''We made changes as they were needed''

, EvertonFC.com , 24 September, 131comments  |  Jump to most recent
After a good first half against Fulham, Roberto Martinez justified the team changes and bemoaned a lack of luck but was guilty of watching somewhat transfixed as Fulham came out after the break and regained the momentum to score two rather soft-looking goals that cut short another League Cup campaign prematurely for Everton.

“One of the things it's fair to say is that we never had a little bit of luck today,” claimed the boss.

“The first-half was outstanding, very, very dominant but the only criticism is that we didn't take more chances. I felt we created enough chances to win the game and that's why it's so disappointing not to get through.

"It was one-way traffic in the last ten minutes and it was very pleasing, the manner that we adapted, the way we changed the shape a little bit and the personnel,” he said. “We made changes as they were needed and we looked like a really strong side, clearly we knew what we were doing and that's credit to the players.”

Martinez made eight changes to the team that had started at West Ham at the weekend and he said this of the players who came in.

“Some of the players looked really sharp and will benefit from it. They need to be playing games to be able to help the team. Darron Gibson has been a long time away injured so it was really important that he had some playing time. John Stones performed really really well and Gerard Deulofeu showed flashes of the outstanding talent that he has.

“Throughout the team it was a performance from a group of players who are ready to help the team to achieve our aims. It's not one of those disappointing days where we didn't do ourselves justice. I thought we performed extremely well and obviously the scoreline doesn't reflect the full story but we should take the chances that we created.”

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (131)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kev Johnson
1 Posted 25/09/2013 at 00:31:20
I'm distinctly unimpressed by RM's post match interview on the OS.

http://www.evertonfc.com/news/archive/2013/09/24/Martinez-rues-missed-chances

Apart from the paragraph beginning "The first half was outstanding" it's complete and utter gobbledygook.

Tony Farrell
2 Posted 25/09/2013 at 01:03:17
I've just listened to Martinez's comments on last night's game. I can't believe he stated that the changes were needed... WHY???

Two or three at the most... but EIGHT!!! He can't be serious by saying some players needed a rest... six games in to a new season? Surely not.

The only good thing to come out of last night is the fact that his so-called fringe players are not good enough. I feel sorry for those travelling 3,000 blues trecking down to a Tuesday night game in London, would all of them have gone if they knew he was going to make eight changes (they probably would've — they're Evertonians....)

The substitutions were very Moyes-like as well. Some pundits on here have written the side we put out should've beaten Fulham.... think again, boys — we only just beat Stevenage with a better side. Let's hope Roberto realises he's fucked up and dosen't make the same mistake in the FA Cup and Premier League, respectively.

Jim Knightley
3 Posted 25/09/2013 at 02:16:14
Whilst we may have been unlucky, I don't understand the mass changes. We are never going to get fourth this year, so we should put out our best teams in the cup, and the Capital One offers the best chance for silverware. There should have been three or four changes tonight, and no more in my opinion. Personally I'd have like to have seen McCarthy, Robles, Def and Lukaku come in, and the rest of the team remain the same. We could always have given more a run out as the match went on.

Very very unlucky, but I can't agree with the team selection. Martinez won't improve our finishing positions in this league...I think he needs to win a cup, and swapping practically a whole team is not the way to do it.

Brian Cleveland
4 Posted 25/09/2013 at 03:40:10
Disagree with his comments.... we were disjointed because it was a completely new team. Passes went astray because passer and receiver were not on the same page, formation didn't hold up to scrutiny once pressed... first half was OK because Fulham didn't threaten, second half showed defenders not knowing who was marking who or what position they should be taking up.... hence easy 2nd goal with Bent welcomed into the box complete with ball, red carpet and champagne... abominable lack of marking and no challenge whatsoever.... pathetic

Not impressed

Phil Davies
5 Posted 25/09/2013 at 04:25:20
The way I see it, both goals came from stupid mistakes, the first Heitinga shouldn't have tried to play the ball to Lukaku when he had a Fulham player stood right behind him and the second was down to Gibson not picking up Bent in the box and poor goalkeeping.

Naismith did very little again, Deulofeu needs to work on his crossing, sometimes I couldn't tell whether it was a cross or shot. The defence looked fine, Oviedo still needs work defensively. Heitinga struggled throughout the game, he clearly isn't suited to the deep lying midfielder like Barry or Gibson.

The biggest issue I had though was the substitutions, 2-1 down with Jelavic, Barkley and Mirallas on the bench Martinez opts for a centre-half who struggles to pass and a defensive midfielder...

Bobby Mallon
6 Posted 25/09/2013 at 05:31:42
Tony Farrell,

Don't feel sorry for us, we would have gone anyway. Honest mate, he needed to play the fringe players, it told me one thing, Robles is not the answer to Howard...

Gibson was not match fit but showed some good touches in first 20 mins. Lukaku will be great and the young Barca kid will be a superstar come next season. Oh and Naismith really is rubbish and should be sold, goal or not he was poor.

I enjoyed the game.

Tony Fearns
10 Posted 25/09/2013 at 07:50:32
Far too many changes I would have prefererd he made a couple of changes against Newcasle on Mon. He should have played his strongest side possible as a good cup run is our best chance of anything this season.
Mike Green
11 Posted 25/09/2013 at 07:50:11
Too many changes and left it too late to change back when it was clear Fulham had the better of us in the second half.

A real shame as for the sake of resting players, giving others game time en mass we've sacrificed a route to a trophy and invaluable momentum built up by the team and the support.

Fantastic away support again last night by the way - and I'm not knocking the effort by the lads put in last night, they just didn't look like they really knew what they were doing.

A mistake, but it's how you learn from them, eh Roberto....

COYB.

Kev Johnson
12 Posted 25/09/2013 at 07:51:36
"Throughout the team it was a performance from a group of players who are ready to help the team to achieve our aims" is just gibberish.

We totally lost control in the second half and that's what needs to be addressed. I don't expect him to repeat his mistake of last year, when he carried on talking about Wigan as though they were playing a blinder as they slipped inexorably towards relegation. Positivity is nice (as Aristotle said) but I demand a basic sense of realism from our manager.

"Some of the players looked really sharp and will benefit from it. They need to be playing games to be able to help the team." I don't know where to start trying to unravel that... It's as if last night's match was a friendly!

I am not gruntled - quite the opposite.

Adam Fenlon
13 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:08:48
If you're not going to give fringe players a shot in the early stages of hte League Cup then they'll never get a game.

Fully support the manager's decision here, even if it didn't quite come off in retrospect.

Henry Enzio
14 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:10:37
Why don't we ever take this competition seriously?

Too many changes for me.

John Ford
15 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:14:06
Surely there's a need to keep all squad players involved ?How do our second choice get properly match fit if they're not playing first team matches. We were good enough to win, but it didn't happen for us. Poor defending for the second and some missed chances.

I reckon we'll scrag Newcastle.

Lewis Barclay
16 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:18:44
We lost a cup game marginally to a premier league side, with eight of a first 11 who probably wouldn't start against them in the premier league.
That was the most talented bench I ever remember seeing for a competitive Everton match.

We looked outstanding in the first half, Deulofoue and Lukaku looked a lot better than every other player on the pitch at times.

Fully support what Martinez did. Looking forward to taking 6 point off of Fulham in the premier league.

Mark Palmer
17 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:31:05
Roberto was correct - we should have won and the team put out was good enough. We murdered them in the first half and the 3 thousand travelling fans - it seemed a lot more - were very happy. And the substitutions regained our foothold on the match. No complaints apart from the result. How else can Roberto blood fringe players but in the League Cup? This is a transition, boys. Be patient!
Kevin Tully
18 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:35:00
Can't we use the under 21's to get the like of Gibson match fit?

Shouldn't be using games like this as a platform for match practice.

Colin Glassar
19 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:46:59
Spot on Mark Palmer. This was a case of damned if you do, damned if you don't. I'm glad I'm not a manager.
Dan McKie
20 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:49:03
I can never understand it when a manager claims he wants to see how the fringe players get on, so plays almost a whole team of them. If we do get injuries, the player(s) that come in, wont be playing with more than half of the team they played with last night, so what is the point? We have gone 18 long fucking years without winning anything, and we throw our fringe players at this competition every single year. 2 or 3 changes would have been fine. As for sticking with bringing on Barry and Jags when we have just gone a goal down, then only bringing on Mirallas with 10 minutes to go...whats that about? It should have been, right you two sit back down, Kev, Jela strip off you're on.
Dave Lynch
21 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:58:13
So when are the "Fringe players" supposed to get game time ?
One thing I have picked up from Martinez is that he will learn from this, unlike another person who was once at the club.

He got the job late in the close season and to be fair has had very little time to suss out his best 11.

I'm not panicking and will give him the whole season to get a feel for what he wants and needs.

Anyone with any ounce of football knowledge will know that next season will be the acid test and anything we achieve this season will be a bonus.

Michael Winstanley
22 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:00:18
I don't get the criticism on here. We battered them first half, best 45 mins I've seen in years. After we scored we sat back and played counter attacking football with Del Boy being the main threat, he was brilliant.

The reason we lost isn't because of the changes he made, although Robles should have saved Bent's shot, terrible goal keeping. We didn't take our chances, it's as simple as that. How Coleman missed an open goal I still haven't worked that out.

Denis Richardson
23 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:57:41
I think a lot of people have posted whilst still gutted at the result and have let their feelings cloud their judgement.

Like most, I too thought there were too many changes when I saw the line up but that was obviously not the case given the first half performance. We absolutely battered Fulham in the first half with some of the best pass and move play I've seen from an Everton side for a long long time - and that was with half a dozen first teamers out! We looked completely comfortable on the ball and there always seemed to be options for the guy in posession.

The only mistakes in the first half were that we simply didnt score enough. The score could and should have been 2-0 or even 3-0 and had that been the case, the result would likely have been different.

Fulham regrouped and came at us in the second half and credit where credit is due, they were much better and pinned us back. Lets not forget that we were playing a premiership club away from home and not Shrewsbury or Brentford. The likes of parker, berbatov, hangeland etc are top draw players who would get into our side. Also Coleman missed an open goal at the end which would have taken it to extra time.

Very disappointing result but I'm philisophical about it as there were so many plus points that I saw. I was really impressed by Delboy although he needs to work on his end delivery. However, having a player who can dribble past people at PACE is so refreshing to see in a blue shirt. Stones also really impressed me with the composure he showed and he will also be a top player. Oviedo showed signs of a good player as well although he's got a long way to go to get to Baines' level.

Disappointments for me were Heitinga, didn't really do much or add anything and most of us know/knew under the previous regime that he is not a CM. We really should have sold him in the summer. He's a bench warmer at best and at 60k a week thats too much. Anyway, maybe we can sell him in Jan.

Naismith is not a top draw player but I have to admit he didnt look as shit as what I remember of him from last season. He should not be starting games but seems to be making a case for a squad player who puts a shift in when asked.

Overall gutted with the result but excited by the future and the potential in this side. Imagine Mirralas, Barkely and Delboy behind Lukaku - sorry but imo that is not far off a top 4 front line.

Was just a bad day in the office but the future is still bright and blue.

Alan Williams
24 Posted 25/09/2013 at 08:38:54
I don’t normally comment on football matches but I made the trip last night with many other fans and whilst he made stupid changes 3 or 4 max should have been the rule it was about the formation that got me. Goalie was clueless especially on distribution via his feet, he played Stones at centre back Jonny H in midfield when we had Gibson and McCarthy in there too, sort of 2,2,1,3, 1, 1 in a diamond sort of shape and whilst attacking with speed we looked ok, at the back and in the middle we looked out of sorts and the players weren’t too sure how to play the formation. When Fulham eventually worked out how to break us down we were clueless in dealing with it and RM should have made the changes as soon as they scored rather that waiting longer. RM gambled and failed and yet again we Blues are sitting there wondering why we actually bother entering the league cup these days. RM needs to use his squad when he can but changing the formation and that amount of players doesn’t actually achieve anything in my book, sometimes I think he is too clever for his own good and sometimes in football modern managers just miss the obvious. He should of attacked this competition and tried to be the only ever Manager to win it for us. Massive opportunity missed here to win over the fans, very poor show and we got what we deserved for showing a lack of respect to Fulham and the competition.
Ciarán McGlone
25 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:27:56
The problem I have with last night - is that even after experimenting and using fringe players - he'll still start with Osman & Naismith in midfield next Monday.. and the barca kid will be dropped..

It's worrying that he doesn't know his best eleven players by now..

Jim Bennings
26 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:18:00
Very down in mood today after going out of the cup, our one only chance of silverwear so soon onto the season.

Nothing changes in regards to Everton's woeful cup record really, is it any wonder I don't bother with cup draws, I am not even arsed who we get in the third round of the FA Cup, I know for a fact that even if we do get past the first few rounds we always blow it when its on a plate in the quarters/semi final.

I don't think last night was anywhere near as wretched a performance as last years exit to Leeds when the whole team was terrible.
The first half we should have killed the game dead last night, sadly its a problem thats dogged us too often especially away from home over the years, cant kill a game off when we should.

I maybe would have started one of Baines or Jags in defence.
I was also quite let down by how easily Parker wrestled the midfield from our grasp so soon into the second half.
Gibson, on a yellow card should have been replaced by Barry at half time.
I do like Gibson but from what I have seen I believe Barry is a better all round player, neater on the bal (why does Gibson feel the need to blast his passes to players?)

Oviedo was again just ok, its simple to see why we HAD to keep Baines.
Its too early to judge John Stones.
Likewise Robles. To say he is no replacement for Howard after just two appearances is ridiculous, has Tim Howard not had some truly shite games this last year or so?

Deulofeu was the one positive, at least he tried to make things happen, its not his fault that we couldnt get that second goal in the first half when we should have.

All in all I am yet again pissed off though.
We know face a long hard slog in the League and for what really?
The top five has now become completely out of bounds for anyone other that Chelsea, Arsenal, City, United and Spurs.
Liverpool with all the cash they have splashed don't even have that much chance.
Its not like it was six or seven years back when we went out the cup early under Moyes and we really though we could reach Europe through the League positions, they were the days City and Spurs were'nt really established spenders and bigger and better than us.

To everyone saying that its a cup we are better off out of and why do we want the Europa League well I would simply answer that with 'well what are we actually playing for then?'
We are not going to win the League or finish in the top five are we?
Why bother participating?

Kev Johnson
27 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:41:49
Michael (369) - but what you say is precisely WHY there are valid criticisms. We were so good in the first half and were worth more than a 1-0 lead then let it slip badly in the second half. That shouldn't have happened.

A confession: my streams were so bad that I missed the last 20 minutes, so I can't really comment on that. It sounds like we came back into it a bit at the end and applied a bit of pressure.

I don't think anyone is getting it out of proportion - it was just very disappointing to lose a match we had in our grasp, that's all.

Brent Stephens
28 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:45:05
Dave #368 "He got the job late in the close season and to be fair has had very little time to suss out his best 11".

I hardly think he suddenly twigged that last night's starting XI was his best XI. So I assume he was trying things out. But to experiment with so many changes only makes sense if you don't think that competition is worth the candle. Maybe that's what he thinks - FA Cup or nothing!

Mohammed Horoub
29 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:33:54
Disappointing loss... Going into halftime with only 1 goal to show for the excellent first half performance meant we were risking a Fulham backlash... It still took a Coleman assist to Berbatov and Robles blunder to give them the game... I don't think Howard is sweating his No.1 position too much right now.

Positives: Deulofeu's dribbling and passing (when he looks up) Stones's composure, Gibson getting 60 mins under his belt (He was off the pace but we are going to need him at 100%) Lukaku, Naismith and Oviedo were all positive going forward. It will take Oviedo time to improve his defensive game.
Negatives: Heitinga is already in Turkey or Holland. He's checked out. (That 60k/week can be spent on a much more useful player)
Coleman's finishing (Just saw the replay and I don't think the shot was going in) McCarthy seems a little tentative, not the same player we saw last year with Wigan. Hopefully it's just settling in nerves and we will see better performances as the season develops.

Based on last night's performance my current starting 11 are:
Howard
Coleman - Jagielka - Distin - Baines
Mirallas - Barry - Gibson - Barkley - Deulofeu
Lukaku

Brent Stephens
30 Posted 25/09/2013 at 09:50:52
Michael #369 "The reason we lost isn't because of the changes he made, although Robles should have saved Bent's shot, terrible goal keeping. We didn't take our chances, it's as simple as that".

Michael, I think another (nameless) manager would have got a bollocking on here for letting slip a one-goal lead, based on some really good football. I actually don't subscribe to the view that everything has to be the fault of a manager but if people take that line then they have to be consistent and say that that was Robertos' fault.

I think he is culpable in his initial selection (too many changes), his lateness of changes and the lack of attacking possibility in the Jags change.

But I'm still very hopeful overall.

Max Wilson
32 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:01:51
8 changes was crazy. A midweek game is the norm for all the top clubs and these are pro players are'nt they?
The only good thing to come out of this game seems to have been the glimpses of what Deulofeu can do. Some defence splitting moves from him.Lets hope he replaces the injured Ossie this weekend.
Phil Sammon
33 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:12:17
I think it's about time we got rid of Heitinga now. He can't play CB anymore, plus we have Stones there, and he's certainly no centre mid.

Martinez' decision to play Heitinga, McCarthy and Gibson in the middle was a dodgy one for me. Gibbo was furthest forward and that isn't a role that suits him. I'd have much rather seen Gibbo, McCarthy sitting in behind either Naismith or Mirallas...or Ross Barkley of course.

McCarthy was absolutely invisible too. I hope there's much more to come from him.

Ciarán McGlone
34 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:28:47
Phil,

I thought that McCarthy was the one who was playing furthest forward - a role he's not suited to...and that's why he was quiet..

Ciarán McGlone
35 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:30:34
I also think the attempts to play Oviedo in left back have failed..he's not a defender.

Either play him in left midfield or don't play him.

When we went to 3 centre halves and he was pushed on he looked a different player.

Damien Dempsey
36 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:16:50
I think the first half performance demonstrated that those fringe players were good enough to play. It is important that those players get games otherwise when there are injuries and suspensions we as a team are not well enough prepared to adapt to those types of situations.

The problem last night was the players did not seem to be able to anticipate the speed and the sense of purpose that Fulham attacked us with immediately in the second half. We seemed lulled into a state of comfort, we had total control of the first half but the one goal lead was not enough. Fulham used this to their advantage. The goals that they scored were soft goals but the warning signs were there. Fulham were beginning to look more and more dangerous and it is fair to say that Martinez did not react quick enough.

Certain changes should have been made before we had to chase the game.

Norman McIlwain
37 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:44:13
RB has to take this one on the chin. After the break, Everton lost the midfield play and I just wonder how many fans sensed goals coming - for Fulham? As a manager, you don't just wait until the side is losing to make changes - you need to respond decisively when danger threatens. He waited and we lost.

Still, I hope he learns not to make this mistake again. RB has done well, but got it wrong on this occasion.

Delofeo needs to show in the first team squad. - A great asset. He will learn quickly.

Brian Harrison
38 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:46:48
I think the problem that all Premier clubs have is giving game time to fringe players. Light years ago we used to have a reserve league were if you were not in the first team you got regular competitive football in the reserves. But unfortunately we no longer have reserve football only an under 21 league, and I think you have a limit to how many over age players you can play. So how do we give the over 21s game time, if not the league cup then maybe the early rounds of the Europa league which we didn't qualify for.

While RM quite rightly suggested feeder clubs for younger players that still leaves the problem of how do you give your seasoned pros game time, without reverting back to a strong reserve league.

Darren Alexander
39 Posted 25/09/2013 at 10:45:31
Yep, like some others I would have liked to have seen minimal changes - maybe 2, 3 max (including Deulefou, who I think would have benefited even more from having more experienced players around him).

Why 'rest' all these players 5 games in? Is it for all our upcoming, gruelling Champions' League qualifiers? Few clubs in the top flight will have fewer games to play than us this season - we have 33 league games and, at best, a handful of FA Cup matches left. And our next league match is almost a full week after last night's match, FFS.

While I do think that side we played wasn't at all bad - which says a lot about the good condition our squad is in - and I do agree they could (and should) have won the game in the first half, I think it was experience more than ability that nudged Fulham over the line. We had some great, talented youngsters out there but a starting 11 that includes Haangeland, Parker, Berbatov, Karagounis etc. is always going to have the edge when it comes to knowing a thing or two. They were happy enough to gamble that we'd shot our bolt in the first half without too much damage to the scoreline, were given a couple of soft goals by the sleepwalkers who'd emerged for the 2nd half, then were happy to sit back and take a chance that that would be enough. And it was.

Jol's use of subs was much better - if our 3 had come on at the hour mark it might have played out differently...

And Bobby #339 - I agree re: Robles. When RM signed him I assumed we were going to see his FA Cup winning 'keeper really push for the #1 spot, but at the moment he appears no closer than Mucha was.

Chris James
40 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:05:30
I don't think making changes was terrible, to be fair the side looked really good early on in the first half.

However, we should have made 1 or 2 subs at half time. We'd failed to put the game to bed in our early flurry and then from about 30 mins on Fulham started to look dangerous - they were very much in the ascendency at the end of the first half and that continued into the second half including 2 goals. It wasn't until we'd gone behind and Jags+Barry came on that we really looked to be back in control and making chances again.

Whilst we really should have at least got back on level terms with all he chances we had in the last 15-20, we should never have been in that position in the first place. Bring on Jags or Barry at half time to steady the ship and we'd have a much calmer start to second period looking to build on lead.

Norman McIlwain
41 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:15:05
I wonder if RB ever reads our advice?
Chris Ashton
42 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:14:11
Look I may be in the minority here but going out the cup last night does not affect me one bit. Martinez is going to make mistakes this year as he has stepped up the calibre of football he is in charge of. He clearly isn't going to turn us around in 3 months and all of a sudden get us in the top 4.

My point is, I would rather him have made this mistake or mistakes last night rather than on monday and if it costs us a chance of the league cup for 12 months then so be it. The changes in all honestly were not bad ones and you can see why he made them. Heitinga, Oviedo, McCarthy, Gibson, Lukaku, Naismith are all international players that made the team up last night. Delofleu is apparently the best spaniard since Iniesta/Xavi and you always play your back up keeper in the league cup. We may have changed a winning team but the one that went out was not a bunch of kids like some people would make out.

So we lost, same old story every year. But it seems from some reactions that fans expect Martinez to win us a trophy this year simply because he did last year with his former employers. If we did then he would be a much better manager then we all think of him as.

Just enjoy the season!

Chris Ashton
43 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:23:48
Oh and as for tonight's game, well I would prefer if they were both kicked out for undisclosed reasons rather than see one of them win.
Tony Fearns
44 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:21:43
He made a lot of changes in the game against Stevenage and we just about scraped through. He obviously didn't learn from that match.
Bill Griffiths
45 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:14:17
I hope that as Denis believes, most of these posts were made in the heat of the moment. Personally I have my doubts as to whether Martinez is good enough but I do realise that he and this applies to any other person who the Board may have appointed, will require time to make their mark and get things as they want them. Accordingly there are always going to be highs and lows.

Before the team was announced my personal opinion was as most others, in that not too many changes should be made. At first when I saw the team selected I was surprised at how many changes there were but on looking at the team I thought it was one well capable of doing the job. Based on the first half performance I would suggest that this was the case and we were perhaps a bit unlucky to lose.

To date, though I have my doubts about Martinez, I have on the whole so far, been quite impressed by him.

There's no doubt that he's a fine person and exceptionally media savvy and is a joy to listen to. I'm also impressed by his sense of positivity though to my mind it's a little bit too much so sometimes.

Let's see if the usual service is resumed on Monday with a really strong performance following a setback as was often the case under our former manager.

Damien Dempsey
46 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:14:52
Brian I think the problem also playing in the U21s team is there is not the same type of pressure that you would have playing in the first team. I watched the highlights of the U21s playing Chelsea this morning at Goodison, there was absolutely no atmosphere. There was no crowd so they are playing under a completely different set of conditions than that of the first team.

The function of U21s is good for the progression of a young player or even someone just coming back from injury. But first team action is necessary for keeping those fringe players not only match sharp and conditioned, but also motivated. It is why clubs prefer to send their promising players on loan to lower league clubs rather than playing them in the reserves or U21s.

Phil Sammon
47 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:34:12
Norman

Who is this 'RB' you keep referring to?

Chris Sillett
48 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:47:06
I think there's been a bit of over reaction on here. Yes it's disappointing to go out but don't we go out at this point virtually every year? We lost to Leeds last season didn't we? I see people are complaining that Martinez didn't make changes at half time, didn't he change the game at West Ham with his substitutions and we were all praising him for doing what Moyes would never have done?

The reality is the League Cup is now seen as a competition to play your fringe players, and that's what Roberto did; we lost but he gave players like Stones and Deulofeu chances to shine. Let's not get on his back after one defeat for god's sake! Beat Newcastle on Monday and last night will be forgotten.

Nick West
49 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:52:50
When are people going to take this competition for what it is – a plate competition? Great if you get a few rounds in to give your fringe players a run-out but you don't want to waste time and energy on it with your main guys.

Glad Martinez's comments after the game didn't pander to the hysterical fan element who bemoan the loss of a trophy opportunity. A club like ours needs to be in the Champions League – period. So all resources need to be channelled to that end.

Paul Ellam
50 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:48:15
Once again the club don't seem to have understood the importance of trying to actually win a cup competition.
This is one of few opportunities for us to win silverware and just as we did against Leeds we have shown the opposition and the tournament a lack of respect in my opinion. We need to play a strong side from the beginning and then if we do get 2-3 goals up, rest the better players. Doing it the other way round rarely works.
This club has never won the league cup - right now it is only 1 of 2 that we can win so why not put the effort in required?
Swansea and Birmingham have shown that teams outside the top 4 can do it and I for one would be overjoyed at winning this cup - even if it meant we finished 15th in the league!
After all, we will probably finish 6th or 7th and miss out on Europe anyway so as long as we don't get relegated let's win a trophy because 1995 is a long long time ago :-(
Raymond Fox
51 Posted 25/09/2013 at 11:29:43
As has been said before, if your not going play your fringe players in this Mickey Mouse comp. when are you going to give them a game.
The team he picked murdered Fulham in the first half, only prob. was they didn't put the ball in the net!
So don't blame RM for for the team he put out, each match that's played he will learn more about the players.

Its the League and the FA Cup that has credibility lets give them 100%.
He could have played all the 1st team players and got halve of them crocked, there would have been some moaning then.

We lost, it was against a premier league side,
it was never going to be easy, we'll lose some more matches before the seasons out, that's for certain.

Kev Johnson
52 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:11:05
Phil S - it's Roberto Bartinez, obviously!
Tony J Williams
53 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:14:36
"As has been said before, if your not going play your fringe players in this Mickey Mouse comp. when are you going to give them a game."

I am all for that, but not all at once though.

Tony J Williams
54 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:15:23
Also, it may have been my feed, but what was wrong with Stones' challenge at the end to merit a yellow card?
Phil Sammon
55 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:10:29
I think some changes were needed. I want to see Stones and Deulofeu get minutes and McCarthy need to prove himself. My team would have been:

Robles

Coleman
Stones
Distin
Baines

McCarthy
Gibson
Barkley

Deulofeu
Mirallas

Lukaku

That's 6 changes from last week but I still think its a really strong side. With hindsight perhaps Robles shouldn't have started.

Heitinga definitely shouldn't have started. He has nothing to offer us anymore. Naismith may have scored but he isn't good enough. His link up play is non-existent and his goal was drilled straight at the 'keeper. He did make the run I guess, I just think he's lacking the required quality.

And what the bloody hell is going on with Kone?!

Raymond Fox
56 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:22:06
Phil you've made 6 changes!
The only criticism I can make of RM is his substitutions, he could have been more positive.

Tony, but the team with 8 changes dominated Fulham, 1st half!

Tony J Williams
57 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:34:57
Cliché alert, but Raymond it's a game of two halves, not one.

The only criticism? He played Heitinga for flips sake!!

Jim Knightley
58 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:36:03
It doesn't matter that we were unlucky...what matters is that we lost after making eight changes, and we cannot forget that part of our good performance came from Fulham's poor display. We arn't going to make top four, but we could realistically win this cup. Making eight changes to the team for an away match in Fulham was always going to leave us with a high probability of going out.

Personally I would have liked to have seen Lukaku, Def, McCarthy and Robles come in. I don't understand the view that we need to play fringe players in the Capital one cup..is anyone under the conception that one, or two or three games over the course of the season will develop them as players or keep them on their toes? We could have made less changes and brought on other players in the second half if we were playing well.

Matty Williams
59 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:15:52
I would rather us go all out to win this Cup & finish 17th in the Prem.

My only hope is that one day we have a manager that wants to win all the Cups we have never won in our history & goes all out to hammer teams we have always had a piss poor record against or have hurt our club with Cup shocks. Revenge is sweet, folks! Villa & the RS are still owed in this competition!!

Kev Johnson
60 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:37:18
So, in bullet point form, this is what I learnt from yesterday's game:

* When we're on top we need put the game beyond the reach of the oppo - in other words, translate our dominance into more goals
* As Tony says, Heitinga has had it
* Gibson is rustier than a very rusty thing
* Defo showed both why he is under contract at Barcelona and, simultaneously, why he is not ready to play for them; bags of skill but not much footballing common sense

OK, they're asterisks, not bullets, but you get my point.

Patrick Murphy
61 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:35:34
Like most other fans I was disappointed that Roberto made so many changes last night and undoubtedly he was inexplicably slow in making adjustments during the game when the tide turned in Fulham's favour.

We could have won with a strong starting eleven or we may not have seen Fulham so laid back and still lost. That is all over and done with and the reality is that we are out of a competition.

I am very much in the pro Martinez camp, however, a few of his statements in recent weeks have started to ring some alarm bells for me. Everton FC is not Swansea City a club who had almost gone out of existence or Wigan - a one-man band playing football in a rugby town.

The Goodison audience doesn't need a lesson in how football should be played, it doesn't need informing of how systems and methods are difficult to enforce and it won't accept sugar-coated words to mask defeats.

Liverpool as a city is a football crazy place and there is very little that any one person can teach the match-going audience that it hasn't heard before.

Everton supporters in particular are a knowledgeable crowd and they will recognise BS for what it is - just ask Bill Kenwright - so please Roberto remember that this is a proper football club with a long history and its supporters have seen every type of player and style during their time.

In short Everton supporters are not that keen on snake-oil salesmen, they prefer to judge a product on its merits and not on what the seller claims it can do.

Robbie Muldoon
62 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:38:55
There is nothing to moan about from that game yesterday other than the result. Coleman should have put his open goal chance away, simple.

Martinez was right to make all the changes.

Kev Johnson
63 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:56:44
Well said, Patrick. Well said.
Laura Haseman
64 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:43:36
Gibson needed to play, as did McCarthy. We all wanted to see Deulofeu and Stones. And it would have been a massive poke in the eye to Heitinga if he had not started. So, not wanting an unhappy player on his hands, he picked him too. The problem was he played Distin (34?) the most likely to need a rest, so Heitinga had to go in midfield.

To be fair to Martinez if you had no misgivings before the game you shouldn't criticise now.

I'm not bothered that we are not going to win a cup with 3 handles in February that barely anyone is interested in if they are not involved. There is scant reward for winning it.

We should have gone through anyway, but for bad finishing and at least we learnt Deulofeu is ready.

Chris James
65 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:57:30
Spot on Jim Knightly.

Resting so many players in a year without European football does seem mad, especially against Premier League opposition at their home ground. What's more, this is definitely a competition we should have had a run at, considering it's one that the top teams probably WILL rest players in.

In terms of the specific replacements:

I totally agree with the points on Heitinga, he looked lost on many occasions and we were a different proposition when Jagielka came on.

Stones seemed solid, but unexceptional; McCarthy like-wise (also didn't realise how small he is in the flesh – tiny fella).

Delboy was promising but needs to look up more; although he was always willing, he ran down too many dead-ends towards the end and seemed to lose ideas in the last 5-10 minutes.

Robles utterly failed to convince, lots of dramatic catching of easy balls and then beaten way too easily by Bent; distribution also poor.

Oviedo was solid without being exceptional, a willing runner but he's clearly no Baines replacement.

I felt a bit sorry for Naismith, as usual he gave it his all, scored the goal and was involved in some good stuff but ultimately still gets stick.

Lukaku looked lively at times and a good target (although not as much of a beast as at the weekend) but probably should've got on the scoresheet (although his chances obviously not as gilt-edged as Coleman's!!!)

Matt Woods
66 Posted 25/09/2013 at 12:45:02
Oh, who gives a fuck? Yeah, yeah I know there is a trip to Wembley and the Europa Cup, but going on mad trips in the League Cup and getting turned over is a right of passage for Evertonians. It's part of who we are.

Occasionally we get a magic midweek fix like the Ferguson inspired win at Boro, but more often than not its fucking York, Portsmouth, Bradford that knock us out. Ridiculous draws at Rotherham with Preki making his debut in a first leg and my mate Wayne overtaking a huge wagon on Snake Pass to get us there!

Oh the fun of the League Cup! If you've been on these crazy evenings there is no explanation....you just know! Haha!!!

Watching the Blues in this competition is fucking mental, there are always hopes, but we all know what's coming! What is amazing is that we keep doing it in huge numbers... and you know why... because we just fucking love going to watch Everton play mid-week away! It's the camaraderie, it's the banter, it's Newcastle and winning on penalties.

People are going on about team selection and tactics and blame... ffs we have never won this cup and we got done by Grimsby at home with our greatest ever side! Anyone who was at that game knows there was a monsoon in L4. We could have scored 20, but I'll never forget the tackle Pat van den Hauwe put on their right winger in the first five mins... Put it this way – it looked like slip-fielding in the Paddock. The poor bastard never looked at the ball after that.

We were unbeaten before the League Cup, yeah, we do want to win it, but I sense that something is happening. We have no divine right to win games, mistakes will be made, but we are heading somewhere better... believe!

Robbie Muldoon
67 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:17:53
Well in Matt!
Ben Jones
68 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:13:59
It's just pointless criticism.

If we had taken those chances in the first half, everyone would be applauding Martinez for making the changes. But when we lose, we criticise and that's too easy.

Kevin Tully
69 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:23:02
For for the record...We will get beat again this season, and Martinez will make mistakes.

It seem some are genuinely shocked by this defeat.

Jim Knightley
70 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:24:17
Ben it's not pointless criticism. Our first 11, with players more use to playing with eachother, are far more likely to achieve a positive result. Making eight changes says we don't give a fuck. We could have made 4 and kept a strong spine, but we choose to do what clubs in the Champions League and Europe, who have better squads, more chances of silverware and more games, do.

We'll probably come sixth or seventh this season, and unless we win the FA Cup, will look back on this as a wasted opportunity. I don't think Martinez will improve on league positions, but I did think he would bring a trophy. But making eight changes to our first 11 in an away match to a Premier League team is not the way to do it.

Jim Knightley
71 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:28:40
I don't think it's shock though is it Kevin? It's criticism of team selection.
Ben Jones
72 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:32:25
We've got a good squad though Jim, and as the performance suggests, we should have won.

If our players took the chances, we would have won.

It's just very easy and convenient to criticise Martinez, when it should have been players like Seamus Coleman, who should be criticised, where he missed an open goal!!

If we win, would you criticise Martinez for fielding a weaker team? Many would praise the change. In my eyes, whatever the result, he did the right thing.


Kevin Tully
73 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:36:20
All valid Jim - but a defeat away to Fulham will happen again, it's not like we were playing lower League opposition.

I'm not happy about it, but I think we deserved at least a draw, even with 8 changes (which was far too many.)

He should have kept Jags in with Distin, and I believe Heitinga is only here for the money now.

Let's hope he realises that.

Tony J Williams
75 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:34:50
"It's just pointless criticism" = My Irony detector has just exploded.

I know this is the new guy in charge but by fuck, that has got to be the biggest pile of cack posted so far.

It's a competitive game of togger that should be played to win, not make eight changes to give so called fringe players a game. It was against a Premier League team, at whose ground we have had a terrible record.

We need to win games and we need to play players who will do that for us. Not put out fringe players, especially as it's almost a week until the next game.

These are professional footballers for fuck's sake..... at the very start of the season. They don;t need resting yet!!

Pointless criticism???? Fuck me!

Damien Dempsey
76 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:01:52
Sorry Patrick I do not agree. We have as many idiots (as well as those who consider themselves to be knowledgable) supporting our team as any other club. We are not Wigan or Swansea but we have been very close to going out existance before Moyes came. In terms of winning the league we are miles behind and for many supporters of the modern game in other countries on a whole we do not exist. Only for those old enough to remember us. We are rich in history that is all.

I think Martinez does not under estimate our fan base, he is aware of our great history and tradition. I do not think he is trying to dress anything up or hide our problems, I just think that it is in his nature to be positive. He comes across as being a very methodical type of person (as well as philosophical). Positivity is contagious in the same way as negativity. A positive environment is essential for us to move forward.

I think it is us who under estimate Martinez in what he is trying to achieve for our club. He is astute enough to know our problems and the aspects of our game that need changing without having to be negative or critical in his comments to the media.

Steve Barr
77 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:46:49
Anyone watching the game yesterday would agree we should have won. Notwithstanding that, Fulham away is no easy ask. To make wholesale changes for this game was at best mis-guided from Everton's point of view and an insult to Fulham and their manager from their viewpoint.

Of course we should rotate players throughout the season for all of the reasons cited in this thread, but eight changes at this stage of the season seems to be completely unnecessary and clearly disrupted the flow and understanding amongst the team.

I can't help but think this manager lark is over-rated and over-hyped. Too much credence is given to these overpaid average strategists, tacticians and motivators, whatever you want to credit a modern manager with these days.

To follow this with the waffle RM espoused on the official website as justification has me more than concerned as far as our future is concerned.
I'm fed up listening to so-called TV pundits and soccer experts talking about how great certain managers are e.g. City, Chelsea etc., when in my opinion the only reason they're successful is because they've been given millions to buy the best players. Remember Mancini claiming he was the best manger in the Premier League when they won the league. Management, coaching skills tactics, strategy... just money in my opinion.

Message to RM: Keep it simple, don't over-think things. We've got a decent squad for this season. Don't cock it up.

COYBs

Jim Knightley
78 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:01:31
Ben, if we won Martinez wouldn't be criticised. But if we lost with a first 11, at least we couldn't criticise the intention to win. If we play Fulham's first 11 at Craven Cottage with a largely second string team, we will lose most times.

It's the team selection, which relates to the result, which is the problem here. It's indicative of a lack of a desire to win the Capital One Cup, and we are criticising Martinez just as we criticised Moyes after the Leeds match.

Playing a first 11 does not guarantee a win against Fulham, but it gives a far bigger chance of one and when a manager makes mass changes he takes a risk, and by losing Martinez will necessarily be criticised.

Unless I'm out of touch, we all want to win a cup don't we? And, given the strength of the top four, I wouldn't mind a run in the Europa and the Capital One Cup offers one route into it.

Damien Dempsey
79 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:54:08
Why do we assume that we are resting players. We are giving our fringe players competitive matches to play because, when there are suspensions and injuries, they need to be match fit, conditioned and fully motivated. They are squad players – we are not talking about the U21s and reserves.

Our first-half performance fully justified their selection but it is fair to say that Martinez did not react quick to making substitutions in the second half. In the end, we still created enough to have won the match.

Who is to say we would have won the match with a stronger team, it does not always work out that way. We cannot say for sure the things that would or could have happened. We are speaking as though we would have won the match but with our play yesterday we should have won anyway.

Raymond Fox
81 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:00:02
Again, when are some of the squad, going to get on the field without playing in this match?
I can understand some criticism such as the subs, but little else.

By the look of it RM didn't make this comp. a priority either, but my only regret is maybe a few more matches in the comp. would have been useful to give the 2nd string players more match time.

The League and the FA Cup are the priorities.

Harold Matthews
82 Posted 25/09/2013 at 13:24:29
Thanks Matt. Your post has helped lift my spirits.

Actually, I've just read all the thread and appreciated the differences of opinion and, for once, the fairness. Maybe that was because Ossie wasn't playing.

It was a match we should have won but, for a dozen assorted reasons, we didn't. Let's hope we fare better against Newcastle and the dangerous Ben Arfa. We all know his every move and if he manages to cut inside and score I, for one, will be very annoyed.

Bill Gall
83 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:18:37
Cant blame the manager for the team he put out last night as the first half performance proved that they should have gone in at half time more than one goal up after dominating.

My question is on the subtitutions after going behind. I agree a that a midfielder to calm the midfield down but why another centre back and not an attacker as we needed goals to get back in the game.

The only reason I came up with was he was trying to implement the 3 centreback system he is said to prefer that did not proove to be too successful at Wigan but the middle of a game is not the time to experiment.

Gary Mortimer
84 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:36:35
If we hadn't created any chances and been embarrased in a similar fashion to Leeds last season, then I would be criticising Bob. As it was his "rotated" team should have put the game to bed in the first half, or taken a couple of the good chances we created in the last ten minutes of the match, they didn't and we paid the price.

I do not think Bob siad to the lads "Go out and take it easy, don't worry if we don't win, it's only the Mickey Mouse Cup". As I stated on the other thread, too many players short of match fitness in the centre of the park gave Fulham the opportunity to take advantage of a lucky deflection to Berbatov and a bad keeping mistake to take advantage.

Hopefully Bob will realise who his best players are and who to move on in January.

Patrick Murphy
85 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:34:05
Damien, I'm sure you are correct about us having our fair share of idiots within the fan-base as have all clubs. But on the whole the match-going public on Merseyside are in general savvy about all things football and pretty good at spotting what is good and what is bad. Whilst we had some bad times prior to David Moyes's arrival, you'll have to refresh my memory as to when we were close to going out of business.

Yes, I too like positivity as it does make things feel better and negativity can make things feel worse than they actually are; however, when things do go awry, it is better to recognise those mistakes and improve the next time out.

James Stewart
86 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:48:46
Too many changes to the spine of the team. Fine bring in 2 or 3 but as soon as I saw the line up I feared the worst. No need to rest Barkley he needs as many games as he can get. We need to beat Newcastle soundly for that selection to be justified
Tony J Williams
87 Posted 25/09/2013 at 15:09:01
It doesn't matter that we looked great first half, we lost.

It's a twat of a ground to go to so eight changes are simply too many.

I am worried about Oviedo, as he gets pushed off the ball way too easily.

Dick Fearon
88 Posted 25/09/2013 at 15:04:25
Yet another manager on a learning curve.
Damien Dempsey
89 Posted 25/09/2013 at 14:47:22
Sorry, Patrick, I was not talking about Everton going out of business in a financial sense, I was meaning a non existence in a footballing sense.

In the period before Moyes arrived, most supporters of other clubs would have regarded us as a poor team. There are many young supporters in this country who would not have even realised how great we once were. In those dark times, which are not that long ago, there have been many 'big' teams who have not escaped relegation from the Premier League (or the old First Division) and seemingly disappeared. We have a history and we have a great support but in terms of footballing status, we are no better than Wigan or Swansea. Our greatness exists in the past.

At this moment in time, like it or not, we are battling it out against Swansea in trying to achieve our own objectives and footballing ambitions.

We have a very young manager who has a very difficult task a head of him. Nobody coming to our club would have considered it an easy option. It is not as simple as building on the foundations set of a team that finished 6th last season. He is going to make mistakes. Every manager is going to make mistakes at some point or another during a game.

Like I have already said, we should not under estimate Martinez, just because he does not give critical comments to the media; this does not mean he does not recognise those mistakes or problems being made. Like in all aspects of life, it is better to concentrate on the positives then focus the energy on how to correct any problems or find a solution. Negative comments do not have to be made. The differences in the treatment of Barkley of both Moyes and Martinez is a perfect example of this.

Raymond Fox
90 Posted 25/09/2013 at 15:58:00
Dick, were all on a learning curve until we die!

I think that the difference opinion between us, is more to do with how serious we took the League Cup. I couldn't give a toss for it, and I suspect our manager didn't rate it very highly either.

Patrick Murphy
91 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:12:54
Damien I agree with a lot of what you are saying however, Everton have been a top six club for most of the last seven years and our players have proved what they are capable of against top opposition at least in terms of results. I want Roberto to succeed and do well, but he mustn't become as blinkered as our previous manager was. Last night there were players on show who are clearly not good enough and some who are not as good as they think they are.

What I hope that Martinez instils a will to win, no matter who we are playing and who is in the team. I think he has to demand a lot more of the right attitude from his players and no longer can they continue to pick and choose which games they will raise their game for and which they will try and walk their way through. It was a problem under Moyes and it continues to be a problem under RM, it's ok performing in the 'big; marquee games but I want the team to have that attitude in every game.

Steve Cotton
92 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:26:27
anyone else think the ref was a twat or was it just me??

a number of our lads were fouled and he invariably shouted play on, they had one lad on the left wing who kept throwing himself to the floor and the ref almost couldnt wait to get his whistle in his gob every time.

or is it because we lost I think that?

Phil Sammon
93 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:32:28
A bit of both, Steve. He penalised a fair few good challenges by us, yet let theirs go.

That said, Gibson could quite easily have got a second yellow.

Patrick Murphy
94 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:30:09
Steve I too felt that Atkinson - I think it was him anyway - has always given Everton short-shrift and is another of the clan of the celebrity loving species who think it is ok to give decisions against 'smaller' clubs. Last night he was bad and so too where his assistants especially when flagging Naismith off-side just after we had taken the lead when to my mind he was well onside. How he failed to award us a corner when Distin's shot had obviously come off the Fulham player I'll never know. But he also awarded other decisions against Fulham which were equally mystifying. He is just a terrible referee and he is way out of his depth in the PL, but then again most of them are.
Matthew Williams
95 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:50:06
The comments I read on twitter before the game were in the whole positive, most people thought it was a good team, didn't see anything negative.Its easy in hindsight to say the changes lost us the game but actually looking at the highlights we should have at least drew the game, we looked very good going forward but a little shaky at the back. I personally never see the logic in resting a goalkeeper, I think Robles in time will be a top keeper and he of course already has an FA cup winners medal but in a tough away game against a prem team we should have been a bit more stronger at the back.

I think we should avoid wholesale changes in cup games unless its against much lower league teams

Damien Dempsey
96 Posted 25/09/2013 at 16:23:21
Patrick do you not feel we deserved to win though? If we had won like we we deserved to have done people would not be making these comments now. I can understand the criticism if we played really badly. You have said Martinez cannot afford to make the same mistakes as Moyes last season, but one of the faults of last season was Moyes never rotated the squad. He played the same team week in week out. One reason for this was he did not have enough confidence in the players. I think people also forget we are trying to build a team and a squad that can operate and be fully functional when there are suspensions and injuries, not just for this season but for the future as well. Like it or not, this is a transitional season for us.

People keep mentioning that we have biggest and best squad for ages this season. They need to be playing competitive matches othewise whats the point? Substitute appearances do not count for anything nor do reserve team matches. Also Martinez needs still to establish which relationships work on the pitch and which do not or which still need time in developing.

It was evident last night that certain players are not good enough to play but I think Martinez acknowledged that when interviewed. He said something along the lines of there being mixed performances by certain individuals. It is important that Martinez sees this now rather than never.

Patrick I agree, certain players need to stand up and show their worth and attitude, they cannot just be carried by other players in the 'stronger' team or just raise their game when they feel like it. But it is only in important competitive matches that we as supporters and Martinez have the chance to see this and make judgements.

James Marshall
97 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:15:11
He did the right thing - playing our fringe players in the lowest of the 3 competitions we're in. If you don't play them then, when do you play them?

The league is our priority for obvious reasons, and we played against Fulham's first 11 at their place last night, and but for a bit more luck in front of goal, we would have battered them.

The Fulham fans sitting around me couldn't believe we hadn't taken them apart and were stunned to win the game.

Tony J Williams
98 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:30:32
He clearly didn't "do the right thing", we lost. The same way Moyes didn't do the right thing last season at Leeds and any other game where we fielded a weakened side and lost.
James Marshall
99 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:33:31
He wasn't playing Tony. That was down to the other 11 or so blokes charging about in blue tops.
Steve Carse
100 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:28:50
Damien (491) - bit of a chicken and egg here -- of course Moyes never rotated the squad and one reason being that we were knocked out the LC early! So there was absolutely no reason to rotate with then only having one game a week to contend with and so able to keep his players fresh anyway.

Making 8 changes was indefensible. Reacting far too late to the loss of the midfield domination that we had for the first 20 minutes or so (it certainly wasn't anywhere near the whole first half as many on here and the manager seem to be saying) was Moyesesque. Making so many changes shows a manager who totally mis-judged the risks. Making the changes so late shows a manager still learning the game.

Ajay Gopal
101 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:23:21
Martin Jol has been very lucky against Everton the last 2 games. I remember last year also we battered them but incredibly came away with only a draw.
Tony Waring
102 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:37:50
Calm down lads. Since the transfer window closed everyone commenting on TW has without exception (I believe) been saying that we have the best squad we've had in years. As soon as we lose people start moaning and blaming RM. He's new at GP . You can only put out 11 guys at a time + the subs bench. The result is'nt always going to go our way. Mourinho can field 2 top class teams and look where Chelsea are at the moment. Going out of the League Cup is hardly the end of the world. I'd sooner we concentrated our efforts on the PL and the FA Cup. They are the serious competitions.
Sean Kelly
103 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:42:08
All you guys moaning about the changes last night, where do you think RM is goin to find out if fringe players are up to stepping into the first team? It's definitely not in the league, that's for sure.

What do you want him to do? Risk injuries to first trampers and play them every game and end up where Wigan are?

Give the guy a break. Christ knows, we gave Gollum a break for 11 fucking years...

Damien Dempsey
104 Posted 25/09/2013 at 17:39:47
Steve our players were not fresh last season, we had the same players performing week in week out without ever being changed. Certain players were almost begging to be rested because their performances were so bad and Moyes could still not rotate the squad. He had absolutely no confidence in our fringe players, he did not know how to use them. The squad players so they need to be able to perform and be as dependable as those players on the pitch. If you asked everybody what our starting line up should be you would be given a whole list of different player's names. We still do not even know what systems and tactics Martinez wants to be able use and with which players.

Making 8 changes is only indefensible because we lost, if we had won would those 8 changes still be indefensible? We deserved to win and should of scored easily more than 1 goal. The only action indefensible action was that Martinez did not make certain changes before they scored in second half. It was pretty obvious that was a risk even though their goals were sloppy and avoidable.

Wayne Smyth
105 Posted 25/09/2013 at 18:14:35
Not a lot wrong with the team selection. In my opinion, Gibson was probably the worst offender in terms of general performance as well as conceding the second goal and he's hardly a fringe player. Infact most people would consider him a cert to start when fit.

Away to any premier league side is always going to be a tough game and being an expert/smart-ass in hindsight is not exactly difficult.

Raymond Fox
106 Posted 25/09/2013 at 18:33:48
We didn't win a game that our play deserved.
What was missing was our finishing, end of story!
Peter Thistle
107 Posted 25/09/2013 at 18:27:51
I don't understand his comments about being unlucky. There was no luck involved in Fulham's goals, they were down to piss poor defending. Should have had the game won by half time, so many chances but the final ball was always lacking, something Deulofeu needs to work on.
Darren Hind
108 Posted 25/09/2013 at 18:41:37
Tony J Williams


After spending so much time on TW trying o convince people that the players should also take their share of the blame . . .I do believe you are being accused of being a player appolgist.

Now THAT my friend is irony

Frank Crewe
109 Posted 25/09/2013 at 18:28:20
Well it's groundhog day again. 2nd round of the league cup and we're knocked out again.
At the beginning of every season we here the same mantra

1. Finish as high as we can in the league.
2. Qualify for Europe.
3. Try to win a cup

This cup fills two of those three criteria yet every season we sacrifice our chances of making progress in it on the alter of "squad rotation".

A measly 5 games gone and the manager decides to rest eight players, although apparently our oldest player 35 yo Distin doesn't need any rest yet players 10 years younger do.

If we wish to keep our best players and attract others we have to start winning trophies. As it is that's it until January when the FA cup starts. Lets hope we don't get stiff opposition or we could be out of both cups and have to listen to waffle from the manager and players about how the season isn't over and we must finish as high as possible in the league.

Second point. What about us the fans? Don't we matter? Don't they think we want to see Everton win a cup? After all it's only been 18 years!
Isn't football about winning cups anymore? Is league position all that counts now?
What is the definition of stupidity? To do the same thing over and over again yet expect a different result. Well we put a weakened side out again and got exactly the same result as all the times before. When are we going to learn.
If the RS wins tonight it will be all the more galling because with a few less changes we could have been in the next round as well.

Paul Ferry
110 Posted 25/09/2013 at 19:20:03

I'm a little sick and tired now of daft comments like this: Henry Enzio – 356 – ‘Why don't we ever take this competition seriously?'

Are you honestly suggesting for a single second that we did not take the match last night seriously?

This is a strong team and pre-match comment was positive for the most part although there was some apprehension.
Robles, Gibson, Heitinga, Oviedo, Deulofeu, Naismith, Distin (C), McCarthy, Lukaku, Coleman, Stones - subs: Baines, Jagielka, Jelavic, Mirallas, Barry, Barkley, Howard.

That is no Leeds away Moyes team and that is one mouthwatering bench! A strong starting eleven (as we saw in that dazzling 1st 45); and I would even argue that not one of them is when all is said and done a fringe player; not one of them as have all been on the pitch or bench for the most part this season.

Changes yes but still strong and I was more concerned about the subs than the starting eleven to be honest.

I am still so down about the loss like all of us but to say Bobby or anyone else did not take last night seriously or did not respect the competition is 100 per cent dogsbollocks.

It was interesting seeing the snipers or as one of them termed himself a non-convert coming out after the game to take pot-shots at Bobby; interesting to see how blind loyalty to ex-gaffer has now turned upside down and is now sniping at Bobby at every opportunity, speaks volumes that.


Dan Brierley
112 Posted 25/09/2013 at 19:42:05
'that is one mouthwatering bench!'

That has to be the weakest argument I have seen on this page.

'Don't dwell upon losing the game, and being dumped out of the cup. Look at that bench we had!! Isn't it just wonderful??'

Paul, you seriously sound like you are trying to convince yourself that it is acceptable to lose.

As has already been said, the boss tinkered with his set up by playing lads with less than 6 hours playing time between them all season, and got his subs wrong by leaving on Gibson too long, and bringing Mirallas on far too late. He has to take it on the chin, and move on. I don't see what the big deal is, nobody is asking for him to be sacked, everyone is saying he fucked up, and hope he learns from it. You might lap up every word of his press conferences, but there are others out there that judge him on what happens on the pitch, not the silver tongued spin he spews out in the media.

Barry Rathbone
113 Posted 25/09/2013 at 19:42:56
Mild irritation at being knocked out but it was a prem team at their place and fans who went reckon we should have won!

We didn't cave in or surrender as in times past it just seems an honest footie match that didn't go our way.

Don't really get the melodrama.

Peter Mills
114 Posted 25/09/2013 at 19:38:16
Matt #448, I salute your indomitable spirit. However, I assure you that, despite the eventual disappointment, the 5 Final matches we played in and their 4 prior semi-final games were also bloody good occasions. I was hoping for more.
Ian Bennett
115 Posted 25/09/2013 at 20:12:29
Pretty gutted that we lost last night.

Really wish we'd learn to make 2-3 changes, get the game won, and then make 3 from the bench. It seems a false economy to be making 8 changes and then bring first teamers on.

Sadly players get a game to keep them happy, with reserve football unheard of these days. Squad rotation if you are playing 60 games plus, yes, but with no Europe our lot will be lucky to make 45 games.

Paul Ferry
116 Posted 25/09/2013 at 20:12:59
There you go once again Dan Brierley you little cherry picker you - 517.

it's really becoming somewhat predictable and boring now whenever your Ferry radar tingles and you sprint to these boards to make like 517 yet another poorly misconceived selective tadpole post. OKAY.

The point about the bench soft lad was not made in isolation; it was instead one of a fistful of points and quite frankly the one with least substance - more of a gloat at our deep squad if you like but your Ferry radar needless to say homes in on it and turns it into the point on which my post hangs.

HA! 'You might lap up every word of his press conferences, but there are others out there that judge him on what happens on the pitch, not the silver tongued spin he spews out in the media' HA HA HA!

BBrierley I don't think I referred to the spoken word so don't put things in my mouth or mind that I did not say or think OKAY!

Permit me to repeat myself:

'interesting to see how blind loyalty to ex-gaffer has now turned upside down and is now sniping at Bobby at every opportunity, speaks volumes that'.

Poor Forrest Brierley still shedding tears for ginger!

Stop judging Bobby through your wet ginger-tinted glasses; stop sprinting on here whenever your Ferry radar hums to rattle off tadpole snide remarks; and lastly whenever in future you choose to spar with something I said don't attribute things to me that I never said and have the fucking guts to deal with an entire post not just your cherry-picked nugget.

OKAY

Paul Ferry
117 Posted 25/09/2013 at 20:40:37
Spot on Barry 518
Dan Brierley
118 Posted 25/09/2013 at 20:41:54
There is no sniping Paul, the boss fucked up and needs to learn from it. I know that may be difficult for you to understand, but for once just try to pull your head out of your arse and look at things with a slight sense of balance. Your posts regarding Moyes are frankly pathetic, yet again you try and attack people personally because they share a different view to your own, and insist on labeling them. Schoolyard stuff Paul.
Mick Davies
119 Posted 25/09/2013 at 20:54:36
I can't believe some posts on here criticising Coleman for missing a 'sitter'! He's a fuckin defender running at pace and shooting from an angle late in the game. It's the forwards who should take the blame, even Lukaku and especially Naismith who reads a game like a 5-year-old reads Nietzche.

Great football, but too many changes and the team should spend the whole week learning to shot straight.

Paul Ferry
120 Posted 25/09/2013 at 20:50:42
Yet again Brierely you hide behind points about personal; attacks -a gem that one lad look at your own choice of words - and general doggerel about yours truly being pathetic - no personal abuse there eh! - and what needless to say you do not do or have never done is address substance and in the Brierley way avoid points counter to your own particular foibles.

Grow up and grow some and deal with substance rather than your smokescreen generalizations that avoid issues and construe others - me - in your self-fashioned style

Listen seriously I am quite smart and in future do not take up my time with your tadpole cherry-picked self-serving schoolyard posts and quite frankly shameful misrepresentations of what I say or think.

Either that or I have to muster the strength to just ignore your tadpole snipes.

When you respond to this as you undoubtedly will respond to the substance of my 1st reply coz your Ferry radar is spinning out of control.

Wayne Smyth
121 Posted 25/09/2013 at 21:09:10
Dan, I'm not sure there is a vast deal for RM to "learn" from that, other than you win some, you lose some.

He put out a very strong squad. We created quite a few chances, including coleman missing an open goal. The players that fucked up most were international players that are 1st team regulars. We played ok for the most part, but narrowly lost an away game at a premier league team with Berbatov and Bent up front, two strikers who are extremely good and have changed hands for a ton of money not so long ago.

To my mind, a lot of the criticisms are made from a position of hindsight. You want RM to do what Moyes did and play the same 11 in every game? I don't recall too many complaints before the match about the first 11.

Andy Crooks
122 Posted 25/09/2013 at 21:06:04
Barry,#518, your post makes sense today but, frankly, last night I was livid. Melodrama is my normal post match response to a defeat so my response on the post match thread was a master class in restraint.

Managers usually field weakened teams for two reasons. They expect to be involved in a top four challenge or they expect to be in a relegation battle,Now, we're not going to be relegated so maybe RM thinks we can challenge for a op four place.

I posted last night that I thought there was a touch of arrogance about the team selection. I actually hope there was because I never believed that David Moyes had enough confidence in his players.

Ross Edwards
123 Posted 25/09/2013 at 21:28:17
Dan, you say that on many occasions when he was Everton manager, that Moyes in your words "fucked up" many big games.
Ben Jones
124 Posted 25/09/2013 at 22:42:43
I think the pile of cack that Tony Williams suggests in my post is way over exaggerated.

Most people were happy with the team yesterday. Yet when we lose with that team, people's heads turn and go and criticise the scapegoat I.e the manager in this case.

The players are at complete fault here for not taking the chances and lack of communication rather than the manager. I will criticise the manager if he does nothing wrong, but I don't think he did here this time.

Kevin Tully
125 Posted 25/09/2013 at 22:51:33
It seems all footie fans suffer from the same disease - our badly done to neighbours have gone from a serious title challenge (this is our year) to suicidal thoughts in a 5 day period.

On the other hand, we are in the same boat, but only 1 point behind them.

Does that mean we can mount a challenge for the League?

Gavin McGarvey
126 Posted 25/09/2013 at 23:22:27
Barring exceptional circumstances, the success of a team selection can only be judged by the result. Expecting people to be happy when Everton lose, or to turn round and say it's no big deal, is hardly fair.

It may be only the league cup but it's a fair point to say it's one of our better chances of getting into Europe. The team selection might have been alright while Fulham were giving us the freedom of the park, but it certainly wasn't once they got their act together. RM may have been being positive in public, and with the players I would expect him to be, but in private I would have thought he would be angry with himself. He took a gamble and it didn't pay off. We'll see if he really wants to win the league cup next season.

Paul Ferry
127 Posted 26/09/2013 at 04:48:03
We'll see if he really wants to win the league cup next season - 580 .

Dear Lord! Of course he wants to fucking win the League Cup!

Paul O'Hanlon
128 Posted 26/09/2013 at 12:19:22
There's a reason fringe players are on the fringe, because they're not yet good enough to be part of the 1st team!

When a 1st team player is injured, suspended or needs a rest a fringe player gets his chance. Throwing them all in at once isn't the way to do it and I'm sick of throwing away chances to win a trophy! 18 YEARS AND COUNTING...

Robbie Muldoon
129 Posted 26/09/2013 at 12:48:18
I can't help but think some fans are just all 'me, me, me, me, me' (Paul #620). Anybody with a brain who can see the bigger picture with Roberto Martinez at the moment can easily take that result the other night, that's football – no team has a god-given right to win every match.

If after 11 years Martinez is sticking with somebody like Phill Neville in midfield and getting knocked out at home in the FA Cup in the Quarter-finals against a team struggling against relegation, well criticism is justified and should be rightly fierce.

Right now though, be happy that we have an amazing squad with huge potential. A full season of hope ahead of us and the FA Cup.

James Marshall
130 Posted 26/09/2013 at 14:31:10
Barry#518

Exactly. A somewhat melodramatic response to a competitive game that we lost.

You can't win em all.

As my son says, "take a chill pill"

Damien Dempsey
131 Posted 26/09/2013 at 14:39:34
Paul 620, you are correct it is 18 years (and counting...) so you've picked a great year to throw your toys out the pram. Five league matches into a new season with 5 new players, a new manager, a new style being implemented. Not really sure what people's expectations are for this season but certain supporters seem to seem to be suffering from a slight case of delusion. Yes we might win a cup, yes we might finish 6th in the league (or higher) but when you look at the position that we are actually in, are these goals really attainable this season? Are not our long term goals more important to us then any short term rewards?

And sorry Paul I do not agree, our fringe/squad/ substitutes do not exist because they are not good enough for the starting eleven. Perhaps we have become accustomed to this ideal for the past few decades but most teams that win trophies do not use this principle. Those players should be there because they are equally as good. They are acting as replacements or to provide alternative options on the pitch. None of our players should be guaranteed a starting position on the pitch - this increases competition, motivation and desire to perform well. Martinez's main objective is that we become tactically flexible, so the roles and the types of players on the pitch need to accommodate change as well. I do not think we should envisage Martinez naming the same starting eleven for every match even in the league fixtures.

I'd rather he acknowledges our strengths and weaknesses now then discover them later on when we are in a less fortunate position. The upcoming transfer window in January is the time he can reinforce and rectify his choices.

James Marshall
132 Posted 26/09/2013 at 16:26:45
Well said, Damien.
Barry Rathbone
133 Posted 26/09/2013 at 15:53:55
I think the point of keeping the squad happy played a part in team selection.

Sunderland and Di Canio possibly illustrate the pitfalls of steaming in all guns blazing, it worked at Swindon were I believe they spent a lot allowing leverage with his "my way or the highway" methods.

Steve Bruce and Alex Mcleish commented yesterday on the matter saying Prem players are about man management not coaching.

Neither are what you would call modern coaches but it does hint at the importance of keeping a happy ship particularly in these early stages.

Look it's shit we are out but as the new kid on the block Martinez deserves every bit of slack we can give him this season.

The portents are good he is brave changing a style embedded over a decade with more or less the same squad and there will be fuck ups, but be fair, there have been glimpses of light.

Surely as long suffering blues battle hardened by disappointment since '95 we can see this through with perspective and patience.

James Marshall
134 Posted 26/09/2013 at 17:13:24
Key words, "perspective and patience"

I feel like a commentator on this thread.

Frank Crewe
135 Posted 26/09/2013 at 17:56:22
@ Mr Muldoon

The only picture I want to see is an Everton 11 with a cup in front of them. But the RS got knocked out by Manures reserves so this has eased my pain.

Eric Myles
136 Posted 27/09/2013 at 16:00:40
Barry #665 " a style embedded over a decade with more or less the same squad"

Can you tell me which players we have in the current squad that we had a decade ago?

Barry Rathbone
137 Posted 27/09/2013 at 16:37:19
Eric, I see the misunderstanding caused by my usual crap writing.

I am trying to convey the style is 10 yrs old with the inherited squad educated to play in that 10 yr old system.

I think only Hibbo and Ossie have been at EFC a decade but I hope you now see that was not my point.

Jimmy Sørheim
138 Posted 30/09/2013 at 01:38:01
I miss the 4-4-2 formation. If we had Lukaku and Mirallas up front we would have won that game.

I understand resting a few players, but he rested way too many.

Hopefully RM got some answers regarding who is our best first eleven.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads