Baines wanted to leave, says Stubbs

, The Independent , 20 September, 212comments  |  Jump to most recent
Alan Stubbs has admitted that Leighton Baines wanted to leave the club for Manchester United this summer but was refused a transfer in the last weeks of the window.

The Independent claim that "Baines had a series of meetings with Roberto Martinez and the chairman Bill Kenwright asking for them to agree a deal with United," after David Moyes had come in with a joint bid for him and Marouane Fellaini.

United would later split their offers in an attempt to force Kenwright's hand but are reported to have had a final £15m bid for the 28 year-old rejected on transfer deadline day.

Speaking at a Football Writers' Association event at the Museum of Liverpool last week, Stubbs, now the club's Under-21s manager, said: "The way the transfer deadline goes, everyone looks at it and it got to a stage where we knew the Gareth Bale thing was going to happen. That was the big one, underlying from that there wasn't really an awful lot going on.

"Probably come seven o'clock on the night [2 September] at Everton, the word from the training ground was that no-one was going to go. Fellaini was staying. Bainesy was never really an option, the club had dug its heels in. Bainesy had obviously said he'd like to go.

"And then come nine o'clock suddenly we started to get linked with [Romelu] Lukaku and then the Fellaini thing was starting with negotiations with United. By the time it had finished we'd bought three in and they are great additions to the squad."

Quotes or other material sourced from The Independent



Reader Comments (212)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Richard Reeves
1 Posted 20/09/2013 at 11:53:18
I've just seen some articles about Stubbs confirming Baines wanted to go... Great, that won't divide some fans opinions on him, will it?

I was surprised that he didn't go in the last window but I've said it is inevitable that he will in January. Does Stubbs really have to do Kenwright's dirty work?

Gerry Quinn
2 Posted 20/09/2013 at 14:02:23
So Stubbsy reckons that Bainsey wanted to talk to Man Utd – despite RM stating the opposite. This does not look good whichever way we look at it, but I am sure that RM will have his options covered long before the bloody window re-opens in January!!!
Jamie Barlow
3 Posted 20/09/2013 at 14:18:21
Me too Gerry.

Why has he felt the need to come out with this now?

Too tell you the truth, I don't like him. I think he's a bit of a dick.

Steve Beck
4 Posted 20/09/2013 at 14:20:34
Stubbs needs to learn when to keep his mouth shut. All this will do is keep the speculation about our players on all the news reports.

Eddie McBride
5 Posted 20/09/2013 at 14:30:17
As we all know, newspapers only tell the absolute truth, so Stubbsy should be hung drawn and quartered.
Mike Oates
6 Posted 20/09/2013 at 14:35:49
I'm surprised Stubbs, who has continually spoken out abut issues over the last year wasn't given a warning from Moyes . Once again after the dust has settled after the transfer window he has now once again brought out the dirty washing. Martinez needs to get rid asap - Stubbs will never make a PL managers role and causes too many issues with his mouth. Unless of course Baines has had a word in his ear about spilling the beans.

Dan Nulty
7 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:04:51
Is Stubbs for real? How on earth can this have anything but a negative impact on the club? Some fans will now boo Bainesy next home game. Ridiculous decision to go public and I hope Stubbs is sanctioned by the club. Roberto will not be happy with this, expect Stubbs to be gone next summer. Idiot
John Crawley
8 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:04:26
Absolutely no need to make the Baines comment, just stirs the whole thing up again and gives Sam Wallace ammunition to start stirring the shit again!
Kevin Tully
9 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:03:12
Martinez confirmed there were no ongoing talks over a new contract for Baines, which means he's either off in January, or the summer.

Didn't we read he was 'only' on around half of the reported £70k per week Fellaini was getting?

My take on it would be somewhere along the lines of BK saying: "We'll look right twats if we let both of you go to Utd, you can have your move, just give us until January"

Tony J Williams
10 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:03:40
Wasn't it Stubbs who suggested Wayne should do one too?

Why can't these people just shut up for once. A loaded question is asked, respond with a steely glare and say "Next Question"...it really isn't difficult

John Gee
11 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:01:04
So he got tanked and said something that everyone knew already. I mean it's not like it was in front of a room full of journalists, or something we've obviously tried to keep quiet or anything.

... Oh it was and it was?

Fucking hell stubbs you pillock.

Phil Sammon
12 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:07:56
I'm a big fan of Stubbs but this seems a very ill advised comment.

If Baines wants to go then I would let him leave in January. It has to be at least £20M though. Moyes knows this lad will replace Evra – he should be willing to pay the price. If he isn't then Baines stays, keeps his head down like the good lad he is, runs down his contract and leaves with my blessing (my blessing being crucially important to him).

The good thing is Martinez has plenty of time to identify and sound out a replacement. Oviedo is not the answer by the way.

Liam Cullen
13 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:17:13
Could this signal a further attempt in January from Moyes, knowing that the player does want move on?

And, more importantly, do we keep a good player who wants to move on, or capitalise on the situation and try to get a good fee for a player approaching 30 and only contracted until the end of next season?

Phil Sammon
14 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:16:39
*Evra
Brian Harrison
15 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:07:04
I cant imagine why Stubbs needed to say anything about this matter. He is in charge of the under 21s so this has absolutely nothing to do with him. Also I assume he isn't stupid, so what did he hope to achieve by making this information available to the press.

So where does this leave Everton and just as importantly RM, is Stubbs implying that Baines still wants to leave us and will ask for a transfer come Jan. One paper this morning is reporting that Moyes has given up on signing Baines and is looking at the boy Shaw from Southampton.

So whatever the reason is I think Stubbs should be disciplined by the club what form of discipline I will leave to the club. So just when we all thought we had kept hold of Baines and could now look to build with him for the future Stubbs has managed to scupper those thoughts. So we will now view the Jan window with the same fear of losing Baines as we had with the summer window. Thanks Stubbs!!!!

John Keating
16 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:12:20
Dan,

Baines will not get booed next home game, by our supporters anyway. Baines is a top player and rumours of him leaving will be ongoing for all the time he's here. If he goes in January then he goes. As long as we get top dollar for him and Martinez can get a replacement in - if he chooses.

I've seen great players leave us over the years and we're still here. Anyway, why would he want to go to United? After all, Moyes has already said he'll only be back up for Evra – yeah right!

Lee Mandaracas
17 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:17:19
I'm not sure Oviedo is not the answer as we simply haven't seen enough of him to form that judgement yet. What little I have seen I like as I think there is talent there.

What I am incredulous about is that Stubbs has learned nothing whatsoever from the bile he engendered when he openly stated that he had encouraged Rooney to move to Man Utd. Radzinski did the same thing at the same time and was quite rightly shipped out to Fulham. Stubbs being a true blue bought him some grace but that is rapidly running out with me if he keeps pulling stunts like this.

Matt Traynor
18 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:23:39
Tony #453, Stubbs was a shareholder in Proactive - Stretford's agency at the time, and therefore had a vested financial interest in Rooney "doing one".

Never had any time for him since that nugget emerged.

Lyndon Lloyd
19 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:27:19
Have to agree with the previous comments on this one. What on earth is the point of revealing this now, at a time when the feel-good factor is back and everyone is pulling in the same direction?

To echo the sentiment above, just keep your bloody mouth shut and know your place. You're not the manager and aren't likely to be if you can't keep things under wraps... except perhaps at Wigan where there's a similarly leaky chairman at the helm.

Roger Trenwith
20 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:27:39
It's not exactly news is it? OK, Stubbs has never come across as the sharpest pin in the box, and revealing this like he did was a bit dumb, but the fact that Baines wanted away down the road is hardly a revelation.

Let's face it, if you were in Baines's position, you'd want to fulfill your ambition of playing for the top prizes, at the most successful club in the country, would you not? The days when players caught the same bus as the fans to the ground are long gone, and the loyalty with it. Applies in all walks of work life, not just football.

And anyone who boos Baines at the next game needs their heads testing. When he goes, in January or the summer, good luck to him I say, he's been brilliant for us and always conducted himself with dignity.

Gerry Quinn
21 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:31:07
STUBBSY OUT! I like your BBQ sauce, but not the shite you come out with lad!

There, I am the first one to feel better

Eugene Ruane
22 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:16:51
Well 'OBVIOUSLY' he wanted to go.

Jesus wept, simply incredible!

He's like some oul gossip, can't keep his fucking trap closed.

Blabbing the club's (and the player's) private business like Hilda fucking Ogden.

"Well you never 'eard it from me chuck but (looks around conspiratorially) but Baines WANTED to go" (taps nose).

I really hope Martinez kicks the big gozzy-eyed galoot out, in my book he should have gone over Rooney.

Twat!

Cindy Cole
23 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:40:04
Time he was stubbed out.
Neil Favager
24 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:36:14
Stubbs should remember his place and confine his comments to the role he performs at the club.

Try this in future Stubbsy - "That’s a matter for the manager to comment on."

Kevin Sheedy could do with heeding similar advice as well after mouthing off at a supporter’s function in Southport last May.

Tony J Williams
25 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:42:49
Strange that we seem to keep getting twatty news right before our games isn't it?
Harold Matthews
26 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:18:14
Impossible to replace.
Richard Waters
27 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:47:19
Here we go again... seriosuly lads..

Baines is the 1st/2nd best laft back in the world depending on who you believe.

United were in for him.. we all know this...

Baines did as anybody else would've done.. If the right offer comes in for me boss, I'd like to go to play CL football and enhance my career etc etc.

The right offer didnt come in, he never went, he never kicked up a fuss, he's still an Everton player...

Stubbs has done nothing but state the fucking obvious..

Have a day off..

Dave Roberts
28 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:48:39
There's another slant to this. BK wants to show how 'tough' he was in refusing to let Baines go so he gets Stubbs to say so. It also oils the inevitable departure of Baines in January when Bill will be able to say something like....'well we did our best to keep him and we did in the summer, but we just couldn't manage to ensure he stayed this window....hey Robert, is that £12m in the bank yet?

Maybe Stubbs was just the mouthpiece.

Michael Evans
29 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:46:16
I agree with previous comments that Stubbs should either be disciplined by the club or asked to leave quietly.

Amazed that he could be so stupid in commenting on such sensitive issues.

Simon Temme
30 Posted 20/09/2013 at 15:53:00
Stubbs has shown that he is certainly not management material with this gaff.

Credit to Baines, he didn't hand in a transfer request and is getting his head down like the true pro he is.

Now for a couple of improved performances please Leighton.

Roger Trenwith
31 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:02:21
@473 Richard - Well said, that man!
Ross Edwards
32 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:10:04
It seems after persuading Rooney to leave, Stubbs is now trying to persuade Baines to leave.

Who next? Barkley?

Why is a man who works for us trying to effectively get rid of our best players.

Get rid of him. He clearly had his own interest at heart in that interview.

Ken Crowther
33 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:02:44
I was reading down the thread; and asking myself why nobody was asking what I thought was the obvious question - with his previous history (re Rooney) why would he put his head on the block? Answer, for me, he got a bit of encouragement 'from upstairs'.

Then, sod me, Dave Roberts #474 steals my thunder.

I think you've got it in one, Dave.

Dave Roberts
34 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:03:22
Richard Waters

You may well be dead right....but that's not the point. The point is it wasn't Stubbs' place to vomit it all over the place (unless of course I'm dead right and Stubbs was just the mouthpiece!!....that was supposed to be a joke by the way)

Football supporters are sensitive souls and the media prey on that kind of thing. Every time Everton or England appear on the box now commentators will be making references to Baines and his desire to play for Man Utd. I can just imagine it....'that was an excellent cross from Baines, and that's something Manchester United have been missing this season. Perhaps they can look forward to that kind of service after January can they Peter?' (or whoever)

This could also have an effect on team morale after a while . I'm not denying Baines' professionalism but I despair Stubbs' lack of it.

Tony Fearns
35 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:11:55
If he really wanted to leave he would have handed in a transfer request. Sounds as if he he has said he wouldn't mind playing in the C/L for the dirty manc shiite.
Eugene Kearney
36 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:11:21
Why not just ignore it, forget about it - go back to the feel-good spirit that's come upon us recently?
....before there's 685 posts on this artice!

WHU 0 - Everton 3.

Dave Roberts
37 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:17:12
Tony....don't call the Mancs 'shite'. That word is reserved for somebody special. How about 'faecal matter'?
Chad Schofield
38 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:11:21
Eddie McBride #445, they'd get sued if made up that Stubbs said this. It's doubtful he phoned up and told the reporter this, but a naive and inappropriate thing to say. Why would a man who is contracted as an employee of our team say these things about a player who is under contract? I don't know... but there's no way that they would have just made up that our under-21s manager said "Bainesy had obviously said he’d like to go."

Yes, they may have added some strength to his words in the way they've reported it... but it's not like Stubbs doesn't know how the media works.

Chris Hockenhull
40 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:19:08
Totally agree with most of the comments above. Soon as I read this this morning I thought 'Why?'. What is the point of Stubb's comments now when we are trying to get things settled. He totally undermines Martinez here and should be shunted out asap. He is a club employee and in any other organisation there are 'whistleblower' policies in place so I assume EFC should have one in place and therefore should be clear that this sort of fifth collumist shite gets it's due rewards. Careless Talk Costs Jobs should be placed for all employees to adhere to
Kevin Jones
41 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:14:57
Apparently, and this is a my mates uncles window cleaner type of thing, is that Leighton had a personal text from Moyes telling him to put in a transfer request, against the rules by the way. Bainesy texted back saying " why do you want the people of Liverpool to hate me so much, I'm staying here.

There you go, straight from the horses mouth, via a window cleaner, two milkmen a lorry driver and 3 other horses. he just said neeeeeyyyy

Ross Edwards
42 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:22:10
I didn't know you could see into the future Eugene Kearney.
Mike Gaynes
43 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:17:57
Poor Stubbs. Too many headers. Brain damage and loss of mouth control. Idiocy.

Good point from Tony Fearns... if Bainesy was truly committed to leaving, he'd have done as Fellaini did and handed in a transfer request. But if he wants to go, he'll have another chance in January.

And while I would be heartbroken by his departure, I say Oviedo is definitely ready to step in. I've seen a lot of him in World Cup qualifiers, and he's quality. Not Baines, but pretty damned good.

Brian Harrison
44 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:12:03
Amazed how some fans make out this is a ploy by Kenwright what a load of bollocks. This is a stupid employee opening his big mouth, and to achieve what exactly. Some have said well he is only stating the obvious, so those fans must think that RM is a liar because he has told us that Baines was OK with what had happened and he was a top professional and its all a ploy by Kenwright.
Ian Burns
45 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:15:24
Dave Roberts and Ken Crowther have got this absolutely spot on - there is no mystery when you look at the way this club is run.

Although I would be lying if I said I also thought of this, now it is pointed out by Dave and Ken, I can see as clearly as I can see my gin on a Saturday night - which believe me is very clear!

Don't forget to close the door on you way out Stubbs.

Jimmy Kelly
46 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:17:51
Have to agree with Richard Waters, this is a real storm in a teacup.

I did say at the start of the month when everybody was deifying him and talking about erecting solid gold statues of him that he'd done exactly the same as Fellaini only the right bid hadn't come in. Hell, even when confronted with a load of scouse ninjas in his car asking him if he was leaving he couldn't bring himself to say 'no, I want to stay'.

This isn't a criticism by the way, there isn't a footballer in the world who wouldn't have their head turned by a beter offer from a more successful club.

Jason Heng
47 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:24:11
If we get 50 million pounds for Baines and Barkley, that's half a new stadium, no?
Eugene Kearney
48 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:25:58
Ross 489 - sitting out here in France with the sun shining on my crystal ball!!
Mark Tanton
49 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:29:09
Baines's best chance of leaving was this summer - after that his value for money seriously begins to decrease; I think he can probably kiss his Man Utd move goodbye now. Very good for the club, but not so good for Baines. Ah well, such is life - he is still a millionaire and idolised so perhaps that should soften the blow.
Carl Sanderson
50 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:22:22
Sam Wallace wrote a few articles regarding Baines during the window. Given that Baines doesn't appear to play the media game I wondered who Wallace's snouts were. Now I think we have the answer. Stubbs is ranging beyond his brief; I would hope that Kenwright sacks him if I didn't suspect Teflon Bill of (at least tacitly) agreeing with him.
Carl Sanderson
51 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:32:15
Mark 496,

I disagree; I think we are already being softened up for a move in January.

Ross Edwards
52 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:36:14
Eugene 495

Could you tell me next week's lottery numbers please?

Ross Edwards
53 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:40:45
If this was a Kenwright plot, it wouldn't be Stubbs as the mouthpiece. It would be from someone higher up the chain.
Lee Mandaracas
54 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:31:21
It's not about whether Stubbs stated the obvious or not. It's about whether he had any right whatsoever and what were his motives?

Here's a hypothesis for you Richard (473) & Roger (477). You find out that your wife screws around behind your back. What the feck gives me the right to tell the world that is happening?

Baines kept his own counsel, acted impeccably and can continue to hold his head up high. I don't care whether he wanted to leave or not. I care whether he wears our shirt with pride and continues to be one of the few in this industry to actually earn their wages. To me, he will stay up there with Arteta & Cahill

Ken Crowther
55 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:40:51
Eugene #495 - What's the other ball made of?
Eugene Kearney
56 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:50:44
Roos/Ken
Don't have lottery numbers- sorry. The crystal ball at the moment is the French betting system online.
Just about to go to the café and put a couple of wee bets on for the weekend.
Odds are -WHU 2.90/1 to win. Everton 2.25/1 and a draw is 3.15/1.
Ken Crowther
57 Posted 20/09/2013 at 16:58:49
Eugene #509, I'm still interested in the material content of the other ball!

However, despite the fact that I think we can get a win tomorrow, I'd be very tempted by 3.15/1 on the draw. The odds against a draw in almost any match in the Premier League comes within a fraction of 5/2.

Linda Morrison
58 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:06:27
Think Baines has lost his chance to move to MU, Moyes will be expected to go for big players now, whoever they are.

Stubbs should have kept his gob shut but he hasn't told us anything new, it was all in the papers for weeks over the transfer window, Does anyone know what's happening bout this new contract?

Ross Edwards
59 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:15:57
So why Linda in many papers is Moyes being linked with a Southampton Left Back for £25 million?
David Chait
60 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:13:24
Honestly this is a serious breach by Stubbs.. Wouldn't be surprised if he went on the back of this.. Probably will be ignored, but I would respect RM more if he threw Stubbs out for this..
Brian Denton
61 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:11:32
When did we acquire the second Eugene? Damn, I can see confusion ahead.......
Eugene Ruane
62 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:12:20
Ross (502) - "If this was a Kenwright plot, it wouldn't be Stubbs as the mouthpiece. It would be from someone higher up the chain"

And probably someone who could be a mouthpiece without covering the front of their shirt in drool.

Al Reddish
63 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:17:39
At the end of the day Baines is still here and is not publicly kicking the door down to leave. Wait til after the world cup and let him leave with our blessings to play on a stage his talent deserves to be, so long as we don't make it to champions league ourselves.
James Royston
64 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:04:39
I really like Stubbs as a player but he has an apparent history of stories like this,.. is he an enemy within....
It may be true and not the most well kept secret in the football world , BUT even if so why stir it up again now ?.... There couldn't possibly be there is an ulterior motive perhaps for his old buddy/boss, could it... NO.... they are all to honest and upright for that aren't they ?????....
Surely this could well be a breach of contract and if so the club should publicly (just as he has done) discipline him or preferably just get rid NOW. Duncan is a reported good replacement for U21s.
Peter Cummings
65 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:08:55
Biggest surprise to me was Bainsy not going up the East Lancs along with Felli, thinking a Kirkby lad had showed his loyalty to the fans and the club by refusing to go, but at the same time wondering why he had no comment to make on how he felt personally about the speculation.

Now, according to Stubbs, it seems he was inclined to make the move and was upset not to, like most of the posters, if this was the case it will disappoint those who thought it was a case of 'loyalty' and he's now only biding his time until January. Stubbs has made a rod for the guy's back by shooting his mouth off and should be shown the door asap.
Denis Richardson
66 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:26:30
As already mentioned above several times, there was no real need for Stubbs to say this in public.

On the topic of Baines, I hope he signs a new contract soon. If a new contract has not been sorted by xmas then the club should try to cash in in Jan. Once we get to summer next year when (I beileve) he'll only have a year left on his contract, we're not going to get much for him.

If Moyes wants him that badly and is willing to pay around 15m-20m in Jan, then I say take the cash and give it to RM. Baines is a great player but under the new playing system am not sure he'll provide as many assists/goals as before anyhow.

Wouldn't mind bringing in Luke Shaw as a replacement if Bainesy went...

Peter Thistle
67 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:32:38
FFS Stubs, keep yer dopey mouth shut. Zero reason to say any of that but he couldn't help himself, dumb arse.
Nick Entwistle
68 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:34:41
Of course he wanted to leave, why wouldn't he? Would he prefer to reach the top with Everton than Utd? Yes. But he knows the likelihood of that as much as we do.
Eugene Ruane
69 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:41:26
Brian (515) - "When did we acquire the second Eugene? Damn, I can see confusion ahead"

Hummm..yes I can see how it WOULD be confusing, two people with the same first name.

Still if it helps, just think of me as the Eugene who was named after the 4 popes who were named Eugene and Eugene Kearney as the Eugene whose parents just liked the name.

If Eugene Kearney was ALSO named 'papally' then I can't help and confusion seems guaranteed.

Unless...well it's a long-shot but..how about (and I feel daft even suggesting it) but...looking at our fucking twatting surnames!!

Tony Doran
70 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:36:09
Any one upset at Stubbs for coming out with this has a good case, he should be let go asap. But any one suprised by the content should be lorded off to the quacks. Of course he wanted to go, so would I and i'd also advise my son to go. It's a no brainer going to a higher profile club for more money, more oportunities to win things. Saying this but Everton is the club I support but until we show the same ambition as others that's the plain facts.
Ross Edwards
71 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:49:27
Can't see any confusion Brian to be honest with you. Although, when you do get confused, use their initials, ER and EK, and you have (say in Yorkshire Accent so you get it) Er EK! (Oh Eck if said in Yorkshire dialect)
Mark Taylor
72 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:40:49
It's hard (albeit not impossible) to believe that our under 21 manager is as stupid as these comments suggest.

So my money is that he is preparing the ground for a departure in January.

Unlike many on here, I don't actually oppose that. Yes, Baines is an excellent player but he is also getting to the point where we won't get decent money for him and I do think it is legitimate for us to optimise transfer income- Wenger for example, always had a knack of shifting out some of his best players for top dollar, just at the right time and using to money to re-build (Marc Overmars, anyone?). Given the choice, I'd sooner lose Baines, but keep Barkley.

However, I am somewhat more jaundiced about this probability because we still have- according to Kenwright- most of Fellaini's transfer revenue to spend but I think this money will be muddled up with receipts from Baines' transfer and we will end up with a somewhat less good replacement for Baines and another negative transfer balance.

Like a few others on here, I watch BK and our board like a hawk. Not so much because I object to their asset stripping (though I do), more because their claims not even to be doing so hack me off even more.

Max Wilson
73 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:53:17
No-one seems interested in assessing whether our Bainesy still wants to play for us:Is his heart in it? Or in Old Trafford with Shrek?

As for Stubbs. Speculation about sensitive subjects which affect the morale of the whole team is a no no. Definately agree with those that would give him the elbow . Lets be kind. It was stupid. Now lets be managers. Sorry, we can't have this, we'll have to let you go.

I hope Bainesy plays a blinder tomorrow and shows us he's a good Evertonian. He could be in the hall of fame if her stays.

Eddie McBride
74 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:27:02
Chad Schofield #484. I actually posted that comment on a different thread, and it was moved across by our esteemed editorial team. While I now realise that he stupidly did make that comment, I do think you are naive to think the press are unable to manipulate the simplest of comments. Without leaving themselves open to liable.

Are you any relation to Dave now residing in Kidderminster.

Richard Reeves
75 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:28:04
The only thing in this article that we didn't already know about,100% for sure, was that Baines wanted to leave... so why mention something now that could create some negativity amongst fans to a player who has behaved with dignity and treated our club and fans with such respect?

Could it be a way of creating a transfer for January, a message to Moyes that he doesn't need to look elsewhere? Remember, Kenwright's business model is to sell to buy... so the only way the team can rebuild with younger players is to sell the ones that will bring in big money. It's what he's always done and will continue to do.

Martinez must know that Baines will more than likely be going in January and I'm sure he has ideas about who to fill that position with... one of those options for the near future being Garbutt — I do think the lad is very much in his plans.

Eugene Kearney
76 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:02:19
I was only named after one pope!! he was in the chair when I was born!!
So the first Eugene here was born four times?

Simple - no confusion.

I came across this site about a year ago and only signed a couple of months ago. I enjoy the banter and the "cultual" input you all bring to these articles!!

It feeds me with bumf to spout about to my French friends!

Keep it up - it's great craic!!!

Lewis Barclay
77 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:05:16
Maybe this is an intentional "leak" by the club because Baines won't sign a new contract?
Why would he, he wants to go, and knows OFM won't pay over the odds for him in January.
As much as I like Baines I get a feeling this could end up turning very sour.
I'm sticking with the club on this one and hoping that they are in fact managing the interests over a want away player very well.
Eugene Ruane
78 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:49:20
Tony (526) Agree completely but it's not the content that I think anyone has a problem with.

If we remove our Everton heads for a moment and look at what was (possibly) on offer for Baines it was Champions League, a good (much improved) chance of trophies and maybe another ten to twenty grand a week in his bin, so I think most of us know that had the right money been offered, he'd have gone.

However right through the transfer window, whatever was or wasn't going on, the player did the right thing - kept his head down and said fuck all.

There were no relatives crying to the paper to let him go, no transfer requests and when the window closed and he was still our player, whatever he was feeling, he'd come out of it well.

He was in a good position with supporters as we (even it was complete delusion) could applaud his 'loyalty' and say 'onwards and upwards'.

We could tell ourself "Maybe he WANTED to stay" or "Yeah, I heard he didn't like Moyes" etc etc etc.

Now after four games and on the eve of our fifth, this big soft gossiping tart decides the world needs to know "Hey he DID want to go you know".

I imagine when Baines himself heard he must have put his head in his hands and muttered "You dopey useless CUN..."

And if he did, he was right.

Ste Traverse
79 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:29:27
Many of us have always thought Stubbs to nothing be nothing but a gobshite. I never took to this phony when he was a player with us.

The rumours of him being shop steward in a player revolt against the management during the disastrous 2003/2004 season and him publicly advising Rooney to leave at the end of it, then rumours he made a few quid for himself when Rooney left.

What he thinks he's going to get out of these comments I don't know. Another few quid, perhaps?

Time for RM to get this bad apple out of our club...now.

Brian Denton
80 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:37:05
Eugene (525) the single word 'Eugene' has previously been enough to guarantee an interesting read, since as far as I know you were the only one. However, it was only meant as a gentle tease. I shall take my 'fucking twatting' admiration elsewhere....
Raymond Fox
81 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:04:58
If its true what the papers say, we don't know for sure.
If it is, lets face it you only need to look at stubbs to see he wasn't in the front line when they were dishing brains out!

Those saying he might have been put up to spill the beans, have been watching too many detective programmes, methinks.

Roberto should fire him off so fast, his feet wont touch the ground.
He shouldn't be that difficult to replace with another coach, David Unsworth for instance, he might have come in at a very opportune time!

I think I might be viewing Mr Baines in a slightly different light from now on though, if we get a fair offer, let him go.

Steve Guy
82 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:47:01
For the conspiracy theorists, fuel will be added to the fire if the contract promised by the Dear Leader fails to be signed (or even offered) any time soon. My money is on no new contract and Baines gone in January (although I sincerely hope I am wrong)
Alan Smith
83 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:50:55
Get off his case! He said 'Baines obviously wanted to go'. Which is exactly what it is; bloody obvious. Every single one of our players wants to go to utd. Moyes knows this, as does anyone with a brain. Stubbs stating as much wont affect anything.

Non of the players will loose any sleep over it. But typical fan over the top reaction on here.

Trevor Lynes
84 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:57:18
Whatever the truth is 'so what'??
If we are doing well and challenging for Europe by the time the next window comes around maybe the lad will stay ?

He is on contract and he is a professional so will honour it.
The truth will come out if he refuses a new contract at enhanced rates of pay. Until then its hardly worth chatting about. In the meantime he is playing well and its in his best interests to continue playing well to remain of value.

Eugene Ruane
85 Posted 20/09/2013 at 18:53:43
Brian Denton (543) - It was taken as a gentle tease and my response (I thought) was in a similar vein (maybe swearing always seems aggressive when written down.

Still not to worry, your response gave us (imo) TWs best line of the day.

"I shall take my 'fucking twatting' admiration elsewhere"

Lovely stuff! (nb: not my words, the words of TV Quick).

Brian Denton
86 Posted 20/09/2013 at 19:08:45
Okay - shake little fingers.
David Holroyd
87 Posted 20/09/2013 at 19:10:55
Martinez spoke yesterday about Baines and said they Arne't in contract talks with him seems ominous
Brian Denton
88 Posted 20/09/2013 at 19:22:52
And here was me thinking Sir Leighton was in the Stuart Pearce/Matt le Tissier mould of loyal players. Sigh.............
Jackie Barry
89 Posted 20/09/2013 at 19:37:52
If I was RM and stubbs didn't run this by me he would be out of a job right now. Nobody would talk about things like this without my say so, I am the manager and everything goes by me.
Peter Foy
90 Posted 20/09/2013 at 19:34:53
We have to sell him because we're skint. This is just the start of the discrediting of Leighton Baines.

We've been here before.

Who was the player from Kirby heavily involved in the promotion of our proposed move to a 78m pound cowshed in Kirby?

Wayne Smyth
91 Posted 20/09/2013 at 17:55:18
Doesn't surprise me that he'd say such a thing.

Years ago, when he was in the first team, I vaguely recall a sky sports interview with one of the other players who said that out of the entire squad, stubbs stood out as being particularly dim.

I'd like to see Rhino given the u-21 job. I was really impressed after reading his views on coaching and the effort he'd put in to see how things are done in different countries.

Tony Fearns
92 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:09:57
This punch drunk talking whopper has now put a lot of pressure on the relationship between the fans and Baines. If he has a bad game the fans will wonder if his heart is still in it.
Colin Glassar
93 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:33:04
Stubbsy should've kept his gob shut. He's not a club spokesman and should be fined or disciplined for being a big mouth.
Sean Patton
94 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:29:04
Ah the oracle that is Alan Stubbs a man who thinks everyone hangs on his every word, he even went around telling anyone who would listen that he was a shoe in for the manager's job this summer which was why his odds were so short.

I can't stand him for many reasons and I genuinely fail to see what he contributes to the club.

Peter Cummings
95 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:18:03
If we have any ambition to compete with the 'big boys' we must stop being a breeding ground for them to loot our best and brightest. At the moment, we seem to have a veritable Pandora's box of riches, with the likes of Barkley, Mirallas, Deulofeu, Barry, Gibson, Stones, Lukaku, McCarthy, etc, to name a few. With this amount of talent, I see no reason why we can't compete for the ECL on an equal footing with the so-called best, which means no-one would want to leave...

This could be our season.

James Brand
96 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:47:10
After the Rooney comments and now this I cannot see how this doesn't make his position untenable.

Martinez will and should be furious. Martinez can also fire a shot over the starboard bow by sacking him to send a strong message that although he comes across Mr Nice Guy, fall out of line and you're gone!

P45 for Stubbs!

Darren Hind
97 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:10:57
Did he mean to cause unrest, or is he really so fucking stupid he cant see the damage he has caused ? This is right up there with Kenwright telling the waiting press that Martinez promised him CL football. Absolutely no need

How did we allow these Kirby advocating fuckers a platform to speak on behalf of EFC ? The embarressment they cause us is seemingly never ending

Oliver Kearney
98 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:01:59
Can't believe this idiot was actually in the running for the manager's job.

Can you imagine his weekly post-match interviews?

Scary!

John Gee
99 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:49:50
Peter Foy, it's Kirkby, the "Kirk" is Norse (I think) for church. It's a silent second 'K' and it's a relatively small town so I'll correct you but forgive you pal!

Alarm bells ring for me with these somebody tells a journalist something stories. It's indicative of that someone trying to manipulate their way to the top by feeding stories to the media to boost their profile. Being from Kirkby myself, I'd love for Stubbs to be an Everton legend but he's either doing Bill's dirty work or acting selfishly. He's not fit to lace Southall's boots with these comments, whatever the motivation was.

He should walk. Just another selfish dickhead who sees Everton as a place to promote himself. And take Graham sharp with you. Hang your head in shame.

Darren Hind
100 Posted 20/09/2013 at 20:10:57
I blame the arl corpy John.

The 44D ran down Scottie, up the valley, past the old lady and along the lancs for yonks with kirby on the front. When it was finally picked up and the second K was inserted, half of Liverpool thought it was going somewhere else

Jimmy Sørheim
101 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:20:54
This just goes to show that Stubbs is even more stupid then a dove.
I mean when did he become the communications director of Everton?

I wuill personaly write an e-mail to the club and ask that they fire his arse .

I have had enough of his Moyes lovin fake shit.

Peter Foy
102 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:18:39
John,
apologies for my spelling. It's one of those where I hesitate each time I write it but never bother to check. I'm sure I get mixed up with the spelling of Kirby as in West Kirby. I think.
Ross Edwards
103 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:27:09
Alan Myers usually replies to fan mail Jimmy.
James Royston
105 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:24:10
Looking at most comments not many are naïve enough to be very surprised at the content of the comment(see Tony @562). But that does not in the least excuse the unwelcome tactless messenger, he should be out on his backside already. Where would he find a new post "HUGE BIG????" obviously not wanted & not chosen at Old Trafford....Promote Duncan and/or Rhino.....
Andy Walker
106 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:24:28
What a complete fucking idiot Stubbs must be. Can you imagine what Baines must be thinking now? How about: "They wouldn't let me go but I understood and I didn't put in a transfer request as I felt a sense of loyalty to the club. Now I've been shafted as the bastards have made a highly confidential conversation public. What a bunch of wankers, I will be off in January, fuck 'em."

Sack that complete fuckin numpty Stubbs.

Callum McNab
107 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:25:07
Stubbsy is the least of our worries,no doubt Moyes and Billy liar will discuss him in there weekly phone calls.
Ross Edwards
108 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:34:04
Moyes can take him then Callum, and BK can take himself to Old Trafford with his lover as well.
Paul Smith
111 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:40:39
The truth should always be out there for fans no matter who it comes from. Fans cry an moan for being kept in the dark an now theres comments of 'why is he saying this now'. Would you have preferred he said it during the window? Personally i've been suprised with all the praise Baines has got for still being here when I thought it was quite obvious he wanted to go. Hes a local lad and never once committed to us during the window. I'm glad hes still here but don't doubt for a minute he'd want to leave and to all the ones who love to moan about anything, think back to the commitment of Stubbs and be content with truth for a change.
Kunal Desai
112 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:44:26
I hope Baines stays with us for a few more years, but if he does decides to leave either in Jan or in the summer then so be it, he's given us 6 odd years service, arguably he's reached his peak playing years with us, he'll be turning 29 end of this year. If he goes then I won't be-grudge him, it's not like he's wanted to jump ship after a season or two. Based on the business Martinez did on deadline day, I trust him to bring more than an adequate replacement to fill Bainsey's void should he leave. Oh and Stubbs should be reprimanded by the club for speaking out of 'terms'.
Colin Glassar
113 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:45:05
Darren Hind, I don't remember the buses using kirby instead of Kirkby and I used the 44D, the 545 and the 19B zillions of times. Still doesn't stop Stubbsy from being an absolute dickhead. He was at school and he remains so today.
Paul Mackie
114 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:45:53
Baines wanting to leave is hardly a massive secret. Personally I think, as long as his performances don't suffer (which they probably won't as he's a model pro) we should just let him run down his contract.

Unless of course a suitable replacement is found in which case cash in come June. No way we should be disrupting our season to sell to Man U in January for the sake of a few million extra. Fuck that noise.

Lewis Barclay
115 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:52:54
Is Big Dunc still at the club!? Shouldn't he be next in line for the job of looking after the under 21s?
Ross Edwards
116 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:53:23
I don't recall him saying that he wants to leave to my knowledge, so why have we got people on here saying that he does?

John Gee
117 Posted 20/09/2013 at 21:51:56
Darren Hind, thanks for the laugh. Peter Foy, no apology needed, but wouldn't it be funny if you were from Llandair-what-the-hell-gogogoch in angellsey as I'm correcting you spelling!

The people on here who called for Rhino to replace him... Great shout!

Ross Edwards
118 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:00:26
Or the full name for Bangkok John.

Krung Thep Mahanakhon Amon Rattanakosin Mahinthara Ayuthaya Mahadilok Phop Noppharat Ratchathani Burirom Udomratchaniwet Mahasathan Amon Piman Awatan Sathit Sakkathattiya Witsanukam Prasi

That's quite a mouthful. The name that is.

Christine Foster
120 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:07:34
Can't believe some of you sometimes, to a footballer it's a job. They get well paid for it but they are like you and me, if someone from another company wanted you and was prepared to pay you 5 times more than your getting and you can work with some of the best people in the world.. What planet are you on???

Face it, we are all for rent, some of us are paid more for it. There is another word for it too.

Fans are passionate and love their club, players don't. Loyalty is a one way street demanded by all but rarely returned.

John Crawley
121 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:03:32
Hmm the Football Writers Live Event was held on the 12th September in the Museum of Liverpool. It was a panel discussion of the opening weeks of the season and this was where Stubbs made his comments. No other paper has printed the comments and Sam Wallace (who has plenty of form) writes the story the day before we are due to play West Ham!

Stubbs was naive and stupid to make the comment but I bet he didn't think Wallace would pick it up and run with it.

Ross Edwards
122 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:14:59
Christine, this hasn't come from the mouth of Baines. It is a claim by Stubbs. He hasn't said he wants to leave.
Derek Knox
123 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:11:18
Ross (597)

Why did they abbreviate it then?

Christine Foster
124 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:14:09
By the way, I always thought the 44D was a bra size I aspired to, I ended up with the 28A going to Netherton...
Ross Edwards
125 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:17:42
The Thai for Bangkok Derek is Krung Thep, which is the name used in Thailand, but in the West, we refer to it as Bangkok as that is the English translation.

The full name is Thai for "City of angels, great city of immortals, magnificent city of the nine gems, seat of the king, city of royal palaces, home of gods incarnate, erected by Visvakarman at Indra's behest."

Steve Burgess
126 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:02:48
I can imagine that Baines might have been a little uncomfortable with his beatification. If a deal is still possible perhaps he wouldn't want a false impression to build that he is devoted to the club and wouldn't leave unless pushed out.

Stubbs clearly lacks the communication skills of Roberto (don't we all) but sometimes, organisations release stuff in interesting ways. Remember how Blair kept Prescott around to communicate to the uncouth grass roots. Of course, he could have just run his mouth off and talked himself out of job.

Christine Foster
127 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:20:15
I know Ross, got that, but even so, true or not, we shouldn't be surprised that any of them think that way.. Wasn't having a go at Baines at all..
Fran Mitchell
128 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:20:56
Christine Foster #599

Can’t believe some of you sometimes, to a footballer it’s a job. They get well paid for it but they are like you and me, if someone from another company wanted you and was prepared to pay you 5 times more than your getting and you can work with some of the best people in the world.. What planet are you on???
Face it, we are all for rent, some of us are paid more for it. There is another word for it too.

Fans are passionate and love their club, players don’t. Loyalty is a one way street demanded by all but rarely returned.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B01o2xtJwgk

Avant Kapoor
129 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:20:18
Perhaps Baines has refused to sign a new contract so the club will sell him in January, which means the PR games have started. The club may have told Stubbs to say this — just my thoughts!
Phil Sammon
130 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:22:25
Man who walks through airport door sideways is going to Bangkok.
Christine Foster
131 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:27:00
Errr thanks Fran, so my comment was clap or you applauded? Lol
Ross Edwards
132 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:25:32
There are many, many players you can say have been loyal in their careers Fran and Christine.

See how many you can list.

Ross Edwards
133 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:28:22
Very good Phil.
James Flynn
134 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:00:15
Of course, Baines not signed to a new contract by his Club and no longer allowed to bomb up the flank at will by his Club's manager has nothing to do with him wanting gone.

That fucking Stubbs!!

Steve Burgess
135 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:26:15
Fran #608

I see your:
and raise you:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pNvOOjhRvM

Christine Foster
136 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:28:22
Exception not the rule springs to mind Ross, besides in the top flight it's all about money, I know every club has loyal players, but how loyal are clubs to players?
Money talks, players walk.
Ross Edwards
137 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:31:27
Just to irritate you beyond belief Steve and Fran, I raise you this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCNrK-n68CM

Eugene Ruane
138 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:22:49
Ross - "The full name is Thai for "City of angels, great city of immortals, magnificent city of the nine gems, seat of the king, city of royal palaces, home of gods incarnate, erected by Visvakarman at Indra's behest."

Bolton town council tried to adopt a similar naming idea a few years ago but it was eventually dropped.

It was basically felt there wasn't much kudos to be had from - 'Town of fat pastie-chomping, trackie-wearing meffs. Home of Peter Kay. Place of infinite woolness. Erected by Fred Dibnah"

Fran Mitchell
139 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:24:10
Evertonians.

You have a choice: A great, hardworking lad who came through the youth system. Grandad a Blue, Dad a Blue, Sat in the Park End since before he was even consummated, scouse accent, from Walton, the lot.

Scores 7 goals a season, ain’t bad an all, and loyal as they come.

OR

Some other git, who thought Everton was a first name, uses hair gel, looks in the mirror too much and would jump ship for an extra 10%.

Scores 25 goals a season.


who would you rather have in the team? The former, cause loyalty is most important, or the latter because success rules?

Osman or McCarthy (loyal vs money grabber)?
Hibbert vs Coleman (loyal vs money grabber)?
Anichebe vs Lukaku (loyal vs money grabber)?

Oh wait, Baines happens to be a good player, so loyalty matters now does it?

Find me a loyal footballer (apart from Matt LeTissier) and I’ll find you crap/average one.

Ross Edwards
140 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:33:34
Well Christine, I thought one particular example of a lack of club loyalty was Barcelona's treatment of Abidal.

The man had just beaten a battle with liver cancer and had recovered to play again after a transplant, and they just got shot of him at the end of the year.

Christine Foster
141 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:34:26
Could have been worse though, the 20 to Aigbuth or even the 55 to Litherland, lol
Ross Edwards
142 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:35:36
Is McCarthy a money grabber Fran? No, he rejected Liverpool at 16, to stay with Hamilton Academicals.

Coleman a money grabber? Utter rubbish.

It wasn't Anichebe, Osman or Hibbert that were loyal really, it was Moyes who was loyal to them.

Fran Mitchell
143 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:35:22
*Before even been conceived....Must not comment after drinking, must not comment after drinking, must not comment after drinking
Trevor Powell
144 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:36:08
Irrespective of Stubbs putting his foot in his mouth, if Baines wanys a move then he should put in a TRANSFER REQUEST. Simples!

Players should not be rewarded for wanting to break a contract that was willingly signed!

Ross Edwards
145 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:39:30
I can see why it didn't catch on Eugene.
Fran Mitchell
146 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:39:22
So if McCarthy was offered a chance from Man Utd on deadline day, you reckon he would have rejected?

If Coleman was so Loyal, why not try to help Sligo Rovers make a fist of it in Europe?

Christine Foster
147 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:39:01
Many a chairmanship path is littered with those who trusted the words but never saw the deeds coming. Like the bus, there will be another in 5 mins...
Christine Foster
148 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:41:14
Oh come on, wasn't that a brilliant way to link two wayward threads? Lol
Christine Foster
149 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:45:09
Ah well, time to face the day and shower, wondering what happened to the 44d.....
Fran Mitchell
150 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:41:03
Players play for a club for 2 reasons;

1 - Money.

2 - to better their career.

Fans support a club for 1 reason

1 - were idiots who waste our time and money watching rich people kick a ball about, when we really should be trying to improve our lives and take care of our family.

Eugene Ruane
152 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:43:51
Don't know much about the buses Christine.

I used to get the train (Edge Hill was my stop).

Ross Edwards
153 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:44:43
I think to say that Coleman and McCarthy are money grabbers is just ridiculous.

The likes of Ronaldo, Vieri, arguably the biggest mercenary I've ever seen play football, Bale (threw a strop for 2 weeks didn't he?), Odemwingie.

Are you telling me that you could put them in the same category?

Christine Foster
154 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:47:34
Oooooo you must have been posh Eugene,
Ross Edwards
155 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:47:38
If McCarthy is such a money grabber, why did he stick with Wigan, fighting relegation year in, year out for nearly 3 years?
Fran Mitchell
156 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:48:16
Well, the former 3 grab much much more money than both Coleman and McCarthey, and they’re (were) also much better players whom I love to see play for Everton.

How do you define money grabber? If Chelsea offered Coleman 200k a week would he accept it? Yes, in a heartbeat. Will htey off it, no, he ain’t good enough.

If coleman played for a team in the bottom 3 or championship would he command a move and bigger salary, yes, but the fact is he is probably playing at his level, no bigger club than us ould buy him so why command a move/bigger salary?

McCarthey jumped ship from Wigan, why? Are we offering parity? No, he is earning more,maybe double or more than he was. Becasue he wasn’t on the back pages for 3 weeks demanding a move means he’s loyal? No, it means he’s uninteresting to the mainstream media, no suprise there. You reckon he didn’t charge his agent with the task of agitating a move?

Define a Money Grabber? Ronaldo and Bale all moved to ’develop their careers’, the respect of playing for ’Real Madrid’ and happen to earn 300k a week.

Are they money grabbers, of course they are.

Ross Edwards
157 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:56:11
Well, I don't see Coleman and McCarthy as money grabbers, so we agree to differ, but I certainly don't think Baines is either.

I will forecast right now, that Baines will stay in January. He will not leave.

Mark Frere
158 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:54:41
Fran Mitchell (622) Absolute drivel!
Derek Knox
159 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:48:39
Christine (635)

Re: the 44D were you referring to the bra or the bus?

I think they both went 'tits up' !

Ross Edwards
160 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:00:23
Mark

Good to see I'm not alone in my disagreement.

Coleman and McCarthy don't strike you as being money grabbers do they?

I certainly don't think so.

Also Fran, the reason that Anichebe remained here for 8 years is that he simply isn't good enough for the Premier League, plus Moyes remained loyal to him, not the other way round, and it is the same with Osman and Hibbert.

Fran Mitchell
161 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:04:09
"Also Fran, the reason that Anichebe remained here for 8 years is that he simply isn’t good enough for the Premier League, plus Moyes remained loyal to him, not the other way round, and it is the same with Osman and Hibbert."

Indeed, hence my statement...."Find me a loyal footballer (apart from Matt LeTissier) and i’ll find you crap/average one."

Fran Mitchell
162 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:05:52
"Coleman and McCarthy don’t strike you as being money grabbers do they?"

Mainly as they’re not interesting enough to be interviewed by The Sun, SSN & the BBC every other day. Or the fact that money hasn’t been offered to grab... but, given the chance, they would — of course they would.

Ross Edwards
163 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:06:26
Alright, Gerrard is a perfect example. He, Fran, could have gone to Chelsea in 2006, and if he had, would have won 2 PL titles, another 3 FA Cups, and the Champions League.

Instead, he has stayed with the RS for over 14 years, and looks increasingly likely that he won't win a single league title.

Fran Mitchell
164 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:08:32
Tell me of 1 good player to remain at a club below his level of ability on a wage below the market value except Matt Le Tissier.

Fran Mitchell
165 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:10:53
Gerrard earned what pay rise to stay at Liverpool? Or did his wage stay the same?

Jim Engleman
166 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:12:13
Talking of Gerrard..if you look at the advice he has given Barkley recently, maybe he ain't such a shithouse..
Fran Mitchell
167 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:12:13
Also rumours of threats to his family if he moved... hardly loyal to the bone.
Ross Edwards
168 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:08:53
What's "not being interesting enough to be interviewed" got to do with loyalty?

Gerrard is one of the people most devoid of a personality or a charisma that I have ever seen, yet he has remained at his club for 15 years.

If he would have accepted a move to Chelsea in 2006, he'd have far more in his trophy cabinet than he has to show for his efforts now.

Ross Edwards
169 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:15:21
Fran, Bobby Moore, Gerrard.
Phil Sammon
170 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:12:26
There are other factors at play here of course. Some would rather play first team football than sit on a bench. Many only learn those lessons after making the wrong move.

Some nice words from Steven Gerrard to Barkley though. Credit to him for talking sense on that one.

It does, however, confirm that with England duty comes transfer talk within the squad. Of course we knew that, but I still wish it didn't happen to our lads.

Suresh Gill
171 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:58:08
We are getting constant attention all over the media. Who does Stubbs think he is, should just leave the manager do the talking.

The season has just begun for us the players need to focus on the field and not all these bullcrap going on off-field. By Roberto saying in his last press conference he's not offering Baines a contract anytime now sums it up for me.

Ross Edwards
172 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:17:22
I'll tell you why I said them Fran, Bobby Moore was certainly one of the best defenders of all time, yet he spent most of his career at West Ham, and I'd certainly say, and I'm sure you'd agree, that Gerrard has an ability well above the RS.
Fran Mitchell
173 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:16:08
What’s "not being interesting* enough to be interviewed" got to do with loyalty?

if your interviewed a lot, you will get questions like ’ would you like to play for X,Y or Z’ to which the player goes ’well, i’m happy at the mo, but I never say never’ to which the sun prints ’X player reveals dream of move to Z’ and forums all over the show call for his head for being disloyal.

*Interesting : in media meaning someone who will sell papers, not their ability to host a dinner party.

Fran Mitchell
174 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:19:31
Were talking modern footy, Bobby Moore don’t count.

Gerrard, I’m sure, is one of the highest paid players in the Premier League, if Liverpool never had the conditions to pay him so high he’d be gone... not to mention threats against the family.

James Stewart
175 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:33:25
Stubbs has always had a big mouth. Never liked him since the Rooney affair. Tosser keep your mouth shut and get on with your job.
Christine Foster
176 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:28:21
I agree Fran, the game has changed and for every loyal premier league players there are 10 who would sell their grannie for more. I understand that players also stay at clubs because they know when they are on a good thing or actually enjoy playing with a group of players they are having fun with.

But they are symptomatic of the modern game where the premier league is king and for a very short space of time, maybe only a season, a player can make a fortune. No one begrudges that because nearly every one of us would do the same.

But loyalty? No, sorry, as a concept it's great, in reality it's few and far between. Don't forget too the other side, as Ross pointed out, loyalty too players from the club? How many incidents can you find where a club stands by a player?

Cynical view perhaps but money is the game changer, further down the leagues I suspect you find marriages of convenience between players and clubs, but that's rarely loyalty.

So stoking the fire if I may, where you find loyalty do you find financial reward? Does it ever lend well for the player?

John Gee
177 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:33:12
Ross Edwards, thanks for the Bangkok translation, I learn something new everyday. But, I'll forget it by tomorrow!

Christine and others, loyalty is the lifeblood of football. Ex-players are constantly used as pundits when one of their former clubs us in a high profile game. We can counteract this by phoning the radio/tv shows and saying "what the fuck does he know about my club? He was he here for a year/engineered a move/took the money to sit on a bench/is a 5 club journeyman."

I have no respect for a player who moves for medals. If you want medals so much, take a pay cut and play for Celtic.

Steven Telford
178 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:37:19
Alan Stubbs has clearly shown that he has no place at the club, first his underhandedness during the Rooney transfer, and now this. He had nothing to gain other than to upset the team and the supporters. It is the NEEDLESSNESS of this comment that is most annoying.

He should be put on gardening leave, while we looking the legal grounds of firing him, it could not be more clear that he does not have the clubs best interest at heart, what's this clown still doing on the payroll?

If I was in Martinez's position, I would be furious, and I would in no uncertain terms tell Kenwright, that I want this guy out now – maybe even go as far as to offer the public embarrassment of my resignation.

Steven Telford
179 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:52:49
Get him out before he starts to tout Barkey for sale. You simply can’t run a serious club like this – with a loud-mouthed U21 manager who thinks we are a feeder team. Stubbs is an absolute disgrace.
Fran Mitchell
180 Posted 20/09/2013 at 23:57:16
I don’t intend to respect players. I have no ideals of any player ’representing’ myself or ’my club’.

I hope that the 11 players on the pitch wearing the everton kit win, it’s a completely nonsensical hobby beyond the friendship with other supporters. But I won’t let it take over me and pretend that my club represents my morals or values, or that players ’make me proud’. Sorry those days are over, it’s not a community sport anymore, and it hasn’t been for a long time (never in my lifetime.)

Suarez is a scumbag but i’d have him play for Everton anyday of teh week becasue he’s 1000x better than Naismith. I want us to win because I enjoy the game that way, just like I like my beer cold and strong....whether the brewer is dedicated or not doesnt bother me, I wanna nice beer.

If a player plays crap, no loyalty to it, he’s gotta go. For a player, same logic, they want to win, they want to earn and they want to spend time in bars/with family....soundbites about love for the club or loveing the supporters are just that , soundbites that they are told to say like actors to sell teh product that is the Premier League,

Its a bull, and it don’t bother me. It shouldnt bother you. I’d be sad if baines went because he’s a good player...but talk of loyalty and shit, sorry, gave that up when I was 17.

Brian Denton
181 Posted 21/09/2013 at 00:25:43
Christine, just back from the pub and bloody annoyed that Eugene got to the 'getting off at Edge Hill' line before I could.....
Steve Cotes
182 Posted 20/09/2013 at 22:32:32
What a stupid thing to say. Just when I was on a high looking forward to the season, Stubbs goes & ruins it. What an idiot! He should be fined by the club for releasing such things. Baines may not be bood by the fans but we will all feel a little distaste in our mouths now. Nice one Stubbs, a nice way to demotivate our season. What a complete fool!
John Gee
183 Posted 21/09/2013 at 00:27:27
Edge hill... I'm trying to remember if that's a posh part or not. Relatively speaking.

Sent from my iPhone 14 in Mayfair.

Jamie Sweet
184 Posted 21/09/2013 at 00:23:00
Fran, I think I get the general point you are trying to make, and I think I agree with you to certain extent. But Seamus Coleman is a very bad example to use to make your point. While money would be a factor in him making the move from Sligo to Everton, there would be many other factors involved.

Now take a look at nearly every player in the Man City squad and it would be hard to argue that many of them are there for anything other than the pay packet because they could all be at clubs with better Champions League prospects.

Fran Mitchell
185 Posted 21/09/2013 at 00:42:50
I used Coleman as an extreme example.... mainly to prove a point. He’s not a blue; if I was a Sligo fan, maybe I’d call him disloyal.

Harold Matthews
186 Posted 21/09/2013 at 00:39:45
This thread is a bit dodgy for a guy of my age. Jackie@553 is definitely a Dominatrix and Christine is for rent, wants to stoke the fire and is 44D.

Great to be blue.

Eric Myles
187 Posted 21/09/2013 at 01:07:13
Trevor #548 "He is on contract and he is a professional so will honour it"

And then get slagged off on here for letting his contract run down and us not getting a fee for him.

John Pulman
188 Posted 21/09/2013 at 01:37:43
Not the first time Stubbsy has come out with a blatant pile of bollox. Time to ship him off and get someone in who can develop the U-21s.
John Zapa
189 Posted 21/09/2013 at 02:11:34
I think the club expected to get a few million more for him from Man U, and they refused to get screwed on a second deal. It went to the wire it seems without any agreement.

Now the club is in a position where in the next transfer window Baines will be 29 with 18 months left on his contract. Hardly conditions in which to expect more than the £15M that was offered.

Tim Jones
190 Posted 21/09/2013 at 04:33:21
Just like he did with with Rooney, Stubbs's comments come either from stupidity or malice, there can be no other options. But it seems that Disgusting Deceitful Disrespectful Dave is pulling out all the stops to ensure that Baines joins him at Deceitful Lying Man Utd in January. Surely the FA can put a stop to all this illegal backdoor tapping up in the media too.
Chad Schofield
191 Posted 21/09/2013 at 07:39:42
Eddie McBride #532, sorry for not responding a little quicker by this thread' blown up and I generally prefer to read all comments before relying - regardless of how relying out is to immediately type away hastily in response.

Personally I'm glad your last was moved here as it keeps posts about this subject mostly in one place.

I'm not trying to berate you out make you look silly, I just disagree with what you said about the press simply making this up.

Leighton Baines isn't likely to be happy as has been shown in this thread, there are now people calling him disloyal. It doesn't matter whether he chooses to leave out not really in the context of what we're discussing here... Alan Stubbs simply should have not spoken about the situation as he did - that showed incredible naivety on his part.
Perhaps my point was lost that I am aware that the press sensationalize... but although they will do so around the commentary of their piece our add a "close source" our two, use quotes out of context... they would not simply make this up.

Mark Dunford
192 Posted 21/09/2013 at 09:07:19
Idiotic and entirely unnecessary thing for Stubbs to have said. Honesty is a virtue yet stupidity is just stupidity.

It just adds to the lingering impression that this saga isn't over and Everton''s main hopes were (a) that it would simply go away after the transfer window as Baines settled down with his rep intact as a loyal player and (b) if not the fee would be even higher in the inflated January market. Stubbs comments don't help either scenario, so I just don't know why he bothered opening his mouth on this one.

Perhaps, the appointment of the highly qualified David Unsworth points to the exit door for Stubbs. Martinez made some very telling recent comments about how u18s often lose their way in England while the developmental path is different and more productive in Spain, etc. He was making a broad point but ditching Stubbs may be one way Everton could address this. We have what seems to be a strong crop of young players and could reasonably hope for more than Barkley to come through. Too many promising youngsters have drifted away in recent years.

Shame as Stubbs is obviously a big Evertonian but a loose tongue is not an asset in any role. Gossip like this should be saved for the next ghosted autobiography.

Ken Crowther
193 Posted 21/09/2013 at 09:08:59
Eugene and Brian, I deserted this thread early yesterday evening, and was disappointed at Eugene's #525 when I returned to it .Glad you made it up (#549, #550).

Eugene #549 you're quite right, swearing is ALWAYS more aggressive when it's written down (because one can't catch the nuance of emphasis or the twinkle in the eye), which is why I'm often surprised that somebody as eloquent as you does it so routinely.

ps. This is from someone who's first ever post was to tell the late(?), great Martin Mason to fuck off.

James Crolla
195 Posted 21/09/2013 at 09:45:38
Stubbs was doing Kenwright's bidding, he has a vested interest because he has shares in the agent managing Barkley or he is just an idiot.... WHO CARES!

Everton to win 3-0 today playing amazing footy, and looking forward to the most interesting season for a very long time. I actually go into games for the first time supporting Everton (I am 34 years old) that we can win any game home or away. We also have a manager who I believe is the real deal.

COYBs!

Peter Mills
197 Posted 21/09/2013 at 10:33:31
Alan Stubbs is a bit of a chap who alights the train at Edge Hill station.
Gavin McGarvey
198 Posted 21/09/2013 at 10:25:29
Didn't know about Stubbs's part in the Rooney affair. Can't help but think his was probably not a decisive contribution in what must be one of the murkiest transfers in modern football. Still it shows a strange lack of empathy with the club fans and a lack of loyalty that is staggering.

It is also clear that this latest incident was a quite frankly brainless act, especially given his previous. Why for one thing did he go on the record? Was he trying to impress with his inside knowledge? Surely it would have made more sense for him to have done this off the record if he was just the money grabbing skunk this paints him as.

I think more likely that this is sheer stupidity. As such he's given his boss a decision to make hasn't he? If Roberto doesn't feel he can trust him with club business he's within his rights to let him go in my opinion.

Raymond Fox
201 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:28:40
Kunal 588, Baines hasn't given us 6 years service, he's charged the club a great amount of money each week.

I understand the context that you said it, its only people that help without payment, that are giving.

Frida Ericsson
202 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:09:39
Roger Trenwith, by the time dithering davey has finished with manure, I hardly think they will be at the top of the league or in the champions league come the new year.
Why we never got rid of stubbs is mystifying to say the least, after his stunt with wayne
Bob Hannigan
203 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:23:33
I'd say if MU/DM want him set a "Bale type valu" of 100 mil. [albeit way high] See if he still wants him that badly, if not he is still ours!
Mick Davies
206 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:06:25
Never knew Stubbs was involved in/encouraged the Rooney fiasco. That Deliverance extra should never have been allowed near our club again, and now he disrupts the club when we're at our highest point for years. Who needs enemies when our club's own staff are conspiring against us?
Daniel A Johnson
208 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:23:29
Stubbs needs to be sacked a real snake in the grass, probably sore about being passed over the top job so is trying to undermine Martinez.

Get rid of him ASAP, a done nothing lanky defender getting fat on an easy wage at the club

Harold Matthews
209 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:33:45
Ken Crowther. Spot on. Never occurred to me before but explains a lot. Thanks.
Harold Matthews
210 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:39:14
Mick D. Fantastic observation. So easy to visualize him in old dungarees, wearing a big floppy hat whilst chewing on a piece of straw. Wonder if he plays the banjo.
Garry Martin
211 Posted 22/09/2013 at 14:46:38
EFC need to nip this in the bud now with Stubbs remarks. Since the WHU game Baines value & attraction has just doubled........sack Stubbs considering the comments he also made during the Rooney episode many years ago. He should'nt be allowed to go near any of our players !.
Eugene McLoughlin
212 Posted 22/09/2013 at 14:57:05
Brian (543) I'm the other one!! LOL
Eugene Ruane
213 Posted 22/09/2013 at 15:44:33
Ken Crowther (720) - "Eugene #549 you're quite right, swearing is ALWAYS more aggressive when it's written down (because one can't catch the nuance of emphasis or the twinkle in the eye), which is why I'm often surprised that somebody as eloquent as you does it so routinely"

I hope this explains it.

http://www.openculture.com/2012/05/stephen_fry_language_enthusiast_defends_the_unnecessary_art_of_swearing.html

Brian Denton
214 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:29:08
Steven Fry is a pain since he became A National Treasure.....
Matt Traynor
215 Posted 22/09/2013 at 15:54:53
Ross #605, if you ever spent an evening in Nana Plaza you'll know that descriptive name bears no resemblance to the place.
Kevin Tully
216 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:48:47
Could be the perfect footballing weekend - We win a fantastic game, the shite are crying into their pints, and Utd are getting their arses handed to them on a plate, 2-0 down at H-T and not a shot on goal.

Good to be a righteous blue this weekend.

Jackie Barry
217 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:51:27
Baines won't save United right now any way, they are a sinking ship.
Charles Brewer
218 Posted 22/09/2013 at 17:38:08
Perhaps we could get Fellaini and Rooney back in January. They might want to play in Europe next year.
Jimmy Sørheim
219 Posted 22/09/2013 at 20:50:52
I hope Unsworth was brought in to ship Stubbs out gradually.
The sooner the better in my view.

I remember RM saying that Baines would be offered a top new contract.
Has he refused it?

Why have we heard nothing about the contract yet?

I fear he has rejected it and will be sold at the end of this season.

It is vital we keep Baines, we have to offer him what he wants.
Has anyone heard where the contract thing stands right now????

Phil Walling
220 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:30:47
I am positive that Man Utd's pathetic performance yesterday will ensure that OFM comes back for Baines in January. Then, it will not be to hassle over the fee but to agree to whatever Kenwright asks for our star.

The lad wants to go there and all the scribes believe a red shirt will nail his place for the World Cup. So, good friends, enjoy his skills whilst you can.

Nelly Verdonghan
221 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:58:11
Baines didn’t look like a man in a hurry to leave to me on saturday...with those two fantastic free-kicks

As for Stubbs he should be told to keep his mouth shut or FUCK OFF !! I remember him doing a very similar thing with Rooney just before he went...You’re employed by EVERTON FC Stubbs you fucking idiot NOT Manchester Utd or is he Dour..."I’ve just been twatted by Man City & given Man Utd their worst start for 9yrs"...Davie’s mole in the camp !!

Stubbs you are a dick !!

Noel Early
222 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:01:15
I hope Roberto and the board have pulled Stubbs up over this, he has no business in talking about first team players. He should just do his job with the Under-21s and get on with it. Maybe Stubbs wants a move to Man Utd as well...
Joe Edwards
223 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:09:46
Stubs wants to leave comments on 1st team issues to the 1st team manager and concentrate on his own job, whether this was a faux paux or intended to undermine El Bob due to being passed over for the job is irrelevant he needs to be put in his place and remeber who is paying his wages.
Eugene Ruane
224 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:13:39
Brian Denton (260) - "Steven Fry is a pain since he became A National Treasure"

What a wonderfully none-specific and pointless 'criticism'.

("Hey he's far too smart and popular, better slag him off in a staggeringly general way")

A 'pain' (whatever that actually means) or not, he's fucking spot on.

John Keating
225 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:24:14
More important than all of this.
Where is Martin Mason ??

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads