Manchester City vs Everton

, 4 October, 120comments  |  Jump to most recent
Match Preview
Six games into the 2013-14 season, Everton remain the only unbeaten team in the Premier League as the frustration of three draws to start the campaign has given way to the immense satisfaction of recording three League wins on the bounce.

Monday's victory over Newcastle under the Goodison lights lifted the Blues into the familiar environs of the top four, a spot they held until Christmas last year after an unusually strong start under David Moyes, but they face their sternest test of Roberto Martinez's tenure so far when they travel to the Etihad Stadium to face Manchester City.

The deposed Champions replaced Roberto Mancini with Manuel Pellegrini and spent big over the summer, leading many oddsmakers to install them alongside Chelsea as hot favourites to challenge Manchester United for the Premier League Title this season. However, erratic form thus far means that Martinez's Everton sit above them in the table coming into this weekend's programme.

Successive defeats to Aston Villa last Saturday and Bayern Munich have checked City's progress on the domestic and European fronts and led many to question whether the malaise that afflicted Mancini's expensively-assembled but disjointed side remains a blight on the Pellegrini reign.

Though their dressing down by Bayern took place on their own turf at the Etihad Stadium, their last home game in the Premier League was a comprehensive dismantling of neighbours Manchester United  and there will likely be a forceful attempt by Pellegrini's men to make a statement of intent to get their season back on an even keel this weekend.

Martinez used his Thursday press conference to express that he is under no illusions about the size of the task that awaits his team but, by the same token, having seen off Chelsea already this season, his players will travel up the M62 with confidence that they can exploit any doubt in City's minds and spring a surprise. 

Everton will have to do without new central midfield linchpin, Gareth Barry, though, as the loanee is ineligible to face his parent club and with Darron Gibson struggling to attain 100% fitness after mostly recovering from a knee injury, Martinez may have to do some reorganising in midfield. 

He has options, however, including James McCarthy being asked to fill in as the holding midfielder alongside Leon Osman and deploying Steven Naismith wide right, or handing John Heitinga a rare appearance in the defensive midfield role and keeping McCarthy further forward.

Naismith may end up being a guaranteed starter anyway as Kevin Mirallas is a doubt after twisting his ankle taking a corner in the first half on Monday night but it's hard to see any changes in defence or up front.

This side of Manchester has been a relatively happy hunting ground for the Blues in recent years, of course, where they have won on four of their last six visits and might have triumphed again last season were it not for a scandalous decision by referee Lee Probert that gifted City an equaliser via the penalty spot.

What should be uppermost in Martinez's mind is that, if his team can get at City and strike early, they can hopefully unsettle them and grow further those seeds of self-doubt in the former Champions' minds. As Villa and Cardiff before them demonstrated, they can be vulnerable when seriously examined and there is opportunity there for Everton while Romelu Lukaku is on the prowl.

» Read more



Reader Comments (120)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jamie Barlow
1 Posted 04/10/2013 at 07:38:32
First goal in this game is huge.

Hopefully our recent record at their place wasn't down to the Moyes factor. It always seemed to be his biggest game against these lot.

Ged Simpson
2 Posted 04/10/2013 at 08:09:16
We will wallop them
Stuart Gray
3 Posted 04/10/2013 at 08:10:21
I think Barry is a big loss. I'd love to see us win there again, but I have a feeling that this could be the end of the unbeaten run.

But then I'm an Everton fan, I would think that wouldn't I?

Mark Palmer
4 Posted 04/10/2013 at 08:36:26
Had a dream last night we won 0-2. Now I'm not saying I have a gift but.......
Graham Mockford
5 Posted 04/10/2013 at 08:31:18
Will be really interested to see how RM sets the side up here, although with Barry out and Mirallas, Gibson and Pienaar all doubtful his hand may be forced in terms of personnel.
I would be worried if we are too open like the second half against Newcastle. City showed in the United game that if they are given the space to play in they have some very good players who can destroy you.
I think the role Barkley plays will be key. He will have to prepared to give a bit more defensively.
Still a 3-0 win puts us top of the league.
Brian Sharples
6 Posted 04/10/2013 at 08:41:10
I do so hope Gibbo is fit to replace Barry as too much disruption to Monday's set up may well see us floundering.

With both Gibson and Alcaraz proving to be almost permanent sick-notes it does pose some questions about the medicals they were subjected to on joining.

Has the Club so much money that it can afford to gamble c£50K a week on guys who contribute next to nothing due to their inability to stay fit?

Craig Fletcher
7 Posted 04/10/2013 at 08:50:54
I may be in the minority here but I think Heitinga should start as defensive midfield in Barry's absence; even more so if Gibson is still unfit.
Heitinga has generally done a reasonable job in that position before for us; it's been more as centre back where he has been bullied by big centre forwards of the ilk of Benteke.
No doubt City will have a go at us from the start, and I've a feeling Distin / Jags may be a bit more exposed if they have McCarthy / Osman in front of them.
With Lukaku, Barkley and Miralles we have goals in us but we'll need more of a defensive spine against a City team at home who will be hurting after their recent results.
Peter Laing
8 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:08:34
I would take the game to City and go with the following set-up :
Howard
Baines Distin Jagielka Coleman
Gibson
Osman Mc Carthy
Kone Lukaku Delefeou

If Mirallas is fit then play him ahead of Kone

Graham Mockford
9 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:13:53
Peter,

Why would you drop Barkley?

Col Wills
10 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:06:19
Brian,

It's nothing to do with the medicals – haven't you ever pulled a muscle or twisted your ankle when you're out "swinging ya pants"?

We knew what the score was with Gibbo when we bought him, that's why he was only £500k.

The Birdman has simply got a hernia which 70% of footballers get at some point.

They'll both do well for us in the coming months.

Phil Sammon
11 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:15:03
Peter

You'd leave out Barkley? Probably the most in-form player in the side. Madness.

Craig

I agree that Heitinga had looked better in midfield. Still not impressed though. I'd much rather he stayed on the bench tomorrow.

Derek Knox
12 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:16:02
I think a lot will depend on, who we have available, as fellow posters have said. Also, a major factor will be, how City approach it, they must be aware of their recent history against us. It will either galvanise them into making sure that our winning streak doesn't extend, or they could be a little wary, and be still smarting from Bayern's humbling of them.

It should be interesting all the same, I obviously hope we get the points, but I think maybe a draw could be viewed as a decent outcome, and still preserve the unbeaten record.

James Fletcher
13 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:36:42
Brian - agreed on those medicals. Particularly when they seemed capable of finding fault with a player who has played every game available since failing.......
Drew Shortis
14 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:28:01
Coming into this game the pressure is off us after our good start and with most pundits probably expecting a City win at home whilst they are under a lot of pressure to get a result after their slow start. This can only be a good thing for Everton and will allow us to have a go at them.

One thing worth bearing in mind is that despite all of Man City's resources they can only start with eleven players and at the moment our starting eleven looks like a match for most teams in this league. Over the course of a season it certainly pays to have a squad of the size and quality of City's but we shouldn't be overawed by them. I just hope that Gibson and Mirallas are passed fit as we stand a better chance with them on the pitch. It's a shame Barry is ineligible, but with Baines, Barkley and Lukaku in the team we have match winners. COYB!

Richard Dodd
15 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:39:39
Straight swap: Heitinga for Barry. If Mirallas is unfit (he is still to play a full 90 minutes since he came here) it's got to be Naismith over Del-Boy, if only for his work-rate.

I'm very confident of getting a result as long as we don't have to bear too many positional changes.

Sharabi Singh
16 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:32:16
I think Peter just forget about Barkley.

I'd start with Deloufeu if Mirallas isn't fit enough, I think he deserves more game time as always looks dangerous when he's come on also the city defence will be quite wounded after conceding 6 goals in their last 2 matches. Osman had a good game against Newcastle so depending on Gibbos fitness I think it's a banker on him and McCarthy starting on Saturday.
Would be great to go into the international break still in the top 4.
COYB

Dave Lynch
17 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:44:54
Depends on which Everton turn up !

The first half Newcastle team or the 2nd half Newcastle team. If its the former then we hav a great chance.

The 2nd half and we'll need snookers by half time.

Dan McKie
18 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:28:04
We need Mirallas fit. He, Barkley and Lukaku are our pace where it matters, and with the replacement being Naismith, it will slow us down. I would hope Martinez would be brave and just throw Deulefeu in, because 19 years old or not, he is 10 times the player of Naismith, and Man City wouldn't know what hit them.
Dan McKie
19 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:50:11
If we turn up with Ossie on the left, Naismith on the right, Deulefeu on the bench, and get tanked. I'll be one unhappy blue. Sin Miedo!!
Kevin Gillen
20 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:47:53
A big test for Martinez. We need to go out and surprise them. They have problems on the left side of their defence and have a goalkeeper under pressure. They might have a lot of possession at some points in the game but if we get the ball down and play some footy ourselves we could turn them over as we have done on numerous occasions. We need Barkley to find his shooting boots!
Kevin Tully
21 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:52:46
If City have to put in another shift in the first half, I can see a little tiredness creeping in after their midweek game.

We really need our new keep-ball approach to work, and cut out the sloppy passing, just giving the ball away in midfield will be our undoing here.

They will be extremely wary of Barkley & Lukaku, so they will have to worry about us going forward - something a 4-5-1 and a stranded striker never gave us.

Jim Bennings
22 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:57:43
I know this may sound odd but I would just go to try and score as many goals as possible, that is the best form of defence.
If we could get an early goal then you just never know their confidence may take a hit even further.
I don't think we can afford to sit and wait for them to create chances, this City team at home blows most sides away once they go a goal up so basically its waiting to be the slaughtered lamb.

Overall I do think this will be our first loss but we cant complain,probably only one or two sides are likely to take anything from Man City away this season.
We can only give it our best shot and there will be no regrets, just a shame its another bleeding Iinternational break next week so we cant instantly rectify the expected loss.

Drew Shortis
23 Posted 04/10/2013 at 09:57:46
This might be an ideal game for Delboy to start. He's raw, but he has no fear and could really upset the City defence with his direct running. I think it would be a bit of a gamble as he doesn't look like the type to get back and put in a defensive shift like Naismith. If we gamble with an attacking setup and manage to get our noses in front we can then bring on the workhorses to hold onto the lead. If I was in charge for this game (thank God I'm not!) I would go for the death or glory approach. If we go for it but fail there is no shame. We can't expect to play for a draw or defend for the whole 90 minutes, so lets just go for it!
Andrew Hawes
24 Posted 04/10/2013 at 10:06:42
Definitely have to attack this side, their defence is very poor. It'll be interesting to see Martinez's approach to these away games against top 4 sides as we know that Moyes was on damage limitation mode from the off!

Apart from another billion spent this season on players who have not set the Premier League alight and a good performance against a very poor Man Utd, why should we show them any more respect???

A decent result here and I will definitely start to believe that this could be our best season for years! COYB

Dan McKie
25 Posted 04/10/2013 at 10:20:47
Even the wins we have had against Man City recently have only been enjoyable after the final whistle. Generally on most days, they would have stuffed us and its been backs to the wall bar the odd attack. I remember Deulofeu legging it back to defend the other night against Newcastle, and even if he doesn't, their full back should be too worried about our counters to leave him alone for too long. The sooner we start seeing Lukaku, Barkley, Mirallas and Deulofeu on the pitch at the same time, the better.
Ian Burns
26 Posted 04/10/2013 at 10:37:50
RM has done OK so far, particularly his handling of Barkley.

Heitinga might not be a bad shout as defensive midfield alongside McCarthy but this is RM's moment.

If sin miedo really is his mantra then start with Deulofeu because we need to be at them from the first whistle otherwise they will start to regain confidence and a late appearance for Delboy if we are chasing the game would, in my very humble opinion, be an opportunity lost.

Michael Winstanley
27 Posted 04/10/2013 at 10:45:24
Just listened to Mirallas on the BBC, he reckons we're going there to win.
Drew O'Neall
28 Posted 04/10/2013 at 10:57:20
If Gibson is unfit Osman will drop in next to McCarthy, Naismith or Del will take the other wing position.

I would be very surprised he gave Del a chance unless he's spent all week working with him on the tactical brief (which is entirely conceivable) and believes he has the discipline to follow the gameplan.

There is a very specific way to play against City and Moyes knew what it was, RM does too but it requires a professional and disciplined performance from intelligent and experienced players.

Barry Rathbone
29 Posted 04/10/2013 at 11:10:06
After the Bayern whupping if anything can restore calm at the Etihad it's a win against their hoodoo - they will be frothing at the gums.

If we remain unbeaten something extraordinary is happening here.

Graham Mockford
30 Posted 04/10/2013 at 11:21:04
The midfield line up will be dependent on the fitness tests on Gibson and Mirallas.

If they are both fit I suspect he will go with a midfield of Gibson, McCarthy, Osman, Barkley and Mirallas.

If only one of them is fit Naismith will come in. If they are both out either Oviedo or Deulofeu will come in.

Mark Tanton
31 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:17:10
My team, and not by choice but a forced hand (who'd be Roberto?!)

Howard

Coleman
Jagielka
Distin
Baines

Deulofeu
Osman
McCarthy
Heitinga

Barkley

Lukaku

Mark Tanton
32 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:19:25
Whatever side we take, let's just take a gun to this fight please.
Paul Smith
33 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:28:05
If Mirallas and Gibson are both unfit I would be tempted to bring Oviedo in on the left to help Baines with Navas and also give young Gerard a go on the right but wary of Osman being overrun in midfield by Toure. If Gibson is fit he replaces Osman for me and Mirallas replaces young Gerard if he is fit. Personally would take a draw right now but we look a threat at the moment especially the 1st 70 minutes before Barkley seems to tire.
Peter Norris
34 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:39:35
If Gibbo and super kev are not fit I'd go with:
Tim
Stones, Jags,distin, Baines
Coleman, Jimmy Mac, Ossie, Oviedo/Naismith
Ross
Lukaku

Come on you Mightly Blues

Patrick Carty
36 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:16:57
I'm praying that Mirallas and Gibson pass their fitness tests. If Johnny plays in the middle, we would be over run as he is the slowest player I have ever seen.

I think they should scrap the rule of not playing against your parent club, it's ridiculous, they are professional footballers who should be playing every game.

If we play the strongest team we have at our disposal, we should go all-out attack and go for the win. My starting eleven:

Howard
Coleman
Baines
Jagielka
Distin
McCarthy
Gibson
Osman
Mirallas
Barkley
Lukaku.

If Mirallas and Gibson fail their fitness tests, I would be very happy to come away with a draw.

Conn Prosser
37 Posted 04/10/2013 at 12:24:56
We need to twat 'em. Not sure about Deulofeu starting, but I agree with other posters that it would be better to go in hard with GD and then bring Naismith on at half time for his defensive back up. I'm not confident about Osman in the middle, thus Heitinga is worth starting with.

It would be lovely to see Barkley recreate Fellaini's turning of a City player in the middle of the park.

This game has 3-2 or 4-2 to either team written all over it.

Sam Hoare
38 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:01:05
I'm just not sure about Deulofeu starting.

City are at home and will have real fire in their bellies. There's no way that they will not have a lot of the ball and having someone who does not care for following his man is very risky indeed. Would be more inclined if Mirallas is out to give Oviedo a chance (who has pace and discipline) and bring on Del Boy later on.

Really hope Gibson is fit as osman and McCarthy is a bit lightweight.

Hopefully we can field:

Howard
Coleman jagielka Distin Baines
Gibson McCarthy
Mirallas Barkley Kone
Lukaku

Think Jags will have to play a lot better if we are to leave with points.

Vince Hindson
39 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:08:12
I like the idea of talking about which team turns up from the Newcastle match; the first half team or the second half team?

I reckon if the first half team played the second half team for a full 90 minutes. the first half team would win 16:0.

...and I maybe have a little too much time on my hands.

Derek Knox
40 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:10:08
Conn #549

This game has 3-2 or 4-2 to either team written all over it.

I am a bit worried by this mate, the home score normally comes first, so can we say, 2-3 or 2-4 ?

I think we would all settle for that!

Conn Prosser
41 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:17:12
Absolutely derek. I'm through with predicting us to lose. Apologies all round!
Steve Jones
42 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:11:15
Yeah I'm not sure about starting Deulofeu either, but, like weve said about Ross you don't get the player until he starts getting the game-time. I think start him, to add an unsettling element for City, but have Oviedo on the bench to cover in case he gets out of his depth is the best compromise.

If Gibbo and Kev are out it gets tough...I think that point might be time for a little of that sin miedo stuff and to try something a bit different:

---------------------------Howard---------------------------------
---------------Jagielka---Heitinga---Distin------------------
Coleman-----------------------------------------------Baines
--------------------------McCarthy------------------------------
--------Osman------------------------------Deulofeu----------
------------------------------Barks-------------------------------
-------------------------Lukaku----------------------------------

Bench: Robles, Stones, Oviedo, Naismith, Jelavic, Kone

McCarthy needs backup so he doesnt get over-run by Toure so Heitinga can push up as needed. This setup allows us to overload left or right with the only real weak spot (assuming Deulofeu performs) being Ossie on the right and Seamus might just be strong enough to carry him.

Susong Hermawan
43 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:33:48
Good luck Bob, COYB!
Craig Walker
44 Posted 04/10/2013 at 13:33:22
Hope I'm not being too pessimistic but I see us losing this one 2-0. I think this is a far bigger game for City than it is for us. They have a formidable record at the Etihad in recent years. I would have fancied us more if it were at Goodison. At least we'll have Lukaku and we'll try to play some football. Would love us to win but can't see it. Hope I'm wrong.
Richard Reeves
45 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:03:15
I hope we hold out to the end and just nick a goal but I would be more than happy with a point.
Ian Burns
46 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:08:54
Craig - 562 - Por Favor - Sin Miedo!! - Vamos!!
James Lauwervine
47 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:20:48
I've predicted 3-1 to us and stand by it. I do hope Gibson can play though with Barry out.
Steve 557, if so then Gibbo for Heitinga and you may well have the 11, though I don't think he'll play that formation.
If we win this one things could start getting serious!
Sam Hoare
48 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:27:48
Wow, Steve. That IS bold.

A 2-1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1 formation by the look of it?

Mike Gwyer
49 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:26:50

Craig #562.

"this is a far bigger game for City than it is for us". Wow.

How do you work that out? The blue's are on the up, we are a proper footy team with proper fans. The Etihad is full of plastics who probably didn't even know that City were in division 2 around 2000 and when they finally arrived in the EPL they spent their entire pre Arab life fighting relegation. Pellegrini may want a win but ha fucking ha to that!!

How do you think Everton have stayed in top flight football for so many decades? Craig - no team wants to win more than Everton Football Club.

Gerry Quinn
50 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:41:27
You just can't beat his arrogance....Chelsea manager Jose Mourinho has a history of making interesting comments in the media and this morning's press conference ahead of the Blues clash with Norwich City this weekend was just as enticing to ponder as ever.

When asked whether he had any regrets as to having loaned out Romelu Lukaku to Everton this morning via his press conference aired on Chelsea TV, the Portuguese manager responded with, "it is one thing to play for Everton, another to play for Chelsea."

Anyone have any ideas as to what he meant?

Mark Taylor
51 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:17:54
I tend to agree with the article's author, that our best form of defence here will be attack. If we sit back with 10 men behind the ball, I think City will pick us off at their leisure. We need to put out a team capable of scoring goals.

This is not made easier by having so many injured or doubtful- if I have this correct, we are missing or likely to be missing Barry, Mirallas, Gibson and Pienaar- arguably close to a whole first choice midfield.

I think we may struggle to play through them so my thinking is to set up for counter attacking, with extreme pace up front. So I'd have Lukaku up front, flanked by Delboy and Kone (assuming he is fit)

I'd push Ross back into midfield alongside McCarthy and Heitinga- I think that gives us enough brawn to cope with Toure and co. I'd hope the threat of a counter with a lightning quick front 3 would be sufficient to make City think twice about overloading the flanks. I'd be hoping Ross can be the person who springs the counter.

This is high risk, no doubt about that, and may lead to a heavy defeat but I think it also gives us our best chance of winning if the ball breaks for us. I think we can almost afford to take this game as a no lose situation, play accordingly and hope City succumb to the nerves they are prone to, when facing a team they are supposed to beat.

In reality, what will probably happen is that Naismith will play instead of Delboy and Osman instead of Heitinga, Gibson or Stones instead of Kone and Ross in the usual attacking midfield position. In which case, I think we'll be heading for a 'comfortable' 2-0 defeat.

James Flynn
52 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:02:26
I don't get it. Why, exactly, should we be afraid of Man City?

They just surrendered 6 goals in their last 2 games and were dismantled, at home in a big game, this last.

How about an alternative view on Man City's thinking, "Well, we're going to take out our frustration on our next oppon... wait, it's Everton? Aw fuck!"

What, just me?

Oh, and I like the idea of Deulofeu starting. Let's go right at 'em. As far as I'm concerned, it's ONLY Man City. A first-rate club and no doubt about it. But no great threat to our boys these last several years. Go right at 'em and get the 3 points.

Gerry Quinn
53 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:50:36
Hoofball will be the answer to this match - KITAP1 scored by Lukaku
Mark Taylor
54 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:43:34
Gerry 571

Yes I think it means that while a club like Everton will work hard to make things work out for a player (god knows, the patience we've shown with Jelly) at Chelsea, team spirit is replaced with cliques and it is sink or swim time for forwards.

Post Drogba, they appear to have destroyed the progress of Torres, Ba, Moses, Sturridge and of course, Shevchenko.

It looks like they are on the same path with Lukaku, and things are not looking too rosy for Schurlle and the wingers, Marin, Willian and de Bruyne. Go back even further and you have Mutu and Crespo who both left as lesser players.

If Eto'o flops, it really will look like a forward's graveyard

Mark Taylor
55 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:01:37
James, if that was a response to me, then in a sense, you are only saying what I am saying, namely that our best chance lies in not showing them too much respect and setting up to do more than merely contain, but to go after them on the counter where, with all the injuries, I think our strenghts lie.

I think we sometimes do better against the 'bigger' teams precisely because there is perhaps a little less pressure or expectation, but we can then struggle against teams we're supposed to beat (ref: the first three matches this season and god knows how many over the last few seasons).

James Lauwervine
56 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:58:53
Gerry 571, I think he means that he's a deluded knobhead. We just beat them FFS. There's arrogance and there's plain stupidity.
It's also a very disrespectful comment.
Gerry Quinn
57 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:07:10
Disrespectful - you got it in one, James.

Clique - correct, Mark.

Never liked Mourinho, still can't see what's so special about him other than the way he gets mega-millions behind himself - a complete and utter prick of the highest order!

Steve King
58 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:10:08
I know its a bit off topic but I see that Dan Gosling just went to Blackpool on loan. Glad to see his treachery has paid off and his career is blossoming!!
Brian Sharples
60 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:15:58
Just had a thought. Don't get too many ! If Lukaku does as well for us as we hope he will,Could that encourage one of the European Champions clubs to make a massive offer for him in January and ,if so, could Chelsea accept that offer notwithstanding he is on loan to us until the end of the season?
Mike Allison
61 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:27:35
Brian that would depend on the loan agreement but its very, very unlikely. There will be people who come on here and say something along the lines of 'Kenwright is so stupid that...' but I think you can safely assume he is ours until the end of the season, we have that right under the loan agreement.

The only thing that has occurred to me, and it is entirely without precedent, is that someone might try to buy our rights off us. Meaning we could receive a fee, either from Chelsea or someone trying to buy him, for allowing his loan to finish early. This is also unlikely, and has never happened before, but imagine being given say £5M just for letting them have their own player back.

Mike Allison
62 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:36:26
Steve, Gosling was never good enough anyway. I at no point gave a shit that he'd left us for Newcastle.
Max Wilson
63 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:38:18
Steve Jones (557) for Assistant manager! He's picked the best team without a doubt. But we all know we'll see Naismith for some reason.Don't know why he's picked Jellybaby for the bench though.Why not Hallam Hope? Anyway, this will be a huge test for us without our best midfield players and if we come away with a clean sheet or a point I think we'll have done well . Sorry to be a bit neg.
Of course if my mate Chris and I went to the match we'd win because everytime we attend, we win. Perhaps we ought to as a special service.
But we've got a carriage driving rally the following day and our women wont let us off the leash.
James Lauwervine
64 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:42:41
Agree Mike 587, even his famous goal was a bit on the flukey side. Bloody loved him for it at the time though. I think without that goal he would never again figure in an Evertonian's thoughts.
Brian Harrison
65 Posted 04/10/2013 at 15:39:01
I think Lukaku is brilliant and will enjoy his season long loan. As for Jose commenting on Lukaku in his press conference saying its one thing to play for Everton and a completely different matter playing for Chelsea. Well Paul Merson said exactly the same thing last Saturday, his take on it was many teams will come and attack Everton which gives Lukaku extra room but against Chelsea many teams play 10 men behind the ball and that Lukaku wouldn't have the same space to work in.

I don't agree with this but I can well understand were Merson and Mourhino are coming from. I think Mourinhos record in winning 2 champions league titles with 2 different clubs means his views should be listened too.

Raymond Fox
66 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:48:43
I don't think you can start Deulofeu he's too much of a passenger in defence.

I'd start with:-
Howard
Coleman Jags Distin Baines
Gibson Barkley McCarthy
Osman
Mirallas Lukaku
If Gibson not fit, Stones to right back and Coleman goes in midfield.
If Mirallas also not fit, play Kone or Naismith.
I honestly don't have a clue how this game will pan out! But I know one thing, their going to be very wary of our attack as well, more so if Mirallas is fit.
Aquero is a great player, one of the best I've seen, so we need to keep him quiet.
I think I have to favour a home win by 1 goal, but who knows, if we can get off to a good start!

Might come down to which manager has the best game plan.

Harold Matthews
68 Posted 04/10/2013 at 14:22:45
Wish I could be as confident as Martinez and most of the posts on this thread but with Barry absent and the likely inclusion of half fit crocks, I'll probably watch the match, kneeling in prayer, from behind the sofa.

As Barry Rathbone suggests above. "If we remain unbeaten, something extraordinary is happening here." Nice one Barry. Great line. Made me chuckle.

Well, looking at the league and the Newcastle first 45 minutes, something extraordinary is definitely happening here but Martinez says he is still studying players and partnerships and will probably need the January window to strengthen areas of weakness.

Quite frankly, I haven't a clue about the City game but, win or lose, I'm hoping for a decent performance.

Tahir Abdullah
70 Posted 04/10/2013 at 16:35:46
Tough one it will be indeed. Man C will be smarting after the humiliation at the hands of the Lords of Bavaria in midweek and will have a massive score to settle (with their detractors, not necessarily EFC). In the heat of battle (which this match will no doubt boil down to) we will need cool, seasoned operators who are willing to work their socks off from first to last whistle. That excludes Delboy for me; he is no doubt talented, but lacks the work ethic and team focus to start this match. In Barry's absence, Heitinga is the obvious inclusion (disrupting our back 4 to include Stones at RB and to move Seamus to midfield will be counterproductive IMO) as he has very rarely disappointed in the DM role. Heitinga also has a not-shite eye for a pass. As for Kev, I would not start him if there is even the remotest chance of him being unfit; Kev at anything less than full fitness has rarely failed to be anything but a liability on match day. As much as it pains me to say this, I would opt for Nais as direct replacement for Kev; the lad is no doubt limited in ability but will always work his socks off (which for sure will come in handy tomorrow). Win or lose though, I am 100% behind my beloved Blues. NSNO, COYB
Ross Edwards
71 Posted 04/10/2013 at 17:09:35
I think the ones crying foul at Mourinho's comment need to chill out a little.

There is more pressure for him to score at Chelsea than at Everton. If he scores 10-15 goals here, next season Mourinho would want him to score 20 and so on.

Ross Edwards
72 Posted 04/10/2013 at 17:13:43
Their defence is utterly abysmal. Hull could have scored 2 or 3 when they went there. It seems a direct style helped Villa to score 3, and Hull seemed to create a lot of chances through long balls from defence.

So, long passes to Lukaku may be City's undoing.

I'm not advocating KITAP1, Moyesist football, I just think it's effective use may trouble their defence.

Matty Williams
73 Posted 04/10/2013 at 16:37:36
Nailed on draw for me. City will come out firing, if we can hold our own and counter with more pace than we've shown already then we have a good chance of getting through and remain still unbeaten.

Just a pity we'll have international matches to contend with, another fucking boring weekend hoping our lads don't get crocked in some piss-poor meaningless match.

I predict 2~2 final score! COYB
Tom Dodds
74 Posted 04/10/2013 at 16:58:50
Fancy Mourhino making a statement about Lukaku being in a different league of club when with Everton than Chelsea after we'd just beaten them without him !...EH ??

The arrogance of these 'spoilt bastard' villain/planet's oil resourced guardians by defaulting 'Sheiks' et al backed multi-billionaired sugar-daddy-owned club's managers ....beggers fuckin belief.

This particular tosser was bribed on his last birthday to come to Chelsea with a brand new Ferrari, and millions more by 'Blowfeld'.
Steve Guy
75 Posted 04/10/2013 at 17:41:28
This will be w
John Ford
76 Posted 04/10/2013 at 17:37:06
I'll take the draw, now please. They're going to be gagging for this.

A win however would send a whopping message.

Steve Guy
77 Posted 04/10/2013 at 17:41:57
This will be win or lost in midfield and I worry for us in that regard. MacCarthy still bedding in and Gibson not match fit if he plays at all. Hope however springs eternal !
Keith Young
78 Posted 04/10/2013 at 18:26:49
Gerry # 571 I think you will find The Pensioners ( Chelsea) are playing Norwich the Blues are playing Manchester City. Please let us fight back for our brand. Remember once a Blue always a Blue is EVERTON
Paul Ferry
79 Posted 04/10/2013 at 18:45:58
If EFC are still unbeaten come 8-45AM Chicago time tomorrow: (1) something special is flickering at EFC (2) the premiership will stand up and take very serious notice (3) we are taking on the look and shape of a potential top-4 team (4) Martinez deserve a heal load of praise (5) Entwhistelers and anyone else who - yawn - has yet to throw their Moyes toys out of the pram had better start respecting what Martinez is doing.

If all of them are fit: Howard - Coleman - Distin - dodgy Jagielka - Baines - Gibson - McCarthy - Mirallas Delefeou - Barkley - Lukaku

I think this might be an ideal game for Delefeou and I know many disagree about that but I just have a feeling - that's all it is - that he is suited to this sort of game.

Brian Sharples
80 Posted 04/10/2013 at 19:37:00
Hate to piss on chips but as the article above clearly states, we were well in contention (top 4) going into the Christmas break last year, so even a win tomorrow can mean only that the team is showing good form AT THE MOMENT.

How that impacts on what happens later is an entirely different matter.

Vince Hindson
81 Posted 04/10/2013 at 20:34:11
At what point would the press actually take us seriously? When we have been at the top at Christmas, they look upon us as a mild irritant. Even when we did finish in the top 4 the press were immersed in the success of our loveable neighbours.

I'm afraid we just don't fit the script so it's easier to ignore us than for them to rewrite / update the script.

Having said that I'm usually okay with us dipping under the radar.

Graham Mockford
82 Posted 04/10/2013 at 20:37:48
Paul Ferry,

So you wouldn't play Osman?

Don't bother answering because I'm bored of the debate, but I would bet my house he is in the starting line up.

Peter Cummings
83 Posted 04/10/2013 at 21:39:17
Hardly any mention of Barkley v City. He could be our ace in the hole with his ball control and shoot on sight attitude, shown by Bayern.

Would like to see Delboy start and give Jeli another go alongside Luke to give Kompany a hard time. Risky to play Gibbo until he's fully fit.

A tough game but we can stay unbeaten. have to get up early game starts at 7-45 am for we expats. Give 'Em Hell boys.
Paul Andrews
84 Posted 04/10/2013 at 22:00:41
I am surprised that a few of you are surprised when Moutinho makes a c**tish statement.
He has to say something smartarse on a daily basis.
If he was a mars bar he would eat himself.
Brent Stephens
85 Posted 04/10/2013 at 22:04:33
Paul #668 "If he was a mars bar he would eat himself".

Cracker. I guess that as he's a prick he could also go...

Andy Meighan
86 Posted 04/10/2013 at 22:08:08
Jim (#525) you say they blow most teams away at home and while that's true in some respects, I watched them against Hull a few weeks ago and thought they looked quite ordinary. Hull were unlucky not to take a point. Having said that, they were awesome against Man Utd.

But, coming off the back of two bad defeats, the pressure is on them to win well. Could be a good thing for us. I'd be more than happy with a point but delirious if we won — but please no Neitinga or Naismith in midfield!!!

Chern Lee
88 Posted 04/10/2013 at 22:52:17
Does anyone know if Hibbert is fit again ?

Assuming Mirallas and Gibson are out, how about this team to face Man Shitty:

Howard
Hibbert Jagielka Distin Baines
Coleman McCarthy Osman Oviedo
Barkley
Lukaku

Mick Davies
90 Posted 04/10/2013 at 22:34:10
Just a couple of points re previous posts; Gosling ditched us knowing he was depriving us, and struggling Plymouth, of much needed cash. Then the slimy toe rag gets away with tipping a goal bound shot that would have won us the game, around the post with his hand, so that erases any credit for THAT goal.

As for the mouthy Mourinho, how difficult is it to manage multi-billionaire clubs with top coaches like Steve Clarke, nutritionists, psychologists, space age training facilities, unlimited transfer funds etc. How would he have coped at Wigan or Swansea when they were in the lower divisions? He's just a jumped up translator and even he realised his limitations when he couldn't be top dog in a two team Spanish league. Horrible despicable twat who loves himself too much.

James Martin
91 Posted 04/10/2013 at 23:11:31
Be interesting to see what formation they have out tomorrow. Their fans seem to despise the 4-4-2 that Bayern massacred on Wednesday. If they played this you'd be reasonably confident of whatever midfield three we put together seeing quite a bit of the ball. I'd also wager we'd do alright on the flanks as well as long as Osman is ridiculously tasked with tracking Navas or something stupid like that.

My only concern is Jagielka and Distin seem to be unable to deal with the msot basic ploy of a long ball flicked on by one striker to another. They can defend all day expertly against any number of tricky midfielders, false nines, number 10s, players cutting in from wide. But two big donks upfront nodding balls down to each other seems to have them all over the place. So perhaps our best hope is that they play three in the middle, we nick one and defend boss for the rest of the game despite being completely overrun.

Tony Marsh
92 Posted 04/10/2013 at 23:31:45
I believe we will score at City. I also believe we will concede. I reckon this game could be almost NFL like as the two sides go at each other for 90 minutes trying to outscore one another. Can we win it is the big question and I would say its a coin flip. If City are feeling sorry for themselves then you never know.

I predict a score draw and that won't be a bad result.
Tom Bowers
93 Posted 04/10/2013 at 23:38:12
Tomorrow will be an acid test for the Blues.

They may well indeed feel a backlash from City after a shock at Villa and being totally outplayed by Bayern.

Everton will have changes, as well as starting the weak link Osman again which may once again see a struggle to cope in midfield.

Everton's defending has been somewhat lacking this season but have gotten lucky so far in avoiding defeat.

There has been some improvement in the Everton ranks but they are not yet the real deal. However a good result tomorrow may just convince many of us that a new era is beginning.
Iain Johnston
94 Posted 04/10/2013 at 23:44:14
Well, I think Mick has summed up Mourinho perfectly!...

I think we're a bit ambivalent with regards to Ozzie. With the injury doubts I'm happy for him to play, It's his fitness that worries me. He faded badly on Monday. I felt the left flank was left exposed as Baines was doing all the running. I was surprised he stayed on so long. I was equally surprised to see Mirallas come out for the 2nd half, he was limping for a good portion of the 1st.

I can see them starting with Milner, using his strength to counter Seamus I also think Ross against Toure will be significant, maybe the key to winning the Midfield. Jags and Distin are pacey and experienced enough..

If RM has to change it further, I can see him opting for Naismith for Mirallas as he appears to be more of a "ballwinner" but I really want to see Deulofeu given a go at their defenders.. Lukaku WILL score!!

2-1 for me COYB!!

Adam Weight
95 Posted 05/10/2013 at 02:02:23
The team has to be:

Howard
Baines
Distin
Jagielka
McCarthy
Osman
Heitinga (DM)
Barkley
Jelavic
Lukaku

If Mirallas is fit, switch him for Jela. If Pienaar is fit, stick him on the bench anyways, he's been fairly average of late.

COYB!

Harold Matthews
96 Posted 05/10/2013 at 02:05:21
Chern. Good shout mate.
Paul Andrews
97 Posted 05/10/2013 at 08:14:24
3 in central midfield is a must.
Watching the Bayern game on Tuesday I wondered how long it would take Pellegrini to realise he was being swamped in midfield,he didn't.
If he persists with his 2 in central midfield we can get the upper hand in there.
Darren Hind
98 Posted 05/10/2013 at 08:34:39
We may as well not bother going if we are frightened that City are "frothing at the gums".

Most of our boys know what it takes to win there and, but for a penalty awarded for the type of incident we see go unpunished every week, we'd have beaten them there last season too.

I hope their fans are invading Everton websites after the game, whinning that we treat all games against them as "cup finals" – AGAIN!

I hope their manager is so gutted and frustrated he either wants a fight with Robbie or he can't face the press afterwards – AGAIN!!

I hope (know) when I get there, around three thousand defiant Evertonians will turn up, with a "Fuck you and your money, we're Everton" attitude – AGAIN!!!

Guess I just hope it's business as usual...

Nick Entwistle
99 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:05:39
Dreamed that we won 6-1 last night. But then Martin Peters was playing and Jack Charlton was playing for City in his Leeds kit.
Paul Gladwell
100 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:14:14
Great read in The Times today with RM pissing all over the top six is the best we can hope for attitude that ginger preached, this constant positive chat is making me too happy at times, imagine if we actually won today.
Ciarán McGlone
101 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:18:36
I'm worried about this one... given our injuries... forced sit outs and options

However.. at least its likely to be a decent match and we'll at least try..

Graham Mockford
103 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:24:16
Adam #715

That's the height of confidence, take them on with only 10 men!

Peter Leslie
104 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:07:24
Way I see it, despite them lot scoring most of their goals from crosses so far, central areas are key today.

Without Barry, and with Gibson unfit/half-fit (and the only viable cover being Heitinga, who tackles like a ten-year-old) we could be be dominated physically unless we swamp them with extra numbers, and play round them on the deck.

I'm favouring a 3-5-2 (or 5-3-1-1 if you like) :

Howard

Distin, Jags, Stones

Baines, Osman, Barkley, McCarthy, Coleman,

Nais (or Kone)
Lukaku

I think this works, because normally our joined-up play is left-biased, and our breakouts into space come more down the right.

Stones would give cover to Coleman, and from what I've seen, would add something stepping into midflied with the ball off the keeper.

Naisy/Kone would be the spare man, biased to the inside-right, having fewer defensive responsibilities, and the task of wearing out Clichy and Kompany for 60 minutes before we stick Deulofeu on for the last 30 to rip them a new one.

COYB!!

Phil Sammon
105 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:27:47
I don't know if everyone's just forgotten we signed the guy, but Konè could do a job on the right wing if need be.

I sincerely hope Mirallas is fit but if not it could be:

------------Barkley
Deulofeu-Osman-Konè
-------------McCarthy

Or Gibson in there if he's fit. I just don't want to see Ossie on the wing, or Naismith in the side despite a good performance against Chelsea.

I do fear that Naismith may be our Park Ji Sung and always get picked for the big games. Without excelling technically, he works hard, pops up with a goal and will track back all day. Maybe he doesn't deserve a hard time, he's just not a very inspiring player.

Trevor Lynes
106 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:28:42
Unless Del Boy totally changes his game I cannot see him being a starter. I reckon he will be kept on the bench depending upon how the first half go's. Surely not conceding an early goal will be the priority. I would rather start Stones than Heitinga as Johnny Dutch has lost pace and his tackling is suspect. Im afraid that early freekicks could be our downfall if Heitinga plays or a striker trying to do something new.

I would play either Naismith or Oviedo as both are more used to combat in the midfield areas. Leave the back four as they are, they should be able to combat City as well as they usually do unless City hit top form that is !

At least with Lukaku we have a forward who can hold the ball up as he is stronger than Jelavic in that role. Barkley already has an affinity with Lukaku's style and hopefully Osman can be influential prompting them. McCarthy will also need to step his game up against City and if all the above comes to pass ? Then we can use perhaps Kone as a replacement for Lukaku at the hour mark and bring on Del Boy for one of the tiring midfielders. All this is conjecture but Im being an optimist. We cannot afford to let City attack us, we must have something to hit them back with. Mirallas would be a big loss as he is playing well in front of Coleman. I suppose Naismith will be played in his place because of his type of game. Maybe he will sneak a goal !!

I really hope City continue to struggle today as they played UTD off the park when they were on song.

Ben Patchesa
107 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:47:12
I find it hard to be negative about Osman in games against Man City. That delicious match-winning header where he outjumped Kompany is one of my favourite Everton goals of recent seasons.
Carl Sanderson
108 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:42:51
Darren 734,

Excellent post. I agree with most of that, but I must say that lots of Man City fans are sound. Unlike Chelsea, who are all plastic, imbecilic Johnny-come-latelies, many City fans remember the days when they were being relegated while United went from strength to strength.

I used to drink in a City pub, the Bull's Head in Piccadilly, and the lads in there were great.

Ben Patchesa
109 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:55:22
And obviously this one too
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atnSDHyInTU
Rob Smith
110 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:51:10
As long as the lads give it a shot, at least under RM, they will be allowed. I think Barry will be our biggest loss, hope Gibson is fit.

I get the impression that Mourinho thinks mistakenly, that Lukaku is just an Andy Carroll type, to big to be quick footed, I think he is the incredible hulk in blue, if anyone can tear MC a new one, he will.

Carl Sanderson
111 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:54:30
Ben 746,

Without going through the usual tiresome debate about Osman, I think you're right. He plays well anyway, but Man City is one of those opponents that suit his game.

Jim Lloyd
112 Posted 05/10/2013 at 09:37:18
Think I must be born pessimist but I think we will do well to get a draw today. It's a shame that Barry can't play. With him in the team, we've got a player who can defend and also get the ball out of defence to start attacks off.

Even with him in the team, we looked vulnerable aghainst Newcastle in the second half.

I just hope though, that even if we do lose, we make a game of it. Others can see then, that Monday was no flash in the pan and that there is something special beginning to grow at EFC.

So, I think we might get beat here...mind you, I've never won the pools so it shows I'm rubbish at predicting results!

Barry Rathbone
113 Posted 05/10/2013 at 10:14:12
734 , why should we not bother going ?

Ludicrous statement.

Ian Bennett
114 Posted 05/10/2013 at 10:17:40
If Gibson and Mirallas are out, then 3-5-2 looks a good shout.
Mike Allison
115 Posted 05/10/2013 at 10:22:20
Barry did you actually read that post?

Go on, read it now, as it seems you stopped after the first sentence, or totally missed the point.

Barry Rathbone
116 Posted 05/10/2013 at 10:25:14
Mike, so you agree if a team is up for it we shouldn't go then?

REALLY??

C'mon lad wakey wakey.

Tony McNulty
117 Posted 05/10/2013 at 10:47:52
Hopes for today:

· City are knackered and demoralised after midweek
· Their keeper (either current or new) is leaden-footed and spreads fear through their defence
· The team remember how Roberto out-thought them in the Cup Final
· We play as we have been lately

What will happen? I am like that policemen after Shergar was stolen: I haven’t got a clue.

Neil McKinney
118 Posted 05/10/2013 at 11:00:18
Barry, read the original post again!

I think that if we are still unbeaten by 3pm today it's an excellent result. As much as I'd like to be positive we have a number of injury doubts and considering what city did to Man U when Valencia failed to track back then I believe starting Del boy would be very risky.

Good luck to the boys.

Mike Hughes
119 Posted 05/10/2013 at 11:18:42
A draw would be a positive result today. This has "banana skin" written all over it with our unbeaten run and Citeh's poor form. Personally, I'd be happy with an away point. There'll be other days to break our poor form away at the "sky four"

With a potentially more winnable sequence of games coming up, it would be great to maintain our unbeaten tag today.

Jim Lloyd
120 Posted 05/10/2013 at 11:38:09
I agree Mike. If we can come away with a draw today, I think we'll have done well. Sky and the rest will just be waiting for us to get snotted and to stop interfering with their "Sky/Big four or five"

If we play well, I'll be happy, if we get a draw, I'll be made up; if we win I'd be dancing on the ceiling except for me artheritis!

Trevor Lynes
121 Posted 05/10/2013 at 11:42:48
Come on lads..City has a great side..on paper ! They are fantastic on their day. Our team has cost a fraction of the amount theirs cost. They are realistically one of the favourites to win the league.

They are all facts !!

If we come home still unbeaten then we will be taken very seriously as we are without Barry and Pienaar and maybe Mirallas and Gibson.
Its tantamount to a miracle if we win and much more likely to be a draw at best.

Jim Lloyd
122 Posted 05/10/2013 at 11:56:36
Exactly right Trevor.
Peter Cummings
123 Posted 05/10/2013 at 11:51:33
About an hour to go before the game... I've been up since 5am, it's now ten to seven in Ontario and I'm reading yesterday's Echo on line: RB talking about our defence being 'rock solid' — let's hope he's right today, and the lads get us at least a point!
Tom Bowers
124 Posted 05/10/2013 at 12:05:58
Given the squad City have, one is understandably concerned about the outcome today.

Obviously the longer Everton can keep them off the scoresheet, the better, and I do hope Martinez will use his substitutes a lot quicker than he did on Monday before anything untoward happens.

The absence of Barry and/or Gibson may be crucial unless Heitinga can come back with a big performance by keeping YaYa quiet.

David Chait
125 Posted 05/10/2013 at 12:10:48
I dreamt we won 8-3.. Had to read it in the paper the next day though.. True story!
Brian Denton
126 Posted 05/10/2013 at 12:18:00
Mike Hughes, our 'poor form away at the Sky Four' refers to Man Utd, Chelsea, Arsenal and RS. Our away from at City and Spurs has been quite good in recent years, and we have won several times.
Ciarán McGlone
127 Posted 05/10/2013 at 12:38:55
I don't mind playing Naismith if we have to... What I do mind is playing him as a wide player. Especially whenever we have at least two good wide players on the bench.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb