Season › 2013-14 › News
McCarthy: Dream first start was an honour
'The fans were different class'
James McCarthy was elated after making his full home debut in the 3-2 win over Newcastle, describing his first Premier League start for the Blues in front of the Goodison faithful as an honour.The 22 year-old made his first appearance since joining Everton from Wigan Athletic as a substitute in the win over Chelsea on 14 September but was named in the starting XI for the first time in the League on Monday evening.
Playing alongside Gareth Barry in the centre of midfield, McCarthy helped the Blues roar to a 3-0 half-time lead and might have scored himself but for a save by Tim Krul to deny him midway through the first half.
“It was brilliant to get out there in front of the home fans,” McCarthy told evertontv. “It's what you dream of as a kid to come and play at such a big stadium like Goodison. The fans were different class and it was a real honour to get my first start, especially at home.”
The Irish international knows, though, that he will need to be on top of his game to keep a regular place in the side given the competition for places in that part of Roberto Martinez's side.
“Obviously there's Gareth [Barry] in there alongside me and Ross [Barkley] just in front. I really enjoyed it but I still need to keep my head down and carry on working hard, because it still comes down to day-to-day basics.”
The win over Alan Pardew's Magpies lifted Everton into fourth place and above Saturday's opponents, Manchester City, but McCarthy, who will be a good bet to start seeing as Barry will be ineligible to face his parent club, is under no illusions about the size of the task to stay there as the season wears on.
“Now we need to kick on,” he said. “It's three important points [against Newcastle] and the unbeaten record is still going. We're gelling as a squad and long may it continue.
“[Fourth is] where we want to be but it isn't easy. Every game we will keep working hard.”
Quotes or other material sourced from evertonfc.com
Reader Comments (52)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 02/10/2013 at 19:52:08
3 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:19:38
Also - he's Coleman's best mate - so we are more likely to keep them both while they are together.
4 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:22:15
5 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:10:59
If McCarthy enjoyed the atmosphere the other night, he's in for a treat when the crowd turns up.
BTW. Anyone else see shades of Paul Bracewell here? If he turns out to behalf as good, he'll be a great signing.
6 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:29:40
McCarthy was a player I was hoping we'd sign all summer, I hoped we would get him a little cheaper but he won't be on extortionate wages, and he's still young and will only get better IMO.
7 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:38:29
I'll be honest, the thought that we shelled out the best part of £20m on him and Kone is a little uncomfortable but I'm choosing to rationalise it with the belief that half of that investment is for now and the other half is what we will get out of him over the long term.
Specifically, I think he is the natural successor to Leon Osman. He doesn't have Ossie's talented feet (at least, not so far) but he is faster and more robust in the tackle and links play across the middle more efficiently and consistently. I think he'll ease Osman out of the first team over this season, make one of the midfield slots his own and we'll be better for it.
8 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:42:37
9 Posted 02/10/2013 at 20:29:40
McCarthy was a player I was hoping we'd sign all summer, I hoped we would get him a little cheaper but he won't be on extortionate wages, and he's still young and will only get better IMO.
10 Posted 02/10/2013 at 21:15:33
Age is on his side and he can only improve in our team... being Seamus's mate takes him halfway there already!
11 Posted 02/10/2013 at 21:17:44
If he's half the player....
13 Posted 02/10/2013 at 21:30:19
14 Posted 02/10/2013 at 21:02:45
He very nearly scored on his full debut, which I thought was excellent.
RM knew what he was buying and he's well experienced and will only get better at he's age.
If you look at Kones face on the extended highlights while the match is being played, he doesn't seem to be enjoying sitting on the bench while Lukaku is getting all the plaudits.
Pity for him, but he'll have to get use to it I'm thinking!
16 Posted 02/10/2013 at 21:46:48
Now that the disease that was Fellainitis has passed I'm looking forward to seeing more quick forward thinking football in the midfield like the last few games. Hopefully McCarthy can slot into the midfield machine well. With him Barry and Barkley we suddenly have a strong pacey (ok perhaps thats pushing it for Barry) midfield three who can all play. Maybe we won't get steamrolled in their by those yarddogs across the park in every derby now.
As an aside when Fellaini wa shere it was three draws - take him out the team and its three wins. how many games have Man U won since Fellaini went and clogged up their midfield? So glad his massive shackles are off our midfield for good.
17 Posted 02/10/2013 at 22:16:47
Negatives are probably not enough forward drive and sometimes a bit too ambitious with his passing. I think he has everything bar the aggression to really hurt teams, a bit too 'nice' - so in many ways his strengths could be his weaknesses.
But - he's 22 and I think we're going to get great enjoyment watching him become a very, very good player but probably not a "great" one.
18 Posted 02/10/2013 at 22:50:50
19 Posted 02/10/2013 at 23:13:22
20 Posted 02/10/2013 at 23:13:37
I am always dubious about a midfield built around one player like Newcastle are around Cabaye and we were around Mikky. With the latter, it meant that other players were played out of position (like Osman) and Baines was denied set piece responsibilities for 3 seasons. It may work when that one player is bang in form but if they are struggling your entire midfield is hamstrung.
I am actually quite happy that we have exchanged a very specific, fixed type of player like Fellaini for a player in the shape of McCarthy who can suit a system as opposed to dictate one.
21 Posted 02/10/2013 at 23:02:13
Well, I hope we'll see him. With no distinguishing features, he is hard to pick out and I have to keep looking for the number 16....and I'm not alone. Commentators miss him out on numerous occasions.
Jags can also be a bit like that. ..Holy cow. Who was that? Oh yeah, number 6, Jags.
22 Posted 03/10/2013 at 00:14:54
Yet those players are often huge to the team like Carsley, like Joe Parkinson. They do the work that, when absent, has us scratching our heads as to why we are on a losing streak and in the relegation zone.
Remember the season when Carsley was injured? We really struggled until he returned.
23 Posted 03/10/2013 at 00:42:17
Was not the same rhetoric directed at Felli when he first played for us, cost to much, won't fit into Premier league, no ball control, sold for 27.5 mill.
McCarthy had a decent game, new young kid, fit in, don't make any horrendous blunders, listen to the senior guys, he wasn't bought to be the immediate midfield boss, that will come later, meanwhile he plays for the team, learns off players like Barry and adds to his worth.
Last year that game would have been a draw at best, this year we will turn more draws into wins.
24 Posted 03/10/2013 at 01:03:49
He actually reminds me of a young Roy Keane, when United bought him for a record sum I hadn't seen anything of him when with Forest, although a certain Maradona said that he was the best young player he'd played against after a friendly game whilst he was still at Forest.
When he went to United he didn't seem to do much, but then when you watched him you saw what he did, read the game brilliantly, was always in the oppositions face, won almost all of his 50-50 tackles, never stopped moving, controlled the defensive midfield area and generally freed everyone else up to play the beautiful game.
I trust Martinez, and from what little I've seen of McCarthy so far I'm really excited that we have got our own Keane/Viera in the making. He's still only 22 years old and just been bought for $13 million! Imagine what he'll be like after a good run of games under his belt and playing with a bit more confidence, or better still with a bit of a swagger!
25 Posted 03/10/2013 at 01:31:11
Andrew. Very true. The unsung heroes. Hardly noticeable and not fully appreciated till they've gone.
26 Posted 03/10/2013 at 05:24:23
He is a more of a known quantity and actually established at premier league level than Fellaini was when he came to us for a higher price and in a simplistic view he is more than half as good as Felllaini if you compare the cost of both to their now employers.
27 Posted 03/10/2013 at 06:30:40
One subtle tactical point is that the advanced midfielders are left-biased as highlighted in Robbie Savage's piece on the BBC Football website:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/24339775
To me, this suits our players perfectly – and is a very clever adaptation by Roberto of his 3-4-3 last year, which also had a left-bias.
The anchor midfielders win it, or get it from the defence and either give it to Ross to play off Lukaku or neat triangles with the likes of Baines, Ossie/ Pienaar, or it goes wide to the right where Mirallas and Coleman have loads of space to put in crosses.
Can't remember a midfield shape I've liked so much in recent years: it promotes good carpet football, but also allows for fast counter-attacking and even direct out-balls to Lukaku and playing off the second ball. Having the personnel & options to play this way bodes well for the rest of the season.
McCarthy has been bought specifically to play in this role with Barry next to him. Barry is the insurance, and McCarthy provides the legs.
While Barry is fit, Gibson is relegated to third choice. But this at least means we can keep him in cotton wool. Once he's fit, Roberto can rotate the pair, which he will need to because Barry cant be flogged like a 25-year-old at his age – but I still see McCarthy being ever-present.
As has been said elsewhere; this is a transition season for many top teams, and others below are stronger and will nick points off them, so it's much more open.
I cant see us getting past City, Chelsea or Arsenal over a whole season, but anywhere from 4th to 7th place is realistic – it's between us, Man Utd, Spurs and the Shite – all 3 have greater resources (and usually have the referees as a 12th man) but in our favour we have a settled squad, genuine team spirit and a lack of European distractions.
If the players stay fit, and are feeling as bullish and confident as many of us, it's going to be a fun ride.
28 Posted 03/10/2013 at 08:19:08
I'm also very pleased with the new formation. For the past few years I have been groaning every time I saw us line up in the tired old 4-5-1. I have been longing for two up front, but this new system is even better as the Barkley, Mirallas, Lukaku combo is more dynamic and will give defences more of a headache. If you throw Colaman and Baines - Pienaar into the equation then we have a really exciting attacking element backed up by a solid back four - defensive midfield base.
Far from a season of transition this year may turn out to be our best chance to break into the top four for a long time!
29 Posted 03/10/2013 at 08:23:50
I see Juve are reported to have an interest in Lulu this morning.
Anyway this is a thread for McCarthy - the boy will do good and has made at least a half decent start if Monday is a sign of things to come.
30 Posted 03/10/2013 at 08:41:40
The best thing about it is that it frees up Ross to do what he's best at, without too many defensive responsibilities.
The lad McCarthy has been likened to quite a range of players on this thread: Bracewell, Carsley and Parkinson - even Keane and Viera, FFS! To me, what he does is fetch and carry. Fair enough, every team needs that, but I remain baffled as to why that low-level skill warrants such a high transfer fee.
Does anyone remember the Arsenal teams of George Graham? They had a succession of anonymous midfield fetch-and-carry players. The only one I can recall is David Hillier. Nothing players, really, but I suppose they did a valuable job because the team couldn't stop winning. The thing is, those lads cost next to nowt and just allowed the big name players to strut their funky stuff. That's my main reservation, that he cost so much.
31 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:05:53
I think McCarthy is much more than an average fetcher-carrier. I agree that every team needs this type of player, and James will do that job for us. The reason we paid a premium for him is that he is one of the best young players in that role and he has the potential to be outstanding. He's not a flair player who will catch the eye with regular defence splitting passes or mazy runs, but he passes the ball confidently and in a positive way (even passing sideways can help the team drive forwards!), has good pace, is tall enough to challenge in the air and can tackle. With Barry and McCarthy running the midfield the forward four and the wing backs will have much more freedom to attack.
Martinez knows him very well and he already has a lot of premier league (and SPL) experience for one so young (over 200 senior appearances and 18 caps at the age of 22!) and if he develops as we all hope he can we can look forwards to him being an integral part of our team for many years to come.
His tendency to be overlooked by commentators and his relatively anonymous media presence could be a positive thing for us. If he does develop as I'm sure he will I can't see him being pursued by the money clubs in the same way a flashy media darling Fellaini type player might be. Also, he seems genuinely thrilled to be at Everton and back with Martinez so I don't foresee him angling for a move away if he does turn into our Keane / Viera. I think he will be happy to get his head down and get on with his job without all the infuriating comments coming out from his agent.
32 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:36:44
I certainly think that "team balance" is an important and often undervalued idea. It's certainly not about having the best XI individuals. It's about having the best team. Hopefully, McCarthy can quietly play his part.
33 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:46:10
34 Posted 03/10/2013 at 09:55:27
35 Posted 03/10/2013 at 10:28:24
In my view he should at least be playing for the U-21 side in order to get him going again.
We have got big problems without Lukaku to say the least.
36 Posted 03/10/2013 at 10:40:32
P.S. Kone needs game time. Where? When? I haven't a clue tbh.
37 Posted 03/10/2013 at 11:20:58
38 Posted 03/10/2013 at 11:24:27
39 Posted 03/10/2013 at 10:54:12
For the most part, he didn't allow people time on the ball.
Peter Reid (and before anyone faints, I'm NOT saying "We've found a new...") did a lot of things very simply and one of those things, when the opposition had the ball, was to hurry them the fuck up.
To get right up get up their arse and MAKE them play it under pressure.
To keep them on the move.
I noticed McCarthy doing this a lot and was thinking 'GO ON, GET UP HIM!" (erm..type stuff).
He doesn't have to stick a foot in, or give daft fouls away, just stick to his man like glue and make him play a pass he doesn't want to play.
Yes it means working VERY hard but he's only 22 (so even if he's not Messi, there's no reason he shouldn't work as hard as Messi).
Anyone who saw Trevor Brooking play will think of a player who seemed to have time to receive the ball, look up and hit the 30 yard ball and to an extent, that was true (especially when West Ham were at home)
However when anyone decided to do a Reid on him, he was hopeless, might as well have not been on the park.
Not everyone in a team has to be doing the ("that's one for my compilation tape") 'showy-off' stuff, but If the lad works his nuts off every game and sticks to the simple stuff, I'll be happy.
The perfect team is players who can produce the amazing, playing alongside players who work like bastards for them.
Very early days but re McCarthy, for me, so far so good.
40 Posted 03/10/2013 at 11:43:56
McCarthy fits in the system, whilst Fellaini dictates one. McCarthy's inclusion makes our whole midfield a lot balanced, and his energy in playing further forward and back is going to be more important as time goes on.
Fellaini was a luxury player we could not afford. Although I believe James Martin's criticism of Fellaini is a little over the top, he did not fit in to the way we play. There is a system, where Fellaini can fit in and be unplayable, but that is so far and few between.
I think McCarthy has the potential to be our new creative player, but he needs to impose himself in games more. But he's only 22, and he seems very level headed, so I have no doubt he will succeed here.
41 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:04:03
http://whitehouseaddress.blogspot.co.uk/2012/07/why-water-carrier-is-essential-for.html
42 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:06:56
43 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:49:38
44 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:50:18
Indeed you are not alone Harold, this is a kid crying out for a perm or a mullet or dreadlocks or a fluorescent 'tache; I certainly feel more comfortable that we had a thirteen million quid player on our hands if he ditched the short back and sides.
Here's hoping he can emulate the greats mentioned above - regardless of his mop - but, with no great criticism intended, after two games he's not shown me anything to get overly excited about.
45 Posted 03/10/2013 at 13:15:47
46 Posted 03/10/2013 at 13:30:26
47 Posted 03/10/2013 at 14:10:00
Craig. Rodwell is exactly the same with City. Terrified of losing possession. For me , he is a different player when shoved forward and told to chase a goal.
48 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:04:44
That said, I'd rather be paying larger fees for players with potential than low fees for average players.
49 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:00:03
I agree with what you've said about McCarthy, he does appear to do the simple things very well (and not all players do this). We probably paid 3m over the odds for him, but I just wish some of the people on here would give him a chance, he's 22 and just joined his first big club.
I remember when Bainsey first came, would any of us say patience and time hasn't improved him at this club?
50 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:58:16
51 Posted 03/10/2013 at 18:47:12
I think at 22 he has a great deal of promise.
I remember watching Rodwell and thinking he had every attribute you'd want, all those mentioned above plus two equally good feet. The trouble was, he would never grab the game by the scruff of the neck. I think that's something McCarthy will do for us in time. He will be a great player for us for many years.
52 Posted 03/10/2013 at 19:01:25
53 Posted 03/10/2013 at 19:59:23
54 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:24:52
I thought McCarthy was excellent on Monday and given time will be a big player for us. Yes a big fee but when you think what others have paid for ordinary players its not that big
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 02/10/2013 at 19:47:41