Elstone backs Premier League firepit

, 11 October, 44comments  |  Jump to most recent
Robert Elstone has been stirred to write a passionate defence of the Premier League as being the best possible environment for the development of English youth players, with the number and quality of top foreign players creating the highest standards, insinuating that the real problems regarding 'England FC' lie elsewhere...
I write as a committed ‘Premier Leagueist' but I'm certain those in the game know which organisation has transformed the fortunes of English football, has put our game back on the map, has put respectability back into our game.

The world's most admired, envied and respected League is ours. And it's not just about the money. The Premier League has created the most demanding and competitive league in the world where only the best survive. The Premier League has created the perfect environment to develop world class players, a research and development laboratory with maximum stress testing and the potential for true Darwinian outcomes.

It is the political capital leveraged by the revelation that ‘only' 30% of total minutes played in the Premier League is English that has moved me to write. It's hardly revelatory, it's something we've known for a while, and, it is claimed to reveal the root of the problem, our League is full of foreigners. But maybe we should consider whether ‘full' is a problem. How many great players do we actually need to win a World Cup? The Belgians might do it with fifteen? 30% is actually quite a big number when you consider they're playing in the most demanding League in the world.

Read his full blog at the link below...

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (44)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Ashton
1 Posted 11/10/2013 at 14:41:50
The Analogy I will always use when it comes to international football youth is this...

When Germany took part in the 2006 world cup they took a lot of the youth team that won their respective championships the previous year, beating England's kids in the process. They had Keidra and Ozil amongst others but all quality players. The kicker with this, the young players were also playing for their clubs at the same time, not on loan to some 3rd division minnow to toughen up. So Bayern Munich, Leverkusen, Dormund, Hertha Berlin? and any other top club was playing their youth already.

Compare it to today, how many of the England under 21s are even playing in the premiership? How many are playing lower league or rotting away in academies/reserves? How many of the team genuinely step up to the top level as they pass 21 and how many just end up in the lower leagues for the rest of their careers? The problem is there, we cannot progress because hardly any of the players in the under 21s are simply not getting the game time. Combine that with poor coaching at that level and we are stalling year on year. Pearce and Southgate are not good enough as top coaches, and we have not had a proper talent since Peter Taylor was it? Not the best club manager admittedly but certainly did a good job internationally.

A side note on the argument of whether to keep the English team English? Only an Englishman could get on their high horse and stick to the flag and queen and a lovely cup of tea over the matter. The fact is, the teams that knock us out of major tournaments have foreign born players so if that is another stumbling block on us actually achieving greatness then its there in black and white. France, Germany, Portugal out perform us every 2 years yet we can't do what they do because we are England?

Erik Dols
2 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:06:32
So all of a sudden Belgium has won the WC? Seriously, Belgium hasn't qualified for the WC the last 12 years and he is using them as an example? And what on earth has Belgium to do with the PL? Ridiculous. Made me laugh out loud.

From an outside perspective, the England squad just isn't that good, hasn't been for the last 15 years or so. To me, England is a bit like Everton in the PL the last 10 years. They will qualify for the tournament but you just know that they will be out before the semi finals are played, just like you know Everton will get a decent mid-table position. Last time England had strikers (plural) that really would make life bad for world class defenders was Owen/Shearer in 1998. Defence always has been shaky. In midfield England had world class players but all the same type (Lampard/Gerrard for example). And do not get me started on the goalies... Throwing young players in the deep and starting them in the PL could help this indeed, although I think the last years England simply lacks the quality anyway, PL or no PL.

Brian Harrison
3 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:12:37
I think RM wrote a very interesting piece a few weeks back pointing out that many of our youngsters get to 18 and find there is very little chance of making the squad in the premiership never mind getting into the team. I listened to Glenn Hoddle today and found it encouraging some of the things he is trying to promote now he is part of the new FA set up.

I know its the trend in many sports to have players born in other countries playing for national teams. But my question to that is then if we allow non nationals to compete for countries then what is the point of having International games at all as they are meaningless. Might as well replace it with a Premier league team playing a La Liga team. The England cricket team has 2/3 South Africans, Zola Budd represented team GB. The list is endless and it seems the criteria is that if their successful and we can claim them as our own then great.

Patrick Murphy
4 Posted 11/10/2013 at 15:34:22
The real question is not the number of non-English players plying their trade in the Premier League, but the quality of those players in comparison to say ten or fifteen years ago, While it's true to say there are still a few very good overseas players in the PL there are a few, but not as many as in the past who are truly world-class and a great many more who are merely average.

Cost is the reason pure and simply that so many non-British players are in the top flight and not just the top divisions but throughout the league pyramid. British players and England players in particular cost far too much and because of this their chances of gaining experience in the top league are restricted.

Phil Sammon
5 Posted 11/10/2013 at 16:05:17
It's because of the money.
It's because we have the best league in the world.
It's because English players won't play abroad.

How many top Belgian, Dutch, Brazilian, French players remain in their respective countries? Some do, of course, but if they can't get in the very best team then they seek new clubs abroad. English players don't do this. They stay put, maybe move domestically, but so few make the leap to another country. Consequently we have a glut and many potentially good footballers are playing too infrequently.

We also have situations where even our Championship clubs are filled with completely average foreigners rather than nurturing their own talent.

I think the idea of getting this panel together is a good one - but I think they've selected a group of muppets to carry it out. Has anyone ever heard Danny Mills say anything remotely insightful? The guy is a first class nugget. Howard Wilkinson - 30 years out of date and that's when he was managing Leeds in the 90's.

Ahhh, I don't know, I just think I should have made the panel to be honest.

Al Reddish
6 Posted 11/10/2013 at 17:22:13
The trouble is England managers never look past the sky 4 and believe gerrard and lampard are still the answer. Other players don't get a look in we have elsewhere. A lot of English players have been sat on the bench at city and chelsea ... not because THEY want them, they don't want anyone else to have them. Also a lot of English coaches are so tactically inept and ate to stubborn to adapt. Look no further than Woy with his 442. They reckon he will play wellbeck left wing. What a farce...is there no other English player who actually plays in that position able to put a few decent passes and crosses in against montefukinegro?
Mike Allison
8 Posted 12/10/2013 at 00:29:50
"It's because English players won't play abroad."

I think this is it. If we accept that we have a truly open, global, free market whereby English clubs will simply buy and pick the best players wherever they can get them from, then English players have to play for the best club at the best standard wherever they can get game time.

At the moment there is a completely asymmetrical relationship here. The clubs will play anyone from anywhere, but the players will only try to play for English clubs.

Young English players moving abroad does happen occasionally, but they are then treated as 'off the radar' and ignored, rather than recognised as having taken a courageous step, and learning another perspective on football that they wouldn't have picked up at home.

There's a column/article on the BBC website at the moment about how English players are getting game time in the Championship. The general point is that this is a good thing because the Championship is such a good league, in fact better than some European top divisions like in Belgium and Serbia. This smacks of desperation. Surely if so many French players can make a living in England, there must be a few English who can make a living in France?

In the end the problem comes down to the same thing its always been deep down. English players are thick, and not capable of thinking about the game (obviously there are exceptions to this), and this is so much more important than anyone seems to realise as they bang on about 'technique' or 'technical skills' which our top players actually have in abundance. If they were less thick and more open to new ideas and new experiences, a lot more of them would move abroad and be successful. As it is, we have players who struggle to move out of their parents' houses and be successful, and therefore a national team of lost little boys who often look out of their depth on the biggest occasions.

Ian Burns
9 Posted 12/10/2013 at 08:20:19
If this self-serving load of "jumping on the bandwagon" diatribe had been written by somebody other than by an officer of our beloved EFC, it would have earned a glance and the thought "I don't give a flying duck, I've read it all before".

But unfortunately it turned up on my favourite website TW and it had to be read.

Can somebody with half a brain on this site, please tell me what the following means:

"a research and development laboratory with maximum stress testing and the potential for true Darwinian outcomes".

And also the following:

"It is the political capital leveraged by the revelation that ‘only' 30% of total minutes played in the Premier League is English . ."

"It's not just about money . . ." - I understand that bit.

It might not be about money at EFC because we don't have any but we are desperate to get into the CL because the fans want the best competition at GP, the board want it because it brings in the income.

I could site many reasons why it is all about money but we have read it all before. Funny that this gentleman doesn't once mention it is all about the fans and the Club itself but at least we know it's not all about money. TOSH.

30% of English players in the Premier League is more than enough it would appear. If that is so, then why not bring in a rule which says 30% of the squad named for the season is English or England qualified?

"The Belgians might win the World Cup with 15 players." I can't even bring myself to comment on this sentence!

Please Mr. Kenrick, yourself and Mr. Lloyd and the fans excellent, diverse, humorous comments and articles make this website a joy to read, posting this regurgitated diatribe only makes me think you should have brought in a translator so we could understand some of the gobbledegook language – or am I just thick?

It all boils down to the fact: "Do we care are about the England football team?" Well I do, it is my second team behind EFC so for somebody to drown out the argument by lauding the Premier League (as good as it is) is not the answer. It lies deeper and some of the comments already posted on here show far more understanding and knowledge than the officer of EFC who wrote this article.

Chris; Erik; Brian; Patrick; Phil; Al and Mike have already posted far more intelligent comments than the article itself. Somebody is in the wrong job for the wrong reasons.

Mike Allison
10 Posted 12/10/2013 at 14:09:28
"a research and development laboratory with maximum stress testing and the potential for true Darwinian outcomes".

Assuming yours is a genuine inquiry Ian, I'll attempt some translation. This means that only the best get selected in the Premier League, so if an English player is succeeding regularly in the Premier League, he's bloody good, the shit ones fall away and have to play elsewhere. No more Lee Dixons.

"It is the political capital leveraged by the revelation that ‘only' 30% of total minutes played in the Premier League is English . ."

This bit is basically part of his argument that it doesn't matter how many English players there are, it matters how good the ones that are there are. For example, in extremis, if there were only 25 English players in the Premier League, but they were the 25 best players in the world, the England team would be a bloody good team.

This fits in with his comment about the Belgians. You can only put 11 on the pitch, 3 subs later in the game, and you'll want a decent other option or two and maybe some good back-ups, but England shouldn't need 200 Englishmen to choose from, just a really high quality 40 or 50. Elstone is saying that the current Premier League set-up is geared to produce that high quality 40-50, and he's arguing that that's fine. I actually tend to agree with him, hence my point above about some English players needing to go abroad to play top division and European football. For example, if you're Tom Carroll and Tottenham's 8-10 imported midfielders get picked ahead of you, go to France, Germany, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Holland or somewhere and get into the teams they've vacated. Not only will you play top division football, maybe some Europa League or even Champions League, but you'll learn other perspectives on football (and, dare I say it, life) that may make you a better player.

Erik Dols
11 Posted 12/10/2013 at 15:51:10
Mike, I appreciate you explaining the Belgian comment. But England has actually performed better than Belgium on every single WC since 1994. Belgium never won the World Cup and never even reached the final of a WC. It's just plain ridiculous to use them as an example of, direct quote, "How many great players do we actually need to win a World Cup?".
Nick Entwistle
12 Posted 12/10/2013 at 16:25:18
Erik, Since 94 Belgium have had a wealth of talent coming through and England's apparently Golden Generation have exited all championships without any pride at all.

France qualified... no, actually given a bye to the WC in 98... their first since 86 and won.

Their rise was bigger than Belgium's. And Greece won the Euros with no great players... Maybe next year is too soon but they have a great team and is yet to peak.

Ross Edwards
13 Posted 12/10/2013 at 16:50:23
I agree with you Nick (I know, that stroll helped!), Belgium have a very good chance of winning this World Cup.

If they avoid the likes of Brazil in their group with some big hitters going out early, you just never know.

I mean, like you said, who would have thought that of all teams, Greece would win the Euros in 2004?

Erik Dols
14 Posted 12/10/2013 at 19:12:22
Although Belgium obviously has a wealth of talent coming through they will not win the World Cup. They'll probably reach the quarter finals or so, IMHO. But that is not the point I am trying to make. The argument is that Elstone is using Belgium as a direct example of a World Cup winning team. Even if they were to win it next summer, they currently have not won it or even reached the final – ever. They managed to miss the last two World Cups. It is ridiculous to use Belgium as an example of a World Cup winning team, simply because they are not. That's my point.

Personally I think there are about 8 or 9 countries who have a better chance at winning the World Cup than Belgium, BTW. They are a bit overrated at the moment. I do understand why, they are an exciting young team who play a nice attacking game, what's not to like? But there are some teams who will beat them for sure.

Paul Smith
15 Posted 12/10/2013 at 20:59:59
Elstone's comments seem like office-boy ignorance to me. Our league is overloaded with foreigners and it's the ones who come here and sit on benches at best who are the problem in my eyes. How many foreigners did Rafael Benitez bring over here that never made the first team as a regular, Houllier before that? This isn't a rant at Liverpool by the way but they are examples that spring to mind straight away.

These kids come over here and we all expect big things when we hear the names but how many really come here to succeed? How many go back without doing anything at Premier League level at all. I'd rather see an English kid given one of them vital places at youth level and developed by the best possible coaches around.

Vellios for us is a fine example of the waste of squad number, he's seemed very happy to settle in England on a nice wage and doesn't seem keen at all to become a better player at the moment.

Until the FA and government invest in some excellent grass root facilities then England will stand still. The streets are too dangerous for kids now and there's not much else out there where they can safely learn the game. It's a big project but the Germans, Belgians, Africans and Holland before that have proved it's the way forward.

Watching England is dull to me and I see more patriotic passion from the opposition in most cases. I want to see the next generation play with the passion they use at their clubs and then we'll see some hunger at least. So come on the powers that be and do what's right for the game.

Nick Entwistle
16 Posted 12/10/2013 at 23:20:00
Why has nadir been replaced by the word wealth in my last post? It makes it sound like the Mpenza brothers were as good as Scifo and Ceulemans.
Raymond Fox
17 Posted 12/10/2013 at 23:32:34
The main reason very few of English or UK players for that matter play abroad, is that in most cases their not good enough, and are not wanted.

Also if we have the best and most admired league, why doesn't an English club win the European Cup more often?

Ian Burns
18 Posted 13/10/2013 at 08:44:52
Mike - 113 - Many thanks and yes my request was genuine!

It might not be a bad idea if Elstone - if he reads this site - might contact you to write his next diatribe so at least it can be understood by the likes of myself - just an ordinary EFC supporter who needs things spelling out clearly. Now I've just written that, maybe the Board read this site and they might take the same advice!

Mike Green
19 Posted 13/10/2013 at 09:26:30
I agree with the point that you only need c.20 high quality Englishmen to create a World Cup winning squad, but the issue is percentages.

To 'get' those 20 you need them to be the top, say, 10% of Englishmen, playing at the highest level day in day out - the chances of having 20 playing at that level and them all coming good are a bit like doing the lottery.

Because the competition, fashion, economics of the Premier League might exclude many Englishmen with potential then the suggestion that they should ply their trade elsewhere is a valid one but it would probably would make their chances of getting noticed enough to get into PL 1st team or the England team even harder.

I think the players are there - just look at what the City of Liverpool have produced in recent years - the issue is they aren't learning from being around 'the best' because 'the best' are keeping them on the training ground, which means they can't develop into being 'the best', they just become 'the rest'.

Matt Traynor
20 Posted 13/10/2013 at 09:30:27
There are a multitude of problems at the root of this, and the obscene money paid to average players is part of it. However, imagine if all the money generated by the Premier League wasn't going straight to players pockets, where would it go?
- Investment in stadium improvements / new stadium; reduced ticket prices for fans?
- Into the owners pockets

For me it's sad that a prospect can be a millionaire before he's kicked a ball for the first time. At an impressionable age that can lead to all sorts of irresponsibility (and there are plenty of examples) often at the expense of football development.

When they eventually don't make it, they don't give two fucks. They're loaded. At least for now. The saddest image I saw recently was the Newcastle U-21 squad getting onto a coach after a match, with a certain Peter Beardsley loading their kit hampers onto the bus. A player I always enjoyed watching, but particularly for Everton. A bit unsure of signing him at 30, he was (unless mistaken) the last player to score 20 league goals in a season for us (I think all 20 goals he got that season were in the league). And we still sold him for a profit at 32. (More short-sightedness from EFC).

Keith Glazzard
21 Posted 13/10/2013 at 10:23:25
English players playing abroad? What, and learn a foreign language? Its an easy joke to make, but many seem to struggle with English. Remember when Rooney first emerged? Moyes wouldn't let him anywhere near a microphone. And think of the many other home comforts they would miss - Rush was a good example. No mate, abroad is for holidays.

And 'English'. I wonder, because I don't know, what the percentage of English players in the First Division was before the 'foreign invasion'? Scots and Irish, plus some Welsh had always been an important part of the picture, hardly potential England material.

Nigel Gregson
22 Posted 13/10/2013 at 11:03:40
Its because quality young english players with high potential are bought by richer clubs, only to rot on the bench rather than getting game time with other clubs (Rodwell?). Very few are allowed to truly develop (Ruddy?). There is no incentive for young players to force a move or to reject a move to a higher paying club in exchange for more game time. Take Lukaku for instance - he forced a loan move for game time. Ever seen an english lad have the courage ?

Furthermore, the style of english football has been dross and uninspired for as long as I can remember. The Germans, the Spanish, the Brazillians are defined by their footballing ideologies. What have England got ? Kick it up and 10 men behind ?

Steve Pugh
23 Posted 13/10/2013 at 11:19:19
Since when does "Belgium might do it with fifteen" translate into Belgium are a world cup winning team? FFS read what is written instead of just the odd word and then filling in the blanks to make it say what you want.

To my mind there are some simple solutions to help this problem. One, stop issuing work permits to non-EU kids because they are an exceptional talent. More room in academies for our kids. Two limit the number of foreign players allowed to play in the reserves. Whilst it doesn't sound like much at least it will give our kids some sort of game time to develop, and it is unlikely to cause the uproar that a limit on first teams would create. Three put a minimum number of Englishmen in every teams first eleven. Only has to be three or four but it would make a difference, the teams with lots of Englishmen will stay that way whilst the rest have to adapt.

Eric Myles
24 Posted 13/10/2013 at 11:29:36
Nigel #224, the home grown quota could account for some of that also as clubs have to have English players in their squad of 25 but don't have an obligation to play them. So the likes of Rodwell make up the percentage while the foreign players take to the field.

(Yes I know 'home grown' doesn't necessarily mean English, e.g. Tim Cahill, but more often than not they are)

Brian Denton
25 Posted 13/10/2013 at 11:44:05
You can't do quotas anyway, can you? So as a solution it falls at the first hurdle.
Michael Winstanley
26 Posted 13/10/2013 at 11:58:46
England are shit for the simple reason we don't have any tactical acumen. That goes to the players and management.

The last time I watched England and thought we had half a chance was under Hoddle.

As for our players playing abroad, when was the last time one of Europe's elite came in for an English player at his peak?

Ian Burns
27 Posted 13/10/2013 at 14:01:50
I read today that Belgium's first 11 all ply their trade in the Premier League and they have run away with their qualification group.

The England 11 - 15 - against Montenegro all play in the Premier League and they are not out of the qualifaction group yet.

It means nothing I know - just a comment.

Eugene Ruane
28 Posted 13/10/2013 at 14:38:53
"Hello" he lied.
John Haldane
29 Posted 13/10/2013 at 14:46:56
Can anyone remember the last time an all English 11 won the league?

My GUESS is that it was 1970 ...

West, Wright, Newton, Kendall, Labone, Harvey, Husband, Ball, Royle, Hurst, Morrissey.

Could be wrong but don't think so.

Mike Allison
30 Posted 13/10/2013 at 16:03:19
"To 'get' those 20 you need them to be the top, say, 10% of Englishmen, playing at the highest level day in day out - the chances of having 20 playing at that level and them all coming good are a bit like doing the lottery."

Not necessarily Mike, and that's Elstone's point. When he talks about 'stress testing' and 'Darwinian outcomes' he's putting the case that what you say isn't true.

The argument, which I mostly agree with in principle (though I would qualify some important details) is that the other 90% of Englishmen are still out there, they're just on the bench or playing in the Championship, whereas in the 80s they'd have been first teamers in the top division. The 20 (actually its more like 50 or so) are therefore also playing at a higher standard week in week out than they would be if there were a load of journeymen duffers getting a game just because they happened to be English.

Therefore its not analogous to doing the lottery, if there are 20 English players in the Premier League, they are by definition fucking brilliant players, because they couldn't survive there if they weren't.

Mike Allison
31 Posted 13/10/2013 at 16:12:38
"England are shit for the simple reason we don't have any tactical acumen. That goes to the players and management. The last time I watched England and thought we had half a chance was under Hoddle."

I agree with all that.

However, as for foreign clubs signing English players, I don't think you're right. Only two clubs in Europe have paid bigger wages than English clubs over the last 10-15 years or so, Real Madrid and Barcelona. Therefore English players have not shown any interest in going abroad. There has certainly been serious interest in the likes of Gerrard, Lampard and Ashley Cole, but they all just used it to get even fatter contracts at their current clubs. Barcelona have grown their own and bought Dutch and Brazilians so not looked at English players at all, but Real Madrid have signed Steve McManaman, Michael Owen, Jonathan Woodgate, David Beckham and now Gareth Bale (who is a product of the English system).

Another problem, as I mentioned before, is that unless its to Real Madrid, when English players do move abroad we ignore them completely. Joe Cole, David Bentley, Michael Mancienne and even the likes of Jay Bothroyd, Darius Vassell, Matt Derbyshire and Scott Carson have played in foreign leagues in the last ten years. Many of that list simply weren't good enough to play for England anyway, but there must be a fear for a young player that if he did take that step he would be 'out of sight out of mind'.

Ross Edwards
32 Posted 13/10/2013 at 16:24:32
I think the national side has declined rapidly since Graham Taylor.

Anyone who has watched that documentary, The Impossible Job, will know what I mean.

I mean, lets be honest, England under him were playing football 10 years out of date, I know Norway played a direct style then under Egil Olsen and got a lot of success, he has Phil Neal, the ultimate yes man, and tactically, out of his depth.

All he ever disputed tactically wise during that documentary was "We'll bring Wrighty on anyhow", or "Hit Les over the top", and all Phil Neal ever said was "yep, yep", or copy everything Taylor did, or shout "In the hole"

Just watch that documentary, find it on Youtube or if you have it on tape somewhere, and you will see my point.

Nick Entwistle
33 Posted 13/10/2013 at 16:40:45
Though it never worked out for Graham Taylor I would put a bigger emphasis on the state of England's current situation on Terry Veneballs, more so Keegan then the last ounces of pride thrown out the window with he FA's inferioity complex in hiring a Swedish bloke.

Another way to look at it is to ask what is English football now? What identity does our play have? The PL is so chock full of foreigners we don't have one. Unlike the Germans, Spanish, Italians, Brazil of course... It may well be the Championship that can answer that but when I do see Englan play I just think they're trying to do something you see in the PL but they're generally passing the ball off to better and more effective foreigners.

Not that they are better per se, but the select choice come to play in England.

Ross Edwards
34 Posted 13/10/2013 at 16:49:22
Venables did well though Nick to get to the Euro 96 Semis.

I think Keegan, well he quit because he couldn't do it, like he did with Newcastle, twice, Fulham, City and England.

I think Taylor is the man to blame, I know it wasn't all his fault, obviously Koeman should have been sent off against Holland, Gazza being unfit, Shearer injured, etc.

He had a good bunch of players he could have played, like McManaman, Le Tissier, Chris Waddle, how he didn't pick him is amazing, yet he persevered with Des Walker, Carlton Palmer, Andy Sinton, Ian Wright left on the bench.

The players he did have, Shearer, Ferdinand, Seaman, Adams, Platt, Wright, Ince, formed the base of the Euro 96 squad that reached the semis.

He had a strong team Taylor, yet a mix of bad luck, tactical ineptitude and complacency led to our failures in Euro 92 and failing to qualify for USA 94.

Mark Frere
35 Posted 13/10/2013 at 17:00:02
Ross,

Venables was vastly over-rated IMO. Its much easier to succeed when we were playing in our own back yard. Many of England's performances in Euro 96 weren't that good anyway. We were out-classed in the quarter finals by Spain and they got perfectly good goal ruled out. The opening game against Switzerland we were also piss poor.

Venables had a great squad of players at his disposal and was unable to deliver on our own soil.

Ross Edwards
36 Posted 13/10/2013 at 17:13:30
He was, but who else would have taken that job at the time?

I wonder what would've happened if Kendall was appointed rather than Taylor?

In 1990, it was Venables, Taylor and Kendall, and the FA bigwigs went for Taylor, would history have been different if Howie was instead?

Mark Frere
37 Posted 13/10/2013 at 17:19:59
Kendall was far the superior of the 3.
Ross Edwards
38 Posted 13/10/2013 at 17:25:17
In fact, we've failed to mention Cloughie Mark. If only the FA would have had the balls to appoint him rather than playing safe and getting Greenwood in 1978.
Mark Frere
39 Posted 13/10/2013 at 17:39:05
Cloughie was the greatest manager never to get the England job. TBH I think the FA were terrified of Clough.
Ross Edwards
40 Posted 13/10/2013 at 17:46:43
I think they wouldn't have been able to handle Clough's personality or charisma, I think a reason why Mourinho will never be a contender for the England job.

He would have been brilliant for them success wise, but he wasn't softly softly, politically correct enough for the FA, hence the reason Greenwood got the job.

Nick Entwistle
41 Posted 13/10/2013 at 18:07:58
Venables picked a few shockers as this documentary clip shows.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIqjO7rk014

Keith Glazzard
42 Posted 13/10/2013 at 20:48:50
Ross - I agree that Clough could well have been a very good national team manager. And the fact that the FA never gave him that job says a lot about them. But 'politically correct'? Outspoken, yes. And that's why he didn't get the job.

ps - best England manager for me was Joe Mercer, played Duncan McKenzie and others the usuals wouldn't look at. And was ex Everton of course. And he sat next to my dad at school. I have absolutely no bias.

Erik Dols
43 Posted 14/10/2013 at 08:30:54
Steve Pugh #228

"Since when does "Belgium might do it with fifteen" translate into Belgium are a world cup winning team? FFS read what is written instead of just the odd word and then filling in the blanks to make it say what you want."

Ok, I do read what is written and that is this:

"How many great players do we actually need to win a World Cup? The Belgians might do it with fifteen?"

How does that mean I am filling in the blanks to make it say what I want? FFS read what is written instead of just leaving out a vital part. The word "it" in "Belgium might do it" clearly refers to "win a World Cup".

Ciaran Duff
44 Posted 14/10/2013 at 10:51:51
You can blame the EPL, you can blame foreign players (except if they are Scottish, Irish, Welsh or Australian of course), you can blame every single England manager since Sir Alf Ramsey but IMHO you are just kidding yourselves. The National team, and the representation of English players in the EPL, is the end product of a crap youth development system, a system that has barely changed in 50 years. In that time, the rest of the world has cottoned on and learnt how to develop all-round, skillful, technical players. Most of the best ones who have come through are the exception rather than the rule. The FA is trying to turn the ship around but it is a very big and slow ship to turn and results, if they do come, will take a long time (a generation of kids) to come through.
David Ellis
45 Posted 15/10/2013 at 11:28:44
The reason why there are so few English players in the Premier League is because the Premier League attracts a big chunk of the best talent on the planet. It would be astounding if more than 10% of the best 1000 players were English. The better the Premier League does financially the better it will become and the fewer English players will play in it. Its just mathematics, economics and bell curve distributions of talent - these are immutable laws of nature.

Don't worry though. 57% of players in the Championship are English players. You can always pick a team from there - and if the Premier League becomes more successful (relative to its competitors) that is going to become commonplace. The Championship is the 7th biggest league in Europe by revenue so it ranks ahead of domestic leagues such as Belgium's or Portugal's for example.

Does this matter. No. There is no correlation between the rise of the Premier League and the performance of the English team. 40 years ago we could not get out of a group including Wales and Poland. We didn't qualify in 1978 either. Or in 1994 (when the Premier League was two years old and hardly to blame). Our world ranking has largely remained constant over the 20 year period. There is simply no real evidence for this theory that more good foreign players harms the national team.

The real problem was identified in the 1970s following our 10 year absence from major competition finals, Not enough technical skill, and not enough good coaching at youth levels. The steps taken to fix this have not been enough. To me this is a national scandal, and the problem lies with the FA not the Premier League.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb