Gibson to undergo knee surgery

, 16 October, 80comments  |  Jump to most recent
Irishman suffers cruciate knee ligament injury
Darron Gibson is to undergo surgery after scans confirmed that he suffered a cruciate knee ligament injury during the Republic of Ireland's game against Kazakhstan last night.

The midfielder was stretchered off 38 minutes into the Republic's 3-1 win after his knee buckled as he went in for a routine tackle. He left the stadium on crutches and traveled back to Finch Farm where the severity of the injury was assessed by Everton's medical staff.

Gibson has only just recovered from a knee problem that kept him out of action for the first five of the Blues' league games and this will be a major setback to a career that has been dogged by serious injury.

He will be out of action for between six to nine months but will, in all likelihood, miss the remainder of the season.  



Reader Comments (80)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mark Jones
2 Posted 16/10/2013 at 15:30:30
I'm not usually one for the blame game but, in this case, I can't help but think the FAI should be held responsible.

Martinez couldn't have been more cautious in easing Gibson back in gently after injury, then he goes off with Ireland, plays a full 90 mins against the Germans, and then starts again with just 72 hours rest in between.

For someone with his injury problems that just strikes me as a bit irresponsible. If those were Everton matches on the Friday and the Tuesday, he would've maybe 45-60 mins combined over the two games.

I'm gutted for him, and for Martinez who has been patient with him, and because this now puts pressure on our small squad for the rest of the season. Thankfully it wasn't Barry or McCarthy, who should be our first choice partnership anyway.

Fingers crossed this will prompt another centre mid purchase in January!

Kevin Tully
3 Posted 16/10/2013 at 15:37:17
One consolation is that it looks like FIFA will be paying for him while he is out injured:
A major point of dispute between clubs and governing bodies has been addressed with FIFA on Friday signing off on its new Club Protection Programme (CPP).

The Programme seeks to tackle the thorny subject of insurance for players whilst they are competing on international duty. The CPP was rubber-stamped at the FIFA Congress in Budapest and will provide clubs with a maximum annual payout of US$9.7 million per player injured whilst competing in games included in FIFA’s international match calendar. The agreement will initially run from September 1 through to the end of 2014.The payouts for any injured player will vary from individual to individual depending on the size of their salaries but the maximum amount payable on an injured player will be $27,000 a day. FIFA said the overall estimated cost of the Programme is around $75 million.

“This is very important and is a significant step forward,” said FIFA secretary general Jerome Valcke. A FIFA statement added: “Through the club protection programme FIFA achieves a global harmonised solution on the insurance of players’ question to the benefit of confederations, member associations, players and clubs. With this programme FIFA marks an important step for the benefit of the entire football family in a spirit of dialogue and solidarity.”

UEFA has already established an insurance scheme covering the injury risk of players while on international team duty from the start of Euro 2012. Clubs have long asked for such an initiative, a campaign that intensified after Bayern Munchen lost forward Arjen Robben for six months when the Netherlands winger returned injured from the 2010 FIFA World Cup.

Paul Ferry
4 Posted 16/10/2013 at 15:34:59
This guy was an injury night-mare when we picked him up and he remains today an injury nightmare.

Good on his day, we know, but when I hear people on here talking about him as a key cog or around who the rest of the team moves I always think; for how long, one, two, or three matches in a row?

Quite clearly he is someone on whom we cannot depend never mind build a team around or pencil in as indispensable. By the end of this season by my reckoning he would have featured in around 20 per cent of the games since his signing.

It's time to forget about Gibson for the time being at any rate and buy big in his position. If he returns to fitness and his various injuries hold off long enough for a decent stretch in the team then well and good and we'll revisit selection if that happens.

My hunch is that his boots will be hung up before he reaches 30.

Timothy Sebastian
5 Posted 16/10/2013 at 15:44:51
Gutted for Gibson and frustrated that it happened while he was on international duty for what was, in my mind, was a meaningless fixture. No way he should have been playing the whole game having just come back from injury.
Patrick Murphy
9 Posted 16/10/2013 at 15:53:39
What is this meaningless fixture nonsense every time an International team takes the field it has meaning to its players, management and fans, in the same way that every Everton game has meaning to us.
Kieran Fitzgerald
10 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:05:55
Part of me feels that Gibson may have rushed himself back as he was desperate to get back into the international team. Part of me feels though that it is the only way to do things if you are injury prone. You can't allow the fear of injuries to cause a mental block to form. The thing is though, an injury at international level was the last thing he needed in terms of his career and livelihood.

I suppose it's a balancing act for players. Do you choose to ignore international duties for fear of injury and losing your main employment at club level; or do you look to play as many games in as many situations as you can in what is a relatively short career.

Sharabi Singh
11 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:10:02
Bright side is we got better cover with Barry, and McCarthy will get more games and that will give him a chance to get established. I always thought the Barry Mccarthy partnership looked better on paper. Heitinga and Osman can cover if necessary. RM like to give youth a chance so maybe he'll pluck another diamond out of our youth setup and give them some valuable experience too.
Sam Higgins
12 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:11:46
I think the club should look at a way of getting rid of Gibson – and try terminating his contract. I know it sounds harsh but to be brutally honest I don't have much sympathy – it's not like he'll starve.

Remember these guys would not face the financial worries if you and I were terminated from our jobs for being unfit to work. He's a nice enough guy but what's the fucking point of owning an asset that only works 20% of the time? Its pointless.

Okay, so it's a shame that the guy is a footballer and his body betrays him but at the end of the day you can't run a football club and be carrying liabilities like Gibson. Get shot. Fergie played us a blinder... again.

Steavey Buckley
13 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:21:01
I do believe clubs should be able to loan players immediately when one of theirs is injured on international duty. Clubs like Everton suffer proportionately more than others by having so many players away with their national teams. Gibson could be out for a year.
Drew Shortis
14 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:24:59
Will be sorely missed. Another couple of midfielders in January will be crucial. I know we still have to pay his wages, but at least we only paid £500k for him in the first place. I can't really see Darron having a prolonged run of fitness in his career now which is a real shame as he is a good player.
Chris Williamson
15 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:20:16
An interesting point, made by Kevin Tully, and some scant comfort that our threadbare purse won't be stretched by paying his wages while he's recovering.

I wonder if the Everton board KNOW of this arrangement?

All internationals, at any level, are an honour and opportunity to play football at a different level to usual and for fans to wave a flag and hope for the best.

Gibbo, as any player, could have equally been easily been injured dropping a bottle of shampoo on his foot at home. We can't wrap the players in cotton wool, and I don't understand why people get angry.

On the other hand - perhaps the FAI SHOULD have eased him back more carefully. I did my ACL after an injury. After a lay off, the supporting muscles around the joint have withered away and take time to get back to full strength. The rehabilitation is all about getting the strength back before the player gets back on the field.

At least it is an injury that can be repaired these days. It used to be a career ender.

We do seem to have more than our fair share though. Perhaps some more leg muscle work is needed.

Trevor Lynes
16 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:26:47
I feel really sorry for Gibson as this recurring injury problem/s could curtail his career. I must say that most pro footballers really want to play for their countries and EFC have never tried to stop any player from playing for his native homeland. I must agree with one of the other comments when it seems really foolhardy of the Irish to have him play both games in such a short time considering him being injured at the beginning of the season and not being fit enough for his club. Other players on International duty have been used sparingly to protect them from injury. Gibson was over used in my opinion.

Luckily it is a position that we have reasonable cover for and all I can add is my commiserations with Gibbo and hope he has a full recovery.

Kieran Fitzgerald
17 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:31:23
Sam, I don't think Fergie did anything malicious. Gibson wasn't going to get a game at Utd. He gave him the chance to resurrect his career with Everton for what was basically a nominal fee. From our perspective, for what we paid, it was worth a punt.

The punt didn't fully pay off, I'll accept that. But look at James Vaughan. With his injury record, most clubs woudn't have touched him. Huddersfield took a punt and he is already into double figures this season for goals scored. The Championship is a physical division to play in and he has taken very well to it, injury record or not.

Trevor Lynes
18 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:35:01
Chris..I actually got a double fracture (patella and fibula) banging my knee against an opposing player's knee. He was OK and I was not ! It's not down to leg muscle work, it's down to bad luck in a lot of cases.
Pablo Connelly
22 Posted 16/10/2013 at 16:26:37
Don't really understand why some people feel the need to find someone to blame here. Some players are just injury prone, gods knows why but they are. The fact is Gibson was fit before the game, if he wasn't we wouldn't have let him go. The fact the Irish started him in both games would have been good for us because he badly needed the minutes. We can only hope he can make some sort of contribution to this season now, as unlikely as that is. Personally I am gutted, I still think he is our best midfielder because he has the best range of passing. We can only hope now that McCarthy is the real deal.
Ian Riley
23 Posted 16/10/2013 at 17:22:01
I am sorry for Mr Gibson and his injury. However, over the past year he has suffered injuries and has not had a run of games in the side. The club should have told him international football was too soon for him. I know its selfish but how many times have other clubs pulled players from international games to protect them and the club. These games for Ireland were pointless and Mr Gibson should have put Everton first as he is not 100% match fit to compete in 2 games in 5 days. Everton should receive compensation for his injury from the Irish FA. I thought Mr Gibson was around 32 years old, due to his injuries and fitness issues but he is only 25. I don't know how long his contract is but hopefully everton take this injury into account and offer him a 1 year extension to prove himself following the injury. I hope all goes well for him during and after the surgery.

Best Wishes to all.

Jim Bennings
24 Posted 16/10/2013 at 17:55:59
I cannot make out whether this is simply a case of horrid bad fortune or shocking judgement from both the player and the Republic of Ireland manager.

We knew at the start of the season Gibson was sidelined because of knee problems so when I first heard about him being stretchered off my initial though was it must be knee again, and so it proved but with knee ligaments going this time.

The question needs asking is if Gibson has had a problem with his knee why was it not looked at more thoroughly and second of all I want to ask 'did he ever have that operation that we heard about last May regarding his on-going thigh problem?'
Did we not hear Moyes mention that just before the end of last season that Gibson was supposed to be having a corrective operation to rectify the long lasting injury?

It seems so sad that this has happened now for Darron Gibson and although I agree its no fault of his own to fall down with this depressing latest setback we must now look at the near future and possible long future with him.
It generally takes fit athletes nine months to recover from this injury, I think Arteta was actually out from February 2009 to January 2010 so that was quite a long battle for fitness, and Phil Jagielka too was about 10 months out with his knee ligaments so Gibson will not be seen again this season and probably not the start of next.

I can only wish him well and say that I hope we see him within the year and that our midfield of Barry, McCarthy and Barkley remain in good health, fingers and everything crossed.

Brent Stephens
25 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:14:36
Chad #771 "The sooner we can stop these pointless international matches for Irish, Scottish and Welsh players. the better.

Sorry!"

The sooner we stop these pointless posts the better.

Sorry!

Liam Reilly
26 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:22:56
Err; the games weren't pointless.

Ireland needed 3 points last night to have any chance of being seeded in the second seeds for the Euros and if Romania fail to win both of their playoff games then that will have been achieved.

Just saying.

Brent Stephens
29 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:24:41
Are some players more "injury-prone" or just have more bad luck? How do we tell the difference? That fucking Ross Barkley, missed a full year or more already and he's only a teenager!

I would be staggered if every single player had exactly the same number and type of injuries over their career. Surely some are going to end up with more injuries than others, just through the way the dice roll.

Raymond Fox
30 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:13:48
I feel very sorry for Darron on a personal basis, but I have to say from the club's point of view, he's one employee that they can't rely on.

Looks like it's bad luck with this incident, but he's spending far too much time on the injured list, to be worth much more long-term investment by the club.

Nick Entwistle
31 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:24:27
Easing him back, isn't a dead rubber international against Kazakhstan doing just that?

Moyes took gambles on a few cheap signings. Gibson and Saha because their injury record priced them well below their talent.

Then you have Drenthe and Van Der Meyde because their drinking priced them well below their talent.

Saha did in the main well for us, and signing Gibson allowed Fellaini to play to his potential and was sold for value. One cross from VDM at I'm eternally grateful. Yet Drenthe... what a waste. Hope he's enjoying Reading with all his five appearances.

Not sure what success rate you would call that though.

Alan Corken
32 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:35:47
Gibson sustains injury. What a surprise! When did a Man Utd ever sell a decent player?
Jim Bennings
33 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:41:15
Errrmmm..Cristiano Ronaldo? David Beckham?
Ian Burns
36 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:22:01
Disappointed for Gibson; disappointed for EFC fans, no blame should be attached to anybody because it was all handled in good faith.

Two 90 minutes, had it worked out, would have been wonderful for EFC as we were using the international to get him match fit. It didn't work out, so blame is a pointless exercise.

However, step up young Master Lundstrum - time for RM to show "sin miedo" and give the lad his opportunity. If it works out, we can save the funds to purchase Lukaku given the chance arises.

Ian Burns
37 Posted 16/10/2013 at 19:16:31
I mean "save the funds to put TOWARDS the purchase of Lukaku"!
Peter Thistle
38 Posted 16/10/2013 at 19:16:16
He makes Rodwell look fit as a fiddle.
Karl Masters
39 Posted 16/10/2013 at 19:18:02
I wish Darron a speedy recovery.

I have suffered from knee problems, operations etc, and unless you have been through it, it's hard to know how painful and frustrating it can be.

Whether you're a fan of his or not, just bear in mind that the lad will be more gutted than anybody, and wondering what the future holds. Also for whatever reason, when he plays very rarely lose - something like 3 times in 30 matches I believe. That isn't likely to be just a coincidence.

Lee Robinson
40 Posted 16/10/2013 at 18:45:20
Kanchelskis?
Paul Melarange
41 Posted 16/10/2013 at 19:46:33
Shame to hear about his injury and what a pity he chose to go back and play for the Republic — although, saying that, it could have happened in any game. The only good thing for the team is we have Barry and Barkley but if one or either get injured then we could be quite short of midfielders. Wish Darron a good and speedy recovery as he is a decent player when fit!
Michael Evans
43 Posted 16/10/2013 at 19:41:04
I wish him a speedy recovery

Always wondered over the years why some players make you wince when they tackle, run for a ball, fall over etc because you are worried about them getting injured.

Then there's the 'run through brick wall' types that seem to be able to shake off the physical challenges of playing professional football.

Luck ? Poor pre-season ? Not fit enough ?

Not meaning this in a sarcastic way, but I would have thought that with all this sports science data now available they could identify more clearly why players like Gibson suffer in this way.

Simon Jones
44 Posted 16/10/2013 at 20:01:08
Gibbo, if you are reading this then I hope you take comfort from all of the well wishers hoping you have a speedy recovery, lose your job, get sold, should never have been bought in the first place.

For what it's worth I hope you have a bionic cruciate fitted to both knees so you can keep unleashing those rockets. Get well soon lad.

Mark Dunford
45 Posted 16/10/2013 at 20:04:11
Really sad news. Only the other day I was talking to a friend and we agreed that Gibson's was a career which hadn't flowered because of injuries - mostly niggling and now severe. His best spell was when he first joined Everton. Can only hope he recovers fully and is - as they say - raring to go next year!
Bill Gall
47 Posted 16/10/2013 at 19:45:59
Having had a problem with my knee that eventually had to be replaced I feel sorry for Gibson.

In my case I was able to continue working but in his case not only will he not be able to continue playing, at his age retirement may be in his future earlier than expected..

This will mean that a new midfielder is going to be required in January unless we have someone that can be used from the Under-21s that can be given time to develop as a substitute.

As other people have stated, Gibson with insurance and wages will not be as bad off as the average supporter can be after loosing his career but I still feel gutted for him.

If the manager does buy a midfielder in January, I hope he does not go for an older experienced player for a fill in.

Kieran Fitzgerald
48 Posted 16/10/2013 at 20:12:04
Michael 833, I think that the level of physical effort these players work off makes it harder for the body to fully heal itself. While in the peak of fitness the work they do to keep themselves there must put a strain on your body.

Take Gibson as an example. He has had surgery on a bone spur, what ever that is. It has probably affect the other muscle groups in his leg as they are all interconnected to some degree. It means the whole leg is now under pressure to perform at the level footballers nowadays work at. This means it probably takes less for your body to pick up another injury than it usually would.

Sam Higgins
49 Posted 16/10/2013 at 20:18:09
Paul (837), I don't think its 'well out of order' as you put it.

You're getting too sentimental like a lot of folks on this thread – you think Gibbo's your best mate – he's not, he's an important asset that belongs to Everton FC and he's an asset that's always broken. Everton are not a club that can afford to have first team sick notes spending extended periods in the treatment room. We just don't have that luxury. If he was a Man City player for example they could send him on a 2-year rehab holiday in the Maldives and it would make fuck all difference to their team or finances.

Don't get me wrong, I think on his day Gibson is one of our best and we play better with him. But when is that? Three games at the beginning of every season.

Like I say, we just can't accommodate for that – we need a robust replacement for him and we need to free up the cash to fund that. Everton FC and Everton fans can't afford to be sentimental!!

Alan Corken
53 Posted 16/10/2013 at 20:43:40
Beckham - overrated, one footed, slow. Kanchelskis - well past his best when sold. Ronaldo - ok I will concede he is a decent player but at £80m it was more extortion than sale! But then there is Gibson, Howard, Saha, Neville - aaaaaaaahhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!!
Alan Corken
54 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:09:37
Oh, I forgot that other great Man Utd purchase — Norman Whiteside.
Brent Stephens
55 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:08:36
Sam #842 "You're getting too sentimental like a lot of folks on this thread – you think Gibbo's your best mate – he's not, he's an important asset that belongs to Everton FC."

I wonder what our asset line-up will be on Saturday. Hope asset Lukaku scores - murmurs of "valuable asset, that asset" from 40,000 GP stakeholders.

Mark Frere
56 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:18:37
Alan (849) I take it you're joking there?
Mark Dunford
57 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:19:42
Cold hearted Sam - the John Galt of ToffeeWeb - (786/842) is best off playing around with the balance sheet of rational self interest, while the rest of us get on with following the football and offering a little human sympathy for someone who performed well (and we admittedly don't know) but has suffered a cruel injury. Seems to me that Sam is a questionable asset that could be easily be lost to benefit this thread.
Nick Wall
58 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:48:54
For your information Sam, a contract is a legally binding agreement. When the club signs a player on a long term contract there is always an element of risk. The risk is factored in to the wages and the terms of the contract. As Gibson isn't in breach of any of the terms, the club can't terminate the contract (other than possibly by buying out the remaining years, which would gain the club nothing).
Peter Cummings
59 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:45:51
I think we can forget Gibbo ever playing for us again. He's finished for the season and his injury record is pathetic.

I still wish him well as he could have been a good addition to our squad. I don't think it's a disaster when we have decent cover in most positions now and still have Alcaraz and Pienaar on the way back,

Ciarán McGlone
60 Posted 16/10/2013 at 21:56:25
Sam is spot on..

I raised the issue of selling Gibson during the transfer window. He will never have a prolonged run in our team.

Tom Bowers
62 Posted 16/10/2013 at 22:15:24
It's so bloody typical. Just when we start to think we have a competitive squad, this happens.

Hindsight we know is 20/20 but how many times has this happened to key Everton players, especially midfielders, except the ones who are not that good?Everton started last season brightly until Gibbo got injured and, in previous seasons, after Arteta got injured, Everton suffered.

On the bright side, we still have the likes of Barry and Heitinga who can play a similar role so let's hope they stay fit at least until January when hopefully the squad can be bolstered again.

Tough games coming up with Pienaar set to miss another game but let's hope McCarthy, Barkley and whomever can get it together.

Jimmy Sørheim
63 Posted 16/10/2013 at 22:15:53
A pay as you play contract seems to be the only option for GIbson.
I think it is a waste of money to pay top wages for a guy like GIbson.

Martinez was the only one who could have prevented Gibson playing, but he wanted him to play as much as possible and it failed on him big time.

Win some lose some I guess.

I wonder if GIbson will be able to play again.

Peter Warren
64 Posted 16/10/2013 at 23:04:57
Feel for Gibson and believed he has been v good for us as we have to him. Don't agree with these sick note jibes at all
Willy Russell
65 Posted 16/10/2013 at 23:28:50
Alan (849) Yep, Beckham was one-footed, Kanchelskis was past his best and Ronaldo was overpriced, but there was fuck all wrong with Jesper Blomqvist!
Sean McKenna
66 Posted 16/10/2013 at 23:38:56
Write a player off at your peril!! Look at Van Persie... injured his whole footballing days with The Gunners then, Boom! Two seasons in a row at Manchester United, injury free... it's a funny old game indeed.
Ernie Baywood
67 Posted 17/10/2013 at 01:42:26
Really feel for Gibson and can't help but think that's his top flight career done.

Underrated when he was fit, and never really had enough of a run of fitness to prove himself at the level he's capable of.

Paul Ferry
68 Posted 17/10/2013 at 01:47:32
Peter Warren - 871 - what on earth do you mean that you do not agree with these sick-note 'jibes' - your word. In order to add substance to your general remark will you please now make the case that Gibbo who I admire by the way is not a 'sick note'?
David Ellis
69 Posted 17/10/2013 at 02:36:04
It's just bad luck – as it was for Jags, Yak and Arteta. Difference this time is that Gibson is currently not in our first XI so the impact on us should be limited – whereas the other 3 were all in our first XI and all injured at the same time.

Some of the "get rid" comments on here are very un-Evertonian if you ask me. We honour our contracts. We fans get uppity when players lack "loyalty". Loyalty is a two way street.

Michael Kenrick
70 Posted 17/10/2013 at 04:00:50
It's good to see more sensible comments from Nick Wall and Dave Ellis counter some of the nonsense from people who don't seem to understand the first thing about contracts. And the guy is only 26!!! And he's contracted to Everton through June 2016 — another three years.

Yes, he's injury-prone... but 'sicknote' — be ashamed... be very ashamed. That is lazy and disgusting from a couple of our contributors. He is out probably for a year; let's hope he can come back strong for the 2014-15 season. Who knows... Barry may only be here for the season. We may really need him this time next year....

Jackie Barry
71 Posted 17/10/2013 at 06:18:19
I believe we are going to get compensation for gibson which will either cover or at least pay for a large part of his wages.
Paul Andrews
72 Posted 17/10/2013 at 07:48:54
That is good news. We have lost an influential midfielder to a bad injury, but we are getting his wages paid. Everything is rosy.

Well said Michael 885

Erik Dols
73 Posted 17/10/2013 at 07:44:53
Jackie, will we get this compensation from the insurance company, in which case it will probably be full wages for the coming months, or the Irish FA, in which case I can't see us getting his true wages? Imagine if Cristiano Ronaldo had the same injury on a trip with the Portuguese. The Portuguese FA would go broke if they had to pay Real Madrid his wages... You could argue that the Portuguese FA should take out an insurance for these cases but I can imagine the insurance fee being sky high/unpayable for smaller FA's who happen to have one or two real star players. I have no idea how these things work exactly, anyone who can help out?
Sam Hoare
74 Posted 17/10/2013 at 08:07:53
Erik, read Kevin tullys post at 773.
John Zapa
75 Posted 17/10/2013 at 02:15:44
He still is only 25. He will lose a year of his career now and take time to regain match fitness. I don't see the possibility of selling him while he still has a contract.

Realistically I can see the club offering him a new contract in the near future, one that is a pay-as-you-play type. Something similar to what Owen was on while at Man Utd. By doing this, the club can save a chunk on his wages if he continues to be regularly absent as his history shows, it also gives him the security of a longer contract. A win win situation.

He can still be a useful squad player in future. Lucas had a similar injury and followed that with another injury soon after his return. He is back now, a little off the pace but inching towards match fitness. Even though he was out for nearly 18 months I don't recall him getting the kind of abuse and negativity from Liverpool fans that Gibson is getting.

Alan Huggins
76 Posted 17/10/2013 at 08:34:08
Hopefully after the surgery Gibbo will be back in action. He was outstanding for us when he first joined. I really hope he can get back to that form and avoid any further injuries. We need to reinforce the midfield in January.
Sam Hoare
77 Posted 17/10/2013 at 09:11:36
There's no point selling Gibson but there's also no doubt that he cannot be relied upon for a consistent spell in the team given his bad luck with injuries and likelihood of re-occurrence. With osman and heitinga not ideal replacements and Barry not certain to stay we will need to bring in at least 1 more deep lying midfielder in January. Think Lundstram and Conor Grant etc are probably a year or two away at least from being ready for a sustained first team run.
Jim Bennings
78 Posted 17/10/2013 at 09:46:04
Kanchelskis past his best when sold?

We signed Andrei Kanchelskis for £5 million and what we saw was 16 goals from a winger (yes winger) and one of the most devastating players I have witnessed at Everton Football Club.

I would say signing a player who was "past his best" is well worth it if he scores 16 goals which included the winners at Anfield in front of the Kop and the winner at Arsenal — remind the last time an Everton player managed that? We also sold Kanchelskis for £8 million so gained a profit.

To say that Manchester United never sell good players is a bit of a joke when you consider some of the cack that they have bought over the years,

Ray Roche
79 Posted 17/10/2013 at 09:48:25
Anyone who has played the game – at any level – must surely feel for the lad. For those who've never had a serious injury you can't empathise with the guy and appreciate just how deflating it can be. 35 years ago, a cartilage injury would finish some players or at least reduce them to lower-/non-league matches. Nowadays, an injury like this can be overcome and players return to their best, and Gibson has been excellent for us when he's played.

He's a footballer. He'll want to be playing football. Have some sympathy for him, at least.

Jim Bennings
80 Posted 17/10/2013 at 09:55:39
What Gibson really needs to do now is keep positive, find support from the likes of Jags(who also suffered this same injury, or other players in the gane who have had it) and get the best possible recovery period and fitness physiotherapy programme going possible when the time is right.

We all know we will not see him for at least a year, thats not being negative, its being realistic, its a 12 month inujury together with the long battle to regain fitness then anything like match fitness.
We are looking at at least November 2014 before we see him back in the first team, so in many ways I know this may sound like a strange cold comfort for Gibson but Republic of Ireland not qualifying for the World Cup turned out to be a blessing in disguise,imagine how gutted his mood would have been to miss that World Cup in Brazil?

Remain positive Gibbo lad.

Erik Dols
81 Posted 17/10/2013 at 10:38:34
Sam Hoare #889 , thanks! Must have missed that one. All clear now, we will get compensated, fair enough.
Sean Kelly
82 Posted 17/10/2013 at 12:45:36
I wish Gibson best wishes and hope he makes a full recovery. I really hope he can get this sorted; he's a decent player and a decent lad.

RM is putting a spin on it for both Gibbo and the fans. He needs to have a look at bringing in backup in central midfield as we were not really covered there as we couldn't rely on Gibbo to stay fit. JH or Ossie aren't the answer.

COYB. 3-0 on Saturday to lift the mood.

Alan Humphreys
83 Posted 17/10/2013 at 13:20:43
Quite simple for me.

No player is allowed to play for his national team until he is declared fit and (this is my main crux) has played for his club side.

In Gibson's case, Everton have been patient with him in his rehabilitation only for him to make hus comeback by playing a full game and then nearly another half for the Republic.

The international sides, clubs and players need to work together.

Anyway, didn't you just know one of ours would get crocked !

Dave Lynch
84 Posted 17/10/2013 at 13:35:04
Didn't he need an operation on his thigh anyway?

Use the time to get that sorted and this recent injury and he'll be like a new signing....

Ciarán McGlone
86 Posted 17/10/2013 at 23:25:14
Its neither lazy nor disgusting Michael. We cannot afford to carry players who play as little as Gibson.

This is about Everton. Not Gibson.

Alan Corken
87 Posted 17/10/2013 at 23:22:59
Willy 873, good one, I forgot about Jesper, he could sink a pint with the best of them! Jim 897, Kanchelskis devastating? Come on you didn't even remember him in your original post. Let's get real, we have only ever got duds from Man Utd - still we have got our own back at last by sending them a dud manager!
Lyndon Lloyd
88 Posted 17/10/2013 at 23:37:34
I posted this on Twitter but Mohamed Sissoko (yes, I know...) is currently a free agent after being released by PSG. He's still only 28 and could fill the hole in defensive midfield on a short-term contract.

And, yes, Kanchelskis was devastating for us, for one season at least. He could single-handedly win a game for us back then and often did.
Alan Corken
89 Posted 17/10/2013 at 23:41:28
I bet he has a dodgy knee
David Pearl
90 Posted 18/10/2013 at 03:04:26
Weird how people take the news of a players injury. My fledgling career was cut short by a knee injury... it's not nice. Really!

From an Everton point of view, at present we actually seem to be able to withstand such news with Barry and Heitinga being able to fill in. Lucky we are in as strong a position squad-wise as I can remember over the last number of years.

Alan – we gave them Mark Higgins...

Peter Warren
91 Posted 18/10/2013 at 07:17:35
Paul Ferry - sick notes is a derogatory term which to me implies he can't be arsed, ie has a snivel and refused to play like a wimp. Gibson was playing with a thigh injury second half of last season and always gives us all.

I guess you would call Reid, Bracewell sick notes? Bang out of order and kicking a guy when he's down. There's no reason he can't come back and be a vital part of our future and I wish him all the best

Michael Kenrick
92 Posted 18/10/2013 at 07:21:01
Cairan, there's a contract in place that no doubt deals with periods out injured. To persist with these calls that we can somehow just get rid of him when that contract runs through June 2016 isn't just lazy — it's plain stupid.

Look what happened with Van der Meyde. If ever there was a case for a player's contract being terminated.... yet Everton kept him on for the full four years of his contract. Gibson has already played twice as many games as VdM in less than half the time with the club, and it shouldn't even need saying that he is far and away a much more valuable player. He's 26 next week, and his injury is not as bad as it could have been. Let him recover with a little dignity please!

Ciarán McGlone
93 Posted 18/10/2013 at 10:07:34
I made a point about potentially selling him Michael (and obviously not while he has a cruciate injury as no-one would buy him) - Whereas you appear to be suggesting I was talking about terminating his contract - Which is certainly not the case.

My point is that in the long term I cannot see him forming part of a stable first team as he's never fit long enough to let us see his best.

It's more of a problem for Republic in my opinion - as irrespective of what I think about his self imposed exile - he's clearly head and shoulders above most of Ireland's midfielders.

Sam Higgins
94 Posted 18/10/2013 at 12:31:28
We appear to be in the minority Ciaran, with wavering support from Paul Ferry.

We will fight them on the beaches....

I think its laughable to discuss an EPL football player contract in terms of UK employment law - when we all know that these contracts are not worth the parchment the dam things are quilled on.

I also don't like the tone of our critics here. We have expressed our opinion with reasoning. I would much prefer a response along the lines of 'I don't agree with your opinion and this is why' rather than being told that my views are disgusting. I havent personally attacked Darron Gibson. That would be disgusting. I've simply alluded to the fact that he is suseptible to injury more than most and condensed this point and used the word sicknote.

Being told that my views are disgusting reminds me as to why I very rarely contribute anything to the site in way of post or thread comment. Particualry as these comments come from the editor! I find it especially offensive as some of my previous posts have focused on the editorial team themselves congratulating and thanking them for the service they provide!!

To reiterate. Gibson is a fine player. We play better with him. But he is 90% of the time injured. This is unsustainable for a EPL football club like Everton and the limited resources we have both player wise (wont use the word asset) and financially. So we should identify a way in which we can allow Gibson to leave the club and reinvest the money in a more robust midfielder! So we don't pay Gibson's salary while he's injured. OK but he's still not available is he?! And this comes back to Ciaran's point - he'll never be able to form part of a stable team!

Brent Stephens
95 Posted 18/10/2013 at 14:41:50
Sam, the issue I have is with the notion of somebody being "injury-prone" when the term is used to imply or even state (as in your last sentence) that the player will be injured more than others in the future. Unless it's medically known that the player has a specific weakness in a particular part of his body, I don't see how we can make predictions from a past injury record.

I don't know the ins and outs of Gibson's previous injuries. Maybe it's well known that a particular part of his body does have a (medically-established) inherent weakness?

Steavey Buckley
96 Posted 18/10/2013 at 14:54:49
Players who play for their country should remember that playing for club is more important than country. Premier league clubs pay their high salaries.

Gibson, being injured by being over-played by the RoI after just returning from another serious injury, he may not be the same player again and will be less valuable when it comes to obtaining another high-salaried contract.

Steavey Buckley
97 Posted 18/10/2013 at 15:08:14
Ian Riley: "I am sorry for Mr Gibson and his injury...." Gibson should know better than most being injured most of the time is one of his occupational hazards. Playing for ROI made his situation even worse especially under ROI's temporary manager, King, who took chances with his fitness which resulted him being out of action until next season. By that time, Everton may have replaced him as surplus to requirements.
Ross Edwards
98 Posted 18/10/2013 at 21:09:16
The people who are staunchly defending Gibson are the ones who widely overrate him to extreme. Paul and Ciaran are absolutely right.

Why should we waste our money paying a player £45-£50k a week for hobbling on crutchers and sitting on his backside?

He looks deeply unfit, he is constantly injured, and he is a waste of money that could be better spent on a player who is better than him and more reliable.

Seriously, how many games has he played for us in the last 3 seasons?

42. In 3 years. Baines for example has played 93.

That is a terrible return, and we are paying him thousands a week for absolutely nothing.

We should get rid of him in January, just like we did with Anichebe.

Anything over £5 million will be miraculous considering the number of games he has played.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb