Everton prevail in tussle with Hull

, 19 October, 195comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton 2 - 1 Hull City

Everton got back to winning ways with a hard-fought victory over a tenacious Hull City side thanks to a goal in each half and a decisive intervention from the returning Steven Pienaar.

Roberto Martinez named his expected line-up that saw Gareth Barry return to the side at the expense of Steven Naismith and his team immediately set about the task of bouncing back from their first defeat of the season at Manchester City two weeks ago, going ahead as early as the eighth minute.

A short corner exchange between Leighton Baines and Leon Osman ended with the latter feeding Kevin Mirallas 25 yards from goal and though his low shot seemed to lack sufficient pace to Alan McGregor in the Hull goal from that distance, the ball crept inside the post.

Coming into the game a place a and a point below the Blues, Hull had looked unfazed in the early going and were causing Everton plenty of problems in the air at set pieces.

Their equaliser came from impressive work down the right by Aluko, though, as he powered to the byline and centred through Baines' legs where Yannick Sagbo, an early substitute for the injured Danny Graham, was on hand to rifle home unimpeded from 10 yards out with half an hour gone.

The pattern of play established in the first half continued into the second but Everton had failed to really open Steve Bruce's side up until Osman was removed in favour of Pienaar, making his first appearance for seven weeks following a hamstring injury.

Ross Barkley made a characteristically purposeful forward run, fed Mirallas and his first-time centre picked out Pienaar to slip the ball home with his first touch and restore Everton's lead.

Arouna Kone replaced the tiring Romelu Lukaku with 23 minutes left and he was presented with a gilt-edged chance to score his first Everton goal but, at the end of a quick-fire attack, the Ivorian somehow contrived to smack the ball off the post with just the 'keeper to beat.

A second chance opened up for him less than a minute later but McGregor foiled him with a good one-handed save.

Everton saw out the remaining quarter of an hour in relative comfort, recording their third home win of the campaign and moving temporarily into fifth place in the table.

Roberto Martinez was pleased that Pienaar, a surprise inclusion after recovering from a hamstring injury, was able to play such a decisive part in a vital victory.

"We were all delighted that Stevie was able to play today," the manager said after the game. "It's been a frustrating time for everyone because the injury kept him sidelined.

"He seemed desperate to play a part, desperate to be involved and his first touch was a reflection of what he is - someone who can give you that little bit of magic that you sometimes need to win.

"It was pleasing to see him do that and it's great to have him available to help the team again."

As expected, the Tigers proved to be no pushovers and Martinez acknowledged the challenge they posed to his team throughout.

"Hull have had a really good start to the season. They are confident and you could see they were full of energy.

"They were pressing us really high up, trying to stop us from playing and we found it very difficult. But in those situations it's important that you are professional enough and clever enough to find a way to win."

The Blues' match-winner hero was typically modest after the game, describing his goal to evertontv as "a lucky touch," but he was clearly pleased to be back playing after his injury layoff.

The midfielder also explained his unique celebration, saying that the upside-down South African flag draped over the advertising hoardings had been annoying him ever since he'd taken his seat on the bench and he took the opportunity to correct it rather than his customary lifting of the jersey to display his "God is Great" t-shirt.

 

Reader Comments (195)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mike Allison
1 Posted 19/10/2013 at 19:21:41
Evening everyone. We didn't play too well today, we were certainly nothing like the side that ripped Newcastle apart for 45 minutes a few weeks ago. Watching that second half, there were poor passes, sloppy mistakes, and I lost count of the number of times we went from a promising attacking position to passing it back to the centre backs and even Howard.

However, I think today is a game you just have to chalk up as a win, make your excuses (international break, difficult conditions etc) and move on. If we were to be as sloppy as that week in week out then questions would need to be asked, but as it was, we still dominated the game, took three points and should have had more goals. The slight frustration I feel at only winning 2-1 can be taken as a positive sign that we have really high expectations of our Everton side now.

Hull are a decent side as well. As the report says, they were only a point below us before the game, are well organised, and in Huddlestone and Livermore have some quality in their midfield. They seemed to cope well with our full backs going forward, and though both Baines and Coleman are good enough that they still had their moments, it certainly looked like something Bruce had made plans for. Fortunately this was at the expense of their own attacking threat, something which only altered towards the end as they made attacking substitutions to chase the game.

That we are picking up wins now is a great sign as I always feel other teams fade away over the season, where we stay strong. Early season is a great leveller, all teams brim with optimism and possibility, and play with a confidence that gradually fades as results don't go their way. There are no easy games in the Premier League at the moment, but as the season wears on, some teams' heads drop and they begin to appear (Incidentally this was always my explanation for why we were 'perennial slow starters' under Moyes - we were the same over the season, it was the other teams that faded).

One final point is about how nice it is to look at our bench and see all those attacking options. I might argue he even went a step too far having 5 attacking players in reserve, as I'd have settled for four, but I'd go as far as to say the biggest difference between this year and last is that you feel we can improve the side by making substitutions now, whereas last year all we ever did was replace tired legs with a lesser player.

Karl Masters
2 Posted 19/10/2013 at 19:55:54
Lets stick to talking about Everton and not a certain Ginge up the road! I wonder if we can do it? :)
Colin Glassar
3 Posted 19/10/2013 at 20:06:30
It's very difficult not to laugh at you know who Karl.
Andy Crooks
4 Posted 19/10/2013 at 20:09:20
Colin, say it out loud. Moyes looks out of his depth and it's good to see. The look on his face when Southampton scored was a joy to watch. What happens to him is relevant to Everton because he will be back in January to try and make a signing to get him off the hook.

Everton win, Liverpool draw and Moyes looks a twat. A good day.

Peter Cummings
5 Posted 19/10/2013 at 20:10:37
Lost the game thread here so had to rely on BBC commentary. When the service resumed our game was over so we had to watch City beat WHU, a very good game. I will look at the highlights from Goodison tonight... The ,stats say we dominated and, as usual, should have won more handily. Welcome back, Pienaar!!
Kevin Rowlands
7 Posted 19/10/2013 at 20:46:19
Have to say this tippy tappy shit at the back between Distin, Jags and Howard makes me nervous as hell, other than that very happy with most of what I've seen. For anyone who thinks McCarthy was overpriced I would argue that he's a bargain compared to Fellaini who cost twice as much to the Mancs and has been stinking the joint out over there, him and Barry look superb in central midfield.
Drew Shortis
8 Posted 19/10/2013 at 20:49:19
Not our most convincing home performance, but at the end of the season we will only remember the three points. To be fair a lot of the lads had already played two games this week and can't have been at their peak of fitness. Barkley had a disappointing game, but he is still very young and hopefully he's learning with every game. I'm glad Martinez continues to show faith in him and is letting him develop. I would have liked to have seen Deulofeu on at some point.

Kone had two decent chances and although he managed to fluff the one that hit the post at least he was getting involved and was able to have the opportunities. It is important for his confidence that he buries one of these chances soon though as the longer he goes without a goal the more he pressure grows. I still think he will come good and make a contribution this season.

Ralph Basnett
9 Posted 19/10/2013 at 21:17:49
Yet again another team that we should put to the sword only to be hanging on.

I know he has had injury problems but how the fuck is Huddlestone stuck in a shit team like Hull?

Still, onwards and upwards, a win is a win, but still over passing - we must have the most passes completed without actually any real penetration.

Hopefully it will come good in the end, but the results count first and foremost.

David Heaton
10 Posted 19/10/2013 at 21:53:29
I'm very impressed with Martinez, bit worried at first why he kept playing Osman and Naismith but now can understand they are just there because he thinks they are the best available at the moment, He takes Osman off as soon as possible and only plays Naismith when there is not an alternative. I used to scream at Moyes to make obvious change which he never did but every time I'm thinking of substitutes Martinez has it covered. Really impressed with his management skills.
Played OK today they tried coasting after they scored the first goal because a lot of them looked knackered after being away on international duty, so we did well to knuckle down and get the winning goal.
Gary Poole
11 Posted 19/10/2013 at 22:07:39
Ralph – on what level were Hull shit? I thought they were decent, caused us problems, particularly at set pieces and stopped us playing it out from the back.

I think we did well to win today – on a different day it could have gone a bit Pete Tong.

If we can keep that going at Villa and grind out another win, then it's looking good.

Ian Bennett
13 Posted 19/10/2013 at 22:10:07
You can see Martinez looking to add to the left hand side. Guardado possibly.
Jon Withey
14 Posted 19/10/2013 at 22:16:49
Winning when playing badly is not such a bad sign.
Brent Stephens
15 Posted 19/10/2013 at 22:31:02
All this possession football with little penetration. Is it actually a form of KITAP1?
Kevin Rowlands
16 Posted 19/10/2013 at 22:33:59
I agree Ralph, a fit Huddlestone is top drawer, at 5mill he's got to be one of the signings of the season, we should have been all over that one, imho he's better than Englands current creative duo Lampard and Carrick.
Paul Ferry
18 Posted 19/10/2013 at 23:13:35
(313) 'a lot of them looked knackered after being away on international duty'. Ah bless, poor old sods, 180 mins work in 8 days for some of 'em, the toll must be awful, bless.

No. Don't put the blame squarely on the shoulders of international duty as we have looked cream-crackered in the last quarter of games with or without international duty for much of this season. Don't recall Howard, Barkley, Barry, Distin, or Osman (who looked more shagged out than anyone by minute '60) being busy during the week.

This second-half cream-crackered-itis is - along with all the bright and sunny things that I salivate over - fast becoming a theme/condition of the season along with the creaky, dodgy, central defence - whenever we get a corner it's like when you knew the daleks were coming and you dive for the back of the sofa.

The first? Is it down to new training regimes? Dunno to be honest.

The second? Defending like 2 less physical John Inmans at corners has absolutely zilch to do with new formations, yawn ..... There's not much tippy-tappy about going up to win headers or a professional sense of
positioning at said set-pieces. Perhaps Jags is a lucky fella to be in the
national team at this less than stellar time for home-grown central
defenders. His distribution is at times eleventh-division; that fella from Peters and Lee could do a better job. We badly need to sort out central defence. Distin's last season I fear; a window buy perhaps and/or Stones?

Patrick Murphy
19 Posted 19/10/2013 at 23:34:09
Pity we don't have these world-class centre-backs that all these top clubs have Paul? Terry, Ferdinand,,Mertesacker, Lescott et al all wonderfully gifted ball playing defenders who cost peanuts,,,,not

BTW is this the longest without scoring at the Gwladys street End in the league?

Patrick Murphy
20 Posted 19/10/2013 at 23:39:39
don't answer that last question Paul I'm laying off the tea
Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 19/10/2013 at 23:41:30
What are they on MOTD? I agree that he should have been booked for his first foul so with the second yellow could have been off, but his yellow card wasn't a straight red, he took the ball midway and his foot then went over the top of it. Mind you he probably was offside for the goal. I just dislike every error or things that go in Everton's favour are studied to the nth degree, but if they go against us they are generally glossed over.
Brent Stephens
22 Posted 19/10/2013 at 23:48:16
Interesting when people say "did you go to the game?" I did today, as usual, and didn't quite catch how bad Barry's tackle was (ooh, no missus, don't - you know what I mean). Watched it again on TV and he should have been sent off. We'd have been spitting chips over a tackle like that against one of ours. Two tackles in fact.

And Barry off side. No goal.

Kevin Rowlands
24 Posted 19/10/2013 at 23:55:42
Brent, after the last refereeing debacle at City, the breaks went our way today. I agree, Barry was offside and he's seen telling Barkley on TV that he touched the ball, but I think a yellow was fair; he actually got ball first but his momentum took him into the Hull player.
Jon Withey
25 Posted 20/10/2013 at 00:02:04
Note that Fer didn't exactly own the midfield against Arsenal.
Roman Sidey
26 Posted 20/10/2013 at 00:04:54
David Heaton, I agree with you about Osman and Naismith seemingly only playing because there's not much else. However, from what I've see when Oviedo plays, I can't for the life of me figure out why he's being left out of the side - not even making the bench even.
Mark Taylor
27 Posted 20/10/2013 at 00:25:11
I only saw highlights on MOTD so only have a very limited picture, but it looked like we were very average. You do get those days, so maybe just be happy with a win and forget the performance (after all, three times more points than OFM).

It does seem odd that Oviedo never gets a look in- looks a decent player when I've seen him, at least as good as Naismith on the left- and that Delpo isn't at the least, getting decent sub time, given he has usually looked one of our most threatening players.

MOTD pundits seemed to be convinced Barry got a touch for the goal but there wasn't a definitive replay. If he did, it was a nick that was easy to miss.

On the tackles, the first one seemed to me to cause more damage to the player than seemed feasible from the tackle. I'm not even convinced it was a foul, I just think it ended up with their guy falling awkwardly.

The second one was a 50-50 which Barry arguably won, but his momentum took him through into what looked worse on slowmo than I think actually was. I don't think there was evil intent there and therefore I don't think it merited a straight red, but I've seen them given.

Good to see Peanuts back. He was a bit below par before he got injured but I'd sooner see him on the left than Ossie.Hopefully he can revive that partnership with Baines.

Steve Yoder
29 Posted 20/10/2013 at 02:29:28
Was very impressed with McCarthy and Barry today--only missing Fellaini's goal scoring touch, rather than that and his defensive abilities. Defense was very,very poor today. Usually a big supporter of Distin, but he had a poor game, as did Jagielka who I am not usually as high on. Kone had the opportunities at least, and knew what to do in them; the goals will come. Barkley has moments of great vision and touch, then moments where he appears blind to the passing options available. Mirallas was and is the creative engine behind the offense. Overall, I thought it was a decent game; good midfield control, poor defensive control, and too few shots on goal, many of which were available but for a second's hesitation wherein the window closed. Still, much more created, I'd say, than last year. From last year, I would like to see Coleman have some more opportunity.
Tim Jones
30 Posted 20/10/2013 at 02:47:54
Just a word about 'possession' which seems to becoming a derogatory word here on TW:

When WE have possession. THEY cannot score.

Patrick Carty
31 Posted 20/10/2013 at 02:55:17
A win is a win, how many decisions have gone against us in the past? I honestly thought we would win handy but would take any win the way games have gone.

Four points off the top, we have to be happy enough with that. I do not like the bad comments about Moyes ,he did a good job with us, and fans are too fickle to judge him so badly.

Paul Ferry
34 Posted 20/10/2013 at 03:36:35
Oh and Patrick lets get down to the nitty gritty it takes up less time - your thoughts on our defensive display v Hull?
Derek Thomas
35 Posted 20/10/2013 at 02:59:35
This is not 'playing it out from the back' - ' making the ball do the work' or whatever...It is plain old fashioned 'Fannying around' aka 'Piss balling about'.

Jags and Distin are plain old stoppers, if you put the two of them together you wouldn't make Beckenbaur's 'weaker leg' ( if he had one which I doubt).

It now seems to be affecting their core business of defending.

All the opposition have to do is put some one on Distins left foot and that's Jageilka's plan A (no planB) for passing it out.

Bobby mate I'm all for 'Without fear' but to stick to the total football plan at all costs is just reverse Moyesism, your will end up with a different set of Sq pegs in a different set of round holes.

Net result; Jags and Distin playing like arseholes at footballing russian roulette

Gerson Rodriguez
36 Posted 20/10/2013 at 03:54:49
Good win if a little sloppy. I blame the international break and the conditions, but Hull played a great match too. Distin did make me nervous just about every time he touched the ball today and I hope he only gets better from here on out.

I know many of us here don't appreciate the "playing from the back" game but controlling the game this way keeps looking good and it will only get better. It's nice to see Martinez's philosophy coming into view rather nicely.

Steve Brown
37 Posted 20/10/2013 at 04:57:23
Derek 347, agree completely. Both Jags and Distin are average in possesion and expecting them to initiate our attacks is affecting their all-round game. They became increasingly edgy and the sin miedo game degenerated into Jags sending penetrating 40 yard passes straight to Hull and Distin sending lofted aimless balls down the left flank.

Perhaps the defence might also practice tracking their man at corners as I can't remember us losing our man at corners so often, but let's not forget we won a tough game and are well-placed.

Harold Matthews
38 Posted 20/10/2013 at 03:51:39
Right Derek. The Kaiser had no weaknesses. Once saw him play a blinder with his arm in a sling. Of course, It's all about being comfortable on the ball, which our two CBs are not. On top of which, Jags can't judge high balls. In fact, when Hull had a corner all our lads seemed glued to the ground and this will have to be sorted double quick.

Their goal was the result of Baines being skinned and Barry wandering away from his man but they'll both be well aware of it.

On the plus side we had the welcome return of Pienaar, Kone getting match-time, Mirallis looking more like Super Kev and McCarthy putting in another big shift. Also, according to several live reports the voice of young McCarthy could be heard yelling instructions throughout. A future captain perhaps.

Tough times ahead but we are flying high with a decent improving side.

Jackie Barry
39 Posted 20/10/2013 at 06:19:41
So basically our style of play under Moyes masked the fact that in Jagielka and Distin we have two players who can't manage one of the basics of the game. Fantastic! If a professional footballer can't pass the ball or feel comfortable on the ball for extended periods of time then they have no right being a professional footballer. In the end you can play hoofball all day long but I can bet it won't bring the success that passing the ball will. Yes of course there is a need to go long sometimes but bloody hell if you can't do a short pass accurately how on earth can you expect anything from a long ball up field?
Sam Hoare
40 Posted 20/10/2013 at 07:25:13
Jags and Distin are clearly not the best passers but it is also up to the system and other players to ensure that they don't get isolated and have simple passes to play into the midfield. Often they would find McCarthy or Barry who would ping it straight back with a man closing down. Work must be done on how to deal with teams pressing us high.
Patrick Murphy
41 Posted 20/10/2013 at 08:00:08
Well Paul maybe we should just go back to our back four lumping it as high up the pitch as possible, with the net result it came right back at us - as it did yesterday every time TH launched it up the pitch. My point about the other centre-half's at the other clubs is that there is a paucity of footballing centre-halves in the league if not throughout Europe.

We as fans are in danger of focussing on the negatives, when what our players need is support. It is far easier for defenders to shine when they are under the cosh and putting their bodies in the way, but like goalkeepers they pay a heavy price when they make a mistake - Distin Wembley springs to mind. Fans either buy into the new method of playing or they don't.

The style has nothing to do with the players flaws, and a change back to a style that they had become used to, won't make them better players, it may make them look better but it won't make them better footballers.

Graham Mockford
42 Posted 20/10/2013 at 08:53:40
First home game of the season and I came away a bit underwhelmed. I think RM is still trying to get the right balance in the side in midfield. Barry and McCarthy gave us more solidity and they were competitive, however when we were in possession we were ponderous and slowed it down too much.
Barkley although always looking to create ran into a lot of blind alleys and therefore Lukaku was given very little to work with. Hull's CBs both played well and were very strong and physical.
Our biggest failing was playing too narrow and not bringing Mirallas and Baines into the game. The highlight was the return of Pienaar who gave us more options and a higher tempo from the minute he came on.

For me if you want to play a mid three of Barry, McCarthy and Barkley it is where you play Barkley. At the moment he is too advanced in a quasi No.10 role and needs to play in a more traditional advanced midfield role. I think this brings the wide players into the game more and stops us being so narrow.

Mike Gwyer
43 Posted 20/10/2013 at 08:56:09

Not a great lover of MOTD but got up this morning to watch the blues but I had to sit through several other games before we came on. Well, it seems we are not the only team who are pressed high up the pitch - additionally, it seems we are not the only team with CB's who make mistakes or are given the ball with a marker only a couple of yards away. The days of CB's just putting their bodies on the line seem numbered, CB's are now required to take part in the pass and move play that most EPL managers seem to want.

I'm going to put yesterdays display down to the world cup games played last week, which Jags, Baines & Coleman played a huge part. As we all know, crowd support plays a big part for players and you will soon see them disappear if they know the crowd are going to moan as soon as they make a mistake. Jags, well as soon as he bossed the CB role & Distin have always commanded huge respect at Goodison, so lets not get so negative & give these two great players the support they deserve.

Steve Pugh
44 Posted 20/10/2013 at 09:11:19
Reading some of the posts on here I can see some definite signs of Wenger-itis afflicting the Everton faithful.

Replays showed conclusively that Barry touched the ball and was offside. His first tackle was studs showing above the knee, if it had happened the other way around everyone on here would have been screaming for at least a yellow card. The second tackle probably started out as a better challenge than the first but again, if it had been the other way around we would all have been demanding a red card.

I have to agree Patrick #327 on the MOTD bias, Sagbo's challenge that was easily as bad as either of Barry's didn't even get shown.

Phil Sammon
45 Posted 20/10/2013 at 09:14:15
I think it's quite clear that Jags and Distin aren't comfortable with the ball at their feet. Another thing that concerns me is how the defenders split so wide when we have the ball. Distin is basically at left back and Baines is standing around like a spare part. We're reducing the effectiveness of probably our best player. Also, it's been mentioned before but Jagielka's judgement of high balls is shocking. He was caught out on so many corners. I like both players but I feel like they are struggling to do the basics right now.

Barry had his first poor game in an Everton shirt. He looked painfully slow and almost lethargic at times. I'm sure it was just a blip, but I don't think he deserved to be praised for that performance. He didn't deserve a sending off though. His first tackle was nothing. The second, he clearly wins the ball and then his foot rolls over it. Things like that happen when players are kicking around a round object. Interesting that nobody mentioned the tackle on Jags. They didn't even show it on MOTD but it was worse than Barry's. Studs up and no contact with the ball.

McCarthy was outstanding. His aggression was incredible. That's how I wished Fellaini had handled himself at Everton. He went into every 50/50 wanting it more than his opponent and usually came out on top. What a great signing.

A final mention for Pienaar who it's great to have back. A fine finish for the goal...but more importantly, did anyone else see him running on all-fours like a crab? It had me in stitches!

Steve Cotton
46 Posted 20/10/2013 at 09:45:02
To be honest, Hull looked more dangerous from set pieces where they constantly had men roaming free in our box. At set pieces, the new passing style cannot be blamed and the tough international schedule cannot be blamed: it came down to lack of organisation. Let's hope RM does not forget the basics of defending by adopting this new passing style.

As a side issue, at the time, I never thought either of Barry,s tackles were that bad, possibly as I am a blue, but the Sagbo over-the-top challenge on Jags looked a leg breaker and wasn't even shown on MotD!!! Possibly a case of MotD wanting to show that Hull had been hard done by...

Trevor Lynes
47 Posted 20/10/2013 at 09:38:33
I really cannot believe the critics on here moaning about Jagielka and Distin who are right up with the best centre-back pairings around. We have not been beaten in a league match at Goodison Park since 2012. Name me another club in the Premier League with a better record!

Last season only the two Manchester clubs conceded less goals than Everton. Defenders have consistently been voted our better players and they are the players who have carried our team for seasons. It's only this season that we have had some optimism about our attacking strength. Our main four defenders are excellent and very seldom get booked.

Three out of the four were on international duty and none were rested. Man City for instance completely changed their back four and they have Kompany out injured. We do not have the squad strength in depth to be able to do that. Look at the facts before heaping criticism on our mainstays.

Barry is getting plaudits but is surplus to City this season. To maintain the general consistency level we have achieved for so long is a tribute to the defence as we have not had top class strikers. This season we have three of our first team squad in on loan and two have been regulars when fit. Lukaku will go back to Chelsea and Del Boy will very probably go back to Barcelona. Barry may stay but its in the lap of the gods.

We did not lose! We have 15 points from 8 games! I am happy!

Max Wilson
48 Posted 20/10/2013 at 09:47:40
Paul Ferry! Lots of us agree with you. Two games in a week should'nt be an excuse for any pro "athlete". And a couple of our players haven't look fit enough- the Belgians.They all live on chips and cream cakes in Belgium.But Mirallas stayed with the tempo better this game. The re-appearance of Peanuts is great news. We've been waiting for our stronger more creative mid-field and slinky link ups with Bainesy.
This was one of those games where a result was ground out and McCarthy showed he's going to be a grinder outer; was'nt he solid? Barry defo scored the first goal and we got a grinding out decision here and there.Was the Ref fit? He seemed far away from play at times. Barry is not a dirty player. His career proves that. Just watch him , McCarthy and Peanuts in future. Lukaku needs some extra fitness training and a lot less "frits".
Matt Smith
49 Posted 20/10/2013 at 09:55:05
If all of us armchair managers can spot that Distin and Phil don't do possession football then I am afraid something has to go, either the results or the CBs. Having just watched Arsenal's frontline, it wouldn't be pretty up against those and are defence. Nothing illustrated the issue better than Distin's blind pass/come shot back to Howard who hacked it wide when under a little pressure.
Brent Stephens
50 Posted 20/10/2013 at 11:15:44
Several posts saying Barry's tackle (one of them) was him getting the ball and then his foot rolling over the top of it. That is and was an "over-the-top" tackle, in my view. The foot followed though, over the top of the ball and into the shin. "Winceable".

I think it's irrelevant whether it was intentional. Reckless is the issue. He should have been off, IMO.

Andrew Clare
51 Posted 20/10/2013 at 11:37:05
It is obvious that if we want to go to the ’ next level’ and play a passing game we need two new centre backs.Jags and Dustin are great defenders full stop. Rudy Krol and as mentioned before Franz Beckenbauer were two great footballing centre backs who could bring the ball from defence to attack. I can’t think of anyone in the modern game who is of that calibre apart from the guy at PSG who’s name escapes me.

Anyway if we can get the equivalent type of player we will be a force to be reckoned with. Glad we won but Barry should have been sent off and Hull deserved the draw.
COYB.

Lee Simpson
52 Posted 20/10/2013 at 11:57:23
I cant understand why some people are moaning. We got the winning goal early in the second half, kept the ball well and I honestly cannot remember Hull having the ball in our box in the second half.

In the past we have sat back and defended one-goal leads in our half. Especially in the last 10-15 minutes of games. Yesterday we kept the ball well without over committing and Hull never looked like scoring in the second half. Job done very well in my opinion.

Harold Matthews
53 Posted 20/10/2013 at 10:51:32
Agreed Max. Lukaku looked well off the pace, Maybe we should copy West Brom and bring him on for the last half hour against tiring defenders.

Forwards on the bench have a good chance of game-time but lads like Stones don't get a sniff. Seems such a pity. Experience is the only thing this quick, skilled, two-footed lad lacks. He could also slot into any midfield position, should someone get injured. Martinez says it's all about being creative, as he proved by moving a winger to a DM at Swansea. Perhaps he will eventually utilize Stones elsewhere.

Andrew Clare
54 Posted 20/10/2013 at 12:14:27
Just remembered. Thiago Silva is the best ball playing centre back in the world today. Playing at PSG.
Brian Harrison
55 Posted 20/10/2013 at 12:40:19
Not the best performance so far this season, but at least managed to take all 3 points. Thought Hull looked well organised and as always Huddlestones passing was a joy to watch, cant understand why he never became a regular for Spurs.

I like many think the incessant passing between Jags and Distin is causing us more problems, funny as I watch a lot of Spanish football and have never seen Barcelona have their central defenders making 6/7 passes between themselves.

Sam Hoare
56 Posted 20/10/2013 at 12:50:32
If ball playing centre backs is the way forward then might we expect to see Stones and Alcaraz at the heart of our defence by the end of the season?

Would I feel more comfortable in the unlikely circumstance that those two started against Villa. Probably not. For me, even in the modern game, centre backs have to defend first and foremost and Jags and Distin do that pretty well.

Peter Foy
57 Posted 20/10/2013 at 13:03:09
Don't forget though, ball playing centre backs need some to actually play the ball to. If players are not making themselves available for a pass then the 'ball playing centre back' inadvertently ends up looking a bit of a tit.
Robert Collins
58 Posted 20/10/2013 at 12:55:42
No our most convincing performance, but winning when you're not playing your best football is good habit to have. How many times have we seen ManU under fergie look mediocre, fumble through games and still manage to get the victory?

We're still in rebuild phase, we must remember that.

Now then! Gollum snatched a draw from the jaws of victory yesterday by bringing off a world class forward in good form (shrek) and bringing on a defender, does any of this sound familiar to anyone here? It's took him just 8 games in charge to return to his natural type!! He left the ManU prawn cocktail brigade enraged after seeing a game fergie would have grabbed by the scruff of the neck, turn into one of 'Dour Davies' a draw will do 'survive at all costs' games.

Marvellous and long may he be with them.

Mark Frere
59 Posted 20/10/2013 at 13:41:09
Sam Hoare (400)

I can see Alcaraz replacing Distin at some point this season. Alcaraz is known for his good ball playing skills from the back and is a very good defender by all accounts. Perhaps he might be better at defending set-pieces as well. Still, he won't have Distin's pace though.

I can't see Martinez dropping our captain jags. Maybe its bit too soon for Stones to be thrown in at the deep end, he's played most of his short career at RB. Jagielka's distribution is a worry though, he's purely just a good defender, that's all he is I'm afraid.

Nick Entwistle
60 Posted 20/10/2013 at 14:08:24
An uninspired but solid performance. At least in terms of not sitting back with 20 to go. Got the job done and 3 points as expected.

In hindsight Jely would have been better with Lukaku as impact sub.

Kone, I just don't know why Martinez brought him in, and McCarthy I'm still not sure what he does other than guarantee a 6 rating.

Pienaar is back and that's beautiful.

As peeps may know I'm not a Martinez fan, but it looks like he can achieve a consistency in delivering points, even if the Euro places will just be out of reach this season. Liverpool and Southampton have added to the scramble.

Jamie Barlow
61 Posted 20/10/2013 at 14:31:20
I thought McCarthy was good. Rarely gave the ball away and put in some crunching tackles. He was everywhere yesterday. Somebody mentioned he was like a young Scott Parker. I like him. Much better than Barkley who was strolling around in the last half hour, refusing to put his foot in and track back.
Mark Frere
62 Posted 20/10/2013 at 14:45:26
Nick,

I'm just curious to know why you are not a Martinez fan? What have you seen him so far, for you to come to this conclusion? What has Moyes got, that Martinez hasn't?

Just curious that's all.

Mark Frere
63 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:02:14
Jamie: Barkley's role in the team is to play attacking midfielder. I don't feel there's a great need for him to do lots of tracking back. McCarthy and Barry are more then adequate enough to do that job. As long as he performs well in an offensive manner, I will be happy. Sadly yesterday it wasn't one of his best displays, but he's still young and is no way the finished article yet. Martinez should be applauded for just throwing him in there and letting him develop. There's no doubt in my mind, Barkley will become a top, top player
Kevin Tully
64 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:08:42
So we shouldn't be playing the ball out of defence because Jagielka & Distin cannot seem to master this magical way of playing football???

Have you ever read such tripe?

They'll have to fucking learn then, won't they?

Or sell them to Sunderland.

Ben Jones
65 Posted 20/10/2013 at 14:53:18
I can't believe some of the bias there with regards to the Barry tackle.

His first tackle he studded a player and got him injured. It wasn't intentional but it looked nasty. Easily a yellow.

Second one, yes he got the ball, but also got the man and studded him too. I don't agree it was a red but it was definitely a yellow. Barry should have been sent off with those two tackles.

The first goal should also never stood. Even if he didn't touch the ball (he did), he still interfered with play.

But I'm not bothered about the performance, we won. That to me is a sign of a good team, and I have to be honest, I did not think Martinez's teams had that graft in them. It's very pleasing.

It's also pleasing to hear good comments on McCarthy. I really like how he plays and he is going to be one of the best midfielders in the league one day.

Paul Smith
66 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:34:13
Kevin Tully

I commend and endorse your last!!
Good stuff

Raymond Fox
67 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:09:36
I think RM has a difficult/ unpleasant decision in regard of our captain, because I don't think he's able to make the transition into a ball playing defender!

I mentioned yesterday that Alcaraz would be a excellent replacement for Jags if we can rely on him staying fit for the season, its a big if though.

Opposing managers no doubt will continue to press us high up the field as was the case yesterday to attempt to make it difficult to play the passing game that RM wants. Part of the reason is also our players are too static and not helping the passer by not making enough runs to find space.

Its going well but we have way to go yet. We need 2 new signings, 3 if Baines leaves.

Andrew Clare
68 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:39:34
If Jags and Distin are unable to bring the ball out of defence then we need a deep lying mid fielder a la De Rossi to come back and take the ball from them.

The reality is that Jags and Distin are Sunderland material.

Jamie Barlow
69 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:39:14
He could at least track back to the half way line Mark. I'm not saying he isn't or won't be a great player but for the last half hour yesterday, when we didn't have the ball, it was like playing with 10 men.
Ralph Basnett
70 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:40:09
Gary (315), I should have stated Hull as a prem team are shit, we are still a team that lower (shit teams) think they can get a result from, know we only play for 45 minutes and know that until we are settled in our new style we can be knocked out of synch by pressing us.

Hull overall seen that we still have not hot into a habit of putting teams to the sword and new that if they do all of the above their is potential for a result. 1-0 up after eight minutes at home you press the advantage, score a few more (Newcastle!!!!) and push on. I hate to say it but until we do that we will always be an also ran team.

It is a great habit to have of winning, but it is a mindset that we never seem able to achieve.

Jackie Barry
71 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:41:09
Okay, so Barry's tackles were rough but the fact remains he didn't get sent off. You know what many of our players have had this done and far worse to them over the years with no booking or cards produced on the offender. The difference is our manager was not shouting from the rooftops like Bruce was and MotD were not showing it in some way to make us look lucky. Also remember our sendings off that have been mysteries, remember Gibson getting sent off?

No, I am not going to dwell on this or stick the knives in our players, other fans don't so I am not going to either. Barry is hardly malicious so I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

Paul Andrews
72 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:59:29
Look at the table.
Brent Stephens
73 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:54:17
So we "ship Jags and Distin out to Sunderland because they're not good enough".

They are part of a defence that was one of the most solid last season in terms of goals conceded, if I remember correctly.

OK, people are simply saying not good enough for Roberto's way of playing? Then I suspect we are talking big, big money to find TWO replacements who are just as solid defensively (I know, they had their lapses yesterday) AND are comfortable retaining possession at the back and bringing it out of defence, if that's what Roberto wants.

Darren Hind
74 Posted 20/10/2013 at 14:53:45
Not sure I understand why people get upset when Martinez is cricised.

We were an absolute Titus at the back yesterday. I've been saying all season that it's a mistake to try and get out-and-out defenders to play football against top quality predators and fuck me were they exposed again yesterday.

Jagielka looks like he's never played.... and Distin? – That pass he played back to Howard was as bad as anything I've seen at any level in half a century of playing and watching.

Robbie simply doesn't know his players. When is he going to realise Baines and Coleman are attacking full backs? Make these two stay home and you nullify an awful lot of our threat.

Martinez may have the back five onside now, but for how long? How much longer will they want to stick to a system that makes them all look shite? ... Change the style or change the players, Robbie lad.

I really don't get why people are so deliriously happy – we have a real problem here; anybody logging on to ToffeeWeb will know that teams who press right up on our back four will get some joy and you'd have to be seriously mutton to have not heard the boos ring around Goodison yesterday... that's THREE times already this season... People pay good money to see pros do what they can't. Apart from LB's free kicks, they are not seeing it, certainly not from the players who have done it in the past.

And why do people think this jittery suicidal garbage constitutes attractive football and that the only alternative is to twat it down the park? Whatever happened to getting the ball quickly into your footballers in midfield and sending your full backs down the line to offer options?

Mix it up Robbie, or you will lose the players and if you do that you"ll lose the crowd.

Jackie Barry
75 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:55:25
Ralph did you see Hull against Man City or Chelsea, now neither of them bathed themselves in glory in those games. Of course the performance could be better but in the end we did win and that is what counts. Overall I would say RM is doing a good job and as we improve things are going to get very interesting. Also we are still undefeated at home in 2013, many teams come to Goodison knowing that and I suspect think it unlikely they will be leaving with anything.
Phil Walling
76 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:47:09
So according to many, Jags and Distin have now become inadequate defenders under the tutelage of our new manager. Some even say they should be replaced by the likes of Stones and Alcaraz – or perhaps Per Krøldrup could be enticed back to Goodison!

What total shite. Both Phil and Sylvian are amongst the most competent centre-halves in the land but because they can't – or won't – adjust to Wigan's relegation tactics, they should be bombed.

If The Great Roberto has done anything since he came here, it is to brainwash so many of our following that he alone holds the key to 'perfect football'.

May I just remind his ever-growing army of disciples that his predecessor's 'People's Club' utterances sucked them all in in just the same way... and now he's the Devil Incarnate!

Brent Stephens
77 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:02:31
Jackie Barry #424, I won't cut and paste the bits from what you say that I'd take issue with because that would be too much.

First, I don't see how wrong decisions about bad tackles against us is any justification for bad tackles by our players. If it's a bad tackle, it's a bad tackle.

The fact he didn't get sent off doesn't necessarily say it was a fair tackle, only that the ref didn't see it as a bad tackle. As we know refs can get it wrong (and I think that's probably you're point in referring to tackles against us).

I don't see what MotD says or what a manager shouts about as being relevant. If it's a bad tackle etc etc.

And nobody is sticking the knife in. It's called honesty.

And I agree, Barry isn't probably malicious. But don't the rules talk about serious foul play and violent conduct rather than intent?


Jackie Barry
78 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:14:27
Get over yourself Brent, I agreed with what you said I thought they were rough tackles and yes they could have been a booking or sending off. However how many time have we been left wondering why opposition players have not been booked for what they have done to our teams.

Nowhere did I say it was a fair tackle in my response to you, also our managers have a tendency to accept what the ref decides on the understanding that it's in the past. RM interview with Sky show a true professional, he accepts what the decision is, even when they have gone against us, and remains calm. They were hard tackles, hardly the ugliest tackles ever and the ref chose to not send off Barry, now I'm moving on.

Paul Ferry
79 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:49:36
Patrick - 365 - I'm not being relentlessly critical for the sake of being well relentlessly critical, I am feeling rather good about everything for the most part - I am no Nick Entwhistle, for instance, whose views on Mccarthy are well bordering on insanity and who may or may not answer the simple question 'why you got so much against 'r Bobby ya chipper geezer?'

But there are two things that worry me and its plain silliness to brush them off as Mike Gwyer still does - 370 - as bless 180 minutes play in 8 days on international duty - this changes everything apparently, 2 games in 8 days for Engerland or whoever is more knackering than 2 games in 8 days for Everton!

These two things are the wobbly central defence not yesterday but for the most part of the season and this for me anyway quite worrying 2nd half cream-crackered-itis regardless of whether or not players turned up for international duty - it's hardly the explanation is it Mike (Gwyer) when five if yesterday's starting eleven did not kick a ball for a national team.

This international stuff is a lazy red herring and not helpful as it deflects attention from explanations that are almost certainly local to us at Everton.

I have no priviledged access, insider knowledge, or expert knowledge on things like fitness, the nature of training, diet, and so on ....... (I also recall people commenting on some players and 2nd half fitness when the other fella who now manages Manure was in our hot seat, but not I think to this present degree).

The players under the microscope here are no Franny Lees or Ralph Coates but finely-tuned lean machines with an expert to turn to for each aspect of their performance. Something right now is not all it could be at Finch Farm but I for one am confident that it will be sorted out,in part by allowing one or two 'offenders' to drift to the bench and then the door - Osman springs to mind.

Listen, I like Jags and have in the past called Distin 'imperious', but they ar ebeing caught out over and over again and we are conceding at a rate that might make goal difference an issue for us in the time to come. Positional sense, distribution, control, reading - the by now near perennial Jags lapse when someone scores who is a yard away from England's number 6.

I suppose the simple answer is to go with Sam (Hoare) - 400 - and think about a 'fit' Alcaraz and Stones stepping up for well Distin - and I would add a window signing to the mix. Just coz it's simple doesn't mean it's wrong! But my feeling I fear is that the once formidable Jags/Distin pairing needs to be broken up and, needless to say, as Jags is apparently untouchable - skipper, England, younger, and all that - the chop will fall on SD.

Patrick elsewhere I am bouncing and bouyant about are first-rate new gaffer and what he/we are doing, but defence and cream-crackered-itis hang heavy in my mind right now. I might well be making too much of one or both and sadly most of us - well me - tend to find it hard to skip over apparent 'problems' even when the sun is shining so brightly.

Jackie Barry
80 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:22:56
Paul completely agree, do you think the issues in our defence can be sorted out with the current players in that as professionals they should be able to adapt or are changes needed? I would hope that as professionals they would be able to adapt, but maybe too many years of playing a certain way makes this impossible.
Paul Andrews
81 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:27:27
Posters above are over reacting.
Early days yet for Roberto to implement his style.
Raymond Fox
82 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:09:38
Good one Phil, you can always be guaranteed to pop up and slag off Martinez and mention Wigan.

The argument is, Roberto wants to play the more modern type of football and, if players can't adapt to playing this way, they will have to be shipped out! Not nice, especially in Jagielka's case being Captain and also with the lead-up to the World Cup; it's a cruel world but, if it's necessary, that's what RM should do.

Whether that's the right thing to do is open to debate of course.

Mark Frere
83 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:22:01
Why is it so hard for people to understand that we can't just simply teach Jags and Distin to pass it around at the back as if they were Sammer? Does it occur to anyone they might not have the natural ability to do this? Kevin Tully's post was absolute bollocks! While we are coaching them to be great passers of the ball, why don't we teach them to be great strikers, we can play them up front then - we won't need Lukaku.

Martinez needs to play to their strengths (which is purely let them defend) or replace them with ball playing CBs. I can see some major disasters occurring this season with all this farting about at the back between players who are not suited to playing this way.

Kevin Tully
84 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:37:23
£60 grand a week Internationals can't pass a football - and I'm the one talking bollocks.

Take a bow son, as Mr. Gray used to say.

Brent Stephens
85 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:24:26
Jackie #431 "Get over yourself Brent". Not sure what that's saying, first of all.

All I was posting was that Barry's tackle was a sending-off offence. Nothing more, nothing less.

"Nowhere did I say it was a fair tackle." Quite right. I should have worded my thoughts better and said that the fact he wasn't sent off doesn't mean that it wasn't a sending off offence.

Jackie, I was just responding to the overall tone of your post which seemed to suggest that this wasn't a sending-off offence. And your post seemed dubiously to use other things to justify it, such as tackles against us. One incident doesn't justify another.

And I was only suggesting that to say it was a sending-off offence is not sticking the knife in, just being honest.

Agree, I've seen worst tackles. But I and some others are just saying our opinion is it was a sending-off offence and the ref got it wrong. Only an opinion, if we're allowed...

Happy for you to move on.

Paul Andrews
86 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:38:41
Phil Walling,

Take a look at the table, see where Roberto's "relegation tactics" have us placed.

Paul Andrews
87 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:40:49
Mark Frere,

Martinez is hardly asking them to play defence splitting passes that need vision. He is not asking them to play pinpoint passes over 50 yards.

Simple passing along the back line and into midfield is well within the range of any professional playing in the Prem. They need to get used to, and be confident in, when they pass and move into space to receive the passes.

Ross Edwards
88 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:46:32
Phil, if there's anyone who's displaying relegation tactics, it's Devil Wears Moyesy: taking Rooney off for Smalling, and Nani off for 82-year-old Ryan Giggs when 1-0 up.

Manc fans are not happy about it.

I'd understand your complaints if we were in 18th, but we're in 7th. It's been a good start.

Tony Marsh
89 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:51:48
Dear oh dear, Mr Walling, are you so absorbed with OFM that your brain has ceased to function? Martinez is doing a great job with the whole club and you want to slag him off? Roberto has only been here 3 months and yet we are making giant strides and we are definitely not doing a Wigan like you want us to do.

This clinging to the Moyes years is embarrassing, mate, it really is. Go and take a look on that Redcafe website and see what the Man Utd fans are saying about Darling Dave:

Shithouse tactics, Hoofball, defender on strikers off at 1-0 up, cowardly approach to the game, shits himself under pressure etc... Does that sound familiar or what? Can all these Manc fans now also be wrong as well – hundreds of them?

Get a grip, Phil: Moyes has gone and we are much better for it. Unless 75.000 prawn Sarnie eaters don't know football either, you have got some serious amounts of people who think your views suck,

Mark Frere
90 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:56:33
Paul,

When the opposition are pressing high up the pitch and not giving our defenders any time on the ball what-so-ever, our defenders need to be comfortable on the ball when they have so little time think. Distin and Jags are great defenders, that's all they are. Tony Adams was a top CB in his day but he wouldn't of been able to play quick passes at the back.

Its about knowing players limits of capabilities.

Paul Andrews
92 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:03:50
I think we can trust Martinez to know the players capabilities Mark
Patrick Carty
93 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:48:49
I agree Kevin (#439) – these are professional footballers getting well paid and they find it hard to pass a football, for fuck's sake. This is a joke. If they find it hard to pass a football from A to B, they should be in another profession.

Brian Harrison
94 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:02:52
I think most of what RM has done since arriving is terrific, and most of the players he has brought in have made a difference. The only negative side is our build up from the back is often painstakingly slow, and allows the opposition to set themselves which make them harder to break down. So I would just like RM to take a look at the top teams and see how quickly they move the ball from defense to attack, without having to play long balls. I also think what becomes evident in a lot of our games is our opponents know we are reluctant to play the ball long out of defence so close down our back four very quickly which has caused us problems already.

While we all like to see good passing football, I think against the top sides we will come off second best if we try to play an open passing game against them. And yes I know we beat Chelsea but I think most fans will think we should have lost that game by a couple of goals and again overpassing in that game should have cost us a goal, thankfully Eto made a hash of the chance. So please Roberto lets be a little less rigid in playing the ball out of defence.

Barry Rathbone
96 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:04:46
Phil (#429) – at least we gave the previous lad a few years to prove he was a mate of Satan; surely change was necessary after 11 years?

I am a great advocate of Roberto, I want change and am prepared for a few issues en route. I firmly believe the net result will be improvement.

The glaring vulnerability of tika-taka in defence is a Catch-22 situation: if they don't practice, they don't get better... but resorting to hoofball puts us back to same old, same old (pukes!).

Remarkably we haven't been caught out yet; perhaps the positives are outweighing the negatives playing this way... little things are going with us – perhaps we are creating our own luck.

Whatever it is, we're winning and 38k were there – can't be bad.

Kevin Tully
97 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:24:57
This Villa side don't look up to much at all. Let's hope Benteke is still out next week.
Ralph Basnett
98 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:32:34
Kevin (454), never mind Villa... Spuds the week after and I am worried with either Ossie or Naismith in midfield against real Prem midfielders, but that’s for another thread...
Kevin Tully
99 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:34:36
Sorry - Benteke on as sub. Spurs could be 4 up though.

Villa 1 shot on target after 77 min's.

Patrick Carty
100 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:26:16
On another note, does Kone look like he will ever get a goal for us? Would fans prefer Jelavic or Kone from the bench?

A striker is a must in January, I think we all know that Lukaku will only be here for the season, and this position must be seriously looked at.

I think Jordan Rhodes would make the step up, do any other fans have any strikers in mind.

Kevin Tully
101 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:36:16
Ralph - looking forward to that one. They are playing a very similar style to us.
Patrick Murphy
102 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:26:23
The observations regarding corners are quite correct, and as somebody mentioned yesterday, Jelavic does, when he is playing, win a lot of headers in his own area from the opponents corners. I also think that our crossing in general has got worse this season, which may be a reason - if they are either not working on corners or crossing - that our defence looks all at sea.

In the first-half some of the general play was criminal and we weren't working as a team. I thought the second half we were far more comfortable and how many times did Distin have the ball in their half - quite a few from what I remember. I thought Lukaku, Barkley and Osman gave their least effective performances so far this season, don't know why but perhaps Hull ran that extra mile.

If there are issues with the system, then you would think that as professionals and as our senior players the likes of Distin and Jags could talk to the manager or sort it out between themselves and the midfield. I can't see RM as the sort of manager who would fail to listen to their concerns.

It takes courage and belief to try and play the passing game, but I'm not sure we are conceding any more chances than last season. But I do agree our set-pieces at both ends of the pitch require a lot more work, and if we are to be successful we need every player performing at full tilt for the whole game and carry no passengers - hasn't that always been the case during the last 12-15 years.

Steve Pugh
103 Posted 20/10/2013 at 16:50:47
Before a ball was kicked in anger this season how many people said that our back four were so good that RM's tactical changes would not make them look bad?
Barry Rathbone
104 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:00:23
I don't think anyone said that, Steve. I think they were saying they were better than at Wigan so wouldn't have the problems that beset them.

Also not sure the back four is uncomfortable - the two centre-backs perhaps.

Jamie Barlow
105 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:07:03
It's no big problem. Let them get used to playing a certain way. You don't become bad defenders overnight. One thing I think I'd do is take the captaincy off Jags and give it Barry. It won't happen but it should.

By the way, we'd let in 9 at this stage last season (one less than this season) so it's not as if our defence has gone drastically tits up.

Sam Hoare
106 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:19:32
Paul Andrews 'Simple passing along the back line and into midfield is well within the range of any professional playing in the Prem. They need to get used to, and be confident in, when they pass and move into space to receive the passes.'

I really think this is a massive oversimplification. Both Jags and Distin are obvioulsy capable of playing simple passes along the back line but the what happened yetserday and will again is that the back line get pressed and there are no simple passes to play. That is when a good ball playing CB is able to pick a harder pass and play it through midfield to someone unmarked. This requires a certain level of vision and passing accuracy and Kevin Tully is wrong if he thinks that this can be easily coached.

Simon Harris
107 Posted 20/10/2013 at 17:59:17
All this faffing about at the back is all well and good if you mix it up, and it doesn't get much better than our winner yesterday.

Big punt up field to the big centre forward - flicks it on to his strike partner - quickly gets it out wide to the winger - who crosses first time to his fellow wide man to stroke it home with his first touch.

A timeless goal - one HK, Gray, Steven, Sheedy and co would surely have been proud of.


Ross Edwards
108 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:21:30
If you have to be coached to pass a ball accurately, Sam, then surely you're in the wrong job.
Paul Andrews
109 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:26:07
Sam,

Read the rest of my post.

Bill Griffiths
110 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:09:12
Can't believe the garbage posted on here regarding yesterdays game. I've been watching The Blues now on and off for 46years and for many seasons especially the last few years my nerves have been on a knife edge when we have been defending one goal leads as we sat back further and further before more often than not surrendering that lead.
Yesterday even though Hull put in a decent effort I didn't think they caused us any problems at all other than from set pieces.
I also can't believe the stick Barkley's getting both on here and from fans at the game yesterday. Fair enough it may have been his most least ineffective game yet but at least he always wants the ball and tries things even if they don't always come off.
We should all be applauding his efforts and willingness to try things differently not trying to stifle his individuality.
I am someone who doubted Martinez's ability to do this job but am more than happy with what he's done so far and even if there's a dip coming I think he's showing he can make a real go of this.
Kevin Tully
111 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:28:57
Sorry Sam, you have completely misconstrued my main point.

If we find ourselves in a position that we have to start teaching two of our most experienced players how to pass out of defence - I would hope they would be sold at the very next opportunity.

I don't believe for one minute they are that bad however, and they can both fit in to how we want to play, with Distin slowly making way for Stones*

* If he can control a ball.

P.S. - Glen Hoddle has just said we need more technically gifted players in the English game, and not have clubs concentrating on power, running etc. if we want any success in the future.

If that means the hoof is eradicated out of the game - brilliant. How can we charge supporters to watch pro's at the top of their game twat it upfield has always been beyond me.

You may like it though - who knows?

Paul Andrews
112 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:39:37
Well said Bill.
Too easy too make snap judgements after only 8 games.
Give the lad a season to impose his playing style on the squad.
David Chait
113 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:39:38
The flak Barkley getting is nothing short of astonishing. We want hi. To learn and develop, but how can we do that without giving any rope to have a poor game or 2 or 3.... He must play ... End of...
Paul Andrews
114 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:42:27
"The boy will learn from the mistakes he makes"
Martinez a few weeks ago.
A player like Barkley will not have everything he tries come off.
Give me a player who takes risks with the ball over a player who has a fantastic pass completion rate but passes safe every time.
James Flynn
115 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:05:21
Phil (429) - What I'd like us to have a go at, is a game or 2 set up as last season. Pienaar and Baines up one flank, Coleman and Miralles the other. With Barry and McCarthy anchoring the middle and the Barkley/Lukaku combo up top?

I'd like to see that team have given a chance.

Ross Edwards
116 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:56:42
What, Lukaku isolated up front on his own James?

We are moving on from the dark days of hoofball and negativity James, not resuming them, or maybe there are so many negative naysayers that want Moyes and his anti-football reinstated.

Even the Mancs have seen through his clueless tactics after 8 games, yet we have some morons demanding the return to 1 up front, completely isolated, 1990s type football, and enthusiastically supporting our negative tripe without complaint for 11 years, yet 8 games in, playing the best football we've seen for 2 decades, and we have some idiots slagging off Martinez already.

Hit it up to the target man and hope for mistakes is 1980s football. Move on from Moyes and shut up complaining.

Sam Hoare
117 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:55:54
Paul, I have. I still think you are underestimating how easy it is to do that and clearly it is not 'well within the range of any professional playing in the Prem'.

Kevin, sure. I agree with what Hoddle says but i'm not sure its so simple as just selling our best two centre backs because they struggle to play that style. Perhaps Alcaraz may replace Distin giving us at least one CB able to distribute more effectively but for me defending ability trumps distribution. Just look at David Luiz! I think we could also make life easier for them by making sure the midfielders pick the ball up from them and move it forward quickly, this is what Carrick did for Man u so effectively last season.

Brian Waring
118 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:09:46
It's funny, Moyes got 11 yrs grace from his disciples, Roberto gets 8 games.
Paul Ferry
119 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:14:57
Bill (469) - Paul (472): 'Too easy too make snap judgements after only 8 games. Give the lad a season to impose his playing style on the squad'.

Hang on, there are not many people on here making snap judgments about 'the lad', apart from Entwhistle and Waring and they are just silly sausages.

The discussion has taken a number of directions, for sure, but latterly a focal part is concerns about our defence.

So, when someone pops on here saying I can't believe what ... or stop being so ... or 'Can't believe the garbage posted on here regarding yesterdays game' ...

Listen, if you watched that game yesterday and don't think that our centre-back pairing is not an object of concern and discussion and if you think that by participating in such a discussion it is worthy on a 'can't believe' then I'm sorry, you need to be on another planet .........

Jamie Barlow
120 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:50:18
Doesn't mean he should be excused from flak when he has a bad game or doesn't look like he can be arsed.
Paul Andrews
121 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:23:31
Bit touchy there Paul.
James Martin
123 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:04:44
Some of the views on here expressed about Jagielka and Distin are ridiculous. They are two of the best centrebacks in the premier league. They are not perfect but who in the division is? David Luiz is supposedly a great ball playing centreback but has made more mistakes on the ball than Jagieka or Distin recently.

As I see it it works both ways. You can't expect centrebacks to thread eye of the needle balls through to the front men. They have to look for midfielders, but equally the midfielders have to show for them. They didn't do this often enough or well enough yesterday so it resulted in the centrebacks splitting and one of the midfielders dropping in to take the ball. Not ideal but not the worst way to bring it out either.

There's been some huge overexaggerations on here, for most part of yesterdays game Jags and Distin were fine on the ball. In open play they defended really well, they only had a problem on set pieces which is nothing to do with playing from the back. If you want to criticise Martinez's set piece defense then fine but the open play defense looks alright. From what I could see it looked like a man to man marking so really the blame lies with Distin and Jagielka simply for not tracking their man.

Whilst some things have changed at Everton: the directness of the midfield (probably because Fellaini is gone), some things haven't. Although we pass a lot more thwere was still a large number of long balls yesterday both from the centre backs and the keeper. Its not always a bad thing, sometimes its preferable to win the ball in a midfield tussle and then take control - gives you a better opportunity to catch the opposition unaware. It beats rolling the ball out to the centrebacks with the opposition ready to bare down on them in the most dangerous position on the pitch, it takes fantastic football to go from goal keeper to striker passing through an opposition 11 that are in formation. A lot of the best attacks are actually formed when there is a turn over of possession. Managing the transition of possession is what is key and is what Ferguson did so well at United. Looking to dominate possession is something that I've only seen work for two teams, Barcelona and Spain. Perhaps Martinez knows this which is why we continue to take goal kicks long and Jags and Distin when nothing is on look to go long.

Brian Waring
124 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:35:28
Wow Paul, that time of the month is it?

When Roberto fucks up, the same goes for the players, everyone is entitled to criticise, that's their right, for me it's still early days.

By the way, I'm willing to give Roberto a couple of seasons to get it right.

Phil Walling
125 Posted 20/10/2013 at 18:44:58
Tony Marsh is as addicted to Moyes bashing as I am to anti Wiganitis! My reservations about the Great Saviour that is Roberto in no way indicate that I loved Moyes in his hoof - ball years but the man knew how to make the best of the players he had at his disposal.

My list of great centre-halves includes the likes of Labone,Ratcliffe,Butcher,Adams and Terry and I don't recall any of them being made to fanny about in the interests of the philosophy of the managers under whom they served.

Most of the short passing along the line achieves nothing apart from providing a seminal experience for the manager.I'd get off more if he'd teach them to defend /attack at corners.Or,at least, go back to the Moyes Method.But everything he did was shit......wasn't it,Tony?

Paul Andrews
126 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:54:48
Phil,

You are the only person I have heard call Martinez the "great saviour"
Do you remember how Baresi,Maldini,Bobby Moore,Thuram,Desaily etc etc fannied about in the interests of their managers philosophy?

Kevin Rowlands
127 Posted 20/10/2013 at 19:56:47
Nick #407, you don't know what McCarthy does? right there is proof to me you have neither played or know that much about football, he was outstanding yesterday easily the best player on the pitch, your dislike of RM seems to be making you delusional.
Paul Andrews
128 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:19:53
Kevin,

Well said.
Give the lad time,he will develop into a very good player

Raymond Fox
129 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:08:28
James I don't think you can't blame RM for our defending of corners, hardly rocket science is it? You each mark an attacker, you'd think Jags and Distin especially with all their experience could manage it better than yesterday!

Phil, the game's changed since most of your examples of centre halves played, it's because the coaching in this country has not changed with the times that our national side is now so low in the ratings.

Paul Andrews
131 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:35:59
Phil,

Moyes is not doing too good with the players at his disposal this season...

Raymond Fox
132 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:35:50
Oh god, just forget post 496 please.
Kevin Tully
133 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:41:36
It's funny, if you were reading this thread without knowing any results this season, you would think we were getting stuffed every game.

Don't think we have been 4 points off top spot after 8 games too many times in the last 20 years. ( I will do some research on that tomorrow)

Darren Hind
134 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:08:17
How can we hope to solve the problem if we're not prepared to recognise it?

Martinez is failing to get the best out of his players. I can't think of one who has improved on or even matched the form he showed last season... why?

I put it down to inflexibility. Let's not pretend this is just about the centre-backs (who look unrecognisible from the players we know they can be); let's examine other areas. How long do we expect Coleman and Baines to put upwith this? Two of the most attacking full backs in the world and they are having to stay home scratching their arses while Pinky and Perky fool about... Baines must spend his time preying for free kicks just so he can get out of our half.

What's it gonna take for people to realise we have a major problem? – an absolute battering? How confident will you guys be when rat boy starts snapping at our centre-backs as they fuck about? – he already gives them nightmares.

This bollocks about being in transition is a piss weak argument; with the exception of maybe Arsenal, they're all in transition.

Paul Andrews
135 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:50:24
As I said earlier Kevin.
They should look at the table
Phil Walling
136 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:48:40
Paul: Why, is his new team not doing so well? I only look out for Everton......with a peep at the Wigan score cos that's where I was born.
Paul Andrews
137 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:53:52
That explains a lot Phil
Patrick Carty
138 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:50:05
I do not think you will have to research that, Kevin, that's a fact. A win again Villa and we really will be in the mix.

Make no mistake, this was a great three points for us; no game is a walkover any more.I was delighted to see Pienaar back, and I'm looking forward to seeing the great partnership he and Baines had last season.

Drew Shortis
139 Posted 20/10/2013 at 20:45:39
Watching MotD last night I was really impressed by Southampton's high pressing game, something we could learn from. We would be much more dangerous if we could consistently win back possession higher up the pitch. Hull were causing us some problems when they pressed high up and prevented us from playing the ball out from the back. It can be a risky tactic if you commit too many men forward, but I love to watch teams giving it a real good go like that.

Sometimes we struggle to make headway when we play out from the back and the opposition have time to get back in formation. Naismith is a good player for this kind of tactic as he will willingly close down opposition players and he cant tackle. Just a pity his passing isn't always up to scratch when he does win possession.

Tony Marsh
140 Posted 20/10/2013 at 21:23:22
Phil, go and have a look at what the Man Utd fans are saying about Moyes on the Redcafe site. A poster on here mentioned it yesterday so I had a look. We can't all be wrong, can we?

Moyes has only been at OT 3 months and they hate him. His negativity is like a cancer and it consumes everything he touches. I bet we could manage a win at OT now we have a manager who wants to win rather than just survive. I have never heard RM say we used to be frightened for our lives when we played there – even though he was at Wigan... That's a Moyes quote all day long.

James Flynn
141 Posted 20/10/2013 at 23:14:58
Speaking of Tim Cahill . . . . .

http://deadspin.com/tim-cahill-scored-the-fastest-goal-in-mls-history-1448758204

NY Red Bull talisman he is. Leading us right towards winning the title. And when will one of these corner flags put up its dukes?

Must note, we perked up once the arm-band was taken from Henry and attached to the arm best suited.

Paul Holden
142 Posted 20/10/2013 at 23:49:45
Can somebody tell Jags to stop his Hollywood passes — distribution dire!
Paul Ferry
143 Posted 20/10/2013 at 23:48:25
Spot on Kevin - 492
Robert Collins
144 Posted 20/10/2013 at 23:46:08
Not our most convincing performance, but winning when you're not playing your best football is good habit to have. How many times have we seen ManU under Fergie look mediocre fumble through games and still manage to get the victory?

We're still in rebuild phase, we must remember that.

I don't think the goals we conceded were because of the system, they were conceded because both Jagielka and Distin were marking space and not men. Fucking schoolboy errors.

Now then! Gollum snatched a draw from the jaws of victory yesterday by bringing off a world class forward in good form (Shrek) and bringing on a defender, does any of this sound familiar to anyone here? It's took him just 8 games in charge to return to his natural type!! He left the Man Utd prawn cocktail brigade enraged after seeing a game Fergie would have grabbed by the scruff of the neck, turn into one of Dour Davie's "a draw will do... survive at all costs" games.

Marvelous, and long may he be with them!

Mick Davies
145 Posted 21/10/2013 at 00:12:11
Darren Hind @500, your anti-Martinez stance could be construed as anti-Everton; aren't we supposed to get behind the manager of our club? Like we did with Moyes for 11 barren years, even giving him a huge send off as he was ditching us for Man Utd and then coming straight back to disrupt our players.

Thanks to RM for acting incisively in the transfer deadline chaos.

The problems we have in defence is that for years now our club has played a defence-first system, where midfield was indistinguishable from defence, and EVERY player came back to defend corners; when the ball was hoofed out, it just came straight back. Did this save us from hidings? Well unless 7-0 at Arsenal, 6-2 at Newcastle, 5-1 at Man City,

Thrashings at Benfica, Bucharest etc don't count. The system we are trying to perfect now demands that the defence get the ball to the midfielders or wide men without wildly kicking it forwards where the opposition are better positioned to send it straight back.

It's early days yet and 11 years of hoof cannot be erased easily, so I expect the deep midfielders will be getting told to drop back and receive the ball to take the pressure off. It all makes sense and when we judge everything by one game (which we actually won) that is just nonsense.

Hull played at Goodison like we sometimes did in the past at the richer clubs, getting in their faces, trying to throw them off balance and tiring ourselves out to be picked off near the end. We have to expect this if we are to be successful and I think, to a large extent we done the job, even with a lot of players having an off day (possibly due to a fortnight's disruption when things were starting to come together and other factors).

So let's not jump down the manager's throat too soon; give him a few transfer windows to bring in his own choice of personnel and then if it's not working, then criticise

Paul Ferry
146 Posted 21/10/2013 at 03:47:26
Lovely thoughtful and perfectly worded and pitched response Mick - 537 - I appreciated each word, although I don't think the utter tomfoolery you were responding to - 500 - deserved such a measured, considered, and erudite reply. Jeez that Hind fella spouts some gibberish, the 'reasoning' behind his stabs and pokes and pops is embarrassingly easy to dismantle. I suppose that once a Hind-like-hawk decides that something is the case and always true then aforementioned Hind-like-hawk will just go on and on and on and on and on and on and on .......... ad infinitum ........ ad nauseum .........
Darren Hind
147 Posted 21/10/2013 at 05:44:59
But Mick 537 we are still hoofing it, but only when somebody panics after fucking about with it for too long... and we still get all hands on deck when defending corners.

This particular back five did not play in the hidings you mention, they are a decent unit, but did you see them on Saturday? Did you not hear the crowd booing them? The confidence of these players is shot.

I know managers whose teams always play hoofball, but I'm yet to meet a fan who advocates it, so I really don't get why this is continually thrown back as the only alternative to the excessive fucking about at the back we are witnessing.

I'm not anti-Martinez and certainly not anti-Everton, but I worry (really worry) that he will prove to be inflexible. The style he wants to introduce is right up my street, but he will not be successful trying it with this defence.

Martinez should play to his players' strengths, at least until he can draught in the players who can play to his style.

Tommy Coleman
148 Posted 21/10/2013 at 08:10:11
Everyone is wasting their time arguing with Nick Entwistle and Phil Walling. They've made their minds up about the guy that replaced their Moyesie.

It's sad that they can only concentrate on any negative they can find and have dragged down this thread with their bitterness when we should be enjoying a very good win.

Keep it going RM, it's a breath of fresh air. The technique of the the team continues to improve, thanks to his coaching style.

James Fletcher
149 Posted 21/10/2013 at 10:05:26
Perhaps Alcaraz is the answer to our defensive issues....?
Phil Walling
150 Posted 21/10/2013 at 09:51:28
Tommy,just because we don't all sing from the same hymn sheet or praise the same saviour doesn't mean that our views have no credence.

I'm delighted when we play a good progressive passing phase but square passing across the box does not contribute anything apart from inducing high blood pressure in us fans and panic amongst the players concerned.

Although he is now a hated figure in these columns - and I was certainly no big fan - Moyes did much good for our club and I am sure Roberto will make a similar contribution. But it doesn't mean that I am required to worship at his shrine or desist from voicing my reservations about his obsession with piss-ball in any circumstances.

Kevin Tully
152 Posted 21/10/2013 at 10:59:06
It's official, the results are in!! (Must do more work on a Monday morning)

This is our best start in the P.L. era for being closest to the League leaders after 8 games.

Our previous best was a 6 point gap, and we are 4 behind Arsenal as it stands. Some of the previous seasons starts made horrible reading.

I don't think it tells us anything yet, but at least lay off the guy until we do start losing games.

*Please note, I went back 20 years, so as not to upset some loons.

Phil Walling
154 Posted 21/10/2013 at 12:07:40
Good work and great news Kevin. With Moyes we usually had a bad start and then started to play after Xmas or, very occasionally, it was the other way round. I'm just hoping that this guy can provide some consistency throughought the campaign.

I'll settle for 7th at the finish although my book-maker won't be too happy as he tells me Evertonians have lumped big bucks on that position - now available at evens.

David Donnellan
155 Posted 21/10/2013 at 12:16:11
#568, Phil, "square passing across the box does not contribute anything apart from inducing high blood pressure in us fans"

As opposed to taking attacking players off & bringing defensive players on, inviting heavy pressure upon ourselves?

I am not a Moyes hater (although I am not far off, after the way he has behaved since leaving are great club), he did do a lot for the club over the years (except win a trophy). However, the brand of football Martinez is trying to implement (albeit in its infancy) is a better brand for the paying supporter to sit & watch. He does need time to make it work the way it should. I am sure the passing will become more fluid over time & less forced. As mentioned in an earlier post, a lot of these players have been playing a different style of football for many years & it will take time for them to buy into this new style of play & be settled & comfortable playing this way.

He has got my backing, I will give it time & put these little errors down to the transition in our style of play. All things considered he has done a great job up until now, look at the league table.

Steve Brown
156 Posted 21/10/2013 at 13:00:05
Not sure what the Moyes-Martinez debate has to do with the fact that Everton lost their man at just about every corner at the weekend (by the way it was Barry marking Faye). The answer is easy on that one - the team need to work it through in training till we are doing what should be basic - defending properly.

What is an issue is that when our centre-halves receive the ball under pressure they are uncomfortable and sqander possession - Jagielka with diagonal 40 yard passes straight into touch or to an opposing defender and Distin with lofted balls down the left touch-line. This has led to our fullbacks being by-passed vompsred to last season. This has been evident all season and is based on the tactic of the centre-halves moving out wide to receive the ball from the keeper and the fullbacks pushing further up the pitch.

Now every premier club is going to adopt the tactic and pressure us high up the field so the options are 1) bring in Stones and/or Alcaraz .....really any better? 2)change tactics to start possession with the fullbacks 3) persevere with Jags and Distin until we can bring someone in whose game suits this tactic. But to pretend it isn't a problem is odd.

Kevin Tully
157 Posted 21/10/2013 at 13:26:35
Incredible - The champions are now in to 6/5 to finish outside the top 4 places.

Robert Collins
158 Posted 21/10/2013 at 13:14:34
Phil Walling @ 568

"I'm delighted when we play a good progressive passing phase but square passing across the box does not contribute anything apart from inducing high blood pressure in us fans...."

Phil, under DM the ball would have been immediately pumped up field to relieve any pressure on the defence and then come back at us with interest. Do you remember Norwich last year?

Agreed sometimes there is a need to hoof and I'm happy to see it done when necessary, but logic suggests if we have possession of the ball then we're not being hurt?

The goals we conceded yesterday were because of schoolboy mistakes, Jags and Distin marking space and not men. We're just 8 games into his reign and things are so much better than last year, he goes for the win in games that dour Davie would just like yesterday against Southampton be happy with the draw.

I've got some concerns myself about RMs style (I wanted him 3 years ago!), but I'm giving him 2-3 seasons to sort them out. We gave 11 seasons to the dour one, surely we can give Roberto a few seasons?

Phil Walling
159 Posted 21/10/2013 at 13:38:05
What we are hearing now is a call for Jags and Distin to be replaced for the sake of the manager's philosophy which is seen as all-important. So the England centre-half and his still-quick partner who would walk into at least half Prem sides must be sacrificed on the alter of so-called pretty football.

What total bollocks. The manager should be clever enough to amend his 'dream' system to accommodate the talent he has available. Of course the ageing Sylvan will have to be replaced eventually but now is not that time.

Nick Entwistle
160 Posted 21/10/2013 at 13:51:51
I keep being mentioned. Is this what grooming is?
Steavey Buckley
163 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:14:01
I do believe Romelu Lukaku needs support alongside of him if Everton are going to get the best out of him. Having to play against 2 centre halves will lessen his impact. So instead of the opposition being constantly on the 'back foot' with Romelu Lukaku with another, he is expected to forage a lonely path.
Raymond Fox
164 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:07:43
If anyone who can't see that Martinez is going to be a great manager for this club, I don't think much of their judgement.

As far as the critics are concerned, you've shown yourselves anti-Martinez before a ball was kicked.

God knows what you'd have been like if the results were not as good as they are!

James Flynn
165 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:24:55
Phil (606) - This is how he's always managed. Not gonna change because he's ours.

Would love to see a couple games or three in last year's formation, with both flanks attacking and Barkley/Lukaku up top. Think we could really get after teams.

And I believe we're seeing Jags in his last season at Goodison.

Tony J Williams
166 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:28:27
"If anyone who can't see that Martinez is going to be a great manager for this club, I don't think much of their judgement."

Raymond, in the same vein, those who can't see any wrong are also just as bad.

There is a middle ground you know, praise when it is warranted and criticism when it is also warranted.

Baines's threat has seemingly been nullified, Coleman isn't bombing forward as much, and we have had dodgy back pass/losing the ball moments several times already this season. Our two centre-halves are having mares in the last couple of games.

Criticism when it's due, the same with praise.

Not being a happy clapper doesn't make your judgement any less valid than all the "all's right in the world" clan.

Tony J Williams
167 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:33:47
Also, the Pienaar crab movement was brilliant. like he was doing the can-can on his arse.
James Flynn
168 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:32:37
Nick (607) - Made me laugh. Well done.

You do seem to be the current poster-boy for those who know they can just add "Entwistle" to a post and have others elbowing one another out of the way to agree.

Carl Sanderson
169 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:34:05
Tony 624:

"There is a middle ground you know, praise when it is warranted and criticism when it is also warranted."

Exactly. I never wanted Martinez, but he does appear to be learning quickly that he will need to mix some pragmatism with his idealism. He seems to have absorbed the message that he will need to win a far greater proportion of his games at Everton than he did at Wigan.

His positivity is laudable insofar as it inspires his players, otherwise it's just Rodgers-style waffle.

On the field of play we are quite good going forward, building on last season's performances, some of which were excellent. It is the defence that still worries me. We are still shipping goals and we were lucky not to concede more on Saturday.

Another six games or so will give us a clearer route-map for the season.

Mick 537:

To criticise Martinez does not make him anti-Martinez; to be anti-Martinez would not make him anti-Everton.

Paul Gladwell
170 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:45:17
Phil (#606) — how about we keep our managers tactics and the two centre halves just get their heads together and start passing from A to B correctly?

They are pro footballers in the top league — not two lads playing on a mud bath in Arrowe Park.

Phil Walling
171 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:31:35
I sincerely hope you are right, Raymond, but talk of 'greatness' after just 8 Prem games is a bit over the top, don't you think?

In nearly 50 years, I consider only Catterick and Kendall Mark1 to deserve that epithet – Moyes certainly didn't merit it – so I think such talk about Roberto to be both premature and misguided. Just see how the tide will turn when we lose a couple on the bounce!

Yes, the guy's made a decent start but he inherited a decent team so that was to be expected. Surely the less sycophantic amongst us are entitled to comment about those aspects of his philosophy which landed his previous club in the Championship without being dubbed 'anti', aren't we?

Kevin Tully
172 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:54:31
Last 5 seasons, goals against after 8 games; 18,12,7,11,8 - this season 10.

Sack him!!!!

James Flynn
173 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:40:02
Tony (624) - "Baines's threat has seemingly been nulified, Coleman isn't bombing forward as much and we have had dodgy back pass/losing the ball moments several times already this season/

Our two centre halves are having mares in the last couple of games."

Too true.

Given our team last season, didn't want Fella gone. He's gone. Barry and Macca in is terrific. Really want to see how it would go if we reverted to our lasts season's formation, given we have Pienaar back, and young Ross and Lukaku up front.

No Fear, right?

Paul Gladwell
174 Posted 21/10/2013 at 14:58:31
Coleman and Baines are nulified, our centre halves are pissing about too much passing around the back, yet we have the highest amount of possession in our opponents half than any team in the league, I'm getting confused here.
Jamie Barlow
175 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:01:29
I don't think we're pissing around at the back as much as we think. It's just that when we do, we're not very good at it and it's terrifying. We're just not used to watching it. Time seems to slow down.

Nobody is saying sack him Kevin. No need to be a drama queen. You have to admit our defence is a worry. We've gone from being a pretty solid back four into nervous wrecks.

Robert Collins
176 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:12:05
Phil Whalling @ 606

Phil, whatever other people are saying I didn't say replace Jags or Distin, they're are both still excellent players.

They're just making basic errors, that are nothing to do with any system, he needs to have a work with them, while he's there he could also have a word with about the quality of the marking with a few of others also. The defence is making basic mistakes.

Paul Gladwell
177 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:12:24
Jamie, we are getting reminded that one is a super fast centre half who would walk into most teams and the other Englands centre half and yet we are getting people moaning asking for a change of tactics as them pair shit themselves at a bit of closing down from forwards.
I saw no difference in England's build up play last week to ours on Saturday and yet Jags looked a bag of shite on Saturday whereas against one of the top forwards in Europe he did well, could it just be they where simply poor on Saturday and need to improve.
Andrew Clare
178 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:26:13
Jags and Dustin are undoubtedly good players and they would do a good job for any Prem team.
If we want to move to another level then they are not good enough.
For example if we qualify for Europe they will be ’taken apart’ by quick thinking high class players. Against the bread and butter Prem teams they do OK.
If RM wants to play passing football, which is great, he needs the right personnel.
I do think that he should vary tactics but over all I think he is doing a great job.
As long as we score more than the opposition I don’t care how many we concede.
Attacking football I’d forgotten what it was like under the other bloke!
Paul Gladwell
179 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:41:31
The fact we sold out on Saturday says alot of what people are thinking right now compared to not even selling out against The Shite and Man Utd in recent seasons. Yes, it's not perfect but surely it's there in front of us that, given time and a bit of cash, he can offer far more as a manager than the other fella.
Colin Glassar
180 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:42:25
I agree to a point with you Andrew. Jags and Distin ARE top class defenders they just seem to be struggling with the new philosophy a bit but, as top defenders they will adapt. Remember they played for years under OFM philosophy of get it up the field quickly (nothing wrong with that) now they are being told to bring the ball out and find a team mate not hoofing it to the opposition.
Michael Dawson of spurs is a good example. When AVB arrived at WHL he dropped Dawson as he thought he wouldn't fit into his style of play. What did Dawson do? He got his head down, started practicing his passing and positional play and now he starts every game. jags and Distin will be fine once they start to feel comfortable and if not, well there's always Stones and Alcaraz waiting in the wings.
Raymond Fox
181 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:19:09
Tony, everyone is open to criticism I agree, but we know what I'm talking about, criticism for the sake of it, because they have made their mind up a long time ago and it matters not how well RM and the team does they just want to criticise.
Observe how they disappear when we have a good result!


Phil, great in the sense that he's a all round manager, he wants to develop all aspects of the club, that was why he chose us, shite and A.Villa wouldn't give him that control.
We are never going to be able to spend our way to the top our only means is by developing from within and concentrating on our young players, in my opinion RM will be a great manager to do just that.

Tony J Williams
182 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:58:48
"Tony, everyone is open to criticism I agree, but we know what I'm talking about, criticism for the sake of it, because they have made their mind up a long time ago & it matters not how well RM & the team does they just want to criticise.
Observe how they disappear when we have a good result!"

I completely agree Raymond. One issue is that you could have posted the above paragraphs last season (changing DM for RM) and it would have been true too.

People like to complain, strangely it makes some people feel better. I am a bit of a player moaner, because I think they get off too easily on here. Many posters are just too quick to blame the manager but excuse the player

Max Wilson
183 Posted 21/10/2013 at 15:54:11
OMG! The possession footie debate is a hot potato alright. The fact is that recently that's what we've been playing.On Saturday for most of the game we had 65%of the ball. And other games lately its been similar for long periods.Roberto seems to be saying "if you've got the ball,they can't beat you with it", which is logical even to a New Chester Road School intellectual like myself. Distin and Jags are formidable most of time, and when they are forced into mistakes, we ought to cut em some slack. Jags recently said he liked the "new philosophy", although though, pardon me, what is new about it? We've got some ageing players. Maybe it is showing sometimes but at the mo, they are still delivering most of the time. Am I long winded? Scuse me whilst I have a fart.
Ian Burns
184 Posted 21/10/2013 at 16:06:03
Criticism of Jags and Distin is fair and Colin (647) makes a great point about Michael Dawson who chose to get it right rather than move to QPR.

Jags has done exceptionally well recently for England but when teams press him deep in his own half, he struggles but surely he and Distin can adapt to these new passing requirements without panicking each time they are confronted with a passing decision. I have to say that players in front of them also have a responsibility to make themselves available in space as quick as possible. Carrick always seems to find such space to take the ball from the centre backs, so it is possible!

I didn't want RM to begin with but as the season has rolled on, I think he is becoming a terrific appointment.

Kevin Tully
185 Posted 21/10/2013 at 16:30:36
Colin #647 - Spot on about Dawson. I watched Spurs yesterday, and it was a stroll in the park really, they never even played that well.

Villa never pressed them high up the pitch, and let them pass it out from the back - very surprising.

It's obvious that your midfielders need to be able to beat a man for this system to work, and in Barkley, McCarthy & Pienaar, I think we have the personnel.

Be interesting to see if they try to press our two next week.

Jamie Barlow
187 Posted 21/10/2013 at 16:55:40
Absolutely Paul. Both centre backs are going through a rocky patch. It's an all new ball game for them. It'll come in time. Hopefully pretty quickly.
Dan Brierley
188 Posted 20/10/2013 at 15:47:56
Paul Andrews, this is one of your posts form July:

"Collectively we have the best back 4 in the prem in my opinion.
Fans worrying that Martinez will turn them overnight into a poor defensive unit have not thought it through.
They may well be a little more exposed with a more attack minded coach,but balancing that off with the greater goal threat I think we will be fine."

Do you still think that those who doubted whether or not our defense would suffer 'have not thought it through'? To me it is clear that some of the concerns raised are justified, based on the performances we have been seeing in every game at the back. Something is clearly wrong and needs addressing. If the manager deserves time to adjust, then surely the players also do?

I have had a look through the PL squads, and can safely say that there is only David Luiz I would replace Jagielka with. I personally don't see any other Centre Half that is better, regardless of his passing skills. Without doubt there are other players who can pass better. But call me old fashioned if you want, as I think a Centre Half's core attributes need to be bravery, pace, tackling, positioning and aerial ability. Passing is next on the list, and comes at a huge premium. Its all very well saying Jags and Distin are 'Sunderland' material, but you are talking 15-20 million for top class, ball playing centre halves.

Our very own John Heitinga is certainly a better passer than Jags or Distin, so who would have him in the starting eleven? Thought not.

Barry Rathbone
189 Posted 21/10/2013 at 17:34:07
Dan, I think you shot yourself in the foot there, Paul's quote seems spot on the back 4 haven't gone to pieces we score cracking goals and are doing better!
Dan Brierley
190 Posted 21/10/2013 at 17:42:17
I guess its down to opinion Barry, if you think the defence is playing well then so be it. I personally don't agree, and think its one of our major weaknesses at the moment.

Barry Rathbone
191 Posted 21/10/2013 at 18:02:12
Dan, I agree the CB passing is a concern and in truth expect us to get caught out sooner rather than later but looking at the bigger picture my vote is to keep persevering.

A shit patch will no doubt occur but the pluses seem to outweigh the negatives at the moment so I'm just enjoying the ride ...... it's been soooooooo long!

Paul Andrews
192 Posted 21/10/2013 at 18:24:25
Dan,

I think I am right in saying we conceded 10 goals in our first 8 league games last season. How many have we conceded in our first 8 league games this season?

Ross Edwards
195 Posted 21/10/2013 at 19:25:07
David Luiz over Jagielka, Dan?

Judging by that error on Sat, I'd rather have Titus Bramble.

Dan Brierley
197 Posted 21/10/2013 at 20:54:25
Agreed Barry, we have to persevere and change the mindset. Although I cant ever see Jags becoming this ball playing centre half, same applies to Distin who scares the shit out of me when he is doing anything more than side ways or back passes. I think there might be a compromise in playing someone deep to give them both an 'easy' outlet to, at least until they become more accustomed to the style of play. At the moment they both look uncomfortable with the style, which is inviting the high lines and pressure game we saw against Hull. I think playing this way against the likes of Arsenal and Spurs is going to be a real struggle, so lets hope there is some kind of alternative strategy that can be employed.
Dan Brierley
198 Posted 21/10/2013 at 21:23:30
I am not sure I understand your point Paul, do you mean because we have defended poorly in history, its ok to do so now? Were you not concerned about the performance at the back against Hull?

I remember the Newcastle game, and Wigan games from early last season, where I think we all agreed that it was defensively poor. I am quite sure we threw another few opportunities away due to bad defending early last season. It was a concern then, just like it is now.

Colin Grierson
199 Posted 21/10/2013 at 20:24:15
In the first ten minutes our midfielders (Barry in particular) were dropping deep and offering more options for our CB partnership to give easy distribution from the back. This problem of possession football that we are experiencing is not unique to our CBs. When a team presses as high up the pitch as Hull ( and they are not the only side that we will face with this strategy ) it makes a good first touch essential.

I believe that Jags and Distin both have a decent first touch but they're distribution is poor as they are hesitant in possession and have too few options and when in doubt they should protect their goal and not flap, as Distin did when volleying the ball towards Howard.

There has been little mention of Howard in this forum with regard to his role in possession football. A keeper who can play a bit gives the defenders more time on the ball and offers an extra problem for the opposition ( an extra man ) when it comes to creating triangular passing sequences. It is solvable and shouldn't rely too much on personnel change.

I'm certain that RM is very aware of the shortcomings of recent performances and trust that he will remedy our failings. As many have stated the most worrying aspect defensively comes from our lack of organisation at set pieces. We look vulnerable at every set piece and were lucky not to concede several times on Saturday from floated deliveries that should be meat and drink to an experienced pairing such as ours.
Raymond Fox
200 Posted 21/10/2013 at 21:36:25
Dan, the bad defending in the Hull game were simple basic schoolboy individual errors, hardly the managers fault.

Your not suggesting that RM needs to teach them how to mark their man are you?

Dan Brierley
201 Posted 21/10/2013 at 21:47:41
Of course not Ray, but he certainly needs to be clear on his instructions. Jags in particular does not seem to fully understand his role this season, as at times he looks lost on whether he should cover space, or mark a man.
Paul Andrews
202 Posted 21/10/2013 at 22:00:09
Not at all Dan. I'm simply pointing out you seem to think our defending has deteriorated under the new manager. Same goals conceded this season to last in first 8 games would seem to indicate that was not the case.
Paul Gladwell
203 Posted 21/10/2013 at 22:16:02
These people claiming that all of a sudden we look shakey at the back should cast their minds back to our so solid defence last season, we actually went 18 games on the bounce conceding in every game including goals against rubbish like Leeds and Cheltenham.
Gavin McGarvey
204 Posted 21/10/2013 at 22:38:32
Paul, I agree that we have had problems in defence for some time. That being said, the changes to the team have definitely exacerbated those problems. Certainly we are less physical in midfield so maybe that's the problem.
Mick Davies
205 Posted 22/10/2013 at 00:51:46
For a club in transition with a new boss inheriting an ageing squad (similar to Moyes at OT)... I think RM has done well. As for our defenders, didn't we go 3 games without conceding? We haven't been battered by anyone yet but because we had an off day and still should have won more comfortably, some people aren't happy.

This may be a symptom of raised expectation amongst the fans, and a sell out against unfashionable Hull bears this out. Getting thrashed by relegated Wigan at home last year, basically ending our season, would justify all these negative views. But if we dominate possession and beat teams in the top 8 like Saturday, then I'm at a loss to find anything to moan about.

Damn this Martinez... come back Shrewsbury et al.

Paul Gladwell
206 Posted 22/10/2013 at 06:48:54
Gavin, if we get anymore physical in midfield than. Saturday we will be in trouble, Barry and McCarthy where certainly physical and Barkley is no coward either, you can throw in Pienaar too, who certainly likes to challenge, I would say we have become more physical in midfield with what we have brought in and replaced as Fellaini was just a sly arse with his bookings, he never put in the challenges Barry and McCarthy do.
Phil Walling
207 Posted 22/10/2013 at 09:47:46
'Progress'- or lack of it - seems to be being judged on the ability of our centre-backs 'to play it out of defence at all costs and the demands on our star full-backs to pass, pass, pass it rather than run at people which was their strength.

The result of these demands is that the soundest centre backs in the Prem now look edgy and uncertain and our full-backs look far better whilst playing in Internationals than they do in club colours.

My guess is that pretty soon at least two of the four will be plying their trade elsewhere!

Paul Gladwell
208 Posted 22/10/2013 at 10:06:08
Phil, as I have said on other threads, soundest centre backs who went 18 games conceding last season on the trot and took until the last five games of the season to record three clean sheets on the trot, something we have already done this year, mate. Rather than blame our new passing game maybe look at the evidence from last year too, mate: we were not sound at the back like people claim.
Chris Ashton
209 Posted 22/10/2013 at 10:21:18
Jagielka Is not as good a defender as he is made out to be. Before the pitchforks come out, I am happy he is our captain and I do rate him highly. However what he is good at is being the last man back, rather than marshaling the defence. This is probably because he was a utility player before coming to us but it means that Distin has to be on top of his game. Idon't expect Jags to stop danger happening before it does, I expect him to be making the tackle to stop the final shot coming in.

Personally I think Distin is starting to show his age and is becoming a liability now ever so slightly more. I'm not saying he is bad, but we need to get his replacement in ASAP if it is not Stones. He is 35 years old, of course he will make mistakes now, it is when the mistakes start joining up together we will see him dropped and unfortunately retired.

It seems to be a theme here, players do not retire until they are dropped!

Mike Gwyer
210 Posted 22/10/2013 at 11:19:39
Darren Hind.

“Did you not hear the crowd booing them?”.
When? Where I stood there was constant jesting to the ref, who was continually allowing Hull to get away with both late and ugly tackles throughout the whole game. At no time did I hear any booing towards our CB’s.

A lot of posters pulling up Barry! Why? Thank fuck both him and McCarthy were putting it about because Hull came to Goodison with one idea and it wasn’t football. Barry let Aluko have it because that boy was dishing it out to any blue he could get hold of and on another day Jags would have been carried off (but yeah, let’s not mention that tackle). Days gone by, no team came to Goodison aiming to kick us off the park. Never!!!

Paul Ferry.

Maybe you are right. But over the years I have seen players come back from high pressured World Cup games looking totally fucked. I do feel that Jags and Baines would have felt the stress of qualifying for the World Cup, I mean the papers were full of that shite for days (even before the games) so I can see the mental stress affecting players (nothing to do with being match fit).

Additionally, Jags has always hoofed the ball. It’s no state secret and I’d bet that Jags has built his CV around that fact that he is king hoofer. Now, Wenger thought so highly of king hoofer that he bid £12M and the current England manager loves king hoofer so much he is almost a cert CB for the next World Cup. Now I’m only guessing here but I’m 99% sure RM knew this about Jags.

Furthermore, we have one of the best ball playing CBs, Heitinga, sitting around collecting his £60k a week – now I’m also guessing, but I’m sure RM knows this as well. But you guessed it, Jags still plays, he’s played in all 8 games and I have no doubt he will continue to play even with Alcaraz, bench warmer Heitinga, or even Stones being 100% match fit. As for Distin, the man is a fucking legend. He plays, end of.

Jim Knightley
211 Posted 22/10/2013 at 11:42:46
Paul: Last season we conceded 40 goals, the fourth best in the division. The season before we also let in 40, which was the joint third best in the division.

Trying to argue we didn't have a good defence is just bizzare...I don't know why there are so many spats on here about subjects with easily identifiable statistics.

This season we are letting in more goals, despite playing two pure defensive midfielders who are both defensive improvements on last season's options.

Martinez will not set his team up defensively as well as Moyes. That's one of his negatives. But it is in attack where we will hopefully improve. My one concern is that our defence is the best part of our team. I believe that the back four are top four material. It seems strange to me therefore if we negate our defensive ability with an overly attacking style which leaves certain people exposed.

But, we are doing great in the league at the moment, and I don't think we can judge Martinez in any capacity until the season is done (Well, save for the League cup resting of players anyway). This season was always going to be a year of transition, and our points total in view of that is absolutely fantastic.

Paul Gladwell
212 Posted 22/10/2013 at 12:14:23
Jim you are right, but there was a long stretch after a good start last year where we could not keep a clean sheet and winning only once in nine games which had everyone asking the same questions as now, maybe people need to give it more time before starting to claim we are going to be shipping goals none stop throughout the season.
Tony J Williams
213 Posted 22/10/2013 at 12:30:11
Distin/Jags look shaky but we are not shipping any more goals than we did last season.

My biggest worry is that the new formation has nullified the Coleman/Baines threat. They are almost playing like wingers now...... and not getting the ball much. Coleman had one run at goal on Saturday, and that's not like him.

I'm not arsed too much because we are still picking up the points, but we need to be able to change formation for different games.

There just seems to be too big a gap between Jags and Distin in this set up

Ian Riley
214 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:41:52
This was one of those games that we should win, but in he back of our minds we are nervous as fans. Hull out of all the promoted three, I said at the start of the season could stay up. Why? Steve bruce, been there and done it. He sets his teams up to be difficult to break down and this was no different. It was a nothing to lose game for hull and we had to step up. Players on the bench will make the difference for the first time. If your not performing, our bench has quality to change games and this was shown.

This was the first game back following the international break and from the stats we don't do well. Lets take the win and move on. Why moan at certain players when you win. We have villa on Saturday which will suit our formation and play.

Best wishes all


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb