Lethargic Blues drop two more points

, 9 November, 178comments  |  Jump to most recent
Crystal Palace 0 - 0 Everton

Everton slogged their way through another goalless draw as Crystal Palace arrested a seven-match losing streak with their first clean sheet of the campaign.

The Blues controlled the game with an astonishing 72% of the possession but were let down by a depressing lack of urgency and an absence of any punch in the final third that resulted in just two shots on target all afternoon.

Surprisingly it was Palace, overseen by caretaker boss Keith Millen, who spurned three gilt-edged chances as they opened up Everton's usually stingy defence, Kagisho Dikgacoi missing arguably the best of them with an embarrassingly mis-timed header in the first half.

Jerome Thomas also forced a great save from Tim Howard with an attempt to curl one under the crossbar.

For Everton, Romelu Lukaku narrowly missed connecting with Leon Osman's sliced shot after 12 minutes, Kevin Mirallas forced the only real save from Speroni with an excellent low shot after 21, while Osman shot straight at the ‘keeper in the waning moments of the first half.

The assault from the Blues after a lethargic first period never really materialised after the break and though they looked more threatening following the introduction of Gerard Deulofeu and Ross Barkley for Mirallas and Osman after 55 minutes, they didn't manage a single shot on target, Jagielka coming the closest to breaking the deadlock with a header off the bar from a corner late on.

Thomas, meanwhile, had earlier passed up another great chance for Palace when he sprung the offside trap but chipped into the side-netting with just Howard to beat.

A second-successive 0-0 draw — the fourth of the campaign so far — represents more crucial dropped points but Everton extended their unbeaten run to four games.

Roberto Martinez was disappointed with the result and lamented the fact that his team couldn't find "that little bit of sharpness in the final third" against a well-organised Palace defence.

"In the first half, we had a couple of half chances and you probably feel that we should have made better decisions," Martinez said after the game. "We probably allowed ourselves to get a little frustrated. When the ball went out it took ages to come back in and it was that sort of game; very stop-start. We couldn't get into a position to break them down in their defensive set-up."

The Spaniard took heart from another clean sheet, however, pointing out that when you're as focused as his team were on trying to break the opposition down, "you're vulnerable to a quick break or at a dead-ball situation you can lose a clean sheet. It's important when you don't win that you keep doing the right things and keep a clean sheet.

"You can understand our disappointment," he continued. "When you have all the play we had, you need to be able to make that final pass with a little bit of know-how to break the other team down."

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Reports



Reader Comments (178)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Sam Higgins
1 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:40:34
Poor today. We do not have a player who can unlock stubborn defences.
Nick Entwistle
3 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:45:01
Stubborn would be a blessing, but Palace is another thing.

Too slow and laboured in the build up. What's the point of Bainaar and Miralman if you don't link them up like they're good at?

Patrick Murphy
4 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:42:05
I don't suppose this idea will go down well with many, but I honestly believe now that we are half-way to safety that RM would be wise to write-off any hopes for European football at Goodision and start to rebuild his team for next season.

I know we have little in the way of money and we can't radically alter things until January but we cannot afford another wasted season where the usual suspects retain their places in the side as the holy grail of Europe seems attainable but is ultimately out of reach.

Players win or lose football matches not systems or managers and our players have flattered to deceive all too often no matter who was the manager or what system they employed. When a guy like Lukaku doesn't have a decent chance in a game where his team have dominated possession you realise the team has problems.

Roman Sidey
5 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:47:28
Can't answer that, Brent, but we certainly didn't look like scoring very many times today.

Here's a quote from that closed thread: "You'd think we had lost 11 out of 11 the way some are going on." No, you'd think we'd just failed to beat a team that had lost nine out of 10.

Brent Stephens
6 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:51:43
Patrick, a really good question. I was about to post something perhaps linked to that, which is whether we should continue to try the manager's new approach against Liverpool and suffer the probable consequences (as has been said, we've a long way to go before he gets there) or we try to come out of that game with some respect by reverting to something the Scottish Manager would have played?

Stu Cameron
7 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:54:18
How Osman gets in our team is unbelievable. No urgency in the lad whatsoever.

As for Mirallas, for me, he will never be a winger. I thought when we bought him he was top scorer in Greece with 20 goals and got Greek Player of the Year as a striker. I think with his speed, skill and eye for goal we are totally wasting his ability by playing him out wide. Also, I don't like the way our defence are passign it around the back.

Nick Entwistle
8 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:03:56
Patrick, any manager worth his salt should be able to get our starting XI banging them in against Palace. Its a healthy well balanced squad we have. You won't find answers in January because the questions relate to here and now.
Mike Keating
10 Posted 09/11/2013 at 17:53:24
Sounded bloody awful today – we had 70% possession and relied on a wonder save from Howard and two poor finishes from the leagues worst strikers to scrape a draw .

I'm getting worried: two goalless draws back to back with Lukaku in the team. And we have the derby on the horizon – bet they are relishing it more than us.

Patrick Murphy
11 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:07:35
David Moyes tried and failed for the most part in the last three years Nick and that's my point really, the players are far too comfortable and don't have to give their all in every match to stay in the team.
Sam Hoare
12 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:05:46
Loads of possession and very few chances. Ideally we would have lots of both but if not I'd rather the latter.

Feels a bit like we will soon lose sight of the top 4 if we don't do considerably better in the final third.

Graham Mockford
13 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:04:25
I'm wondering if our lack of cutting edge is linked to playing two holding midfield players. Both do the job they are employed to do but neither bring much in an attacking manner. The build-up play is slow and ponderous and our wide players are not brought into the game quickly enough.

In 11 games now we have had 14 goalless halves — not I guess what most were expecting from Martinez. We also rather worryingly don't seem to have the intensity in our play that has characteized us over previous years.

I can only think of one half against Newcastle and West Ham where we have dominated a game and, if I was being charitable, 20 minutes against Man City and against Aston Villa. I would suggest our results have been better than our performances have warranted. I'm not feeling optimistic for a fortnight's time.

Patrick Murphy
14 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:15:25
Graham if we had Ronaldo, Rooney, Bale and Messi in our line-up in a fortnight's time I still wouldn't be optimistic when playing our neighbours.
Mark Frere
15 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:15:43
No Graham, its got nothing to do with McCarthy and Barry. Our problem is: Mirallas, Pienaar, Osman and Barkley aren't playing anywhere near good enough. We need much more from our more creative players.
Ian Glassey
16 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:14:47
Not looking forward to the Derby game at all, we have got to help Lukaku he cant do it all on his own.
Tony Cheek
17 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:01:10
Infuriating....unbelievable that we didnt lose by three at least. The RS will crush us if we put in a performance like this in 14 days time. To be quite honest I can clearly see why Mourinho let us have Lukaku. He may be a good finisher, but that is all he is. His hold-up play is attrocious and I have seen junior players with a better first touch.

The first half against Spurs last week was probably the worst I have seen from an Everton side for many years, but today was a real step backwards. Predictable, slow build-ups, crap finishing and at times, very poor defending. I hope Martinez uses the break to get some confidence back into our players, otherwise we are on a slippery slope.

Steve Brown
18 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:25:06
Mark 021, I would add Baines into the mix. He has been poor all season and it's obvious his head has been turned.
Peter Thistle
20 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:21:50
Baffles me how ya can play a team as poor as Palace and only have 2 shots on target. Time for Roberto to lose the mr nice guy approach and slaughter them in training to put some fire under their arse before the derby.
Mike Price
21 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:20:40
Patrick 002, I know what you mean. This is a season of transition and I would be happy for him to sort out the squad and have a good attempt at the FA cup, because I don't think we're ready for a serious top 4 challenge.
It was painful to watch today and I was shocked to see Osman start. My main worry is the lack of a warrior anywhere in the squad. We urgently need someone to rouse the other players, lift the tempo and be hard and aggressive when need be. We're just too nice, and it's because of that that I'm getting worried about the next game...let's face it, the horrible bastards have lots of nasty, aggressive twats and a horrible manager who has learnt to use the media to plant seeds for their future gain.
Praying that we don't get out psyched or outfought!
Mark Frere
22 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:30:24
By Baines's very high standards, he has been poor, Steve. Certainly today, his delivery was the worst iv'e ever seen it. Still, I don't see Baines as being the major problem of how we've played so far this season.
Graham Mockford
23 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:35:05
Mark

I'm not criticising either player, they have been two of our better players, it is just they don't create much.
By the time our attacking players especially Mirallas and Baines get possession they are normally facing a bank of defensive players. We have lots of possession but we seem to lack penetration.

Steve Burgess
24 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:29:22
Mark Frere - yes. We need much more movement from the front 5 players (I'd include McCarthy in this group). I think Martinez also needs to work out how he can incorporate full backs in the attack, probably our best attribute under Moyes. At the moment both Baines and Coleman look blunted and lacking in motivation. I think Martinez is intelligent and his ability to make incisive changes in the game gives confidence that he can see these problems and will sort them. It is possible that not all of our players are up to this change in style (fitness/technical ability) but I would have thought that McCarthy, Mirallas, Peanut, Barkley and Delefeu have enough between them to do better.
Ian Glassey
25 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:29:27
What has happend to the form of both fullbacks, wingers? So many players off form and only ten games into the season. I think we will need to get a few players in come January, but who and where from is anyone's guess.
Brian Waring
26 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:34:31
Huge decision for Martinez when we play the Shite. When Delboy Barkley have come of the bench, we have looked better and there seems to be a bit more urgency in our play; does he take the chance and play the two of them from the start, and replace two of the more experienced Osman, Pienaar and Mirallas???
Roman Sidey
27 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:37:06
Mark, good point. Baines is not the problem. However, I think he encompasses our problem. The commentators were saying at the start of the match how well we've been playing, and I thought, "The only thing they've seen of us is the league table." Likewise, Baines is surrounded by a lot of, fairly earned I'll add, hype and hasn't really played all that well in about six months, yet he's still being touted as the best LB getting around. As was asked on GoT, when was the last time we scored from a corner (Baines takes most of them doesn't he?)? And, when was the last time Baines set a goal up with a cross or pass?
Brent Stephens
28 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:42:48
Brian, my feed on the game was none too good at times today but I didn't see Barks do much at all and did see him make a few mistakes. Delboy was a bit more in the game I thought.
Sam Hoare
29 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:42:46
Who would have thought that our defence would be stronger and attack weaker under Martinez?!

Really, really not looking forward to the derby. I suppose form goes out the window but they look considerably sharper than us at the moment.

Brian Waring
30 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:44:21
Agree Brent, Barkley did make a few mistakes, the big difference I thought though, we just looked a bit more threatening, and there was a bit more tempo to our play.
Mark Frere
31 Posted 09/11/2013 at 18:40:24
I wasn't saying you were criticising them Graham. I'm just saying, the players which we rely on to be creative are playing piss poor. It would be nice if we had the luxury or option of Gibson to add a bit of passing range from deeper positions. But the blame needs to be put on the shoulders of players that aren't doing their job properly.
Dan McKie
32 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:03:53
Is anybody else concerned that under our new so called attack minded manager, that our decent attackers from last season now often look utter garbage? When things clicked under Moyes, we looked unbeatable and we were fluid and looked like scoring despite our desperate need for a decent striker, but then he would go all defensive again for seemingly no reason. Under Martinez, our build up is always the same, starting with Howard, then 10 or 20 passes between Jags and Distin, before one of our more attack minded players recieves the ball, looking void of any ideas. We play in straight lines, Coleman doesn't seem the player he was, Baines and Pienaar neither, and don't even get me started on Mirallas! It seems it is just about having the ball, rather than what you do with it that's important to Martinez. Four 0-0 draws from 11 games is not what you would expect from fluid football.
Aman Kanji
33 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:08:16
Not impressed. Is the jury still out on our 'Roberto'? Talks the talk, but I didn't see it on the pitch...

Mirallas should have stayed on, attacking with Lukaku. Pienaar should be rested... Baines shouldn't be taking corners, and rotate free kicks.

Gutted.

Kevin Tully
34 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:22:20
Leroy Fer has just scored, and threw his knees into the crowd.
Colin Glassar
35 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:29:32
Aaron Ramsey has just escaped from OFM's house.......again Kevin!!
Kevin Tully
36 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:29:30
I thought Baines & Coleman were both allowed to get forward all game Mark, when they got there though, every move just broke down for one reason or another.

The manager has to take some of the blame of course, but too many players were not at the races today.

Kevin Tully
37 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:32:23
Col - definitely some scope there for one of Eugene's tales.

Tommy Coleman
38 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:45:28
Defo going through a funny spell. Another slow start and lack of sharpness points to the team's week of preparation.
We've got to beat Liverpool to keep up the chase with Arsenal and the rest.

Barkley must start against LFC.

Matty Williams
39 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:39:08
Today was painful & also a disgrace for this great club; players need to be dropped NOW! Fuck 'em... stars or not — I'd drop Baines & Coleman. Just the idea of dropping these lads will scare the rest into producing a decent display verses the RS in a few weeks time.

We need two strikers now, we have to play Jelavic with Lukaku, no more packing midfield shite, no more tippy-tappy shite, we need pace, speed & a willingness to shoot on sight: 4-4-2 now verses every fucking team, home or away, league of cup tie.

I want us to attack more with pace! Most of our squad have been half-arsed all season; a poor show in the Derby & we can write off this season NOW ! Today, we were a joke!

Jim Bennings
40 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:35:10
I think you're missing the point to say McCarthy is just a grafter and at £13 million you would rather have brought in Cabaye. Is this the same Cabaye who spat his toys out of the pram when his move to one of the big boys didn't quite come to fruit, and will probably do the same again in January?

It's not McCarthy's fault that the likes of Pienaar, Osman, Mirallas, Deulofeu and Barkley (lately) are not producing enough end product. Our best two most consistent players this season so far are our two new midfielders, Barry and McCarthy. They have both done their job admirably well, if only we could say the same of several other so-called big name creative players.

Starting with Mirallas... I knew last season that he was never an 'away match player' and had a tendency to disappear in the big away games – the no-show at Anfield when so much was expected from him particularly. This season though he is not even shining in the home games or against sides he should be making more of an impact against.

Pienaar has not been the same player since signing again permanently; he was fantastic on his loan spell but since last year he has been bloody frustrating, at times awful.

Baines cannot take a corner, I want to see corners whipped in with pace like Hinchcliffe used to take, not floated in; he can't even keep them in play lately.

When is the last time we scored direct from a corner? I watch other teams and think we really miss a trick when we never seem to profit from any goals hardly from set-pieces.

I know it's going to be a season of transition, it's going to be hard for Martinez at times. We still have the same old problems that rear their ugly head, the problems that were there last season, failing to take three points in games like today etc etc. I want to look on the bright side: it's six clean sheets already (this time last season, just the two).

Whether I can put my hand on heart and say I am looking forward to the derby?? No chance. I havent looked forward to matches against Liverpool since the days when we used to bully their spice boys in the 1990s. (Did we really go five years without losing to that shower? Oh for the days to return.)

Brent Stephens
41 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:03:08
Michael, would it be worthwhile shifting posts 054, 058, 063 and 064 to the Talking Points piece??
Roman Sidey
42 Posted 09/11/2013 at 19:33:56
Agreed, Kevin, and in response to Dan Brierley, our wingers must have had the ball 20 times each in the attacking third and probably put in three crosses. A big forward like Rom would thrive on quick crosses catching the halves on the back foot. Though at this rate we're relying on 20 yard shots through five or six bodies to get us the goals.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
43 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:05:54
Will do, thanks, Brent. I moved #059 over as well...
Mark Frere
44 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:00:25
I wonder if we would look any better playing 3-5-2 or 3-4-3 formations. This would at least keep Baines and Coleman further up the pitch where they are most effective. We could also play Mirallas along side Lukaku with Barkley behind, playing 3-5-2. Not saying this is the answer...but it maybe worth a try. Thoughts anyone?
Richard Farrington
45 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:14:38
I've just got back from the game and the journey back to my Essex home sums the day up perfectly - shite. It took me longer to go 30 miles on public transport than it does to drive back the 220 miles for a home game.

The performance today was shocking and lacked any urgency. They were all worth no more than a 5/10 other than Howard who kept his third clean sheet, the back four were shite, Baines looks like he's off and maybe that's disrupting the group, the distribution from the back was terrible. Jagielka played like he got in at 5 this morning after a 12 hour bender. The midfield as a creative and attacking force were woeful and our supposed 'flare' players Mirallas/Delofoue were garbage. The Spaniard lokking completely out of his depth against errrr.... Crystal Palace.

The honeymoon period is over from Martinez - time to see what he's made of.

SHITE.

Paul Holden
46 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:23:41
We'd better find that sharpness against the shite or we're fecked
Kevin Rowlands
47 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:43:14
Have to say what I've seen of the supposed Spanish wonder boy in his admittedly sparse playing time so far hasn't been that impressive to me, the couple of times he tried to take a man on today, he just simply ran into them and gave the ball away... and some of his decision making is awful.

Hopefully he'll prove me wrong, but I certainly don't see a potential superstar in him, am I missing something?

John Malone
48 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:38:24
Well said 078 Richard Farrington say it as you see it, today's performance was nowhere near good enough and might bring to light the fact we havn't played well for a whole game since Martinez arrived. Every game I've watched this season has been really open no matter what opposition we've played, I'm seriously thinking about selling my derby ticket because from what I've seen this season we'll get smashed. If we never had Lukaku we'd have few points and have rode our luck in most games. Still yet to be convinced by the tactics or the formation, can't understand why you need two holding midfielders/playmakers when the team is not creating r scoring enough.
Ken Farrington
49 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:33:52
Thankfully, unlike my son (078) I did not have to suffer the inconvenience and frustration of public transport nor the sheer insult of an awful view from his exorbitantly priced seat in a dilapadated stadium as I was lucky enough (?) to watch the match on my lap top computer, sheltered from the heavy rain that swept the country making a drab, lifeless performance seem even more depressing. (even though I watched it for free I still feel like requesting a refund!)

I still believe, however, it is too early to judge RM, we have some big games coming up in the next few weeks and then there's the January transfer window when his judgement will surely be tested providing the board back him and that several players leave the club wich is easier said than done if they're on long, lucrative contracts.

I trust that the work has already started to freshen up the squad and that the search for better players than what we have now extends a bit further than his previous club down the East Lancs Road.

Richard Farrington
50 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:55:13
Yes John, say it as we see and every blue that saw that today will be worried about the derby as we didn't have a clue and even worse they didn't seem to be that bothered.

I agree that we have taken some fortuitous points so far (West Ham/Chelsea - even Hull) where we just haven't been convincing at all and I am far from convinced about Martinez' strength of character and his tactical ability, like I said - its time to see if he is up to the job as another post mentioned that the entire team weren't at it today which may suggest a more serious problem at Management level.

Harvey Miller
51 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:11:47
It's pretty lame when you can't beat a team that's already going down,

The problem right now is that we just don't have good enough players. Mirallas on his day is excellent but every other day he's nowhere.
Osman was never a proper midfield player: it tells a lot about England's poor status when such a player who can't shield the ball, wins a cap.
Coleman plays well at times and the next game could be a disaster.
I think Baines has decided to go to ManU.

Andy Crooks
52 Posted 09/11/2013 at 20:52:20
I fear there's a real thumping coming for us soon. The RM project,which I believe is for the long term good, is going to hit some snags and require some patience. We had a huge amount of possession today but created nothing.

We have a mixture of good players, past it players and players totally out of form. Our limited resources mean we just cannot afford much of the latter The first half against Newcastle showed what this side can do, doing it more consistently is going to require changes.

Finally , serious question, I thought Mirallas was going to be a top player. Why has he been so poor this season?

Mark Tanton
53 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:15:30
He's never been the same since he got done by Buck Tooth when he was terrorising those snort pigs in the Goodison derby.
Eugene Ruane
54 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:14:11
Andy, re Mirallas, he can obviously play (better than most of them) but that means nothing if he's not arsed and/or more interested in gold Bentley's and daft haircuts or whatever the latest glittery distraction is. He needs a REAL kick up the hole.
Steavey Buckley
55 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:04:49
Crystal Palace team talk before the match by the temporary manager was simple, "stop Lukaku and that's it and we will get at least 1 point" - should have got 3 - 3 Palace guilt edge chances spurned in the first half.

The Palace manager must have realised after Everton's match against Spurs how toothless they are when Lukaku can't score.

Going into the match with the same formation as the previous week was a blessing in disguise for Palace. 3 in midfield and Lukaku isolated. What a great pity without someone up front to shoulder the responsibility of scoring and making space for the other.

Steven Telford
56 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:19:12
I admit I only got to see the first half because I got called into work but, judging by today's performance, unless we seriously pick up, I see us finishing 8th in the table. We were all over them, then in font of goal we were a pile of shite.

We started way too cocky, our guys took the 3 points for granted, and played like a knock around the park........ By God, we can't even get consistency on something as simple corner taking. KM needs a kick up the arse.

What is disturbing is, it was a goalless draw that we would have lost if they had a quarter decent striker.

John Malone
57 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:13:05
I think what's lacking is firstly competition for places and secondly the ginger nut's fear factor, too many players are not at it and need a good rollicking, Jags needs to step up and dish it out to the likes of Mirallas who needs to work harder I'm worried he's going to be a flash in the pan and not tough enough to last in the prem.

All will be forgotten if we beat the rs but being honest I'm full of fear due to the fact Suarez is flying and we seem to lack leaders on the pitch, say what you want about Neville but he was always there to be counted on and rallied the troops in battle we're definitely missing some character in the team.

Kevin Rowlands
59 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:36:53
I think were just going to have to hope Mirallas finds his form because no chance is Deulofeu ready to start in a derby, I think the only change I would make is Barkley for Osman and hope for the best in two weeks.
Brent Stephens
60 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:48:06
Just seen the Chelsea penalty - atrocious decision.
Ralph Basnett
61 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:44:36
She was a red when I met her so no chance of changing and unfortunately as I love her have stayed with her and for every derby have always said before hand that "I think this one is your" and hoped not, but I really fear for us after today.

Weak and weak followed by a little more weak, and Osman, Pienar and Mirallas will still start. Playing against a team who’s manager was taught by RM ’s style at Swansea but seems to do it better!!!

We had a near miss at home last year and the only thing that I think will get us through is there internationals all getting injured, a thing I don’t ever wish on anyone but to the rule this has to be the acceptance...

James Flynn
62 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:24:54
Stephen (085) - "What's going on?
We do not seem to have the fighting spirit just now. The last two games especially it appears the players are missing something. Be that energy, self belief or a leader who shouts and demands more from the group as a whole".

It shows, doesn't it. I think the players are adjusting to a different . . . . . temperament, if that's the right word, in the locker room. The last 18 months or so have seen the departure of old drill sergeant Moyes, Neville, and Cahill.
Especially Neville and Cahill.

They were past it as Prem regulars and had to go, especially Neville. That I won't quarrel. But, they were the spine/steel in the Side.

We need someone to step up to that. But who?

Dave Lynch
63 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:53:09
We are either.

A) Going through a blip.

B) Seeing the real Martinez.

The Martinez that had Wigan playing high tempo attacking football 20% of the time.

Unfortunately they where shite the other 80%

Dick Fearon
64 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:49:47
John M @114, you voiced my concerns about not having a leader on the pitch.
For all his get stuck in never say die attitude Jags does not fill the bill.
He always comes across as being under pressure to do his own job he does not inspire confidence in others.
Richard Farrington
65 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:50:20
Kevin, Deulofeu is not ready for the Premier League, a derby is way beyond him and I am beginning to worry about Martinez making bold statements about players that is basically just bollocks.

He stated that the young Spaniard was ready to take the league by storm, well we've just played the bottom club and he had half an hour in which he was miles away from the standard required and is nowhere near strong enough physically to make an impact. They just took the ball from him like candy from a baby.

I just pray that the players and management can find a way in two weeks but its more in hope than expectation as I sit here right now.

John Malone
66 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:59:29
Got to agree 100% James Flynn defintiely lacking the character and spirit what we were known for under Moyes era. Jags is captain and is a quality defender but has never come across as a great barker/talker I'm not sure if we have that charcter anywhere in the team so the leadership and ferocity needs to come from the manager. Being calm, controlled and technical is great as long as there is a passion burning beneath it, at the minute we're getting neither and I think the riot act needs to be read before the derby if we want to make a success of this season.
Kevin Rowlands
67 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:59:10
I honestly think Martinez made a mistake benching Barkley, yes he makes some mistakes and some poor decision making but when he's firing that's when the team looks a real threat, I don't want to beat a dead horse but surely RM can see at this point that Osman should only play a limited role. The next couple of transfer windows are going to be important because not only will we have to replace Baines, but we are going to have to start looking for long term replacements for Osman, Pienaar, Distin, Jelavic, Hibbert, Howard, and Heitinga...gulp.
Richard Farrington
68 Posted 09/11/2013 at 22:13:32
Yes Kevin, very sobering thought that on a Saturday night - oh shit!!!
Mark Dunford
69 Posted 09/11/2013 at 22:05:47
Terrible game to watch and I thought we were lucky to be playing such a dreadful side. One serious shot on goal from Mirallas but otherwise we didn’t have a serious effort. They played eight defenders who watched us pass the ball sideways in front of them. Whole thing was dispiriting and nothing more so than seeing Distin come over to the crowd at end for what seemed like some sort of argument about something or other. Miserable game to watch. We perked up after the subs but it says a lot that Barkley was pos our best outfield player. Howard made one great sVe and some telling interception
Kevin Rowlands
70 Posted 09/11/2013 at 22:14:43
Richard, agree 100% on the so called Spanish wonder boy, from what I've seen, utter crap, and he looks overweight and unfit, I don't understand some of the posters on here calling for him to start??? I watched the late game today and that lad Redmond looks a far better prospect, we should have gone in for him at 3 mill he's a bargain.
Mike Hughes
71 Posted 09/11/2013 at 22:36:30
Well, according to Roberto, we did OK today and that worries me more than the player performances.
Raymond Fox
72 Posted 09/11/2013 at 21:59:10
Disappointing game.

When Moyes left we could have carried on playing in the same style, and maybe finishing 6-8th as usual, ok if that's what your satisfied with, after all, Moyes got the rep as a miracle maker for doing the same, on our budget.

Martinez came in with a promise of playing a more passing approach and at least trying something different.
It now seems pretty obvious that with these players, top 4 isn't going to happen, not this year!
I think we got carried away with a promising start, but reality is starting to return.
In the end it all comes down to money, I think we all know that, but would rather like to forget the fact.
I mean, we can talk about dropping players, but who are we going to replace them with?

Jason Heng
73 Posted 09/11/2013 at 23:42:52
Fielded 1 striker against the bottom team. Nothing changed has it?
Ernie Baywood
74 Posted 09/11/2013 at 23:40:04
When a team has 72% possession the opposition should be exhausted from chasing, but that never really happened because our passing just wasn't incisive enough to warrant chasing.

There needs to be a change in the way we play. I'm not accepting that good players become average across the board without reason. I wonder how much RM would have liked to play 3 CBs so we could support Lukaku better and give Baines/Coleman space to provide our attacking width?

Right now I'd be changing things to a front three. 4-3-2-1. Wingers are wasted on us... Ross and Kev playing off Lukaku. GB, JM, and one of Leon or Pienaar in the centre. We need to find a way to get the best out of our creative players because this current system isn't working.

Suarez gives me nightmares.

Harold Matthews
75 Posted 09/11/2013 at 22:54:26
As mentioned previously, too slow and ponderous. The lethargic build-up starting with Jags going sideways, allows the opposition to get 8 men behind the ball. No matter who plays where or when, the system discourages alertness and aggression. Everything loses sharpness. The legs, the feet, the mind. We need to quicken up all round and Martinez will have to stop waffling and start putting things right.
Trevor Lynes
76 Posted 10/11/2013 at 00:05:36
Just reading about Adam Lallana the new wonder boy at Southampton. He was an Evertonian and so is his Dad.

Why Oh Why do we not produce anyone like him from our youth system? The last one was Rooney and he was away whilst in his teens. Lallana came through the Southampton youth system and has stayed with them.

This is by far the best Southampton team I have ever seen. They all pass and move... we just pass!

Colin Grierson
77 Posted 10/11/2013 at 00:10:43
We were poor today. Let's hope that RM learnt enough today about the team selection and the performances of the majority of the team to form a plan for a fortnight's time.

Both Baines and Coleman have posed little or no threat of late and we have looked toothless. I would like to see Deulofeu start a game to see if he will bring that inspiration that is missing. He did one great cross-field run which led to a cynical foul and a wasted free-kick from Baines. I reckon playing him wide right and pushing Mirallas alongside Lukaku would give us more threat.

I'll trust RM though cos, even though today was frustrating, he has already made us a better club!

James Flynn
78 Posted 10/11/2013 at 01:24:34
Colin (155) - "We were poor today. Let's hope that RM learnt enough today about the team selection and the performances of the majority of the team to form a plan for a fort nights time".

Let's hope Roberto understands managing EFC isn't the same as managing Swansea and Wigan.

Andy Crooks
79 Posted 10/11/2013 at 01:47:53
Colin, I think you make a good point suggesting playing Mirallas along side Lukaku.It seems that double acts are now the in thing and we don't have one.

About today's game; I thought that the recent thread about piling in goals against Crystal Palace was, at best, silly. They should have won at West Brom, they have good team spirit and good support. After their recent run today was the FA cup final for them; make or break.We got them on a good day for them and a bad day for us.

Kevin Rowlands
80 Posted 10/11/2013 at 03:37:33
Trevor, erm.....Ross Barkley?
John Gilfoyle
81 Posted 10/11/2013 at 04:25:11
After watching our performance today and currently viewing Southampton on MotD, I noticed the way they were playing was to get it forward quickly and get in behind the fullbacks and cross. I remember us doing this to great effect last season with Baines and Coleman bombing, Mirallas as well... although Pienaar is just a pivot for Baines, albeit a good one.

The countless times we got in wide positions just to pass infield/backwards and then run out of ideas with McCarthy recieving and having nothing on. Got to use our pace rather than pretending were Barcelona, keep it for 10 minutes let them get 10 men behind the ball and one to it through their defence. Lukaku needs to sort out his first touch as well.

Anto Byrne
82 Posted 10/11/2013 at 04:19:14
We are a hard lot to please, let's not forget that RM has inherited a team assembled by OFM with a particular way of playing. It's going to take 20-30 games to turn it around and that of course means certain players will be moved on who just don't fit the mould. The foundations are there and we have seen flashes of what is to come. We need to be patient and let RM do his job.
Tom Dodds
83 Posted 10/11/2013 at 05:26:06
The pattern emerging here is becoming SO obvious... By the time we get upfield, they've parked the bus. Every attack when it arrived in their area was the perfect deja vu... So near yet so far. The same pattern with the team for the last 12 years – no matter who's managing them.

The only way we will achieve any consisent real crack for a Champions League place is to get investment. Sadly. Which, from now on and ever more so will agitate our emerging or present top talent to eye wealthier clubs.

Steve Brown
84 Posted 10/11/2013 at 05:47:08
The question Anto 173 is whether RM is willing to adapt his philosophy to take account of the players he has in the squad, given he will need at least 2 transfer windows to bring in the right players for the tactics he wants to employ.

Lukaku is not suited to the slow possession play. He thrives when the play is played up the pitch quickly - early crosses and balls between the centre backs. Given he is here for one season only and is the reason why we have made a decent start, then I think RM has to adapt the style we are playing to get the ball forward quicker.

Otherwise we risk writing off another season when we don't really need to.

Steve Brown
85 Posted 10/11/2013 at 05:55:33
John 172, I posted before reading your comments. I needn't have bothered as you said it far better than I could. Spot on mate.
Tim Jones
86 Posted 10/11/2013 at 06:00:10
Over 70% possession, resulting in ONLY two shots on target, is just not good enough.
Sam Hoare
88 Posted 10/11/2013 at 08:09:13
Depressing to go into the international break on such a result. But worse than the result was the performance. In truth we were lucky to get a point against a poor team in terrible form.

Creativity is clearly the problem and for me that is down in large part to the faltering attacking trio of osman, Pienaar and Mirallas but is also down to a system that is not moving the ball quickly and incisively enough. Posession in our own half is meaningless when all it does is allow the opposition to get men behind the ball and get organised.

Anto Byrne
89 Posted 10/11/2013 at 07:55:55
I was watching the game and thinking we are the away team here. We have 70% of the possession and a wall of eleven players to get thru. They were happy to give us the ball as we crabbed it to the left and then back again. Okay, let's do something different, hoof the ball to them and defend like it's the Alamo only this time we have two forwards that can play the counter-attack game.

How was it Palace sprung our offside and got through one on one? How did they get free headers in our box? They were playing like the away side: keep it tight and pinch one. One goal would have been enough. Sometimes we just have to be a little bit clever. It's goals that win games and we look a little lost. I do agree we need a leader on the pitch. Barry?

Scott Jones
90 Posted 10/11/2013 at 08:06:51
Ralph Basnett (#118)

RM has only been at the club a few months, how can you compare our style to theirs? For the first 8/9 months of Rodgers's reign, they were the same LFC as the previous regime. Pochetino had 12 months at Southampton before he stamped his mark on the Saints.

Let's see where we are in 4 transfer windows, then we can judge the boss with more accuracy.

Sam Hoare
91 Posted 10/11/2013 at 08:23:51
Also Southampton really are good. Was on a stag few weeks ago watching them demolish Fulham. Sadly I think they will finish above us this season with a younger team and money to burn. Those saints fans were very happy and with good cause.
Alan Williams
92 Posted 10/11/2013 at 08:48:14
Come on, lads, let's give RM a chance. It's only been 10 games, it's going to take time to get to how he wants us to play. When we beat Villa, eveyone was saying how good we are... now we have drawn two games, fans are having moan. I think long term we will better under RM than the negative Moyes, so lets get behind the boys in the derby.
Jim Bennings
93 Posted 10/11/2013 at 09:44:43
Still waiting to see that Ross Barkley is actually as good as we all want hime to be at the minute. There is a hell of a lot of hype through the media and various other people that are making him out to be the saviour of English football. I am still a bit wary to be honest as we seen all of this with Jack Rodwell.

I actuallyy remember being even more excited about Rodwell's future after that goal against Man United in February 2010.

For me there is still alot of work for Ross to do. I like him but so far he still is not really taking the game by the scruff of the neck, I know he is still young and has limited experience but when you look back at Gerrard when he was 19 or Rooney, they were dominating games at that age.

I need to see a little bit more from Barkley this season before I get carried away too much. May sound like I am being harsh too soon but I think we do need a reality check, too many people are bigging the guy up too soon.

James Byrne
94 Posted 10/11/2013 at 09:49:22
We were shocking yesterday and our manager has his work cut out prior to the Derby; we lack a lot of belief at the moment and that needs to be sorted ASAP.

What scares me more than anything is not LFC but watching the likes of Southampton play! If Martinez needed some inspiration he just needs to show our players how Southampton play; fkn ruthless passing and work rate and the movement off the ball!

Tony Fearns
95 Posted 10/11/2013 at 10:02:08
Like someone said earlier – stop Lukaku from scoring and Everton will not win. We are getting too predictable.
Brian Waring
96 Posted 10/11/2013 at 10:18:49
Everyone keeps going on about what Pochettino has done at Southampton, but fail to mention that he has had a lot longer at Southampton than Martinez has had here, also he has spent something like £40M, so has had huge fianancial backing. Also, he got Southampton to a 14th place finish in the league, hardly great.
Shane Corcoran
97 Posted 10/11/2013 at 11:08:30
Can anyone explain how McCarthy didn't get booked yesterday when we were lead to believe before the game that this would definitely happen with the biased officials, Sky hating us and God being a red?
James Martin
98 Posted 10/11/2013 at 10:57:06
The creative players arent firinng because the midfield two don't service them enough. We've swapped Osman and Gibson two progressive passing midfielders for two defensive mids, its no mystery as to why our goals have decreased and so have our goals conceded. 4 0-0s out of 11 3 of them against fodder sides is not good enough and shows you something is wrong. We have become unadventurous in comparisonnn to last season. We had Baines and Colrman tearing forward and midfielders knocking it around in dangerous areas. McCarthy didnt play one risky forward ball all game yesterday, once again it was left solely to Pienaar to try and make something happen for us. Oneof Osman Barkley or Pienaar should sir in midfield mext to Barry. The loss of Gibson is a massive blow.
Brian Waring
99 Posted 10/11/2013 at 11:11:26
James, the game I watched Baines and Coleman were getting forward all the time, it's just that they were shite. Baines' delivery was piss poor.
Norman Merrill
100 Posted 10/11/2013 at 05:53:03
One things for sure, there needs to be a good rethink, on our tactics next game, & certainly team selection.
We need to start with our strongest eleven, not leave it to change after 60mins, and tell players they can shoot from outside the box, working the opposing keeper, hopefully for any spills?
More effort in the opposing half, for sure. While we are attacking them, they can't be hurting us, we need a wake up call.
Brian Waring
101 Posted 10/11/2013 at 11:31:51
Agree on that point Norman, how many times did we get into shooting positions, only for that player to turn and pass the ball backwards.
Phil Sammon
102 Posted 10/11/2013 at 11:38:35
Those lauding Saints and Liverpool should remember that we're only 2 points off the former and 3 off the latter. I agree we were poor and there is plenty to criticise...but let's just have a little perspective.

That said, let me just rip the team to shreds:

Howard - Been great of late and another top performance. That diving save in particular was something special.

Coleman - Defensively he is now an accomplished player. It seems to be his attacking play that has stuttered under Martinez. I also don't know how well him and Mirallas work.

Jagielka & Distin - A decent display. Sadly our tactics lead to Jags and Distin spending the most time on the ball. If these lads could pick a forward pass straight to Lukaku/Pienaar/Mirallas then we could maybe speed things up. Sadly every pass goes to each other, Barry or Howard. Tiresome.

Baines - He did it in an England shirt, but he seems a shadow of himself at Everton. Set pieces have been shocking and he can't cross a ball anymore. Perhaps RM is discouraging him from crossing...but even when he does - it's poor.

Mirallas - For a supposedly quick player, he has no pace. A player down on confidence and also lacking in effort. I think I'd like to see him up front with Lukaku. He has talent and it's time he started showing it.

Barry - Steady in a game that didn't really call for his presence. After 60 mins I'd have taken him or McCarthy off in favour of Jelavic or Naismith.

McCarthy - Did ok. Not as all action as normal but perhaps mindful of that yellow card.

Pienaar - The only player who actually tries to create something. Sadly it's just not happening. Wish he'd learn how to shoot though.

Osman - Did nothing.

Lukaku - Hard to criticise a quality player but he doesn't seem at it and we are not playing to his strengths.

Possession is fine, but can we please mix it with speed and the odd cross.

Ian Bennett
103 Posted 10/11/2013 at 12:28:28
Games against Arsenal, United and Liverpool will tell us really where we are, and wake us from this slumber.
Jimmy Sørheim
104 Posted 10/11/2013 at 12:32:14
I hate to say it but we are heading towards a downward spiral if we do not get a striker and a winger. Our squad is good without injuries, but things are turning sour with Baines affecting morale, not knowing if he will stay or go.

I bet we will continue to slide downwards with Martinez spouting his usual over-positive propaganda; I have to say I miss Moyes "no bullshit" attitude. However we were always going to struggle because this squad needs new fresh blood badly. Osman, Jelavic, Naismith, Kone and Pienaar have no place in a top side.

Moyes was able to squeeze that little extra out of his players, but RM does not have that in him. He seems too afraid to try something drastic with our formation, and we badly need more options upfront, not just the lone striker.

I have grown tired of only playing one striker at a time, it is God awful boring. I want to wary between 2 and 3 outright strikers, but Martinez seems afraid to try it.

Tony J Williams
106 Posted 10/11/2013 at 13:24:38
Shane 213, probably because he never put in a hard tackle all game until the very last minute......for which he probably could have been booked
Kevin Rowlands
107 Posted 10/11/2013 at 14:08:31
Phil, what was your opinion of the subs? From what I saw, Barkley looked okay... Del boy, awful.
James Martin
108 Posted 10/11/2013 at 14:35:59
Laughably Naismith has come on this season put himself about scored goals and given everything for the team yet gets slated. Deulofeu has done the grand total of absolutely nothing, loses the ball with almost every touch and has no concept of defending yet everyone always calls for him to come on.

Likewise Lukaku seems to be getting a free ride from the critics whereas yesterday he resembled Saha on his worst day, I mean what did he do? I don't think he had a second touch all game, he was absolutely atrocious and was worse than Jelavic was on his worst days. Jelavic should have come on a lot earlier.

Lukaku reckons he's untouchable now and has gone right off the throttle (probably why Mourinho sent him out); at least when things weren't going well for Jelavic he kept going. Lukaku and Mirallas seem to just not bother as soon as they receive the slightest bit of praise.

Paul Andrews
109 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:01:38
Mirallas asked the bench for a pair of gloves after 20 minutes.... I would have subbed him straight away
James Flynn
110 Posted 10/11/2013 at 14:58:37
Well, on the bright side, we just went ahead of Spurs in the Table. The Newcastle keeper was spectacular.
Mark Frere
111 Posted 10/11/2013 at 14:39:15
James Martin (214)

You're talking nonsense. Its got nothing to do with swapping Osman and Gibson for Barry and McCarthy, last season, Gibson got injured early against West Brom. We were actually playing with Neville and Osman in the middle when we were playing our best football in the first 10 games last season. We were just getting the ball forward much quicker and playing with more intensity - creating more chances.

To blame the way we are playing on Barry and McCarthy is lunacy. For me, they have been the only shining light along with Lukaku so far this season. Osman was playing the deeper role early doors this season, guess what? He was atrocious, McCarthy has been 10 times better.

It would be a nice option to have Gibson to rotate with McCarthy, we could've played Gibson more in home games against weaker opposition to help unlock defences with his good passing range. We could've played McCarthy more against teams like Man City and Arsenal who have quality CMs, to stop us getting over-run in midfield.

If Martinez insists on playing this tippy- tappy, slow build up football, then, our creative players ie: Pienaar, Osman, Barkley and Mirallas need have much more cutting edge in the final third. The lacklustre shite they've served up so far is not good enough.

I'm thinking, it might be time to try 3-5-2 formation - this would leave our full backs further up the pitch, where they are most effective, and we could play Lukaku and Mirallas along side each other. We could also draft Alcaraz and stones into the back 3 as soon as possible - much better ball playing CBs.

Harold Matthews
112 Posted 10/11/2013 at 13:35:53
It was exactly the same for West Brom against Palace last week till Steve Clarke took off a defender and put on an extra attacker. In the past I've been critical of Gibson but if he had played in McCarthy's place we'd have gone forward quicker with more creativity. The young lad is a fine player but he needs to study the ways of Ramirez, Ya Ya Toure, Lampard, Gerrard and other top players with a better all round game.

Lack of quick, intelligent movement off the ball in all areas of the pitch is causing people to go sideways and back in an effort to keep possession. The above posts have covered everything I'm trying to say. Let's hope Martinez and his staff bang a few heads together and shake certain individuals out of their overpaid comfort zone.

Jimmy Kelly
113 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:06:35
Brian, Pochettino has had 'a lot longer' than Martinez? I make it about 5 months, he's not exactly on for a gold watch.
James Stewart
114 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:23:50
Some of the comments on here are hilarious. We are playing well and not really conceding anything, the only problem we have is our so-called creative players are not turning up. Pienaar, Osman & Mirallas create absolutely nothing. Lukaku barely gets a chance per game so what is he supposed to do?!

We have virtually no pace whatsoever so it's easy for teams to defend against us as no one commits or beats his man. Mirallas used to but he seems to have forgotten how to even play football these days. Barkley was doing it until he got dropped.

Jimmy Kelly
115 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:23:11
Mark, I understand what you're saying (and agree to a point) but you're massively oversimplifying things,

The attacking players need a platform to attack from, they can't be picking the ball up in front of two banks of 4 and waltzing straight through them. At the moment our attacking players are regularly being given the ball by the midfield two and asked to do it themselves - that's not acceptable. A number of times yesterday McCarthy played slow balls to the feet of Coleman and Delofeu when what they needed was a ball in front of them to run onto at pace.

There's no doubt that Barry and McCarthy have done very well at what they do, the pertinent question though, is whether they actually 'do' enough.

Ross Edwards
116 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:27:03
Jimmy, Pochettino has had nearly 10 months to impact his philosophy. Martinez has had 11 league games. He needs time to impose his ideas. Even the players have said this themselves.
James Martin
117 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:19:57
Mark just actually think about the results last season then match them to the periods when Gibson was fit. We started off well when he was fit, when he was injured Neville performed admirably at times but eventually the quality dropped especially when we were on our run of draws. When Gibson got himself back fit at the end of the season we had another good run.

Osman was off form in the first few games this season (I'll leave out my well worn theories on the effect of anyone partnering Fellaini in the middle, I'll also leave out his excellent performance against Chelsea). But in my mind we've swapped one set off skills for another. Osman and Gibson are slow and fairly weak on the ball but can both pick a forward pass. Yesterday McCarthy was just going side to side and Barry wasn't much better, both need an Arteta type next to them to move us forward. Mirallas Barkley and Pienaar can't do anything if they're picking up the ball with their back to goal. How often was Mirallas played in with a run at the defender? Hardly ever. Yes he was poor but our midfield isn't giving him a chance to help himself with some dire service. Equally I'm not sure what people expect Osman to do when Lukaku couldn't trap a bag of cement and the mdifield barely put a ball into his feet, retain possession from goal kicks and hoofs? (of which there were plenty for the purists on ehre to tactically ignore for another week). Instead we went back to our tried and trusted technique of asking Baines and Pienaar to come up with a bit of brilliance just to get us into the opposition half, neither were on form so we were left with nothing.

Every team has to have a goal scoring threat and this is only unlocked by quick direct balls from midfield. United own the title last season with a good defense and Carrick playing the ball into Van Persies feet quickly so he only had one man to beat and he'd be in on goal. The widemen were generally poor, Rooney had a bad seaosn and Carrick was partnered by Tom Cleverley, yet because he plays early and forward it doesn't really matter. We don't, and no Everton team in recent times has if one of Gibson Arteta, or Osman isn't playing. Managing the transition is essential in football but we don't we just hog the ball much like Fellaini and Rodwell used to, sideways backwards sideways backwards sideways backwards, out to Baines who overhits the cross - repeat a nauseam. It may as well have been Moyes in charge of the team yesterday, there was no difference except the number of sideways passes before Baines wasted it. There was the same flippant attitude in front of goal, the same number of aimless hoofs, the same lack of desire to get a win, and the same mental block against the easiest sides in the league just because we're away from home. Our players are just not mentally prepared to win consistently, they're more comfortable being nearly men, and it iwll take more then a bit of extra passing in midfield to shake off that mentality.

Chris James
118 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:10:24
I don't know if it's better or worse that everyone else is fucking up. We should be alongside Southampton and a point off Liverpool now. Sounds like Newcastle played well and maybe Sunderland too. But to be frank Palace weren't good at all, it's just that we were so bloody slow to get going on the day.
Jimmy Kelly
119 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:30:00
Ross, I'm not disputing he needs time at all. I'm not looking to suggest Pochettino is a better manager either. I'm just making the really quite obvious point that 'nearly 10 months' and just over 6 months are not exactly poles apart. The idea of using the amount of league games for one and a time for period the other to try to make the difference sound bigger doesn't really pass muster i'm afraid.
Ross Edwards
120 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:38:40
We actually have the same points and record, 5 wins, 5 draws and 1 defeat, as this time last season. That, according to many on here, was our best start for a long time.
Chris James
122 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:49:10
Hey Ross, clearly you're still chipper due to ratboy's fantasy haul! ;-)

From my perspective, and I think a lot of people on here, the frustration is not with Martinez generally or even with tweaking the style, it's just the lacklustre performances that have come out in last few weeks, specifically Villa and Spurs first half and Palace all flipping match.

I think it's partly strategy and partly team selection, but either way Martinez has to take some responsibility. For me Palace were totally there for the taking yesterday and we could barely get a shot on target. The only time we really started to push hard was in the last 20-30 mins with Barkley/Delboy on, but by that time we'd pissed away an hour of the game with just knocking the ball about the middle and didn't make enough chances to push on for the win. We needed to be driving hard at them from the first whistle. We didn't. We need to have not played Osman. We did. We needed to win the game and we dropped 2 points. That's the frustration.

Kunal Desai
123 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:57:06
What were the odds on both Spurs and Man City losing this weekend to the northeast clubs? Over to you now, Arsenal!
Chris James
124 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:57:05
Clearly the crapness is catching, Spurs and City lose, Chelsea draw. If Arse give the Mancs a spanking, they're going to be opening up a gap and will have to be taken really seriously for the title.
Ross Edwards
125 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:57:55
I completely understand that frustration Chris. Hey, I'm frustrated too, I really am, but it takes time.

Look at Southampton. It took Pochettino a few months to get his ideas across towards the end of last season, and in May they beat City and the RS 3-1 and beat Chelsea 2-1 to secure safety.

It will take a while yet before it all clicks, but if we are in the shake up by January, who knows what might happen.

Look at today's results, Spuds beaten by Newcastle, City beaten by Sunderland. Nothing is certain in this league.

James Martin
126 Posted 10/11/2013 at 15:52:40
Ross according to many on here that start wasn't good enough. The football was also a lot better in those ten games. I can accept a draw if it was like Newcastle last season, or Fulham were we through the sink at them only to be sucker punched. Against Tottenham and Palace how many shots on target did we muster? Barely any.

My annoyance is similar to last season, this team is capable of so much more yet limit themselves by being happy to just pick up draws remain unbeaten blah blah blah. When was the last time we won with a last minute goal? We don't keep pushing, we give up around the 80 minute mark. Our players just don't have the stones to win when the pressure of actually achieveing something is on. Smarting the big boys when no one expects you to is fine for them, winning at the worst side in the legaue when you've got the chance to go into the top 4 is just too much for them. We'll probably fall back just enough to go off the radar before then going on another winning run, getting close to something achievable and then choking. This squad just needs more winners, not even better players because on their day they're as good as anyone's starting 11, but they just don't believe it and that will continue to be a problem until a manager can beat it out of them like Mourinho does with his teams. We have no arrogance, no assurance that we belong with the top teams, we're still the teachers pet grateful to be allowed to the party not wanting to upset anyone there. The 04/05 teams had characters like Cahill, Gravesen, Ferguson, Carsley and Martyn who just didn't think that way, they smashed their way into the top 4 and won against United, Liverpool and Newcastle when the pressure was really on. They may not have been as good as football (although that's increasingly becoming more debatable with every season of failure that passes) but they believed they deserved to be there and made it happen. Never seen that since and haven't seen it at all this season.

I'd love us to come out super confident in the derby and just play them off the park as we should do given our home record. I'd take a scrappy one nil as long as showed the desire to actually win. Instead I'll predict with absolute confidence that it will be one of glorious failure or turgid draw.

Ross Edwards
127 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:06:34
James, the way we've been playing recently, a draw against the RS will be a miracle.
Trevor Lynes
128 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:02:00
Chris..Osman played a bit part and shone and that's why he was played from the start. As I have said before we do not have much in the way of options. We only have Barkley, Mirallas, Del boy,Osman, Naismith, Barry and Pienaar available to perm any five from. If Barkley starts then Osman comes on and if Del Boy comes on then Mirallas go's off. The only other alternative is starting Naismith or God forbid Heitinger.

We do not have loads of talented players sitting on the bench so your comments are a bit short-sighted although no doubt well meant. I just wish we had some youngsters who were really pushing for a place but it seems that none are showing enough to impress Martinez.

Steve Brown
129 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:07:45
No way we have to beat the shite! If playing them doesn't fire up this talented team then I just don't know what will.
Colin Glassar
130 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:12:50
Results are going our way this weekend. Despite being shit, we are still in the mix, especially if Man Utd and Arsenal draw. God must be a blue.
Ross Edwards
131 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:17:17
Steve 305 "If playing them doesn't fire up this talented team then I just don't know what will"

A flamethrower?

Brian Waring
132 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:19:15
Jimmy, Pochettino has spent around £38m as well.
Raymond Fox
133 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:08:23
Hate to admit it, but RS from bits I've seen are playing well and chomper is on fire.

The derby should liven us up, shouldn't it, and who knows if we can stop him we could get a win.

We cant be that bad, were still in 5th place, as the Utd game stands!

Raymond Fox
134 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:27:49
Brian, there lies the problem!
Jimmy Kelly
135 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:24:14
Indeed he has Brian, although that doesn't make your point about the length of time he's been there any more valid. It's also probably worth noting that - if we include signing on fees for Alcaraz and loan fees for the other 3 - Martinez has probably spent somewhere around £27m so the difference is not necessarily as big as you make out.
Ross Edwards
136 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:32:58
Has he Jimmy?

Lukaku – loan
Deulofeu – loan
Robles – £1 million
McCarthy – £13 million
Kone – £6 million
Alcaraz – free
Barry – loan

So, that's £20 million. £18 million less than Soton have spent.

Ross Edwards
137 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:42:11
See, Davey Moyesiah has got off to a slowish start, but his players at Utd are beginning to take in his ideas. 8 unbeaten now and just scored against Arsenal.
Jimmy Kelly
138 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:38:50
So Ross, despite me making it clear in my post that I was including loan fees you've chosen to ignore them?

Do you think Chelsea just let us have Lukaku as a bit of a favour? The more conservative estimates of his loan fee have been reported at £3m, some as high as £5m. With the supposed interest from many other clubs in Deulofeu I think it's fair to assume we probably had to pay at least £1m to secure him. There's then Alcaraz (nobody is ever 'free') and Barry, who we may not have actually paid a fee for but are probably paying him around double what Southampton's highest earner is on.

So that's not £20m, £18m less than Southampton have spent.

Colin Glassar
139 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:43:28
Ross, but playing Kagawa as a winger? Some things never change.
Ross Edwards
140 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:45:17
All Brian is saying Jimmy, is that Pochettino has more money to spend, and has had more time to impose his ideas than Martinez has.
Ross Edwards
141 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:47:08
No, they don't Colin, but it takes time to get used to new players, and even more time when you impose an entirely new way of playing. It won't happen miraculously overnight.
Ross Edwards
142 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:48:14
I just hope for Martinez's sake that we don't get a hiding from the RS, because there would be horrendous pressure on him, and we'd be on his back if that were to be the case.
Brian Waring
143 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:37:57
Jimmy, Pochettino was in charge for 16 games last season as well.
Jimmy Kelly
144 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:48:43
I know what he's saying Ross.

He said that Pochettino had 'a lot more time' and suggested that the amount of money spent at Southampton dwarfed that spent by Everton. He also suggested that people were not taking this into account.

I am suggesting that the reason they are not being taken into account is because neither of them are really true.

Again, this isn't a criticism of Martinez, or a suggestion that Pochettino will prove to be better than Martinez - simply a rebuttal of the point being made Brian.

Brian Waring
145 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:55:27
I'd say 16 games was quite a bit more in charge Jimmy.
Winston Williamson
146 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:50:55
James Martin - 301

I was actually thinking the exact same thing..re.never taking an opportunity to advance.

I believe it goes deeper than the first team. It starts at the Boardroom and feeds into the fabric of the club.

We, as supporters, want to advance. We hope. We pray. However, can anyone honestly say before the Spurs game, that there was no doubt - that the thought never crossed everyone's mind, that we'd bottle it against Spurs, with a chance to go 2nd?

Last January, we hoped, we preyed the board would release some funds to helps us push. But we knew it was going to be bottled.

We now expect the board and players to bottle it whenever we get to a position whereby we can advance.

We need winners. Top - down.

Jimmy Kelly
147 Posted 10/11/2013 at 16:57:54
I'd say it was 'a bit more' too Brian, but I wouldn't say it was 'a lot more' - it's not particularly difficult to understand surely?

Again, I'm not making any judgement on either of them, I just didn't think your point was valid as you appeared to suggest Pochettino had been there much longer than he actually has. The fact that you mentioned their finishing position last year lead me to believe you thought he had been there all through last season. If that's not the case then no worries, maybe it was just a case of not using the best phrasing.

Colin Glassar
148 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:02:32
We've been like this for years now. Every time we think we can make that next step up, we fall flat on our faces. This is all about poor mentality and I think it's inherited from the former regime, as well as the board. We were pathetic against Spurs, and even worse against Palace.

Where are our leaders? Wtf goes on in the dressing room? Why do decent players forget how to do the basics? You can blame the manager(s) all you want but it's the overpaid pricks on the field who have to perform.

Brian Waring
149 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:08:07
I know he wasn't there from the start of last season Jimmy, his first game in charge was the 0-0 against us ( I think)
Ross Edwards
150 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:15:15
He took over on 18th January 2013 Brian, a 0-0 against us at St Mary's.
Michael Penley
151 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:29:01
The problem as I see it is obvious – too many comfortable players.

In my opinion, Everton shouldn't sign or keep married players. They get lazy, there's no drive or fight to win and it just becomes a day job to earn money for the wife and kids.

Jags, Mirallas, Baines, you can see the lack of desire clear on their faces. What is Jags actually doing to earn his captaincy stripes? He should have been in the faces of each and every player at half-time and throughout the game, but no, as long as he brings home the bacon, a draw against relegation material is fine. We need someone like Cahill who lives and breathes the game. One player like that would change the whole team.

Eugene Ruane
152 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:35:51
Michael (335) - "In my opinion Everton shouldn't sign or keep married players. They get lazy, there's no drive or fight to win and it just becomes a day job to earn money for the wife and kids"

Christ, the debate bottom of the barrel has officially been scraped.

Looks forward to "We shouldn't sign anyone handsome coz they'll be distracted by all the wags like."

Oh and Cahill was/is married.

Michael Kenrick
154 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:53:34
Lordy, lordy.... some crazy comments but that one, Micheal, takes the biscuit. Players lacking passion and drive on the field may be a valid concern.... but it's because they are MARRIED?!?!?

Where's Cap'n Mainwaring when you need him?

Ross Edwards
155 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:58:28
Mirallas is obviously distracted because of his gold Bentley

Baines obviously has his eyes on Old Trafford.

The rest of them, god knows, but they have to be at their best against the RS or else we'll face a hammering.

Michael Penley
156 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:57:45
Cahill got married in 2010, around the time we started saying he was past it.
Graham Mockford
157 Posted 10/11/2013 at 17:56:59
A team of un married players.... Absolutely fucking genius.

Pele, Cruyff, Maradonna, Charlton, Moore — all married but what the fuck, George Best struggled a bit.

Kunal Desai
158 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:07:20
Sky says Man Utd are right back in the championship race, does that mean Everton are as well seeing as they are on the same points as us?
Colin Glassar
159 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:09:13
No chance Kunai, they will say United are joint 5th with Spurs. We are the invisible men.
Kunal Desai
160 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:11:42
Martin Tyler seemed to continuously mention all the top 8 bar us — Sky bastards, I tell you!
Paul Ferry
161 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:09:28
Penley you've slipped below the surface, you're struggling flaying arms and all above the sea, you're drowning in utter pure diamond shite. Schowaddywaddy bollocks of pure crystal quality.

Actually, married men are probably more stable for the most part, more settled, more mature, more responsible, less given to spontaneous crockshite, more likely to be tucked up in bed before midnight, snuggling up to the lass.

Needless to say, you Penley are a Sorheim WUM, but you clearly do not know or understand a single thing about psychology or life for that matter.

There's a hole over there, go to it, crawl inside, don't move, stay there, do not breathe another shitty word.

Paul Andrews
162 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:10:30
We do need more of a winning mentality. Players who hate getting beat.
Eugene Ruane
163 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:13:55
HA HA HA HA HA HA HA - BRILLIANT!!!!

Vicar: "And do you Timothy Ozington Cahill take Sharon Wag to be your lawful wedded wife"

TC: "I do maaaaaate!"

Cut to a week later at Goodison

Blue 1: "What's wrong with Cahill? It's like he's lost all his desire"

Blue: 2: "You know he got married?"

Blue 1: "Oh THAT explains it, well we might as well sell him then, coz he's going to be shit from now on, all the married players are"

(shakes head)

Craig Fletcher
164 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:15:31
I'm engaged to be married, Michael Penley (335).

Ah well, the days of having enthusiasm, drive and goal-setting seem to be behind me. Get ready for a life of home comforts, domestic servitude and waiting for the grave.

You douche.

Colin Glassar
165 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:19:08
Martin Tyler hates us. I remember him commentating one of our games last season, or before, and he said something like he’d prefer to be at the dentists than watching this game.
Dave Hall
166 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:24:53
Baines was utter crap on Saturday. How much longer can the man demand to take every set piece when he's curling corners over the by-line? When was the last time we saw Bainsey really whip a cross to the back stick?

Lukaku had zero service all day long, and Baines was by far the worst offender. Really poor stuff.

Kunal Desai
167 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:24:34
Ah well each to their own I guess - Martin Tyler is boring, the sooner he’s resigned to collecting his pension the better! On a separate, spurs can’t buy a goal and £100 million spent...and city are shite away from home, count them both out of the title hunt, personally think it will still be between Arsenal and Chelsea.
Colin Glassar
168 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:30:57
Martin Tyler sounds like he’d be more suitable to commentate on bowling or grass growing. He has one of the most boring voices I’ve ever heardzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
James Flynn
169 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:11:03
They can call us invisible all they want. We're 5 points off the league-leaders. And Chelsea and ManCity lost. What a difference a day makes.
Brian Waring
172 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:36:23
I would think being married would make you want to go out and smash the opposition to get rid of the frustration that comes with being married.
Mike Price
175 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:40:20
Nice one, Brian!

But really, we do need someone with some fire in their belly. I usually detest the international breaks but think that this one may be to our benefit as they were flying yesterday and we were abysmal. A couple of weeks away could mean a reset of sorts... a nice injury to Suarez would be fabulous too.

My other nagging fear is the early kick-off at Goodison... the last thing we need is another tempo lowering factor, it's never the same as a later 'bear pit' atmosphere.

Ian Burns
176 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:58:07
There I was spending a quiet Sunday evening, wallowing in 6th place (ok false I know but I don't care this weekend, 5 points off the top after 11 games, that'll do for now), reading the wonderful TW website, then I choked on me fecking gin!

Michael Penley - 335 - I will read this again in the morning and I presume what I've just read is the effects of me gin getting the better of me.

A team of single guys - feck me I'd be worried in case they didn't turn up! I've seen some excuses in my long time as an EFC supporter but this one takes the biscuit - in fact the whole fecking tin!

I need a ruddy big swallow of Bombay Sapphire.

What this team is missing is a Peter Reid - even a fecking married Peter Reid - right in the middle of the park where he can kick them in the bollocks at the back or up the arse if they are up front.

Peter Mills
177 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:12:57
I certainly don't think everything has been, or is, perfect. But I'm looking at the table after all teams have played 11 matches and am thinking "That's OK".
Keith Young
178 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:55:21
Colin (#360) — Most on this thread would rather be at a Dentist than watch us against Palace on Saturday and we love Everton! Maybe Martin Tyler doesn’t hate us but can’t stand the crap served up to us under OFM.
Mark Frere
179 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:28:43
James Martin (286)

I'm a massive Darren Gibson fan and I do think we would benefit from him starting in most games if fit, I just don't think playing Osman and Gibson would eradicate the problems like you suggest. Osman is finished as far as playing the deeper role, there's enough evidence of that over the past year.

Neville did not perform admirably like you say, he just happened to be playing CM at the time when Osman, Pienaar, Mirallas, Baines and occasionally Fellaini were playing at the top of their game. This was early doors last season, when we were getting the ball forward much quicker and creating plenty of chances. I find it quite ridiculous that you thought Neville performed well and then you think Fellaini was the cause of all our problems.

And the ironic thing about all this is: you wrote a article about McCarthy titled "A proper midfielder", singing his praises, then 2 weeks later in your opinion, he is the root cause of our problems. Make up your mind.

Kevin Rowlands
180 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:44:53
Naismith should play in the derby, there I've said it(dons tin hat). I would also start Barkley and sit Pienaar and Osman, and pray Mirallas gets his head out of his arse.
Matt Smith
181 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:16:00
I only got to see the highlights, but after only a few minutes, I was hiding behind the sofa due to the horror unfolding and I knew the score beforehand...! The three missed chances by Palace were criminal, Suarez would have buried those and be going home with the match ball.
Roman Sidey
182 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:33:42
To be fair to Penley, single blokes are better athletes...
(stir, stir, stir)
Paul Ferry
183 Posted 11/11/2013 at 02:25:17
That Mo marathon fella is married Roman and so is Osman so your argument has been decisively destroyed!
Thomas Windsor
184 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:24:42
Good shout that, Kevin Rowlands I also think Naismith should be brought in for the Derby game. Osman and Pienaar are not playing well at the moment.
Charlie North-Roberts
186 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:33:09
I don't get this whole "stop Lukaku and Everton are rubbish" bullshit that everyone is stating? EVERY team in the Premier League is dependent on one or two players performing (even the RS) that everyone has all of a sudden come to fear?

Look at Man City and Sunderland — they stop Aguero, they win. Man Utd stop Ozil, they win; Liverpool without big-toothed idiot upfront (stopping him I understand is easier said than done), but you're going into this game expecting a loss...

Have some faith in our lads. Let's not forget, from last year that not only are the lads getting used to a new manager but also new players!! Last season, there was no Barry, Barkley, McCarthy, Lukaku even Deulofeu. We will come good; we can't be perfect every game!! The fact that we have such high standards shows how good we are!! So try and take positives!!

Ross Edwards
187 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:22:22
You are all slating the fact that we drew against a terrible side but they could have beaten Arsenal, they created a lot of chances, they went down to 10 men and conceded a dubious pen at Old Trafford, they conceded a late pen against Spuds at 0-0, and nearly beat us.

They aren't as useless as you all make out.

I seem to remember Moyes losing to Reading, after being 1-0 up.

Matty Williams
188 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:29:34
Re: Ian Burns — spot on, lad. We need a Peter Reid leader type in the side pronto. Mr Barton would be my shout; failing that, Joe Ledley of Celtic.

We're in grave danger at the moment of being the Prem's nice team: no fight, no bottle, no graft, no guile, no fucking goals... where is our leader on the pitch?

Paul Ferry
189 Posted 12/11/2013 at 00:12:46
Ross mate they are a terrible side and have put a little money on 'em ending up with the lowest ever prem points haul. Best thing about 'em are the chairman and fans. No gaffer, pathetic number of window buys, employing Holloway, no idea anywhere of the best starting 11 - makes spuds look settled.

Thin and lame excuse Ross mate, we lost a game we ought ot have won when all is said and done.

Michael Penley
190 Posted 12/11/2013 at 00:28:36
"Actually, married men are probably more stable for the most part, more settled, more mature, more responsible, less given to spontaneous crockshite, more likely to be tucked up in bed before midnight, snuggling up to the lass."

Ah so that's what we need is it? Watch some of Jags' interviews. Lethargic doesn't describe half of it, he sounds like he's been hit by a tranquiliser dart.

I'll admit the married joke was a nothing more than that, a joke – but I still want to know why we're lethargic. Where's the passion? Mature and responsible isn't what's needed – I'd take spontaneous crockshite on the pitch along with some recklessness and fire over what we showed in our last performance.

James Fletcher
192 Posted 12/11/2013 at 16:17:41
Pienaar has been utter sh!te for the past few games. He may well have scored the other week but he breaks up our attacks constantly, holds onto the ball for far too long and misplaces a hell of a lot of passes.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb