TW Crest Poll result

, 1 October, 81comments  |  Jump to most recent
Over 4,000 ToffeeWeb readers cast their vote in our unofficial poll for their preferred crest from three options presented by the club.

The official vote for Everton's new crest closes at midnight on Tuesday 1st October but we at ToffeeWeb looked to gauge our readers' preference with a poll of our own.

As expected, Crest A, the most traditional of the choices, was overwhelmingly preferred to the other two options, garnering 72% of the 4,168 votes cast.

Everton will unveil the crest that received the most votes in the official Crest Vote on Thursday, 3rd October.  



Reader Comments (81)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Holden
1 Posted 01/10/2013 at 23:24:31
I voted for A but there's nothing wrong with the old crest, and if it aint broke....
Robert Collins
2 Posted 01/10/2013 at 23:36:53
If ain't broke don't fix it?

BK will probably sack Roberto next and start managing the team himself !!

Karl Masters
3 Posted 01/10/2013 at 23:29:56
I prefer A to the one we have had in recent years. Never liked the pale blue, dropped 7 or the 18, 78 and Everton floating outside the badge that Kenwright brought in in 2000.

I liked the traditional badge that disappeared 13 yearsago, but if the name Everton and founding date have to be on there A is acceptable for me.

It's a pity we have had to suffer this season's abomination and the Club could maybe have given more choice for the vote, but at least they saw sense over the Beehive crest and tried to put it right.

I would give them 1/10 for the beehive, but 8/10 for the final result which we all know will be A. Whilst 10/10 would have been better, the chances of pleasing everyone, especially the anti-everything brigade were always minuscule.

Rich Williams
4 Posted 01/10/2013 at 23:39:20
The new crest has actually grown on me, much cleaner and sharper and fitting for the modern age. I voted B. Been an Evertonian for 30 years, I know my history, just didn't see what all the fuss was about here. Credit to the club for putting on a vote.
Derek Knox
5 Posted 01/10/2013 at 23:48:14
It could turn out to be a milestone in the club's history ! At long last, the fan's are being recognised as entities, rather than being taken for granted as the lifeblood of the club, who turn up week after week, to pledge their support!

We are on the cusp of a new era at Everton, I have a feeling that this season will be the start of the revival!

Jim Lloyd
6 Posted 01/10/2013 at 23:57:25
I think 1 is the best of a bunch that ought to have been much better.
James Newcombe
7 Posted 02/10/2013 at 00:19:02
The current graphic has grown on me a bit now too. It looks really striking on the club website for example. It's not perfect but if we changed the yellow outline to white, and refined the tower drawing - just so it's less squat and not so cartoony... I think we'd have something better than any of these. I'm sure Crest A will do the job anyway.
Conor Skelly
8 Posted 02/10/2013 at 00:32:58
I actually love option ’A’ & I can’t wait to see it replace the current blob.
Garry Corgan
9 Posted 02/10/2013 at 01:01:28
Well those results are emphatic.

I believe option 'B' would have been the club's choice, given its simplicity and similarity to the current badge.

I do hope that the official poll was fair and that the results are not skewed, as in the questionable result of the Destination Kirkby poll.

Paul Kelly
10 Posted 02/10/2013 at 01:39:01
Still don't like any of them. Shit, rant over.
Conor Skelly
11 Posted 02/10/2013 at 01:50:48
The blue in Option B is visibly brighter and stands out in the middle of the 3 on the part where you vote.The club want B.
David Chait
12 Posted 02/10/2013 at 06:09:54
When looking at it here A is the clear choice.. But on the shirt I felt C was the sharpest and looked the best...
Phil Sammon
13 Posted 02/10/2013 at 07:14:13
I've not spoken to anybody that hasn't voted for 'A' and I'm glad to see these results on TW. It was interesting to see Martinez' choice and most of the players, they all wanted option 'A'.

If it doesn't get picked there's something dodgy going on.

Simon Smith
14 Posted 02/10/2013 at 07:20:50
So if nothing else it just goes to prove what a waste of money it was in the first place to change the crest without asking the fans first!
Of the 3 I voted for A) but in my eyes this was a completely useless exercise in the first place!! and it should have been left alone.
Mike Green
15 Posted 02/10/2013 at 07:40:24
Well - if thats not emphatic not much is.

I don't know how many will vote in the official poll but 72% of a 4,168 representative slice of Evertonians says that the new badge cant be anything other than A.

I voted for it, I like it, don't love it, will live with it but personally think its an opportunity missed.

The club could've done something really great here - but then they couldve done something equally awful too (as has been proven).

If it was a game of Blackjack I'd see this as being dealt 18 - and if so I'd "stick". Maybe next time we'll get dealt an Ace and a King.

Peter Foy
16 Posted 02/10/2013 at 07:48:26
Gerry,
I believe you've hit the nail on the head. It's gonna be B. Even though nobody voted for it.
I can't see how the fans favourite A is easier to reproduce than the proper one.
It would be a massive blow to fan relations if they do this. Not because choice B is shit but because they will have treated the fanbase like idiots again.
John Keating
17 Posted 02/10/2013 at 08:18:40
I voted A but I agree with David Chait.
On the shirt C looks quite good.
Kevin Jones
18 Posted 02/10/2013 at 08:32:19
Does It really matter what WE pick, if the clubs says A, B, or C then A,B, or C it will be. Whose going to know any different, figures can be altered to suit your agenda you know

just for the record I voted for C, because it's new, sharp and different to anything else we've had

Scott Hamilton
19 Posted 02/10/2013 at 09:12:27
The problem is whichever one is chosen, the club will put a 9 foot by 9 foot version of it on the shirt and it will look stupid!
Mike Rourke
20 Posted 02/10/2013 at 09:15:52
Garry, I wouldn't worry about the vote being skewed, as we can see option 'B' garnered 15% of the vote, if we extrapolate that figure over 1 million we arrive at a figure of 150,000 Evertonians! Clearly this is nearly 4 times the capacity of Goodison and as such the club are delighted to announce that option 'B' is a popular and worthy winner!
Tommy Gourlay
21 Posted 02/10/2013 at 09:19:01
Option A for me.

Like others have said - I am also beginning to like ASPECTS of the new badge. I like the modern design of it, but if they could've at least added the motto to still tick the history box.

It would have been nice if the motto was added a line at a time in the 'hoops' of the tower (like one of the fan suggested designs, I can't find the link to that article now)

Jason Ingham
22 Posted 02/10/2013 at 09:30:54
More people watch X-Factor on a Saturday night then any other show. The majority usually go with rubbish, which is excusable in this instance as rubbish was the only option.

By the time the vote was put on the options that came out, was anybody still bothered?

Ian Burns
23 Posted 02/10/2013 at 10:00:15
We were given three options - none of which were mind-blowingly good but it is all subjective anyway.

I voted "A" and I will be a little miffed if 72% is not carried through to the official vote.

Surely it will be "A" - won't it?

Lewis Barclay
24 Posted 02/10/2013 at 10:04:50
Oh god no!

This is the very reason why big companies appoint design agencies and they don't (usually) just ask the people that make purchases to "design their brand for them".
We will never compete with the likes of United, Chelsea, Barcelona or Real Madrid if our board doesn't grow a pair of balls, make some courageous decisions and stuck by them.

What an utter farce.

Noel Early
25 Posted 02/10/2013 at 10:53:44
I voted A but option 3 has really grown on me; it is modern and incorporates everything needed. I showed it to a few non-Blues and they all said 3 was the best by a mile. It's obvious what the club wanted. Roberto, Big Dunc all preferred A. So it's a given A is the option.

Good little sheep are we...

Mark Stone
26 Posted 02/10/2013 at 10:59:07
I agree with James and Rich (9 and 16, respectively).
Neil McKinney
27 Posted 02/10/2013 at 09:51:03
So we have a landslide on the ToffeeWeb poll. It will certainly be very fishy if the official vote turns up a different result. The result may not be as convincing but you'd still expect this poll to give a pretty good reflection of the fans preference.

I was uninspired by the three options, especially after seeing some really interesting efforts from fans, but I accept that everyone has different tastes so it would always be difficult to tick all boxes. When I saw these 3 options I instantly preferred A but then I found myself cherry picking bits I preferred from the other two. This then led to picking bits from other crest designs outside of the 3 vote options.

One thing I am sure about is that IMO the club name (if it must be included in the crest) looks better at the top of the crest, as in option B. I also think it would be better in capitals as it gives it a more symetrical look (but I note that the way it is currently portrayed on all the crests seems to be the existing preferred club branding as it is all over the website).

I just had a quick mess about using Option A as a base (excuse how crude they are but I was not using particularly advanced software and you will note I have no real talent for this type of thing) but I thought at least the start point met much of the club's brief. Whilst the banner under the crest makes many say "it's similar to the old one but not as good", I can see how it is simpler and the motto is more evenly spaced. The club name is included and I have used various different tower designs. The motto is on as is 1878 and the colour pallette is simple.

I guess this is the problem with design by committee, everyone will have a slightly different take and may want to change little things here and there even with a broadly popular design. I hated the current one and I don't hate option A, so if that's the one they pick then I will move on.

COYB

Matthew Tait
28 Posted 02/10/2013 at 12:13:22
I'm in the unsurprising minority who voted for option C.

All three of these designs are pretty boring to be honest. I can understand the desire of most fans to retain the traditional badge and something like option A is certainly the best way of doing that - option B looks unbalanced to me and I've never liked the yellow used in the badge either.

I do wish though that a more interesting and radical modern option was presented. As others have said, the fans put forward some interesting ideas doing away with a shield design entirely - using a circle, using large wreaths to frame the tower, or using an ultra-simplified design focused just on the tower. I would have liked to see something like that put up for consideration. Option C is the nearest attempt to do something a bit out of the box, but it's been pretty poorly executed unfortunately - what is the point of that white bit at the bottom of the shield? Strange.

I have to admit that I quite like the simplified approach Liverpool have taken to their crest, focused on the liver bird... it's a shame something similar wasn't put forward here. Though realistically fans would have probably voted for tradition anyway.

Drew Shortis
29 Posted 02/10/2013 at 12:32:45
I was not happy with the design of the current badge, although I did see what the club were aiming to do do with the redesign. It has grown on me a bit, but I will be very happy if option A is selected. Or last badge had become very dated looking with the 1990's style shading and dodgy yellow outline glow. It was about time we had a fresh one.

Option A contains all the components the fans wanted and is a clean, crisp design, though I still think the club should have stuck to their guns over the scroll which looks a bit too fussy, exactly what they wanted to get away from. Anyway, if A wins the vote I will be happy enough!

Daniel Starkey
30 Posted 02/10/2013 at 12:43:59
Getting shut of the yellow/amber is the priority for me so I'll be made up if it's that one.
Craig Walker
31 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:06:24
I would have liked to have seen 'EFC' rather than 'Everton'. I'd also have liked us to ditch the shield, keep all of the remaining elements and go for a circular design with 9 gold stars around the edge to denote how many times we've been top division league champions. These days, kids will grow up thinking Man City are a top side because of their 3 stars.

My favourite crest from our heritage was from the mid 80s with the tower, wreaths and EFC. Simple, elegant and timeless. Why do we need to spell out our name?

Ste Byn
32 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:16:13
I like most voted A. The only thing that gets me about it, is that little spike on the scroll, every time I see it I put the tip of my finger over the spike, and it looks ten times better, try it?

They could've quite easy on the old badge, just done away with the yellow and fitted 1878 and Everton in the shield, job done!

Richard Jones
33 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:14:55
Come on boys! this is another stunt by the board to stop us dealing with the real issues, such as the sale of the club / "finding investment " They've been doing it for years with pie-in-the-Skye ground moves, the infamous Everton place project and the badge issue. Its a deflective ploy to get us discussing anything but money and where its going to come from to put us back with the elite.
Neil McKinney
34 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:20:19
Craig 083 - I agree on the EFC rather than Everton. For me (and from comments it would appear many others), many of the designs put forward have been spoiled by tring to shoe horn in the club name.

However, whilst we as lifelong supporters may not require such signposting, I can understand the logic of wanting to include the name on the badge for marketing and recognition outside of the loyal fanbase. If we were winning things domestically and in Europe, season in season out, then we may not need to spell it out as success would surely build the brand regardless. Anyway, the club seem to have the inclusion of the full name 'Everton' as a non-negotiable part of the brief, so I have begrudgingly accepted it.

I've seen the league titles/stars idea before on comments but I'm not so sure. History is a wonderful thing and our club certainly has that in abundance, but surely the ultimate aim is to win more titles, so if the dream scenario occurs and we start to challenge for the league again regularly, do we add another star each time we win it? The three stars on Manchester City's badge don't represent league titles as far as I'm aware.

Point is it's all about opinions and I could even take my favourite crest from the multiple fan designs and still mess about with it forever, changing this and changing that. The current crest just left me cold and I'd definitely be happier with Option A above.

Denis Richardson
35 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:40:25
72% voting for A from 4k+ votes is pretty conclusive I would say. If the club now comes out saying that one of the other two designs has won then we know there is definitely a fix on.

I just about trust the club not to do this as it would just be too obvious a con. I guess only Kitbag has really lost out this season with the new badge, as merchandising income is presumably irrelevant to the club given the shite deal they signed with kitbag.

Eric Myles
36 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:48:04
Lewis #064, on this occassion I'm pretty happy that our board are farcical as I'd hate to be stuck with that insulting Mickey Mouse Clubhouse logo.
Craig Walker
37 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:56:58
Neil (089) - if/when we win the league, we simply add another star. It works for Brazil each time they win the world cup. I may have been mistaken about Man City's 3 stars then. Seems that they are only decorative. I think in Italy club football, 1 star denotes 10 league champions titles or something.
Matt Doyle
38 Posted 02/10/2013 at 13:51:48
None of these are good enough for Everton.

Ironic considering the reinstatement of the motto.

If the Nike kit deal really is the main driver behind these two recent redesigns, I would hope the club does not renew it once expired so that any future rebranding is carried out without the restrictions which have seemingly been placed on them, and which inexplicably don't seem to apply to other clubs. Hopefully then we'll get something of the quality befitting of Everton Football Club.

In the meantime we still have one of the worst crests in the Premiership.

Tommy Gourlay
39 Posted 02/10/2013 at 14:21:17
I mentioned earlier "It would have been nice if the motto was added a line at a time in the 'hoops' of the tower (like one of the fan suggested designs)". I've found the design I mentioned, it's number 18 on this page ....

http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/12-13/comment/edblog/24770.html

Roberto Birquet
40 Posted 02/10/2013 at 14:30:51
Where I think the club got it right on a new badge was that the old one was too busy. I think A is too busy. And I agree with another comment above: the club wants B; hence, it's brighter and word Everton is bolder.

It's simpler, but it hasn't grabbed me. I tend towards C as it's at least slimmer than A. Probably my favourite was when we were great: mid 80s. Much simpler, and with that - to me - seems more confident of who we are.

Vinny Garstrokes
41 Posted 02/10/2013 at 14:46:30
Can we move on please!
Albert Crocker
42 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:28:51
Some time ago someone, a printer I think, told us what the exact name of Everton blue is correctly called.

Anyone remember this? Can I get Dulux to knock up a few pots?

Eugene Ruane
43 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:21:51
Vinny (106) - "Can we move on please!"

Christ, I really thought we might have seen the back of this particularly irritating and pointless expression.

Please don't take this the wrong way, but take your 'move on' and shove it RIGHT up your arse.

Move on to WHAT ffs?

If YOU want to move on, fucking well move on.

Seriously, what is it with the (AHEM!) 'move on brigade'.

Instead of starting a thread, or ignoring a thread, they come on to a thread people are (obviously) interested in and plead (affects really whiny irritating voice) "Can we move on".

It's like a spoilt bleedin' kid.

"Don't talk about THAT - talk about stuff I want to talk about"

"And what's that?"

"I don't know, just....not this"

You can move on whenever you like, but when you're trying to drag everyone along with you, you're just begging to be told 'fuck off!'.

Imo.


Christopher Kelly
44 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:39:22
A
Neil McKinney
45 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:45:36
Eugene (117) - Totally agree. Never could quite get people who come on to a thread, that has a very self explanatory title, and then moan about the fact that people are discussing the topic at hand.

I understand if someone doesn't find this issue interesting or worthy of debate, but then why click on to a thread about it.

I said in my post that without loving it, if they pick option A then I will "move on" but I still see some merit in have a discussion.

Tommy Gourlay
46 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:47:09
I have to agree with Eugene here, it doesn't make sense Vinny to post your statement.

It's like asking the TV to immediately stop showing yet another reality programme that has just started on it, you don't do that, you change the channel.

So Vinny, I'm afraid you should change the article you are reading if you're sick of reading this one.

Matt Doyle
47 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:44:17
Albert (114)

I'm not sure the club have ever specified an exact CMYK value for Everton blue.

I did a bit of research on this when I was doing my own crest design. According to Wikipedia Royal blue can vary between the shades we associate with Everton and one that is almost navy, hence the colour of the home shirt changes from season to season but presumably still remains within the definition of 'royal blue'.

I can tell you that the gradient shades the club used on the 2000-2013 crest version sure ain't royal!

Lewis Barclay
48 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:57:53
Roberto Birquet #105

Exactly. The whole reason for changing the crest was to simplify and make it more transferable between mediums. Option A - just moves back to how it was with a large spend and lots of people's time wasted. Brilliant!

Phil Sammon
49 Posted 02/10/2013 at 15:58:35
Christopher Kelly #118

A stirring and succinct post. There's too much embellishment on this site. Finally a man who just says what everyone else is thinking.

Bravo.

Stuart Foster
50 Posted 02/10/2013 at 16:06:26
Re Denis, 092, the deal with Kitbag has already been revised. Under the old deal, kitbag lost money! The club have now taken back the commercial rights.

Also, Matt, 098, the crest design was nothing to do with kitbag/Nike, but the club. The kit for next season has already been designed - and it is Adidas

Lyndon Lloyd
51 Posted 02/10/2013 at 16:20:06
Albert (114), I recall the Club confirming the colour as "Reflex Blue" a few years ago during a home kit rollout.
Matt Doyle
52 Posted 02/10/2013 at 16:31:43
Stuart (127)
Don't mean to nit-pick but according to the club website Nike were involved -

"as well as the Everton fan-base, key commercial partners such as Kitbag and Nike were also consulted and their input and ideas were fed into the design process"

source: http://www.evertonfc.com/crestevolution.

Exactly how much meddling, ahem, input they had seems to be open for speculation.

Good news that the new shirts will be Adidas IMO, much prefer their designs to Nike at the moment.

Robert Collins
53 Posted 02/10/2013 at 16:39:43
Statistics, statistics and yet more lies!

I wouldn't be surprised if C is unveiled as the winner, we've been guided to our choice remember that, it wasn't a choose your own from many choices and the best one wins.

I can just imagine the club statement: "It was extremely close but C just by a nose .........."

Why the fuck would they need so many days after the poll has closed to process these votes and declare them? This isn't the general election with millions of votes and hundreds of different constituencies to declare.

Eugene Ruane
54 Posted 02/10/2013 at 16:56:22
Robert (136) - This being BK, I trust absolutely nothing he is involved with/in and consequently share your concern.

Anything other than A and it is a nailed-on fix.

Stuart Foster
55 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:04:52
Matt, maybe I should have said it wasn't initiated by these two. The idea to change came from the club
Robert Collins
56 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:05:32
Eugene Ruane @138

BK has some "Outs" with this badge choice, he can point out that most of the people on this forum are here to complain and grumble and went down the traditional route with A.

Whereas the greater and more open minded of the blue horde, have open minds and chose much more freely than us, hence the 'new cleaner easier on the eye' C badge was chosen.

He/they (corporate partners) want a badge that is easily identified by hormonal pubescent American schoolkids, to hell with what we want! We only pay their wages, what do we matter?

John Raftery
57 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:14:35
The vote is being conducted under the auspices of the Electoral Reform Services, an independent organisation which among other activities manages ballots for trade union elections. To suggest that the club could or would manipulate the result is completely wrong.
Kevin Jones
58 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:06:11
Eugene, you really have to move on about the whole move on thing mate. If you don't move about the move on thing then you won't be able to move on about other things other than the move on thing. And then where will you be.?

Unmoved I think

Now say to yourself 3 times taking a deep breath in between

" I can move on" In 3 Seconds exhale 7 seconds
" I can move on" In 3 Seconds exhale 7 seconds
" I can move on" In 3 Seconds exhale 7 seconds

And relax. There isn't that better.

My work here is done

Brent Stephens
60 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:25:09
John, I've posted before that I think Electoral Reform Services is not Electoral Reform Society and the latter is the well-known, independent organisation you're probably thinking of.

I don't know but I would guess the former is a for-profit organisation and the latter is a not-for-profit. Billy boy and another "cunning stunt" as they say?

Eugene Ruane
61 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:35:52
Kev (149) - "Eugene, you really have to move on about the whole move on thing mate. If you don't move about the move on thing then you won't be able to move on about other things other than the move on thing. And then where will you be?"

Well if I move on about the whole 'move on' thing then those who feel it ok to tell people to move on, may feel emboldened and continue to tell people to move on so I will continue to tell those who tell people to move on to fuck off.

Eugene Ruane
62 Posted 02/10/2013 at 17:47:06
Robert (147) - "BK has some "Outs" with this badge choice, he can point out that most of the people on this forum are here to complain and grumble and went down the traditional route with A."

I'm sure that would be an 'option' for him, but even if we're miserable, glass half-empty complainers (nb: who complain 'for the sake of it') he'd have to be at his most devious to go against 72% out have 4168.

Remember, the 22500 who shamed them into changing the beehive must have (at least on this issue) been thinking along similar lines to many TWers.

Garry Corgan
63 Posted 02/10/2013 at 18:25:18
John (148) and anybody else who thinks the club is 'above' manipulating the result to meet their own ends...

The very same 'Electoral Reform Services' were the company that oversaw the Destination Kirkby ballot (http://www.evertonfc.com/news/archive/ballot-result.html)

And I will always refuse to believe that 59% of balloted members said 'Yes' given the strength of opinion that permeated the entire Everton community at that time.

Brian Denton
64 Posted 02/10/2013 at 18:39:09
Hmmm, at best a draw on that one Eugene.
Kev Johnson
65 Posted 02/10/2013 at 18:55:17
How about instead of moving on we "move on up"? In the Curtis Mayfield sense, obviously, not in the M People sense - that would be ridiculous.
Robert Collins
66 Posted 02/10/2013 at 19:04:50
Just imagine if Roberto was not our spiritual leader and we still had Dour Davie, with the same old same old.

We'd be venting ourselves big time about these badges (and also about DM & BK), but as it is Roberto has given us all hope and we're all in jolly old mood and can't wait for the next game to come.

You've picked the right time to foist this one on us panto Billy!

Jon Beck
67 Posted 02/10/2013 at 19:07:15
A quick trawl of the Internet shows Electoral Reform Services was set up by the Electoral Reform Society to run ballots. The service is now independent with the society owning a minority shareholding. I'm sure they will be delighted to hear their reputation being disparaged on here so feel free to share your conspiracy theories with them directly along with supporting evidence. Badge A for me too by the way and whilst I don't believe we can really say ToffeeWeb is a true cross section of our support the result of the poll is likely to be indicative given the size of the majority.
Karl Masters
70 Posted 02/10/2013 at 19:20:27
If we are changing to adidas ( and I have heard that elsewhere as well ) I wonder what sort of deal we will be getting.

There's a lot of teams wearing adidas in the Premier League this season and with the exception of Chelsea ( who will get special treatment I'm sure ) it looks like they use an identikit design for most of them. Hull, West Brom and Sunderland all have the same shirt with funny looking blocks on the sleeves, just different colours and Stoke's shirt looks like Sunderland's.

Fulham have a weird looking ' le coq ' type collar, Chelsea have some rather odd socks and West Ham's is very fussy.

Having finally got a decent Nike kit this season, going to adidas will be a shame I think. Back in the day ( 20-30 years ago ) the 3 stripes were cool, but now they have become a bit of a badge for Chavs if truth be told. IMO of course!

Pete Dawson
74 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:15:33
Not a great choice... but... A!
John Raftery
75 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:15:33
Kev (167) Anyone who quotes the great Curtis Mayfield will always have my vote!
John Raftery
76 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:22:40
Brent (152) Yes, they are two different organisations. Reading the two websites the Electoral Reform Society seems to be an independent campaigning organisation whereas the Electoral Reform Services claim to be the UK's leading independent supplier of ballot and election services. The latter organisation is authorised as an independent scrutineer of voting by the UK Parliament. Given that their whole business is dependent on a reputation for integrity and independence I would be astonished if they would allow anything or anybody to undermine that reputation.
Joseph Bell
77 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:33:05
I suppose A is the best of a bad bunch. It still does not sit right with me though. Some of the fans creations are better (just Google "Everton fan badges").

Eugene – Well played, pal. I have a massive problem with people telling us to stop moaning. Why take the time to read our moaning to moan about it. Dear oh dear.

Kev Johnson
79 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:54:55
You can't beat a bit of Curtis, can you John. You simply cannot beat it.

Yours sincerely, Kev 'Superfly' Johnson

Jamie Morgan
80 Posted 02/10/2013 at 21:27:15
What a total waste of time! Keep the existing "club crest" we had last year and if anything put a stylish simple tower, reaths and EFC on the shirt similar to the mid-80s.

Dare I say it the shite got it right, keeping the club crest and simplifying the shirt.

Harold Matthews
81 Posted 02/10/2013 at 22:37:56
Didn't know about Adidas. For me it's one step too far.
Nick Armitage
82 Posted 02/10/2013 at 23:22:55
All the new ones are too cluttered.

The new one looks better and the club should have strapped a pair of bollocks on and kept it.

Eugene Ruane
83 Posted 02/10/2013 at 23:40:02
Nick Armitage (231) - "All the new ones are too cluttered. The new one looks better and the club should have strapped a pair of bollocks on and kept it"

I agree, too cluttered.

Same with those Canaletto paintings, why so many boats, buildings and people?

Couldn't he have simplified things - why not just one stylized feller, in a gondola by a walI?

(Jesus, the idea that there are Evertonians out there who would keep the Fisher Price beehive depresses the shite out of me)

Simon Smith
85 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:08:26
So the club has spoken and the A’s have it!!
Tony Fearns
87 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:42:49
I have gone off my initial choice A and would just like the old badge instead.
Brent Stephens
88 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:36:01
John #193. I was pretty sure that the well-known one is ER Society. Whenever I get anything to vote on (TU, building society linked etc) it's always through ER Society. ER Services does say on its website that it is authorised by the UK government but I'm not sure that tells me much.

However, Wikipedia says ER Services is a closely related organisation. So maybe you're right - if it's wrapped up with ER Society it can be trusted.

Brent Stephens
89 Posted 03/10/2013 at 10:27:38
EFC announced that it's A.
Michael Kenrick
113 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:31:59
Interesting how similar the TW results are (above) to the official voting percentages....

Jus sayin'


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb