Fans back Martinez in Echo Survey

, 10 October, 122comments  |  Jump to most recent
A survey of Everton fans by the Liverpool Echo reveals some interesting feedback, most Blues fans being delighted with the start to the season. 84.4% of respondents felt the Blues were doing better than expected before the season started, and 97.8% believe the style of play under Roberto Martinez is better than in previous seasons.

» Read the full article at Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (122)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Keightley
1 Posted 10/10/2013 at 17:11:12
And 80% of statistics are made up on the spot.

I'm delighted with the way we have started but feel we could and should be 6 points better off.

Paul Andrews
4 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:05:35
The 97.8 % are pretty indicative of the feeling amongst the Blues I mix with.
Martinez style of football over the ginger mingebags style every time.

Tim Howard is quoted today saying the team is playing more positive attacking football under Martinez.
It is a different player every week saying the same thing.

Ian Bennett
5 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:10:18
I look forward to seeing what Roberto does over the next couple of transfer windows. Positive so far, although surgery still needed particularly with the sticking plasters on loan.

What's that you say? a ball playing centre half who is tall and quick. Watching the England U21s Eric Dier looks the man.

Ross Edwards
6 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:35:38
Eric Dier, the man David Moyes got rid of, because he wouldn't have got into the first team until he was 40.
Phil Friedman
8 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:36:12
The style of play is great, but decidedly mixed transfer window performance from RM so far: Barry and Lukaku great (although only loans); Deleufeo incomplete; Alcaraz and Kone, poor. Need permanent replacement at striker, and Distin won't go on forever.
Andy Meighan
9 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:45:04
How can anyone say Kone is poor? He hasn't played a full game yet... he's got to be given time.
Peter Norris
11 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:47:00
Phil. Lukaku, Barry and Deleufeo agree. What you basing Kone and Alcaraz on seeing as one's hardly played and the others not played?
Danny Broderick
13 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:49:25
Phil,

I think Deulofeu is an exciting capture - Moyes would never have gone for an exciting young attacking player like him. Don't forget McCarthy also, who is another good prospect, even if we did pay a bit over the odds....

Nick Entwistle
14 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:46:46
Oooooh some bait.

Nah not hungry.

Though I'm sure that ridiculous Lukaku thread is still going strong for anyone casting a line.

But if people think the Martinez brand is better than at this stage last season then no, its not. The first ten games last season was the best there had been under Moyes... which then reverted to hoof and huff.

...and people said there was no plan B.

I am fully in agreement with the 84.4% though. And we will decimate Hull. It could get embarrassing. Tigers come unstuck type headlines...

Mike Gaynes
15 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:46:44
Phil, seriously? You forgot McCarthy completely, and he looked pretty damn good against City. Alcaraz can't be poor if he hasn't played. Likewise Kone. And if Deulofeu only rates an incomplete, you must be the Iceman, because everybody I know gets a serious adrenaline rush the minute the guy touches the ball.

Give it some time. I think this is going to turn out to be the best transfer window in years.

Kevin Tully
16 Posted 10/10/2013 at 20:58:55
Thought a survey such as this was slightly premature - maybe a dozen games in would have given a better indication of where we are heading.

It was very interesting to hear Tim Howard say we don't change the way we play to suit the opposition, shows the manager has belief, and is not scared of going to the likes of Anfield and Old Trafford.

I bet we break our 11 year hoodoo this season, at one of 'those' grounds.

Brian Harrison
17 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:02:28
I think way to early to be conducting a survey on how good the manager is, not sure if the Echo would have conducted this survey had we lost a couple of the early games. The time to give an honest appraisal is at the end of the season, and with it being his first season even that maybe too early.

I think most fans are enjoying our style of football but like all fans we want the wins as well as the good football.

James Martin
18 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:01:15
Kevin it doesn't really matter if we break the hoodoo or not. All that matters is the league position/ points earned are better. I couldn't care less where the points come from. Winning at Old Trafford, Anfield the Emirates and Stamford Bridge but finishing tenth would be a poor season.

Regardless of the manager people get too obsessed with statement wins at big away grounds usually because a load of media adulation come with them. Blackpool and Blackburn picked up wins at Anfield and Old Trafford on their way to relegation. It means nothing. Nothing annoys me more than dropping points against easy sides at home, that is where good league campaigns are made or broken, not in four of the toughest away games of the season. Top sides raise their game at home when big sides visit, you don't get any of these complacency wins that smaller teams often pick up at the big boys. Man U haven't won at Stamford Bridge in the league for ages, Spurs haven't won at the Emirates, and hadn't won at Old Trafford before the win last year. I can't remember the last time Arsenal won at Old Trafford either. Having no fear is all well and good but as we saw against City it takes a bit more than 'just going for it' to beat a top side when they're on their game on their own patch. I hope Martinez can do it but I'll be judging him on his overall league performance rather than a few minutes of media love in on match of the day if we win away somewhere big.

Nick Entwistle
19 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:09:00
The argument on whether Moyes would or would not bring in who Martinez has is a false argument because Martinez has spent more on loans this season as Moyes had to spend in his final window. A big fat zero.

The sheer number of players out there who are possible to bring in means that no it may not have happened, and the argument assumes that the best possible loanees and signings have been brought in and couldn't have been bettered - and yet why would Moyes not have done better? Other than Lukaku, and why not him any way?

Moyes loan players... erm, Arteta, Pienaar, Ferarri, Donovan x2, Fernandez x2, Drenthe, Straq, Yobo... won't mention Jo's second spell, or Tommy G's. But he didn't have the money to bring in some kid from Barca who is at the moment an interesting side show.

What he did do was bring in Arteta, Pienaar, Mirallas, Baines, Coleman, Jags and Gibson for a sum total approximately the same as Johan McCarthy, and Edson Arantes do Nasci Kone combined. So from that point of view, maybe the argument stands up.

Kevin Tully
20 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:09:55
James, sorry mate, it means a hell of a lot to me if we give it to Liverpool on their ow patch.

It will indicate we can finally shrug off the underdog mentality that we have wallowed in for too long now.

We have bent over and taken our medicine at these grounds for over a decade FFS! We need to be able to go anywhere and say 'We are Everton'

When the day comes at Wembley, or in a big game, they opposition won't be looking at each other and saying 'these always bottle it' as Liverpool & Chelsea did at Wembley, or if there is something riding on an Anfield derby.

It's indicative of the attitude of the team, not winning a single game.

Gary Poole
23 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:42:09
Sorry Kevin - beating the RS is a hollow victory if we finish below them at the end of the season. Yes it feels good for a week but at the end of the season it is meaningless if they are looking down at us. It's small time Kevin.

And if we end up on the wrong end of a 3-1 scoreline each time we play the "big sides" because "we're going for it and we're not scared of anyone", well...... we might as well be managed by Ian Holloway.

Before I'm lynched,I've been really pleased with the start although there are a couple of alarm bells slightly dinging.

The premier league isn't school footy when we play goalie in and out - it's about getting results and that's the most important thing for me.

Kevin Tully
24 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:53:00
If it's all about results for you Gary - fair enough. I take it you would have been happy with Pulis if we could manage another 6/7th finish?

It is not about pretty football, that's where a lot of supporters are getting a little mixed up.

When Swansea went to Valencia and won 3-0, it wasn't because of 'tippy tappy' football - they will get results like this because it's the most effective way to beat good sides.

Winning at Anfield and Old Trafford will mean we can finally match teams with an intelligent, modern style, which will only lead to better results in the long run. It's not about a single result.

Paul Andrews
25 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:02:06
Kevin Tully,

"It's indicative of the attitude of the team,not winning a single game."

Pick anything off the top shelf Sir.

Mark Frere
26 Posted 10/10/2013 at 21:45:01
James Martin (865)

I can't agree with you more. People are obsessed with winning away at the top 4 clubs or Anfield, at the end of the day we only get the same amount of points whoever we beat.

Admittedly, the Anfield derby is a bit more special, it would give us all a great sense of pride to sort out the horrible shite across the park on their own patch, but it shouldn't be season-defining as some people see it.

Not getting a victory against Hull City will be considerably more infuriating than getting beat last week at The Etihad. After all, we were playing a world class team who have spent £100s of millions on players and hardly ever slip up at The Etihad.

If we get positive results against all the so-called inferior teams, then we will have a great chance of top 4. All the draws against the lesser teams last season were the main reason for us failing to get into Europe IMO.

Gary Poole
27 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:04:50
Kevin - if we are able to do that then I'm with you. For me, results come first and style comes second. I realise I might be accused of wanting to play like Stoke but its never that black and white and it depends on the players that you have.

Yes, I agree that if you have the players you need to give yourself the best chance of getting a result. Sometimes though that means shutting up the shop (Chelsea at Man U this season).

It would be great if we could play like Citeh all season but we know we haven't got their resources so I just feel that we have to be more pragmatic sometimes.

Likewise, if (as in previous seasons) we can't beat the likes of Hull at home then the big games become a bit of a sideshow.

I really hope that Martinez does turn us into a team that can play footy and be consistently competitive.

It needs to be tied into results and league position though otherwise its a bit pointless.

I think we had a collective off day at City (too many sub-standard performances) so lets see if we can get back on it next week. November is a bit of a crunch month though when I think we will really start to see just how effective (in terms of results) this style is.

Ian Tunstead
28 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:16:03
I don't give a toss about the style of play, it's the results that count. Although I don't think the style has changed all that much. We played some very good football last season, the difference now though is that the ball sticks up top and the attacking moves are not breaking down as much in the final 3rd because of the quality of Lukaku and he can also put the ball in the net to get us the results. I think it's best to reserve judgement until the end of the season. We have seen our season fall apart before.
Kevin Tully
29 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:15:41
Absolutely agree it's all about where we finish Gary, but I've never understood how £50 or £60 grand a week Internationals are excused from playing good football because the opposition cost more.

We have discussed Everton performances against these sides like we are a second or third tier team.

I believe we can match them in one-off games, but not over a full season, because of the quality & depth of their squads.

Nick Entwistle
30 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:17:41
Swansea went to Valencia and won 3-0 because the Spanish had a man sent off early. Swansea had parked the bus like never seen before until that point.

If you saw the game you'd have seen the home kop end suddenly disappeared during the first half for 15 minutes as a protest at Valencia's recent form, then came out just in time for a Swansea goal so they all buggered off again. Great entertainment.

Nick Entwistle
31 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:25:52
Kevin, we are a 2nd tier team. The top 4 literally play in a different league to us... and at the same time the same one. Modern football for you.
Gary Poole
32 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:33:39
I would like nothing better than to be able to match the top teams but, for me, that means doing better than them over the course of a season - that's just not possible give the balance of power.

As I've said, sure we would all enjoy a win away at these grounds but we have to be able to follow it up in the "bread and butter" games otherwise, for me, its froth.

The reason for our end of season position last year (and in all the previous years) was not the result of our games against the top teams it was our inability to get wins against the so called lesser teams - that's the difference between the top tier in the Prem and where we sit.

James Martin
33 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:25:18
Kevin that rationale would mean that we would be able to match them over a whole season. Everyone expects us to beat sides worse than us home and away because we're better yet don't expect us to be beaten (sorry even draws aren't enough...don't expect us to draw) by better sides regularly away from home because our players should be able to match theirs in a one off game.

The cup final was a one off game but it wasn't the attitude of the players that lost us it (whatever some people like to portray) it was the huge gulf in quality between a team without all its best players and one fully fit that was one of the top sides in Europe. You could play them 50 times, you might win one, that's the one-off game you hope for, but you can't expect it to crop up every time we play a big boy away from home.

People make such stupid comments about our players after games along the lines of 'why can't a footballer earning 60k a week make a simple pass and keep possession'. Why do they never consider that the opposition is putting them under such unbearable pressure that they can't pass accurately or that they're so tired from chasing the ball that when they do get it they're knackered. Barcelona and Bayern have made some of Europe's top teams and players look as though they couldn't make a five yard pass.

Beating top sides away from home is not simply about comparing the two 11s and saying 'well our players can still pass and move just as good as theirs so why shouldn't we be able to beat them in a one off game if we just 'go for it'. These sides possess some of the best players in the world who if even one of them turn up can win the game by himself as Silva did for City. If two of them show up then you're on the end of a battering. All of our players would have to turn up and all of theirs have a bad day. Most of the time you only have a hope if you follow the RS formula of meeting these teams conveniently when half their stars are injured, having the ref on your side to gift you penalties, and then defending like mad for the majority of the match whilst getting ridiculously lucky.

I want to see us win away at these grounds too but if I had to have a punt at it I'd bet on perhaps only winning at one of them and that would be Liverpool because I genuinely believe their team isn't that great. A change of manager though won't stop them making that game their cup final, it won't stop the ref from favouring them all the time, and it won't stop them from defending and playing us on the break, a tactic that has done for us many a time both before and during Moyes' reign.

Anyone expecting us just to stroll up to Stamford Bridge where a Mourinho led Chelsea have never lost a game, Old Trafford (lose perhaps once at home per season) or the Emirates (barely lost at all since January) is delusional.

Kevin Tully
34 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:47:32
Let's just forfeit these games.

Give them the points.

Why bother turning up?

FFS!

We have just witnessed a very average West Brom outplay the Champions at their own ground and win.

Have we really dampened expectations that much over the last 20 years?

Gary Poole
35 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:01:35
Kevin we couldn't beat that very same average West Brom team at home a few weeks ago - isn't that what we're talking about?
Gary Poole
36 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:02:43
And yes Kevin my expectations have been dampened that much since the introduction of the Premier League - unfortunately....
Kevin Tully
37 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:03:16
As a Martinez supporter, I won't be making any excuses for him if he doesn't manage a few wins at these grounds in the coming seasons.

You can be sure he will be expecting to win some of these games, even if the supporters don't.

I'm sure the poor Liverpool sides of recent times have gone out with one result in mind.

Phil Friedman
38 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:08:58
Forgot McCarthy--mea culpa, the best signing of all, since he is young, exciting and not a loan. Alcaraz and Kone haven't contributed anything, nor shown that they will eventually, which is exactly why I rated them poor, on the evidence. Hope I'm wrong.
Gary Poole
39 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:09:11
Is that your definition of success though Kevin? An away win at a top 4 ground?

Don't get me wrong if we do it then I would be buzzing for the entire weekend but we're playing 38 games this season and it's about how we do overall.

Actually, if we could actually beat the teams that we are supposed to and then get results against the top teams that, for me, would represent success.

Beating Chelsea away, for instance and then drawing at home to Sunderland is just rubbish - I want us to be consistent over the course of the season. I do believe that we are a bigger club than just signposting our season by the odd marquee win over a so called top 4 side

James Martin
40 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:57:26
Kevin its not about dampening expectations, some fans can see though that its not a level playing field, they don't just turn a blind eye to the obvious disparities and then moan at the manager/ the players when we don't consistently win at top sides.

Over the 11 years of the Moyes reign there were a few occasions we went out stricken with fear and handed the game to the opposition (the Anfield derby loss is obviously at the forefront of the mind). Other times (a lot of the time) we were just absolutely battered by better sides and did well to come away with draws. Very rarely we were presented with chances to win one of these games such as at the Emirates when Vaughan failed to put us 3-1 up and then Rosicky's shot deflected off Lucas Neill over Howard. Another day you pick up one of those 'one-off' game wins. Similarly at Anfield when leading 2-1, if the ref doesn't gift Kuyt a pen we would have won that as well. The statistical anomaly for Moyes came in the city fixtures.

You mention West Brom but what is their record at Old Trafford like? First win in 35 years was it? That's my exact point. They got a win at Anfield last season too after getting ridiculously lucky and being battered for 88 minutes. That doesn't mean that seaoson on season we'll be able to replicate that though. Sunderland won 3-0 at Stamford Birdge once, doesn't mean we're going to do it when we turn up there this season.

Everyone would like to win at these grounds. You can thump the tub and say 'we are Everton' as much as you want but its not the 80s anymore. there'll be some United/City/Chelsea fan giving it loads as well viewing us int he same way as we'd view a Fulham if the came to Goodison - expecting to swat us aside but knowing that once in a while they'll sting you. I'll revel in a lucky win at Stamford Birdge or Old Trafford as much as the next person but it dosn't mask the huge gap in quality. As others have said the true measure of our progress this season and Martinez as a manager will come in the other 34 games of the season. If we won every game we 'should' win we'd win the league. Instead of concentrating on why that isn't the case however people get bent out of shape about Liverpool or Chelsea away. Ferguson didn't, most seasons he'd lose both of those away games yet finish above both teams.

Liverpool rev up for us or United as though its the world cup final, yet fall flat on their face at home to some of the league's worst sides. Despite this they've finished behind us and United for two seasons in a row - even taking 6 points off us in one of them. For all of Moyes' failures I always felt that he tried to get his team to treat all the opposition the same and avoid this small club mentality of only getting up for big games. I want us to be up for every game. Hopefully Martinez can bring that to us. If we get wins away for home at th ebig 4 then great, but I won't be basing my opinion on Martinez as a manager by his results in these games. It was always a ridiculous stat to judge Moyes by that could hav been broken due to fate at any point (like it was strangely regularly at the Etihad) but owuldn't have made him any different as a manager. League position is king, not statement results - a lesson small clubs that have been finsihing below us recently fail to heed.

Kevin Tully
41 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:31:34
As stated above, it is not about a single game or result. It's all about belief, which will be severely tested one day in a big game for 4th, or a Cup Final, or a CL qualifier.

That belief can only come by winning big games, not looking for draws.

There will be bad days along the way, but if we don't change the whole attitude of the club, we will never have any hope.

The practical amongst us may be right, but I can dream fellas.


Brent Stephens
42 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:35:12
Kevin #878 "I've never understood how £50 or £60 grand a week Internationals are excused from playing good football because the opposition cost more."

Kevin, if you only have a certain amount of skill, then you only have a certain amount of skill. Just giving somebody a bag of swag doesn't magically increase their skill level! The higher pay of the opposition is normally a reflection of their higher skill level.

So pay is determined by skills level (ok, and other things) rather than pay determining skill level.

Kevin Tully
43 Posted 10/10/2013 at 23:46:51
Brent - Fellaini has just had a £30k per week rise, has he suddenly turned into a better player?

If Baines doubles his play, is he any more of a player?

Will Barry's performances drop by half if his wages do?

The gulf is not as wide as is sometimes painted.

Brent Stephens
44 Posted 11/10/2013 at 00:06:08
Kevin "Brent - Fellaini has just had a £30k per week rise, has he suddenly turned into a better player?"

I think you've grasped my point! The answer to your question is clearly - no, Fellaini (or any other player) doesn't become a better player just because somebody suddenly pays him more!

Kevin Tully
45 Posted 11/10/2013 at 00:18:37
So I think we agree that a £50k a week player can easily be as good as a £100k per week player?

If Barkley, Baines, Jagielka, Barry, Mirallas, McCarthy, Lukaku were all playing for Man Utd on £100k per week they would be the same players, so why do we expect less of them because they earn less?

I am sure our manager realises they are a match for the bigger earners at other clubs, which was my original point.

Harold Matthews
46 Posted 10/10/2013 at 22:45:40
Rooney seems to be very impressed with what Martinez is trying to do. Cynics say he is having a sly swipe at Moyes but I prefer the idea that he is just seeing thing through the eyes of a life long Evertonian.

I'm supporting our new manager and his plans for the future of our club but realise that it will be two or three years before we begin to see the fruits of his labour. What we're witnessing now is a juggling act to keep fans happy while he quietly assembles a squad which will do the business.

Forget Yankee oil barons or Sheiks. We won't get one. He doesn't need one. " Money is just an accelerator," he says, " It gets you there quicker."

The only thing he needs is time. Be patient and let this fine, intelligent, young man put together a side we will all be proud of. He has only been with us five minutes and we must not let our desperate need for silver trophies hinder his long term plan.

Gary Poole
47 Posted 11/10/2013 at 00:36:17
Well said Harold - I like your style. Here's hoping that I can yet again witness an Everton side that will really challenge for honours.

And then I remember we haven't got a halfpenny to scratch our arse with - never mind footy is all about the dream hey!

Harold Matthews
48 Posted 11/10/2013 at 00:30:31
James. I would love us to beat the RS just for you. Your memory of those nightmare confrontations is absolutely awesome. In fact, your memory of everything is absolutely awesome.
Harold Matthews
49 Posted 11/10/2013 at 00:45:22
Nice one Gary.
Gary Poole
50 Posted 11/10/2013 at 01:16:47
Harold - you are so right. James, how do you remember everything!!
Gary Poole
51 Posted 11/10/2013 at 01:42:00
I'm going to bed but I think we've just had a debate, based on what we've seen this season, without reference to "he that shall not be named"...

I reckon that's progress!

David Ellis
52 Posted 11/10/2013 at 03:11:23
Fellaini hasn't become a better player because he has had a pay rise at Man Utd. But... er... he now plays for Man Utd because of the pay rise. And we don't have him anymore. That's why we can't truely compete (not that I particularly miss Fellaini, but some of the points made above on this topic seem to miss the point about salaries and quality).

As for Martinez, I think we are a work in progress. There are many players who do not fit our style – Jelavic, Naismith and Jagielka are some obvious ones. Pienaar and Osman may be slowing down. I hope we continue to develop and find affordable replacements for these players who fit the style. For me, this is a transition season supercharged by the presence of Lukaku. Top 7 would be a decent return, but of course hope springs eternal.

Paul Andrews
53 Posted 11/10/2013 at 05:57:32
Nick,

In my opinion Johan McCarthy, as you snidely call him, will develop into a top player.

Eric Myles
54 Posted 11/10/2013 at 06:14:54
Kevin #898 "Will Barry's performances drop by half if his wages do?"

Yes, yes they will. Would you work hard for a company that halved your salary?

Brent Stephens
55 Posted 11/10/2013 at 06:56:33
Kevin #900 "So I think we agree that a £50k a week player can easily be as good as a £100k per week player?"

Ah! Nice one, Kevin. It's your use of "can", though. That could mean it might be the case that a 50k player IS PRESENTLY as good as a player who is on 100k. BUT that might be because, for example, one has an agent who drives a better bargain.

Or it could mean that a 50k player HAS THE POTENTIAL TO BECOME as good as that player who is on 100k. BUT, there is no guarantee that a player would develop greater skills.

I think my point is clear - just giving my dog an extra bone won't make him bring my slippers any faster unless he has the ability to go faster.

Steve Pugh
56 Posted 11/10/2013 at 07:39:44
Kevin, Fellaini isn't a better player because he got a pay rise, he got a pay rise because he is a better player than those on his old wage.

Doesn't take a genius...

Phil Sammon
57 Posted 11/10/2013 at 08:10:47
Eric

'Yes, yes they will. Would you work hard for a company that halved your salary?'

It's different to most employment though isn't it. Barry is (hopefully) taking a pay cut to improve his quality of life and enhance his career. He wants to play every week and get back in the England fold. We may still be his best option, even if we can only offer him £50k p/w...which I personally wouldn't get out of bed for.

Nick Entwistle
59 Posted 11/10/2013 at 09:29:45
Paul, I think you're right.

Ross, you posted at 9:02am. Have a hot water and lemon, meditate, take a stroll. Something.

Adam Luszniak
60 Posted 11/10/2013 at 09:20:08
I like the debate concerning beating big teams away vs overall consistency across the season. Clearly we would love both, but probably lack the footballers to do it. One point I would like to make is that the derby actually falls into both categories, in that it is an away game to 'thump the tub' and feel proud about, and it is also the kind of game we have to go and win to progress from where we are. The league finishes of the two clubs are not a million miles away from each other if you look at the past 4 seasons. For me they are the kind of team we have to deprive of 3 points at any available opportunity. Spurs are probably in the same camp. As someone rightly pointed out above we are a 2nd tier team playing in the premier league, we need to beat the teams immediately around us to progress.

So yes, we need to be consistent, home and away to the teams below us. The teams around us we have to go for the win home and away. The teams above us? Well I would expect us to go for the jugular at home as I think on our day we have what it takes. Away from home I expect Martinez to go out and try and play his game, and why not? Moyes tended to park the bus, and more often than not we would concede a late goal and lose anyway.

It's also an interesting debate regarding why our 50k players can't stand up to and play against 90k players week in week out. I think this is a gross oversimplification. Football is a psychological battle as much as it is physical. Atmosphere, expectation, ref decisions etc etc all have a huge influence on how a 50k or 90k players goes about his game.

Robbie Shields
62 Posted 11/10/2013 at 11:36:16
I don't know how to break it to some of you guys, but you don't get the same amount of points for beating a top 4 team than a bottom 4 team! Shock horror!!!!

WHY??? How could this possibly be true???

Simple really, they are our bloody competition you fools! Ever heard of the phrase 6 pointers??? give me strength.

If Liverpool beat us home and away, that 6 points to them, if we beat them home and away that's 6 points to us. A swing of 12 points.

Now, if we get beat by Hull, assuming they aren't competing for a Champions League spot against us, then we lose 3 points, but Liverpool May still lose or draw in the other game.

IT FUCKING MATTERS MORE AGAINST YOUR DIRECT COMPETITION!!!!!

Understand???????

Adam Luszniak
63 Posted 11/10/2013 at 11:51:00
Robbie Shields. I think we can all agree that your argument is definitely leant more insight by the liberal misuse of capitalisation and superflous punctuation.
James Martin
64 Posted 11/10/2013 at 11:48:25
Robbie the season before last we lost to Liverpool twice yet finsihed ahead of them by four points meaning we were ten points better off than them against everyone else. It doesn't matter who is playing who. If we were playing Liverpool Hull and Norwich in a 3 game spread, if you lose the first but win the other two you get 6 points. If you win the first and draw the other two everyone feels boss about themselves but you've only got five points, it doesn't matter what Liverpool do in their other games.

Last season we drew against Liverpool twice, by your reckoning that shouldn't really matter points wise as Liverpool are our competition so nothing lost, but in reality we were 4 points worse off than if we'd beaten them twice.

Its really very simple, its 3 points for a win against whoever you play, there are 14 teams worse than us in this league who we have a better than average chance of getting those three points from. 28 lots of three points is 84 points more than enough to get automatic qualification for champions league. Rather than focusing upon why we fail in a large proportion of these easier games, however, everyone seems to want to focus on those 4/5 teams that are better than us who give us a less than average chance of picking up three points, and even worse than this, want to focus on games against them away form home where we have the lowest chance of picking up three points, even more than this a lot of people won't even tolerate draws at these grounds. There's only 12 points to play for here.

You can even see it in the reactions to Martinez's first games. Lost points at Norwich, Cardiff and West Brom were accepted on the whole without too much deep questioning of the team. We lose to City however, and everyone is up in arms about how we can't beat top sides away. We lost three points to a team thats going to be nowhere near us at the end of the season yet lost 6 to some of the fodder of the league. If we beat everyone we should beat in a season then we'd do great, I'd rather focus on why that isn't the case than get bent out of shape about away games at four certain sides.

Kevin Tully
65 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:25:08
Paying £100k per week to those QPR players worked out well.....
Sean Kelly
66 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:18:18
Robbie (926) – Did someone piss in your pot mate? You're right – we don't get anything extra for beating the top four or the shite but it would be nice for a change. Getting three points from any of them is only a bonus only if we are consistent against against the rest.

I think RM is getting it right but as said above there are a few areas we need to improve on. We do need a Plan B as other teams are adjusting to our new style – particularly in the second half of games... eg, Newcastle and Fulham.

Remember, the other 19 clubs are our direct competition, not just the mercenaries of the top four or the shite across the park.

Kevin Tully
67 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:26:30
Some boxers were beaten before they got in the ring with Tyson - that's the mentality we have taken to Old Trafford & the likes for years - time to man the fuck up!!!
Tony J Williams
68 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:30:57
Eff off with your logic James......
Sam Hoare
69 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:44:25
Would you rather lose to the RS twice a season but end up above them in the league or vice versa? I think i'd take the former. Ultimately every weekend really boils down to where you end up at the end of the season. If we are above the RS then I reckon there's a very good chance we will be in the Champions league.

It's been said before but what a shame we didn't have Lukaku for those first 3 games as we'd surely be at least 4 points better off. It's too many draws that derailed our European challenge last year so lets hope the same is not true this time round.

Robbie Shields
70 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:48:08
James, I officially give up! Even my "Liberal misuse of capitalisation and superfluous (Note spelling Adam) punctuation" didn't make a difference, lol.

I'm sure you'd try to argue black is white.

Your right of course James, Sir Alex (That famous big game bottler and winner of sweet FA) never put any more importance on the big games against his key competitors did he? Made no difference to whether they won the league or not you see.

Robbie Shields
71 Posted 11/10/2013 at 12:58:23
Sam, why is it always one or the other?

If we beat Liverpool twice in the season the chances are much higher that we'll finish above them as well, this isn't mutually exclusive, in fact, I argue the exact opposite. Those results have the single most direct impact onto whether we finish above them or not. What is so difficult to understand about that?

Brent Stephens
72 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:00:02
Robbie,

I don't know how to break it to some of you guys - black is white.

Understand??????

Kevin Tully
73 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:08:20
Surely if three teams at the bottom count the game as a 'six pointer' the same would apply to three teams aiming for a top 4 finish?
Robbie Shields
74 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:13:46
Brent........ Oh bollox, you're right!
Robbie Shields
75 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:15:26
Kevin, no room for logic on here mate, it doesn't apply at the top of the league, because, because, because........ you don't get relegated at the top of the league do you. Case closed.
Paul David
77 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:13:48
I agree with Kevin, its important for us to win away at the CL clubs. We need to change our attitude and believe we can beat anyone. There isn't a choice of winning glamorous away games or finishing higher in the league, both or neither could happen. All I know is I'd love to win at Anfield and to destroy Arsenal after some of the beatings they've gave us.
Graham Mockford
78 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:11:12
Robbie,

The 'six pointer' is a lazy media phrase. In reality it doesn't exist. Every game is played for three points, it does not matter who you are playing.

The concept of a 'six point swing' between two sides exists even when they are not playing each other. Next time we play if we win and Liverpool lose it's a 'six pointer'.

Craig Walker
80 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:29:37
Kevin Tully - you talk a lot of sense to me sir. I couldn't agree more with what you're saying.

It matters to me that we don't go to places like Anfield as "little, plucky old Everton". Our former manager took teams their resembling rabbits caught in headlights. Sometimes he'd even have the luxury of a 1 goal start but he'd resort to KITAP1.

It matters to me that we play good football. I don't want to watch a team playing kick-and-rush alehouse football. This is the club of Harvey, Kendall, Ball, the 80s team etc. etc. I don't want to follow a team of hard working cloggers.

It matters to me that our manager sends the players out to keep the ball and to be positive.

I don't believe that you can't beat the money teams because of a lack of spending power. I admit that over the long run, the money teams will be more successful but to not win at some of these grounds for eleven years is not all down to money. Dare I suggest bad management plays its part as well?

Sure, we can pick odd teams and say that they have a bad record at a certain ground. Everton have a bad record at many grounds. Might it just be down to a manager who starts ever season with a "let's get to 40 points mantra?"

Why do people necessarily think that a team who keeps the ball more will be more of a walk over than we were last season? In my opinion, we lost/drew many games under OFM by giving possession straight back to the opposition. Therefore, I don't accept that entertaining football means unsuccessful football.

Wimbledon in the 80s were successful and hard to beat but I couldn't watch them every week.

Kevin Tully
81 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:33:05
Graham, I think the phrase was coined if you knew the two teams were going to be in direct competition for either relegation, the League title, or a C.L. spot.

If for instance we play Man Utd in April, that could easily be billed as a 'six pointer' in relation to finishing 4th or 5th for either team.

If one side is 3 points ahead of the other, they could either go level, or six points ahead.

All depends on how close the teams are in the table. Clearly, a game against Crystal Palace would never be considered a 'six pointer'

Robbie Shields
82 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:36:10
Thanks for clearing that up Graham, six pointers don't exist, silly me, understand Kevin!

Piece of trivia for you all, what do Sam, Mark and Graham all have in common? answers on a postcard to...... Old Trafford.

Kevin Tully
83 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:41:27
Craig - you should post more often.
Sam Hoare
84 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:44:01
Robbie, sure. No reason we can't do both and obviously one makes the other easier. Just saying that so long as we finish above them at the end i'll be more than happy.
Robbie Shields
85 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:42:45
Craig, Amen, I have found another kindred spirit, that is what Everton FC should be about, what it once was and what it can be again under the right management, Martinez.
Eugene Ruane
86 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:48:47
Craig Walker (950) - Agree with every single word.
Graham Mockford
87 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:53:44
Kevin,

It's been a hard long week and I'm not sure I have the stamina for this. I am well aware when the phrase is used and anytime you beat a side it improved your chance of finishing above them, you have just taken three points when they have none.

But no game is more important (in a mathematical sense) than any other, they all represent the same opportunity.

Where it does differ is in the emotional sense. If you win a derby game or away at Old Trafford or a close rival for a league position it feels better, but it's still three points.

I'll stop now!

Tom Bowers
90 Posted 11/10/2013 at 13:57:57
Whilst opinions are pretty diversified regarding the new additions to the squad and the reasonable start to the season I think caution has to be exercised before any real judgments can be made. I am sure many ''sensible'' RS fans are not thinking about winning the league after their decent start.

There is of course a long way to go and hurdles to climb but certainly a cause for optimism is in all of us and rightly so.
RM seems to have introduced a ''new wave'' Everton with more strength in depth that will favor the team in the long run although they will lose some games along the way.

Injuries will be the key especially at the back where they still seem a bit short of options if Distin or Jags gets injured.

They have to take every game as it comes as there are a lot of improved teams in the league not to be taken lightly. Patience is the key.

Craig Walker
91 Posted 11/10/2013 at 14:03:19
I would post on here more often but I contributed to an article over summer and a fellow ToffeeWeb contributor told me that I "should support Wigan" because that's where I was raised despite me stating in my post that my dad was a lifelong Evertonian and I've supported them for 30+ years (through good times and bad - though mainly bad). It kind of put me off posting. I read TW every single day though and think the contributors and the guys who run the site are amazing.

In relation to the six-pointer, each game is worth 3 points. That is true. However, certain games take on more significance and the result can mean more than just 3 points. "Six-pointer" is a cliche but I think it is a good one (unlike the often used "let's give 110%" which is just plain wrong).

There's a scenario in the following page which explains why a game can be more than 3 points. It's the difference between being 1 point behind or the difference between being 5 points ahead:-

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six-pointer

Graham Mockford
92 Posted 11/10/2013 at 14:19:37
Craig

You have officially numbed be into submission, it just not worth the effort.

After all everything on Wikipedia is true right?

Craig Walker
93 Posted 11/10/2013 at 14:23:55
Graham. Don't read it then. No-one is forcing you.

I know this though. When you've lost 3 times to the RS in a single season including a cup semi-final and you have to face coming to work and facing them, after hearing their entire fan section singing "10 more years", you realise that it was worth more than 3 points - though not in a mathematical sense. I'm still feeling the pain now and waking up in cold sweats. Those games to me are "6 pointers", "must wins", whatever you want to call them.

Dan Brierley
94 Posted 11/10/2013 at 14:46:39
I would love nothing more than to see Everton beating the top teams, but ultimately its not a yardstick to judge a managers performance on over a season is it?

Martinez himself proved in the FA Cup last season that you can certainly beat the top teams, but at the same time proved that its not something sustainable by getting his team relegated. Moyes on the otherhand was as average as they come in terms of taking risks. But there has to be a balance, and an equal ground that can be found between the both extremes.

But in all honesty, I think its a bit early to suggest we should be going to the top 4 teams expecting a win. I'd prefer we start with the teams in the bottom half of the table, like Norwich or Cardiff for example.

Tony J Williams
95 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:09:42
Mr Neutrality here

If we don't beat teams we are expected to beat, the manager/players gets slaughtered.

If we get beat by teams expected to beat us, the manager/players gets slaughtered.

Who'd be a footballer/manager with logic like that?

Kevin Tully
96 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:20:50
Swiss Tony.
Sam Hoare
97 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:29:36
Graham,947.

I usually agree with all that you write but I think you are slightly off this one. The point of a 'six-pointer' is that unlike when we play Hull, you get to directly outcome you're closest rivals result as well. So whilst it's only another 3 points gained for us we are also assured that said rival has lost 3 points...hence the term. You know all this I know.

Brent Stephens
98 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:27:04
Graham has it, for me. There are only 3 points, to be given to one side only (or 1 point each). I feel the use of the term "6-pointer" is more psychological / emotional.
Brent Stephens
100 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:44:58
Sam, isn't it more the case that the losing side has not lost 3 points but lost the opportunity to gain 3 points? Feels like a significant difference to me.
James Martin
101 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:44:23
Craig I get what you mean about the work place and the importance of beating your local rivals but this debate has gone from what it originally started out as: why Martinez's season shouldn't be judged on his performances at the top 4 grounds, to tryign to argue about the benefits of beating your rivals. No one on here doens't want to beat all these teams twice a seaosn for the exact reasons that everyone's talking about.

To go back to where this started though I said that I wouldn't judge Martinez if he didn't win at any of these grounds because they're tough places to go and they don't make or break your season. Craig you could brag a lot more in the work place if we got fourth and they didn't reardless of how often they'd beaten us in a season. The key to unlocking those higher league places is to beat the lower teams more regularly than we are doing. there's no shame in admitting that, even Mourinho knew he wouldnt win at Old Trafford every season and based whole campaigns on beating the bottom 14 home and away and not losing away at top grounds.

My ultimate point is that I can't understand why people get so annoyed about losing some of these games. Yes the ones to Liverpool hurt emotionally but in my opinion people should be more outraged at the points we continuously drop to lesser sides home and away - they are what make or break our season. A season of beating Liverpool twice, United twice, Arsenal twice, and City twice, but finishing 7th is worth nothing. in fact its even worse because those wins are just devalued by your league position behind all those teams you've beat. Finishing fourth and drawing all those games is such a better season but you haven't shaken off the Voodoo, that's why I said I wouldn't judge Martinez as a manager if he doesn't break it this season.

Kevin Tully
102 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:52:20
If there were 2 games to go in a season, we were in 4th and the RS one place behind in 5th and it's derby day, would that not be a proverbial 'six pointer?'

Therefore my friends, the mystical six pointer does in fact exist.

Jimmy Kelly
103 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:39:59
Dear oh dear.

If we're level on points going into the derby and win we go 3 points clear - YAY!!! But then if we lose the following 2 games against sides nowhere near us in the table and they win theirs, we go 3 points behind - BOO!!!!! So how was the first game more important than the second two?

Kevin Tully
104 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:04:10
James - "Yes the ones to Liverpool hurt emotionally but in my opinion people should be more outraged at the points we continuously drop to lesser sides home and away - they are what make or break our season. A season of beating Liverpool twice, United twice, Arsenal twice, and City twice, but finishing 7th is worth nothing."

Tripe. All managers are judged on big games, not at home to Hull.

Brent Stephens
105 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:02:35
"Mystical" is the word. Psychologically / emotionally / as a short-hand - ok let's just call it a six-pointer. But I can't see where there are in fact 6 points in that one game between us and them. There are only 3 points to be gained at most, by only one side. As above, the losing side doesn't lose 3 points only loses the opportunity to gain 3 points.
James Martin
107 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:14:56
Its not tripe Kevin, all managers aren't judged on big games. Managers are judged on how well they do in competitions. When you get to the latter stages of a cup competition, they are all big games, not because of the opposition but because you have the chance to win a trophy. Its just a sad fact that its usually top sides in the latter stages because they are better but the point remians that its only a big game because of its place in the competition not because of the opposition.

Equally the Everton manager should be judged on how he does in the competition that is the league. Managers should be judged just as much for what they do at home to Hull as to how they do away at Man U as both games are worth exactly the same. In fact he should be judged more harshly for how he does at home to Hull because there three points are begging to be taken - passing them up is far worse a failure than winning at Old Trafford is a success. I will judge Martinez on how many points we have at the end of the season regardless of where they came from. If it's a low tally it won't matter one bit how many big games he won along the way. If its a high tally it won't matter if we didn't win any 'big' games. Managers aren't judged on big games, they're judged on competitions.

Dan Brierley
108 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:38:51
Kevin, so you think it would be better during a season:

● To win at the top four's grounds, and lose all the other games and get relegated?

Than:

● To lose at all top four grounds, yet win the title because you beat all the other teams?

I am surprised how highly you value winning at the top four's grounds. I couldn't give a shite if Martinez doesn't win at those grounds for another 11 years as long as he gets us into the CL by ensuring we beat those teams at home, cancelling out their 3 point win.

Jimmy Kelly
109 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:38:10
Kevin, I think you'll struggle to find too many Sunderland fans who would like to still have Di Canio in charge, despite him leading them to a 3-0 away win against their biggest rivals (their first victory at St James's Park for 13 years). At the end of the day, it was the results against the likes of Hull that they judged him on.
Harold Matthews
110 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:28:24
Agreed James. Those first three draws will haunt me all season.
David Chait
111 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:15:27
Tis is probably the best thread in the history of TW... Love it! Kevin came closest to convincing me the 6 pointer does exist if you are 3 points behind etc.. But that is just a math sum to prove a very inaccurate point.

The craziness of the thread is that there are almost 2 completely different arguments going on.. One saying that 6 pointers exist because its important to beat your direct competition to get ahead and others working purely from an accurate maths point of view without emotion to whom we are playing.

Personally I don't sit at the end of the season and feel bitter about not beating Man U away from home. I look at the freakin Newcastle game where we buggered up the last minute, the Fulham match last season etc etc. those games get on my tits big time because if we had won the games we are expected to win, and should have won based on the 90 minutes on the pitch, we could have bridged the gap!

This season I am already looking at 3 first 3 games and know come the end of the season we will regret the missed opportunity we had. Yes every other team makes mistakes and doesn't win every match they should. But I watch Everton and couldn't give a toss what they do or didn't do!

So from that perspective James argument is right for me. Wins against the top 4 is a bonus, but consistently beating the lesser teams is just as important.

By the way, I'm a numbers person and can't let this slide without my own scenario. We play Liverpool first game of the season, we win! We are on 3 points and Liverpool 0.. Next we play Hull. We lose and Liverpool win.. They are on 3 and us on 3... What happened to our 6 points... Oh yes.. That's right.

Ross Edwards
112 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:01:24
Kevin, James is right. You could win at all big 4 grounds and do the double over Liverpool, Man Utd and the like, but if you can't beat beatable teams like Hull, you have a problem — squad, manager or otherwise.
Paul Andrews
113 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:10:38
The issue is not with the fact that Moyes had 44 attempts to win at the sky 4 and didn't manage even one.
The issue is with the manner he approached the games in question.
Sam Hoare
114 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:08:01
Brent, yes, I guess you are correct. But to deny them that opportunity is what makes '6 pointers' perhaps more crucial than other matches.
Paul David
115 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:14:57
Paul

Nail on head.

Kevin Tully
116 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:20:44
A lesser spotted six pointer has apparently been holding press conferences at Old Trafford.

We could re-brand it a 'multi pointer,' or just a very important game.

Brent Stephens
117 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:36:26
Aye, Sam, they feel more crucial.
Michael Evans
118 Posted 11/10/2013 at 18:32:48
Would have to agree totally with Craig Walker (950) and Paul Andrews (994).

DM didn't win at Sky 4 because psychologically he didn't believe it was possible ... inherent negativity, inferiority complex against the 'bigger' clubs etc take your psychological pick.

As someone who works in the 'psychobabble' field I always found DM's tenure at Goodison fascinating.

Bingham, Lee were sacked for NOT winning anything. Our 'Howie' came mightily close to being sacked but for that back pass. The 1984 Cup win was vitally important in that it broke through a psychological barrier and the players and HK then believed we could win.They carried that through the 84/85 season and even when they didn't play well they benefited from the psychological edge over their opponents.

DM's close relationship with BK certainly helped him enormously. Who was using who in that I wonder ? The DM era will be viewed as a time where the Everton manager was no longer judged on winning trophies.

Paul Andrews
119 Posted 11/10/2013 at 19:20:20
The big teams almost smelled the fear when they played against Moyes's Everton at home. Wave after wave of pressure building up over the course of the game.They went out against us with the psychological boost of knowing our manager believed we were out of our depth.
Darren Hind
120 Posted 11/10/2013 at 20:01:53
The shite are not a top four club, haven't been for some time now and even if they were, that's not the reason we want to beat them so badly. We owe them and we have owed them for the best part of half a century.

The first time I went to Anfield, 43 years ago, we surrendered a two-goal lead and I can count on one hand the number of times we have won there since. We've been robbed so often by them, not just in games but of our one chance to create a dynasty. When Distin's goal was disallowed, it was merely the latest episode of what seems like a lifetime of injustice.

Beating Liverpool at Anfield would be nice, but it will not suffice; only a sustained period of beating them big and beating them often will come close to payback.

Our record against top teams has been desperate since the turn of the century, we just weren't good enough. You cannot send people like Weir, Stubbs, Hibbert, Neville, Davies, Radzinsky and Pistone to face world class quality like Keane, Vierra, Overmars, Van Nistleroy, Henry, Drogba, Alonso and hope to compete.

Our performances against the big boys has improved beyond measure in recent seasons, Spurs and City have contested to four recently and our record against them is as good as anybody's. We were robbed at the Etihad last season just as we were at Anfield. We could easily have won at the Emirates and only a lucky late equalizer, prevented us from winning at WHL again. We couldn't have come closer to winning one of these games without actually doing so; if we don't do it this season, can we really talk of improvement?

We have our striker now and I expect to win at one or two of these grounds. Given their spending power, we will probably never be as close to the big boys again.

Jimmy Sørheim
122 Posted 11/10/2013 at 21:51:46
I am not delighted about RM. I think he is too used to being a relegation manager.

Overall besides Chelsea I am not pleased at our start this season.

I am not prepared to lower my standards for ANY manager no matter how friendly he might be.

I do think there is hope of RM learning how to become a top 6 manager, but he has a long way to go, as showed by his purchaces.
I judge him on his PERMANENT signings and I have to say I am not impressed by Jobles, Kone, and ALcaraz.

I think Bill Kenwright and RM has managed to fool most fans by getting Lukaku and Barry in on loan and in that way pretending that our transfer policy is better than it really is.

The 3 first transfers he made was straight from Wigan and from those players he had last season, and given they got relegated I think those 3 are far below OUR standard Moyes had sat here.

Mccharthy is being described as a top young talent, but in truth he is not a talent anymore as he is 22 years old, and his skills may not rise beyond what he currently can.

I find if you look closely and with a critical viewwe simply have failed in this transfer vindow, and only bought average players that does not build on what we already have.

Lukaku is a young top talent being 19 years old, BUT he is only here on loan until the end of this season.

I feel RM has to to the following:
1.
Employ top scouts and use them.
Currently he has not used his scouts at all if you look at his transfers and loans, these were players he already knew very well.
2.
Employ at least 2 top youth coaches and fire Alan Stubbs.
3.
Be smart and send his scouts to countries that are in money trouble, such as Spain, Greece and so on.

I would grade RM as following:
Results could be better in many matches, and the overall fitness of the players are too low compared to when Moyes was in the reign.
His tactical changes are good, but I think he should explore 4-4-2 or another formation with 2 strikers as I am worried about Kone, Vellios and Jelavic losing their ability to find goals while they just sit on the bench.

Overall Roberto has done okay with Everton, but there are large rooms for further improvement.
Compared to Moyes he is a lot more positive, but his winner instinct is a little lacking.

Phil Sammon
123 Posted 11/10/2013 at 22:27:03
We're 7th after 7 games, Jimmy, how many times did Moyes better that in 11 years?

I'm sorry to resort to petty name calling but you're a dick, mate. You've got it in for the manager and that's that.

I can't believe you're using successful loan signings as a stick to beat the man who brought them in.

Robles is a good number 2 (did you see Mucha's howler tonight?)
Alcaraz will prove to be a super player - my balls are on the line with that one
Kone will be good too, but probably overpriced.

There is certainly enough evidence to begin evaluating Martinez, but the way Jimmy talks about him is uncalled for and, frankly, fucking irritating.

Mark Frere
124 Posted 11/10/2013 at 22:36:21
Come on Jimmy, its far too early to judge Martinez and his signings. Alcaraz was a free transfer and if we can get him back to full fitness I'm sure we will see a very good player, I've only heard good things about him.

Kone probably was a bit of silly signing, purely because of his age and transfer fee, it's quite clear now with the addition of Lukaku, Kone won't be first choice. There's no doubt though, Kone looked a very good player last season, he's got pace to burn and a decent goal scoring record.

Robles is a very young GK with lots of potential it's far too early to say he's a bad signing, let's make that judgement when we've seen him for a sustained period in the first team.

McCarthy, Barry, Lukaku and Deulofeu have been nothing less than a breath of fresh air IMO. I know three of them are on loan but let's not forget there should be plenty of money left for Martinez to spend if BK keeps true to his promise.

Just give RM a chance mate!

Sean McKenna
125 Posted 11/10/2013 at 22:43:12
Wow, Jimmy, you stooping a bit low, mate.

Firstly, Martinez has "patched" over the squad; I believe he said he will give every player a fair crack of the whip, which he has.

How can you say the signings have been poor? Robles is backup keeper, Kone has played 100 minutes of footie, Alcaraz has been injured. How can you judge these guys already?

You talk about standards, how about zero cups in 11 years under Moyes? Or zero away wins at the top clubs? A hard standard to follow.

Karl Masters
127 Posted 11/10/2013 at 23:43:32
When you think about it, perhaps we need to approach our view on a season line this:

70 points would give us a good crack at Top 4. To do that let's day we need 40 Points at home and 30 points away.

So at home 11 wins, 7 draws and 1 defeat or 12 wins, 4 draws and 3 defeats would get the 40 points.

Away from Goodison, 8 wins, 6 draws and 5 defeats or 7 wins, 9 draws and 3 defeats or even 10 wins and 9 defeats!

That's the sort of standard required and its a question roughly overall of winning half your games, drawing a third and losing 1 in 6.

Last two years we have been ok on the defeats ratio, but drawn too many and therefore not won enough. 5 draws instead of wins is 10 points and the difference between top 4 and 6th or 7th.

To turn draws into wins you need late goals and a level of fitness and stamina and match winners. We appear to have the services of a match winner this season and on that basis if RL stays fit and in form we might just be able to make the leap!

Robbie Shields
128 Posted 12/10/2013 at 02:01:49
Phil, I'm with you 100%, Jimmy, you're talking utter utter crap, some of the worst shite I have ever read on these pages, you are embarrassing yourself.

You are judging RM on his permanent signings only? WTF

Have you seen how superb McCarthy has been in Central Midfield?

We are 7th having played superb possession based football from day 1 and having played 2 of the big 4 spenders already, with Hull at home next.

Utterly utterly idiotic post.

Jimmy Sørheim
129 Posted 12/10/2013 at 01:49:59
Phil Sammon, no need for name calling, it is so childish and uncalled for so I will not stoop to your level.

I do NOT have it in for RM. I always try and look at things the hard truth way and, though I accept it is early, I think it is just right and fair to point out the weak spots about our team, manager and Chairman. But I love Everton and only want what is best.

I think RM could be a great manager, but to be honest, he has a bit to learn to be a top, top manager. However, I find hope in his latest transfer dealings, being McCarthy with Lukaku and Barry on loan. That is the calibre of players needed and, since we have little money to spend, I think that we have to scout and choose very very carefully before we buy.

Can RM adapt to being a top 6 manager? Probably... but it is very clear that he needs time, maybe a season or so, to adapt fully. Both RM and Moyes have taken a step up, and RM is the one who has adapted the best in my mind.

I urge you to not get carried away from all the positive talk in the media, and try look at the cold hard truth, as that will help to put things in perspective. Bill Kenwright has to prove himself in the January transfer window: if RM does not get the players he wants, then we will fall backwards and I do not want that. First task is to keep hold of Baines and hand him a new contract, and the second is to free up as much money as possible to help RM build a much stronger team for the seasons to come.

I am feeling positive, but I fear we will not show up to take Hull seriously and in the end either lose or draw. A win against Hull is a must to keep pace with the top 4.

Ross Edwards
130 Posted 12/10/2013 at 16:00:30
I have to say that I agree with Mark, Phil and Robbie on this, Jimmy. I think January is when we can judge whether we have progressed from last season.

We have the Felli and Anichebe money to spend in January, so I am very confident of the good season to come.

David Donnellan
131 Posted 12/10/2013 at 15:48:32
It is not the end of the world that we have been beaten by Man City away. Let's look at the results of a few of the teams around us, so far this season:-

Arsenal 1 Villa 3
Spurs 0 West Ham 3
Liverpool 0 Southampton 1
Man Utd 1 West Brom 2

These are just some results that spring to mind, my point is that it is a fairly open season thus far and our results stand up reasonably well at this stage of the season, there is plenty more football still to play & we are only 4 points off the top, with a very good squad of players imo. I think whilst we are obviously still a team in transition, RM is doing a very good job thus far & taking us in the right direction, long may it continue!

I was as underwhelmed as many on here were at RM's appointment, but credit where credit is due, he deserves a pat on the back for what he has done so far.

Interesting reading different posts on here regarding RM's transfer dealings, mainly commenting on how good or bad his permanent & loan signings are. For me, I am impressed with his belief in Barkley, he has picked him as his attacking midfielder since day one of the season & has stuck with him so far. Something a lot of the fans have been screaming for in the past couple of seasons. It is clear whilst still a little raw, he is definitely improving & could be something special, he is definitely justifying RM's belief in him.

If we were still under the previous regime, I do believe he would still be making cameos or dare I say it, on loan to somewhere like Barnsley! Although OFM may have recognized his talent, he just didn't trust him & just gave him 10-20 mins here & there. The result was that when Barkley did come onto the field, he would try way to hard to make an impression & would end quite often when I saw him make the wrong decisions, this wasn't aiding his development. Fairplay to Martinez on bringing him in & letting him develop.

All-in-all, I think there are signs to be optimistic so far, I know there is a way to go yet.

Tony Marsh
132 Posted 12/10/2013 at 16:42:41
Ross @126, "We have the Anichebe and Fellaini money to spend in January"... Really?

I would wager a tidy sum Roberto doesn't see Penny One of that money. We may sign Barry on a free but, as for spare change change floating around... I don't see it.

Ross Edwards
133 Posted 12/10/2013 at 16:58:41
Well Tony, Bill said at Roberto's first press conference that he would get every penny from player sales, and I am sure he would want to back his new man as much as possible.

Do I think he was being truthful?

Of course not, but I'm damn sure Roberto thought it was genuine, so I'd be incredibly disappointed if there were no January arrivals.

A new LB is high on the agenda. Baines is stalling on a new deal, and I don't want us to be caught out on deadline day with no chance of a replacement.

Tony Marsh
134 Posted 12/10/2013 at 17:55:25
Time to let Baines go now... we cant hold him back from a chance to play CL footy and a double-your-money pay-rise. Every player has his price and we should ask for £15-20 million for Baines plus Wilfred Zaha who Deadly Dave has frozen out, Antarctic style. I never understood Moyes when he used to ruin players by putting them in too deep...
Mark Frere
135 Posted 12/10/2013 at 18:32:31
Ross Edwards (132)

At the press conference, BK actually promised Martinez a few bob to spend and all the money from player sales. I think the few bob was spent on Kone and Robles.

We sold Fellaini and Anichebe for a combined fee of £33.5 million and bought McCarthy for £13 million, so Martinez should still have £20 million left to spend. Lets hope BK stays true to his word.

I don't think we need to strengthen in January like you say, we need to strengthen in the summer when Lukaku, Deulofeu and Barry's loans have expired. Lukaku will definitely take some replacing, we will probably sign Barry on a permanent bass, Deulofeu – who knows?

Finally, you could be right about us needing a new LB, Baines doesn't look like signing a new contract and he will only have 18 months left on his contract come January. We should get round about £15 million for him if we sell. What about Bertrand from Chelsea? Seems as he has been frozen out there and he is young and a very good player IMO.

Kevin Tully
136 Posted 12/10/2013 at 20:36:57
York races - not even a sniff of a winner. Salt & pepper chicken consolation prize.
Kevin Tully
137 Posted 12/10/2013 at 20:39:42
Marshy. What table you on in the Alex?

Describe yourself in less than 20 words you handsome bastard.

Ross Edwards
138 Posted 13/10/2013 at 14:13:52
Good suggestion Mark, Bertrand is a decent player. What about Danny Rose?
Dave Southword
139 Posted 15/10/2013 at 12:47:42
Mike 859:

"And if Deulofeu only rates an incomplete, you must be the Iceman, because everybody I know gets a serious adrenaline rush the minute the guy touches the ball."

For balance, it is worth pointing out that the same thing happened in the Paddock whenever Peter Beagrie got the ball and set about beating 5 men... or was it the same man 5 times?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb