Hard-hitting comment from KEIOC over ticket prices

, 24 October, 55comments  |  Jump to most recent
Keeping Everton In Our City take issue with the club's partnership with StubHub, the third-party ticket marketplace where Goodison ticket holders can sell their unused seat(s).

Tickets for the upcoming Merseyside derby have been listed as high as £575, however, which has led KEIOC to brand StubHub as little more than legalised ticket touting.

KEIOC have published a follow-up article on the same topic.

Everton have defended the platform and their association with StubHub saying that it is the prerogative of season ticket holders to list their ticket for the price of their choosing and it's up to the potential buyer to decide whether to meet that valuation.

» Read the full article at Keeping Everton In Our City



Reader Comments (55)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Robin Cannon
1 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:27:01
"...rather than an understanding of the English football fan psyche which finds touting abhorrent and has long since had their own methods of utilising unwanted tickets."

...those methods largely including selling (i.e. "touting") said unwanted tickets?

"...but apparently if you're an "Official Partner" of the club it's acceptable so that's okay then."

Yes, and legally so; that's how the law on ticket touting works. Any resale of tickets that isn't approved by the match organizer is technically illegal. Any resale that is approved by the match organizer is perfectly valid?

I don't have any major issue with StubHub, and it's a reasonable way to ensure that otherwise unused tickets are made available. Pricing is always going to be an issue; but it's more a result of the deeper issues of ticket pricing as anything that's the "fault" of a middleman like StubHub.

Dave Roberts
2 Posted 24/10/2013 at 16:50:50
I don't really know anything about StubHub as on the rare occasions I can't get to the match I give my ticket to my mate who takes his brother or his girlfriend. I suspect StubHub take a percentage of the sale price so it would be in their interests to sell tickets for the highest possible price. If that is not the case and its a fixed fee (?) that assumption obviously wouldn't apply.

I take the club's point though, it is up to the vendor to set the price and what concerns me personally is just that....how could you get another bluenose to pay £575 for your £40 (approx) seat? I know I couldn't but that's probably why I'm not a rich bastard!

I might charge a kopite and extra tenner assuming I knew my seat was going to one!

Peter Mills
3 Posted 24/10/2013 at 18:07:01
As a 15 year old lad I queued for 2 hours to buy a couple of tickets for the Anfield derby at, I think, 5 bob (25p) each. 5 minutes after buying them I sold one for 100% profit, and was rather pleased with myself. So much so that I mentioned my business acumen to my Dad that evening, explaining to him that the purchaser had been prepared to meet my valuation. I was met with silence and a look of complete, withering disdain. And if that wasn't hard enough to take, we went into a 2-0 lead in the match only to lose 3-2.

I learned my lesson, and have never done it again, even selling a spare we had for the 1995 cup final at face value an hour before kick-off. I hate spivs, official partners or not.

Patrick Murphy
4 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:12:22
Surely there must be an upper limit as to what any individual can request for their ticket? If somebody bought x amount of tickets on general sale and then put them up for sale on Stub-hub they could make a handsome profit for doing practically nothing. It's an utter disgrace and doesn't reflect well on the club or the game.
Raymond Fox
5 Posted 24/10/2013 at 19:16:41
Its supply and demand, you cant blame stub hood for the price.
They have take a percentage to at least cover their own expenses, and presumably attempt to make a profit.

If the ticket is overpriced no one will buy it, and they will fail to take a cut!
You would have to have more money than sense, to pay so much, but I suppose there are a few around!

Chris James
6 Posted 24/10/2013 at 21:03:01
It's ludicrous to pillory the board for this and makes KEIOC look reactionary and small minded to me.

Stubhub, seatwave and the numerous other reselling programs may cause certain issues in themselves, but they're all essentially the same and I guess many other clubs use them.

As has been mentioned above it's a demand driven system, if the prices aren't sustainable then the tickets won't get sold.
Aside from trying to monitor and manage the third party (which a - they wouldn't allow probably and b - would cause lots of resource for no benefit to the club), the option is to not allow a reseller system and have tickets go to waste.

Lyndon Lloyd
7 Posted 24/10/2013 at 21:57:54
My only issue with StubHub or a similar ticket exchange would be under the conditions Patrick describes above (#599) whereby that *would* be tantamount to touting — i.e. accumulating tickets that might otherwise be bought by ordinary fans in order to make a profit.

As it is, StubHub is just facilitating the exchange of tickets between two people; the open market dictates the price and the sale price is up to the individuals concerned. (KEIOC seem to disagree vehemently with that interpretation, though).

It works the same way with concert tickets, memorabilia, old programmes... once they have been sold by the original vendor/organiser (in this case, Everton) the tickets are worth what someone will pay for them. (And that's true whether StubHub exists or not).

If someone is OK with fleecing a fellow fan of £575 and there is someone out there who wants to attend the derby so badly they they'll part with such an exorbitant amount, then that's up to them. If no one does, the owner of the ticket can bring their asking price down to a saner level as the match gets closer or miss out on selling it at all. eBay works the same way (but without take a cut like StubHub) – if the price gets too high, I'm just not going to buy.

Either way, if the seller is bent on profit and doesn't find a buyer, that seat remains empty for the match come what may. It's not pricing the ordinary fan out of the game any more than the price of a season ticket already is and that is another debate altogether.

Paul Jamieson
8 Posted 24/10/2013 at 22:26:28
One thing we've all learned over the years is that KEIOC do their research and when they speak they get it right. Just watched the video they've posted and you begin to see why there is something very wrong with these companies.

And as for Alan Myers defending ticket touts... well all I can say is some have short memories as to why he was sacked the first time around.
Peter Mills
9 Posted 24/10/2013 at 23:14:43
ToffeeWeb has made me quite sad over the last couple of days. Evertonians insulting one another over the actions (real or imagined) of our previous manager, and now posts which suggest it would be ok to extract the maximum amount of money from a fellow supporter to allow him to watch a match. FFS.
Lyndon Lloyd
10 Posted 25/10/2013 at 00:24:05
I'm not sure there are many saying it is OK, Peter. At issue here is StubHub and people's perception that the club is endorsing "legalised touting" through the StubHub partnership.

My point is that the person who wants to fleece a fellow fan of £575 for his ticket is going to try and extract the maximum profit however he sells it — whether that's via an online exchange or face-to-face down the pub. That's on that person and anyone mad enough to meet his asking price. Freedom of choice on both ends.

Is the argument that the community that abhors selling tickets to fellow fans above face value doesn't have the same power of deterrent on the market on an online exchange as it did in the old-fashioned methods of exchange before StubHub came along?

Tom Hughes
11 Posted 25/10/2013 at 03:30:26
All tickets used to have small print on them declaring them non-transferable. This was to deny touts the legal right to sell on for profit what was not entirely theirs to sell on. Now the club is simply being complicit in this, no doubt profiting in some way by supporting this abhorrent and immoral activity.

It's all well and good people saying it's simply supply and demand... well what if individuals or groups buy up larger numbers of tickets for big games and it starts affecting availability for ordinary fans... what if the club masquerades as the seller? Isn't its complicity already tantamount to touting? We may end up in the same situation as the kopites where thousands of their followers regularly tout their tickets when so many can't go.
Robin Cannon
12 Posted 25/10/2013 at 07:06:20
@Tom (689) - "It's all well and good people saying it's simply supply and demand... well what if individuals or groups buy up larger numbers of tickets for big games and it starts affecting availability for ordinary fans... what if the club masquerades as the seller?"

A good number of "what ifs?", and none of them really changed by an online exchange like StubHub. Numbers of tickets purchased are limited in any case, so that kind of mass buying isn't really possible. As for the club; why would they need to masquerade as a different seller, given that they're the seller and the price setter in the first place?

Unlike previous illegal sales, a legal and monitored exchange at the very least provides for a refund in the event of a fake ticket being sold, and tracks who's doing the selling and the buying.

From KEOIC; "Wouldn't it be better for the fans and the clubs to set their prices at an affordable level and remove the parasite causing all the problems from the equation?" Well, yes...it'd be better for the clubs (in particular) and fans selling tickets on to set their prices at affordable levels. Which has little to nothing to do with the supposed "parasite" that's providing the exchange service.

Steve Pugh
13 Posted 25/10/2013 at 07:49:00
The alternative would be that people returned unwanted tickets to the club, got a refund and the club put them up for resale. Going off the WBA game that shouldn't be too hard.
Tom Hughes
14 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:24:12
Robin...... it isn't hard to buy several tickets if you're organised, and if there is potential mark up of 1000%, then "what if" very quickly becomes "why not". I hold 4 season tkts and on occasion have bought many tkts, even for games that have eventually sold out. A well organised tout could replicate this several fold. Not to mention the effect of thousands of individuals investing in a ticket for similar gain.

Years ago the spivs just employed local urchins to queue up for the big games... now the capacity is much lower and they can simply invent an alias or ten. As for a club partaking in such invention you have to remember that this club created email accounts and characters to fill forums with anti-keioc and pro-Kirkby propaganda. I'm not suggesting that they have created inflated priced demand.. but their complicity and potential profiting from these transactions is in itself touting, IMO.
Dave Roberts
15 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:16:59
As I said in my previous post on this matter, I didn't know anything about stubhub but I did have a look at the website out of interest. I didn't actually see any tickets for the derby for sale at £575, the highest price I saw was £490 which is still unacceptable. Most seemed to be between the £100-£150 mark.

I think the problem with the likes of stubhub is that it offers an opportunity to sell your season ticket on a one-off basis without any face to face contact with the buyer. Some people obviously could, but I imagine that very few real football fans of any club would have the brass neck to ask for such exhorbitant sums of money face to face. I certainly couldn't, I couldn't live with myself. But stubhub provides an environment where any embarrassment would be kept strictly to yourself and the guilt (if any!) would be much easier to bear. Nobody need ever know how unscrupulous you had been. As big a rip-off merchant as British Gas.

Accordingly, having thought about it a bit more, I believe stubhub is making it easier for one fan to fleece another which is more unfortunate than being fleeced by a tout who does it for a living. At least we know who those bastards are and what they do.

I see no reason why the club couldn't do this job on fan's behalf. Anybody with a ticket they cannot use (season ticket or otherwise) just goes to the ticket office or telephones, gets his ticket registered as being available for that game and when tickets go on general sale, these can be offered too for a small charge to cover the vendor's and club's expenses. By inroducing this middle man the club are helping some supporters to take ridiculous amounts of money out of the pockets of other supporters who just want to watch their team play by providing anonymity and that is scandalous.

If anybody really wants to sell their derby ticket for the price of a year's season ticket, try and sell it in the alehouse and see what happens!

Rob Sawyer
16 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:49:54
I am wary of Stub Hub but understanding was that the facility only applies to season tickets. So a season ticket holder could make a killing on, at most, 5 games a season by selling on his seat through Stub Hub. For other matches he/she would do well to sell for face-value as Goodison is rarely full (unless it is a prime seat on sale).

Living in the Manchester area I know of people who own several Man Utd season tickets and make a tidy profit in "selling" the seats game by game. This sort of practice is a concern to me as it seems to be fans fleecing fellow fans.

Dave Roberts
18 Posted 25/10/2013 at 10:59:36
I forgot to mention in my post above that if the club acted as the middle man I appreciate that it would still not be a face to face sale but the club could set a fee, say £10, a fiver of which they keep for their expenses, the other fiver the seller gets for his journey to the ticket office or for waiting on the phone for half an hour listening to Z cars!

If the seller is not happy with getting his ticket value plus a fiver ....then as I say ask for £500 in the alehouse and see what you get!

£50 for a seat in the Upper Bullens for a derby game is a price I would be more than happy to pay.

Dave Roberts
19 Posted 25/10/2013 at 11:05:31
Rob,

I used to work with a United 'supporter' who had 3 season tickets and who never even went to the games herself! They used to belong to her husband who died, her son who moved abroad and herself. She decided she didn't want to go herself anymore but continued to renew them every year and did exactly what you say.

Meanwhile there were thousnds of supporters on their season ticket waiting list.

It's a disgrace but did the club give a fuck? I doubt it even if they had been made aware, it would be just a big season ticket sale to them.

Alan Williams
20 Posted 25/10/2013 at 12:41:52
What next? Have Amnesty International on our shirts or maybe we can donate two pound from every ticket to the Judean Front — or was it the National Front of Judea! Seriously, how much more liberalism can we take?

This facility is set up for fans who can't get to the game to sell their tickets which is probably a good seat with no obstructed view, at the market price. The exaggeration of £575 is exactly what it is but normally the tickets goes for very close to the gate price and it is a safe environment for the buyer and seller which is endorsed by the club, as it is with many other EPL clubs.

Why do you always look at the poor fan who pays £575? I would say he can either afford the price or is a complete idiot to pay that price when the game is live on TV so he can just pop in to any pub on County Road and watch the game live.

I have two season tickets and I can't always make the game but I give them away free to my family and friends but one of my other mates uses StubHub because he can't afford to let it go for free which is totally understandable.

I may not agree with your tactics (KEIOC/BU) of challenging the board on ownership and how the business is run but I respect the fact you do challenge and I find the whole debate very interesting but, I'm sorry, you are now going off piste. Is it beyond yourselves to ever issue a positive story like EFC have sold out against Villa, Palace and the Shite game and we got 38,000 against Hull? No, you can't. Now that attendances are up and we have a little bit of a feel good factor, you now slam the club because all the normal tickets have gone so it's the club's fault we have a ticket exchange sponsor! Step back and be a fan for once, you may just enjoy it.

Dave Kelly
21 Posted 25/10/2013 at 11:58:20
As with most things in life if you actually look a little deeper, all that glistens isn't necessarily gold. On the face of it, Everton claim that they are providing a service to their most loyal fans. Those fans who year-in & year-out invest in our Club, up front, purchasing a Season Ticket at considerable expense.

Any fair-minded supporter would surely applaud our club for entering into such an agreement with StubHub, one that allows fans to recoup some of their original outlay in the unfortunate set of circumstances that they couldn't attend a game, for whatever reason. To use one of our CEOs favourite phases "at nil cost to the club" the fans win, and we win via the partnership agreement with our approved secondary ticketing partners (Touts).

All sounds good to me... where do I sign? ............. Well, unfortunately it's not!!!

Let's look at some facts and move away from "what if"...

After the universally condemned £575 derby ticket (yes Dave Roberts @740 it was there but has now disappeared) I have taken the opportunity to do a little research and my findings are somewhat surprising.

Let's cut to the chase here, name names and give details. Although not scientific by any stretch of the imagination I was saddened to learn that a Season Ticket Holder (I wont call him an Evertonian because he isn't ) is using a system endorsed by our beloved club to tout tickets, aided and abetted by Everton and their partners in crime – StubHub.

We have 15 games left between now and the end of the Season, the Season Ticket Holder for the seat Park End, section 3, row JJ,seat 47 currently has that seat for sale for all the remaining games of season 2013-14. The cheapest seat priced at £34.50p up to the most expensive at £230.

In my eyes, this pondlife is touting tickets, Everton and Stubhub are complicit in this crime, albeit by association. If Everton are sincere in their actions, the Season Ticket should be cancelled forthwith.

To use one of Robert Elstone's other well used phases "action speaking louder than words"...............let's see some action on this.

Tom Hughes
22 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:13:30
Alan..... KEIOC are simply highlighting a process that they believe to be immoral. Several on here agree with their stance. This would apply if we were top of the league, so what selling out at Crystal Palace has got to do with it, or Judean People's Front jibes, is beyond me.

We sell out away games regardless, what is to rejoice in in that? That is what Evertonians do...... and you can rest assured that the likes of Dave Kelly will be wherever, whenever enjoying every moment of whatever relative success is achieved.

Ken Williams
23 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:29:19
I cannot understand what the issue is — someone is trying to make money out of a ticket. So what? If there is a mug out there willing to pay the asking price, that is up to them.

In general, football supporters in the UK are taken for mugs by the footballing fraternity; players, managers are on obscene amounts of money for producing 90 minutes of football... the clubs then charge some of the highest prices in Europe for tickets, food and drink. No surprise that so many people only attend the big games and the others would rather stream the game or watch in the pub...

Tom Hughes
24 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:47:30
Sorry Ken but that has to be one of the most nonsensical posts on here for a while. You condemn all concerned for greed except those who wish to rip off their fellow fan even more. StubHub was heralded as a way to redistribute unwanted tickets when all it is is a profiteering racket....... and that's plainly wrong.
Alan Williams
25 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:37:54
Tom, how is it immoral? Any fan who is a member of the club can very easily get home game tickets, it isn't hard if you look for the announcement on the club site and plan your application accordingly like we all do for away match tickets every week.

StubHub prices for normal games are reasonable; when an event sells out through the official means, then you have to as an individual decide if you want to take your chance on the open market. If an individual wants to go so much then he has to pay the market price – it's so simple, otherwise you simply say "No, I'm not going". The game is sold out, tough luck unless you are stupid enough to pay the inflated price, just says no!!

This would only class as immoral if the resource that is being sold is a necessity like food, fuel or medicine. Look at Hotel prices when special occasions are on or booking holidays in school breaks; it's supply and demand simply working – nothing else.

Brian Denton
26 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:51:09
Interesting level of detail there, Dave Kelly. I suppose it is just possible that the holder in question has just landed an unforeseen job in Dubai, which he just couldn't turn down.....

I think KEIOC have the moral high ground, but said high ground is worth diddly squat in the society we live in. Corporate sponsors buying seats at the Olympics then leaving them vacant, as a terrible eyesore for the less fashionable events; concerts where it is impossible to buy at the face price because you HAVE to book online or by telephone with associated 'booking fees' etc etc etc.

Not enough people could give a damn in this country which is why we get fleeced on just about everything. This is a nation of legalised pickpockets!

Tom Hughes
27 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:03:25
So touting isn't immoral? Are you a tout by any chance? 1000% mark up isn't profiteering or ripping off people......? What's wrong with if you've no intention of going the game then don't buy one just to profit from it. If we applied the basic its simply supply and demand mantra to all products we'd be all getting ripped off for everything by those who control demand.
Dave Roberts
28 Posted 25/10/2013 at 13:56:35
Yeah we are taken for mugs by the football establishment. But is that good reason as supporters to make mugs out of each other?
Tom Hughes
29 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:11:34
Brian.... if he's landed a job in Dubai he can afford to give his ticket away...... as I do for the games I'm away for.

Years ago, a friend of mine got me 2 tickets for the Anfield derby. He charged me a fiver over for each to cover costs. It represented approx 25% mark-up at the time. I later found out he'd lied about the additional costs..... he was practically excommunicated from our group (Blues and Reds) and is still nicknamed the "tout" all these years later.

Brian Harrison
30 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:01:36
Dave Kelly

I do think that the club does need to look into the seat in the Park End being on sale for all of our remaining games, although there may be extenuating circumstances but it definitely needs looking into. As for someone spending £575 for one game when they could buy a season ticket for less is just daft, and there are still season tickets for sale.

Martin Cameron
31 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:07:03
I don't understand why anybody would want to sell a derby ticket in the first place. Most magical occasion I can think of. I'm going to my first one this November as I finally managed to get one despite not being a season ticket holder. And yes I bought it direct from the club!

But, in all honesty, if some idiot wants to pay that for a ticket, then let them. Personally I couldn't add anything on to the price of a ticket for a fellow fan.

Kevin Tully
32 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:27:15
If the club is putting it's good name forward with StubHub as a commercial partner, then there is clearly a corporate responsibility issue here.

Any decent company would not put their name to an organisation that openly encourages selling tickets at ten times face value - whilst promoting fairness and equality as official club policy.

It clearly comes across as hypocritical nonsense to be officially associated with such an organisation.

Tom Hughes
33 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:33:59
Like all rip off schemes. ... it feeds off ignorance and desperation. That is why ticket sales should be in the hands of the club only. What next.... hordes of Chelsea or Man Utd fans in our seats for those big title deciders? Just to satisfy someone's greed?
Tony J Williams
34 Posted 25/10/2013 at 15:06:31
Yes, it's legalised touted but if someone is daft enough to a) put that kind of price on the ticket and b) someone to actually pay the daft price then it's no skin off my nose.

I pay my season ticket price and get on with it, if I can't go, I give it to one of my mates. My mate is actually giving me his season ticket for the Derby as he is abroad at the time. No charge. (My arl fellas made up he is going)

The prices are set by the owner of the season ticket for each match and more fool the mug paying that price, if it ever sells.

Just because it is up for how many hundred quid, doesn't mean he will sell it.

Dave Roberts
35 Posted 25/10/2013 at 14:50:34
In 1966 when I was 17 years old, Everton, as we know, got to Wembley. I had seen them win the league a few years earlier but this was Wembley and for all I knew I would never have another chance of seeing my heros play there. For this reason in desparation because I had no easy way of getting one I bought a ticket off a workmate who knew someone (he said) who had a few to sell.

I paid £8.

My weekly wage in those days was £6/10/6. (£6.52 for the youngsters) This represented well over a weeks wages for me and involved me getting into a bit of debt with my dad who was too ill to go himself (which was what prevented me taking a chance a chance and queuing up for one but that's another story) but wanted to give me every opportunity to go.

Somewhere along the way, even within that £8 which seems such a small amount today, somebody had made a considerable profit out of me. I have no idea who that person was although I have always suspected it was my workmate himself who was in some small way associated with the FA (via kids football) and a Kopite....so he wouldn't want to go.

I paid half as much again as a weeks wages to watch my team play at Wembley. In the same circumsatnces I would probably do the same again but the idea that any football supporter could seek to rip somebody off in that way just because the buyer was loyal enough, daft enough or, dare I say it desparate enough to pay the price appalls me.

The fact that in doing so the rip-off merchant was being aided and abetted by the club itself is even more apalling. The club sells tickets. It is very good at it actually. It could just as easily sell a vacant season ticket seat on a supporters behalf for a reasonable fee. I just don't see the need for Stubhub ...unless of course there is a backhander or two involved.

Alan Williams
36 Posted 25/10/2013 at 15:32:37
Tom (#785) — you're missing the point completely. These tickets are available at face value if you put a bit of planning and organisation in to it – as long as you're a club member – which is just a case of filling in a form. If you choose not to follow this route, then your only hope is general sale or the open market. This person that wants to pay the £575 has a choice to do so and the choice is his or her decision to make in a free market.

This is a ticket for an event of pleasure (hopefully) and not a necessity of life, so any normal person will just say fuck to the £575 and watch it on the TV. I haven't purchased BT sport, the first time ever I haven't got all the footy on my Sky package for the simple reason they wanted £15 connection and £15 per month when EFC only on twice I think so far, and that second game was the Shite when I will be there, so I said, "Sorry, no thanks" and saved myself £195.00 by doing so.

I'm not a spiv, I actually hate them – especially at horse racing events – they never leave you alone and one always has the urge to chin them as soon as they squeal "Any spares?" but if I have a situation where I may have one extra customer with me, I may have to bite the bullet and see what price comes back. It's the real world, I'm afraid, especially when that event is a sell out.

Tom Hughes
37 Posted 25/10/2013 at 16:17:33
Alan..... I'm not missing the point at all. It's not about free markets or supply and demand which I understand perfectly well. That is why for the entire history of our club tickets were nontransferable. The game is not technically a sell out if someone possesses a ticket they have no intention of using. More so if large numbers of individuals and organised groups hold tkts with this intention. It is artificial manipulation of supply to increase demand for the purpose of profiteering, and has nothing to do with whether a product or service is one of life's essentials or not. If you are not a provider of the service or product you should not be allowed to sell it. Otherwise it leaves the opportunity for this type of profiteering. Match tkts are not sold wholesale for individual retailers to fix their own prices and discard segregation rules..... it's simply farcical to believe that touting is ok imo...... and that is what you're saying whichever way you try to dress it in mock economic theory.
Alan Williams
38 Posted 25/10/2013 at 17:18:16
Ok Tom lets agree to disagree on the theory behind our opinions but any individual has the right to say no to inflated prices and walk away, that's a free choice in anybody's book. EFC aren't a closed shop when it comes to tickets and as mentioned above any individual can buy these tickets for every home game once you follow a very simple process. Is it immoral that STH with 6/8 away matches get priority for every away fixture, therefore meaning the same people have a monopoly on such games? How far do you take the moral argument to suit your predicament?
Dave Kelly
39 Posted 25/10/2013 at 17:56:46
Alan Williams, I'm proud to be pigeon holed as a fully paid up member of what you call the Judean Front Merseyside Branch ( I got my membership via a Tout)

I would be absolutely delighted if Everton proudly adorned "Amnesty International" on their shirts. Certainly that would be far more palatable than "The Free School Co Ltd"... or why not something similar to what "that" other club with a social conscience, Barcelona did with UNICEF.

The whole issue of tickets and ticket pricing needs to be debated, not just by Evertonians but by all of the footballing family. With the Football Supporters Federation and Supporters Direct playing a lead role.

I'm surprised and disappointed that many of the posters on this thread haven't watched the video on the KEIOC website outlining the pitfalls of secondary ticket agencies and have no concept of the camaraderie within our fan-base, a fan-base that inter-changes and exchanges tickets on a daily basis. Fan helping Fan rather than Fan ripping off Fan. No inflated or extortionate prices, no handling fee or expense added. That's what the Evertonians I associate with do.

I have exercised my right to an additional Derby ticket, the grateful recipient being a German Toffee, who had previously paid £300 for a Derby ticket 3 years ago. I was happy to do so because he had already spent £600 on travel and accommodation to fulfill his lifelong dream to watch Everton play in the Merseyside Derby.

No longer a dream but a regular occurrence because he met Evertonians who didn't and wouldn't rip him off and we now have an enclave of Blues in Germany.

Job in Dubai or not, Everton have a moral responsibility to its members and should either refund the remainder of JJ47s season ticket or withdraw it and ban him for breach of Ts&Cs as per ground regulations.

Regarding the free market, it never has been and never will be. The market that StubHub are operate in is a Cartel, It's a closed shop. I can't sell my ticket for an extortionate amount, nor can you. If we do, we run the risk of prosecution and or a football banning order.

One final point, that hasn't been touched on. When is a sell-out not a sell-out ?..................... When Thomas Cook are still selling tickets for a game that's already sold out, that's when. They are currently selling Derby tickets for £139 with a one night stay in Hampton by Hilton at JLA.

The whole issue of ticket pricing is to make them affordable to a wide as possible audience. Not to the Judean Front but to the Free Marketeers too.

Colin Wainwright
40 Posted 25/10/2013 at 19:39:47
Spot on Dave Kelly (841).
Andy Crooks
41 Posted 25/10/2013 at 21:51:46
It seems to me that the"if someone's daft enough to pay " defence is pretty poor and condones exploitation in any context. Fools and their money really don't deserve to be parted.
Karl Masters
42 Posted 25/10/2013 at 23:25:13
I arrived late for an opening day fixture against Villa in 1998 after a big motorway hold up, my friend never made it and went home as he was never going to make the match. I had his ticket.

Outside the Bullens Rd was a group of 'urchins' all asking "Got any spares?", looking for a cheap ticket to get in to what was a sell out. Imagine the delight on one of those kids' faces when I just handed him a ticket and when he asked how much, I just told him not to be daft! His mates were open-mouthed.

We obviously then sat next to each other for the game and although he wasn't a child of many words, he did tell me how grateful he was as he could never afford to buy a ticket.

I'd like to think he goes regularly now he's an adult, but even if he isn't, the thought of ripping off a fellow blue for a ticket just doesn't do it for me. As for StubHub, I have never used them, but maybe a limit of face value plus say 20% would keep things at a decent level satisfying any costs incurred without extorting fans.

Karl Masters
43 Posted 25/10/2013 at 23:56:07
The wider issue is that ticket prices are too high. The big jump in TV money this year, plus the spiraling kit deals (except us of course!) give all Premier League clubs a chance to bring prices down.

The Twenty's Plenty campaign has a lot of merit. Guess it's unlikely to happen though.

Thomas Lennon
44 Posted 26/10/2013 at 08:53:20
Interesting debate.

I don't think anyone has sympathy with someone retaining a season ticket and selling all games, but then if I'd bought a ticket, wanted to keep my seat and was now away for 6 months I would welcome the chance to recoup my money and keep my seat. Before Stubhub than would not have been possible for me and certainly not something I could have overseen from abroad. It is now little trouble to do.

Now - if that job became permanent should I carry one and operate a profit making little sideline? No. But now it is easy for the club to spot this activity and step in because it is regulated through a partner. Arguably the club has made its money on my seat and if I clear my costs at market prices fair enough and the seat is still filled - everyone is happy?

Morally there is an issue if I want to jack the price up to ridiculous levels. That is my moral dilemma rather than the clubs. I imagine the club is paid by Stubhub rather than taking a cut of the proceeds? Perhaps that is the point that needs clarifying. Does Stubhub make an unreasonable profit? How many tickets go for less than cost price?

I stopped having a Season Ticket some years back as I could not make more than 12 - 14 matches and the cost then becomes uneconomic - I think a season ticket gets you 2 free matches in essence? In the last season I owned a season ticket I gave away my ticket to relatives but they don't normally go and it was really a waste of money. Now I am faced with a much better proposition if I buy one - those matches I cant go to I can sell and get my money back at quite short notice and with little trouble. This now makes it more likely I will do so in the future. I wont look for anything above cost though!

Dave Kelly
45 Posted 26/10/2013 at 10:30:19
Thomas Lennon 920, you make a number of really good points. I think you also need to understand that my criticisms of Stubhub are quite simple. They profit and thrive on greed. It's in their best interest for the vendor to ask an extortionate price, given that Stubhubs take 27% of that asking price. The greater the vendors greed the bigger Stubhubs profit.

The service could and can be invaluable to supporters who are unable to attend the occasional game during the course of a season. If thats the case with owner of the Season Ticket, Park End JJ 47 I apologise. However I suspect that not to be the case due to the fact that for the Derby and Manchester United games his required recompense becomes extortionate.

The other issue, how can it morally be right for the Club to aid and abet secondary ticket agencies to sell tickets at inflated prices, but if you sell your ticket ( even below face value ) it's a crime, you can end up having a criminal record you can have your season ticket revoked and face a football ban order.

In my world, that's just plain wrong................ Sorry, I must dash, need to get myself off to Villa Park. It may well upset Alan Williams but that's how I socialise and derive my enjoyment. Hopefully all you travelling Blues without a ticket don't require the services of a Tout or an approved secondary ticket agent (Tout) Up the Toffees

Tom Hughes
46 Posted 26/10/2013 at 10:54:17
Thomas.... I go away to sea on a 2 on 3 off rota. Before that it was on an equal rota. I've always had a season ticket and simply gave it away when I was at sea. Nowadays I have four tickets as I take the kids and my wife does the honours when I'm not there. There where times in the past when I could've done with this facility as I hated tickets being wasted and I too welcomed its arrival. However, there needs to be a price ceiling otherwise this system not only facilitates touting, it positively encourages it. If you were caught touting outside the ground you could be arrested or at the very least suffer the wrath of irate fans. This system offers anonymity to the unscrupulous and/or those desperate to make a few bob. I can't see it as anything but a collective lowering of moral standards, when it shou
Tom Hughes
47 Posted 26/10/2013 at 11:23:49
...... should be a convenient method of reducing wastage for people like mewho want a season tkt but can't always attend.
Philip Roberts
48 Posted 26/10/2013 at 12:22:52
I live away and couldn't make a game last season so decided to use stub hub to sell my ticket. I put it on for £1 and it went in about 10 mins.They made 25p out of me so it probably cost them more in admin etc... Tickled me anyway...
Matt Traynor
49 Posted 27/10/2013 at 06:58:34
Secondary ticket retailers like Stub Hub are legalised touts. Their sole purpose is to stop ordinary members of the public ripping people off outside stadia - so they can do it instead.

A few years ago I worked with a couple of promotions companies that did music and sports events in Asia. I found out in a lot of cases that official ticket retailers "place" a portion of tickets with resellers. Astoundingly in many cases the reselling companies have ownership ties back to the ticket retailers - who often have ownership ties back to the event promoter.

Some countries (US was one) a few years ago introduced legislation to outlaw touting / scalping by members of the public, and in doing so legalised reselling companies, hence as usual creating another way for big business to profiteer.

Dave Kelly
51 Posted 27/10/2013 at 10:56:57
It's interesting to see how much clubs who have secondary ticketing agreements can influence their agreements.

It would appear that some clubs will just sign the dotted line with these companies and wait for the cheque to clear. With little or no regard for their supporters

However, I find it really interesting that a club with a social conscience Celtic, have ensured that their supporters can not be fleeced by opportunists hoping to make a quick buck.

"The agreement will see Celtic use Stubhub as "an additional distribution channel" for its home match tickets.

Tickets will be independently priced and listed by the Celtic ticket office. The club says it will never sell tickets above face value, nor will there be ticket reselling allowed."

The above quote sourced via BBC Sport demonstrates the latitude that Stubhubs partners have in influencing any agreements.

I would suspect that any club with asocial conscience would look at the detail of the Celtic agreement and learn.

Colin Fitzpatrick
52 Posted 27/10/2013 at 13:27:05
Well put, Dave Kelly.

Highlighting the shortcomings of the StubHub agreement isn't as simple as being against external businesses being involved in distributing or redistributing tickets, agreements with whom are a decision for those responsible for the successful management of Everton Football Club.

Even before watching the video on the KEIOC site, many are beginning to realise that something isn't quite right as they also did with Kirkby, Kitbag, the Park End and how they treated Richard Knights, to name but a few – it's simply not good enough yet again.

It's essential that the sport remains affordable for the ordinary fan, this is what the Twenty's Plenty campaign is all about; this is why the Premier League introduced the Away Fans Fund; this is why Celtic's management have ensured that tickets sold through their secondary partner will never be sold above face value and have agreed a maximum commission of 15% of that value.

There's no doubt that in the past most season ticket holders simply passed their ticket to friends or family for games they're unable to attend, and may continue to do so in the future... but having a facility for season ticket holders to be reimbursed is, in principle, a useful service that, if they choose to use, they can – for their benefit and that of their fellow fan.

In an electronic age, why that needs to be provided by a third party is debatable as the numbers must be relatively small and a match on a fan card can be cancelled electronically and replaced by something as simple as a QR code sent to a Smartphone. These advancements in ticketing technologies should be for the benefit of everyone – not just for the few who either decide to rip off their fellow supporter or those who sit like Pontius Pilate claiming no responsibility whilst accepting their "cut". Let's not forget, we're dealing with tickets that remain the property of Everton Football Club here, it tells you that on the ticket, it's not debentures we're dealing with so I believe Everton should take some responsibility for what is being sold and how it's being sold. Is that such a difficult concept to undertake and understand?

Ticket prices are an issue across the Premier League, So far, Everton have embarrassed themselves over their Away Fans Fund efforts whilst others have shown them the way, as Celtic has in making a responsible secondary ticketing agreement – as opposed to one that is a free for all.

The real question is: Does the commercial management of our club have the acumen to tackle it? Sadly, I'm of the opinion that the list at the end of my first paragraph tells you everything you need to know, but I live in hope of being proved wrong.

Guy McEvoy
53 Posted 30/10/2013 at 20:08:09
I can't get upset with this one. I've used StubHub myself to sell my season ticket when I couldn't go (like this weekend – just found out that trains from Crewe are on bus replacement and I can't now make the time I would need to leave to make the early kick off). Every time I got less than face value, but am glad another fan could go and I got something back.

I've also used it to buy – when I want to take my daughter you can usually get family enclosure tickets (again – most games less than face). Sell mine in the Top Balcony, buy two downstairs – sorted. It's a great service. No chance of the tickets being fake if you're a buyer. If you are a seller, you shift the vetting accountability for the buyer to StubHub (who get addresses and credit card details etc.).

I watched the prices last year and honestly I think it was only the Derby that went above face value. Just because people list them at £575 doesn't mean they have sold at that! And because the transaction is electronic, the club at least knows who's got the ticket. It is a genuinely good service. I wish the commission wasn't as high, but there you go.

Michael Kenrick
54 Posted 30/10/2013 at 20:25:57
Thanks for some really sensible comments on this topic, Guy. You've provided some much-needed balance to the highly questionable accusatoion that this is leagalized touting — hradly so if tickets are mostly exchanged below face value. Then, as you say, the only reasonable objection can be the extortionate commission charge.

And if ever you feel the need to pen a match report....

(Just sayin!)

Paul Andrews
55 Posted 30/10/2013 at 20:36:23
If season ticket holders used "their prerogative" to sell a ticket for the derby game in the street for £575 – or indeed for anything over face value – they would be arrested and charged with a criminal offence.

What is the difference in doing it through an agent of the club? Apart from the club's commission.

Barry Jones
56 Posted 31/10/2013 at 11:16:41
Guy (051) Don't despair you may still be able to go to the game on Sunday. I'm in the Crewe area over the weekend and I'm going to and returning from Goodison and will probably be able to sort out a lift for you from the station. Should be a great game and it would be a pity to miss it because of some engineering works. Just respond on here and we'll sort out meeting up.
Guy McEvoy
58 Posted 01/11/2013 at 19:28:05
Hey Barry - thanks for the offer. I had already shifted my ticket though! (Stub hub 10 pound below face, sold in less than an hour!)

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb