Green hat-trick beats Baggies U-18s

, 28 September, 51comments  |  Jump to most recent
George Green was the star of the show as Everton Under-18s beat West Brom 3-1 on Saturday. Green slotted home two penalties either side of a superb individual strike to help the young Blues maintain their excellent recent run.

This was their fourth consecutive victory and unsurprisingly the Toffees began in confident fashion, stroking the ball around despite being away from home.

They soon broke through when Courtney Duffus was illegally halted in the box and Green converted the penalty for a 25th minute lead. It remained that way at the break after Tyrone Duffus and Joe Williams missed decent chances.

The killer second goal came via a moment of sheer class from Green on the hour mark as he cut in from the wing and unleashed a brilliant effort into the top corner from 25 yards. George Green then completed his hat-trick with another spot-kick after sub Oliver Shannon had been fouled.

Everton U-18s: Griffiths; Jones, Robinson (75' Langton), Connolly, Thorniley; Ledson, Williams (60' Shannon), T Duffus; Dyson (70' Donoghue), C Duffus, Green.

Quotes or other material sourced from Everton FC



Reader Comments (51)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Bobby Mallon
1 Posted 29/09/2013 at 07:08:37
That sounds promising, George Green, what a great old-fashion name. That name would not be out of place alongside Finny, Lofthouse and Dean.
Dick Brady
3 Posted 29/09/2013 at 08:44:20
I have to admit I was beginning to wonder about George Green. When Moyes brought him to Everton, Green was tipped as an exceptional talent but then he seemed to disappear and some reports claimed he was having trouble making good on his potential.

Now at 17 he needs to start making an effort to reach the first team (remember Rooney, Rodwell & Baxter were all 16 when they made their debuts).

I really hope Green can continue to develop and fulfil his potential to become a special player. It would be a wonderful legacy to David Moyes if in amongst his last business at Everton bringing Green and Stones to the club actually played a major part in Everton's future.

Kieran Fitzgerald
4 Posted 29/09/2013 at 09:20:09
The main thing for now is that he puts in consistantly good performances with the u21s. This will make it too hard for Martinez to ignore him.
Derek Knox
5 Posted 29/09/2013 at 09:24:22
Things are certainly looking good with the younger players at Everton, and a lot of good results, from week to week.

I think a lot of the more promising ones will be offered contracts, and I feel Roberto will take more of an interest in the up and coming potentials.

Kev Johnson
6 Posted 29/09/2013 at 09:36:01
Mike Green will be pleased.
Raymond Fox
7 Posted 29/09/2013 at 10:01:12
I agree Derek, the club is on a roll from the youngest to the first team, long may it continue.

The youth teams will get guidance and encouragement from Martinez because he wouldn't take charge of any club that didn't give him control of all the matters appertaining to the players in the club.

It's central to his long term plan for developing the club from top to bottom, and was the reason why he refused the jobs at Aston Villa and our friends across the park!

Mark Belcher
8 Posted 29/09/2013 at 10:20:15
I went to the game and, trust me, Green is well on course for the 1st team within 12 months. He stood out like a sore thumb for me, his 2nd goal was a long range worldy but it was his work rate that impressed me. If we lost the ball, he would run his balls off to get it back.

Trust me, there will be comparisons to Rooney... an excellent display from the kid.

Jon Withey
9 Posted 29/09/2013 at 10:21:32
Let the lad build his confidence first, no need to push him too soon. Next step he can be a key player for U21s then maybe some cameos towards the end of the season / beginning of next.

Or maybe a loan would be the best thing at some point, seemed to help out Ross.

Wayne Smyth
10 Posted 29/09/2013 at 10:22:18
Great to see players like George doing well in the U18s and U21s. I wish Everton TV would either show the games live or give us the full games to watch after the event.

I'm far more hopeful about the future of all of our top young players like Barkley, Stones, Robles and Green now that we have a manager who is prepared to give them an opportunity and take a real interest in improving them as footballers.

I was interested in what Martinez had to say about how we, and many other English clubs, fail to get the best out of our footballers in the age where George is now. Will be interesting to see over the next few years if we notice a larger proportion of our youngsters making it into the first team with him in charge. We certainly can't afford to let that kind of talent go undeveloped.

Phil Sammon
12 Posted 29/09/2013 at 11:08:54
Dick

Does he bollocks need to be hitting the first team at 17. What are you talking about? This is a promising young lad, but he's not even a regular starter for the U21's yet! He could quite easily have at least another 2 or 3 years of development before he makes the first team.

And as for Stones and Green being Moyes' legacy, I'd love to see how many minutes Stones would have got under Moyes this season.

Why is every post you make a brown nose to David Moyes and a carefully worded slight on Martinez?

Sam Hoare
14 Posted 29/09/2013 at 11:32:57
As Phil Sammon says George Green has hardly played for the u21s and is a long long way off the first team. But he's very young. Do well for the 18s and try to become a regular starter for the u21s should be his goal for now and start worrying about the first team in a couple years time.
Sam Hoare
15 Posted 29/09/2013 at 11:37:28
Ps if Mrs Duffus is on these pages then glad to see your boys continuing to flourish!
Dick Brady
16 Posted 29/09/2013 at 11:48:06
Wondering how much time John Stones would have gotten under Moyes, well Moyes always played youngsters in the League Cup so I imagine Stones would have played in that just like he did under Martinez.

So far in the Premier League, Stones has had just a couple of minutes against Chelsea. Like literally 2-3 minutes.

Colin Glassar
18 Posted 29/09/2013 at 12:05:45
I was starting to think that George Green was some urban legend but, apparently, he does exist. Players develop at different rates to others. I hope he can make the grade.
Mark Frere
21 Posted 29/09/2013 at 12:28:07
Dick Brady

To say Green should be knocking on the door of our first team already, is lunacy, young players all develop at different stages. For example Giggs was a regular at manure at the age of 17, Beckham and Scholes developed into first team players when they were 20-21 years old. We can't deny though, they were all world class players.

For once in your life stop talking complete bollocks!

Paul Andrews
22 Posted 29/09/2013 at 12:50:52
Roberto will know when he is ready and play him accordingly.
Harold Matthews
32 Posted 29/09/2013 at 13:45:49
The scouts and head of recruitment bring these boys in and hand them over to the youth coaches. Moyes wouldn't know Green if he passed him in the street.
Dick Brady
35 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:34:09
Harold Matthews you seriously need to do some research before deciding David Moyes "wouldn't know Green if he passed him in the street."

First of all George Green was all set to join Harry Redknapp at Spurs and it was only the determination of David Moyes which changed all that.

First Moyes agreed a £350,000 deal with Bradford which could rise to over £2 million. This itself was a coup as Spurs had offered the same deal with up to £600,000 up front.

And Daniel Levy offered George Green far better personal terms but Moyes brought George Green up for a game at Goodison Park, a game which just happened to be a super charged derby against Liverpool.

Moyes let Green soak in the derby day Goodison Park atmosphere and then granted the 16-year-old privileged access to Everton’s dressing room and then after that took him to the Manager's Office and explained what it meant to play for the People's Club.

By the end of that meeting Moyes had persuaded George Green to turn down the better financial deal Daniel Levy offered at Spurs and had a verbal agreement that George Green would join Everton.

Its fair to say David Moyes pushed out the boat for George Green and used all his determination and influence to sign him. So after all that effort we could assume Moyes had more then a passing interest in the boy and would undoubtedly know him if he passed him in the street.

The deal to sign George Green and the deal to sign John Stones were both engineered by David Moyes and hopefully they will both be major players for Everton over the next few years.

Make no mistake, Moyes is nothing if not methodical, every small detail at Everton was overseen by David Moyes, the man is a workaholic and a control freak. Moyes knew more about the Academy and its youngsters then you could possibly imagine.

James Martin
36 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:56:05

Apart from signing players, watching them and setting out a philosophy for the academy, then the manager probably does not do much in terms of a player's development until he starts getting to the fringes of the first team squad. Geogre Green, like Ross Barkley, will be the player he turns out to be because of the coaches of the Everton academy and U-21 team until he break sinto the first team.

We should be thankful that we have a club who see the value in investing in youth (if they invest in nothing else!) and be glad that in the forseeable future a good proportion of our first team could well be made up of young talented English players.

Look how the much vaunted Liverpool academy that splurted a load of kids out all at once is suffering in comparison to ours. Wisdom, Coady, Flanagan, Robinson – they were all supposed to be the next best thing yet none of them look good enough to make it. They banged on about their youth team so much yet it hasn't produced one player of note since Gerrard. In that time, we've had Rooney, Rodwell and Barkley. If Green can make it to the big time and is as good as people say he will if he can fit in a midfield with Barkley, then we potentially have two thirds of a fantastic midfield that could last for a decade.

Phil Sammon
37 Posted 29/09/2013 at 15:03:13
A sensible comment from Dick Brady. Well I never.

Moyes did go all out for Green and really pushed the boat out to get the young lad. Fair play to him on that one.

With regards to John Stones - yes, Moyes got the player in, but I seriously question his management after getting his man. He was playing first team football at Barnsley and really making a name for himself. Surely he could have stayed there for the rest of the season and continued his development. Instead he was starved of first team football for months on end. What was the point?

Eddie McBride
38 Posted 29/09/2013 at 14:50:00
What is relevent is that a young blue, who it seemed had lost his way. Has just scored a hat-trick for one of our junior teams.

I sincerely hope that Martinez refreshing new outlook has contributed in some way to the resurgence of the young mans very promising career.

Mike Allison
40 Posted 29/09/2013 at 18:57:17
Just add my voice to those disagreeing with Dick Brady's first comment. Green is 17, Everton fans need to forget about him and wait for a bit.

Just because some other players came through earlier, doesn't mean its right for him. Clearly it wasn't right for some of them either.

Nothing has gone wrong with Green at any stage, we signed him at 15 and he's now 17. I wouldn't expect to see him near the first team next season let alone this.

Ross Edwards
41 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:05:21
"Make no mistake, Moyes is nothing if not methodical, every small detail at Everton was overseen by David Moyes, the man is a workaholic and a control freak. Moyes knew more about the Academy and its youngsters then you could possibly imagine."

So Dick, his methodical approach isn't working at Man U is it, particularly in the transfer window?

If he knew so much about the academy, why did he have a central midfield partnership with the combined age of 68, Osman and Phil Neville, keeping Barkley in the reserves in his last season?

Dick Brady
42 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:20:18
Moyes will be a success at Man Utd and he will win trophies that us Everton fans can only dream about. Stop reacting just because a manager loses a couple of games.

Why did Moyes pick Osman and Neville in midfield??

Well possibly because age means fuck all. Good enough, old enough. And that works both ways with young and old players.

Osman and Neville fired us to a 6th place finish last season. Lets see where Barkley fires us this season.

That's if Barkley manages to keep his place in the team because for me our strongest midfield is Pienaar, Barry, Gibson, McCarthy, Mirallas. Barkley and Osman on the bench.

Dick Brady
43 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:25:00
I think it is worth considering that, at 15, people were comparing George Green to Rooney and Gascoigne; now, at 17, he's nowhere near the first team.

Rooney, Rodwell and Baxter all came through at 16 and I'm sure Barkley would have too had he not broken his leg.

Don't get me wrong, there's plenty of time for George Green to come good but exceptional talents like Wayne Rooney push for the first team at 16.

And I'm surprised Green hasn't developed quick enough to do that. Probably having such a high reputation at such a young age has worked against him.

Phil Sammon
44 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:27:09
Dick

How do you do it?

Every opinion you hold is categorically wrong.

How is having three defensive midfielders in our team a preferred option? Barkley has lit up our season so far. That ball carrying midfielder with pace, power and a great shot. It's something Everton have missed for as long as I can remember.

Phil Sammon
45 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:36:00
And Dick, have you seen the size of George Green?

He is still a child. How on earth can you be surprised he hasn't broken into the first team?!

Dick Brady
46 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:39:48
Phil

I don't get to any games anymore and only have MOTD highlights to see Everton. So the "ball carrying midfielder with pace, power and a great shot" actually means very little to me.

What I do enjoy though is finishing above Liverpool. I fucking love that we have finished above Liverpool the last two seasons. I've enjoyed every second of ramming that fact down the Red Shite fans throats.

And much of finishing above Liverpool the last two seasons running has been down to the likes of Moyes, Osman and Neville. And for that they have my loyalty and respect.

Will Martinez and Barkley be able to deliver the same? Will they get us to finish above Liverpool this season???? We wait and see.

Ross Edwards
47 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:41:11
Neville also was one of the causes of our destruction against Wigan Dick.

The age of the squad needed reducing, and there was Moyes playing a past it 35 year old when he had a hungry 18 year old chomping at the bit to show us what he can do.

"Moyes will be a success at Man Utd and he will win trophies that us Everton fans can only dream about. Stop reacting just because a manager loses a couple of games."

He's already written off the Champions League you know. Nearly 6 points behind already, after 5 games.

Ross Edwards
48 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:44:23
It wasn't Dick down to Osman and Neville.

I'd say it was a number of other players like Mirallas, Baines etc who were responsible.

You make Neville and Osman sound more important than Xavi and Iniesta.

Patrick Murphy
50 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:53:40
Like you David I too suspect that Mr Brady is not a bona-fide blue, he seemed to believe our win against Wimbledon was played at Selhurst Park in May 1994.
Ross Edwards
51 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:02:10
I think anyone who bets against his own team doesn't have any morals or credibility whatsoever.
Brian Sharples
52 Posted 29/09/2013 at 19:39:13
After barely a week as a contributor to ToffeeWeb, I am bemused as to why virtually every thread too quickly degenerates into a debate on what Moyes did, didn't do, should have done or just might have done were he still our manager.

Of course, his eleven or more years casts a shadow over all things Everton but he's gone now, never to return most hope, and so it seems irrelevant to keep harping on about his possible treatment of any of our young players.

All that matters is that the future of young Green is in the hands of Roberto Martinez. I, for one, am happy about that – at least he'll be taught how to pass properly!

Ross Edwards
53 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:09:57
Not another one trying to tell us what not to write. I'm sick and tired of being told not to mention this, not mention that, don't mention Moyes, culminating in this OFM rubbish because of the paranoia of not mentioning his name.

He was our manager for 11 years ,only leaving 4 months ago. He has treated us with utter disrespect, and yet we are not allowed to mention him?

It's becoming childish that people are so paranoid about the mere mentioning of him.
He is still a relevance, one of our rivals, and if people want these blinkered views that the only person on Earth who exists is Martinez and that anything else is irrelevant, then fine.

Brian Sharples
54 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:21:48
That's me told then. I wonder what Moyes would have said about that!!!
Wayne Smyth
55 Posted 29/09/2013 at 20:30:36
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MIaORknS1Dk
Gary Reeves
56 Posted 29/09/2013 at 21:18:17
Phil Sammon... Whilst not wanting to get involved in any of the finer points of this particular thread, I do have one point to make.

For me, IMHO, Barkley is not ready for an out-and-out midfield position. He lacks the discipline and destructive side to his game .

I’m happy for him to cause trouble higher up the pitch though. As I say – just my opinion.

Patrick Carty
57 Posted 29/09/2013 at 21:10:13
I've been on the site a couple of months now and I enjoy reading people's views, some negative and some positive, but everyone has the right to voice their opinion.

There's not many Evertonians where I live and I have put up with a lot of bullshit from Liverpool, Man Utd, Arsenal, Spurs, and even Chelsea fans who seemed to come out of the woodwork when a bit of silverware came their way.

I am optomistic now that we finally have the squad to compete for a Champions League place, and I look forward to sharing my views with fellow fans.
Up the Toffees

Harold Matthews
60 Posted 30/09/2013 at 00:52:33
Yes Dick. Hands up. Sometimes it pays to look things up before opening ones mouth. Even the Editor had a swipe at me. Fair enough. It makes a change from being ordered to get my paragraph spacing right.
Robin Cannon
61 Posted 30/09/2013 at 04:24:04
Definitely good to hear continued good things about our youngsters.

Does anyone who watches the U-18/U-21 have any comment on the style of football and formations they play? It'd be great if we were starting to follow the more European model of youth teams being trained to play like the first team; with a consistency of approach throughout all levels.

Agree with the comments pointing out that there's no point putting expectation on Green or others to be pushing for the first team yet. 16/17 year olds getting near the first team of any club is extraordinarily rare, and players develop at different rates. It's all very well citing a few examples of 16/17 year old debutantes, but really the ages of 19/20 is the most common kind of age for young players to really break through.

Christopher Kelly
62 Posted 30/09/2013 at 04:31:09
A couple of idiotic comments and everyone is off the apple cart?

Of course you can't expect too much from such a young boy. Especially one who appears so young. How are we talking about a child who has never even appeared for the U-21's?

He'll develop when he's supposed to.

Next.

Christopher Kelly
63 Posted 30/09/2013 at 04:34:30
...And if we're not training our youth players to play in the same style as our 1st team, our coaches need their heads examined.

RM is way too smart to not do that.

Not sure if that's a new thing, Robin. But if it is, that's ludicrous.

Robin Cannon
64 Posted 30/09/2013 at 04:42:36
@Chris (450) - A lot of what I've read about English youth training (not just us) suggests that this isn't the case, and clubs very often don't implement a consistent approach across all levels. Instead they allow the coaches/managers of the teams at those levels far more leeway than would be expected on the continent.
Harold Matthews
65 Posted 30/09/2013 at 11:37:52
Christopher / Robin. (???) Your point about youngsters being trained to play in a similar fashion to the first team is very interesting,

Unfortunately, my experience in this particular area is extremely limited but I do have an Everton ceefax snippet concerning Dennis Lawrence who came to us via Swansea and Wigan where he worked alongside Roberto Martinez.

"Lawrence is there to liaise between the different groups and help to spot players who are adapting to the Martinez system quicker than others. These they will try to progress further."

I'm not sure what "progress further" entails... and Martinez may be following the youth policy of Toshack at Real Sociedad which he greatly admired.

Haydn Milloy
66 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:42:58
I feel I need to add to this conversation. George Green is a very special young footballer and to compare him to any other footballer in my opinion is unfair.

To try to make an issue out of the fact that he has not played for the first team at 17 is way out of the park. When Rooney made his debut, the first-team squad was so much weaker than today.

Yes, he has been called up for the Under-21s but has only got on for a few minutes at the end of the game with no chance to show what he can do in the company of players further on in their careers; when he gets the chance to play a bigger part in the U21s, I think we will really see what he is made of.

In the Under-18s there are a few I feel the same about; I feel they are further on in their development than others and need to be given more playing time at a higher level to improve more... George Green being just one of them.

Also, I feel he is played in the wrong position, as they tend to play him out on the wing and while, over a short distance, he is quick, over a long distance, there others who are faster.

In my opinion, and when I have spoken to George, in his opinion, he is best playing in the hole; not really Everton's way. He would be great with a free role in midfield. Great at tackling, great at dribbling with tight ball control, great vision, great passing and can ping a cross-field pass, great engine and a great left-foot shot.

When the U18s played Leeds at Finch Farm, I stood beside some guys from Leeds and they were saying how he was controlling the game and everything from Everton was going through him.

I have seen comments on George saying he had taken a few steps backward, and that he had a problem with attitude. This is untrue; he had a bit of home-sickness, missing friends and family, but with help and support from the club, he has found a new spring to his step this season. This has resulted in him being called up to England Under-18s...

So keep the faith, let the coaches do what they need to do with him, and I'm sure he will become the player he was tipped to be at 15 years old.

To finish with, the second goal he scored on Saturday at West Brom was world class and his work-rate up and down the pitch was great to watch.

Kevin Jones
67 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:27:47
Well I'll be bumswizzled. Only last week I thought to myself, "I wonder what happened to young George Green?" So, being a curious type of fellow, I logged on the official Everton site to look at his profile, and found it quite interesting. Asked what his ambitions are for this season, he replied "to get into the reserve team".

[Ahemmm, I thought (might've even said it out loud... can't remember... doesn't matter because no-one else was in.] Anyway... ahemmm, I thought:] I thought he'd've been further on than that by now... but then I thought, [see, I do a lot of thinking when I'm on my own, only because when my missus is in she does the thinking for the two us she's that fucking clever! Anyway...]

I thought, No, the lad's only 17 and let's not rush him in to early, nurture him along till he's 19 / 20 then expose his talent to the football World. Hopefully by then, young Ross will be an England regular and he can help young George along, and advise him never to leave.

By the way, when asked who he plays most like, he said "Wayne Rooney". Remember the Name: George Green.

Mike Allison
68 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:21:12
Brian Sharples (382). Brilliant. Post more please, this website needs more like you.
Ian Mackenzie
69 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:47:46
Ross 379:

It's a bit rich for you to start calling people childish for merely expressing their frustation at the increasingly tedious obsession on here with David Moyes' faults or otherwise - I'm afraid your final paragraph provides a fine example of what a childish post looks like.

Harold Matthews
70 Posted 30/09/2013 at 18:10:36
Hadyn. Thanks for filling me in on George Green. Unfortunately, in an earlier post I confused him with someone else but this boy seems to be a cut above the average for his age group. Let's hope he continues to progress.
David Chait
71 Posted 30/09/2013 at 18:40:39
I needed that Hadyn... Very good insight.. Thanks.. I saw this report on EFC and it was a breath of fresh air! I was one of those who, months ago even, was questioning what has happened to GG (TM). I also benched him against our other superstar teenagers and the hype (yes there was to the idiot who said there was none), when he arrived. Great to hear first hand info. You have actually confirmed he has taken a little bit of a step up recently, which now we can see as I hardly read his name in any reports, which seemed to show lack of contribution. That is where my concern came from.

Baxter week in and week out was always a leading contributor in every match report and I wanted the same from GG.

I hope we eventually play him in his rightful position (same position of Baxter oddly enough). I guess we cant bank on him though anymore as a guaranteed star.. As we could do on Barkley. We knew Barkley would be a superstar. Right now it seems GG is on the Baxter path... He might become a legend.. Or drift away not getting game time at the top. I eagerly await all the junior reports and his name in every one.

Dick Fearon
73 Posted 03/10/2013 at 22:03:40
As I remember and I hope not looking for an arguement, was there not talk on these pages that Baxter did not have the physique suitable for the PL.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb