Lead squandered to feisty Fulham

, 24 September, 118comments  |  Jump to most recent
Fulham 2 - 1 Everton
Everton fell to their first defeat under Roberto Martinez as a much-changed line-up surrendered the initiative to Fulham in the second half after a barnstorming first half hour.

Steven Naismith smacked home the opening goal on 12 minutes after an excellent run and brilliant through-ball from Gerard Deulofeu, but the Blues paid for their ensuing profligacy when the Cottagers upped their game after half time.

Dimitar Berbatov made no mistake when the ball broke to him in front of goal and Darren Bent came on to the winner. A late fightback almost yielded an equaliser but the impetus had been lost and Everton crashed out.

Match Summary

Martinez made changes to his team, with Darron Gibson a starter after missing the first six games of the campaign with a knee injury.

Romelu Lukaku was declared fit despite blacking out against West Ham following a clash of heads with a defender as he scored the winning goal but Leon Osman, who was withdrawn from that game after 52 minutes, is ruled out through injury.

Naismith smacked home the opening goal on 12 mins after an excellent run and brilliant through-ball from Deulofeu. Lukaku and Naismith continued to create or get on the end of promising chances as the first half progressed before a rather sparsely populated Craven Cottage.

Fulham put up greater resistance after the break, giving the Everton defence a little more to occupy them, Robles required to make a good finger tip save to parry a shot from Kacaniklic. So it was no real surprise when found himself in space with the ball at his feet and it was all too easy to slip home.

Bent came on after the hour mark and Bent scored rather easily through the legs of Robles to turn the tie on its head, with Martinez a little slow to respond to the situation, eventually putting Jagielka and Barry on in place of Heitinga and Gibson.

Coleman lashed a curling shot fractionally wide of the far post as the Blues looked to come back from a 2-1 deficit for the second game in a row in the Capital.

A fantastic move by Deulofeu deserved a goal but his shot bounded just the wrong side of the fsar post as the Blues went all out for a goal to keep them in the cup, with Mirallas on for Naismith. Mirallas went on a great run and fed Lukaku who could not dig it out, then he had a shot that was driven along the ground to Stockdale as the intensity approached panic levels, McCarthy getting booked for a somewhat 'professional' foul.

A fantastic sweeping move would surely tie it with two minutes left but instead of smashing the ball into the net, Coleman contrived to drive it at the goalkeeper's legs. An unbelievable miss that would see Everton's horrible record in this competition continue for yet another season as Roberto Martinez fell to his first loss as Everton manager.

Fulham: Stockdale; Zverotic, Senderos, Hangeland, Riise (74' Amorebieta); Taarabt (65' Bent), Karagounis, Parker Y:16', Kacaniklic; Kasami; Berbatov.
Subs not Used: Etheridge, Riether, Sidwell, Buomesca, Rodallega.

Everton: Robles; Coleman Y:79', Distin (C), Heitinga (70' Jagielka), Stones Y90+2'; Gibson Y:35' (70' Barry), McCarthy Y:84', Deulofeu, Oviedo, Naismith (80' Mirallas), Lukaku.
Subs not Used: Howard, Baines, Jelavic, Barkley.  



Reader Comments (118)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Stephen Coles
2 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:54:21
Very disappointed!
Charles Brewer
3 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:52:51
Oh who cares. This has never been a serious competition and with a bit of luck Suarez will try to eat someone's leg in it and get banned for life.

The best news is that we won't get any injuries in further pointless matches.

Patrick Carty
4 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:52:56
The usual story, we just do not want to win this cup.

Too many changes, and it pisses me off that we do not field full strength teams.

Kevin Hudson
5 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:54:46
Absolute bollocks in this competition yet again. We pissed the first half - then seemingly forgot that it was a cup-tie; different year - same shit.
Phil Rodgers
6 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:56:37
Ridiculous that we lost that. Absolutely battered them.

Bad mood city. Population me.

Steven Scaffardi
7 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:55:46
I'm actually a little disappointed as I think this game was there for the taking and would have kept the momentum going, and competition healthy throughout the squad. Not the end of the world, but a lost opportunity of some realistic silverware.
Bill Gall
8 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:57:04
Cant blame the managers team selection Everton had enough chances according to the commentary to score more in the first half.
Paul David
9 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:56:42
I've no major issues with the starting 11 but was disappointed with the subs, what was the point in bringing on Jags just after going 2-1 down? Gutted we got knocked out of this cup, it was our best chance of a trophy.
Ralph Basnett
10 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:00:06
Oops...........
Noel Early
11 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:58:35
Sickened by that, we gave away such bad goals again tonight. We had the majority of play again but final ball was shocking. The wait for League Cup victory goes on...
Robbie Muldoon
12 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:02:02
Well at least that's the last time we'll see Barkley rested!
Steven Scaffardi
13 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:00:32
I found the Jags substitution bizarre but was only listening to snippets on the radio. Anyone shed any light on that one. Would've liked some earlier changes offensively on. Jags and Barry came on around 70 mins, but Mirallas only came on with 10 mins left.
Tommy Coleman
14 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:59:09
Arrghhhhhh!

How did we lose that?

Bent's goal was terrible.

And how Coleman missed that open goal!?

Another annoying way to go out that Cup.

Peter Laing
15 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:02:06
The hoodoo in this competition goes on !
Steven Scaffardi
16 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:04:20
I heard that Deulofeu looked good so hopefully he'll continue that form into the league. A good bounce back against Newcastle this weekend would be just what the doctor ordered!
Ross Edwards
17 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:07:59
It's one of those things. 8 changes. Battered them. Couldn't finish. Pay the price.

We move on.

Phil Head
18 Posted 24/09/2013 at 21:53:52
What a shambles that was, thought Martinez did his best impression of Moyes tonight, by sitting on his hands throughout the second half as Fulham increasingly improved. Football's all about momentum and from the moment the second half kicked off, it was clear something had to be done to get the impetus back. But as Moyes used to do, Martinez ignored the signs, waited for them to score twice, then finally made a positive move with 8 minutes left, half an hour too late.

I thought his team selection on Saturday nearly lost us the game, if it wasn't for two pieces of magic from Baines that would have been the case. We were completely outplayed by Chelsea the week before and Martinez thought that same team warranted a start against West Ham??? I do wonder sometimes how on earth these Incredibly well paid Managers don't see what the rest of the viewing public do?

Patrick Carty
19 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:06:15
I do not understand some fans being happy to get beat and dumped out of a competition that we should be going all out to win.

Personally I am pissed off, and my girlfriend has just asked me to sleep in the sprare room because I gets that mad over defeats, even friendlies.

Tommy Coleman
20 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:03:26
As for the substitutions, at 2-1 down I didn't see the point in having Jags on. I'd have preferred that Naismith stayed on and Miralles going up front.
David Flanagan
21 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:11:03
Sick of people saying it doesn't matter, Mickey Mouse etc... We've won nothing for 18 years. 6th or 7th in the league is bullshit... Trophies matter and yet again we go at it half-hearted...

FFS, we haven't got a game until Monday.
Kevin Tully
22 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:09:32
Deulofeu was great in the first half, but showed his naïveté in the second 45 I'm afraid - he treated that second half like a training session, trying to beat too many men.

Barry brought a calming presence to midfield when he came on, a lot of stray balls in that area before that.

It's never easy to win away from home, but we needed a stronger first 11 to get through there, Fulham were well up for it in the second half alright.

6/10 for me. Could do a lot better.

Jamie Barlow
24 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:15:29
They were pretty strange subs but we did start to play a lot better when they came on. Just a shame we waited till they scored to change them.

Great first half for everyone. Deulofeu being the pick of the lot for me. Second half shite. Too many wasted balls when in good positions, bad refereeing and shit shooting.

Tony Marsh
25 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:14:58
Phil Head, since when did goals scored from free kicks stop becoming part of the game? How about if West Ham's first goal didn't take a wicked deflection or the ref didn't give them a pen. Its Moronic. We scored 3 belters two from dead balls, they all count. So now you don't want Everton to win unless they totally dominate a game.

Well we just battered Fulham and ended up losing!?! Martinez has had 6 fucking games to get his methods across and try to get the players to adapt and gel. We are on the right tracks and blips will occur along the way... .At least this current manager tres to win... FFS, get a life.

David Flanagan
26 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:24:03
Wasted oppourtunity... no reason for the amount of changes when we don't play again until Monday.

We need to win things but the managers don't seem to get it.

Raymond Fox
27 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:15:59
Mickey Mouse waste-of-time competition for me, always has been. We should have had the match out of their reach in the first half anyways.

We still need to concentrate on the League, and make a serious attempt at the FA Cup as well, it's the only cup worth winning for me.

Terence Tipler
28 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:26:47
Howard has had his detractors in the past. But I think he will have less after tonight . Why does a goalkeeper need a rest? Dellboy plays with blinkers on.
Phil Sammon
29 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:29:13
Robles was massively at fault for their second.

Stones is a player I like and should be given more chances. His distribution tonight was terrible though. All long balls. All aimless.

Oviedo: not a left back in a million years. My cat, Duncan (Ferguson), could shrug him off the ball.

Gibson: love him but was off the pace.

McCarthy: anonymous.

Deulofeu: fabulous in patches. Selfish and blind in others.

Naismith: scored a goal. Hopeless otherwise.

That's the negatives. I'll sleep on the positives.

Ste Traverse
30 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:31:33
Fuming at this defeat.

I'm fucking sick of hearing gobshite Everton managers telling us how important the League Cup is then go and put out half a side on we then go out meekly.

We aren't in Europe, have momentum from 2 good wins of late and don't play for nearly a week now so there's no excuse for putting that team out.

I see already have some dickhead at the top of this thread dismissing the League Cup as 'pointless', the sort of thing we hear off a few every year after we exit this competition.

How is a trip to Wembley, some long overdue silverware and a place in Europe seen to be 'pointless'?

Utter moron.

David Flanagan
31 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:39:37
Ste 245. Couldn't agree more... we talk as if we're better than the League Cup... never won it, won nothing for nearly 20 years but don't seem bothered. What do the fans want? More 5th-7th place finishes....
Clive Lewis
33 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:41:32
No point in calling this a worthless cup, we are not in Europe and have 2 chances to win silverware, we now have one. The idea to go for Europa league well wasn't this an easier route into that? no excuse, could anyone suggest why we played a really weakened side in this competition?
Stevie Leary
34 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:45:15
Well said, Tony Marsh!!
Tony Hanlon
35 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:44:15
Since losing to Chelsea in semi-finals that's now 6 consecutive seasons we have failed to get passed the 3rd round of league cup. Considering this is 1 of 2 trophies available to us each season - for a club that has gone 18 years without a trophy , why do we continually play weakened teams in this comp......
Ciarán McGlone
36 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:45:56
Looked like a training game..

During the second half I was trying to figure out who was playing where.. I'm all for being innovative.. but theres a thin line between innovation and needless fuckin about.

He needs to find his first eleven and play them consistently.

Sean Patton
37 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:45:08
Poor all round far too sloppy it seemed like we just expected to win and the only time anyone displayed any urgency was when we were 2-1 down well it is too late then.

Players,the manager and the referee were all not good enough!

Ian Taylor
38 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:54:31
Pointless matches in a not serious competition? Check your head.
It's a tournament that we have a slim chance of winning. WTF?
Lloyd Brodrick
39 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:46:53
Very disappointed tonight. Whilst looking forward to seeing Del-boy and Lukaku we needed to start with more stability particularly midfield.
James Martin
40 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:54:20
Too many changes in personnel and formation to go to a premier league side away from home. Even more baffling considering our game is on Monday. Why did we just sit off after we'd gone 1 up and invite Fulham onto us? A wasted opportunity to get a trophy and get into Europe.
Milos Milenkovic
41 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:44:20
Martinez started this day by saying that Baines will not be offered new contract and than he started the game with 3 center halfs and finished with bringing on another center half and defensive midfielder after going 2-1 down. Very bad day in the office and this is not the league where you can repair things. I don't't have any problem by trying other players but when I see 3 center backs it's like you want to lose deliberately.
Gerry Quinn
42 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:52:37
Agreed, definitely well said, Tony. Feeling deflated, but do believe in how we are trying to change and control.
Peter Mills
43 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:46:15
We've played 6 games in 6 weeks, the next one is not for another 6 days. To play a weakened team, which we did, gives the message to all the players that this is not an important match. What an insult to those supporters who spent their cash attending the game.
Kevin Tully
44 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:54:31
Lukaku & Deulofeu had the beating of that defence on the break about 4 times tonight, but any attempts at a through ball were shite.

Mirallas should have been on earlier, and Heitinga is just raking the money in. If he's not first choice, he doesn't give a feck.

Harold Matthews
45 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:41:26
Jags and Barry had to come on to block up the hole left by Gibson, Heitinga and Stones. It also allowed Coleman to get forward.

Before the game their manager said a win was absolutely essential. Ours didn't.

Kevin Hudson
46 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:52:22
What’s the point of ’resting, so many players when our next game isn’t until Monday?

...and for those trotting out the old ’aw shucks, no biggie - it’s only the Mickey Mouse Cup.’ - two points:

None of you would be so dismissive if we actually won it one day, and 3000 Evertonians took up their full allocation tonight.

Michael Winstanley
47 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:57:50
The first was the best I've seen us play in years. The pace of our counter attacks were frightening. We really should have buried the tie by half time.

Changes should have been made to replace Gibson and Heitinga in midfield in the second half as Fulham started to dominate midfield. The changes came after we were 2-1 down after Robles error to let Bent score, he really should have saved that.

Disappointed with the result but can't fault any of the players, the effort was there and if Del Boy learns to pass then we'll have more chances to score from.

Barry Hughes
48 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:51:14
Anyone have any views on Naismith tonight? I missed the first half where he scored but when I sat down to watch the second I thought he looked out of his depth...

The Lukaku back heel seemed to sum it up. How was his first 45? Was his goal fortunate?

David Crewe
49 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:10:46
Barry - just got back from the game. Naismith was ok first half, could have had a couple.

A full strength side would have cruised this but was good to see Gerard, excellent first half then tried to do too much second.

Very disappointed to lose this one but we had enough chances to win it. Back four looked dodgy though playing around too much and Robles has some work to do on his distribution.

Have to move on but the 3000 of us there feel a bit let down. Not sure how seamus missed that one at the end...place would have gone mad.

Wish Newcastle was on Saturday.

Kevin Rowlands
50 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:15:11
All the top clubs rest players for this cup until the quarter/semi finals, we have a very good squad now so I have no problem with RM rotating, we played well especially 1st half, Newcastle next week is a much bigger game for me.
Michael Winstanley
51 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:22:44
Barry. Naismith was good first half, him, Lukaku and Del Boy linked up well. Second half his game suffered as we didn't keep the ball until we made the subs.
Karl Masters
52 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:13:41
I am on the train home from that and it was so like Reading away last year it was untrue. You could see this coming from about twenty five mins.

To clear up one point, he brought Jags on to go three at the back and push the two full backs right up.

Got to say, we were saying before it kicked off that it was too many changes in one go. Just like Moyes at Leeds last year. Once he brought on the three subs we improved dramatically.

4000, yes 4000 of us there tonight and we were ripped off by our own Manager not taking an away tie at a premier league team seriously enough. It wasn't a home game against a league three team! Irony now is that now we are out he can't give the fringe players a chance other than in the premier league do its a double shoot yourself in the four from Roberto. Not good enough, señor!

Danny Broderick
53 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:12:53
For anyone who wasn't there, he brought on Jags to play 3-4-3 for the last 25 minutes. Barry came on in midfield and then settled things down, and we dominated after that.

By the way, Naismith is a trier - but he's not a winger. He has a good knack of scoring goals and getting on the end of things in the box. But he has to be played just off the front man. Tim Cahill wouldn't have had a very good Everton career if he had been played on the wing.

Naismith took his goal well, and covered a lot of ground, but offered little apart from that. Lukaku and Del Boy looked a bit rusty, it's good they both got 90 minutes. Disappointing result though...

Patrick Murphy
54 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:11:39
Naismith played OK in the first 20-25 minutes but he still managed to miss a gilt edged chance before he scored his goal. I just don't think he has the necessary skills to cut it against Premiership opponents. When Fulham wised up and squeezed their right side he went missing or couldn't retain the ball. I was also a little disappointed with Lukaku as he often let the defender move him off the ball, granted that defender was Hangeland.

Everton lost the plot a little after about 30 minutes and they never fully recovered their composure, Fulham upped the urgency and we couldn't cope with it. That was the most disappointing aspect from the players that RM chose to start with.

Like many I wanted us to have a really good go at this competition but I think RM like DM realises that our squad is short in numbers and he took a gamble that we could get through with what was essentially a second-string side, The competition itself doesn't lend itself to clubs like ourselves as the later stages are played in an extremely demanding part of the season. That doesn't excuse RM or the team for not taking it seriously but you can see why managers make the choices that they do in this competition

Del Boy has bags of talent, but he has to learn when to release the ball to his team-mates when they are in good positions. The defending for Bent's goal was appalling and it shouldn't happen to a team that is usually adept at that part of the game.

It was overall a very disappointing night given our performance in the first 20-30 minutes, Fulham wanted to win more than we did and that is never acceptable no matter which players are wearing the shirt.

Milos Milenkovic
55 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:23:53
Kevin, how is Newcastle game much bigger than this one? We will have 32 games in the league after that game, while we went out from the cup tonight.
Ste Traverse
56 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:24:30
Given the way some arrogantly dismiss the League Cup, you'd think this club had been a trophy machine over the last couple of decades.

NEWSFLASH...we ain't.

Do some fans not even want to break to 18 year (and counting) duck??

I'd give anything to see a blues captain with a piece of silverware in his hands. Even if it is that three handled effort.

Barry Hughes
57 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:26:04
Interesting feedback on Naismith - cheers guys. Wish I'd seen that first half!
Mike Keating
58 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:34:34
Didn't realise McCarthy was on the pitch until he got yellow carded.

Pathetic against a poor side.

Aman Kanji
59 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:29:11
I was at the match. Bad decision to make so many changes from kickoff. Naive or arrogant, not sure which...

We had enough to have that game won, Fulham had nothing. We were the makers of our own downfall, especially with poor distribution from the back – Robles couldn't hit a barn door! A long throw out, then kicked it straight out. His confidence was then shot...

Howard, Barry were a MUST tonight. Kevin should've come on at least 64 mins... as soon as he came on, we were attacking at will from all sides and Fulham just hung on...

We had to win this... Roberto, no post-match conflagration about experience for young players... blah blah and mire media blah... You took the risky decision of the starting 11 and you'll have to admit you messed up...

Kevin Rowlands
60 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:36:07
Milos, because a. I despise Newcastle with a passion and b. I think if you polled any premiership manager and asked them what was more important the league cup or the premier league I guarantee you 100% of them would pick the PL, I feel the same way, that's all.
Lori Fekete
61 Posted 24/09/2013 at 22:58:01
Same old same old.

Dominate the game, wasteful in the final third, get punished.

Deulofeu can be amazing, but knows he's only got limited minutes to show it, so ends up trying to do too much.

McCarthy was anonymous

Naismith has more skill in his little finger than the rest of his body put together

Limp out if the competition again!

Karl Masters
62 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:40:42
In a train carriage with 8 everton fans going back to Kent and all agreed we made too many changes to starting eleven.
Nick Entwistle
63 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:33:30
For 30 minutes I was a RM convert, then we changed the system or formation or something, because the players didn't know what they were doing, and let an average Fulham get back into the game.

No problems with the line-up, they had it all under control and the Spanish kid was frightening. Then it just went blah...

Second half more of the same and Bent was the game changer.

Gibson was very solid on his return, Lukaku woefully served but always looking, McCarthy... how much?

30 mins showed the potential of RM, then 60 minutes of the standard shown this season.

Aman Kanji
65 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:39:12
Mike #280... Now you tell me... £13 mill for him... I sort if know what Man Utd fans feel like after buying Fellaini for £27mill! Ripped off...

Berbatov is slow, but he managed to shuffle past McCarthy so many times it was embarrassing....

Andrew James
66 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:33:55
We looked like world beaters in the first 30 mins and then seemed to lose our way. Yes Fulham got lucky but when you drop your best players like Jags, Baines and Barkley this is what happens.

There was some wonderful attacking football but some baffling messing about between the keeper and the back five and they seemed to be under instruction to play long cross field balls to Del Boy (every single one being over hit)

Definitely a work in progress but it was folly not to start with Barkley and Baines.

Lori Fekete
67 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:41:36
And if it makes any difference, the subs were being readied before they scored their second goal
Paul David
68 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:53:40
Lori

That makes it worse, how can the plan be the same after conceding.

Kev Johnson
69 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:50:18
"Gibson was very solid on his return". He wasn't, Nick. He really wasn't. McCarthy? I'm with you on that one. I remain utterly baffled as to what people see in him.

First 45: great stuff. I don't know what happened at half time. Were the orange slices laced with diazepam? Fulham didn't even play that well in the second half, but they did belatedly turn up. We were more sluggish than a big, sluggardly slug.

Rob O'Brien
70 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:14:48
Don't care what people say, that starting 11 should have been good enough to beat that very average Fulham team! I still have my doubts about Oviedo and Naismith as starters in any game and I though Deloufeu wasted a lot of possession in the 2nd half. Very sloppy defending for the 2 goals also! Good to see Gibo back even though he looked very slow and rusty!
Peter Cummings
71 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:50:28
I couldn't believe we handed it to Fulham in the second half. The point is made by many posters about putting out a 'second eleven' when our next game is on Monday, even though we should have had it out of sight by half-time.

Deulofeu was unstoppable and should have had two, Naismith scored one out of three good chances, and we should have had another two at the death, Lukaku seemed out of sorts and the least said about Heitinga the better.

Second half was shambolic until Mirallas and Barry arrived, too late; like West Ham, it was a game of two halves. Fulham had two chances and took them. Gibson was the culprit for their wnner, after a second yellow card (not given) foul from which they scored. I felt deeply sorry for our fans who as usual,made it sound like a home ground and deserved better.

Tony J Williams
72 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:15:41
Second half was frustrating, I think I could have marked Del Boy out of the game second half. Show him the outside and he will run to the line and either a) dribble it out of play b) hit it into the goalies arms or c) overhit the cross.
Simon Harris
73 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:09:32
Why dick around with arguably our best chance of silverware, given other prem teams resting players. As we're not likely to be in a relegation fight or finish in the top 4, we should play our strongest team and go for it full on.

It does my swede in.

Karl Masters
74 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:31:09
Walter Smith v Sunderland, Bristol Rovers, Oxford and Palace, David Moyes v Liverpool, Leeds, Oldham, Shrewsbury, Brentford - they all thought that they could get away with putting out weakened teams and still get through. Guess what they lost the lot, every match above.

Now Martinez is at it too. At least the above ones were against lower calibre opposition, but tonight we were Away to a Premier League side.

Won't these people ever learn? PUT OUT YOUR BEST TEAM! Make one or two changes if you really must, but no more. Bring the fringe players on when the game is won. It's not like splitting the atom is it?

Derek Knox
75 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:38:10
I'm pretty sure I feel as gutted as the rest on here, but couldn't believe the way the team seem to take their foot off the gas, in the second half. Okay, Jol would have given them a team talk at half time, with one eye on keeping his job, but getting the side to at least have a go.

It worked for them, although they raised their game, we seemed to do little to counter it. There did not seem to be any real sign of commitment.

If it was bad for us, my thoughts go to those, who made the journey to turn up in their thousands to support them, only to be let down. It's a pity the team, second half, did not match those fans in their efforts!

Paul Ferry
76 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:54:36
Phil Head – 233 – just about each word of that crock of shite is top-drawer bollocks. Oh and you are the spokesman for the ‘rest of the viewing public’! You’re funny and so is your tadpole post and you speak for very very few.

Ho hum and then we get yet another piece of shining wisdom from Davey cheek-tear-streaked Entwhistle – 286 – first a rather upbeat assessment of Gibbo so wide off the mark it missed by country miles
and then this deep and thoughtful and penetrating and sharp state-of-the-club summary: ‘30 mins showed the potential of RM, then 60 minutes of the standard shown this season’.

This is Moyes-mong-nostalgia of a type we rarely see. Allow me to say it once more – indulge me - the standard shown this season’ the stunning and smart implication of this latest Forrest Gump Entwhistleism being needless to say that post-ginger Everton are of erm a shoddy and poor standard!

Undefeated Entwhistle; sitting pretty in the prem; a squad that by our ‘standards’ is to die for. And you just can’t wait can you for something to go wrong so that you can crow and squawk like well as you say a non-convert and sneak your fingers under the top of your greying Moyes underwear with that nice pic of an unsmiling Moyes.

SAD.

Darren Alexander
77 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:50:24
Just got back from the game. Very disappointing - what should really be our best chance of a trophy squandered yet again. So, let's now hope Roberto wins the FA Cup for a second year running, eh?

I'm no fan of this too-cool-for-the-league-cup attitude, and all this seeing half a proper team fielded (and, let's be honest, the only reason there are a few established players in there is so it doesn't look like a complete two fingers to the fans who've turned out). Was sick of it under Moyes, and am equally sick of it tonight.

Matty Williams
78 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:31:11
All I wanted this year was a League Cup win. We're cursed never to win it, it seems, a day out at Wembley, silverware at last, easy route into Europe early doors, a few extra quid in the clubs coffers as well... but it's not to be AGAIN!

Why do we always lose at the Cottage? No doubt the RS will go on to win it now. We might as well give our place up to a lower league side as we always have mangers that don't give a fuck about winning this cup. I pity the fans at the game, same old shit every season, hard to believe some fans think the Toon game is more important???

Kev Johnson
79 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:02:11
I don't blame the team selection. The players who came in were little short of superb for the first half. If they'd performed even half as well in the second half we'd be through to the next round.
Andy Crooks
80 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:49:55
Nick Entwistle # 286, spot on.I can take this defeat because I believe we are genuine top four contenders but I can just about take it. There was a confidence about the team selection that bordered on arrogance but, frankly, I'll take that ahead of what we had become used to.

Roberto hasn't found his best side yet and I'm disappointed that he was experimenting tonight. Still, I would expect he will now know his best eleven and will stick to it.

All the good things that Roberto has brought should not make him immune to criticism. We are out of the League Cup and I believe it is down to him.

Paul Ferry
81 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:04:12
Agree Kev - 312 - all kudos to Darren - 307 - for being there but he is wrong about the selection tonight and that purring rolls royce 1st half performance which showed if nothing else that the boys really wanted to win.

Fulham turned up 2nd half; a leaky goalie did a howler; a sub some question; a 2nd half showing nowhere near as good as the 1st.

Shit happens!

And don't say that we did not want to win.

I feel sorry for the barcodes next week - well not really!

Eugene Ruane
82 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:04:06
Should have been 3-0 up at half time, we absolutely battered them.

But...we weren't and they were obviously going to get their arses kicked at half time and be reminded they were at home and told to get at us, which they did.

And although they were much better second half, we STILL missed a bagful.

We could analyse all week, but had we stuck away a couple of easy chances, it would have been a comfortable win and into the hat.

C,est la vie as they say in Wales.

Ian Daniels
83 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:10:59
I agree with Phil's synopsis. I think it's harsh of those who blame Coleman for a disappointing miss as he got it unsuspectingly but still managed to get a quick shot on target when really should've been running over to congratulate Kevin, who was clean through with fresh legs and had all day.
Ian Daniels
84 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:20:33
I was there tonight, and wasn't too disappointed with the line-up as after 20 mins it was obvious we had more than enough quality to win. Even with the Milky Bar flid up front, who then got a goal and made me eat my words which tasted wonderful... til his next touch. But hey ho, had a corkin Kebab. Bring on the skunks.
Steve Guy
85 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:31:53
A few tired legs in the second half. Gibson should have been replaced at half time....great shift but not match fit. Deulofeu tired and was over elaborate but what a prospect. Also thought Lukaku tired but 90 minutes will help with his match fitness. As I texted to my son, "We beat ourselves".
Paul Ferry
86 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:52:36
Spot on Steve - 323 - 'Gibson should have been replaced at half time'.
Sharabi Singh
87 Posted 25/09/2013 at 02:28:05
I managed to watch the game online; even though we lost, we played really well. The young forward line played with a lot of energy, Deulofeu especially. He tore the Fulham defence to shreds every time he got the ball. The guy's looking closer to a Premier League start the more I see him.

Naismith seems to be growing in confidence and had a few chances. I think he's starting to get used to pace of the Premier League now. Lukaku also did well, I really holds the ball up great and gets into some good positions. I just wish we had him at the beginning of the season.

I think overall though the reason we lost was Fulham played with a lot of experienced players and, once they weathered the storm, pretty much took control of the game towards the end of the first half and most of the second. It did even up towards the end when Jags, Mirallas and Barry came on but by that time I felt it was too late.

You could see Fulham's experience was getting the better of it in the first half so I'm not sure why RM didn't make earlier changes in the second. He'll learn I guess... Nothing wrong with giving the youth a chance but you need a few older heads in there to rein them in.

Dan Parker
88 Posted 25/09/2013 at 03:35:15
As much as I like what Bobby's doing and our league form, we needed to be winning this. Not good enough. Can't we just bloody win a cup for once, we're better than fucking Fulham surely
Dan Parker
89 Posted 25/09/2013 at 03:35:15
As much as I like what Bobby's doing and our league form, we needed to be winning this. Not good enough. Can't we just bloody win a cup for once? We're better than fucking Fulham, surely?
Paul Ferry
90 Posted 25/09/2013 at 04:16:48
Dan - 332 - perfect mate exactly how I feel drunk on red wine in Chicago at 10:17pm...
John Zapa
91 Posted 24/09/2013 at 23:14:25
It amazes me to see so many people calling this a 'Mickey Mouse Cup' or some similar nonsense. The club this year is in 3 competitions, which they have almost no chance of winning one of them ( the league) and is now out of another.

Going out at this early stage will also affect the potential earnings, as the club did not benefit very much from the match day earnings, as there was only 1 home game which was half full at tickets that were at half price. A total loss and waste to go out like this.

Brent Stephens
92 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:07:20
One observation. RM (and I like a lot of what I'm seeing so far this season) and others are saying it will take time for his lads to learn how to play his system. But I thought they'd grasped that in the first half, already. So why the loss of "memory", the unlearning in the second?

Why, oh why, those subs?

Why, oh why, that initial selection with so many changes (it wasn't our strongest team) when we're not overloaded with games at the moment.

Solo Lo Mejor, Roberto.

James Fletcher
93 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:05:28
To be honest while I liked a lot of what I saw when we were attacking we seemed to spend a lot of time fecking about at the back and inviting a lot of unnecessary pressure which resulted in some horrendous passing across our own box.

On the plus side dollyfolly looked good but needs to work on his end product a little bit.

Simon Smith
94 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:58:42
A cup run is a cup run and a shot at Europe!
Played like a team possessed in the first half and like a team of chickens in the second. Unlucky not to have been 3 up by half time or even get a draw and take it to extra time.
Only hope this doesn’t bring the first team down to earth with a bump on Monday against the skunks
James Marshall
95 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:49:32
The subs made perfect sense, I don't know why nobody can understand them?

We played well in the first half an hour, scored one, should have been 3-0 up. Then Fulham came into the game for the 15 minute period either side of half time and scored 2 goals.

At that point Martinez brought on Jagielka & Barry and went to 3-at-the-back with Coleman and Oviedo as wingers in what was effectively a 6-man midfield with Barry holding & Lukaku up-top.

It was the right thing to do because Fulham had our midfield by the throat with Parker directing things, and Gibbo getting tired & overrun.

This is the first time I've seen Barry play, first-hand and I had exactly the same view as Martinez in row 2 on the halfway line and I can tell you the changes made ALL the difference. Barry is a cut-above any midfield player in our squad, and one of the best we've had in years. The guy is a class act. And I never thought I'd say that, but I can see why he's played so many top level games, and played for England.

We didn't play badly last night, in fact we played really well apart from the 15 minutes each side of half time when they ran the game, and should have scored a hat-full.

I was sitting in with the Fulham fans, who could NOT believe how we hadn't hammered them, and how they won the game.

As Greavsie used to say, it's a funny old game.

Sam Hoare
96 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:44:55
Ah well, plus ça change.

Early days and he's very young still but I hope McCarthy does not turn into a considerably more expensive Simon Davies.

There were always going to be hiccups but lets hope our run in the FA Cup is a little longer.

Wonder if we may see Barry and Gibson starting vs Barcodes?

James Marshall
97 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:57:31
A small footnote on Deulofeu:

His problem, and moreover, the problem managers have with him, is that while he has the ball he's happy. When he hasn't he is not happy at all.

He fails to track his man, and leaves Coleman continually exposed. Riise was unmarked all game on their left because Deulofeu just left him.

Gibbo and Lukaku spent the entire match telling him to track back but he just doesn't, well, maybe once in every six times he's asked.

This is the reason (I believe) he's not trusted to start Premier League games. It has nothing to do with his undoubted ability with the ball.

Alex Doyle
98 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:11:34
@ James, must have been about 10 rows behind you and agree with your views on the game. We looked home and hosed in the first half. Deulofeu would perhaps be better as a 10 in a counter attacking style, as he was dominated when on the back foot. Not at all convinced by McCarthy, he needs to impose himself a lot more and thought the subs could have come earlier. Went up to shake BK's hand after the game and wished him good luck for the season. Must have thought I was a Fulham supporter and paused before shaking my hand.
Lee Robinson
99 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:49:25
Very disappointing, a game we should have won and had the chances, Fulham will count their selves very lucky to have got away with a win there.

I was there last night, firstly I will say fantastic support from our fans.

I thought the team selection was fine, first half we were in control and maybe should have gone in 2 up. We seemed to get really sloppy though towards the end of the first half, I thought Gibson had a shocker although he must be rusty. A few times in the first half Robles kept rolling the ball out to Distin or Stones, and Fulham kept closing down often causing us to look silly. Now we WILL get caught out in the end doing this as teams are starting to wise up, the midfielders need to drop deep and show for the ball if we are going to do this, Gibson was stood miles away uninterested many times, we need to drop deep and offer triangles and options.

Positives
Ovideo, Stones, McCarthy were all excellent I thought. Once Barry came on we were awesome, looked a totally different side.

Negatives
We came out second half looking disinterested, looked uncomfortable on the ball, sloppy mistakes. Something needed to change, they had 2 chances and scored.
Once Martinez made the changes we bombarded them and came so close about 4 times where we really should have scored.
I thought Del boy second half was terrible and probably cost us an equaliser as Fulham had sussed him out second half, he is very raw and has no end product for me at the minute, gave the ball away about 10 times, ran out of play or either got tackles trying to take too many on. His team mates did not look impressed.

Naismith offers zero for me in build up play, went missing last night.

All in all very frustrating as we had some great chances, we battered them at times start of first half and end of second. A dire 20 mins and we let the game go.

I thought this would have been a perfect cup for the start of Martinez' reign this year.

Onwards and upwards, plenty of positives from a defeat though and we look great going forward for once with plenty of options.

Ian Burns
100 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:15:04
I hate the next day after a loss! Watched second half on line. The starting XI couldn't have been so bad as a friend watching told me we were by far the better team but after 30 mins we just tailed off until the second half substitutions, which were made to push more people upfield and to be fair to RM it worked. I just wish Mirallas had more than 10 mins.

So wanted to give this Cup a real go, thought we had a real shot this year.

At least players got playing time, no consolation I know but I have to find something to cheer me up!

Conn Prosser
101 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:29:26
Gibson tired and should not have come out for the second half. Heitinga was also questionable for a lot of the game. It's time for him to move on. Unless he's getting a good run of games and beings to own the defence, he is ineffectual. Unfortunately for Johnny, there are enough decent players to keep him on the bench.

I didn't see a lot from McCarthy either - so three players not doing their bit in and around the engine room and things need to change. I bet Fulham couldn't believe their luck when we carried on as we were for the second half.

Absolutely gutted to have lost that, I'll take any silverware and chance at Europe, regarless of how we get it. I hope Martinez has learnt a lot of lessons. And Deulofeu learns to pass.

Lee Robinson
102 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:45:51
I disagree on McCarthy, I thought he was neat and tidy and broke up a lot of play and got stuck in when needed. He looked even better when he had Barry next to him.
James Martin
103 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:43:43
Just like under Moyes, far too much blame gets heaped on the manager when we lose.

I believe despite the error of changing the team a lot, Martinez had given us the platform to win that game. Is it his fault that Deulofeu missed chance after chance, that Coleman missed an open goal, that Naismith passed one to their keeper, that as a team we just sat off them and let sub standard midfielders run the show. Did Martinez tell the team to defend that free kick in the most ridiculous manner I've ever seen? No he didn't.

As usual with Everton we just don't have enough players in the team who can take responsibility and perform well when the pressure is on. They just don't have a winning mentality and that will take time to change. Whatever it seems to be, and this is not just the Moyes reign I'm talking about, there always seems to be some excuse, bad refereeing, a pass back, missed chances. The bottom line is these players just didn't have the stones to finish it off the same way the players last year didn't have the stones to get into the top 4.

Gary Mortimer
104 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:12:45
For one thing I think everyone wanted us to win last night, we are all putting a positive spin, by calling it the Mickey Mouse Cup etc….
My thoughts are:
We played really well for the first half when the players all looked fresh and up for it and Fulham weren’t.
The lack of fitness/match sharpness in central midfield was really obvious for the first 20 minutes of the second half. With Fulham obviously getting a rocket at half time, it became obvious that Gibson was nowhere near match fit. Heitinger isn’t mobile enough for centre midfield. McCarthy was anonymous, hopefully due to lack of match sharpness, but I am concerned that we’ve spent a shed load of money on someone who might not be good enough for our first team.
As stated by others, Gerard looked brilliant in the first half, but he continually tried to do too much in the second half, all the way up to the final whistle, if he learns to play the pass after beating three or four defenders then he’ll be a real danger. If he doesn’t learn, then he won’t be given too many more chances, as he wasted a number of chances to put someone in by trying to beat “just one more player”.
Nais is still Nais. Give him a few chances and he’ll tuck one away, but beyond that he is not the most gifted of players.
Robles was massively at fault for the second goal – he let a relatively weak shot by Bent straight through him. Very poor, even Howard would not have messed that one up. Why do keepers need resting anyway?
Lukaku came down to earth with a bump, flashes of brilliance, but lack of match sharpness also a factor.
If Coleman had managed to hit the target when he had the open goal (replays showed his shot was actually going wide) then it would have been a different story. He was quite quiet all game.
Oviedo is not a left back, played further forward he is fine, but not strong enough in defence.
So a missed opportunity and it’s disappointing, but we beat ourselves by wasting those first half chances. Hopefully, RM will have learnt a lot about our fringe players.
Tony McNulty
105 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:49:12
"Everton out of League Cup" - the journalists should file their copy early and go to the pub because the result is always the same.

Little did I think all those years ago at Wembley, when Hansen got away with his handball, that we would still be nowhere in this competition in 2013.

You win some, and lose some. My only consolation will be tonight when I will be delighted at whichever team loses: the RS, because, well, they are the RS; and the Manure because I would like to see the faces of the Three Stooges on their bench as in turn each hears, speaks and sees no evil.

Bitter? Moi?

David Hallwood
106 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:06:48
Tony McNulty(#408) that's what I did: 1-0 @ HT I went to the pub and I've only just switched on the computer to find out we lost! FFS What happened?
Kris Hall
107 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:57:11
Similar to last season's (league) visit, when we pummelled Fulham only to concede a late equaliser. Everyone was guilty of missing chances: in the space of four second-half minutes, Lukaku was put clean through and smacked it straight at the goalkeeper and Coleman managed to miss when it was easier to score (why did he hit it with his right?!).

Still, it was never a free kick for their second goal – it was a terrific tackle from Gibson. What is was, however, was diabolical defending. Hence the decision to bring on Jags - Johnny H was again found to be sadly missing.

It's a damn shame, but it's not all doom and gloom. Albeit for a hatful of missed chances, we'd be in the next round. Aside from two moments of madness, which resulted in goals, we dominated and there were some really good attacking performances. I'd rather see my side beaten playing well than be tamely kicked into touch.

Get the fellas back to Finch Farm, dissect the performance, learn from it... and take the Geordies to the cleaners. Let's keep climbing that Premier League ladder.

Tony McNulty
108 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:43:40
David (411),

Usual stuff: some players visibly tired; we did not cope well with their second half tactical changes; we were a bit unlucky with some of our shooting; in retrospect so many team changes probably cost us, as players unfamiliar with others’ moves, misplaced passes; karma came about because you were chatting up the barmaid …

Arild Andersen
110 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:07:21
I had the rare opportunity to watch the game as it was live on a free channel in Norway. The first 30 mins were great, but as always – or at least as in most games I have watched the last 2-3 seasons, we can’t finish our opponents off. This should have been over by half-time, so I can’t really complain about the changes in the starting XI.

I have no problem with the substitutions either, except that they came too late. Gibson was clearly struggling from the off in the second half, and I actually hadn’t expected to see him in the second half. After all, he isn’t match fit yet, and it was quite predictable that Jol would have dried his players’ hair during the break and that they would come out fighting.

OK, their goals came from a deflection straight to the feet of Berbatov (who I still think is a joy to watch) and some shocking defending, but even after five minutes, it felt inevitable that Fulham would come back as our midfield was way off the pace in the second half and they won most 50/50 challenges.

The players? Agree with most here, but I was very unimpressed by Oviedo. Seemed far too lightweight to defend in the Premier League, and dodgy passing or muscled off the ball going forward. Our left side was no threat. Even more important to keep Baines I guess.

I don’t really trust Robles either; I thought he looked rusty at best. Deloufeu is clearly talented, but reminds me of the second best player in my 8-year old son’s team (the best player is not my son, just to get that straight), who is strong, pacy and tricky, but hasn’t passed the ball all season because he really really wants to show that he is as good as the best player.

Deloufeu has brilliant feet but need to mature a bit as a player. Perhaps some PL-starts would do the trick as he wouldn’t feel the need to prove himself in the same way. But it would give Coleman some very busy matches, I admit that.

Hopefully it was just one of those nights, as we should have won it by half-time. But what slightly worries me is that we still can’t convert our chances, that we were outmuscled too often – even Lukaku, by Hangeland – and that it didn’t look like our players were prepared for the different approach from Fulham in the second half. The team screamed for a leader but there was no-one on the pitch who took responsibility, and that's maybe the most disappointing thing in my opinion.

Norman Merrill
111 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:40:01
Phil Head, If you want perfection, even watching Barcelona, would let you down.
Harold Matthews
112 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:47:14
Arild. Excellent post. Have to agree with your intelligent and very accurate observations. Let's hope for more live Everton games on your free channel. Your contributions will always be welcomed.
Michael Winstanley
113 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:06:02
James 404. Nailed it mate. That is Martinez's biggest task, the change in attitude of the players. Which is why when I see what he's doing with Barkley it gives me hope he can do the same with Mirallas, Lukaku and Del Boy and we'll start to take our chances.
Eugene Ruane
114 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:25:17
Arild (447) - Like Harold (Matthews) I think your view is just about spot on.

Re your last paragraph - "The team screamed for a leader but there was no-one on the pitch who took responsibility, and that's maybe the most disappointing thing in my opinion"

Again I agree completely, but this type of leader we have (imo) been screaming out for, for years.

The reality is, football 'leaders' are few and far between and I can't think of many 'out there' right now.

It simply isn't enough to stick an (captain's) arm-band on someone and hope they'll drag everyone along with them or command respect (see Neville, Jags).

I really believe these types of player (with 'the leader gene') are born and given at one point every team had at least one, it's strange that they appear to have all but vanished.

I believe absolutely that one (or two) in our side right now to 'direct operations' and give out bollockings when needed would improve things considerably.

Maybe these days they get weeded out out early - "got a big mouth, upsets the others, too much to say for himself"

That might seem fanciful but (particularly re the PL) consider that a manager just got the welly after 5 games of the season, basically because 'his' players went to the board and (of the manager) said "He shouted at us"

Drew Shortis
115 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:30:20
Good post Arild Andersen 447

I think the first half performance justified the team selection. There were several players out there with a point to prove (Roubles, Stones, Oviedo, Heitinga and Deulofeu) and bringing Gibson back into the team made sense. We dominated the first half and it looked like we would come out on top.

In the second half Fulham upped their game and we became a bit sloppy, especially with the two goals. One was down to some inexperienced defending from an otherwise impressive Stones, and the second was a combination of poor marking by Gibson and poor goalkeeping from Roubles.

The substitutions by Martinez weren't quite right. Bringing on Jags when we had just gone behind was a bad decision. Barry on for Gibson made sense. Mirallas should have been introduced instead of Jagielka and should have been on sooner.

After the first half display it was very disappointing not to win. We played well, but if you aren't taking your chances then you have to be much tighter at the back. That said, Berbatov and Bent are both excellent strikers so its a far cry from our exit against Leeds last year.

I agree with all those who say this is a winnable competition and a good route into Europe, and I am very disappointed to go out. I just can't agree with those with an agenda against Martinez. He has made some great moves in the transfer market and is slowly getting the team to adjust to his style of play. It will take time for it all to gel, but the signs are encouraging. When it works we are playing good football and the squad is looking a lot stronger with a good blend of youth and experience. With players like Barkley, Deulofeu and Lukaku we have added real quality to the team, but they will have off days and this was one of them.

Have some patience, it has been a decent start to the season and we still have the FA Cup to look forwards to. Its so easy to dwell on the negatives. We need to pick ourselves up, take the lessons from this defeat and strive to continue the improvement we have seen already. Any change of management and style is going to take time to work, and so far the transition has been better than most people expected and a damn sight better than most of the Martinez haters predicted.

Three points against Newcastle on Monday and were back on track!

Drew Shortis
116 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:55:01
Regarding a leader. I think Jagielka is in his own way, but I see Barry as a better option for captain. He is a model professional and a calm head in the midfield. Jags is an excellent player, but he doesn't seem vocal enough. He is also working hard to adapt to the new system and the pressure to organise the rest of the team may be a bit of a burden he doesn't need right now. I understood why Moyes selected him, but perhaps Martinez could lighten the load on him and appoint Barry. I wonder how Jags would react to such a change?
Raymond Fox
117 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:07:30
As far as captain is concerned, were not privy to what is said in the dressing room, and other times the players are together, maybe Jags is more of a leader off the field.

I agree though, that I too would like to see him giving more direction on the playing pitch.

Mike Allison
118 Posted 25/09/2013 at 21:07:02
I can't believe there are Evertonians claiming they don't want to win this competition. Maybe its just a post-facto rationalising reaction to how shit we've always been in it.

I'm fucking gutted. Assuming we rule out the league championship as a realistic target, we have two chances of winning a trophy every season. We've just chucked one away and the next attempt doesn't even start until January.

I have no problem with changing the team around for it, don't get me wrong. The players like Deulofeu who come in should be playing for their places and more motivated than those who played on Saturday, so its a perfectly acceptable thing for Martinez to do. I've not really seen a full explanation of who played where, it seems to me like at least one and maybe two players were out of position, which I do find annoying.

Colin Glassar
119 Posted 25/09/2013 at 21:40:12
Nothing to add to that Drew#485. Spot on.
Steve Green
120 Posted 25/09/2013 at 22:52:57
we lost for one blindingly obvious reason last night.... Leon wasn't playing...simples
Clive Lewis
121 Posted 25/09/2013 at 22:49:08
I think its a bit arrogant to make 8 changes. Let's be realistic, we have two chances of silverware now we have 1. Maybe some managers seem to think we are a premiership side play a weakened team, give the boys a chance. What are you giving the boys a chance for, to win what? We are out now, so the boys no longer will get a chance, should have played a few at a time.
Dan Parker
122 Posted 26/09/2013 at 02:01:50
Exactly Paul. I'm fairly happy so far this season and football is predictable, but Everton are predictable. We can't follow up a good spell with consistency as we get carried away with our own hype and media hype. Ok so we don't spend billions to win the league but this was fucking Fulham, nothing but the best will do. Any manager describing this as a Mickey Mouse competition after losing is looking for an easy excuse.

It's not the end of the world but the sad thing is, it's not surprising, it's somewhat expected and the norm.

James Bernard
123 Posted 26/09/2013 at 20:30:57
Kevin -264 Spot on mate

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb