Card count is starting to mount

, 5 November, 53comments  |  Jump to most recent
After the card-weilding antics of Mr Friend at the weekend, some Everton players are surprisngly close to getting a one-match suspension if they pick up more yellow cards before the end of the year. James McCarthy is on four while Ross Barkley and Tim Howard each have picked up three.

McCarthy's first booking of the season actually came on the opening day while playing in Wigan Athletic's 4-0 win over Barnsley. He has subsequently seen yellow in three games for Everton, against Fulham, Aston Villa and now Spurs. A fifth at Crystal Palace means he would miss the derby.

Roberto Martinez isn't unduly fazed by the pre-derby tightrope that McCarthy is walking, though, preferring to concentrate on one game at a time.

"At the moment, we need to take every game step-by-step and the focus now is on Crystal Palace," the manager told evertonfc.com.

"It doesn't matter who you play, you only get rewarded three points for a win and one for a draw and that doesn't change.

"In that respect, we look at preparing for Crystal Palace and not any further than that."

After 31 December, the slate is wiped clean, and the totting-up process begins again for the second half of the season.

Quotes or other material sourced from EvertonFC.com



Reader Comments (53)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tony J Williams
1 Posted 05/11/2013 at 12:26:14
One thing I have just remembered and was fuming about on Sunday, was that Howard booking.

He went over to take a free kick, which was a foul, and the dickhead in the middle, with the equally thick as fuck lino, had given a throw-in, so booked Howard, as if he had gone over on purpose to have a go at the lino.

What the fuck was that about?

Patrick Murphy
2 Posted 05/11/2013 at 15:29:56
I also thought that McCarthy was unfortunate to be booked as was Lukaku. These cards are so randomly issued it makes a complete mockery of the system.

Was Sunday's game really worthy of a total of 5 yellow cards — I don't think so... Expect at least one absentee for our next home fixture..

Ralph Basnett
3 Posted 05/11/2013 at 15:32:25
Rest McCarthy for Palace and play Barkley, not rocket science.

Chances of Howard getting another before Xmas is pretty slim so after derby pick a game, take a card and lose Ross for a game simples......

Shane Corcoran
4 Posted 05/11/2013 at 16:08:14
On the flip side, McCarthy could be in the middle of a three game ban for his tackle against Villa.
What a bit of luck that is.
Kevin Tully
5 Posted 05/11/2013 at 15:42:09
Ridiculous - a couple of weeks ago we were the most fouled team the division.

McCarthy missing for the derby would be a serious setback.

Pablo Connelly
7 Posted 05/11/2013 at 16:43:08
I remember I few years back Felliani was in decent form but one card away from a double ban. So when does he pick up the yellow? In the bloody game before we had a season-defining double header against Liverpool. History will tell you if something can go wrong before the derby it generally does. I would take the risk and rest McCarthy at Palace.
Al Reddish
8 Posted 05/11/2013 at 16:51:40
You can see McCarthy getting booked for having his shoe laces undone in the changing room now the refs know he could miss the derby. We need him to clatter Gerraldine in the first minute to put his marker down and scare the twat back into his own shitty shell.
Liam Reilly
9 Posted 05/11/2013 at 16:53:46
Although the Derby has its own importance and of course the bragging rights, it's still only 3 points.

The reason Everton haven't qualified for Europe over the past couple of years is because of the inability to dispatch the piss poor sides. 3 points on Saturday are a must and we should play our best footballers.

Brent Stephens
10 Posted 05/11/2013 at 16:56:46
Rest him against Palace, play him against RS, pick up his 5th yellow against them, miss the Stoke game, back for MU and Arsenal away.
Gerry Quinn
11 Posted 05/11/2013 at 17:19:11
The Lukaku card was absolutely ludicrous - can the club not ask the FA to rescind it based on the video evidence?
Kevin Tully
12 Posted 05/11/2013 at 17:27:53
Gerry - Yellow cards can only be rescinded in a case of mistaken identity.
Si Cooper
13 Posted 05/11/2013 at 17:49:03
McCarthy was booked for a pull back (hand on shoulder rather than fist full of shirt). This seems to be treated as an automatic yellow card at the moment (though I am sure some will have gone unpunished and anything in the box is rarely dealt with appropriately) so it could be said to be soft rather than unfair.

It is ludicrous when considered alongside other challenges that are only punished with a yellow. Consistency of ruling is always the bugbear.

Denis Richardson
14 Posted 05/11/2013 at 18:15:01
Tough call - obviously the derby is important but so is getting 3 points at Palace. If McCarthy is 'rested' then presumably Osman would come in beside Barry and Ross goes in the middle up top. That change should be enough to see Palace off although Osman was really poor starting against spurs. Also means that of the 3 AM players who played really badly against spurs, at least 2 would still start against Palace (assuming delboy starts).

Then again Palace are not Spurs...then again there is the school of thought that you should only worry about the next game....mmm. Will be interesting to see what Roberto does...

Guaranteed McCarthy will get booked in the derby and so would probably miss the Stoke game afterwards, so better to miss the Palace game. With manure and arsenal up after that, we really don't need any suspensions in the next 3-4 weeks.

Essential to get another central midfielder in Jan to give cover for Barry and McCarthy. God help us if one of those two gets injured!

Graham Lloyd
15 Posted 05/11/2013 at 18:32:09
Friend is an absolute egotistical prat. I couldn't believe some of his decision making he made a bad game even worse on Sunday.

The Tottenham fans should have been given their money back for travelling to a game were the referee wrecked it.

Steven Telford
16 Posted 05/11/2013 at 18:38:44
The guy was a serious card Nazi.

The FA need to sit Mr Friend down and explain to him that football is contact sport, and talking by players to the referee is actually permitted.

James Martin
17 Posted 05/11/2013 at 18:52:19
You know McCarthy will miss the derby and two of Lukaku, Barkley, Pienaar, Mirallas & Baines will also be missing through injury. They'll then crock one of our better players early on in the match leaving their full 11 against what is effectively our B team... every... year.
Trevor Lynes
18 Posted 05/11/2013 at 19:39:48
Behave yourself James and don't be so bigoted. Perhaps one of our injured players will be available, surely Alcaraz and perhaps Kone may be fit for the bench at least. Hibbert may be a good shout in a derby match or even Naismith. Perhaps it's Stones's chance for a run out against Palace. He must need some game time rather than just warming the bench.
Darren Hind
19 Posted 05/11/2013 at 19:48:34
Too many bookings for silly whining at the officials.
Patrick Murphy
21 Posted 05/11/2013 at 20:07:58
How many for dissent Darren?
Mark Dunford
22 Posted 05/11/2013 at 19:54:40
Friend was a disgraceful ref. So many ridiculous decisions and I recall Pleat saying on the commentary that Friend had a tendency to book players who complained. All four bookings should be appeallable. The Lukaku one was simply ridiculous and - while Mirallas and Howard were both booked for querying the referees competence - Lukaku's booking merely demonstrated his inability to do the job
Ross Kerry
23 Posted 05/11/2013 at 21:20:04
Put the best team out we can for every game, if they're suspended for the derby tough shit.
Mike Hughes
24 Posted 05/11/2013 at 21:38:41
James #234 - A fellow cynic.They were my thoughts exactly.
Unfortunately fate often conspires against us when the red filth come to town (from Norway etc.)

Knowing our luck John Barnes will get his referees license and the derby will be his first in charge.

Patrick Carty
25 Posted 05/11/2013 at 21:50:15
I have to agree with Liam Reilly and Ross Kerry, play your best team. Of course the Liverpool game is important but the Palace game is more important because it's our next game.

Let's take it one game at a time and get a good result at Palace. If James gets booked, he gets booked, we move on. We should still have enough players who will fight tooth and nail to get a start and a result against Liverpool.

Mick Davies
26 Posted 05/11/2013 at 21:58:05
Just watched Manure game and Rooney hacked a Sociedad player down, totally cynical. Free kick but no yellow card. The victim got bollocked by the ref for complaining but not a word to Shrek. Better news though, the Belgian wig salesman got two yellows. Would like Jimmy Mac on bench at Palace; he's too valuable to be missing the Derby. . .it does mean more than 3 pts
Ray Roche
27 Posted 05/11/2013 at 22:00:24
So, we get ridiculous cards for minimal "offences", visible only to the bellend in black, yet Soldado can elbow Jags without a murmur from the FA? (I notice that Man Utd have got their current little darling extra protection and Reither has been called to account for his alleged stamp on Adnan Januzaj.)

I know it's only a dream but I'd love to see us get parity with some of these other clubs regarding disciplinary matters. Can you imagine the furore if Duncan Ferguson had elbowed anyone in the manner Soldado did?

Patrick Carty
28 Posted 05/11/2013 at 22:12:48
Just read an article on the Spurs site saying the media should have a closer look at Lukaku's tackle on Sunday.

Whoever wrote this may get their eyes tested. What a fucking prick.

Phil Gardner
29 Posted 05/11/2013 at 22:21:47
Same old Everton, not cynical and winey enough by half. Shouldn't RM call a press conference à la Brenda last season? Anyone remember the media-fuelled bleating from Anfield last year when several referees had the temerity to not award The Vermin penalties? So Billy the Fish calls a press conference (dutifully attended by Da Meedja) and squeals about how Ratboy's diving should be rewarded.

Guess what happened two weeks later? Mr Kevin Friend attended a two day 'meet and greet training day' at Melwood... now three guesses who refereed the Scum's next homegame? Yup... you better believe it — the bold Kev.

The point is, honourable or otherwise, isn't it time to start levelling the playing field here? Maybe a bollocking for Baines for not collapsing in mock agony when, say, Bellamy elbows him, demanding retrospective action against the Cardiff Codpiece? Maybe teaching Baines/Coleman to scream and writhe when fouled in the box and the team to surround and harrangue the ref/linesman etc, to gain an advantage. I'm sick of watching it go against us, I'm afraid, it's time for the team to become horrible... it works very well for others!

Nathan Moore
30 Posted 05/11/2013 at 23:38:33
Howard's booking was for waving his hand in the air, suggesting a card be shown. That's a bookable offence these days.

Mirallas's was for dissent and not getting a corner from a blocked shot, he gave the linesman a bollocking so it was probably deserved. But I also remember the foul against Townsend after his run into the box/push on Baines, you could clearly see him waving his arm and yelling "No fucking way!" at least twice, straight at the unfit referee.

McCarthy's was, as suggested, for a cynical pull back which pretty much is a yellow all the time now. Funny thing though, that was in between 2 of Dawson's fouls in the same manner which BOTH went unpunished.

Lukaku's was just fucking ridiculous.

Harold Matthews
31 Posted 05/11/2013 at 22:14:26
Must field our strongest team every match. For me, not winning the Palace game would be worse than losing the bi-annual derby farce.

With Stoke, United, Arsenal and Southampton also coming up before New Year we'll do well to hang on to 7th or 8th by the halfway mark. So much will depend on suspensions and injuries.

The perfect replacement for McCarthy would be John Stones who can tackle, head, pass and has pace. This lad could play anywhere and it's about time we got him onto the pitch.

James Stewart
32 Posted 06/11/2013 at 01:12:43
Rest McCarthy for the derby. His last booking was a joke and so was Lukaku's which wasn't even a foul!
Douglas McClenaghan
33 Posted 06/11/2013 at 02:01:52
Ray 278 - good call. They would be in traction, heh, heh, heh.
Terry Murphy
34 Posted 06/11/2013 at 05:36:11
No matter which way you look at it, the yellow card for Lukaku was ridiculous. If the ref thought it was an accident, then why did he give a card? And if he thought that Lukaku deliberately kicked the keeper in the head then it's a straight red. Either way, a yellow card is a sign of incompetence.
Shane Corcoran
35 Posted 06/11/2013 at 09:56:27
Good to see some United fans and Ray Wilkins having a go at Young this morning.
Nathan Moore, a very well-balanced post and not a hint of paranoia.
Chris Ashton
36 Posted 06/11/2013 at 09:43:48
The yellow mistified me for Lukaku although I was not aware until afterwards that he had been. Picture the scene, sat at a table in Monkey Bizness with the young 'un having a good time and i'm watching the game on my phone which on the table is at least a metre or so away from my eyes. My first thought on Lukaku was he was always trying to get away from Lloris to avoid contact. whether it was to round him or to avoid what happened, I could see in that situation that there was absolutely no intent to hurt the keeper. If I could see that in that circumstances, how could the referee see differently?

The F.A commite is a load of old tosh (putting it nicely) with the appeals and what can and cannot be looked at retrospectivly. Is it not the rule they will not act if a referee sees something on the pitch to begin with? The conspiracy theorist in me sees it set up to benefit the same clubs and punish the others. Only when one of the favourites cause serious trouble do they make an example of them, and that is usually United. Case and point, Rio Ferninand misses drug test and gets 9 month ban. Not guilty of drugs mind you but just misses a test. Yet Adrian Mutu found guilty of Cocaine use and Chelsea can do whatever they like regarding him with no F.A step in despite him being a registered F.A footballer.

If all that happens, what hope have we really got?

Sean Kelly
37 Posted 06/11/2013 at 09:55:01
Rest McCarthy for Palace as he is vital against the redshite. I have been saying two things on different threads for some time. One how short we are for cover in CM ( Gibson is our sicknote) and two that as a team we are too fucking nice. We need a Keane type leader on the pitch but for me Jags is too like pipe and slippers. We need a bollocks on the pitch that will roar and bark instructions and critisism to all around him. This includes the bellends in black we seem to be getting for our games.
Kevin Tully
38 Posted 06/11/2013 at 10:28:20
If you look at the Lukaku incident - he keeps running in a straight line, and their 'keeper slides into his knee.

A simple case of two players clashing - the ref had clearly lost all control of the game on Sunday, same as the other fella at City.

We need to start standing up for ourselves, Barry was the only player giving the ref some back.

John Zapa
39 Posted 06/11/2013 at 09:49:54
Come what may, the club should always pick its strongest 11 available for any and every competitive game. Anything less is an insult to the fans who pay fortunes to watch games.
Brian Smith
40 Posted 06/11/2013 at 13:26:56
I think that, before deciding who to "rest" and who to play to manipulate the cards situation, you need to see who is available. For example, I have read that Lukaku is a doubt for Palace and Kone is out for a while which maybe means a chance for Jelavic.
Bill Gall
41 Posted 06/11/2013 at 13:56:24
As supporters, we exepect the players to show commitment and passion in the game but the sad thing is, due to the saturation of the Premier League by the TV companies, a lot of the newer referees apear to want to be the centre of attention.

In regards to last Saturday and the referee who appeared to downplay the meaning of his name, I shudder to think how many players he would book in a Chel sea-Man Utd game whose players seem to swarm the referee over every decision.

Trevor Lynes
42 Posted 06/11/2013 at 14:48:47
Already after just ten games we are beginning to find our squad is too small to cope with any additional fixtures we may have if we happen to make Europe. All the top teams can do without players in virtually every position. We are almost back to making do and mending with the prospect of players asked to play out of position as was the norm a few seasons ago. The players we have out injured are players we actually own. We are relying on loan players and the season is just over quarter over. It seems Kone will be a long term absentee as are Alcaraz and Gibson. Soon it will be all hands to the pump.

Fans on this site openly castigate players when we actually have no alternatives. I really hope that Lukaku is fit for the weekend against Palace and McCarthy does not get booked otherwise it will be Naismith and Jelavic back for the derby match with Heitinga back on the bench !!!!

Bill Gall
43 Posted 06/11/2013 at 17:56:23
Just read a comment by the Tottenham manager that he thought Lukaku did not make enough of an effort to miss Lloris in the collision.

This to me seems like sour grapes over the flack they are receiving over their refusal to take off Lloris after the collision.

Watching the incident in slow motion it appears that the keeper fumbled the ball and Lukaku had every right to go for the ball but tried to avoid a collision that made his booking a farce.

As the FA discipline committee regularly suspend players after viewing games at a later date, surely they should be able to cancel unjust yellow or red cards given unjustly.

Harold Matthews
45 Posted 06/11/2013 at 21:25:27
Yes, we're a bit thin on the ground but the likes of Oviedo, Stones, Deulofeu and Naismith can all come in and do a job. Don't know about Jelavic. He is a bit leaden footed but if we are hanging on with 10 minutes to go, he defends well at set pieces.
Steavey Buckley
46 Posted 07/11/2013 at 00:51:32
Everton players must learn not to dive in but close down the opposition. The opposition are always waiting for a reckless tackle to make more of it, to get the other booked or sent off.
Jamie Crowley
47 Posted 08/11/2013 at 14:27:31
As we draw closer to our game, I concur with many posters above. McCarthy simply can not be risked against Palace. In fact, I think it's the ideal time to also rest Lukaku a bit. I'd go like this:

Howard
Coleman Jagielka Distin Baines
Barry
Deulofeu Osman Pienaar
Barkley
Mirallas

Let Lukaku come off the bench. Ditto with McCarthy if the game is tight. And I might move Pienaar to the middle and take off a tiring Osman and put Naismith on the wing.

Mirallas has been awful but the one bright light I saw from him was when we put him up top for 20 minutes earlier in the season. He ran his socks off while up there. I think with a quick chat from RM to him telling him he expects a strong work rate from him up top; he'll do a good job. Sorry Jelavic...

That lineup can handle Palace and will protect McCarthy and rest a very heavily used Lukaku a bit.

Col Wills
48 Posted 08/11/2013 at 15:13:34
Sorry, Jamie and Harold, but you don't rest your best players until you absolutely have to... We are only TEN games in, for Pete's sake, don't you remember what happened in the League Cup against Fulham? Martinez's one and only mistake so far that was.

3 points are 3 points – whether it's against Palace or against Them – and are equally as important.

It's down to Jimmy Mac to conduct himself in the correct way, as he did for an hour after his Spurs booking.

Tony J Williams
49 Posted 08/11/2013 at 15:37:14
Sounds good Jamie, my only worry is thinking apart past cup exits, change the team a little and we have lost a game.

Play your best XI and hope for the best, win at Palace and worry about the Redshite later

James Flynn
50 Posted 08/11/2013 at 15:24:08
Jamie - The 3 points are the same regardless of the game. If McCarthy's healthy, he plays. The Top 8 are strong sides. We can't afford to slide back in the Table.

ManU wins at home, we win at Palace, we're right in it.

By the way, congrats on beating the Cardinals.

Tony Marsh
51 Posted 08/11/2013 at 16:04:55
If I were laying odds on McCarthy picking up a yellow card at Palace tomorrow, those odds would be very skinny indeed. It's an absolute cert James gets a booking and I would go 1-3 it happens. Don't forget which ever shitbag ref we end up with for tomorrow's game will be looking to get Macca banned for the derby match as its what these clowns in the middle live for.

If McCarthy plays at Palace, he gets booked and there is no escaping it.

Jamie Crowley
53 Posted 08/11/2013 at 20:04:02
I agree with Mr Marsh.

Whereas I do understand and frankly usually agree with the logic of win what's in front of you, tomorrow's worries are for tomorrow.... I think in this case we have an extenuating circumstance.

McCarthy will be booked - they hate us and will make sure of it.

Liverpool is a game where u break the proverbial rule book to ensure your best are on the pitch prepared to play.

In fact I'd sing an entirely different tune if we were playing ManU or any other "big" club game after next.

James Flynn
54 Posted 08/11/2013 at 20:39:16
Jesus Tony - Take a pill. The best players play against our next opponent. McCarthy plays, card or not. We'll worry about the RS when they're next up on the schedule.

Jamie - 3 titles in the last 10 years and STILL with the Red Sox supporter paranoia? Jeez.

Shane Corcoran
55 Posted 08/11/2013 at 21:07:46
Oh man do I hope McCarthy plays and doesn't get booked.

What would Tony say then? Surely it'd shorter than 1/3 if there's no escaping it. I mean all the refs and everyone involved in football demand it.

Raymond Fox
56 Posted 08/11/2013 at 21:06:11
I am in the "McCarthy plays at Palace" camp, what happens if he doesn't play and we lose to Palace? — My god, RM would be asked to resign by some on here.

It would be great to play our best team against RS, but not sensible to risk the above scenario, I'd say.

Jamie Crowley
57 Posted 08/11/2013 at 22:20:16
James -

When you've gone through a lifetime of hell, only to reach Nirvana...

I'd personally rephrase "paranoia" to "prudence" or possibly "long-term vision".

However, I do take your point along with all the others that say win at Palace and come what may.

Opinions... the fuel that makes the TW motor run.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb