Martinez keen to stay unbeaten

, , 27 September, 127comments  |  Jump to most recent
Roberto Martinez is keen to extend his team's "beautiful" unbeaten Premier League record — with Everton the only side in the top flight who can claim that honour just five games into the new season.

Liverpool's defeat to Southampton last weekend left the Blues as the only team yet to taste defeat in the League and the manager will be looking to extend that record on Monday with a home game against Newcastle United.

"It is a fantastic label to have but it is something we will have to work really hard to extend," Martinez said.

"It is a beautiful label to have but in September you don't win anything. What we need to do is work harder because it is only beautiful if you can keep it until May because otherwise one day it will become a negative."

Everton had to wait for their first victory of the season after being held to three consecutive draws to start the campaign, dropped points that have prevented them from joining the likes of Tottenham and Arsenal in the lofty heights at the top of the table.

Martinez knows, though, that his side played well enough to win those first three games.

"It is fair to say that we felt hard done by with only getting three points from our first three games. But back to back wins from two difficult games is great and also the manner in which we have done it.

"I don't think we have been exceptional in terms of what we have been doing on the ball but we have defended extremely well, restricted West Ham to very, very little and when we went behind, managed to come back from behind twice which shows you the mentality, character and strength in the squad."

Though the Blues lost in the League Cup at Fulham on Tuesday evening, Martinez's much-changed side played well enough to have won and the Spaniard took heart from the overall performance and what it says about the depth of his squad:

"We have many options in the squad, nobody can take their place for granted and that is very exciting moving forward."  



Reader Comments (127)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Susong Hermawan
1 Posted 27/09/2013 at 14:30:06
Yup... Keep it please.. Up the Blues!
Paul Kennedy
3 Posted 27/09/2013 at 16:25:44
its great not to have to listen to negative comments from a manager!!!
Norman McIlwain
4 Posted 27/09/2013 at 16:27:07
A team to challenge the the top four:
Mirallas, Lukaku, Deulofeu (Jelavic),
Barkley,
Barry, McCarthey,
Baines, Distin, Jagielka, Coleman,
Howard

subs: Jelavic/ Pienar/ Gibson, Stones

Naismith, Kone when injuries occur.

This is a team that can beat any other in the Premier. I am more hopeful of success this year with RM. Everton will be the surprise team.

Michael Coffey
5 Posted 27/09/2013 at 16:57:14
Newcastle at home? Never mind unbeaten - I want to hear him tell us we're taking a knife to a bunfight. .
Barry Rathbone
6 Posted 27/09/2013 at 17:12:06
I think Roberto is going to be great for us but there is a touch of hippy about some of his stuff - "oddball" played by Donald Sutherland in Kellys Heroes comes to mind.

Here's a typical line between oddball and a Moriarty (suspected Moyes fan).

Oddball: "Why don't you knock it off with them negative waves? Why don't you dig how beautiful it is out here? Why don't you say something righteous and hopeful for a change?"

Moriarty: "Crap!"

If you have 10 mins check these clips:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IatwoA00E0

Jamie Barlow
7 Posted 27/09/2013 at 17:40:55
Have a little faith baby, have a little faith.
John Brennan
8 Posted 27/09/2013 at 17:51:11
It all seems pretty quiet on the Pienaar front.
Does anyone have any idea when he is coming back, and what about Alcaraz?
Perhaps we can give them a run out after we have gone 4-0 up around the 70th minute?
Peter Cummings
9 Posted 27/09/2013 at 17:46:08
It's obviously great to be unbeaten, so far anyway, but we must turn our superiority into goals. The Geordies have a largely 'French' squad with one or two who can turn it on and make life difficult for defenders. After last season's debacle against them, revenge would be very sweet but as against WBA we can't assume they are there for the taking and not take our foot off the pedal, as we did v Fulham.

If Deulofeu can turn it on with Mirallas and Lukaku, we should take the points. I would also like to see Coleman step up a gear. I'm looking forward to a good game.

Harold Matthews
10 Posted 27/09/2013 at 18:09:06
Yeah Barry, Luv it.......and we could go on the attack with pink paintballs and loud music. What a blast.
Patrick Carty
11 Posted 27/09/2013 at 18:14:02
We should put Newcastle to the sword. We are creating a lot of chances without really killing teams off, and I feel some one is going to get a drubbing soon. Three points at home is a must and would set us up nicely for the Man City game. I am going for a 3-1 scoreline with a Lukaku double and a Mirallas strike.
John Brennan
12 Posted 27/09/2013 at 18:24:07
Harold, you're always up with the larks, and well aware of whats happening.
Can you enlighten us re the injuries? I don't expect to see Osman for the Newcastle game, but the others?
I'll go for the loud music (Zeppelin at full blast with Whole Lotta Love), but don't wake the neighbours, we want them to sleepwalk to defeat by Sunderland.
Mark Frere
13 Posted 27/09/2013 at 18:20:46
Perhaps we can become the new Arsenal invincible's this season, an whole season without defeat.....okay maybe not. It would be nice to challenge for a top 4 though, we just need to turn more of our rather huge amount of draws into wins.

I think the addition of Lukaku is going to make a huge difference for us this season, finally we have someone who can put the ball in the back of the net when we are on top in games. Lukaku certainly isn't a one trick pony either, his all round game oozes quality.

I personally will be very disappointed if we are not in and around the top 4 all season, unlike other teams we aren't in European competition, so there should be a certain amount of freshness to our team.

No excuses Martinez! This squad should be challenging at least top 6 all season, and after the lack of respect shown to League Cup competition - hopefully he takes the FA Cup a little more serious

Derek Knox
14 Posted 27/09/2013 at 18:43:45
Hopefully, we can see the month out with a home win against the Barcodes, with a bit of flare thrown in, pity about the blip at Fulham, which spoilt the momentum. He could still be a candidate for Manager of the Month (Roberto) but if it brings the usual curse with it (poor run follows) they can stick it where the sun don't shine! Or, even better still give it to Brenda or Ginger!

I hope he starts to give young Gerard a decent run, because in the first half he was brilliant in bursts into the box!

Slightly off thread, was watching Sky Sports before, and Noel Gallagher of Oasis was picking his best ever Man City team, and he couldn't praise Gareth Barry enough, and obviously included him.

Raymond Fox
15 Posted 27/09/2013 at 18:50:34
We've a cracking squad there's no doubt, lets hope we don't get any serious injuries to the best players.
I think its likely Baines will leave, which is a big loss if only for free kicks, that's beside his general play.
He could be the difference between us getting in the top 4 and not, without him I don't think we've any chance, with him we might do it!
We could do with scoring a few goals at the moment too, were missing some easy chances.
Harold Matthews
16 Posted 27/09/2013 at 19:01:04
Sorry John. Not up to date with the injury situation. Kone got himself kitted out for yesterdays photo session but sat down when the lads were having a kickabout.. Must admit. Barcelona do it better. Jelavic and Stones don't quite have the touch of Iniesta and Messi.

Couldn't see Alcaraz but Osman was flying around like a 2yr old. For one photo he threw himself into a diving header.

No news on Pienaar but I'll keep looking. Seems it might be a long one but fingers crossed.

Kevin Tully
17 Posted 27/09/2013 at 19:33:44
Nice 1/2 hour segment on Sky Sports there with Martinez. Been a long time since the media have taken such an interest in the club - we are usually just a footnote at the end of a programme.

He mentioned all our League titles, and the fact we should be fighting for a top 4 place with our history, and size of the club, even though there are financial restraints.

Let's hope we can lose our status as the League's favourite underdog, I always hated that tag.

We are a big club - and he obviously gets it!

Phil Sammon
18 Posted 27/09/2013 at 19:50:03
I enjoyed it too, Kevin.

I recall a few people on here suggesting that Martinez was almost condescending towards Everton fans when he talks of 'educating' them in how he likes to play football. It was put forward that Evertonians are knowledgable and have seen the game played in every style - no education needed.

Well I disagree. I'm 28 and I have never seen an Everton side play with method and patience like this. Of course I watch a lot of football and I've seen other sides do it. Then it's pleasing on the eye and I can appreciate it. However it's very different when it's your own club. The last ten minutes of an Everton game, if we're losing I instinctively want that ball in the box immediately!

That has to change. People need to adapt and get behind the manager's method. I'm really excited for the future under Martinez and am happier with the club than I have been for a long time.

Paul Gladwell
19 Posted 27/09/2013 at 20:04:45
Derek, Barry played more games than any other City player when they won the league and many a City fan are gutted they let him go and yet up until his debut many slagged his purchase.
Kevin Tully
20 Posted 27/09/2013 at 20:01:53
Phil, when we had that free kick just on half-time against Chelsea, and we didn't launch it, I along with everyone in the ground thought WTF?

When we scored, it obviously justified the decision, and 38,000 of us were proved wrong!

Listening to him say that by launching a ball into a penalty area, you are hoping for a bit of luck, or a bounce of the ball, you understand perfectly what he means.

It's brainless to hoof it these days, and I guarantee in 3 months time, you will hear Goodison collectively groan when one our defenders needlessly hoofs it out of play.

These will be the same supporters who were booing at full time against West Brom a few weeks ago. You can see where the education is needed.

Paul Gladwell
21 Posted 27/09/2013 at 20:08:29
Phil, those last minutes last week where quality how we kept keep ball and actually kept the ball up the field near the corner flags, this suggest we could be actually learning and it was refreshing from the usual sit back and throw two defenders on bollocks like we witnessed away at Oldham amongst other games last year.
Patrick Murphy
22 Posted 27/09/2013 at 20:10:37
Phil fair cop as a long time supporter and a member of the older generation I was one of the people who worried about the possibility of RM being an educationist rather than a football manager. I agree it is necessary for some fans of the younger generation to learn to live with the new methods and embrace them rather than dismiss them out of hand. I am truly a supporter of RM and if he manages to make Everton play the way he speaks with purpose and elegance then I will be more than happy, as long as he remembers that we need to win games along the way - which I'm sure he does.

By the time I was your age I had personally witnessed Everton win 2 titles an FA Cup and a European trophy, so I hope you get to see at least one of those things happen in the coming years, preferably under the tutelage of Roberto.

Darren Hind
23 Posted 27/09/2013 at 20:04:20
Well thats our hat thrown into the ring.

All aboard

Patrick Carty
24 Posted 27/09/2013 at 20:57:35
Can anyone tell me the last time we had 40,000 capacity crowd at Goodison Park?

I think it's been a while and I would like to know the reason why the stadium just does not seem to fill — even against top teams.

Any ideas? Thanks.

Matt Traynor
25 Posted 28/09/2013 at 06:36:30
On Radio 5 Live's Friday preview show last night, they had Danny Murphy and Peter Schmichael as guests, along with Rory Smith of the Times. When the Everton unbeaten thing came up, Murphy said he thought we should've won the first 3 games as well, and been the early front runners.

A recurring refrain from us seems to be we created the chances, and didn't put them away. Hopefully we'll see the difference a £20m striker makes as opposed to a couple of £5m players.

Ben Dyke
26 Posted 28/09/2013 at 08:02:39
You get the feeling that the mental courage is there with this squad and that when we do eventually get beat in the league they can bounce back quickly. We are not the finished article by a long way and need to become clinical in finishing to become a real threat to top 4.

It's refreshing to have such high possession stats and over time hope we translate it to more chances and goals. RM's positivity and football philosophy are becoming more evident in the teams play.

Phil Sammon
27 Posted 28/09/2013 at 09:08:54
Koné and Osman should be fit for Monday. Alcaraz is out for 4 weeks after he felt his groin again.
Sean Kelly
28 Posted 28/09/2013 at 10:37:36
I'm getting worried about Alcaraz feeling his groin "again" . Send him back to Wigan under warranty. Two players from Wigan, one feeling his groin and the other one malnourished. WTF are we doing wasting scarce money on them two?
Guy Hastings
29 Posted 28/09/2013 at 11:32:42
You have to applaud the sheer professionalism of Shreeves for not only asking questions that a half-baked potato would think woeful in their predictability but in taking a sip of tea so the cup gets in the camera line while RM is speaking he must have achieved some broadcasting first. How has the man survived on Sky since 1992? It makes you weep.
Raymond Fox
30 Posted 28/09/2013 at 11:35:24
Real shame about Alcaraz because he's a class player, does not sound good though does it.
Kone will prove his worth I don't doubt it.

Alcaraz didn't cost anything Sean he was out of contract at Wigan, were paying his wages though.

Jon Withey
31 Posted 28/09/2013 at 11:48:45
Wages for players on frees are likely huge, that is why they wait for their contracts to run out, they effectively get the transfer fee.

It's a bit crazy to call it a 'free'. They are no more free than getting a contractor in at work.

Phil Sammon
32 Posted 28/09/2013 at 12:24:16
Jon

That's ridiculous. Alcaraz was on £25k p/w at Wigan. He's maybe on £35 - 40k here. Virtually every player these days gets a 'signing on' fee when he joins a new club, regardless of whether or not they are a free transfer. The player does not 'effectively get the transfer fee' nor will Alcaraz be on mega-wages (in football terms).

Robbie Muldoon
33 Posted 28/09/2013 at 13:32:29
I was one who didn't want Barry. I was so wrong.
Wei-Jek Keng
34 Posted 28/09/2013 at 14:50:50
Hi Lyndon/ Michael - thanks for this !

just to say that I think the link to Part 2 links back to Part 1. The link is here :

http://www1.skysports.com/watch/video/sports/football/teams/everton/8945167/Martinez-everton-have-evolved

Frank Crewe
35 Posted 28/09/2013 at 15:28:22
I don't mind remaining unbeaten as long as we don't start stacking up draws. The idea is to win games and get three points and not just preserve unbeaten runs.
Mark Frere
36 Posted 28/09/2013 at 15:35:35
If we beat Newcastle on Monday we will have 12 points on the board - a very good tally from 6 games I think we can all agree.

Our unbeaten record will be under serious threat after the Newcastle game, when we face Man City away - I will be over the moon if we manage a draw. Anyway, we can't do much worse than Moyes and Manure.

Assuming we beat Newcastle on Monday, and I will be very disappointed if we don't, I think there's every chance we can pick up a similar points tally from the next 6 games:

Man City (a)
Hull City (h)
Aston Villa (a)
Spurs (h)
Crystal Palace (a)
Liverpool (h)

The Man City, Spurs and RS games should give us a good indication of how well we are progressing

Michael Kenrick
37 Posted 28/09/2013 at 16:11:08
Thanks Wei-Jek... fixed now!
Mike Hughes
38 Posted 28/09/2013 at 16:15:37
Early days but this season is pretty wide open in my opinion and a top 4 place is up for grabs for whoever can string a run together and stay in the mix.

We should stuff the barcodes and wipe that smirk off Pardew's smug face.

I then see us getting at least a draw against City then a great run of 5 games against low-mid table sides (no disrespect to Spurs).

(West Brom 2-1 up against MUFC as I write!!!)

Derek Knox
42 Posted 28/09/2013 at 17:08:03
Mike # 951

Yes Mike I am a little surprised to be honest, while being realistic enough to know it's still early days in the marathon, which is the Premier League season.

Taking today's results into consideration, a lot of the big spenders are not seeing a return on their outlay. Both Manchesters losing (aaw, I don't half feel sorry for the ginger prick) and Hull above us, what's going on ?

It would appear that all sides are beatable with the correct approach, I know that probably sounds like stating the obvious, but for a manager who studies the opposition and adjusts the tactics accordingly the points and positions are there for the taking !

Step up to the plate Roberto, the Prem's your oyster!

Patrick Murphy
43 Posted 28/09/2013 at 17:22:30
Our next couple of games may well shape our season, we have to try and get all three points on Monday, not a simple ask, and then go to Man City and get something there. It makes you wonder whether the so called Sky-four or Sky-six players are becoming complacent and are more interested in European games these days, which if you're a club like us and Spurs it presents an opportunity which I hope we try and take advantage of.
Carl Sanderson
44 Posted 28/09/2013 at 17:22:39
Matt 924:

Rory Smith is a Red gobshite of the worst kind; if he was bigging Everton up then he must be worried.

It is notable that the media no longer talk about the "Big Four": they now refer to the "top six teams". Anything to shoe-horn the Redshite into the elite. It will be ace if Everton gate-crash that little self-serving cabal.

Andy Meighan
45 Posted 28/09/2013 at 20:16:30
Mike 951, I totally agree with you. But come on — we all know the game doesn't work like that, does it? I mean how many would've had a double of Aston Villa and West Brom today??? Exactly.... Not many.

I predict a hard game on Monday. And though our record is decent against them, I remember almost a year ago on a Monday night we slaughtered them but only got a 2-2 draw... albeit with bad refereeing decisions. So no, let's not get too far ahead of ourselves: it'll be tight but I'll go for us.

Harold Matthews
46 Posted 28/09/2013 at 20:14:41
Some people are being a bit unrealistic and definitely unfair. The manager doesn't even know his best team yet and the lads are still trying to adjust to the way he wants them to play. In a recent interview he predicted the end of Jan into Feb as the time we would "become stubborn and win points."

When such a positive person states that " we have not been exceptional when we are on the ball," it's his way of saying we should be doing it an awful lot better.....and he's right. We lose possession far too cheaply, whether it be a careless pass, running into the fullback when strikers are crying out for an early cross, dwelling on the ball or hoofing it out of play. There is much to improve upon before we start going places and it won't happen overnight. We have a fine set of players and I'm sure they will eventually get things right and bring us much success.

Danny Broderick
47 Posted 28/09/2013 at 22:40:47
I love the way our new manager speaks, it's so refreshing after 11 years of everything being played down...

Make no mistake, if we want to succeed, we need to be good at keeping the ball. All of the best sides can take the sting out of a game if they are 1-0 up, or break down the most stubborn defences by passing the ball for 90 minutes if necessary and tiring the opposition out. We are going the right way. We need to make sure we are not giving away silly goals though - the one thing we need to keep from the Moyes reign is a strong defence.

John Gee
48 Posted 28/09/2013 at 23:27:32
This might be a bit of a stretch but, is there a parallel here between us and Arsenal when Wenger took over? Defence first manager is replaced by a manager with a passing philosophy and desire to play the beautiful game..er.. Beautifully.
Michael Coville
49 Posted 29/09/2013 at 01:14:21
Carl #991. Couldn't agree more, watched the United game today and the commentator repeatedly talked about the "top six teams". He didn't name them but for sure we were not included. Would be great if we could burst their bubble.

I have Directv in the US and the game on the NBC channel 220 is listed in the guide as the Chelsea vs Fulham game at 3:00 pm. EST. Anyone know if this is a mistake and NBC will show our game verses Newcastle?

Christopher Kelly
50 Posted 29/09/2013 at 02:03:28
No way!!! He doesn't want to lose?? Huge story guys
Michael Kenrick
51 Posted 29/09/2013 at 02:39:12
Michael (#179),

It's a mistake. Chelsea and Fulham have already played this weekend (not each other!), and Everton v Newcastle is the only Premier League game on the slate tomorrow.

Michael Coville
52 Posted 29/09/2013 at 03:04:46
Michael #192,
Thanks, I presumed that was the case but I believe Chelsea did play Fulham last week and I was concerned that it was a replay of that game. Anyway, thanks for the confirmation,
Mike
Mark Andersson
53 Posted 29/09/2013 at 05:20:04
As a new member of this site it's been quite interesting reading your comments over the last week. I see the majority of you are positive and are behind the appointment of our new manager.

Just one point I would like to make, the new singings of McCarthy and Kone should not be compared to the loan singings. Surely there is less pressure on the loan deal players. The fees paid for the new singings must certainly feel they have to justify their arrival. So in saying that, as a supporter, I would always give them more time to settle.

Newcastle on Monday will be a great game and I hope that the Goodison roar will inspire a great victory. As I now live in Australia, I can only watch the games via Foxtel. So here is hoping that my subscription fee is worth it as now I have 3 reasons to pay my money. 1st watching the blues win draw or lose, 2nd watching the shite getting beat and now 3rd also watching Man Utd suffer under the management of David Moyes.

My predictions for the league, it's there for the taking which should make this season one of the most exciting for many a year.

Rob Smith
54 Posted 29/09/2013 at 05:49:41
I can see top 6 being top 8, with only Arsenal maybe getting clear at the top, ( Marty Feldman's son was the best transfer business). MU look a shell of a side, We have MC's general and Chelsea's best sriker, on paper as good as anyone, with the prospect of additions in Jan.

It is only early days and the rich moguls will buy their way out of trouble, leaving more good players redundant on benches but the competition looks far more even at the moment than it has for some time. I harbour high hopes for us this season

Michael Coville
55 Posted 29/09/2013 at 12:21:08
Rob #207.
How true about good players redundant on benches. Remember Rodwell? I remember when he went to City he said "It's a dream come true". More like a nightmare, he may be earning a lot more money but he will get very few games at City and he can forget about his future as an England player,
Mike
Nick Entwistle
56 Posted 29/09/2013 at 12:41:23
Interesting that the new dividing line on TW seems to be going with who are 'positives' and those who are 'negatives'. I don't know if we need that again, its all a bit tiresome.

Either way, when RM was hired I had a few days of stomping round pissed at all the 'top' managers who BK could have approached and didn't, but chose to hope that all the right things about RM would come true and forget what my fears were, in pre-season at least.

Yes, I know we're trying to play football... which being a 'negative' (yawn) is no more than splaying the ball around the back four which anyone can do. But what is obvious to me is how in attack it isn't working...

That leaves me thinking two questions

1, will it ever work - my answer is yes.
2, will it ever be good enough to move us forward and make the step up to Champions League - I don't know, like all of us, but right now I don't think so.

And that's where my negativity comes from. Because for however many people think he's the second coming the fact remains, taking away extra time v Stevanage, we have won only 2 games from 7 this season. And that I'd put down to the slow predictable build up.

Yet, that first 30 against Fulham was exceptional. But how we let them back in was the opposite.

Now with RM, he's one of these managers with a philosophy, a project, a vision. And however you view that he is therefor a manager, unlike Di Cannio, who will get time. And all managers should get time... except that even if all were, there'd still be a tiny amount of winners, and there'd still be plenty given the boot.

Baines, still committed on the pitch, has career wise had his time with Everton, Jags, were it offered, could well have accepted the transfer to Arsenal a few seasons back , Arteta, Lescott,Pienaar, Fellaini they all want to be there playing in the CL.

That the potential was there under the old manager helped keep most players around. If that potential for CL isn't still in place for next season, what will that do with the player's careers in mind?

Newcastle on Monday, and Three from 8 will have us sitting pretty, but 2 from 8 and all this grand adulation would be the Emperor's new clothes.

At last its interesting times, verrrrrrry interesting.

Paul Andrews
57 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:23:58
Ross Barkley in The Times today.
"It's difficult progressing to senior level,yo have to be mentally tough.You have to work hard and not give up.
You have also got to have a manager who trusts you,plays you and believes in you."
Kevin Tully
58 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:28:04
"Newcastle on Monday, and Three from 8 will have us sitting pretty, but 2 from 8 and all this grand adulation would be the Emperor's new clothes."

Anyone who judges a manager after 6 games clearly knows nothing about football - that also applies if we end up in the top 4 on Monday night.

Is there an 'ignore' function on this site?

If not, we need one.

Kev Johnson
59 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:22:03
A rather muddled post, Mr Entwistle.

So you're saying... what, exactly? That if we don't beat Newcastle then we'll have had a dodgy start but if we do beat them we'll be sitting pretty. Er, right. Thanks for clearing that up.

As for your two questions... If the answer to the first one is "Yes, passing it around will - in the fullness of time - work, making us more dangerous and productive in attack" then why isn't the answer to the second question "Yes, we will be good enough for the Champions League"?

Players such as the ones you mention come to Everton, and stay at Everton for a period of time, because we offer what I'd call a "realistic outside chance" of getting into the top European competition. As things stand today, nothing has changed. If we beat Newcastle and move up to 3rd then things will have changed for the better, albeit briefly, perhaps.

So what the flipping flip are you on about?

Nick Entwistle
60 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:45:15
Erm, Kev, you certainly seem to have made up your mind.

Kev, you answered it yourself. Football is from the supporters' perspective capricious in the least.

Of course none of us know what the future will hold and whether our view on RM will bare out in reality, but it doesn't stop us from talking football. Never has.

It will be great to be in third at this early stage, but that doesn't mean this adulation is right, as two from 8 would have had people seething at the old manager. Capricious.

Kevin Tully
62 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:51:27
Nick - it's two wins from 12 actually, you forgot to include the pre-season friendlies.

FFS.

Paul Tran
64 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:40:04
Nick, I agree with your dislike of the 'dividing lines' - they don't help anyone.

You've spoken before about your like of the way Bayern play. I agree with you, but these guys were probably not born with the ability to play fast and accurate. The 'all-action' style under the previous regime was great......when it worked. Too often it was sandwiched by turgid draws against lowly opposition. The fact that it often completely disappeared for months at a time suggested to me there was a lack of method in there.

So Martinez has come in with a method of the players keeping the ball. They're not used to it, so right now they're doing it too slowly. My guess/hope is that the more they do it, the more confident they'll get, the faster and more accurate they'll do it. If it doesn't work right now, the fact that we keep the ball more means we're less likely to lose.

German and Belgian football is getting stronger because of a long-term emphasis on ball-retention and pace. If we're the big club we like to believe, I'd like to see us follow the same path. I'm happy to support a manager who is clearly aiming at this. After ten years of 'effort' and running, he and his players need time to make this change work.

Out of curiosity Nick, who were the 'big-time' managers you were hoping for? Would they have actually come to EFC? What would they have offered that would have made a difference?

James Martin
65 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:50:41
Martinez shouldn't be judged until the season ends. All you have to do is look at Chelsea's 2012, on paper the most glorious season in their history yet they were awful in the league and fired their manager but still ended up with two pieces of silverware. Whether a manager is a success or not hinges on such fine lines.

I think we've made a good start as far as you can tell through watching 5 games. A bounce of the ball one way and we could be sitting here on no more than 3 points, a bounce of the ball the other and we could be top quite easily with a 100% record. There has not been enough games yet to equal out any luck or lack of luck that certain teams may have had in 6 games.

What I do think this year though is that we look better prepared for sustaining a level of performance over a longer period of a season. I think the football in the early part of last season was better in terms of being in control of matches but it descended in the middle part of the season due to the fatigue of key players like Osman and Pienaar and injuries to Gibson and Mirallas. I think squad wise and tactically we're more flexible now to deal with a long season.

I'd like to see at some point a routine home win that we control just to give us some idea of what sort of consistency we possess at the moment. As thrilling as West Ham was it could have gone either way was it not for Baines. Hopefully Newcastle will be that nice safe home win that any decent side has to be capable fo grinding out if they want to do anything in this league.

Nick Entwistle
66 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:03:03
Absolutely Paul. If it comes our way then great, I'll hold my hands up, but if that footballing philosophy replaces Moyes' end product in the league table and we end up 8th or 9th with fancy play then what good has it done?

If we get both, then great.

Big managers? Well BK seemed to start at Wigan and end at Wigan in his managerial pursuit. I wrote an article that he should be on the first plane to Madrid, and if Jose says no... obviously... then he should work backwards. Hiddink, Rjkaard, Bielsa, Bilic... managers who have their reputations based on real success, not the supposed success of keeping Wigan with their heads above water for far longer than 'expected'. His record year on year worse than Paul Jewell and Bruce.

So would those manager's have come? If you don't ask you don't get. And Gus Hiddink has his feet up.

James Martin
67 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:14:59
Nick would any of those managers fit the brief of what we needed? The only way we can achieve anything is through building from the ground upwards with continuity. We can't just throw money at the problem or have a manager in for a season or two before he bombs off somewhere else. None of those managers would be content to stick around at a non champions league club for say 5 years.

Moyes built the foundations of this house very well, we have a high value first 11 who can compete aginst anyone in the league and we have a very good academy as well. We don't need someone who'll come in and swing the wrecking ball in pursuit of a bit of short term success to look good on thir own CV before leaving us in the lurch. We needed someone to finish the last stage of the job that Moyes oculd never quite do - improve the consistency to get us into the champions league and keep us there without any significant transfer funds. Roberto seemed a good choice and so far he appears to have proven to be so.

Brian Waring
68 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:14:03
Nick, it's great to actually have a manager with a footballing philosophy for a change.

Whilst Moyes deserved a lot of credit for what he achieved with us, his tactical acumen (if you can call it that) has already got the Mancs on his back, they are already coming out with things like:

'No plan A'
'Negativity'
'In less than 4 months we have become shit. Very shit'
'If we were at least good to watch or had a clear direction we're going in, then it wouldn't be as bad'.

For me, I'm willing to swap Moyes's finishes for an 8th or 9th place finish for the next couple of years, if it means playing football.

Nick Entwistle
71 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:37:40
James, we've got him now so this is going over old hypotheticals, but we had continuity. We had the club a Lukaku away from CL qualification last season, and with now with better transfer funds. Why would these managers swing the wrecking ball?

That we are in the most high profile league on the world, a club finishing 6th, with Sky money to come, why shouldn't BK have looked up these guys?

Paul Tran
72 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:22:29
Nick, I hope BK did try for Jose and Hiddink, not so sure about Bielsa. We'll never know.

What has been clear for the last three years that we needed some change. What we were doing was great to get us from mid-table to 5th/6th. I'm not convinced that it would ever have taken us further. The previous regime had many years to develop clear, identifiable methods of play, to develop youngsters, to have a consistency of play throughout the club. It chose not to do this. I think this regime has already set about doing this and despite the changes, is still unbeaten.

Your comparison with Jewell and Bruce is a valid one. Both they and Moyes are great at getting the best out of players who can 'do a job', great at organising solid teams. The difference is that only one of them had ten-plus years in the same job and failed to consistently do anything beyond this.

We desperately needed someone to build on this. I hoped it would be Moyes. When he clearly chose not to do this, I hoped it would be someone else. I don't know if it will ultimately work with Martinez. What I do know is that we needed someone with a vision beyond the next game - whoever that person is, they need more than a few weeks to be judged.

Brian Waring
73 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:47:17
'and with now with better transfer funds' how do you work that out Nick?
Brian Denton
74 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:50:48
Fair post, Paul Tran. I don't think Nick could take too much umbrage at that.
James Martin
75 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:43:23
Nick you know I always respected your views on Moyes as they were very similar to mine. I honestly think that if he'd had another season or two then we would have had a good shot at Champions league, for all of his so called failures last year in the league we were still right up there for a long period of time.

BK will/would not release the sort of money that these managers would have demanded. Bielsa likes to completely overhaul the clubs he works for and implement many of his strange techniques. Yes they work for a period but Bilbao haven't been that good since and will probably require a repair team when he leaves. Bilic has looked good with the Croatian national team but what else has he achieved? He is as much of a gamble as Martinez would have been, why is his name any bigger?

When Moyes walked through the door I had a feeling we had the right man for Everton at that moment in time. I think for where we are now we have the right man in Martinez. If he does the job we hope he can do perhaps in 5 or 10 years we'll be talking (and some will be onerously repetitively moaning) about how he's hit his glass ceiling with us, and how to win the champions league or the title we need a Hiddink/ Rijkaard type. I think now is the wrong time for that and Martinez was the right choice but as ever it is only an opinion that will be vindicated or proved to be wrong by what he achieves or doesn't over the coming seasons.

Nick Entwistle
76 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:51:24
Paul he may not have taken us further (though lets not forget he did in '05). Its a tough glass ceiling with all those teams and their money, but he was on their coat tails.

Identifiable football? Well, Moyes did mix it up for sure. His consistency was playing the numbers game and yeah, back fired against lower teams and on big occasions I give you that.

But philosophy is a term which is given to managers who play 'the right way'. Clough, Michels etc. But don't forget catenaccio is a philosophy. Mourinho has a philosophy. Sacci, Rehhagle.

Brian, well all that Sky money. Gave any new manager more wiggle room than Moyes ever got that's for sure. As I said before, last season we were a Lukaku away from qualifying.

Brian Sharples
77 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:26:06
Panned on this thread in my first week as a poster, I didn't realise that the tone is now as much pro Martinez as it was anti Moyes when I last logged in regularly.

I don't think patience has anything to do with the depth of your support for a club rather than its manager although I have to admit that I have little for that so-called virtue when it comes to 'pissing about' at the back.

With no Everton game yesterday, I watched hour long highlights of two games on Sky last evening. The first was Man Unt. v WBA and the second Swansea v Arsenal.

Most surprisingly, Moyes had got his new players - including the goalkeeper - playing tippy-tappy throughout. I lost count of the number of times passes were made -and repeated- in the home half.Only Rooney seemed capable- or willing- to attempt passing more than ten yards. Consequently,the Baggies had all the time in the world to re-form and obliterate Red attacks when they eventually crossed the half-way line. The Mancs lost the game.

Arsenal,in their game adopted similar tactics but with one very significant difference.Their myriad of passes - whilst not always forward - were made and received and moved on with such pace that their Welsh opponents were often left gasping by the speed of it all. Indeed' back' to 'front 'was often achieved so quickly that every defensive phase became an immediate counter attack. Arsenal won that one.

So my Damascus moment came in the space of those two hours.It wasn't really anything to do with the route, after all - it was all about how fast the journey was completed.So just hurry it up Blues; success will follow and Martinez will have one more convert. Me !

Mike Gwyer
78 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:37:09

Personally I feel like we've turned a corner, though all the chat seems to be about RM coming in and DM fucking off - for me it's more to do with Everton finally having a striker (a proper striker who can hold the ball up, play other players in AND score goals). A real number 9.

The away end at West Ham was absolutely rocking when Lakaku came on, you could feel the support crank up several notches and what we saw from Lakaku was eye opening, I really do mean eye opening. I'm confident tomorrow night will be the same because Goodison has been waiting a long time for a front man who has all the answers - rest assured, Lakaku is going to be fully aware of his popularity.

The discussion about managers - who is good or who is total shite seems to fall short, as our previous leader seems to be fucking it up big time with a cast of players that previously he would of only dreamed of.

RM has gone out and acquired Barry, McCarthy and Lakaku - two have hit the ground running and McCarthy is gagging to play. So as supporters of this truly great club, lets be fair and give RM an equal crack of the whip. I mean its near on impossible to get tickets for Everton away games and Newcastle looks like a sell out, so RM is obviously doing something right.


Phil Sammon
79 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:17:21
Mike

If you're going to laud the lad for 4 paragraphs then could you at least get his name right.

I agree with you though.

Brian Waring
80 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:21:14
"Well all that Sky money gave any new manager more wiggle room than Moyes ever got, that's for sure" and "last season we were a Lukaku away from qualifying"

It's almost as if you are saying Martinez should be expected to finish 4th Nick and nothing less, because if Moyes would have had what Martinez has now, he would have got us to 4th???

Paul Kennedy
81 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:29:13
Yep Brian like he is helping his new team already telling them they are not good enough to win the champions league
Si Cooper
82 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:07:53
Too right Brian (304).

The whole point of tippy-tappy is to create offensive opportunities by disrupting the defensive structure of the opposition. That is best achieved by drawing a defender towards the ball when they think they have a good chance of intercepting it, and then zipping the ball back to a colleague and immediately looking to exploit any space that the defender's wandering has produced.

It is often defined by small margins at the outset and it requires pace, precision, work-rate and a fair bit of confidence / courage. Passes don't have to be relentlessly forward, but the intention has to be positive and chances to threaten the opposition should be eagerly grasped.

Do we have enough players of the required ability / mind-set to make it work consistently? Time will tell, though the manager seems to think they can do it.

Brian Waring
83 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:42:26
If there is one negative at the moment for me, the way we are playing seems to be restricting Baines and Coleman getting forward.
James Martin
84 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:58:21
Brian they needed restricting to be honest. Distin used to be all over the pitch because Baines was never in the left back spot. The goal West Brom scored yesterday after Buttner was dispossessed was exactly what we used to concede: the left back out of position, one centreback getting dragged over leaving a load of room in the middle.
Paul Tran
85 Posted 29/09/2013 at 17:02:48
You're right Nick, he did it 2005 and damn great it was. Then we went missing for a while. There was that year where we finished 6th with the UEFA cup run , we played some great stuff that year. Then we went missing for a while, too. We played some great stuff early last season and then went missing for three months. I remember you rightly talking about 'form and fitness' - why did we keep playing men that were tired and out of form? No money? What about the players that were bought and not played? I think 2005 was our equivalent of Greece winning the Euros.

I'm not interested in 'philosophy'. The best sides keep the ball, keep their shape, all know what they're meant to be doing and are allowed to get on with it. Of course they have to mix things up at times, but their core game remains.

This is the first transfer window for ages where I've felt better at 00.01 hrs, I could see exactly why every player was bought and what he's meant to do. Now, whether they do it..........

I find it hard to believe that suddenly, this summer, we had loads of money to spend and got some good players with a net profit, whereas United were skint and got no one except Fellaini. Maybe just a coincidence?

You're right about the glass ceiling, Nick. But it's there to be broken. I think there's also a mental glass ceiling and when it came to the crunch games, the manager and players couldn't break that one, either. Maybe it will be the same under Martinez - I don't think it would have changed under the old regime. It's good to have a manager that isn't constantly whingeing about no money and is just getting on with improving the squad.

No-one knows whether any managers or players will perform better, but you never improve by doing the same stuff year after year.

Nick Entwistle
86 Posted 29/09/2013 at 17:54:23
Brian, not at all. In fact I mentioned Lukaku in the same way before the season started. And with Darren Bent, who was at least was available in January.

We had two barn door sympathisers to choose from while Spurs had scorers plus Bale. Arsenal plenty of scorers too. We really were a decent striker away.

Ross Edwards
87 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:14:15
I think the people who criticise our new style of play either know nothing, or are complete and utter morons who need their heads checking.

The people on here recently who have said on the Live Forums or on threads that we play "tippy tappy shit", their words not mine, you know who you are, are complete idiots.

If hoofball and dreary football floats your boat, support West Ham

This is the best football I've seen here in a long time, long may it continue.

Ross Edwards
88 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:28:08
Who are Arsenal's striking options Nick?

Yes, they may be relying on Ramsey at the minute but there's no forwards to step in if Giroud is injured.

Darren Hind
89 Posted 29/09/2013 at 17:51:40
I'm afraid some of you have spent too long on Man U sites or are watching through you're desperate to be right specs

"Playing good football" lol... WHEN?

We barely mustered an attack in the first half at Norwich, finished our next two home games with boos ringing in the players ears, clung to a dodgy penalty claim in Wales, struggled to create a thing until Baines produced his magic at the Boleyn.

If watching Jagielka, Distin and Howard raise our posession stats by exchanging nervous bobbly passes to each other, before one of them panics and launches it, is your idea of good football then you may as well go and watch the games in the Park.

I Like our new boss, I like what he says and I like what he intends to do, but please... we are Evertonians, we know our stuff, give him the time he needs and stop this "Emperor's New Clothes" bollocks.

Ross Edwards
90 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:32:58
My point proven exactly by Darren's stupid post. Idiots. If you liked Moyes' hoofball, go to Old Trafford.
Barry Rathbone
91 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:33:11
Darren, you don't like him, you like Moyes.

Stop trying to kid Evertonians "who know their stuff" ~ you're a complete bluffer.

Ross Edwards
92 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:37:39
Give him time he needs....

by slagging off our start and writing absolute crap it seems.

Darren Hind
93 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:37:52
Barry Rathbone

You're the guy who claims Evertonians want us to lose.

You're the guy who said Barkley was no good.

And you're the guy who wanted big Vic to play center-mid instead.

Why the fuck would you think I was thinking about you when I spoke of "Knowledgeable Evertonians"?

Barry Rathbone
94 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:45:39
Darren, knew you'd spit your dummy out revealing your true colours - welcome back Dave Wilson.

Wondered how you would cope with Moyes going - just as I expected - sheer lunacy.

Paul Andrews
95 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:52:53
Darren,
That's a very negative take on our games this season.
The vast majority of Blues will see it different to you.
Darren Hind
96 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:49:26
Ross

I think if you read my post I slag off the players - not as defenders, but as footballers

Theres a difference between saying what you see and happy clapping.

Barry

What ?

Steve Guy
97 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:55:57
http://www.theguardian.com/football/who-scored-blog/2013/sep/24/player-team-tactical-talking-point-week

The stats above suggest that our possession is up top and not from passing along the back four... Just sayin'!

Barry Rathbone
98 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:56:38
Darren (call me Dave) Hind - nailed lad.

Give us a reprise of the goal in the wembley derby .... just for old times sake.

Darren Hind
99 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:56:08
Paul

You may be right, the majority may well see it different to me. . .does that make me wrong?

Paul Andrews
101 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:00:11
Not neccessarily,it puts you firmly in the minority Darren.
I think you are wrong for what it is worth.
Ross Edwards
102 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:00:21
Yes, or it makes the majority of Evertonians look like morons.
Mark Frere
103 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:59:00
Performance wise, I think we've been a bit of a mixed bag so far this season. First game against Norwich I think we played pretty well and deserved to win. The Cardiff and West Brom games were dreadful and rigid displays by ourselves.

The Chelsea game, we showed a great togetherness and battling display, lots of character if nothing else.

West Ham - Truly shocking first half, but Martinez didn't dither, he made changes at half time and we were excellent 2nd half - Lukaku made a world of difference.

Its a little too early to say we are playing really well or not.

Its certainly not depressing so far though

Sam Hoare
104 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:06:35
Look up Eugenes discourse on why the majority is usually wrong. Can't remember what thread it was on but very amusing.

One thing I will agree with Darren on is that possession stats are relatively meaningless. I think the most revealing stats (beyond the actual score line) are how many chances are created and conceded. Not sure how we fare there but probably not as well as in possession.

Ross Edwards
105 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:13:12
Mark, here's the test to prove we are playing well...

Answer these questions, please

Have we been keeping possession well?

Have we been creating chances?

How many goals have we conceded in the league so far?

How many clean sheets have we kept?

How many defeats have we suffered, in comparison to our competitors above, or in some cases, below?

If they are positive answers, there's the proof.

Ross Edwards
106 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:16:47
"The Cardiff and West Brom games were dreadful and rigid displays by ourselves."

We battered Cardiff Mark, and should have had a stonewall pen, and WBA parked the bus.

Mike Gwyer
107 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:47:44
Darren (#328),

Did you go West Ham? Other than their penalty the second half was one way traffic, it was all Everton. I can also take it that WBA's 7 shots at goal against our 22 and Norwich's 6 shots against our 18 are pure fiction – teams are now coming to Goodison and playing for a point, they will not take us on. That is how highly we are rated by the opposition.

If you have your own agenda, great but please keep it real regarding how well we are playing.

Mark Frere
108 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:17:56
Ross, I can give you different answers to all your question depending on which games we are talking about. Like I've said we have been a mixed bag this season.

I have plenty of optimism though, especially after the best transfer window we have had in years. I'm so excited about Lukaku. Barry and McCarthy give us lots to be cheerful about as well.

Raymond Fox
109 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:11:16
My first look today on the site, and what do I find, the same suspects moaning and attempting to belittle RMs time at the club and also what he did at Wigan!

Criticism is ok, but I/were sick of hearing the same bunch of you coming out with the same decrying stuff everyday.
What is your agenda? do you want him to fail,
because it certainly feels like it, your behaving like a lot of killjoys, I mean what the point of going on about Moyes did this or Moyes would have done that, he's fucked of to a big club and left small time us behind he says and yet you keep championing this jerk.

Anyone would think were at the bottom of the league!

Paul Andrews
110 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:28:03
Sam,

The most revealing stat is the one that says if we win tomorrow we will be in 4th.
3 points behind the leaders.
We can't have had that bad a start.

Kevin Tully
111 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:29:18
I am officially starting a "Cheerleaders for Everton campaign"

Take a look at the game on now at Wembley.

A promise off one of those lasses for our lads if we win, and we would easily make top 4!

Darren Hind
112 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:24:51
Mike

Yes I did go to the Bolelyn, it was top quality high octane drama. I actually posted on here that if we cant play great footall, I'll settle for wining 5 goal thrillers any day.

I have high hopes for the future, but I cant describe the present as something it isn't.

If that makes me negative ( or someone called Dave) . . So be it

Mark Frere
113 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:28:07
Ross - Its up to us to break down West Brom, the display was totally uninspiring with no penetration what-so-ever. I certainly didn't think we battered Cardiff at all - another pretty drab display from ourselves as I remember it.
Ross Edwards
114 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:36:09
61% possession to Cardiff's 39%

13 shots to Cardiff's 4.

That hints Mark we battered Cardiff.

54% possession v WBA to their 46%

22 shots for us to WBA's 7

I don't call that "totally uninspiring with no penetration whatsoever"

If that doesn't, my name is Bill Kenwright.

Mark Frere
115 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:40:50
Ross. I prefer to make judgements by what I saw with my own eyes rather than mere stats. If you thought the West Brom game in particular was in anyway inspiring, then god knows what game you was watching mate.
Ross Edwards
116 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:48:41
If we were without penetration Mark, that shot count would be significantly lower than 22, with significantly less possession than 61%.

I thought we played well against WBA.

Clarke said it was "hard fought". If we were without penetration, he wouldn't have said that.

Obviously the pro-Moyes camp are still bitter about their hero leaving. [Do not respond with the same old "forget Moyes, stop talking about him" rubbish as it is becoming tiresome and dictatorial.]

Mark Frere
117 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:56:07
Ross

I hope you aren't insinuating that I am in the pro-Moyes camp? Moyes can go bollocks as far as I'm concerned. The way he behaved over the Baines and Fellaini transfers were the final straw for me mate. I wish him all the failure in the world.

I was just giving my opinion on how I have seen things so far this season. If my opinion isn't exactly the same as yours it doesn't give you the right to start accusing me of things that are way wide of the mark

Ross Edwards
118 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:05:24
You did support him before he left though didn't you?

If not, I do apologise for sticking that unfortunate label upon you.

Ross Edwards
120 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:15:48
Seriously, I am sick and tired of this. Stop telling us what we can and can't write. If I want to mention Moyes, I can, and if you don't like me giving my opinion, Nick, then say so, I won't post again.
Darren Hind
121 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:08:20
That/s the trouble, Mark. If your not prepared to deny the evidence of your own eyes people like Ross will be on like a shot shouting "Moyes lover".

It's their go-to argument, even if you don't mention Moyes.

Ross is full of worthless stats, but if you ask him how many shots we had ON TARGET against WBA, he'll go quiet; ask him if we ever looked liked scoring, he'll be quieter still.

Don't dare ask him how many we scored or what were the boos at the end about, because that makes you a raving Moyesophile.

These guys have yet to figure out that all managers are self-serving hypocrites and it's only the team that counts.

Mark Frere
122 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:10:04
Yes, I did support him while he was here, Ross. I remembered the dark days under Walter Smith, I remembered the last day of the season clinging onto PL survival by the skin of our teeth under Mike Walker and Howard Kendall 3. Moyes put a stop to that and give me hope for a while. Although we stagnated from lets say 2006 onwards, and I saw plenty of faults in his managerial capabilities, I was willing to give him the benefit of the doubt. The main reason for this was because BK never give him sufficiant financial backing.

I also used to think Moyes was a man of integrity; how wrong I was on that front. I'm very much anti-Moyes now.

Ross Edwards
123 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:24:25
Darren, I think booing a manager off after 2 games in charge does you no credibility Darren whatsoever.

8 shots on target Darren,

How many did WBA have?

I'll tell you. 2.

7 shots in 90 minutes, 2 on target.

If we had 7 shots on goal and WBA had 22, I'd understand, but the fact you were slagging off a manager after his 2nd game proves you are fickle know-nothing idiots.

Ross Edwards
124 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:27:33
Mark, good man. My apologies again.
Darren Hind
126 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:32:07
Ross, I hate to blow your latest argument, but the booing came from other quarters, I have never booed a manager in my life, not even the oppositions.

That's just something else you assumed.

I don't think you realise the difference between debate and argument and for that reason.

I'm out.

Paul Smith
127 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:22:16
It seems to me a lot of our fans just want to be right all the time (it'd be nice if we were) and completely rule out any kind of perspective.

Looking back on the Moyes reign, I'm not sure he wanted a Champions League run with Everton in fear it might make him look stupid after the first effort. Constantly playing our top players apart from Baines out of position only ever resulted in us falling short and never being able to construct a real balance in play.

Moyes made us solid in what he believed was the best way forward and he gained us respect but he was always too busy in being safe to give us that last push we needed. Martinez however is different as we all know and comes across really positive. His game style is different and he's willing to let his vision of football take off early with a mixture of youth and experience.

Comparing the 2 managers is a thing most Evertonians will look to but to actually side with Moyes over Martinez is absolutely ridiculous. The new man really deserves his chance and he seems to have the drive to take us forward. I'm sure there'll be some mad results along the way and no-one should be stupid enough to believe otherwise coz even Man Utd suffer some terrible shocks.

Already in the Martinez era, I've seen a lot of positives: Barkley given some freedom; the guts to go for Lukaku; Stones given a start or two; playing like the home side away. Give the man a chance and let's see how the team develop their abilities with positive football.

Signings will be the life or death of any manager but most certainly for Martinez with the lack of funds our board produce, that's my only worry with Martinez right now, nothing else... but I'd feel the same no matter who was in charge. So far, he's done well in that department.

Ross Edwards
128 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:47:31
Darren, did you boo at the end of the game, yes, or no?
Gary Reeves
129 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:47:48
Watching Martinez on MotD last night, you can’t help noticing the fella’s passion. He’s also quite humble too, and seems willing to learn. You sense he’s got a shot and he’s gonna give it his best. If there’s games there to be won, let’s have a go – unlike the previous regime!

BK knows how to tell a story and his one about the interview might one day go down in folklore - "How did you mug City at Wembley, when you had no right?"

I wonder if Moyes’s interview for Man Utd followed similar lines? "So David... A couple of seasons ago. you were in a semi, ahead at half-time. You had a chance for glory. A chance to wipe away years of misery for a generation. You had nothing to beat David, but – if you forgive me – you appeared to shit your pants. You won’t be planning on doing that here will you?... Well will you??"

Sam Hoare
131 Posted 29/09/2013 at 21:05:49
There's a great deal of false assumption on here that anyone who questions Martinez must also have been a huge supporter of Moyes.

I was a big fan of Moyes and although I'm not hailing him as the second coming I'm a big fan of Martinez.

Stop the lazy stereotyping.

James Martin
132 Posted 29/09/2013 at 21:14:41
You can be a fan of the manager and still not be an absolute bufoon when viewing the games. I'm a big fan of Martinez but Darren has a point regarding some of the performances. The first halves of Norwich, Cardiff and West Ham were awful.

Ross, there's loads of stats for shots on target but I was at lots of those games and it wasn't as though we were working the keeper, some were daisy cutters from stupidly tight angles that the keeper just picked up. Equally, though, the second half of Norwich, second half of West Ham and whole of Chelsea game were very good. the Stevenage game and the second half of Fulham were shambolic, the first half of Fulham was mesmeric at times.

Why do some contributors to this site always have to deal in absolutes, stupid people try and push people into categories if they don't agree with their extremist views. Ultimately results are all that count, Liverpool put in one of the worst away performances I've seen form them in a long time yet came out with a 3-1 win, this automatically makes it a better performance than when they played decently agianst Man U but lost.

Too many people have this view of 'Moyes was rubbish therefore Martinez must be brilliant just to further confirm my view that Moyes was rubbish, anyone who doesn't agree that Martinez walks on water is a Moyesophile and is pining for him back and treated him like a demi-god.'

I support Martinez fully but the day you can't give an honest opinion of the match without being censored by some sort of anti-Moyes brigade (thought he'd left ages ago?) is a sad day indeed. Bit like the days when under Moyes we'd batter an opposing team come off two-nil after 90 minutes of controlled good football and someone would call you a loon if you didn't think it was yet another example of KITAP1. Then again I've been said to have a closed mind on here because I didn't like the idea of Anichebe playing centre-mid.

Raymond Fox
133 Posted 29/09/2013 at 21:59:40
James, I don't think anyone is trying to stop all criticism of RM, but certain people are continuously talking negatively without equally mentioning what they think he's doing well.
Its all negative, as if he's the worst manager there's ever been!
James Martin
134 Posted 29/09/2013 at 22:26:46
Raymond Darren raised a fair point about the football this season and depsite offering the caveat that he was in support of Martinez and liked what he was doing overall he was told that his post was idiotic and that he should go and watch United at Old Trafford because he obviously loved hoofball. Is that not the sort of censoring I'm talking about?
Barry Rathbone
135 Posted 29/09/2013 at 22:27:40
James Martin you protest too much, first you waffle:

"Why do some contributors to this site always have to deal in absolutes, stupid people try and push people into categories if they don't agree with their extremist views"

then piegeon-hole people like this:

"Too many people have this view of 'Moyes was rubbish therefore Martinez must be brilliant just to further confirm my view that Moyes was rubbish, anyone who doesn't agree that Martinez walks on water is a Moyesophile and is pining for him back and treated him like a demi-god.'"

You stretched a number of points to the limit with that contradictory monologue not least the "closed mind" remark – it had nothing to do with Anichebe and everything to do with Allardyce..... as you well know.

Done yourself no favours with that garbage you just come over as a whining tart flailing about and telling porkies - very poor.

Raymond Fox
136 Posted 29/09/2013 at 22:36:38
Fair point James, but I think it has become too one sided from certain quarters.

James Martin
137 Posted 29/09/2013 at 23:21:35
Barry you rate Allardyce over Moyes, and you thought Anichebe rather than Barkley was the answer to our midfield problems. Forgive me for not agreeing with your whinig tart verdict - or anything else you have to say for that matter. Your support for Roberto is the one opinion you've ever expressed on here that's reassured me that you actually know what football is and how its played.
Roman Sidey
138 Posted 30/09/2013 at 01:30:35
Totally agree with Sam there. I was outspoken MoB (how good is it that the United supporters have picked that up?!) but I was also underwhelmed when we signed RM. I'm into him a bit more now. The first half of the Norwich game, I was thinking, "This will be a long season," but now, I honestly think that a win next week against City (which is always possible for us) will mean that we really are capable of beating anyone, thus, finishing the season in an extremely high position - league champions anyone? If Lukaku is fit and firing all season, no team is going to have an easy day against us.

In all seriousness, an undefeated run is excellent, but I am really just hoping RM can win his first derby in which is getting closer by the day. That would be something special.

Barry Rathbone
139 Posted 30/09/2013 at 10:54:54
James Martin, you either have a very vivid imagination extrapolating points wildly or you are a congenital liar.

Desperate stuff, truly woeful postings.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads