Everton Free School secures top-four finish

, 4 October, 28comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton Free School has recently secured a top-four finish in the prestigious European Club Association Awards (ECA).

» Read the full article at Everton Free School



Reader Comments (28)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Karl Masters
1 Posted 05/10/2013 at 20:47:18
Probably the first Club to open a Free School and see it end up in a PR disaster when it leads to them banning a season ticket holder.

It can be added to dug outs, goal nets, numbered shirts and staging a World Cup semi final as an Everton first.....

Richard Knights
2 Posted 06/10/2013 at 17:49:29
Since 2012 I've been asking the question - the school claimed it would educate 200 pupils, so... how many pupils in the Everton Free School? Freedom of Information request denied.

Many Free Schools would rather spend out on massive salaries for Headteachers and Principals. So, what is the salary of the Principal of the Everton Free School? Freedom of Information request refused.This. Is. Taxpayers'. Money.

2013, we were promised that the Everton Free School would have its own premises, instead it's still stuck on the top floor of the Liverpool Community College, one pokey office, two bog-standard classrooms, no playground, no green fields in sight.

Why all the secrecy? What have they got to hide?

Dave Kelly
3 Posted 06/10/2013 at 18:07:38
Richard, I have the utmost respect for your principles, your tenacity and diligence. Your unwavering commitment, to your cause is to be admired. Lesser mortals will have given up and walked away.

How Paul Tyrell our former Director of Communications and serial loser has managed to get away with his actions beggars belief. For you to face the ultimate sanction that any match going supporters could face, the removal of your season ticket is one of the most shameful acts, taken against any fan, of any club. Shame on all involved in this draconian measure.

Over the coming weeks and months I would urge you to stand firm, be robust and resolute. Surely now is the time to move the campaign to the next stage?

In my humble opinion I believe that Everton Football Club need to spend more time on it's core business objectives, running a successful football club. The excellent Everton in the Community should be run as a stand alone Charity, that's run independently of the football club.

Laudable as it may be, I wonder how much of Robert Elstone's and Denise Barrett-Baxendale's time is spent working on the Free School projects?

Good luck for the future Richard, JUSTICE will be yours, you just may have to wait a little longer than you should have to.

Peter Collins
4 Posted 07/10/2013 at 20:40:14
Richard, keep up the fight keep up the struggle. Because if they thought that taking away your season ticket you'd just disappear, they've got another coming.

It may take a along time, but you'll have the last laugh and justice will be done.

Andy Crooks
5 Posted 07/10/2013 at 21:24:26
Sorry for appearing a cretin but what is a Free School and is it a good thing for Everton to have?
Alan Williams
8 Posted 08/10/2013 at 18:09:02
Richard, we take on board what you say about facilities, which I’m sure will be addressed once the school grows, but surely if these children are better for their experience and by the end of the schooling they have better social and academic skills, then how can you as a teacher argue with that? Nothing in your post points towards the kids' improvement and that the success of such schools should be assessed accordingly.

The current state system has many flaws of which you are part of and kids both underachieving and overachieving under the current system are failed by the system recognising average as the bench mark. What are your views on this and how can the current system be changed so kids aren’t left behind?

If the current state system worked, we wouldn’t need Free Schools; I have experienced this myself with my son and I have had to take him out of the state school and pay for his schooling because he would never have reached his potential in the current system which we were told personally by his Year 3 teacher! — Much to the anger of the Head.

This isn’t a political argument as I live in a Tory area where the biggest selling point for local Prep schools is the state education system, which is totally wrong. I had an excellent education in a state school and I owe my teachers a lot but by the time I grew up and realised this, sadly my mentor died and it's one of my regrets I never went back and said Thank You to her because good teachers are worth their weight in gold; the problem is your too young to appreciate it.

My main point is, if these kids are given a chance to get education and good life skills, be that associated via football, then as a society we are all better off and what the Principal gets in my mind is totally irrelevant isn’t it? Don’t Principals who turn around poor performing schools get big bonus like Mr Elms who reportedly got £200k for turning around a state school in London. Please explain what the difference is, as moaning about the pay doesn’t help your argument; in my mind, it totally trivialises you political point.

Dave Kelly
9 Posted 08/10/2013 at 22:05:41
Why am I not surprised by your comments, Alan? I am amazed when well-intentioned but ill-informed people make inappropriate comments. I find it both condescending and ignorant when you state "This isn't a political argument" and then supplement it with "as I live in a Tory area" — it's irrelevant.

As with most things in life, it's Political, just like when you get your bins emptied (or not emptied as the case may be), like how long you are on a hospital waiting list, or waiting for a bus.

It doesn't come as a surprise to me that the Everton Free School is a Limited Company, it has Directors and it's run as a business. The only mechanism for income? The Public Purse. Yes, you and me funding a private business to provide a Public Service!!!

This, against the backdrop that for every child that leaves the LEA, means the reduction of resources for the Public Sector and an increase for the Private Sector.

I'm more than happy to have a debate on the pros and cons of Public Sector v Private Sector, free collective bargaining etc. but I'm sure you will agree with me that ToffeeWeb ain't the vehicle for such a debate.

Let's cut to the chase, EiTC or EFS will argue that they are giving children in last chance saloon an opportunity that they won't be afforded elsewhere, a very commendable argument too...

Are they? I suspect not. Everton Football Clubs should concentrate on it's core business interest: running a Football Team, Winning Silverware and entertaining its supporters.

I think Robert Elstone, Denise Barrett-Baxendale and all the other Club employees would be better served by spending the time they're employed, by us (Shareholders/Stakeholders) on the core business interests and like us, spend any free time supporting the excellent EiTC.

I leave you with this: if Everton really had concerns about its supporters and its community, maybe they should start an Everton Food Bank, maybe an Everton Credit Union or even Everton Medical Care — or does the social conscience not stretch that far?

Alan Williams
10 Posted 09/10/2013 at 08:16:00
Hi Dave, the reason I give it as none political is Education is done via postcode lottery and you have issues no matter what colour your council is. When you have kids opinions change and it’s your duty to make sure they get the best education possible and that means parents making sacrifices at every level which is wrong in some ways, the state system is failing many pupils and I wanted to make that point to Richard. The EFS should be assessed on its results and what is brings to those pupils that attend, Government offered this initiative EFS just took it up. If you look at the past expertise the senior team has at EiTC then you can understand why they have taken this up. On your point this is not a discussion for TW then look at Richards post as he set the agenda I was very interested to hear his opinion, from a different direction I actually agree with him in that the state should do the schooling but it should also be secular and inclusive to all and offer the best education possible for all levels of ability, currently the state system (especially in my area) fails pupils at the lower and higher ability levels, hence why initiatives like the free school have been brought to the table.
Andy Crooks
11 Posted 09/10/2013 at 18:30:32
Can anyone provide a link to read up on this?
Dave Kelly
12 Posted 09/10/2013 at 18:25:47
Alan, I've previously stated that in my opinion ToffeeWeb not to forum for the intricacies of the ConDems policies or the Tory Parties manifesto, incidentally are you a Tory, blue in a Sporting and Political sense ?

You conveniently side step most of the issues I originally raised. I'm more than happy to agree to disagree with you on this issue. Clearly I think it is Political and I'm right, you think it isn't and you're wrong.

Let's sort the wheat from the chaff here, the whole issue of the Everton Free School is a Political one, albeit one that the vast majority of Evertonians have very little or no interest in.

The whole episode is yet another sad chapter in our club making the wrong decision, on the wrong person, at the wrong time. Richard's perfectly entitled, in a Democratic Society to peacefully protest and he has.

Personally I will defend and support any individual's or organisation's right to protest. I will also support any individual's or organisation's right to defend itself, including Everton.

I make one point and one point only, Alan: Why do you think Everton Football Club withdrew his Season Ticket and prevented him from attending games? I imagine you and most other Evertonians won't be able to answer that... The answer is not what you would think it would be.

I look forward to yours or any other Evertonians response with interest.

Paul Andrews
13 Posted 09/10/2013 at 19:31:08
Alan,

Any idea how we could find out if and when " once the school grows" ?
If the powers that be won't provide basic information such as how many pupils actually attend the Everton Free School how can we hope to monitor progress?

Michael Kenrick
14 Posted 09/10/2013 at 19:40:49
For Andy: Free Schools (in England)

Hopefully we can move away from the pointless assertion "political/nnon-political" and answer some of the more intersting questions this whole business raises... like:

1) Why exactly did Everton Football Club set up Everton Free School?

I recall a concern stretching back a number of years about maintaining the education of young Academy players who were obviously required to spend a heck of a lot of time playing football in the Academy, and less time studying, especially homework, broadening the mind through reading (does anybody still do that?) etc. Does this have anything at all to do with it? Are any of its pupils budding footballers in the Acedemy? Or am I mixing two barely related concepts...

2) Why exactly did Everton Football Club withdraw the Season Ticket from Richard Knights and prevent him from attending games? (A question posed by Dace Kelly above)

I guess I thought it was 'punishment' in some obvious retributive sense, a response by the Club to the claimed misdemeanours Richard was said to have committed. However, your follow-on, Dave, suggests something different? I'm intrigued...

3) Shouldn't Everton FC concentrate 100% only on matters directly contributing to football on the field, the players they need to compete, and business elements directly supporting those endeavours?

That's the position I would take. I'm not convinced that EiTC — however wonderful it might be — contributes anything substantive towards this end. And even moreso EFS — especially when it results in such bad PR with bad blood spilt between the club and any of its supporters.

Brent Stephens
15 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:12:02
Well done Everton Free School.

But I wouldn't send my kids to a school that's allowed to recruit staff who aren't fully teacher trained! And they are going to improve on fully trained teachers?!

Jon Beck
16 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:09:04
I have to disagree that EiTC adds no value. Surely there is value in a club offering something to the community it exists in? Didn't Everton grow from community roots? I for one am impressed and proud by this facet of the club.
Ian Bennett
17 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:18:23
Michael / Brent - I think the point of free schools is to help the kids where main stream schools fail. I don't think it's being pitched at our academy kids, rather those children who get nothing from the traditional route. That's my understanding anyway.
Brent Stephens
18 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:26:11
Ian. I'm not sure who this particular free school is for. I'm just making the point about them being able to recruit teachers who aren't fully trained.

They can also determine their own curriculum – and yet Government lambasts maintained schools for the inadequate curriculum!

You couldn't make it up.

Paul Andrews
19 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:31:01
Jon Beck,

I don't know an awful lot about the Everton Free School.

You sound very impressed by it — can you post details of the good work it does please.

Andy Crooks
20 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:39:30
Thanks for the link, Michael. Having read it, my first reaction is to ask the same question as number one in your post #684.
Ian Bennett
21 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:39:58
Brent - it depends if they are getting any Joe off the street, or someone who can connect with kids where fully trained professionals have failed.

I genuinely feel sorry for the thousands of kids that go through the system, that are wasting their time or get little value from the current system. A complex subject.

Brent Stephens
22 Posted 09/10/2013 at 20:57:13
Ian, if fully trained teachers fail, then there's a mechanism to get rid. That's not the point. Teaching is far more than "connecting with kids" - that's necessary but not sufficient. There's a vast array of skills required. Putting lesson plans together; delivering a teaching session; setting assessments; providing feedback to pupils; understanding how kids develop cognitively at different ages; etc etc.
Karl Masters
23 Posted 09/10/2013 at 21:01:53
I have to say that reading this thread, I'm getting very little education from it. I'm still wondering:

1/ Why did Everton FC get involved in this at all? Is it for kudos or money? Can a school make money? Surely that's only for Public schools and anything using Govt. money can only plough back 'profit' into the school? Or can it?

2/ There seems to be more than a hint of idealogical points scoring by some posters, but this is a football website so can't we just stick with the banning of a season ticket holder, which is the only link to football it would appear? Politics make me want to tear all my hair out quite honestly. Adults arguing like children with diametric polarised views stopping anything getting done. Most people in my position would vote Tory, I always voted Labour, but currently I have come to the conclusion they are all a bunch of self serving Kuntz who disgust me and I don't think politics should be on here..IMHO of course.

3/ Which all leads to the main point of interest now that Dave Kelly has indicated it's not all it would appear. Just why did the club ban a season ticket holder for asking questions about a school?

That's the only thing I want to know.

Patrick Murphy
24 Posted 09/10/2013 at 21:53:24
Karl like you I have my own politics and I don't want the site to turn into a left-wing, right-wing contest. But as you rightly say the withdrawal of somebody's season-ticket because of his political beliefs is an unsettling aspect of the football club we support. I would also like to know how much time, money and effort is diverted from the core business to help with community projects and the free school project.

Of course the club is part of the community and as such it should facilitate and support local initiatives, but there appears to be something afoot that we are not party to and for that reason a more transparent stance by the club would be helpful to all involved. Speculation is bound to surround the motives for the Free School project whilst it appears to be surrounded by secrecy as to why the club are involved and to what ends.

Paul Andrews
25 Posted 09/10/2013 at 22:02:43
I have been told this evening that the school the club is professing to aspire to teach 200 plus has an actual attendance of less than 20.
I have no idea if that is correct.
Can anyone shed any light on that?
Karl Masters
26 Posted 09/10/2013 at 23:34:49
I think we agree Patrick, although as we already 'enjoy' one of the shadiest boardroom / ownership set ups imaginable, another game of smoke and mirrors where nothing is what it seems is unwelcome. Surely not more fingers in the cookie jar!
Richard Knights
27 Posted 10/10/2013 at 05:22:00
Free speech?

On September 17th 2012 I was visited by Merseyside Police (acting under instructions from Everton Football Club) and was given a Recordable Verbal Warning for 'harassing' the Principal of the Everton Free School - a man I have met once for about ten seconds.

In 2012 October I received a solicitor's letter from the club threatening me with a court injunction - this could have bankrupted me.

Later the day before the derby game I received a letter informing me that my season ticket was withdrawn. All the staff on the match day stewards got an e-mail warning them not to talk to me and to bar me from entering Goodison Park.

The actions of a bully.

The 'allegations' against me are lies. One allegation is that on June 27th 2012 I went into to the Everton Megastore and frightened the staff. I haven't been in there for over ten years. Peter Calloway, an Everton security official then completely changed his evidence to Merseyside Police. This case has been referred to the Independent Police Complaints Commission.

As for the Everton Free School since October 2012 under Freedom of Information I've been asking how many pupils are being educated. they have refused to answer. This is farcical.

Everton should try to run a football team.

Richard Knights
28 Posted 10/10/2013 at 05:31:39
http://www.theguardian.com/education/2013/oct/09/free-school-head-no-teaching-qualifications-leaves-job
Pat Finegan
29 Posted 10/10/2013 at 05:55:26
This happened under the watch of previous communications director, Paul Tyrell. Has Alan Myers said anything on the matter? Has he been contacted?

I don't have a well formulated opinion on the politics of free schols but I'd like to think that political views aren't discriminated against. I am proud to say that Everton are not strongly linked with secterianism in the same way that many clubs are. I'd like it to stay that way. I don't think that this incident has made us secterian in nature but it certainly doesn't look good from an outsider's perspective.

Sort it, Everton.

Dave Kelly
30 Posted 12/10/2013 at 09:48:38
I was left a little surprised that the baton was not picked up regarding the question that I posed earlier (673) " Why do you think Everton Football Club withdrew his Season Ticket and prevented him from attending games?"

It was never the intention of the powers that be (in this instance Paul "Red Adare" Tyrrell) to deny Richards Knights the opportunity to attend games. They merely wanted to prevent him from any extra curricular activity.

To his credit, Richard had mounted a campaign against a Limited Company (yes the Everton Free School is a Limited Company) with a minimum of fuss and meagre resources.

His campaign, based on principles and his own experiences within the Industry, is commendable, irrespective of where you stand politically.

The removal of Richard's season ticket was uncalled for, unwarranted and draconian. The ultimate sanction that you could impose on any match-going fan.

It also gave Tyrrell what he believed to be the upper hand in a campaign that was becoming increasingly embarrassing to him personally and to his employer, given his remit when joining the Club. A remit to quell fan activism in a similar way that he had attempted at Anfield during the long, bitter and protracted battle over Hicks and Gillett.

The removal of Richard's Season Ticket meant, in real terms, the removal of his Customer Reference Number. Once removed, he could no longer continue with his complaint via the Club's own internal complaints procedure.

Unfortunately, Everton Football Club have a long and proud track record of gagging dissenters. They repeatedly enter into compromise agreements to buy dissenters silence, ex-managers, CEOs, members of the Senior Management team, Coaching and Ancillary Staff have all left the employ of the organisation with an agreement in place. The latest being a former coach, who this week agreed to a pre-tribunal agreement and a vow of silence was part of the settlement.

The remedy is a simple one, reinstate Richard's Season Ticket and Customer Reference Number, allow him to attend games, like he has done for 50 years and apologise.

The alternative, doesn't bear thinking about; it's the intention of a number of concerned Evertonians to set up a group to assist Richard in his fight for Justice.

If you would like to get involved, can offer any help, advice or assistance, contact Justice4ritchie@goodisonpark.com


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb