Three new crest options revealed

, Everton FC , 22 September, 326comments  |  Jump to most recent
Voting opens at noon on Monday

The choices selected for the new Everton badge have been posted on Twitter by the club.

They feature a strong blue impression throughout — with only a feint hint of yellow on the middle of the three... which is most like the current version.

All feature the four prime components: Tower, Motto, 'Everton' and 1878.

The early consensus is that the rendition of the Prince Rupert's Tower is certainly more appealing than the dreadful 'beehive' that is front and centre on the current, unpopular badge that brought the latest redesign about.

Voting begins at evertonfc.com/crestvote tomorrow (Monday) at noon but we're polling our readers as well to see if there is a different consensus here.

Quotes or other material sourced from Everton FC



Reader Comments (326)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Robbie Muldoon
1 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:14:36
Is this a fucking joke?
John Keating
2 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:13:59
One on the left.
Oldie looking but modern and no shitty yellow in it
Dermot Ryan
3 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:14:46
Either the left or the middle option would do me.
Peter Laing
4 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:15:14
The one on the far left is a belter in my opinion, can't see what your problem is Robbie
Derek Knox
5 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:12:35
I think if I had the choice of one of those three options, it would have to be the one on the left, or number 1. (even though they're not actually numbered)

I doubt whether we will get a vote on TW, or will we?

Peter Laing
6 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:16:09
The crest on the left combines the retro elements well with a contemporary feel to it.
Patrick Murphy
7 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:16:41
It seems we are not far away from the original badge here with the badge on the left. Which proves don't fix it if it ain't broke. I think the middle one will probably end up as the new badge, But I do prefer the one on the left.
Phil Sammon
8 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:16:34
Overreaction there Robbie.

I like the one on the left. I'm one who values the 'shield' but the one on the right is nice in its own way too.

The middle one isn't my cup of tea.

LEFT LEFT LEFT

Peter Fearon
9 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:18:10
As a traditionalist I prefer the left one. I can see the point of the middle one. Hate the right one.
Ian Bennett
10 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:17:16
Jesus Christ - did they spend more than thirty seconds on these. Fucking amateurs. How can fans knock something up better than those 3 choices....
Brian Hennessy
11 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:19:23
Definitely the one on the left for me, middle one not too bad but one on the right is terrible.
Raymond Fox
12 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:18:26
1 or 3 in that order is my choice.
Michael Kenrick
13 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:18:31
I think the middle one is the ringer... have they slightly bloated the shield?

If you go with the left one, how different is that really from the previous version? Personally I think it's inferior. Doesn't the scroll underneath make it too hard to reproduce???

Garry Corgan
14 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:20:16
Despite all the time, feedback and consultations these are the best they could come up with? The Everton community did better than this in 15 minutes flat!

With that said, Number 3 (right) is probably the best looking but it's not Everton. Therefore I'm going to plump for Number 1 (left.)

Jamie Barlow
15 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:17:05
The one on the left for me.

I don't understand how our badge last season could be deemed digital unfriendly (or whatever it was) and the one on the left isn't. It has everything in it that the old one had. Should have kept last seasons.

Brent Stephens
16 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:21:39
KEEP LEFT.
Gerry Quinn
17 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:25:18
LEFT, definitely, but needs some yellow or gold in it. Were the school kids only given a blue crayon?
Robin Cannon
18 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:26:49
Not hugely impressed, but the one on the left definitely the best. The one on the right is some awful joke, right?
Michael Kenrick
19 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:27:26
Gerry, you are such a bad lad!
James Martin
20 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:19:57
Think I expected something a bit better from this consultation process. I can't imagine 1878 or 'Everton' featured too highly on anyone's questionnaires. I mean the one on the left looks like the most recent one with 'Everton' just shoved awkwardly into it.

I think the middle one will magically get chosen because it looks the most likely to be rotating around on the background of Monday Night football although it is crucially missing the laurel wreaths (again I can't imagine anyone voted for their omission from any new crest).

I think the one on the right is actually the best layout of all its components although the bottom of the border is a bit strange. I don't think this fits the brief of what the club want though, it doesn't look that easy to reproduce without error so I don't know why they've fit it in really.

The one on the left would be perfect if it didn't have Everton rammed into it. Then again it would just be the old badge and what would be the need for a consultation process. #1 gets my vote but I wouldn't be crushed by three. I can't stomach an Everton crest without the laurels on it though — although I'm sure the current board can quite easily.

Jarrod Prosser
21 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:27:41
Left. Done.
Alex Doyle
22 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:27:39
They're not great. Prefer the current one to these.
Tommy Meehan
23 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:25:40
Think the one on the right looks to be the best of them, but none of them seems to be an artistic feat. I still don't know why "Everton" needs to be blazoned across the crest
Brent Stephens
24 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:28:41
If I keep staring at the one on the right, the two laurels look like eyes peering back at me and the tower is the nose. Try it.

Fuck, get a life, Stephens.

Winston Williamson
25 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:29:07
I thought the one on the left is a little crammed. The one on the right is European looking. The one in the middle is a compromise between the shit they served up this season and the previous years'....

I think something better could definitely be created...

Phil Sammon
26 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:31:45
Well, I tried it Brent. I swear I saw Kenwright's face.
Brent Stephens
27 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:32:44
The stuff of nightmares, Phil! Do you see him in the boy's pen, there. Look hard.
Michael Kenrick
28 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:31:40
Great analysis, James: Spot on.

'Everton' does need to be on there, for the overseas millions who have no fucking idea who we are or where we are from. They are the new demographic I'm sure being targeted here — not the Old Guard from L4 and neighbouring burbs.

Mind you, since they have allowed a lock to be placed on the sale of our shirts, I'm not sure I really get the point of all this, TBH.

James Martin
29 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:31:41
On a second glance at this, I wouldn't be surprised at all if there was a bit of subliminal messaging going on. It is just too coincidental that the one most like the current version happens to be in the middle of the three with all the proper shading and definition. (Why isn't this on the other two badges?) I mean, looking at it already, it looks like something you'd push on a touchscreen.

The other two aren't as visually impressive and, like I said before, I think they deliberately included some off-putting features that would stop what would be an easy selection of a decent layout of either of those forms. Number 2 has Everton board written all over it and I will be shocked if that doesn't get selected regardless of the outcome of the vote.

Craig Fletcher
30 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:36:12
Keep left. Done.
Gerry Quinn
31 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:33:18
Michael - I'm not a bad lad - just still chuckling at Liz France's cartoon!
What might help everyone choose better would be if they put these badge designs on (a) a blue shirt background or (b) yellow shirt or (c) on a white shirt...just a thought
Lakovos Lasonidis
32 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:32:29
From these 3 definitely the left one but I have to admit I was expecting more, much more...
Harold Matthews
33 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:21:10
They appear to have everything covered and Miss Piggy will probably win it..
Eugene Ruane
34 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:30:01
All better than the Fisher Price baby crest (ie: our current beehive) but that isn't saying much.

As for choosing one of them...um...the one on the left is the least shite.

(the MilkyOne on TW makes them ALL look like they were designed by a particularly unartistic potato).

Brent Stephens
35 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:38:23
James, as I posted before, somebody called Electoral reform Services are validating the vote. I know the Electoral reform Society (well respected, bro) but never heard of the former. A private outfit who can be bought, by any chance?
John Ford
36 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:40:20
Left.... surprised at the lack of different options.
Robbie Muldoon
37 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:33:30
It's all subjective, but what can't be denied is these three efforts are rushed, unimaginative efforts slapped together with a big fat 'here you go you crying bastards' type attitude. Now just fucking pick one will ya.

It's been a farce, and Kenyon Fraser are not the right people to be designing these. Neither was a solitary inhouse designer (even though he done a real redesign) it should have went to a massive design company with a proper brief.

Mike Hughes
38 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:41:53
As I recall, the reason for the "modernisation" was due to some technical stuff about "reproduction issues".

As they all have the same elements of the badge we had last season, why bother changing from that badge?

They are all improvements on the current badge (the fridge magnet as I call it) - but let's face it, that wouldn't be difficult.

Stop buggering about and go back to last season's badge.


Gerry Quinn
39 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:46:56
I like that one - oh, hang on they've disappeared - no, yes, I do like all of those not shown anymore
Lewis Barclay
40 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:40:52
The crest in the middle is worse than the one we are trying to replace!
The one on the left looks pretty much the same as the old one.

I like the one on the right and because of it's simple shape it would transfer well.

I can however see us voting in a crest that either :
A: is the same (pretty mush) as the old one (what a waste of time and money this all was!)
B: voting in a crest that is worse than the one that the vote was arranged for in the first place.

Jim Lloyd
41 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:45:46
Christ almighty. They are awful! The one on the left is about the best of a bad bunch. The one on the right looks like a weird father christmas!
I've walked down the length of the Bullens Road many times and the badge there is miles better than any of these toytown badges
Garry Corgan
42 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:45:51
Michael & Lyndon ... Can we get a TW poll on these? Results shouldn't be too much different to the official result due next week.
Paul Ramsey
43 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:35:43
The left crest best represents Everton Football Club and I will be choosing it. I would hope the club will provide a breakdown of the votes so we can be certain we wont get fobbed off with the middle crest, which is truly awful, in a similar vein to current one. The right crest would be a acceptable, but I would be loathed to have such a simple crest shape.

Regardless, the tower and the laurels are key and cannot be missing. Please vote crest (1) left - and hopefully when overseas broadcasting collapses we can simply remove the awkward insertion of Everton and 1878. We know who we are, we know who we are....fuck off back to art school, we know who we are.

Gerry Quinn
44 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:48:08
You wicked boy, Michael - you took them off to re-draw them? You are taking the piss!
Steve Jones
45 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:35:34
These are basically the suggestions that have come in from the fanbase arent they....I've certainly seen the first two as submissions in the build up to all of this.

Middle one is a compromise blend of the old badge and the new one. All you can say for it is that its better than the current mess.

Left one doesnt fit the brief for ease of reproduction.

Right one doesnt fit at all.

I'd buy shirts with the left crest on.

Alan Corken
46 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:53:19
I like the current badge, it reflects our new confident approach. These are old school - like Moyes. Let's move forward!
Mike Hughes
47 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:51:32
If it's only between these three, then it has to be number 1.

Number 3 looks medieval to me, like it could be on a knight's armour !!!

Number 2 smacks too much of the current fridge magnet "effort".

Gerry Quinn
48 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:56:56
Can I vote for the Submission Code - it's a better design and easier to stitch than the 3 shown?
Phil Friedman
49 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:52:25
The benefit of the one in the middle is that the name of the club is large, which should be the most important message. Towers, laurels or Latin should be subordinate.
Michael Kenrick
50 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:57:29
I'm canvassing Mr Lloyd to add a fourth option in our poll: None of the above.

These are simply not good enough.

End of!

Ken Finch
51 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:49:30
The web site explains the rationale for all 3 options and ToffeeWeb will be having its own poll. All everybody has to do is vote.

I think the one on the left is the best because it is closest to the one we wanted to keep and features all the elements most fans are bound to say they wanted in response to the consultation. It is blue and white for the 'boys in the royal blue jersey' plus the tower is the traditional shape which is what we all wanted.

Amber or gold is not an overwhelming part of our tradition so that rules out the middle one for me.

The right hand one is, perhaps, futuristic and is intriguing but it would be a bold step. I would pick that one second.

Michael Kenrick
52 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:04:37
But the previous badge (that the new one replaced) is far to superior to Crest A. Indeed to all three.

VOTE NO! BOYCOTT THE CREST VOTE!!!

Jamie Barlow
53 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:00:44
There shouldn't be a fourth option in your poll. Surely we'd want a true reflection on what we want from what we can have? I can't see them changing again.
Mike Hughes
54 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:07:30
So how do we retract our vote?
I voted for number 1 under duress.
Mike Green
55 Posted 22/09/2013 at 22:57:40
Out of the three - 'A' by a country mile.

BUT - it's just a revamped version of the old crest, not a particularly improved one.

When the shit hits the fan and they outlined a six week turnaround it was obvious this was bollocks and there wouldn't be something great. I hoped there would - but hey, I like A more than the current abomination mainly because it has the wreaths on it, which I feel are second only to the tower.

'Everton' doesn't have to be anywhere near the badge - I've never seen 'Christian' written under a cross.

Win and they will come, and if they don't - fuck 'em.

Steve Ferns
56 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:07:38
The one on the left, but they should removed "Everton" and "1878". Oh wait that's the old badge we all know and love!

Ok, some they are set on Everton being in the badge, why not put Everton above the tower like in the middle one, keep the winners Laurel Wreaths, and just sack off the "1878". so foreigners don't know who Everton are from just looking at the badge, but would the same guys really give a shit we were founded (not as Everton I might add) in 1878?

I'd also like the motto's colours to be inverted - a white scroll with blue writing.

Gerry Quinn
57 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:17:46
Believe it or not, the 1878 seems to impress most people who look at my badge when I wear the shirt - they always seem to be blown away by how long the club has been going...
Gerry Quinn
58 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:21:11
..and then look at me and think I helped form them :)
Eric Holland
59 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:16:26
Left again.
Very much like the old badge retro and a bit of modernization.
Adam Smith
60 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:11:50
Why is it that when things are finally starting to pick up on the pitch, these morons conspire to make everything feel embarrassing and disheartening again?

That this is the sum total of a team of designers' work, with fan input, is truly appalling. How much do these people get paid? I think I could design a better crest by squatting over a piece of paper and wiggling whilst clenching a pencil between my arse cheeks.

What may I ask was wrong with the crest we have used these past 10 years or so? It kept our heritage but looked fresh and contemporary (and yes I think it is important to have our name on the crest for international audiences). The club have yet to actually explain what they mean when they say that the crest is hard to reproduce in the digital age. I'm sorry, but if in the last 25 years computer design has been able to create photo-realistic dinosaurs, level cities and create alien worlds full of giant smurfs, then I fail to see how trying to photocopy a shield and a banner is going to cause Microsoft to implode!

The options are appalling - the first looks like some horrendous throwback to the 80s, the second like a toddler has reconfigured the components of the old crest randomly using his set of fuzzy felts and the third - well this one looks the most like the crest of a 21st century football club, but absolutely NOT what an Everton crest should look like.

I said that I would never buy an Everton product with the new crest on it and have stuck by it despite the fact I love the new third kit (which is let down by the crest). Now I think I will not be buying an Everton product for the next decade or so.

Sad times.

Paul Smith
61 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:21:14
One on the right is awful, gotta be Number One for me. Have to say I'm not to enamoured by any of them really! But at least we get to choose this time.
Nik Ramsden
62 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:15:03
I should never be surprised at the reaction of some here. The official site explains each crest and the reason for its inclusion. We can all talk of conspiracy theories because the final three don't match up to the one we mocked up at home. I don't think you can knock the club for the way they have handled this and the results, like them or not, are the result of 20k Evertonians giving their opinion.

PS: Crest A please (the one on the left!).

Eugene Ruane
63 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:14:42
If it must have Everton on it (and it seems it must) and we want all the traditional elements, I like this (and like that it has no shield or circle) - http://www.designfootball.com/design-galleries/football-crests/img-efc-new-crest-2014-14242

If I was allowed to choose it, it would defnitely be http://www.bluekipper.com/articleimages/1370279577-Emilkyonedesign.jpg

As for 'Alan Corken' - "I like the current badge, it reflects our new confident approach. These are old school - like Moyes. Let's move forward!"

Fuck off Bill.

Guy McEvoy
64 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:25:12
I'm surprising myself by liking the one on the left even more than the last one. I never liked the yellow they sneaked in at the last iteration, always preferred the badge from the 1990s. I actually prefer this one (left) to both of them. For gods sake when you vote don't go worrying about 'difficulty to reproduce'. Vote for one that looks like, well, the Everton badge.
Jim Lloyd
65 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:25:16
Michael, that I will do! Please can we have a poll with a fourth option. That option being "none of these toytown excuses for our club's badge"

How can you have a choice of three bloody awful badges; and say you have got a favourite, because you've chosen the least pathetic?

Mike Green
66 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:19:01
If you hold your hand over the other two and look at them in isolation one by one A bosses it for me. Because essentially it's the nearest thing to our previous crest!

Interesting that B is the one that has the hint if yellow, the fading in the shield etc.

If it turns out we get B I will personally get the train into London and burn down the ERS.

Actually....that was a bit rash........nope! Checked again - I will burn down the ERS!

Also - the shield on C with the white tip and squeezed in motto on the top. I will stick a knife between my ribs to refer pain to a different area to cope with this if it gets voted in - I think it's called self harm.

Also - do you think the designers spent a lot of time and admittedly came up with a we'll designed, modern, multi functional platform blah blah marketing solution which we completely rejected, the clubs said you've got to do something different and they've said it'll cost you so with the crumbs of budget left the WANKERS have given us three fairly wank options.

About as creative as my next post. But I don't get paid for this shit.

Paul Smith
67 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:29:19
One on the left or in the centre. Number 3 is hideous.
Peter Thistle
68 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:24:40
None of them. All uninspiring and nowhere near as good as some of the fan ones i've seen. Guess the left one is the least bad.
Jim Lloyd
69 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:31:01
Spot on Mike!
Karl Masters
70 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:36:35
A definitely.

They are all better than the current one. The last one was rubbish anyway after Bill had it revamped in 2000 with that pale blue with 18 and 78 floating around it and Everton just stuck underneath it. He ruined the proper crest, which has only been on the shirt twice 1978-1982 and 1991-2000.

So stop crying Michael, the proper crest got binned 13 years ago. Boycott the vote? You wonder why ToffeeWeb gets the negative tag?

B is horrible, too much like this season's abomination.

C is better than B, but don't like that shield, especially the lines drifting apart at the bottom. What's that all about.

You can't please everybody, but they have tried and I will be perfectly happy with A.

Mike Green
71 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:38:08
Thank you Jim - actually the more I drink the better A looks. From experience I made that mistake with my wife 20 years ago so fools jump in.....

I genuinely think it's bollocks having 'Everton' on there. Isn't one of our sayings 'Needs no explanation'?

La Coste don't have "The Crocodile", no national flag has the name of the country underneath it (a pedant will prove me wrong) and no stamp says 'Royal Mail' on it.

We have an iconic crest, it needs no explanation and If we win games wearing it we won't be introduced on tele as 'the team with the badge with the tower and leaves on it' - we'll be introduced as EVERTON and any half wit will make the connection and if they don't thank fuck they don't support us!

Jim Lloyd
72 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:45:32
If you don't like any of these cack handed attempts at a badge , then how is ToffeeWeb being negative? If they were good creations, or if there was one good creation, then I wouldn't not choose it in order top be negative,

We are, in my humble opinion, being offered a choice of three pathetic creations, of which one will represent our club! Dearie me. I wonder at times why some think it's being negastive to say that none of them are worth putting on a shirt of EFC.

Jim Lloyd
73 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:52:25
Mike, in my long winded way, thats the point I wanted to make, so well done again. Very amateurish to have the name of the club emblazoned so prominently.
Karl Masters
74 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:52:34
Matter of opinion isn't it, Jim? My opinion is that you are being overly negative. Two of the three would be alright in my opinion and I prefer A, again in my opinion.

Your opinion is that they are all pathetic. That is clearly a negative opinion.

Luke Berry
75 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:57:29
The right crest looks best from a design perspective. I'll be sending the club my thoughts on how utterly uninspiring these designs are.

Whoever had a hand in designing them should be sacked immediately - and it maybe a good idea to get a new career.

Peter Foy
78 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:43:29
Wasn't the current one leaked early due to the application for copyright?

I presume Everton will have had to apply for copyright on all three. Or have they already applied for the copyright on ONLY one of these piles of shite.

Just a thought.

Anthony Jones
79 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:49:30
1 and 3 both look like faces with Everton blazened where a mouth would be. 2 is just shit.

Why the boring Everton font?

Why no non-shield options?

Why no imaginative variations?

Seems a complete waste of time. There were much better options produced by the fans. Even Lyndon's effort beat these.

Jim Lloyd
80 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:59:12
Aye aye Karl! My opinion is negative because its different from yours? If you had said that you believe my opinion is negative, then that's a fair opinion. What you appear to be making though, is a statement. My opinion is different from yours, so mine is clearly negative. Have I got that right?
Karl Masters
81 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:01:42
Yeah, even Lyndon's! Poor old Lyndon. Yours was a good effort.
Mike Green
82 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:55:54
Jim - point in case.

Last year I was on holiday in Spain and bought a ball to play on the beach with my lad - who at the time was 5.

It was smaller than a standard football, was just the right size for a kick about, was made up of the Barcelona colours and had the Barcelona crest on it.

My lad loved it to bits, pointed at the crest and said 'what's does that mean'? I explained it was Barcelona Football Team and he's six now, loves them to bits, has absolutely no idea how good they are but he's 'chosen' them as a team he likes.

If a 5 year old can do it, anyone can.

Robbie Muldoon
83 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:51:00
People need to understand why the badge needs changing. It doesn't reproduce well digitally because of the floating elements outside the badge and scroll. 1878 and Everton are the problem parts but essential for how the club wishes to market itself, NAME and LONG HISTORY.

The problem with the redesign was the dumping of the wreaths and the ugly tower design. Fix them two and we would have been ok.

Now we're just in farcical territory. I know, I work with designers every day.

Karl Masters
84 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:03:29
Read it again Jim. My OPINION is that you are being overly negative.

It's bloody obvious we have different opinions, which of course is the way of the world. I don't think the word pathetic has ever been used as a positive though.

We all want what's best don't we? So let's not fall out, eh?

Mark Eccles
85 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:56:31
I really like a or the one on the left its basically the old one but just modernised... and it will attract the younger crowd which is a good thing. But I really don't like the other two.

Sometimes change is good... and I like the current one now anyways even though I'll get slaughtered for saying it.

Mike Green
86 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:10:48
Karl - Brendan Rodgers is pathetic, that's a positive. :)
Jim Lloyd
87 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:08:27
Don't think I understood your last sentence Karl. Read very much like a statement. Mind you, that's only after several very nice real ales tonight, so fair enough. I don't however like any of the designs as they stand.

Aye we all want what's best but I don't think any of these live up to our motto.

Michael Kenrick
88 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:09:34
"We all want what's best, don't we?"

You may think that, but clearly it's not the case.

Anyone voting for these who thinks a better job could be done is obviously settling for "not what's best" — aka something 'pathetic', at least in the context of what COULD be achieved.

Ironically (or not) it's exactly the same argument we had between those who accepted OFM and what he was doing to our club as 'good enough' because we didn't deserve / couldn't afford anything better. And guess what: people like you, Karl Masters, were very quick to label them as "negative" — because they wanted something better.

True Colours...

Kev Johnson
89 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:08:05
The first is too similar to the original (and therefore hard to reproduce, etc) and the middle one too similar to the current redesign (and therefore shit).

The best designed is number 3, on the right. It doesn't make me want to leap up and down with glee, but such is life...

Gavin Fennessy
90 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:11:21
Not too impressed with these three choices. Thought several of the fan submissions struck the best balance between tradition and modern design.

Of the three, Option A is perhaps most acceptable but the scroll below the shield looks a bit fussy and the entire design is a bit busy. I think someone else mentioned that it would be useful to see mock ups of how these designs would look on the shirt.

I voted for the change to the circular badge as I was really impressed with some of the fans designs. Surprised that not one circular design made it to the last three for consideration.

Tony Draper
91 Posted 22/09/2013 at 23:54:13
My suggestion for the TW poll would be to have six options, of which we could select two

First three would be the "new" options,
#4 would be the badge before "the abomination"
#5 would be "none of options #1>#4"
and
Option #6 would be "Fuck off Kenwright"

Just a thought

Jim Lloyd
92 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:19:14
I like option 6 Tony! Or can we have 2 votes? Then I'd have 4 and 6
Tony Draper
93 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:21:19
Jim (609)
The bit where I said " of which we could select two" LOL

And Yes that's what I'd vote too Jim !

David Munro
94 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:19:30
I would have prefer a circular badge too, but of the three I think everything fits nicely in C.

A looks like a bad version of the old one, and B just looks silly.

C for me.
Jackie Barry
95 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:26:35
One on the left.
Jim Lloyd
96 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:34:22
Ha ha Tony, only just noticed you'd given us the two option! :)
Keith Edmunds
97 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:39:00
C for me. Depends partly on the size. One of the problems I have with the current badge is that it looks huge on the shirt.
Phil Bellis
98 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:28:08
Not read all the above posts, as these are, after all, personal opinions
The choices reinstate the motto due to fans' complaints - OK

BUT..
for fuck's sake, the only reason we have the 2 fat badges is to include the name Everton

I refer the forum and the tossers at the Everton "commercial" dept to Harry Catterick's 60's statement "we don't need our name on our shirts; everyone knows the team in Royal Blue is Everton"


It's simply a marketing ploy to make the sweat-shop, Asian production easier so our "partners" can make greater profits


Note the complexity of some other PL badges

As well as the worth-consideration, non-My Little Pony badges designed and offered by "ordinary" Evertonians, what in God's name is wrong with the 1991 badge?

http://www.historicalkits.co.uk/Everton/Everton.htm

I like the 3rd strip worn at West Ham but will not buy anything sullied with that abomination (collectors' item?)

I give up; this club is hard going, a lot of the time

Mark Jones
99 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:49:02
A for me.

Though I really don't see how it fits the original brief of needing a modern, scalable crest - I've never seen so many individual design elements crammed into such a small space.

The problem is trying to design anything by committee isn't going to work. Even though I'm not a fan of the crest we're using this season, I honestly wish they had the gumption to just stick with it - everyone would get over it sooner or later.

All this does is drag the issue out and still we'll never please everyone.

Mike Green
100 Posted 23/09/2013 at 00:51:30
On Saturday market, the three options are

A - knocked up Everton Badge

B - pppphhh!!!!

C - am I on cam

Phil Bellis
101 Posted 23/09/2013 at 01:10:37
"everyone would get over it sooner or later"

Speak for yourself

Pat Finegan
102 Posted 23/09/2013 at 01:15:57
In America we can vote for a write-in candidate for president. I voted for Frank Reynolds in the last election because I thought the candidates were equally terrible. Do we get a write in on the badge vote as well?

My vote: Lyndon's

Of the three available, A.

Simon Temme
105 Posted 23/09/2013 at 01:52:30
I voted for A.

A conservative, historical knee-jerk that is actually a lot worse than it's predecessor.

I Should have voted for B:
Clean, modern, Nil satis,Tower, Shield (Date) in an enclosed space...

No Laurels; however, I really liked the round badge #5/#6 on the previous crest post as it had everything but may have been deemed to Chelsea?

IRMWT.

Jamie Sweet
107 Posted 23/09/2013 at 01:52:21
After seeing efforts such as the Milky One, I was anticipating something quite special to come from this process. I thought that the design "experts" would come up with something well beyond the scope of my creative thinking.

I was wrong.

Are they better than "the abomination'? Clearly yes they are. Well done.

Are they better than the one before that? Not particularly.

I understand that the message from fans was not to break too far from tradition. A and B meet that criteria, but they are just so uninspiring.

I hope we didn't pay a lot to the people who came up with these because I have seen at least three designs from fans which shit all over these.

I think A is the best of a disappointingly mediocre bunch.

Paul Columb
108 Posted 23/09/2013 at 03:35:11
Got to admit, I'm pretty floored at the poor quality of the designs. Was expecting much more in terms of innovation. I'd actually take a slimmed down version of the last incarnation above them all. Really dissapointing.
Kristian Boyce
109 Posted 23/09/2013 at 03:53:40
I think all three are pretty poorly designed. By the looks of it the left badge includes the popular responses on the original survey the club sent out. Unfortunately it looks like someone from the clubs marketing department has just tried to stick everything into one badge.

For such a stink about the changing of the badge, I feel it's a pretty poor attempt from the club to update the badge (again). Unfortunately the club will turn around and say 'We asked your opinion, and you gave it, and this is what you wanted."

Peter Warren
110 Posted 23/09/2013 at 04:15:25
Montgomery Brewster - vote no to all of the above.

Bloody hell. What a choice. We have to pick a badge we don't like just because its not as bad as the others. All our crap so disappointing

David Ellis
111 Posted 23/09/2013 at 04:56:12
It's only a crest!

Some will like it. Some won't. Its easy to agree we don't like something.

But you could put up a million different designs and have the vast majority of fans hating each one of them.

Eric Myles
112 Posted 23/09/2013 at 05:04:47
Prefer A-C-B in that order but I would be happy with any of them.
Stu Cameron
113 Posted 23/09/2013 at 05:17:40
I can't believe this is the best we have got to choose from. I know 'A' looks similar to our old one, but it's a very, very poor version of it. Just doesn't look right to me. The middle looks the most modern but is still shite.
Phil Sammon
115 Posted 23/09/2013 at 06:22:42
I like Badge 'F'. Though the alien's eyes could do with being larger and the dog should be much more defined. Certainly captures our heritage though.
Tom Hughes
116 Posted 23/09/2013 at 06:43:03
All these show is that there's nothing wrong with the 1938 original which if included in the vote would wipe the floor with the lot. The reproduction issues are a complete red herring. If we need instant recognition then try winning something. .... works a treat every time. The whole process is a joke and unnecessary distraction.
Andy Codling
117 Posted 23/09/2013 at 06:58:42
All three are crap, get a blue liver bird in there somehow.
Ian Bennett
118 Posted 23/09/2013 at 07:08:16
Surely the motto should be changed to 'Any badge is good enough, I am off down the pub'.
Mark Jones
119 Posted 23/09/2013 at 07:26:32
Laurel wreath eyes, a towering nose and a scroll for a mouth...crest A is smiling at us all.
Ben Dyke
120 Posted 23/09/2013 at 07:54:49
I have decided not to care about our badge because its not worth it. I do really care about how the team does on the pitch. I do buy the shirt when I can to support the team regardless of what it looks like, albeit I like some years more than others, not surprisingly when its all subjective matters of taste and preference.

You can't do this by committee as its too many voices but I applaud the club for listening. We got the procedure we wanted so we can't complain too much when it produced something we are unhappy with.

Rob Pryor
121 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:10:03
Yeah but Phil (647) a well defined dog would be difficult to reproduce with some modern multimedia. What I want to know is where the hell is the dancing mongoose??
Mike Green
122 Posted 23/09/2013 at 07:57:24
David #643 - why don't we wear red shirts too.....? It's only a colour after all.
Brent Stephens
123 Posted 23/09/2013 at 07:59:36
I surprised myself with how angry I got at the announcement a few months ago about this season's crest. For me, the focus of the anger was the loss of NSNO.

NSNO has been reinstated in all 3 options, as have the laurels (in two).

I think the process of development of the design options so far has probably been "clean" and inclusive of fans opinions. What has emerged from that process has (I guess) converged on what, for most people, are the key design features. So no surprise that the 3 look not a million miles away from each other.

No way they are now going to iterate in the process and allow a wider range of options to be suggested and consulted on. So we get on with it. Just hope we can trust that Electoral Reform Service!

Number 1 for me. NSNO

Brent Stephens
125 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:21:38
PS, boycott the crest vote and they'll just go with the crest that polls the greatest number of votes. So a wasted non-vote as you'll possibly end up with your least preferred option. Let's have the Australian system - all fans MUST vote or they won't be admitted to GP.

Or we could ask them to use something such as the single transferable vote system! Yeh...

Simon George
126 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:13:45
Not the best selection to be fair, B and C are pretty poor.

So its A by default for me.

What's the deal with the club continuously trying to get yellow into the home colour? It's like we're desperate to incorporate yellow in some way.

My Everton is and always has been Blue, White, White at home, so the badge should reflect those colours.

Dave Charles
127 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:33:33
And these are the best three. Get back to the drawing board.
Mike Green
128 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:19:19
I work in Sales and it's well known in business we have a notoriously bad relationship with Marketing and this is an example of why.

Marketeers wouldn't know a customer if they came up to them and shook their hand - and if they did they'd wash it afterwards.

I could "sell" A all day long - the others not so much - and the last one would've been a tough one, but do any of these really inspire me? Not really - and I don't think they would my "customers" either.

I don't really give a toss about reproduction, or giving a la-de-da agency an easy life - all I care about is the integrity and quality of the product (Everton Football Club) and the customer (Us) - everything else is a side issue and it irritates the fuck out of me when people who understand neither are paid good money to get involved in either.

The 'new' crest is a perfect point in case - looked great to anyone that wasn't an Evertonian, looked shit to anyone who was. Now with an abundance of help from "the customer" they chuck out a handful of lazy, uninspiring, sulky efforts over a skinny Latte.

Typical.

Kev Johnson
129 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:51:18
Talk about a self-fulfilling prophecy! It's no wonder Sales have such a bad relationship with Marketing, Mike. The latter may not understand your side of the equation - but you've just shown that you don't have a foggiest idea about the importance of what they do either!
Paul Mackie
130 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:51:49
I like all 3 of those with the one on the right just edging it.

The club can't win here. No matter what design they go with there'll be a whiny and very vocal minority who absolutely hate change of any form.

Mike Green
131 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:06:34
Kev - having worked alongside them for 20 years I understand exactly what they do and it's wrapped up in the penultimate line of post #644.
Peter Warren
132 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:06:59
Mike 664 # I know the guy whose business was instructed to come up with 3 (I think he said out of 7) designs. Unsure if any of his feature here (I do not particularly like any) but to be fair he is an Evertonian
John Ford
133 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:06:28
Free the 'Milky one'

John Keating
134 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:09:05
I voted for the left one straight off.
However, the Echo have superimposed the 3 badges on the actual shirt.
The middle one with the shitty yellow still looks atrocious but surprisingly the one on the right looks not bad.
Ken Crowther
135 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:02:01
For fuck's sake!!

I was happy with the 'old' (pre-2013) crest; but if you're going to vote, vote now and get on with your lives.

We weren't consulted when they (the club) made any of the previous nine(?) changes. They've learned a lesson (i.e. "The bastards will whinge whatever you try to do to please them") so let's stop trying to re-design a uni-cycle.

Ken Crowther
136 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:19:57
ps - I prefer the one without the laurels.
Matt Traynor
137 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:06:59
Brent #659 "Let's have the Australian system - all fans MUST vote or they won't be admitted to GP."

It seems these days you can be refused admittance for a lot less!

Of the 3, like the majority I go with A. (Dunno why loads are referring to 1, 2 and 3 - they're clearly labelled A, B and C or was this some late editing shenanigans?)

Re the dropping of the motto from this season's badge, it's telling how with the new motif around Goodison, they've re-instated the motto. Thereby negating their "consistency" argument. However, as pointed out in previous threads, many organisations have multiple logos to reflect different reproduction situations (colour v B&W for instance). I once worked for an organisation that had multiple operating divisions, each with it's own variation of the logo to differentiate it.

But all 3 options fail to excite / inspire.

(Topical off-topic snippet - a few years ago, Singapore held a big consultation exercise to rename the new Marina Bay area - where yesterday's F1 was held - after a lot of new development. $400,000 contract with a brand agency, they came up with "Marina Bay". I was sat in the meeting with the Tourism Board when the big reveal was made, and practically wet myself. No-one in the pub later would believe me).

Sam Hoare
138 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:18:33
Doesn't look great in isolation but I think the right one might look good on a shirt. All pretty unimaginative and uninspiring.
Nick Entwistle
139 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:17:27
None of the above, Because none are as good as the badge no one wanted replacing.


Mike Green
140 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:29:25
And if they don't Peter #671 then that illustrates the point! :)
James Newcombe
141 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:29:35
I'm a little disappointed with these, but I would go with C if they could lose the gradient. It just looks smarter. Failing that, A, but it needs some work on the motto and i'd lose the weird extra outline!
Ian Burns
142 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:25:34
The one on the left "A" in isolation but the one on the right "C" may look better on a shirt.

I am not going to qualify my selection with a comment on the design as it is all subjective and personal.

Can we run a poll on TW that would count towards the official vote?

Peter Mills
143 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:39:51
I'll be voting A, and think it is better than the one we had prior to this season.
Tony Draper
144 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:14:49
At first look, I instantly found both A & B acceptable, but strongly prefer A. For me it echoes the "mental image" that I have of the Everton Football Club Crest

C does not do that at all, frankly it looks like it belongs to Portsmouth
Similarly the fan offerings with circles would be readily confused with both Chelsea and Rangers (from which Chelsea drew inspiration both as a club and for the Crest), I would strongly want this avoided

I recall NO expressions of dissatisfaction with the "pre-abomination" crest from either the fans or the Club itself

As I understand this process it is to "Update" the Club Crest, NOT to rebrand Everton FC (example Cardiff "The Bluebirds" now playing in red)

I like Option A

Nick Entwistle
145 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:37:35
When us human types have a choice of two opposing options then the choice will be made on preference alone.

However, when there is a choice of three, and two of those are similar and the third option much different, many studies have shown that the much different option is dismissed.

The reason is that the weaker of the similar two will make the superior one shine all the more sparkly and take our vote.

This is extremely common knowledge when it comes to influencing the public and hey presto, Kenwright has a badge very similar to the old one.

I'm presuming here the left one will be chosen.

They would never tell you of course, but its the reason why Alex Salmond and Dave Cameron had a barny over the independence vote having three options. Full independence, partial independence or stay in the union.

Keith Edwards
146 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:45:11
I don't think im overly fussed on any of them, and I thought there were going to be at least 5 crests to vote on. If I have to chose any of these 3 it would have to be A with C second choice. What is the rush to get the new crest done and dusted?? It's not going to be used until next season so why not give the the designers a little more time and less pressure to come up with better designs.
Mike Green
147 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:52:54
Nick #687 - they had a Barney about that because it would've been Option A, Option Have Your Cake And a Eat It and Option C.
Kev Johnson
148 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:58:25
In case anyone hasn't noticed, the OS shows the three designs in their different contexts - ie, on the shirt, the website, etc. Just click on the crests in "More Features":

http://www.evertonfc.com/crestvote

Steve King
149 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:02:55
C, A, B in that order for me.

I think Option C looks great on the shirt.

Option A is the closest to the old one but kinda messed up by the EVERTON written across the middle.

Option B is just shit.

Mike Green
150 Posted 23/09/2013 at 09:57:26
#686 - "Portsmouth" - spot on!

I've just put the new options against the old / last years crest and for me it's easy - keep it as it was and take the word 'Everton' out, you can even take the 1878 away for me.

The badge is an emblem, a symbol. So for menthe Tower (where we're from), the wreaths (our aims) and the motto (what we stand for) are all that are needed.

Despite what I said earlier I have genuine sympathy for the agency that designed this seasons badge as all they were doing was following a brief, and I'm sure they executed it perfectly. The issue is whether or not they tried to dig down deep enough to find a solution that would suit both the business and it's customers - and I think the answer to that is 'No'.

So after making a bad effort of cracking a nut they have put the nutcrackers back on the table and glued the original nut back together as best they can.

Andrew Clare
151 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:10:44
Left. Without Everton name.
Darren Scotland
152 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:12:59
This crest debacle goes from bad to worse!

The original redesign is terrible and if anything, these 3 options are even worse!

Cobbled together by throwing every element at the page at once with no regard for sizing and how they might in different formats etc.

I'm flabbergasted. And to think a 'proper' agency is responsible for these now, eh?

Jason Ingham
153 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:16:39
When the current crest was launched, my initial reaction was close to aghast. Now I'm apathetic. The consultation exercise for the new new-crest hasn't delivered an improvement and I wonder is anybody really bothered now? Seems like a money-wasting exercise all-round.
Kevin Jones
154 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:09:36
I will be voting for option C. A, is to close to the one we've just changed, B is to close to the one we have now, whereas C is different, looks slim and has everything that means anything to us.
Darren Scotland
155 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:18:42
A classic 'design by committee' outcome of ever I saw one.
Dave Guest
156 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:28:37
ToffeeWeb,
Is it too late to allow the designers to adapt your badge. I love it and reckon it would be perfect image wise.
Maybe go ultra modern and try the cathedral in a modern swansea swan type way?
I hate the three choices!
Jim Lloyd
158 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:20:08
"It's only a crest, vote for one and get on with your lives."

Well, I think there's a few issues here. The club bring out what I consider to be a bloody awful design for, presumably, the purpose of "modernising our image, making it clearer, snappier and, by the way, to make it easier to manufacture and stick on merchandise they wish us to buy.

It also does something else though, doesn't it. It pronounces to the world, the symbol representing our club. The misbegotten attempt that caused at least 20,000 Evertonians to sign a petition opposing it's introduction, looked like something from a kid's printing set from Noddy's Toytown.

They've now come up, with what I see, as poor attempts to incorporate the various ideas/designs that fans have submitted and given us a vote now, on which one wuill represent our club.

It seems to me that we have poor representations of our club's history and the Corinthian ideal of our forefathers. So poor, I don't really want to voter for any of them but think about voting for A as least worst.

But I'm not going to vote as that, to me, lends credence and support to a poor firdst image of our club to the world.

It also gives the club a perfect answer to criticism "well, you voted for it.

I hate to say this but the club over the Park are light years, in my opinion, in design, marketing and importance of image.

They have taken the Liver Bird and made look something like a rampant eagle, rather than the Cormorant that it is, and put that crest on their shirts. They then come up with with the clarion call to arms "Rise Up" (and |Bite People, is the missing bit.) They have redesigned their club badge and that's their image and their brand.

I look at ours and just shake my head.

Brent Stephens
159 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:52:57
Jim "It also gives the club a perfect answer to criticism "well, you voted for it"

Aye, but if you don't vote, they can say "you couldn't be arsed to vote, so don't come whingeing". BTW, Jim, that's not me saying it; it's delivered in a Corrie Street-type accent.

Tony J Williams
160 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:51:54
Easy choice - Left one.
Ed Casey
161 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:58:15
A
Robbie Muldoon
162 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:58:15
For what it's worth I have just asked my colleague who is a professional graphic designer to touch up the redesigned Everton badge, I think this is spot on. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BU1jYwjCIAAC9__.jpg
Jim Lloyd
163 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:55:44
True enough Brent. A bit of damned if you do, damned if you don't and Luvvie boy will be able to stick his cheesy big gob all over the screens and say what an all inclusive club we are.

Mind you, I'll not be coming whingeing, but I'll not give my vote to any of those designs. Not likely to be buying any merchandise with it on either.

Robbie Muldoon
164 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:00:20
We don't need NSNO on the badge. It's still our motto.
Neil McKinney
165 Posted 23/09/2013 at 08:32:05
Pretty uninspiring as many have said above. It does annoy me that these design companies are supposed to be the experts and will charge exorbitant amounts of money for not very much. We have seen the creativity from fans with their own designs and quite honestly it puts this lot to shame.

However, All 3 are better than the current Mickey Mouse offering, and if I have to opt for one then it would be A. I hated the current one and I definitely don't feel the same strong opposition to any of these, so as disappointed as I am in the effort and money that must have been wasted on this whole badge fiasco, I think I could at least move on with any of the 3 options above.

I'm glad that at least one of the three options (C) was a bit different (albeit still a shield) as 3 slight variations on the same theme would've been a little bland, but I suppose that the aim of the questionnaire was to try and narrow down the brief. A circular one would've been interesting as despite the obvious similarities to the Chelsea badge, there's been some really interesting circular ones thrown up by fans.

I am no designer and it is all a matter of taste, as the differing opinions above demonstrate. Clearly there is no 'right' answer or design that will please all, but the current one is just so bad that it almost united everyone (save the odd person) in their utter contempt for it. Many people have cited the Milky One design, which I must admit that I liked when I first saw it, but as with the shield on the right above with its strange detail at the bottom (where the inner shield separates from the outer ??) the Milky One design had the strange feature of the club name text and club motto text forming different size circles. An obvious flaw for me (one that was pointed out by Peter Leslie in another thread) but one that could've been easily rectified to create a good design. I'm not having a pop at Milky One, just trying to demonstrate that even with a fundamentally popular design, there was a small design feature that bothered me. I said before on the other crest thread that I was realistic about what I would get from this whole badge thing and didn't expect to love the eventual choice. I just hoped that I didn't hate it like I do the current one. I think I can say that they have satisfied that wish, but it's all very underwhelming isn't it.

Jim Lloyd
166 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:01:33
Robbie,
Are you able to do a link to that, at all. I haven't got a clue how follow the directions, being a total Luddite.
Eugene Ruane
167 Posted 23/09/2013 at 10:10:41
Actually, if ever anything has shown just how staggeringly badly run our club is and how out of touch and inept our board is, it is this whole crest thing.

Here's what has happened so far.

Everton supporters have opposing views on everything.

On TW each day you can find a 'debate' about just about every Everton-related issue one could think of.

Ground, manager, coach, midfield, new kit design, new grass, Osman etc etc etc.

But one thing NOBODY seemed to have a problem with was our badge.

I don't recall a single 'Our badge is shite' thread or (consequently) posters at each others throats over it.

So of course, OF COURSE soft arse sticks his oar in and decides to change it.

He grabs in a couple of soft touches, gives them tea and a few sausage rolls and says (holds up Fisher Price beehive) "What do you think of this, we love it?"

They (apparently) say "Er...yes it.."

"Hurrah!" says Bill "The supporters have spoken!"

The badge is then rushed to Nike and there we are - done.

And we certainly have been.

Outrage follows instantly and within a couple of days 22,500 blues have told Bill to stick his kids drawing up his arse.

Realising a large hairy testicle has been dropped, panic ensues and we are told 'Er...sorry, we'll do it again only this time you'll all get a say (as long as you understand that 'a say' means "Please tell us which of these three style-free designs - that you've had NO say in - do you think is least shite").

So we are where we are, got to be A because...er..it isn't as bad as B or C.

Terrifying thing is if they can make such an almighty fuck up of getting a badge (nb: that didn't need changing) right, what the FUCK is the state of our finances/loans?

I personally won't be surprised to see the headline "Everton owe £15 trillion in interest on thirty five nicker loan taken out 10 years ago"

(ok, a slight exaggeration but..)

Eugene Ruane
168 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:06:56
Robbie (714) - "For what it's worth I have just asked my colleague who is a professional graphic designer to touch up the redesigned Everton badge, I think this is spot on. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BU1jYwjCIAAC9__.jpg"

It is (fortunately!) worth nothing and maybe you'd like to define 'spot on'.

Phil Sammon
169 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:07:19
How much better is this than any of the proposed options -

http://www.90magazine.co.uk/2013/09/04/fan-designed-everton-badge-wows-twitter/

Brian Cleveland
170 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:17:13
Oh dear.... is that the best all those creative minds can come up with... or was the brief they were given too restrictive?

if I have to choose one it would be the left one, but the Nil Satis nisi Optimum needs more work as its just too flat and linear....

I'd rather go back to what we had last year to be honest and be done with it.

Tony Draper
171 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:07:59
Eugene (720)
Thanks for at least raising a laugh, I deeply appreciate that

TBH I'd expected the options to have been:
#1 http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-Fr6YvCVLcUA/TeNkfC8p9fI/AAAAAAAAAP4/y6Kgiu8nG6Y/s1600/1960%2527s+Club+Crest+Original.jpg

#2 http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_jLlqDrcSYeQ/S8YJTPNjufI/AAAAAAAABic/lb88QZH7IWE/s1600/Bill+Kenwright+3.jpg

#3 http://i883.photobucket.com/albums/ac39/expatblue/badge_zpsedff8496.png

Stuart Mitchell
172 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:41:47
I think there were some much better fan designs out there, should have given a larger range to choose from.

The 1st one is ok but hate the other 2.

Chance missed to really let the fans pick our new badge.

Mark Stone
173 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:02:08
All three of these are awful. The current one is better.
Denis Richardson
174 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:12:31
Has to be A surely, its the one most like the old crest. B is shite and similar to the current crest and whoever came up with C needs their head examined! Not exactly much of a choice after the 'extensive consultancy'!

Happy with A anwhow.

Neil McKinney
175 Posted 23/09/2013 at 11:55:07
I am somewhat confused by the sizing as well. The current badge is so big on the shirt that it's like the numbers on my grandma's telephone. Have they consulted fans and established we're all partially sighted?

Then there's my preferred (if that's the right word) option of the three above, Option A or 1 or the left one, where it seems like the crest is too small for the rest of the elements it contains.

Tony J Williams
176 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:11:43
Voting done, A.

I don't see the need for the name Everton on the badge, we know who we are already.

Mark Stone
177 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:18:37
http://www.rgvblogger.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/brewster.jpg
Kevin Tully
178 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:22:21
Roberto has chosen option 'A'

Live presser here ;

http://www.evertonfc.com/live

Trevor Thompson
179 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:27:00
Was really hoping for something a bit more modern with a traditional twist. The badges presented aren't that much different to the ones we've had since 2000. Disappointed in them but I'd vote for badge A. At least it's a step up from this season's badge design...not much, though.
Robbie Muldoon
180 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:29:02
Jim Llyod (719) you'll have to copy this... https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BU1jYwjCIAAC9__.jpg ... and paste it into your address bar.

Eugene (721) it's spot on the original brief, a redevolped badge that looks distinctly Everton and includes the most important components all in one shield which will work across all multimedia platforms and kit embroidery.

This badge design needs a vision and direction, this design has all of that.

Matty Williams
182 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:25:11
A for me, but why only thee crests to choose from? We have three shirts, so why not three simple designs to put on each one?! The simple EFC on the home shirt would do me, circa 1972~1975, a simple tower design for the away shirt, and the 1978 badge for our third shirt.

We're a unique club, so why not three badges!!!
Niven Teh
183 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:19:35
First of all I don't know why they narrow it down to just 3 crests for us to vote for. There should at least be 10 crests to choose from. Out of the 3:-

A - looks too similar to our previous badge except that there are too many elements cramped inside the shield making it slightly elongated and the font used is too plain. Majority of you chose A because of the sentiment towards our previous crest. But I do feel we need to progress with the time to something different.

B - is the worst of the lot because the laurel wreaths is missing and it is too similar to our horrible current crest.

C - is the modernized version balanced with the traditional elements. Simple, modern yet tradition.

So my vote goes to C.

Niven Teh
184 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:19:35
First of all I don't know why they narrow it down to just 3 crests for us to vote for. There should at least be 10 crests to choose from. Out of the 3:-

A - looks too similar to our previous badge except that there are too many elements cramped inside the shield making it slightly elongated and the font used is too plain. Majority of you chose A because of the sentiment towards our previous crest. But I do feel we need to progress with the time to something different.

B - is the worst of the lot because the laurel wreaths is missing and it is too similar to our horrible current crest.

C - is the modernized version balanced with the traditional elements. Simple, modern yet tradition.

So my vote goes to C.

Matt Traynor
185 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:42:05
Tony #741, as pointed out, the name on the badge isn't for us - it's for the international viewing audience who need to know who we are. The overseas TV deal is worth £1bn over 3 years, and unlike the domestic TV money, it is split equally between all clubs. (The RS lobbied to have this changed and split according to global "popularity" but got no backing).
Ross Edwards
186 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:55:15
I think A gets my vote.
Tony Fearns
187 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:59:59
It doesn't matter what we think. they will choose the pimped up new badge B as they have made the original looking badge A worse and thrown in a totally stupid space age looking thing C.
Paul Willis
188 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:45:18
Not sure it's worth the stick but C is a grower. Horrified to lose the crest at first but it's an awkward shape to deal with and, although the first ever badge, it was not part of the great 80s team... so why are we so desperate to hold on? It's gone before; it can go again.

When news came out we were in this Guiness Cup and they lined up the badges, the current badge looked embarrassing against the other modern classy and clean badges and I thought we should have designed something sharper, like Arsenal's badge. Clearly, looking at C, I wasn't the only one as this is a complete rip-off of Arsenal's badge shape but it does work and looks neat. The Latin isn't wedged in like an afterthought, it follows the shape of the badge nicely rather than B which looks like a poor cut-&-paste straight from Microsoft Word.

A is good but it's not far removed from what we had except containing it within the crest as needed. It's safe and that was fine when we were under Moyes but now we're on the Roberto roller-coaster with a fresh style — let's get something new in the badge too and truly welcome a new era.

Conn Prosser
189 Posted 23/09/2013 at 12:43:03
A.
Chris Keightley
190 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:15:43
If anyone went down to the monument itself, you will notice that size wise it,s much more in keeping with the badge that we have right now, The building does not slightly resemble the images on the current badge.

f your unsure, take a trip down there – you get some great distant views of Wales from the monument.

Kev Johnson
191 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:13:12
I find it strange that a couple of people have said that some of the redesigns look like a face with eyes. I've always thought our crest looked like a face. I thought that was totally obvious!

As far as I'm concerned, the laurels, bridewell, motto, date and club name are all of secondary importance. The main thing is: it has to look like a face, with eyes, nose and, if at all possible, a mouth...

You know, in a weird way, the 1920 crest was the most modern of all: http://d25yla7xp697oa.cloudfront.net/assets/_files/cached/may_13/590x330/efc__1369492743_placeholder7.jpg

James Martin
192 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:35:41
Kev I agree the two laurel wreaths either side of the tower are what are most instantly recognisable about Everton which is why I think crest B just doesn't do it. None of those single huge laurel ideas did it for me either.

Why they couldn't have stuck two laurels on Crest B besides the tower is beyond me, that would have looked alright then.

Badge C would actually be ideal without that stupid border on it.

Steve Brown
193 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:41:27
Tried looking at them with 3D glasses but they were still unpleasant.
Jon Ferguson
194 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:39:50
I would rather we kept our current badge, but if we have to change, the one on the left is the one.
James Marshall
195 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:43:57
I begrudgingly would say the one on the left, though I don't really like any of them to be honest.

The one on the left would be better without Everton written across it - surely EFC would have been better?

The one on the right looks like a mistake - what's going on at the bottom of it!?

The middle one is too simplistic, but is very much in keeping with other clubs in Europe so don't be surprised if that's the one that gets chosen.

Just because it's being put to a vote, doesn't mean the club has to go along with public opinion - it's not as if this is a legally binding process.

Good PR though.

Alan Williams
196 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:21:32
The cub re-design the badge for modern mass reproduction which lets face it needed doing as my sons kits and jackets last year all the badges were glued on and most fell off after wash so they wanted a hard all in one badge like I had as a kid in the seventies think it was circular with white background. They pick one and get smashed for it, and then they decide to ask the fans to vote for a new one and get smashed for that too! If the club offer us 10 choices they will get 10 different answers and whatever they choose you will always have the fan that says I hate it, or club conspiracy to hide something else. Its just weak management for me, I would have kept the new one and ignored the complaints like other clubs did. We can’t run a club by proxy or like a cooperative, make a decision and move on. I didn’t like the new badge at the beginning but now am not really bothered too much its just become the badge and doesn’t look that bad on some things, yes looks odd on the new third kit but doesn’t stop us winning at WHU does it. Seriously some people need to get a life, stop moaning and enjoy being an Evertonian! I went to the game on Saturday and got home at 3am much to the wife’s anger, had a great time and click on here today to see what others thought and you’re all moaning about the badge choice!!!
Brett Jonathan
197 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:50:56
Badge A for me. Looks great.

I am pretty sure that had this been released earlier this season (instead of the awful one we ended up), nobody would have complained at all.

Remove yourselves from the whole shitty logo/fans revolt of 2013 and look at them objectively. Badge A would not have caused a stir at all right if it was pitched as our new logo a year ago?

Brett Jonathan
198 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:52:45
And I am still shocked people are still missing the point about requiring the name 'Everton' on the badge somewhere. So simple and so incredibly essential these days.
Steve Pugh
199 Posted 23/09/2013 at 13:56:48
Just looking at the images at the top of the page A was my choice. But since looking on the official website where they show how it would look on shirts, stadium, publications and a spinning video, option C actually looks really clean and good.

Yes I actually think it looks a lot better in situ than on a blank canvas and I like it.

Option B just looks crap no matter how it's dressed up and whilst A is good on the stadium and as a spinning logo it is too fat on a shirt and publication.

Brent Stephens
200 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:00:22
If none of A, B and C gets a majority in the voting, do we get a coalition? Two for the price of one? One on the right, and one sort of in the middle - but not really sure.

Mike Green
201 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:14:31
Interesting that there's no objection to the tower given in the options.

It's very similar to the old one but has its differences - I think it may even have been lifted from a fans attempt. The 'new' design must have got absolutely slammed.

Kev Johnson
202 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:19:29
Brent, I think in those circumstances a workers' revolutionary party would probably bypass the democratic process and forcibly seize power, possibly making 'The People's Club' the official name of the team. So it would be West Ham 2, The People's Club 3 - that sort of thing

I expect their new crest would probably feature a depiction of... er... I dunno... some people?

Karan Oza
203 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:39:41
anyone know how to figure out your customer number?
Steve King
204 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:42:41
Karan,

I got mine from my last boxoffice ticket confirmation email

Jim Potter
205 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:30:20
As I have the last badge as a tattoo - I wish we'd kept that.

As a bona fide coward I did not enjoy the procedure. Similarly I did not enjoy the wife’s third degree interrogation of why I’d chosen to have the name of my football club ingrained into my skin for the rest of my days - and not hers. My attempted humourous response of "Because I know I'll always love Everton?" died a suitable death - as did nearly I.

Now I’m going to be out of date and unfashionable to boot.

Of these 3 - if only to honour Bainsey – I choose left is best.

And no, I won't be having any new inky additions - no matter how well they're designed or even if Angelina begs me to be the next Mrs P.

Richard Reeves
206 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:27:48
All of them are shite and it say's something when most of us prefer the one on the left (myself included) which mostly resembles our old badge.

The scroll underneath the badge is more simplistic than the old scroll but is it so much so that we had to change in the first place. Just a bit of tweaking on the old badge was all that was needed as I've mentioned before. The shield is the wrong shape as in it is slightly stretched and, as I predicted, it all looks a bit congested with the Everton name in there.

These are really disappointing designs from so called professionals and I have to agree with many above who've said there were better fan designs. The only thing they got right was the colour blue and not having any yellow on it. I don't know why but I was expecting about 10 designs to choose from.

Although I have no experience in design, I'm sure I could've created something better than what they have.

Patrick Carty
207 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:55:56
It has to be the left one; reading everybody's comments, I think this will get the vote.
Richard Reeves
208 Posted 23/09/2013 at 14:53:24
I did also mean to say that returning to the old tower is a good thing but the fence around it looks a bit dodgy, not as good as previous badges we've had where the fence looks like a fence. So that is the tower, colour blue and omission of yellow that they got right; apart from that, all shite.

So when you look at it, the wreaths are the same and the tower is pretty much the same so what they have done is stretch the badge to accommodate Everton and 1878, surely it would've been better to use the badge we had before the Fisher Price effort and simply change the colour blue, get rid of the yellow, and focus more on changing the scroll slightly to accommodate the Everton name and 1878.

Mike Green
209 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:06:07
In all honesty for me I would just have had Prince Rupert's Tower and the wreaths. Job done.

If we must have Everton on it though (because otherwise people might have to actually think....) try A without the motto and the date - simple, traditional but modern and iconic.

Robbie Muldoon
210 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:11:02
This is sick, this is what we should have and end this farce once and for all https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BU2SSsfCMAMuG9i.jpg:large
Conor Waters
211 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:03:03
Jesus we are a miserable bunch.

Lets face it, you cannot please everyone, it would be almost impossible to create a badge that keeps us all happy. But the club did make an attempt, albeit belatedly, to get input from the fans on what they felt were important crest issues. Clearly a rounded crest was opposed, a narrower tower preferred, motto restored, wreathes returned, a shield style favoured. Granted the quality of the finished products can be questioned and the inclusion of ’Everton’ seems to have been unavoidable – but take a quick look at the other 19 Premier League crests. All except Norwich mention the club name and only Fulham and Man City abbreviated it to initials.

You got your wish, EFC fans, now shut up and vote.

Liam Young
212 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:31:53
All 3 are extremely amateur, these badges do not represent a club like ours, too much focus on a retro look, not enough of a modern style, and the tower looks absolutely terrible, a few modifications to the one on the current badge, but using the original crest shape.

I designed a better badge than these, and I put the "1878" verticallu up the tower, which looked fresh and clean, the text for "Everton" is not clean enough, and I think the slogan "Nil Satis Nisi Optimum" should appear below the everton name, this way, it makes a clear statement of Everton - Nothing but the best will do....

Come on everton, you are getting all the wrong people in to design these logos, I am a graphics designer myself, and I can come up with 3 much better badges than these poor attempts!!!

Paul Ellam
213 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:38:41
Is it too much to ask that our club name is written in CAPITALS? EVERTON looks so much better and more important than Everton.

Would prefer the club badge in a circle, a bit like Chelsea's, but that aint gonna happen so I'm not really fussed which we end up with as I don't really like any of them.

Phil Bellis
214 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:39:24
Neil McKinney 740 "Have they consulted fans and established we're all partially sighted?"

Those on here who say they prefer this season's abomination may well be

Karan Oza
215 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:46:04
Thanks Steve
Steve King
216 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:39:12
Quite curious to know how many people complaining on here gave their feedback to the club through the website......I guess we can never know.

I only bring it up cause a fella at work has spent all morning moaning about the choice, then revealed he "couldn't be arsed with that shit" when I questioned how he had answered the feedback!!....Cretin!!

As my old man always taught me: "if you don't vote, you forfeit your right to an opinion"

Luke Dunn
217 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:57:14
Looks like the same vegetables that designed the current one are it again. All 3 are shit – deal with it.
Richard Reeves
218 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:44:50
Paul Ellam (#816), I agree that the Name Everton should be in block capitals, I've thought this since it was first introduced to the badge. It just doesn't look right, a bit wonky, unlevel and a bit cheap looking. Block capitals would give more of a statement that we are a big club but I suppose the original look Kenwright was going for was Little Old Everton.
Nick Entwistle
219 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:59:44
Not when opinion is restricted, Steve. Where's the option for our previous badge, or none of the above?
Brent Stephens
221 Posted 23/09/2013 at 15:52:54
Kev #793. Thoughts of chairman mousey tongue (sorry, Kev, you can't be chairman of this one):

Without a People's army, the people have nothing.
A journey of a thousand miles starts with one step in Stanley Park.

Duncan McDine
222 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:02:59
Deliberately shite so we all start to think...

"HEY THE CURRENT ONE IS QUITE GOOD"!!!!

Very clever

Duncan McDine
223 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:08:05
Robbie 808... that is feckin top notch mate. The only design I've liked so far. Well done that man.
Steve King
224 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:25:55
To be fair though Nick the club carried out a consultation with Fans.

It's quite clear that a majority liked that particular tower so it is on every design, a majority wanted NSNO back in so it is on every design etc. etc. And so we see the result of that consultation in the three options.

I don't see whats so restrictive about that?

Mike Green
225 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:36:21
Robbie #808 - good effort.

Great simplicity and nice to see someone do something genuinely innovative with the date / wreaths to save on space.

For some reason they make me feel a bit 'funereal' if you get my drift though, and I can't get to grips with the new tower. Put the tower the club have chosen above on your badge and I think you're pretty much bang on the money.


Drew Shortis
226 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:35:37
Three good designs in my opinion. I can't understand all of the negativity.

I'm torn between A and B. I think the motto on B looks like it is just shoved in there, whereas the scroll on A looks intentional. I do like the yellow outline on B, but badge A has all the elements I love and is the best executed design. C is a tidy design, but a little bland and I don't like the bottop part of the shield.

I'm going to mull it over for a while before I vote, but I think A looks like the best to me, though it is very similar to our old one, begging the question why bother with this whole process at all. I'm glad they have listened to the fans in the end!

Nick Entwistle
227 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:49:55
Because Steve, you're having your choices defined and restricted for you. No one asked you to change the old badge did they?
Mike Green
228 Posted 23/09/2013 at 16:46:42
Actually, Robbie, the more I look at it, the more I like it. The difference the wreaths make is massive for me; I don't know what they were thinking of getting rid of them.
Eugene Ruane
229 Posted 23/09/2013 at 17:50:32
What should now be obvious (given the response of supporters over the last 24 hours) is that should we end up with anything other than A, the whole thing is a ludicrous complete set-up.

My reading is that about 85% have gone for A, about 10% for C and Lenny Peters, Ray Charles and Stevie Wonder for B.


Mike Green
230 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:06:31
Agreed Eugene - I think the vast majority are saying A, the TW poll will give us a better idea when it's out.

There are quite few Blues I've spoken to today who've said B until the penny drops there's no wreaths. If they'd got the wreaths into B it probably could've gone either way.

Daniel Starkey
231 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:11:03
C for me, and lets get shut of that yellow nonsense, how that became part of our badge is a mystery to me.
Eugene Ruane
232 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:09:36
Actually, earlier I performed a quick experiment with an American girl (yeah yeah fnaar etc).

She's been in design and art direction for more than 30 years but knows nothing of football or Everton.

I said..

"Ok I'm going to show you three designs of the same badge, take a quick look, don't analyse them and just give me your favourite"

She looked for about 6 seconds and said "that one"

A.

"Why?" I asked.

She said "Erm...it looks kind of older so like...cooler"

What more..er..'proof' is needed?

Kev Johnson
233 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:19:40
What do girls know?
Mark Knight
234 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:18:41
A for me....
Mike Allison
236 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:28:34
I voted before coming here and went for 'A' (the one on the left). Without any prompting my 3 year old girl said the one in the middle was 'a bit rubbish'. I also quite like 'C' but its the wrong shape for the Everton badge so it was never going to get my vote.

I'm amazed anyone said B. All wrong somehow.

Eugene Ruane
237 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:29:28
Just saw this - a very unusual design yet one that ABSOLUTELY says Everton.

http://imgur.com/0dA86ME

Kev - 'What do girls know?'

Far too much (Mrs Eugene is like Sherlock bleedin' Holmes).

James Stewart
238 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:45:51
1 or 3. Middle one is disgusting and pretty much the same as the current badge. Poor choice of designs hardly gives much option.
Alan Khan
239 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:43:45
Option A for me....
Liam Young
240 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:04:36

http://instagram.com/p/aRWSvIssNe/

This is my effort I did a couple of months ago, for me this represents Everton better.

Tony Draper
241 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:08:04
Eugene
Yes it really does

And from the same website is the following image, which somehow reminds me of our board:

http://imgur.com/gallery/RBuxMhZ

Matt Doyle
242 Posted 23/09/2013 at 18:15:47
Hmmm, well it's disappointing but I'm not surprised.

As already said, this is what you get with design by committee.

As a designer I don't like to shred other people's work but there's just nothing exciting about any of these designs. They come across as timid, rushed and aiming to appease the diverse opinions of the fanbase

Where's the imagination? Where's the balls? What's with the whole 'retro' thing. 'A', so far the most popular, is like a railway heritage plaque FFS.

There'll be a few pissed off designers out there today who've had a decent crack at this but haven't been included in the process.

I'd pitch my own design against any of these, and I've seen several - Lyndon's TW design and MilkyOne to name just two, which would stand up in a vote against all three.

I've got some sympathy for the club for the way they've tackled the situation, but ultimately you have to ask whether this process has really given us an inspiring new crest? Answer - no.

Just go back to the original please.

Mike Green
243 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:11:57
I'm getting a bit of crest-blindness now.....

Good effort by the way Liam, no need to half the background though.

Robbie Muldoon
244 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:10:32
Mike Green (837): I agree with you, it's actually not my design. It's the creative who designs all the stuff for the magazine I work on, he did it this morning after his shock at what Kenyon Fraser (a PR company not a strict design firm) have rushed up.

I think it's a brillinat design and has corrected all the bits that look so wronng on the original version.

Crest alone: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BU1jYwjCIAAC9__.jpg

On the shirt: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BU2SSsfCMAMuG9i.jpg:large

Liam Young
245 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:29:36
I think with a solid colour background, and even maybe a white crest border instead of yellow, and this could be the future everton badge, I really don't like the 3 options we have been given, very amateur.

http://instagram.com/p/aRWSvIssNe/

If you like mine, let me know everyone.And spread it around so more evertonians see it.

Mike Green
246 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:30:22
Yep Robbie - if it's any consolation tell your man that if that we're up against the other three it would most likely get my vote, beehive and all.
Robbie Muldoon
247 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:25:51
Kevin Fowkes
248 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:31:54
Awful!! This is clearly the reason why you shouldn't ask the opinions of non creatives to pass judgement on new creative designs. I have worked in marketing for years and every man and his dog thinks they are design experts. All the fuss has now resulted in something worse.

Although the current new crest isn't brilliant (better than the new three though), it's a massive step in the right direction, modern, easy to re produce etc. Latin went out years ago, if we were all learning Latin at school then I can see a case for keeping it but we aren't...time to move forward not backwards.

Arsenal were brave when they changed theirs. We could learn a lot from them...

http://arsenalarsenal.wordpress.com/2011/02/19/proof-that-arsenal-are-the-greatest-club-the-world-has-ever-seen/

Drew Shortis
249 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:42:30
Robbie 882
Now that one is one of the best I have seen yet. The new style tower even looks good. The shield is still a bit fat bottomed, but that could be resolved by making the Everton font slightly smaller. Was this designed by a fan?
Susong Hermawan
250 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:46:19
Design A for me..
Noel Early
251 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:45:08
Reading all the above comments, it's official: we really are the biggest bunch of moaners about. Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't we all get to have a say in the whole process? These are the three options that "we the supporters came up with".

For what it's worth, I like the 3rd option, think it's new, bold and modern. But Option A will be the chosen design because Roberto Martinez, Baines and Duncan have all come out in support of it, so basically we are being told how to vote. Whichever one wins, I'll wear regardless.

Robbie Muldoon
252 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:50:52
Drew, this was designed by the creative director of the magazine I work on. He is not a fan, but I asked him to get the wreaths in and all the elements the club want (name and date). He tidied the tower up and it looks much better now, feels fitting for the times.

Vic Flange
253 Posted 23/09/2013 at 19:53:18
Three poor designs in my humble opinion. Though I really enjoy the deep blue colour scheme.
Ian Bennett
254 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:10:55
Robbie I'd take that design with nil satis nisi optimum stitched underneath. The three other options not look as good on the kit etc.
Paul Dark
255 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:38:29
Thank God the motto is back - I'd prefer a crest with the motto - and no Everton. We are Everton and don't need the name on the badge.
Drew Shortis
256 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:32:32
Robbie
The tower does look much better and blends well with the rest of the badge. The tower on the current one looks like it was copy and pasted in as an afterthought and the dark navy blue clashes with the royal blue of the badge. I like your bosses date and wreath combo, neat solution.

With the badge choices we have I prefer choice A and could live with choice B. The shape of C just doesn't look right for an Everton crest. I have a feeling the majority will vote for A as it is the most traditional looking of the three and in time we will all grow used to it. I do have to question the skill of the designers Everton have employed, as despite badge A having all the right elements it still looks a bit like a first draught. I would expect a better finish from professionals!

Jay Roach
257 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:51:13
Robbie, that is best I have seen by a distance mate. Email it to the club!!!!
John Beesley
258 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:04:30
I think design A

It's not bad of the club to ask the fans but after all it is in their own business interests, isn't it!
Alan Corken
259 Posted 23/09/2013 at 20:55:28
Kevin 884 - quite right the current design is a step forward unlike the old fart preferences we are seeing here. I think the Moyes era has left Evertonians with the belief that our best years are behind us. All I have to say is Nil Satis ....... (Aaahh!! even I am at it).
Brian Garside
260 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:08:27
A with an amber surround. Carnt they get anything right?
Clive Lewis
261 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:22:49
I like this one
http://uk.eurosport.yahoo.com/29112009/8/photo/everton-crest-side-goodison-park.html

Clive McBride
262 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:23:13
Looks like they kept the same designers who made the present design, all still look amateurish. But if I had to chose I'd pick A, as it reminds me of the 70's badge, and that's when Everton 'chose' me :)
Barry Rathbone
263 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:06:21
The area marked "art and creativity" is a vacant lot untroubled by innovation in my skull.

Please someone choose the fucking thing so I can follow blindly like the sheep I am re design.

Too much choice for too long is painful.

Clive McBride
264 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:27:10
...and if I'd been given the choice, I'd pick Clive's (#912)
Tony Draper
265 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:20:24
Though I am strongly in favour of retaining an Everton Club Crest which attests to our heritage and longevity only today I came across something that made my jaw drop in its breadth and fanaticism, this is not some uber rich club I'm referring to, it's an old once proud club that's seen as having fallen behind . . .

Wolves
http://www.designweek.co.uk/news/wolverhampton-wanderers-rolls-out-new-branding/3035527.article

After further thought and consideration, the jealousy that I felt at their all encompassing view did leave me with a question
"That's fine when it's all new and still has impact, but what about in 10 years time ?"
Though maybe by then the benefits will have been reaped

Though I'll bet that the impact such a "Clubwide Styling" would have on prospective partners, corporate involvement, investors and potential owners could ONLY be very beneficial

As a result I just wonder what could be done with such powerful modern branding at Everton

Graeme Jenkinson
266 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:32:51
I'm going with Clive (912) too.
Mark Taylor
267 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:40:49
The one on the left is closest. For those who quibble with the 'heritage' look, then remember, that is by far our biggest attribute. We've been round longer than most and were winning league titles before some clubs were invented. We need to look like we have history.

That said, not do we need clutter. I'd lose the wreaths, they add little if anything and maybe put the foundation date where the wreaths are- and where they originally were.

The club badge can be two colour, white and blue. I'd contemplate a different version for print, e.g with the amber outline that people have mentioned- but I don't think it's needed.

Of course we keep the f-ing motto. Who cares who speaks Latin. It screams heritage and as a positioning statement for the club, it can hardly be bettered. Shame the board don't seem to be interested in fulfilling its promise....

Tony, you are correct about the Wolves logo. Long, long before 10 years are up, and the first thrill of change has evaporated, Molineux will look like a branch of B & Q.

Matt Doyle
268 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:41:20
Tony Draper 924

Absolutely - great example that.

They've their whole imaging scheme spot on. Everything's simple & bold, nice touches like those wolf eyes on the staircases. This is what you get from a good design agency with a clear design focus - creative & modern even though it's based on a crest design from the 70s.

Peter Mills
269 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:53:00
I'm glad our manager has contributed to the debate. Not 4-1 moment do I believe David Moyes would have done the same thing.

Not my joke, I just thought it was worth passing on.

Anthony Hawkins
270 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:03:42
Just how bad are those three designs? And why did the board chose those three? There's nothing inspirational or new there. It's the first time I have to seriously admit that the Everton marketing team have been absolutely abysmal. The 'old' new badge is growing on me and is much better than the 'new' new badges and that's not saying a lot. the badge on the right looks shite in the extreme.

It smacks of the board saying "let's give the supporters the option and blame them for the bad design". Given the choice of three bad designs which would you go for?

John Malone
271 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:18:30
It's a no brainer there wouldn't even be a doubt if option A was spruced up like option B it's near enough the same as the one we had last year, the sad thing is it's not as good and looks as if it's gone further back in time.

How obvious is it that the club want you to pick option B giving it all the extra colours and shading so it blends in with website and placing it bang in the middle to make it the focal point, no matter how much they dress it up they still can't play fair.

I expected more options and I'm not impressed with these efforts and would like to know the constraints they are working within as the new badges are slimmer and lack the symmetry throughout. Also other teams have bigger more complex badges such as sunderland, newcastle, palace so why the need for change, I suspect it's all down to Nike if you look at the majoriy of teams they sponsor they've got the 'modern' badge.

Mike Green
272 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:09:13
Robbie 888 - I still keep coming back to that one of your mates.

Looks really strong when held up against the rest. I reckon the club would've gone for it too, given it's essentially an improved version of what they wanted in the first place.

It's weird how on all the others I don't like Everton being in it - including the old one but really quite like it on this. I'm going to have to stop looking at it, when I go back to A, B and C it's just making me feel depressed.

Night all.

Tony Draper
273 Posted 23/09/2013 at 21:54:13
Mark (932) & Mark (933)

Oddly enough I do agree with BOTH of you and here's why

A lot of what they are doing in the Molyneux "precints", is little more than a lick of paint, but a lick of paint applied with "House Style"
My seat is in the Main Stand, the concourse in there is Stalinesque with the pipework, ducting and cabling in full view with bare breeze-block and unpainted plaster-work. It reeks of lack of care, not heritage

Ten years ago it looked the same, and ten years before that

When BK arrived following that close season we returned to GP, given a makeover, and royal blue gravel in the track around the pitch
The makeover told me that we were moving forward, it looked good, fresh, bold

It all looks shit now, faded and with a "Club Logo" that was bodged by some kid in the office during a "work placement"

Molyneux could look like B&Q in 10 years, or they could "update" things, even by just swapping all the "murals" around the ground so they are new to each section

Probably the MOST telling remark in the piece was that the message was a distillation of what "Wolves" means to those who are passionate about Wolves. They did NOT rebrand Wolves they just made it bloody clear to all just what Wolves means
The reference in the piece was to the effect that "Wolves" wanted people who worked or came in contact with Wolves to understand Wolves on Wolves terms and values

For that effort alone they have impressed me

Chris Williamson
274 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:15:42
Disappointed compared to those fan designed ones I've seen. I would go heavily for A if I could find my customer number to vote. I have no record of it, despite having bought from the website many times in the past, and having looked for an hour am just going to have to give up.

Surely if all my details have been logged with them for YEARS I should get a vote by just logging in! Why make it so damned awkward?

James Marshall
275 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:25:54
On the OS, they have the reversed version of these (if this hasn't been mentioned) and the one on the far right looks really good. I'd vote for the one on the right if it was reversed, but as it is above, not keen.

They all look better reversed in fact.

Harold Matthews
276 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:29:11
Blue without a touch of amber tends to be cold and lifeless. This is a colour theory fact.
Raymond Fox
277 Posted 23/09/2013 at 22:59:42
James, do you mean the reversed one when its reversed, or when its reversed, the third one on the left.
Richard Reeves
278 Posted 23/09/2013 at 23:01:45
Of course A is the best by far but it looks a bit like the old badge with a dislocated jaw.
Gerry Quinn
279 Posted 23/09/2013 at 23:11:49
Blue and Amber were what the Holy Trinity played in - be a little more respectful, Harold! :)
Robert Collins
280 Posted 23/09/2013 at 23:20:21
Boys & Girls let's cast our minds back to panto Billies statement after the internet poll made it clear to him what we thought of his new badge (and in many respects of him also).

He said (or words closely to this): "It's clear the fans don't like the new badge .....(blah blah blah)", then he said: "We will consult the fans over a new replacement badge".

The key word hear is "consult". This in legal terms means to ask for advice (and nothing more!).

The new Director of Lies and Spin ( I can't remember his name) said (or once again words close to): "We've had hundreds of badges sent in and were chuffed to bits with them and will be sending them to some horrible arty farty agency so they can design our new badge", he then went on to say: "It would be unfair to pick any single fans designed badge out and make that our new badge".

Why the fuck would it be unfair for us the fans to make a majority decision and pick out a fellow fans design and say that the one we want? This fan who has taken time to design it and has put his/her heart into it would represent us all!

Instead panto dame Billy has screwed us again, by allowing some payed for, couldn't give a fuck about us agency, to coldly design our new badge so kids in America and other places can Identify with it.

I think we can all see what's gone on here with "Everton and 1878", but bill has kindly allowed us to have our NSNO back.

Fuck Off Kenwright!!!

I for one will be glad to see the back of that theatre ponce.

Kevin Fowkes
281 Posted 23/09/2013 at 23:54:24
Robert 961...Take a bow son. Best comment of the day!
Robert Collins
282 Posted 24/09/2013 at 00:06:42
Kevin @ 962

Hello Kev,

I had enough of him, he's a cluster fuck up.

The sad thing is when he does eventually let go of his toy, he'll probably sell us to a wanker worse than himself.

Tony Draper
283 Posted 24/09/2013 at 00:20:52
Robert (966)
That's just what "Bill-bo Blaggins" would love for us to believe

Weren't we supposed to believe that gollum was the best that wretches such as us could possibly hope for ?
And that we should be truly thankful for what little we had ?

I don't believe that gollum was entirely shit, because he wasn't
But he's NOT the only manager on the planet
I don't believe that Bill-bo Blaggins is entirely without merit, because he isn't
But he's NOT the only possible Chairman

If Roberto Martinez NEVER achieves anything solid as manager at Everton then I for one will be forever grateful that he's encouraged me to re-open my eyes and think positively/hopefully
FFS the guy oozes possibilty

So no more fear of their Dickensian workhouse mentality with us terrified to ask "Please Sir, can I have some success ?"
Only to be told "Success ! SUCCESS BOY ! Shut up and swallow your pride ! Have we not given you stability ? And now you want SUCCESS ?"

Bob Marley
http://www.youtube.com/watchv=OFGgbT_VasI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvK8E-RHZOk
and

Karl Masters
284 Posted 24/09/2013 at 01:48:48
Great line there Tony Draper. Agree completely.
Harold Matthews
285 Posted 24/09/2013 at 03:46:42
Gerry. You've lost me on the disrespect bit but nice one. If that doesn't prove they go together nothing does.
Gerry Quinn
286 Posted 24/09/2013 at 06:32:55
No offence meant to you young Harold - just that I have so much "lerrrvvv" for that blue and amber strip (except 68 FA Cup final!) - wish we could go back to it as an away strip - it holds fabulous memories for all of us
Peter Thistle
287 Posted 24/09/2013 at 06:40:26
After looking at the crests photoshopped onto the park end of Goodison my opinion has changed slightly. Crest "A" looks much better than the other two and it's probably a bit classier than last seasons one. Admittedly the font on the "Everton" bit is a bit cheesy looking but overall it works.
David Chait
288 Posted 24/09/2013 at 06:48:16
Ok so I've now spent quite some time looking and relooking.. Checking the older crest, Lyndon's etc... Slept on it.. And decided I actually like crest A . It's not modern or funky but it has clean lines and looks impressive. I think it is an improvement on even our last design.

It is a show of respect to our past which we, more than most, seem to appreciate.

If it had to be B fine.. Don't hate it. I don't get what is happening at the bottom of crest C. The whole badge seems disproportionate for some reason.

David Chait
289 Posted 24/09/2013 at 07:14:34
Looking at C again I wonder how it would look if they hadn't done that white stip thing and painted it fully blue.. They have done the Nike armband thin which on the home strip I'm not a fan of. C could have worked maybe all blue, but I'll never know.
Peter Jamieson
290 Posted 24/09/2013 at 08:27:33
I really like any of them, but if you put a gun to my head, I would probably choose B.
Mike Green
291 Posted 24/09/2013 at 08:35:13
Robbie 888 - just to let you know I've emailed your mates design to the club asking them to consider it.

Never going to happen but I've suggested they run a poll to see if fans would like to consider it, and then put it up against the winner of A, B or C.

Pointless I know and the ERS would probably have a baby but I reckon you've almost got the answer there so at least I feel like I've don't my bit now.

I could almost write the repsonse I'm going to get now...

"Dear Mike..."

:D

Denis Richardson
292 Posted 24/09/2013 at 09:19:44
For anyone like me who didn't have a clue what their customer number is (which you need to vote), you can simply email crestvote@evertonfc.com and they will send it to you.

In fairness to the club, I emailed them late last night and have already gotten a reply this morning.

A it is!

Tony Draper
293 Posted 24/09/2013 at 09:35:39
My vote went to Option 1 (or A as some call it), the more trad looking one

The middle one has little to offer in terms of "Power" or heritage

And the 3rd looks like a badge from the uniform of Capt James T Kirk of "Starship Portsmouth" which is in the process of peeling off

In contrast to most comments, I find the fans submissions not even worthy of a fridge magnet. The overwhelming majority are presented as "but you get the idea". Well no, I don't. Whatever is going on in peoples heads when they see these half baked tripe simply baffles me

Utter bloody crap and whatever graphics software they dabbled with while the boss was out the office takes loads more skill and familiarity than the waste of the 5 mins it took them to cobble these primary school attempts together
Just because they managed to knock a "well received" leaving card is mistakenly interpreted as being some undiscovered graphics genius

My advice is stick to leaving cards and don't give up the day job

David Chait
294 Posted 24/09/2013 at 09:55:28
Mike in answer to your poll.. A then B then Robbie then C
Alex Parr
295 Posted 24/09/2013 at 10:01:15
Not read the whole thread yet, but a few people mentioned seeing it ona kit to decide. If you look at these links it shows each on a kit, and explains the thoughts behind each one and why it helps with the transfer onto modern media etc (I can see some differences and how it makes sense). My vote is for the left one. I like it.
Mike Rourke
296 Posted 24/09/2013 at 10:25:17
I consider my vote for 'A' damage limitation - kinda-like our old badge, just...worse, but at least I can put my hand on heart and say it is not total and utter shite like the other two which make the beehive look like a Van Gogh.

I must admit if Robbie Muldoon's effort had been put up there I would have voted for that.

--sighs--

David Smith
297 Posted 24/09/2013 at 11:32:45
Crest A, but there's something not quite right : doesn't it look better (more like the good previous ones) when the ribbon with NSNO is "chinked" in the middle with that break in the otherwise too-uniform shape ?
Bring back the chink.

And probably the shield shape is a little too fat and rounded at the bottom : the lack of chink in the ribbon emphasizes this fatness.

Regarding capital letters for EVERTON : I don't agree. I think seeing the "E" capital on its own above the other letters makes it somehow stand out : Everton.

Just my two cents worth from Paris.

Tony Draper
298 Posted 24/09/2013 at 11:48:14
David (050)
Your constructive criticism very much echoes my own thoughts, those are the bits that I would amend/improve

Regarding the ribbon/banner bearing the Latin Motto, I feel that this has always been an issue and that there hasn't been an elegant compromise. I'm not sure that there actually is one, since the fundamental problem is this:

Nil Satis
Nisi Optimum

The two halves are very inequal (a motto of 2 halves)

The "kinkless" banner does allow the motto to flow, sadly at cost of the "flourish" which it lends

The heraldic shield, for me, would benefit from some tweaks (which I don't think need disturb other elements)

Namely:
The outline is weak, a bolder more solid line would be eye-catching and given the distinctive (unique ?) shape would tick the "instant recognition box"
(visualise the 1920 Crest with colours reversed ?)
The actual shape of the shield is too circular at the bottom, I think that with straighter vertical sides that it would lend a greater impression of strength (thereby reinforcing St Ruperts "Tower of Strength", which I think has been rendered really well this time)
I would also venture that the spike at the base should be squared as the two spikes at the top left and right are (making 3 and echoing "The Holy Trinity")
The Laurel Wreaths for me would be more effective at about 2/3 the size

Though I'm sure that it won't happen, I'd love to think that the club would offer "tweaked" versions of the most popular design

Stephen Coles
299 Posted 24/09/2013 at 12:32:43
I have looked at these on the main Everton website where they show you how they will look on the kits and stadium etc. And I have to say they all look rubbish.

When we first got the new badge, I was unhappy about the motto not being there, but now, after seeing it on these 3 badges, I would be happy if they got rid of it.

Badge A does look the most like the old badge, but it's still worse than it. Badge C could be better, on the Everton website they show a reversed version of it which makes it look better. I like the one Robbie has posted above!

Darren Gough
300 Posted 24/09/2013 at 12:50:31
A will win. So basically an expensive exercise in making a worse version of our old badge - which was fine in the first place.
Eugene Ruane
301 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:03:40
Darren (074) - Exactly. I wouldn't leave the goons who 'run' or club in charge of a hot-dog cart.
Karl Masters
302 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:20:00
Darren & Eugene. I'm not making an argument out of it, but A is far better than the 2000-2013 version. IMHO.

BK ruined what was the best, and of course the untainted since 1938, badge by sticking that stupid looking 18 and 78 on it and the word Everton underneath it. The club are right, they were just floating around and the 7 looked like it had slipped down as well. He also made it pale blue.

The club have confused the issue by showing us ten SHIRT badges when all along since 1938 the crest was basically unchanged and appeared the same on say headed paper all that time.

I have been surprised by some of the rantings, especially by Mr Kenrick with his boycott cry, as A is as close to the traditional badge as we will get whilst incorporating our name on it at the same time. All three of these are vast improvements on what we have just now. I have looked at plenty of fans efforts over the last few months and some have been truly excellent, but I don't like any of them any more than A, so I am voting for A.

Robert Collins
303 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:47:11
Hello all,

For those who are happy to accept either of those three apparitions presented, read the 961 post.

And it has to be asked again, are we going to let him get away with it?

Paul Mackie
304 Posted 24/09/2013 at 14:02:53
Get away with what Robert? Presenting three perfectly acceptable designs and then consulting the fans to see which of the three is preferred before making a final decision?

What a monster!

Robert Collins
305 Posted 24/09/2013 at 14:05:15
Paul Mackie @ 096

Reading through the above posts, the vast majority couldn't be more happier with panto Billy and his three amigos, they're jumping with joy aren't they?

You've read what you wanted to read and nothing more eh?

Chad Schofield
306 Posted 24/09/2013 at 13:13:34
Well, I think they're better than current thing. Even if in the unlikely event voting goes for C space-age-with-added-piss-flaps, I'd be OK with it.

They have tried to consult us... a number of people seem to be posting the bulbous badge with the obese tower and simply replacing 1878 with laurels... but then both DFS and ScS are still in business, so there's accounting for taste.

Personally I like B... but if I were to place a bet I'd go A.

Robert Collins
307 Posted 24/09/2013 at 14:12:30
Chad Schofield @ 099

Hello Chad,

My post 961 was not really about how they look compared to the last badge, but it was about who actually designed them - not us and that's for sure!

It's Panto Billies club / toy and not ours, we just give our hearts to the club and pay everyone's wages.

Steve King
308 Posted 24/09/2013 at 14:14:36
Robert,

Thre was an extensive list of questions posed to fans on the OS. Everyone who is interested gave their feedback within the allotted time. And using that feedback they have now presented these three badges.

Where is the conspiracy and lack of interaction?? I don't understand peoples refusal to ever give the club any credit. They fucked up, they knew it, so they did what they could to make it right.

If you missed out on giving your feedback that's hardly their fault.

The three badges aren't particularly inspiring, I would agree with that; however, I also understand they have been produced with our thoughts and wishes in mind. They're not trying to get away with anything!

Kevin Jones
309 Posted 24/09/2013 at 12:48:36
Here's an idea. Us fans have got together to get the current badge ousted. Now why don't we get together again to say we don't like any of them give us some more options please. I'm pretty sure someone on here has the know-how to get in touch with the club with our views.

Don't forget proportional representation is what it's all about here, so as soon as the voting finished, if badge A has 34% then badge A it is, even though 66% of the proletariat don't want it You have been warned

Robert Collins
310 Posted 24/09/2013 at 14:46:02
Steve King @ 101

Consultation means sweet FA, what your seeing is democracy in action: Everybody gets what nobody wants!

Steve King
311 Posted 24/09/2013 at 14:49:55
"Consultation means sweet FA..."

Can you elaborate Robert? As far as I can see the following has happened:
the majority asked for NSNO and there it is, most asked for the traditional image of the tower and there it is, Most asked for the wreaths back and there they are....

Tony Draper
312 Posted 24/09/2013 at 15:03:58
People ARE uncomfortable with the style in which they were consulted, that much is evident

Seems to me that a pretty useful stage was missed between the "Questionnaire" and the "Election"

Something along the lines of (except with proper graphics):
"The majority of fans indicated that St Ruperts Tower was an essential feature, please rate the following 5 versions in order of preference" (where 5 = stick it thru your hoop)
a) Bill-Blo's Blaggins Hut
b) Mary Wilsons hair
c) A deformed toadstool
d) The Walt Disney Princess Castle
e) A competently rendered "Tower of Strength"

"The heraldic shield; please rate the following versions"
a) Looks like a "last roll of the dice at the Grafton" arse
b) Star Trek
c) A circle
d) Amphibious landing craft shape
e) The 1938 profile

Then even people who did not want certain elements could have a say in just how they were depicted

Harold Matthews
313 Posted 24/09/2013 at 15:13:56
Chad. I liked your round design on the other thread and the blue and black round one above it.
Robert Collins
314 Posted 24/09/2013 at 15:54:13
Steve King @ 105

If most asked for this or that and got what they wanted, then why are the vast majority on here so upset and grumbling : "A (or B or C) isn't as bad as the others, I suppose it'll do".

If this went to a poll, just like the one that shot down the panto Billy's current badge, I'm sure there would be another massive majority against.

I don't think you've understood any of my posts.

Tony J Williams
315 Posted 24/09/2013 at 16:09:20
I thought the questionnaire was very leading and didn't really ask the correct questions.

Especially the part where it asked you to pick your favourite three club badges and proceeded to show the worst pile of shite badge in the leagues.

A is the best of a bad bunch with the Everton stuffed in under the tower.

But it's hardly much more different from the original badge so what's the fucking use? Apart from the paid twats who "designed" them, no-one is happy and we have ended up with a shitter version of our last badge anyway

Eugene Ruane
316 Posted 24/09/2013 at 16:45:13
Steve King (101) - "Thre was an extensive list of questions posed to fans on the OS. Everyone who is interested gave their feedback within the allotted time. And using that feedback they have now presented these three badges. Where is the conspiracy and lack of interaction??"

'Feedback'?

What you mean...

"I sort of like the VW badge..ish..I suppose...as you ask...never really thought about it though"?

Jesus!

Sorry but in my opinion there's a good chance you are either...

Deliberately being obtuse and/or disingenuous and possibly working for Bill

Or..

Staggeringly easily duped.

(hope it's the second!)

I'm sorry if either of those things offends you, but if it is any consolation, I'm genuinely offended that anyone would, by way of an argument, put forward the club's STAGGERINGLY FUCKING SKEWED 'extensive list of questions' as some sort of justification for the below average shite we're now forced to choose from.

Seriously, have a look at the TW thread/s re the 'consultation' - many knew right away the thing was skewed and pointless and pointed it out immediately.

"What's your favourite logo?"

"Which brands make you feel warm?"

"What's your favourite sandwich?"

"Do you prefer you left foot or your ri.."

Etc wank waffle blah.

Few weeks later it's "Here's three shit crests, pick one" - Voila!

You say there was an extensive list of questions?

Maybe.

But that list contained many irrelevant bullshit questions, so it could have been a list as long as Peter Crouch's arm, it wasn't going to help anyone but Mr Smoke & Mirrors and it appears (to me) you fell for it.

(nb: I understand we're dealing with a superb con man, but Christ, how many times do people need to get fuddle-duddled up the wotsit before they go "HEY WAIT A MINUTE, HE JUST FUC...")

Andy Whittingham
317 Posted 24/09/2013 at 16:46:30
10 minutes ago I grabbed the logo that Robbie posted (888). I liked it, but it didn't contain all those elements 'we' voted for. So I stuck it in Adobe Illustrator, resized a thing or two and added a couple of bits that I thought were missing.. just ignore the rushed job on the NSNO (I'm meant to be working).. You get the idea

http://i.imgur.com/LrJ7pJP.png?1

Chad Schofield
318 Posted 24/09/2013 at 16:41:56
Hi Robert #100,

I know where you're coming from but at least we've had some input.


Open-ended voting can go horribly wrong (see Mountain Dew Names a New Flavour) and not only would Kevin Jones' point at #102 be even more pertinent, but we have we'd have probably have ended up with the Godzilla vs King Kong one.

Eventually it does have to come down to one of a few and while I would have loved to have seen the very popular Milky One's (which mine heavily took from, but thanks Harold) offered as an option I'm pleased that the club has actually offered us a way to vote.

Abstaining from voting isn't really going to show "the man" anything, and may well simply make the club feel that offering a mechanism for fan input on this process is actually a waste of time.

Yes, in future it would be nice if it were a competition... and it's a shame that the club has wasted so much time creating this year's "thing" and now is spending more money making up for what they did, but they at least in my mind deserve some credit in the way they have acted promptly on this.

Ray Roche
319 Posted 24/09/2013 at 17:16:03
Steve King @ 101

" I don't understand peoples refusal to ever give the club any credit. They fucked up, they knew it, so they did what they could to make it right."
Steve, I'd be more than happy to give the club credit if they DIDN'T fuck up so royally in the first place. And as for the "extensive list of questions " , they were so loaded in favour of something "new and modern" ,i.e., something cheap to reproduce, that it was like asking a 20 year old if they'd "Like a nice new, modern Ford Focus (boring), or a crappy old Morgan (interesting classic) " . It was obvious which way the club wanted you to vote.

Robert Collins
320 Posted 24/09/2013 at 18:27:49
Chad @ 137

Hello Chad,

I think BK and his little men knew all along where they were going with this process and kept full control over it. I find it really cynical the way they asked us lots of questions and and took our designed badges of us and then gave the to some agency that doesn't give a fuck, to only give us three choices (that nobody wants by the looks of things).

Why didn't they allow us to see all the submitted badges and then make our own choice with a vote?

Harold Matthews
321 Posted 24/09/2013 at 19:31:08
Amanda Holden, Big Dunc and Bainsey like A.
Joseph Bell
322 Posted 24/09/2013 at 20:58:01
All three look poor. I like the Milky One or some similar variant, very classy. I don’t buy all this "hard to reproduce" nonsense. You can reproduce anything these days. Our club deserves better than this.

The badge means everything to a lot of us so don’t just put up with shite, strive for better. After all we all want the best for our club.

ps: For all the lads who don’t like us moaning. You have taken time to moan about us moaning... ironic, don’t you think?

David Munro
323 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:21:18
I agree, the new crests leave much to be desired but I think the current uproar regarding the questions is unjustified.

Crest, logos, brands, whatever you want to call them are a difficult thing to get feedback on. The questions you need to ask, such as what things do you want on the logo, what shape do you want, are difficult questions to answer. And often the answers that you receive to these direct questions are often different to things people actually want. This is why marketing is such a hit and miss business.

That is why you have the questions about different brands and sporting logos. Because these questions can often identify inconsistencies in opinions. When asked outright what logo shape people want people might say shield, but all the logos they identify might be circular for instance.

Attacking these questions is weak. I don't think the designs are rubbish because of the questionnaire, as all the elements that we think are important are in the crests.

It's just POOR DESIGN.

David Munro
324 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:45:36
Still C for me though. Looks better on the shirt and in 3D representation.
Laura Haseman
325 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:55:24
Why has there been no variation on the lettering (font) of the 'Everton', the tower. or the representation of the wreaths?

The 1878 could be dropped, or placed in the fence around the tower, or in the wreaths as in Robbie's version.

I like the blue in B and C, the way it fades in and out. The red on the Arsenal badge is a very subtle darker tone on one half if you look closely and it works very well. In royal blue would look excellent.

The three offerings from the club are very poor and I will not vote on them. Robbie Mulldoon should be hired by the club and given a month to come up with something.

Colin Fitzpatrick
326 Posted 26/09/2013 at 13:31:29
I find myself mostly in agreement with a couple of things highlighted by Alan Williams in his earlier post, #777.

Firstly I agree with him that this whole farce is a prime example of weak management; what I see as second-rate amateurs who are only here because of the second-rate board that allow their repeated catastrophes and continued existence which means that, no matter what happens on the pitch, we’ll always be held back until all of their highly dubious existences are collectively terminated along with their deceptive practices which are endlessly spun to, or ignored by, an impotent and unquestioning media feeding our long-suffering fanbase.

It’s worth remembering that professionals don’t go to amateurs to solve their problems – they bring in professionals, get the job done and lead from the front, à la Steve Jobs or Bill Gates. The farcical manner the current badge was introduced and implemented, over a matter of months, defies belief. As late as the last day of the transfer window, the sign at Finch Farm, which was being beamed around the world, still portrayed the old badge.

How the launch should have been implemented is irrelevant of course because ultimately you can’t polish a turd; the Fisher Price badge was appalling and, when the inevitable backlash began, Everton adopted their default position: they lie. “Fans and shareholders we’re consulted” they claimed; they weren’t. “The old badge wasn’t media friendly” they claimed; in my opinion, that’s rubbish – the old badge looked fine on every media device I own but was being changed primarily because Nike wanted a change for production purposes, as Alan indicates.

And then we have, as an excuse not to immediately rectify the self-made fiasco, “whilst the time-constraints of kit suppliers in particular present challenges” which again is rubbish in my opinion as, let’s be perfectly honest, the design is nothing more than a morning's work if you know what you’re doing and let’s not pretend vast stocks of merchandise are held by our, err... “partners”.

Why do you think version A appears to be leading by a country mile in what I see as little more than a three-card trick – and why is it a three card trick? Examine the demographic: the average Everton supporter is forty something... now go to the Intellectual Property Office website and look at the account for Everton, account number 80415, look at the oldest trademarks registered in the seventies when your average supporter was growing up, and you’ll see a 90% version of badge A to which you add 'Everton', '1878' and a bit of a tidy-up over a cup of coffee, and there you have what most people will accept and be comfortable with – no need for consultations, votes or consensus management – just a good old fashioned combination of knowledge and getting it right first time principles which the people who pass for executives at our club are clearly oblivious to.

Add to version A an improved version of the Fisher Price badge [version B] and one that the demographic could perceive as far too modern [version C] and you have your three-card trick which purports to offer a choice of three but actually offers the majority nothing more than a choice of one.

The same principle applies to those repeatedly liking the “Milky One” badge and the host of close copies it has spawned. Most of you won’t know the guy who designed it; his name is Thomas Regan, he’s a local artist and graphic designer who’s previously worked for the Echo and, funny enough, Kenyon Fraser before opening his own studio, Milkyone Creative. He’s responsible for amongst other things those special additions of Southall’s and Kendal’s autobiographies. He’s a great artist, I own some stuff by him myself and guess what? He’s a forty something lifelong Evertonian so is it any wonder he had his finger on the pulse?

I think it’s fair enough improving the badge and getting rid of the floating Everton and 1878 but I’m not sure why we need the song and dance that’s gone with it. It was all too avoidable in the first place in my book and has just turned into a joke with all this so called consultation. I’m also not sure where the people who’ve cropped up on here defending the actions of the club are coming from; all these, “they’ve admitted they’ve made a mistake, apologized and are putting it right so stop complaining, they’re doing a good job”, I can only assume that they’re the kind of people who on discovering burglars in their houses would make them a cup of tea, help them load the van and give them a tenner for their petrol money home.

I think that you’re all best doing what Alan suggests, just enjoy the football whilst you can, don’t join in the mind-numbing charade and pantomime of "The People’s Club" and don’t ask any really searching questions such as why Nike and Kitbag appear to be dictating to Everton how high they should jump whilst snaffling tens of millions, which Everton’s next accounts will show – or won’t to be more precise, as we appear to be the only top club in the Premier League who aren’t in receipt of a substantial kit supply deal.

Don’t ask any questions like that, just stick to the fluffy stuff and don’t expect to be able to question the board on this performance, they’ve already reneged on the reintroduction of the time honoured AGMs to discuss the performance of the board and their accounts. In fact, don’t attempt to delve into any area other than what they’ve already agreed to answer questions on, preferably submitted in advance so that they can carefully choreograph an explanation – otherwise you’ll be persona non grata, banned, blacklisted and photographed by people dressed as press photographers… Best just play along; you know it makes sense… Fan engagement? – Don’t make me laugh.

Brian Sharples
327 Posted 26/09/2013 at 16:10:23
There doesn't seem to be an option to vote for the badge currently gracing shirts and merchandise.

My view was that such an 'uncluttered' design was long overdue.

And who wants yet another change, aren't we playing into 'their' hands by agitating to get the opportunity to spend yet more bread on keeping up to date?

The management should have the courage of their convictions and stand by their re-design.

Robert Collins
328 Posted 26/09/2013 at 16:52:02
As everyone will see from my post 961 I'm not happy about any of the three choices, but having been force into a choice (panto Billy is getting his way again!) I choose C.

For a start that B badge has to be in there (as a ringer) to try limit our choices. We've been guided towards either modern or old (A or C). That B badge has the same shape as A but still annoys like the new badge we have. A is like a dull version of our old badge before Billy decided to ruin things.

I suspect he's trying to guide us towards C and he's won in my case, some people may be resentful that A is not as good as the old badge (but close to it) and go for the newer some might say cleaner badge?

Anyway, enough conspiracy theories, Billies won whatever we choose!

David Chait
329 Posted 26/09/2013 at 19:46:56
Oh heck.. Everton just posted the 3 crests on the away and 3rd strip... And crest C looks by far the best on the 3rd strip and even the best on away kit... Above in isolation it looks shit with the white bit at the bottom.. But on the shirt it really works...

Everton! How about showing us these things before the vote!

David Chait
330 Posted 26/09/2013 at 19:49:03
Oh shit I have changed my mind completely 180.. Not being able to vote I didn't actually spend enough time in the official site where I see they had the home strip with the badge.. And again crest C works... What is it about the above that makes it look shit.... The background.. It doesn't work against white...

Shows I never go to the official site as its useless propaganda generally...

Vote C!!!!!! Trust me on this! It looks sharp on the kit.. Modern but has all the elements..... The other 2 look bulky on the shirt...

Dennis Stevens
331 Posted 26/09/2013 at 20:13:35
Hear! Hear! Colin.

Let's not forget the 'old' badge was only in need of decluttering, because the numpties at the club had added the somewhat superfluous, but now apparently sacrosanct, 'Everton' & '1878'.

Neil Hutchinson
332 Posted 26/09/2013 at 20:44:03
Got to be 'C' for its clean simple lines but striking presence. Nothing but the best with its heraldic shield, the statement of who we are and historically where we come from. What we believe in and aspire to in the new era guilded with the laurel leaves of champions. Ut tibi sic aliis
Robert Collins
333 Posted 26/09/2013 at 20:51:53
We also have to get the choice right because if you remember in the champions league final, UEFA lays two giant badges, one for each club on the pitch before the game.

We wouldn't want to look scruffy would we?

Chris Fisher
334 Posted 27/09/2013 at 13:51:19
Will be happy with A or B and will be happy when this is all over so people can fuck off moaning!
Gerry Quinn
335 Posted 27/09/2013 at 14:25:37
Harold - Amanda Holden, Big Dunc and Bainsey like A....I wouldn't argue with that:
to Amanda - whatever you say, sweetheart, darling
to Big Dunc - whatever you say, Sir, Sir, Sir...don't hit me
to Bainsey - whatever you say, Bainsey lad - you want A top left?
Aman Kanji
336 Posted 29/09/2013 at 09:38:24
I can't believe the amount of moaning that's going on over thus, Christ, vote already and move on...

Crest 1. Old Evertonians, harking back to the old day's – Tradionalists

Crest 2. Blend between Old and New

Crest 3. Younger fans, open to progressive change

I prefer 3 purely as we have a new manager, bringing in a totally new style of play within the club. We also have a new, 'youthful' sponsor that can market the he'll out of anything, and do it well.

We need to retain our character, but also move with the times. Let's move on from the Morris Minor marketing and get with the Fiat 500 (that's all we can afford for now).

Joseph Bell
338 Posted 01/10/2013 at 20:52:56
Very poor Chris 843. You don’t like us moaning yet you have taken the time to read our moaning so you can moan about it.

Aman226. You can’t believe the moaning and then have a moan. Oh dear.

Go and tell Anne Robinson!


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads