Baines and Lukaku light up stunning win over West Ham

, 21 September, 311comments  |  Jump to most recent
West Ham United 2 - 3 Everton
An unchanged side began the game, and soon looked stale in terms of ideas, made worse by a simple deflection a that allowed Morrison's shot to get past Howard. Martinez rightly rang the changes at half-time, Lukaku and McCarthy making a huge difference but the Blues had to wait for a Baines special to equalize brilliantly on the hour. But dominance was insufficient for the lead which swung back to West Ham when McCarthy gave away a penalty. Then up stepped Baines again after Noble was dismissed (fouling Barkley from behind for his second yellow) to curl another brilliant free-kick in the other side of the West Ham goal. More great work from Mirallas set up Lukaku for a powerful winning header that made him an instant (if wounded) hero in a fantastic result for Roberto Martinez.

Match Summary

Despite Darron Gibson and Arouna Kone supposedly being declared fit, neither even make the bench, where Romelu Lukaku is eligible to make his debut, as Roberto Martinez sticks with an unchanged line-up from the side that started in the win against Chelsea. Steven Pienaar and Antolin Alcaraz are out injured, while Gibson and Kone do not make the bench.

The contrast in styles was clear from the off with plenty of hoofballs from Big Sam's side while Everton built steadily with their patient passing game... neither initially looking particularly effective against two teams classed as 'hard to beat' until Barkley picked out Mirallas who cut inside and took a decent shot that forced an early save from Jaaskelainen.

Jarvis sprinted rather easily past Jagielk and it needed an amazingly fast run from Distin to dispossess him before he pulled the trigger. Everton looked a little at odds defending the corner through a number of scrappy phases. West Ham thankfully squandered a couple of free-kicks while pushing Everton back with their high pressing game.

Neat passing across the back was all well and god, but the lack of cohesion moving the ball forward was increasingly obvious, while West Ham's more direct approach was winning set pieces that put the Blues defence under pressure. Barkley did try a clever jink forward to Jelavic but it did not come off. A midfield free-kick won by Mirallas was wastefully scooped over the attack to Jaaskelainen.

Then a simple shot deflected from Morrison past a hapless Howard and a goal to West Ham.

Barkley appeared to be on a break but he showed too much of the ball to O'Brien, then Morrison got the first card for a challenge on Naismith. Barkley then got himself booked for the fourth time this season, for stumbling into his opponent a a largely ineffective Everton side trooped off at the break with a massive hill to climb.

Martinez acted at half-time, hauling off the ex-Rangers pair to be replaced by Romelu Lukaku and James McCarthy. And it was a thousand times better form Everton as the big Belgian looked to make an instant impact, playing a great ball forward for Mirallas, who took it wide and his return ball was poor. His strength in the tussle was immense, which could not quite be said for Osman, who was bundled over... and then came off with a groin injury. Oviedo replaced him on 52 mins.

Barkley finally felt he was positioned well enough to shoot but it was an awful attempt. Lee Mason was blowing up for every contact that ended in a tumble, but none that didn't much to the annoyance of Mirallas who was clearly barged off the ball.

Some ferocious attacking developed from Everton with juicy attacking moves threatening the West Ham goal, but Barkley was still seeking the perfect shot, he did draw a foul from Collins and the free-kick looked perfect for a strike on goal... and that's just exactly what Leighton Baines did, curling it inch perfect, high over the wall, just beyond Jaaskelainen and high into the net.

But, with Everton dominant, McCarthy's first real contribution was to clip Petric in the Everton area and Noble slotted home with ease and all the good work for nought.

As Barkley strode forward, Noble cut him down from behind and Mason had no option but to show him a second yellow. Baines then nonchalantly curled hos free-kick the other side of Jaaskelainen's goal, smacking in off the post this time as the keeper stared at it bounced in behind him, and the Everton fans behind him went bananas.

Then some great work from Mirallas set up Lukaku for a powerful header that he drove hone despite some afters from O'Brein that floored the new Everton hero on his debut for a good 5 minutes, getting attention for a smack on the head.

With 7 added minutes, Lukaku looked to score again but allowed Reid to steal the ball off his toe as he readied to shoot. Everton kept pressing all thee way to the final whistle, and registered a tremendous win in the end that looked a long long way off before half time. Excellent decision-making in the end by Martinez, to make up for placing too much faith in his poorer players (Jelavic and Naismith), given much stringer forces on the bench.

West Ham: Jaaskelainen, Reid, Nolan (80' Taylor), Jarvis (72' Vaz Te), Rat, Maiga, Morrison Y:37', Noble Y:68' YR:81', O'Brien, Collins, Diame.
Subs not Used: McCartney, Tomkins, Collison, Adrian, Petric

Everton: Howard; Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines; Naismith (46' McCarthy), Osman (52' Oviedo), Barry, Mirallas; Barkley Y:38'; Jelavic (46' Lukaku).
Subs not Used: Robles, Heitinga, Stones, Deulofeu. Referee: Lee Mason

 

Reader Comments (311)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ged Simpson
1 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:18:18
I expected Lukaku to score a hatrick within 20 mins. But I guess to put him straight in messes up team morale.

So – Jela hattrick in 10 and the Lukaku hattrick second half.

I am so optimistic today I can almost taste the disappointment...

Adam Luszniak
2 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:21:42
Anthony, I hope he does. Whenever I bemoan Naismith's inclusion, he always has a blinder; ditto Osman. I'll be cursing Jelavic's name all game in the hope he gets a hattrick!
Brent Stephens
3 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:22:37
Kone has been told to stay home and get more calories in him.
Patrick Carty
4 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:24:50
I think the team picked itself after last week, although I would have liked to see Lukaku start.

At least we have a strong bench if the game is not going to plan.

Jimmy Sørheim
5 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:20:25
I am baffled Lukaku is not starting. The only reason for keeping Jelavic is because he thinks after the CHelsea victory that Jelavic and Naismith will continue their combining and hopefully score a goal or two.

I have to say I am not optimistic.
Lukaku is the sort of player who could have killed of this game by half time, instead we will likely have to wait until the 65th min. to see Lukaku out there.

I would be pissed if I was Lukaku to not start the game.
Lukaku knows very well that he is miles better than any of the forwards already at the club and for RM to not see that as well is truly abysmal.

As I said RM has to be gambling long term here that Jelly and Naismith will again find their nice combos and goals, but Jelavic is in such bad form it is the same as putting Hibbert up front.

Never change a winning side is the motto, but here it should be almost automatic that Lukaku goes in for Jelavic, even Martinez himself has said he has been smashing them in on training.

I am baffled. I mean it doesnt matter how many games you give Jelavic when he is in such poor pfysical form, he barely wins any headers and his pace is welll below his best.

I truly hope RM has seen a positive reaction from Jelavic in training since the Chelsea game, otherwise this can very well cost us the 3 points.

I bet we suffer yet another draw because of Lukaku not starting.

Kevin Day
6 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:34:49
I think he has to stick with a winning side, I know we want to all see Lukaku starting, but I see this is as saying to Jelly get your scoring boots, he knows who's sitting on the bench, if he doesn't get a goal by 65 minutes we will se Lukaku coming on, who then has to stake his claim. No brainer for me.
Sam Hoare
7 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:40:29
Lukaku has barely played in the last month. Loathe as I am to see jelly toiling away again at least this way romelu gets to come on for the last 30 mins against tired defenders.
Colin Williams
8 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:42:37
Shite team!
Clarence Yurcan
9 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:42:45
Kone not even on bench??
Also, I don't agree with this 'stick with the winning side' rationale. So that means we have to keep running out inferior players until we lose, then the better players can start?
Patrick Carty
10 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:39:49
That is a poor West Ham team. I think we will win this game two-nil with Mirallas and Lukaku to score.
Mark Taylor
11 Posted 21/09/2013 at 14:58:36
Rather as I suspected. For better or worse, RM is clearly an ultra conservative manager.
Tom Murphy
12 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:19:49
I bemoaned the inclusion of the Naismith, Osman, Jelavic trio last week and, as happy as I was to be proved wrong, I do so again this week.

They don't have the quality at this level and with RMs 'nowhere to hide' style of football, they are being shown up again.

Jimmy Page
13 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:27:06
I couldn't believe it when my son told me Jelly was starting. Then he said David Haye split his eye in training — fight off, what next? Hibbert on for Baines?
Kevin Rowlands
14 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:33:10
Awful 1st half, this is not our best starting eleven, normal service resumed for the usual suspects I'm afraid.
Zaid Omar
15 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:40:50
I can't understand why Jelavic is on the pitch... Absolutely hopeless.
Clive Rogers
18 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:47:07
Not good enough Roberto. Shake it up!!!
Kevin Rowlands
19 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:48:02
How the hell do Jelavic and Naismith offer us more than Lukaku and Deulofeu? RM keeps banging on about them looking great in training then sits them on the bench, very frustrating!
Ralph Basnett
20 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:51:59
Sorry, if any team has got a voodoo to break, why the fuck is it always against Everton?

Why don’t managers have the balls to change things that don’t work? I tried not to slag anyone off after last week’s result but Osman, Naismith and Jelavic are a waste of space.

Patrick Carty
21 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:52:13
Changes fast, Roberto: Osman, Naismith and Jelavic off.

The first half was dire.

Danny McFlosum
22 Posted 21/09/2013 at 15:53:04
As frustrated as I am to see The Black Hole that is Jela out there, with his lack of pace, inability to hold onto a ball and absolute zero threat to score, I think I might be a little more disappointed to see Osman in instead of McCarthy. Big changes needed at half 'cause this side just isn't playing good enough.
Rob O'Brien
23 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:36:44
How the fuck are we losing to this shit team.....
Steven Scaffardi
24 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:42:15
Oh Ralph @806 please eat those words!!!!!
David Chait
25 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:44:21
Forum not working for me.. If it was I would be going ballistic ...!! Hold on boys!
Nick Entwistle
26 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:54:28
I got to admit, that was exciting.
Drew Shortis
27 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:56:08
What a game. We looked like a different team after half time with Lukaku on. Baines pure class and I think I wet my pants when Lukaku headed the winner. Great goal and I'm glad he wasn't hurt too bad! Hopefully Martinez will look at this and the three subs will start in place of those they replaced next time out. Fantastic game, I'm gonna celebrate this one late into the night ;-)
Phil Smith
28 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:55:29
Absolutely brilliant performance against the leg-biters of the Prem! What a game!!!
Drew Shortis
29 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:59:47
And now the only unbeaten team in the league. Martinez to win the title in his first season?
Derek Knox
30 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:56:25
Just remind me guys, who's the only unbeaten team in the Premiership? I was biting the nails a bit (the ones on the door) when we gave a penalty away and thought ' oh here we go again ' the big scalp, followed by poor team turnover syndrome strikes again!
What a difference after a few decisions going in our favour! I know it's hypothetical, but if we had started with the side we finished with, what would have happened!

I am over the moon, and feel we can start to put a decent run together.

COYB

Tommy Coleman
32 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:59:55
Brillant. World class free kicks from Baines. Lukaku makes a huge difference.

And LFC got beat. Great day.

Ross Edwards
33 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:57:29
Ralph Basnett, would you like the humble pie mate?

Wow, wow, wow, put us through the mill there, absolutely brilliant 2nd half performance. Baines should be elevated to sainthood. He does not look like a man who wants to leave at all.

Sensational free kicks. If Gerrard or Messi had done them, SSN would be going on about them for weeks on end.

RM went for it, and he got his reward. If Moyes was in charge, we'd still have been clinging on to a 1-1 draw there.

He was still going for it a 3-2. If this is what the Martinez era brings, bring it on, the future is certainly bright.

The people who said that they couldn't watch us because "the tippy tappy shit" as some said was so boring, what do you say now?

Onwards and upwards with Roberto! COYB! Sin Miedo!

Mark Burrage
34 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:01:49
Interesting that Oviedo is getting pitch time. I thought he would have put Mirallas on the left and Deulofeu on the right.... Is it possible that he is getting match time before the January window!!!!

Everton bossed the game today and deserved the win... COYB!!

Mark Taylor
35 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:03:33
Ross 820

To be critical, one could easily argue that RM was being over conservative with his starting XI and only when he brought on the players who many said should have played from the start, did we start to look like we could win.

Great win in the end though. Seen enough of Baines to know what he can do at free kicks. Not seen much of Lukaku but I sure like what I see. Hope he isn't out with concussion though.

Dave Long
36 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:05:05
A perfect Saturday, courtesy of Mr Baines.
Danny McFlosum
37 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:04:11
Beautiful! They looked like inspired men after half. I love the Baines celebration... Both of them!!!
Kevin Rowlands
38 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:04:24
Derek #817, spot on, the finishing eleven HAS to be the starting eleven going forward, maybe swap Oviedo for Pienaar when fit, I'm fed up of hearing Jelavic is lacking confidence, he's a fucking yard dog and Naismith is average at best.
Richard Reeves
39 Posted 21/09/2013 at 16:57:16
Wow, I missed the first half but watched the second. At last, now we have Roberto, we have proper football; no favourites, just football on the ground, pass and move, clever stuff, people moving for each other in an intelligent manner.

Sometimes it looked like mates playing for fun, all really enjoying it. And as for Lukaku, he looks the business,strong and athletic and possessing a delicate touch. How can anyone be unhappy with what Martinez is doing?

Alex Mullan
40 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:07:45
Some people should refrain from commenting until the game is over, unless it is actually constructive. It was the same from certain people -before- the Chelsea game had even started and it just makes them look ridiculous.

Baines is an absolute hero.

Ross Edwards
41 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:07:28
He was unconscious for a little bit Mark. I agree, the team did look a bit conservative, but we got the result in the end.

Martinez gambled at HT, it paid off massively.

4th place. The only unbeaten team in the PL.

Brian Waring
42 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:12:14
Ross, don't think taking Jelavic and Naismith off was a gamble!
Kevin Joszko
43 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:10:10
Only just stopped bouncing around the room and peeled myself off the ceiling! Baines is Priceless!

I was surprised Deulofeu didn't replace Osman with McCarthy already being on.....

Great start from Lukaku, we look a top 4 team with a proper centre forward linking things together. It's definitely going to be a thrilling season with Martinez in charge

Michael Kenrick
44 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:14:02
Richard (#827), it was a definite "game of two halves". The first half was almost as bad as it gets, and I was very very frustrated at the way we were playing.

Huge mistake by Martinez to do exactly what you said he didn't do: stick with 'favourites' for their goal against Chelsea. Not playing Lukaku from the start was a surprise and, I think, a big mistake.

But it's results that matter, and reading the Guardian piece after that display sure feels a hell of a lot better than reading it before and thinking "Wigan relegated... Wigan relegated... Wigan relegated..."

Well done, Roberto!

Brent Stephens
45 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:18:45
Songs for Lulu...Give Me What I Want and Give It to Me Now!
Kevin Hudson
46 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:15:04
Wow - what a game.

In the light of Stubbs's comment, I loved Baines's significant celebration, particularly with his first goal.

Also love the possession football, and the character of the squad seems stronger than ever.

Great 3 points & the Kopites beaten. That, coupled with beers in the fridge, makes for a sweet Saturday night.

Jamie Barlow
47 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:19:55
Come on Ross. You watched that first half. It was dire in the extreme. I didn't see many people saying the last 30 was boring.

Ralph Basnett
48 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:20:27
Steven 811 - rapidly eating a large slice of the humble stuff, but would still like to see McCarthy start, Lukaku start and Delafaou given game time and drop Osman, Jelavic.

But yes, did not taste nice but worth it for the result.

Ross Edwards
49 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:22:50
We got off to a slowish start Jamie, yes, but the 2nd half was brilliant.
Kevin Joszko
51 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:26:42
Baines is totally priceless!
Kev Johnson
52 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:25:24
Kevin Hudson - what did Baines do when he scored the first?

I was only able to tune in just after we scored. I believe we were dire in the first half. We could have scored a hatful in the last 25 mins, which was the bit I saw. Maybe I'm a lucky omen-mascot-thingy?

Jamie Barlow
53 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:27:55
It sure was. Much better when Lukaku came on. He looks very lively and a real handful.
Frida Ericsson
54 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:19:52
feed lulu!!! awesome second half performance, really proud of the team, especially against chavski, and then coming from behind to beat wh. Horrible first half, second half premier league contenders stuff .cmon you blues!!
Derek Knox
55 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:22:20
Michael (834)

I have just realised there is another (although early days) record in the making here, it used to be, until injuries kicked in, "We have never lost a game when Darron Gibson plays".

Now we have Gareth Barry — played two; won two!

Or am I being prematurely over-optimistic?

Either way, it feels good, and will hold true, until our next game at any rate!

Michael Kenrick
56 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:29:54
Jags sez they got a good telling off at half-time.

And rightly so... first half was shite.

Mark Frere
57 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:18:45
Terrific second half performance, lets hope Martinez has learned from his mistake with that starting 11. We looked so much better in the second half with the additions of Lukaku and McCarthy. Lukaku was sensational - it was like watching Drogba at his best - pure strength and quality.

Lots of credit should go to Martinez for not dithering with substitutions, but most of the credit should go to super Leyton Baines - what a player he is.

Barry Rathbone
58 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:25:54
Surely it should be "humble paella" all things considered ... must be driving a fragment of our fans up the wall all this.
Kevin Hudson
59 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:27:30
Ross,

Martinez continued Moyes's 11-game unbeaten streak against the Hammers.

...So don't assert that he did something that Moyes couldn't.

Ross Edwards
60 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:32:28
I was saying on the Live Forum Mark that if Messi or Ronaldo had scored those Free Kicks, Sky would be waxing lyrical about them for days on end.
Ross Edwards
61 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:33:38
Kevin, what are you on about?
Ross Edwards
62 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:35:25
Kevin, yes Moyes was unbeaten in 11 against West Ham, great achievement. I'm not taking it away from him.
James Kirrane
63 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:28:36
What a great second half performance. Possession level something like 70-30. What a player Ross is. Two great free kick positions. Baines a legend. Lukaku a legend in waiting. Exciting times!
Kevin Hudson
64 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:33:26
Kev, (847)

Nothing major, but looking at his expression, I just thought it looked like a 'meaningful,' goal for him.

Ernie Baywood
65 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:32:47
Exciting 2nd half. What a difference a presence upfront makes. He should have scored again but I'll excuse him for being only half conscious at the time!

The goals we conceded were poor; especially the 2nd which came from giving it away in defence then the poor shielding attempt. By the way - who was the WHU player who dived in the lead up to it? I was waiting for them to be booked but the next break in play was tge penalty. If it was Noble then he should have been off.

Paul David
66 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:32:19
Shite first half, much improved second and that was simply down to the subs. I hope that signals the end of a couple of players as first choice. The signs are good when we are unbeaten when I think we are a long way off top form, a few players still have to up their game and it was great to see Mirallas did that today.

Baines will get the headlines for scoring 2 and Lukaku for changing the game but Mirallas was MOM for me today, we need him playing well cos he is so dangerous.

James Flynn
67 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:27:45
Lukaku, my goodness, the sheer size and athleticism of him. Who's going to keep him from going wherever he wants on the pitch? And it appears he has a chip on his shoulder.

Thank you Mourhino. You really are a special one.

Now Bill, about Baines's new contract...

Timothy Blanshard
68 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:33:20
What a great game, don't have any fingernails left though.
Kev Johnson
69 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:40:55
Are we the only unbeaten team in the Prem? I do believe we are!
Jamie Barlow
70 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:38:01
"must be driving a fragment of our fans up the wall all this."

I don't think so Barry.

Raymond Fox
71 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:40:12
Did someone mention Moyes?
Mark Frere
72 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:36:16
Just hope he signs a new contract Ross, you never know, we might me above Manure in the league come January
Ross Edwards
73 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:45:19
We are Kev. That will shut the kopites up! We are also in 4th place.
Ross Edwards
74 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:46:16
Mark, I will tell you now, Baines will stay. He did not look like a man who wanted to leave his club. Stubbs should be sacked immediately. Absolute idiot.
Tamhas Woods
75 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:48:33
A manager that ACTUALLY makes changes when things are very quickly going to feces!

A team that manages to hold onto the ball and see injury time through with relative comfort.

A STRIKER WHO SCORES ACTUAL GOALS WITHOUT THE FLAG BEING RAISED!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Whatever next??!

Peter Jones
76 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:45:54
First half we were crap. Osman, Naismith, and Jelavic leave the game. Lukaku, Oviedo, and McCarthy enter. Immediately we become dangerous. It's not a coincidence. I don't ever want to see the first 3 start another game. And we haven't even gotten Deulofeu or Kone into the mix.

This could be a very, very special team if our manager doesn't worry about the feelings of the players of yesteryear. Unbelievable second half! Absolutely awesome. The possibilities of this squad are endless and I couldn't be more proud to be an Evertonian. Undefeated!!!

Ross Edwards
77 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:50:30
Tamhas, would Moyes have made those changes? I doubt it.
Simon Smith
78 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:49:42
Very poor 1st half; great 2nd half. Nice not to have to wait till 60 mins to make a change but it very nearly backfired on us!
Rob O'Brien
79 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:42:03
WOW! A great day. In previous years we would have drawn or lost that one but to come back twice really shows what we are all about this season.

Defence looked a bit shaky at times especially in the build-up to the penalty but up front Barkley, Mirallas and Lukaku looked like a threat every time they got near the WH box! I don't think Oviedo is or ever should be a starter, he loses the ball too much.

A couple of very win-able home games to come plus our annual 3 points against Man Shitty in between should see us above the Red Shite by October....

Nick Entwistle
80 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:47:25
Shoddy first half, better second. You can't rely on free kicks every game and again there was precious little threat up front.

Saying that, Lukaku is a beast and will surely better his 17 from last term.

It was a poor West Ham side and we didn't start playing till they went 10 down.

If it weren't for Lukaku, I'd be worried for our season. With him we can possibly do something!

Kevin Day
81 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:38:47
I'm not agreeing with any of this "he should've started Lukaku etc from the start" — it's clear to see he's keeping faith with a team that constantly finishes in the top 6.

Martinez is doing the right thing and not making too many changes too soon, but the players who came on at half-time have staked their claim to start at Fulham, shows what competition for places can do, excellent win and play from the blues today!

Barry Hughes
82 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:27:18
Ross, what are you smoking? The first half wasn't 'slowish', it was awful. Fair play to Martinez for making changes, but when we start with blatantly better players on the bench than on the park, i.e. Jela, Ozzie and Naismith, of course it's right for people to question the manager's culpability for a piss poor first 45. You seem rather blinkered in your view on Martinez. Running around calling for 'humble pie' to be ate makes you look a bit daft.
Ross Edwards
83 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:54:26
Nick, will you at least be happy for once. We are in 4th place for God's sake. You'd think with your negative crap that we're in 17th.
Phil Walling
84 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:41:19
Praise due to Bill Kenwright for standing firm when his best mate 'persisted until the eleventh hour to sign Baines'. Also glad he got rid of Curly Top to find cash for a couple of decent players.

Fuck me... did I just type that?

Well done to Roberto and the team, I'll be nice about everybody tonight!

Ross Edwards
85 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:56:00
Barry, It's called positivity. Many people on here should try it you know.
Ernie Baywood
86 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:52:05
Ross, no he wouldn't have brought on two players who weren't at the club and yes he would have subbed an injured Osman.
Ross Edwards
87 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:58:09
He would have settled for 1-1 Ernie.
Jamie Barlow
88 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:56:51
What about that "Wigan" lad who gave the penalty away, Phil?
Frida Ericsson
89 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:34:35
Kevin Hudson, it's matches like this, that at the end of the season can loose league placings. Today, I have witnessed the real coming together of a really good team, particularly in the second half. There is no way in hell, we'd have won that match under Moyes and certainly not in the manner in which we did it.

There is massive difference, in hoping for the best than going out there and making sure you win. right up until the last minute Everton fought, and they also fought really impressively against a chelsea side last week, when they threw everything but the kitchen sink and bath at them. Give Martinez some credit for the instant tactical / substitution change he made right at the start of the second half...Moyes would have been waiting until the last 20 minutes if where lucky, to make a change.

Phil Bellis
90 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:57:08
"...we didn't start playing till they went 10 down"

Absolute bollocks!

I'll give you "until the 46th minute"

Ross Edwards
91 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:04:43
Nick, did you watch the match? If so, you are talking out of your backside. We were excellent in the 2nd half. You just can't bring yourself to giving some praise.

Nick Entwistle
92 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:03:19
Not as a team Phil. That was all Lukaku... and his Belgian mate Kevin.

Frida, 'I have witnessed the real coming together of a really good team' we already were!

Phil Walling
93 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:04:11
Jamie re 'Wigan Lad'. Can't comment until I've seen the Sky edit tonight.But he must be better than Naismith!
Paul Thompson
94 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:57:47
Managers tend to like to bring new players in slowly and to have a transitional period, but the abysmal first half performance forced RM's hand. And boy, did we look different. And, predictably, Lukaku was the biggest (literally) difference. Barkley was didn't have the best of games, but his greatest asset is his belief in his own ability and willingness to make those direct runs at defenders - 2 fouls, 2 free kicks, 2 incredible Baines' goals.
Ralph Basnett
95 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:23:19
Alex 828, bit heavy lad, it’s a forum we banter, chat, slate and then like me every week eat huge slices of humble pie!!!

>It’s called supporting Everton.
Frida Ericsson
96 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:01:30
Ernie Baywood, you're right, because I seriously doubt he would have brought Barry or Lukaku in. He would have done his usual last-minute panic buy just like he did at Man Utd.
Ross Edwards
97 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:09:18
I can see it is physically impossible to say something positive Nick.
Sam Hoare
98 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:08:23
Great result. Didn't get to watch the second half but clearly we must have improved immeasurably. Did McCarthy play well?

First of many goals for Lukaku hopefully. Such a shame he's not here to stay.

Well done Martinez and the lads. Onwards and upwards.

Raymond Fox
99 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:55:49
My god, were 4th in the Prem. unbeaten and we still have some moaning about the opposition being poor, the first half was bad, etc!

He's not a mind reader, its ok in hindsite, easy aint it.
He changed the team which went on to win, who's perfect.

He's only been our manager for 5mins, he's trying to change our style at the same time and we've not lost yet, what more does it take to please you?

James Stewart
100 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:11:57
First half dire. Second half what a difference a decent striker makes.
Nick Entwistle
102 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:11:13
Bit of a nonsence Frida. One, because there are plenty of players out there and you're basing his record of having no money compared to RM having much more in comparison. There's no way we could have afforded the Lukaku and Barry loans in seasons past. Two, because on loan Moyes brought in the likes of Pienaar, Arteta, Donovan, Drenthe, Fernandez, Ferrari and a whole bunch more.
Mike Hughes
103 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:04:15
What a cracking day!

The Mighty Blues turn it around away from home to become the only unbeaten Premiership side. RM intervention regarding subs made the difference at half time. Half-time subs!!!

The RS get stuffed. Moaning kopites on Radio Merseyside (it's gone from "we'll win the league" to "atrocious", "papering over the cracks" in a matter of hours. Fantastic! Switching to R5L now for further hilarious moaning.)

Singing the Blues tonight in the run up to MoTD.

3 cans of Kronenberg in the fridge (it was on offer); one and a half bottles of red wine in the wine cellar (well, cupboard) and a multi-pack of Quavers on the kitchen table. Let the party begin.

(I also have a soft spot for Stenhousemuir and even they stuffed Arbroath 4-3 away!).

I just love days like this.


Mike Gaynes
104 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:16:47
More than a bit of nonsense from Frida. Total nonsense.
Nicholas Page
105 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:16:25
Everton Everton Everton........

Enjoy your night blues!

Lori Fekete
106 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:13:30
So we played much better with Jelavic & Osman off and Lukaku & McCarthy on?
Who'd have thought?!
Frida Ericsson
108 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:10:09
Nick Entwistle, under Moyes never in a million years, because it's clear Martinez is working to something wonderful, even if it take a little while to work..have some patience. Its one thing to bring in quality players, which he [Moyes] did, but it's another to get them playing as they are now. The difference between Moyes 11 and Moyes 11 under Martinez, is as clear as day for everyone to see. Okay the first half was shit, I will give you that, but during the second half, the improvement between all the players grew with each passing minute. WH where awarded a pen for a really stupid challenge. 3 players shouldn't have started, because I don't think they warranted it, yes despite naisy scoring last week..more of a fluke than anything else. Today he and Jelavic along with ossie, where headless chickens running around aimlessly.

Lukaku was immense when he came on, and it clearly inspired the rest of the lads, has he fought for everything, unlike anything that occurred in the first half.

At the end of the day, the result is what matters, not necessarily in the manner in which we achieved it, but you know, it feels good, seeing this team being far above, the way they used to be under Moyes. Under Moyes, we'd have been really lucky to get a draw out of that match.

I am going to give WH credit for their defending, absolute dogs to break down, but really crap up front.

Mike Hughes
109 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:21:41
I'll also raise a glass for Southampton tonight. Well done lads!

Frida Ericsson
110 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:20:42
Moyes was a fucking god, had Everton playing far and above better than Martinez... happy now?
Nicholas Page
111 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:18:55
An old classic......

Said Shankly to Yatesy come listen me boy,
I've devised a great plan you're sure to enjoy,
Those Everton Toffees their progress will stop,
And a great celebration we'll have on The Kop.

We'll cripple Young Alex and Harvey as well,
And the pace on them Toffees I'm sure it will tell,
The one man left standing will be Brian Labone,
And he can't beat eleven reds all on his own.

But Shankly oh Shankly your plans they went wrong,
And the downhearted kopites could not raise a song,
For you had forgotten the greatest of all,
The red-headed dynamo named Alan Ball.

Was the 45th minute of goal-less report,
Smith, Yates and Lawrence one footed were caught,
And the loose ball off Husband with great first was met,
Off the boots of young Ball to the back of the net.

So remember Bill Shankly our team is supreme,
Yours is the dirtiest side I have seen,
Those Liverpool yard dogs Smith Yates and St John,
Are a poor second best to the great Everton.

Derek Knox
112 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:18:45
Mike (908)

Feels good doesn't it mate? Let's hope it may continue for as long as we can!

You have disappointed me though, with your RED wine!

I would have thought BLUE NUN would have been more appropriate!

Nevertheless, enjoy! As I think most of us will, there will still be a few thinking we were lucky, or some other way of taking the shine off!

Drew Shortis
113 Posted 21/09/2013 at 17:59:48
West Ham did their homework on us and got right in our faces in the first half which made the usual possession game very difficult. When there is no outlet up front, and Naismith / Jelavic were no outlet at all, they were always going to keep on coming back at us. Second half we looked like the home team and Lukaku gave us an attacking presence and played in his fellow attackers. I think Kone would do a similar job in this respect, though Lukaku is a much better version.

I think Jelavic has to move on in January. He contributed almost nothing today, though the service to him was lacking in the first half. A centre forward needs to impose himself on the game, not just hang around up front waiting for things to happen. I think Naismith will be a useful squad player for us with his versatility and endeavour, but he should not be a starter. If a good enough bid were to come in for him I would take it. I would also look at moving on Heitinga in the new year. With Alcaraz and Stones we are not short of cover in the centre and he surely can't be happy warming the bench at this stage of his career.

McCarthy looked decent, except for the penalty and I think he should start ahead of Osman. Barry was a steadying influence and when Gibson is fit again we have some options in midfield.

Overall I'm very happy with the team Roberto has assembled and the way he has gone about transitioning from the Moyes era. It was a wise move not to make sweeping personnel changes from day one, but over the first half of the season it will become more evident which players don't fit into the new system and January will be the time to let these players move on and get on with their careers elsewhere.

After today's result my biggest concerns about the future are with Baines, Lukaku and Barkley. If a big bid comes in for Baines in January and he is keen on a move his contribution will be sorely missed. It looks like the likes of Chelsea and Man U are already circling Barkley and Lukaku is out of here at the end of the season. My hope is that we can take advantage of this window of opportunity and push for a high league position by January and the promise of Champions League football.With that we would have the added resources and the draw to convince out best players to stick with us.

Early days still, but I do feel like this could be a special season for the Toffees. With no money, success on the pitch is the only way we can turn this good vibe into something tangible. I'm very encouraged by the spirit we have shown in the last two games and ... should really stop typing now as the booze is taking over ;-)

David Greenwood
114 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:25:25
Great win, another happy Saturday night, I could get used to this...
Richard Reeves
116 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:10:24
Michael Kenrick, yeah, you're right and I see what you mean but it was good to see Lukaku on in the second half along with McCarthy and Oviedo and with plenty of time to affect the game.
Barry Hughes
117 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:17:01
One or two self-styled 'positive' people on here really are trying to act as the thought police and are coming across as having a bit of an agenda...

Speaking personally, I like a good, objective, honest exchange, a dialectic you might say. Not so keen on those trying to muzzle legitimate comment.

Harold Matthews
118 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:04:08
The camera angle at West Ham always makes the pitch look small with everyone on top of one another. Every match appears to be a scrappy affair.
Mike Hughes
119 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:28:12
Derek #921

The red wine is being drunk from a blue glass. No red in my house!

(Blue Nun? Thought that was a dodgy movie......:) )

Kevin Tully
120 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:27:14
Anyone who has played in the shittest Sunday League side knows why Martinez went with that side.

Seven days before, that team had beaten Chelsea, and ran themselves in to the ground. You don't suddenly say "thank's lads, but three of you are dropped after that win."

He knows Lukaku is better than Jelavic FFS! He knows Naismith is only a squad player, and McCarthy will be in before Osman.

Clueless comments on here.

Patrick Murphy
121 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:29:21
Mike 908 that result for Stenhousemuir got a loud cheer from me as well, I don't have any reason for looking out for their results apart from always feeling sorry for them as they attract such low crowds.

A good result today, I am hoping we can start turning in first-half performances that see us kill games off earlier, if that happens we could well have a season to remember.

Phil Bellis
123 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:26:56
Nick, I think the other 9 helped the Belgians to keep the ball for 62% of the playing time; though that may have been the 90 mins split.

It was good to see Magic Mirallas up his game; enjoyed his touchline twinkle-toes display near the end...

Dean Adams
124 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:30:49
Good win. Lets hope that Roberto learns which are his best 11 and quickly and effortlessly slip into overdrive with our best PL squad ever. He has so many options, which could not be said of the previous manager. Mostly glad that Steve Round is no longer here though.
Jamie Barlow
126 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:36:18
I disagree Kevin. That's exactly what you do if you have better players who couldn't play in the previous game. You drop the players who played shite. Jelavic, although he had an assist for Naismiths goal, was shite.

I don't know who the other two are but I'd have only made one change. As I say above.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
128 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:43:48
Can we please fucking just MOVE ON! Let's talk about our current manager, Roberto Martinez, who appears to be doing rather a good job!
Andy Walker
135 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:46:14
We were fantastic in the second half and RM deserves full credit. Nice bottle of wine and will enjoy watching us tonight and the shite loosing.
Kevin Tully
138 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:41:12
Jamie, I wanted Lukaku to start, but if a team have given their all and won, you give them a chance to repeat that performance. This is professional sport, not some armchair manager computer game.

If any manager went about dropping players and changing his mind every week directed by the loons on here, we would soon be another Sunderland.

Luckily, Martinez had the balls to change it after 45 min's, so he can say to Jelavic & Naismith he gave them their chance.

John Haldane
139 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:28:31
Because Evertonians are gentlemen, I know not one of you will mention these results down the pub tonight. ;>)

If I were BK, I'd be doing everything & anything to get enough money together to keep Lukaku. What a fucking beast.

Peter Thistle
140 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:26:07
I've never felt more like singing the blues
When Everton win and Liverpool lose

Oooooooooh Everton........ you got me singing the blues !
Mark Taylor
141 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:42:19
A quick word here for Oviedo. Sure he wasn't a game changer like Lukaku but I thought he looked useful and very pacy. Nice to have another option to Peanuts- he looks better in midfield than at left back.

He's had very very few chances but the rare times I've seen him, he has not looked out of place.

Ross Edwards
143 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:52:48
Peter, that's stopped the Kopites crowing. A lot of winding up to be done next week!
Ross Edwards
144 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:53:44
But Mark, surely Bryan's got to sort out his Hitler hair cut?

Maybe he wants to control the left of midfield for 1000 years.

Sam Hoare
145 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:53:40
Can someone please tell me how McCarthy played?

Will him and Barry be our first choice midfield from now on this season? Or Barry and Gibson? Or will Ossie stay in there somehow.

Paul Hesketh
146 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:51:19
Lukaku looks quality, first name on the sheet next week...

[I've just seen Jelly in Next buying himself a nice comfy cushion....]

Alan Smith
147 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:44:40
How mad are Chelsea? Two over-the-hill finished strikers and they loan us DrogBoy! We might as well take Mata off their hands in January on loan, seeing how he can't get on their bench.

Just think... a decent ref versus Cardiff or no freak sliced shot versus Norwich.

Kone hasn't played yet, Deulofeu just minutes.

Ged Simpson
148 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:53:02
Cue weird horror film music and me, wide eyed, going "Ha ha ha" for next 24 hrs.

What a day

Mark Taylor
149 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:52:52
Kevin 932

Had we thrashed and outplayed Chelsea, you would have a point, but we were fortunate to win. The very best managers won't hesitate to improve a team if they see the chance to- and what we saw today with Jela, Naismith and Ossie coming up short, we've known for a few games now, including even the Chelsea win.

That may sound a little harsh on RM as, in fairness, he is only settling into the job, but this is a tough school...

Ross Edwards
150 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:56:39
He gave away a penalty Sam. I can't really say whether he did much, to be honest I didn't really notice him much as it was Lukaku, Baines and Mirallas who did the business.

Osman is out for the Fulham game.

Mark Taylor
151 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:57:44
Ross, it is one bad haircut, but then that seems de rigeur for the average footballer- there's been some shockers...
Ged Simpson
152 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:57:15
And just to make you even happier, comment on RS fan site

"Appalling performance. What the fucking fuck has happened to our passing? I'm absolutely livid after watching that shite. Fuck off."

Ross Edwards
153 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:58:01
Alan, I would certainly say that Mourinho has lost it. For sure. He's left Mata out of the squad, and is persevering with Eto'o who is past it. I bet he regrets letting Lukaku go.
Sam Hoare
154 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:00:49
Thanks Ross. I would imagine RM may give the likes of Gibson, McCarthy and Kone (if fit) a start against Fulham.
Harold Matthews
155 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:42:27
What's with all this crap about Moyes and his assistant? We're in a new era now. They are long gone. Break the chains. Let's move on.. It's ruining every thread.
Jamie Barlow
156 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:53:00
I can see where you're coming from Kevin but I don't agree with you. You do whatever's best for the team, not individual players. I wasn't talking about Martinez changing his team every week but he knows ( because he has been going on about it all week) that Lukaku is better for the team than Jelavic. So he has to change it. I don't give a shite if he upsets them. They'll have to get over it.

Let me give you an example.

Lukaku has scored 10 goals in the last 7 games and then gets suspended for one game (5 yellows). Naismith replaces him in the next game and although we get battered off Man City, Naismith scores with his only decent contribution to the game. Do we keep Lukaku out for Naismith? Do we fuck.

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
157 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:03:29
Agreed, Howard. It's becoming really annoying now. I shall be taking action.

I think, however, they are appropriate on the Big Changes thread, so... if you really must talk about fucking Moyes, do it on that thread — not this one.

Kevin Tully
158 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:58:00
Mark - there's more to it I'm afraid.

Jelavic and Naismith have been at the club a couple of seasons now. Ossie has been here over 10 years.

You don't drop those three after a win against Chelsea, for lads who have only been here a couple of weeks, no matter how good they are.

No doubt it wouldn't even be up for discussion if the replacements had been established first team players, or If we had have been badly beaten by Chelsea.

You just don't manage a team or squad like that. Better players or not.

Matt Doyle
159 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:42:13
Right now Martinez is looking like the perfect antidote to the former manager's substitutional & transfer conservatism.

Lukaku looks more dangerous merely stood on the pitch than Jelavic does on the ball. I thought the first few games of the season would decide whether Jela comes good or not. Presuming Kone makes some kind of impact, Martinez must surely be looking to ship him and Naismith in January now. If Roberto prefers to stick with a winning team I'd guess we can look forward to seeing Lukaku start most games.

And what a performance from Baines. Again. I watched an old YouTube vid of Kevin Sheedy scoring the same free kick both sides of the net, then Baines does exactly the same. Brilliant player.

Matt Doyle
160 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:42:13
Right now Martinez is looking like the perfect antidote to the former manager's substitutional & transfer conservatism.
Lukaku looks more dangerous merely stood on the pitch than Jelavic does on the ball. I thought the first few games of the season would decide whether Jela comes good or not. Presuming Kone makes some kind of impact, Martinez must surely be looking to ship him and Naismith in Jan now. If Roberto prefers to stick with a winning team I'd guess we can look forward to seeing Lukaku start most games. And what a performance from Baines. Again. I watched an old Youtube vid of Kevin Sheedy scoring the same free kick both sides of the net, then Baines does exactly the same. Brilliant player.
Jamie Barlow
161 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:08:48
About time MK.

Who's Howard?

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
162 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:13:04
Ooops, Harold! Sorry
Harold Matthews
163 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:04:00
Yes Ross, it was a niaive tackle but otherwise he did ok. Jags had a few dodgy moments and Coleman was quieter than normal.
Paul Ferry
164 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:05:23
Sam (965) - others might correct me here - but McCarthy looked quietly efficient to me, nothing special, nothing particularly colourful - except for the pen needless to say! Did not give the ball away too often; dinky little passes for the most part, playing his part in a great 2nd half team performance.

I would pair McCarthy and Barry with Gibbo on the 50 per cent of the time when he is fit as back-up; Osman was again simply awful today and while on the live forum there was some sick gloating at his injury - one said I hope it is career threatening believe it or not - I feel that if he is not around for say three games that it might become clear that we do have better options. I can't see Ossie starting in say January. However you can read between the lines and you would be right: I hope Ossie does not start in say January.

Barcodes next week and we will not lose that so that is 6 undefeated and we will win so 6 games/12 points.

Never mind this fella on the pitch or that fella on the pitch what about our gaffer: great subs - attacking when ahead - having the guts to change things at half-time in effect saying my selection can be questioned as the game unfolded and therefore showing humility unlike guess who! Oh the differences in three short months!

Onwards and upwards - COYB!

Brent Stephens
165 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:03:24
Well said, Harold.
Denis Richardson
166 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:11:54
My my, left it late but I'll take that result any day. Starting XI looked a bit dodgy but no messing about with the HT substitutions. Moyes would never have done that!

3 points, unbeaten so far and no major injuries (hopefully). Future is BLUE. One game at a time though, Fulham next then a nice home game again.

The RM revolution marches on!

(David who?)

Kevin Tully
167 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:21:30
Down to 5th now after that Chelsea win.

Martinez out!

Derek Knox
168 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:15:35
It will be interesting now, to see if the philosophy of maintaining the winning side, carries over to the next game!

I know we have the cup tie at Fulham on Wednesday, which I expect a couple of changes in, and we don't play our next game till Monday 30th, so I would hope we can carry on from today!

It is looking like Roberto is favourite for Manager of the Month thus far, so let's hope if he gets it, which he well deserves, he doesn't get the dreaded ------------------ let's not even go there!

Mark Taylor
169 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:15:47
Kevin, you're obviously entitled to that opinion but I don't agree.

I'd hope that Naismith and Jela themselves knew their recent performances (not just one game) have been less than stellar- Osman too. There is a fine balance to be achieved here but what we don't want is players deluded into imagining they are better than they are and have a sense of entitlement.

I would hope their reaction to being benched would be, ok fair point, I haven't been stellar, even if the side won or done well, so I must fight to win my place back.

If any of those three had sulked at being dropped, then they should not be at EFC. In fairness, I don't think any of them would have done that.

We have more competition than ever before, which is good, but only if we exploit it and change people when they have not been playing well- regardless of the results. The EPL is too close a competition to allow half a game to pass when you don't have your best, most in form players out there.

John Crawley
170 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:02:50
Sam I thought McCarthy played well in the second half, always available and tackled well. He was a bit unlucky with the penalty. Seemed to link well with Barry as well. Lukaku was very impressive on his debut and Baines was as good as Sheedy and I can't give higher praise than that!
Raymond Fox
171 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:15:53
I agree with Mark about Oviedo, a pity we cant have the lad in the team somewhere, but where I've no idea, we have an embarrassment of riches at the moment.

Looks too classy to be vegetating on the sidelines, but what can you do.

Simon Temme
172 Posted 21/09/2013 at 18:46:43
Well said Michael, Martinez is stamping his authority onto the team in an unhurried fashon, however he clearly knows what he wants and is acting accordingly (subs at half time) to get it.

Do we have the start of a silk and steel evolution?

COYB

Carl Sanderson
173 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:33:02
Derek 990,

"I know we have the cup tie at Fulham on Wednesday..."

It's on Tuesday, mate.

Carl Sanderson
174 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:36:23
Top of the bill on Match of the Day...
Mike Hughes
175 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:29:58
I see that on the Lawrenson's Predictions on the BBC website, Usain Bolt had us down to beat WHU 2-1 and also had Southampton to beat the RS 1-0. Impressive (unlike "Lawro").

Always liked Usain Bolt and strongly predict he'll do well for himself that lad......

Mike Gwyer
176 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:06:11

Are the mighty blues back where they belong? Oh fucking yes.

What a game, sheer will and that boy Mirallas got us over the winning line. Loved it and can't wait till a week Monday for the bar codes to come and get a total fucking battering - something they are more than due.

So, Naismith - played shite but what the fuck, he pulled it off last week so credit where it's due. Jelavic - he knows the new "Drogba" kid is going to kick his arse, the Lakaku boy was amazing and how Mourinho let him go is probably equally amazing.

Sit back and enjoy, we are undefeated and looking good, the oh so mighty RS have gone into meltdown after one defeat and Roberto talks to the SKY news boys like they are his best mates. We are so on the up!!!!!!!

Carl Sanderson
177 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:38:02
Today's game is top of the bill, I should have said. Apologies.
Kevin Tully
178 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:34:41
Thought Mirallas had his best game this season BTW.

We've been missing his trickery, and he will only get better from this point onwards.

Let's hope we can get past Fulham in the Cup, and build some momentum.

Can't wait for that Newcastle game at home now.

Patrick Murphy
179 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:29:51
How many would have thought that an Everton team without Fellaini, Gibson and Peanuts would get 6 points out of 6 before the season started?

I happen to agree with Kevin, it is mostly best not to change a winning team unless you really have to. Nais and Jela may have been the heroes last week, but today they offered very little and could not complain when they were replaced.

Competition on and off the park is what professional football is all about and even the Captain will have to justify his place in the team or he could be replaced if he has a few dodgy games.

if only we had been awarded that Penalty at Cardiff and if only the Felli strike against WBA had have gone in off the post rather than bouncing back, we could be sitting pretty at the top of the PL. I'm hopeful that if we can keep getting results and then start to click properly for the whole 90 minutes we may just get European football back at Goodison. But just like last season let's see where we are after 10 games and then again at the mid-way point, it is still very very early days.

Mike Gaynes
180 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:39:51
Lukaku says he remembers absolutely nothing about the goal. Says he woke up and asked "who scored?"... and when told he had, he said "thank God"... but has no recollection.
Mark Frere
181 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:26:51
Watching Lukaku today just for just 45 minutes, was like watching Drogba at his best - power, barging defenders out of the way, skill and technical ability. Since Drogba left Chelsea, I thought there were 2 pretenders to his throne last season - one being Benteke the other Lukaku....but I always thought Benteke was the better of the 2, now I'm not so sure.

Nick Entwistle
182 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:42:57
Isn't there a rule where you miss the next two weeks if you go unconscious on the pitch?
Kunal Desai
183 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:38:33
Great result and it's brilliant that we can make changes from the bench that can influence the result if it's not going in our favour. Deulefeou didn't get on and we still have Gibson, Pienaar and Kone to come back, some real competition for places, which now means the likes of Naismith and Jelavic are going to really struggle to get back into this side with all the options available.
What Martinez needs to instill in this side is to play with high tempo from the start, get at the opposition and stuck in right from the off. I expect Martinez to make a few change from the cup game, perhaps give Gibson, Kone and Deulefeou a chance.
Derek Knox
184 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:39:32
Thanks Carl (997) ! You can see the result today has put me in a time warp.

You are obviously right, and thanks for correcting me. I have just watched the Chelsea v Fulham game, and again, as todays opponents while not being outstanding, should not be taken too lightly either!

As I've always maintained, this cup is the one we have never won, but come close on few occasions, let's go for it! After all it is a short cut to Europe, but would rather qualify on merit.

Patrick Murphy
185 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:46:28
No doubt there is some rule somewhere Nick, but I think we should claim that the lad just has a poor memory. Nothing like pointing out gloomy things when we have had a good win on the road in the PL only our second of the year.
Mike Hughes
186 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:46:36
If it doesn't divert you from TW, watch this from Usain Bolt from about 1:10 in:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/24152623

Top man.

Eddie McBride
187 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:42:06
A round of applause for M K not before time.

Brilliant Brilliant Blues

Carl Sanderson
188 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:52:45
Derek 008:

"You are obviously right, and thanks for correcting me."

I just didn't want you to miss it! 😉

Wayne Smyth
189 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:13:04
Only one way we can afford lukaku and actually persuade him to join us:

Champions League qualification.

That said, I think it 99% likely that if we qualify for the champions league on the back of lukaku's 25+ goal haul, they'll be wanting him back.

So, lets forget about getting him in permanently. We have him for a season, enjoy the football, enjoy him terrorizing defences and scoring a shit load of goals. Lets hope he can spearhead our top 4 finish and/or help us win some silverware. Next summer we can sell Jelavic, Naismith and any other deadwood and use the cash from our top 4 finish to find and buy the next lukaku.

As for the game I thought we were mostly poor. West ham worked incredibly hard and I was seriously impressed with Diame who bossed the midfield for most of the game.

As an aside, if any evidence were ever needed that selling your "best players" isn't always bad, I doubt our side shorn of barry, lukaku and McCarthy, but with Fellaini in the centre would have beaten west ham today. Admittedly if we'd sold baines that may have been a bridge too far, but selling one overrated played for a bucket load of cash and allowing the manager to spend often results in a stronger unit with more depth and balance.

Mike Hughes
190 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:51:50
Derek #008

Agree totally. The League Cup was one of my wishes for the season posted on here some time in July. It's about time we made a decent stab at it and think RM will give it a good go.

Seeing the likes of Swansea and Wigan in Europe - two of RM's former clubs - might just give us a fresh perspective and impetus on this competition. Here's hoping so.


Peter Cummings
191 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:33:06
A poor first half but an amazing second.

We were running into brick walls for 45 minutes: passing was sloppy, possession lost too easily, almost like playing Bolton or Stoke, cue restart and instant magic, Bainesy shoved any thoughts of wanting away down Stubbs's throat with two trademark strikes and Luky's header to win it was eerily reminiscent of a Davey Hickson 'suicide' header, even down to the flowing locks.

I said before the game a win should be on the cards, glad I was right after last week's prediction that we would either draw or lose v Chelski. Let's hope we can roll over Fulham next week.

Paul Ferry
192 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:05:23
Sam (965) - others might correct me here - but McCarthy looked quietly efficient to me, nothing special, nothing particularly colourful - except for the pen needless to say! Did not give the ball away too often; dinky little passes for the most part, playing his part in a great 2nd half team performance.

I would pair McCarthy and Barry with Gibbo on the 50 per cent of the time when he is fit as back-up; Osman was again simply awful today and while on the live forum there was some sick gloating at his injury - one said I hope it is career threatening believe it or not - I feel that if he is not around for say three games that it might become clear that we do have better options. I can't see Ossie starting in say January. However you can read between the lines and you would be right: I hope Ossie does not start in say January.

Barcodes next week and we will not lose that so that is 6 undefeated and we will win so 6 games/12 points.

Never mind this fella on the pitch or that fella on the pitch what about our gaffer: great subs - attacking when ahead - having the guts to change things at half-time in effect saying my selection can be questioned as the game unfolded and therefore showing humility unlike guess who! Oh the differences in three short months!

Onwards and upwards - COYB!

Andy Crooks
193 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:48:59
Top management from Roberto. Make changes gradually and send out the message that there are no longer favourites. If you play well you'll keep your place. But, he'll be ruthless when necessary. Great show. First on MOTD ?
Andy Crooks
194 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:48:59
Top management from Roberto. Make changes gradually and send out the message that there are no longer favourites. If you play well you'll keep your place. But, he'll be ruthless when necessary. Great show. First on MotD?
Julian Exshaw
195 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:09:38
A perfect Saturday indeed. Only negative for me were some comments regarding Osman and his injury. They don't bear repeating but how anyone could utter such statements about any player, let alone a loyal Evertonian is beyond me. Up the Blues, WHOEVER wears the shirt!
Paul Ferry
196 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:02:35
Wayne Smyth -016 - 100 per cent on board with your last paragraph but: 'As for the game I thought we were mostly poor'.

No!

We bossed the second half and as MK said it was the proverbial game of two halves. There was a fair bit of top-drawer joined-up football and some peach individuality.

Love your bright and breezy 'Let's hope he [Lulu] can spearhead our top 4 finish and/or help us win some silverware' but be bright and breezy about the 2nd half today too!

That said, can I have a drop of rain on the parade: is anyone else a tad worried about iffy Jags and his quite frankly shaky start to the season? Yes, he's England's #6 and our skip but that doesn't pitch him above criticism.

Yep, Wayne Diame was first-rate first-half and with his Bobby previous I for one would love to snap him up.

Brent Stephens
197 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:13:14
Just started to watch the game (again) on Sky. They said before it started that Baines gets 2 and a Lukaku winner! They don't normally tell the score before they've shown the game do they?! Some people watch this as if live, not knowing the score. Am I being parawhatsit in thinking that's a deliberate spoiler for our fans who are tuning in as if live?
Tony Draper
198 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:52:20
I have a bloody big daft grin on my face, but no sign of muscle fatigue

Great decisions Roberto, gave last weeks winning side fair opportunity then mad the right call at half time

Leighton Baines

The second half perfomances were superb all around
Delighted for Lukaku scoring on his Blue debut

Still early days for Roberto, but since his arrival I've really taken to him and could not possibly have asked for better than this

Very encouraging indeed

Martin Mason
199 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:02:42
I don't wish this to be controversial or confrontational but we had a great transfer window and got in a new manager with a positive outlook, we're unbeaten and have just had two results that you wouldn't have necessarily expected from Manchester United. It is fantastic and apart from the downer that Barry and Lukaku are only on loan everything looks great considering that we are competing against sides that have multiples of our resources?

Given that the buck stops at the top I'd like to put in a word for the man who has put it together and would take the inevitable blame for it not working. Great work, Bill Kenwright

Jim Hillier
200 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:11:54
I don't think it took West Ham going down to 10 men to put us on top. We were poor in the first half, in a way that we so often were under Moyes. It felt like one of those days at half time, but the substitutions changed the game completely. We were absolutely all over them, and they never looked like holding on to their 1-0.

The penalty, totally against the run of play, looked to have spoilt the day, but it didn't because of the way we were playing. Throughout the second half, West Ham were becoming more and more desperate, and dirtier by the minute. That, too, was because of the way we were playing. We ran them ragged.

David Pearl
201 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:32:26
Yes exactly Julian. Anyone wearing blue surely you'd wish them the best but for some on here it's a different story.

Loved the reaction of Charlie Nicolas here... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_eq4WnBzpxM

Kevin Tully
202 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:36:33
Don't think Bainesy will be getting rid of those rainbow laces anytime soon!
James Flynn
203 Posted 21/09/2013 at 19:30:00
I like that Roberto is coming around to the fact that Everton are not Swansea or Wigan. 90 minutes to our full capability, instead of the second 45 minutes we've seen these last 2 weeks, please.

It remains amazing to me Chelsea sent this kid to us. Someone in that organization did tell Mourhino Everton were in for the CL for most of last season?

Mike Hughes
204 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:28:58
Tony #031

I'm the same.
I think about the EFC result - daft grin.
I think about the RS result - evil snigger.
I listen to the red misery on phone-ins - sadistic cackle.
I just love it when that happens.

(Imagine what it'll be like when we actually win a trophy!)

Mike Hughes
205 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:40:38
David Pearl #037

That's a Housemartin's video

Jim Hillier
206 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:28:44
Got the solution to the earlier red wine dilemma:

http://www.corksout.com/brown-brothers-everton-red.html

Stale Haverstadlokken
207 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:43:50
This afternoon has been a roller coaster!! All my yelling frightened my mrs, children (2) and dogs (2) several times. Couldn't keep it quiet.

Thanks to Baines and Lukaku I can enjoy my Brown Pale Ale :-) RM showed his leadership when he got Mccarthy and Lukaku on for 2nd half. Wasn't impressed by Mccarthy ,but Lukaku is a beast!

Only unbeaten team !

Mike Hughes
208 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:49:04
Jim #044

Genius! That's probably the best wine in the world......

Brent Stephens
209 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:48:15
Interesting negative comments against Osman again today. Now I'm no Ossie lover or hater. I'll say if he plays bad or well. I just can't see where some of the negativity comes from at times.

So I'm watching the game again tonight on Sky. He must have had over 20 touches / passes (and some say "did he touch the ball"!). I counted (you don't even need to count!) one misplaced pass, to Nais. Twice clattered into a man (and he aint picked to tackle). Constant jockeying and closing down space, playing his part in keeping a tight midfield. Constantly showing for the ball. Receive - give - go; receive - give - go. The goal wasn't his down to him - he picked up man going behind Coleman and Coleman's man took the ball across the front of the box, passing to another man who wasn't closed down by the rest of the defence / mid.

The same old suspects come out with the negativity in a totally predictable way. If you think I'm telling porkies, watch that half again and count. I'm not saying he was great but neither was Jags, nor Coleman etc. But he's wasn't poor.

Colin Glassar
210 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:52:16
I had to work today but I followed (tried to) the game on the live forum and some of the first half comments were bang out of order. Watching the highlights on sky we weren't that bad in the first half.
Al Reddish
211 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:33:34
Jagielka says the substitutes (no shit!) and a massive bollocking from El Boss was enough to give them a kick up the arse for the second half.

It still seems to take a bit of time to get us going, but when we do we look a match for anyone. I was pleased that RM was brave enough to haul off two ineffective players with only 45 minutes gone, and it was fantastic to see us keeping the ball and not giving the initiative back to the opposition once we went in front. I was also pleasantly surprised to see Oviedo on for Osman, I was expecting Heitinga.

Martinez seems like he is prepared to take risks to win games and as Barkley says, he gives the players the freedom to play, understanding that players do make mistakes. It's how you recover from them that matters.

Mike Gaynes
212 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:59:24
Well said, Brent (049). Osman is never much appreciated here, even when he plays brilliantly, but both of his managers keep picking him. Must be a reason.

That said, it’s no coincidence that our offense clicked in when Oviedo came on. He works beautifully with Bainesy and opens up the side for him to operate. We got wider and quicker with Oviedo on. And like Osman, he almost never makes a bad pass.

James Martin
213 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:39:28
Great to see us winning away from home. West Ham were shocking and anything less than a winn would have been a travesty based on the second half. More good management by Roberto, good to see the players having the stones to win it. The more we win these nail biters like Chelsea and West Ham the more we'll develop that knack of winning those sort of games we mightnt have won last season.
Richard Reeves
214 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:53:33
Mat Doyle (#981)

It's funny you should say that because I swear when Baines was about to take that second free kick, I thought of that very thing, the Sheedy free kick, and for some reason I had a feeling he was going to score.

Although I wasn't there, I managed to watch the second half on the net and haven't enjoyed a performance like that for a long time.

Colin Grierson
215 Posted 21/09/2013 at 20:14:47
I hope one of the physios who ran on after the Lukaku winner told him, when he came to, that he had pledged himself to us for life.
Great game! Great win! Can't wait to see us on MOTD.
COYB!
Colin Wainwright
216 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:08:54
Great second half performance. McCarthy looks the part, Lukaku scared the shit out of me and I'm in Scotland. Baines did a "Sheedy", only spread over two goals. The shite got beat.

Good to be a blue tonight.

Andy @ 020. I doubt it mate.

Noel Early
217 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:11:20
Brilliant, absolutely brilliant.

Brutal first half but fair play to Roberto for making the changes quick. The team that finished the game was good but the most pleasing thing is we still have Gibson, Pienaar, Osman, Naismith, Jelavic, Kone, Stones, Hibbert, Heitinga, Deulofeu and much more available.

When did we suddenly get a squad??? HAPPY DAYS!!!

Kevin Tully
218 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:17:02
Chris, surprised anyone would look at how many time Ross was dispossessed, rather than the fact he won the two free-kicks that led to two goals.

Each to their own I suppose.

James Stewart
219 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:25:00
Imagine if we had had Lukaku since the start of the season. We'd be top. He's the difference. Awesome player.
Colin Grierson
220 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:27:02
I think we just might be first on MotD, Colin, but you're right to doubt it. They don't deserve us!
Chris Jones [Burton]
221 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:28:52
Kevin, I was making a point about our performance in the first half. You've clearly not taken in the totality of my post. Anyway, the fact is, as I saw it, a number of promising moves in the first 45 broke down when we lost possession. That was the first half. The game did not end at half time. The second half was a different story, but if you want to judge my post on one comment on the first half, fine.
Wayne Smyth
222 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:28:31
Kevin, he also made the surging run that lead to the 2nd yellow for Noble who had to drag him back, leaving us with the man advantage which undoubtedly helped us.

Some people always look for the negative or expect young players to be the finished article and play a blinder every game.

David Pearl
223 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:32:01
Mike Hughes,
sorry... haha yes I was reminiscing last night.

http://www1.skysports.com/watch/video/8934884/the-story-of-soccer-saturday-21st-september sky sports reactions for the goals brilliant. The housemartins not bad either... :/

Mick Davies
224 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:15:48
Can I have a sip of whatever Mike Gaynes is on? Osman never makes a bad pass? Really!!! He can't even do that anymore, and why RM opted to play him against a side of Fat Sam's with the strength of Diame is baffling; a weak CM causes more work for the defence.

Even with a lack of matches, McCarthy was more combatant and the tide turned dramatically. Frightening thing is, if Osman hadn't been injured, a £13m player would be playing second best to him.

The side that finished the game must be our strongest 11 now (maybe excluding Oviedo) and the rule must be... Play to your strengths!

Wayne Smyth
225 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:33:34
Actually, tonight, I'd be happy for the RS to be first :)
David Pearl
226 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:36:59
I got lucky there.. considering other things I was watching last night
Mike Green
227 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:40:06
I was there today and in many respects Baines got us out of jail, Lukaku looks like a monster and Jelavic.....well......

Average performance, awesome result in the end - looks like the last 20 is where we're at. Need to create more chances - much more.

Otherwise - it was fucking great!

COYB!

Kevin Tully
228 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:45:24
I was listening to the radio on the way to work, and they had a delude on from the Anfield fanzine some bollocks or other talking about the Swansea game.

He said "I was really uptight watching that last night, I forgot how stressful a title challenge can be."

After 4 twatting games. What utter cocks.

Mike Hughes
229 Posted 21/09/2013 at 21:44:27
David - thanks.

Yeah, liked The Housemartins as well but looking forward to MoTD judging by Charlie Nicolas' reaction to the Baines goal.

I hope we have many more days like this with RM.

Jamie Barlow
230 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:07:27
Yeah, thanks for that David. I've never seen that before. Do they do it every week?

@073 Brilliant.

David Pearl
231 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:06:57
I don't like to take 'all' the credit.. but I placed my first ever bet on the RS to win this morning. The best $10 I've ever spent.

We are nowhere near the finished article. The hunger shown by Lukaku to get on the end of that cross was superb. Still unbeaten too, brilliant.

Colin Glassar
232 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:10:20
No wonder they call Lukaku The Beast. He's twice the player Drogba was at that age. Remember, Didier was a late developer (23-24). I just hope we can find the pennies to keep him.
Brent Stephens
233 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:10:14
Mike #042 - yes, I like Oviedo. And he seemed more solid today than in some previous games. The squad does seem to be strengthening in so many ways.
Colin Glassar
234 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:26:25
I thought Barry was immense again today, solid as a rock. McCarthy looks the real deal and will get better each game and as for Lukaku well, no comment needed really. And we have the likes of a fully fit Kone, Alcaraz and Pienaar to look forward to.
Mike Gaynes
235 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:27:26
Brent #082, I've been an Oviedo admirer since before we signed him. Saw him play for Costa Rica against the US. He's pure quality. Even better at LB than midfield, although I hope it's quite a while before we find out.
Mark Jones
236 Posted 21/09/2013 at 22:47:58
Why were we wearing the third kit today?
Steve Guy
237 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:49:45
cos the third kit looks ace
Kev Johnson
238 Posted 21/09/2013 at 23:56:42
You're not wrong there, Steve. It does look ace! We've got a 100% win ratio when we wear it, as well.

It's my favourite kit since the one we wore when we won the FA Cup. The conclusion is plain: wear a smart and stylish kit and we win a trophy...

It's gonna be our year!

Trevor Lynes
239 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:16:57
I enjoyed the result but only for Baines two top class free kicks we may well have been struggling to get a draw. Im still not convinced about the ability of the players to play the short passing game effectively.

The first half was rubbish and West Ham were pretty poor.
With Mirallas in the side we should be moving the ball accurately and quickly.
I reckon he was our MOTM overall.

We cannot just play out from the back as was patently shown in the first half.

Andy Peers
240 Posted 22/09/2013 at 01:20:35
I just wish Chelsea's strikers would start scoring so they don't want Lakaku back. In 5 Premier League games not one of their strikers have scored a goal.
Michael Kenrick
241 Posted 22/09/2013 at 01:29:21
Match Report from Kevin Kilbane, c/o 606:
Brilliant game, first and foremost. Lukaku made a huge impact.

West Ham played very well in the first half with Morrison and Diame outstanding.

The introduction of Lukaku made the difference — he scored a brave, brave header.

Baines outstanding in the second half and scored two incredible free-kicks.

Ben Jones
242 Posted 22/09/2013 at 00:34:51
I don't think McCarthy is getting enough credit here.

Though ironically enough I thought Osman was better than Barry, the midfield was slow, therefore West Han could continued pressing with ease.

No one noticed McCarthy but you look at the pace of the midfield and how quickly he distributed it. McCarthy was a big part of it. He stil needs to impose himself in the game more, but just watch the next game he starts, were a lot quicker with him in the side.

The difference with Jelavic and Lukaku was unbeliavable, and that was Mirallas' best game by far. Only major disappointment was Jags, thought that was his worst game for a while.

But we've seen a team that can click and still with Gibson, Kone, Pienaar and Deulofeu to potentially come in, all looks bright!!

Suresh Gill
243 Posted 22/09/2013 at 02:09:35
Baines's stock have gone through the roof.

Put a ridiculous pricetag and we shall keep him if you can't afford it.

Thank you.

David Pearl
244 Posted 22/09/2013 at 03:13:46
Most Man Utd fans didn't want Baines anyway... wonder what they are thinking now? Hopefully they don't come in again next window. If they do and we are not in with a chance of Europe, I can see him going.

And if Stubbs actually did say those comments, he should be fired.

Kevin Palmer
245 Posted 22/09/2013 at 02:22:06
Great win.

I do have to question the wisdom of allowing Lukaku to continue after showing several clear signs of concussion. Frankly, I would have preferred nervously watching the match finish 10 against 10, than nervously watching a young man risk serious, long-term brain injury. Are there any physicians on here who might be able to speak to that?

Mike Green
246 Posted 22/09/2013 at 07:27:01
Also - a word for our support.

Due to circumstance I had to sit in the home end yesterday, at the other end of the pitch from the Everton support. Throughout they were fantastic - when the third went in I thought the roof was going to come of the stand! :D

Well done lads, a credit to the club.

Mike Walker
248 Posted 22/09/2013 at 08:10:13
Are we starting to see a very very good Everton side? We are playing some very good football — now keep the good work going.
Dave Richman
249 Posted 22/09/2013 at 07:32:17
Brent: I won't dispute your analysis of Ossie in the first half, but did you not see him either shrugged off the ball or just allow a West Ham player to take it off him 4 times in the short period he was on in the 2nd?

As mentioned before, it's no coincidence that we looked like a wekk balanced team once Ossie went off.

Steve Pugh
250 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:22:47
Dave I saw that, one of them was when he got injured, God knows how that wasn't a foul, two more occurred afterwards when he could barely move and was obviously in pain.
Chris James
251 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:09:13
The difference for me, that we'll see in the next few weeks is Lukaku. Lukaku. Lukaku.

We have a skillfull passing team with pace, trickery, great team spirit and plenty of hard-work. Barkley, Mirallas, Coleman, Baines, Pienaar and Delboy can all make things happen, Barry and McCarthy keep the ball ticking over and our back-line are one of the best in the country (albeit still trying to get up to speed with new tactics).

We've been dominating games for sometime (even pre-RM), but the difference has been the final touch. Jelly started like a train in the first half season, but appears to have well and truly lost his way, the jury is out on Kone and Naismith is a trier and fair enough as a squad player but not first team premiership. The big Belgian not only provides a cutting edge (as clear from his goal yesterday and willingness to shoot) but also a genuine, direct attacking impetus and a target-man to hold the ball up.

Yesterday afternoon he looked even better than last year and I firmly believe will prove to be the missing link in our play.

Brent Stephens
252 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:31:13
Dave 160. Yes, Dave I saw that. But he was only on 5 minutes of second half! Surely we can't slag him for a couple of incidents in the context of his overall contribution over 50 minutes?!

The side looked better from 46th minute - Osman was still on then! The difference was Lukaku! Immense.

Anto Byrne
253 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:28:18
When Moyes comes back in January for Baines, he will have to pay a lot more for him than the £15M tabled. Today he was outstanding — not just for two exceptional free-kicks but also his link play and all-round defensive performance.

The best left back in Europe must be worth a fair bit when you add the goal-scoring and penalty-taking prowess that comes with the player. In my estimation, £30M has to be the minimum Everton will accept. My price for Ross Barkley is £50M.

If we sell Baines and purchase Lukaku, that would be a good deal unless we can find the money from elsewhere to buy this kid. Time for Kenwright to find the investor/buyer Everton should have.

Brent Stephens
254 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:38:18
Chris #165 - exactly. I was quite excited going into this season and after transfer window but seeing Lulu's contribution yesterday! Well, just 5 minutes said it all. Strength, control, touch, vision for a defence-splitting pass.

As for Jelavic. Well, Jelly by name, Jelly by contribution.

Neil Quinn
255 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:41:20
Chris James at 165, you are spot on with your second paragraph. Over the past two seasons apart from Jelavic's games when he first arrived, we have dominated but simply failed to finish teams off. Lukaku (possibly with Mirallas alongside) could see an end to all this.

Leaves us with an interesting conundrum for a starting line up, methinks. Do we play somebody else on the right, leaving Mirallas to play up-front? Will Pienaar and Gibson come straight back in? Some nice strength in depth for a change.

Jon Withey
256 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:50:03
Never seen Lukaku play before, absolute quality, should enjoy having him for this season. Mirallas and him up front must be a nightmare for the opposition.

Still amazed by Barkley, panicked the defence twice for our free-kicks. Still dwells on the ball a bit sometimes and has a few skied shots, but I'll take the rough with the smooth, he's like having a £15+ million new signing.

McCarthy gets around the pitch well, shame he gave away the penalty, I guess he's still young too.

I like the look of our team a lot, we didn't play great but still scrambled a win - not a bad habit.

Thought Martinez was brave with substitutions and Oviedo is an attacking threat too.

Joe Bibb
257 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:57:14
First on Match of the Day. Highlighted on Football First on Sky 8:15pm... Martinez is knackering my Saturday night, I can't go out now.

It's great to watch this Everton team. Attacking until the final minutes of injury time. Holding the ball and passing it well.

It would be nice if we beat Fulham and then we can start to plan for a Wembley trip.

Great to see Barkley getting 90 minutes every week. That's how he will learn his trade and not being stuck on the bench like last season. He will make mistakes but he will also make wonderful moves and passes.

Colin Glassar
258 Posted 22/09/2013 at 09:59:51
Chris James spot on. Everyone can see that we are building something special except the four morons on Sky's Sunday Supplement who have just totally blanked us out again and insist on Bainesy joining a top club if he wants to become a regular English international. Twats.
Kev Johnson
259 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:02:36
My thoughts entirely, Kevin Palmer (@128). There is no way Lukaku should have gone back onto the field of play after concussion. God knows, I wanted us to hold on to the win, but it's a bit blinkered to endanger a man's long term health! West Ham were down to ten anyway, with Noble off. In fact, at one point they were down to nine as O'Brien needed stitches after the collision with Lukaku. What was our club doctor thinking?
Max Wilson
260 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:10:28
CATHARTIC! Posh word I didn't learn at New Chester Road School. There will now be fundamental change:

● Those of us that have criticized Roberto will shut our gobs;
● We are unlikely to see our Rangers recruits very often unless we are hard up;
● Bainesy now has the proof he's in a team that can fulfill his ambitions (fourth for a few hours); and
● Our two new boys proved they fit in.

I felt sorry for McCarthy getting booked because he was making a contribution. He'll have to be careful how he goes in in future. As long as Romelu doesn't phone home and say "this lot are doing my head in".
Mike Corcoran
261 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:15:42
I thought he was dead for a mo..
Mike Corcoran
262 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:25:11
Teams are going to be loathe to press us with the threat of being caught out by long ball to lukaku. I have never been so impressed with the all round game of a blue centre forward. Immaculate control, passing, aggression and finishing. He dropped into midfield and looked like everything Felli should have been but clearly couldn't manage too.
Laura Haseman
264 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:41:15
We just need Chelsea to loan us Mata now, the nutters!
Phil Sammon
265 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:40:19
I've not seen the penalty replayed. I was sure Nolan dived. Ok, JM left his foot there, but it looked a certain dive from a guy I've always regarded as an honest pro.

Any thoughts? Did I see it wrong?

Dave Richman
266 Posted 22/09/2013 at 07:32:17
Brent: I won't dispute your analysis of Ossie in the first half, but did you not see him either shrugged off the ball or just allow a West Ham player to take it off him 4 times in the short period he was on in the 2nd?

As mentioned before, it's no coincidence that we looked like a wekk balanced team once Ossie went off.

Peter Askins
267 Posted 22/09/2013 at 10:54:41
Yes, a certain dive by Nolan, Phil, but as much as I'd like to criticise him, practically every player would have done exactly the same thing these days.

A pity that it was McCarthy committing the ultimate offence, and being penalised, but both Jags and Gareth Barry should take equal blame in the lead up to the incident. Sometimes Jags, just hoof it - we won't mind, honestly !

I agree with everything said about Lukaku (apart from maybe labelling him "the missing link" !). What a 45 minutes. He might look ungainly at times, and the ball really shouldn't stick to him, but it does. The West Ham defenders were terrified - mark him tight, and he'd spin them ; lay off him, and he'd turn and run at them. Injuries permitting, he really could propel us towards the Promised Land.

It's worth reminding ourselves that despite the meticulous planning and thought that goes into modern football, it really may have been a couple of strokes of luck, that led to Lukaku landing at Goodison Park :-

1. Chelsea conceding an equalizer to Bayern Munich in the Super Cup with the last kick of the ball, and then Lukaku missing the decisive penalty. The Special One certainly bears grudges, and I'm sure it was this outcome that prompted him to move on Chelsea's best forward !

2. The transfer window closing during the International break, with Mirallas having the free time to get into the head of Lukaku.

Happy days !

Gerry Quinn
268 Posted 22/09/2013 at 11:04:34
Phil, "Nolan" and "honest pro" CANNOT appear in the same sentence!
Ray Said
269 Posted 22/09/2013 at 11:10:05
The thing that most impressed me about Lukaku wasn't the muscle and speed-although there is clearly that in his game-it was his control, the subtle touches and incisive passes. The class of the player is apparent and we should be busting the bank to at least make an effort to get him in. Okay we will probably fail and will have to settle for one season but its going to be a great one.
Brent Stephens
270 Posted 22/09/2013 at 11:15:33
Dave #191.

As Steve Pugh says above, "Dave I saw that, one of them was when he got injured, God knows how that wasn't a foul, two more occurred afterwards when he could barely move and was obviously in pain".

And, again, we looked better from 46th minute when Lulu came on - and Osman was STILL ON.

Look, I'm not a great fan of Osman but I just have to smile at some people's (not necessarily yours) prejudices which mean that no matter how he plays, he gets it in the neck. I'll defend any player from that, not just Osman.

Gavin Ramejkis
271 Posted 22/09/2013 at 11:18:31
Ray have to agree with your comments on Lukaku being more than a one trick battering ram of a player, watched him last season at West Brom and yesterday he showed again he is a classy team player with his unselfish passing and hold up play a pleasure to watch, if the Chavs decide to start playing him they've got a great player for years to come.
Phil Sammon
272 Posted 22/09/2013 at 12:19:28
I really thought Martinez had dropped a clanger bringing Oviedo on instead of Deulofeu. It's still baffling me as to why he made that sub to be honest. All worked out well of course. Perhaps Martinez sees something in the young Costa Rican.
Sly Silverman
273 Posted 22/09/2013 at 12:51:00
To understand the starting XI, you have to put yourself in Roberto's shoes. You have a squad of players that you want to utilise fully.

A game can be retrieved with quality on the bench but, if we are losing with Lukaku starting up top, would you sub him for Jelavic? Of course not. Effectively Jelavic and Naismith are surplus in an ideal world but they are still getting paid well, you still have to communicate all week in training.

In hindsight, it was misguided loyalty or foolhardiness to start with them at WHU, but they would be finished in real terms if benched. A larger, stronger squad can bring problems.

Great second half.

Gerry Quinn
274 Posted 22/09/2013 at 13:16:14
Just totally unbelievable the crap that comes out post-match, post-window..........................wanted to change their title to "Leighton Baines joins Everton greats by scoring a free-kick brace - Sheedy-esque!"

http://talksport.com/football/leighton-baines-joins-manchester-united-greats-scoring-free-kick-brace-13092261115?p=4

Carl Sanderson
275 Posted 22/09/2013 at 13:22:38
Phil 188:

I, too, thought Nolan dived - but it was a fucking stupid tackle as well. (Can you imagine the shit-storm on here if Osman had been the culprit?)

Kwame Asiaw
276 Posted 22/09/2013 at 13:16:28
First time poster.

Shoddy, piss-poor 1st half. Great 2nd. 2nd half team should start every week, but Pienaar (when fit) back in for Oviedo.

I didn't see anything to worry us from Fulham against Chelski. I recall last season when we should've beaten Fulham away at least 5-0 and ended up drawing through poor finishing. Now we've got Lukaku, fingers crossed for a different story.

Richard Reeves
277 Posted 22/09/2013 at 13:34:41
I forgot to mention that I've changed my mind about the third kit. I don't like the home or away kit but the third is quite nice apart from the huge slab of cardboard that passes for a nineties badge, if you could call it a badge.
Brent Stephens
278 Posted 22/09/2013 at 13:58:39
Exactly, Carl.
Mark Frere
279 Posted 22/09/2013 at 14:37:45
Kwame Asiaw

Welcome to ToffeeWeb

I also think our 2nd team is nearly our best 11, like you say Pienaar should start in place of Oviedo when fit, but I think Gibson when fit should start along side Barry.

You're definitely correct about Lukaku, he will make a world of difference this season

Phil Sammon
280 Posted 22/09/2013 at 14:56:55
Full strength for the Fulham game please. Let's see some silver this year.
David Donnellan
281 Posted 22/09/2013 at 14:52:53
Bloody fantastic! On top all of the 2nd half, only a hefty deflection & a penalty against the run of play, flattering West Hams goal tally.

Lukaku is definitely going to be the difference between us doing anything this season or not. There is enough talented players around the squad to provide him with the ammunition he needs.

One of the greatest plusses that RM has brought to the team, is his belief in Barklay, allowing him to develop into the great player he could become, not penalising him for trying things. He could become someone very special for us.

Although I thought it was a penalty, I think it was soft, Nolan went down very easily. I agree he isn't no honest pro, ask Anichebe.

Brent Stephens
282 Posted 22/09/2013 at 15:20:12
Kwame, welcome mate. For me, I'd start the strongest XI against Fulham. If and when, a win is pretty well assured (steady, Stephens), then ring some changes. And the strongest XI is...? Lulu plus any 10 others (how about Howard, plus 9 defenders?!).
Wayne Smyth
283 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:03:12
Phil, my initial thoughts about getting deulofeu on for osman was the same as yours.

However, a few minutes after the sub it occurred to me that we weren't playing the west ham of Harry Redknapp, but Allardyce, with shithouse's like Nolan in midfield.

Seeing how hard West Ham worked, closed down and tackled I don't think Deulofeu could've coped. Osman isn't the biggest, but he is usually up for a battle. Same for Oviedo. From what I've seen of Deulofeu, he's great going forward, but doesn't work back or work hard when not in possession.

Whatever you think of the pro's & cons, we can't complain about the effect. Baines was a menace late on and we looked far more dangerous down the left.

I think we'll see Deulofeu against Fulham, maybe from the bench, but he's probably one for home games or games where we're already ahead.

Steven May
284 Posted 22/09/2013 at 16:52:11
Just out of interest, thought I would compare our points so far this season with those against the same teams and venues last season. I've ignored the Cardiff game, as they weren't available to play last season, so, points so far this season - eight. Points against the same teams last time - eight.

There's a different mix but same total.

I'll keep going as long as no-one accuses me of bias in some way, not that ToffeeWeb subscribers would ever misinterpret for their own means.

Roger Helm
285 Posted 22/09/2013 at 17:22:01
Kevin 128 - I remember Cloughie's (perhaps apocryphal) comment about a concussed player: "Boss, he was knocked out - he doesn't know who he is" BC; "Tell him he's Pele and play him up front"
Mike Corcoran
286 Posted 22/09/2013 at 17:52:55
And the potato peeler went to the gunfight again!
Kevin Day
287 Posted 22/09/2013 at 20:17:15
Mike he forgot the peeler lol
Denis Richardson
288 Posted 22/09/2013 at 20:19:34
And the potatoes.....
Jimmy Sørheim
289 Posted 22/09/2013 at 20:25:44
Rm picked the wrong starting eleven.
He at least changed it at the half time break which was not a moment too soon.

Jelavic is so poor these days he belongs in the reserves, for RM to not start Lukaku was a mistake.
Naismith is average at best, I doubt he will ever find his feet at the PL, but he is a squad choice at least.

I like the fact that we won, but RM made it easy for West-Ham by not starting Lukaku.

Had it not been for Baines we would have lost the game.

I am a realist now, I think that RM has still not adapted his thinking from Wigan to being a top 6 manager.
Though slowly he seems to be getting there.

Any manager worth his salt will know Lukaku is miles better then Jelavic, and if you include who is in best form or not then Lukaku becomes the clear first choice.

I hope this game showed RM he should have started Lukaku.

All in all we were lucky that Baines scored those 2 free kick goals.
He saved us today.

I do think we are looking at a more positive time ahead as Lukaku will surely be starting most games in the league, to keep Lukaku on the bench is just to costly for us.

It is high time Jelavic gets dropped, he has done us no good bar the Chelsea game this season.

John Crawley
290 Posted 22/09/2013 at 20:45:30
Steven 270 - think you've got your facts wrong! Last season v this season we are a couple of points better off for the same fixtures:

Last season:
Norwich away - Lost
West Brom home - won
Chelsea home - lost
West Ham away - won

Total 6 points.

This season:
Norwich away - draw
West Brom home - draw
Chelsea home - win
West Ham away - win

Total 8 points.

Not that I would want anyone to accuse you of bias!

Ian Riley
291 Posted 22/09/2013 at 20:21:58
At 3 .45 yesterday, our manager made changes that influenced the game. I don't like to be critical of our previous manager, but he never made changes at half time when players were not putting in a shift or the formation was not working. It would be around the 60-70 minute mark, if still in the game (Manchester derby today, fine example).To be fair, for the first time in many years, we have players that can come on and change games.

The importance of keeping baines was proved right yesterday, a dead ball specialist which many teams in the league don't have. We have something different in baines that can win games and the club must keep him. I don't know if baines wanted to go to man utd, but all credit to him showing true professionalism and the club for standing firm. It would have been easy for the club to accept 15 million for a 28 year old left back. However, the manager and fans know he is worth far more than that.

For the first time in many years I am excited for the future in the group of players and style of football being played (hope its not a kiss of death).

Best wishes to all!

James Martin
292 Posted 22/09/2013 at 21:04:43
These manager comparison posts are ridiculous considering Martinez has had all of five league games with us. After the first three some people were calling him dithering Dave in disguise because he didn't change things aorund enough to get the wins we needed and only brought on Deulofeu late in the Cardiff game. After this game he's being lauded as a managerial genius - the extremism is ridiculous.

We won today because of the brilliance of Baines. Yes Martinez changed the players and the system but if Baines doesn't bend in two pearlers where were the three goals going to come from?

Now that Martinez has got more of the players he wants the results are improving as they should and its only fair he is judged with his own team and not Moyes' first 11. I really like what he's doing with the team so far and thought that the two wins a row were good exhibitions of different types of football. Can we please just not knee jerk either way though. At half time Martinez was a phony to some, at full time he's the messiah. We've come from behind many times before at Upton park, we've also thrown away points against lesser sides many times like we did at the beginning of the season. It would be great if we just went on a massive winning spree but knowing Everton as I do there's probably a slap in the face waiting just around the corner.

Enjoy the win, praise Martinez for the role he had in it (although I'm mostly thanking Baines for this one), but don't build him up into this messianic perfect manager (even though I hope he is) because when a set back comes the same people will be throwing him to the dogs. Martinez needs time and patience to gradually improve us (although a sudden huge improvement would of course be nice) he doesn't need ridiculously bloated expectations.

Raymond Fox
293 Posted 22/09/2013 at 21:15:26
Jimmy, the manager is privy to a lot more information than us, he might know Lukaku is feeling under the weather, McCarthy has a knock and is not quite 100% etc etc not true just examples of possible inside information were not to know.

Also everyone is an expert after the event, he was giving the team that beat Chelsea (albeit with terrible finishing by their forwards) a start to see how they went.
Managers obviously have a big influence on teams performance, but don't forget they are limited by their players abilities, RM should therefore have more success with our players than he achieved with Wigan players of less ability.

Ian Riley
294 Posted 22/09/2013 at 21:30:06
Mr Martin, I agree with you. Its early days. Our style of play is changing for the first time in 10-15 years. For many players this will not come easy as for many years it worked under Mr Moyes. I do think the players brought in understand the managers style of play. Most of us on this forum I think are more delighted that we came back from defeat rather than we are going to win the league.

For many years, I have not had any expectations as a everton fan based on the money we spend and players we sell. All I want to see is good style of football with a determination to put a shift in. Our manager is very lucky as he has come to a club that has that, installed by Mr Moyes over ten years.

Supporting everton is like my golf, I have no expectation but when something good happens, I go back for more!

Best Wishes to all!

Raymond Fox
295 Posted 22/09/2013 at 21:41:51
James, what has been irritating is, Moyes admirers including yourself have continually crabbed at every bit of success that RM has achieved, and any small amount of praise appeared to be given very grudgingly!

Moyes did well for us if you look at where we finished in the league most seasons,
nevertheless we never won any silverware of any description.

DM wasn't dismissed, he choose to leave us of his own accord, so just come to terms with it, he's not our manager any more.

Garry Corgan
296 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:04:40
Opinion on Martinez may be split but we all have to agree he's doing better than former Sunderland manger, Paolo Di Canio.
Phil Sammon
297 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:05:43
Crest options revealed on Twitter guys. A million times better than the current one
Phil Sammon
298 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:10:18
The one on the left gets my vote...if you've seen the pic. Follow Alan Myers
Garry Corgan
299 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:08:14
Thanks Phil! Three is very cool and modern but I've got to go with the classic ... Number 1 for me.
Brian Hennessy
300 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:14:28
I'm thinking Fellaini might need to move again in January if he wants to play champions league football again next season....ouch...
Steven May
301 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:02:20
@ John Crawley - whoops. Error with the spreadsheet. Not a good start. So two points better off. After only...now how many games, if I exclude the Cardiff one. If we could win the Newcastle game, that would be four points up.
Harold Matthews
302 Posted 23/09/2013 at 02:16:41
With a few exceptions, the fans are thinking short term while the manager is thinking long term. Judging by his recent comments, he experienced the same scenario at both Swansea and Wigan where fans were initially confused with his methods.

To him, loan players are a temporary quick fix for positions he has yet to fill on a permanent basis. Gradually this will be rectified, loan players will no longer be needed and his squad of loyal Blues will start to perform on an upward curve. Practice, practice, practice. At Finch Farm and on the pitch. Learning to think and move as a team. Anticipating runs and passes. Eleven men in perfect unison. His very own dream team. This is what he is begging us to understand.

Unfortunately, he'll probably end up banging his head against a brick wall. Two decent results have transported many fans to Fantasy Island where, according to Toffee Web and radio phone-ins, we're about to win everything bar The World Cup.

So yes, Mr Martinez. The task you have set yourself is not entirely hopeless but it could be a tough and bumpy ride. Let's hope the majority of fans understand your long term aims for the future of our great club. Let's hope they appreciate why the loyal, permanent players must not be discarded too easily and may all your dreams come true.

Kev Johnson
303 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:39:12
"Two decent results have transported many fans to Fantasy Island". I'm offended by that, Harold. How dare you! I live on Fantasy Island, I'm not a tourist. Born and bred here, as a matter of fact. Other than that, I agree with everything you say.

So anyway, Fulham... It might be best for us if they field their first XI, given the fact that they are currently exhibiting relegation form. We'd all love to win the League Cup so this is a big game.

Conn Prosser
304 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:30:11
Baines' goals were unreal. He looked a little nervous approaching the away fans after his first goal, but after the second he looked like he want to jump in with them. How good was Mirallas' cross for Lukaku's goal - it came from an impossible position but he showed tremendous skill and trickery. As for Lukaku himself, he's a monster! He seems to saunter into dangerous positions. And great technical ability 'for a big lad' (I know that phrase doesn't really work in the top flight these days)

I'm not convinced by Oviedo, I thought he was marginally effective and had an easy lay-off for Barkley whilst chasing the ball across the edge of the penalty area, late on. Instead, he chose to shoot from an awkward angle and wasted a good chance. That said, it's good to see him get a decent run out, I hope he can improve in the manner of Coleman or Barkley.

Harold Matthews
305 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:20:21
Nice one Kev.
James Martin
306 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:40:52
Raymond 'James, what has been irritating is, Moyes admirers including yourself have continually crabbed at every bit of success that RM has achieved, and any small amount of praise appeared to be given very grudgingly!' - Don't tarnish me with this brush - any sort of look through my posting history would reveal nothing but praise for how Martinez has done so far. I even wrote a whole article eulogising his tactics from the Chelsea game. its a popular game on ToffeeWeb to try and redraw the old battle lines and to somehow try and make out that if you supported Moyes you either automatically hate Martinez or that you don't deserve to be able to support him. It is absolutely ridiculous. I liked Moyes and I like Martinez so far. Some people hated the former, some people don't like the latter, don't try and push us all into the same camp though.

I would also remind you that winning two games isn't 'success' yet. That's not crabbing at anything, that's a reality that I was trying to articulate in my previous post.

Wayne Fortune
307 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:47:17
This side looks to have more of a will to win. Come on the blues.
James Marshall
308 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:54:05
All the people talking about sticking Lukaku straight into the team, have little idea about man-management. This isn't Football Manager on your PC, it's about managing human beings and Jelavic is one of those and should be managed as such.

You don't change a team that just beat Chelsea, simply because the guy you think is a better player is available - what would that do to Jelavic' already fragile confidence?

Lukaku is class, we all know that but he should be used from the bench when you have a recognised starting central striker in Jelavic. His performances have got better, and he created the winning goal brilliantly against Chelsea - that was some header back across goal I assure you.

Time will tell if he continues to start, but it's worth being mindful that Jelavic is a potent poacher, and should stay in the team for now. He's getting closer.

Nick Entwistle
309 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:55:52
Absolutely James. I think Barry 929 put it best.

With so much possession it in the least stops the opposition from having the ball. Clean sheets a plenty so far.

Going forward is where I have a problem, but I wouldn't be surprised if Lukaku could carry the team through to the moment where RM gets it right. I'm just not sure what that is though.

Excited for the Fulham match. Hoping to see the Barca kid and Lukaku again. Haven't seen Barkley in the flesh yet either.

Nick Entwistle
310 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:59:49
James M. Why not? Lukaku can do it all on his own... or just about. As much as I want to see Jely succeed we're obviously going to get more points with Lukaku in the one up front.

Jely needs a strike partner but that just isn't the way unfortunately.

Phil Sammon
311 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:21:06
James

Ridiculous. Sentiment only goes so far and Jelavic has been poor for months. We have stuck with him and given him every chance. If he can't perform then get someone in who can.

Any word on Kone from Martinez today?

Raymond Fox
312 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:14:03
James Martin, if I've got it wrong, I apologize.

After all, everyone is entitled to a different opinion, it would be very dull if we all thought the same.

James Marshall
313 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:42:29
Phil - where did I mention sentiment? I talked about man-management, which has nothing to do with sentiment. He's played as the spearhead, the poacher. Look at it another way - if you don't play Jelavic from the start, what use will he have a sub? Could you see him coming on to change games?

Who knows what will happen over time, but I don't think Jelavic has played badly so far, albeit no goals.

Ciarán McGlone
314 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:05:36
James,

Jelavic has been terrible for quite some time.

When he's not scoring, he brings very little else to the table.

I'm afraid his time's up.

As for 'man-management'...it works both ways. You can't have a player perform so badly and still get the nod every week - ahead of others. That's bad management too!

Jelavic has been given more than enough time....shepherd's hook.

James Marshall
315 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:18:26
He's in the team though, so surely we have to work with what the manager is doing? Dropping him after playing well (without scoring) recently seems like RM's plan, and I agree.

I also agree with you (and others) that he HAS had a BIG chance and been given plenty of time to score goals.

It's a tricky one, because like I said before, if he gets dropped now, what use is he to the squad? You might be right, perhaps some time on the bench will help, but didn't Moyes try that and he was worse when he came back?

I like him as a starter for now with Lukaku as an impact sub. Things will change though, no doubt.

Ciarán McGlone
316 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:22:40
James,

I think you're in a small minority of people who think Jelavic has played well..

I don't concur.

James Marshall
317 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:28:44
Maybe played well was an overstatement - perhaps I should have said played better :-)
Ingi Eyjolfz
318 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:30:17
Jelavic works his socks off every game, but doesn´t score. We have enough players that work their socks off on the field as it is. We need a striker that scores goals. I say put Jela on the bench and see if he starts scoring then, he surely isn´t doing it now.
Phil Sammon
319 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:25:54
He hasn't played well at all. He had the assist against Chelsea and has done nothing else of note.

Your idea of starting him because he's not good enough to come off the bench is completely warped.

Sentiment or man management - call it what you want, you don't play players just to avoid hurt feelings.

I like Jelavic, but you can only persist for so long. It's time to give someone else a chance.

James Marshall
320 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:01:48
OK I give in. Let him rot.
Kevin Palmer
321 Posted 23/09/2013 at 17:10:54
Kev Johnson #179 -

Glad I wasn't the only one shocked by that decision.

Because of the prevalence of those sorts of injuries in the NFL - and the resulting premature deaths, dementia, substance abuse, depression and numerous suicides - what were once considered little knocks to the head, are now treated with very, very seriously on this side of the Atlantic. I was surprised Lukaku's head injury wasn't dealt with similarly.

Patrick Murphy
322 Posted 23/09/2013 at 17:24:30
Maybe tomorrow would be an opportunity to play Jelavic and Lukaku up front together, with Jelavic in the centre and Lukaku on the left wing and RM on the right, not ideal but it may give Fulham something to think about and if it doesn't have the desired result in growing Jelavic's confidence then I don't know what we should do with the Croatian.
Kev Johnson
323 Posted 23/09/2013 at 17:20:20
Kevin: as someone commented above, there are stringent rules about concussion injuries in rugby over here in the UK - basically, you can't play for three weeks afterwards - but oddly, there seem to be no rules for football. I'm utterly baffled.

If we hadn't used all our subs at that point then presumably he'd have come off, but that should be irrelevent. If you lose consciousness then you should have to go off, as simple as that.

Mike Green
324 Posted 23/09/2013 at 17:53:01
Personally, if we're going to rotate players I'd like to see Delafeu get a run out from the start. If I was him I'd be a bit peeved I'd not seen much action yet.

As for Jelly, he was anonymous on Saturday, simply because I don't think we're really playing to his strengths anymore - and without that he's got nothing more to offer unlike Lukaku who looks like he can batter, harry, hold up, break, head, shoot, lay off, pass, thread.....anything.

The boys a monster.

Phil Sammon
325 Posted 23/09/2013 at 17:57:51
Well call me old fashioned, but I was DELIGHTED to see Lukaku knocked out in an Everton shirt. If it were up to me every member of the squad, coaching staff and management should lose consciousness at some point throughout the season. It builds character for gods sake!

Well done Lukaku.

Kev Johnson
326 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:08:46
Thank you, Doctor Sammon.

For those of you who are interested, Phil's new book 'Brain damage - in 10 easy steps' is due out just before Christmas...

Sly Silverman
327 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:00:39
There are some similarities between Lukaku and Anichebe. Both are big strong units. Both have played for Everton and WBA. Both can score with head or either foot.

That is were the similarities end. Numbers are king in sport. Victor has scored more goals for Everton and spent less time lying on the floor.

Ray Robinson
328 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:27:28
Sly, have you been concussed recently? I'm assuming your post is some sort of surrealist joke but I'm afraid, like Baines cross to Mirallas, it went over my head ? Victor spends more time on the floor than Lukaku does when knocked out!
Roger Helm
329 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:21:13
Apparently Lukaku was most effective for West Brom when he came on as a second half sub and monstered the tiring defenders. I think Jelavic is more effective facing goal, not with his back to goal, so if he played with Kone in a 4-4-2 to give more physical presence up front, he'd be back in the goals, with Lukaku to come on later to get even more goals
Harold Matthews
330 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:46:25
Mike G. Yes, I know Deulafeu is not part of the Martinez long term plan but I would also like to see him on from the start. His forlorn expression on the bench reminds me of Ross Barkley last season. It's tearing him apart.

Roger H. Interesting point about Lukaku. I didn't know about this.

According to Martinez we are now approaching the time of the year when Kone starts playing like Pele. Fit as a fiddle and sharp as a whistle,.....he's ready to fly.!!!!

Raymond Fox
331 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:33:58
Introducing Sammon and Johnson the comedy duo.

We learned one thing on Saturday if we didn't know before, Leighton's priceless to us, we simply should not sell him!
The question is how much will be offered now?
Where did we buy Leighton from, oh I forgot, it was Wigan!

Harold Matthews
332 Posted 23/09/2013 at 23:59:17
Raymond. I think we're all with you on Baines. A real star.

Personally, I'm hoping he has a blinder against N'castle because the thought of that guy, Ben Arfa, cutting in across his right leg is giving me nightmares. Of course, it's then up to the midfielders to get across and close him down, something they will surely work on.

I see Jol is putting out a full team because they badly need a win. This will be a tough one and I only hope our boys are really up for it. With Berbatov and Bent up front we can't afford to give them a sniff. These guys rarely miss.

Sorry if I've double clicked. Not sure.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb