Ferguson urged Moyes not to renew Everton contract

, 22 October, 461comments  |  Jump to most recent
Sir Alex Ferguson has revealed his hand in David Moyes's stalling over a new contract at Everton earlier this year, saying that he advised him not to extend his 11-year tenure at Goodison Park.

The former Manchester United manager has been ruffling feathers today with the publication of his autobiography in which he spills the beans on everything from his views of David Beckham's penchant for celebrity, the transfer policies of a succession of Liverpool managers, and the time he alleges a tearful Bill Kenwright allowed his mother to rip into him over the phone over the transfer of Wayne Rooney to Old Trafford in 2004.

His admission over his role in drawing Moyes away from Everton will come as no surprise to Evertonians, however. Moyes had been putting off talk of a new deal at Goodison for months and Ferguson confirms that, starting in February, he urged his fellow Scot on a few occasions not to sign a new contract. “[Moyes] phoned me around February for some advice about his contract, they were pushing him to sign a new contract," Sir Alex says. "I said to him, 'do not sign a new contract'.

“I knew in myself I was going to retire, so I'm thinking If he signed a contract it would be more difficult for us.

“I said to him you've had ten years there that's long enough, you'll get a bigger club.

“I kept phoning David to make sure he wasn't going to sign a new contract.

“We had to wait till the League was decided. Once the League was decided I got David over to the house and I think he thought we were going to talk about his contract again, but I said, 'look, I'm retiring, I want you to take over'. He was flabbergasted.”

Moyes left Everton in May, six weeks before his contract expired, leaving the club with nothing in terms of compensation, an issue that still rankles with some Blues fans.

 

Reader Comments (461)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Andrews
1 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:31:00
What??
The most Honourable Mr Moyes, working behind the back of Everton FC...

Board and fans treated like shite by Mr Everton — the man of the people?

Never!!!

Noel Early
2 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:30:11
Only confirms what I already knew long ago: Davie boy Blue was angling for a move to Man Utd and didn't care whose arse he kissed along the way. I will gladly boo him for 90 solid minutes every time he sets foot into Goodison Park. No defense can be made for him now by the usual apologists on here.
Ian Tunstead
3 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:30:05
This is yet another lesson as to why people should be so quick to jump to conclusions and that we should always consider that we don't know all of the facts about what are going on behind the scenes.

If you've got any sense you listen to any advice that Alex Ferguson offers you. Moyes did what any sensible person would who wasn't a born and raised Evertonian.
David Marsden
4 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:37:04
Fergie: vile man!!
Colin Glassar
5 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:39:03
So OFM received 'advice' from Lord Valdermort regarding his future betrayal of his employers whilst earning a fortune on our payroll? Surely we can get some damages off the Mancs?
James Lowrie
6 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:37:48
We all knew the rat had been tapped up but, now Old Red Nose has confirmed it, action must be taken. Moyes has stolen our right to compensation. The dog has taken us as fools, lost all his integrity... no class whatsoever. Stolen from the club who made him; he was nothing.
Lee Irvine
7 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:42:30
No shocks here then... and Moyes can continue to claim he didn't know what Fergie was truly referring to until May time. Even though we can all read between the lines...
Ross Edwards
8 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:43:55
We knew that Ferguson was in league with Moyes since 1998. He wanted him to be his assistant before he joined Preston, so we knew eventually that he would try and get him to manage the Mancs.
Niven Teh
9 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:48:43
Moyes is a puppet played by puppet master SAF!
Paul Gladwell
10 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:47:35
Why was he ringing Fergie for advice about signing an Everton contract, how old is he 18?

Oh, I forgot, the coward also expected to get invited to his house whenever Fergie was after one of our players.
Wayne Smyth
11 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:47:33
David, I think you'll find Fergie did us all a favour.

Given what has transpired since June, Fergie is now my 2nd favourite manager after RM.

Andy Meighan
12 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:34:05
Don't believe a word of it. Ferguson had obviously decided before the start of last season to call it a day and had already earmarked the artist formerly known as our previous manager to be the one to succeed him. There's no way Moyes wouldn't have signed that contract otherwise. It was all done underhandedly and engineered for us not to receive a penny in compensation. Cynical words maybe but I'm guessing that was probably the gist of it.

I will say this though: I'll bet old blotchy face is kicking himself now seeing the start his beloved boys have made. I seen him on SSN before bemoaning the start Moyes got fixture-wise and saying that he'd have been fuming if he'd have been in charge. Now, correct me if I'm wrong – don't each side have to play each other twice? Does it matter when you play them?

My guess is Ferguson will be back in possibly temporary charge there shortly because the natives are already getting restless and, as I've stated on here on many an occasion, them lads aren't certainly as patient or as tolerable as us. Don't say we didn't warn you, Ginge!

Craig Mills
13 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:52:07
I hope Bill Kenright reads Fergies' admission, he will maybe see Moyes in a different light. Now I hope he gets everything he deserves, ie sweet FA.
Morne van der Merwe
14 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:53:37
Thank fuck Fergie did that. Who knows where we would be if the soon-to-be-unemployed one was still in charge here...
Kevin Rowlands
15 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:50:10
And to think we gave him the send off that we did! The two-faced twat knew for several months he was going, just kept stringing us along. He'll never be warmly welcomed back to Goodison from me and maybe I'm being childish but I don't care. I have taken extreme pleasure in watching Man Utd struggle so far this season and watching him squirm on the touchline, long may it continue.
Ross Edwards
16 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:56:52
It also shows how much of a liar Moyes is. He swears that he only knew when he was summoned to a meeting at Fergie's house in May.
Ross Edwards
17 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:00:28
I also seem to remember the "I'd like to manage in the Bundesliga", and the "I'll renew if we qualify for top 4, I'll renew in May", when all along he knew that he was an United's de facto manager from February onwards.
Dominic Pitt
18 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:59:46
Moyes is dead to most of us now I hope. Move on and light a fire under his backside when we play them.
Shane Corcoran
19 Posted 22/10/2013 at 18:59:37
Ross, I've lost a lot of respect for Moyes but in fairness, reading between the lines aside, this version of events backs up that he didn't know about the United job til May.

You could argue that he suspected it or whatever but Ferguson told him he'd get a bigger club but didn't mention his retiring until May.

Ross Edwards
20 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:04:59
It does seem a bit suspect Shane if I'm honest.

Fergie would not have contemplated retirement way back in February if a replacement wasn't lined up, so that's when I think Moyes was told not to sign as he was going to be lined up to replace him.

Surely Moyes was one of the first people Fergie informed when he said he was contemplating retiring.

Robert Elliott
21 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:00:16
Nothing too surprising in all this I wouldn't think. Ferguson considered Utd's interests above all else so shafting Everton for a bit of compensation wouldn't have bothered him in the slightest. Moyes was clearly running his contract down to attract other parties and I suspect if Utd hadn't come calling he would've sat around waiting for another club or gone abroad. He was never staying at Everton whatever happened.

Clearly Moyes wasn't being entirely honest when asked about the situation, and his eyes were probably fixed on Old Trafford a long time before the news became public. Did it affect his focus on the job he had and hurt our season? I guess we'll never know.

I can't say this particular revelation alters my views on Moyes too much to be honest. The day Rooney left was the day I finally realised that loyalty in football exists in supporters only. I didn't blame Moyes for going to Utd, nor did I wish him well. The moment he announced he was Utd bound he became totally unimportant as far as I was concerned. I did find the warm reception given to a man who had clearly stated his preference for another club (and a local rival to boot) a tad strange, but each to their own.

Hopefully what this will do is remove some more of the stars in Kenwright's eyes where Moyes is concerned with the added result that he does not even entertain for a second selling either Baines or Barkley to him in the future. I wouldn't hold my breath however!

Mike Green
22 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:04:11
Paul #922 - your first paragraph is spot on. What's that all about?

If it's true it's pathetic, plus pretty disrespectful to Everton asking the manager of one of our competitors what he should do with his contract - when he's still getting tens of thousands of pounds a week from us?

It stinks.

Patrick Carty
23 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:04:06
Who cares? Moyes is gone now. Sir Alex is gone after doing us a great favour — we have a new manager with new ideas who plays a better brand of football. I think all our fans are happy how it has panned out.

Moyes had his time with us and in fairness I think he did a good job, but I would prefer Martinez and the way he sets the team out to play. Our future looks bright; I do not give a shit about United's.

Wayne Smyth
24 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:17:14
Dominic, Moyes is not dead to me. He's still dieing on his arse, and I'm loving every fucking minute.
Kevin Rowlands
25 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:16:25
Shane #934, if you believe that, mate, I've got a bridge to sell you in San Francisco.
Kevin grimes
26 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:19:34
Surely compensation due now. First class tapping up.
Ross Edwards
27 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:19:53
It is enjoyable to see the abuse he's getting from the Mancs already, after 8 games. They've sussed him. Now they know what we suffered for a decade.
Shane Corcoran
28 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:25:45
Kevin, #934, what exactly do you believe?
Kevin Rowlands
29 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:22:32
Ross, Alex Ferguson may like the twat, but my brother lives in Manchester and has a lot of Utd supporting mates, he tells me to a man they can't stand him and think the club have made a huge mistake.

Fellaini isn't highly regarded either... I believe he's commonly referred to as fucking spider legs. Baines needs to think twice about moving there.

Kevin Rowlands
30 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:27:23
Shane, I believe he's a bare faced liar, do you honestly for one second think Ferguson was advising him not to sign a new without actually giving him at least a hint of why he was doing that, c'mon.
Ross Edwards
31 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:32:30
I side with Kevin on this Shane. Moyes must have been told to shelve the contract talks because he was getting SAF's job in May.
Ross Edwards
32 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:34:11
It will be funny Kevin if Manure fail to make the Champions League. That was the only reason why the hairy galoot and ginger left in the first place.
Mike Price
33 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:37:48
Every day feels like Christmas when I wake up and realize he's gone and we've got Martinez. Thank you SAF!

I do wonder why it's only taken 8 games for most United fans to suss out Moyes and Fellaini when half of ours were still blinded to the obvious after a decade?

I've only just heard of Redcafe, a Utd blog, and reading the Moyes and Fellaini threads gave me enormous, schadenfreude filled pleasure!

John Keating
34 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:39:52
Shane, let's not be stupid or naïve. Moyes knew from his first conversation with Ferguson he was lined up for the Man Utd job. All the shite about the Bundesliga etc was just smoke and mirrors.

I, amongst many, said that on the day the announcement was made, that he was going to Utd, and he should have been sacked on the spot. The thought that we were paying the lying scumbag bastard for another couple of months was a disgrace to all Blues.

All the shit Moyes spouted during his tenure was just that — shit!!

An honourable man, a gentleman — a two-faced bastard from Day One!!

Ian Tunstead
35 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:39:43
I don't understand the anger. Moyes honoured his contract. He didn't owe us anything, just as we didn't owe him anything. He gave his best for 10 years and relatively we were very successful when considering where we were when he took over to when he left.

It seems most of you on here wanted rid and urged him to leave. He does what they wanted and they are still complaining. Unbelievable. Just let it go.

Kevin Tully
36 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:38:39
Don't believe that's the whole story either - those two Glaswegian minges have been conspiring with each other for years.

About time all ties were cut with that club, let's hope we get new owners who are big enough to tell them where to shove it.

Utd fans are already talking about taking McCarthy in a couple of years.

Sickening for the more gullible amongst our fanbase I suppose.

Ross Edwards
37 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:45:38
I think also the farewell we gave him against West Ham inflated his ego further. He thought he was infallible and could get away with anything whilst he was our manager.

Many Blues sussed him out towards the end of his tenure.

The Mancs have sussed him out after 8 games.

Ross Edwards
38 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:47:49
Kevin, don't be surprised if they get even higher and mighty by thinking they can steam in for Barkley as well.
Dave Weston
39 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:49:42
Surely this amounts to tapping up unless BK and went along with it.
Kevin Tully
40 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:47:40
Ian - 'relatively we were very successful'

Dear God!

If we were a Swansea maybe.

Ross Edwards
41 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:51:46
It depends how you define success for Everton.

If it is 6th or 7th every year with a biennial quarter final rollover, then brilliant — no-one better.

But we want silverware, and he didn't deliver in that aspect.

Peter Thistle
42 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:48:23
Cheeky bastard that Ferguson, but glad he took the dour ginger prick off us. Now we can actually move forward with a new manager who is positive and not a whiny arsehole who loses every game before a ball has even been kicked.
Kevin Rowlands
45 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:49:57
Ian, you don't understand the anger? This man strung us along for close to a year(or more) with his will he or won't he sign a new contract whilst it now seems he knew all along he was fucking off. We then all gave him a fantastic send off at Goodison and wished him well.

What transpired after that was where the real anger stems from, remember? trying to steal our best players for peanuts, belittling our manager, talking shite about our club, informing us that we were holding back Baines/Fellaini's careers by making them stay and other snide shit that went on, and now we have this just to rub salt in the wounds, he can fuck right off as far as I'm concerned.

Ian Tunstead
46 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:54:19
Kevin we were on the verge of relegation when he first arrived with an ageing squad and no money. Since he took over we have consistently challenged for European football and competed with the money teams finishing above many teams that have out spent us. If that is not relative success I don't know what is.
Barry Rathbone
47 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:49:23
The woeful thing is fans are complicit in all this excusing every rotten display, woeful cup exit and derby debacle is it any wonder Moyes treated this club like shite? Absolutely untouchable he was.

The inane claims he was holding the board to account squeezing transfer money out must have had him laughing like a drain chatting to Fergie.

Every week, nearly every day, the myth gets eviscerated - truly appalling man and manager.

Ross Edwards
48 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:01:40
Kevin, I completely agree with you.

It just shows how gullible we were that we stood by and let him do this.

He should have been put on gardening leave until the end of the season when he was announced as Manure's manager.

Ross Edwards
49 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:04:27
The Mancs and some in the media have seen through his infallible myth haven't they Barry? It's taken Man U fans 3 months. We still have fans going on about his "successes and achievements."
Kevin Rowlands
50 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:01:09
Ian, like I've said, after the Goodison send off I would say most of us wished him well and certainly thanked him, its what happened since then has everyone pissed off at the twat, and now we find out he was lying to us all for a long time, I have no time for the man.
Richard Dodd
51 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:41:38
Over Wigan way you could find a hundred Pie Eaters who will tell you that both Whelan and Kenwright knew all about this scenario way back last Christmas.

I used to laugh at the conspiracy theorists until one of the Latics' big sponsors started looking to place big bets on the Moyes and Martinez job moves.

Of course it was all coincidence and Sir Alex was just dispensing friendly careers advice to my former hero....... Of course!

Ian Tunstead
52 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:59:57
Kevin 976. Like I have said in another thread, we don't always know what goes on behind the scenes. He never strung us along, he just hadn't made up his mind, it was a huge decision to make which would have seen him tied down for perhaps another 5 years. Its not a decision you make lightly.

As for trying to steal our best players for peanuts, I don't go along with that because what transpired was that we got better money for Fellaini than I think most people would have expected. Moyes and Kenwright are very close and will have discussed what they believed the true value of Fellaini to be. Moyes knew he wasn't going to get Felaini for the first offer made but he has to try and get on good terms with the Man Utd fans and get the Glazzers on side too. I don't think it was any coincidence that we got the extra few million because of the issue with Felainis contract. Moyes, Fellaini and Kenwright would have all known the situation but Moyes has done us a favour in my view.

Spragg Johnson
53 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:09:26
Did Ol' Red Nose forget to mention the future dangers at this little get together? He could at least told Moyes ... "Keep your daughter away ... this new kid I've signed from Palace is a massive shagger!!"
Ross Edwards
54 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:12:26
They only paid £27 million for Fellaini Ian because they were desperate to sign someone on deadline day. That was the epitome of panic buying.
Barry Rathbone
55 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:07:48
Ross, the problem is some just won't have it, the faith they put in to the Moyes myth has sent them over the edge.

Hardly bring themselves to give Martinez a fair go because he is the complete opposite to the morose incompetent.

Got one on here now excusing the tapping up and subsequent loss of compo for the club, compo we paid Wigan because we acted above board.

Peculiar to say the least.

Callum McNab
56 Posted 22/10/2013 at 19:52:39
The bit were fergie said, one day you will get a big club you deserve . Cheeky get. Also I think that shit house Kenwright knew . As fergie said that Moyes told him the board were trying to put pressure on him to sign. When he came back and told Kenwright I'm not signing, he should of told Moyes to fuck off then.

Fergie basically told him, if United had to pay anything for him, they wouldn't offer him the job. Could you imagine if a player did that to Moyes. The only good thing that may of come out of this is Kenwright might tell them to do one over Baines.

Kevin Rowlands
57 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:07:56
Oh and one more thing Ian, this is the same twat that told us year after year how brilliant a chairman Kenwright was and always stood up for him, when we all knew different, the fact that Moyes, Neville and Cahill were all given that send off still makes my blood boil, all three were complicit in helping cover up Kenwrights failings, and not one of them close to being an Everton 'legend'.
Lenny Kingman
58 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:10:31
He'll soon be back at the level he belongs. League 1 Preston Nob End.

One can never say about the Moyesiah that he was born without business acumen. £35 million in his Santa sack for a job he could never master and he knew it. Frauduently obtained.

Sir Alex will not be amused being taken by his fellow Glaswegian. Though of course from different sides of the Clyde.

Good Christmas coming for the Moyes retinue in his Ribblesdale mansion I would venture.

John Keating
59 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:10:20
Ian,

Forget contracts. Listen to the so-called honourable man and the shite that came out of his mouth. He said at the start of last season that he would not make a decision until the END of the season. Er no he didn't! The deal was done early doors. He lied to us. Please don't try and excuse him – he lied to us. This 'honourable' man.

Even up to the day the announcement was made by Man Utd, he was still saying to us all "Don't worry... all will be sorted at the end of the season." Do not try and rewrite history.

This shit bag that slagged Lescott, Radsinsky et al was no better – in fact a fucking sight worse!! Kenwright was so besotted with Moyes he actually paid him until his last day, regardless of the fact that, whilst the season was still playing out, Moyes was meeting his future players!!!

As time goes on, more will be revealed. Please do not try and make excuses for Moyes – the man was proven to be what most paid staff are – mercenaries.

Ross Edwards
60 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:16:41
What about the knife to a gunfight?

Or his new one before his first Anfield meeting with Man U about now having the tools to attack at Anfield?

Or the "When I played at Old Trafford I just wanted to get out there alive"?

Kevin Tully
61 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:09:41
Ian - We had a very small, but highly paid crop of players under Ginge. There were occasions when he had no money for transfers, but he also had plenty when we sold Rooney & Lescott.

How long are we going to make excuses because we flirted with relegation in the 90's? 2 or 3 years after that we had a stable side.

I bet no-one makes it an excuse for Martinez, so why was it always rolled out to protect him after 11 years??

Martinez has a negative net spend - I won't jumping to his defence if he doesn't deliver, and I certainly won't be mentioning what went on 15 years ago.


Anthony Flack
62 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:22:32
Long may he slowly suffer and rot. I know of no one who thinks we are worse off without the miserable egotistical arse.

Ste Traverse
63 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:14:41
He strung us along a lot of last season knowing he was leaving. His totally not arsed attitude at the calamity against Wigan in the FA Cup when we were all devastated at the result (further evidence he knew he was off).

Trying to act the big man by attempting to push our club around and publicly belittling us when trying to acquire Baines and Fellaini in the summer. It's no wonder there is anger directed at the sneaky twat.

Oh how I'm loving seeing him struggle down the East Lancs and watching him squirm in front of the MotD and Sky cameras after every poor result.

I have a nose at Redcafe from time to time and many Mancs have sussed out this overrated blagger already.

Paul Doyle
64 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:15:15
So, poor old Davey, worried about signing a new contract. One probably in excess of the £70k a week he kidded us out of rings Taggert for some friendly neighbourhood Spiderman advice... yawn!!!

Isn't his wee brother Jimmy his fuckin agent?
What a load of bollocks!! Yes, poor Davey turning up in his new Flemings, shitting it whether whiskey nose wants Baines or Fellani or god forbid Osman!!! This yarn couldn't be made up yet these two pricks expect us to swallow this crap.

Hopefully Yoda will slowly turn Man Utd into the club they were before Ferguson landed in '86 — a team of overpaid mulleted cunts — and ends his season commentating in the World Cup, with a sunburnt kipper matching Ferguson's nose!

Ross Edwards
66 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:28:09
What about judging a game in the Cup against Sunderland to be more vital than an Anfield Derby, resulting in a 2nd string XI getting utterly humiliated by Gerrard?
Andy Crooks
67 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:16:27
Ian, no matter what I take into consideration I just cannot see how we were "very successful" under Moyes. Also, how can you not understand that anger? Moyes was, in my view, vastly overpaid for his work and "the best" that he gave wasn't good enough.

However, many of his critics, myself included, still respected his honesty and integrity. To contact a rival manger for advice on his contract and to refuse to sign it , then to replace that manager some months later, not only makes me doubt his integrity; it makes me incredulous that anyone can see him as other than a self-serving charlatan.

Nick Entwistle
68 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:33:34
If someone can fill me in it would be appreciated because I take the summer off from football news.

But I came back to all things footy in August and on here there was a lot of talk stating as fact Moyes knew of Utd's interest at Christmas. I would have missed a headline or two during the summer and thought it would have been part of that.

Yet from time to time football fans are subject to a smidgen of hyperbole.

What I know is that last season we were all thinking it could well be Moyes' last season. He wasn't signing a contract and were he to choose had every right to leave at the end of season. And there was absolutely no reason at all to sign a contract, as much as some would like, just to get Everton some compo from his future employers. That is just silly to think otherwise.

Moyes said he was looking at Everton signings for the following season when he got the call from Fergie in May... or rather the invite round to Chez Alex.

So from what people know to be true, as like I say I missed out in the summer, why the bitterness?

Ian Tunstead
69 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:19:42
Like I said Kevin, we don’t always know what goes on behind the scenes I don’t personally know Kenwright so I am not going to judge him, but the fact that everyone seems to talk highly of him not just the 3 you mention speaks volumes. There are far worse chairman we could have that’s for sure.

John, From what I can gather the decision wasn’t done early doors, and Alex Ferguson pretty much says so when he talks of constantly checking on whether Moyes had signed his contract or not. One thing people don’t seem to be considering is If Moyes had come out early on and said he was leaving at the end of the season what kind of effect do you think that would have had on the team? It would have been a silly thing to do in my view.

You can criticise Kenwright for being “besotted with Moyes” but its hypocrisy because the same applies to a lot of the fans on here who relish every opportunity to stick the knife into a man who gave 10 years of his life to turn this club around from relegation fodder to the team we see today.

Kevin Rowlands
70 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:31:25
Whilst were talking about whiskey noses book, I did come across this beaut on twitter, you really couldn't make it up...


Jim Hourigan
71 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:19:28
Whilst I realise many people can say they heard this or that, and you can only take it at face value, I can tell you that – having dealt with DM senior on football related matters – he stated to me in May that his son knew he was going to them in January. The deal was sorted and the hierarchy at Everton were also informed.

His dad, at the time, said he would not go to Man Utd and work scouting young talent and he has kept to his word, so I have no reason to doubt his comments.

Like many on here, he's gone, we move on. Fergie's comments are a smokescreen for poaching him and Moyes has lied to try and maintain some respect with us. There is no loyalty in football for people who see clubs as stepping stones and that is what Moyes believes. The man is out of his depth – as he showed in the last 3 years with us.

Ross Edwards
72 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:34:28
He only used us to suit his own career. I bet he doesn't give one jot about how we get on. I seem to remember his grovelling after West Ham "Everton will always be in my heart, etc, etc, lie, lie lie"

The way he has treated us has been nothing short of despicable, and it is astonishing how the old "successful, honourable, saved us from relegation" chestnuts are being recycled yet again.

The Mancs have seen through him. It's only taken 8 games.

The uproar after his Rooney off for Smalling on Saturday shows that they won't put up with small time, bottling, cowardly, inept, tactical weakness like we suffered.

Ross Edwards
73 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:39:03
Those statements Nick were just some of the reassurance lies he came out with before he left.
Nick Entwistle
74 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:41:20
What statements?
Andy Mack
75 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:24:34
I hope we pull the shutters down on our little happy relationship with Man U. You scratch my back, we'll sign Baines etc. Maybe the penny will drop with even Kenwright.

Sick of this backslapping, long may they remain outside the top 4 with our dour pal in charge.
Tony Cheek
76 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:35:09
SAF had been urging Moyes since February not to sign a new contract!

Christ, I've been urging him for at least 5 fucking years. Why didn't he listen to me?

Kevin Tully
77 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:42:47
I said at the time, anyone who believed Moyes when he said; "The first I knew about it was when he called me to his house, a couple of weeks before it was announced." was a fool.

No need for the lies, and the complete disregard he has shown for this club, who made him a multi-millionaire.

John Hughes
78 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:43:35
Ian Tunstead – do you really mean it when you say Moyes "gave up 10 years of his life" to manage this club? So tell us, what else would he have been doing during that time on an average of around £3m a year?

Gave up 10 years of his life – wouldn't we all given half a chance?

Brendan McLaughlin
79 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:47:10
Pretty much vindicates Moyes's version of events.
Ross Edwards
80 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:43:02
Nick, all the excuses for stalling on a contract, the "I'll wait until May and see where we are" "If we don't finish top 4, I'll leave", "I'd like to sign this player, that player", appointing Jags as captain after he was announced as United manager, "I'd like to manage in the Bundesliga one day, but I still have a job to complete at Everton", blah, blah, yadda, yadda.

His credibility, if he had any, was destroyed in my mind when he sneaked off for a meeting with Giggs and Fergie 3 days before our final match of the season against Chelsea.

Also, the embarrassment of giving him a royal farewell, the "Davie Moyes" cringe chants on that day as he paraded around the pitch with that smug grin on his face.

The fact he was paid for a month for no work at all was nothing short of disgraceful. We should have terminated his contract as soon as his appointment at Man U was announced. It would have spared us some embarrassment.

Ian Tunstead
81 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:35:06
Andy, I said "relatively very successful" — I don't know how else to say it without repeating myself. Taking a team that were consistently relegation strugglers to a team that is consistently European challengers. Is that not relative success?

Your opinion might be that he was vastly overpaid but my opinion was that he was consistently best of the rest so I would think that deserved best-of-the-rest money. But how much he is paid is not his fault or his problem; it's down to the Chairman.

Brent Stephens
82 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:42:19
Let's just look forward to being able to savour our RM beating the Scottish Manager when we meet them. Clearly our RM is superior, isn't he?
Barry Rathbone
83 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:47:04
Nick, fair play at least you admit you are ill informed.

I love the cheek of asking others to do the leg work because you had the summer off — I trust you won't be contributing till you've done your homework; good luck with that, lad.

Look forward to hearing from ya.

Nick Entwistle
84 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:50:32
Ross,

"I'll wait until May and see where we are".

That's what he did, no? There was no CL, no added investment. Took up the challenge of the biggest job in football. What is the problem.

His farewell was hardly 'royal'. I don't think there was a speech, but he was announced to the crowd along with club captain Neville (I think) and Cahill and took part in a lap of honour like the last game of every season.

Ross Edwards
85 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:50:30
Ian, if he cared so much about the club why has he treated us like trash since he left?

Why did he leave us in limbo for 4 months? He could have easily said in February, "Look, I'm not renewing my contract at the end of the season, I''ve had a wonderful time at Everton, they still have a place in my heart, but I want to move on"

That would have been fine, but to lie through his teeth for 4 months, sneak off for meetings with Giggs and SAF barely 3 days before our last game, and accept a month's pay for nothing shows me he didn't care one bit about the club, more about using us as a stepping stone to his next job.

He's not a loyal, honourable man at all like he is claimed to be, but a cowardly, lying, disloyal, egoistical mercenary.

Kevin Rowlands
86 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:49:14
Whilst you want to tell us about his successes Ian, I think its fair that we should also be allowed to point out some of his failures, right?

How about ZERO trophies in ELEVEN years, 0-44 in wins at Stamford Bridge, Old Trafford, Highbury/Emirates and Anfield, and a derby record that reads: 4 wins, 8 draws and 13 losses! Need we say anymore?

Nick Entwistle
87 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:55:29
Barry, I'm not searching the net for an article that may or may not exist. I did though look through all the news items on TW that I missed and found nothing there. But if you know where to find it...
John Keating
88 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:45:23
Ian,

You would have to be a fucking half-wit to miss that Fergie telling Moyes NOT to sign a new contract, and checking periodically to ensure he did not sign, and mentioning a "bigger" club in FEBRUARY is not telling Moyes he's next man in!!! Jesus wept — what does Fergie have to say!?!

You would have to be a fucking half-wit to "understand" the Everton manager asking the reported in every section of media soon to retire Man Utd manager their "opinion" and "advice" and getting the above vibes — to get that he's the next man in!!

But let's disregard all the above. Let's just concentrate on the man who, more or less according to you, saved Everton Football Club from oblivion and made us into the Club we are today – how long have you supported us?? This lying bastard told everyone that HE would announce his decision at the END of the season!!! Lies!

You seem to be trying to rewrite history. You seem to be trying to make excuses for this hypocritical bastard. Please don't make yourself look as daft as the man who saved us from oblivion has done.

Ross Edwards
89 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:56:22
It was, his farewell was pathetic, rolling out Neville and Cahill for no reason, why?

I'd say it was more rapturous than SAF's. You'd think that Moyes had won 39 trophies for our club the way he was sent off.

Kevin Tully
90 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:56:18
P.S. - Anyone who thinks Fergie is telling the whole story wants their head testing as well.
Robert Jones
91 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:53:50
Who cares? Moyes was here, did a decent enough job, went at the end of his contract. Everton have brought in a new man as a result who looks pretty decent. That's all I care about anyway.
Phil Bellis
92 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:55:10
I'd say there are some who are being relatively very gullible, consistently myopic, touchingly trusting and are, apparently, still very much in love...
Ross Edwards
93 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:00:20
Ian, I'd say Kendall in his 3rd spell saved us from oblivion. If we would have gone down in that season, that could have been the end of Everton Football Club, for sure. The squad in that season was terrible, yet he kept us up.
Andy Crooks
94 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:00:15
Ian, #025, sorry I missed that "relatively" in my eagerness to bash your post.
Neil Madden
95 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:05:28
Callum #997. First paragraph nails it. I have no strong opinion on Moyes one way or the other, he was our manager, now he ain't. Like most people in today's football he'll look after himself. But, let's not excuse Kenwright in this sorry mess. Is right he should have told Moyes to walk the walk when he refused to sign. And this nonsense about us losing out on compo! Do me a favour! It's Kenwright's job to bring new money in, not his manager's!

I'll have faith in the future of Everton FC again when the fans get angry with the people in the Directors' Box. I stopped going 3 years ago, and I won't be back until Kenwright has nothing to do with the running of our great club.

Sean Kelly
96 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:37:37
Ian,

He was here for eleven years, won fuck all and blamed all around him for not winning anything. That cunt won't get away with that at Manure.

He failed here and the thing we are pissed about is putting up with it for so long and giving that twat a great send-off.

RM deserves that support now as he has done more to improve the team and given us REAL supporters a lift in the four months he's been here than that useless cunt up in Mancland.

Nick Entwistle
97 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:13:23
Start of last season Moyes doesn't know if he's going to sign a contract. It would probably take CL spot or a lack of approach from another club to make him sign at the end of the season.

Come April, Everton are finally unable to claim a top 4 spot with three games remaining.

Two games to go and Ferguson retires with Moyes announced as replacement, in line with public company rules, an announcement that allows Fergie a deserved send off at his last OT appearance at game 37.

If someone can back up their well directed abuse with something substantial, then forgive me if I don't join in until then.

Ross Edwards
98 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:15:31
Nick, do you condone Moyes going for meetings with Ferguson and Giggs whilst he was still our manager, and accepting a month's pay doing nothing at all?
Michael Kenrick
99 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:17:07
Nick,

There's a post from Jim Hourigan at #014 that sheds some interesting light on this discussion.

He says (via Moyes's dad) that it was January, and that the club (Everton) was informed.

Carl Sanderson
100 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:15:24
A football manager leaves his Club after honouring his contract. Meanwhile, life goes on.

Incidentally, I believe that Kenwright should've said to Moyes in the summer of 2012, "Here's three more years, sign here or fuck off."

Nick Entwistle
101 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:18:45
What do you mean doing nothing at all? Did he not go into training or something?

And meetings with Fergie and Giggs.

Is that what all the name calling comes down to?

Kevin Rowlands
102 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:15:53
Nick did you read what SAF has publically stated in his new book? he was advising Ginge for several months NOT to sign a new contract, you don't need to be a rocket scientist to figure out why do you. I think that is substantial enough, we were lied to for several months by you hero, even you should be smart enough to realize that or are you on another wind up?
Mick Davies
103 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:58:50
Dirty, horrible, whisky-guzzling old twat. Calling Everton a small club; if it wasn't for the Heysel ban and Murdoch's millions, we would still be hammering them 5-0 every season. All the gratitude for him taking the 'dire one' has now dissipated.

I have been posting for at least 3 years for a change of manager, realising he was out of his depth. His luck in Rooney coming through and gambles like Cahill and Arteta paying off just papered over the cracks. He inherited some good strikers like Campbell, Radzinsky, Dunc and aforementioned Shrek, but managed to fall out with most of them. We ended up just taking Utd's cast-offs and playing some of the worst 'football' since Gordon Lees days.

Taking Steve Round on was the last straw, he knows as much about football as I do about quantum physics! And as for being a man of principle, why join a club where the hero is a player he once sued after he was libelled and leave a chairman who he describes as a decent and honest football man to be working for a venture capitalist shyster who wouldn't know a football from a market stall?

As for football nous, we only need to look at how John Ruddy is playing and the difference Arteta makes in his proper position as Arsenal's playmaker, not a left/right winger.

Ross Edwards
104 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:22:42
Nick, Moyes was being programmed for 6 months by Fergie to stall on his contract. Why would he do that? Simple, he told DM that he was retiring and that he was being lined up, hence the reason he told him to stall on a new deal.

He came out with the excuses about delaying and being interested in managing in Germany and signing some players, when he knew full well in February that he was leaving to succeed SAF.

Ross Edwards
105 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:25:42
Mick, he didn't say we were a small club. What he meant by bigger club, was obviously Manchester United.
Nick Entwistle
106 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:23:33
Michael, yes I read that but how many times do people come on with their cousin's dog said stories.

But hey, I'm open to that it may be so, but unjustified ranting at the man I won;t accept.

Kevin, you've cherry picked one quote and ignored the one where he says it wasn't until May that he approached Moyes to take over.

Yes, he could be covering his arse here, but given what he's said about Beckham, Kean, Lampard and Gerrard in his book would it be such a big deal to say Moyes was approached earlier in the year?

I may be wrong in this but isn't their like a 6 month period before a contract is up where by talks with other clubs are allowed, and not deemed tapping up?

Callum McNab
107 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:07:49
Neil, could not have put it better myself, spot on. I have watched my beloved club for a long long time now, followed them all around the world. But I always followed the belief that if any player did not want to play for the club, then let them go. But on our terms — not theirs.

Sadly due to this incompetent board, Moyes, has been allowed to not only embarrass my beloved club, but humiliate us as well. How many clubs would've continued to not only let the manager stay, but pay him as well for two months after stringing them along for months then signing for another club???

Wayne Smyth
108 Posted 22/10/2013 at 20:50:19
Ian/Nick, neither of you can see any wrong in anything Moyes does. You're both clearly Moyes fans first, Everton fans second as far as I can tell.

As has clearly been explained by many people, the bitterness most feel towards him is in his behaviour AFTER he left, rather than his dithering over his contract.

He was lucky to manage such a great football club as ours, have the backing of the fans and absolutely full support of the chairman who allowed him to operate for so many years with such stability and no pressure. Year after year wondering at Christmas if we'd be in a relegation fight, yet Kenwright stood firmly behind him all the way. Let's not mention his massive salary compared to his peers (ie, other managers who've won fuck all). We did him a favour? Only in your eyes.

He treated the club like dirt when he left with his derisory bids and undermining Martinez's position with his comments about knowing "how our club works" and telling Martinez he would've let Baines and Fellaini go for their own good if he was manager still.

The fact he paid a realistic fee for Fellaini had everything to do with his own club's ineptitude in the transfer market, Martinez and Kenwright's willingness to barter for top whack, and his own shit start to the season putting pressure on him to sign "someone".

If he could've fucked our club over paying less for Fellaini than he signed him for as a raw teenager 5 years ago, he'd happily have done it. For anyone to think his actions towards us after he left had any positive intent towards our club is frankly laughable.

Nick Entwistle
109 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:28:01
Ross, tell me why you believe that to be true? I know why you want it to be true, but labeling him everything you have done isn't going to convince me.
Ross Edwards
110 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:28:54
I think the permission of the club is required Nick, and we didn't give him permission until May, yet he was in league with Ferguson, who told him to intentionally refuse to sign a contract from February onwards as he would be succeeding him.
Mike Price
112 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:28:32
He strengthened his own bargaining position at Everton's expense but the clueless fool just did an 'Andy Carrol' paying nearly $30 million for a cart horse that just won't work. They've already lost about $20 million on the deal and he's probably unsellable anyway. Plus he has to play him having paid so much, which totally screws up their 'style' of play...it's a joy to watch for us and absolute torture for them.

It's totally benefitted Everton and it's killing the Mancs. Fellaini, like Moyes is incredibly overrated and I was always worried we'd get peanuts for him. I can't believe we got rid of both of them and despite Moyes' going for free I think we have come out of it light years ahead!

Barry Rathbone
113 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:44:11
It just descends into nonsense this show me the forensics garbage regarding Moyes antics - finger prints and tape recordings required - normal intuition abandoned, a futile exercise in semantics.

The idea Moyes did no wrong while we pay out compo to wigan and utd get away with it pre-empted by Ferguson briefing the Everton manager not to sign to avoid obstacles is ludicrous.

Ross Edwards
114 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:30:47
Wayne, not forgetting the "I still hold regular meetings with Bill Kenwright"

Nick

Sir Alex said in his book, and to the press after he retired, that around February, he was contemplating retirement, which,( you might say this is purely coincidental, but this I feel is my proof,) is around the same time that contract negotiations with Moyes began to stall.

I think, obviously, I don't know this, that in February, SAF contacts Moyes and says "Keep this a secret David, but I am thinking of retiring, and I would like you to be my successor, so leave any contract negotiations on hold until I announce it formally."

Moyes does this, makes his excuses that he will delay talks until May, then Ferguson formally announces his decision to retire, with Moyes announced as the new man.

Remember Nick, in 2001/02, Fergie publically announced that he was thinking of retiring, and eventually changed his mind, and that affected the performances of his team, he said that himself.

So, he wanted to keep it secret until the league was wrapped up, so he told Moyes in February the circumstances and to stall his contract until an announcement was made. .

Kevin Rowlands
115 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:40:27
Mick #550, regarding his football nous this is the same genius that had Phil fucking Neville as the 1st name on the team sheet every fucking game when the rest of all knew he was absolute shite, although he was good at waving his fists though.
Ross Edwards
116 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:47:41
Keeping Barkley out of the first team too Kevin.
Nick Entwistle
118 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:45:52
Let's say what you think is true Ross, tell me the best and most honourable way for Moyes to step down.

Two things to consider. 1, Moyes stepping down mid season as we're competing for CL and keeping his intentions secret before Ferguson announces his retirement later in the season would never work. That alone would have the press sniffing out the reasons. 2, Ferguson announces his pending retirement in February as he's fighting City for the title, and those two games we had Moyes 'in charge of us when he's Utd manager' is extended to double figures would be massively unsettling for either club.

My opinion is, if its not how its being spun that Moyes only knew in May, then playing it that way in the press was the best way to handle a very unique situation.

Paul Andrews
120 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:46:08
The worst part for me is the subservient nature of Moyes's behaviour. The absolute arse-licking he gives to Suuralex is sickening.

We all know he had an inferiority complex when it came to playing the bigger clubs, but this is a disgrace.

Ross Edwards
121 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:52:48
I'm sure that you agree Nick when I suggest that the contract saga disrupted our run in and led to us falling away by May. That would have been avoided if he would have announced in February that he wasn't renewing his contract and that he was leaving.

I think he would have got more respect from the likes of me.

Mick Davies
122 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:42:35
Ross, by saying Moyes should go to a BIG club obviously implies Everton are a small club. Being the 4th most successful club in England and holding numerous records; most years in top flight, Dixie's 60 etc makes me wonder what constitutes a small club. Is it anyone less successful than Man Utd? And are Celtic or Rangers bigger than us? Are Liverpool a small club?

Obviously this big/small club shit has no logic. Wealth is the new divider whereas in days gone by, other factors came into the equation, like West Ham who were massively popular for the football they played, the class players like Moore, Hurst, Peters etc and the devotion of their support, yet they were relatively unsuccessful compared to others like our own club. So don't be brainwashed by the idiotic, lazy and self-promoting czars of the new hierarchy; Skysports, The Sun and other college media-educated know-alls.

Michael Kenrick
123 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:36:49
I could be wrong but I don't believe Bosman-type rules apply to managers. So this six-month stuff and "tapping up" is simply nonsense. As professionals, I doubt if managers are constrained whilst under contract in regard to whom they may contact concerning future employment.

However, the lies the deceit and the compensation business are not nonsense.

Tony McNulty
124 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:41:57
We can discuss the minutiae until we are blue in the face (actually, a lot of us are blue in more than the face). But as more and more of this story unfolds, let me put it this way:

If MUM and Whisky Nose had started a Christmas Savings Club together last January, how many widows and orphans would now be expecting some cash back plus the promised interest this December?
Kevin Rowlands
125 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:53:28
Your just not getting it are you Nick, the main angst against the man is his actions and words toward and about our club AFTER he left, the same club that made him a millionaire many times over and enabled him to get his 'dream' job, all today confirms is that he's a bare faced liar and a classless twat, how you can defend him is ridiculous.
Ross Edwards
126 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:59:06
I totally agree Mick, we will always be a big club, and money, or the lack of it will never change that.

From a Moyes perspective, Man U is as big a job as he will ever get.

Nick Entwistle
127 Posted 22/10/2013 at 21:59:53
Kevin, we're talking of his last six months at the club. Want to talk about his Man Utd ramblings, start another thread. If that is the main angst, it shouldn't be altering the 'reality' of what went on in his last 6 months which is what we would all love to know.

Michael, the lies and deceit as you call it... okay look. Did Kenwright know? If so could he, should he have got compo? Did he use this time to get Martinez on board as people state above? Or would that be accusing Martinez of all the flack going Moyes's way.

I'd still pose the question I put to Ross: What would have been the best way out of this for all concerned.

Paul David
128 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:01:36
I find it amazing that anyone can still defend the man, even if there's only a couple. One of the reasons being used to defend him is that he honoured his contract, he didn't have to sign a new one and he did nothing wrong in walking away at the end of it.

Now maybe that is true but I think its fair to say that Moyes himself doesn't believe this is right. In his 11 years I can't think of a single player that Moyes wanted to keep that left on a free.

Ross Edwards
129 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:09:16
Nick, I just offered my suggestion. Announce that he is not renewing his contract, and that would avoid the whole issue of unsettling the squad, as he did.
Neill Taylor
130 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:07:16
I'm flabbergasted that Moyes never worked out that Ferguson's constant calling and asking him not to sign his new contract was a not big clue that that he was leaving. :-)

Joking aside, Moyes served Everton well and turned our fortunes around. So I for one will not be booing when he returns. More a dignified silence.

Andrew Clare
131 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:02:23
Well I’m delighted he has gone but very sad about the weak people in charge of our club. The whole way the Rooney/ Moyes affairs were dealt with was totally embarrassing.
Now at least we have good manager the next thing we need is a good owner.
Kevin Rowlands
132 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:07:53
The point is though the 'utd' ramblings as you put it most definitely come into this, because todays SAF's book admissions is confirmation to a lot of us that the Ginger prick is a lying, scheming, selfish twat who in the last six plus months chose to shit on the hands that fed him for eleven years. Btw the best way out would have been for Kenwright to show him the door as soon as he announced he was off, and for him to have shown a bit more class towards Everton the last 3 months, you do care more about Everton than Moyes, right?
Nick Entwistle
133 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:14:01
Ross, that just opens up more problems. If you think that the squad wouldn't be unsettled at that then... then I don't agree. The press would be all over it.

Where's Moyes going, who's going to replace him, do the player's stop playing for the man who's given up in February etc etc...

Also, if Kenwright is in on it, why does Everton have to shoulder all the crap that this announcement entails. He wouldn't stand for it when we were a point or two off 4th.

I'm not saying Moyes knew in Feb or even Christmas (Is David Moyes Snr prone to mouthing off?), but if he did, given the fall out of any information about Fergie retiring, the way in played out would have been the best way all round.

And if Moyes did know early on, when did St Roberto decide he was going to Everton? Of course, if he kept Wigan up he'd have never come!

Barry Rathbone
134 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:16:11
Nick he should have signed a contract at the end of the previous season.

It would have given us a lever in the compo game - he didn't - he screwed us over for his own benefit.

Let's give him a big hand.

Kunal Desai
135 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:21:10
It was his last, but best decision old whiskey nose ever made in his career in taking Moyes of us.
Ross Edwards
136 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:24:22
Nick, it would. All his dithering and faffing created uncertainty. You don't have to be Johan Cruyff to realise that.

If he would have sorted this by announcing he was leaving, all that uncertainty would have been avoided, rather than the "Is he going to be here next season?", "Will he, won't he?" that we had from Feb to May, which disrupted our run in.

If he would have announced his departure in February, I believe the players would have gone the extra mile to get Europe for him as they would have know that he was leaving anyway, but as it wasn't announced until the second to last game, the squad was unsettled and as a result, we missed out on European qualification.

Nick Entwistle
137 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:39:57
It would have been a choice between having a slightly unsettled squad, which we had, or unsettling them massively with that announcement. Don't see it going any other way.

I don't think we missed out on Europe because of the lack of signature. More that Spurs had a Bale and we had Anichebe and Jelavic.

You could also equally say that the squad would have gone, or try to go, the extra mile to keep him round last season with the lack of signature.

Kevin Tully
138 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:45:12
Nick, you have just put everything on this thread in perfect perspective for me.

Anichebe - he'd still be here if the ginger one had any bearing on his future.

Thank you Sralex!!!

Nick Entwistle
140 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:54:11
And yet by playing Anichebe, Clarke benches Anelka! Whaaaaaaaaaat?
Kevin Rowlands
141 Posted 22/10/2013 at 23:00:20
SAF " I said to him you've had ten years there that's long enough, you'll get a bigger club, I kept phoning to make sure he didn't sign" you have no problem with this shit going on whilst he's supposed to be managing Everton and looking after our interests then Nick? sure sounds to me like he was looking after his interests, whilst lying to us and being 'monitored' by Ferguson, the whole thing stinks.
Paul David
142 Posted 22/10/2013 at 23:04:51
The veteran Anelka who nearly retired a few weeks a go, I see Anichebe is still waiting for his first goal.
Ste Traverse
143 Posted 22/10/2013 at 23:12:05
Talking of Anichebe, it was good to see Big Vic put in a top performance to help the Baggies fuck Moyes and the Mancs over a few weeks ago.

Michael Kenrick
144 Posted 22/10/2013 at 22:11:15
I firmly believe Kenwright knew... likely back in January or earlier. That's one reason why we bought no players.

Kenwright was in a bind. He could not/would not sack Moyes then and there, even if he really should have done. He would have to pay out his contract for the last 6 months anyway, and there was no way Man Utd would have come in for Moyes and paid him compensation at that stage — SAF had still to secure his final trophy — so he probably thought there was no alternative but to keep Moyes on and allow Man Utd to call the shots (no surprise there).

And them Manc twats say thank you how? By fucking us over regarding our best players.

Phil Bellis
146 Posted 22/10/2013 at 23:51:10
Sorry Nick (Ian?)

The world isn't flat, whatever you believe

Visit the Argument Clinic if that helps you

I would never call a fellow Evertonian a deluded, unctuous, supercilious, one-eyed twat...but I am willing to make an exception

Robert Collins
147 Posted 23/10/2013 at 00:01:22
Paul Doyle @ 007

He and Ferguson are a pair of despicable cunts, there's no doubt about that now.

"Hopefully Yoda will slowly turn Man Utd into the club they were before Ferguson landed in '86 — a team of overpaid mulleted cunts — and ends his season commentating in the World Cup, with a sunburnt kipper matching Ferguson's nose!"

Well said fella, I like it!

I think though, that Ferguson has shot himself in the foot hiring that despicable cunt, he well and truly returned to type against Southampton (forward off defender on while drawing 1-1 at home, any of that sound familiar?).

He's already lost the team and Prem after 8 games and playing defensive football.

Davie Boy, the Preston awaits your return!!!

Nick Armitage
148 Posted 23/10/2013 at 00:03:10
Dear Sir Alex,

God bless you and Manchester United.


Paul Ferry
149 Posted 23/10/2013 at 00:30:23
Only Ian Turnstead would make his first response to a thread on events in 2013 into a tiny-minded rant about the last eleven years. Quite pathetic not least because of the joyous colours he paints in.

What is reassuring about this thread - and others - for me is what seems to me to be a more general sense of harmony and agreement on these boards since Ginger took his REO Speedwagon and Journey box-sets along the East Lancs. And I don't just think that it's all down to giving Bobby time. There is for me a positive feel around here which might well be - in fact certainly is - tempered as there is still much diversity on the arguments to be cheerful and degrees of cheerfulness but this is a different world to the sometimes vicious debates about you know who and the degree of polarization.

It's a joy for me in this more positive harmonious era to see on this thread a grand total of two myopic, belligerent, immovable, irretrievable dissenters - Entwhistle and Turnstead - who between them might have 20% of the posts on this longish thread who will never change their minds and who have dug their shiny winkle-picker heels in so deep a bomb could not dislodge them being made to look so foolish and cantankerous by the vast majority who get it.

Two little voices barking in the dark will not change in any way the good vibes nearly all of us now feel,

Nick Entwistle
150 Posted 23/10/2013 at 01:04:53
"There is for me a positive feel around here which might well be - in fact certainly is - tempered as there is still much diversity on the arguments to be cheerful and degrees of cheerfulness but this is a different world to the sometimes vicious debates about you know who and the degree of polarization."

You know who more than most Paul. Though debates is an interesting word you use. Don't see much of that with the plethora of adjectives you thrown in my and Ian's direction.

ps, it doesn't bother me that you always choose to spell my name wrong. I don't think it bothers Ian either.

pps, "...the vast majority who get it". That's a worrisome turn of phrase.

Drew Shortis
151 Posted 23/10/2013 at 01:13:14
I have no issue with the whole affair. Ferguson wanted Moyes to take over and I expect Moyes was aware of the possibility and didn't want to sign a new contract and jeopardise his chances. Man United is a massive club, like it or not. To sign a new deal knowing there was a good chance he would be off would have been disingenuous of him. Of course it sucks not to get any compensation, but he served out his contract (almost). He couldn't burn his bridges by coming out and saying "I won't sign a new deal because I think Man Utd will offer me a job" so he had to play dumb, but I think most people realised it was a distinct possibility he would be off.

Moyes did a great job for us in his time here but I think we needed a change and I'm much more positive about our future under Martinez so I'm more than happy to move on from this. I know many Evertonians would disagree with this, but if you were to look at it from the point of view of an outsider it all seems pretty logical.

Ian Tunstead
152 Posted 23/10/2013 at 01:06:00
Paul, here we go again getting personal, can we just stick to the football?

Lets get it straight, I like Roberto Martinez, he is a nice guy, and I hope he does well for his sake and for Evertons sake because first and foremost I am an Everton fan. But I also like David Moyes because I appreciate what he has done for Everton, and nothing can change that. Whether you like it or not, it is fact that Moyes took an ageing squad that was struggling at the bottom of the table and took us to the top end of the table. He has built a very good squad and put us in good stead for the future which Martinez is now reaping the rewards from. If you don't appreciate that and want to concentrate on how much he was paid for it and how he wanted to leave for a bigger club, even though you wanted rid of him in the first place, then that's up to you, but I don't share your view. You should be happy that he has done you a favour and left... but your hatred of Moyes is still eating you up.

I understand that you are angry because you are an Everton fan and you think he shit on us but you have got to accept that he isn't and has never been an Everton fan and he owes us nothing. He did what he felt was in the best interests of the club but also himself because, at the end of the day, it is just a job to him and it is his life, there is no point being somewhere that he doesn't want to be or feeling that he has taken us as far as he can. Get over it and move on with your life – just like Moyes has. Your obsession is becoming frightening.

Jimmy Sørheim
153 Posted 23/10/2013 at 00:53:35
I find that the mantra that it is important to keep a manager for 10 years or more is not as smart as Moyes wanted it to look. I agree that there was a conspiracy between the two close managers, but I am actually really happy to have gotten rid of Moyes.

The only problem left now is Kenwright. And God, is that a big problem. Kenwright is still friends with Moyes — Moyes said that they talk every week since he went... Is that not the biggest problem of all??? How can we trust Kenwright to do what is best for Everton when Moyes comes calling for Baines and Barkley?

It is high time to see what is going on right now, Moyes is gone but he is not history, at least not for Bill, and there is my problem..... Fuck Moyes and SAF: in January we are faced with losing Baines and Barkley because our chairman is too close to Moyes.

Where is the Blue Union on this issue? It is high time to get rid of Kenwright, and if not, then appoint a sports director to handle the transfer deals from now on. I vote for Neville Southall.

I too am bitter over how Moyes betrayed us by leaving without compensation, but I think we are in for a shock in January when Baines leaves for just £15 million and perhaps Barkley too for the same amount. All because we have a chairman who is best friends with a rival club's manager. Anyone else see this as a problem?

Kevin Rowlands
154 Posted 23/10/2013 at 01:28:12
Ian, nothing that Moyes did in the last six months was in the best interests of EFC, lets keep it real.
Anto Byrne
155 Posted 23/10/2013 at 02:23:07
Thanks, SAF — we now have a proper footballing manager with a smile on his face and a positive outlook. I think most will agree that it feels good to be an Evertonian.
Ian Tunstead
156 Posted 23/10/2013 at 02:19:44
Well, I disagree Kevin. We don't know all the facts so I don't like to assume anything but as everyone else has been I will give my view how he had Everton's interests at heart.

Perhaps he wanted to leave because he felt he had taken Everton as far as he could. Perhaps he didn't know for sure he was going to leave until that meeting with Alex Ferguson, or if he did, perhaps he didn't want to say anything in case the players dropped their performance levels and didn't want the distraction from the media wanting to know where he was going.

The truth is none of us really know, only Moyes, so I'm not going to sit here and criticise or sit by while people talk complete shite about things that they know nothing about when the man in question has done so much for the club. If you want to concentrate on the last 6 months that's fine but I want to remember how he has turned this club around over the last 10 years. Thank you, David Moyes.

Kevin Rowlands
157 Posted 23/10/2013 at 02:33:35
Ian, I don't know what part of "we all wished him well and thanked him" (Goodison send off) you don't understand; it's his actions and words since that have created this animosity and today's revelations have just rubbed salt in the wounds. Whilst you may keep referring to his many successes, I would point out he had many failures — see my post #030. None of this needed to happen; he himself has created this mess — now he is going to have to deal with it.
Nicholas Ryan
158 Posted 23/10/2013 at 02:39:16
Moyes did some good things; Moyes did some bad things. The past is Ginger, the future's rosy!
Paul Ferry
159 Posted 23/10/2013 at 03:03:54
The typcial Entwhistle response; no debate, polarization, asserting things in a dogged inflexible manner - Jesus Lord wept the irony is almost crushing ...

And another piece of breath-taking irony as I'm sure most will agree on the basis of Ian's participation in this thread and elsewhere; 'Get over it and move on with your life � just like Moyes has. Your obsession is becoming frightening'.

Ian unlike you and Entwhistle I have moved on and totally embraced Bobby's Everton with gusto. So 'obsession' is what a trite comment about Moyes and what I suspect is his appalling music taste and moving along the Eat lancs! Dear Lord Ian you're funny. My 'obsession'? Pot Kettle Black. I simply accept that Moyes has been a shitbag this year and the best thing that happened to us was him going.

Move on! Ha! I'm well moved on in your terms. Here's a tip, I think that there is rather more need to 'move on' and accept the 'new Everton' in your case rather than mine.

To be fair your response was more measured and rational and sound so perhaps it's unfair of me to lump you with Entwhistle - if so, I apologize. But honestly ian I will not be lectured to about 'moving on' by people who long for something that no longer exists.

And a last note for NE - just read the thread we are nearly all against you so by default by being against you - as has been your forte in Moyes and post-Moyes Everton we must be somehow stifling debate. Doesn't work like that NE, if I was so pithy and lame I could simply fire the shots back in your direction but I wont immovable one, I'll just let the burning irony burn bright.

John Haldane
160 Posted 23/10/2013 at 05:53:22
Football is a nasty business. SAF has shed just a little more light on it & OFM appears to have been not immune to its murkier side.

If there's shit on your carpet and the dog looks guilty, do you really need video evidence?

Meh. We'll see who got the better of it soon enough. At the moment, I'd say Evertonians are a damned sight happier than Utd fans.

Neil Pickering
162 Posted 23/10/2013 at 06:17:07
Why are we all arsed about this? Cant we just move on? Moyes was a great manager for us to a point, but that point expired about 4 seasons ago for me. Imagine if he had have signed a new deal? Would we be happy then? No we wouldnt, we would have wanted him out!

The only thing that has pissed me off about Moyes is how he has treated us over the baines/feli debacle; thats why I now want him to fail!

Even if we don't finish in the top 10 I am so much more happier with Martinez at the helm because I can see a plan forming. In 4 months he has already shown me that tactically, and as a man manager he is streets ahead of Moyes.

Utd have made the mistake appointing Moyes and it will set them back at least 2yrs, and I for one think its brilliant!

In Moyes I trust!

Mike Green
163 Posted 23/10/2013 at 06:44:53
I wanted Moyes out for the final two or three years of his tenure, so I shouldn't have any cause for complaint.

However, my frustration comes from us having a chairman who either couldn't see the writing was on the wall, couldn't face up to it, didn't prepare for it, or lied to us, a manager who transparently strung us along with his 'I want to see where we are in May' pitch and happily took hundreds of thousands of pounds from us whilst negotiating a move - even at the softest level - with one of our competitors, and continued to do so once he'd been announced as their manager, followed up by doing his level best in the past six months to unpick any good feeling he had amongst Evertonians by either trying to belittle the club or insult our intelligence.

Combine that with the flair and imagination that has been shown by his replacement, compared to the stale, depressingly predictable fare we've endured for years then yes, the way in which David Moyes has behaved in the last 12 months has left a pretty bitter taste in my mouth.

Could he have done it differently? Of course he could.

He could've come clean with BK, drawn up and agreed a contract which he would sign if no other offers came up, help draw up a succession plan and not taken another penny from the club the moment he was announced as Fergusons successor.

But then BK should've done this as soon as Moyes said he wanted to see how the season panned out, as it was then that to anyone with half a brain it was clear he wanted out.

Steve Foster
164 Posted 23/10/2013 at 07:44:26
I just do not care, this is how little I think of this man.

After a few months in charge, RM has shown how a manager should act.

This man does not exist anymore. I want us to turn over Man Utd, but the team, not the Manager or the backroom staff.

Read the story and move on, this man is dead to us all. If we could only wipe the history facts that stated he was once manager of our great club.

Brian Cleveland
165 Posted 23/10/2013 at 07:44:50
I never thought I would learn to hate someone more than I hate a red shite manager.... but do you know, by God, I think Moyes has acutally achieved that status... and in such a short space of time.... bloody amazing!

Come on Real Sociedad, tonk the bastards!

Sam Hoare
166 Posted 23/10/2013 at 07:24:28
Hmmm. Won't surprise the regulars to know I'm with Ian and Nick here. Despite what many say what actually went on is unclear and perhaps because of the regard I held him in I'm prepared to give Moyes the benefit of the doubt whereas those who hated him unsurprisingly are not.

Either way I'm glad he's gone and enjoying the new era before anyone makes the often repeated idiotic assumption that fans of Moyes must be detractors of Martinez.

James Stewart
167 Posted 23/10/2013 at 08:18:20
Hard to be bitter. He did us a favour. We are a better side without Moyes end of story
Tommy Coleman
169 Posted 23/10/2013 at 08:07:42
Ha ha. Nick Entwistle and Ian Tunstead, the Moyesie PR Gurus working in over drive mode again. Look how many responses they've made defending him! LOL

Where is Phil Walling ?

No one has any respect for your opinions anymore, give it up.

If I ever meet Fergie I'll be buying him a pint for tapping up the most overrated manager in the league.

Here's to you Fergie, Cheers! !

Mark Jones
170 Posted 23/10/2013 at 08:32:59
All's well that ends well.

Jason Lam
171 Posted 23/10/2013 at 08:47:41
They made the classic corporate mistake of allowing the departing employee pick his/her successor.
Ged Simpson
172 Posted 23/10/2013 at 08:31:14
Hell hath no fury like..............

Premier league football. Loyalty ? Openness ? Fair play ? You must be watching a different league to me if you are expecting that. So in the end what pisses people off it seems to me is Moyes put his ambition before the club and lied. Just like so so many others in our game. We all have our heads in the sand as fans and, in our hearts, know we are always being ripped off by the Premier League.

Like the scorned, it is the knowledge that they have your heart that hurts.

Brent Stephens
173 Posted 23/10/2013 at 08:54:20
Ged #157. Agreed.

Said it before, dissatisfaction depends in part on your expectations. Some highly dissatisfied people here because of deluded expectations about honesty in the game.

Can't even trust Evertonians at times - Rooney, anybody? So why put your trust in a non-Evertonian like the Scottish Manager? Asking for trouble and deluded.

Do people trust Roberto?

David Finney
175 Posted 23/10/2013 at 09:29:04
When Moyes left I considered myself neither fan nor detractor. He was a good manager for us not a great one. He took us from regular bottom half of the table to regular 5th to 8th place finishes. He bought wisely and well in the whole with some notable stinkers (show me a manager who has not bought a stinker). He was not a great manager because he couldn't get us up another level, he only managed 3 semi finals in 11 years which was poor considering our league position and his inability to beat the big teams away.

When he left I wasn't cheering but nor was I crying. I wondered whether his cautious approach was his nature or down to an inferiority complex he had against the big clubs. Well now we know its his nature because he has no reason to feel inferior with his current squad and yet still is defensive.

One thing I always thought was that he was an honourable man. This revelation makes it clear he lied to the fans for 6 months. Whilst I have some sympathy with the view we should expect nothing better from someone who is not a Blue, he presented himself as an honourable man and how Everton were in his heart when he left and this has completely undermined that.

When I have been treated well by my employer, I have always reciprocated that by being honest about my intentions and giving as much notice as possible of any intention to leave; this is the way decent people conduct themselves.

Those who say we don't know exactly what went on are being ridiculous. Short of spelling it out, Ferguson couldn't have been clearer. This new revelation is the end of any respect I had for the man, which has been slowly dwindling during the summer with his use of transfer tactics that he had spent 11 years condemning.

Jim Bennings
176 Posted 23/10/2013 at 09:45:57
This news comes as no surprise, those two were always as thick as thieves.

As far as I am concerned, it was best for all concerned that Moyes left when he did, both for himself and for Everton FC. Moyes had taken Everton as far as he could with his ideas becoming stale and Everton had taken Moyes as far as they could. We as a football club needed fresh ideas, a new horizon to look forward to, and a change in mentality.

Already I think we have seen that Martinez is a more positive manager in the way he sets about winning games and his substitutions come at the time we ask and are positive rather than negative.

Does anybody think Moyes would have brought a striker on for Lukaku when 2-1 up on Saturday? Would he have hauled off Osman after just 57 minutes? NO.

We thank Moyes for the years he gave us and some of the good times but last season was the perfect time for change at Everton really. Rather than drag out Moyes with the same defence-first, 'knives to gunfight' mentality and bemoaning money problems, and trying to squeeze one more year out of Phil Neville, playing Heitinga in midfield instead of Barkley, we know have moved our club into forward thinking times.

It may not always come off and there will be bad times but we should always remind ourselves there were some rotten times under David Moyes also. We need only look back at 2003-04, lowest ever points total, 2004-05 when we scored just TWO goals by the end of October and were crushed 5-1 by Bucharest, 7-0 by Arsenal and 4-0 by the might West Brom and Bolton in the same calender year... I could go on and on.

We had to move on when the time was right and maybe Sir Alex Ferguson did both Everton and Moyes the favour they both needed.

Tony Doran
177 Posted 23/10/2013 at 09:55:59
Knowing what Moyes new halfway through the season, wouldn't it have been in his interest to have certain players not sign new contracts! How many hints to certain players that, if he was ever to go to a new club, would they fancy a piggyback?
Sam Higgins
178 Posted 23/10/2013 at 09:58:39
One of the massive positives of these new revelations by Taggart is the unhindered overwheming joy I feel when reading Paul Ferry's responses to Ian Tunstead's and Nick Entwistle's posts. It's not the subject matter in particular, but the Russell Brand esq use of the English language that must be applauded and celebrated. It's given me no end of pleasure this morning sitting at my desk, and I've been chortling along quite merrily.

What really made me snort though was Ferry's continued insistence to mispell Entwistle's surname – and Entwistle picking up on this but pretending not to care. Lovely stuff lads and long may it continue – not only does it provide some fantastic mid-morning entertainment, it once again depicts the sheer passion of all the contributors on ToffeeWeb, their intellect, and the fact that all stops will be pulled out to reinforce and rationalise one's own opinion on any give Everton subject matter. It also displays some good old-fashioned British sense of humour.

As for my opinion? I appreciated what Moyes did for us 2002 - 2009. After that period, he should have been asked to leave – there was nothing left in the tank. And he has shat on us since his departure with regards to Baines & Fellaini. I'm just pleased BK was forced into the change of management that was required – because Everton are becoming a real pleasure to watch at the moment. Under Moyes, they were becoming a real pain to watch.

Steven Telford
179 Posted 23/10/2013 at 10:25:48
I have also re-assessed my imagine of Moyes, but that re-assessment came after he came after Baines and MF. I see pretty much nothing in this "(hardly) new information". He said he found out once the league was concluded; while I don't anymore have a high opinion of Moyes, it must be said that that is the story that he always told.

His friend told him to consider not signing a new contract... every body is entitled to give their friend advice. We may not like the advice, but I don't see the big deal in that.

As for people citing conspiracy throes going back into years – well, I think most people should see that that's a bit far fetched.

Phil Sammon
180 Posted 23/10/2013 at 10:31:34
Nick

You are right when you say that Moyes was put in a predicament by SAF giving him a heads up about the Man United job. He couldn't sign a new deal with Everton and I don't think he could have announced his intention to leave. The former would have been wholly disingenuous, the latter would have shattered morale.

Where I completely disagree with you is your dismissal of events since his Man United appointment. If he'd have come out, told Everton fans he was sorry how it ended but he couldn't turn down a 'dream job'. If he'd had offered to waive his last couple of paychecks as he rocked up to Carrington still on the Everton payroll. If he'd have not made derisory bids for our top players and then insulted the club and the new manager by suggesting that David Moyes was still the man who knew what was best for Everton.

I always respected Moyes and I was grateful for the way he stabilised the club. I never particularly liked the man as he seems quite cold and prickly, even to the in-house media. However I would have wished him well. With events gone-by I find myself cheering his every disappointment.

Gonna stick a tenner on Real Sociedad tonight.

Phil Sammon
181 Posted 23/10/2013 at 11:07:46
Sam Higgins

Can we please not compare Paul Ferry to Russell Brand.

One is an articulate comedian - the other is a greasy-haired smack addict who pores over a thesaurus before projecting himself on the assembled masses of fuckwits across this nation.

Steve Guy
182 Posted 23/10/2013 at 11:22:35
If Moyes had wanted to do the "right thing" by Everton, he could have signed a new contract, but instead he wanted to make sure a consequent payoff negotiation wasn't an obstacle to his leaving. However, he was clearly given the nod by Whisky Nose in (let's be generous) February and all his subsequent actions were governed by that knowledge.

He could have acted selflessly but instead acted selfishly with no consideration for the Club and (let's face it) the man (BK) who gave him his platform and stood by him long past his sell-by date. The sight of him and Phil Neville grinning like Cheshire cats at the end-of-season walk round the pitch should be sticking in the throat of everyone who applauded that day and those who were not there too.

We can only hope that "you reap what you sow" is true in his case.

Graham Mockford
183 Posted 23/10/2013 at 09:38:07
So here's the way I see it:

Fergie decides he is retiring at the end of the season. He tells his Board and recommends Moyes as his successor. Moyes is approached and the deal is shook on, I suspect Moyes told Kenwright he's not signing and he's off to United.

Neither club is going to announce anything with six months of the season to go as it puts both managers in a difficult position managing their respective teams. Moyes spends the next six months prevaricating (lying some will say) and, when there is nothing left to play for in the season, the deal is announced.

Nothing that doesn't happen in any field of employment and something I can't get too hot under the collar about. We needed the change anyway so all's well that ends well!

Steve Guy
184 Posted 23/10/2013 at 12:06:14
Graham Mockford.181....your version and that of SAF appear to differ somewhat. Whilst I am sure you are a man of integrity on this one I'm going with the Man Utd manager's line !
Gary Reeves
185 Posted 23/10/2013 at 11:50:13
I’ve never rated Moyes so I’m not gonna bat that one around now – I’ve long since wanted him away. What I wanted to add to this thread though, is this:

Our performance at Old Trafford last season was a joke. Clueless, sloppy, uninspiring and totally without ambition. It looked like we couldn’t wait to get back on the coach. I had my Dad round to watch on Sky but he went home early saying (and I always remember this) "This isn’t even a game." As you’ll know it ended 2-0 but it was never in doubt.

Now considering the season before we had fought to the death (4-4) and that we’d absolutely tonked them at Goodison in August (Fellaini’s header), this performance didn’t sit well with me. It just seemed out of kilter, amongst some decent performances last season. I’m not for a minute saying that we threw the performance, but it did look like our players were convinced they couldn’t get anything... Now, who would take responsibility for a mind-set like that?

And the date of this abject collapse? 10th February.

Tony J Williams
186 Posted 23/10/2013 at 12:11:30
Couldn't give a flying fuck what the boozed up Scotsman did or did not do in his "tapping up" of Moyes. He's gone; no compensation because Moyes saw out his contract. Once he left, he became another manager of team I want to see beaten all the time; nothing more, nothing less.

Let's put is this way, if you were working for Giffgaff and the head honcho from O2 tipped you the wink of a great job opportunity, but only if you didn't sign another contract with Giffgaff... what would you do? I would shut up, get on with my job and wait for the lucrative contract to be put in front of me from O2.

He wasn't an Evertonian and he wanted to manage at the top end of the league, manage in Europe etc. Why wouldn't he not sign?

The fact remains he is now the Manc boss and we can hate him with impunity. He has been a cock about Fellaini and Baines but ultimately he is just a man who used to manage us and now doesn't.

All the threads about a former manager is a little much, especially as they are usually the longest and filled with the most bile between posters.

Last point in this ramble, as stated: pro-Moyes (when at Everton) does not mean anti-Martinez.

Matt Traynor
187 Posted 23/10/2013 at 12:14:40
Bear in mind that everything in his book is his version of events, so I wouldn't take it as gospel as some would that this means Moyes may still only have known for sure in May. Seriously, the guy is sitting on a £4m a year deal in the safest job in football, and he's being asked to stall on signing an extension? Of course he knew.

For me, I imagine the book would be an interesting read, if only to show what a manipulator and controller Fegie is.

I asked a Man U supporting mate if he would thank Fergie for bringing in the Glazers to Man U. After he asked me if I was crackers, I pointed out Fergies role in the departure of Magnier and McManus from Man Utd over Rock of Gibraltar (the nag, not the one Spain gets upset about).

I'd love to know Fergie's innermost thoughts on that. Except he doesn't mention it in the book. At all.

Sean Kelly
188 Posted 23/10/2013 at 11:08:13
Nick & Ian

It's obvious from the the above comments that you are in a minority amongst us. While respecting your opinions on Moyes, he is no longer our leader and the majority of opinion on TW seems to think he should have gone at least two to three years ago.

He did enforce a style of play on us that wasn't pretty to watch and his plan was always to nick a goal and defend it. This was even against lesser teams.

SAF has done us – the football purists amongst us – a great favour by taking him off our hands and giving us the opportunity to get a "football" manager.

To all my fellow football purists, let's get behind RM; give him his time to enforce his style on our team and exorcise the mindset that Moyes enforced on them. Of course this will only be possible if Billy Bullshit keeps his promise of giving him the money.

Moyes is gone, is history and is now the enemy. His status within our club is now lower than shark shit.

Billy bullshit should not be feeding his ego with their cosy chats. Does he have cosy chats with any of our other Premier League enemies?

Peter Cummings
189 Posted 23/10/2013 at 12:56:11
Talk about Blair being a Yankee Poodle? Moyes has turned out to be nothing less to Ferguson. Everton FC should have nothing more to do with Man Utd, and that should include any transfers to them — starting with Bainesy, even if it means forcing him to see out his contract or upping the price for him to double what they might offer.
Tony Cunningham
190 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:21:06
Am I missing something? Moyes refused to sign a new contract as he hoped after 11 years he might get another job (one with (sadly) more prospect of success). In the end he got the other job and so left.

I think the last time I changed jobs I failed to mention to my employers at the time that I was considering moving as realised that would burn my bridges in that role.

Tony McNulty
192 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:33:06
Tony C.

You ask if you might be missing something.

When you changed jobs, did you hang around for six months taking decisions (or not taking decisions) which would work in the favour of your new employers whilst still being paid by your current employer?

Paul Gladwell
193 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:38:48
Tony, during your role in that company, did you spend years preaching about morals and unwritten rules etc?

These people trying to justify his decision by putting it similar to the average man on the street and his job are missing the point: he had an obligation to thousands of fans, some who worshiped him and gave him a send off no other Everton manager has ever received in 135 years.

Yes, he had every right to move on to bigger things, but lying and showing no respect to the club afterwards was something he never had to do. He could have left with his head held high and came back to an applause, that now has been destroyed.

Dave Arrow
194 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:49:17
The way things unfolded was typical Moyes. Cake and eat it.

The chain of events factual or applying a modicum of intuition is not difficult to piece together.

Ferguson was only ever going to retire as a winner and would only leave if they’d won the League. I reckon he’d have gone a year earlier if City hadn't snatched it at the death. And probably Moyes would have left us a year earlier which would have been better timing all round, because after our double capitulation against our neighbours that was when he should have gone.

So telling Moyes not to sign the new deal because he could get a bigger club was simply putting him on notice.

Moyes was on a no lose. Ferguson goes he gets the job. Ferguson stays he signs a nice new contract. No big deal keeping us suckers dangling.

It clearly didn’t matter to Moyes that our season crashed and burnt within the space of a few weeks around the time of the fireside chat.

Throwing away a lead at Norwich finished any top 4 ambition and the cup capitulation put paid to any trophy. So it was Moyes first and Everton a long way second.

I agree with Michael’s summation that all this positioning went on earlier than has been written because we went AWOL in the January window despite having our best chance in years of a top 4 finish.

Moyes didn't want to sign anyone because he thought he’d be off or Kenwright wouldn't sanction the purchases because he knew Moyes would likely not be around, or a combination of both. I do find it hard to believe that Kenwright was in the dark about all the shenanigans, but either way he had put himself in a no-win situation.

Kenwright should have grown a pair and actually withdrawn the contract and served Moyes notice after the cup defeat. We’d have taken our chances for what remained of the season, which with a distracted manager was what happened anyway.

Having said he should have gone the season before, I’m not shedding any crocodile tears but if he had signed a new deal in that summer as was the custom within a year of the old one expiring the issue of compensation would have been taken care of. Another example of Moyes before club.

The time for change was overdue but it’s the way we were taken for patsies that rankles with me.

I’m only glad I was hot footing it down County Road after the West Ham game when the adulation for our former manager was riding on the breeze. One of my better decisions.

Eric Myles
195 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:56:50
Ross #920, you may have known it but there were many on here that said Moyes would never get the United job and were left with egg on their face and have been obsessing about it since.
John Keating
196 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:55:30
Any Everton manager that thinks a 3rd or 4th or 5th round Cup replay against Sunderland is more important than a Derby match is a total prick and should not be manager of Everton Football Club
Mike Corcoran
197 Posted 23/10/2013 at 14:13:28
He's gone, move on. The play was dire for 90% of the time. I am loving watching Man Utd lose their power and honestly think they will take a long time to recover. I am enjoying the blues again, job done.
Tony J Williams
198 Posted 23/10/2013 at 14:02:22
I understand your thinking John, but hypothetically (setting aside prejudice) would we have more chance of winning a cup then winning the league? Would you be saying the same if we were playing Crystal Palace before said 5th Round match?

Dave, as you say, Moyes was in a no-lose situation, get the Man U call, great, don't I will sign the contract with Everton. Doing what's best for him. It's what every person does, it's not an unusual scenario at all.

Sam Higgins
199 Posted 23/10/2013 at 14:16:01
I never did see the Moyes send off – didn't realise he was given such adulation.
Chris Ashton
200 Posted 23/10/2013 at 13:29:52
Everyone grumbling about this fail to see the facts that Moyes faced. In the last seasons with the club he had no transfer money for 2 years and then a total of 20 million (ish) from 4 player sales in the space of 6 months. His job at this club was made so difficult it is a testament to the man for not walking out after Arteta left due to his team slowly being picked apart with no chance of replacing them like for like. The club wouldn't match Pienaar's contract demands, we sold him for less than his worth and then Moyes had to sell TWO players just to resign him again.

In all honesty why do you blame him for what he did? He was working an impossible job that gets worse every year. Martinez has walked into the same problem, loaning a few players in to fill the gaps instead of investing any money in our manager and future. Ferguson said in regards to his book that the most important thing for a manager is to have control of the dressing room. Jesus, Moyes didn't know who would be in that dressing room at the end of every window by the end!

This little rant is not a sticking up for OFM as it may sound. I am actually glad we have changed manager, and for good or bad I am excited by watching us develop under Martinez in the coming years. Moyes lost me personally away to Sunderland 3 years ago, then lost my support after the derby results 2 years ago. But instead of being righteous about the whole thing, how can you blame him? Would you have preferred if he had walked out on us stating he couldn't work for us? Would we still have ended up where we are or would we be a Newcastle? A yes man for the owners who don't like to invest in the team? For what he was, good or bad at least Moyes stood by us and worked with the board the best he could. He has moved onto the worlds biggest club, a dream job for anybody who has no affiliation with a hometown club and if he survives until next summer when he will have a board that backs him unlike with us.

For the record, the reason why Moyes is failing is simply down to one thing, Himself. And although it cost me my bet on Saturday, it was nice to see him fail in all the same ways he did here.

John Keating
201 Posted 23/10/2013 at 14:37:01
Tony, I said at the time that in my opinion we should always put out our strongest team regardless of League or Cup fixture. This nonsense about players being tired is just that - nonsense! Barcelona play about 5000 games a seson and never play anything but their strongest 11 regardless. Lampard went about 10 seasons without missing a match.

Players say that they want to play week-in & week-out, they don't want to miss a game. If a player gets injured then so be it. He has to be replaced by someone not of a similar calibre as we didn't have a strong squad.

What Moyes did was a disgrace. The proof was that we got through against Sunderland....... and then?? Waste of time!!

Kevin Tully
202 Posted 23/10/2013 at 14:44:55
Chris - "He was working an impossible job that gets worse every year."

Maybe the £3-4m per season was probably helping to soften the blow?

(Plus having a dick-head of a Chairman as his boss, who was in fucking tears every time we won a game)

Kevin Rowlands
203 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:03:19
Sam, count yourself lucky you didn't see the send off, cringe worthy at best, have to say though it was watching Phil fucking Neville strolling around as if we were waving off Alan Ball that pissed me off the most, oh and on another note CMON Sociedad and Stoke this weekend!
Carl Sanderson
204 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:22:07
Kevin,

"...count yourself lucky you didn't see the send off, cringe worthy at best..."

Actually it was warm appreciation for a manager who had come to the end of his contract and was leaving for pastures new.

Kevin Rowlands
206 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:28:40
Carl, at the time it happened I had no problem with it whatsoever (except for the Neville inclusion); it is what has transpired since, and with the news that came out yesterday that now leads me to conclude, yes it was cringe-worthy. You okay with that?
Carl Sanderson
207 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:34:00
Kevin,

So it was not cringeworthy at the time but it is now? Right-ho.

Am I ok with that? Of course. You have a right to spout any shite you like.

Barry Rathbone
208 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:32:59
Possibly the lamest excuse for Moyes shenanigans is the "just a job" routine including the "just saw out his contract" bollocks as justification.

Changing jobs in industry is in no way comparable wiith football.

Nick Barmby and Wayne Rooney moved to a "better" job as did Cantona, Sol Cambell and Paul Ince - all hammered by their previous fans.

People using this have no idea about what drives football.

Mark Knight
209 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:55:46
Is that right, teary Bill's Mum havin' a go at Blotchy!!!
Nick Entwistle
210 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:01:14
Drives the football fan, more the point Barry.

But Barmby did go to the shite, Wayne once a blue always a blue, Cantona banged Leslie Ash, and Paul Ince had the shirt on before the transfer went through or something like that.
Don't forget we all knew he was going to Utd when the farewell took place.

Didn't Pienaar run his contract down to go play CL football?

Colin Glassar
211 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:02:53
Two questions.

1) Can BK sue his darling David for adultery?
2) Is fergie eligible for a double knighthood for taking this ginger traitor to OT?

John Gee
212 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:56:28
I was a big Moyes supporter on these pages and wasn't shy to poor my disdain on other posters, telling them to 'get behind the manager' and such like. The beginning of the end for me with that cunt was when he acted like horny virgin during the Euros when asked about the Spurs job. But still I supported him because he was Everton manager and had a vision of how to progress the club on a limited budget...

Or so he said. As it transpired, he was on a one-man mission to boost his profile and be Fergie's bitch to ensure that when SAF retired he would be ideal as he will always be Fergies bitch, thereby giving Whiskey Nose a nice little ego handjob every time a journalist mentions him.

Seeing the send-off he was given was the first time I have ever been embarrassed to be a Blue. All of you who clapped and cheered him were HOODWINKED. Do you hear me? HOODWINKED I tells ya!

Message to Moyes: You could win every trophy going but, at the very best, you will only ever be Shankly's Paisley. But that's not going to happen anyway; you were lucky to have a chairman who has an aversion to sacking managers because, if you were at any other club, you would have got the bullet a while ago.

In 10 years time, we'll be having a conversation about some bloke called Damien Moyles who got sacked by Utd and replaced by a half-senile old man, dragged out of retirement after he made a comment about 'knife/gunfight' at the Etihad.

Dave Lynch
213 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:50:54
For some reason I didn't/don't have a problem with Neville, he did what he could in a blue shirt and gave 100% every game even if he was shite in his last couple of seasons.


Moyes on the other hand I do have a problem with, he discredited himself over the way he treated us in regards the LB/MF transfer bids and the way he handled his depature.

I am an Evertonian and anyone who treats Everton with the distain and arrogance he did treats me the same way.

Everton are a big part of my life and have been since the day I drew breath so I take any slight on them personally, I can't help it, it's come from 50+ years of blind, unwavering love which makes no sense whatsoever in a sane mind.

Mike Gwyer
214 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:25:47

All part of the master plan - BK had noticed that Moyes was becoming a bit to high powered for his liking. Additionally, SAF wants to keep his high powered status as the best manger ManU ever had.... so..
(1) Moyes out to United - he fuck's them right up with his "keep it tight and nick one theory", play's with one striker for most games, always, I mean always sub's the striker at 78 minute mark - fuck knows why but its a Moyes thing, fuck it, if ManU play with two strikers sub them both. (2) Moyes to make an absolute stupid bid for both Fellaini and Baines, this makes Woodward look a tit knowing that he had better get one of them before the transfer window shuts. Moyes & BK agree about Fellaini, so Moyes buy's Fellaini - Nooooooooo, not at the release price of 23M, wait till the last fucking minute and make Woodward pay top dollar - 4 and half million over the 23M asking price. (3) Moyes speaks to BK about Baines and they both agree he is fucking really good - shit wait, Moyes then offers 15M for Baines but 30 seconds later the transfer window closes. BK & Moyes agree that was a bit close - phew, Everton keep Baines (4) Everton sign RM as football manager who has major plans regarding pass and move footy - fuckinghell says BK. (5) BK reverts to days of old and brings in the players RM requires, starting with McCarthy for half the price of Fellaini. (5) Everton start the season with pass and move footy - bit like tippy tappy, however the mighty blues are having about 200 shots at goal and about 99 pct possession. (6) Mighty ManU lose at home to "bring a knife to the gun fight" WBA - sad to say Moyes was desperately trying to sub RVP whilst WBA were putting the ball into the onion bag. (7) Moyes states that he needs about 7 world class players to win the CL & EPL - however, Fellaini, costing 27M is not one of them. (8) ManU fan base goes into meltdown and want the Glazers to sack the fucker pronto, but with a 6 year contract at 6M a year - no fucking chance. (9) Everton make huge strides towards top 4 whilst the mighty ManU are rubbing shoulders with Stoke, Hull and the Barcodes.

SAF and BK are as happy as happy can be.

Linda Morrison
215 Posted 23/10/2013 at 15:53:35
I can't believe that people are so wound up still about Moyes.

It was obvious something was going on when he kept moving the goal posts about when he was going to sign the contract. If he was genuinely undecided, he would have stated at the start of last season, he would make his decision in the summer. But he didn't. He kept moving the date, one excuse after the other. How do people think this must have affected the players?

The last statement he made was before the Wigan FA Cup game, and we all know what happened there!

He did good for Everton for a number of years, but in the last few seasons he looked and acted uninterested, all the reports from staff is that he changed and the atmosphere changed.

He's out of his depth at Man Utd, he needs to rebuild that team from choice, not like at Everton where the financial situation decided what would happen. a much harder scenario. Also, teams like Chelsea etc are much better this season than last so making the job harder.

I found it strange that a few weeks ago Fergie was asked about rumours he was going back for a short time. Moyes looks stressed at present but they should still finish in the top 4.

After the Summer transfer saga, there's no way I can see him coming in for Baines in January, he'll be 29 then; Moyes will be expected to bring in big names.

Come on, we're with a new manager now, let's support him and the board too look at what's happening to Cardiff. BK took out a loan secured on his house to buy the club from hamper man, without which we could have been in real serious financial shit

John Gee
216 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:25:18
Mike Gwyer, that's a good theory but a little bit paranoid. Is your TV wrapped in tin foil by any chance.

I'm not dismissing it by the way. Here's another one, Man Utd tell the PL how they want their fixtures for the coming season and make dead sure that they don't visit Goodison with Judas until the dust has settled and then throw a bit of miss-direction about the opening fixtures. Well I think we have longer memories than they think!

Mike can I borrow your foil, they're watching me through the TV.

Barry Rathbone
217 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:28:42
Nick I wasn't talking about the farewell that was just the flock being shepherded.

I am totally against the tax payer paying for the royal family but if the queen visited places I worked at graciously I would go along with the applause - anyone viewing it as a sign of support rather than good manners would be mistaken.

Professional football folk deserve all the odium they get if they start treating fans like idiots which is exactly what Moyes did over his contract.

Andrew Clare
218 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:39:34
The whole embarrassing affair happened because we have a very weak Chairman.As soon as the manager was non committal regarding a new contract he should have been marched out of the building so to speak.
Absolutely delighted he has gone. He should have been given his ’cards’ five years ago when it was obvious that he was of limited managerial skill.
Kevin Tully
219 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:49:54
Holloway bulleted....
Kevin Rowlands
220 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:40:57
Carl, yes at the time it didn't bother me. Personally I didn't participate as I didn't see him deserving to be given that kind of send-off, and especially Neville. But I look back now and, yes, I wish it hadn't've happened. Why? – because he should have been shown the door as soon as we knew he was off.

What has happened since – problems that he himself has created, and the fact that he was in regular contact with Whiskey Nose – make me look back at that send-off and cringe now. It might be shite to you, but it's how I feel, ok?

Thomas Windsor
221 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:34:39
I think all of us had an idea Moyes had been tapped up for the Man Utd job along time ago, so it is old news now.

We will stay round about the 6th to 9th position till Billy Liar starts to either spend the Sky money or sell the club.

Denis Richardson
222 Posted 23/10/2013 at 16:25:51
Wow - obviously a touchy subject given the 200+ posts.

Simple fact is that Moyes all along had/has one priority and that is to look out for Number 1. Now admittedly that's probably the same position as 99% of the people involved in the Premier League, so am not sure that's necessarily a stick you can beat him with, regardless if you want to.

What I cannot stand however is his smug demeanor, utter bullshit and hypocrisy he came out with. Gems include: how Everton were/are in his heart; players are overpaid and should take a 20% pay cut (particularly love that one given he was the 2nd highest earner at the club!); Kenwright is a great caring chairman; Baines is priceless (then puts in a low ball offer); saying Everton were holding LB and MF's careers back (even though he would not sell them when he was the manager); treated the club as if he owned it and us fans with contempt (FA cup game against Liverpool, FA cup against Wigan?), etc etc.

As soon as he got the chance to go somewhere supposedly better, he was off like a shot. Let's not forget, he'd been itching to go for a while, not just a 'couple of weeks before the end of the season'. (Remember when he lapped up the press and thought he was a shoe-in for the Spurs job? - Levy was however too wise to touch him with a barge pole.)

Unfortunately, he was never going to walk away from £4M a year (Kenwright's fuck-up there.)

I am 100% convinced that SAF, Man Utd, Kenwright and Moyes all knew about the manager change at least 6 months before the end of the season. (They are listed on the NY stock exchange - do you really think an important decision like that would be made in 5 minutes?) Personally am not too bothered by that, I can understand why both sides would want to keep it secret up to the end of the season and hence the crap that they spouted during that time. (Probably also explains the lack of transfer activity in January – why would Kenwright allow him to spend money when he was off a few months later...)

I did and still do cringe at the send-off we gave him (and Neville and Cahill), as if he was the second coming or something – he won FUCK ALL in 11 YEARS!! And made watching Everton really painful at times – Straq and Vic up front, Neville and Heitinga in midfield... jeez!!

And to the usual mantra of 'he had no money' – people conveniently forget that he broke our transfer record 3 years on the trot! Rooney money, Lescott money – amnesia anyone? Granted he was not given money in the last two years or so but he had 9 YEARS before that to build a squad and one of the highest wage bills!

Added to that, he also chose not to play Barkley (could have had another player), hung on to Bilyaletdeshite for 2½ years (even though he was crap), could have sold Saha, Rodwell, Arteta, Jags and others to generate funds to reinvest in the squad etc etc. We were not has poor as people make out!

Anyway, apologies as this was not supposed to be a rant but, when I think of that dour prick, I just get so annoyed. The last 3-4 years have just been a waste under him and I was depressed thinking that he just would never go, he should have fucked off 3-4 years ago – he well and truly outstayed his welcome.

My man of 2013? Sir Alex Ferguson – I will forever be grateful for taking that overrated, dour defensive dinosaur of a manager off our hands.

Amen – rant over.

Tony J Williams
223 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:17:49
His send off was no different to the applause he and the team received at the end of every season. He did a decent job for us and was applauded for it.

Can't see how that is cringeworthy. Your mind seems to make it cringeworthy now because he has been acting like a cock since he left us.


Ian Burns
224 Posted 23/10/2013 at 14:59:12
Please don't get me confused with the Ian (and Nick) who have had lumps kicked out of them on this thread but I have just sat through 189 posts (at the last count) as always fascinated by opinions expressed on TW.

The passion we have for EFC is summed up in this thread - if it's not blue it's not right and although we reluctantly understand there is a better job up the East Lancs (it was never always this way), we hate to be thought of as a stepping stone.

Moyes did extremely well out of this club and we did OK out of him for 6 or 7 seasons. His manner since he took the other job has been less than respectful towards EFC (the nicest way I could put it), not just to the club but far far more importantly to the thousands upon thousands of fans to whom this club means everything. It is this total lack of respect which is the main thrust of everybody's argument on this thread and Ian/Nick have completely missed the point, which is difficult to take on board being myself of blue blood (in the EFC sense I might add!).

Time to move on guys Sin Miedo because we have RM and he seems to REALLY care and understand what EFC stands for. Long may it continue and do I care if Man U finish without a top 4 place; any silverware at all? Er, no. I care about all things EFC.

Kevin Rowlands
225 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:27:22
What about singing his name for nearly all of the second half, Tony? Did we sing Lescott's name in the last game before he fucked off?

What's cringe worthy is now knowing that in all likelihood he had been on the phone with beetroot chops in previous weeks discussing their strategy on how they could try and take our better players off us for peanuts, that's why I look back and wish it hadn't happened.

Tony McNulty
226 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:42:00
Moyes 21/1 to be next sacked manager. Hmm. Do they do each way on these bets for a place?
Ian Tunstead
227 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:15:42
Sean Kelly, The majority on here is not necessarily the majority of Everton fans as a whole, and doesn’t make my opinion any less valid. If the sheep want to head off into the desert mislead my a few who themselves are misguided doesn’t mean I shouldn’t say anything. Just because it might seems like they are a majority on ToffeeWeb doesn’t mean I shouldn’t voice my concerns.

This site is renowned for having a very negative theme. I’m sure when Moyes first arrived the majority backed him and a few voiced their own concerns. Over time when he failed to win a trophy or break into the top 4 some of the faithful began to turn. The cycle will repeat itself when Martinez fails to live up to the hype and expectation.

The realists realised Moyes was always going to struggle against the money clubs but he at least kept us in the mix and brought us some hope and stability taking a regular bottom 6 team to a regular top 6 team. Martinez on the other hand took a mid-table team down. The FA Cup win and his so called attractive football have clouded the judgement of many and Lukaku has been the plaster holding it all together.

You say “He did enforce a style of play on us that wasn't pretty to watch.” — I’m sorry but I don’t agree, I think a lot of people will admit over the last few seasons, when we have had a fully fit first team to pick from, we have played some fantastic football but couldn’t find a top class £20-£30 million striker to make the difference. You seem to be choosing to remember the first 2 or 3 seasons when he had a very average team and so needed to play a certain way out of necessity which was quite effective rather than trying to do a Holloaway.

As for the “football purist”comment, what exactly does that mean? If you think Martinez is going to have us playing like Barcelona, and have success doing it, I think you are in for a rude awakening over the next 2 or 3 seasons. If we play the Wigan way and bring in Wigan's players we will go the same way as Wigan.

Mike Gaynes
228 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:17:29
Denis (251), I think you've summarized the whole debate very nicely.

"I am 100% convinced that SAF, Man Utd, Kenwright and Moyes all knew about the manager change at least 6 months before the end of the season...." – That's probably the smartest thing I've seen written today. Of course everybody knew, and they weren't going to leak it to the public.

As a big Moyes supporter when he was ours, I do understand all the anger here, but I don't share it. It's not that I care how Moyes does in the future, because he became irrelevant when he walked out the door.

It's because we've come out BETTER for all of this.

Moyes hid his intentions to leave? Fine with me. If he hadn't, maybe the chips wouldn't have fallen that brought us Martinez... who, while he hasn't proven out yet, certainly looks like a very good manager and a terrific player recruiter.

Moyes came in for our players? Wonderful. It triggered the moves that brought us Barry and McCarthy.

Moyes tried to lowball us with insulting offers? Excellent. It backfired. I liked Fellaini, but we wound up getting WAY more for him than he was worth. And if Moyes comes back in for Baines, it'll cost him a lung – especially if they're still below us in the league.

We gave Moyes a nice sendoff? OK by me. Everton's reputation as a classy organization only grows, and maybe that helps bring in better players, or helps us keep them (Baines/Barkley).

Personally, watching Barkley crack shots and Lukaku send bodies flying and Deulofeu dancing around defenders, I can't be the least bit angry with Moyes. I love the side and the manager we have now, and I wouldn't change one damn thing that has happened in the last six months.

Kevin Rowlands
229 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:52:23
Nice one Ian, use this thread to get your inevitable dig in at Martinez, Wigan, relegation etc, when the subject has absolutely fuck all to do with that, you just can't help yourself can you. BTW how's your hero doing in his first three months with the reigning champions, oops.
Phil Walling
230 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:49:51
Nobody seriously thinks that RM has a different agenda to his predecessor do they? All this talk about the new man's 'care and understanding' of the Everton ethos is just as much bullshit as that bestowed on Moyes in his first few months.

The aim of ALL football managers is to maximise their income by getting their team as high in the league as possible.And so should it be. Yes,the new man seems to be of a more pleasant demeanour than the old one - but so bloody what?

He's promised us Champions League and he can fart in my face if he delivers on that undertaking.Nice guys win fuck all!

Eugene Ruane
231 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:44:52
Tony (253) - "His send off was no different to the applause he and the team received at the end of every season"

Sorry but imo it was VERY different for two reasons.

1) I don't remember him being wildly applauded BEFORE the last game of any season.

2) At the end of all the previous seasons, he was Everton's manager.

The fact is we (ie: Bill) showed ourselves to be incredibly small-time with our send off party and Moyes (particularly with what we now know) showed himself to be staggeringly self-serving by going along with it all.

For football reasons, I was more than happy to see him leave but always thought he was a decent feller.

I was wrong - his behaviour and utterances towards us since he left, show him to be a total and utter twat.

Raymond Fox
232 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:07:25
You're forgetting the FA Cup, Phil!
Barry Rathbone
233 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:51:31
Ian, you should check other Everton forums, the recent Liverpool Echo poll and talk to neutrals about Martinez it's hard to find an unfavourable appraisal of RM.

We will hit a rough patch and doubtless you and the other 3 or 4 will go to town on RM but it just looks like an agenda when the same names forever announcing what a man of integrity Moyes was are getting stuck in despite our transfer business and season start surpassing expectations.

Hard to take seriously in that context to be honest.

Mike Gaynes
234 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:07:01
Eugene (265), admittedly this is a small issue, but why do you feel the sendoff made us look small-time? I thought it showed our fans' class.
Kevin Rowlands
235 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:12:41
Ian, have you forgotten? Leighton Baines was a Wigan player.
Phil Walling
236 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:14:12
I'd just allow him a raspberry for that, Raymond!
Ian Tunstead
238 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:20:10
Kevin, Baines was at Wigan before Martinez arrived when they were a mid-table team and he was a young and upcoming player who Moyes was able to get the best out of.

You can be all smug that "my hero" seems to be struggling but I've said it before and I'll say it again: it's a marathon not a sprint, let's see where everyone is after 38 games, and let's try not to write off 10 years of history and chose to only concentrate on half-a-dozen games.

Raymond Fox
239 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:23:47
Give it up Phil, your surrounded and outnumbered, come and join our happy band.
Danny Jones
240 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:35:31
“Resentment is like taking poison and hoping the other person dies.”

Let it go.

Carl Sanderson
241 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:32:37
Kevin 247:

Of course it's ok. As the feller said, I disagree with everything you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.

Kevin Tully
242 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:28:57
Ian T - at least you are up front about your admiration for ginge, fair enough.

What pisses me off is the slating Martinez (the EVERTON manager) took before a ball was kicked, and is the fact some are looking to find fault at every opportunity. They are even slagging every signing before they have kicked a ball FFS!!

I don't know what they are hoping to achieve, but no fan in their right mind would talk this way, that's why I don't even bother replying to their obvious baiting on here.

It took years before anyone turned on Moyes – and with good reason.

Brian Cleveland
243 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:33:31
So many posts to read it is obviously a very touchy subject.... but if I can just say to Phil Sammon (177)... that's exactly how I feel, so I won't repeat it and type it all again, and I think you said it more eloquently than I would have!
Carl Sanderson
244 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:37:13
People on this site don't rate Moyes as a manager: fair enough, that's their view and it must be respected. But some of the posts have gone beyond reason in their abuse of the man. Some posters have called Moyes a rat, a dog, a ginger tosser, a twat, Gollum, etc, things they would never dream of saying if the man was standing in front of them. And the same people have taken to calling fellow contributors idiots and half-wits for not adhering to their cosy consensus.

Well, the warm and near-universal praise he received from 40,000 Evertonians at his last match conveys a clear message that lots of Blues appreciate his efforts.

To me that means more than the thoughts of individuals who are so deranged with hatred for Moyes that they are blind to his achievements.

Now that he has gone I don't give a shit about him, preferring to concentrate on Everton and Martinez.

Moyes now acts for Manchester United. But to me he was a success at Everton.

Kevin Rowlands
245 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:37:23
So, Ian, using your well thought-out logic, James McCarthy is dogshite (we haven't seen enough of the other three) because he played at Wigan; Martinez is useless because he managed at Wigan, and we will be relegated this year because of that?

What the fuck is wrong with me, man, how did I not figure that out??? Thank you for enlightening me, pal.

Ian Tunstead
246 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:45:35
Kevin T, I haven't slagged any of Martinez signings, I think they have been very good and was happy with them before they kicked a ball.

Kevin R. No I don't think JM is Dog shite I have been saying for a long time what a good young player he was and when everyone was saying what a great player Rodwell was, that he was the next Beckenbauer, I was given a load of abuse for I saying I couldn't see what all the fuss was about and that I would prefer to get rid of Rodwell and we could probably get McCarthy in at a much lower price with not being an overhyped over priced English player who would be much more effective than Rodwell.

Alan Corken
247 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:49:47
Folks I was one of the few, the very few who saw through the Moyes myth years ago. I wrote on this site about him being an exponent of mediocrity. I also condemned the last day love-in as crass. However, now is the time to let it go, he has been found out and we are well rid. As for those who still defend him well ... You can fool some of the people all of the time...etc etc
Michael Kenrick
248 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:51:19
Nice touch from Ian Tunstead (NOT!!!) to play the old and frankly pathetic "negative ToffeeWeb site" card as he argues his thoroughly negative personal position re Martinez.

All while fielding countless positive posts about the current manager, encouraging him to perhaps take a more considered viewpoint. Oh the irony.

And this from a fan who would have us believe Moyes "GAVE 10 years of his life" to this club... How much did we PAY him again???

Paul David
249 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:56:44
Carl

Lets see how them same 40,000 react when the mancs next come to town ( as long as he's still in a job by then ).

Sean Kelly
250 Posted 23/10/2013 at 17:52:29
Ian (261)

Having been an Evertonian for more than 50 years, I have seen proper football played in the eras of Catterick and Kendall. I can spot a proper football manager / coach from a mile off. Moyes will never fall into that category as he is and always will be one-dimensional.

Look what's happening up in Mancland to the same players Whiskey Nose had last year and see what Moyes and that utterly useless cunt Round are imposing on that squad.

As I said earlier, you are entitled to your opinion but so am I. I have only recently joined TW but my opinions are not based on the comments of others but on the evidence in front of me on the pitch.

As for RM, he may not get us playing like Barcelona but then what other team is? As long as he has us playing attractive football and picking up points along the way, I'm happy.

On the few occasions over the last few years when we did play attractive football under Moyes, I think you will find the players took the initiative themselves despite that dour cunt.

Eugene Ruane
251 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:29:43
Mike (270) - "Eugene (265), admittedly this is a small issue, but why do you feel the sendoff made us look small-time? I thought it showed our fans' class".

Well if that's how you see it, nothing I'm going to say is going to change that and I accept it is purely an opinion thing.

However as you ask why, I'll try to explain.

I'm sure you would agree that whatever the opinion of Alex Ferguson, he was/is 'a winner'.

Sure in recent years he had the money to buy great players but don't forget he won trophies with Aberdeen and managed to break the old firm grip on things for a while.

Plus as well-supported as Utd have always been, when he took over they were going nowhere.

One of the reasons I believe he was as successful as he was, was because he wouldn't let anything go - players, refs, directors of football, coaches, anyone who crossed him was fucked off sharpish and every decision no matter how small was fought over.

He obviously had the idea that the institution of Manchester Utd football club was all and that they should/could never be fucked with or taken advantage of in any way.

He was the predator, everyone else the prey

(nb: John Moores seems to me to have had a similar attitude).

Everton supporters showed 'class'?

Not in my opinion.

The way I saw the Moyes send off was was an indicator of how far we've fallen.

With two games to go before the end of the season, our manager is named as manager of Manchester Utd.

Instead of him immediately be told "thanks, bye" and a caretaker being put in charge, it was fucking party time (maybe it's an age thing but it sincerely depressed the shite out of me).

I will think of Everton supporters as being classy when all that concerns them is battering teams and the majority, instead of whooping and applauding the manager of another team managing Everton, instead, to a man, shout 'If he's manager of Utd, he's not manager of Everton so fuck him off out of it"

It is football, it is not (as some appear to think) a being patted on the head contest.

Maybe you know the name of the American coach credited with 'Show me a good loser and I'll show you a loser'.

Carl Sanderson
252 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:02:32
Paul, I sincerely hope that, by then, those 40,000 are too busy roaring the team into the Champions League to give a toss who sits in the opposite dug-out.
Ross Edwards
253 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:06:21
Totally agree with that MK. I'd give 10 years of my life for anything if I was given £4million a year and immunity from the sack by an idiot.
Barry Rathbone
254 Posted 23/10/2013 at 18:56:58
Carl if you read the posts you would see umpteen people saying they either didn't clap or did it out of politeness or for the others introduced to the throng.

Pro rata those posts and the picture of 40k as you describe takes on a different picture.

As for Moyes doing a decent job of course you are entitled to that opinion but if it's effectively countered claiming people are deranged is dummy out the pram time.

Kevin Rowlands
255 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:10:27
Ian, I refer you to your post #261, "if we play like Wigan, bring in Wigan players, we will end up like Wigan" what does that mean then, we're going to win the Champions League?
Ross Edwards
256 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:14:32
Deranged?

Well, I've been called worse I guess.

Ross Edwards
257 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:15:56
So, if you buy a number of players from one club, you turn into that club?

Yes, I'd love to be in Europe with an FA Cup win.

Kieran Fitzgerald
258 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:00:01
Whoever said Everton fans were bitter are lying fuckers who are all out to get us.

I honestly don't see what the problem is. It's universally known that there is no loyalty in football. Football clubs/managers/chairmen behave with a lack of decorum every day of the week. Just because it has happened to us doesn't mean we should allow ourselves to get this annoyed or angry or bitter. Not only do I think that it makes us look self indulgent, I think that it belittles us and lowers the tone of what we stand for as a club.

We have taken Wigan's manager, their star midfielder and their top goal scorer from last season. If I was a Wigan fan, this, on top of relegation, would trump whatever slight I may feel over the whole Moyes saga. Yet I don't read any comments that shows any recognition of this. I have not read any comments stating that we have treated Wigan badly. As Everton fans, this idea that we will only worry about what affects us puts us in the same boat as Utd and Moyes. It's football.

Barry Rathbone
259 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:22:29
No Kieran, we were above board and paid compensation to Wigan — an entirely different picture to what you allude to.

If you're not annoyed about another club affecting the destiny of EFC with sneaky phone calls etc, I'm not sure you know what's been going on.

Ross Edwards
260 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:27:01
Well said Barry. It's one of the last arguments against Martinez after all of them have been rebuffed by the majority.
Kevin Tully
261 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:22:40
Who knows how many players he tapped up whilst picking up a fortune in his last few weeks?

As I said at the time, Imagine any other club like Spurs or Liverpool letting the fucker still have the run of the club after he had been named Utd manager?

Only with teary bollocks. A fucking farce from start to finish.

Andy Crooks
262 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:24:44
Phill# 264, I don't accept that the aim of "ALL football managers is to maximise their income,,,". To me ,that is a cynical view and a vague generalisation.

I admire people who stand up for their views as Nick and Ian have one. However, sometimes the majority are right, Frankly, I find it incomprehensible that any person with a semblance of wit can accept that Moyes was "flabbergasted" to be offered the United job.

Moyes betrayed Everton and , in my view, demonstrated himself to be a greedy, self serving hypocrite, utterly devoid of integrity. I think it is understandable for any Evertonian to gloat at the weekly exposure of the ineptitude that he inflicted on our club.

Mike Gaynes
263 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:08:40
Eugene (295), your comparison of SAF to Vince Lombardi is apt, although I think in both cases the legends about their toughness obscure even bigger reasons for their success -- brains, ability to assess talent, strategic thinking and ability to motivate players. There are thousands of tough, single-minded, unforgiving coaches out there who could never compare to SAF and Lombardi because they don't have all the other characteristics of greatness.

However, you're comparing a coach's conduct to fans' conduct. I think that's apples and oranges.

FYI... after Lombardi left Green Bay and returned as the coach of Washington, he was greeted by an ovation from the Green Bay fans that reduced him to tears. His death the following year was treated as a day of mourning in Green Bay. It certainly didn't hurt the Green Bay franchise. Would the ManU supporters have howled down SAF had he returned as the manager of another side?

Whether a caretaker should have been appointed or not (and I happen to agree with you on that), I was fine with the sendoff and pleased that there was no chorus of voices chanting for Moyes to fuck off. I guess we just have differing opinions of what's classy.

Peter Cummings
264 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:05:45
Linda M, the reason Moyes is being, justifiably, slagged off, not because he went up the East Lancs, or should that be the M6, we all expected it. It is the way he has acted since his 'royal Blue' send-off by Evertonians who appreciated his efforts, promising he would not go after any Everton players, then doing just that and making a truly insulting offer for our best two. Then making veiled insults as to the quality of the Blues and 'the best club in the world'.

Now we have the Fergie revelations of the underhand way they both conspired in his departure. Therefore, if he falls flat on his face, justice will be done. The Ferguson book will go a long way to his demise, I think.

Carl Sanderson
265 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:26:18
Barry 300,

I am referring to the level of abuse that some people are giving to other posters. The sort of language that would earn them a crack on the nose if they uttered it to someone's face. It is unnecessary.

It's notable that this thread on Ferguson/Moyes has accumulated 200-odd posts, yet the one on Kone (ie about football) barely has 30. And even that thread has begun to turn toxic.

Dummy out of the pram? Right-ho.

Barry Rathbone
266 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:31:45
Ross, the thing about the Moyes/SAF collusion is it cost us several million pounds... if they snook in wearing balaclavas with sawn-off shotguns and looted the place, it would be no different.

Yet people maintain this insanity, this deluded loyalty that 11 years of no relegation justifies anything – monstrous.

Barry Rathbone
267 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:38:50
Carl I was talking about your simplistic 40k approval rating - it was wrong.
Michael Kenrick
268 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:32:23
Keiran, Wigan were also relegated, which changes the dynamic massively when it comes to staff/player retention.

Yet we treated Wigan and their mouthy Chairman with respect and made reasonable offers for his players.

Whereas Man Utd should be considered our direct rivals, but we had been talked down to our "proper" place as also-rans punching above our weight — all cowardly nonsense perpetrated by the previous manager well before he left us for "bigger things", while our Chairman had us "celebrating" his appointment instead of packing him off pronto — where he would continue to belittle and demean us, while going for our best players on the cheap.

Simply no comparison.

Ross Edwards
270 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:38:06
And that 11 years included the utterly amazing achievements of no wins at big 4 stadiums in 44 attempts, bottling big games at home and abroad in the cup competitions, defensive subs, cautious tactics, negative football, and no silverware at all.

Overrated by the media, and with low expectations from the club and us for only accepting 7th and a rare cup quarter final defeat, with an annual League Cup defeat to lower league opposition.

Carl Sanderson
271 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:43:38
Barry

"Carl I was talking about your simplistic 40k approval rating - it was wrong."

Sorry about that. I was merely going by the evidence of my own eyes. Forty thousand people all applauding. I must have dreamt it. Silly me.

Barry Rathbone
272 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:51:51
You just jumped to the wrong conclusion - "to err is human" - don't worry about it.
Kevin Rowlands
273 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:49:04
Ross, don't forget the incredibly successful record in the derbies, NOT, I wonder if Ian's doing somersalts around his living room right now, his beloved Moyes's UTD just went one up.
Ross Edwards
274 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:54:50
Of course Kevin, the media were gushing over him surrendering a 1-0 lead against Shakhtar, saying it was an amazing result for him.

Oh yes, the derbies, the 0-3 humiliation was the last straw for me.

Eugene Ruane
275 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:40:56
Mike (315) - "I guess we just have differing opinions of what's classy"

Possibly, but whether we agree or disagree, my point is it's football and it's all about success ON the park.

As a club we should give NOTHING away and should be seen as nobody's soft touch.

I believe the youngsters use the phrase 'being someone's bitch' and that's how I see what went on re Moyes/Utd.

Utd won titles because they had the best team but what helped is that instilled right throughout the club is the idea 'This is Utd, nobody fucks with us'

I'd LOVE to see us get bit of that (back).

Class imo is what supporters talk about when they don't win trophies.

When they win stuff, they gloat like fuck and class goes out of the window.

And how do I know this?

Because I've followed Eveton sides that HAVE won trophies and although hopefully not acting like a complete twats when we did, the last thing we gave a fuck about was "Do Utd/Liverpool supporters think we're being classy?".

It was we're champions, fuck them.

(sadly, something I'll probably never get to say again)

Andy Crooks
276 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:50:00
Mike # 315. The Everton supporters who applauded Moyes were unaware that Moyes, over the previous months, had been a fraud. That he had been in talks with the manager of a rival club and that he was treating Everton with utter contempt.

I suspect that when he returns to Goodison park he will get the response he deserves. If I had been there for his last game I would have applauded politely and right now I would be feeling duped.

Carl Sanderson
277 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:56:01
Barry,

That's your opinion, of course. I prefer my own. And I'm not worried, thank you for your concern.

In the meantime I may say that not one person in my part of the Paddock shares your view of Moyes. (In fairness, they're all right behind Martinez.)

Barry Rathbone
278 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:02:00
are we talking horses here?
Ross Edwards
279 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:03:21
Really, you know every opinion of over 2,000 people Carl?
Kevin Rowlands
280 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:05:48
Barry #318, couldn't have said it better myself, Everton were basically shafted out of what could/should have been several million pound, yet some on here tell us to get over it, its football, he saved our club etc. I'm not going to get over it, the man is a total hypocrite, don't forget this is the same person who was in the press on regular occasions spouting off about underhand transfer dealings and doing things the proper way, he's lower than fucking pond life.
Kieran Fitzgerald
281 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:01:55
Barry @311. I'm neither stupid or blind. I am well aware of how Utd have treated us. I am not happy with it but my point is that I am not going to allow it to make me feel bitter or angry. I enjoy being a fan too much to allow the bullshit and hypocracy that is modern day football take away what I enjoy so much about it.

Barry and MK @321, fair enough point. We did behave in a way towards Wigan that was proper in the extreme. While a poor example, I suppose the point I was trying to make was that there is always a club that will feel that it has been taken advantage of by what is perceived to be a bigger club. Yet, the perceived bigger club will always get it's back up when some other club does the exact same thing to it. Perhaps it's all a matter of perspective. A Utd fan will tell us they did the right thing for their club.

Ross Edwards
282 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:17:18
Really Kieran? They did the right thing?

Judging by what is being said on Manc forums at the moment, they think that the appointment of Gollum and the signing of the galoot were huge mistakes, and they worry about not even making 4th.

Kevin Rowlands
283 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:16:41
Carl #331, I wouldn't be surprised if some of them you know in the paddock may have a different perspective after yesterday, and btw why wouldn't anyone who's an Everton fan not be behind Martinez? he's our new manager, unless of course your names Entwistle or Tunstead, but of course they have an agenda, they can't wait to get on here and crow if everything goes tits up.
Ian Tunstead
284 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:41:50
Ok Sean at least you admit we did play well under Moyes which is the opposite to what you said to begin with, but it was in spite of Moyes not because of him because "the players used their initiative". You're dammed if you do and your dammed if you don't.
Kieran Fitzgerald
285 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:20:59
I don't mean Moyes and Felliani Ross. A child of six could tell you Moyes wasn't up to the job. I meant the way in which Utd as a club treated Everton as a club. Utd fans will let that go in a heartbeat. What they got for their sins can just be seen as bad karma!
Steven Telford
286 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:12:51
Moyes and SFA did not cost us several million......... the idiocy of our chairman cost us several million.The David Moyes story simple as so: Stabilised a club that was in piss poor shape. had us punching well above our (financial) weight............ now some people see fit to belittle those achievements. fine, but personally, looking at his input to outputs......etc I think its unfair to belittle what it took to stabilise us

Did not sign a contact because he was offered the United Job. We'll probably never fully know the full details surrounding his conversation with SAF, - its a bit of a pisser he did not sign so we could be compensated, but that's more a weakness in our board to not spotting it coming.
Subsequently showed himself to be a dick by chasing Baines and MF......... (that's the worst par for me)
I am sincerely hoping that next chapter results in the decay of Man United. But that's the story so far, simple as that, some people are really going OTT on the conspiracies and premeditated malice perspectives.

sorry to say, but I bet the majority of posters on this forum would have no problem changing employers. yes - its a football club, and that's different....... well, it is and it isn't - unlike Rooney, he wasn't born a blue.

Ross Edwards
287 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:32:04
" A child of six could tell you Moyes wasn't up to the job"

So, does that mean Kieran, that Sanderson, Entwistle and Tunstead are all toddlers?

Darren Hind
289 Posted 23/10/2013 at 19:53:17
Andy Crooks

"Moyes demonstrated himself a greedy self-serving hypocrite, utterly devoid of integrity"

Couldn't agree more. They all are, yet we still have people ready to go to war in their name.

These Prem managers regularly get together, I always imagine they spend their time laughing like drains at us. Greedy hypocrites all of them

I don't trust any of them.

Barry Rathbone
290 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:34:48
Steven, you can't absolve Moyes and Ferguson you simply can't.

They colluded together during his final year with the stated aim that EFC would have no contractual hold on Moyes.

The by product of costing EFC millions probably never entered the heads of the arrogant conniving duo but that is no defence.

The money we paid wigan should have come from utd, millions of pounds was taken out of EFC coffers because of Moyes duplicity.

To not see this is wilful ignorance.

Ian Tunstead
291 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:37:33
Exactly Ross, its becoming play ground stuff with a few people, instead of discussing the football.

As someone has said already If you dare to defend Moyes then you are considered to be anti Martinez and anti Everton. As I have said already I like Martinez and I want him to do well but I don't agree with some of the hype around him or that his "footballing Philosophy" or "footballing purest" mentality will get the results we require over the long term. I think Moyes is a better manager and I think over the course of a few seasons Moyes will show himself to be a better manager as he has already proved over the last 10 years.

Kieran Fitzgerald
292 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:41:53
Not what I meant at all Ross. I think that Moyes is a capable manager in many ways and I think that he did a lot for Everton. He just didn't have the necessary experience to manage Utd and it seems to me to have been a very strange appointment.

I can see both sides of the debate running through this thread Ross. I can see what was good and bad about Moyes as a manager, I can see how both he and Utd should have behaved better towards Everton but can also see that they had to put their own interests first. I can also see that to some degree I appear to be sitting on the fence. I'm not. As I stated above, I am just not prepared to let how the situation developed make me angry or annoyed. Apart from getting worked up, it would do nothing for me. If I were to look back at every negative thing that has happened to Everton, even just over the last thirty five years since the heady heights of the eighties, I would just end up packing in football.


Regardless of the debates between people on this thread, It is just good to see that you,Carl, Nick, Ian and everybody else are willing to voice their opinion.

Carl Sanderson
293 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:55:24
"The money we paid wigan should have come from utd, millions of pounds was taken out of EFC coffers because of Moyes duplicity."

Why "should" it have come from United?

Moyes was at the end of his contract and he left having honoured it. In his contract negotiations he acted in his own interests; what else do you expect?

Martinez did not honour his contract and so Wigan were due compensation.

Man United acted in their own interests; what else do you expect?

If anyone is at fault for last season it was Kenwright. He should have told Moyes to sign again or piss off.

Ross Edwards
294 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:01:27
Of course, I thought that right up to the minute he was appointed by SAF, but he's got at least 3 years to prove us wrong hasn't he?

At the moment, it's going swimmingly.

Ross Edwards
295 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:02:59
I agree Carl. Kenwright should also take a share of the blame. As soon as he was appointed by the Mancs he should have terminated his contract or put him on gardening leave without pay until July 1st, but we were absolutely humiliated by the fact he was allowed to attend meeting at Utd whilst still on our payroll.
Kevin Rowlands
296 Posted 23/10/2013 at 20:59:25
Ian, I suggest you read post #261, written by you, that is your idea of liking and supporting Martinez? Btw this thread was never about who is the better manager or who will be more successful at their new clubs, it was you who turned it into that.
Ross Edwards
297 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:05:44
You did describe Martinez's style of play as "so called attractive" Ian, It is much better to watch, and easier on the eye than Moyes' hoofball tripe.
Carl Sanderson
298 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:09:47
"If anyone is at fault for last season it was Kenwright. He should have told Moyes to sign again or piss off."

To clarify, I meant to say that Kenwright should have done this in the summer of 2012. Apologies.

Barry Rathbone
299 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:10:17
Carl, no.

Moyes was not at the end of his contract the matter was raised at the end of the previous season and consistently through the last season the quotes are numerous from Moyes when questioned.

Admittedly he looked like he was hiding something but many theorised this man of dignity and integrity was forcing the board to cough up more funds. (i think you posted as such)

We now know what actually was happening were secret conversations with the utd man bluntly saying "don't sign".

Now Moyes of course could have signed he was Everton's manager fuck all to do with utd but he didn't.

At this stage you have to be as dull as dishwater not to see what was going on, not to recognise the last thing on the protagonists mind was any consideration for EFC.

The fact it's been a resurrection does not remove the fact we were tricked out of compo - simply can't be argued against.

Ian Tunstead
300 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:07:38
Kevin this thread has been pulled all over the place by lots of different people so don't try and blame it all on me. As I have said twice already I do like Martinez and I will support him while he is Everton manager but that doesn't mean I have to agree with everything he does. I have praised him for his signings and I am glad that he has got off to a good start but he hasn't exactly re-invented the wheel. I find it annoying when the same people who criticised Moyes are the people praising Martinez when he is doing very similar things to Moyes. That to me suggest it was something personal with these people. Like I say not much has changed, the main difference is we have a striker of the highest quality which Moyes was never able to attain.
Kevin Day
301 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:31:53
What happened has happened, all this "Moyes did this" and "Moyes did that".

Fuck him is what I say.

We're better off now, that's the most important thing.

Carl Sanderson
302 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:29:46
Barry,

"Moyes was not at the end of his contract"

Since when do people wait until their contracts end before negotiating a new one?

"Admittedly he looked like he was hiding something"

Pure conjecture and emotionalism.

"At this stage you have to be as dull as dishwater..."

Ah, the usual pathetic ad hominem abuse. Right-ho.

"The fact it's been a resurrection does not remove the fact we were tricked out of compo - simply can't be argued against."

Insofar as this paragraph makes sense it is implying that we were in some way conned. I disagree.

Barry Rathbone
303 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:33:02
Ian, "Moyes similar to Martinez" just isn't correct.

You only have to look at the audacious transfer window, the speed of thought, swooping in for Lukaku, the transformation of Barkley, and the inclusiveness of the man – I mean Kendall not seeing Finch Farm before this week – scandalous.

But mostly it's the football.

Despite the growing pains some of the play is from a different planet from the majority of Moyes tenure.

Poles apart.

Kevin Rowlands
304 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:35:21
Ian, you said and I quote, 'if we play like Wigan, sign Wigan players we will end up like Wigan' that tells me you believe we will be relegated, or am I missing something here? You also in the very same post had a snide dig at Martinez taking a mid table team and getting them relegated as you put it, but of course you like and support our new manager.
Ross Edwards
305 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:40:51
Gollum 1- Sociedad 0

Had to rely on a fluky own goal for him to win. You know you have an issue when you can't score against a team with 3 or 4 of their best players out.

Ross Edwards
306 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:42:02
Absolutely Barry, it is disgraceful that our greatest ever manager wasn't allowed to visit Finch Farm until last week. If it wasn't for Kendall we would have been in dire straits.
Carl Sanderson
307 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:39:05
"... the last thing on the protagonists mind was any consideration for EFC."

I thought I answered this in my post (349). The one person who should have acted out of consideration for EFC was Kenwright. And he should have done it in the summer of 2012. Why he didn't do so I can't say. But I can guess.

Mike Green
308 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:47:40
Mark Knopfler might have something to say about that Ross.
Patrick Murphy
309 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:42:27
Whatever the true chronology of the events - if DM was tipped the wink in February either directly or indirectly, I will always believe that it cost Everton the FA Cup, as that performance against Wigan was so out of character even for a DM side, that somehow the players or board or both had also had their suspicions that he was unlikely to stay past the end of that season.

Given SAF's a nod's as good as a wink to a blind horse confession, I honestly believe that MUFC should have had a case to answer to the football authorities but of course that won't happen.

Whatever DM does or doesn't do in the future is no concern of mine but as Keegan once said I Would just love it if we beat United in an important game let's say an FA Cup Final and watch as they realise that Everton is a bigger club than they thought.

Paul Andrews
310 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:48:25
Looking at the posts above I think Moyes may get a surprise when he brings his team to Goodison.
Barry Rathbone
311 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:41:18
No Carl, your point was Moyes did no wrong, ie, his contract ran down and then he got into negotiation with Man Utd.

We now know Ferguson told Moyes not to sign during the season which most would interpret as being in negotiation with Man Utd WHILE running down the contract – not at the end.

The net effect of the secret dealings was no compo – it's very straightforward.

Well ........

Ross Edwards
312 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:49:36
Very good Mike. Money for nothing and all that...
Raymond Fox
313 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:10:43
I have to admit I find it perplexing why Everton supporters should apparently care so much about an ex-manager who, as seems extremely likely, has connived to cheat/fraud this club of millions of pounds in compensation.

Add to that, often attempting to belittle our new manager! I think you're carrying your loyalty to him too far, gents!

Ian Tunstead
314 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:45:53
Barry R. A few managers were in for Lukaku, including Sam Allardyce, so we just don’t know whether Moyes would have gone for Lukaku or not but we all knew we needed a striker so I think Moyes would have gone for him if he new he was available. Anyway from what I have read it was more thanks to Mirallas than Martinez. Barkley was always going to get into the team sooner rather than later especially with Neville retiring. Barkley has matured from a boy into a man and as a result has got stronger, faster and fitter he has also gained in confidence thanks to his loan spells that Moyes sent him on.

Ross, haha, a fluky win — Man U battered Sociedad, it should have been 4 or 5. It just shows once again the obsession and hatred in people. It's funny, Moyes seems to have this reputation on here for ruining strikers but it seems he is the one getting the best out of Rooney.

Carl Sanderson
315 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:55:02
Barry,

No. My point is that all these conspiracy theories about how Moyes allegedly did the dirty on Everton are ludicrous. One lad has just posted that this is the reason why we didn't win the FA Cup.

You may feel that he acted unethically but you would have a hard time convincing a jury that he did anything illegal. Everton were not tricked by Moyes: Kenwright should have protected our interests.

Ross Edwards
316 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:57:49
Seems to have ruined Van Persie though. 1 goal in 5 games Ian.

He isn't doing as well in the CL as you think Ian. He struggled to a draw against Shakhtar, who just got beaten 4-0 today, he only won 1-0 against Sociedad, who are bottom of the group, and conceded 2 at home to Leverkusen.

I can't see him advancing any further than the last 16. I don't. He'll bottle it just like he did against Sporting Lisbon, and that was in a half empty stadium in the UEFA Cup, God knows what he'd be like in a full stadium against the likes of Real Madrid or Barca.

Man U have the easiest group. They should be winning these games confortably, which Moyes doesn't do.

Ian Tunstead
317 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:57:26
Kevin, I made a prediction a few months ago before Martinez arrived I wasn’t afraid to stick my neck out and I’m still not. I never said we would be relegated because I think he will be sacked before it gets that far. My prediction was that we would be fighting relegation within 3 years of Martinez being manager.
Ross Edwards
318 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:03:11
Rooney didn't score Ian. It was an own goal.
Tony Cheek
319 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:01:58
Actually I would like to congratulate Moyes........he has tried to get Everton in front of United for 11 years, well he has finally done it....got to hand it to him, he doesnt give up till the job is done, well done mate!
Ross Edwards
320 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:04:31
Goodness me Ian. Unbelievable. Relegation candidates in 3 years. Who in their right mind as a Blue would confidently predict we could be relegated in 3 years.
Barry Rathbone
321 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:57:21
Ian the thing that kills that theory is a 10 million pound chelsea striker was available the previous season and Moyes didn't get him .... can you guess his name.

(hint: he went to WBA ).

Considering Chels had bought him it was probably a safe bet he was a good 'un.

Have to say I agreed with Moyes about Barkley he was indecisive and error prone - I should have known better as soon as Martinez got hold of him a different player arose.

Really don't think it coincidence.

Ross Edwards
322 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:06:34
These anti-Martinez arguments are just becoming dafter, and more ridiculous by the minute. Ian, do you seriously think we could be relegated by 2016?
Steve Pugh
323 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:59:40
Let's pretend Moyes is as thick as two short planks, the fact that the manager of the club that he signed for told him not to sign a new contract is as close to tapping up as it is possible to get and if Bill Kenwright doesn't sue United now he should be taken out into the middle of the Goodison pitch, tarred and feathered as a traitor to the Toffees.

Will all the Moyes lovers please give it a rest. By Moyes lovers I mean those that still love him, and those that loved him so much that they can't handle the fact that he dumped them and are constantly lashing out.

Kevin Rowlands
324 Posted 23/10/2013 at 21:59:18
Ian, do you think Martinez should get any credit for bringing in Delofeu? maybe we should give the credit for that to Oviedo as he speaks Spanish right? Was it Martinez fault that Neville played in our biggest game of last year, whilst Barkley and Gibson sat on the bench, sure it was he was there we were playing his team, Moyes would never do something that stupid. How were we all so naïve as to not realize that it was Moyes decision to loan out Barkley that made him the player he is today, the fact that Martinez has played him every game and throughout pre season plus constantly praising and supporting him has fuck all to do with it, right, if Moyes was still manager Ross would have been starting them England games and scored a hatfull, right. Crack on Ian.
Ian Tunstead
325 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:10:49
Ross, I know Rooney didn't score but it was his shot and his performance was superb. He is in the form of his life since Moyes arrived and Rooney himself said afterwards it is down to Moyes and his staff because he enjoying his football. Probably because Moyes is actually playing him in his favourite position.
Colin Glassar
327 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:11:42
After the last 24 hours I cannot believe there are still people who defend that unnameable little, ginger shyte.
Ross Edwards
328 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:14:49
So, he's no longer "an important option when Van Persie is out" Ian, as Moyes said within a week of taking over?

When Van Persie is back permanently, Rooney's goals will dry up once more.

Barry Rathbone
329 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:07:38
Carl, as I said on another post it always comes down to forensics with Moyes supporters you have to have finger prints and a taped confession.

You could ask 100 neutrals: "Do you think Fergie secretly telling Moyes not to sign a contract during his last season related to Moyes running his contract down to get the Man Utd job?

You wouldn't get one person saying "No." Ask 100 Evertonians and you would get one or two... madness.

Kevin Rowlands
330 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:20:32
Ian Tunstead — "I like and support Roberto Martinez but he will have us relegated within three years," Martinez = BAD, Moyes = GOOD, I'm convinced this is a wind-up at this stage, surely no-one can be this stupid?
Ian Tunstead
331 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:14:22
Ross, to be fair I made the prediction before I knew he was going to be the Everton manager.

Barry, which striker are you talking about? Surely not Anelka because I don’t think we can afford to be paying £10 million and striker over 30 with reputations for having attitude problems. And your right its not a coincidence that Ross is doing quite well because we all new he is a talented young player and he just needed the experience which he got thanks to Moyes sending him out on loan.

Colin Glassar
332 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:26:06
Kevin Rowlands, totally agree. He sounds like like a certain Dick Brady.
Ross Edwards
333 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:25:12
It's a weird way of showing your support for someone isn't it Kevin?

"I like and support him but he'll make us relegation candidates within 3 years".

I can't see the logic there at all, if any was used.

Desperation if I ever saw it. Obviously all the other arguments have been over clichéd by Phil Walling so Ian thought he could go one better and say that we will be in the Championship in 2 years time.

Barry Rathbone
334 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:26:44
Ian, Lukaku.

Frightening really you might think Moyes scouting system would be up to snuff on the likes of chelsea farming out top talent but it just didn't happen.

Martinez in here for 5 mins and the lad is wearing Royal blue.

Kevin Rowlands
335 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:24:37
Ross, Rooney's form has all of a sudden dramatically improved because of the man who was taking him to court for libel? its so ridiculous you just have to laugh, I would suggest its improved because he wants to prove a point to whisky nose, also how come no one else's form has improved dramatically, they've stunk the joint out, has to be Martinez fault if you ask me. Ian needs to put the Moysie blow up doll away for a while, he's wearing it out.
Ross Edwards
336 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:30:53
Yes, the same man who gave us Bilyaletdinov, Castilo, Kroldrup, Jo, Simon Davies and so on, I hardly think Lukaku was on his list.
Ian Bennett
337 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:32:09
Lukaku cost Chelsea about £20m I thought, and with Chelsea that would have been probably all up front. Everton signing him would be £20m over 20 years...
Ross Edwards
338 Posted 23/10/2013 at 22:32:26
Or maybe Ian because Barkley is well suited to Martinez's system. Chasing hoofballs everywhere isn't his thing.

Kevin

Or maybe it's Rooney's attempt at sucking up to Gollum to make up for their previous row.

Ste Traverse
347 Posted 23/10/2013 at 23:30:31
What a beaut this Tunstead bloke is.

So he's happy with Martinez, yet he'll make us relegation candidates within three years?? WTF is that all about???

Ian Hollingworth
348 Posted 23/10/2013 at 23:05:09
Wow I am flabbergasted reading these posts. How can some try and defend what some suspected and now has almost been confirmed by someone involved. The case for the defence seems to centre around that he did a good job for us??

Sorry, this is not about the job he did for us – that is a separate topic. This is about all the man stood for: integrity, honesty and let's not forget "The People's Club". For me, all of that has been thrown out of the window to reveal a dishonest hypocrite.

That statement has nothing to do with if he was ever one of us or not or how good a manager he may or may not be – it is about David Moyes, the man.

Ian Tunstead
349 Posted 23/10/2013 at 23:39:48
Ste, I was asked a question and answered it. A few people have took a few cheap shots and called me a wind up as if my opinion isn't valid. I have been insulted a number of times, so I think I should be able to defend myself, so if they can't take it don't dish it out. Let's try and stick to the football discussion, because I don't like to see a football discussion turn out like playground insults either. You are right though, I apologise for acting like a beaut and went too far.
Steven Telford
351 Posted 23/10/2013 at 23:53:20
There seem to be a lot of people jumping the gun here.........

Starbucks (legally) pays fuck all tax in the uk, now who do you blame for that? Them for not voluntarily not paying more than they have to, or the people who are supposed to design and administer the tax system? I blame the latter.

That Moyes acted in an unsavoury manner to everton is not in doubt. But the way its being famed my post posters here is completely OTT.

I could well believe (and am deeply hoping) that Martinez will be a better manager, certainly his football is more attractive, but don't people think it's all a bit early for us to be drawing grand conclusions for these sorts of things. Both men have something to prove.

Matt Woods
353 Posted 23/10/2013 at 23:31:18
Going with the OP, I was taken in originally by Moyes; however, after 5 seasons, the writing was on the wall. It became painfully clear that he was a coward and would never have the bottle to mix it with the big boys.

The fact that he earned megabucks to reduce expectations was in my opinion scandalous. However — and this is my point — modern-day football has no morals. Fans have such an enormous emotional investment that is completely absent from those inside the game. We like to believe in ethics and the Corinthian spirit; however, this is a global professional sport. Billions of pounds wash around in this business, and those in it do not give a fuck about you and me.

The worst thing about all of this, is that we were taken in and manipulated by Moyes... that's why it hurts. Nobody likes being taken for a mug. It's because we thought Moyes was honorable and no Happy Harry that he got away with so much.

Sadly football has been totally corrupted by money and celebrity but we need to be real when it comes to expectations of ethical behavior. I never liked Moyes because he was a shithouse manager... and, as the Mancs are slowly finding out, he is a fraud.

Ian Tunstead
354 Posted 24/10/2013 at 00:36:23
You see, Kevin, this is were it breaks down when the playground insults come out. Is it not possible for you to give your opinion without calling people a tit or a wind-up? To be honest I don't mind too much when the insults come out because to me it is a sign of desperation that the argument is lost, I don't like it however when people try to make out like I am not an Evertonian and that I am a wind-up.

Just because I have a different opinion to you doesn’t mean I am a wind-up, I will admit, when people start to take the piss being, sarcastic and dishing out the insult,s I return the favour, but I think most people would when provoked.

As for my obsession with Moyes, to be fair, I am going to discuss Moyes in this thread because that is what the original topic is about. You have admitted yourself you have been very childish and your comments about Moyes have been very petty in my opinion.

I am willing to support Martinez but I am an Everton fan first and if I don’t agree with something I will say so. I prefer to give constructive criticism rather than slag people off but if its okay for people to slag Moyes off then, I will slag Martinez off – especially when people are being hypocrites, as – for me – Moyes has done far more for Everton than Martinez.

As for questioning my loyalty for Everton because of my prediction that I made before he was even the Everton manager, I have heard many fans on here predicting we would be relegated while David Moyes was our manager, but I suppose that was okay because it's David Moyes and you didn’t like the guy, different rules apply.

Karl Masters
358 Posted 24/10/2013 at 01:00:57
Wow! If there is one person who gets a vitriolic 300 plus thread going again, it's OFM.

I would like to thank Old Whiskey Nose for putting in print what we all suspected all along. Of course, he's careful to start the comments from February so it looks like it all started after Moyes said he would see if we made Champions League before signing, just as he doesn't like that Rooney hasn't officially asked to leave and therefore waive loyalty fees etc.

It just proves what a rotten barrel football is, full of grasping bastards trying to pile millions on top of millions and saying whatever they need to say to do it.

Moyes, Ferguson, Rooney — all cunts. Ferguson arrogant enough to know he will ruffle a few feathers, but if Andy Murray publicly says, "I haven't read a book for years, but I'll be reading this one!' he will make even more money and get even more attention.

Derby tickets went on general sale today. General sale! Our fanbase is growing greyer and older and a lot of us are fed up with this money-obsessed circus. Where's it all heading?

Finally, I wonder if Roberto is going to turn out as big a cash cock as the rest of them? You'd love to think not and maybe the behaviour of Ferguson, Moyes and Rooney is a very British thing of working class not being able to handle new money? Guess that time will tell...

Steven Telford
359 Posted 24/10/2013 at 01:18:18
The problem with looking for the sort of loyalty that we may once have had a right to expect, is that "mobility" in football is pretty much gone. If you achieve success with a mediocre sort of club, your reward is that a big club buys you ..... and that's one of the main reasons that Loyalty has gone out the window.

I hope Moyes rots at Man Utd, but only because of his brazen and disrespectful approach for Fellaini and Baines.

Actually, that raises an interesting point: to be consistent, are people on this forum going to turn on Baines if he leaves in January? I mean, Moyes probably talked to him... just like Ferguson talked to Moyes.

Karl Masters
360 Posted 24/10/2013 at 01:41:12
Good point Steven. Do we let Baines run his contract down too? He will be 30 by then, but letting him go for nothing would be a scandal. Hopefully he will sign a new deal, but this season at Everton is critical in that respect.

If you were Leighton you would see what happens at the World Cup, keep your options open till next Summer. If he has to make a decision then how Everton are looking will be part of the equation. Good chance of silverware and he may take a bumper new deal and sign on till 33, same old same old and he will go elsewhere, still on a bumper deal as transfer fee will be less as only a year left.

Gerry Quinn
361 Posted 24/10/2013 at 02:31:55
Bainesy won't go - he is older than we think...
Harold Matthews
362 Posted 24/10/2013 at 02:40:01
"He's a lost soul in an alien landscape, treading gingerly on the shifting sands of indecision." (anon).
Matt Hunter
363 Posted 24/10/2013 at 04:07:59
Looking at some of the discussion on here, in particular between Ross and Ian, it's really interesting and also sad. I love this website but I can't really bring myself to post on here because of some of the attacks on our own people.

I only missed four of Moyes's home games in the 11½ years he was in charge and I can tell you he did an outstanding job at the club because my memory of life under Walter Smith & Howard Kendall is that it was a living hell. He changed the image of the club.

Now I am very disappointed in him since he left as obviously he has been shown to be a liar and a hypocrite but he still managed my football club for over 11 years and did the very best he could. Some of you on here who curse him and call him all the names under the sun are pathetic.

Loyalty and respect is a two way street. He was a part of our football club for 11 years. OK, so now he is on the other side of the fence, but we have a better manager now anyway, so why so bitter? He's gone now, who cares? He is clearly limited in many aspects and we are better off with our new manager but the name-calling and short memories shown on here needs to stop.

As for all the talk about him holding us back for the past so many years, and the need for change sooner, that was always being called for on this site, often by the people who run the site. I wonder can anyone tell me which managers we were actually a better option for us than Moyes during the past 11 years?
Paul Andrews
364 Posted 24/10/2013 at 06:07:37
Ian, not a wind up. Besides steering us away from the lower end of the table and solidifying the club what are your thoughts on the achievements of Moyes over the last 6 years of his time at Everton?

"He did a lot more for Everton than Martinez has."

Lyndon Lloyd
365 Posted 24/10/2013 at 06:22:53
Matt, I agree with a lot of what you say and I'm glad you felt comfortable enough to dip your oar in – Lord knows we need some fresh opinions, particularly on this tired topic.

The fact remains that, as optimistic as things seem to be under the new regime, it's too early in Martinez's Everton reign to say that he is an improvement on Moyes and that our former manager was "holding us back."

While I'd be lying if I said I wasn't quietly enjoying his challenges at Old Trafford, it's much too early to declare that Moyes is a limited manager who will be found out as such at United. It certainly *looks* that way so far; I'm really enjoying Martinez's fresh, optimistic outlook, and his handling of Barkley is one area where he really has shown his predecessor up. But it's just too early to make determinations one way or another.

At the *very least*, Moyes's tenure should be regarded as successful in what he achieved in turning our club around and providing the platform of annual top-eight finishes on which Martinez can try and launch us to the next level. Moyes's conduct over the summer, the manner in which he walked out leaving us with nothing, and his sour demeanour in general make it so easy to hurl insults at him; I prefer to just move on.

Sam Hoare
366 Posted 24/10/2013 at 07:05:34
Matt Hunter, excellent post.
Wayne Smyth
367 Posted 24/10/2013 at 07:40:28
Matt, it's very simple as to why some people dislike him and take great pleasure in now seeing him fail:

He went out of his way to belittle and damage our club after he left with his comments and actions. We're all Everton fans. It's only natural that we dislike people who try to hurt the club.

I'd agree with most of the points you say about the job he did for the majority of the time he was with us. Many managers leave under good terms. He chose to sour the relationship with the manner in which he did things after he left.

Stuart Gray
368 Posted 24/10/2013 at 07:36:47
Matt, Lyndon – I completely agree. I've switched off a bit from these posts – in fact I haven't really read many of them because I know what the conversation will be. I just look at the recent comments on the homepage and if something grabs me (such as "Matt Hunter, excellent post." then I'll have a read.

The fact is that Moyes probably stayed 5 or 6 years too long – but before that he did an excellent job in taking us from relegation candidates every year.

Yes, he's treated us poorly recently. It's like your best friend suddenly turning on your mum. You're going to be hurt and bitter about it. He'll no longer be your best friend and you'll hope the worst for him. But you have to move on and realise your new best friend seems more fun, actually.

David Chait
369 Posted 24/10/2013 at 07:39:48
I couldn't be arsed to read this post at all as I knew where it would spiral. Seeing in the comments section your post, Lyndon, got me to open it up. And thanks Matt for bringing back the middle ground... A place supporters fall from so easily.

I'm in the camp that thanks him for what he did... Wanted him to go but never hated him. I was just frustrated at times as I believed he was sometimes so close to moving us forward but would retract at the worst time. I actually wanted to see him succeed at OT... and he still might.

There is a little interest in the perceptions the Man Utd fans have of him and saying maybe we were right in thinking he was over-appreciated by non-Everton fans. Unlike us with RM, I don't see their fans giving him any time. They expect success from Day 1, and nothing wrong with that when that is all you know.

Adam Baig
370 Posted 24/10/2013 at 08:33:11
Matt. I may be a little bitter, but when you say 'he changed the image of our club' – did he change it for the better? I'm not sure.

In the late '60s and mid '80s, we were THE team, the School of Science. When we started to look good under Kendall, you could sense an uprising – Everton were back!

It's hard to imagine another uprising in my lifetime. We have become a likeable 'second team' – gutsy Everton, punching above their weight, 'hard to beat'. Easy to have as a second team cos we will never win anything.

For me, Moyes was complicit in the gross mis-management of our club. There are seven clubs who have enjoyed every season of the Premier League gravy train – when you take a look at the stadiums of the other 6 and compare them to Goodison Park, it becomes obvious just how badly the mis-management is....

Kevin Tully
371 Posted 24/10/2013 at 09:28:39
Matt #441.

I completely agree Moyes turned things around when he took over, but I find it a little strange that we always had to go back 12-15 years to justify his tenure at times.

If he was here this season, no doubt we would have heard the same excuses made for him of "I remember the Walter days"

Will anyone say this if Martinez finshes 8th/9th? No chance.

People conveniently forget Moyes had money at times here, had a highly paid squad, and generally got the full backing of the fans, the Board and the club as a whole - he should have achieved what he did.

Not having a go - but can we please stop mentioning the 90's as some sort of yardstick for comparing managers?

It's now irrelevant, and has been for the past 6 or 7 years.

Barry Rathbone
372 Posted 24/10/2013 at 09:07:32
I'm gonna put this out there and I really don't care if I get my posts blocked for the umpteenth time for upsetting the sensitive.

People who say "forget it, move on" (Lyndon Lloyd et al) are a completely different type of Evertonian to those of my family and friends who grew up in Liverpool spending thousands going to GP and following the team through thick and thin.

Shrugging the shoulders with a c'est la vie nonchalance as people damage my club is simply wrong imo.

This has nothing to do with Moyes being a good or bad coach — it's all about abusing his position, lying to the fans, and effectively feathering his own nest at the expense of "our" club.

It is undeniable Moyes's behaviour colluding with Ferguson is wrong on just about every level and very likely against the rules of the game. The pair should be held accountable via the fury of the fans and most definitely official channels from the club.

A recent post involved the "small time" reference to this club – walking away whistling dixie upon discovering another club manipulated your manager during a live season is as good a definition of "small time" as I can think of.

I will rail against this because every Evertonian I know thinks Moyes's behaviour absolutely stinks and he should not walk away Scot free.

I might add, if this comes over to any of our global community as a dig, so be it. Everton are a Merseyside club and scousers don't take kindly to having their noses rubbed in it and treated as fools.

By all means support the club in your own way but a bit of "when in Rome" applies here.

Sam Hoare
373 Posted 24/10/2013 at 09:55:42
Kevin, it's not about people going back 11-15 years it's just about saying what you started with and where you took it. Moyes started with a team that flirted consistently with relegation and left us with a team that flirted consistently with Europe. Of course the Walter days are less relevant to Martinez's reign because, unlike Moyes, he inherited a team that was established in the top 7.
Richard Tarleton
374 Posted 24/10/2013 at 10:09:41
I've no time for Moyes and believe he's a poor, defensive-minded manager who'll fail to get Man Utd into a Champions League place next season, but to castigate a man for not taking an opportunity to improve his salary and status in his job is plainly ridiculous. Only fans are loyal to clubs, the rest are merely working for an employer.
Stuart Gray
375 Posted 24/10/2013 at 10:26:10
Barry, I wouldn't disagree with your sentiments, but having the same argument time after time is like watching the same episode of Last of the Summer Wine every day. It wasn't great to start with, and now it's just crazy.

I don't think many would disagree that Moyes has acted disgracefully recently and I hope he fails miserably. But repeating the same argument over and over doesn't actually achieve anything. At a time when we actually can be positive about something, it's just a bit sad to see.

Kevin Tully
376 Posted 24/10/2013 at 10:19:19
That's a poor argument Sam - Every club goes through a bad patch, that doesn't mean a current team, Board, or manager can use it as some sort of benchmark for years to come.

I will give you an example of how much can be achieved in 10 years - Swansea.

Every time they put a poor performance in, I doubt their fans say "Well, we were nearly out of existence ten years ago, so that's okay."

Carl Sanderson
377 Posted 24/10/2013 at 08:28:22
Matt 441, Lyndon 460:

Your excellent posts sum things up well. Balance, insight, moderation - rare commodities.

Sam Hoare
378 Posted 24/10/2013 at 10:50:52
Kevin, I didn't say it should be used to evaluate performance by performance but more as a marker of the progress or lack of it during a manager's tenure. The point being that, although things were going stale for the last few years, a comparison with Walter smith era shows how Moyes moved the club forward during his reign. Only the most closed minded of individuals could fail to see that.
Barry Rathbone
379 Posted 24/10/2013 at 10:48:08
Stuart, trouble is the same old arguments are being concluded, ie the idea Moyes was prevaricating over his contract for anything other than self-interest was conclusively demolished just 48 hrs ago.

This point is of the moment not historic; should we just say "Ah it's Man Utd – they are allowed control over us?" I'm all for letting Moyes, Ferguson and Man Utd know, in no uncertain terms, no they can't.

As I said in the Homeland, all my Evertonian contingent are of the same mind.

Kevin Tully
380 Posted 24/10/2013 at 11:02:46
Of course not Sam - but what relevance Walter Smith has 15 years later is difficult for me to comprehend.

Do we still have some of his players in the squad?

Smith, Walker, & HK3 should never be mentioned again, but you can be sure some would have brought it up if ginge was still here.

Do Liverpool fans say - "we're lucky really, remember Souness, or Hodgson?"

The whole of football has been through a revolution this past 15 years, even Everton have their pick of players from around the globe for 㿞 grand a week or more.

Those dark days have the same bearing on our current situation as the glory days in the 80's - none.

Just because we have changed manager, it doesn't mean the relegation struggles were any less, or more relevant.

Sam Hoare
381 Posted 24/10/2013 at 11:18:00
The only relevance Kevin is as I said in assessing Moyes's tenure because Smith was his immediate predecessor. I agree that it has no pertinent relevance to Martinez's reign.
Graham Mockford
382 Posted 24/10/2013 at 11:09:28
Barry,

Moyes was undoubtedly prevaricating out of self interest, this upsets you more than it does me.

What that doesn't mean is that you are in some way a better Evertonian. You are however perfectly entitled to keep picking at the scab, others have moved on.

Brent Stephens
383 Posted 24/10/2013 at 11:23:41
Matt 441, Lyndon 460. Welcome moderating comments.

There were views of the Scottish Manager before we heard he was leaving, views of him as a manager and about his personality. Those views have been changed by many as we learnt of his departure, and with the more we learn.

I can understand that views of his personality (honesty etc) have changed as we've learned more. I hope, though, nobody is changing their view of him as a manager for us just because of that (now that would be dishonest - not a positive personality trait!). But I do sense (no more than that) that these things have become conflated.

So that's history, it's all been said, ad nauseum. Then there's the future in terms of the wish-list - wanting him to fail, or not, at MU. For many that's driven by their view of his personality. For me, I don't really care. What I do want is for EFC to achieve and, on the way, MU to fail.

And then there's the future as prediction and judgement of managers at their new clubs. Many enjoying the Scottish Manager's recent failure with a sort of "I told you say". But if we value honesty, and have said that Roberto deserves time before he can be judged at his current club, I guess in all honesty you have to say the same about the Scottish one.

I enjoy the debates on TW but there's become a pack mentality against a few guys who have held a contrary opinion to the majority. I sense that some relish that more than the substance of the debate itself.


Peter Lee
384 Posted 24/10/2013 at 11:51:35
I think this must be the longest thread I’ve seen on TW, prompted by the self-interested ramblings of a rather unpleasant old Scot who couldn’t lie down straight.

In today’s Telegraph, one article describes the whole book as a paean of praise for Paul Scholes, as the antithesis of other players. It is as if Scholes is praised for all his qualities and others are damned with fainter praise because of their lack of some of those same qualities, clearly qualities the old megalomaniac sees in himself.

Perhaps he used the same excuses in his own playing days for crude and dangerous tackles. He was always making them for Scholes. Scholes was a gifted player, no doubt, but brave was not a word I would use of him.

I remember a reserve game when we were getting comfortably beaten 3-0 and we had a corner. The ball was cleared and came towards Richard Dunne in the centre circle. Scholes was chasing it and set himself for a flying two-footed lunge, appeared to look up at Dunne and pulled out as he hit the floor, Dunne drove through, the ball took a slight deflection and went straight in the top corner. Dunne stood over Scholes and made the W sign. For all Scholes’s skills, I never saw reason to disagree with Richard on that.

The manager appears to me to have always tried to bully others and he largely got away with it. I recall a story from a match official who was at OT for the first time. Having been left with the ref and his fellow assistant to find their own way to what he describes as the worst facilities in the Premier League, the officials were treated to a visit from everyone’s favourite Glaswegian. Getting straight in the referee’s face, he abused him and demanded how long he was going to give Keano before booking him this time, 5 minutes, 10 or longer?

The ref did nothing and after they were left alone it was explained that that was not unusual. Sure enough, in the first couple of minutes, Keane took out the opposition main man with a tackle that merited a straight red and he wasn’t booked.

The question nobody has had the courage to ask of the man is why he left the squad in such dire straits. My only Man Utd supporting mate explained on Cup Final day that everyone knew that they didn’t have anything like a good enough midfield and in his view there were up to 8 players at the club who weren’t up to snuff.

From that point of view, Moyes has taken on a job which is far bigger than that which he started at Everton. With us, he had an aging and underperforming, overpaid team; if we had gone down in the first few years, nobody would have been surprised. Expectations, though never hope, were not great. Credit to him for changing those.

With them, he has an aging and disparate squad; neutral commentators would not be surprised to see them having to work desperately hard to secure CL football. The difference is two-fold. Firstly there is money to spend and secondly expectations are such that he won’t get three years to show that he can’t do it. If he does, all credit to him.

With regard to the rest of the thread, football is a job. We tap up players, we have tapped up managers in the past. For all kinds of reasons, some certainly self-serving, everyone in the game tells lies. Get on with it.

Tony J Williams
385 Posted 24/10/2013 at 13:03:34
"Moyes was prevaricating over his contract for anything other than self interest"

Of course it was, it's his own personal contract, nothing to do with his players or the club. It's about what HE gets paid and what HIS powers are. That's what personal contract are....ermmm, personal!

Brian Waring
386 Posted 24/10/2013 at 13:20:45
Listening to the radio last night, Manc fans saying under Moyes they have become Everton, playing in red.

Ian, not being funny, but how you can give Moyes any credit for Barkley just because he sent him out on loan is a joke. As soon as Barkley made a mistake he was dropped like a lead balloon by Moyes, that must have done the lad's confidence right in.

John Keating
387 Posted 24/10/2013 at 13:43:27
The thing about Moyes is that he was a two-faced bastard – pure and simple.

Unfortunately we supporters are amongst the most stupid gullible people when it comes to our Club and those that play and work for it. In any other industry, if a new employee was to say he loved the firm, wished he'd worked here since he left school, wanted to stay here for the rest of his life etc etc - we'd probably sack him immediately on the spot!! Because it's our Club we lose all sense of reality.

Moyes was a mercenary. He was a mercenary from day one, we just couldn't see/accept it. Moyes was well paid but never had the class or the guts to do the right thing when it came to the last year of his contract.

As many have said, it is an age thing. When I hear that the Moyes era was a "success", I cringe and think back to the early sixties when my first truly successful team was on show.

Everyone has a right to their opinion and mine is that Moyes was a two faced lying bastard who had no guts or class!

Steve Brown
388 Posted 24/10/2013 at 13:27:00
Moyes would definitely chuckle reading this post as we are spending far more time thinking of him than he will be about us - good manager, restored the club to a stable base, had to go because he won nothing in 11 years. He got what he saw as a better offer and negotiated his new job while still in his old job. That was hardly a shocker as it is how I've landed every new job I've had.

I actually hope he does okay in his new job, as I want British managers in the mix for top jobs, growing and signing British players. Actually Martinez shows a great willingness to invest in youth (honorary Brit) and might actually prove good enough to manage a top 6 club. Early signs are very promising but it will be a lot clearer by Xmas.

Ian Burns
389 Posted 24/10/2013 at 13:28:18
Ian B here, not Ian T - so don't kick me, I'm too old!

Matt 441 - Lyndon 460 and Stuart 464 - I think you have each stepped in at the right time as the thread, understandably in many ways, has become so vitriolic that there is a sense of enjoyment being taken out of the theme.

Passion has been shown and has been aired and I fully understand Barry 472 because I am too from a long line of true blue EFC fans going back far too many years!

However, I think the majority have spoken and the time has come to move on and spend our energy supporting RM's new regime.

That is not to forget what Moyes has done to this club since the beginning of this year and the fans can let him know how they feel when he next visits the Old Lady but it is somewhat heartbreaking to see the passion spilling over into insults which on occasion have overstepped the mark, in my opinion (old twat I know).

I can't count the time I have spent reading this thread but may I make a personal request to say, point made - RM's in charge, let's get behind him.

Whoever said EFC relegated in 3 years by the way cannot be an EFC supporter, not possible. Even if I thought it, I could never express it unless we were 10 points adrift with 3 games left!

Carl Sanderson
391 Posted 24/10/2013 at 15:47:11
Steve 505:

I include your post with Matt's and Lyndon's, well-balanced and thoughtful. I disagree, however, that Moyes "had to go". Kenwright would have signed him up for another five years without blinking an eye. He never got the chance and to my mind he is the reason for the shambles at the end of last season.

I note that Wayne Rooney today said that working under Moyes and his staff has given him a new lease of life.

Callum McNab
394 Posted 24/10/2013 at 15:23:49
I love these comments about the success we had under Moyes.

Last time I can remember, winning fuck all for nearly 11 years isn't being successful.

Colin Glassar
396 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:21:18
Callum McNab, it might be an age thing. If you were born in 1990 then you were probably too young to remember our last cup success so the Moyes years might be considered 'successful'. Not you obviously but some of the Moyes fans on here who consider his reign as a success.
Carl Sanderson
397 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:21:47
Callum,

The success was relative, obviously. I remember when the spectre of relegation, as they call it, didn't just loom over us: its icy hand clutched our vitals. Years of shite football, eight defenders on the pitch, 0-0 draws, etc ad nauseam.

Moyes stabilised the squad, revamped the scouting system, and gave us numerous top-eight finishes in the league. No, he didn't win a trophy, but we came very close in '09. (I firmly believe that we'd've won that trophy if Jags, Arteta and Yak had played.)

And all on a shoestring budget, thanks to Widow Twanky.

Barry Rathbone
398 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:34:43
Callum it is entirely relative those of us of a certain age put the Walter years in a different context to younger fans it was a small shite period not a definition of EFC — far from it.

Moyes's arrival was the start of a return to what most thought as our rightful place at the top table. Unfortunately, it was not to be... arguments about Why will endure till we next win something.

I always say judgement of the past decade is coloured hugely by how long you have supported Everton.

Richard Reeves
399 Posted 24/10/2013 at 13:15:32
Can we all just agree Moyes is a twat and let him know about it when he visits us or when we visit them? And if someone starts applauding or breaking out into "Oh, Davie Moyes", then someone, anyone, give that person a cuff round the back of the head or, failing that, a bloody good slap.
Jimmy Kelly
400 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:24:11
Barry, I'm a born and bred scouser and I'd put my house on the fact my family's spent at least as much as yours on following Everton, and yet i'm not a pompous, arrogant, 'superfan' idiot who pours scorn on the very people who make our club what it is. So keep your ill informed and frankly embarrassing comments about what 'we' are like to yourself.
Dave Arrow
401 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:07:25
To those sat on their high ground telling others to move on, what is wrong with a vigorous debate about the circumstances that lead to last season ending in March?

Courtesy of the story teller new information has come to light that is worthy of discussion and joins up a lot of dots.

Most of us are quite capable of moving forward whilst also looking in the rear view mirror.

I'm with Barry Rathbone on this one. Going to senior school in Liverpool in the '70s when our neighbours were winning everything in sight was character-building to say the least. All we had was Big Bob's 30 goals, Kings Drive and two replays in the League Cup Final.

I have balance and a rational approach to most aspects in my life but when it comes to Everton I get very tribal and protective. After what we've suffered, I'm a fully paid-up member of the Grassy Knoll Club and the Schadenfreude Society. It's a product of my teenage years that I haven't shaken off.

Move on... so we get a dodgy decision in the forthcoming derby match and the threads will be full of every bad decision we've had since Clive Thomas.

Moyes stayed too long and was allowed to stay too long. Gratitude for giving us our dignity back was gradually replaced by a frustration at choking in big games along with the clever manipulation of expectations which always grated.

These latest shenanigans have tarnished him further because, no matter what he did in the 11 years, he took us for patsies in the end.

Barry Rathbone
402 Posted 24/10/2013 at 17:27:45
Jimmy Kelly you need to be specific so I can address what you are blathering so emotively about - you just seem to be stamping your feet about some made up "super fan" guff.

Please explain so I can deal with you without resorting to name calling!!

Andy Riley
403 Posted 24/10/2013 at 17:23:49
This is really about trophies. Those of us above a certain age remember Catterick, Kendall Mark 1 and to a certain extent Joe Royle because they all won something. Bingham and Lee both came close to winning the League but ultimately failed. Similarly Moyes will ultimately be considered alongside them, Harvey, Smith, and Kendall's other stints as being essentially failures whereas the jury is still out on RM but he has a chance to join the icons. Moyes has gone and we all need to move on from his failures however glorious some consider them bearing in mind the overall circumstances!
Nick Entwistle
404 Posted 24/10/2013 at 17:43:01
Maybe fans of a certain age need to take off their rose-tinted glasses and remind themselves that the good times under Catterick and Kendall which they base their idea of success on makes up about 15% of the club's history. The remainder was below the record of the man they criticise who was a year shy of equaling the club's record run in the top 8 which is the man's failure.

Those of this vintage seem incapable of ascertaining the influence money plays in the pursuit of success in the modern game. It's no longer a squad of 16 Brits with two places on the subs bench.

That you could take your pick of players from the 14 teams without money and not be close to any of the 6 teams who do will mean little... maybe you can when you include Everton players in that 14 but that's dangerously close to a positive towards the former manager – even if he couldn't make a cash signing in 5 out of his last 7 transfer windows.

And none of the managers who won trophies before had the CL casting its shadow, making the clubs who don't have their chance of qualifying as second rate opportunities in the eyes of the best players.

Would Royle have been in for Kanchelskis in this era? And would Kanchelskis have signed? Answer – we couldn't afford him or his wages.

That's modern day football. It's far from perfect but has changed out of all recognition from the last time we won a trophy, or got close to a League Title.

You know, the days when music had a tune you could whistle to...


Steve Brown
405 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:06:01
Barry, Jimmy Kelly was referring to post 472 when you say you are a more authentic fan than the likes of Lyndon et al.

Barry Rathbone
407 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:31:44
Steve Brown, you said that not me - nothing like.

I've purposely avoided that shifty little interpretation because I think it says more about those alluding to it ie they can't read.

Dan Brierley
408 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:14:35
One thing that is clear, it is far too early to call Martinez a saviour, but by the same token it's too early to also write off Moyes at United.

Has Moyes come back for players? Yes, and that did piss me off. But Martinez has hardly been respectful to his old club, who are now mid table in the Championship.

I think Eric Myles has called this spot on. Those most vocal are the same people who were adamant that Moyes would never win a trophy, or be offered a job at a top club. The embarrassment seems to have driven some people to want him to fail EVEN MORE badly at United, hence this obsession that leads to extremes such as trawling United websites to bask in the difficulties of the current situation at Old Trafford. It's like those fellas that hope their ex goes on to have a shit life because they were dumped, and unable to get over it.

Whatever United or Moyes has done to us, is no different to what we or Martinez has done to Wigan.

But what is important now, is whether or not these changes turn out for the best for Everton. If Martinez takes us to the CL as he has promised, Moyes will not even make the footnote of Everton's start to the millennium. I hope everything that can be said about Moyes now has been, and we can focus on our own team instead.

Barry Rathbone
409 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:38:58
Nick, how did you get 15%?
Nick Entwistle
410 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:43:41
A complex series of quadratic equations combined with poorly considered guestimate.

John Keating
411 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:31:15
Nick

What do you mean "base their IDEA of success"?? That sounds as if they weren't successful periods in our history, just our interpretation.

Let's not try and rewrite history here. Catterick with Moores's money won us titles and a Cup. Kendall with very little money won us titles and a Cup. Now I really don't know about you but that to me looks pretty successful and NOT an idea/interpretation of success.

As far as I'm concerned, Moyes is on par with Gordon Lee and Billy Bingham. They had workmanlike teams that didn't achieve anything during their tenures.

To listen to you and a few others, Moyes was some sort of Saviour that saved us from fuck knows what. What do you have to back up the assertion that we would have been relegated had Moyes not dropped in from another dimension?

If Martinez over the next 4-5 seasons keeps us in the top eight, is he going to be classed as a hero like Moyes?

Nick Entwistle
412 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:49:21
I've never made that assertation John.

As for 'their idea of success' - if I were to edit rather than just type and click send I'd rewrite that as 'their experience of success'.

Not that it was the crux of the post.

Barry Rathbone
413 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:53:16
Nick, Ahhh! I get it, you popped in the caveat cutting off EFC history at the 60s.

Tremendous work because those of us with older family members obviously ignored their tales of Mercer, Dixie, Lawton, Sagar etc and didn't embrace them as our own.

Remarkable nonsense.

Dan Brierley
415 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:50:17
Martinez own words was that he will take us to the CL. If he achieves that he will certainly be a saviour that eclipses anything that Moyes achieved. If he doesn't get us to the CL, and wins nothing in 11 years then he will be lesser to Moyes, based on the quality of squads they both inherited. Martinez now has arguably the best squad since we won the title. But it is aging, so if we don't achieve in the next three years it might become a lot more difficult.
Si Cooper
416 Posted 24/10/2013 at 17:58:44
No problem with DM looking to move on and keeping his options open in order to take advantage of any attractive offers that came his way.

However, couldn't he have signed a contract with Everton that left these options open whilst ensuring the club some level of compensation? This has become fairly standard with players and so surely the same could apply to managers who are getting paid equivalent wages.

Would Man Utd really have baulked at appointing SAF's chosen successor for a few million pounds extra? Instead it seems that our club has missed out on a sum that would make a difference. That money has bolstered the manager's deal or simply stayed in the coffers of a mega wealthy club, and Fergie gets to crow about how he did things to benefit his club. That is annoying, so why are people having a go at the people who are annoyed by it?

Personally, I am not particularly interested in the opinions of people who justify poor behaviour by maintaining that 'everyone does it'.

Ross Edwards
417 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:00:16
Dan, when did Martinez say that?

Bill claimed that in his cringeworthy press conference.

Nick Entwistle
418 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:56:51
No, to both Barrys. Posters above have used these two managers' form as a way of defining their experience and age to separate from those of us too young to appreciate when times were good and thus have a different perspective.


As you say... "I always say judgement of the past decade is coloured hugely by how long you have supported Everton."

Carl Sanderson
419 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:00:29
"If Martinez over the next 4-5 seasons keeps us in the top eight is he going to be classed as a hero like Moyes ?"

That is actually an excellent question. If our business model remains the same, then my answer would be a resounding yes.

Ross Edwards
420 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:09:25
He'll be more heroic than Moyes, especially if he wins at Anfield, plus more successful.
Nick Entwistle
421 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:06:30
"If Martinez over the next 4-5 seasons keeps us in the top eight is he going to be classed as a hero like Moyes ?"

Or classed a fuckwit?

Moyes was never classed a hero when he had the money in the first half of his tenure, but used it well. Top 4, three seasons in Europe etc.

Then the money dried up which is when he really earned his wages. It wasn't until the whistle blew on game 35 that the top 4 wouldn't happen last season.

He had, to repeat, five windows out of seven when he couldn't make a cash signing.

If Martinez can keep us as close as Moyes did under these circumstances then he won't be considered a success from those who dismiss this attainment (not success) by Moyes.

That said, what Roberto has spent on loans this season would have had Moyes cough out a lung. Martinez gets the Sky windfall money, and good luck to him.

Barry Rathbone
422 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:06:51
Carl there is a lot more to judge on than the tarnished best of the rest title.

Fortunately RM seems in tune with it, I doubt his aspirations lay solely with upper mid table existence for a decade no matter how much we pay him.

Dan Brierley
423 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:15:02
He said it during his interview with Kenwright Ross, apparently his ambition and belief we will get to the CL under him was one of the reasons he got the job.
Nick Entwistle
424 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:17:54
Nicely dodged Barry.
Barry Rathbone
425 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:27:01
More of a swerve really nick.
Ross Edwards
426 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:23:30
Do you believe ANYTHING Billy says Dan?

Nick, you say he spent well in his tenure, but I recall him blowing nearly £40 million on a load of flops like Richard Wright for £3.5 million, Per Krøldrup for £5 million, Beattie for £6.5 million, The Yak, so good he is now in China, for £11.5 million, Bilyaletdinov for £10 million, Jelavic is becoming a flop at £5.5 million, as well as some poorly judged loans: Jo??, Castillo, Shandy Andy, couldn't even control Drenthe.

More sour grapes from the Moyesists as most of our spending, on McCarthy, came from the Fellaini and Anichebe sales on deadline day, so Martinez spent £6 million on Kone, £1 million on Joel, and bought McCarthy from the Fellaini money, so he has £20 million to spend in January.

Just ridiculous the lengths the anti-Martinez group can go to with the aim of smearing him after 8 games in charge.

Nick Entwistle
427 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:29:53
A Fellaini pirouette.
Dan Brierley
429 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:30:19
So what do you think he said Ross? 'I think I can not do better than Moyes, but give me the job anyway?'

I sincerely hope he does have genuine ambition to our get us to the CL. If he hasn't, what's the point in him being here?

Barry Rathbone
430 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:32:56
Nick as the more erudite of the "give Moyes the benefit of the doubt" viewpoint, what's your take on the "Ferguson talking to young Davie" saga?
Ross Edwards
431 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:36:04
Dan, I felt truly embarrassed watching that press conference and you could tell Martinez was uncomfortable when Bill said that.

Why would he be uncomfortable if he did indeed say that? It was Bill being Bill, trying to hog the limelight as usual, putting unnecessary pressure on Martinez, and something for his opposition, the likes of Entwistle and Walling, to bring up time and time again to bring him down.

Nick Entwistle
432 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:35:49
See post 067, Barry.

If he was approached earlier than the official narrative, the way it was handled was the only conceivable way out.

There's just too much we don't know.

Wayne Smyth
434 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:30:01
Nick, what has Martinez spent on loans this season?

We have Barry, Lukaku and Deulofeu. I believe Lukaku's loan fee was around ١M, but I've no idea about the others, or infact what they're costing salary-wise.

Its worth also putting into perspective that he's probably recouped in cash, a lot more than he's actually spent on loans or transfers, yets still managed take our squad to another level in terms of quality and strength in depth.

Barry Rathbone
435 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:40:39
Nick, I reckon Moyes could have just said "look I've had 11 good years" - this WILL be my last campaign at Everton" and I for one would have accepted that (cheered him actually .. ahem!)

He could have phoned who he wanted when he wanted and vice versa without question. I reckon Fergie wasn't definitive in his decision and Moyes hedged his bets - not a good enough reason to justify things for me.

Pure luck it's worked out but such machinations will never be acceptable to me - especially given the real financial penalty we suffered.

Raymond Fox
436 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:39:21
On the argument about Moyes getting us into the top 4, I'll hazard a guess that its much harder to achieve now than back then, because of the extra number of millionaires investing their fortunes into Man City, Man Utd, RS, etc. I haven't researched it, so I stand to be corrected!
Barry Rathbone
438 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:59:14
Wayne, I think that is very relevant.

Manipulation of the loan system particularly from the elite clubs with disgruntled talent hanging around could be a real winner for RM already his rep is growing for good footy and clearly he is a motivator - quite looking forward to january tbh.

Raymond, deffo agree throw in Spurs getting their act together and it is tougher - but we do have Roberto!

Joe Bibb
440 Posted 24/10/2013 at 20:05:10
The only place Moyes should have been was in the Everton Board Room explaining he was not going to sign his contract, not in Fergie's house drinking the finest Scotch.

It took eleven long years to get rid of the negative sod. I think it might be less than eleven months before the Manc get shut.

I am just glad he has gone.

Oh by the way wasn't it an illegal approach by Manchester United?


Nick Entwistle
441 Posted 24/10/2013 at 20:17:24
Barry, I'm sure you've complained about being Utd's lap dogs like all of us, so why should Moyes just be the one to announce his leaving?

He had his targets for the season as much as Ferguson did. Fergie wasn't stating he was leaving in Feb or Christmas etc because why unsettle the squad in its chase for the title? Why should Moyes in the pursuit of 4th and what turned out to be a half decent cup run.

Also, there was no financial penalty, but neither was there financial recompense due.

If he did announce what you feel, then we'd still have him at Utd with this thread going on wondering when the hell did he really know he was off to Utd.

Ian Riley
442 Posted 24/10/2013 at 22:08:42
Who would let a contract run down at a club he has full control and no expectations from a chairman who pays him a salary worthy of a Champions League club?

Mr Moyes did a good job over the 11 years with our financial situation and towards the end, our style of football was improving. However, if Mr Ferguson had advised our manager, still under contract at EFC, not to sign a contract, is that tapping up?

I was a fan of Mr Moyes believing he had the club at heart. He knew the financial situation at the club and compensation for him would have helped the club pay Wigan for our current manager.

I still believe we don't know the truth about the manager leaving and compensation. If Mr Moyes was allowed to run his contract down to July this year with no Plan B, then this shows more about leadership in the boardroom rather than Mr Moyes behaviour. I know very little of hiring managers but don't alarm bells start ringing when there are no discussions in the final six months of a five-year contract that the individual may have other plans.

If anyone sees Mr Ferguson please thank him from me!

Best Wishes all!

Karl Masters
443 Posted 24/10/2013 at 23:15:46
It would be an old Everton trick to let the person departing look like the bad guy.

It's been done countless times with players like Lineker, Hutchison, Ball, Jeffers, Rooney when it actually suited the Directors to sell them. You do have to ask why the Hierarchy at the Club let him run down the contract and do as he pleased. They are doing the same again with Baines it appears.

I think the fact Moyes has turned on Everton probably has something to do with a total lack of respect for Kenwright and the murky boardroom set up he presides over.

Yes, Manure, Whiskey nose and Ginge do themselves no credit, but it suits certain people to stay in the shadows and let them take the flak whilst avoiding it themselves.

Karl Masters
444 Posted 25/10/2013 at 00:01:46
Also, just have to ask, is this story about Kenwright's late mother giving Fergie an earful on the phone over taking a young Wayne Rooney whilst Billy was grizzling in the background really true? Really?

It can't be! Can it?

Oliver Molloy
445 Posted 25/10/2013 at 00:59:58
Moyes has disrespected Everton F.C. and I hope it come back to haunt him I really do.
He has shown himself to be a complete hypocrite and I agree with those who say he deliberately done us out of compensation because he knew he was getting to utd job.
Until any evidence contrary to that becomes public,then this has to be the only truth.
I hope he gets the reception he deserves when he comes to Goodison,and we roast them,that would be a little pay back for me.

At least our Martinez will try and win games and perhaps in doing so we might get a hammering a few times,but I would much rather have a manager that does not want to sit on 1 goal lead and will make positive subs other than negative ones.

As for Baines,if we get the price we want,good luck to him,he seems a decent bloke and it will not matter what Martinez thinks or says,because it will be Kenwright who will make the decision.

It will take our new manager time to build his own team,and he is still learning and he knows what we Everton fans expect,as do the players who pull on the shirt.
If we can get a result against both sets of red shite,that will heaven for me.
COYB

Brian Waring
446 Posted 25/10/2013 at 09:25:25
Karl, the club never fucked up letting Moyes's contract run down, it was always on the table, it was Moyes, all we ever heard was I'm going to see what happens etc from Him. Even when it was made official as the Mancs new manager he came out and said he had always planned to sign a new contract.
Barry Rathbone
447 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:12:35
Nick, he should have done it because it was the honest thing to do.

The hypotheticals of what might have happened could equally be argued the other way ie the players going all out for the gaffer getting 4th and winning the cup!

Ian Holloway has shown more integrity.

Richard Tarleton
448 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:37:20
I repeat, you do your job, a bigger firm comes along and offers you more money and a higher status, you leave. That's it. All this crap about loyalty and integrity, this is football we're talking about. The only loyal people in football are the fans, the rest go where the money is greater.
Barry Rathbone
454 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:41:56
On this subject, the contrast in EFC and LFC reaction is stark: straight away Brendan Rodgers is rolled out to defend criticism of Steven Gerrard and Henderson... while the tapping up of our manager costing us millions is met with what???

Sometimes the fans and officials of this club are their own worst enemies – spineless.

Phil Sammon
455 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:52:43
Karl Masters 673

'You do have to ask why the Hierarchy at the Club let him run down the contract and do as he pleased. They are doing the same again with Baines it appears.'

He has two years to run on the contract and has had an offer on the table for the best part of 12 months. You can't really do a lot more as a club.

Also, your justification of Moyes' actions after his MUFC appointment is absolutely astounding. If Moyes wanted to get back at BK and the board, he could have just come out and told the world what a joke they are. In doing so he'd probably have cemented his place as an Everton legend.

Unfortunately for both him and you that wasn't the case. Moyes acted the way he did because of sheer arrogance and a sense of entitlement. He's insulted the fans more than the board.

Yet still some defend him...

Tim Jones
456 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:52:54
It seems that those who were blind, naive and gullible when the Ginger Twat first defected to Man Utd, when SAF cocked his finger at him and he came running, remain just as naive and gullible now. Still that must be easier than eating humble pie and admitting that they were flat out wrong and those of us who said he and SAF and Man U were lying disrespectful scumbags were spot on.
John Keating
457 Posted 25/10/2013 at 12:35:49
Nick,

Read your first paragraph on 564. You say that us "older" supporters base our idea of success on this period!!

Sorry, mate, you are way off line and totally incorrect. The '60s and '80s were periods of great success and if you look at the history of Everton Football Club you will probably find there are not many periods of 11 years where an average 6th-8th position was our norm.

The Moyes years in context of our "history" was turgid shite; however, I would say I do not blame Moyes — I blame Kenwright and the Board.

Though for you to suggest in some sort of roundabout way that Moyes was a hero is quite unbelievable. Believe me, our history did not start with Walter Smith!!

Ste Traverse
458 Posted 25/10/2013 at 12:42:36
Sad analogy I know, but if your girlfriend cheated on you and sacked you off for someone you didn't particulary like after 11 years, would you say "it doesn't matter, we had 11 good years" or would you fucking hate her?

Why some are so desperate to defend Moyes on the basis he did a good job (without any sliverware) despite him ultimately shitting on and belittling this club, is beyond me.

The bloke isn't fit to wipe the backside of men like Harry Catterick or Howard Kendall.

Brendan McLaughlin
459 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:00:48
Ste #764,

Sad but very true.

Tony J Williams
460 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:11:57
Ste, I think you'll probably find that the "defending" is of his time with us and the revision of history because he has been a bellend since leaving us.

He gone, he's acting like a cock, he is hated now, like every other manager who isn't the manager of Everton, yet we have a 400+ thread on him and some of the shite posted here is unreal.

Steve Brown
461 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:11:49
Barry 571, if you are going to make the claim at least have the balls to stick it.

The clue was when you started with "I'm going to out this out there and I really don't care if II get my posts blocked." We can all read you perfectly.

Steve Brown
463 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:17:18
Of course Barry, you can take the opportunity to explain what you did mean if you didn't mean what it was evident that you meant when you wrote it. I understand why you'd want to backtrack from it.

I would as well if I'd written it.

Sean Kelly
464 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:11:57
Ste 764

Thank fuck for your comment about Catterick and Kendall. Moyes is gone, long live EFC. Maybe NE and his mates are glad of mediocrity that Moyes, Walker, Lee and fucking Walters brought to our club but I for one am glad to remember the Catterick and the Kendall days.

RM appears to be aligning himself to the Kendall era by getting to the soul of the club. Decency, integrity along with a dollop of ambition for the club to progress is what I'm seeing from RM and if we get the odd stuffing along the way (but not tomorrow) I can take it if it's in the pursuit of proper football progress with the squad and some form of European action.

I'm not blinded as others (NE) might acuse me of being to the fact that Wigan are in the Championship but I believe RM has learned from that experience and is now working with a better pool of players.

Earlier in this thread others were suggesting RM would have us relegated within three years. The enemy is within and maybe working with Billy the Bullshitter to undermine my beloved Everton. Maybe their objective is to see us relegated and get parachute payments and return to the Premier League with "a few quid" in our pockets.

Michael Penley
465 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:07:45
I can't be the only one who noticed David Moyes's face has aged about 20 years since he left Everton. To me that says more about the situation than anything else.

I remember one manager, perhaps Moyes, once saying something about referee decisions balancing themselves out. Maybe conscience works the same way.

Barry Rathbone
467 Posted 25/10/2013 at 16:58:52
Steve Brown, sorry to prick your pompous and scurilous bubble but you (and a couple of other tar and feather blowhards) seem determined to play the martyr card and insist upon something that was not said.

No "Better Blue" was mentioned – just a relay of my experience of family and friends reaction and their family and friends reaction (the vast majority of whom still live on Merseyside) to "Fergiegate".

The noticeable contrast to the shoulder shrugging of a fair number on this thread recognisable as not of this parish was worthy of note; any new reader might have left the thread at that stage thinking "not really arsed are they?" whereas I want it known the overwhelming majority view ON MERSEYSIDE is "ARSED!"

Of course the association of being open and honest by mentioning one of the "eds" by name would explain to anyone without an agenda the "comments blocked" statement but sanctimonious and brainwashed is not confined to fans of other clubs – a few trigger points and the small-minded appear everywhere.

You know those beauts from across Stanley Park who at the mention of their heinous association with crowd trouble and deaths scream "HILLSBOROUGH!! HE'S SAYING STUFF ABOUT HILLSBOROUGH!" .....

Yeh .... is it getting in there yet?

Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
468 Posted 25/10/2013 at 17:24:38
A word by way of clarification, re this point Steve is needling Barry over...

Not sure if it's ad hominen or whatever the shrink's label is, but this idea that anger with Moyes goes lock-step with living on Merseyside is not something I would accept at all. I hate arguments structured like that, and if I we were going to remove Barry's post, THAT would be the reason. Jimmy Kelly's post at #539 proves that Barry's logic is seriously flawed — and it only takes one!

The other side to Barry's flawed contention is also total bollocks: I'm sure there are plenty like me who no longer live on Merseyside (or others who never have) but are very like-minded with Barry in their reaction to the topic of this thread and their anger with Moyes.

It's a point I keep trying to make on here periodically, that Evertonians do not all view the same situation in the same way. There should be no need to justify opinions by age or location or any other arbitrary basis: it's what you think. For this reason, I reject Barry's assertion about all fans on Merseyside; I don't believe it's valid — even though personally I totally identify with his reaction in this instance.

Barry Rathbone
469 Posted 25/10/2013 at 17:57:19
Michael, you seem to be suggesting I say "ALL" on this site (ex or never from merseyside) are of the same "shoulder shrug" view or that ONLY merseyside folk are angered???

Be interested to know how you come to that conclusion.

Just to be clear the 24 evertonians of my family (20 of whom live on merseyside) are incandescent over Fergiegate similarly their evertonian pals are of the same opinion.

Now clearly that isn't every evertonian on merseyside but I'll stand by my extrapolation.

Nick Entwistle
470 Posted 25/10/2013 at 18:11:42
Michael, always like a Latin phrase, and ad hominem has an interesting graphic on its wiki page about the 'hierarchy of disagreements'.

This shows, after name calling, ad hominem to be the lowest form of argument.

Given the seven types of argument, there isn't one against Moyes in all of the above that can claim a place in the top three.

This is not to say people are wrong (you all are, and of course I am correct at all times, even right now) but that football fans subsume to the irrational thought processes stirred when passions are high, far more than I would presume and hope in any other facet of our lives.

Alt_Text

Matt Butlin
471 Posted 25/10/2013 at 18:31:48
I'd never seen this before.

Darren Hind
472 Posted 25/10/2013 at 17:51:34
I live in the city but my work takes me all over the country. My experience would certainly back up what MK is saying. Where you live has little bearing on your point of view.

Barry is correct in one sense: there is a degree of shoulder shrugging, but mention the name of Davey Moyes and an unmistakeable flash of anger will appear in the eyes of most of the Evertonians I meet... He's in for one helluva reception when he comes back

There's comfortaby over 400 posts on this thred. At first glance you could easily believe it has generated colosal interest, but a closer look will show a small group of returning repeatedly to the thread... Express your anger on a website by all means, but by returning repeatedly to show you are even angrier, you risk giving the impresson that your outrage is, err... forced.

I didn't post when Moyes was here, but I can tell the people who were the most abusive towards him and who showed the least respect ... They are the ones who are screaming the loudest now because he hasnt respected them.

Moyes will not care if a few dozen people want to drive themselves into an early grave typing frenzied hatred, but the thought of returning to face those he betrayed will give him sleepless nights.

The reception Moyes receives when he comes back to Goodison will stay with him forever.

Ross Edwards
473 Posted 25/10/2013 at 18:52:46
In fact Nick, if Sir John Moores (God bless his soul) was still alive, and our chairman, Moyes wouldn't have lasted 5 years mate.
Kieran Fitzgerald
474 Posted 25/10/2013 at 18:18:07
Matt @441, and Lyndon's response at 460, should be read by anyone who has posted on this thread over the last two or three days.

Regardless of what your take is on Moyes or Ferguson or Kenwright, is it really worth the way we have treated each other on this website? Regardless of whether you feel you should or shouldn't voice your anger, is it honestly worth the way in people have spent the last two days on this website belittling each other.

You know what has really gotten under my skin about the whole Moyes to Utd thing, it's this thread. If being an Everton fan and ToffeeWebber means either putting up with this shite or having to engage in it, then I'd quicker leave ToffeeWeb altogether.

Of course I'll probably now be told I love the anti-Christ Moyes, or hate Everton, or that I'm not a real fan because I'm not spitting bile and spite left, right and centre, or that I'm not a real fan because I'm not showing my anger clearly and loudly enough. Or that all the vitriol above is actually proper opinion and how dare I be so anti-democratic. Go for it, but I would then ask you to read Matt's first paragraph again.

Ross Edwards
475 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:10:08
To clarify, I meant if John Moores was our chairman today, Moyes wouldn't have lasted 5 years.
Colin Wainwright
476 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:15:05
"He's insulted the fans more than the board."

If only that were true, Phil, no matter what anyone thinks of the hypocritical, sanctimonious twat.

Brent Stephens
477 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:16:25
Kieran #830. Agree entirely.

We've sunk really low in this thread. Sad.

Tomorrow's another day. Can't wait to get to Villa Park.

Sin miedo!

Colin Glassar
478 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:14:45
You're right Kieran, it just goes to show how much damage OFM has done by his underhand, sly, dishonest, treacherous, malovelent actions.
Colin Wainwright
479 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:28:50
Kieran, any bile on this thread is valid, simply because many blues feel let down by a man they put their trust in. It doesn't, imo, alter the fact that this club's fanbase is as solid and together, right now, than it has been over the past decade.
Barry Rathbone
481 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:40:51
Kieran, the secret is to read posts carefully, most folk with different opinion approached respectfully will culminate in the words "agree to differ".

Misrepresentation through not taking the time to read properly is, and always will be, the biggest source of fallout on forums.

Regarding Moyes just check the numbers, a thread talking about 4 4 2 or the stats about x and y player get 10% of the traffic.

Market forces mate.

Kieran Fitzgerald
482 Posted 25/10/2013 at 20:13:46
Colin Wainright, have at Moyes any way you want. He has managed, in the space of a couple of short months, to show the height of disrespect towards the club. For me, while angry, I'm just not prepared to let that anger be my main focus in terms of my day-to-day routine around being an Evertonian or how I access ToffeeWeb. I am not going to let it bring me to the point where I would speak to people on here the way some people have been doing.

If you or others want to vent their anger on what Moyes did, I am happy for you to do so. My way of showing my anger is to move on from it. Moyes is no longer part of this great club so I won't let my anger towards him upset me. Yet some people who have taken my favoured approach on this thread have been told that they by doing so, they have condoned his behaviour, that they don't see what really happened. That just doesn't make sense to me.

Barry, Martinez could win every trophy under the sun this season, and Moyes would still dominate proceedings. Like him or loathe him during his time here, he was a huge part of the club for 11 years. I think that it is unfortunate that what he did at the end will colour every discussion we have about him for years to come.

Ross Edwards
483 Posted 25/10/2013 at 20:40:50
Nick, what is the point of pasting that triangle?

Barry Rathbone
484 Posted 25/10/2013 at 20:43:21
Nick, I would think number 2 using the quotes of Fergie nails Moyes as shifty!!!
Andy Gleaves
488 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:04:19
Why has all this come as a surprise? There is no way all this went through with honesty and integrity — it was all too coincidental. All I will say is that what goes around hopefully comes around!!
Nick Entwistle
489 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:08:04
Could be right there, Barry!

Ross, that comment can go down as a number 6.

I wouldn't know how to post the graphic, I only pasted the link.

Amazing you'd ask that though when there's a freaking clip from Keeping Up Appearances right below.

That too is a number 6. Good clip though.

Paul Ferry and Tim Jones score both a 6 and definitely a 7 with every post.

Ross Edwards
490 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:16:33
What would your posts be Nick? An 8?
Colin Wainwright
491 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:10:08
Keiran (856). "For me, while angry, I'm just not prepared to let that anger be my main focus in terms of my day to day routine around being an Evertonian or how I access ToffeeWeb."

Neither am I, but this thread is specifically about how DM treated the club in the light of Fergusons revelations. As I said, it seems the fanbase is, as united as I've ever known it. The one positive legacy the man left. Get shut of Bills crew and were on our way.

Kevin Tully
493 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:37:48
It never fails to amaze me when footie fans ask for a bit of logic, or compare football to everyday life - "when I moved firms" being a favourite it seems.

If we applied any sanity to the footballing world, would grown men act the way they do at matches?

Who would ever give a shite about watching prima-donna millionaires kicking a bag of wind on some grass?

Would anyone waste their time posting their opinions on something that is clearly has about as much relevance to our daily lives as Coronation Street?

So anyone who wants to post on a footy forum and calls for sensible, logical debate should log on to a serious intellectual forum for quantum physics.

We are dealing with raw emotion here, and if you upset us as ginge has, what do you expect?

Brin Williams
494 Posted 25/10/2013 at 20:18:17
Bloody hell, reading that lot has left me knackered!!

Good on yer all lads - keep it up - great stuff.

It's like listening to politicians , this one speaks and it sounds plausible then another one comes along and you think he has a point then someone else spouts up and in the end you have to sit down and try to remember what it was you actually thought about in the first place.

My take on this Moyes/Fergie/bit is that WE as fans have been well and truly stuffed by Moyes. I stood and clapped him, I had promised myself that I wouldn't - but I did. Why? Partly because he was going and I was pleased about that.

I had suspected as much for some time and despite our football improving over the latter months of the season there were still wranglings about the Semi final, the Derby, the Wigan game and the way we/he would settle for a draw! In fact if he hadn't gone I would have cancelled my Season Ticket.

The fact that we were cheated out of compensation left a bad taste but compared to the audacity of the man to come back and try to raid out best players for a pittance was the final straw and I shall be at Goodison when the twat returns with his minions and I shall give him the reception I should have given him when he left.

There is an argument that BK should have protected our interests better - without being privy to any inside knowledge I cannot comment but I do think Everton may well have turned a corner in their association with Moyes and his club. The January window will be interesting and IF we roll over and let the sods walk all over us I for one will not be there next season.

Roberto was not my first choice, BUT he is turning out to be one hell of a guy - time will tell whether he can become the success we all hope for.

Turning back to this saga that has been playing here for the past few days, I don't know who is right - it all depends on your own stance and perspective of events over 11 years, 20 years or 50 years or longer.

I like a bit of passion and Barry exemplifies that is abundance as for the rest of you, keep it up you all have made good points, its a good thing that we don't all agree otherwise ToffeeWeb would be a very dull place.

Kieran Fitzgerald
495 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:50:36
Kevin, you are right, being a football fan makes no sense. I'm happy to accept my part in that. I can be as childish and as idiotic as the next fan. Does that make it right that we speak to other Everton fans like they are shit? I just happen to think that it doesn't.

Colin, fair enough. I would hope that the fanbase is united. We deserve better than to be pulled apart by David Moyes trying to be Billy Big Bollox now he is at Utd. He should remember that he has rather big shoes to fill at Utd, and he ain't won a thing there yet. His replacement at Everton has managed just as well so far as he has.

Karl Masters
498 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:48:35
Phil Sammon, I'm not going to get into an argument with you, but you have misunderstood my point. I have as low an opinion of Moyes's actions as anyone, but seeking an explanation of why he has behaved this way is not defending him.

I just happen to think that our useless Board with its murky set-up of so few active Directors that you could fit them in a phone box, the Green link, net selling on player trading etc, have done us no favours and perhaps Moyes was as non-plussed with that situation as we are. Thus he has no problem in showing Everton a level of disrespect he felt he had from the Board. It's just a theory, Phil. You find it astounding, I don't. Don't let Martinez hide the fact our Board is useless.

As for the Baines situation, we don't have two years, we actually have 14 months until he can sign a pre-contract agreement elsewhere or go for peanuts in January 2015 – just like Pienaar did (pardon the pun). Perhaps the Club are trying, but outwardly they are saying this week there are no planned contract talks. Make of that what you will. You are relaxed about it; I'm not, so again it's just a difference of opinion.

Graham Mockford
499 Posted 25/10/2013 at 22:21:41
Nick Entwistle

You are now my favourite TW poster, a sterling effort may I say and if I could find one of those triangly diagrams to show it I would.

Derek Thomas
500 Posted 25/10/2013 at 22:55:01
From about this time last year, when Moyes's contract shit surfaced, OFM has been digging himself a hole, aided and abetted by, in no particular order, our and the media's (with a bit of self-help from himself) perceptions about his character.

He didn't go as far as to claim the moral high ground, but he didn't mind any photo opps that seemed, so to speak, to show him with his feet firmly placed on the upward slopes, gazing steely-eyed toward It's summit.

We then have the whole Fergie-gate thing. Moyes's poor results which may or may not stem from his play-not-to-lose rather than play-to-win attitude.

Which brings us to the two camps: Apologistas and The MOB.

The first may feel more let down than the second, who are happy to have their suspicions confirmed.

As a result, Moyes seem to have scooted well over the line into those we, if not love to hate, really dislike and have no time for, eg, many and various RSs, Clive Thomas, Barmby, etc etc.

Come next April, and the return of the prodigal(s), Rooney will be welcomed like a long lost son compared to the shellacking Moyes will get. And given what went on, it couldn't happen to a nicer guy.

Yes, we are bitter and fickle, it's in our nature as blues and fans. Moyes vs Everybody else is what it is but both sides would do well to remember that loyalty works both ways and the only way to get and keep it is to buy a dog.

Mike Gaynes
501 Posted 26/10/2013 at 05:16:41
Derek (893):... "the two camps: Apologistas and The MOB."

There's a third camp... those who really don't care what Moyes did/said before and after his departure.

I don't take Moyes' behavior personally because it's exactly what I expected... as a sports journalist for 25 years, I long ago learned that loyalty to a professional sports team in any sport is a fairy tale, a fantasy cherished by supporters but generally (with some notable exceptions) an afterthought to coaches and athletes.

I was a huge Moyes supporter when he was here because he was our manager, and I considered him a really good one. I view his subsequent actions ONLY from the perspective of where our team is now. And in every way, we are better off because of Moyes's actions.

Had Moyes, Fergie and Bill gone public with their secret that Moyes was Man Utd-bound six months earlier, Moyes might have been forced out then and we would have wound up with a different manager. I'm happy with Martinez, and I doubt any other manager could have brought in more good players, so I have no hard feelings for Moyes's secrecy.

The moment Moyes departed for Man Utd, I assumed his loyalty was with them and he would come in for our players instantly, so I wasn't let down when he did. And when he came in with the insulting offer for Fellaini and Baines, it blew up in his face. Had he made a reasonable offer the first time around, Bill might have accepted it. Instead, he got slammed back and wound up overpaying for Fellaini alone. Now we have Barry, McCarthy and money in the bank, and Baines is still with us.

Could we have done any better if we had been appropriately compensated for Moyes? Don't know. But I love where we are right now... a deeper, more exciting side than last year, and looking down on Man Utd.

So there are folks here who are neither Apologistas or Moyes haters. Some of us just don't give a damn about him. We're too busy enjoying where Everton is now.

Derek Thomas
502 Posted 26/10/2013 at 06:01:07
Mike #908 I must fess up having the NEA as a 3rd category prior to posting and dropped it down to 2 because saying the NEA are well... not even arsed at Moyes's shenanigans seemed redundant and pointless.

I will be surprised in this whole saga, a soap plot from the home of the quintessential soap, if there emerges any winners, that is if you don't count the compo that all the soon-to-be ex-United employees will get... Oh and of course our good selves in blue... it's been worth the price of admission just for the laughs, nevermind with the added football bonuses you mention.

Mike Gaynes
503 Posted 26/10/2013 at 06:39:22
Derek (909)...

NEA = Not Even Arsed... perfect!

Thanks for a great chuckle at the end of a long day. And you're right, the laughs are what makes it all worthwhile.

Brent Stephens
505 Posted 26/10/2013 at 08:36:29
I'm a dyed-in-the-wool NEA. Always have been, always will be. NEAs are born not made.

In NEAs we trust!

Barry Rathbone
506 Posted 26/10/2013 at 09:39:35
"not even arsed"

(casually walks on by)

Jim Bennings
507 Posted 26/10/2013 at 11:13:35
SHREWSBURY..OLDHAM..BRENTFORD..DINAMO BUCHAREST..0-3 AT HOME TO WIGAN...0-7 AT ARSENAL..ALL THE WOEFUL SPINELESS DERBY MATCH DISPLAYS..2003-04 SEASON...A LOWEST EVER WIN TOTAL POINTS TOTAL...
2005-06 SEASON..LOST 4-0 TO BOLTON AND WEST BROM AND VILLA IN THE SPACE OF A MONTH.
2002-03 SEASON SCORED JUST THREE GOALS IN ONE MATCH ALL SEASON, A DEFEAT AT SPURS.
1-6 AT HOME TO ARSENAL IN 2009?

ALL OF THE ABOVE ARE JUST SOME OF THE REASONS WHY IT WAS NOT ALL ROSY UNDER MOYES.
YES HE STEADIED THE SHIP,HE HAD SOME GOOD STEADY SEASONS BUT HE ESCAPED WITH HIS JOB ON MANY MANY DIFFERENT TIMES DURING HIS SPELL HERE.
HE DID A DECENT JOB BUT LETS NOT MAKE OUT HE IS THE GOD OF ALL EVERTON MANAGERS

Gary Poole
508 Posted 26/10/2013 at 11:40:27
Mike (908) that's a great post. Sensible, realistic, and completely in perspective.

Some people need to get a grip and stop behaving like jilted teenage girls.

I'm firmly NEA (and was a supporter of Moyes, like Mike says, because he was our manager)

I find it ironic when some of the posters (who spent years hurling dogs abuse at Moyes) complain that those who dare to criticise aspects of Roberto's management are guilty of disloyalty - you couldn't make it up.

We are now on the way to 500 posts. I can't imagine we would get that many if we won the FA cup. In a way it's funny and yet, on another level, it's imensely depressing that some supporters can get so vitriolic and agitated about what is such a banal episode - bloke who works for a company for 11 years gets offered another job but needs to keep quiet about it for a while. I mean, Moyes is not an Evertonian, he's a professional football manager with aspirations in that direction. Why can't people get that?

Jim Bennings - that has to be the most juvenile post I've seen for a long while (I won't bother to use CAPS). I presume, therefore, that you have already started your "reasons why it isn't all rosy under Martinez" list - Fulham 1-2, City 1-3. Hang on, I've just had a thought - do all football managers lose games?

I did think (foolishly) that when Moyes moved on that we would enter a new era on TW when people would be able to coalesce around the new manager and we would, for a while, get some concensus and talk about the now. How wrong could I be!

Tim Jones
509 Posted 26/10/2013 at 12:01:23
The Moyesophiles still don't get do they. The MOB were not unhappy that TGT was leaving — it was the lies and deceit from TGT, SAF and Man Utd associated with his leaving that left such a bad taste in the mouth.
Callum McNab
510 Posted 26/10/2013 at 19:06:52
Carl Sanderson, I can also remember the icy winds of relegation when Joe Royle took over,and then went on and won the FA Cup, and as to the defenders comment, I think I counted 11 Everton players defending when Wigan had a corner in the FA Cup.

I have supported my beloved Blues since 1965, and I have seen many ups but more downs over the years. I can remember chairmanship shitting on our club like this crowd (Mr Johnson comes to mind) but I cannot remember a manager being as devious, cowardly and so disrespectful as that Ginger get. He may've stabilised the club as some might say, but boy was he paid well to do so, while asking others to take a pay cut may I add.

For me, Martinez has got me more excited the way he has the team playing in these first few months than Moyes ever did in the whole 11 years in charge.

Paul Melarange
511 Posted 26/10/2013 at 19:22:59
Can I just thank Sir Alex for persuading Moyes to take the Man Utd job? After 11 years, I think we had gone stale under his management. We can't really complain at the way we have started under Roberto and, by the sound of what some of the players are saying, they are loving it too, being allowed and encouraged to express themselves.

The likes of Barkley are actually having a run of games unlike under Moyes — play well one game and we didn't see him again! I liked a lot of things Moyes did for the first few years but the way he has conducted himself at Man Utd, insulting us with derogatory offers for top players, trying to unsettle players...

I am actually glad he got the Man Utd job and will watch with interest how long he is actually there for! Onwards and upwards under Roberto and I am made up he took Woods and Round up the M62 with him!

Up the toffees!

Roman Sidey
512 Posted 27/10/2013 at 00:58:34
Feel like I missed a party that is ultimately personified by Entwistle's use of the frankly atrocious portmanteau "guesstimate". Sorry, mate, just could not let that one slip through to the 'keeper.

Quite simply, Ferguson tapped up Moyes the same way that Redknapp use to tap up players. Not sure if there's law against it, but it certainly wasn't accepted as ethical when Hawwy did it.

The thing that I'm surprised about the most is that Ferguson would put this in his book when he is clearly still involved with Moyes on a professional basis. Not that I care about Moyes' feelings, but I imagine he gulped and tugged his collar when he read it.

The part I'll be most interested in will be if or when some of the Everton players under Moyes start talking about what they knew at the time and how the feel it affected the team.

For the record on the tangent this thread took, I lost my time for Moyes when he failed to really improve in accordance with his improved contract. In most lines of work, when your pay increases, you are expected to show a higher level of talent to justify it, and for me, this didn't happen.

Kevin Freaney
513 Posted 27/10/2013 at 01:01:24
I will never understand how people are still trying to defend Moyes after everything that has happened. Nick & Ian, guys, I love your dedication but seriously, open your eyes and realise what the hell is going on!

Callum McNab got it spot on in his post in my opinion

Paul Tran
514 Posted 27/10/2013 at 16:40:56
I wanted Moyes to go. He went. I'm happy. I don't care what he does apart from when his team plays my team.

I'm not interested in whether he's an 'honourable' man. That was a piece of nonsense to justify/compensate for his lack of success.

He works in professional football. If you expect morals, you are hopelessly naive.

Why don't we just focus on the good work of our current manager?

Max Wilson
515 Posted 30/10/2013 at 08:24:35
Funny that; red nose doing us a favour!
Max Wilson
516 Posted 30/10/2013 at 08:24:35
Funny that; red nose doing us a favour!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb