Everton v Newcastle United

, 30 September, 75comments  |  Jump to most recent
Match Preview

Everton are back at Goodison Park under the lights this Monday evening for the visit of Newcastle United as Roberto Martinez looks to shrug off last Tuesday's Capital One Cup disappointment and extend his side's unbeaten start in the Premier League.

As they have done so in all of their matches so far this season with the exception of the win over Chelsea, the Spaniard's side dominated their cup tie with Fulham, particularly in the first half, but, having grabbed just the one goal from their efforts, they were at risk of the Cottagers mounting a comeback in the second half. Fulham duly did and won the tie 2-1 thanks to two second-half goals.

With their focus now back on the League, the Blues are back home after beating West Ham 3-2 in thrilling fashion nine days ago and they have the huge incentive of fourth place being up for grabs should they beat the Barcodes in front of the Sky Sports cameras.

As he did against Stevenage in the League Cup second round, Martinez made eight changes on Tuesday and most of the team that started against the Hammers is expected to return to the starting line-up. That should include Ross Barkley, Kevin Mirallas, Leighton Baines and Tim Howard and it should be a landmark night for Gareth Barry, set to make his 500th appearance in the Premier League — only the 10th player to pass that milestone.

Martinez is suitably impressed by his new midfield general saying, "I don't think there are many more significant records than that. I think it represents his professionalism, the way he looks after himself, the way he sees the game and the experience that he brings into any side.

“And you can add the 50 appearances he's had for England, so far. He's in such a great moment in his career.”

Barry is conceivably battling for a starting berth with fit-again Gibson, whose struggle to regain match fitness is much needed in the Evertion midfield engine room, although it's possible — though unlikely — that Martinez could deploy them both in the centre at the the expense of Leon Osman and James McCarthy.

Indeed, the Spaniard has perhaps his most difficult selection to make since taking the reins at Everton, with Steven Pienaar also apparently recovered from a hamstring strain and Steven Naismith having scored in two of the last three games from attacking midfield.

Up front, Romelu Lukaku was given the nod at Fulham and he is vying for the striker's role with Nikica Jelavic and Arouna Kone who has yet to start a league game this season but is back in contention after recovering from injury of his own. Jelavic started at Upton Park last weekend but was replaced at half time by Lukaku and it's hard to look beyond the Belgian for the starting role against Newcastle.

For his part, Alan Pardew has struggled to get any consistency out of his team this season after a poor 2012-13 campaign — making a mockery of his those ill-advised comments a while back (or perhaps driving home his point but not in the way he intended!) about his club being "in a dfferent league" to Everton.

They lost their last Premier League game at home to Hull after twice leading and they sit in 16th coming into this match but they have won once on their travels so far, that a 2-1 win at Aston Villa two weeks ago.

Given the respective league form of the two sides and home advantage of Goodison Park, this really is a game from which the Blues should be looking to claim all three points. Victory would put them into the top four and onto the heels of the Arsenal at the summit and also signal Martinez's intent in his first season in charge.

» Read more



Reader Comments (75)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Vijay Nair
1 Posted 30/09/2013 at 07:06:53
COYB!!!
Craig Fletcher
2 Posted 30/09/2013 at 08:27:30
Tough game, this one - with Cabaye, Ben Arfa and Remy Newcastle will be no easy-beats.
They seem to be a bit suspect at the back though, something hopefully Lukaku, Barkley, Miralles and company will be able to exploit on home turf..... get into it, boys!
Stuart Gray
3 Posted 30/09/2013 at 08:24:26
This is a good barometer for me. I remember last years game which we should have won but it was "typical" of the first half of the season - we were playing well but not winning. Then Moyes reverted to his natural "too defensive" game for the second half of the season and it all fizzled out.

If we can get a good win tonight against a similar Newcastle team to last year then we can be happy that, even though Martinez is probably nowhere near where he wants to be, we are progressing nicely. And in theory it can only get better.

Sam Hoare
4 Posted 30/09/2013 at 08:36:58
Assuming Pienaar is fit is go with:

Howard
Coleman jagielka Distin Baines
Gibson Barry
Mirallas Barkley Pienaar
Lukaku

Newcastle have some great players going forward and cabaye and Ben arfa in particular will have to be well shackled.

Derek Knox
5 Posted 30/09/2013 at 08:35:09
I have got to agree with you there Craig, and I have said it many times before on here, that there are no easy games in the Prem. The only time a game can be viewed as easy, is after the final whistle.

Watching Roberto on Match of the Day on Saturday, Gary Lineker asked him about his start at Everton and about tonight's game against the Barcodes, and he said exactly that, there are no easy games. I really like the guy and think he has his head screwed on correctly.

As I also mentioned on another thread, I am totally surprised by the way the first few games have gone, and teams expected to do well have had some strange results. I think with the correct approach in every game, which Roberto seems to be managing well, there is no reason why we can't break into the Elite club this season!

The so called experts are still not acknowledging Everton as a serious contender, it is the Usual Suspects with Tottenham and the RS being talked about in forming the Top Six with differing permutations as to the finishing order.

Ciarán McGlone
6 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:10:14
I think McCarthy needs to start this one..

Pienaar was poor before his injury and shouldn't walk back in..I think the Barca Kid has shown enough to warrant a starting place..

It'll be a tough game.

Craig Fletcher
7 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:11:48
Good team, Sam (469).

It's a nice prospect to have Lukaku, Pienaar, Miralles and Barkley in full flow, and to be able to call on Deulofeu in the second half.

Doesn't Ben Arfa normally play right wing? If so, it'll make for an interesting battle between him and Baines.

Ajay Gopal
8 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:16:44
Sam (469), I think Naismith has a good chance of retaining his place, and I wouldn't find fault with that. Pienaar shouldn't assume that his place is secure, or conversely, Naismith should feel he has a chance if he keeps scoring goals. But otherwise, I agree with your team.

Subs: Robles, Stones, Heitinga, McCarthy, Jelavic, Pienaar, Deulofeu

Sam Hoare
9 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:25:21
Naismith does pop up with a goal or two but I think Pienaars all round game is far better and in terms of Martinez game being based on quick, intricate passing I think he is a better bet than Naismith though the scots movement is very good in particular.

If we are winning I'd probably bring on Naismith for his defensive capabilities and work rate, if losing then Deulofeu who is capable of conjuring something from nothing.

Sam Higgins
10 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:41:06
Its just so good to have all these options for once though - isn't it. I don't think our players pick themselves anymore with the exception of Bainsey.
Patrick Carty
11 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:43:09
I agree with Sam's team there, and without doubt I feel this is the strongest team we had since the Premier League started, with game changers on the bench. Newcastle are not a bad side, but winning home games against the likes of Newcastle is a must.

I predict a 3-1 scoreline to Everton with a brace for Lukaku and a Mirallas strike. Coleman's last couple of performances have been average so I am looking for a big game from him, with plenty more attacking moves.

Ciarán McGlone
12 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:56:42
My team would be;

...............Howard
Coleman ....Jags...Distin....Baines

...........McCarthy...Barry
Mirallas....Barkley.....Del
...............Lukaku


I think Martinez will pick

...............Howard
Coleman ....Jags...Distin....Baines

...........McCarthy...Barry
Mirallas....Barkley.....Naismith
...............Lukaku

Drew Shortis
13 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:49:26
I agree that if Pienaar is fit he should go in instead of Naismith unless we play Nais as a partner up front with Lukaku. Naismith's passing is nowhere near good enough to play him in midfield. Pienaar needs to improve his final ball, but his instinctive partnership with Baines works so well for us.

I would love to see Deulofeu start, but I suspect he will get another appearance from the bench tonight. The other choice seems to be Gibson or McCarthy to partner Barry in midfield. Personally I would go with McCarthy as he needs playing time to get up to speed. I'm not sure Gibson is up to 100% fitness just yet.

Howard
Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines
McCarthy, Barry
Mirallas, Barkley, Pienaar
Lukaku

Subs: Robles, Stones, Oviedo, Gibson, Deulofeu, Naismith, Kone

Iain Love
14 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:56:08
I'd prefer to see McCarthy and Barry given time to build a partnership due to Gibson's injury record.

As for the left side, I wouldn't shoe Pienaar straight back in as his form wasn't great and leaving him on the bench for a game or two might give him a much-needed kick up the arse. As, minus Pienaar, the left berth isn't nailed on, I'd like to see Delboy given a start at home and with our 1st team around him and see what the lad can do.

Newcastle are a bit fragile ATM and if we can get service into the beast that is Lukaku early doors we might see a hatfull of goals.

Anthony Flack
15 Posted 30/09/2013 at 09:34:32
My stab at a team

Howard
Coleman
Baines
Jagielka
Distin
Barry
McCarthy
Barkley
Lukaku
Mirallas
Deulofeu

Too attack-minded maybe... so perhaps Pienaar for Deulofeu...

Kevin Tully
16 Posted 30/09/2013 at 10:03:47
Think you've nailed the starting 11 there Drew. Although there may be one surprise - little Leon is available I believe!

Ciaran - I thought Deulofeu was great to watch, but he needs to be able to beat his man and give a pass, before he will be trusted to start a League game. I think the same goes for Ross Barkley, they both try and beat three men before they think about passing.

They will both be top class players once they have a bit more experience, but are both prone to giving the ball away in dangerous areas.

Sam Hoare
17 Posted 30/09/2013 at 10:16:50
I would like to see McCarthy start to have a good look at them but from what I've seen so far Gibson is the more likely to play an incisive forward pass that will set the likes of Barkley or lukaku free. It's a very blunt analysis but to my mind mcCarthy is the safer option whilst Gibson more likely to create chances for his team-mates. I'd prefer the latter. Mind you he probably only has 65 mins in him anyway.
Steve King
18 Posted 30/09/2013 at 10:16:18
Deulofeu was excellent in the first half against Fulham. But in the second, and particularly when we were chasing the game, he became really frustrating to watch. Hisg touch eluded him and it seemed everything he did was a strugle. Lots of complaining to the ref when he had legitamtley been tackled or hassled off the ball. At times it was almost like he was trying too hard.

No doubt this is why he is at Everton this year and not playing for Barcelona. Also I have no doubt that this is why Martinez is using him as a sub so far. He can be devastating when he gets it right, but hugely annoying when things aren't going his way. Hopefully he will mature quickly and be ready for a more prominent role in the run in to the season.

Leung Chi Ho
19 Posted 30/09/2013 at 10:14:55
I hope Naismith and Deulofeu can start the game and give one more chance to Jelavic because I think Lukaku can change game in the 2nd half if Jelavic don't work again.
Ciarán McGlone
20 Posted 30/09/2013 at 10:32:47
Kevin,

I don't disagree with you about Deulofeu... however, if it's a choice between him giving the ball away and Naismith giving the ball away — I'll take him everytime.

He'll get a few minutes at the end though.

Raymond Fox
21 Posted 30/09/2013 at 11:12:27
Ciaran, I think the team that you believe RM will pick will be the starting 11.

About tonight, the opposition will have plenty of info. on how we like to play and plan their tactics accordingly. The betting is Everton 4/7 Newcastle 9/2 which is pretty short enough for us, in my opinion.

Somehow I'm not getting good vibes for tonights game, I think were plenty good enough to win but if you follow sport for a long time you see the same sequences cropping up, as soon as things seem great and going your way up pops a setback and I think it could be tonight.

Call me a pessimistic pillock if you like!

James Morgan
22 Posted 30/09/2013 at 11:09:19
If it were up to me I wouldn't start Pienaar or Gibson, I think they need to be brought back gradually. I would have young Del next to Lukaku and Mirallas and should we need to change it we could choose from Oviedo, Pienaar, Naismith or Kone.

Isn't it great having options?

Roger Sunde
23 Posted 30/09/2013 at 11:45:48
Think he has to pick Gibson since Barry is ineligible for the next game and we really need Gibson fit again.
David Stuart
24 Posted 30/09/2013 at 11:20:59
Any chance Roberto may go for a back 3 tonight? Newcastle have been going 4-3-3 when attacking, with Ben Arfa and Remy both driving in towards goal from either side of Cisse.

..............................Howard

...........Stones...........Jags...........Distin

Coleman........Gibson...........Barry.. .......Baines

..............................Barkley

................Mirrallas.................Lukaku

This would give us 3 vs 3 when defending with Barry to provide a central overload, and Baines/Coleman providing an overload from wide. When attacking this would provide us with Lukaku and Mirrallas one on one with Yanga-Mbiwa and Coloccini, with Anita occupied with Barkley, and either Baines or Coleman one on one with their fullbacks.

The drawbacks of this are Baines and Coleman would have to be slightly more cautious as it only leaves Gibson able to cover, so as one goes forward the other may have to hang back.

I think this is the kind of formation change we will see from Martinez as we come up against opponents with different setups and styles, it may be too early to be changing formation on top of a change in style however, and 4-2-3-1 it may remain.

Harold Matthews
25 Posted 30/09/2013 at 13:05:21
Martinez raved about the Barry / Osman partnership after the Chelsea game but I'm more concerned about the blocking off of Ben Arfa when he cuts inside. Let's hope the DMs stay wide awake. This lad's left foot is dynamite.
Col Wills
26 Posted 30/09/2013 at 13:46:35
Any chance Newcstle will bring any fans tonight?
Graham Mockford
28 Posted 30/09/2013 at 13:59:46
I don't think are too many decisions for RM to take assuming he has everyone fit. In my view 9 players pick themselves.

Howard
Coleman, Jags, Distin, Baines
Mirallas, Barry, Pienaar
Lukaku

Then it is perm any two from Gibson, Osman or McCarthy

I'd go for Osman and McCarthy personally but I don't think there is much in it.

Graham Mockford
29 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:14:30
Sorry that should have included Barkley, it's nice to have a decent choice of midfielders that I can forget one!!

So it's McCarthy for me for the other spot.

Jay Harris
30 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:15:14
Graham you seem to have overlooked Barkley who IMO would be good for a goal against Newcastle.

Barkley, Mirallas and Lukaku for a 3-1 scoreline (Cant see the clean sheet at GP record holding out).

I would play Gibson ahead of Ossie or MCCarthy and maybe give McCarthy the last half hour.

Matty Williams
31 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:10:11
A tough game in store tonight... The Toon will settle for a point, I am sure> The Blues to grab a late winner in a tight match, 2-1 win methinks.. just. We need to keep our unbeaten run going by any means as we have some real hard games to come & Bobby still needs to find a settled starting 11.
Andrew Hawes
32 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:24:15
I really think this is a season-defining game, even this early on: win and go 4th and tails are up for Man City on Saturday; lose and it's 2 losses in a row and mid-table.

Ssigns are good the way we have been creating chances and our play in general. It would be great to thump a decent Newcastle side for a big boost of confidence in this new style of play.
COYB.

Denis Richardson
34 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:29:26
Sam 478 — I agree that our options are finally getting to a satisfactory level but, truth be told, if everyone is fit, I would say 9 players pick themselves — not just Baines, as someone mentioned.

We have cover all over the pitch (which is a first for ages) but the strongest team still consists of mostly the same faces, which is not necessarily a bad thing as they are very good players.

Only choices for me would be who partners Mirralas and Barkely behind Lukaku (any one of Pienaar, Delboy, Naismith). And who partners Barry in CM (any one of Gibson, McCarthy, Ozzie).

It's a tough one but I would not go with Ozzie (other options better) or Delboy (should hopefully have enough in Mirralas and Barkely). Gibbo vs McCarthy is a tough one, I'm inclined to start with Gibson (for his passing) and swap for McCarthy after an hour. Pienaar vs Naismith, pains me to say it but it would be harsh not to start with Naismith given he has scored a couple. Also Pienaar is just coming back from an injury so best to start him on the bench.

The barcodes are a bit schitzo at the moment and you're never sure which team will turn up. They have some top attaking players but are dodgy at the back. If we can keep the ball and our defence stays on top, then I fancy us winning this by a couple. Lukaku will be rubbing his hands...

Here's hoping anyway and I am looking forward to Everton going fourth / forth after this match. (Sorry for the pun!)

Now I just need Ross to finally get me some points for my fantasy team!!

Sam Higgins
36 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:38:50
I agree Andrew – this will be defining: win and we are right up there in it. We need to take advanatage of the strange results in the Prem at the weekend.

At the moment I think we are capable of beating anyone – and we have always enjoyed a good game against City plus Barry is nailed on to score in that one.

We have to make tonight count. And I don't like the Barcodes. And we still haven't forgotten Pardew's 'another league' comments.

Max Wilson
37 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:41:03
Hey Sam Hoare (#477), I don't think we'll see Pienaar tonight, he's still not 100%. Also there's some doubt we'll see Gibson and Barry together.

Don't know why. I hope , along with the majority of contributors to these columns, that Roberto has seen enough of Naismith to realise he's not a complete player. He's just been lucky to score twice. Any of the others would have done so too in his place. When is this guy going to lose us a game by failing to control a good pass? It's been happening. Everyone's been commenting on it . Get them on the break with Mirallas and Lukaku!

Wish I was there tonight.

Steve King
38 Posted 30/09/2013 at 14:53:35
Sam #541

Don't think Barry can play against city mate.

I just read the bbc's pre-match report and cant believe some of our statistics this year!! Make me wonder why I'm always so pessimistic!!

"Everton haven't conceded a league goal at home since Robson Kanu scored for Reading.
Seven hours and six minutes have since elapsed, with West Ham, Fulham, QPR, Manchester City, Stoke City, West Brom and Chelsea all drawing blanks.
In fact, only Wigan under Roberto Martinez have won at Goodison Park in 2013, and that was in the FA Cup. Everton are undefeated at home in the league this calendar year, a run of 11 matches."

Liam Reilly
39 Posted 30/09/2013 at 13:36:45
Cant see anyway Stones will be starting tonight David.

So far in the Premier League RM has brought change through gradually (which is ironic seeing he made 8 changes in the Cup) and I would expect close to the team that defeated West Ham.

I think this will be a tight game and for that reason I wouldn't expect to see Del at all unless we are chasing it with less that 15 mins to go.

Tony McNulty
40 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:00:19
Last year's game against this lot left me annoyed for several days:

- the Anichebe goal which was disallowed
- their dumb equaliser
- their manager's face

I know I will have to live with the third one of these tonight but it would be nice if the officials could get the big decisions right.

3-0

Brian Sharples
41 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:02:51
If Ossie is fit, he is a certain starter. Otherwise McCarthy will get a start. Bet he finds a way to get Naismith in there somewhere.
Paul David
42 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:08:15
Using Martinez's usual formation, I would go with

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
Gibson Barry
Deulofeu Barkley Mirallas
Lukaku

Newcastle are shit at the back and we need to get at them, not play Naismith cos he tracks back.

Tony Marsh
43 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:12:34
Please... No Osman or Naismith, start with the team that finished at West Ham.

Surely Osman has been found out by Martinez. Naismith is a trier but isn't worth a shirt. My bet tonight is we win 3-1 with Lukaku and Mirallas on the score sheet.

Newcastle are poor: they lost 3-2 at home to Hull last time out and Pardew is a Grade A Cockney Tosspot who models his quiffy hairstyle on Steve McLaren's dodgy Barnet.

Newcastle play their football at a different level to Everton, Pardew quote season before last — remember that?... Let's see tonight, Big Al.

Peter Cummings
44 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:13:45
Noticed the Man Utd fans website had many complaints saying 'We should be beating teams like this'... sound familiar?? Many of ours said exactly the same when West Brom came to Goodison and they got a deserved draw. On Saturday they were awesome and could have had four...

Again, the same is being said by a few that we 'should' beat the Magpies, so I for one will just be 'hoping' that we win. Nice to see the old badge featured on top of the page, keep it up there!

Susong Hermawan
45 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:32:21
No Osman please... Good luck senor, COYB!
Jimmy Sørheim
47 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:41:42
I would like to play 4-4-2 withLukaku and Kone on top.
Delfoue,Barry,Mcharthy,Mirallas
Baines,Distin,Jags,Coleman
Howard.

The reason for this formation is to up our chances of our strikers getting to find the net more then they have until now.

The current formastion being played is not yielding enough goals.

Right time to go for 4-4-2 in my view.

Ian Burns
48 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:49:22
Tony - 551 - Good call - we must start with the team which finished the game at West Ham. That second half was the best half of football we have played all season and it's not rocket science to see why we should pick up from there.

Interesting to see how RM plays this tonight.

Tony McNulty
49 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:51:03
Tony M - didn't he say they were in a different league?

With a bit of luck at the end of the season they will have their wish ... following their relegation.

Graham Mockford
50 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:45:14
Tony Marsh #551

I am afraid you maybe disappointed about Osman. I suspect it may well be the opposite in that Leon is exactly Martinez's type of player.
He retains possession, he links play well and he covers a lot of ground. I think if he is fit he will start ahead of Gibson or McCarthy.
Now I don't necessarily agree with that but he is a much better player than his detractors on this site give him credit for.
This is not a post to start a discussion about his ability but more my opinion that the manager fancies him as a player.

Viv Sharma
51 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:57:08
What's the deal with Koné? Was he just a bad buy or is he still struggling with fitness after his religious fasting? I would have thought he would have been starting to feature now.

Good thing we off-set his purchase with the sale of Big Vic, but I pray he starts to come good. I was excited about him but it's not looking great...

Raymond Fox
52 Posted 30/09/2013 at 15:29:31
Not a chance he'll start with Deulofeu, neither will Pienaar for me, think he'll pick Pauls team apart from McCarthy in place of Gibson and Naismith in place of Del Boy.
RM sees something in Naismith that most of us cant, (must be work like mad for the first half, and then I'll take you off)?
Kev Johnson
53 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:00:31
The question is: which half shall we play well in? The first half (like Fulham) or the second half (like West Ham)? Or will be get increasingly sophisticated and excel between 30 and 60 minutes?

It's often been said that football is a game of two halves - in our case, that's (a) the half we play like champions and (b) the half we play like relegation candidates.

Dave Lynch
54 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:10:05
We will batter these tonight. Trust me, I'm a nurse...

We will have far to much pace and strength for them and I predict a 3-0 win.

Come on you blue boyyyyyyyys........

Brian Harrison
55 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:00:01
I think we have already seen this season that nothing is guaranteed for any team and we are only 5/6 games into the season. Southampton winning at Liverpool, West Brom winning at Old Trafford and Villa coming from behind twice to beat City. I think the one thing that was common in these games was the team that took their chances won the game, its all very well having 75% of possession and creating loads of chances but failing to turn chances into goals can end up losing a game you should have won.

I think this applies to our game tonight we need to start in a high tempo and make sure we convert our chances when they come along. We all remember murdering them last year only for them to get an undeserved equaliser with virtually the last kick of the game.

James Martin
56 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:11:43
Tony remember Fellaini's was ruled out for offside as well even though it wasn't offside - we destroyed them that night and it was a huge travesty that we didn't get three points. Ultimately our CBs inability to deal with a long ball cost us the match.
Tony McNulty
57 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:26:06
James - you are correct. I must have repressed that memory (sometimes it's a useful skill for an Evertonian although less helpful at the approach of the wedding anniversary).

So it's four things that pissed me off that night.

I'll still go for 3-0 tonight though.

James Lauwervine
58 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:36:03
I think the team will be:
Howard
Coleman, Jags, Distin, Baines
Mirallas, Osman, Barry, Barkley, Naismith
Lukaku

I would prefer it to be:
Howard
Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines
Mirallas, McCarthy, Barry, Barkley, Deulofeu
Lukaku

Either way I'm looking forward to it!

Andy Meighan
59 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:36:00
Leung (#492) what are you basing that on? That Jelavic should get one more chance?

He's got 1 goal in his last 27 appearances... Lukaku scored in his 1st game after coming off the bench and totally turned the game on its head. Admittedly he's not going to do it all the time. But it's an absolute no-brainer to pick Romelu ahead of someone who just doesn't look like scoring.

I wouldn't have Jelavic in the squad; I'd have Kone on the bench to come on in case we're struggling (hope not). Jelavic couldn't really have one complaint if he's out of the squad or benched.... because his recent goal scoring record says it all.

David Booth
60 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:46:22
For the first time in many seasons, we seem to have an overwhelming consensus on our best XI:

Howard
Coleman, Jagielka, Distin, Baines
Barry, Barkley, Gibson or McCarthy
Mirallas, Lukaku, Deulofeu or Pienaar (in midfield)

Anyone who thinks Naismith or Osman should be anywhere but the bench is misguided. They do nothing but give us an Achilles heel and offer nothing other than being 'good triers'. I hope Martinez has got them sussed. Naismith's two goals might cloud his judgment, but really...

And Osman's injury ought to be the final straw that breaks the camel's back as far as his automatic selection is concerned. He has been a major factor in preventing us moving up that vital extra gear for far too long. I despaired when they both lined up against West Ham last weekend – and we got what we deserved with them both on the pitch.

Pienaar offers much more of everything Osman allegedly does: eg, gets stuck in, can pick a pass, has great energy, a will-to-win, is combative, and let's the opposition know he's there. So, if fit, Osman shouldn't get near the team now.

But that is to ignore Deulofeu, who has looked nothing short of sensational in his two cameo appearances so far. Get him in now, for me.

Barkley, playing behind Mirallas, Lukaku and Deulofeu: we haven't had that much of a threat since the mid-eighties!

Ajay Gopal
61 Posted 30/09/2013 at 16:55:14
I am strangely apprehensive about this match - can't put my finger on it, just that it looks like a lot of TWers are tempting fate by writing off Newcastle. I sincerely hope I am wrong and we bulldoze them, but .....
Paul Ferry
62 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:03:17
James - 573 - this I agree is the best blue team: Howard -
Coleman - Jagielka - Distin - Baines - Mirallas - McCarthy - Barry - Barkley - Deulofeu - Lukaku

I can't get last season's home barcode game out of my mind - 'orrid! This will not be a walk in the park; they have two or three class players I would kill to have at The Old Lady.

That said though I'm plumping for 7-1 (Lukaku - Barkley - Deulofeu (2) - Howard - Baines - Jelavic) 1 (Jagielka o.g.)

UP THE WORKERS

COYB

Michael Kenrick
63 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:02:41
David (#576),

I think it's a probably a good sign that your so-called Best XI lists XIII players...

... but this conviction that both Osman and Naismith will be dropped seems misplaced... unless injury intervenes. Personally, I hope you are right but, just in this short spell of games with Roberto in charge, I think we're starting to see a few patterns emerge. Just off the top of my head:

● Not making many changes to the team that performs well and/or gets results
● Showing a lot of faith in Osman and Naismith, at the expense of more dynamic alternatives
● Players declared fit but then not appearing in the team or on the bench
● Not giving all that much time to the potential talents of Stones and Deulofeu

I'll be very happy to find that these are down to short-term expediency, and hope we'll see progressive change going forward that will bring... exactly that on the field! More attacking football played at a higher tempo.

Carl Sanderson
64 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:03:55
We owe these bastards from last season. The most one-sided first half I have EVER seen. Two disallowed goals plus numerous near misses. That twat Pardew and his "footballing lesson" (West 'aaaaaaaam) and "different league" (Geordie Gobshites) comments. Those fucking oafs they call fans with their slavish adoration. That human space hopper of a Chairman. Fuck me, what a rogues' gallery.
Ian Burns
65 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:13:42
Ajay 577 - don't worry about being apprehensive, it's called being an Evertonian. The only time I wasn't apprehensive this season was the friendly against Accrington!

But relax, we will get home 2-1.

There you go another vote for a win - you can feel apprehensive again now!

Kevin Tully
66 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:19:37
What is wrong with Graeme Sharpe?

Just heard him on the radio saying it will be very difficult against a good Newcastle side, and we will do well to keep our unbeaten run intact.

It gave me flashbacks to someone recently departed.

He can fuck right off with all that 'woe is me' negative shite.

Paul Ferry
67 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:31:25
KT the demise of Sharp has been one of the saddest things over the last decade or so.
Carl Sanderson
68 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:29:34
Michael 580:

Deulofeu has got loads of ability, no question, but he is going to have to learn to track back and work the line.

Kevin Tully
69 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:35:46
Hey P.F. - remember all your stories from pre-season that had me green with envy?

Just called a cab for Goodison!

Ian Burns
70 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:36:59
Sharp's been listening to Ajay, 577 Kevin

Even if Sharp's believes it, he has no right to state it, he should be giving the club a lift not putting the nervous boot in before their bus has even turned up!

No confidence in the boss. He and Stubbs need a bit of a talking to.

COYB!

Ian Burns
71 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:40:46
Kev - 588 - you should have called one for Sharp!
Denis Richardson
72 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:22:02
Michael 580 - to be fair to David, he did chuck in a couple of 'or's so actually did have XI players....but who'e being picky.

I cannot wait for this game - I just cannot imagine anything other than 3 points. Am slightly amased at how confident I am but when I think of Lukaku against their shite defence, with Mirralas and Barkely behind, I just cannot see us not scoring 2 or 3. I really hope we take an early chance and then batter 'em.

Feels great to be confident before a game, rather than the usual angst!

2 hours and counting....

Paul Ferry
73 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:41:11
KT
F----i-- S---b-- -i---- -f ---t-
Ba----- --bs---e ---k --f
W----e-
James Flynn
74 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:15:45
David (576) - "Anyone who thinks Naismith or Osman should be anywhere but the bench is misguided".

Does that include our manager? Careful there.

And if anyone reads your post and saysa, "Personally, I hope you are right"? Well, me, I'll stick with our manager's decisions.

Hey, call me old-fashioned. I'll admit it.

Raymond Fox
75 Posted 30/09/2013 at 17:58:51
Kevin 585, I usually agree with your viewpoint but overconfidence is the biggest reasons Favs. get beat!

Sharps only nervous because he's desperate for us to win, I think were a better side than them, but RM will be saying much the same you can win this, but don't be complacent! go get em'

Harold Matthews
76 Posted 30/09/2013 at 18:36:27
Sharpe was never a laugh- a- minute type guy but he was a terrific player. Like me and many other long suffering Evertonians he is glass half empty with fingers crossed and he will never alter. It has become a way of life. May Roberto bring much needed joy into our lives.
James Martin
77 Posted 30/09/2013 at 19:08:50
Why is there always so much hate for Sharpe? When I hear him speak about games he often speaks the truth - it will be difficult tonight, these are a decent team any with Krul Tiote Cabaye Ben Arfa Remy and Cisse all fit of course will be, and we will have done well if we keep our unbeaten run going. Sharpe has never sugar-coated stuff, a bit like big Nev he was part of a great team so isn't about to eulogise one that isn't.
Dave Lynch
78 Posted 30/09/2013 at 19:15:19
James@613.

Does that include the. "We would have won that game under Moyes" quote after the Cardiff match.

He should show some respect toward Martinez instead of still kissing Moyes's arse.

Michael Kenrick
79 Posted 30/09/2013 at 19:20:38
We're closing this thread now, lads...

Please use the game thread.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb