Everton unveil new club crest

, 3 October, 84comments  |  Jump to most recent
Crest A is the clear choice in official vote

Manager Roberto Martinez wore the new crest on a training shirt this morning in this image tweeted by Director of Communications, Alan Meyers
Roberto Martinez unveiled the new Everton club crest at his press conference this morning, with Crest A garnering 78% of the votes in the club's official poll of supporters.

The design by Kenyon Fraser was the anecdotal favourite of the three choices from the outset and it will replace the controversial current badge at the end of this season.

Everton announced in May that they would be changing the badge they had revealed to fans at the end of the last season when it was met with a groundswell of opposition to the overall aesthetic and the omission of the club's famous Latin motto, Nil Satis Nisi Optimum.

Three new options were presented to Evertonians last month and the vote was opened up to the club's customer base where the first design, Crest A, was the clear winner.  



Reader Comments (84)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brent Stephens
1 Posted 03/10/2013 at 10:29:47
On the EFC website "The three options were produced following an extensive consolation [sic] phase during which around 20,000 Everton supporters provided guidance towards what they wanted to see from a new crest".

Director of Communications and he can't even check the speeling [sic].

James Marshall
2 Posted 03/10/2013 at 11:27:28
Unsurprisingly, the people of the People's Club have spoken and gone with the most traditional looking crest, thus in keeping with us being viewed as a traditional club with traditional values, which mean little in the modern era, but we'll stick with them any way, because it's important to 'know yer 'istory' because it's history that makes things great.

Zzzzzzzzzz....

I think the club should have just stuck with the new one, and said bollocks to the supporters because we need to modernise in every way. Just ask our manager.

A controversial view I know, but we're all entitled to an opinion, no matter what it might be.

Lakovos Lasonidis
3 Posted 03/10/2013 at 11:48:43
A is good, I like it.
James Marshall
4 Posted 03/10/2013 at 11:54:08
It's not really any different to anything that's gone before.

I don't dislike it, it's just a bit 'meh', as the kids say.

Eugene Ruane
5 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:16:25
James Marshall (297) - "I think the club should have just stuck with the new one, and said bollocks to the supporters because we need to modernise in every way. Just ask our manager"

Have you just woken up from a coma?

They DID 'just ask our manager' and (along with 78%) he voted A.

James Marshall
6 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:25:00
I mean they should have just stuck with the old/new one - as in, the one every hates = the reason this vote happened in the first place :-)

Apologies for not being clearer.

Steve Jones
7 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:21:35
James: "we're all entitled to an opinion, no matter what it might be"

...what you are missing James is that if your published opinion is indefensible or moronic then everyone who reads it is equally entitled to call you out on it or form an opinion of you based on what you've written.

In this case what you've said is that the club should steadfastly ignore the views of 20,000+ of its fans because of an unproven theory that the new crest will increase our appeal in new and emerging markets.
So you advocate jeopardising 20,000 existing traditional fans loyalty for the slight possibility that we may attract new fans from far, far away.

Are you sure that is the opinion you want to express?

Brian Denton
8 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:27:23
James Marshall, "Modernisation" (like "Reform", a word our politicians are also very fond of) is not synonymous with "Improvement".........
James Marshall
10 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:33:19
I guess what I really mean is that I think the newer, more modern crest was OK by me, and that all this vote has done is choose one that's basically the same as the older versions, which are thoroughly old-hat.

I'm of the opinion, that like many of the top European clubs, a more modern, and much simpler one would be a better idea moving forward.

Steve #311 a fair point about me saying bollocks to the supporters, which was a little rash.

Paul Mackie
11 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:41:16
James Marshall "all this vote has done is choose one that's basically the same as the older versions" - Spot on.

If the club had a reason for changing the crest (easier manufacturing, better global appeal, whatever) then they should have had the courage to stick to that change. For what it's worth I don't think the current badge (the one that caused all the fuss) is too bad. Placed next to other badges in the pre-season tournament it looked fine. It was simple and clean.

If I were in charge of the marketing department I'd just design a badge so that various parts can be added/subtracted depending on the purpose. So for example when it's showing during TV graphics it would be just the tower and the word Everton. On printed merchandise/side of Goodison it would have all the trimmings like the motto and the wreaths. Instead we now have a new badge that's almost identical to the old badge and is just as cluttered/difficult to manufacture. What an expensive exercise in achieving bollocks all.

Kev Johnson
12 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:48:18
"What an expensive exercise in achieving bollocks all." Well, that's consumer capitalism for ya!
James Marshall
13 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:49:34
Paul#322

You've just written exactly what I was thinking, but far better than I did!

I agree with your post in it's entirety.

Eugene Ruane
14 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:37:50

Thousands of those who (like me) voted for A, didn't do so because we thought it was great, but because out of the three choices put forward, it was (clearly) the best/least shite.

Relief not happiness is what I'm feeling and I won't be forgetting that there was NO need to change the badge we had.

Steve Jones
15 Posted 03/10/2013 at 12:57:13
The irony of this being here:

http://www1.skysports.com/football/teams/everton

...if you follow the link and scroll down to the 'Latest Squad' header you'll see the club crest below. Doesnt appear that they had so much trouble reproducing it?.

The new crest is a 60/40 compromise between what the fans want and what the club wants. The club has demonstrably listened here, which is a step forward...and something to be encouraged for the future, and both sides have taken away something of what they want out of the exercise. I'd call that a fair result and draw a line under it.

Eugene Ruane
16 Posted 03/10/2013 at 13:03:08
Steve Jones (311) - "what you are missing James is that if your published opinion is indefensible or moronic then everyone who reads it is equally entitled to call you out on it or form an opinion of you based on what you've written"

Well said, the (bar-room lawyer) cry of "Ahm entitled t' me opinion like" should have been stomped on the first time it was uttered (Eve: 'Just eat it Adam, nothin' will happen. I'm fuckin' entitled t'...")

There should imo be fines for anyone uttering this desperate losing an argument 'get-out'.

Judge: "Mr Krint, this is the third time you have appeared before me, each time for the same offence. And on each occasion you have been told you're ONLY entitled to your INFORMED opinion (whacks gavel) £200 fine and if you appear before me again, I can guarantee a custodial..."

Ben Dyke
17 Posted 03/10/2013 at 14:47:17
I was never up in arms about the new badge and actually agreed with trying to modernise, and that without the yellow outline and too cartoon like tower, in essence I liked the new badge. Which means I actually voted for B. I also knew that the majority preferred something a bit more traditional and that we would get A!

But at least I was heard and voted down so fair play to the club. It felt that little bit more like my club again in contrast to a lot of off-the-field nonsense by the club in recent years, not naming any names.

Alex Bonnar
18 Posted 03/10/2013 at 14:46:43
I demand a recount! Am I the only one who likes the one being used this season? Who the hell speaks/understands Latin nowadays? Even most Evertonians only know one phrase and few people around the world have any idea what it is all about. We need an international image to market.

Anyway only 4000+ voted for the latest badge - what happened to the 90% of supporters who did not bother or were unable to vote. Let's keep having another vote until I get my way. :)

Kevin Palmer
19 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:02:14
All three are stronger than the current re-design. The first, and winner of both the TW and official club poll, did what this year's redesign should have done. Retained all the main elements, eliminated the color gradation, and brought everything together within a single contiguous shape.

Basically, it takes what were problems with the previous badge, and fixes those problems without creating any new problems. So, well done. Should have happened 6 months ago, but better late than never!

James Lauwervine
20 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:12:59
Alex 353, no there's me and I think four other people globally, including the guy who designed it.
James Marshall
21 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:20:08
Paul's opinion on this (#322) still feels right to me. I like the simplicity of the new/hated one, even though it lacks various elements.

Someone also also mentions the Latin aspect, which is also dated as hell.

I think the club has shot itself in the foot over this, and should have stuck to it's guns and gone with the new/modern/simple crest.

Drew Shortis
22 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:30:24
Very happy with this outcome. The new badge has all of the elements the fans wanted to retain and it looks more up to date than our old one without being radically different. Saw it on Martinez's shirt in his latest press conference and it looked great. Interesting that the club got Martinez to unveil it. I guess its harder to rail against our smiling, unbeaten, manager than against the muppets who caused all of this mess in the first place. Perhaps they have learned something from this process.
Adam Luszniak
23 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:44:54
Well it won't set the world alight, and as can be seen already on this thread, it is a divisive issue. Having said that it is in my opinion, better than the current crest, and also better than the predecessor. The latter was crappy looking and I didn't like the use of yellow.

So I would say this is progress. Not perfect, but progress.

Mike Allison
24 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:48:27
Alex, its not about people speaking Latin. You yourself say "We need an international image to market." well the strongest part of our image is probably 'heritage' as exemplified by a Latin motto and a club badge that isn't simplistic, cartoon-like and akin to a corporate logo.
James Marshall
25 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:54:18
By the same token, Mike, our image needs changing. We're viewed by many as a bit of a dinosaur in many respects. A traditional little club & all that.

I'm all for modernising, and the crest is representative of our club. As someone said above, when you looked along the list of crests for the pre-season tournament, ours fitted in nicely. This one is just harping back to the 'good old days' which I don't think is a good idea any more.

David Pearl
26 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:49:02
Good to have made a decision on the crest and I do like it better than the old one and better than its replacement... but isn't a bit too early in the season to do this when it's just kicked off? I'd've thought after the New Year would've been better or as we are gearing down in our title push.
Eric Myles
27 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:53:41
Paul #322 "Placed next to other badges in the pre-season tournament it looked fine"

But placed next to the other badges in the EPL it looks like a joke.

Scott Hamilton
28 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:06:32
I don't dislike "crest A". It's just that you'd swear Mick Lyons was wearing a shirt with exactly that logo on it many, many years ago.

Maybe that's the point but for me it is definitely regression rather than progress.

Richard Reeves
29 Posted 03/10/2013 at 15:09:08
As mentioned above, a relief more than anything... but this whole re-branding exercise has been a total disaster. The reasons given for changing the badge were to include the name so we will become more recognisable abroad and to simplify it to make it easier to reproduce which would've possibly also made us more recognisable.(A) was the only option from my point of view but it is cluttered in design so only ticks the box of including the name.

I just hope one day, after the board (whoever they are......erm....yeh, I know) feel that the club is well recognised, can return to either of the badges from the last two decades, preferrably the 1990 version without the name.

The club should of focused on re-working the scroll, only slightly, to fit our name in, bottom centre of crest... but leave the rest alone or go for something simplistic, completely different but classy.

At the end of all this, I still have one question... why?

Brian Harrison
30 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:14:51
I can't see why we changed in the first place and understand even less the furor it has caused.

As for attracting new fans, as far as I am concerned, winning the league and European trophies is what attracts new fans.

Colin Grace
31 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:25:51
Will the Marketing Director do the honourable thing? The fans of The People's Club have spoken!
Steve Jones
32 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:25:07
Paul #322 "Placed next to other badges in the pre-season tournament it looked fine"

Placed on the front of a Fisher Price trike it looks pretty good too.

Drew Shortis
33 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:28:50
A nice badge won't win us new fans in emerging markets, only success on the pitch will. We now have a badge that the majority seem happy with. Time to put this fiasco behind us and concentrate on getting into the Champions League and winning trophies. That's how we will grow the clubs profile!
Paul Gladwell
34 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:32:01
That's right, James, let's go all modern, change the name of Goodison Park... maybe the kit colour as they are the modern things clubs are doing these days.

And your view that we are viewed as a dinosaur – well, many view us as something else; many other clubs' supporters out there do actually envy what we are about, hence how many like us as a second club.

Our heritage should be used, not thrown away just because some Far East clowns are doing that elsewhere to tin pot clubs. Do you see the biggest club in the world vamping up their badge down the M62?

Aiden Doyle
35 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:45:46
Yes, Paul. Yes I do:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2373176/Manchester-United-change-club-badge--Premier-League-clubs-crest-evolved.html

Brian Denton
36 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:46:32
Paul Gladwell - spot on. Even in bald marketing terms, our history is part of our 'brand' (shudder). It reminds me of the way I felt when Liverpool Museum turned itself into the meaningless 'World Museum' thus destroying at a stroke a 'brand' built up over generations. Somebody should have been sacked for that.
Paul Gladwell
37 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:50:52
Aiden, if that's 'vamping' I would hate to see you dolled up for a wedding! It's a change similar to what we have done to our badge over the past 30 years — not turning it into a bloody kids' shop badge.
Paul Gladwell
38 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:52:37
I read on one Sunderland site: "I hate Everton, everything they do is classy, the kit, the badge, the fans, the atmosphere at the Ground"

You would be surprised how many others feel similar; yes, we are old arses... but should we not embrace something very few have? Move forward, but use your past too as only us, Arsenal and a couple of others we all know have this.

Ian Burns
39 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:47:59
Eugene 328 has said it. It was a choice of 3, whether or not there was a better one out there - it was irrelevant.

Choice is subjective, everybody has an opinion, just as they do about Ossie and McCarthy, we all see things differently which makes the TW site the best read there is outside of Alexander Jack's Telling Tales on Kindle.

I agree with Paul - 382 - our tradition is important and it is who we are as EFC supporters.

However, there is just that little bit of unease inside this old head, which says "have we missed just a tad of an opportunity to take the club forward?".

But again, I agree, funds and a far greater number of fans who will generate cash from marketing our club will come from seeing a successful side on the pitch.

Over to you RM!

Aiden Doyle
40 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:02:33
Let's see. I'm in my forties and, in my lifetime, United have done away with the lion, the unicorn, the latin motto and all the archaic heraldic frippery, replaced the Lancastrian roses with footballs, simplified the badge, changed it's overall shape and introduced the Red Devil. How much of a makeover does it take to impress you Paul?
Paul Gladwell
41 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:08:16
Come off it Aiden, the badge now is similar to what it has been since I was a kid and I'm in my 40s, our badge we are getting shut of was laughed at by all outsiders, there is a difference from revamping to vandalism.
Graham Donnelly
42 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:18:52
Eugene (377) — could not agree more. A cop out for idiots, watch how many times the delightful Robbie Savage utters those words "Well, I'm entitled to my opinion," and pushing it through with a loud forceful voice as if to emphasise his little words of wisdom. The man is reason I stopped listening to 606.
Paul Gladwell
44 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:21:42
By the way Aiden don't believe everything that rag says, the devil was on their kit in the 70s and the other stuff was the Manchester coat of arms they use at cup finals and they still wear it on club blazers now.
Matty Williams
45 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:23:15
Thank fuck it's all over! Hopefully we can now concentrate on the season ahead. The new crest just now needs to go on the late 70s shirt from Umbro, minus the big floppy collars for the start of next season & that's me sorted. Yellow away shirt too, stay traditional like!!!
Barry Rathbone
46 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:24:15
Just logged on and read "Barry, don't be calling people kopites, please" from the eds. - quite right please accept my apologies.

Like the badge though.

Aiden Doyle
47 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:30:51
Paul, it doesn't matter how you cut it, the suggestion that United - a club whose sponsorship deal meant that they went the best part of a decade with Adidas football boots on their badge, by the way - would never mess with their heritage is demonstrably nonsense.
Paul Andrews
48 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:42:28
Can we put the crest away now and concentrate on the great start we have had under our new manager.
Eugene Ruane
49 Posted 03/10/2013 at 16:57:54
Paul (387) - "I read on one Sunderland site, " I hate Everton everything they do is classy, the kit the badge the fans the atmosphere at the Ground" you would be surprised how many others feel similar"

Exactly and I'm NOT surprised as I hear/see this all the time.

And this is why rather than throwing away history, we should be doing everything we can to not only keep it, but embrace it.

Ok so we might make a lot of 'if you know your history' but surely this is natural given all the stuff we don't have (money, trophies, £20m players etc).

Also, as you suggest, given all the new grounds, teams changing colours, badge changes, it is a point of difference for us to be the team that sticks to it's guns and isn't impressed by all that.

If everyone changes apart from us, we have two choices 1) Moan and say 'everyone else has a nice new stuff but not us' or 2) Say we're Everton FC, a real team who play in real ground in front of real supporters' - and you market the FUCK out of that.

The blue collar (pun intended) working man's team etc

Regarding 'modernising' I never see ANY actual solid logical or financial reasons given.

Just "We need to modernise" thrown out there or the even less specific 'we need to move forward'.

Plus nobody ever says HOW we modernise and how our present (spit) 'brand' (and supporters) would be affected if we did.

It is more than fair to suggest that this whole crest issue has shown that a large majority of Everton supporters DON'T want to modernise.

That most appear to have figured out that much of what is modernised in this world, glitters for five minutes but becomes tatty and old fashioned very fast (nb: see the shite 70s-style badges of loads of other teams)

Class, style and tradition on the other hand never go out of fashion.

Maybe things might be different if we were suddenly owned by billionaires who were throwing new grounds and state-of-the-art training facilities at us, but...they're not and while they're not, it's perfectly natural to take comfort in the things we DO have going for us.

In our case, history and tradition and for us to start chipping away at those things is, imo, lunacy.

Paul Gladwell
50 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:40:45
To be honest Aiden you are right there with that Adidas shout I will hold my hand up on that shout.
Paul Gladwell
51 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:46:24
Anyway I'm going down the old town in Albufiera now where all week alls I have seen is our badge everywhere on tops arms and legs, by a country mile more than any other club, dinasaurs, still roaming.
Dan Brierley
52 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:43:19
I can imagine kids up and down the country can't wait to pull on a shirt with that on the front... if this was in fact 1960.

What a huge step backwards, might as well sell choppers and parka jackets in the club shop.

Mike Green
53 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:52:13
We're going to win things wearing that, just wait and see.....

Raymond Fox
54 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:22:36
I agree with everyone who said that the main attraction for fans is undoubtedly a winning team. The problem is, these Marketing people have probably tons of information that the target group are mainly young and prefer a logo to be very modern!

They have given us fans a vote to decide which of the 3 we prefer, now I'll wager that the large % of voters were 35 to 80yrs of age and voted as I did for the finally chosen crest. It looks good to us, but maybe not to the people they are targeting?

Dan Brierley
55 Posted 03/10/2013 at 18:00:15
Ray Fox, you have nailed it in one. Whilst I fully understand the sentiments of those preferring a traditional badge, I'll bet you money that most of them don't even buy anything with said badge on it.

Steven Kendrew
56 Posted 03/10/2013 at 18:03:33
Sadly, like many aspects of the business side of the club, the whole logo issue appears to have been handled hurriedly and unprofessionally. The first new badge is just comedy. The 2014 new badge is fine and traditional and all that (which is important) but somewhat unadventurous in this day and age of global marketing.

The first new badge looks like something that the Apprentice candidates might have come up with in an hour during one of their tasks.

I think we have missed an opportunity to create something more modern and flexible for today's mad marketing world :-)

I voted B by the way.

COYB!

Tommy Meehan
57 Posted 03/10/2013 at 17:59:20
Raymond, these marketing people are probably confusing football clubs with chocolate bars. By that I mean they are extrapolating irrelevant marketing research regarding the latter onto the former. People start supporting clubs if they are successful, not because they have a crest that looks like a simpleton's name badge. All the graphs, flow charts and inane buzz words and phrases ('modernize', 'relevant', 'move forward', 'get to the next level', 'cleaner', 'streamline') in the world won't change that.
David Marsden
58 Posted 03/10/2013 at 19:19:52
I like the current one, as I have said before.
I am bored by the new one for next year. It's shite.
Ross Edwards
60 Posted 03/10/2013 at 20:07:06
So James, you prefer a Yankee Sheriff badge with an elf's hat in the middle then?
Seb Niemand
61 Posted 03/10/2013 at 20:08:09
That's more like it! I hope they keep the slight oversizing as well.
John Crawley
63 Posted 03/10/2013 at 20:14:37
Eugene has got it right I feel, we should be marketing the shit out of the fact that we are a traditional football club, with a history unmatched by ANYONE!

A few years ago I was in Boston and visited Fenway Park, plus the local shop. I was surprised by what I saw there, sure there were lots of modern items but the amount of memorabilia stretching back to 1901 when they were one of the original franchise's was amazing.

They had framed pictures of players dating right the way back. They really played it up, you could get statues, photo's, baseball cards of the old players. Now when I look at our memorabilia it looks just like everyone else's its like we don't have this amazing history and tradition stemming back to being founder members of the football league. We should be playing this up for all its worth, if the Americans are doing it then you know it makes marketing sense!

Lewis Barclay
64 Posted 03/10/2013 at 20:35:53
I look forward to this new less fiddly badge not being missrepresented in various mediums all over the world. Well worth the tens of thousands of pounds we no doubt spent on it.

This new badge that looks just like one from 13 years ago probably cost us the equivalent of a Seamus Coleman.

What a load of wank.

Joe McMahon
65 Posted 03/10/2013 at 20:45:56
James Marshall (297) - I'm kind of with you, but it is in keeping with an antiquated (Archibald Leitch) Goodison park. I just wish the Latin motto was dropped, because we haven't been the best for donkeys years.

How can a main stand built over 40 years ago have "Nothing but the best is good enough" in massive letters on it? That's like a Northern Geezer-bird telling you she's Dita Von Teese.
Dan Brierley
66 Posted 03/10/2013 at 21:08:17
"If the Americans are doing it then you know it makes marketing sense!"

Quite an ironic statement, John, considering it's the American sport 'franchises' that are the ones frequently giving up traditional badges and names for more modern and marketable versions.

Harold Matthews
67 Posted 03/10/2013 at 20:42:17
I ended up voting for B but fully understand why A came out on top. All but one of my grandchildren prefer the Beehive.
Alan Corken
68 Posted 03/10/2013 at 21:30:09
20,000 voted for the new boring badge? 40,000 cheered Moyes on his last day. It seems you can fool all of the people all of the time.
John Haldane
69 Posted 03/10/2013 at 22:43:33
Omnia mutantur nos et mutamur in illis.

As they say.

Mark Taylor
70 Posted 03/10/2013 at 22:32:47
The one chosen is OK and better than the aborted 'new ' version.

The world's most successful brands change that image and brand symbols at their peril, where they have a genuine and legitimate heritage. Try looking up and seeing how often Rolex have changed their logo in the past 50 years. Or BMW or Mercedes.

Whatever else Everton is, it is not a jonny come lately brand. We are not like a telecoms or IT brand. This club has the best heritage and history of any club currently in the EPL- that's only modest hyperbole, it is mostly true. This is powerful, albeit a latent power. Heritage matters in football, it is why Wembley means what it does, why English football is important. It's true we haven't exploited the potential of our brand (which is huge) but that is because of a complete lack of vison and ambition among our owners over recent decades.

I've seen this time and again with meek brand owners, lacking ambition and shying from real investment- oh, let's change the logo, that must be the problem.

No it bloody isn't, that's a cop out. And anyone thinking Everton needs to be positioned as a 'modern' club with a suitably hip logo and trendy font truly doesn't understand brands.

Tony Marsh
71 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:00:40
Why worry so much about the clubs crest? I don't get all the fuss. It's got Everton and the Latin motto on it and 1878,what more do you want?

This new one is better than the last one but not as good as the one before or the one we.had when blah blah blah.Its hardly worth fretting over is it?

Unlike EFC most other clubs have an image of there nickname on the clubs badge .Crystal Palace have a Crystal Palace and an Eagle on their badge, Arsenal have a Gun, Sheff Utd have a Blade, there's a whole lot of them out there.

Owls, Tigers, Blades, Eagles, Canaries, etc can you imagine if we had a massive Toffee in a wrapper on our club crest. Then you would have reason to worry. A huge butterscotch or Even the good old Everton mint slap in the middle were the tower is now.

Actually we should change the club badge again next season to incorporate the clubs nickname into the crest so we make other fans aware of who we are,after all we are the Toffees and so a Toffee should be on the badge.It makes sense to me. After all no one really knows what the tower on the badge represents unless they are an Everton fan so we might be missing a trick here.

See how silly this debate starts to get when we start to take it so seriously. Anyway I have never seen us play football this good until we got the so called Crappy new badge. Hmm maybe the Crappy new badge is our new lucky charm?

Eugene Ruane
72 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:03:50
Dan Brierley - does it ever occur to you that just throwing out an opinion without attempting to explain or justify it, adds absolutely nothing to the debate?

John Crawley (post 440) tells us of a visit to Fenway Park and of the type of historical merchandise on sale.

His point being that maybe history is valid and maybe the way forward.

Doesn't make him 'right' but it's an interesting point based on...something.

Your response - "Quite an ironic statement John, considering its the American sport 'franchises' that are the ones frequently giving up traditional badges and names for more modern and marketable versions"

Right, good, interesting, tell us more.

Oh..........................is that it?

Just a contradiction then, no articles or trends you can point to.

No figures or quotes - 'U.S sports marketing, traditional V none traditional'

So we're just supposed to go "Oh well Dan reckons they're frequently..."

In 406, as a counter-argument you confidently state..

"Whilst I fully understand the sentiments of those preferring a traditional badge, I'll bet you money that most of them don't even buy anything with said badge on it"

'I'll bet you money?

What the fuck does that even mean?

Seriously - how is one supposed to counter THAT?

"No you wouldn't" - 'I would!" - "You wouldn't!!"

Sorry but the level of debate at times is fucking woeful.

Paul Ferry
73 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:48:49
Sociological question: is Harold (453) the first ToffeeWebber to invoke her/his grandchildren to knock the point he himself is making?
Paul Ferry
74 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:50:42
Eugene - 480 - mate you're clearly not that familiar with the Brierley
style but actually reading between your lines I think you are!
Brian Denton
75 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:45:34
Mark Taylor 471 - an excellent summary of the point I was trying to make earlier. Another example you could throw in was when Coca Cola buggered about with its brand in 1985 and [quoting from Wikipedia]

"The American public's reaction to the change was negative and the new cola was a major marketing failure. The subsequent reintroduction of Coke's original formula, re-branded as "Coca-Cola Classic", resulted in a significant gain in sales."

Chad Schofield
76 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:41:10
Good, although, like Harold, I voted for B too.

Almost anything is better than the current horror show, and anyone who believes that the 13/14 badge is anything but a monstrosity is clearly a fool... just my opinion and anyone who has eyes.

Phil Smith
77 Posted 03/10/2013 at 23:03:25
Well, I have to agree with James Marshall and Paul Mackie. This has been somewhat of a waste of time and money. I had gotten used to the new badge. Liked some things about it, not all. I find the outcome of the vote totally predictable. Something classic, if a little cluttered. Voted B but found the 3 choices limited.

The point of vamping Everton into a modern brand (hate using that word in connection to sport b.t.w.) is a way to open up more in the US market, resulting in attracting the right type of investment at our club. Visited The States many times in the last 10 years. You just used to be able to buy Liverfool, Arsenal and Man U tops. Then Chelsea and Spurs crept in (and even Villa for some reason, while Martin O'Neil was there). Now you'll find Man City added to that list. We're a bigger club than most of those sides but you wouldn't know it over there. I also love Goodison to pieces but it can't stay in that state forever. Need hard cash...

What we should have done about the crest is asked the fans from the start. We are the people's club, are we not? ;)

Mike Green
78 Posted 04/10/2013 at 06:27:52
It's not perfect but I give it 8/10 - looks a bit 'bottom heavy' because of the motto and is too cluttered as many people have said.

BUT......when I look at Roberto wearing it in the photo above it does give me a tingle of pride. Our badge, our manager, our club. If people can get used to current badge in less than six months this one will be part of the furniture in no time and overall I think we'll come to love it.

It could've been better but knocked B and C right into touch as far as what EVERTONIANS want - I personally couldn't care less what anyone else wants - so all in all, can't wait to see it on the shirt, wreaths and all.

Mark Taylor
81 Posted 04/10/2013 at 10:19:48
Brian 484

New Coke was even worse, not just changing the logo but the recipe. Worse still, it was actually copying the competition (Pepsi) in being sweeter- a rare case of a dominant brand choosing to fight the battle on the enemy's territory.

Phil 491

The US market would be an interesting point. In my experience, Americans are a group hugely impressed by heritage, perhaps because their own is a little thinner. American tourists tend to make a beeline for heritage when they come over, Buck Palace, the Tower of London, Bath, Stratford, the Cotswolds and maybe add on Scotland or Ireland since so many see a family history there. To put it mildly, I would have thought there was space for one of the founding clubs of modern football.

If we are not well known there, which I don't doubt, don't blame the logo. I've yet to see a logo that promotes itself with no surrounding effort. The problem with our low presence in the US will be down to a lack of promotion, not our logo or positioning.

Conn Prosser
82 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:51:42
Christ, Eugene, not all of us joined he debating society. Or the bar?

My twopenneth, I think Mark Taylor #471 has nailed it.

On a broader topic, this will pan out as a feather in Kenwright's cap - albeit undeserved.

Dan Brierley
85 Posted 03/10/2013 at 21:54:03
Eugene Birkin QC ( I was very....very drunk), thanks for your excellent post. Now wipe the spittle off the screen, and take a bit more Bromzepam. You sometimes also remind me of a shit Alan Partridge. On acid.

I don't normally explain my posts to the nth degree, as in general we have very informed group of people that discuss subjects on ToffeeWeb, and are generally able to understand without insulting levels of detail. But I will make an exception for those, like yourself, that find it difficult to understand.

What I was not so subtly explaining to John (not even you by the way), was that if we were to follow the american style, we would probably called 'The Everton Raptors' now, and have an emblem of a tower with an intimidating face on it. Whilst there are undoubtedly some great things that come from American marketing, I don't agree that just because it is american, it means it is a good idea.

The second thing you seem to struggle with, is even more simple. 'I bet you money' is an english expression used to suggest a high level of confidence about certain things. Generally it has nothing to do with money, especially when used on a website with people you have never met. The point I am making, is that those that voted for the traditional badge, wont actually be buying anything with the badge on it. As Harold explained, the beehive is something far more in touch with kids who actually want products such as the shirts, butty boxes, wallpaper, bed covers, key rings, kit bags etc. So whilst traditionalism has been maintained through the badge, I believe we have essentially missed out on having a modern looking badge that has visual appeal to the younger generation. And the net result of this, is we sell less merchandise.

Colin Grierson
86 Posted 04/10/2013 at 20:22:26
How can anybody state with any degree of certainty that the current 'bee hive' effort is more marketable than the now chosen option 'A'? Without thorough market research this is a pointless debate. The only way we will recruit a new army of fans over and above those 'chosen' is if we experience success over a sustained period of time. We will then be 'lucky' enough to garner the support of the new generation of Norwegians (et al) who will abandon The shite and Manure for us! Be careful what you wish for! I for one am proud to be part of a 'select' band of supporters. Rant over!
Callum McNab
87 Posted 04/10/2013 at 21:37:07
In my opinion ( and only mine) I love the new badge. Especially the bit that says ,nil satis nisi optimum " nothing but the best will do " . I learnt that saying over fifty years ago,and it means as much to me now as it did then. Just like the Toffee girl and Z cars and our famous royal blue kit. I was one of the supporters who e mailed Everton at my disgust at the new badge, and the way they went about it. I stated that in my opinion Everton supporters believed in loyalty and our history,and that I thought the current board was disrespecting both. As I stated earlier ,it's only my opinion. But I for one , love the new badge.
Steve Jones
89 Posted 05/10/2013 at 02:19:42
"I believe we have essentially missed out on having a modern looking badge that has visual appeal to the younger generation."

There are 22,000 members of he younger generation 'turned on' to Everton merchandise by the current design, are there, Dan??? This is the rough number of current fans 'turned off' by the beehive and who are highly unlikely to have bought butty boxes for beloved offspring.

I believe that, instead, we have in fact rescued the bedrock of 'older generation' fans who, through their enthusiasm and demonstrable love for the club, distill that down into the following generations.

I'd say, by that example method, we end up with fans with a genuine emotional connection to the club. These being fans who're far more likely to stay loyal through adversity if compared to those who may have started to support the team just 'because the badge appealed to them'.

Callum McNab
91 Posted 05/10/2013 at 16:01:31
Well said Steve Jones.
Steven Astley
92 Posted 05/10/2013 at 16:36:26
James Marshall - I agree entirely with your opening posts, including saying that the club should have dug in on this one and said bollocks to all of the supporters.

The crest we currently have is something fresh and new - in stark contrast to the past and it kind of reflects what is going on on the football pitch under the new managers reign.

I'd say that our current crest has a slight resemblance to Arsenal & Chelsea's. Did their fans kick up such a fuss when they changed a few years back?

Steve Jones - #311 - 20,000+ fans signed the petition about the current crest, but yet only 13,000 bothered to vote. Says it all really.

I reckon, that now the season has started to bed in, if you started off another petition, you'd only gain half of the signatures.

I think it's a classic case of fans having a knee jerk reaction to something new and change that is all too often evident to see on this very website's mailbag and live Matchday Forums on this very website.

Colin Grierson
94 Posted 06/10/2013 at 07:34:32
Steven Astley - The changes that the club made to the badge were rather radical and upset a large proportion of fans who currently purchase merchandise, many of whom won't while we have this crest. If the club had dug their heels in it would have been financially disastrous as fans can be a stubborn lot.
The club could have offered the current badge as one option but that would have been pointless as next to nobody wants it.
The reasoning behind the modernisation is what baffles me. For merchandising purposes I believe using elements of the crest, such has been done with the TW logo, would not have caused a stir at all. Full crest on the kit and a cheaper to reproduce version on merchandise. We already do it on some of the leisure wear. Some consumers like logos emblazoned across their tops and others prefer subtlety. The official crest of the club should be steeped in history and be an important part of the identity of the club.
At Barcelona, all of the players, from the kids in the academy, to those who play in the first team could talk you through every element of the badge as it is part of the club's philosophy. I wonder how many of the players at Everton both in the academy and in the first team know what our motto stands for and could name the tower in the middle. I wonder if Deulofeu who could talk you throughout the Barca badge has a clue about his current club's crest? I also wonder if the Barca fans would stomach a new badge being unveiled without a thought for the traditions of the club.
Chad Schofield
95 Posted 11/10/2013 at 06:47:22
Bored as no EPL football I returned to this thread. Perhaps an option D with the centrepiece being Kenwright saluting while thrusting his flaccid penis into the face of the The Toffee Lady with a speech bubble from BK saying "Nothing but Mama Noblett's is good enough!" - so nothing gets lost in translation.

I guess that wouldn't be the child friendly though. A rebrand with Thomas the Tank Engine's there tune instead of Z Cars would have the kids flocking in... but then of course "you don't market dog food to dogs", otherwise Pedigree Chum would be called Interesting Anus, or something like that.

Some oeople think we should shed our historical roots, but I can't understand why they say that. They often seem to be the same people who talk about USPs (unique selling points) without having a clue what they're talking about just because it fits into their "overarching strategy" our whatever the latest bullshit management buzzword is flavour of the year. Probably to only to spend their vacation in Cotswold towns querying whether that's "real Cotswold stone" or where Buckinghan Pallace is so they can have cream tea with the Queen - well, that is whenever they can be bothered to glance up from their mobile device.

Send them off to Bolton... their stadium's named after an International sports brand and everything!

Or embrace our history.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb