Arrogance, belief and desire in final third

, 16 September, 60comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez knows how well Steven Naismith can play when he's himself, and has sympathy for the difficult time the Scot has had since he arrived at Goodison Park. The manager is looking for the same arrogance, belief and desire from him in the final third, that he saw when Naismith played for Rangers and Kilmarnock.

“I think Stevie has had it very hard since he arrived at the club. He hasn't really been himself.

“I saw Stevie play a lot for Kilmarnock and for Rangers but here I haven't seen the same arrogance or belief or desire from him in the final third. Everything has been safe, or forced. But the way he works for the team he deserves to be himself.

“I want him to forget about the past. I want him to enjoy his football and show his quality on the park. When he does that he is a very effective footballer. He couldn't have got a better birthday present than scoring the winner.”

And Naismith himself described his opportunistic strike: “At the start of the season, competition for places is tough. Unfortunately for Steven Pienaar, coming out of the team gave the opportunity to myself and I'm glad I've been able to score in the game.

“It was a case of gambling (for the goal), so that if the ball is there you are there too. Fortunately enough, Jela got a great header and I was there to put it in.

“It's been a drastic change from last season with the football we have played. It takes some getting used to but it's a wee monkey off our back and now we can push on and get some more wins.”

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Daily Post



Reader Comments (60)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ben Dyke
1 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:06:08
Naismith deserves a lot of praise and I hope his self belief increases now. He was on a hiding to nothing last year. He knew he wasn't first choice and he had no idea where he would play when he came on. He has the crowd on his back a bit as well and he just lacked a bit of confidence. Martinez uses the word effective and that's a compliment. He will never be a Mirallas so will never get us off our seats but he can do a job like on Saturday and I always said his leap is Cahillesque which can be a great asset in many situations. What we need to see to start believing in him more is less miscontroll of the football and more incisive passing but even with these limitations he can bring something like on Saturday.
Terry Murphy
2 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:20:43
Reading through this site, I have never understood the grief Mr Naismith has endured. He could well turn out to be our new Tim Cahill – never the most gifted but a really decent lad who would run through walls for the team... not bad in the air either. Give the lad a chance and get off his back – he'll be able to jump even higher if you do.
Anthony Flack
3 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:28:46
Observant and intuitive from the manager. OMG is this a dream
Peter Thistle
4 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:40:17
Nicely said by Roberto. He has a way with words to inspire players, kinda refreshing. We've all been on Naisy's back but if he keeps getting in the right areas at the right time ( against Chelsea and the derby ) then he will win us over.
David Chait
5 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:37:34
Very encouraging words from RM.. He really does try give the players self belief... I have seen some glimpses of Naismith that are very encouraging.. None more so than his hatrick, even if against poor opposition. Personally I think he offers more end product than Steven Pienaar, who gets a decent shot on target as an anomaly, which I say as a fellow Saffa.

Naismith was exceptional defensively on Saturday and I feel more of threat than Pienaar, so he would take his spot for me. Maybe Mirallas down the left cutting in.. Naismith on the right... Leaving competition with Delefeou.

Sam Hoare
6 Posted 16/09/2013 at 07:57:21
Nice words from the manager and pleased for Naismith who seems a very good lad. Hope he kicks on this season and rams some humble pie down the throats of those on here who wrote him off so completely last season.
Pat Waine
7 Posted 16/09/2013 at 08:04:17
I for one will wait and see.
Al Reddish
8 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:04:28
Hopefully he will keep his place until someone plays well enough to oust him, as it should be. OFM would keep to the same tried and tested players until they were dead on their feet despite how poorly they may be playing. I am hoping Martinez is fairer and awards places on merit.
Ciarán McGlone
9 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:11:36
If he wants to play him, then play him as a striker..There's absolutely no point in talking about 'belief and confidence' whenever you play him as a winger - a position were he has very little merit.
Ciarán McGlone
10 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:13:32
Where^
Tony Draper
11 Posted 16/09/2013 at 08:58:33
Peter (482)
I think he already has won over this particular Blue
The lad scored in a derby and works his arse off
We still haven't seen him played as a partner in a true "forward two", not a hint of complaint from him
It really is about time the saddoes who run him down gave their golf-ball brains a week off and take a good look at what Nais really does contribute by the bucketload
And for the record, I believe that before the close of this season we will ALL value him as a true Evertonian (and this issue of his technical ability will steadily evaporate)
18 Months laid off is a bloody long time for ANY profession, but for a professional sportsman ?
Some have built entire reputations in less time !

Regarding our new manager, it does intrigue me how often commentators here see his remarks & statements as either smarm or placatory
And yet by odds, how increasingly what he says is born out by result

Roberto was not upon my shortlist (despite the misleading bullshit of some parties here), but from the first moment I have enjoyed his intelligent, eloquent and, I believe, sincere & insightful statements
I want him to succeed, and to outstay his predecessor

Just as a side-thought, my Dad (now in his eighties) has often said "I wonder what Harry (Catterick) would make of him ?", oftentimes it's about some "fancy Dan" all bloody pomp and no performance (not necessarily an Everton player)
Applying that line of thought to Roberto & Nais, In my genuine opinion, I think Harry would largely approve so far, he'd have some constuctive words to give. But I think Harry would approve.........at least for now.

Kevin O'Regan
12 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:09:46
Delighted for Naismith, was giving him grief up to now and thought he wasn’t up to it – but Saturday was a big step up and he looked up for it from the off.
Looks like the Scotland game did him good also. Good on you Steven and unless Peanuts is on top form you might just keep him out for a while if you keep that up.
Otherwise great game all round, good hard working team and excited about Barkley. Great job Roberto. Not missing our 2 exited players a bit- still laughing about that.
Peter O'Connor
13 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:27:56
Don't you just love the consistently positive comments from Roberto.
Totally refreshing attitude.

Let's not concentrate on negativity - yes I know its tough to do that as an Evertionian, it's in our DNA!

Dan McKie
14 Posted 16/09/2013 at 09:29:28
I too am pleased for Naismith, and if Martinez can continue to get performances like that from players that were previously pretty useless for us, then he will quickly win me over. Lets hope Naismith can kick on. It did make me laugh on twitter though, the amount of tweets that suggested Naismith had rammed that goal down all the critics throats. Pity they had been sat on it for about 30 games.

I must admit, I saw the starting 11 once I heard Pienaar was out and thought 'Moyes mark 2', Naismith in for Pienaar, and the only player deemed worthy of being thrown straight into the team was the 32 year old defence minded player, but he pulled it off. We had to ride our luck big time in the first half, but you expect that when beating sides like Chelsea. I was pleased to see that we can still dig in.

Ian Burns
15 Posted 16/09/2013 at 10:24:45
For me at the beginning of the season it was:

RM = No.
Naismith = No.
Osman = No.

Change my mind and "two out of three ain't bad"

Andrew Clare
16 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:01:24
I have just watched the game again and I think that Naismith put in a tremendous performance.
This game is all about confidence and our new manager is fully aware of it’s importance.
I also thought that Osman played very well along with the rest of the team.
Isn’t it great to be rid of a negative minded manager! 11 years what a long time!
Roberto is going to make things happen without a doubt.
Dave Lawley
17 Posted 16/09/2013 at 10:55:38
I have to say I always hoped he could step up, he showed, every now and again a little spark, a little something different which led me to believe he could be better than the performances we have seen up to now.

His problem has been the simple things, a little ball forward that I could have done that goes to the opposition or a mis-control that an academy player would manage, there was still evidence of this but he seems to be improving in that regard and nobody can doubt his effort and commitment.

He will hopefully continue to improve now he has a manager that is prepared to give him a chance for 90 mins and believe in the ability he has shown albeit in an inferior league in the SPL.

Also as Ben said at the start he is excellent in the air for a little bloke and regularly wins the headers he has no right to against much bigger defenders, I would like to see if he and Jela could replicate the partnership they had at Rangers but I don't think they will get the chance.

Andrew Clare
18 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:01:24
I have just watched the game again and I think that Naismith put in a tremendous performance.
This game is all about confidence and our new manager is fully aware of it’s importance.
I also thought that Osman played very well along with the rest of the team.
Isn’t it great to be rid of a negative minded manager! 11 years what a long time!
Roberto is going to make things happen without a doubt.
Darren Alexander
19 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:03:24
Really glad to see Naismith getting a bit of a break here. I've always backed him on here because I knew what he could do and still maintain that he was pretty much the pick of the post-collapse Rangers players, but I think that last season his confidence was shattered after being put in numerous positions, none of which were his own. Even if Roberto chooses not to play him in exactly the same way as he was used in Scotland, I'm sure he will at least always be encouraging to the player.

Late last season (Arsenal away?) I was sickened to see Naismith come on as sub and could see/hear no-one else around me applaud. Really? And given that some were happy to applaud the imaginary-card-waving Arteta?

Anyway, pleased to see more and more getting behind him now. I think he's a tireless worker, can do a job defensively, is an excellent header of the ball, and as Saturday's goal proved, has a knack of being in the right place. And I do like the fact that he always puts it all in, a quality that I think our fans have usually been very appreciative of over the years. And whatever we might say of his technical merits, I don't think anyone on here could honestly say that a recently-departed Belgian gave his all for us every time, could they?

Barry Rathbone
20 Posted 16/09/2013 at 10:55:41
Martinez is the best young manager around and has been for a few years, a step ahead with a mind as sharp as a tack he says and does the right things at every turn.

Even for his biggest long term advocate (me!) I can't believe how quick he's transforming players, fans and everything about the club, it really is remarkable.

I just pray to god we get some money in before the "next level" outfits catch on and make him an offer he can't refuse.

We all know there will be at least one vacancy among the trophy purchasers at the end of the season.

Duncan McDine
21 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:18:36
Well I've never liked him as a footballer. I must admit I've always wanted him to do well and prove everyone wrong, especially as you can see he gives his all.

I still don't think he's what we need to move forward as a team, but very happy to see him put in a shift like he did on Saturday when he gets the chance.

He reminds me a bit of Dan Gosling - not really worth of a starting place, but actually pops up with a few goals, and seems to have a knack of being in the right place/right time.

Trevor Lynes
22 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:22:59
We have two fine players in Pienaar and Naismith, each with different pluses and minuses. Pienaar was brilliant when we lost Arteta to injury and he definitely was worth the parity salary he asked for with Arteta and others at the club. I did not blame him for leaving us at that time.

Now we have our strongest squad for ages and our bench no longer looks filled with has-beens, children and neverwases. I reckon that Gibson will have difficulty in getting into our first choice midfield and Heitinga needs another club as soon as possible. Stones is knocking at the door and Barkley is almost established.

I just hope that there are a few more kids upping their game and ready to move up the ladder. Already there have been press claims that a couple of so called big clubs are eyeing Barkley. I hope he stays where he belongs at Goodison.

Phil Bellis
23 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:57:36
Martinez certainly seems to be more of a Shankly "arm around and lump of sugar" than a Catterick "kick up the backside" man-manager
Like his style...just not been used to it for a long time
Peter Cummings
24 Posted 16/09/2013 at 11:53:03
I remarked on Naismith with my son before the game and we both agreed on his work rate which we compared to that of, wait for it, Dirk Kuyt, our hated nemesis from across the park. Against Chelsea, he was phenomenal; he covered every inch of Goodison, won every tackle had the nerve to score and fully deserved the praise of the manager and those,myself included, who questioned his transfer from Rangers. I just hope he continues to get better and win everyone over.
David McKitt
25 Posted 16/09/2013 at 12:22:56
Andrew Clare, how many times did you watch the game!!!!? ;)
Shane Corcoran
26 Posted 16/09/2013 at 15:13:46
Fair play to RM for his comments but is it just me or wasn't Naismith only slightly better than usual.

His breakaway in the first half when he just seemed to pass to the ball to the Chelsea lads that were back rather than hold it up is one I remember.

Paul Thompson
27 Posted 16/09/2013 at 15:14:26
Peter@561. Kuyt is a good parallel. Touch and passing isn't that good, but fantastic engine, very direct and a decent finisher. I suspect that he'll be used as a utility player rather than in a permanent position, but we need players like that. And, as others have noted, very astute comments by Martinez. Honest assessment, but praise too.
Mark Tanton
28 Posted 16/09/2013 at 15:21:41
I'd agree with him only being 'not shit' Shane, and it wasn't a performance of class - because he doesn't really possess any. Still he scored the winner and worked his arse off.

Didn't he just shit himself with the ball when we broke away in the second half though? How can anyone at this level so uncomfortable with the ball, desperate to get rid of it?

Phil Walling
29 Posted 16/09/2013 at 15:46:19
Always said he was a good 'un ! At least for the time being I'll stop prefixing every mention of his name with 'The Useless..........'

Amazing what a goal can do for public opinion!

Mike Gaynes
30 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:01:22
When I saw Naismith here in the US in the preseason, he was the quickest player in practice and looked great on the field. The Cahill comparison is apt -- he wins everything in the air, does a great job of getting into scoring positions and works his ass off defensively.

Naismith's major weakness is he's not comfortable on the ball... can't wait to get rid of it when it comes to him, and often puts his teammates under pressure when he plays it off.

A midfielder who won't attack off the dribble isn't good. A second striker who can't/won't hold the ball is worse. I just wonder what his position is.

Andrew Clare
31 Posted 16/09/2013 at 16:37:22
Dave @565 A lot by the looks of it! Must be a glitch.
Mike Hughes
32 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:07:00
What I like about this story is that Steven Naismith seems to be displaying a lot of character. I like to see players wearing the Everton shirt with pride and hope it continues. No Ginola histrionics or Joey Barton up himself tweeting for me. Whatever a player's potential, 100% must be given on the pitch.

It would have been easy for SN's head to drop but that doesn't seem to be the case. Good luck to him. If he's being selected by RM then he must be justifying that selection in training.

(By the way, a lot of credit goes to Jelavic for the pull back. Didn't look like he'd get there but good, self-less play.)

Harold Matthews
33 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:15:02
Mike G. I remember your comments from the USA and I think you've got him about right. The way he and Coleman shut out Cole and Hazard was worthy of praise but his offloading of the ball was pretty awful. In the circumstances he did a fine job of standing in for Pienaar but this lad needs to be in and around the box as demonstrated by his liaison with Jelavic for the goal.

Managers love his type of player because they are willing to do any job for the team. Yesterday, he did that job particularly well.

Harry Wallace
34 Posted 16/09/2013 at 18:40:56
I've been really impressed by RM's man-management. He picks the right words and it seems to be working very well.
Wayne Smyth
35 Posted 16/09/2013 at 17:54:21
Lifes strange.

A player gets called every shade of shite for the best part of two years, then scores one goal against a good team and all of a sudden he's the next Tim Cahill!

Talk about fickle.

I've never thought Naismith was good enough to play for Everton. I still don't. He works hard; but that alone isn't good enough. He doesn't seem to have the technical ability or belief to play at the top level.

His proper position is centre forward, but we have 3 other centre forwards better than him.

He's probably not a bad player to have as backup, or to play if you want someone who'll work hard and close down technically better players, such as the ones Chelsea have. I suspect this is what made RM pick him at the weekend... and we can't argue with the net result.

I think he has some things going for him other than his hard-work and professionalism; he seems to know where the net is instinctively, and makes some reasonably intelligent runs but he's not much use anywhere outside the 18-yard box. His passing is poor, he has no creativity and despite evidence during preseason, he seems to lack pace. If he'd score 15 a season, I'd be the first to be happy for him to play up there, but I don't think he has it in him at this level.

I'm very much grateful for his goal and hard-work at Chelsea, but let's not get carried away; he's a very average player, but a good solid pro nonetheless. RM's comments are spot on though. Managers need to talk up their players and give them confidence to get the best out of them. OFM used to wind me up no end by belittling our players in public and telling them they weren't good enough.

As an aside, one player I would like to see up front is Mirallas. I didn't think he had the strength to do the job, but his hold up play and pace resulted in a very impressive cameo when he was briefly played there against very good defenders. Looked a completely different animal to his very lacklustre displays on the wing.

Michael Kenrick
36 Posted 16/09/2013 at 20:04:04
The word 'fickle' (Wayne #691) is another I would ban if I had my way.

It's bogus bullshit that easily trips off the tongue, but is almost never even remotely accurate.

The truth here is that we have a player who has probably had a mammoth mountain to climb in recovering from serious injury, sustained before he joined Everton. So few if any of us have likely seen him perform at his best, or (hopefully) anything close.

His performances were poor last season... but he probably should not have really been playing, by the sound of it. However, he clearly benefited from the close season, and just perhaps he is now starting to regain the form Roberto speaks of here.

Some can see that transition... how on earth does that constitute 'fickle'???

Wayne Smyth
37 Posted 16/09/2013 at 20:49:21
Michael, my opinions tend to be more middle of the road than most. Things are never as shit as some people often them sound, and things are never usually as good, either.

What I've mostly been reading the last 2 years is largely how shit Naismith is. How he shouldn't be in the team or near the team, how he's keeping other players out of the side.

Now I'm reading he's tim fucking cahill in his prime after 1 half decent game and a goal. How is that not 'fickle'?? How many people on here would be singing his praises if he hadn't scored the winner?

He worked hard against chelsea; he always does in every game I've ever seen him play. He's still usually been quite useless and way below the standard we need to be aiming at.

If he misses a goal next game he'll be slaughtered on here as usual and everything about his chelsea goal will be forgotten. If you'd like me to use a different word for people who call him shit one week and the messiah the next, I don't mind.

Colin Williams
38 Posted 16/09/2013 at 21:06:37
Wayne 691/728# top comments! Agree with everything you said!! The lad puts in a good physical shift when he plays and sometimes is a Jonny on the spot! but, I believe we have many better players on the bench who are much more effective with the philosophy our manager demands.

Peter May
39 Posted 16/09/2013 at 22:01:27
We had a lot of players under Joe Royle's tenancy who could put in a shift aka "the dogs of war" tag. This was all well and good and in fairness to Joe, his "dogs" won our last trophy but is this what we want to watch ? Attitude, commitment and running through walls are a given for our great Club. Our finest team (IMO) in the mid 80's had all that and more than half a dozen of Europe's best footballers. The Holy Trinity coud do it too and run rings around the opposition.
The point is that RM is finding his feet and so are ALL the players at his disposal. There is some tremendous talent at his disposal, Mirallas, Barkley, Deulofeu, Lukaku, Pienaar to name just a few.
It's early days of course but I get the feeling that Roberto will get as much if not more than Moyes could. If he can put the belief and arrogance and swagger in their step then it will not only be Naismith getting the benefit, it will be the fans too.
Forever Everton.
Andrew James
40 Posted 16/09/2013 at 22:34:53
Mr Rathbone - "trophy purchasers" - love it!

I went to the Fulham and Arsenal matches last season (away) and was really unimpressed with him but I have always been impressed with his attitude. I would rather have someone like him than a Drenthe. (Jimmy don't start!)

But also, with Cahill and Fellaini going recently, we have lost that opportunistic type of player who arrives in the box and is decent in the air. Those two were once top scorers for us so a scrappy player like Naismith might have a long term role. Yes he's not a Super Kev or a Ross Barkley but our most important player across the last decade was an Aussie who had average technique but the heart of a lion and the leap of a salmon.

Jamie Sweet
41 Posted 16/09/2013 at 22:36:53
You have to give credit where it is due, and Naismith had as big a hand in our victory as any other player on the pitch, and not just because of his goal.

He and Seamus completely nullified the threat down our right hand side. His defensive work was actually better than his attacking play.

He is very busy, works tirelessly for the team, covers every blade of grass twice over and does seem to have a knack of being in the right place at the right time.

He does indeed leap like a salmon, it is just very unfortunate that he often has a touch like a fish too!

I think he has 90% of what it takes to be a first class player. Unfortunately there is that 10% of quality that he is currently lacking, but he may yet be able to claw that back through a combination of hard work on the the training ground and an increase in confidence.

I certainly wouldn't write him off yet and he could still be a very useful squad player.

Would be worth considering selecting him on the right against other teams with attacking left backs to do a job on them like he did on Cole. Certainly against Man Utd and Liverpool he might be a wise choice?

Andy Crooks
42 Posted 16/09/2013 at 22:48:15
A good point from Ciarán. I have defended Naismith and thought he was excellent on Saturday. In my view a main indicator of progress will be when we can consistently have players in their best position, To me Naismith just behind Jelavic would bring out the best in both players.

However, I hope and believe that Barkley behind Lukaku will be a more productive option therefore Naismith can be a vital squad player who will do a good job in his best position when we are stuck.

Frankly, I doubt that Everton with Naismith as a first choice striker would be good enough to achieve what we dream of. He isn't shite, though and is a great lad to have in the squad.

Rob Smith
43 Posted 16/09/2013 at 23:00:00
It is just bloody refreshing to have the manager discuss our blokes in a positive way, when did Moyes offer up anything much about our players. Reading what Martinez says about Naismith, sheds light on why we haven't seen his best, was he suggesting Moyes didn't know what to do with Naismith, referring to the tough time he has had here. Never saw Moyes as being much of a confidence builder to our players.
Ernie Baywood
44 Posted 16/09/2013 at 23:48:13
Seems even the people giving him credit are being a little unfair. Everyone gave the ball away on Saturday when we were pegged back in our own half. Nais actually did well with it. He took responsibility and held onto it and tried to create.

The hard work was great, and was a bit above the norm for him. His actual play I thought was very good.

Granted, he's not performed like that for us before, but maybe that's the start of things for him.

Michael Winstanley
45 Posted 17/09/2013 at 00:18:27
To me this tells of Martinez's most difficult challenge. To change the mentality of our players, to play without fear and to enjoy their football.

I thought Naismith was excellent on Saturday and I agree with many of the points raised about his short comings, he's nearly brilliant but not quite. However his defensive work was out-standing on Saturday plus he got the winner.

I think every player will improve under Martinez.

Mike Gaynes
46 Posted 17/09/2013 at 00:29:32
Wayne Smyth (728), be fair. Neither I nor Terry Murphy, who propounded the Cahill comparison, have ever referred to Naismith as "shite"...nor did either of us promote him as a reincarnation of Timmy at his best. He's not, and never will be.

However, what talents he does have, combined with his obvious heart, could help him play a similar role. Like Cahill, Naismith is willing to make 20 runs to get one chance in the right spot. Were it not for a blinding save by our old friend John Ruddy, Everton would have two wins this season... and Naismith would have the gamewinner in both. I don't think that's a coincidence.

James Stewart
47 Posted 17/09/2013 at 01:16:50
Still unconvinced. Has looked very poor on most occasions I have seen him and one tap in won't change my mind.

Its only fair he is given a go but surely it has to be as a striker?
A winger he is not and never will be.

Drew Shortis
48 Posted 17/09/2013 at 09:03:16
Great effort on Saturday by Naismith and the goal was his deserved reward. I would rather see him play as part of a two man strike force as his passing from midfield is inadequate. Hopefully with a bit more confidence and belief he can improve on this, but for me playing him out of position all the time doesn't really say the manager has full confidence in him. I sincerely hope he takes this opportunity to show what he is capable of and proves myself and his other doubters wrong.
Norman Merrill
49 Posted 17/09/2013 at 07:56:06
Trevor 542. There are some more talented lads on the edge of pushing for the senior squad, One is John Lundstram,who is a regular in the England U20 squads. I've watched him many times, & I'm sure Roberto is well aware, of his ability. and the coaches will I'm sure be making the manager aware of other players, on the books.

Tony Waring
50 Posted 17/09/2013 at 12:11:07
Speaking to a mate who supports Chelski; he thought Naismith was the worst player on the pitch! I can't repeat my response on this family friendly site... I thought he had a great game and his goal was hardly a "tap in" – he jumped high and fully deserved his goal.
Tony J Williams
51 Posted 17/09/2013 at 12:29:23
I can see the comparison with Cahill for his headers, he won nearly everyone of the punts up to him......unfortunately no-one was anticipating the flick ons
James Hughes
52 Posted 17/09/2013 at 16:50:15
I love this site like I love my club but Jeez some on here are so curmudgeonly.

The guy was injured and unable to play for 18 months, gets close to fitness and his employers go bankrupt, leaves employer and signs for us. Then threatened with breach of contract by Green. Then Ginger Tossa plays him occassionally preferring others not in form or adding value to the team.Yet some expect him to be amazing every time he crosses the white line.

I am pleased with what is happening at OUR club, we are still unbeaten and Mr Negative has gone. It's still early doors we all know but sometimes I swear if we had Messi some of you would moan.


Wayne Smyth
53 Posted 17/09/2013 at 19:28:00
Mike(784), I think you'd struggle over the past 24 months or so to find many Everton fans who'd compare Naismith with someone like Cahill. I think you'd struggle to find many Everton fans who actually think he's a good premiership player or good enough for a club aiming for the top 4.

Well....this particular week, I suspect many would actually think he's great, but I'm talking about in general after one of his usual hard-working but ultimately average performances which have been his hallmark.

I agree he could play a similar position to cahill, but I think barkley is already streets ahead in terms of ability, with the potential to get seriously good. Naismith would be a good player for a team near the bottom of the prem or a top class player at championship level.

I'm sure he's a nice guy and a really good pro, but I'm just not seeing the potential for him to kick on. We'd probably get a slightly better game out of him played behind the striker, but I still can't see him getting more than 10 a season.

James(895) - Having a different opinion is not "moaning". I don't expect him to be amazing every game; I do however think he's average and will always be average. He did well at the weekend scoring a goal, but I'm not someone who changes his opinion based on one or two performances.

What I've not been seeing is any improvements in his all-round play, i.e. pace, creativity, passing, link up, over a long period of time which would lead me to conclude that we have a player of the right kind of quality on our hands.

Also, you'll note that Barkley had a leg-break was unable to play for ages, then due to the "ginger tossa" was again unable to play competitive football for the best part of 2 years. However, in the short 5 minutes he was sometimes given, he clearly showed potential. Now he has a manager who believes in him, we can see what a top player he might become.

Naismith probably played more minutes than any player outside the first 11 under OFM and I'm sure he got quite a number of starts, so he's not been as hard done by as some fringe players like Barkley or Oviedo neither of whom ever got a sniff.

Don't get me wrong, I'm really pleased for him to have got the goal. I'd love nothing more than him to bang 20 in this season and prove me wrong. I just don't think he's got it in him, now or next year.....and one winning goal against chelsea or a hatrick in his first ever game isn't going to change an opinion which I formed based on watching him play 35 games last season.

Peter Jones
54 Posted 18/09/2013 at 05:18:14
Right on the money twice Wayne.
Max Wilson
55 Posted 18/09/2013 at 10:00:26
Waynes exhaustive analysis is as good as we'll get upon the N subject.
Down here in HERRY -FORD-SHYRE, the locals have a saying "one swallow don't make a summer". Kilmarnock and Rangers played at Championship standard most of us would agree, and N was selected by the "Glaswegian footy mafia" by a paid up member.

He'd have to do a whole lot more to convince us that what we've seen seen he joined us is'nt all he's got.

James Martin
56 Posted 18/09/2013 at 10:16:37
Until he's played in his proper position we'll never know how good he really is. There aren't many strikers in world football that look good when you shove them on the wing even Rooney one of the more versatile ones kicked up a fuss about it. If Barkley is going to be rested at any point this season (perhaps Fulham on Wednesday) then I think it would be a good idea to put Naismith behind the striker. He has the work rate to close people down and he knows how to score goals. The timing of his runs into the box and positioning is that of a natural finisher something we've lacked since Jelavic 2011/12. He wasn't brilliant against Chelsea but he was strong defensively and he has the stones to get it over the white line against the top teams something only Cahill ever used to do regularly for us.
Brian Harrison
57 Posted 18/09/2013 at 10:47:49
I think James you have a point it is difficult to ask a striker to play wide, I think it is a completely different role. I would just add that probably he wouldn't start many games if everybody was fit, but as we all know its not just about having a good 11 you need players to come off the bench that you can rely on. I think it must be more than coincidence that both Moyes and Martinez have used him from the bench, especially in away games when we may need someone not only to try and score goals but someone who will help out defensively when needed.
Colin Williams
58 Posted 18/09/2013 at 15:59:34
"Comparisons with cahill", sorry, not in a million years will that happen. There is no substitute for talent!! Naismith's overall technical ability is very poor for prem standards. The game is getting more technical/ tactical each year and the players who struggle in the technical phase will gradually be phased out unless their exceptional in other area,s of the game, eg Timmy Cahill.

Andy Crooks
59 Posted 19/09/2013 at 01:03:52
Colin, I like Naismith, but like you I wouldn't compare him to Tim Cahill. Here's the thing, though. If someone were to ask me what was great about Cahill I'd find it hard to say. I think he was great but, frankly, I'd be pushed to find someone to compare him to. Different?
Colin Williams
60 Posted 21/09/2013 at 13:01:47
Andy, Cahill has a massive" Heart", his positional play was top class! The leadership he brought to the team was second to non. He could find space in a telephone box!! His ability to find/ create space in the box was top draw. He scored special goals at vital times,his work rate and team ethic was amazing. The guy lacked tech ability and no pace! But he was very special in so many ways!!! We miss his special talent! There is only one Cahill!!!!! True toffee!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb