Martinez lauds debutant Barry

, 16 September, 94comments  |  Jump to most recent
'He's a pristine professional'
Roberto Martinez hailed the performance of one of his deadline-day acquisitions following Gareth Barry's impressive debut in Saturday's win over Chelsea.

The England international completed a season-long loan move from Manchester City just minutes before the closure of the transfer window and played a crucial role in preserving the Blues's precious advantage against Jose Mourinho's highly-fancied team.

Slotting into the defensive holding role vacated by Marouane Fellaini, Barry did brilliantly to deny Samuel Eto'o a certain goal after Tim Howard had passed the ball straight to Andre Schurrle in his own area.

But he shone in his overall performance and his new manager was full of praise for the 32 year-old:

"I've been a big admirer of Gareth over the years," Martinez said. "I think that no Englishman plays that role as well. I think Gareth is very unique."

"That profile of midfielder doesn't exist in English football. You always get a lot of foreign players coming in and playing that role really well. But Gareth Barry is something else.

"He senses danger like nobody. He gives you great composure, he's full of good decisions, he establishes good relationships all over the park. And then you see a player like him who he hasn't played any minutes officially this season and he shows that fitness level.

"It shows you that he's a pristine professional, that he works really well and I think he's going to be an incredible influence to James McCarthy and Ross Barkley as youngsters. He's going to be the perfect guidance for the future."

Barry, meanwhile, gave huge credit to the home fans for playing their part in a stirring first victory for Martinez.

“I've said all week that I had been looking forward to being on the right side of fans,” said Barry who has tasted defeat under the lights at Goodison playing for Manchester City over the last four years. “They are the 12th man and to have them on our side made the difference in the end. It was brilliant and hopefully that can continue all season.

“There was a fantastic atmosphere out there. These night games at Goodison always have a great atmosphere and the boys put in a great shift and thoroughly deserved the three points.”

Quotes or other material sourced from Click Liverpool



Reader Comments (94)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brian Williams
1 Posted 16/09/2013 at 06:22:45
Agree with everything our manager has said there. If there's one thing that stood out about Barry it was his "sheer professionalism" on Saturday. Even his fouls were carried out in a way not to annoy the ref!!!He just looked like everything he did he did with ease.

I have to admit I was a doubter on deadline day but if he can perform anything like that over the course of the season I'll be one happy Evertonian.

Timothy Sebastian
2 Posted 16/09/2013 at 06:24:05
Fellaini who?

Barry showed more skill, endeavour, composure and thinking in those 90mins than Fellaini ever did throughout the whole of last season.

The only negative is that age is not on his side. But if he can stay on form for the next 2 seasons and help to bring on players like McCarthy and Barkley, he'll be worth every cent of his exhorbitant weekly wage.

Ben Dyke
3 Posted 16/09/2013 at 06:59:00
Fellaini is some player on his day - ManUtd game start of last season anyone? But what Barry will bring even if he has an off day is desire and that British spirit that you can't buy, which leaves Fellaini looking slightly well 'French' and temperamental! And when Barry does play well like on Saturday then you can't really argue that we massively miss the 27.5m man. In fact another couple of performances like that from Barry and its Marouane who? from me.
Tom Dodds
4 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:14:25
Great, just keep shouting on about him his value is bound to go down by the summer... not. The 'press' have already been shit-stirring it up saying how Man City are missing an unsung hero, blah, blah.... Then of course there's other clubs with money knowing his contracts up in the summer as well.

Not being paranoid here, but the sports vulture press gang seem to have camped above our sky continuously lately obviously with the Barkley to every billionaire bastard club going and they wont fuck off until he's gone to one of them.

Anthony Hawkins
6 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:23:16
Despite now being one of our oldest players Barry has highlighted a number of things all in his first single game.

1. Barry showed more desire and passion in this game than I've seen in an Everton player for a long time. The last player to show it was Neville but his age soon caught up with him. Hopefully Barry's desire will rub off on the others.

2. Barry's fitness level is at least a step above our other players. Can you imagine any of our other players having the strength, pace and sheer energy level to respond to Howard's mistake as Barry did? I've been one of Barry's naysayers but that tackle has won me over.

3. How can a single player outshine the other 10 in his first club game by that much? We played well and did well to win but the players need to step it up a level. I certainly hope Barry doesn't rest on his lorrels.

4. We need to find a Barry style player in a younger package. He's 32 and won't stay nimble and agile for too much longer. I would take him on a free at the end of the season but the wages would be killer.

5. Martinez has the skill to spot talent and build a team that can win. The defence needs firming up but the team looks like it can develop beyond the Moyes era. The mentality seems to be shifting towards 'let's to win this'.

I'm sure there are lots of other highlights, these are the one I could think of.

Tony Draper
7 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:30:25
A flawless performance in his home debut, oozed class and composure

Apparently he lacks pace ? When you are so frequently in the right place it becomes very difficult to judge. Personally I'll swap a player with positional nous over one with pace every single time

He's clearly a football fan with an admiration for the great club that many on TW love (and the rest love to criticise)

Welcome to Everton Gareth, glad to have you in The Royal Blue Jersey

Kev Johnson
8 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:46:13
When players sign for us they tend to make the right noises about wanting to come to Goodison, but Barry struck me as sincere in his regard for Everton. He didn't go over the top but I got a sense that he genuinely fancied playing for us. He's going to be a good fit, I think.

Jamie Barlow
9 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:46:05
On SkySports, Martinez described Barrys performance as "a master class". High praise indeed, and not far wrong. A brilliant performance.
Phil Sammon
10 Posted 16/09/2013 at 08:09:12
Anthony Hopkins

I think I disagree with every point you make there - though I agree Barry looks a fine acquisition.

1.I see that desire every week in Coleman, Jags, Distin, Naismith...

2. Barry made that great tackle after 30 minutes. I don't think fitness had anything to do with it though. He's certainly no fitter than Baines, Naismith or Coleman.

3. He looked superb - I think there were others who played very well too though.

4. We've just paid £13M for one.

5. If there's one thing Martinez already seems to have sorted its the defence...which certainly surprises me!

Other than that...good post.

James Byrne
11 Posted 16/09/2013 at 08:42:25
I was one of the doubters when I knew Barry was coming to us and he proved me wrong on Saturday with an excellent performance.

To be fair the team played well even though we rode our luck at times with some shite passing that put us under unnecessary pressure at the back.

All in all I'm excited about the future of Everton under RM but we all need to be patient.

Lets hope the shite have a reality check tonight at Swansea so we can gloat on our unbeaten run.

Dennis Stevens
12 Posted 16/09/2013 at 08:55:59
Tony Draper # 480 : " ... the great club that many on TW love (and the rest love to criticise) " - this sort of 'better blue' comment is not only unnecessary & juvenile, it's a bit twattish.
Dan McKie
13 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:40:31
I was never one of the Barry doubters, we needed a player exactly like him, and I can't believe City felt that he had no place in their squad. Now City have a midfield where nobody knows what it is they are supposed to be doing, where as Barry will play one of, if not thee most important role for ours.

Liked the look of McCarthy too when he came on, always looking to move forward with the ball. I still think we overpaid slightly, but at 22, he has plenty of time to prove the fee a bargain.

Derek Knox
14 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:58:28
I was an advocate that Barry would be a good signing for us, check the posts if you like, but he even astounded me on Saturday, with his almost flawless performance! The saving block from Et'o, after Howard's howler, was one piece of awareness, which we can all be grateful for. Had he not intervened, that would have been a certain goal, and could have transformed the game.

His knowledge and guile on the pitch, will prove priceless as the season progresses, and as it has been mentioned, the tutelage he will be able to impart to our younger players, will also stand us in good stead!

The other ' bonus ' is that he is a pretty robust player, in that, I mean, the treatment room will rarely be his sanctum.

His age has been mentioned, but so has Distin's and he has about 4 years on young Barry ! I know that Distin is a bit of an exception to the rule, but see no reason, why Gareth Barry can't carry on for another 2 or 3 years anyway.

Last, but definitely not least, we should hail the genius, that is Roberto Martinez, for pulling off another masterstroke!

Sin Miedo! COYB

Ciarán McGlone
15 Posted 16/09/2013 at 10:19:22
Barry was always going to improve us..He's a better player than Gibson.

The other thing about Barry is that he has a footballing brain which gives him great positional sense... Gibson would never have got to that Eto tap-in.

Great signing.

Denis Richardson
16 Posted 16/09/2013 at 10:20:56
Our gain and city's loss.

He may be 32 but if he gives us 2 (even 3) seasons worth of those performances, who cares about his age.

His game doesn't rely on pace so if the wages are not an issue I'd definitely sign him up at the end of the season (if not in Jan!).

Also no fannying around with what his best position is, like a certain Fellaini. CDM - done. We now (at least fo this season) have geniune class in the middle of the park. A proper CDM with great positional sense, not like Neville!

Steve Pugh
17 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:11:12
If Liverpool lose tonight what odds that a dodgy decision or two go against us on Saturday to ensure a defeat? Can't have Everton as the only unbeaten side in the Prem.
Paul Thompson
18 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:16:24
Always said he'd be a good signing. Hard to buy that combination of experience, professionalism and guile. But we have done! We are going to have to see over the course of the season how well he plays and how much he ads, but one question arises straight away - is there room for him and (a fit) Gibson in the same team? I would guess not, at least in that deeper role. Gibson has better passing range, but on every other criteria Barry is better.
Danny Jones
19 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:26:48
I was pleased when he signed and he had a great first game. Let's not forget that the rest of the team played well too. Good start though.
Derek Knox
20 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:24:09
Steve (538)

While I know exactly what you mean Steve, not so sure Swansea will turn the RS over tonight. They will give them a good game, mind you, they have been unlucky with results thus far, and are undeservedly in the bottom three, I think, maybe it will spur them on a bit. (hope so)

As for our next opponents, West Ham, I watched them against Southampton yesterday on Sky and I don't think we should be worried in the slightest. The best player was their keeper Jaskalainen who pulled off at least three 'top drawer' saves.

Let's not forget too, that Lukaku will be not only eligible, but chomping at the bit to play, especially after Saturday's result against Chelsea.

Dave Lawley
21 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:36:03
That must be one the best debut's ever in an Everton shirt, blew me away to be honest, I was expecting nothing more than a solid professional performance, a link man able to break up a bit of play, pass simple and position himself well, that is the opposing fans view of Gareth Barry I think, but he was fantastic, tackling, anticipating, superb passing, driving forward, sprinting back, I did not see that coming!

He must be worth a 3 yr deal at the end of the season off the back of this performance alone, what a contrast to the last bloke who wore the no 18 for EFC.

I am very pleasantly surprised to believe RM may have found a piece in the puzzle and bow down to his insight.

Swap Jela for Lukaku and Ossie for Mcarthy and what a team we have, it looks right, it feels right.

Ray Robinson
22 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:47:47
The goal saving block is the obvious moment to pick out but for me there was another incident at the Park End in the second half when Barry, under pressure, cushioned a really awkward ball back to Baines (I think) to clear. It was pure class! The other thing that I noticed about him was the perfect weight that he put on the pass to keep the forward momentum going. He certainly pinged a few to the right in the first half, which made a change from the under-hit passes that some of our other midfielders sometimes make, thereby contributing pace of counter-attack being lost.
Phil Sammon
23 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:59:38
It's only a matter of time on any thread that someone says something that sends me whirling into a rage.

CIARAN!

Why are you choosing this thread to bash Gibson?

How on earth can you say that he wouldn't have got to the Eto'o shot?!

If anything I'm excited to have Gibson, Barry and Barkley in centre midfield. Three wonderful passers and each one poses a threat from long range.

Give it a bloody rest!

Tony J Williams
24 Posted 16/09/2013 at 12:09:18
Certainly better than the Rhinoesque floaty (or as I call them, twatty) balls from our previous No 18
Eugene Ruane
25 Posted 16/09/2013 at 12:05:48
To be honest I had no idea how it would go with Barry, when we did the deal, I couldn't really get worked up either way ("he'll be shite/great" etc).

Now I know he's only played one game, but if he could give us a season playing consistently with the level of intelligence and hard work he displayed on Saturday, I would be a very happy man.

Ciarán McGlone
26 Posted 16/09/2013 at 12:36:53
Calm down Phil, it's an opinion.

There's an obvious comparison to be made between Gibson and Barry - I think Barry's head and shoulders above him..You don't. I won't go into a rage about it though.

Sharabi Singh
27 Posted 16/09/2013 at 12:56:49
Barry's a top player, so he was always going to be a good signing.
Him and Gibson in midfield will be quality (providing the latter can stay fit). There both defensively sound and are not shy about passing it forward to help the attack. Also McCarthy for either is top class cover as well. He'll learn alot from those 2.
as good as Naismith played on Saturday I would like to see Jelli and Lukaku play together. I can see them two scoring more than if he plays with Naismith.
Main thing is that even though we lost Fellaini RM has bought people in that can still compete with the top teams, which is what we'll need if we want to fight for a european place. COYB
David Graves
28 Posted 16/09/2013 at 14:19:34
The main reason Barry had such a good debut was because he was playing alongside Osman.

Shocked, horrified? Then consider the statistics from Optima. (My lunchtime activity today):

Comparing the two (Barry V Osman) provides the following results:

50- 50s
8 (32% won) v 14 (71% won)

Tackles
1 (100% won) v 6 (83% won)

Interceptions
1 v 4

Dribbled past a player
0 v 2

Defensive errors
0 v 0

Recovered the ball
6 v 9

Yes you guessed it... The better stats are from Osman. Who'd have thunked it.

Nick Entwistle
29 Posted 16/09/2013 at 14:29:24
I just wonder if Martinez is going to keep up this positivity when the tanks are rolling into Baghdad.
Kevin Rowlands
30 Posted 16/09/2013 at 14:41:25
Martinez was also full of praise for Osman, in fact saying the duo were fantastic together, Osman gets way too much stick, he was as good if not better than Barry 2nd half. As for Jelavic, I think I'll leave that for another thread.
Ciarán McGlone
31 Posted 16/09/2013 at 15:01:39
David,

Care to post a link to those stats..

To be honest they don't make sense...

I mean how exactly can you recover the ball 6 times and only make 1 tackle?

And what exactly is a 50-50? Because apparently Osman was involved in 14 of them...

And to suggest that Barry only made a single tackle in the entire game is laughable...

Does the stat for defensive errors mean they didn't give the ball away?

Frankly, these don't make a great deal of sense..

Mark Tanton
32 Posted 16/09/2013 at 15:10:40
Lies and statistics hey... I notice there's not one for giving the ball away, for which Osman would surely be champion.
Shane Corcoran
33 Posted 16/09/2013 at 14:41:51
Steve Pugh, can you explain from the initial steps, how this conspiracy would unfold?
David Graves
34 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:06:11
Ciaran,
Here is the link:
http://eplindex.com/40252/player-performance-analysis-gareth-barry-chelsea.html


I disagree as I think that the categories are fairly straight forward and that the stats make perfect sense.
For clarity - A 50/50 is obviously a coming together of two players to challenge for a loose ball.
Recovering the ball is retrieving the ball once play has broken down.
Have you actually counted how many tackles Barry made? I haven't but was prepared to accept the stat as genuine as it comes from Opta sports - the same stats are used by Sky Sports and most pro teams.

David Graves
35 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:23:33
Mark I'm sure that there is a stat out there for pass completion but I couldn't find it.
I've not put the stats up here to be challenged on their veracity by those that don't understand them as I believe that they come from a reputable source.
I've put them up as I believe they add to the debate on who was most effective in midfield on Saturday.
Ciarán McGlone
36 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:26:54
Cheers Dave...

I'm interested in having a look..

What does 'Defending stats' mean - is this only the stats for our half of the field?

There's no way that the clearing tackle on Eto was Barry's only tackle of the game..

David Graves
37 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:32:53
Ciaran I've been challenged on the stats on other posts but I think they add to the debate. I too was surprised that only 1 tackle is recorded for Barry.
However, I was more surprised by how effective Osman actually was.
Ciarán McGlone
38 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:33:16
Dave,

I don't understand the categories because they don't make a hell of a lot of sense... If you're posting them to support your opinion on Osman then you have to be prepared to be challenged on them....

Here's another puzzling

The stats say that Barry made 1 tackle throughout the entire game - yet he also won 8 50/50s....how can you win a 50/50 without it being a tackle...

That's why I asked clarification of what a 50/50 was...

If they make perfect sense then can you explain the above anomaly?

Tony J Williams
39 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:43:59
The stats are clearly wrong then. I vividly remember a sliding tackle in the penalty box from Barry at the start of the first half. It was even replayed on MoTD when they were discussing him

Statistics .....schmabistics!!

Andrew Clare
40 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:45:41
Fantastic debut from Barry.
I wish people would leave Osman alone, when he puts on that blue shirt he gives everything. He is a true Evertonian like the rest of us.Leave him alone!
Ray Robinson
41 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:58:44
My recollection of the match is that both Barry and Osman had fine games. It is true that Osman gave the ball away a few times when he over-elaborated but he did pinch the ball from the opposition on numerous occasions and intercepted Chelsea passes on more than one occasion - the reason for his being able to do that was down to his reading of the game. He has a good footballing brain - his limitations are nearly all down to lack of pace and physique, but make no mistake, there is a fine footballer in there - he would probably shine even more in international or continental football where the physical challenge is not so demanding.

Barry was just superb.

David Graves
42 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:57:25
Ciaran,
I appear to be presenting myself as the champion of statistics. Believe me I'm not but rather a lunchtime on the laptop has thrown up some interesting info!
I believe that Osman's time is up and hope that the midfield will be Barry and McCarthy... however I think that he has been getting a disproportionate amount of stick for his performance yesterday.
A tackle is going in to win the ball off an opponent. A 50/50 is when two players come together to challenge for the ball so by definition it is not a tackle.

Tony - go onto the FourFourTwo statzone webpage and check out the info.
They're their stats not mine!!!!

David Graves
43 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:04:52
Last statto form me for Mark above:

Pass completion:
Osman 81%
Barry 75%
Barkley 69%

Who's the champion now then?

Tony J Williams
44 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:06:24
I am not saying they were yours David, just putting across the absolute fact that they are wrong, because I saw the two tackles with my own eyes at Goodison.
Chris Jones [Burton]
45 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:59:52
Just adding to the stats assessment question vis a vis Barry and Osman. I note in a regular Guardian feature - 'Premier League: 10 talking points from the weekend's action' - it is Osman, not Barry, who appears in the Premiership 'Team of the Week'. Indeed, with the exception of Aaron Ramsey and Olivier Giroud, he has the best stats of the lot - rated 8.7 (out of 10 one presumes?!

Anyway, the Guardian article is here:

The stats were drawn from WhoScored.com

There's also a nice remark in the piece on their COMBINED contribution to our victory: starting with a quote from RM it concludes "I thought Gareth Barry and Leon Osman were magnificent in controlling [Chelsea, they] ... who were able to train together for 10 days before the game having been overlooked for England's World Cup qualifiers against Moldova and Ukraine. Their rapport was immediate, a reflection of two intelligent players. Ahead of them, however, John Terry and David Luiz gave the distinct impression they have yet to be introduced."

Chris Jones [Burton]
46 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:08:42
Sorry, here's the 'Grauniad' link :)

http://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2013/sep/16/premier-league-talking-points-football

David Graves
47 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:07:49
Ciaran,

Have a look at this website.
It's got some great detail on Saturday's game:

http://www.fourfourtwo.com/statszone/8-2013/matches/694932/player-stats

Sam Hoare
48 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:12:30
Think we can expect to see Barry and Osman together again this weekend. Much to the hate of the Osman bashers.

I reckon McCarthy will get his first start in the cup against Fulham.

Phil Walling
49 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:38:31
Have to admit I've never heard a Manc or a Villa fan say a bad word about the guy. My City-following cousin says their team is always better with Gareth and Lescott in it so I wouldn't mind our old boy coming back in the window.
Ray Robinson
50 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:50:22
Barry also once turned down a move to the Dark Side - so another positive!
Tony Cheek
51 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:41:26
Just goes to show you that we DID do good biz on deadline day. Great to see us still going forward to get that second goal instead of trying to shut-up shop.

Impressed with Barry, thought he played solid and kept our midfield together, deffo a good signing/loan.....and was even more impressed that our Spanish boss uses words like "pristine"!


Tony Cheek
52 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:52:03
..........but was a bit pissed off while watching the United lunchtime game, when the commentators (don't know who) started talking about Fellaini. Apparently he had quoted that the training was harder faster and better at United, To which the other commentator replied that the training will always be better at top clubs like City, Chelsea and Liverpool.....WTF!!!
Phil Walling
53 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:04:52
They just need to work harder at those clubs,the lazy,overpaid twats.
Steve Guy
54 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:22:44
Tony what else can Fellaini say ? What you could read into his alleged comment is that it's back to good old M
Steve Guy
55 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:22:44
Tony what else can Fellaini say ? What you could read into his alleged comment is that "it's back to good old Moyes' training regimes, all that passing about and retaining possession that Martinez had me doing...what's that all about ? I'd much rather chase my own tail for 90 minutes under good old Moysie !"

Either way the Everton players don't seem to be doing too badly on a different training regime ....

Colin Grierson
56 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:29:17
David 608

I watched the game as stated on another thread with a particular eye on Osman as I can't for the life of me understand the level of vitriol he receives from his own supporters on here. I made (albeit less formally) the same claim that Osman outperformed all of our other midfielders in the duties to which he is so often lambasted. It's refreshing to hear someone else talking sense as it gets boring reading clueless posts based on a bandwagon bias against one of our most consistent (though not world beating) performers. Sadly, some posters will never have a jar of glue.

Well said though. Most on here see only his faults.

Drew Shortis
57 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:40:17
I was pleased to see us linked with a move for Barry as I though he would bring a calm professionalism to the midfield, but I wasn't expecting him to be this good! His positional sense is a massive bonus, and I think he fits into the team better than Fellaini who wants to be Roy Keane, but blows hot and cold too often. Barry will give us consistent performances over a whole season. I'm not too concerned about his age as he has never relied on pace for his effectiveness. I have always been an advocate of bringing in younger players and remember being a little disappointed when we spent so much on Distin, but look how well he has done for us. There's no substitute for experience!

I accept that Osman had a good game on Saturday, but I think James McCarthy will take over in the middle allowing Osman to play in his more natural advanced role. Osman does give the ball away too often and is brushed off the ball too easily at times. McCarthy will improve us if played alongside Barry. This will allow Osman to challenge Barkley for the AMC spot and Gibson can give competition to Barry and McCarthy. When everyone is fit competition for places will be intense and we will finally have a very strong bench. Feeling very positive right now!

Carl Sanderson
58 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:50:58
Chris 663:

I came on here to post that link! It shows that Martinez appreciates the great firefighting job that Osman and Barry did in the second half.

Paul Ferry
59 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:46:22
Dear Lord Phil Sammon - 560 - cool down and next time you dive into a thread choose words a tad more carefully.

How on earth was Ciaran in your word 'bash[ing]' Gibson?

He was not bashing Gibson he was stating an opinion that Barry is a better player than Gibson. I for one agree with him on the basis on what I have seen of DG over these two years or so. If Gibson is fit - and in his case that's nearly always a big if as Gibson has played a grand total of 24 games in 20 months and there is no need to tell you that he has started zilch this season - Barry would be my pick with our new pie-eater.

It is simply not possible to rely on Gibson as his crock-record is so dreadful. Don't get me wrong I rate DG but he is not in Barry's league. He has age on his side - 25 - so let's see how he develops over the next handful of years and, the nub of the matter, if he can get a decent injury-free stint to continue to develop.

Paul Melarange
60 Posted 16/09/2013 at 19:11:03
So far, so good; I think he could be a great signing. Barry is the sort of player we have never replaced since Carsley left, he does all the donkey work in a no-nonsense way. Hopefully we will see the best of him (as Gibson is a bit injury-prone) — a hungry player with a point to prove after being overlooked by Man City. It can only be good news for the toffees.

Hopefully this could be one of the best transfer deadline day deals we have done. If it does not work out... back to Man City, if it does and he gets the club under his skin, then we could get a real asset to the club for a few more seasons!

Up the Toffees!

Colin Williams
61 Posted 16/09/2013 at 19:07:01
Drew 687, Osman challenge Barkley for no 10 spot!! Are you kidding? Or taking the piss!!! How the hell do you figure that out? There are players who could also play that role and Ossie is not one of them! The strength of our squad now pushes Ossie further down the pecking order in c/m.


Dave Rusk
62 Posted 16/09/2013 at 19:24:26
Brain Kidd lives near me (Alkrington, North Manchester) and knows I'm a Blue and he raved about Barry. Said he is very fit and looks after himself and if we get him on a free at the end of this season he could play for another 3-4 years. He made the point that a few weeks ago we had 3 holding midfielders (Neville, Fellaini and Gibson) and now two have gone and the third is injured.

ps: I still wind BK up about being sent off for us in the 1980 semi final - which our older viewers will recall we lost after two replays to Second Division West Ham.

Phil Walling
63 Posted 16/09/2013 at 19:59:21
For the immediate future, Barry will be the first name on the team list and Osman the second. Over the season, McCarthy will come more into the picture but not necessarily at the price of either of them. Gibson will be a bit part player as he always has been due to his countless injuries. All this with Barkley getting stronger by the game.

Everton is in a good place!

Drew Shortis
64 Posted 16/09/2013 at 21:54:12
Colin Williams 697
Obviously the attacking midfield role is Barkley's at the moment and if he carries on performing like he has been he should be first name on the team sheet. What I meant was my choice in central midfield would be Barry and McCarthy with Gibson challenging them for a place and Barkley AMC with Osman as backup / competition. I think Osman is a decent player, but he is being asked to play a deep role that he lacks all of the crucial attributes for when everyone else is available and his best position is AMC. I wasn't for a second suggesting he should take Barkley's spot and I fully understand your incredulity if you misunderstood my post ;)
Colin Williams
65 Posted 16/09/2013 at 22:05:56
Drew# sorry about that mate, for one moment I thought you wanted Ossie to take Barkley's place as a number 10 in team!! Started to hyperventilate! :)

Tony Draper
66 Posted 16/09/2013 at 21:54:55
Barry has shown in a single performance that 32 may as well be the number upon his shirt as his age

Distin 35 ?
FFS the guy is THE fastest player in a Royal Blue Jersey

These 2 clearly prove that the "statistical likelihood" of players over 30 being a "poor bet" is not a certainty, by a country mile

Barkley at 19 is likewise not a risk, but an investment in talent above maturity

Football players, like fine wines, are best appreciated when they are ready and they are ready when they are best appreciated

Roberto has made some alterations, taken some risks and also hedged some bets
I haven't seen baby discarded with the bathwater yet, though I never suspected that I would

I want Roberto to succeed, to deliver stylish football and to outstay his predecessor

Si Cooper
67 Posted 16/09/2013 at 22:15:02
A very promising debut and I was one of those who was a little worried that GB wouldn't still have what it takes to properly compete at this level.

Not getting too excited yet though.

Chelsea were always going to play more expansively than our opponents in the previous 3 games and create a stage for some heroics and whilst it is fantastic that players stepped up to the challenge, they need to do it regularly and against all-comers to make this a memorable season.

I thought Ossie looked very poor early on but came more into it as the game progressed. He may thrive with younger legs and wily heads masking his deficiencies whilst taking advantage of his abilities.

What use is a passing stat unless it differentiates between easy / safe and difficult / threatening? What about work off the ball, such as cutting down options for the opponent or creating opportunities for your own team by drawing defenders off? Statistics can never tell the whole story and are no substitute for objective observation.

Harold Matthews
68 Posted 16/09/2013 at 23:36:20
Had another look at the full game and Osman played reasonably well from start to finish.

By the 47th minute Chelsea should have scored 7. Of these really good chances 3 or 4 were sitters.

We eventually got our act together but I hope the coaching staff are studying the first half because something was seriously wrong.

Anthony Hawkins
69 Posted 17/09/2013 at 07:41:58
@464 Phil Sammon, we're all entitled to our opinion and I agree the names mentioned all show an element of the passion and desire and to me Barry seemed a step above.
Peter Bourke
70 Posted 17/09/2013 at 07:53:37
@Harold 778.
Chelsea should have scored 7...Slight exageration my friend. This is football and not every attempt goes in especially if its off target. We should have scored at least 16 goals so far this season but haven't. I would say they had 3 real goal scoring attempts in the first half and we had at least 2 by half time. If something was seriously wrong we would not have kept 3 clean sheets in our last 3 premiership games.
Harold Matthews
71 Posted 17/09/2013 at 08:26:23
Peter . you can theorize all you like my friend. I've never seen a team miss so many easy chances in the first 47 minutes. Fair enough, it doesn't bother you and it doesn't bother many others so I won't go on about it.

Personally, I was delighted with our victory and our performances should continue to improve as the new boys settle in but I'm glad we don't have to face Chelsea every week. They're a top outfit.

David Graves
73 Posted 17/09/2013 at 16:17:37
Si Cooper @ 755. I'll tell you the value of a pass completion statistic - to counter the argument that Osman gave the ball away too often. Simple.
Shane Corcoran
74 Posted 17/09/2013 at 16:35:32
Maybe Chelsea had seven chances to score but there's nothing to suggest that had they scored their frist chance that they would have created the other six.
Richard Lyon
75 Posted 17/09/2013 at 16:55:06
I was delighted with the win against Chelsea but feel we should not get carried away by that performance. Last year against Chelsea we lost 1v 2 but played them off the park for most of the game. What's better, play well and lose or get outplayed and win? The next two games will tell us a lot. We should win both. If we do I think we have a serious possibility of achieving something. The jury is still out as far as I am concerned.
Phil Sammon
76 Posted 17/09/2013 at 17:02:37
David Graves

Osman did give the ball away too often, I saw it with my very own eyes. Simple ten yard passes, he messed an awful lot up. Stats are all very well, but there is a difference between forced and unforced errors that does not seem to be reflected. As previously pointed out, pass difficulty is also important.

James Martin
77 Posted 17/09/2013 at 17:15:14
A few uncomfortable stats questioning the old myth that Osman always gives the ball away all the time. From what I see in a game Osman goes for the difficult forward passes. The likelihood of them being intercepted or the recipient timing a run wrong is always higher than a safety first Fellaini going backwards or sideways. Despite this he's still got the highest pass completion stats out of our midfielders. Maybe that's why Moyes and Martinez have continued to pick him.

Perhaps he's also part of the stat that saw us as with the highest possession share int he whole premier legaue a week ago. Just accept that he's earned the right to be an important cog in our midfield. He may not deserve to play every game, some won't suit him tactically. But he is one of our midfield options along with Gibson, Barry, McCarthy and Barkley. Just be glad that we have some actual competition rather than always looking for a player to be a scapegoat.

David Graves
78 Posted 17/09/2013 at 19:27:03
Phil Sammon yet another missing the point. Previous posters said Osman gave the ball away too often and You say he messed up 'an awful lot' (statistically significant??) The stats show he didnt. Period.
Ray Robinson
79 Posted 17/09/2013 at 19:45:33
I'm a big Ossie fan and thought he had a great game the other night but, to be fair to his detractors, he did get muscled off the ball a few times when slow to release. Don't know whether that counts as lost tackle or misplaced pass, but he can be prone to lose possession when overpowered. How do statistics show that?

There is definitely a place for Ossie in the team. Along with Barry, he is the most intelligent of players. Shame he wasn't just built like an ox as well!

Phil Sammon
80 Posted 17/09/2013 at 19:42:04
David

You can save time by just putting a small dot at the end of each sentence comma rather than writing your punctuations out long-hand full stop.

The point is that statistics can be easily manipulated to suit whatever argument you favour. I don't dispute that Osman is a good player, but he needlessly gives the ball away frequently. Be that by misplaced passes or being shrugged off the ball, it happens, and I cant wait to have Gibson back in the side.

John Crawley
81 Posted 17/09/2013 at 19:57:38
Phil statistics can easily be manipulated is a cliche which is easy to throw out but it would be better if you looked at the statistics on Osman giving the ball away and then compare that with your perception of what happened when you were watching the game. I know in my experience I have watched games live and thought a player has misplaced a lot of passes, then had a look at the stats which show that didn't really happen and then had another look at a replay of the game and found out that my initial perception was wrong. My point being that stats are generally more reliable than an initial perception when watching a game live.
Sean Kelly
82 Posted 17/09/2013 at 19:59:49
I'm amazed at some of the comments here about Ossie and Naismith.

Ossie is on decline and it has been clear since last season that Gollum ran the bollocks out of him and he can't recover. The legs are gone and he physically can't cut it at this level anymore. Get McCarthy in there and let's see what he's about.

Naismith is an honest lad but doesn't perform at a high enough level on a regular basis. Let's see Barkley and the Spanish kid (fuck it, can't spell his name) playing behind Lukaku.

Phil Sammon
83 Posted 17/09/2013 at 20:11:13
I'll always trust my own eyes over statistics.

They have a use, of course, but without context the numbers mean nothing.

Harold Matthews
84 Posted 17/09/2013 at 20:43:07
Shane. Good logic mate. A goal would have altered the whole scenario, especially with Mourinho in charge.
Tim Taylor
85 Posted 18/09/2013 at 13:12:18
I like that Barry wears black boots :-)

I think you can tell a lot about people from their shoes - I have a few pet peeves I won't share (for fear of embarrassment), but they nearly always turn out to be correct in what they tell me about the wearer. I know it was Bally who started the white boot thing all those years ago, but a bit of me retains the view that a wearer of black boots is concerned more with the game and their performance than their appearance or endorsements etc. and is therefore a "good guy". Sad to say it was the first thing I noticed when he trotted out on Saturday (I was watching on TV) - but I bet you I'm right......

James Marshall
86 Posted 18/09/2013 at 13:49:04
I agree, Tim. All this poncing about in flashy green boots or whatever colour you care to mention brings me out in hives.

When I was a lad, I was just happy to have boots on my feet, let alone ones with my name & number embroidered into them.

Give me a pair of Adidas Copa Mundial's any day of the week.

Kevin Tully
87 Posted 18/09/2013 at 13:52:51
Here's another stat, one we should be happy with though!

'Ross Barkley dribbled past seven players on Saturday v Chelsea - the most of any player in any game in this PL season.'

James Marshall
88 Posted 18/09/2013 at 13:51:19
Can I also say, about Ossie.....

If Moyes ran the bollocks off him (which he did) and he's now past it - how come at the same time, he got into the England team?

I thought he was excellent on Saturday - it might be fair to say that the last half of last season, when he was having his bollocks run off him by the old manager, that he was clearly being given too much to do. Now with a decent player in Barry next to him, he seemed to show a lot more of his old self.

Personally I've always liked having Ossie in the side, not least because he's committed, but he's an Evertonian and you don't see so many of those playing in blue (or red) these days.

I know we're all being poisoned by FIFA into thinking football is all about people with interesting surnames being better than your Smith's & Jones's but it doesn't have to be that way.

As someone once said.....you're only as good as your last performance...

Tim Taylor
89 Posted 18/09/2013 at 14:14:43
In fact doesn't Ossie wear black boots too. A black booted midfield - we can't go wrong.
James Marshall
90 Posted 18/09/2013 at 14:30:28
No, he wears silly white or yellow ones.
Tim Taylor
91 Posted 18/09/2013 at 14:46:20
Ah. I'm sure he used to no? Oh well....
Kev Johnson
92 Posted 18/09/2013 at 15:32:38
Anyone remember GOLA boots from the 1970s? Check them out...

http://www.vintage-adverts.com/WebRoot/BT/Shops/BT3325/4A4F/5E28/91DA/2ECA/49D0/0A0A/33E8/D1BB/2011-08-11_124705PM.jpg

Tim Taylor
93 Posted 18/09/2013 at 16:28:15
Certainly do. See they have the clubs referenced in the correct order too :-) And "Black hide uppers" = proper boots.
James Marshall
94 Posted 18/09/2013 at 17:16:38
They look everso comfy. Almost like slippers in fact.
Tim Taylor
95 Posted 18/09/2013 at 17:21:56
My favourite pair were a bit like these http://www.whoateallthepies.tv/kits/149211/football-boots-we-have-loved-puma-king.html, with yellow/gold stripe, c. 1974, they were Puma but probably a cheaper model that looked like these. Sadly, I was shit at football :-(
Phil Sammon
96 Posted 18/09/2013 at 17:43:39
I'd like to urge caution on this one. Fellaini was also a black boot wearer remember.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb