The Martinez Project – are goals underrated?

, 10 November, 123comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton have now delivered four nil-nils from eleven Premier League matches with high possession stats but no end result. Gary Naylor updates the ongoing argument over possession versus goals and asks: "What can Martinez do to unlock defences?"

Quotes or other material sourced from Pick Our Team



Reader Comments (123)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Trevor Lynes
1 Posted 10/11/2013 at 11:05:55
The passing game is fine, what is needed is the essential ingredient...moving! All the best teams keep the ball but MOVE into space after the pass has been delivered. I include Liverpool and even Southampton into teams who pass and move.

Southampton are brilliant so far this season. Their manager has got them pressing high and stifling opposing sides who want to play out from the back. He has made three decent players into top-class ones by giving Lallana a free rein to play wherever he wants to and the lad is destroying sides with his dribbling ability and pace. Incidently, he was an Evertonian and so is his dad. Jay Rodriguez and Lambert are both in the England manager's mind plus Lovren has been the buy of the season to my mind. This is a team who shipped 42 goals by this time last season and only four or five so far this.

Martinez has the right idea by retaining the ball but I am not too sure he has the players to get the maximum value. Chelsea and ourselves are playing the game too slowly and not getting behind the defenders enough and it's really down to the players who are passing the ball but not running into space to receive through balls.

Gerrard's through ball for Suarez was made by Suarez pointing and running which made the goal a lot easier to score. No-one in our side is doing the running into space so the defenders are never turned. Mirallas should maybe be tried up front with Lukaku and Del Boy tried out wide in front of Coleman. Mirallas has the pace and shooting power to be the perfect foil for Lukaku if he is told to run off the ball and take men on. Perhaps Stones could be tried at left back and Baines pushed forward a bit more.

At least a change may alter our attacking impetus. Lukaku is not getting the service that he had when he first arrived and he is being used as a target man rather than an out-and-out goalscorer.

James Stewart
2 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:00:00
Not really Martinez's for the most part. Mirallas, Pienaar, Osman have all been poor and do virtually nothing to create any chances for the striker. Barkley at least runs at people and is for the most part positive. The others have barely put a decent cross or through ball in between them. Not good enough and needs addressing come January.
Clarence Yurcan
3 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:10:54
Not that it's much consolation, but at least Spurs and City lost today
Lewis Barclay
4 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:10:26
We must beat the RS this weekend for me to believe we are competitive with the teams around us, including Southampton.
Andrew James
6 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:04:40
As mentioned on other threads, the personnel needs changing. Osman should be a fringe player now, Pienaar needs moving on. People are critical of Distin and Jags, well they are still at the centre of a very tight defence so I am not sure if that is where the criticism should be directed.

What does worry me is that we have completely blunted our biggest weapons: Baines and Coleman. The possession football means teams sit in their half so there's no space on the flanks for them to attack and get in behind the opposition. I am quite surprised that RM hasn't addressed this or, if he has, then the responsibility lies with the centre midfield for playing sideways when they need to get forward quickly to shake up the opposition and suck them infield thus creating space on the wings. This puts a heck of a lot of pressure on Osman and/or Barkley as the creative centre midfielder expected to engineer such moves. One of them is not renowned for his pace and is a fading presence. The other is still learning.

Doesn't help of course that the front men have been injured or useless apart from Lukaku.

Michael Kenrick
7 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:27:52
Fantastic goalkeeping by Krul. A number looked like certain goals for Spurs. Incredible!

Shows that great goalkeeping can sometimes keep out even the most rampant attackers.
Colin Glassar
8 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:32:54
This season the top 7-8 is wide open which makes it so frustrating when we simply don't turn up against the likes of palace. Like I've said on other threads, I don't blame Martinez, I blame the players who aren't putting the effort in.
Phil Walling
11 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:34:42
I don't think I've ever seen a player put in so much quality and effort into a game as Rooney did today. I hope the likes of Mirallas were watching him!
Darren Hind
12 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:34:40
Nothing wrong with possession, thats how the game should be played, but we need to do it further up the park and commit more men.
Andrew James
13 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:39:47
I see what Rooney has done over the last decade: 40 goals a season, carrying a mediocre team after Ronaldo left, overhead kicks...we were absolutely robbed in 2004. He's in that category just below Messi, Ronaldo and Neymar and probably better than Bale and we got £25 million for him? Ugh.
Brian Waring
14 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:44:12
Rooney blows hot and cold, it won't be long before he's whinging again.
Mark Taylor
15 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:41:20
On the original question, I think we could do with being able to mix up play a bit. Possession football is all very well but we don't really have the players to pull it off- the likes of Messi,Xavi and Iniesta know how to unpick defences but we don't have that type of player. If a counter attack is on, then move fast. Long balls can be perfectly ok if the ball is on. Yet I get the impression the players think they'll get ticked off unless they are just manoevring the ball around from the back. Yet this is making us very predictable.

I agree with the earlier poster that it is also the case that pretty much all our attacking players are playing below bar right now- Lukaku, Mirallas, Pienaar, even the two full backs are nothing like what we saw at this stage last season.

Guy Hastings
16 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:45:11
Andrew 353 - agree 100% about the lack of impact this season from Baines and Coleman. By the time Jags and Disin have played tippy-tap enough to boost the possession stats by another 5% even a team like Palace have had the nous to get behind the ball. There's little or no speed on the flanks - or rather there is, it's simply not being used.
Drew Shortis
17 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:49:49
I thought Martinez picked a strong team and brought on Barkley and Deulofeu at about the right time. I don't think we can blame the manager for this result. It was the players on the pitch who failed to play well enough.
Peter Laing
18 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:49:36
The build up at times is too slow and ponderous, although Martinez has a game plan based upon possession I also believe he needs to adopt a more direct approach in certain games. If we are to go into the game with Liverpool with any chance we need Baines and Coleman to be raiding down the flanks. A different formation is definitely needed otherwise I'm not feeling too optimistic.
Harold Matthews
19 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:59:26
Phil W. Spot on.
Dan McKie
20 Posted 10/11/2013 at 18:59:57
The question is 'what does Martinez do to change it?'. Mirralas has been poor most of the season, same with Osman, but they never get dropped. Has Barkleys dip in form really brought as poor performances as we have seen from those two? I don't think so, yet it has been Ross sitting on the bench. The slow build up play, and letting the opposition get 11 men behind the ball before each attack has been there all season, but do we ever notice any change of tactic when we have spent most of the game unable to break them down? Nope!

Martinez will have been gleaming about us having 70% of the ball yesterday, and will be working out how to make that 75%. Goals don't seem as important to him.

Colin Glassar
21 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:08:29
Dan, that's ridiculous. So you are saying Martinez is all about possession and not scoring goals and winning games? He plots the tactics, picks the team but once they cross the white line it's up to the players to perform. He doesn't tell them to pass to an opponent fifteen yards away when they've got a teammate two feet away. It's all about attitude, basic skills and a bit of nouse none of which we have in abundance just now.
Dan McKie
24 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:32:17
Colin, I think any manager that describes 0-0 draws as 'victories without goals' needs to realise there is no such thing. I don't think he does enough to change things. He just stands on the touch line looking deep in thought.
Jim Bennings
25 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:24:06
To be honest I think its all being blown out of proportion at a very early stage. We have a new manager. Unlike Manchester United, we were not a title-winning great football team playing in the Champoins League. I can understand their fans having negative thoughts on Moyes after the success they have been used to but lets look at our situation.

We were not a great team last season under Moyes. We were hard to beat, very good at being hard to beat, but drew too many. This season under Martinez, we are still hard to beat, have spent no real money of our own, yet Martinez has had to start his reign at Everton without our top scorer Marouane Fellaini from the previous season — something which Moyes was blessed with in his final year.

Yes, at times we look slow and ponderous, but we did at times last season didnt we? I recall being at the QPR away game when we were held to a draw, I remember cursing our lack of movement and final ball into the box.

You cannot expect Martinez to all of a sudden turn Osman, Naismith, a flailing Pienaar and the likes of Jags and Distin into overnight Champoins Laegue material. We have signed decent players on a limited budget, the likes of Mirallas is a decent player, not a great one; if he was great we would never have afforded him. We got Lukaku for a one year loan, a Spanish kid we knew limited things about, and a very good experienced former England midfielder. We were able to splash out on the young up-and-coming talents of McCarthy only because we had to sacrifice our top scorer last season.

It's not smooth running because we are not a big-spending club, even those who have spent billions, it's hard even for Spurs without their talisman of last season, despite doing everything to buy world class players, they are struggling for goals.

For the record, I think we can have limited reasons to complain about Martinez; let the man get on with his job and then it's over to Bill and the board again to come up trumps in January.

Colin Glassar
27 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:45:39
Did he say it was a victory Dan? I must've missed that. He makes (positive) changes far earlier than OFM ever did. I'm not happy with recent results or performances but like I said, the players have to stand up and be counted. They've played like a bunch of girls recently.
Terry White
28 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:39:24
I agree with much that has been said here. It is depressing to think we cannot change our tactics for a specific game. Palace had lost their last 7 games by at least 2 goals. So why do we insist on playing slowly forward when going up-tempo against a team with no confidence and who are likely to sit back in defence would be more likely to put them under pressure? We are lacking the skill and pace to break down a packed defence after a slow build up when our more creative players are off their game and indeed look rather unhappy.

Mirallas is not a winger. The way to get him back on form is to have him play more in the middle of the field when he can take a run at the defence and play to his strength.

While I think it unlikely to happen, I would select him and Lukaku to play up front against the Reds' back 3, Let's get the ball forward to them as quickly as possible. Pienaar, McCarthy, Barry and Naismith in the middle with Pienaar and Naismith shading inside to clog up their midfield. Coleman and Baines to go forward as best they can. It means Osman and Barkley on the bench to start but neither has particularly justified their selection recently.

If we sit back and let the RS play, we'll get clobbered.

Andy Walker
29 Posted 10/11/2013 at 19:34:52
Call it what it is, defensive football v attacking football.

We now play defensive football, we defend the ball rather than our goal, that's the purpose of the possession style we play ie if we have the ball the opponents don't so they have less opportunity to score.

But there's the problem, we aren't keeping the ball for attacking reasons, we keep it for defensive reasons. So we play defensive possession football.

The holy grail is to play attacking possession football, like the top European clubs, but you need exceptional players who can keep the ball whilst going forward. We are simply playing the poor man's version of possession football.

Get back to our centre backs playing diagonal balls across to Mirallas/Coleman or Baines/Pienaar and working to pick up the loose balls in the final attacking third. This is why so many of our players are 'out of form' — they are not suited to this negative, defend-the-ball style of play. They want to attack, be direct, use their pace — not try and kill the tempo in an effort to keep the ball.

Our team flatters to deceive; people believe we must be good because we have lots of possession, this is complete bollocks. It's the emporer's new clothes. What compounds matters is RM's natural ability to work the media, I haven't seen so many positive comments about our manager as those about the quip he made about AVB the other day. It doesn't matter, it's what's on the pitch that counts, but so many now seem to be more bothered about how we are reported in the media; style over substance all round.

Don't get your views from the news — open your eyes and look at what's going on where it counts, on the pitch. That's where I judge our side and at the moment it's not good enough.

Patrick Murphy
30 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:04:28
Andy, you are correct; however, I am fiercely critical of the way we played during the last week against Spurs and yesterday at Palace — but that doesn't mean that I am anti-Martinez.

The frustrations from those two performances arose from our lack of belief, confidence or sheer bloody-mindedness to attempt to win those games. We could easily be sat in 2nd spot in the table if the players had have put their shoulders to the wheel and really gone for it rather than thinking not getting beat was enough.

That is an attitude problem as much as a lack of talent or managerial acumen. As has been mentioned, if just a couple of our players had have shown the determination and drive that Rooney showed today, it may well have been enough to tip both games in Everton's favour. That is where the frustration lies — not simply the way we line up or how many passes it takes to get from A to B.

Unfortunately we won't know for a month or so whether the players can respond to 'ordinary' games with the right mind-set and determination. The derby game will be the usual hurly-burly madhouse and all the players will be up for it, but it is in the other games against so-called lesser teams that I judge the players and they still have that infuriating habit of not turning up for those games.

Considering the way the results have gone over the weekend, you could say that we have been lucky but the league is wide open this season and anyone, even us, could have a chance of being right up at the top — but not if we go into games with the attitude we have shown in the last couple of games.

Brian Harrison
31 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:07:40
Have to agree with a lot of the comments made on this post; so, if it is so apparent to everyone that our build-up play is too slow, how come we never change it? For my money, we have the best pair of attacking fullbacks in the league yet this season we don't see as many forward runs by either. I agree that the players have to take some responsibility but so does the manager.

I know players can go through poor patches and we have seen it under OFM with Jelavic after looking so promising and RM doesnt seem to fancy him either. Then we have the enigma that is Kevin Mirallas: last year, he looked like a match-winner... this year, apart from a couple of 10 minute spells, he looks like a completely different player.

I would just hope that for our next match we move the ball a lot quicker out of defence than we have so far.

I heard Pienaar in an interview the other day and he said it was very noticeable how the crowd got anxious and that quickly transferred to the players, so maybe the manager needs to address the problem because, if this constant passing along the back four is making fans edgy and the players, then I can imagine that anxiety will go through the roof for our next game, given the opponents.

Dick Fearon
32 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:23:01
I have little respect for any manager who thinks a place must be found for Osman. How many times must he be bowled over in making a simple challenge argh! stuff it, I was going to present the usual list of his failings but then I thought why bother. Martinez like Moyes before him seem blind to Leon's weak spots, or is it me who can't recognise a midfield genius.
Kevin Tully
33 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:32:08
I think Paul Tran nailed it in another post.

"At the moment, watching Everton is like watching someone learning how to drive; concentrating so hard on one thing that they forget all the other stuff and stall the car."

If you watched the documentary a while back on Swansea, it was interesting to hear what their players had to say. They were extremely sceptical of Martinez's methodology, and did not want to pass the ball in their own half - you can imagine how alien this concept was in the lower divisions.

A few weeks ago, I said you would hear GP give a collective groan if we witnessed a centre-half hoof it down the line, once they had gotten used to seeing some patient, passing football.

Now I'm not so sure. I get the feeling most of our supporters can't be arsed watching a slow patient build up. They want to see pressure football, forcing corners, throw-ins, and generally running around like loons.

Fair enough – each to their own.

Ian Burns
34 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:41:15
Phil W - couldn't agree more - on today's performance Rooney has shown how it should be done - sheer effort was quite remarkable.

What bemuses me is that just about everybody on TW sees the problem, slow play, passing for the sake of it, restrictive full backs, no support for the man up to due to the sheer lack of pace at which we play. Even players not playing in their most effective roles, Mirallas being the most obvious, playing off Lulu down the middle I am sure is where he belongs and I can't help thinking he would put in far more effort because he would be involved more, rather than standing catching a cold our wide.

This is not a criticism of RM per se but I wish he would read TW and see that everybody wishes him to be a great success at our great club but he needs to see what we can see and make the changes accordingly and get our backs into the game and give Lulu some much needed support.


Tom R Owen
35 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:52:34
There is an old saying "never go back"; Moyes made a huge mistake in bringing Pienaar back.

As many have said, Mirallas blows hot and cold – sadly more cold than even tepid. Osman is a fringe player at best.

Over to you, Bullshit Bill, open the cheque book in 7 weeks time.

Brian Harrison
36 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:49:58
Kevin,

Yes I do want to see us ditch slow football that achieves nothing, the very best teams get the ball forward quickly not have six or seven passes between their two central defenders. As for the stats on possession I would love to know how many forward passes we make in our opponent's half. So I guess I fall into the category of wanting to get at sides quicker and force corners and have shots on the opponent's goal. The game is supposed to be exciting, and for large parts of our matches we seem to play with a lack of intensity, with this sanitised possession football.

Andrew James
37 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:39:49
Slightly controversial but I see our gradual evolution to be like that across the Park. Do you remember Brenda's Swansea team who turned up at Goodison and got found out because they passed, passed, passed with no end result?

Brenda's RS did similar last season but got away with it thanks to Gerrard and Sewer Rat.

I think the form of Lukaku has glossed over our shortcomings. We are hard to beat (as two defeats show) but are hardly prolific.

The Derby will be interesting but I fear the worst because their attack is so much better than ours. The only thing I can hope for is that Brenda makes some daft decision in the tactics which RM reacts to during the match.

Dan McKie
38 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:03:52
Colin, it was the 0-0 draws against West Brom and Cardiff when he made that daft quote.
Kevin Tully
39 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:01:46
Brian, I imagine it will take many more months, and a fair few new faces before you will see an Everton in full flow as Martinez wants to play.

You only have to look at how uncomfortable many of this squad are at the moment, some of them can't give a 5 yard pass without giving the ball away.

I now realise many just have not got the patience to wait a season, or maybe even two (god help us if we were in the bottom half) but after 18 years without a pot, I find it hard to comprehend what the rush is??

If we were League Champions and strayed from a successful formula, maybe I could understand why so many of us don't want to see a different approach.

Just look at our record away at the so called 'big teams' surely that alone is enough to convince fans we need to change our approach?

Colin Glassar
40 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:14:14
Then it was a stupid thing to say Dan. I like Martinez and what he's trying to do but I think he needs to start kicking a few backsides after the last few feeble efforts.
Raymond Fox
41 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:13:12
It seems to me, as Kevin as already said, that effectively you're advocating going back to how Moyes played.

Considering the changes that RM has brought in, we're not doing too bad, you need to look a little more long term; after all, with Moyes we usually finished 6 to 8th.

Sean Kelly
42 Posted 10/11/2013 at 20:47:54
Roberto Martinez is trying to change things but either the players aren't buying into it or they are unable to. I think it's the latter with most of them.

Distin and Jags are too slow with their passing and it's always going sideways. Lukaku is getting pissed off waiting on a cross. Baines and Coleman must have been told to hold back as last year they were bombing forward at every opportunity.

Osman, Pienaar and Jelavic need shifting out. They are not up to it anymore. Different systems need players to be able to adjust and ours can't. Mirallas should take the bus out with the other three as he just doesn't give a fuck. He is a lazy cunt and has never put a 90-minute shift in.
I trust Martinez but this project will take some time and at the moment we are in a false position. Mid-table is where we will be when those above us get a bit of consistency going.

Sorry for the negativity but, after Spurs I felt like someone let the air of our tyres... After yesterday, though, I think the wheels have been nicked.

Dan McKie
43 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:13:46
Colin, Mirallas and Osman have been playing rubbish all season, yet their names seemed carved into the team sheet. Where are the positive changes? His subs during the game are always like for like. Yesterday he brought on 2 players who should have started, for 2 players who once again showed they shouldn't be anywhere near the first team right now, just like in the game before that, and the game before that.

When do we show any urgency in going for a game now? Never! Under Moyes, if it was 0-0 with 20 mins to go, you could safely say we would throw the kitchen sink at the goal, but now it's Howard, to Jags, to Distin, Jags, Distin, Jags, Distin, Barry, Jags, Howard, Distin, Jags.......and on and on it goes.

Nick Armitage
44 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:21:42
Irrespective of our transitional state or our change of tactics, the main problem is that we are not pressing the opposition and our tempo is not high enough.

I could write an article about this but, like Steven Pienaar, I can't be arsed.

Raymond Fox
45 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:27:02
We simply haven't the quality subs to bring on though, have we, Dan? I think you have to be realistic, that's why were destined to finish out of the top 4 each season!
Trevor Lynes
46 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:37:54
I fully agree with you, Raymond... our bench actually had Heitinga on it which demonstrates the shortage of quality players.

With Gibson out injured, we have seven midfield players available from which we have to select five unless we change our tactics altogether. We used 13 players against Palace and three are on loan.

We are just five points away from the top of the league which is miraculous. Only Southampton can boast just one defeat (as we can), each of the top teams are also having bad days. Let's just hope we are really at our best for the derby.

John Malone
47 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:49:33
The systems only works when all the team understand the philosophy and apply it otherwise you get what we are seeing disjointed random passing, then a long ball when you get closed down because the movement doesn't match the speed of the passing or the speed of the closing down by the opposition. It's going to be a matter of patience and trust in Martinez hopefully he can pull it off.
Colin Glassar
48 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:08:17
Dan, yesterday Moyes would've brought on Heitinga and Neville you know it's true. I agree about Ossie and Mirallas, both need to be dropped but they will both probably start the derby game.
Barry Rathbone
49 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:06:34
Dan Mckie

"Under Moyes, if it was 0-0 with 20 mins to go, you could safely say we would throw the kitchen sink at the goal"

Wish I'd seen that game.

Tony Farrell
50 Posted 10/11/2013 at 21:47:24
I have always believed in the the words of Bill Shankly:
If we've got the ball, they can't do anything.
True quote... what's the point in hoofing a long and hopefull ball up front? Nine times out of ten, the defenders are going to win it and you've lost possession.

Our defenders are in a transition period playing the ball out of defense across the park, allowing the opposition time to organise and close down any quick breaks, eg Baines and Coleman. Yes, I do realise we have to give this method time to bed in... but, in all honesty, it's not a pleasure to watch.

This type of game is fine if you have quality in midfield who can see openings in an instant and split defenders wide open. We don't have quality in midfield — end of. Four nil-nil draws already... enough said.

Does he change the system? And, if so, to what? I would like to hear from fellow fans what would they do.

Our last few performances have been dire; is it the system? Or is Pienaar and Osman finished? Baines and Coleman have stopped raiding the flanks...

Is it right to leave Barkley on the bench? McCarthy gets through games but dosen't really contribute much... It's up to you, Roberto — don't let the RedShite walk over us. Tell the players to grow a set and start performing like men! I wish Riedy, Psycho Pat, Ratters and Big Dunc and the likes could install their influence into the squad.

Jamie Sweet
51 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:08:39
Well at least a whole bunch of 0-0's mean that Martinez may not turn us into a team that leaks goals for fun as some people were worried about when we signed him.

As for breaking teams down, I think it might be time to unleash Barkley and Deulofeu from the start. Sure they make mistakes, but they are constantly looking to drive forwards and create something. Pienaar and Osman were so pedestrian against Palace I was almost embarassed for them. No spark from them at all.

So much of our good attacking play this year has come from Barkleys desire to pick the ball up and drive forwards at pace. Whenever he gets posession he looks to do something positive. Osmanis a bit more tippy tappy, and we've got enough of that going on behind him.

Steavey Buckley
52 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:21:39
Lukaku needs help upfront to allow him to deal with one defender at a time. Not two at once.
And as a caveat, play some of the Everton under 21s or under 18's in the first team to show some commitment and passion to those who played so awful against Spurs and Palace.
James Stewart
53 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:26:51
Barkley and Deulofeu have to start the Derby.
Jamie Sweet
54 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:28:36
Dan McKie. The thought of Moyes throwing the kitchen sink at anything just gave me a right good chuckle, thanks.

If he ever did more than politely lob a teaspoon at 0-0 during his 11 years, I must have missed it.

Michael Kenrick
55 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:23:10
This 'victories without goals' quote seems to getting flung around a little out of context:

After three trying draws against Norwich, West Brom and Cardiff, I wondered if he emphasized the club's undefeated status or the fact that they have only mustered three points.

"A bit of both," he admitted. "The draws were more 'victories without goals.' I saw many good things in the possession and the chances created that will bring us a lot of points over the season, even though three points after three games is not the return we want."


I think Roberto clearly understands each draw is two points lost. But, as ever, our ray of sunshine was seeking to put a positive spin on the first three games of the season. And the games that followed (Man City apart, where we were done by the ref) seemed to confirm that apporach. It's just so frustrating that we seem to have reached a plateau in these last two games when so many fans were looking for us to keep pressing on up the table.

So a couple of great posts, Andy Walker, Patrick Murphy — exactly what I thought as I watched the match unfold yesterday.

As for this increasing spouted blueprint going forward "...let the man get on with his job and then it's over to Bill and the board again to come up trumps in January." — I'm sorry but I can't think of anything more ridiculous at this stage (or indeed any stage) of the seaon than always relying on 'the next transfer window' as being some form of miraculous salavation to save our season. There are games every week (except for these blasted International breaks) with points to be won. Martinez has supposedly one of the best squads seen in Royal Blue at Goodison Park (according to some...). The focus needs to be one thing and one thing only: The Next Game!!!

Brin Williams
56 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:20:13
'Under Moyes, if it was 0-0 with 20 mins to go, you could safely say we would throw the kitchen sink at the goal, '

Who just said that??

Under Moyes with 20 minutes to go at 0-0 we were sure as hell not throwing the kitchen sink or anything else at the goal. In fact, we were substituting a defender for an attacking player, or (at that stage) taking a good Mirallas off for a damn below-average Naismith.

Colin Glassar
57 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:40:55
I think you stand corrected Dan. Kitchen sink? Moyes wouldn't even throw a wet sponge onto the pitch.
Andrew James
59 Posted 10/11/2013 at 22:52:38
I think the kitchen sink stuff about Moyes shows up short term memories. At 0-0 he often did use that ploy especially at home. I seem to recall a match against Newcastle early on where we had Jeffers, Rooney, Big Dunc and The Rad all on the pitch at the end. If that's not throwing the kitchen sink I don't know what is.

Does anyone recall Pompey at home in early 2005? I am sure he introduced Jimmy Mac and Big Dunc to create havoc in their area so we eventually won the game in the final minutes.

I have watched us at The Cottage where Moyes intensified the attack and in 2011 it worked perfectly as we scored twice in the last 5 minutes.

Please can everyone stop having selective memory disorder. Moyes had his faults but having a go in the final ten was not one of them.

Of course if we were ahead it was a different story but that is another debate...

Eric Myles
60 Posted 11/11/2013 at 00:46:57
What Andrew said at #353 "What does worry me is that we have completely blunted our biggest weapons: Baines and Coleman."

They are not crossing the ball into the box anymore. Just when it looks promising that they will play the ball in it ends up getting back passed to our half way line and knocked to the other side for the same thing to happen.

First half against Palace, the poorest team in the league we had 2 shots on goal, both from Osman.

Mike Price
61 Posted 11/11/2013 at 01:16:39
I just can't believe the negativity towards our transition to a possession based game.

I've suffered the bland predictability of Moyes for 11 long years. We won nothing, were regularly humiliated in the derby (Redshite fans asking for 10 more years should give you a clue), and played a mostly dour, boring, kick-and-rush style that most of the world hated.

Finally, I can breathe again. Obviously it's going to take time to develop the squad and indoctrinate his style and there are going to be some poor patches no doubt, but at least there's some sort of hope.

Do people really think anyone on the planet can just click their fingers and transform a squad into a fast, skilled, possession-based top 4 team in a few months? You need money and a good, progressive manager... at least we've got one of the two.

Harold Matthews
63 Posted 11/11/2013 at 01:59:15
We should take no credit for the latest clean sheet. Palace missed 3 or 4 absolute sitters.

Our players are not showing the speed, energy and total commitment of the three teams which won on Sunday and I'd like to know why. How Martinez reacts away from the cameras is anyones guess but, according to Victor, Moyes used to scare people and maybe his old squad members are now enjoying the new cushy life on Easy Street.

Baines was originally a winger, a position filled successfully by Oviedo at Upton Park. Mirallis couldn't give a stuff out wide. Stick him up front, even on his own. CBs will not like his pace and movement. Skrtle will hold Lukaku's shirt for 90 minutes.

Stones is wasted on the bench. For me, he is not necessarily a back 4 specialist. Like Jones of United, he could play anywhere. He can tackle, pass, head the ball and move at speed. For certain games I would play him in McCarthy's position where he could both defend and attack with skill and pace, something he often does with the England under 21's.

Many sides are enjoying the fruits of lads playing well in new positions and we ought to be following suit.

I notice "new kids on the block," Southampton, have a young, hungry captain. Adam "I'd happily pay anything to watch Everton" Lallana. Maybe that's another area we should be looking at.

Drew O'Neall
64 Posted 11/11/2013 at 03:53:45
I want to see "direct" attacking football when we are losing or drawing and tippy tappy possession when we are winning - we seem only capable of the opposite which speaks of a character / confidence / mental problem to me.
Eric Myles
65 Posted 11/11/2013 at 04:38:18
Colin #392, OFM used to get criticised for the tactics and the players absolved of blame, so why should ONM be any different?

Dan #397, that could be OFM you're describing there.

Ian Tunstead
66 Posted 11/11/2013 at 05:06:23
Have to agree with Andrew James, Just been looking at some old YouTube videos of Rooney with Everton, a few of the vids seem to show us having three forwards on at a time, either Radzinski, Rooney and Campbell or Rooney, Radzinski and Ferguson.

Cant agree with Tony 439. " what's the point in hoofing a long and hopefull ball up front? Nine times out of ten, the defenders are going to win it and you've lost possession."

But are they hopefull long balls? We seemed to find Fellaini very well last season and I don't think he lost the ball anywhere near as much as 9 out of ten times when the ball was lofted up to his chest or head. It gave us a platform to build from and allowed us to start ourattack or build up play around the edge of the opposition box with all our creative players up field ready in position rather than having to start the build up with Jaggs and Distin trying not to pass it straight to the opposition.

I think Lukaku would win his fair share of long balls against most defenders and would be worth using as a Plan B.

Raymond Fox
67 Posted 11/11/2013 at 07:38:57
Good post Mike 482, I agree with everything you say, and most of what Harold 492 says.

We badly need a quality ball playing midfielder who also has goals in him, as a improved link between the defenders and forwards.
We are having bad luck as far as injuries go and Gibson is missed, together with Kone who is superior to Lukaku at finding space and playing one twos in the box (just watched games where we played Wigan).
Also theres not enough movement when the players get forward.
Flog Baines along with Heitiger and give Ovieda his chance at left back, he deserves it from what we've seen of him.

Sam Hoare
68 Posted 11/11/2013 at 08:36:58
I'm slightly surprised that so few young players have been involved apart from Barkley who has been perhaps unjustly benched for the last few games. I guess it will take time for RM to appraise the younger players and intergrate but was slightly hoping for a Lambert esque revolution (without the relegation battle!) where lots of the youngsters were given game time. I'm not sure that the likes of Kennedy and Long could do a lot worse than Pienaar and Mirallas on the wings for example. Oviedo and Stones are the obvious ones to be given a go though oviedo's pace is less effective when playing a measured posession based game as we are at the moment.
Brin Williams
69 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:08:40
' Just been looking at some old youtube videos of Rooney with Everton, a few of the vids seem to show us having 3 forwards on at a time, either Radzinski, Rooney and Campbell or Rooney Radzinski and Ferguson.'

I looked at some OLD movies recently, Humph Bogart in the African Queen and I also watched Bob Hope in Paleface and both reminded me of my childhood, but I'm no longer a child and being an Everton supporter I too have had to 'live in the past' for far too long.

Let's get up to date and straighten out our attacking mentality. So that I have other memories before I leave this world!!

Carl Sanderson
70 Posted 11/11/2013 at 09:55:45
This from the Grauniad sums things up well:

"Roberto Martínez is an old hand at finding positives amid disappointment but his claim that Everton were so dominant against Crystal Palace on Saturday that "nine times out of 10 we would have won the game" was ridiculous. Everton fans must hope he does not actually believe it. A team with better finishers than Palace would have scored several goals against Martínez's men – a team such as the Liverpool side they face next – and, even more alarming, Everton seldom looked likely to prise Palace open. With Romelu Lukaku subdued, Everton's midfielders did not carry enough threat, with Leon Osman, Kevin Mirallas and James McCarthy especially innocuous. The case for starting Ross Barkley and Gerard Deulofeu in the Merseyside derby just got stronger."

Barry Rathbone
71 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:15:46
Brin 522,

Brilliant.

Colin Glassar
72 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:28:21
Nice one Brin#522. I'm the same. I just want to see us back at the top before I snuff it.

P.S. despite all the doom and gloom surrounding our recent loss of form am I the only one who's made up that Phil Neville no longer plays for us? Every game I still have flashbacks thinking he might be starting or on the bench.

Derek Thomas
74 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:20:05
Drew O'Neill #495...This! in spades with knobs on.
Kevin Tully
75 Posted 11/11/2013 at 10:55:10
Can anyone honestly say the players have given 100% the last two games?

New system or not, I would say Spurs & Palace put more hard yards in than us. Apparently Rooney ran over 11Km in that game yesterday, I bet none of our players have come anywhere near that total.

Maybe they think that now they are concentrating on passing the ball 5 yards (ffs) they don't have run as much as the opposing side?

All the great teams work harder than the opposition, no matter how good they are.

Ian Burns
76 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:11:25
Bayern Munich (ah remember that far off day we beat them!!); Barca; even Southampton work and work to earn the right to pass the ball and Rooney yesterday gave a masterpiece on how great footballers feel no shame in their work rate.

Southampton in a very short space of time have learned how to move the ball quickly and at the same time keep a rock solid defence.

I am all for giving RM the time he needs but at the same time I am not seeing any significant progress. I am seeing change but not progress.

Yes I agree RM needs the time to implement these changes but for goodness sake that doesn't mean we stop grafting, especially in the middle of the park.

I am going into hibernation, 12,45pm, Saturday 23rd November and only waking up on Christmas Day to open me prezzies.

Trevor Lynes
77 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:40:11
I am absolutely certain that, if any of our younger players showed themselves ready for a first team start, then Roberto would give them a chance. Unlike DM, I am sure we would have seen much more of Rooney before he was sold. Stones appears to be the only prospect we actually own. Del Boy is on loan!

I'm sure Martinez would be overjoyed if a Lallana was on the books but unfortunately the lad plays for Southampton even though he was an Evertonian like his father. As I said earlier, we have to perm five from seven for the midfield positions. If anyone disagrees with me, please say so and offer alternatives!

Raymond Fox
78 Posted 11/11/2013 at 11:24:43
Poor play is excusable, lack of effort is not, hell, some of them earn more in a week than us poor sods earn/ed in 2+yrs!

They should be dropped immediately, but RMs problem is that he's lacking the players to replace them with.

As others have said, Rooney's some player is he not, he's worth his weight in gold that lad, very rare in a gifted player, is his work rate and his exceptional will to win.

Just think what difference he could have made to our results, if we could somehow have kept hold of him.

Dan McKie
79 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:07:05
We would have at least mixed it up under Moyes. What I meant by kitchen sink was a fair few balls going into the box, Jags punting a few upfield towards the strikers etc. not just back to Howard and start again. Christ, we might even have swung a couple of free kicks toward the goal.

Raymond, 432, it's not about bringing quality on, it's about having them on at the beginning. Just how many games do the players who have been shite get? So far it's 11 with Mirallas and Osman, yet with Barkley it was about 2.

For me, Moyes used to make his poorer decisions when we were a goal up rather than drawing or losing, but at least he made decisions. I can't help but think Martinez plays it too softly softly.

Tony J Williams
80 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:25:05
To be fair Dan, Barkley was rubbish when he cam on too. Lost possession so many times.

We can't pin our hopes on a youngster in his first "real" season and we shouldn't have to. Time for the others to step up.

Raymond Fox
81 Posted 11/11/2013 at 12:30:17
Ok Dan, but I still think RM is pretty limited in the players he can choose from right now, we need 1 or 2 talented youngsters from within, to suddenly blossom and help out.

Even though I'm a big supporter of Martinez I think your right when you say that it would pay to boot the ball into the opponents box a time or two more, especially with Lukaku likely to get on the end of them, it would keep them guessing a bit more, which cant be bad.
The defenders are obviously under instructions not to though, by the looks of it .

Ian Burns
82 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:02:31
Just read this on the BBC Sports website.

So much for EFC and Southampton for that matter!

"Arsenal are strong, Utd have luck, City and Chelsea cash to burn, Spurs inconsistent, Liverpool look the part, will be close!"

Tom Bowers
83 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:23:52
You're darn right saying RM is limited with players if Osman can keep getting picked to start.

Unless that philosophy changes soon, then Everton will not keep up with the top 6.

Colin Glassar
84 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:21:18
Martinez has said he will look to strengthen the squad in January. Unlike OFM, he will not add (dead) bodies to make up the numbers e.g. Hitzlsperger, Gardiner, Senderos etc.... But quality players. If he's unable to do so, he said he would promote from within. So we might see the likes of Vellios, Oviedo, Stones etc.....getting more games after Christmas.
Nick Entwistle
85 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:28:18
I don't think that was out of choice Colin, more necessity reflecting financial positions.

Sky money needs to be spent well and so far RM has been shaky. A lot of cash spent on players that aren't ours, and on some I wish weren't.

Peter Cummings
86 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:45:32
While we dominated possesion, Palace had three clear chances to score against a single attempt from us.

The 'new' system is not working, Mr M; no chance of a win – or even a bore draw next game

Steavey Buckley
87 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:55:52
In every game that Everton have drawn, four nil-nil games, is when Osman starts; he sits in midfield and passes sideways and stays there. Football is at best about pass and move and getting forward.
Tony J Williams
89 Posted 11/11/2013 at 14:29:11
"Football is at best about pass and move and getting forward" — Amen, but we have always been a team that has a problem with the "move" aspect of that tactic.

Pass and admire is usually our stance.

Gavin Ramejkis
90 Posted 11/11/2013 at 14:34:29
Andrew #462 and Ian #500 you both realise you mention players that haven't played for Everton for a very long time; McFadden, Duncan Ferguson and Rooney left 2008, 2006 and 2004 respectively, hardly a cast iron case for the defence of this being a regular tactic over the misery's 11 years is it?
Eric Myles
91 Posted 11/11/2013 at 14:38:18
Pass to one of our own players has been a big failing so far Tony so they have no result to admire.
Max Wilson
92 Posted 11/11/2013 at 14:34:34
Trevor T, Jimmy B, Harold M; you guys are writing what I'm thinking. Essentially there's no penetration into the final third, with guys running into space on to balls. Coleman and Baines overlapping; we know they can do it. Why is this? It's the tempo we're playing at. By the time we're thinking of a positive move, the opposition has had time to close up.
John Zapa
93 Posted 11/11/2013 at 13:14:39
All this transition talk is nonsense, an excuse to shield every poor performance/result. Some say 'give him time to implement his ideas' — that too is rubbish. Any manager worth his salt will get the players to play a system/style/formation that suits their strengths. Not the system that he dreams of playing.

You only have to look across the park to see Brendan change the formation depending on who he has available. They must have used around 7-8 formations this season, sometime using up to 3 formations in the same game. That is progressive management. Being stubborn without changing things around when needed and having a deep-thinking look on your face doesn't make you know what the hell you're doing.

Carl Sanderson
94 Posted 11/11/2013 at 15:35:25
Colin,

"Martinez has said he will look to strengthen the squad in January. Unlike OFM, he will not add (dead) bodies to make up the numbers"

Dead bodies such as Cahill, Arteta, Lescott, Baines, Jagielka, etc? Or quality players who are always fit, such as Alcaraz and Kone?

All managers make mistakes in the market. Moyes was excellent in that regard: let's face it, with Widow Twanky holding the purse-strings, he had to be.

Mike Price
95 Posted 11/11/2013 at 17:08:58
John Zapa don't make me laugh regarding Brendan. He had all last year to sort it out, transfer out his deadwood, buy lots of his players at huge cost and had a world class player in the form of his life gift wrapped for him.
They couldn't beat any of the top teams, except for us obviously, and even this year lost to Soton at home and Arsenal, and were very lucky in the timing of the Utd game which they still shouldn't have won.
All this praise for the redshite and their manager; our managers already being criticized after a few months with a negative 10 million transfer budget in one transfer window and we're only 3 points behind them FFS!
Patrick Murphy
96 Posted 11/11/2013 at 17:45:18
It's bad enough some posters being obsessed by the current boss at Old Trafford but now I constantly read how Brenda is somehow one of the all-time greats in the making? Ratboy is one of the most feared strikers in Europe and we don't stand a chance in the derby. I couldn't give a flying fish-cake how good they are or how brilliant their manager is. I don't care if we lump it up the park for 90 minutes or play tippy tappy football for the whole game in the derby. I want us to win, we have the ability to win and we have the crowd on our side - or at least that's what I thought - until I read the posts relating to how marvellous their manager and their team is.

Get a grip people they are just another team who happen to be from the same city not some football gods from another planet.

John Zapa
97 Posted 11/11/2013 at 17:36:24
Mike,

It's not just about how much you spend, it's how you spend it. I recall liverpool under Kenny spending around 100m in 2 windows on some of the most useless players in the game. They got almost no value for money. Under Brendan they have invested much more wisely especially relative to Martinez. They brought in young players with potential and resale value. Martinez brought 3 players on loan, and 4 wigan players. None of whom would are worth what was paid for them.
I wonder how much the combined cost of players like Coleman, Cahill, Lescot, Jag, Distan was? I'm sure it was less than Martinez spent in his first window. The negative transfer spend you refer to was thanks to the big fee (and profit) from the sale of a couple players signed by the former manager.

Dan Brierley
98 Posted 11/11/2013 at 18:14:10
Getting some support to the front two is the key. Unsurprisingly Osman takes the brunt of the blame, even though most of the time he has to take on 3 players before having some space to think about a pass. Barkley however still seems to be immune from criticism from many areas, even though he has also delivered absolutely nothing in the last 3 games as he suffers from the same lack of support as Osman.

Martinez needs to start committing men forward to give some space to the front men. But it seems he doesn't have the right resources to do that, as he signed two defensive centre mids who offer nothing creative. I still cannot for the life of me understand why he was hellbent on signing McCarthy, when it was clear to a blind man that we needed an Arteta/Cabaye type in the centre who knows how to support the front men. I can't see anything changing until he is allowed to shuffle the pack in January, as Martinez seems too stubborn to consider playing in a different way. Either he is too stubborn, or even more worrying, is incapable of playing different tactics....

Raymond Fox
99 Posted 11/11/2013 at 18:52:07
Were not pulling up any trees but, let's see, we have 20pts from 11 games which equates to 70pts which is 7 more than last season.

So, considering that the manager and backroom staff are different, along with new players having to bed in, plus learning a different way of playing the game, it can't be too bad, can it?
Also as Mike said, RM has £10m left over from the transfer deals. Is there anyone here who wouldn't have taken that when Mr wonderful abandoned ship!

As far as the loan players are concerned, we can't afford to buy them or their like, so presumably we wouldn't have as many points without them.

Ian Burns
100 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:43:08
If we got 70 points at the end of this season, I will give away my entire stock of Bombay Sapphire for free and mow the lawn naked!
Raymond Fox
101 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:54:29
Where do you live Ian?
Mike Price
102 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:29:10
How you spend it indeed...Allen 15 mill, Borini 10 mill, Aspas 7mill, Alberto 7mill, Sakho 15 mill, Assaidi ?...the list is long. His only good ones, so far, appear to be Sturridge and Coutinho and I'm not fully convinced by them just yet.

Kone, well no one really knows yet, same can be said about a few of his freebies. What we do know is that he's got Lukaku in for a season which the whole world sees as a coup, Barry a massive success and he's effectively ours as his City deal is done now. McCarthy will grow to prove his worth and that is relative to the money we got for Fellaini.

Oh and giving praise to the Man U manager for the Andy Carrollesque fee Martinez oversaw....no one but the person who massively overpaid for him first time would be suckered again. Check out Redcaf to see what they think of Fellaini and the fee.

Ian Burns
104 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:56:39
Now Raymond, do you want my gin or do you want to see me mow the lawn naked!
Brent Stephens
105 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:00:32
Ian,

I think we'd need the gin before the show.

Ian Burns
106 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:09:29
Haha - Brent you would most certainly need the gin AFTER the show that's for sure!
Phil Walling
107 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:40:41
I fear that by Christmas, all the Premier managers will have worked out how to counter Roberto's 'steady build-up' tactics and wins will be few and far between.

If he continues to persist with 'one style fits all', then 0-0 draws will, indeed, be seen as 1 point victories. As it is, we only need Lakaku to go off the boil and Baines to disappear and that projected 70 point finish above will be nowt but a pipe dream.

Raymond Fox
108 Posted 11/11/2013 at 19:59:32
You offered both Ian, obviously we may not get to 70pts anything can happen! But then again we may get more.

You know I was just showing that, it's not like we have made a bad start, which you would think reading some posts.

All things considered I think RM has done great, pity he can't get his hands on £50m + which would give him some kind of parity with our competitors for the top of the Prem.

Brent Stephens
109 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:13:20
Ian, I thought the pre-show drinks would ease the imminent pain. Maybe it would just increase the level of laughter.
Ian Burns
110 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:18:57
Raymond - I was being flippant but I must say 70 points does seem a little out of reach having watched the last two games admittedly via a good stream and sitting on TW Live.

I am an RM fan because he is our manager and I want him to be successful so much it draws out the frustration, not only in myself but many posters on TW, some I must admit a little too negative for my liking.

The derby is going to tell us a great deal because if we can't come out and show total commitment from all on the pitch, then I do fear that 70 points will be a target too far.

Boy would I love to see 70 points at the end of the season (well 69 anyway!)

Clive Rogers
111 Posted 11/11/2013 at 20:29:28
You can't teach an old dog new tricks, and obviously Roberto intends to gradually change personnel more in tune with his style of playing. Therein lies the problem. With our board there is never enough money available.

Greg O'Keefe has already said there will be little available in January. He presumably has some inside knowledge. If this proves to be true, where has the £24M extra TV money and the £14M surplus Fellaini money gone?

No matter how much money comes into EFC, it seems to disappear into a black hole. The board's pockets no doubt.

Sean Kelly
112 Posted 11/11/2013 at 21:34:28
The RM project is under way and at this stage we are higher in the league than most people thought we would be. He's trying to get us playing in a new style. Fair enough but winning matches is what it's all about. Win your games and then you can add some style as the players will have the confidence to adjust.

I think at this moment too many players are taking the easy option... sidewayx passing and passing back to our two centre halves. Both Jags and Woody look dodgy with this. None of our midfielders are looking to take it from them and drive forward. Mirallas should stop looking at himself on the big screen.... When is the last time you saw him with a dirty kit and what's with him wanting to come off early all the time? Probably wants to hog the mirrors.
Pienaar and Ossie should be only bit part players at this stage. Their legs are gone

Note to Robbie if we can see the shite on the pitch so should you and be honest and tell the media we didn't play well and stop dressing it up with bullshit.

72% possession and hardly a shot on target is piss poor in any language.

Mick Davies
113 Posted 12/11/2013 at 02:32:29
I recall a Martinez side coming to Goodison last season and not just passing but also running the sox off us, so if his philosophy isn't working, it must be down to the players not trying hard enough. Maybe they all seen Lukaku as a match winner and assumed movement wasn't needed anymore!
Personally I'd bring Dunc into the changies before the derby game to convince them to work harder; they're paid well enough, even if they lack pride in themselves
Harold Matthews
114 Posted 12/11/2013 at 02:25:53
I'm very much befuddled with this whole "keep ball" business. Everton and City both employed the same slow build up system at the weekend with disastrous results. Neither team could find the space to create a decent opening.

Yet we see other sides who like to keep the ball scoring at will. Real Madrid, United, .....even Southampton and the crap across the park. They try to go forward at great pace at every opportunity.

It can't all be down to the players because City are loaded with superstars who recently put 7 past Norwich. OK, Silva was a big miss but the fault must surely lie with a system that allows the opposition time to get organised at the back.

Also, as mentioned in various threads, the victorious weekend teams played as though their lives depended on it. We didn't. For some of our lads it looked like a kickabout with the kids on a Sunday afternoon. Something somewhere is amiss.

Jackie Barry
115 Posted 12/11/2013 at 03:50:17
United most certainly are not playing a keep the ball style of play. Many of their fans are still unhappy at the way they are playing.
Kevin Thompson
116 Posted 12/11/2013 at 04:01:43
We need to be less predictable and play the odd long ball forward. Possession football is great when you are already 1-0 in front.
Jackie Barry
117 Posted 12/11/2013 at 04:28:58
You have to get 1-0 in front first though Kevin. Also, do we rest at one nil and play the passing game at the risk of losing a goal? No, we should wait until we are at least 3 or 4 up.
Tim Locke
118 Posted 12/11/2013 at 07:57:11
I had to double check the league because reading these comments I thought I must have missed something and we were bottom of the league with no points.

We are fifth and above Tot, Man city, the same points as Man U, and 3 points of second. A good win against the RS and we would go second.

People keep taking about Southampton like they the most amazing team ever, where did they finish last year???? ??? Below us, the year before below us, the year before that....not to mention they have been relegated and gone into liquidation. And this season??? Oh year they have won one more game than us and drawn one less???? What's the big deal???? They drew with west ham at home, a team we beat away, they lost to Nortwich a team we drew against. So what??? They play a high pressing game, and have a couple of players people are talking about. I remember a west ham side like that and where did they finish in the bottom 3??? Stop looking around you like what we have is rubbish, we have a good side with some strength in depth, out bench has players on it which would have been starters in side which finished top 6. We are getting better, and yes it might seem frustrating but for fuck sack save your moaning for a time when it really matters.

Tim Locke
119 Posted 12/11/2013 at 07:57:11
I had to double check the league because reading these comments I thought I must have missed something and we were bottom of the league with no points.

We are fifth and above Tot, Man city, the same points as Man U, and 3 points of second. A good win against the RS and we would go second.

People keep taking about Southampton like they the most amazing team ever, where did they finish last year???? ??? Below us, the year before below us, the year before that....not to mention they have been relegated and gone into liquidation. And this season??? Oh year they have won one more game than us and drawn one less???? What's the big deal???? They drew with west ham at home, a team we beat away, they lost to Nortwich a team we drew against. So what??? They play a high pressing game, and have a couple of players people are talking about. I remember a west ham side like that and where did they finish in the bottom 3??? Stop looking around you like what we have is rubbish, we have a good side with some strength in depth, out bench has players on it which would have been starters in side which finished top 6. We are getting better, and yes it might seem frustrating but for fuck sack save your moaning for a time when it really matters.

Tim Locke
120 Posted 12/11/2013 at 07:57:11
I had to double check the league because reading these comments I thought I must have missed something and we were bottom of the league with no points.

We are fifth and above Tot, Man city, the same points as Man U, and 3 points of second. A good win against the RS and we would go second.

People keep taking about Southampton like they the most amazing team ever, where did they finish last year???? ??? Below us, the year before below us, the year before that....not to mention they have been relegated and gone into liquidation. And this season??? Oh year they have won one more game than us and drawn one less???? What's the big deal???? They drew with west ham at home, a team we beat away, they lost to Nortwich a team we drew against. So what??? They play a high pressing game, and have a couple of players people are talking about. I remember a west ham side like that and where did they finish in the bottom 3??? Stop looking around you like what we have is rubbish, we have a good side with some strength in depth, out bench has players on it which would have been starters in side which finished top 6. We are getting better, and yes it might seem frustrating but for fuck sack save your moaning for a time when it really matters.

Tim Locke
121 Posted 12/11/2013 at 07:57:11
I had to double check the league because reading these comments I thought I must have missed something and we were bottom of the league with no points.

We are fifth and above Tot, Man city, the same points as Man U, and 3 points of second. A good win against the RS and we would go second.

People keep taking about Southampton like they the most amazing team ever, where did they finish last year???? ??? Below us, the year before below us, the year before that....not to mention they have been relegated and gone into liquidation. And this season??? Oh year they have won one more game than us and drawn one less???? What's the big deal???? They drew with west ham at home, a team we beat away, they lost to Nortwich a team we drew against. So what??? They play a high pressing game, and have a couple of players people are talking about. I remember a west ham side like that and where did they finish in the bottom 3??? Stop looking around you like what we have is rubbish, we have a good side with some strength in depth, out bench has players on it which would have been starters in side which finished top 6. We are getting better, and yes it might seem frustrating but for fuck sack save your moaning for a time when it really matters.

Tim Locke
122 Posted 12/11/2013 at 07:57:11
I had to double check the league because reading these comments I thought I must have missed something and we were bottom of the league with no points.

We are fifth and above Tot, Man city, the same points as Man U, and 3 points of second. A good win against the RS and we would go second.

People keep taking about Southampton like they the most amazing team ever, where did they finish last year???? ??? Below us, the year before below us, the year before that....not to mention they have been relegated and gone into liquidation. And this season??? Oh year they have won one more game than us and drawn one less???? What's the big deal???? They drew with west ham at home, a team we beat away, they lost to Nortwich a team we drew against. So what??? They play a high pressing game, and have a couple of players people are talking about. I remember a west ham side like that and where did they finish in the bottom 3??? Stop looking around you like what we have is rubbish, we have a good side with some strength in depth, out bench has players on it which would have been starters in side which finished top 6. We are getting better, and yes it might seem frustrating but for fuck sack save your moaning for a time when it really matters.

Tim Locke
123 Posted 12/11/2013 at 07:57:11
I had to double check the league because reading these comments I thought I must have missed something and we were bottom of the league with no points.

We are fifth and above Tot, Man city, the same points as Man U, and 3 points of second. A good win against the RS and we would go second.

People keep taking about Southampton like they the most amazing team ever, where did they finish last year???? ??? Below us, the year before below us, the year before that....not to mention they have been relegated and gone into liquidation. And this season??? Oh year they have won one more game than us and drawn one less???? What's the big deal???? They drew with west ham at home, a team we beat away, they lost to Nortwich a team we drew against. So what??? They play a high pressing game, and have a couple of players people are talking about. I remember a west ham side like that and where did they finish in the bottom 3??? Stop looking around you like what we have is rubbish, we have a good side with some strength in depth, out bench has players on it which would have been starters in side which finished top 6. We are getting better, and yes it might seem frustrating but for fuck sack save your moaning for a time when it really matters.

John Zapa
124 Posted 12/11/2013 at 09:04:29
One more time Tim, best be sure you got your point across. Might is right, those who shout loudest are always right, or are they?
Phil Walling
125 Posted 12/11/2013 at 09:05:29
Tom, I think we've got your point ! The negativity springs not with dissatisfaction at the points garnered to date but the sheer predictability of our style of play. Apart from 45 minutes of the Newcastle match, I have seen nothing to excite me or modify my view that this line-up and tactic is inadequate to see us achieve much above half-way. It's just my opinion and I respect other's views but I am not ,so far, impressed.
Jackie Barry
126 Posted 12/11/2013 at 13:28:59
I get your point Phil, but that has been what it has been like for me over the past few years. People like to go on about last year and awesome we were, it was good but nothing amazing and no more than I would expect from Everton FC. Seasons before that were very dull and boring if truth be told.
Phil Roberts
127 Posted 12/11/2013 at 13:46:26
Whisper this one quietly - but everyone says the best we have looked was home to Newcastle.

Swift break by Mirallas and stuck by Lukaku. Through ball from centre circle for Barclay to score. Hoof downfield by Howard and stuck in by Lukaku. So I think that is probably 7 passes for all 3 goals.

No tippy-tappy, no 45 passes — just good old-fashioned English pace and hoof. I did say whisper it quietly...

Phil Roberts
128 Posted 12/11/2013 at 13:54:42
I get castigated for my prediction method and we have people on here saying on this ratio we can have 70 points.

Simple fact. These same 11 fixtures last season produced 19 points. This season they have produced 20. But as I put in another post, we did score 20 goals not 14 - but the style of football has been so much nicer, even if we have had less to cheer than under defensive Davey.

Matty Williams
129 Posted 12/11/2013 at 13:57:06
Very good point, Tim Locke, but sadly our style of play is shite: boring, slow, predictable, negative, poor, one-dimensional — same old shite as served up by the ginger snake but with more aimless passing. I'm not impressed & fear the Derby more than ever. I shall be watching through my fingers AGAIN!
Jackie Barry
130 Posted 12/11/2013 at 14:19:29
Well taking a look at the teams who win things, Phil, will tell you that approach won't win us anything. I understand what you are saying but the long ball approach requires players who can do it accurately; based on our display at the weekend, we clearly don't have those players. Most long balls were either a) too long and went through to their keeper, or b) hit out of play due to an atrocious lack of accuracy.
Phil Roberts
131 Posted 12/11/2013 at 14:38:41
Jackie, but as most people on here point out - we only play one way. When we did something different then we walked all over the Newcastle side who went to Spurs and won and beat Chelsea.

But we seem to think that hoof, quick is wrong and pass, pass is right. There is a time for both and playing them both will be better.

Mike Oates
132 Posted 12/11/2013 at 14:59:08
We need someone in centre midfield to make things happen, and preferably with some pace. I thought that in the two games earlier in the season against West Ham and Newcastle, Barkley and Lukaku combined so well, starting attacks in areas just in the opponents half. They were both picking balls earlier in the play and making things happen. They were drawing opponents out of shape and this allowed our full backs and wide players space to move into.

At the moment its just stopped happening; I think Lukaku is having a poor little spell, is becoming too static, can't hold the ball up. Barkley also as one would expect is just trying the impossible, and Osman just hasn't got Barkley's pace and strength.

It's no good looking to Barry and McCarthy as neither of them can do that creative role. Barry protects and McCarthy provides the energy, and it's his job to get the ball back.

I think Mirallas is the one whose game has had to change to make Martinez's system to work; he has to give width, which to be fair he did at West Ham and vs Newcastle, creating goals, but I just feel he would give us far more goals if he was allowed to move inside more.

I still feel that we miss Gibson, he had the ability (more than Barry & McCarthy) to thread the ball into spaces, gaps, short and long.

At the moment I don't see any in the squad who can help whilst Lukaku and Barkley are struggling to get us going again. These two lads are the lynchpins Martinez needs to be firing on all cylinders in order to get goals. When playing well they bring the best from Mirallas, Pienaar, Baines, Coleman etc; these lads need space to get into and at the moment it isn't there.

Though if you look at a lot of our goals this year, they have come from set plays, free-kicks, corners or long punts, so in the meantime whilst we still sort out our style, just try the occasional long ball, but get Lukaku & Mirallas together.

Clive Lewis
133 Posted 12/11/2013 at 15:09:56
The problem with possession-type football is it works as long as eventually you are going to play that killer pass either down the line or through the middle. It appears we are missing a key part to the jigsaw and that is a very creative midfielder who has the ability to provide this. I feel teams sit back and let us pass knowing we don't have that within our side.

We need to move the ball quicker in the final third and be very comfortable doing this. I think you need to change to being direct a little bit and then switch back so it all does not become too predictable.

The possession type football works great at Barcelona; however, we are missing a Messi-type dribbler or a top midfielder like Xavi or, Iniesta....

We have Osman!

Colin Glassar
134 Posted 12/11/2013 at 15:15:28
Mike, that's why I think we might see a few Latinos come in the January window. No superstars, just lads who can control the ball and pass it to someone on the same team. I still think that in the summer there will be a major clear out – not because they are bad players but because they can't play the game Martinez wants to.

People say it's frustrating to watch tippy-tappy football. Well I think it must be frustrating for Martinez watching experienced internationals who can't even pass to each other!


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads

© ToffeeWeb