McCarthy enjoying life in Everton's engine room

, 1 November, 33comments  |  Jump to most recent
22 year-old has become a vital part Everton midfield

When James McCarthy arrived from Wigan Athletic on a frantic transfer deadline day at the beginning of September, the biggest talking point was the £13m fee it took to prise him away from the Latics.

Two months later, the Irish midfielder is able to talk about the crucial role he plays in Everton's new-look midfield alongside fellow Goodison new-boy, Gareth Barry, one that has demanded perhaps more industry and graft than he was used to under Roberto Martinez at the DW Stadium where he scored seven times in 120 appearances.

“I think I'm mainly there to do a job,” he says in The Express. “To sweep up and do the dirty work for the flair players to go and express themselves. We have so many flair players in the side that you give them the ball and you expect something to happen.

“If I need to go forward and try and get on the scoresheet I will, but it is difficult at times. If I can help by stopping goals, making passes and getting other players on the ball then I'm happy to do that. I am still young and learning so hopefully I can add goals to my game again.”

Indeed, McCarthy recounts how he was more of a goalscorer as a youngster honing his skills with his brothers and local friends on a patch of ground across the road from his Glasgow terraced house.

“I pretended to be someone like Henrik Larsson. I was more of a goalscorer back then, but I seem to have lost that goal-scoring touch.”

The Republic of Ireland international will turn 23 next month but the Blues' 2-0 win at Aston Villa last Saturday was the 250th appearance of his career, a testament to his importance to the three clubs he has played for since turning professional aged 16 — Hamilton Academical, Wigan and Everton.

He remains focused and aware that he is still learning with every game, though, and was quick to hold his hand up following an uncharacteristically poor tackle in the game at Villa Park on Ashley Westwood.

“It wasn't a nice tackle,” the Glaswegian confesses. “I had a few text messages that night saying how bad it was, but I knew straight away. I thought I would make the ball and I apologised as soon as I did it. It's not me.”

McCarthy and Barry are expected to link up again in the heart of Everton's team against Tottenham Hotspur on Sunday for a mouth-watering contest between two top four hopefuls at Goodison Park.

Quotes or other material sourced from Daily Express



Reader Comments (33)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Phil Sammon
1 Posted 01/11/2013 at 15:06:40
Ten times the player I thought he was.

Great signing, Roberto.

Mark Tanton
2 Posted 01/11/2013 at 15:03:52
Many people were underwhelmed by his arrival - he has been an improvement on Fellaini in my opinion; bringing more balance to midfield and might be the Carsley replacement we've needed since, well erm, Carsley left.
Norman Merrill
4 Posted 01/11/2013 at 15:28:37
On some earlier TW comments, the boy got some unwarranted criticism, some said the fee was to high, others doubted his ability, and some even unfairly compared him to players we should have been after.

Well 4 games on, and against some decent opponents, he has shown he has the makings of a very good player.

I just hope the boy, can keep control of his tackling, and goes on to show the fans what a player he can be for EFC.

Roberto Martinez, has seen the lad grow in stature, since playing him at Wigan, long may it continue.
James Martin
5 Posted 01/11/2013 at 15:39:16
Vast improvement on Fellaini - understands what tempo and aggression mean.
Charlie North-Roberts
6 Posted 01/11/2013 at 16:04:34
I rate this lad! but to say he is better than Fellaini is a bit much at the moment!

Fellaini was and still is a proven Premier League midfielder; yes, Macca has plenty of experience in the Prem but I still can't see him being as versatile as felly!

However he has unlimited potential an I hope he fulfils it!

Michael Winstanley
7 Posted 01/11/2013 at 16:24:25
He has the look of a winner about him.
Steven Telford
8 Posted 01/11/2013 at 16:23:04
It's a pleasure to look at the team sheet these days. Strength, flare and balance.

I love how "unmissed" Fellaini is... Please, please, please let us hold on to Baines.

I'm watering at the mouth for Sunday's game. Biggest game of the season for us so far.

James Flynn
9 Posted 01/11/2013 at 16:27:10
Just keep on young James. Looking like a bargain, so far.
Paul Ferry
10 Posted 01/11/2013 at 16:38:32
Dup
Paul Andrews
11 Posted 01/11/2013 at 16:39:00
Phil Sammon 340

I think he is 10 times the player a lot of people thought. He has thee makings of a top class midfielder in my humble opinion.

Patrick Carty
13 Posted 01/11/2013 at 17:40:16
I myself thought that 13 million was to much to pay for James, but after his bright start to the season he is beginning to grow on me.

Our midfield is the best we have had in years with a great balance of youth and experience.
I would love to sign Tom Ince in january, I think he would be a great addition.

Wayne Smyth
14 Posted 01/11/2013 at 17:43:13
Cue phil walling's bi-weekly snide "wigan" reference....

I didn't know a lot about him before he arrived, but have been mightily impressed with his actual performances. From the short time he's been here it looks entirely possible he will eventually make his transfer fee look like very good value.

He appears to play the game at a faster pace than Fellaini and we'll get punished far less for his misdemeanours. Fellaini used to pick up reds and yellows(often undeservedly) for fun just because he stood out, whereas as we've seen recently, some bad challenges by McCarthy and Barry that could've been a red, go relatively unpunished.

£14M + McCarthy for Fellaini was a great piece of business....with the exception of the £6M for anichebe which I still keep pinching myself about.

Harold Matthews
15 Posted 01/11/2013 at 17:39:31
The way Martinez personally scouted him at Kilmarnock coupled with the determination to bring him to Everton, suggested that this lad was extra special.....and he is. Sitting alongside the Barry masterclass he will learn plenty and Martinez will give short shrift to any clubs with tempting offers. We've got ourselves a real tartar and he's here to stay.
Raymond Fox
16 Posted 01/11/2013 at 18:05:23
As I've no doubt said before elsewhere, he uncannily resembles a young Alan Ball to me.

Not flashy but the type of player every good side needs, the first name on the team sheet.

Andy Meighan
17 Posted 01/11/2013 at 18:04:45
Charlie (#363) — he's better than Fellaini... who, let's face it, hasn't been missed one iota. McCarthy so far has looked worth every single penny we paid for him. Probably the only thing if we're making comparisons is McCarthy doesn't have goals in him, whereas the Hairdo did on account of him being pushed up top because of his height. The old Mick Lyons syndrome if you like.

I still think McCarthy needs to be a bit more careful in the tackle but that'll come. I for one am delighted with the impact he's made alongside Barry and the two of them have hit the ground running. Two excellent signings and McCarthy could be the midfield general we've been crying out for for a while now...

Ask the Mancs what they think of Fellaini and I know what the answer will be.

John Haldane
18 Posted 01/11/2013 at 20:28:43
As I've no doubt said before elsewhere, he uncannily resembles a young Alan Ball to me.

I can see what you mean but for me there's an echo of Tony Kay.

Pat Finegan
19 Posted 01/11/2013 at 20:57:04
I have to keep reminding myself that he's only 23. Excellent player.

I think £13mil was a fair price looking back. Perhaps we could have gotten an equal player at a lesser price but Martinez apparently didn't see McCarthy as a gamble like a cheaper player wpuld have been. We bought to fill a need. We couldn't take a gamble because we needed a sure thing, solid center mid. It looks like money well spent.

Kevin Tully
20 Posted 01/11/2013 at 21:05:05
It's clear some judge a player without even seeing him play (how they come to their conclusions is a mystery)

So judging by his last two or three MOTM performances, and his age, it looks like we have a future superstar on our hands.

Graham Mockford
21 Posted 01/11/2013 at 21:06:28
John,

I like the lad but at two years younger Bally had already been man of the match in a World Cup Final.

If he becomes half as good, I would be a happy man.

Doug Harris
22 Posted 01/11/2013 at 21:30:31
Being where I am, I don't get to see the team live... TV is ok but not the same as being at Goodison or any away game. I'm not passing judgement on the lad yet. If he becomes a stand-out figure in the team over the next few months, all I can say is great for us.

As for omparing him (at the moment) to Alan Ball?!?!? Sorry not a chance... but let's see, given time.

Eugene Ruane
23 Posted 01/11/2013 at 22:59:10
If he just keeps up the work-rate and application he has shown since arriving, I'll be very happy. So far I've been very impressed with everything about him. Seems a good down to earth lad and appears to be concentrating on his football (rather than having his eyeballs tattooed or dating satsuma-coloured scrubbers or buying golf ball-sized diamond earrings or wearing fat cacky wrist watches etc).
Drew Shortis
24 Posted 02/11/2013 at 00:44:17
I'm still a big fan of Fellaini, but I think he had become a distraction to the team as he clearly wanted a move away and it was never clear where his best position was. On paper he should have been a top defensive midfielder (he clearly thinks that's his best position) but I thought he was much more effective as a number ten. He had started to feel like a square peg in a round hole wherever he was playing and I was very pleased to get the £27.5m. I think he will struggle with the same issues at United.

I'm much happier with Barkley as the number ten and McCarthy in the deeper role. They both know what their best position is and Ross will develop into a better number ten than Fellaini. McCarthy has already settled into his role and is happy to do the essential work in the teams engine room alongside the excellent Barry. I'm much happier with our current setup than I was with Neville / Osman and Fellaini in that role.amd mow Osman can now be used in the more advanced role that suits him better.

Mike Gaynes
25 Posted 02/11/2013 at 01:47:34
It's pretty extraordinary that a player who turns 23 this month has 250 appearances under his belt. And he seems to conduct himself with consummate professionalism all the way.

I'm not quite ready to anoint him a "future superstar" this early in his first Everton season, but he certainly looks like the kind of player you build a team around for the long term.

Pablo Connelly
26 Posted 02/11/2013 at 05:20:55
A shoe in for our next captain for me. His desire and determination sets him apart. As he alludes tone clearly has the licence and the engine to join in attacks as well. I think this side of his game will develop in the next few years and we will have a serious player. Possibly the next Roy Keane, and I am not niave to how big a statement that is!
Darren Hind
27 Posted 02/11/2013 at 06:00:55
Barry

He was sent out on loan, not merely "confined to the sticks". Coleman himself has told us it was an invalueable part of his developement. In a short space of time he has been transformed from a talented, but bears arse rough kid, to one of the most exciting full backs in the country. . . .and guess who he. credits with that development?

Mick Davies

Hibbert was " constantly giving away penalties" ? Utterly wrong . I have watched him play since he played for the youth team back in the nineties and there can be few defenders in world football gave away less penalties than him.
If you really want fact to master your perception, try closing your eyes and naming them.

Here’s a few more facts that you two guys may want to consider, because facts trump your "preception" every time

We have not scored well more goals than we had at this stage last year - weve scored less

average attendance is l not well up on this time last season - its actually slightly down

People who want to see the full backs get forward as much as last season are not calling for a return of Hoofball.

Nobody (to my knowledge ) has an "agenda" to "get rid of Martinez" through posting on TW - even those who think he could do even better

And there aint a single Evertonian who wants Everton to lose

Perception eh? If people didnt pass their "perceptions" of as fact. I reckon the responses or "perceived" attacks on Martinez would shrink significantly. . . Maybe thats just err. . . my take on things.

Back on thread

Super article, I thought Seamus lacked awareness wnen he was first introduced, a fatal flaw for a defender, but good coaching, hard graft and shear bloody mindedness have improved himout of recognition - good to see him get the recognition he deserves

Darren Hind
28 Posted 02/11/2013 at 07:13:11
Oops clicked on wrong thread, my post was meant for the Seamus thread
John Haldane
31 Posted 02/11/2013 at 17:45:25
Hmm. Can't see J M ever having the eye for goal that Bally had and not convinced his passing will be as incisive. He has other gifts.

He does seem to share the determination that both Bally and Kay had. His tackling and laying off just remind me of Kay rather than Bally (you'll remember the many 'heart in mouth' moments when Bally went into a physical challenge. Not his greatest strength imo).

Colin Glassar
33 Posted 02/11/2013 at 19:23:26
You're right about Bally's tackling John, it wasn't his strongest point. The similarities between the ginger god and McCarthy is the engine and their economic use of the ball. Nothing fancy, just passing to your teammates and turning defence into attack. Bally was the master. If McCarthy is half as good then we've got a gem on our hands.
James Stewart
34 Posted 03/11/2013 at 00:18:15
A real player and one of those players that are the worst to play against. Never gives up and runs all day long snapping at heels. Top lad
Anto Byrne
35 Posted 03/11/2013 at 05:53:51
I was fortunate enough to see Alan Ball play for Everton then he broke my heart and went to Arsenal; however, I forgave him and watched him play for Southampton were he also has legend status. You put Alan Ball up there with the great players, alongside the likes of:

William Ralph "Dixie" Dean (1924-38)
Neville Southall MBE (1981-98)
Tommy Lawton (1936-39)
Alex Young "The Golden Vision" (1960-68)
Kevin Ratcliffe (1979-92)
Brian Labone (1957-1972)
Ted Sagar (1929-1953)
Thomas George "T G" Jones (1940-49)
Colin Harvey (1963-75)
Roy Vernon (1959-65)
Peter Reid (1982-89)
Graeme Sharp (1980-91)
Dave Watson (1986-2001)
Bob Latchford (1974-81)
Sandy Young (1901-11)
Edgar Chadwick (1888-1899)
Howard Kendall (1966-74, 1981)
Ray Wilson MBE (1964-69)
Joe Royle (1965-1975)
Kevin Sheedy (1982-92)
Gordon West (1962-73)
Dave Hickson (1951-56, 1957-60)
Trevor Steven (1983-89)
Tommy Eglington (1946-57)
Fred Pickering (1963-67)
Gary Lineker OBE (1985-86)
Mick Lyons (1970-82)
Adrian Heath (1981-89)
Johnny Morrissey Snr. (1962-72)
Tommy Wright (1964-73)
Bobby Collins (1958-62)
Derek Mountfield (1982-88)
Sam Chedgzoy (1910-26)
Paul Bracewell (1984-89)
Andrei Kanchelskis (1995-96)
Andy Gray (1983-85)
Brian Harris (1955-67)
Wayne Rooney (2002-04)
Jack Sharp (1900-09)
Mikel Arteta (2005-2011)
Joe Mercer OBE (1932-46)
Cliff Britton (1930-39)
Gary Stevens (1981-88)
Derek Temple (1956-68)
Andy King (1976-80, 1982-84)
Warney Cresswell (1927–36)
John Hurst (1964-76)
Martin Dobson (1974-78)
Tony Cottee (1988-94)
Alex Parker (1958-65)
Tim Cahill (2004-2012)
Jimmy Gabriel (1960-67)
Tony Kay (1962-64)
Duncan Ferguson (1994-98, 2000-06)
Thomas Gravesen (2000-05, 2007-08)

McCarthy has a long way to go and Fellaini is not even in top my100 players. Let's not get too carried away.

Karl Masters
36 Posted 05/11/2013 at 00:52:11
Spurs midfield gave our boys including James a master class for the whole of the first half yesterday. First to everything and fluid off-the-ball movement. We looked like elephants in comparison.

Hopefully, James will turn out great, only a decent start of six or seven games thus far so too early to say. Seems to have a good attitude.

Those saying they don't miss Fellaini... fair enough, but what about the goals? He had five league goals at this stage last season, same as Lukaku this time. Imagine if we had two players with five goals, we'd be second if not first.

Trevor Lynes
37 Posted 05/11/2013 at 11:35:11
I'm afraid like a lot of other young Everton fans, they tend to over-extol the virtues of players they see in a blue shirt. McCarthy is promising and that's all. He may well become a much better player but he is far away from being up to the standard of past wing-halves.

He is not a playmaker. He was over-run in the first half against a very good Spurs team. At the moment, he is learning the game even though he has played so many games. I would say he is not yet up to the standard of Brian Harris or Jimmy Gabriel. To mention him in the same breath as Ball or Kay is a joke. Ball was a World Cup winner and Kay IMO was destined to be even better than Ball if he had not been banned.

Unfortunately nowadays, players are called legends who were/are run-of-the-mill and pretty average. I have seen every player since 1948 and it annoys me when players like Carsley, Gravesen and Cahill are considered legends because they played okay for us. None of them would get into any top Everton side and that's pretty obvious when you consider the opposition they would have had for a starting place. We have had worse players than those three in abundance, but we have lots that were far better.

Chris Morris
38 Posted 05/11/2013 at 12:18:34
Briliant player.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb