sanderson
266 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:07:08
Ciaran 261:

Don't know, haven't seen enough of McCarthy to form a judgement.

Mike Green
267 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:11:05
Ciaran #261 - Yes.
Ciarán McGlone
268 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:06:37
Carl..

Calling contrary opinions 'ignorant' and 'prejudiced' pretty much invalidates your criticism of others.

Gary Reeves
269 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:03:19
Carl,

Osman is obviously a favourite of yours, and it must be annoying to listen to the likes of me. I’ll never forget how, as a starry-eyed kid, my Dad explained to me how, and why, Andy King would never be top-drawer (and, of course he was right).

So, Leon Osman? Here goes...

"Weak in stature,and possession. Lacking in pace and strength. Often feeble in the tackle and easily pushed off the ball. Poor chance/goal ratio. Not commanding of any particular position. Rubbish out wide, and not good enough to support the forward."

Sorry, Carl, and as you say it’s about opinions. I didn’t want you to think there was a vendetta. He never has been good enough, and I (like others) have higher expectations.

Carl Sanderson
270 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:15:46
Ciaran,

"Calling contrary opinions 'ignorant' and 'prejudiced' pretty much invalidates your criticism of others."

Not at all; contrary opinions are fine providing they are rooted in sound logic and not merely based on one's dislike of Leon Osman. Views based on a lack of football knowledge are not and should be debated.

One poster earlier described Osman as a player who lacks football skills. If that doesn't qualify as an ignorant and prejudiced view then nothing does.

Mark Tanton
271 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:23:32
I don't deny he has qualities, but he is not good enough and he gives the ball away with alarming regularity - he is far too cosy and has played rain or shine, tired or fresh, every single week to a point where it's actually driven me to greet the sight of him and his name on the team sheet with resignation and simmering resentment.
Ciarán McGlone
272 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:28:19
Carl,

But it was't just that opinion you were referring to as 'ignorant and prejudiced' - was it?

It's clear from your posts that you think your opinion of Oman is a fact. It isn't.

There's more than enough evidence (if that's what your demanding) that Osman shouldn't have started the game yesterday. and more than enough evidence from yesterday to suggest he shouldn't start the next game..irrespective of what Moyes or Hodgson think.

Phil Sammon
273 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:31:09
Carl

The day we can't find space for Osman will, by definition, be a great day for the club. It will mean that we have another player in the team that is better than Osman, surely.

Ciarán McGlone
274 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:35:58
Spot on Phil..and that day has arrived!
Jackie Barry
275 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:30:40
Carl I like Osman and have praised him when he has put in a good shift, however if I am truthful he is currently just not doing it. Yesterday he certainly put in a better shift in the second half but was still the worst player in midfield. I just don't see how he will be able to justify his place in the team over the next few months if he doesn't start to pick up. It's all right people having a go at Barkley, a 19 year old!, for his misplaced passes but nobody can say a bad word about Osman, a seasoned pro. The simple fact is that he just isn't performing to his usual standards right now, which is making his other weaknesses look like a huge problem, i.e he gets brushed aside far too easily and has to make somebody like Barry work far harder than they should be.
Carl Sanderson
277 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:31:31
Mark,

As I wrote earlier, Ross Barkley also gave the ball away quite a lot. It happens when you take risks; that's in the game.

I've always liked Osman but even I can see that he's at the back end of his career now. I imagine that in a couple of years' time he'll become one of the coaches at Everton. I hope so, anyway.

ps You experience "simmering resentment" when you see Osman or his name on the team sheet? I feel the same thing when a certain thespian gobshite appears on the television screens.

Ross Edwards
278 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:46:44
Looking at it Michael, that might be a fake account. But, I'll paste the tweet, and the link to his page so you can decide for yourself.

The tweet: keith wyness þ@retsub12 22h
Roberto the best possible choice now move it on with the next owners?
Coming soon........

The account: https://twitter.com/retsub12

As I say, it might be a fake, but I'll leave it to your conclusions.

Carl Sanderson
279 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:51:59
Ciaran 277:

"It's clear from your posts that you think your opinion of Oman is a fact."

Not at all: it's merely my view.

"There's more than enough evidence (if that's what your demanding) that Osman..."

Not at all: it's merely your view.

Carl Sanderson
280 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:58:42
Phil 278:

Ha! Very good. But in fact I said "a player like Leon Osman", ie someone with his skills, personality and loyalty.

Ciarán McGlone
281 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:59:58
Carl,

Incidents of misplaced passes, sloppy play and being brushed off the ball is not my view/opinion. It's fact. i.e EVIDENCE!

Mark Tanton
282 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:01:22
Carl I'm actually softening towards our Thespian friend, thought that doesn't mean I actually like him. I have to admit I think he had a good deadline day, despite me being on suicide watch by 10pm. He forced Fellaini's hand, he got the better of Moyes and he had replacements lined up - he somehow averted disaster. Was it luck or good management? I don't know, but he gets the benefit of the doubt on this one...
Ross Edwards
283 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:02:25
"Mark Frere and Ross Edwards have you finished eating your words yet????"

Yes.

Carl Sanderson
284 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:04:20
Ciaran 295:

You could say exactly the same thing about Ross Barkley. Midfield players lose the ball, etc. it's part of the game.

Osman played very well yesterday - in my opinion, of course, especially in the second half. The number of headers he won in midfield was the subject of amused comment in the Paddock. In the second half he did a great firefighting job with Barry.

Ciarán McGlone
285 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:12:18
Yes Carl,

You could say the same thing about Ross Barkley...Not sure how that adds to your argument though..unless you're advocating dropping Ross.

I note your opinion on Osman's performance yesterday. Can't say I agree.

Jim Knightley
286 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:13:44
I think Osman is unjustly criticised on here...Personally I think it comes partly from a narrative born a few years back, when he was played out of position on the right side of midfield. He is not a great player, but he is certainly not Championship standard, and should hopefully add experience and depth to the squad going forward.

That said, I think Barry (glad to see him performing well...and hopefully justifying those of us who wanted him to come in) and McCartney should form the central midfield, with Barkley in front of them on current form. I worry about Barkley's raw nature, but with 2 defensive minded midfielders, he can be given license to play with risk and to attack. With lakuku through the centre, Pienaar left and Mirallas right, I think we will have a good unit.

I'm still a bit troubled by Martinez's reticence to play with any directness. With our height, and the best crosser in the league, I think it would be foolhardy not to use our strengths. It's nice to see passing football, but I think we need a little more directness to go with.

Carl Sanderson
287 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:22:20
Mark 297:

In the short-term Kenwright has done well. I try not to allow KD, DK, NTL, FSF, etc to blind me to that fact.

But there remain loads of questions: will the profits from the window be available to Martinez in January? What about the extra TV money? What's going to happen when Lukaku, Barry and Deulofeu come to the end of their short-term contracts? What about Baines's situation?

Carl Sanderson
288 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:28:28
Ciaran 300:

I wouldn't drop Osman or Barkley against the 'ammers. I would possibly replace Naismith with Deulofeu, though.

Ian Burns
289 Posted 15/09/2013 at 18:38:48
What a fantastic post and comments to sit with a gin and read. Difference of opinions but all posted with a passion for EFC. I am proud to be a true blue and have been for more years than I care to think about.

I would just like to make one comment if I may, at such a late date.

I personally think Osman is a weak link in this up and coming side. He has skill, he has a brain but his brain and his feet no longer speak with each other - they separated recently and are now at the point of divorce.

I personally think Naismith is a squad player who can come in and do a sort of job but I never liked him at Rangers if I am totally honest.

However, I dislike the some of the critics of Barkley. He has to play and if doesn't make mistakes, how will he ever learn? Rough edges were taken off when he went out on loan, now he has to hone his skills in the toughest league in the world and he will make mistakes. It is how he responds and improves that will be the key and what he does lack at this point in time (decision making), once he has learned his trade - boy what a player.

I wasn't keen on RM arriving - however, since he has arrived I have always wanted him to desperately succeed because he is at least trying to give us a different dimension and he should be both supported and encouraged, even if he does pick Osman! At least that seems to now be agreed by the vast majority of EFC fans.

Paul Dark
290 Posted 15/09/2013 at 19:54:53
Some of us think Osman is a bad player and should be dropped; others (most notably, one diehard) believe he is a great player.

So what?

The fact that I'm right makes me feel a bit better [... joke ;-) ].

Julian Wait
291 Posted 15/09/2013 at 20:01:16
I loved how Osman played last season, and I have never been an Osman basher like some, but at this point I would prefer him to be a very useful impact player when we need a bit more craft to unlock a team in the last 30 minutes.

I don't think he's got the legs to play how he used to, and certainly not for 90 minutes, but he's still very good at breaking stubborn defences down and is one of our more creative team players.

He would be even better at that in the final third of the game and in the final third of the field, away from our own goal.

You might say that makes him 2/3 of a player but that would be churlish ... (jk)

Ciarán McGlone
292 Posted 15/09/2013 at 20:03:36
Fair enough Carl..

I'll come back to you whenever MccCarthy, Barry and Barkley start a game in midfield...Because that's when you'll see what our current team are really capable of...

Paul Smith
293 Posted 15/09/2013 at 20:24:09
Great win by the lads but we were very fortunate to go in at half-timea goal up. A couple of tweaks and we've got the makings of a good side.

Firstly, Jelavic has got to be 4th choice striker now and McCarthy has to replace Osman.

Lukaku up front and Mirallas to show effort he produced when pushed up front.

I thought Barry was magnificent and Naismith had a good game.

Jimmy Sørheim
294 Posted 15/09/2013 at 20:03:09
I noticed we are so lacking in height after losing Fellaini.

Osman makes our midfield even smaller and worser off.

Mccharthy and Barry do not have the same ability in the air, but on the ground they are much better then Fellaini.

I thought we would lose today without Oveido instead of Naismith, Naismith got the goal so I guess I was wrong in a way.
The big problem was very visible, we lack a top, top striker.

Lukaku is the answer this season, who will be the answer for next season or if he gets a long term injury?

The transfer of Kone was a joke, I was and am still very very sad at us buying such a lacking striker, as we have Jelavic who is lacking badly already.

WHy was 6 million spent on Kone? Could we not have gotten better elsewhere in europe?
Bobby made a huge mistake in buying Kone, but he should at least be able to get more goals then Jelavic.

The problem with aiming so low as to a striker like Kone speaks for it self.
Relegation minded transfer still in RM thoughts that early in the season.

Though he has adapted better as time has gone by, I still have doubts about the transfer of 13 million for Mccharthy.

This transfer vindow has shown me that RM has not been using his scouts at all, or at least taken some of their advice.
He will have to buy more and better scouts if he does not trust their ability.

We have to rely heavily on scouts in order to find hidden gems in this market, and the departure of chief sout Robbie Cooke has been a big loss to the scouting department.

I hope RM sees this and acts upon it.

Overall it has taken time but I see signs that RM is adapting to being a top 6 manager, and not a relegation manager with regard to his transfer movements on deadline day.

Phil Sammon
295 Posted 15/09/2013 at 21:24:35
Jimmy

1. It's McCarthy.

2. Kone and Lukaku will feature heavily in the next 5 or so games and you will see how wrong you are about the former. I like the guy and it was a great assist yesterday, but Jelavic will be a bit part player from now on.

3. Cheer up will you!

Mike Corcoran
298 Posted 15/09/2013 at 22:35:06
This constant haranguing of Leon Osman is beyond a joke. He had a good game yesterday, paired up well with Barry (witness the usual suspects have changed their tune on him!). He looks to move the ball forward, he created the goal. Every player out there misplaced the odd pass under a lot of pressure. He is a steady Eddie with an occasional spark of genius, has been played out of position his whole career when he should have been at the top of a midfield three but made way for Grav, Cahill, Fellaini et al and carried water for the rest of the team.

David Graves
299 Posted 15/09/2013 at 22:58:56
Jimmy - The negativity in your post is stunning. You say that "It has taken time for RM to adapt to being a top 6 manager" Do you mean the 4 games in which we are unbeaten? You have doubts about McCarthy - after 10 minutes in an Everton shirt? I wouldn't want to read your posts if we had started the season badly.
Ross Edwards
300 Posted 15/09/2013 at 23:08:38
Come on Jimmy, cheer up mate. Drenthe's done next to nothing at Reading you know.
Colin Grierson
301 Posted 15/09/2013 at 22:30:03
Jimmy 366

"Overall it has taken time but I see signs that RM is adapting to being a top 6 manager"

I don't reckon he thinks he's a top 6 manager but I do think he's a top class manager who will make us better. Trust his signings as he knows better than any of us what it takes to make a team. He did it at Swansea and at Wigan. He will do it here on whatever budget is available. We will be better than we were pre Roberto. Patience is required however. We will give the ball away too often for now and lose the odd stupid goal (Tim Howard got away with one yesterday)

Give Kone a chance. He scored a hat full last year in a team that got relegated. It would be foolish to write him off already.

Terry Davies
302 Posted 15/09/2013 at 22:44:31
I really despair of some of you "supporters" criticising Ross. We've all wanted to see him get games for a couple of years and this season he has been brilliant and yet he's getting criticism from some for giving the ball away a couple of times. He had a good game (and hasn't had a bad one yet so for god's sake get off his back). I hope he stays in the side as he can only benefit from the games and get better.
David Graves
303 Posted 15/09/2013 at 23:25:47
Terry I wouldn't worry about anyone who criticises Barkley for giving the ball away as they clearly don't know their arses from their elbows. He is going to be a top, top player.
Tony Draper
304 Posted 15/09/2013 at 23:18:32
Saturdays result was a real plus

We have 6 pts from 4 games. as I see it these points apply:
1) Whomsover you play game #1 of a new season, you "may" expect a maverick result
2) Whomsoever you play for your #1 home game of a new season, you "may" expect a maverick result
3) Lead by a new manager, any team from school 6+ to World Cup Challengers MUST reasonably anticipate at least SOME fuckin adjustment (just some)
4) To the very greatest of my understanding Everton FC remain both active and hopeful in all 3 competitions for which they were active at the commencement of the 2013-2014 season

To any & all critics of our display so far, I offer the following comment

If your "bedroom longevity" is as brief as it appears that your tolerance of our team thus far, then thankfully the likelihood of your genes continuance is likewise brief.

Raymond Fox
305 Posted 15/09/2013 at 23:10:34
Jimmy its safe to say our manager knows a little more about players and tactics than you!

You have watched Kone for max of 120mins, a player that scored 11 league goals last season, and yet you know more about him than RM who managed him for a season +.

Oh, and don't worry about the scouting system, RM bought several foreign players for peanuts at Wigan and then sold them on to bigger clubs at a substantial profit.

I'm sure some people wouldn't recognise a good player even if they fell over one!

Ernie Baywood
306 Posted 15/09/2013 at 23:23:45
Jesus Terry. I understand intent can get lost on the Internet sometimes but I don't believe anyone has criticised Ross.

Statements like "he gave the ball away a few times" aren't criticism, they're facts!

He was excellent again. And he gave the ball away a few times.

Anto Byrne
307 Posted 15/09/2013 at 04:55:40
Stand up Mr Naismith you played really well and scored the winner. On this performance the lad should be in the team on merit. No more favourites being selected.
Brian Wilkinson
308 Posted 16/09/2013 at 02:02:26
Well in, Naismith!

I have commented in the past saying he was played out of position under Moyes but two things you will always guarantee with Naismith is 100% effort and a goal if he's in front of goal instead of the wing. He's come back from a long injury, he will make a mistake or two but he will never hide or stop running. Let's hope the Naismith lynchmob get behind him. for once.

Nice to see Barkley play again and Martinez's belief in the youngsters. I guarantee had Moyes been manager for that game, both Jelavic and Mirallas would have been subbed before 60 mins and we would have sat back... so it was great to see Everton positive and not try to hold out with 11 players back with no strikers on the pitch.

Harold Matthews
309 Posted 16/09/2013 at 23:10:04
This thread is full of silly whingers who wouldn't know the difference between Lionel Messi and a three legged Blackpool donkey.
Max Wilson
310 Posted 17/09/2013 at 09:49:48
NOW GUYS AND GALS, WHAT DO YOU MAKE OF THIS? My mate Chris and I are 160 miles from Goodison but try to make it whenever we can. We have an interesting feature. Everytime we come the Blues win!

We were there Saturday. Should we apply to the club to become sort of lucky Mojo's? Perhaps we should start targeting "difficult" games!

What do you think?

Nick Entwistle
311 Posted 17/09/2013 at 09:56:31
Who are you? Jimmy Saville?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads